Chapter Text
“All right, lads,” says Balin, surveying the dwarves summoned impromptu once again. “It’s been a week, and that eagle is still here.”
Bofur rolls his eyes. “And this required a meeting?”
“You tell me: why hasn’t he left? If he only came to give Bilbo a ride, the task is fulfilled, wouldn’t you say?”
“I’d ask why Master Baggins came back in the first place, when he couldn’t wait to get out of here,” puts in Dori.
“I’ll tell you why,” says an eager Nori. “To pay Thorin back for what he did to Bilbo on the ramparts. He looked around, found someone fit for the hit job, and bingo: there’s his revenge.”
“But Bilbo looked terrified after Balthazar got hold of Thorin!” protests Bofur. “He begged him to stop!”
“Of course he did. Anybody can put on a show, especially when surrounded by dwarves with axes,” replies Nori.
“Now, now,” says Balin. “We should not judge Bilbo based on the behavior of a deranged bird. Let us examine what he’s done ever since.”
“I’ve seen him procure food and offer it to the eagle,” volunteers Bombur.
That’s all it takes for Dwalin to strike. “That a felon who managed to escape life in jail now lives off this Mountain is foul enough; but that Master Baggins is still friends with him is beyond the pale. They must be plotting something, mark my words; and I’ve said it to Thorin’s face, too.”
“And what did he say?”
“He laughed and called me a conspiracy theorist. I can’t speak for the eagle, he said, but Master Baggins has been nothing but loyal and kind.”
A few dwarves raise inquisitive eyebrows. They wouldn’t mind delving into what Bilbo and the eagle could be plotting.
Bofur has a more optimistic take. “Thorin Oakenshield laughed? Hey, at least his mood has improved since Bilbo’s return.”
“Aye, he’s no longer brooding or daydreaming during meetings. But...” Balin sighs, “that’s because he barely attends them anymore. Thank Mahal Fili is stepping up to the plate.”
“And what exactly is His Majesty doing with his time?”
“He’s taken up redoing the ramparts as his day job. Painting the “balcony”, as he calls it now, and building some furniture for it.”
“As if this is what Erebor needs right now,” scoffs Dwalin. “I tried to point out his focus is misplaced. Thorin’s reply? After what that bird did to me, I realized life is too short. I am not going to let Bilbo slip through my fingers again. Dude, I said. You almost died in that #$%#ing battle. Now you realize life is too short?”
“Seize the day,” mutters a pensive Oin. “A healthy response on Thorin’s part. An even healthier one would be accepting that he hurt Bilbo beyond repair and moving on: try to meet some new people for a change. How are things coming along with his suitors, by the way?”
“Things are moving, all right,” Balin says. “Out of respect for our guests, Thorin is now allowing them to his rooms on a one-on-one basis. Just as a courtesy, since they came all this way; he has no intent of pursuing anyone.”
“That’s good,” approves Oin. “There’s no telling what may grow from this.”
“Whatever may grow, rest assured it will be sabotaged by the halfling and that reckless eagle,” says Dwalin. “If you ask what they’re plotting, this may well be it: to ruin Thorin’s chances at finding love again!”
“For Mahal’s sake, brother, will you chill out? For all we know Bilbo hasn’t even noticed what goes on at Thorin’s door.”
Dwalin shrugs. “I don’t trust that hobbit.”
* * *
Bilbo has noticed. For the last few evenings the noise around the king’s suite features a new element: doors opening and closing at regular intervals. Fifteen minute intervals, to be precise. Apparently Thorin has agreed to meet the visiting dwarves, giving each fifteen minutes of his time.
The first chance he got to see Bofur in private, Bilbo demanded answers. Your cousin says these guests are here to show Thorin a good time, and try to gain his affection. Yet you told me Thorin has feelings for me! Which one is it? But Bofur doesn’t want to give away any more secrets; he fears being disloyal to his king. Except it’s not a secret that said king has been advised to find a partner who could keep him on task; his focus has been drifting as of late. I wonder what they’re doing in there, Bilbo pointed uneasily to the wall that connects to the suite next door. It’s anyone’s guess, though I doubt they’re playing cards, Bofur grinned. And Bilbo regretted he asked.
...He hears the king’s guards unlock his door for the tenth time tonight. Some brief exchanges in Khuzdul, a lady’s voice, then the door opens, closes, and is locked. He wonders how many others are standing in the hallway; how many more will claim Thorin’s time. Do they enter in random order, or does Thorin take his pick from a select few. Have the dwarves learned about the incident the king was subjected to on the Mountain’s wall; will one of them make him forget such a humiliation for one night. Bilbo wishes he could be the one; but has learned, as of late, that plans tend to backfire when he wants.
Right. As of late, Bilbo has wanted things beyond his reach. But the small things... perhaps those he can still be good at.
He reaches into his pack and finds the mithril armor. Of course, Bilbo doesn’t take cheap shots: he didn’t see a need to wear it straightaway, what with there being peace and all. But now that Bofur has completely failed to reassure, the mithril is the only thing left to rely on, along with Gandalf’s words: Nothing spells love more clearly than the finest armor. So that is where Bilbo will begin. He may not know how to get Thorin Oakenshield, but he can still tackle the little things.
He puts the mithril on without wearing his coat, and slips outside the room.
* * *
The plan is this: Bilbo will say hello and mingle with the crowd. Perhaps someone will compliment him on his shiny garment; with some luck, comment on its price. Then Bilbo will be able to determine if it could “spell love” or not.
Sure enough, the dwarf guests are queuing up close to Thorin’s door; the guards don’t seem to mind. Bilbo approaches tentatively: it’s clear from the get-go not all dwarves are eager to say hello to him. Many size him up and down, not so much looking at the armor but at him. Some give dejected looks and walk away from the crowd. Others draw towards him, forgetting their place in the suitors’ line. Beautiful, salivates one dwarrowdam, mesmerized. By Mahal, he is gorgeous, groan a few voices behind. We’ve heard rumors of your beauty, noble kindness, brains of steel... but seeing you in person is something else. A feast for the eyes. Many simply stare, drinking him in even as Bilbo hasn’t opened his mouth to greet them.
“Master Baggins, if I’m not mistaken,” finally one of them dares, a chiseled warrior of the Dwalin type. “What do you say you and I get away from this crowd?” “Do we know each other?” “No. But that can be arranged,” grins the dwarf. “You guys... are not here to see Thorin?” Bilbo asks. “We were,” a choir of dwarves respond, approaching him with greedy eyes. “Not anymore.”
“Do you need anything, Master Baggins?” asks one of the king’s guards, who must have noticed the incessant circling around him. “Nothing. Actually, I...” Bilbo glances around. The number of Thorin’s candidates has dwindled, it looks like. “I’m here to see the king,” he says, and takes his place at the end of the line.
In an instant, more dwarves take their place behind him. At this point it’s hard to tell if they’re interested in Thorin or in him. All things aside: for getting a ballpark on the price of mithril, this may not be the best time.
* * *
Thorin looks really embarrassed to see him.
“I... Can I offer you something?” he says, I was not expecting you clearly present in the way he’s pacing nervously back and forth.
“Oh, no, thanks. I’m only going to be a minute,” Bilbo says. And Thorin has no choice but to sit.
Bilbo dives right in. “There’s a lot of commotion at your door these days. These dwarves... you are to marry soon, right?”
“It’s just a formality.” What is - the visits or the marrying - remains lost in the deep edge of Thorin’s frown.
“You know... seeing them put something in my mind,” says Bilbo as casually as possible. “Some tidbits about your culture I’ve picked up. Marriage, courting, that sort of thing. Yet I’m not entirely sure everything is correct. Will you help me put my knowledge to the test?”
Thorin looks relieved. “Of course. You can ask anything.”
“All right. Here’s one. Dwarves fall in love only once. True or false?”
“True.”
“Here’s another: one thing that can prevent a dwarf from pursuing the one they love is the certainty that their feelings are not returned.”
“True.”
“And the only other reason why a dwarf won’t initiate courtship is if said dwarf’s reputation...” Bilbo hesitates, “their honor has been tainted in some way.”
It’s too late to hope Thorin won’t suspect anything. But fifteen minutes is all Bilbo has; come what may, he is intent on using them.
Except Bilbo is not prepared for this response.
“False.”
“False?”
“A dwarf may choose not to pursue their One simply out of a desire to protect them.”
“From what?”
“From... a number of things. Selfishness. Greed. Possessiveness,” Thorin articulates passionately.
Is it possible that to protect has been Thorin’s reason all along, why he didn’t have the courage in the first place... That all Thorin wanted was to keep Bilbo away from the horrible memory of the ramparts. Did this memory stop Thorin from courting him; is it stopping him now. Is it possible that the reason Thorin didn’t pursue him was not loss of honor, but solely love and concern for him.
It certainly is: but it is equally possible Thorin never meant to court, but only to protect him.
“That’s interesting. I haven’t thought about that,” Bilbo says, eyeing the door with sudden interest. “Oh. I almost forgot. I have one more. This has nothing to do with courting, by the way. Can’t remember where, but I heard mithril is a valuable material in Middle Earth.”
No, he didn’t mean to be obvious by wearing it, thank you very much. And no, he didn’t hear it anywhere, other than his own mind.
“True,” Thorin says. “Mithril is not only the most expensive, but the rarest material found in Middle Earth.”
It’s definitely time to go now. Bilbo stands and makes for the door. “What about you?” he can’t resist taking a shot in the dark, because oh, Bilbo is pleased with the results of this Q & A. “Do you have any questions for me?”
Thorin fixes him with his piercing gaze. “None, other than the one I’ve already asked.”
Bilbo knows very well what he asked.
“I left Erebor because of you. And... I came back because of you.”
There. I’ve done it, he converses with the eagle in his mind. I used your line. It’d better be to good effect, or else!
If he had known about the conspiracy theories surrounding his return, Bilbo would probably have been more specific. For you, he would at least have said. As it stands, he is completely unaware that for Thorin, in light of recent events I came back because of you has a certain ring to it. Thorin is used to laughing at the “revenge theory”, of course; yet for the briefest moment, Bilbo’s line gives him pause, leaving him a bit reserved. Thus it is Bilbo is met with a lack of response.
He leaves the king’s suite. The guards motion for the next person to come in. The dwarves remaining in line look relieved to see him.
* * *
It’s a thing of beauty, logic. Bilbo loves how infallible, how flawless it is. You can’t defy it, really. Sure, there are obstacles in Nothing spells love more clearly than the finest armor. Gandalf could be misinformed on what dwarves use for courting, but. The fact is this: Thorin thought of Bilbo highly enough to give him not only the most expensive, but the rarest material found in Middle Earth.
This will do for tonight. He loves me, he loves me not... Bilbo will gladly focus on that, and ignore the clanking of doors unlocked, opened and locked again. After all, there’s nothing to worry about: fifteen minutes is nowhere near sufficient, even for a king, to fall for somebody new. On the other hand, as recent experience shows, to make a hobbit fall deeper in love with a king, fifteen minutes have been enough.
