Chapter Text
Several of the Valar immediately exchanged bewildered glances. Others turned toward Manwë with puzzled expressions, as though he were somehow expected to provide a reasonable explanation for this completely unexpected and rather alarming turn of events.
Only Aulë, standing slightly apart with his arms folded across his mighty chest, was quietly smiling into his thick beard. He was doing his absolute best to maintain the stern, dignified expression the situation supposedly called for, but he was not doing a particularly convincing job of it. Mischief danced unmistakably in the corners of his eyes.
Bilbo caught the Smith's reaction at once and gave a short, knowing snort.
"I'm not some great hero from your ancient ballads," he said calmly, but with unmistakable firmness. "And I'm certainly not that naive, good-natured hobbit from the Shire who will listen to a couple of pretty explanations, get answers to a few questions that have been haunting him, and then happily forget about the whole thing."
He paused, slowly looking around at all the assembled Valar.
"Do you really think I'm just going to nod, politely say 'thank you for everything,' and meekly let you send me beyond the veil?"
None of the immortal lords answered.
A heavy, almost funeral-like silence settled over the magnificent hall.
"Morgoth... Sauron... and all the other dark filth that's been wandering around your lands with practically no consequences for centuries," Bilbo continued, and the steel in his voice grew sharper with every word, carrying all the righteous anger he had accumulated over the years. "You knew perfectly well what was happening in Middle-earth. Every second of it! You watched entire peoples die, ancient kingdoms crumble, babies become orphans, and grieving parents bury their own children. And yet you preferred to sit here, on your shining thrones, sadly watching from the sidelines and leaving all the responsibility to your own mortal creations!"
He tilted his head slightly, giving the Valar an openly skeptical look.
"What? You didn't want to get your hands dirty or waste your divine power on the lives of a few insignificant, foolish mortals?"
"We have no right to interfere directly with the natural course of events or the fate of mortals, Bilbo," Manwë replied.
"Oh, of course! Naturally!" Bilbo drawled, planting his hands firmly on his hips. "How could it possibly be otherwise?"
"That is precisely why the Istari were sent to Middle-earth," the Lord of Arda tried to explain. "To guide and inspire..."
"Five wizards?!" Bilbo interrupted.
His face twisted into an expression of such profound disbelief that Manwë might as well have just suggested defending Erebor from a dragon armed with nothing but a kitchen knife.
"Five old men against Sauron, who forged the Ring using the power and knowledge of your own brother?! What kind of childish nonsense are you even trying to feed me?"
Manwë's brows drew together, and for a moment a stormy light flashed in his eyes.
"Bilbo..."
"No, no, explain it to me. I'm just a stupid little halfling trying to understand!" Bilbo continued, taking several steps across the glowing floor. "Your evil brother gets to interfere whenever he feels like it. The Maiar, who were created alongside you, apparently get to interfere too. But you? You're somehow special, untouchable, and perfectly clean?!"
Bilbo gave a theatrical, deeply sorrowful sigh, folding his arms across his chest and shaking his head with exaggerated sympathy.
"Oh, poor, unfortunate Valar... It must have been terribly difficult for you, sitting comfortably on your backsides and watching your children die! Would you like me to feel sorry for you? Pat you on the head and tell you everything is going to be all right?"
Several of the Valar visibly stiffened, and a heavy wave of wounded divine dignity rolled through the hall.
Bilbo paid absolutely no attention.
"One war after another! Generation after generation buried in the earth! More meaningless deaths, more lives shattered and trampled into the ground! But no, of course, there was absolutely nothing you could do!"
He suddenly leaned forward, fixing Manwë with a biting stare.
"Because what? Were you afraid Eru would scold you? Maybe put you in the corner for a couple of Ages for bad behavior?!"
Behind Manwë, Aulë finally broke.
The Smith of Arda let out a quiet but unmistakable snort before burying his face in his thick beard and laughing.
Several of the other Valar immediately turned toward him, glaring sternly and indignantly.
"What are you all looking at me for?" Aulë replied, utterly unperturbed. He no longer made any attempt to hide his broad, genuine grin. "He's right. Every word of it."
Manwë gave his brother a long-suffering look and turned back toward the disheveled hobbit, trying to restore some semblance of calm to the conversation.
"Bilbo, if we had intervened with all our power..."
"And what?!" the hobbit cut in immediately, not allowing him to finish. "The continent would have sunk again?! Or history would simply have ended without a million pointless deaths?!"
He gave a short, humorless laugh, bitter amusement absent from his expression.
"Maybe children would have grown up with their parents. Maybe families wouldn't have lost the people they loved more than anything. Maybe entire peoples wouldn't have had to spend Age after Age rebuilding their lives from ruins and ashes after yet another one of your 'necessary' wars?"
The hobbit took another step forward, utterly unconcerned by the fact that immortal lords towered over him.
"What a terrible catastrophe that would have been, wouldn't it?"
He stopped directly in front of Manwë, forcing the Lord to look down at the small but utterly unyielding halfling.
"Just admit it already. This stupid, convenient rule of yours isn't there because you truly couldn't do anything."
Manwë remained silent.
"You were simply afraid."
The words echoed heavily through the vast chamber.
"Who better than me to understand what can happen when you interfere with the course of events?" Bilbo continued, his voice still firm. "I've seen it. Every bloody night! I've seen dozens of possible outcomes. I've seen what the smallest decisions can lead to. I knew perfectly well that anything I did could change everything and destroy everything I cared about."
He swept one commanding hand toward the glowing hall around them.
"And I did it anyway. I did what I believed was right!"
A bitter yet incredibly proud smile returned to his face.
"And look at that! Somehow, the world didn't explode."
Behind Manwë, Aulë once again failed to hide his reaction. A broad smile spread beneath his beard, this time filled with genuine respect.
"The people I cared about more than life itself survived," Bilbo added more quietly, his voice filled with deep conviction. "Yes, I made mistakes. Sometimes very serious ones. Sometimes my decisions nearly led to the worst possible consequences. But I acted! I didn't sit helplessly by and watch the people I cared about die. I made decisions. And, most importantly, I took responsibility for every single step I took!"
Bilbo shook his head with genuine disappointment, giving the Lord a sorrowful look.
"Apparently, Great Eru never taught you that, considering that after all these Ages, you still never even tried to truly help us."
A heavy, almost physically oppressive silence followed his words.
The Valar exchanged silent glances.
For the first time in countless Ages, something resembling uncertainty had appeared upon their usually regal, impassive faces. None of the immortal lords seemed eager to answer.
Only Aulë, standing slightly apart, practically radiated delight. The Smith of Arda looked as though he were watching not the most audacious argument in the history of Arda, but a long-awaited and immensely entertaining performance in which a tiny mortal was tearing down centuries of divine assumptions one by one.
Bilbo, entirely unbothered by the silence, continued pressing his point.
"You received a foretelling from Eru long ago that history would, one way or another, eventually unfold as it had been intended in His Music... and then you simply left everything to run its course!"
He pointed accusingly at the Valar.
"You are the last people who have any right to decide my fate!"
He jabbed a finger against his own chest.
"I'm the one who fixed your mistakes. I did the work you simply couldn't be bothered to do yourselves. And now, as a perfectly respectable hobbit, I expect to receive a proper reward for it."
Manwë stared at him for a long time.
There was bottomless sorrow in his sky-blue eyes. The Lord had no intention of arguing or defending himself.
At last, he slowly shook his head.
"Forgive me, Bilbo..."
The High Lord raised his hand smoothly, preparing to weave the spell that would open the way beyond the veil and send the mortal on his final journey.
"Well... if you truly don't care about the lives of everyone else..." Bilbo began mildly.
Then his voice dropped, and he fixed the Lord of Arda with a dark stare.
"...perhaps you might at least care about your own."
Manwë's raised hand froze in midair.
Every Valar present turned toward the little halfling at once. A sudden sense of danger swept through the hall.
"What?!" several divine voices exclaimed almost simultaneously.
Manwë slowly lowered his hand and studied the hobbit's face.
"Did you receive another vision before your death, Bilbo Baggins?"
Bilbo merely shrugged, slipping his hands into his pockets.
"Well... let's say I did."
"And what exactly did you see?" the Lord demanded.
"That's where I'm not telling you anything," the hobbit replied with a smug little snort.
Dark creases appeared across the brows of several immortal lords. A deep, ominous hum seemed to gather throughout the chamber.
Bilbo, however, simply smiled at them with an innocent, almost childlike sweetness.
"But without my humble assistance, you're going to be attacked very soon."
The radiant hall instantly seemed to grow colder. For a moment, the brilliant light itself appeared to turn into a leaden shadow.
"And quite possibly," the hobbit added calmly, tilting his head, "killed."
Manwë slowly looked around at those gathered before him. He studied the faces of his brothers and sisters as though trying to determine which one of them might be a traitor. But there were no obvious clues. No one looked away. Every great spirit wore the same expression of confusion and concern.
Even Ulmo, Lord of Waters, who usually possessed an almost impenetrable calm, was now frowning thoughtfully as he watched the others from beneath his heavy brows.
"Very well," Manwë finally said. His voice was quiet, but it echoed throughout the hall, making the air itself seem to vibrate. He turned his luminous gaze back toward the small, disheveled hobbit.
"Little mortal... if you truly possess knowledge of what is to come, and if you can protect me from the coming attack, I will return you to life. Your soul will be restored to your body."
Bilbo raised an eyebrow skeptically, in no hurry to celebrate.
"Just like that? After all those speeches about non-interference?"
"I have given my word," Manwë replied firmly.
There was the weight of a great oath in those few words, an oath that even the Valar could not break.
With that, Manwë lowered himself onto the glowing floor directly before the hobbit, crossing his legs in a lotus position and closing his eyes.
"We shall have Ulmo judge both our dispute and the purity of your actions. He is among the wisest and most impartial of us."
Ulmo gave a barely perceptible nod, accepting the role without saying a word.
"Agreed," Bilbo said, slipping his hands back into his pockets as he looked down at the god sitting before him. "The attack will happen within the next ten minutes."
Manwë gave a slight nod without opening his eyes.
"Very well."
"The clock starts now. This very second," Bilbo stated.
And the nerve-racking countdown began.
For the first few minutes, absolutely nothing happened. The silence in the hall became so dense it seemed almost possible to cut it with a knife. The Valar, momentarily forgetting their own grandeur, warily surveyed their surroundings. Each of them kept glancing at the others, judging who was standing closest, whose hands were clenched, who might be preparing to strike. If this strange mortal truly had seen the future, then someone in this very hall was about to attack.
But who?
And how?
Manwë remained seated on the floor, perfectly still, almost carved from stone.
Aulë stood nearby. He appeared completely calm, but his sharp eyes examined every inch of the chamber.
Ulmo watched Bilbo silently and without blinking.
The other Lords and Ladies of Arda grew more restless and tense with every passing second, nervously waiting for an attack to come from nowhere. Even those Valar who had considered the halfling's words nothing more than an audacious bluff or a foolish joke only minutes earlier had begun to seriously doubt themselves.
The air in the hall seemed to thicken with unseen danger. The minutes continued to slip away. But nothing happened.
No flash of dark magic. No sound of approaching footsteps. Not even the slightest disturbance in the winds of Valinor.
Ulmo continued watching Bilbo with particular scrutiny.
The Lord of the Deep, who could perceive what lay hidden beneath the surface, slowly studied every detail of the hobbit's posture: his relaxed shoulders, his confident stance, the barely perceptible movements of his fingers. And then the stern expression on the Lord's face changed. The corner of his mouth lifted ever so slightly. Understanding flashed in his eyes. He had realized it. He understood the brilliant simplicity of the hobbit's plan. But, faithful to his role as impartial judge, he said nothing.
Time continued to pass.
Mahal, Aulë himself, who had been genuinely fond of the stubborn burglar from the beginning, shifted uneasily and cast Bilbo a concerned glance.
The hobbit, meanwhile, remained perfectly calm. Far too calm for a mortal whose fate was being decided at that very moment. And then, with only moments remaining before the fateful ten minutes were up, Bilbo made a sudden, practiced movement and drew his faithful blade.
The edge flashed briefly in the radiance of the hall.
Several of the Valar immediately assumed defensive stances, elemental energy swirling around their hands.
Bilbo paid them absolutely no attention. He simply rotated the blade slowly in his hand a couple of times, with the practical air of someone checking the balance and weight of a weapon. Then, with a soft click, he slid it back into its sheath.
Aulë blinked in confusion.
"What are you..."
But Bilbo merely resumed his innocent expression and waited.
The final seconds passed.
Manwë slowly opened his eyes. His sky-blue gaze was clouded with confusion as he rose from the floor with a deep breath.
"Time is up," Manwë announced, his voice echoing through the chamber.
Several of the Valar immediately exhaled in relief, releasing the heavy tension that had gripped them for the past ten minutes. Some allowed themselves to relax. Others exchanged glances. A few of the immortal lords looked at the little halfling with open sympathy.
"I'm truly sorry, Mister Baggins," the High Lord said quietly but firmly, slowly raising his hand to fulfill his duty and finally send the hobbit beyond the veil. "No attack has taken place."
Bilbo said nothing. He remained standing with his hands in his pockets, still watching Manwë with that same playful, cunning glint of a true burglar.
And then, over the stunned silence of the hall, Ulmo's deep, rumbling voice rang out.
"Bilbo Baggins has won."
Manwë froze, his raised hand suspended in the air. He sharply turned his head toward his brother.
"What?"
Ulmo calmly and unhurriedly turned his majestic gaze toward the High Lord.
"He fulfilled your condition exactly."
A deafening silence filled the radiant hall.
The Lords and Ladies of Arda stared in stunned disbelief, their eyes darting between the satisfied hobbit and the Lord of Waters, whose lips had curved into the faintest, warmest smile.
"Manwë, kindly fulfill your side of the bargain."
