Actions

Work Header

An unfriendly halfling

Chapter 61

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Ulmo,” Manwë said at last. He kept his eyes fixed on his brother.

“Does your wisdom speak through you... or is it your love for our creations?”

Ulmo merely smiled. There was something gentle in that smile, yet utterly unwavering.

“Both,” the Lord of Waters replied.

There was not the slightest hint of embarrassment or regret in his voice. He stood before the High Vala calmly and confidently, making no attempt to hide his amusement.

“Even if you believe I outwitted you, you were the one who asked me to be the judge. And I have given my verdict. In my opinion, Bilbo won.”

Manwë’s expression held a mixture of irritation, faint surprise, and a dawning realization that the argument he himself had established the rules for was already lost. Eventually, as the truth of it sank in, the Vala let out a heavy sigh.

“Very well,” he said at last.

Bilbo immediately perked up. He straightened his shoulders proudly and looked directly at the High Vala with a faintly challenging, utterly unapologetic gleam in his eyes.

“Follow this tunnel,” Manwë said, slowly raising a hand toward an arched passage that had opened nearby, carrying the sweet scent of fresh air. “At the end, you will find yourself at the foot of Carrock. From there, you may go wherever you please.”

Bilbo gave a satisfied little grunt and happily shoved his hands deep into the pockets of his rumpled waistcoat.

“Sounds more than good enough to me.”

He had already taken his first step toward the open passage, savoring the thought of freedom, when he suddenly stopped at the threshold and glanced back over his shoulder. A mischievous grin spread across his dusty but utterly delighted face.

“See you around,” he called cheerfully to the immortal rulers.

With that, the halfling stepped lightly across the threshold and disappeared into the cool darkness of the tunnel.

Bilbo had only walked a few steps, listening to the hollow echo of his own short footsteps against the smooth stone, when another heavy, measured tread sounded behind him. The stone beneath his feet seemed to tremble ever so slightly beneath the weight of those footsteps.

He turned around and saw Aulë.

The Creator of the Dwarves was following him, catching up with the halfling in broad, confident strides. The Smith of Arda practically radiated genuine delight. It was as though an entire treasury of precious stones had been lit within his mighty chest. The fact that a tiny mortal had just managed to outwit Manwë in front of the entire pantheon did absolutely nothing to dampen his mood. He smiled into his magnificent beard, his eyes bright with laughter.

“Bilbo,” Aulë asked with enormous, undisguised curiosity as he caught up with him, looking down from his impressive height. “Come on, admit it. How did you manage to trick Manwë? Or did you somehow arrange this with Ulmo beforehand? My brother cannot stand lies or deceit. I simply cannot understand how you managed to get the Lord of Waters to agree to such a thing!”

Bilbo merely glanced sideways at the great smith, raising one eyebrow.

“I didn't trick Manwë.”

“But you didn't protect him from any attack,” Aulë protested, spreading his hands in confusion.

“Actually, that's exactly what I did,” Bilbo replied in the same perfectly calm tone, never breaking stride.

Aulë stopped so abruptly that he nearly struck a spark from the stone floor with his massive foot. He stared at the hobbit with such profound, almost childlike confusion on his broad face that Bilbo couldn't help sighing and muttering under his breath.

“This is starting to sound painfully familiar...”

The hobbit didn't wait for the bewildered Vala to recover and simply continued walking. A few seconds later, he finally explained.

“When Manwë told me he simply had no right to bring me back to life, I was so angry that I was ready to jump him right then and there. Or at least punch him in that magnificent face of his.”

Aulë looked down at his tiny companion with a wary, slightly skeptical squint, apparently trying to imagine the scene.

“But I didn't. I didn't even try,” Bilbo continued, shrugging slightly as he shoved his hands deeper into his pockets. “I didn't attack him. I managed to get hold of myself and stop. And by doing that, I protected him from my own anger.”

He fell silent for a moment, scratching the tip of his nose as he searched for the most precise way to explain it.

“After all, nobody in that hall could have known for certain whether I had even the slightest chance of hurting him. Maybe I did. Maybe I didn't. But as long as I hadn't attacked him, there was still a potential threat, however small. And I prevented that threat myself.”

Understanding slowly spread across Aulë's stern face.

Then the Smith of Arda threw back his head and burst into genuine, booming laughter. The sound was so powerful that the echo rolled through the tunnel and made the stone walls vibrate.

“Now I understand! Very clever!” the Vala laughed, wiping away a tear.

Bilbo gave a short, satisfied chuckle.

“I'm glad at least one of you appreciated the whole performance.”

They continued down the tunnel.

The stone corridor gradually grew darker, damper, and colder. The soft, dazzling light of the Valar's realm had been left far behind, while ahead lay the darkness of Middle-earth, slowly taking shape like night itself.

Bilbo had no intention of continuing the strange conversation. In truth, he would have preferred to walk the rest of the way to Carrock in complete silence, simply enjoying the sound of his own footsteps.

But then Aulë spoke again, and this time there was not a trace of his earlier amusement in his voice.

“You know... even we Valar cannot see everything that lies here, on the very boundary between life and death. I followed you for a reason, Bilbo. I wanted to apologize.”

Bilbo raised an eyebrow in surprise and turned his head toward him.

“Apologize? What for?”

Aulë fell silent for several seconds, gathering his thoughts. His heavy gaze dropped toward the stone floor.

“For making you suffer for so long. And so terribly.”

Bilbo stopped dead. The truth about all those painful years came crashing down upon him with devastating clarity.

The endless nightmares that had made his temples throb. The accursed, agonizing gift of witnessing hundreds of deaths and countless unborn, shattered futures. The maddening inability to simply die and be done with it.

Slowly, the hobbit turned his entire fragile body toward Mahal. A dangerous, icy fire ignited in his narrowed eyes.

“So it was... you?”

The words escaped his trembling lips in barely more than a whisper. Yet that whisper cut through the darkness of the tunnel more sharply than any thunderclap.

The Creator of the Dwarves let out a heavy, remorseful sigh. His broad shoulders seemed to sag beneath the weight of a burden he was not accustomed to carrying.

“Yes,” Aulë answered quietly.

There was no trace left of his earlier grin, excitement, or easy humor. Only a deep, heavy guilt that seemed to have accumulated over an eternity.

“I was the one who kept your soul bound to your body. I cursed you so that you could not die before your appointed time... until the Ring was destroyed.”

Bilbo stood frozen, his fists clenched, unable to utter a word as a bitter, suffocating knot rose in his throat. Every word from the Vala struck against wounds that had only just begun to heal.

“I didn't know what it would lead to,” Aulë continued, meeting the hobbit's eyes without trying to look away. “I had no idea what terrible, inhuman price you would have to pay for my interference. But the lives of my children depended directly upon your choices. Every last one of them. So I bound you to them, hoping you would find the home I had taken from you.”

The Smith of Arda lowered his gaze toward the cold stones beneath his feet.

“I'm sorry. But I simply couldn't allow you to die before your time.”

Bilbo remained silent for a long while, listening to the dull pounding of his own heart.

“So...” he finally said, each word heavy with realization, “you are the one... who caused all those nightmares.”

Aulë simply nodded. He made no attempt to justify himself or soften his guilt.

“Yes.”

Bilbo exhaled heavily and shakily, slowly dragging a hand over his exhausted face.

All those years of suffering suddenly had a simple, desperate explanation.

That was why the nightmares had faded whenever he slept beside Thorin.

His soul had finally stopped wandering. It had found somewhere to remain, firmly tethered to the Dwarf who had become his one true home.

“I saw what your death would lead to, Bilbo,” Aulë continued quietly, his voice almost aching with pain. “And I simply could not allow this world to fall into the hopeless nightmare I had seen. So I had to act in secret, against every law and convention...”

He gave a bitter, self-deprecating chuckle and shook his massive head.

“And deceive my own brothers.”

Bilbo frowned for a moment, feeling the first wave of anger subside, replaced by pure hobbit curiosity.

“But how did you manage that?”

“I created a special artifact using the Primordial Darkness. With it, I deprived the others of their ability to hear the Music of Eru,” Aulë whispered, as though the walls of the tunnel might still overhear his secret. “I simply couldn't allow them to discover what I had done. If the other Valar had seen the same future I had, they would inevitably have tried to stop me. But the artifact had no effect on you. By then, your spirit had already been torn away from the Song and was drifting on its own.”

Bilbo fell into a long silence, staring down at his feet.

For all those endless, agonizing years, he had believed his visions were nothing more than a meaningless curse that was slowly destroying his mind and robbing him of peace.

Now he knew they had been the terrible, unavoidable price for a chance to change fate, save his friends, and simply keep living.

“Well...” Bilbo finally said softly, a hidden warmth in his voice. “I suppose I'm the one who should thank you, then.”

A warm, slightly mischievous smile appeared on his weary face. The hobbit bowed politely, with all due respect, placing one hand over his heart.

Aulë stared at him in surprise, clearly not expecting such a reaction from a mortal who had endured so much pain.

“Because of your audacity and this cruel ordeal, I became who I am now,” Bilbo continued, straightening and meeting the Smith of Arda's gaze without hesitation. “Not merely a frightened Baggins, but a strong halfling with enough will and strength to protect everything I care about. And, honestly, it is comforting to know that among all these immortal and rather self-important rulers, there was at least one who truly cared about our little mortal lives.”

Aulë stared silently at the hobbit for several moments.

Then his face lit up with another warm and genuine smile.

“I am truly glad, Bilbo, that you were able to see it that way.”

The great Smith of Arda slowly bowed his head to the little hobbit in return.

There was no trace of grandeur in the gesture. Only profound gratitude.

“And thank you once again for saving my sons,” he said quietly, his words carrying considerable weight. “You saved them despite the fact that those stubborn fools repeatedly tried to make your life difficult.”

Bilbo couldn't help laughing softly.

“Oh, you're putting it very mildly, great Aulë! Getting in the way, ruining plans, and creating drama out of absolutely nothing... I believe it's a family trait. Passed down in the blood.”

They continued onward through the corridor, which was gradually sinking into a peaceful silence.

For a while, the hollow echo of their mismatched footsteps was the only sound in the cavern. But little by little, step by step, the darkness ahead began to thin, and far in the distance a narrow, trembling strip of light appeared.

The exit.

The closer they came, the brighter and warmer the light became.

The first scents reached them: damp earth still fresh with dew, pine, and fragrant wild herbs.

Bilbo involuntarily slowed his pace.

The unreality of the moment tightened around his chest like an iron grip.

When he reached the very edge of the arched passage, the hobbit stopped completely, spellbound by the sight before him.

Beyond the invisible threshold stretched a real, living world, beautiful as ever.

Golden sunlight poured over endless green hills. The grass swayed softly in waves beneath the cool, fresh breeze, while somewhere nearby, high among the thick crowns of ancient trees, birds called to one another in bright, carefree melodies.

Bilbo stood frozen at the boundary between light and shadow.

He hadn't even realized when he had crossed the entire distance, but now he stood directly before the exit, holding his breath and almost afraid to place his bare foot upon the grass.

An uneasy thought flashed through his mind.

He had no idea how much time had passed down there, in the world of the living, while he had been among the Valar fighting for his right to live.

To him, everything that had happened felt as though it had taken place only yesterday.

But beyond that threshold, life had continued moving forward.

And now he stood before its final door, returning from nothingness itself, standing at the very boundary between eternity and life.

“Are you afraid?” Aulë asked quietly from just behind his shoulder, without the slightest trace of mockery or superiority.

Bilbo did not answer immediately.

He stared at the valley bathed in generous golden sunlight for a long moment. Then he drew in a deep, greedy breath, filling his lungs with cool, fresh air.

“A little,” he finally admitted, feeling a faint tremor run through his fingers.

Aulë smiled warmly, almost fatherly, with the protective affection in his eyes once again.

“Well, then. I hope that next time you come to my halls, it will be only when you are truly ready, and after you have lived a long and happy life.”

Bilbo gave a short but sincere chuckle and glanced over his shoulder at the great Vala, narrowing his eyes playfully.

“Next time I'll try not to stay too long. There are far too many arguments, grand speeches, and rules around here. I'd rather spend my time in Yavanna's peaceful gardens... or in your forges... than standing trial before you lot.”

The Creator of the Dwarves let out a deep, warm laugh, and once again a faint vibration passed through the stone walls of the tunnel.

Bilbo took one last look at the radiant, inviting world ahead.

Then he straightened his stiff shoulders, shoved his hands into his pockets, and gave Mahal one final, grateful nod.

“Until next time.”

“Until next time, Bilbo Baggins,” the Vala replied softly and solemnly, remaining at the boundary of the shadows.

The hobbit lifted his chin, drew one more deep breath, and finally stepped across the threshold, into the sunlight and the new day.

Notes:

I’ve realized that I actually know Tolkien’s universe much more superficially than I thought. 😭

Originally, I thought that the Silmarils, which Morgoth wanted so badly, contained some kind of powerful force, so my initial idea was for Aulë to use one of them. However, I later found out that the Silmarils don’t actually possess any kind of power, which threw a rather large wrench into my plans. 😂

But by then, the entire plot I had in my head was already built around the idea that Mahal had deceived all of his brothers, used some kind of power, and taken away their abilities. So I had to figure out a way to make it work.

I also found out that Ungoliant wasn’t simply one of the Maiar, but was instead created from the Primordial Darkness that existed even before the Valar. I honestly don’t know whether the Valar can interact with something like that, but I couldn’t find another way to write this scene without completely turning the canon upside down... which, admittedly, I’ve already done plenty of times. 😂

So please forgive me for this little plot twist. 😭 I really hope it doesn’t ruin your enjoyment of the fic too much. 🤗🤗

And thank you all so much for your support, your comments, and all the theories! ❤️ It really means a lot to me!