Chapter 1
Notes:
This is inspired by an alternate take of Thorin’s death scene, featured in The Appendices of the Hobbit Trilogy, in which Bilbo looks up and asks for one more moment. I’ve always wondered what would have happened if someone up there had listened and granted his request. I hope you enjoy!
Chapter Text
It’s fair to say Thorin did not see this moment coming.
His last stand is over. Azog is no more. The Eagles are coming. The tide has turned: the battle will be won.
Questions float eerily in his mind. Why did you bring Fíli and Kíli into a death trap. Why did you value treasure over the lives of your kin. How could you choose war over peace.
There are no good answers, though everything he did, he did for them, his Company, his people, his grandfather’s memory. His actions made sense at the time, in a selfless way; he certainly didn’t claim this kingdom for himself.
Fíli and Kíli... He knows where one is. This one dies first, Azog said, and in the next moment the filthy lie Thorin could have scoffed at became truth. Where Kíli is, he can only guess.
If Kíli lived, could Thorin want to live. Would he ever be able to look into his nephew’s eyes again.
He thinks of his missing father. Thorin could never find him, never got word of him. For the guilt and shame of that failure and all of the above, he would gladly take the chance to die now.
Thráin’s image morphs into the Father Thorin has never seen, whom he’s undoubtedly about to meet. Mahal, his Creator, who is probably looking upon all this with disappointment. To him Thorin wishes to speak
“Father... I am not ready. But if you should receive me today...”
as his body is able to stand no longer; the ice takes him.
“Forgive me. I have failed.”
It’s not peace, but the coldest winter chill, this place that was immaculate hours ago. He is so tired, yet he will not find rest here, in the harsh coldness that envelops him.
And then it’s the strangest thing: he can hear a voice, equally from above and below.
The voice says, Take as long as you need, my child.
He’s never heard Mahal’s voice before. Perhaps his Maker is giving him time to prepare his soul. To figure out what he wants. Thorin never gave much thought to that before. Maybe there’s something good in it, worth pondering in this hour.
What he wants... There are no words, but he can imagine it. If he were to surrender to this pain, would the pain turn into a river flowing like leaves between the branches of a tree, giving life, healing everything. What would it take to surrender, to wash away all the sins, to heal all that he’s wronged. What would it take to be that living water, that tree.
To lose everything... Thorin already did. He lost his honor, the respect of those closest to him. He lost the chance at love he never had.
The questions return, bringing with them the one he was running from. It flutters unsteadily before his eyelids shut, as if the question itself is injured, struggling for breath.
How could you hurt the one you love... Why did you hurt him.
No, Thorin did not envision this. He will do his best to prepare, yet, for what is sure to come: an afterlife that cannot ever hold peace.
“Bilbo...”
“Shh... Don’t move. Lie still.”
There it lies, Thorin perceives at once, the impossible wish in Bilbo’s eyes. You’re not going anywhere, Thorin. You’re going to live.
“I’m glad you’re here. I wish to part from you in friendship.”
He marvels at the closeness, the familiarity with each other. How easy, how effortless to say these words in this darkest hour, to hold Bilbo’s hand and not fear he is overstepping.
“You did what only a true friend would do. I was too blind to see it. Forgive me...”
Tears fall on Bilbo’s cheeks inconsolably. Thorin can register the onslaught of emotions, can feel the sense of urgency in him. Bilbo’s horror, the hurt, the wish to save him as he always did. The need for forgiveness, Thorin can read like an open book. Bilbo regrets that he gave away the Arkenstone, that he underestimated the extent of Thorin’s hurt. It’s in his eyes, his tears, his shaky movements, I am sorry I betrayed you... I didn’t mean to cause you anger and pain... if I had known, I would have found another way...
It is all right. Can Bilbo not see there is nothing to forgive, other than perhaps the unspoken, secret thing: that Thorin fell in love with him.
“Farewell, Master Burglar. Go back to your books, and your armchair... Plant your trees, watch them grow. If more people valued home above gold, this world would be a merrier place.”
Hopefully Bilbo can take this heartfelt blessing and live, be happy in his Shire as no one deserves more to be.
...and then Bilbo does something unexpected. Bilbo prays, his eyes lifted to the sky, sincere and innocent.
“One more moment. Please. One more moment...”
The voice Thorin heard earlier comes again, louder this time.
“This is Mahal speaking. If it wasn’t clear the first time, I said TAKE AS LONG AS YOU NEED. Got it?”
Thorin and Bilbo regard each other uncertainly in that light, the sun peeking in and out of clouds, the sounds of battle silenced. The ice no longer feels cold, but warm and welcoming: they can stay a while.
* * *
Bilbo thought he could hide his feelings. He did admirably for the most part: on the quest, during his time in Erebor. But here and now his grief aches like an open wound as understanding slowly sinks into him.
Thorin is leaving.
This is not how the quest was supposed to go. Thorin would reclaim his throne, would live to see Erebor restored.
Yet as Mahal’s voice descends, sorrow changes into something like hope. As long as you need, take as long as you need.
Can I take forever, then, is the first thing that goes through Bilbo’s mind.
His heart is exposed raw like the ice that glows in the sun’s light, and it’s not enough: Bilbo wishes he could say this out loud.
His first impulse is to hail an Eagle, and seek someone who can administer proper treatment to Thorin’s wound. But Mahal probably meant Take as long as you need to say goodbye, nothing more. Not to mention, does Bilbo even have the right to ask for this: for Thorin’s life to be spared.
Does Thorin want to live, first of all. If he does not, then why did Bilbo make his request?
The truth is this: Bilbo didn’t think, when he made it, what he would use one more moment for.
But Thorin does know what to use it for. His eyes break through the fragile walls Bilbo hastily put together to deal with this situation, and pierce him with his firm, decided gaze. Thorin will speak now; of what, Bilbo doesn’t know. Whatever it is, he can hope it’s something that will take a long time to say.
Chapter Text
Don’t say I never did anything for you two, Mahal mutters as he watches with great interest from above.
A few things cross Bilbo’s mind as to what Thorin could say. Thorin... always focused, even when blindsided by the worst enemy. He may entrust Bilbo with his last wishes; instruct him on how to divide Erebor’s treasure; leave a message for the Company, for Dáin.
Bilbo hopes it’s all of the above, and more. Anything.
“Tell me a story,” Thorin says instead, gazing at him dreamily, with no care in the world.
“What?”
“While we’re here, suspended out of time. It would comfort me.”
It’s strange to behold Thorin, so calm and content, not wishing for anything that would, if not fight this terrible outcome, at least make the most of it.
“My nephews always praised your narrating skills. I never got the chance to see for myself. I was always too busy planning and brooding over my kingdom while you all told tales around the fire during our journey here. Now I wish I had listened more.”
Well. When he puts it like that, there’s no refusing him.
“I fear your nephews have grossly exaggerated my talent. But... I’ll try my best.”
And it occurs to Bilbo it’s possible he knows why he asked for more time. There is a chance here, unexpected, for certain things to be said, that would leave no doubt as to what Bilbo wished; wishes, still.
“In a hole in the ground, there lived a hobbit,” he begins apprehensively, trying to guess if Thorin had a novel or a quick summary in mind. As it stands, he’s used to always factoring in not wasting Thorin’s time: better keep it short.
“He thought he had it all, until a band of dwarves came to his house one night and invited him to go on a quest.”
Was that a smile from Thorin? Unlikely, but it’s possible this was a good idea, not just selfishly speaking.
“The hobbit was not into it at first. The dwarves needed a burglar, for which he didn’t think himself qualified; nor was he warrior material, and adventures, he reckoned, make you late for dinner.
How naive he was. As he was about to discover, dinner was a relative term: he was never going to view it the same way.”
Now there’s a definite smile from Thorin. Sweet Yavanna, it looks like his wound has stopped bleeding. His face regained color; there is no question he is enjoying this. And Bilbo wants nothing more than to make him smile like this forever.
“Before the night was over, the hobbit’s mind was changed, though he didn’t admit it to himself, nor did he spend time analyzing what changed it. One look in the direction of the Company’s leader would have clued him in, though. Where others tried to sway their host with words, the proud dwarf king impressed by his mere presence. Resolute, commanding and protective all at once, it spoke “follow me” without trying. And follow him the hobbit did, the next day, once he realized the adventure he had craved all his life had a name.”
Thorin regards him fondly. “Now I see what Fíli and Kíli meant. You have a way with words.” There is no hint of sarcasm in his tone; if anything, admiration.
“Together, the hobbit and the dwarves went through many things. They faced trolls, goblins, orcs, spiders, met with more or less friendly elves and Men... And with every challenge, the hobbit’s heart drew closer to the king. It was foolish, but he felt, beyond the layers of the dwarf’s personality, each one mind-blowing in itself, that he could really know him. Most of all, that he could know his heart: a heart so strong, fearless and also kind, that gave itself for the protection of those it held dear, every single time.”
It is settled: for the remainder of the story Bilbo will look anywhere but in Thorin’s eyes. Which is not altogether unfortunate, for in Thorin’s eyes there is protest now, and a hint of tears, which might cause Bilbo to end sooner than he planned. This moment, everything in it, belongs to Thorin: he’d better not ruin it.
“The closer they got to the lost kingdom, the graver risks they faced; yet danger magnified the trust between them, and only brought them closer. At the end of it all, none of their shared perils, not even the dragon awaiting at journey’s end, could truly separate them. The greatest of evils lay in their own weakness: for in a moment of desperation the hobbit betrayed his friend, and their bond was severed with no hope or time to mend it. The next second war was upon them, the dwarf king was lured into a trap, and the hobbit... for all he saw the danger and tried to protect the king’s life... he arrived too late.”
The tears return. Thorin collects them gently, his hand lifted to reach Bilbo’s eyes. And Bilbo thinks it’s useless to try: he could never find the right words, but what he means when he tries to describe Thorin is exactly this.
“You need not continue if it distresses you so.”
“Too late to save him,” Bilbo carries on; he will not skip this part, for it is only here that something so secret, so deeply heartfelt can be spoken. “Too late for saying all the hobbit wished to say. That after hearing “We’ll live to fight another day” hope smiled at him for the briefest second, only to be smeared by darkness; and darkness holds now over him with no courage left to say it, to make it clear what this person meant to him.”
If there is anything left, it is part of here and now, so Bilbo pauses, wondering what Thorin will allow. Thorin is silent, still.
“He has no wish to go back home and live. He would rather follow him. Even now, he would still follow him.”
Thorin’s fingers brush away his tears while his eyes search him endlessly with questions.
“What you said... Is this truly how you see me?”
“No. Far from it. I feel a lot more for you than anything I could say.”
“Bilbo... For you to follow me this time... I would never allow it. Yet I feel it is not too late. For you to tell me what you wished to say.”
And Bilbo thinks of all those stories where this would be the climactic moment: if a kiss could say it all Bilbo would kiss him now. But there’s the to hell with it part, I know it’s useless because you’re still leaving but what else can fill this time, tell me what is more logical, to let you go knowing we had time or to seize this hopeless chance, and of course, there’s lack of courage, though to be fair, facing the pale orc, fighting giant spiders or riddling with Smaug were nothing compared to what he’s just done; compared to what he’s about to do now.
“I love you,” he says finally, out of tears, trying to keep frustration at a low.
Thorin closes his eyes for a moment; takes Bilbo’s hand and presses it to his lips, and Bilbo wonders if it’s too late to update his prayer to Mahal, before the laws of this world come back into being and time regains its meaning.
“When I asked... when I asked you to tell me a story I hoped you’d find one that would never end. Because I do not wish to be parted from you.”
“I don’t want it to end,” Bilbo murmurs, ready to say I’m sorry, I guess I should have picked something with more potential. Can we start again.
“Tell me what happens next. Tell me what you wish for. There is time.”
It is true. There is time, and there is more Bilbo still doesn’t know how to express. And right now, he’s not sure if what happens next is continuing the story in a wishful thinking way, or just saying what he really wants; that against all hope, he wants Thorin to stay.
Chapter Text
I love you.
Just minutes ago Thorin waited for the end, pondering his wrongs, unsure if he could ever amend them.
Bilbo said he would follow him. And Thorin said, Tell me what happens next; for something else is present between them, has been from the moment Bilbo found him.
“In an ideal world,” Bilbo continues, “what happens next is the hobbit asks a higher being to grant life to his friend. Because the king deserves to live, and this being has the power to fulfill it.” Bilbo’s voice falters, perhaps afraid this is too direct considering Mahal can hear him, or scared that Thorin will reject his request.
“Bilbo...” Thorin gestures weakly, trying to lift himself up to Bilbo’s level. He cannot. “Come here.” Bilbo lies down on the ice next to him, his eyes searching for what Thorin will accept, things kept hidden in the solitude and secrecy of his heart.
“I have loved you since the first time you saved my life. And if Mahal granted me life today, it would be yours.”
There is regret and sorrow in these words; the finality of one who has no hope. Thorin’s hand reaches out to stroke Bilbo’s hair with endless adoration; Bilbo covers it with his own, and in his touch there is longing and relief. It is surreal, those eyes moments ago filled with pain now smile in blissful surprise, even as Thorin has not said yes to his happy ending.
“Do you wish it, son of Thráin? Do you want to live?” the voice of earlier speaks from above.
Bilbo changes instantly; rushes to adjust his position, fix his messy hair and beat-up clothes, but Thorin will not release him. He pulls Bilbo closer and envelops him in his arms. “I love you,” Thorin says as his arms close around the smaller figure, his strength now returned. “You’re all I ever wanted, all I want in the world.” And when he feels Bilbo surrender in his arms, then Thorin looks up to the sky, ready to face Mahal.
“I know you’ve been concerned about your kin,” his Maker presses on. “I can provide you with news of them.”
“Yes, Father. Please,” Thorin voices, and here he leaves Bilbo some room to breathe so as to shield him from incoming pain. “I do wish to know my nephews’ fate.”
“They both passed. A feast is being planned as we speak, to welcome them to my Halls.”
Thorin is silent; Bilbo can hear the unspoken I failed them, and the more worrisome My place is with them. He watches in horror how Thorin’s wound reopens, or is this an illusion, is it only his heart, so close to Bilbo’s that they feel as one, a heart that rages against the unfairness of it all; so close Bilbo can almost feel Azog’s blade in him, and still know to Thorin that was nothing compared to Mahal’s words just now.
Of which there are more. “By the way, your youngest nephew is in love with an elf. Focus on the positive, I told him. You saved her life, that’s something to be proud of. Instead he’s bummed he’ll never see her again.”
Kíli, love, young, youngest... Thorin’s mind wanders helplessly. If Bilbo’s wish is granted, maybe Thorin can switch places with Kíli; maybe Kíli can live instead. This is wrong, too, so many wrongs he cannot see the right thing.
Yet Bilbo’s hand rests on his heart reassuringly, keeping him on the ground and the clouds at bay.
“It would also interest you to know your father is dead,” Mahal delivers, really on a roll. “He came to the Halls a few days ago. On Durin’s Day, if I’m not mistaken.”
Thorin’s voice is a shadow in the dark. “How?”
“He was taken prisoner in Dol Guldur, and tortured for many years. The wizard Gandalf tried to rescue him, but underestimated the dark one’s power.”
Thorin. Thorin... Bilbo is with him, was with him until Thorin drifted, still dimly aware of surroundings, his spirit carried away by the wind. He could still feel Bilbo’s presence, light, graceful and heaven-like in the air around him... Yet Bilbo rests on the ground, wrapped in the arms of a figure fading, not for lack of strength but for lack of will.
“I thought it fit to give you the facts first,” says Mahal. “Now that all that is out of the way, shall we move on to happier things? I would let you live again, if you wish.”
“Thank you.”
The present approach lacks a measure of tact, Bilbo thinks. Perhaps Mahal forgets Thorin is not used to thinking about himself, let alone in this overflow of guilt that’s about to fracture the ice beneath them. He may be able to take in the heartbreak, but not the hope for repair at the same time. If Thorin’s heart can ever be repaired.
Memories float before Thorin’s mind, a feeble attempt to narrow down what he amounts to. Thráin was never far from his restless thoughts. In vain he struggled and searched; now it seems he didn’t search well enough. Fíli and Kíli needed a father figure, the dwarves of Erebor needed a place to live, his grandfather’s legacy remained his to protect. As for who Thorin was? Someone who would one day rule their reclaimed home, with Fíli and Kíli by his side.
And it’s selfish and strange, but he thinks part of him cannot bear to live and be happy with his One while those he should have protected died in a blaze of shattered dreams. Yet this gift... life, unexpected and undeserved, is the fruit of love, Bilbo’s love, impossible to earn in the afterlife: to live is to cherish this gift.
Maybe Thorin can have it.
“Don’t tell me that you want to go with them,” says Bilbo, who guessed both halves of his mind.
“It is not a question of want. I should.”
“Then I will go with you. That is, if...” Bilbo looks uncertainly around him, but Mahal’s presence is above, where he can’t see, yet maybe can still ask.
But Thorin does not wait for any answer. Because he is, once more, alive and solid on the frozen water, and there is no other way to say this except to claim Bilbo’s mouth in a kiss dark as the night and fragile as the air, warm as ice melting in a dying fire. Night is now falling yet a new day begins, and the colors have fled from this world leaving a blur of white and grey where nothing grows, there is no life anywhere but between them. Bilbo gives in to Thorin’s hold, absolute and complete; no longer belongs to himself. He is Thorin’s, even as he takes his lips reluctantly, cautiously, for this is highly improper and would work so much better as a private moment, assuming - no, praying - Mahal is still watching. Yet the longer and more passionate the kiss the more Bilbo welcomes it: it’s Thorin’s way of showing him how much this means, that Bilbo truly is willing to go in the afterlife with him. No, Thorin will not allow it; but it means everything.
“...if Lord Mahal will allow it,” Bilbo barely finishes his sentence, suddenly overcome with the wish to be so small he could hide in Thorin’s hair, or even better, disappear completely. Instead he pulls himself out of Thorin’s arms and kneels on the ice, positively embarrassed, while Thorin follows, proud and unashamed.
“I will allow it,” Mahal echoes from above.
“You will allow me to join Thorin in your Halls?”
“Yes. Of course, there is zero precedent for this, so don’t expect any hobbits there. But we do have the best drinks and entertainment. Plenty of interesting people, and the finest architecture,” completes Mahal proudly.
“What about trees and flowers?” Thorin asks. Bilbo likes nature, green, growing things. Somehow he doubts they’d be present in dwarven afterlife.
“Nope. That’s more my wife’s department. Sorry.”
Thorin turns toward Bilbo; they are now kneeling before each other. “Bilbo... Lord Mahal said he would let me live. I know very well how much you have missed your home. Let me take this chance and go to the Shire with you. I will spend the rest of my life loving you.”
And Bilbo thinks, that is all well and good, except Thorin’s conscience, his heart will not rest until he can be with his departed kin. Not to mention sitting around in the Shire with nothing to do is probably not what suits Thorin best. Well. Come to think of it, brooding in Mahal’s Halls forever does not suit him either, with or without his kin. Thorin was made to lead, to give of himself with purpose, to have others look up to him.
“What about staying in Erebor as its king? Can Thorin live and do that instead?” Bilbo risks, knowing he’s pushing it, but it’s what his love deserves.
“I’m afraid not. My child,” Mahal addresses Thorin, “you have made mistakes that cost others their lives: I am disappointed. I believe Dáin will make a better king. The chance I’m giving you is to live for love, nothing more.”
“Then it is settled. I’m going with you,” Bilbo repeats, more determined than ever.
“And leave everything? Bag End, your books and your garden? Is that what you want?”
“I love you,” Bilbo answers unrepentantly. “And I think you would be happier in the Halls, in your family’s company.”
“And I love you. Enough to be concerned you won’t be happy in a place with no soil, no growing things. Please, Bilbo. I would defer to you in anything but this. Let me go with you.”
“I told you I would follow you before any offer was made.”
“Yet you wanted me to live: that is what you asked for. That is how your story ends, is it not?”
They see what’s going on here: perhaps they’re a little too invested in each other’s happiness. Also, this is a big decision; it’s unclear how to proceed.
Unbelievable, Mahal thinks from his seat in the clouds. It’s possible he didn’t anticipate an innocent love confession to turn into an argument so soon, or that this unpredictable Baggins would be just as stubborn as his child.
Either way, they should get a move on: he doesn’t have all day.
“I have an idea. How about I just let you die, son of Thráin, and you can join us at the feast tonight, never to see this hobbit again. And you, Mister Bilbo “I-can’t-decide-what-I-want” Baggins, can sod off to your Shire with a nice tale to tell.”
“NO!! Please, Lord Mahal, give us a little more time! We’re going to figure this out!”
Mahal sighs, audibly annoyed. “Fine.”
He eyes the distant sun. Time is wasting; it’s already noon. And as Mahal watches the two powerless beings below, he meditates in silence. These two souls are just beginning to know love, and already their efforts to embrace it are way over the top; or maybe there is such a thing as loving too much. All the same, what they feel for each other is real and powerful: it would be a shame for them to part.
Chapter Text
From her garden Yavanna watched the horizon stretching in yellow-pink hues like a veil. Quiet fingers grazed the trees as she took in the sweet scent of jasmine carried along by the wind on the path toward the garden’s center, where birds had flown to be near. Her singing was about to begin.
That is when the words came, lively and clear as if there, from a voice unknown. In a hole in the ground, there lived a hobbit. He thought he had it all, until a band of dwarves came to his house one night...
This would turn into a form of prayer, she knew. For Yavanna can feel hobbits’ stories unfold in real time, especially when they uncover a need beyond what their power can achieve.
She sat against a linden tree, her mind attentive to the breaking voice that poured desperate lines through emotion and restraint, an act of courage in every word. And the green lady was moved, and wanted to help.
Where are you? she called for Aulë in her mind.
Aulë’s voice echoed inside her head. He is in Middle Earth, above a place called Ravenhill.
She vanished, the hobbit’s words still ringing in her ears.
...From his seat in the clouds Mahal watched the dwarves, men and elves emerge victorious in the battle’s end. The sun began to descend; soon it would be time for his child to decide, ideally before Thorin’s Company find him relatively unharmed, locked in another’s arms in a surreal scene, suspiciously miracle-like.
“There you are.”
Aulë takes a moment to feel the change as Yavanna moves gracefully towards him: Ravenhill tower, the frozen waterfall against this luminous being made of kindness and hope; his equal, his partner in all things.
They have never met here before.
She relates details of a quest: dwarves, a lost kingdom, a hobbit in the midst of it all...
“Say no more. Take a look below.”
“Oh.” Yavanna spots the two figures on the ice. “I see. I take it the one with bronze curls, in the blue coat, is the hobbit in question?”
“Correct. And the other is the idiotic dwarf in question. The gist of it? The dwarf wants to live, because Baggins wants him to live. Wanted, to be exact. Because in the meantime Baggins changed his mind: he wants to die so that Thorin can die: which is what the dwarf wanted in the first place.”
“Oh, dear. We’d better get down there.”
As they descend, Thorin and Bilbo’s voices become clear. By the sound of it, they haven’t reached an agreement yet.
“Fine. We will go to the Halls. We haven’t even had one date, and you’re ready to join me in death.”
“Perfectly so.”
“What if a year from now you start missing your life?”
“We’ll deal with it then.”
“Yet that is not how your story ends,” Yavanna says as the two Valar reach the ground. “The hobbit asks a higher being to grant life to his friend. That is the last of what you said. If your wish has changed, your tale’s ending needs to change too.”
Bilbo and Thorin bow solemnly before her, lost for words; the urgency kicks in now.
“Y... you mean I can change it to anything I want?” Bilbo forgets himself, and Yavanna recognizes that shyness and determination, both present in this unlikely creature that manages to surprise. Mahal glances amusedly at her - Maybe you shouldn’t have told him that - and interjects with a stern voice.
“All right, lads. In her infinite grace, my wife grants you one more chance at formulating a request. But mind you, this is the last one. Speak, and be done with it.”
“I have the perfect ending,” says Bilbo, an idea striking him. “Here it goes: The dwarf king was content to die: for his fate was bound to that of his dead kin, the nephews whom he had raised as his own. The hobbit understood: Thorin would never be happy in life if Fíli and Kíli were dead. So Bilbo kneeled before Lord Mahal and Lady Yavanna, his lovely wife, and explained Fíli and Kíli both needed to live: one to rule in Thorin’s stead, the other to pursue romance with the elf. “Please,” he begged, “bring both back to life”.
“Fíli and Kíli have already reached my Halls,” Mahal says. “Bringing them back is not as simple as keeping Thorin alive. On the other hand, if you two accepted to take their place...”
“But I just said Thorin is bound to them! He wants to be near them, not switch places with them!”
“Yet you haven’t said anything about you two’s fate this time. And since you, Baggins, were content to follow Thorin to my Halls minutes ago - in fact, insisted upon it...”
“I... was hoping we could all live,” Bilbo says. “But you’re right, I am not asking for it. I place myself and Thorin at your mercy. Whatever you do, don’t tear us apart.”
“I deserve to die,” says Thorin quietly. “I would be happy to switch places with them.”
“Oh, stop it, you infuriating dwarf. You’re not helping.”
“I’m going to steal your... friend for a few minutes,” Yavanna addresses the hobbit while extending her hand to the king. Wordlessly, Thorin follows her. On the steps of Ravenhill tower they sit, a place Thorin would run from if not for the grace and purity bestowed by this warm, forgiving presence next to him. And suddenly the ice disappears. He stands on a golden shore, still caught in the flow of time, while infinite waves break below.
There is no right choice. The answer is in the sea, if the waves could wash away his guilt and carry him to another shore.
“Child of my husband, what are you afraid of?”
Thorin is not afraid: except of being stripped down to his very soul, or of the tears that start rolling by, unable to be controlled anymore.
“Your own heart, I think. You are used to doing your duty; yet that is not what is asked of you today.”
“It is not duty. None of what I feel is.”
“No. It is not. It is love: for your family, as well as your One. Taking Kíli’s place... you would do in a heartbeat, would you not?”
“Yes. I would.”
“And would you take Bilbo Baggins with you?”
Thorin shakes his head. “I would have him live, if I knew I would see him again one day.”
“Correct me if I’m wrong, but even if you weren’t thus assured, I believe you would have him live.”
“You are not wrong.”
“He wants to come with you. Why won’t you have him? It would bring both of your nephews back.”
“Because he doesn’t deserve to die. He joined me in this cursed quest thinking it would be the adventure of his life. For what? Only to die because I was stupid enough to die? I would have Bilbo enjoy life: he has not had enough.”
“And if his will is different from yours?”
“Then may his will be done. I love him too much to refuse him anything.”
The sea beckons to him. Eternity... He will endure, live on the certainty of Bilbo’s love alone. And they will meet again.
The green lady watches him carefully. “Incidentally, I agree with you.”
“On what?”
“That Bilbo should live.”
Back on the ice, the hobbit has not changed his mind: he will follow where Thorin goes. As Yavanna and Thorin return, Mahal lifts his hands to the sky and calls upon two children in the Halls, not just summoning, but materializing them.
Fíli and Kíli appear, happy, ready to launch the fiercest group hug, oblivious to the inevitable farewell.
“Wait a minute.” Kíli looks around. “How is it possible that we’re here? We were to attend a feast in Mahal’s Halls. Has it been cancelled?”
“No one told us,” Fíli says.
“Nothing’s been cancelled,” Mahal replies. “These two here have agreed to take your place. I should point out, your uncle was going anyway, as he was offed by Azog. But this other one” - he points to Bilbo - “comes of his own will.”
Fíli and Kíli demand answers, outraged. Yavanna whispers something in Fíli’s ear.
“Bilbo,” he says alarmedly, “you are the last person on our quest whom I would allow to die. I don’t want you to take my place. My Lord,” he kneels before Mahal, “this is out of the question. I demand to be taken back, now.”
“Very well. Then you will go back. Your brother will remain here, to enjoy life with the elf. And you, Baggins, will live too: if for nothing else, because it is my wife’s wish.”
“By the way, Uncle, your father sends his love,” Kíli says. “He is very proud of you.”
“Aye,” Fíli confirms. “Thráin is happy and at peace in the Halls. He doesn’t want you to worry about him. His wish is that you live a long, happy life.”
“Well, that’s not happening,” says Mahal. “So. Fíli and Kíli, say your goodbyes. And you too, Baggins and son of Thráin. I’ll be out of your hair while you do. Come, my love, let’s give them some time,” he says to his wife, undoubtedly meaning Let’s get out of here before anyone can change their mind.
“You are right, my dear,” Yavanna says as they drift away, out of sight. “They need time.”
...The waves crash at Thorin’s feet again. It is close, now. Not perfectly right, but perhaps it’s as right as it can be, to go to the Halls without his One and have one nephew live, be happy, and love. Half of his guilt will be washed away. It is fitting to endure the other half: he couldn’t buy both of their lives with his own.
It is close, now. Eternity, and the hope he will see Bilbo again. Yet much closer is the present moment, when they are still here, not ready to say goodbye.
Chapter 5
Notes:
Thank you so much for reading, and many thanks to all who left kudos or comments on this work! I hope you enjoy it to the end ❤️
Chapter Text
“I wish there were something we could do,” Yavanna says. She’s sporting that innocent but mischievous look Aulë usually finds endearing.
They traced the path back to her gardens, vanishing from Middle Earth, and are standing now under a canopy of trees, in the glow of a burning sun.
“There is something in the way Thorin loves. I’m not sure if you’ve noticed, but he’s willing to give up their time together so that Bilbo could live. He’s gladly moving on to the afterlife on pure faith they’ll see each other again. Or even less: the certainty that Bilbo loved him.”
“Meh,” Aulë shrugs, unimpressed. “That’s not much compared to what the hobbit feels for him. Baggins was willing to die when they could have both lived, just so Thorin could have peace in my Halls. Because Eru forbid that dwarf should be happy, you know, just that he exists. That I made him.”
“Yet Thorin accepted to submit to his One’s will.”
“Uh-huh. Too bad in the end Baggins let him have his way. You see? We can’t even agree on which one loved the other more. It makes one wonder if they even have such a strong bond.”
“It does make one wonder,” she wistfully replies. “Who loves more? The one who issued a thoroughly selfless request, or the one who accepted it to the detriment of his own?”
“I’ll tell you who loves more,” says Mahal. “The one who knows how to end an argument. Peacefully, I mean. Which brings me to my next point...”
“Such a love is worthy of a miracle, I would say,” Yavanna remarks casually, and now he knows she’s far from having spoken the last word.
“I’m not performing another miracle.”
“Maybe I can be the one to pray to you? How about this: Oh, Mahal, generous giver of gifts, will you please grant those two hopeless boys one more moment, as they are obviously not ready to part?”
“Negative,” says Mahal, not amused.
“And then, after said moment is over and I ask for more, how about you grant them another?”
“I’ve already intervened on their behalf. And you know my powers are limited. Eru will not allow me to change the rules.”
“Why don’t we try,” she says, enclosing him in a warm embrace. “Maybe we have more power than you think.”
“I’ll give you this moment, because it’s nice. But not any more.”
One more moment.
If you asked Bilbo what he got out of this small request, he would say it’s a lot. Because he and Thorin talked, and things he’d thought impossible were said, Thorin kissed him, and it seemed like they could stay forever in that light, and though the miracle seems to be fading now and things didn’t turn out as hoped his heart is not the same; it will never be the same.
Thorin loves him.
And they still don’t know how to spend it, this moment that for some reason keeps going when it should have been over long ago. How can you spend something you’d rather freeze inside that fragile part that’s left of you, how can you fill this time when you’re no longer waiting for a miracle to come. Maybe they can talk about the little things, a favorite color, summer, winter, or whether flowers can be carved from stone... it’s no use, Bilbo knows what this is, a quietly desperate effort to refuse what’s in front of him; for Thorin, a surrender to this fate. No, they will never be ready for it. Can Bilbo find stillness, peace in the understanding Thorin will not be moved by desire anymore - selfish, he proclaimed it, though Bilbo would disagree; Bilbo liked that about him.
Don’t move. Lie still... hours ago he was unable to comprehend this outcome, let alone accept. But now the possibility of Thorin dying has been entertained, and payment for Kíli’s life has been offered.
Bilbo cannot accept.
May he be happy in your Halls, as much as one like Thorin can be.
He can pray to Mahal, still. Through this experience Bilbo bonded with him.
If love can travel such a great distance may he feel it there, love full of Shire and trees and flowers in the morning sun. And Bilbo has a vision of his love, a field of sunflowers in a sea of green. It’s beautiful. He wants to show it to Thorin; but Thorin is preoccupied, too.
If I am wrong, show me where I am wrong. If there is a way to love him more...
He feels what Bilbo feels; the choice is wrong. Why didn’t Thorin delve more into the impossible, ask questions, search for a better answer. He could have at least talked to Yavanna more.
He wishes he could talk to her now.
“What’s up with these trees? They’re acting strange,” says Aulë as his wife breaks from their embrace, her gaze attentive to an unusual sight. Two young trees in her garden have just started to bend their trunks down as if kneeling at their feet. Yavanna touches them tenderly; the trees shy away from her, wrapping their branches around Aulë instead.
“You should take them with you.”
Mahal frowns. “What for?”
“What for. We both know your dwelling could use more trees. Come on. They seem to like you.”
“So what, you’re just going to dig them out of your lovely garden and have them transported to a sunless, stony place? I doubt that’s what these trees count among their life goals.”
“I think they want to go with you.”
Mahal stares in disbelief. He is double trapped: the trees are properly hugging him now.
“Yeah, whatever. I guess I can take two trees.”
“So when exactly are you supposed to die again?”
That wasn’t meant to sound insensitive. In Kíli’s defense, Fíli and he have been standing in the same spot on Ravenhill for quite some time. He’s just not used to this utter lack of action.
“Whenever Mahal returns, I guess,” says Fíli, as usual the more patient of the two.
“I wonder if we can just get out of here.”
“And when he comes back? What do you think, he can’t do the math? He’ll just go to the Halls with one dwarf?”
“Maybe? He is on a tight schedule after all. Maybe he won’t have time to look for you. That aside, is it possible a walk would do you good?”
Fíli laughs. “After having just been brutally impaled? Yeah. I could use one.”
“Seriously. No point in standing here like two idiots.” Neither meant to make a reference to anyone, though their uncle and Bilbo do happen to be nearby.
As they walk, Kíli wonders about Tauriel: did Thranduil send for her or did she leave with that pesky Legolas? Fíli speaks of family, those in the Halls, those he will leave behind. What was meant as light chatter quickly morphs into a realization. With both Thorin and Fíli out of the picture, Kíli will get the throne of Erebor.
“Queen of the Lonely Mountain,” he says dreamily. “Nah. Tauriel won’t like that. I should probably hand the kingdom over to Dáin.”
“Neither will she like a dwarf who shies away from duty.”
Kíli is horrified. He clearly hasn’t thought this through.
“You know, maybe you should switch places with me.”
“You’re joking, right?”
“I mean it. I don’t want to rule Erebor without you. And you’re right, Tauriel won’t fancy a quitter. I’m not sure she would have me either way. You, on the other hand, will make a great king; that counts for something.”
“Nonsense. You have found your One; that’s more important than anything I could achieve. But you do need to be alive to cash in on that.”
“Ugh,” Kíli grunts, mind you, not at the prospect of living. He can sense an argument is coming.
“Any moment now, this - ” Bilbo gestures helplessly around him, this little heaven carved in ice for a few hours - “this will cease to be. We will never be here again.”
“That moment has not come yet,” Thorin says. The last ounce of strength left in him somehow is strong enough, Bilbo thinks, because if anyone ever had that power, to summon all energy needed to free a kingdom, to bring even a block of stone to life, it’s Thorin; equally, the one to lay down his life. You’re not going anywhere. Thorin, hold on... the scene seems to repeat itself except those words are not said; they just flash before Bilbo’s mind. They kiss in the surreal icy wind clothed in the warm rays of sun, they kiss for the last time and for the hours that will never come to pass; they kiss as if this will prevent them from parting. “It’s not enough...” Bilbo says in sadness. Mahal gave them a lot... yet this closeness is not enough for the love they would have shared if they’d had time. “Time is not,” Thorin echoes, though he’s more resigned than sad, or he’s not showing that part of him that actually can be broken. Only love is enough. “I will come to you. When my time comes, I…” Thorin attemps to silence him, but Bilbo needs this right now, some semblance of certainty that both can agree on. “I will ask the Green Lady to let me. It won’t be long...” And Thorin understands. Bilbo let him have his way; now he will yield to him.
Night is now falling, so ends this day, and still the last goodbye has not been said. Thorin and Bilbo are still there, pressed against one another with nothing left in the world. The hour grows late yet the moment has not passed, and it seems like they’ve been here forever, in a story that burned brightly with hope long ago, like a star whose light only now they see; that hope has ended now. They pour into one another the love, the longing for what could have been, until it doesn’t matter if one lives and one dies; they’ve already felt all the sadness of their parting.
...Aulë has not returned.
Some tales say that in her garden as they embraced, Yavanna did ask for one more moment on Bilbo and Thorin’s behalf. Of course, he couldn’t refuse her. Then she asked for more, and Aulë granted it every time, until he remembered the feast he never got to make preparations for. He hastily took off to the Halls and called it off. Now, dwarves don’t take kindly to a cancelled feast: their loud grumbling gave Mahal a colossal headache that lasted for many days.
Other tales say it was Kíli’s doing. Once he judged Fíli would be better off alive, he begged Mahal to let him die instead. But Fíli would not have it. Soon their chat turned into an argument, which escalated into a big fight. The shouts the brothers levelled at each other were so loud that Mahal, exasperated, kneeled down in earnest prayer before Eru, asking him to let all four live and be done with it: a request easily granted, for, as few may realize, a Vala’s prayer actually holds a lot of power. Thus it is (as Kíli loves to remind his uncle to this day) that a really bad fight accomplished what a sappy love scene could not.
But the truth is this: as soon as Aulë said “yes” to his wife’s trees, she pointed out they couldn’t be brought to Middle Earth; they needed to be carried directly to the Halls. “I’ll help you,” Yavanna said, and held one tree freshly dug out of the ground, ready to teleport one more time.
As soon as they reached the Halls, she unveiled her plan.
“I wonder if we could make these trees count as people. In Fíli and Thorin’s place.”
“Come again?”
“I was thinking, why not? We’re married, dwarves are your children, and trees are like children to me.”
“Except dwarves are persons,” said Mahal. “It’s supposed to be an exchange of persons all around, not dwarves and trees.”
“But they can feel. For example, right now they are sad, because they had to leave their land and family.”
“But they wanted to be here! Or so you had me believe!”
“That’s right, which means they have complex emotions, just like people. They were happy to go in Fíli and Thorin’s place, but can also feel sad at the same time. Much like your... complex dwarves,” she added with a trace of hesitation, which happily went undetected.
“And how exactly do you propose we perform this little scheme?”
“It’s simple. You keep the trees here, and never call Fíli and Thorin to your Halls. If those two are allowed to live, they’ll live. If not... I guess you’ll find out when they arrive.”
“I’ve never heard of trees passing for people,” grumbled Mahal. “But fine. It’s not like I can say no to you. But if this displeases our Maker - keep in mind I’ve already made dwarves behind his back -”
“It’s on me,” she said with a smile like she didn’t care. And he shared in that smile: for Aulë secretly enjoyed this little plot, ingenious in that it didn’t force Eru’s hand; leave it to his wife to devise a subtle form of prayer. Much like that hobbit’s story, except she’s making hers happen as we speak. Another reason to admire his all-time favorite person in the world.
And so the trees stayed, and grew vigorously in the Halls, and whether Eru simply looked the other way or truly accepted Yavanna’s offering no one knows, though Thorin suspects it was she who intervened on his behalf; for he sometimes hears her voice inside his mind. You must learn to live with your mistakes. To forgive yourself. And on nights when he watches Bilbo sleep and finally, it seems the nightmares have ceased and something has clicked in the hobbit’s mind - they’re both alive, their story had a happy ending after all; on days when Thorin has to come to terms with living in the Shire with Bilbo by his side, with not so much as a care in the world while his nephews share the burden of Erebor’s throne; when happiness becomes too much because it will forever be undeserved, it’s Yavanna who will have the last word. You must allow yourself to live, to be happy, and to love.
