Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

One More Moment

Summary:

As Thorin says his farewell on the ice, Bilbo prays for one more moment together. To his surprise, Mahal gives it to them. The only question is what to do with it...

Chapter 1

Notes:

This is inspired by an alternate take of Thorin’s death scene, featured in The Appendices of the Hobbit Trilogy, in which Bilbo looks up and asks for one more moment. I’ve always wondered what would have happened if someone up there had listened and granted his request. I hope you enjoy!

Chapter Text

It’s fair to say Thorin did not see this moment coming.

His last stand is over. Azog is no more. The Eagles are coming. The tide has turned: the battle will be won.

Questions float eerily in his mind. Why did you bring Fíli and Kíli into a death trap. Why did you value treasure over the lives of your kin. How could you choose war over peace.

There are no good answers, though everything he did, he did for them, his Company, his people, his grandfather’s memory. His actions made sense at the time, in a selfless way; he certainly didn’t claim this kingdom for himself.

Fíli and Kíli... He knows where one is. This one dies first, Azog said, and in the next moment the filthy lie Thorin could have scoffed at became truth. Where Kíli is, he can only guess.

If Kíli lived, could Thorin want to live. Would he ever be able to look into his nephew’s eyes again.

He thinks of his missing father. Thorin could never find him, never got word of him. For the guilt and shame of that failure and all of the above, he would gladly take the chance to die now.

Thráin’s image morphs into the Father Thorin has never seen, whom he’s undoubtedly about to meet. Mahal, his Creator, who is probably looking upon all this with disappointment. To him Thorin wishes to speak

“Father... I am not ready. But if you should receive me today...”

as his body is able to stand no longer; the ice takes him.

“Forgive me. I have failed.”

It’s not peace, but the coldest winter chill, this place that was immaculate hours ago. He is so tired, yet he will not find rest here, in the harsh coldness that envelops him.

And then it’s the strangest thing: he can hear a voice, equally from above and below.

The voice says, Take as long as you need, my child.

He’s never heard Mahal’s voice before. Perhaps his Maker is giving him time to prepare his soul. To figure out what he wants. Thorin never gave much thought to that before. Maybe there’s something good in it, worth pondering in this hour.

What he wants... There are no words, but he can imagine it. If he were to surrender to this pain, would the pain turn into a river flowing like leaves between the branches of a tree, giving life, healing everything. What would it take to surrender, to wash away all the sins, to heal all that he’s wronged. What would it take to be that living water, that tree.

To lose everything... Thorin already did. He lost his honor, the respect of those closest to him. He lost the chance at love he never had.

The questions return, bringing with them the one he was running from. It flutters unsteadily before his eyelids shut, as if the question itself is injured, struggling for breath.

How could you hurt the one you love... Why did you hurt him.

No, Thorin did not envision this. He will do his best to prepare, yet, for what is sure to come: an afterlife that cannot ever hold peace.

 

“Bilbo...”

“Shh... Don’t move. Lie still.”

There it lies, Thorin perceives at once, the impossible wish in Bilbo’s eyes. You’re not going anywhere, Thorin. You’re going to live.

“I’m glad you’re here. I wish to part from you in friendship.”

He marvels at the closeness, the familiarity with each other. How easy, how effortless to say these words in this darkest hour, to hold Bilbo’s hand and not fear he is overstepping.

“You did what only a true friend would do. I was too blind to see it. Forgive me...”

Tears fall on Bilbo’s cheeks inconsolably. Thorin can register the onslaught of emotions, can feel the sense of urgency in him. Bilbo’s horror, the hurt, the wish to save him as he always did. The need for forgiveness, Thorin can read like an open book. Bilbo regrets that he gave away the Arkenstone, that he underestimated the extent of Thorin’s hurt. It’s in his eyes, his tears, his shaky movements, I am sorry I betrayed you... I didn’t mean to cause you anger and pain... if I had known, I would have found another way...

It is all right. Can Bilbo not see there is nothing to forgive, other than perhaps the unspoken, secret thing: that Thorin fell in love with him.

“Farewell, Master Burglar. Go back to your books, and your armchair... Plant your trees, watch them grow. If more people valued home above gold, this world would be a merrier place.”

Hopefully Bilbo can take this heartfelt blessing and live, be happy in his Shire as no one deserves more to be.

...and then Bilbo does something unexpected. Bilbo prays, his eyes lifted to the sky, sincere and innocent.

“One more moment. Please. One more moment...”

The voice Thorin heard earlier comes again, louder this time.

“This is Mahal speaking. If it wasn’t clear the first time, I said TAKE AS LONG AS YOU NEED. Got it?”

Thorin and Bilbo regard each other uncertainly in that light, the sun peeking in and out of clouds, the sounds of battle silenced. The ice no longer feels cold, but warm and welcoming: they can stay a while.

* * *

Bilbo thought he could hide his feelings. He did admirably for the most part: on the quest, during his time in Erebor. But here and now his grief aches like an open wound as understanding slowly sinks into him.

Thorin is leaving.

This is not how the quest was supposed to go. Thorin would reclaim his throne, would live to see Erebor restored.

Yet as Mahal’s voice descends, sorrow changes into something like hope. As long as you need, take as long as you need.

Can I take forever, then, is the first thing that goes through Bilbo’s mind.

His heart is exposed raw like the ice that glows in the sun’s light, and it’s not enough: Bilbo wishes he could say this out loud.

His first impulse is to hail an Eagle, and seek someone who can administer proper treatment to Thorin’s wound. But Mahal probably meant Take as long as you need to say goodbye, nothing more. Not to mention, does Bilbo even have the right to ask for this: for Thorin’s life to be spared.

Does Thorin want to live, first of all. If he does not, then why did Bilbo make his request?

The truth is this: Bilbo didn’t think, when he made it, what he would use one more moment for.

 

But Thorin does know what to use it for. His eyes break through the fragile walls Bilbo hastily put together to deal with this situation, and pierce him with his firm, decided gaze. Thorin will speak now; of what, Bilbo doesn’t know. Whatever it is, he can hope it’s something that will take a long time to say.