Chapter Text
After a round of fighting and some more beer with Gandalf, Bilbo left the inn for the night and Thorin returned to his room. Thorin and Bilbo remained relatively cordial when addressing each other directly in conversation after their outburst at Gandalf. But both of them still directed their anger toward Gandalf for withholding a lot of decidedly important information from both of them about the circumstances of Bilbo’s arrangement, Thorin more so.
On his way out, Gandalf made sure to remind Thorin that this was their last night in Bree and he would take Thorin back to Ered Luin in the morning. Gandalf was going to wake Thorin early in the morning again so they could check out of the inn and make the drive west back to Ered Luin.
When he was back in the privacy of his own room, Thorin kicked off his shoes and climbed onto his bed. Once comfortable, he began writing out a text to Dís.
Why didn’t you tell me you were going to get piano lessons?
Dís took her time replying, but the response came through within a couple minutes.
It never came up. It’s not like I was trying to hide it from you. You know I wouldn’t do that.
A moment later, another text arrived. Fundin never even told me when we were going to start. Just that Gandalf was taking care of it.
Well, Gandalf just told me that annoying bloke is the one teaching you. And he took me along because he wants me and Frerin to take lessons, too.
Oh, I’m sure that went over well.
Thorin laughed. Even in the tense moments Dís knew how to push his buttons the right way to calm him down. Yeah, no kidding.
Looking over at the clock, he saw it was nearly 11. That meant he ought to go to sleep soon. Who knew how much sleep he would be able to get before Gandalf came around to wake him up. He grabbed his phone again so he could send a quick goodnight text to Dís.
I’m going to get some sleep. You should too.
Okay then. Goodnight.
Goodnight.
Thorin set his phone down, rolled over, and tried to fall asleep, hoping he would get enough sleep to get him through the next day.
***
Thorin returned with Gandalf to Ered Luin around midday.
As soon as the two said their goodbyes and parted ways, Thorin was bombarded with questions from Dwalin.
“So Dís told us this morning that you’re apparently going to be taking piano lessons from that bloke in Bree you didn’t like and that he’s going to be staying in our house,” Dwalin said. “What’s that about?”
“I still have no idea,” Thorin sighed. “I’ll talk to Dís about it. It sounds like she knew about it already, but Gandalf said she didn’t know everything so I want to find out what she does know.”
Thorin went upstairs, first to his room so he could deposit his backpack, and then he went down the hall to knock on Dís’s door. It was already open a crack so Thorin peered his head in.
“Oh, it’s about time you’re back!” Dís remarked. “Come in.”
Thorin came in.
“You want to talk about last night, don’t you? Look, Gandalf told me that he knew a lot of people in the Shire and that he would be able to get someone to come teach me piano and Fundin was willing to go along with it. I didn’t know when we were going to start or what, I swear. If I had known some guy was going to be staying in our house you know I would have told you already.”
“That’s fair enough, I suppose.”
“I didn’t tell you about the lessons in the first place either because I didn’t know when it was going to happen. So you said this guy is a student? What’s his deal?”
“He’s graduating at the end of this term, so I assume he’s going to be coming here soon.”
“Why didn’t Fundin tell any of us that?”
“Right?” Thorin cracked a smile. He felt better talking through it with his sister. “He’s not one to keep secrets like that from us.”
“But term doesn’t end for another month, so at least he won’t be coming here tomorrow or anything sudden like that. You can calm down a bit until then.”
***
The weeks passed in the Durin household like normal now that they established the situation with Bilbo coming to stay with them. He would be coming sometime after his exams at the Bree Conservatory ended, which would be around the same time Dís and Frerin completed their exams, but Fundin had not yet figured out the details yet, so there was no established arrival date for some weeks.
In the back of his mind, Thorin was still apprehensive about the whole situation. Frerin and Dís didn’t seem to mind, though, and they were more excited about the prospect of piano lessons than Thorin.
Two weeks after Thorin’s return from Bree, Fundin announced over dinner that Bilbo would be coming to stay with them at the end of June. It was mid-May at this point, so Thorin was relieved he would have another month and a half to enjoy the house the way it was before Bilbo moved in and changed everything.
One day in mid-June, Balin confronted Thorin about the situation, with Bilbo’s move-in date looming closer now than ever. The reality of it all was starting to sink in for Thorin and he was apprehensive about not being able to escape the reality.
“Why don’t you just take the lessons?” Balin asked him that afternoon. “I know nobody can or will force you into it, but what’s the worst thing that will happen?”
Thorin sighed. “Won’t it be awkward, though? It would just be me and him alone in a room for all that time together. He didn’t even like me when we first met in Bree so it would be awkward for both of us.”
“Won’t it be more awkward if you turned down the lessons and you two would have to see each other all the time, knowing that you refused to be in the same room as him alone for these lessons? And your siblings will be working with him too, so it’s not just you. It’s not some super serious commitment. Don’t forget that he’s going to be living here, Thorin. It’s not like you can avoid him.”
“You’re right,” Thorin said after a moment of consideration. He wasn’t going to be able to wriggle his way out of this situation as easily as he hoped he would. “I was going to tell Gandalf that I didn’t want to do it.”
“You haven’t yet?”
“No.”
“Good. Don’t tell him. It might not be as bad as you think. Come on, now. I think Dwalin’s playing some video game and he’d be thrilled if we joined.”
“Alright, then.” Balin and Thorin left Thorin’s room and made their way downstairs to the living room, where they could already hear the sound of Dwalin yelling at a game on the TV.
***
Thorin’s nerves began to pick up as the days winded down to the day Bilbo was going to move into the house. The house was big enough that there would be no inconvenience; Fundin already made space in one of the spare guest rooms for Bilbo to stay. But it was so odd for Thorin to imagine Bilbo living in one of their guest rooms, just down the hall from his own room. That was the most jarring part of it all. He hadn’t even stopped to think about the actual lessons proper since his conversation with Balin because all the focus in the house was on Bilbo’s moving in first and foremost.
Finally, the days dwindled to zero and it was time for Bilbo to move in. The night before Fundin told everyone over dinner that Gandalf would be bringing Bilbo up in a moving van with all of Bilbo’s stuff. All Thorin could think about was how the moving van would stick out so much on their street. Their street was rather quiet and everyone knew everyone’s business, so everyone would see the van. Plus the street was physically very small so the van would take up a lot of space on the street.
Thorin slept well that night considering the anticipation building up in him for the next day. As the night wore on, he felt less apprehensive about the whole situation, but that was probably because he came to understand how little there was he was going to be able to do about it.
It will be fine, it will be fine, he repeated to himself in a mostly futile attempt at reassurance. He was no optimist, so counteracting his thoughts was an uphill battle, but it was the best he could do. After repeating it enough times, he started to feel a little less apprehensive about the whole thing, which was better than nothing.
The house was rather quiet by the time the morning rolled around. At first Thorin felt a bit odd when he woke up because the house was usually bustling with noise between the six of them all running around the house, but it wasn’t until he checked his phone to see the time that he realized why. It was hardly 6 and, in a house where no one was a morning person, being up that early without an alarm was unheard of. Residual nerves about the day ahead must have roused Thorin awake at this hour. There was nothing he was going to be able to do about it now—he knew he wouldn’t feel any better if he tried to roll over and go back to sleep—so he resigned to this early morning and got up and moved to his closet to get dressed for the day.
Once he was dressed he was quiet going down the stairs to make sure they wouldn’t creak and wake someone else up. He wasn’t one to be light on his feet, but he did his best in these situations where he didn’t want to wake up sleeping family members and that was good enough. In the kitchen he prepared a mug of black coffee and sat down at the table. Looking out the window, he appreciated the beauty of this morning. The early summer mornings were breathtaking, which made up for the fact that Thorin was awake this early. On the days when he had to wake up early for work, he found this to be the silver lining in his day. But deep down he still thought his sleep was more of a priority than enjoying the scenery
He got to enjoy a few hours to himself before anyone else in the house woke up. The first footsteps he heard coming from the ceiling above were from Balin.
“Good morning,” Balin said as he entered the kitchen, trying to hide his surprise that Thorin was awake before him. On days where nobody had to be awake first thing in the morning, he was usually the first one to wake up naturally. “Are you ready for today?”
“What do you think?” Thorin smirked. “How much stuff do you think Bilbo is going to bring if Gandalf’s driving a moving van up here for him?”
“I don’t know, but hopefully not a lot. We don’t have enough space for that.” The two laughed, albeit very quietly to make sure their laughter didn’t carry to the rest of the house.
As the hours drew on, the rest of the Durin household arose and joined Thorin and Balin in the kitchen. Even though the day ahead was going to be a busy one, they took advantage of this time in the morning to slow down and enjoy their time with each other as a family.
***
Gandalf and Bilbo arrived in the early afternoon, with a moving van as promised. The van was a lot smaller than Thorin expected. He thought it was going to be like one of those big trucks he saw in the movies. Instead, all Gandalf brought was a small van hardly bigger than Dwalin’s SUV parked in their garage.
Bilbo didn’t bring a lot of things with him. Chiefly he brought two suitcases filled with clothes and a box filled with snacks.
“I’m sorry if you don’t have any room in the kitchen to store all of these,” Bilbo told Fundin as the two of them unpacked the box of snacks.
“Don’t worry about it, lad,” Fundin said. “We’ll make room for everything.”
“That’s a relief. Food is a big part of our culture in the Shire; I’m thankful you’re able to accommodate that.”
Fundin chuckled. “There’s six of us in the house, so of course I understand the importance of having plenty of food around.”
So Bilbo and Fundin seem to be hitting it off, Thorin thought. That’s a good start.
Dís, Frerin, and Dwalin stayed off to the sidelines because they didn’t know how to help at this particular moment. Balin offered to help Bilbo lug his suitcases upstairs and show him to his room. Bilbo was so small that it would have been an incredible feat if he could handle it by himself. He sounded appreciative of Balin’s offer, and so the two men headed upstairs together.
“He seems nice enough,” Dís commented in a hushed voice once she heard the footsteps leave the staircase and move to the floor right above them.
Thorin snorted. “I never said he was rude.”
***
Balin and Bilbo spent most of the afternoon in Bilbo’s new room. Balin was helping him to get settled in. Thorin could hear snippets of their conversation from down the hall because they left the door open. Thorin was glad that at least one of them was getting along well with Bilbo.
Bilbo spent the rest of the day getting settled in. He emerged from his room in time for the dinner Fundin prepared for everyone.
“How are you settling in?” Fundin asked Bilbo over the meal.
“I’m settling in great, actually,” Bilbo remarked. “My room is still a mess, but I’ll sort that out over the coming days. That’s not a big deal at all. If Thorin, Dís, and Frerin are ready, I’d actually like to start teaching tomorrow.”
Thorin’s eyes widened.
“I thought we were waiting because Gandalf didn’t bring up your old piano yet,” Frerin said. “Didn’t he say it would be another week?”
“Yes, but I wanted to start teaching you all the theory first. You won’t need an actual piano for all of it. If you all are okay with it, it’d be good to get a head start now because you’ll need to know a lot of foundational stuff and I don’t want to overwhelm you. Once the piano comes I’ll start teaching you all individually.”
“That works for me,” Frerin responded.
“Works for me as well,” Dís said. Turning to Thorin she added, “What about you, Thorin? Does that sound alright?”
Thorin paused and exhaled through his nose. “Yes, that’s alright with me.”
***
The next day Dís offered to let Bilbo borrow her room for the lesson. He still hadn’t finished unpacking all his clothes and getting organized so his room was still a mess, which made it less than ideal for fitting the three Durin siblings in and teaching them.
Thorin was less than enthusiastic about the lesson and both his siblings knew this, but he tried to put on a more positive attitude for their sake. He didn’t want to let his own negative energy drag them down with him.
All Bilbo prepared for the lesson was a whiteboard with a marker and eraser. He really was only going to teach them basics, it seemed. How hard would this be?
But Thorin ended up underestimating how complicated music actually was.
Bilbo started by teaching them about the different kinds of notes in music. The beat was the backbone of every piece of music they had ever heard in their lives and it was this that dictated how the song flowed. Every note had a numerical value relative to the beat of a song: a quarter note equaled one beat, a half note equaled two beats, a whole note four beats, and an eighth note half a beat. Bilbo said there were many more types of notes beyond that, but Thorin felt like he was getting whiplash from even this much information. He drew out the basic notes as he described them and to Thorin it seemed more like an art project than music.
Dís and Frerin, on the other hand, seemed a lot more receptive to the information.
“I’ll teach you more about the notes themselves when I have an actual piano to work with so you can learn what every individual note sounds like,” Bilbo said. “Do you have any questions about the note values as I’ve explained them so far?”
Thorin didn’t say anything because he wasn’t sure how to explain that he simply didn’t understand what Bilbo was saying. Maybe he would start to pick it up once they started playing actual music.
Then Bilbo jumped into the structure of what sheet music actually looked like.
“Don’t worry about the lines for now,” Bilbo said as he drew out lines on the whiteboard. “I’ll go more into that when I teach you the notes on the piano. For now we’re only concerned with the note values I’m going to draw in.” At the top of the whiteboard Bilbo drew in two fours stacked on top of each other.
Thorin wanted to ask what the 4/4 represented but he figured that was part of the explanation, so he kept quiet. He didn’t want to interrupt. That would only draw more attention to himself.
As Bilbo drew out the notes, he would stop every now and then to draw a vertical line down, dividing the notes by some arbitrary measure that Thorin couldn’t figure out.
Once Bilbo moved back from the whiteboard, though, Thorin thought he was starting to get it. Judging by the values of the notes Bilbo drew, they counted out to four beats per grouping.
“Each of these groups of notes represents a measure,” Bilbo explained. “And you’re probably wondering what the 4/4 means. Don’t worry about the four on the bottom for now; I’ll explain that to you all later when we get into more complicated music theory. The top four represents four beats per measure. A measure is one of the groups, and you can tell measures apart by these vertical lines in between them.”
“Wait, so is this like one big math problem?” Thorin asked, trying to put the pieces together in his head.
Bilbo shrugged. “In a way, yes. The total amount of beats in every measure have to add up to four because that’s the top number. If the time signature were 3/4, then all the beats per measure would have to add up to three beats.” He paused, thinking about how to move forward. “If none of you have any more questions, then I’ll move on.”
There was a pause and none of the Durins said anything.
“Great. Next I’ll teach you the basics of dynamics and then I’ll end the lesson for this week there.”
Bilbo taught them the basics of dynamics in music, which Thorin found a lot easier to comprehend. It seemed pretty straightforward. The basic difference was defining the distinctions between “loud” and “quiet” and seemed a lot more basic than the complexity of counting and beats and notes.
Once Bilbo ran through the basics and thought the three of them understood the concept enough, he decided to end the lesson there as promised.
“That’ll be the lesson for this week,” Bilbo said with finality. “Gandalf promised my old piano should be here by next week so I’ll start teaching you all one-on-one going forward. It’s easier for just two of us at the piano at a time, and I’ll run through the different notes on the keyboard and all of that. You all can go now and I’ll see you at dinner.”
***
“So, how was your first lesson with Bilbo?” Dwalin asked in a mocking voice. After the lesson Thorin went into Dwalin’s room—it was also Balin’s room because they were so close they willing to share a room with each other—to fill them in on everything that happened.
“It was alright,” Thorin shrugged. “Why does music have to be so confusing?”
“Because you know nothing about it,” Balin teased. “Of course it’s gonna be hard at first. Come back and complain about how hard music is once you’ve sat on it a while and still have a hard time wrapping your head around it.”
Dwalin burst into laughter and Thorin smiled, appreciating this dynamic he had with his cousins.
“Alright, I suppose I’ll hold out on it.”
“I think that’s the right decision,” Balin said. “Let’s see how that turns out for you.”
