Actions

Work Header

An unfriendly halfling

Chapter Text

Manwë nodded slowly, giving the halfling permission to continue. There was not the slightest trace of irritation in his expression, nor any indication that he intended to interrupt. On the contrary, the Lord seemed to be deliberately giving Bilbo time to gather his thoughts and put into words everything that had weighed so heavily upon his heart for so many years.

That single gesture was enough to convince Baggins that his most frightening suspicions had been correct all along.

"I... I suspected that I had died that day," Bilbo admitted honestly.

For a moment, he lowered his gaze to his trembling fingers, which were tightly gripping the edge of his clothing.

"I knew that something about all of this... that it couldn't possibly be an ordinary dream. Everything felt too real. Too vivid. The pain of others, this incredible sense of grief... And then, somehow, I would just be pulled back."

He fell silent for a moment, frowning unconsciously as he sifted through the memories of the past several years.

"But I never understood why I came back to life," he continued more quietly, studying the elemental spirit's face. "Or why those horrible visions started tormenting me afterward. I still couldn't figure out what had happened to me."

Manwë let out a heavy sigh.

For a moment, the light surrounding him seemed to dim, and a deep, almost human weariness appeared on his face.

"Because we could not take you, Bilbo," Manwë said, his voice echoing softly through the vast chamber.

Bilbo slowly raised his eyes, confusion tightening something inside his chest.

"What?"

"Every night, your soul would slip free of its mortal bonds and come here, to the thread of history," Manwë explained evenly. "But never completely. A thin, almost invisible thread remained stretched between you and your body. That was why we could not take you. You became trapped on the very threshold, without even realizing it."

The hobbit listened silently.

"While you were here, you saw the past and the present. But that was not all." Manwë leaned forward slightly, his gaze becoming extraordinarily perceptive. "You were also shown the future. Not one fixed outcome, frozen in time, but countless possibilities. Everything that might happen if someone made a different decision. If someone chose another path. If a single event happened a moment earlier or later..."

The Lord fell silent for a moment, allowing the weight of his words to settle.

"We still do not know for certain how a mortal came to possess such a gift. Even among the Valar, there is no agreement on that matter. But at the moment your soul nearly left your body, something even stranger happened."

Bilbo tilted his head slightly, catching the change in his companion's tone.

"What?"

"The ability to see the future disappeared from everyone else."

Genuine, unmistakable astonishment spread across the hobbit's face. A realization slowly took shape in his mind. So the gift of prophecy had not merely awakened within him. Without even knowing it, he had taken it from the entire world.

"Everyone?" Bilbo repeated.

"Everyone," Manwë confirmed gently, without the slightest hint of doubt. "Elves. Men. Even us, the Valar. Everyone who had ever possessed even the smallest fragment of that gift."

For several seconds, Bilbo simply blinked.

His bewildered gaze moved from Manwë to the great cord of history and back again, as he struggled to process what he had just been told.

"So..."

"Yes."

The corner of Manwë's mouth lifted into a faint, warm smile, instantly easing some of the tension hanging in the air.

"It seems the souls of hobbits truly do conceal something quite extraordinary. Something even we do not fully understand."

Bilbo gave an incredulous snort.

He had interpreted that very differently.

"Very convenient that you figured that out now," he muttered, a hint of wounded indignation creeping into his voice. "After I spent years going half-mad and suffering through those nightmares."

Manwë merely shook his head.

The hobbit hesitated for a moment, but his stubborn curiosity eventually won out.

"And now...? I mean, after I came back... did your abilities return?"

"No."

Manwë answered with remarkable calm, without a trace of regret or concern.

"And, to be perfectly honest, we no longer need them," the Lord continued. "You see, even with the ability to perceive what lies beyond the present, we, the Valar, could never interfere with events in the way you might wish. We are permitted to observe, to guide, and occasionally to warn... but we have no right to simply rewrite the fate of every living being who happens to be in danger. The freedom to choose has always belonged to you."

Manwë studied Bilbo more closely, catching the brief flicker of skepticism and irritation that crossed his face.

The hobbit immediately reined himself in and forced the reaction down.

"But I will be honest with you," Manwë continued. "At the time, we were... very surprised."

"By my nightmares?" Bilbo asked.

"By your strength of spirit."

Bilbo frowned slightly.

"I don't understand."

"You truly did die that day, Bilbo Baggins," Manwë said gently, and for once, genuine admiration resonated in his normally composed voice. "But even after crossing the threshold, you refused to let your soul completely separate from your body. Something extraordinarily strong within you clung to life, stubbornly holding on to this world. You never fully came before us. We could see you. We could feel your spirit nearby... but we had no power to take it."

He paused for a moment, allowing the hobbit to absorb his words.

"For a mortal, such an act of will was almost impossible."

Bilbo said nothing.

"And yet," Manwë continued, "we were genuinely glad."

"Glad that I was unbearably stubborn?" The corner of Bilbo's mouth twitched.

"In a way," one of the Valar replied with a small shrug. "But above all, we were glad that your death did not become the beginning of the terrible war you saw in your dreams. Had events taken even a slightly different path, Middle-earth would have drowned in blood. We would have lost hundreds of thousands of our children: Elves, Men, Dwarves... The Shadow would have fallen over every land, and the consequences would have been far worse than anything you could possibly imagine."

Bilbo did not answer. Slowly, he turned his gaze toward the great cord woven from countless shimmering threads of fate.

He looked at it differently now. There was no longer the childish fear he had once felt, only a heavy, crushing understanding. He had finally received his answers.

They had simply come far too late.

So many years...

So many endless, agonizing years spent trying to solve the mystery.

Trying to understand why fate had been so cruel to him.

Why every night he had been dragged into other people's lives, forced to experience again and again events that had not yet happened, watching entire peoples die in futures that, thankfully, were never meant to come to pass.

Now everything finally made sense. The pieces had fallen into place. And yet...

Somehow, knowing the truth did not make him feel any better. If anything, the weight in his chest only grew heavier, replacing confusion with a quiet, profound sadness.

"I hope you have found all the answers you have been searching for?" Manwë asked softly.

Bilbo kept staring at the cord of fate for several more seconds, studying the countless glowing threads woven together within it.

Then he slowly, heavily nodded.

"Yes. Thank you."

Manwë said nothing. He simply raised one hand and swept his palm gently through the air.

The white surroundings seemed to burst apart in a wash of light, spreading in every direction until Bilbo once again found himself standing within the majestic circle of the Valar.

They were waiting for him. Calm, almost imperceptible smiles rested upon their immortal faces.

It was as though they were not seeing off some ordinary mortal, but someone whose quiet resilience and stubborn determination had somehow managed to alter the fate of the entire world.

Bilbo slowly took several steps across the glowing floor and stopped directly before Aulë. For a while, the hobbit simply stared at the Smith of Arda in silence, gathering his courage and searching for the right words.

"Could I... ask for one last thing? Before I go?"

Aulë raised his thick eyebrows in surprise, clearly not expecting such a request, then glanced questioningly at Manwë.

Manwë exchanged a look with his brother before turning his attention back to the little hobbit.

For several brief moments, a ringing silence filled the magnificent hall.

At last, Aulë smiled warmly and gave a slight nod.

"Of course, Bilbo."

The hobbit's shoulders visibly relaxed, as though an enormous weight had suddenly been lifted from them.

"I want to see the company."

Manwë's brows immediately drew together, a note of warning appearing in his eyes.

"Bilbo..."

"I mean, just look at them," Baggins quickly clarified. "You can observe what's happening in Middle-earth somehow, can't you? So you can simply show them to me? Just for a moment... I want to know they're all right."

Manwë fell silent. Compassion flickered in his deep eyes. Perhaps, after everything this little hobbit had endured, refusing him now would simply be too cruel, even for the Valar.

The High Lord gave his brother the slightest nod.

Aulë raised his mighty hand and swept it through the air.

The space before Bilbo shimmered with a faint golden ripple, and an image appeared out of nowhere.

It was not merely a flat illusion or a flickering picture. It was as though a window had opened before Bilbo, leading directly into distant Middle-earth. Muted sounds drifted through the translucent surface. The familiar scent of a hearth and pipe smoke seemed to seep through the opening.

And around a massive oak table sat those who had become dearer to him than most things in the world. A company of foolish, stubborn dwarves.

They were gathered around the table. At first glance, it might have looked like an ordinary meal. Steaming dishes sat before them, someone held a heavy mug of ale, and another absently tore pieces from a loaf of bread.

But Bilbo immediately sensed that something was wrong.

An unnatural, oppressive silence hung over the table. No one was laughing loudly over the others. No one was breaking into one of their rowdy songs. No one was trying to cheekily steal the best piece of meat from his neighbor.

Even the usually restless Kíli sat with his shoulders slumped, staring down at the oak boards.

Fíli, who normally would have been teasing his brother, sat completely still, like a statue.

Old Balin stared thoughtfully at nothing in particular, slowly stroking his silver beard.

And Thorin...

Bilbo held his breath as his gaze settled on their leader.

The King Under the Mountain sat at the head of the table, but he looked as though only a shadow of the dwarf he had once been remained. His shoulders seemed unnaturally heavy, as though the entire weight of the mountain rested upon them. The regal light had gone from his eyes. On his stern face lay the despair of a man reliving a loss he still refused to believe had truly happened.

Bilbo took a step forward.

He cautiously raised his trembling hand and touched the surface of the glowing window with his fingertips. The surface rippled beneath his touch, gentle circles spreading outward, but the image did not disappear.

The hobbit simply stood there, unable to tear his eyes away from those for whom he had come so far.

Those because of whom he had somehow managed to endure it all.

"Forgive me..." he whispered into the silence.

None of those sitting there, among the cold stones of Erebor, could hear him. Distance and the very boundary between worlds stood between them. But Bilbo could not remain silent.

"Perhaps we'll never meet again... and all because of my foolishness."

A faint smile touched his lips. It was soft and sad, the sort of smile that could make even an immortal heart ache.

Manwë silently stepped closer and, with surprising gentleness, rested his great hand upon the halfling's shoulder.

"You will meet again, Mister Baggins," the Lord said.

Bilbo slowly turned his head toward him.

"Here, in the Blessed Realm," Manwë continued. "Where the boundary between life and death will one day cease to matter to each of them. In time, they will all reach the end of their mortal journeys and return to their Creator. And then... then you will be together again."

Bilbo remained silent for a while, absorbing Manwë's solemn words. Then his gaze returned to the glowing image. He watched Thorin for a long time. The dwarves sitting around the table in silent mourning. Those who were grieving his death with every part of their hearts.

And then, quite suddenly, the expression on the hobbit's face began to change. The sadness did not disappear, but something else began to emerge beneath it.

At first, it was barely noticeable. A tiny spark in the corner of his eye. A slight twitch of his eyebrow. Then it grew clearer, spreading across his entire face.

Bilbo slowly turned toward Manwë.

A smile spread across the disheveled halfling's face. Far too cunning. Far too playful. And entirely, indecently pleased for someone who had just been listening to a speech about eternal rest.

"And who told you," Bilbo drawled, a faint challenge creeping into his voice, "that I'm planning to go beyond the veil at all?"

The hall fell silent.

Manwë stared at him, momentarily stunned, and slowly blinked.

Aulë froze, his raised hand remaining suspended for a moment before he slowly lowered it.

Several of the Lords and Ladies of Arda exchanged looks of genuine, almost childlike astonishment.

Bilbo, meanwhile, no longer looked anything like a mortal who was prepared to meekly and gratefully accept his fate.

"So, let me get this straight," the hobbit began, pointedly counting on his fingers. "I come here, clean up your messes, deal with problems you've apparently ignored for years, and solve things you couldn't be bothered to solve yourselves? You just sit back and watch while I save your peoples? I stop a war you weren't even able to prevent yourselves?!"

He took a decisive step forward, pointing a finger at the stunned Valar.

"And after all that, I'm supposed to die too?! For the sake of your precious harmony?!"

His voice had taken on that unmistakable, steely edge of stubborn determination. The very same tone with which he had once managed to make an entire company of headstrong dwarves, led by Oakenshield himself, stand in line and listen to his orders.

"You don't just owe me a second chance at life. You owe me for the rest of your immortal lives! Until the end of time, if you had an end of time!"

Manwë's mouth opened slightly as he prepared to respond.

Bilbo immediately cut him off with an authoritative gesture, not allowing him to get a single word out.

"Answers?!" the hobbit scoffed, giving the Lord a deeply skeptical look. "Did you honestly think a couple of pretty speeches would be enough for me?! What in Arda made you think that was going to work?!"

For several seconds, not even the sound of breathing could be heard in the magnificent hall.

The Lords of the Elements stood there as though struck by lightning, while a tiny halfling shattered centuries upon centuries of their assumptions about the obedience of mortals.

Bilbo folded his arms across his chest, lifted his chin slightly, and stared directly into the embarrassed faces of the Valar with absolute, defiant confidence.

"I'm not going beyond the veil just because you were all too cowardly to get off your divine backsides and actually do something when it mattered!"