Chapter Text
Six months later, the most unexpected guest appeared at the gates of Erebor.
A small company of Elves approached the Mountain, led by Lord Elrond. They had come without a ceremonial retinue, making it clear that this was not an official visit. The company knew of the deep and unusual bond between the Lord of Rivendell and the hobbit only through Gandalf, who by then had already left the kingdom beneath the Mountain, setting out on a new journey but promising to return.
So Thorin went out himself to meet the Elven lord.
For some time, the two stood in heavy silence until their guest finally broke it.
“I would like to see him,” Elrond said quietly.
Thorin merely nodded.
They walked through the halls of Erebor, now slowly coming back to life, where hammers rang once more and work was underway everywhere. Everything around them spoke of the kingdom beneath the Mountain rising from its ruins.
Only one path remained unchanged. The one leading to the ancient royal crypt.
Elrond stood before the stone sarcophagus for a long time. He said nothing, merely placed his palm carefully against the cold granite, as though hoping to feel some trace of the familiar presence.
Thorin did not disturb the silence. Only then did he truly understand how dear Bilbo had been to someone other than himself. Behind the Elven lord's calm, almost motionless expression lay the same dark grief that had tormented the king's heart for months.
But while Thorin mourned someone who should have remained at his side, there was something entirely different in Elrond's gesture.
The immortal ruler looked upon the hobbit as though he were saying farewell to a son.
When they finally left the crypt and stepped into the cool corridor, Thorin spoke quietly.
“Erebor is always glad to welcome Bilbo's friends. Please, stay for at least a few days.”
Elrond inclined his head slightly.
“Thank you.”
That evening, a table was prepared for the guests.
No one attempted to turn it into a celebration. The conversations remained quiet, and the long pauses seemed louder and more meaningful than any words could have been.
Only after some time did Elrond speak softly.
“Thank you... for giving us shelter. And for Bilbo.”
The table grew even quieter.
Thorin met the Elven lord's gaze and understood everything without needing an explanation.
Bilbo had been dear to him. Incredibly dear. And his loss had left a wound in that immortal soul that seemed unlikely ever to heal.
Balin, Dwalin, Bofur, and the others instinctively lowered their eyes.
For the first time, they saw not an ancient and wise ruler in Elrond, but a father broken by grief, mourning someone he had considered family.
“We will not stay long,” the Lord of Rivendell said, breaking the silence once more. “We will say farewell to our friend... and begin the journey home.”
“You may remain here for as long as you wish,” Thorin replied.
A faint, sorrowful smile touched Elrond's lips.
“That will not be necessary. But I am truly glad Bilbo found people he could call family. I think... he was genuinely happy with you.”
At those words, Thorin involuntarily lowered his gaze.
The meal ended in almost complete silence.
Everyone at the table was lost in their own thoughts, yet eventually all those thoughts led inevitably to the same painful truth.
Bilbo was gone.
Even after so much time and so many tears, it had not become any easier.
The following morning, Elrond and the Elves accompanying him set out on their journey home. Just before departing, the Lord of Rivendell descended into the crypt once more. He stood before the stone tomb for a long time, saying farewell to a part of his own long life. Only afterward did the Elves silently leave the Lonely Mountain.
Days passed, becoming weeks.
The bustle surrounding the visitors' departure eventually faded, and the kingdom beneath the Mountain settled back into its steady, familiar rhythm.
But one thing in the company's life remained unchanged.
The company gathered around the same table once more. After their journey, it had become their most cherished tradition. No matter how busy the dwarves were, several times a month they would put aside their work and share a meal together, just as they once had around a campfire or in Bilbo's cozy home.
And no one ever occupied the seat to the king's right. The one where the hobbit should have been sitting.
With time, it stopped being a conscious decision. It simply became the way things were.
But today, no one had touched the food.
Thorin's strange summons had caught everyone completely off guard.
The king sat at the head of the table, but he looked so exhausted that he might not have slept in many nights.
Balin was the first to break the tense silence.
“Thorin... has something happened?”
The king remained silent for a long time. It seemed he was desperately searching for words he had been unwilling to speak aloud until the very last moment. Finally, he slowly rose from his seat.
“A king is meant to lead his people toward prosperity,” he said quietly, but firmly. “To make decisions without hesitation. To offer hope when everyone else has lost it. His people must see strength in their ruler...”
He faltered. The tension in his clenched jaw revealed just how difficult the next words were to force past his throat.
“...but I can no longer be that king.”
A crushing silence descended over the table. No one dared interrupt him.
“Thorin...” Balin began quietly, but the king merely raised a hand, stopping him.
“One and a half years,” Thorin said, his voice carrying the weariness of an entire lifetime. “For a year and a half, I told myself this darkness inside me would eventually fade. That one day it would become easier. That I would learn to look forward, toward the walls of our home, instead of backward... toward the crypt.”
He shook his head, looking down at his clenched fists.
“But it never happened. Every morning, I put on the crown like shackles. Every decree, every council meeting, every song in these halls demands a spark from me that no longer exists.”
He paused.
“I am burned out... burned to ash from the inside. A king who rules only out of cold duty will not bring greatness to Erebor. Sooner or later, my condition will become a sentence for our people.”
His voice grew quieter.
“A ruler who no longer cares what tomorrow brings is more dangerous than any dragon.”
Balin let out a heavy, devastated sigh. He had watched Thorin slowly fade throughout all these months, becoming a shadow of his former self. He had seen the King's silent numbness beginning to concern both his advisors and his people.
“What exactly are you proposing, Thorin?” Balin asked quietly, although deep down he already knew the terrible answer.
Thorin straightened his shoulders and drew a single deep breath, as though preparing to step off a cliff.
“I want to abdicate.”
Chairs scraped loudly against the stone floor all at once.
“What?!”
“Thorin, have you lost your mind?!”
“You can't possibly be serious!”
Fili sprang to his feet, knocking over his goblet.
“But Uncle... you can't!”
“In all the history of our line,” Glóin said in stunned disbelief, “the rulers of Erebor have only ever left the throne upon their deaths...”
“Or when they are no longer capable of ruling,” Thorin replied calmly.
He spoke with remarkable steadiness and dull finality. As though he had already crossed that bridge within himself and made his decision long ago.
“My heart will remain in this Mountain forever... beside the one who rests in the royal crypt.”
He looked around the table.
“I am no longer the leader who won Erebor back for you.”
“And who exactly do you intend to give the crown to?” Dwalin demanded sharply, barely containing the anger and pain boiling inside him.
“Fili.”
Every gaze immediately turned toward the young dwarf.
The heir visibly paled and shook his head in horror.
“Uncle... no. I can't. I'm not ready.”
Thorin merely nodded slowly. There was no disappointment in his eyes. Only endless exhaustion.
“Then Dáin.”
He said it so calmly, as though discussing the appointment of another master to the forge. But that hollow indifference frightened the others more than anything else. It seemed that Thorin no longer cared who received the crown, so long as he could finally lay the burden down.
Dwalin shot to his feet. His massive fist slammed onto the table with a deafening crack, sending dishes and goblets rattling across the stone.
“Wake up, Thorin!” he growled, leaning forward. “Since when has Erebor become something secondary to you?!”
For the first time that evening, Thorin raised his head and looked directly into his eyes.
“It hasn't.”
The answer came instantly, without the slightest hesitation.
“Erebor has always been worth more to me than my own life.”
He paused, and his gaze grew distant again.
“That is precisely why I must leave. If a king is no longer capable of giving his people everything he has, without holding anything back... then he is no longer worthy of the throne.”
“Then let us help you!” Dwalin stepped closer, desperation ringing in his normally stern voice. “Give some of the duties to Balin. To me. To all of us, if you must! But don't throw away everything our ancestors died for, everything we fought so many years to reclaim!”
Thorin remained silent.
“Do you think Bilbo would have wanted this?”
Dwalin's words hung heavily in the air.
Thorin flinched as though he had been struck. For one brief moment, an almost inhuman pain flashed through his eyes, the same pain he had desperately hidden for all these months.
“Do not speak of him as though you know what he would have said,” the king replied quietly, a warning edge beneath his words.
Yet deep inside, he knew Dwalin was right.
“Then say it yourself!” Dwalin stubbornly pressed on, leaning across the table. “Tell us he would approve of you running away! Tell us he would want to watch you abandon the throne he helped you reclaim!”
“Dwalin. Enough.”
Balin's voice was unexpectedly firm, cutting through the rising argument. Dwalin turned toward his brother irritably, but the old advisor was not looking at him. His eyes were fixed directly on Thorin.
For several endless seconds, the hall was filled with ringing silence.
Then Balin spoke slowly, with deliberate emphasis.
“The Mountain blessed them.”
It was as though everyone at the table had stopped breathing.
“What...?” Bofur whispered.
Every gaze turned toward Thorin.
The king did not answer immediately. For a moment, he closed his eyes, as though gathering the strength to confess something he had kept hidden for far too long. Then he gave the faintest nod. That tiny gesture was enough.
“Is... is that true?” Fili whispered.
Thorin nodded again.
The hall fell into such profound silence that the quiet crackling of the torches against the stone walls became clearly audible.
The blessing of the Mountain itself.
To the people beneath the Mountain, it had never been merely a beautiful legend. Ancient tales claimed that Erebor bestowed its unseen sign only upon the rarest of bonds. Many dwarven couples lived together for decades, raised children and grandchildren, and yet never experienced that sacred response. But here, the blessing had been granted to a dwarf and a hobbit.
“When?” Bofur asked almost in a whisper.
“On the day of the coronation,” Balin answered, understanding how difficult it was for Thorin to speak of it. “When he swore his oath of loyalty to his people.”
Several dwarves exchanged bewildered glances.
Now they understood what had once seemed so strange. Why Balin had always treated the stories surrounding Bilbo's memory with such care, emphasizing the bond between the king and the burglar. Why, after the hobbit's death, he had been buried beside the royal line.
He had been recognized by the Mountain itself. By their home.
Dwalin slowly lowered himself back into his seat.
All the anger seemed to leave him at once.
“Why didn't you tell us?” he asked, his voice completely changed.
“I...” Thorin hesitated for a moment.
“Bilbo realized that the ritual was not an ordinary one. But I never told him what it truly meant. I wanted him to be the first to know everything.”
He lowered his gaze.
“And besides... I didn't want the people to remember him merely as the king's beloved.”
He dragged a hand heavily across his face.
“I wanted them to see Bilbo as a symbol of hope. As a legend of Erebor.”
A faint, warm smile briefly touched Thorin's lips.
“He was always a stubborn hero. Sharp-tongued. Completely insufferable at times...”
The smile faded almost as quickly as it appeared.
“...and the bravest creature I have ever known.”
No one at the table spoke.
“Now you understand why I cannot simply go on living as though nothing happened,” Thorin said, breaking the silence once more.
“Every day I walk past his sarcophagus. Every day I sit at this table and stare at the empty seat.”
His voice faltered.
“Every day I wake up thinking there is still something terribly important I need to tell him...”
Thorin's voice broke, becoming hoarse and hollow.
“...and then I remember that there is no one left to hear it.”
Fili lowered his head, hiding the tears gathering in his eyes.
Kili gripped his heavy mug so tightly that his knuckles turned white.
Even the usually straightforward Dwalin could find no words with which to argue.
