Actions

Work Header

Anywhere is Home

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Thorin thought Bilbo was rather aloof upon their meeting, but he hoped his initial impression was wrong. First impressions were wrong sometimes. For all Thorin knew, Bilbo could be the most outgoing and loud person in the world.

But this premonition turned out to be all too real. Although Bilbo masked his true feelings under the guise of cordial friendliness, Thorin could tell Bilbo did not particularly like him. Not that Thorin thought too highly of him, either. The feeling was mutual, it seemed. Neither particularly disliked the other, but it also seemed neither particularly liked each other either.

It was Gandalf sitting between them that seemed to maintain some semblance of connection between the two men. Had it not been for this mutual friend binding them together, Thorin would never have found himself sitting across from this man, and especially not having dinner with this man.

“Gandalf told me you’re a student at Bree Conservatory,” Thorin said, hoping to start a friendly conversation before Gandalf stepped in and forced his hand. He came all this way, so Gandalf would certainly want him to at least talk to this man.

“Yes, I am,” Bilbo said. “I’m about to finish my degree in Music Performance with a focus in piano.”

“Bilbo is being humble,” Gandalf said. Out of the corner of his eye, Thorin saw Bilbo’s expression reveal embarrassment as though Gandalf were a parent bragging about his child. “He’s been playing piano since he was a young boy. He takes after his mother like that.”

“And then one thing led to another over the years and here I am now,” Bilbo finished up, waving his hands back and forth as he spoke. Thorin supposed he was humble if he wanted to avoid overemphasizing the accomplishments that got him to this point.

It was then that the waitress brought everyone’s food to the table. They all ordered the same soup from the menu.

Thorin took one sip of the soup to sample it and he thought it tasted better than he expected it to. It was by no means gourmet, but considering the low price point on the menu he thought it would taste a lot cheaper. The kitchen workers here probably made this food from scratch, which was enough to satisfy him.

No one spoke much during the meal, except to comment on how good the soup was and how it complimented the bread the waitress gave them when they first sat down. Thorin preferred it this way. There was an air of more calm and less anxiety now that they were eating.

The minutes passed as they finished their meal. Gandalf paid for everyone’s meal, making sure he left a good tip for the waitress. The restaurant was busy and all the tables were full, but she made sure to give them the attention they needed as if they were her only customers.

As they rose from the table, Bilbo spoke up.

“Thank you for dinner, Gandalf,” Bilbo started, “and it was good meeting you, Thorin.”

“It was good to meet you as well, Bilbo,” Thorin said.

“I’ll see you both at the recital tomorrow night.”

“We’ll see you there,” Gandalf said. “You have a good night, Bilbo.”

“You too.” Bilbo waved them off as he left the restaurant.

Gandalf paused for a moment and then he and Thorin headed for the elevator back to their rooms.

“You don’t like him,” Gandalf commented in a flat, seemingly indifferent tone as they rode the elevator up to the third floor.

Thorin raised an eyebrow. “When did I ever say that?”

“You didn’t need to say it. Neither did Bilbo. At least both of you had the decency to keep it to yourselves.” Gandalf glanced at Thorin and cracked a smile. Thorin couldn’t help returning the sentiment. This was the Gandalf he was used to.

This lightened Thorin’s mood enough that he felt a lot calmer as they emerged on the third floor from the elevator. But still Gandalf’s observation bothered him.

“Do I really have to spend more time with that bloke, though?” Thorin asked when they made it to their rooms.

“Oh, it’ll be fine. I’m going to take you out to see Bree tomorrow, but it’ll just be the two of us for that time. You won’t have to see Bilbo again until the recital tomorrow night.”

“Fine,” Thorin huffed, clearly trying to contain some laughter. “Well, goodnight, Gandalf. I’ll try to sleep tonight, since I imagine you’ll be eager to wake me up early tomorrow morning.”

“Oh, yes, I will.” Gandalf laughed. “Goodnight, Thorin.”

The two men slipped into their rooms. Thorin kicked off his shoes and checked his phone to see a text from Dís, asking how the dinner went.

Thorin sighed and considered how best to compose a reply. It took him three tries to settle on how he could best summarize his impression of Bilbo.

The dinner itself was good, but I didn’t really take to Gandalf’s friend. It’s not like he was super excited to meet me, either. Where does Gandalf find these people?

Dís’s reply was immediate. What was wrong with him?

Thorin thought about it for a minute. Dunno. Do you ever just meet someone and know you aren’t going to like them?


Yes. It’s called a bad vibe.

Exactly. I got a bad vibe from him and I guess he got the same from me.

Well, have fun with that recital Gandalf’s making you go to.

Another text from Dís came through a few seconds later. Okay I’ve got to finish this history assignment now or Frerin’s gonna give me hell tomorrow. Goodnight!

Goodnight. As soon as Thorin saw the text went through, he powered down his phone. He checked the time on the small digital clock on the nightstand when he set his phone down beside it. It was still early. Too early for him to go to bed now. There would be no point in setting an alarm for tomorrow morning, either, because no doubt Gandalf would be awake early enough to come wake him up.

Now that he had the time, he figure he would finally get around to flipping through the channels. He turned the TV on and changed the channel away from the news station. He perused the channels to see what there was until he fell asleep.

***

Thorin awoke the next morning to the sound of knocking at his door. As he rose to make sure it was Gandalf at the door, he realized he never changed out of the clothes from the day before, but he didn’t care. It didn’t matter what Gandalf thought about that because he was going to get changed before they left anyway.

After checking the peephole to confirm it was, in fact, Gandalf outside, Thorin opened the door about halfway.

“I’m awake,” Thorin said, his voice scratchy. “I’ll be ready in a few minutes.”

“Alright, then,” Gandalf replied. “I’ll be downstairs in the lobby. Don’t take too long. The restaurant down there serves breakfast and I’d quite like to try it.”

“Okay, I’ll meet you there.” Thorin closed the door and went to find a fresh shirt for the day.

Once he was ready, he left his room, making sure the key was safely tucked into his wallet before shutting the door all the way. The last thing he needed was to create a situation for the employees at the front desk. They had looked overworked enough as it was and he didn’t want to contribute to the problem by getting himself locked out of his room. Once sure he had his bearings, he let the door click shut and then made his way toward the elevator and down to the lobby where Gandalf was waiting for him, as promised.

***


Thorin always imagined Bree to be a sprawling metropolis in contrast to the rustic and isolated Ered Luin, but the town ended up being a lot smaller than he expected. It was not quite so urban, but at the same time it was nothing like Ered Luin. The day passed quickly as Gandalf led him through the market at the town’s center and they explored the shops that filled the outer streets around the market. By the end of the day, it felt as if they had already seen everything the town had to offer.

Everything except the Bree Conservatory, it seemed. The conservatory sat on the outskirts of the town, so it took a little longer to get there. It felt like they had been saving the best for last.

Gandalf took Thorin to dinner at a fast food place on the conservatory’s campus. Thorin thought the campus was in a lot better shape than the town of Bree proper. While the town looked rather run-down and many of the buildings looked old, the campus looked rather new. The buildings were modern and sleek, and the architects took full advantage of the large amount of land the campus occupied and filled it efficiently without making the campus look too intimidating for visitors who were unfamiliar with the layout.

“How old is this school?” Thorin asked Gandalf after they ate. They finished eating around 6:30, but the recital didn’t start until 7:30. With this spare hour they chose to walk around and Gandalf had taken to giving Thorin an unofficial campus tour.

“Oh, the school has been around for nearly a century,” Gandalf explained, “but they’ve spent the last five or so years going around and remodeling all the buildings so everything is more modern. Bilbo told me all the construction made getting around campus a pain at times, but that the newer facilities have been worth all the trouble.”

“That sounds like a lot of trouble to go to for a music school in such a small town.”

“The school draws in students from all over England, you know. It’s one of the top conservatories in the country. Most of them come from the Shire, like Bilbo. The people in the Shire are particularly musical; music is ingrained into their culture in a way I haven’t seen anywhere else.”

That gave Thorin pause. He didn’t think it would be worth it to protest any of that, since he knew nothing of music to begin with.

“Come on,” Gandalf went on. “ I want to show you the rest of the campus before we have to make our way back to the auditorium.”

Thorin followed Gandalf. The more he saw of the campus, the more he came to appreciate the place. The newly-constructed buildings lent to the sense that this was, in fact, a rather prestigious school.

Gandalf made sure they arrived at the auditorium at least fifteen minutes early, so they would have time to get settled in.

“I have two tickets for us,” Gandalf said and then he produced the two tickets from his pocket.

At the door he showed the usher the tickets and the usher pointed them in the direction of their seats.

“Thank you,” Gandalf and Thorin both said as they walked past the usher into the auditorium. Following the usher’s instructions, Gandalf pointed them in the direction of their seats. They were in the center of the row so they had to squeeze past at least ten people before they got to their own seats. They were in the back half of the rows, but not all the way in the back. It seemed like it would provide the best view of the stage.

“Here,” Gandalf said, handing Thorin a program. “I grabbed these on the way in.” Thorin hadn’t noticed a place where people could take programs, but he accepted the program nonetheless. It might help him make the tiniest bit more sense of what to expect while he was here.

The front of the program announced the title of the performance in large, bolded letters: “A Study in the Romantic Era: A Recital by Bilbo Baggins.”

He opened the program and tried to familiarize himself with the repertoire even though he did not recognize any of it. To him everything sounded like a bunch of random words slapped together.

Bagatelle in C Minor, WoO 52 - Ludwig van Beethoven

Fantasiestücke, Op. 73 No. 1 - Robert Schumann

Hamfast Gamgee, clarinet

INTERMISSION

Fantasie Impromptu, Op. 66 - Frédéric Chopin

Sonata in G Minor, Op. 49 No. 1 - Ludwig van Beethoven

I. Andante

II. Rondo

The auditorium was filled with chatter. As Thorin looked around, he noticed that most of the people in the audience were closer to his age than Gandalf’s. These had to be other students at the conservatory, then, he supposed, here to support their classmate’s performance.

The noise quieted as soon as the lights went down. The only lights left in the room were the green glowing exit sign lights at all corners of the room and the bright shining light that illuminated the stage. At the center of the stage was a marvelous grand piano.

The crowd erupted into applause when Bilbo emerged from side stage wearing a tuxedo. He seemed much more sophisticated than he had at the dinner where they first met.

Bilbo took his time crossing the stage to the seat in front of the piano, but once seated he did not hesitate before jumping straight into the first piece. This piece took Thorin by surprise. Since the title suggested this recital was influenced by Romanticism, he expected the music to sound soft and restrained. Simply, he expected it to sound romantic. But this first piece was quite the opposite. This piece started loud and fast. Thorin swore he had never seen fingers move as quickly as Bilbo’s were as he glided through the piece. The midpoint gave Thorin a moment to relax as the music took on a more mellow tone, but then it jumped back into the harshness that defined the beginning of the piece. Through all of it, Thorin was so fixated on the speed and precision of Bilbo’s fingers that he did not realize the piece was over right away. He only registered it when everyone around him roared with applause.

They all continued clapping as another man emerged from the side of the stage, carrying a clarinet. This man was about the same height as Bilbo, but a lot wider around the waist. Thorin glanced back at the program and confirmed this man’s name was Hamfast.

The piece Bilbo and Hamfast played together was a lot calmer than the first one. The focus of this piece seemed to be more so on the clarinet’s part, but it sounded like both of them played off each other. Thorin noticed that Hamfast was not reading off of sheet music and had to be playing all of this from memory. As he thought about it, he realized he hadn’t seen Bilbo sifting through papers as he played, either. How was it possible they were able to play all of this music from memory? Thorin didn’t think he had an especially bad memory, but he didn’t think he could be able to do what they were doing all while relying on his memory to take the lead.

Thorin sat back and took in the music more so now, worrying less about innocuous details such as memorization. The minutes passed and then the piece was over and the audience boomed with applause once again. Still holding his clarinet, Hamfast took a bow and walked off the stage.

Bilbo waited for the applause to die down before jumping into the next piece. This Chopin piece was another more relaxed piece and Thorin found it an enjoyable listen. When it was over, the applause picked up again. This time Bilbo rose from the seat in front of the piano and he took a bow before walking off the stage. Then the lights on the stage went down as the lights in the rest of the auditorium came on. The intermission began.

The chatter returned to the room as if there had been no interruption. Gandalf rose from his seat.

“I’ll be right back,” he said as he slipped past Thorin and out of the row of seats. Thorin laid back and pulled out his phone. There were no new texts from Dís, but there was one from Balin asking about how things were going. Thorin filled him in on everything that had happened so far, recounting it the same way he had with Dís the previous night.

Balin texted back a minute later. Sounds rough. Is the music good at least?

From what I can tell, he’s good at piano. I’ll give him that. He can play some insanely fast music. I shouldn’t go around saying if the music is any good or not because I have no idea what I’m talking about when it comes to music.

He hit send and looked up. At the other end of the auditorium he saw Gandalf return and make his way back toward the seats. All around the people were still talking, but those who were still standing at this point were making their way back to their seats. Thorin didn’t know how long intermissions at these kinds of events normally lasted, but this one must be ending soon.

“What do you think so far?” Gandalf asked as he sat down in his sat.

“It’s good,” Thorin said in a monotone voice. He didn’t feel enthusiastic about it, but he couldn’t deny that Bilbo was talented at his craft.

The lights began to dim, indicating that the recital was about to continue. A moment passed and then the dim lights faded into nothing and the main lights on the stage lit up again.

Bilbo walked out onto the stage and made his way toward the piano, giving Thorin a sense of déjà vu reminiscent of the beginning of the recital when Bilbo emulated the same movements. This time Bilbo started right in with a much more relaxing piece than the super fast one of earlier. This one was soothing to Thorin’s ears and he decided it was his favorite piece of the night. Once Bilbo finished Thorin moved to clap, but he hesitated when no one else around him was clapping. He was glad he didn’t clap, though, for Bilbo jumped right into the next piece without the long pause he normally allocated between pieces. Why didn’t he stop for as long this time? This piece was a lot faster. It wasn’t as fast as the piece that opened the recital, but it caught Thorin off guard coming out of the more mellow, reasonably-paced previous piece.

Before Thorin knew it, this piece was over and the recital was at its end. The audience erupted into its loudest burst of applause yet, and many of the people around Thorin stood to applaud in a standing ovation. Thorin only joined them in the standing ovation when he saw Gandalf rise out of the corner of his eye. Bilbo stood from the seat and moved to the front of the stage, where he took a bow as he embraced the applause he was receiving for his performance. He paused before exiting the stage. Then the applause died down and the lights in the audience came up.

Thorin stretched his legs now that he was standing up. He hadn’t noticed how stiff they had gotten from sitting in the same position for the entire duration of the recital.

“What now?” Thorin asked. He knew Gandalf too well to know that this was all Gandalf had planned for their excursion to Bree.

“We’re going to wait in the lobby for Bilbo,” Gandalf said. “I invited him back to the Prancing Pony where we’ll have some beer in my room to celebrate. I think even you can’t turn down that invitation.”


“I suppose not.”

“That’s good to hear, because I was going to force you to come if you declined.”

“It’s a good thing I agreed, then.”

The two of them waited for everyone in the row to file out before they tried to leave. They weren’t in any rush so there would be no point in creating a traffic jam trying to get out before everyone else.

“Why didn’t people clap in between the last two pieces that Bilbo played?” Thorin asked, remembering how he narrowly avoided an awkward moment by being the only person that clapped.

“He was playing two movements of the same piece,” Gandalf explained, “and it’s customary that you don’t clap in between movements of the same piece. It’s all one piece so you just clap at the end.”

Thorin found that explanation confusing since he didn’t understand all the nuances and technicalities of music, but he supposed that was the best explanation he was going to get so he didn’t broach the subject anymore.

Once everyone else in the row left, they made their way out to the lobby, which was packed with people. Thorin could see that some of them were leaving, but most were staying a little longer while they congregated and probably discussed Bilbo’s performance.

“It’ll be a few minutes before Bilbo comes out,” Gandalf said. “He’s going to take his time unwinding after the recital. He’ll join us when he’s ready. Why don’t you go walk around a bit while we wait? I bet your legs will be stiff from sitting for so long. Oh, there’s Hamfast! I want to go congratulate him, I’ll be right back.”

As Gandalf took off, Thorin decided he would take a lap around the outer rim of the lobby, where there weren’t as many people standing around. The majority of people seemed to be concentrated in the center of the room. After he completed a lap, his legs felt much more refreshed. Gandalf was right; his legs were stiff and he had not even realized it. He met back up with Gandalf.

“I see Bilbo coming over here now,” Gandalf said, pointing across the lobby to the entrance where the short man slid inside. Gandalf started toward Bilbo and Thorin trailed a few steps behind.

“That was a great performance, Bilbo,” Gandalf said to Bilbo when they met up with him. “Even Thorin enjoyed it!”
 Bilbo looked over to Thorin.

“Oh, yeah, that was great,” Thorin said, angry with himself that he was stumbling over his words, but he didn’t expect Gandalf to put him on the spot like that right away.

“Should we move?” Bilbo asked, looking around. “We’re kind of in the way.” He vaguely gestured to the doors next to them.

“Oh yes,” Gandalf replied, ushering the three of them to the grassy area right outside. “We should get going, anyway. My car is in the lot right here so it won’t be far.”

They walked over to Gandalf’s car and got in. All along the way to the hotel they were all quiet. Bilbo didn’t seem in the mood to talk too much now and Thorin was relieved for it. He felt drained from all the events of the day, especially trying to keep up with the recital. It felt a little better to at least be going back to the inn, which was a little more familiar, even if he had to spend more time with Bilbo while he was there.

Back in the hotel room, Gandalf distributed beer bottles for the three of them. Gandalf called for a toast to celebrate Bilbo’s performance. The men clinked their bottles together and then all each took a sip from their own bottle at the same time.

“That was my last performance as a student,” Bilbo mused, looking a little sad as he reflected on the occasion.

“And here’s to many more adventures beyond your student life,” Gandalf said with a smile.

Thorin noticed Bilbo wrinkled his nose at the mentioning of adventures, but he didn’t say anything out loud about being bothered by it.

“So, what do you plan to do next, once you’ve finished with school?” Thorin asked. He wanted to try to make conversation this time. The dinner the night before was awkward enough with the strong silence between him and Bilbo, so he wanted to punctuate it this time with friendliness, no matter how distant that friendliness manifested.

“That is why I brought you here, Thorin,” Gandalf jumped in. “I’ve arranged for Bilbo to teach private lessons in Ered Luin.”

“Ered Luin? He’ll be teaching in my village? Who will he be teaching?”

“That is the thing, Thorin. Fundin and I have arranged for Bilbo to teach Dís the piano, in exchange for his room and board for the duration of his time spent teaching.”

“Wait?” Thorin could feel his temper rising, but he didn’t care. “My sister? Why didn’t you tell me he was going to be teaching my sister sooner?”

“Wait a second, this family you want me to stay with is his family?” Now Bilbo seemed annoyed at the prospect, too. “You told me I would be teaching a family of three.”

Gandalf remained his composure at the onslaught of anger coming from both Bilbo and Thorin on this united front. As he explained the situation to both men, his tone lent no hint of frustration.

“Thorin, Fundin and I arranged for Bilbo to stay in your house and give lessons to Dís. She knows about this and agreed to the terms, but she doesn’t know the reason why you’re here is to meet her new teacher. I would encourage both you and Frerin to participate in lessons with Bilbo, too, because it would be good for you. At the same time, I recognize you are both of age and therefore neither I nor Fundin can force either of you into it. But know that Fundin is doing me a great favor with this, so I would appreciate your cooperation a lot.”

“What about Balin and Dwalin? Will they be ‘encouraged’ into doing this, too?”

“Who are—”

“They are Thorin’s cousins,” Gandalf explained, his voice still level as if he were unaware of the rising tensions in the room. “Fundin is their father and the head of the Durin household. To answer your question, Thorin, Fundin thinks they are busy enough as it is with work at the mines to commit to this as well.”

Thorin sighed. This was a lot to take in at once, but most of all he didn’t know how he felt about the prospect of Bilbo staying in his house indefinitely.

Notes:

these are the pieces mentioned in this chapter if anyone is interested!

Bagatelle in C Minor
Fantasiestücke
Fantasie Impromptu
Sonata in G Minor