Chapter Text
After the confession, the company breaks camp and continues on. Bilbo rides in silence, looking gray and exhausted next to Bofur at the back of the line. Fili rides with Balin, Kili with Dwalin. Both boys are quiet, but they’ve been casting looks at Bilbo and, probably sooner than the hobbit wishes, will surely inundate him with questions about his travels. From his place at the head of the line, Thorin tries not to let the turmoil of his thoughts distract him too much from their surroundings. The last thing they need is a bandit ambush. It’s less likely as they enter the marshy terrain south of the Shire, but never impossible. Particularly for a company of dwarrow.
Some hours along the Green Way Dis brings her pony up alongside him, catching his eye with a look that is half determination and half apology. Clearly she’s decided that it’s time for them to talk.
Instead of releasing a sigh, Thorin quietly asks, "What did the hobbit in Michel Delving tell you?"
“Not much, really,” Dis answers, her voice also lowered, “Just some blather about the Mad Baggins choosing his unhealthy fascination with travel over duty to his family and how we’d be better off not associating with him.”
Thorin won’t deny his resentment over being driven out into the world in search of extra coin, but that doesn’t translate to rancor against those who travel by choice. That doing so would condemn Bilbo amongst his kin and kind seems harsh to say the least, even if it did lead to him missing his father’s final days. But how was he to know how dire the situation was, if Bungo didn’t tell him? If, as Bilbo stated, Thorin shouldn’t feel guilty for Thrain’s fate which he knew nothing of, then neither should Bilbo. But it seems the hobbit has yet to follow his own logic.
Thorin drags his attention back to Dis as she continues, “I'm glad to have the facts now. Glad to have his honesty. It's been bothering me since we left. His manner didn't seem to match the hobbit I first met. Someday I will ask what he hoped to achieve with his ridiculous behavior, but for now I must ask you- has his dishonesty made him unworthy in your eyes?” At Thorin’s surprised look, she lowers her voice further to say, “We can end this, if you choose. I apologize for not giving you much of a choice from the beginning. I just... Something about him called out to me. But perhaps I was swept up in my relief and gratitude for the boys’ safety. What do you say, brother?”
Thorin considers, and after a moment replies, “I think it too soon for permanent decisions. With his deception ended and the truth out, only now will we begin to gain the full measure of Bil- Mas… Bilbo. We shall carry on.”
“Until?”
“Until Tharbad. It is our last stop before the mountains, it will be easier to part ways there, if that is what we choose.”
“What you choose. I won’t make the decision for you again, you have my word.”
“Very well.”
The pair ride in silence until a youthful exclamation from behind has them peering back. Bofur has come up between Balin and Dwalin and presented Fili and Kili with small wood carvings. Kili is already marching his tiny dwarrow soldier up the mane of Balin’s pony while Fili balances his own on his nose.
Thorin smiles at his nephews’ joy, then glances over at Dis. She is also smiling, a very particular smile that he hasn’t seen for many years, one that could only be earned by a very particular dwarf, or so Thorin thought. “A skilled woodcarver,” he remarks, and Dis starts and whips around to face forward.
“Who- what is?” she blurts before scowling while a blush creeps up from under her beard. After a moment she briskly states, “Wise of Master Bofur to keep the boys occupied. We must stay vigilant. I doubt the road to Tharbad is any better than it was the last time we-”
She stops, perhaps remembering who was with her when she last traveled to Kheled-Zaram. Who isn’t here now. There is a flash of something like shame on her face that Thorin dislikes greatly.
“Times may have changed since then,” he says gently, “We shouldn’t assume things must remain the same, especially if… if there are good changes that might be made.”
Dis looks over at him, mouth opening, then closing. She looks ahead. “Think on your decision, brother. We’ll reach Tharbad before you know it.”
They keep riding.
---
Along with Bofur, Bilbo provides a useful distraction for Fili and Kili when, as expected, they start questioning him about all the places he’s been. Thorin is grateful to them as their cheerful interrogations seem to boost the hobbit’s spirits. As for himself, he hasn’t made conversation with Bilbo beyond what’s needed as traveling companions. He can’t seem to find a way back to that one surprising moment of closeness they shared. Perhaps because he’s not sure if he wants to.
Figuring out what he does want only becomes more difficult as they approach Tharbad, a town of men sunk into the north bank of the Greyflood River. Homesteads appear along the Green Way, other travelers pass them coming and going, and Thorin feels eyes on him and his company. As he always does. As any dwarf does. It weighs down his bones with a specific fatigue. Of course there are bad sorts among any folk, but Thorin would appreciate not being lumped in with them on sight, when he isn’t suspected of hoarding gold in every nook and cranny of his person and possessions. He blames the elves, of course. They pour their prejudice into the minds of the men folk, who- easily swayed by a pretty, immortal face- proceed to take it as truth.
At least Bilbo knows better. Thorin blinks at the sudden thought. It occurs to him to wonder if Bilbo has ever traveled with dwarrow before, and knows to some degree how bad it could get. He almost wants to cast a glance in the hobbit’s direction, but something in his pride won’t let him. In fact, he sits tall in his saddle, and leads his company into Tharbad with all the dignity a son of Durin possesses. By Mahal, he is the Crown Prince of Erebor, no matter the state of him or his kingdom. His very presence honors this sweaty little town.
Calling up his lineage may soothe Thorin’s anxiety, but it’s perhaps not the right energy to start off with when they reach a tavern with an attached inn. Leaving Dwalin, Balin, and Bofur to mind the ponies and the boys, Thorin strides into the tavern with Dis and Bilbo trailing behind.
“Yes?” says the man behind the bar with no further greeting, which Thorin might have noticed if he’d been in a different frame of mind.
Dispensing with greetings himself, he declares, “My companions and I have need of a room. Six adults and two children, for the night. What is the price?”
“Six adults and two children, eh?” the innkeeper echoes in consideration. His gaze wanders over the group and Thorin’s skin crawls as he senses him wondering how much coin they simply must be hiding. “Ten silver pennies.”
Outrage flares in Thorin even as his mind scrambles to calculate how they can afford such a price. He’s almost too distracted to notice a squawk of surprise behind him. But he does notice Bilbo marching up to his side. “Ten silver pennies?” he repeats, voice ringing with disbelief, “Here now, I stayed in this establishment some years ago, when the price for a piece of mattress was some three coppers. Ten silver for a single room is quite the increase.”
Thorin can’t guess what the innkeeper’s experience of hobbits is, but he knows it’s not a dwarf staring up at him. “Yes, well, price is the price, little master,” he mutters.
“Indeed, the price is the price,” Bilbo says, his voice soft but cold, “In that case, it seems I must congratulate you. Surely you have prospered since my last visit, and must be able to offer the finest feather beds and lovely soft sheets, if that’s how much your hospitality costs these days. I suppose we can expect our meals to be delivered to our room too. Is that so?”
Clearly unequal to the task of managing an offended hobbit, the innkeeper’s head bobbles on his shoulders as he hedges, “Might do, maybe, depends…”
“Depends on what, exactly?” Bilbo pauses and waves a hand. “Never mind, I think we’d enjoy a plate of meat and cheese, a bowl of strawberries, two- no, make that three loaves of bread, and a nice pudding for dessert. For ten silver, that seems reasonable to me. Anything you’d like for dinner, Thorin?”
“Now see here-” the innkeeper starts, but is interrupted by a new voice coming from the tables spread among the open space to the left of the bar.
“Bilbo Baggins? Bilbo, is that you?” A man has risen from his seat and takes long-legged steps among the furniture until he reaches them. He wears sturdy traveling clothes, and his hair just brushes his shoulders in thick brown waves. His unfortunate beardlessness reveals a heavy jaw under dark, intelligent eyes.
“Tolson? Oh goodness, hello!” The man smoothly drops to a knee and accepts a hug from Bilbo. Thorin glances over at Dis, and does not react at all to her raised eyebrow.
“The one and only traveling hobbit, it’s been years!” Tolson exclaims as he releases Bilbo and stands. “I was half-convinced you’d died somewhere.”
“Can’t say I didn’t come close a time or two, but no, I’m- I’m quite well. How are you? I never expected to see you north of Lond Daer.”
“Oh, well, let’s just say I’m building up the nerve to wet my feet in the River Angren again.”
This somehow sends Bilbo into a fit of laughter. The thought wanders across Thorin’s mind that this isn’t how he wanted to see Bilbo’s eyes go bright and his cheeks go round and pink a second time. He’s about to clear his throat and introduce himself when the innkeeper delivers a loud harrumph.
Tolson turns a simpering smile on the man. “Oh, do excuse me, you were in the middle of a conversation, weren’t you? It’s only that Master Baggins and I traveled through here together once. We befriended a local lad too, I think his name was Wayred. Do you know him, sir? I believe his father was the sheriff in town.”
“Aye,” the innkeeper replies flatly, “Wayred’s taken his place now.”
“Did he? Well, stands to reason, he was very civic-minded when we knew him. Never wanted anything to besmirch the reputation of Tharbad. Perhaps I’ll pay him a visit, along with Master Baggins and his company. He might be kind enough to put them up, they only need one room after all. Unless…”
Bilbo and Tolson gaze at the innkeeper with enormous, guileless eyes. The man slumps down like he’s made of sand, though his lip maintains a sullen curl. “Five silver.”
The eyes get more enormous, more guileless.
He lets out an exasperated grunt and snarls, “Three. Three, and that’s final!”
“Splendid!” Bilbo cries, pulling out the purse in his coat pocket. “I’ll cover that, no problem at all. Here you are, sir.”
He does nothing to extend his reach, forcing the innkeeper to lean far over the bar to collect his coins. Tolson chuckles into his collar, then smiles widely again. “Well, now that’s taken care of, would any of you fine folk like an ale? We can settle down at my table and be properly introduced, as I’m sure Bilbo’s hobbit-y manners are currently demanding.”
“Oh, bebother you, Tolson,” Bilbo grumbles with undeniable fondness before turning to Thorin and Dis. “But anyway, yes, how does that sound?”
“Delightful,” Dis replies smoothly, “Let me fetch the others.”
It takes some cramming, and Fili and Kili making themselves a fort under the table, but eventually all are seated with mugs of ale and a plate of bread and cheese to share. Bilbo raises his mug and says with his gaze firmly fixed on Tolson, “To the civic-minded Wayred.”
The man rolls his eyes. “Oh please, Bilbo, like it wasn’t you who taught me that trick. I’m surprised you didn’t try it yourself back there.”
“Well I only just arrived, I didn’t have time for my usual inquiries.” As he registers the curious looks from his traveling companions, Bilbo coughs and raises his mug again. “Shall we say- to new friends and old.”
The toast is echoed and ale is drunk. Conversation carries on then, but it’s held almost completely between Tolson and Bilbo as they exchange reminiscences with minimal input from anyone else. That isn’t to say the evening is boring- the reminiscences are quite entertaining tales in themselves. And even if they weren’t, Thorin can barely tear his eyes away from Bilbo, who seems almost like a different hobbit. Or, like the hobbit from the moment they shared, but even more so. Unfurled now like a scroll that was once rolled tight, and Thorin would like to read each word, if only everyone else would kindly go away, starting with Master Tolson.
At one point, Dis frowns slightly and shifts in her seat before bending to peer under the table. Thorin does the same and finds Fili and Kili curled up on their mother’s feet, both sound asleep. “It seems it’s the children’s bedtime,” Dis says, “I think I’ll retire with them. I’ll just carry, ah…”
Bofur perks up. “I can carry one of them. If- if that’s all right.”
His cheeks glow like coals instantly, but Dis gives him a soft smile. “Very well. Thorin, could you get the key to our room?”
Thorin does as requested, and is not above smirking at the still sulking innkeeper as he drops the key in his hand. By the time he’s done, Dis and Bofur have made it to the door to the stairwell that leads from the tavern to the inn. Bofur, with Kili drooling on his shoulder, goes up first once Thorin has passed him the key. Dis stays at the foot of the stairwell and murmurs, “You know, if you’re not careful, your decision about Bilbo will be made for you.”
“I’m aware. Perhaps you might make a decision about Bofur tonight.”
That she can jab her elbow into Thorin’s side hard enough to bruise without Fili even stirring is quite impressive. As she stalks upstairs, he turns back to the tavern and feels panic spike at the sight of Bilbo and Tolson making their way to the door. Durin’s beard, am I too late already?
With a glance at Dwalin and Balin, who seem occupied with their own conversation, Thorin follows the pair outside. What he intends to do when he reaches them is unclear, but it doesn’t really matter, as his ears catch Tolson’s derisive voice saying, “… might have been there all night, the way dwarves haggle.”
“Dwarrow,” Bilbo corrects as Thorin eases into the shadows around the corner from him and Tolson.
“Right, yes, anyway, what are you really doing, tagging along with a group of ‘dwarrow’?”
“It’s just a walking holiday, for all of us. You’ll recall how I like those.”
“Of course, and I’m sure one of them isn’t carrying a contract that swears you to secrecy. Look, whatever they’re paying you for whatever job this is, I can counter it.”
“I thought you wanted to show me your new saddle, Tolson.” Bilbo sounds tired.
“I do! I also want to share with you an opportunity I’ve uncovered. It’s very simple, just ferrying deliveries of metal parts from Dol Amroth to Isengard. The wizard there, I’m told he pays handsomely.”
“A wizard, like Gandalf?”
Tolson barks out a laugh. “That dusty old wanderer? No, I’m talking about a proper wizard. Saruman the White, in fact. Surely that’s of more interest to you than chaperoning a gaggle of rock-crushers.”
Silence stretches, and Thorin holds his breath.
“That is interesting, Tolson,” Bilbo replies.
“I knew you’d think so!” the man crows while something in Thorin cracks. “Meet me at dawn, all right? We can be long gone before second breakfast. Do they even let you have second breakfast, my poor Bilbo? I know you weren’t so thin, last time I saw you…”
There’s the sound of movement and a brief rustle of clothing. Bilbo’s next words are strained. “I- I need to rest now. We’ve had a long ride today.”
“Of course, I understand completely. Good night, dear Bilbo. It really is wonderful to see you again. I hope to see you at least once more, tomorrow.”
“Good night.”
Thorin dashes back and slips through the tavern door as quickly as he can, not stopping until he’s thrown himself into a chair next to Dwalin, who peers at him closely. “All right there, cousin?”
Is he? He can’t say for sure. Before he can summon an answer, Bilbo appears at the table. “I think I’m off to bed now.” He gives a polite nod to the general group. “Good night.”
“Rest well, laddie,” Balin replies with a warm smile.
“G’night,” Dwalin grunts.
“Yes, night,” Thorin snaps, realizes how harsh he sounds, and forces himself to make eye contact with Bilbo and return his nod. It might be the last time he sees his face, after all.
The hobbit looks more confused than offended, which Thorin marks as a win. He nods again, then turns and heads for the stairwell.
Thorin sighs and hunkers down in his seat, waiting until Balin and Dwalin decide to retire, and trudging after them. Dis and the boys have taken the bed, Bofur and Bilbo are tucked into their bedrolls along the far wall. Thorin takes a spot nearest to the door. If anyone leaves the room, at dawn or otherwise, he’ll know, even if he does nothing about it.
It’s a long night. Thorin tries to sleep, while some other part of him tries to stay awake. The result is a fitful slumber that hardly seems to start at all until a ray of sunshine glows upon his eyelids. He opens them, and his gaze jumps with shameful speed to Bilbo’s bedroll. And his heart plummets with shameful force as he finds it empty. It is done then. Over. Without a word of parting or explanation, the hobbit has rejected his right as shaktûn mahinsês, and abandoned his might-have-been-betrothed.
Well, it’s not as if Thorin actually wanted to marry him. He’s still a stranger, and still not a dwarf. Not what Thorin wants at all. It would have been a mistake, a farce. A hobbit can have no place in the line of Durin. It’s for the best, truly.
Thorin rolls over, and curls up tight as if that might protect him from flashes of gold on brown curls, round-cheeked smiles, and gleaming crescent eyes in his memory. It was nothing. None of it meant anything. If it did, Bilbo would still be here.
“Thorin?”
He bolts upright.
Bilbo jerks back where he crouches next to him. “Oh! You’re awake.”
For a moment Thorin is too shocked to do anything but stare. “You… you’re still here.” His voice is rough and wondering, and it’s all he can do not to reach out and touch, make sure this isn’t a dream.
Meanwhile, Bilbo blinks, then studies him with a slight squint. “Thorin, were you eavesdropping when Tolson and I left the tavern?”
A little shame trickles through his astonishment and he admits, “It wasn’t my intention, but yes.”
Bilbo presses his lips together, his expression gone quite unreadable. “You know… I remember Tolson being better company. Perhaps he was, years ago. But not so much now. I… I’ll stay with you- your people, if that is acceptable. To you.”
“Yes.” It just pops out, and Thorin can’t take it back. Can’t replace it with something softer- “you’re welcome as long as you wish it,” or some other response with more words and less meaning. It seems his decision is made, for better or worse.
And yet, he’s blessed with that slow dawn of a smile. “Good. Privy’s free, by the way.” Bilbo climbs to his feet, and returns to his bedroll. Which of course he would have taken with him, had he actually left with Tolson.
Thorin lies back down, and doesn’t quite notice a smile dawning on his own face.
