Actions

Work Header

Bond of Rescue

Chapter 3

Notes:

Warning for discussion of parental death and social ostracism.

Chapter Text

Bilbo’s guts started churning when they came within a day’s ride of Michel Delving.  He told himself they had provisioned themselves well in the Blue Mountains and there would be no need to stop.  But there was, and they did, and now the farcical ruse he cooked up with Bofur has blown up in his face like Griffo Boffin’s attempted recreation of Gandalf’s fireworks.

It’s for the best, truly.  He never wanted any part of this strange dwarrow tradition, but he did want to control his means of escaping it.  Now that control has been ripped away by some gossipy Bracegirdle.  That’s unfortunate, but there’s no use crying over it.  No use regretting…  Bilbo’s gaze drifts unwillingly to Thorin still beside him, but he wrests it back quickly.  He doesn’t want to see how those handsome features have darkened.  It will be painful enough once he learns the truth.

That’s been the hardest part, and the most unexpected- the sting Bilbo has felt eerily close to his heart at every scoff and glare and eye-roll from his briefly betrothed.  Still, he’s persevered, coming up with as many ways as he could to present himself as the world’s greatest fusspot and fool. But then he had to spoil it all, accepting Thorin’s help with his troublesome bandage and promptly forgetting his little plan.  It was just so easy, and it felt so good, like stepping into the sun after days spent indoors.

But now he’s remembered.  Feeling good like that isn’t meant for one such as him.  His fellow hobbits have made him exquisitely aware of this fact.

Caught in a swell of bitterness, he hears himself quip, “I suppose you thought dropping my name would get you the bargain you were after.  I do apologize for any disappointment.”

“Thank you,” Dis replies icily from where she stands over him, “So, do you know where your spouse and children are, or…?”

Shock jolts Bilbo to his core and his eyes almost bug out of his head as he sputters, “What?!  No, I- I’m not- Dis- L-Lady Dis, I am a bachelor, as I told you!  I have no spouse, and no children.  Unless…” He lets out a small cough as his newly recovered honesty compels him to say, “Unless certain people are keeping very big secrets from me.”

Bofur snorts, stifling it in a cough of his own at Dis’ glare, even as she does seem to relax slightly.  “Fine,” she says, “Then what family is it, exactly, that you did abandon?”

Bilbo lets his shoulders slump as he releases a sigh.  Perhaps he ought to thank whoever Dis encountered for allowing him to keep this much control over his confession.  So far, there’s been no indication that his ruse has convinced any of the dwarrow that he isn’t suitable for marriage, but surely now they will see.  He’ll get what he wants in the end.  He just has to endure this unpleasantness first.

With his eyes trained on the campfire, Bilbo begins, “I’m not a very typical hobbit, one might say.  If I was, I would value food and cheer and song above most everything else.  And- it’s not that I don’t see the appeal in those things, I do, but none of them are what my heart has cried out for, as long as I can remember.  All I’ve really wanted… is to travel.  To step into the road and let it sweep me off my feet.  I come by it honestly.  My mother, Belladonna Took, was quite the same.  But you must understand, most hobbits hardly travel as far as Bree, let alone all the places she and I have gone.”  He allows himself a faint smile as a hundred memories flutter through his mind.  “I must have visited most everywhere west of the Misties.  Clambering over those blasted peaks is always a chore though, so the east holds a few mysteries for me yet.  But I’ve seen your mountain, in Rhovanion.  Twice, actually.  It’s lovely.  I am sorry about the dragon.”

Dis executes a gracious nod and gestures for him to continue.

“Not only do hobbits largely refrain from travel, they consider those who don’t to be… well, less than respectable.  My mother made up for it by being rich and well-bred, and then by marrying my father, Bungo Baggins.  There are trees that are less rooted than he was, and I’m not talking about the ents of Fangorn.  But my mother loved him, and he built her a beautiful smial, and they were happy for a time.”

“That’s very nice,” Dis states, “And then?”

Bilbo looks to the fire again, hoping its heat will ward off memories of bitter winds and cascades of snow.  “And then there came a winter, the fiercest in a generation.  The Fell Winter, as it was called afterwards.  On the heels of a bad harvest, snow fell in blankets for weeks.  Then the Brandywine River froze, allowing wolves to stalk the Shire.  They took my mother when she was foraging for root vegetables.  We had to leave her out there for days, until we could be sure the wolves had moved on, until the ice had thawed enough that we could gather and burn- what was left.”

Their hearth fire had been small, like the campfire Bilbo now stares into.  The rationing of wood had begun early.  He had stared into the flames then too, while silent tears welled up and spilled down his cheeks and his gaunt and grieving father had clung to him like he was the only solid thing in the world.

“The Shire… never really felt like home, after that.  People may look at me and see the second edition of my father, but my mother and I shared a spirit.  With her gone, I was truly alone.  And so, I traveled, going as far as I could, seeing all the things she’d seen and things she’d not gotten the chance to see.  I’d be gone for months at a time.  But I always came back, to the love of my father, and the- the disapproval of everyone else.  He was never quite the same either, after the Fell Winter.  Always a little weak, a little frail.”  Bilbo pauses, lowers his head and shakes it.  “Ah, but there I go again, making excuses.  In truth, he was ill.  And I…  I didn’t want to see it.  I didn’t want it to interfere with how I lived.  So I left him.  Again and again, I left him.  Until one day I came back… and he had left me.  He had to stay with my uncle Longo, near the end.  He was too weak to care for himself.  And I wasn’t there.  He was alone.  Because I had left him.”

Nothing unites the Baggins clan like a common enemy.  Bilbo might have thought he was enduring his own personal Fell Winter, so icy was the treatment he received from every blood relation he could name.  And, plague-like, word of his crime spread from every Baggins home.  Soon the Tooks disowned him just as fully.  Bolgers and Bracegirdles turned up their noses in the road.  Chubbs and Proudfoots refused his custom in the market.  Even the kindest of them all, the Gamgees, could only suggest that he take on the Blue Mountains trade route.  It would allow him to earn some coin and, far more importantly, keep him out of the Shire as much as possible.  He couldn’t travel anymore.  Maybe, deep down, he hoped this trip to the Mirrormere would break the mithril chain of guilt that shackles him to Eriador.  He supposes he’s moments away from finding out.

“And so you see, Lady Dis, I did abandon my family.  I left my own father in his final days, to indulge my unnatural urges.”  His gaze leaves the fire and fixes on her, daring her to scorn him, like all the others did.

Somehow, he doesn’t find the familiar ire in her expression.  She seems pensive instead.  After a long moment, she asks, “Was your mother’s desire to travel ‘unnatural’?”

Bilbo bristles automatically, because that is absurd.  Belladonna Took was the living embodiment of a brisk spring breeze racing over the hills.  Only love could stay her, and it was a love she chose.

In answer to his tongue-tied umbrage, Dis says, “Just so.  If the mother is not unnatural, neither is the son.”

Bilbo’s mind contorts around the statement that contradicts what all hobbits who weren’t his parents have told him, yet he knows in his heart to be true.  “Fine, fine,” he peevishly concedes, “But I could have stayed.  When my father needed me, I could have stayed, and I didn’t.  I left him.”

Then Thorin speaks, and Bilbo wishes his voice didn’t feel like a warm cloak draped around his shoulders.  “I told you our mother died in Smaug’s attack.  I did not tell you how our father died.”  He manages to turn his gaze to Thorin and watches him exchange a nod with Dis before continuing, “Some time after Erebor fell, our grandfather Thror grew obsessed with the idea of reclaiming Moria from the orcs and Durin’s Bane.  He gathered what forces he could, even conscripting children to fight, and marched on the kingdom.  His kin followed him, all but Dis.  Only I returned.  Our grandfather and brother were cut down.  Our father Thrain…  There were reports of him wandering on the edge of the battlefield, near a cliff, but when the fighting finally stopped, he could not be found.  And so, as my father’s heir, the decision rested with me.  Cast all our energies into searching for him, or don’t.  I made the choice that we should limp away from the battle, and continue our bid for survival.  Some years later, we discovered that our father had been captured by the enemy, tortured to the point of madness, and left to die, alone.  I must live with that.”

Staring at Thorin’s regal profile, Bilbo can hardly believe what he’s hearing.  It’s almost as if Thorin is trying to comfort him.  He even seems sincere, but Bilbo can’t let this misguided attempt go uncorrected.  “You chose the survival of many over the survival of one.  Terrible as the loss of that one was, you, as leader, made the only choice you could.  And his fate in the end was not your doing.  I, meanwhile, chose my own selfish desires.  If I had simply stayed, couldn’t I have helped my father?  Even if all I did was hold his hand as he passed?”

At some point, Balin took a seat by the fire and lit a pipe.  Now, he expels a puff of smoke and asks, “What did you last speak of together?”

Bilbo blinks, and forces his memory back to the sunny day when he left his father to die.  “I… I told him I was going west.  To see the Grey Havens.  A short trip, no more than a month.  It was meant to be, at least.”

“And what was his response?  Did he ask you to stay?”

“No.  He said what he always said.  He wished me good luck, fair weather, and safe travels.  Said I would be in his thoughts, wherever I went.  I think I recall…  He once told me he imagined my mother like that.  That she wasn’t gone, not really.  She was just… still traveling, out on the road, with the sun on her face and the wind in her hair.”  To this day, Bilbo does the same, often.

“If it’s not too bold to say, perhaps the thought of you and your mother traveling brought him comfort.  Perhaps more comfort than if you had dutifully stayed by his side, and watched him diminish.”

The memory fills Bilbo’s mind with painful clarity.  Bungo sitting on the bench outside Bag End, smiling as Bilbo prattled on about his plans, totally unaware that his health was moments from failing.  Or maybe he was aware.  Maybe, when Bilbo hugged him goodbye, he released his son as one might a bird, delighted to see him take wing and flit away, never expecting to see him again.  Somehow, this sweet fantasy where Bungo didn’t die cursing Bilbo for his negligence makes his throat ache with a sob.

“I… I don’t know.  I cannot know.  I wasn’t there to ask.”

He lowers his head, and covers his eyes with both hands.  Tries to even out his breath, only to have it stutter as Thorin’s wide, warm palm presses between his shoulder blades.  He should shrug it off.  He should stand and leave.  Now is the time.  But no one tells him to go.  Not that day.  Or the day after that, or the days that follow.  So he stays, because it’s easy, and it feels good.  Even if he doesn’t deserve it.