Chapter Text
Thorin spent most of the subsequent days at work with Fundin, but from what he could observe when he was home, Bilbo seemed to adapt quickly to life in the Durin household. He didn’t seem like much of an outsider among the family, despite all of his stark differences.
Now that Dís and Frerin were out of school, Bilbo spent more time with them when he wasn’t by himself. In the middle of the week Gandalf arrived in Ered Luin with Bilbo’s old piano. Once Dwalin and Thorin were home from work Gandalf recruited them to help him carry the piano up to Bilbo’s room because they were the ones who would be strong enough for the task.
“Why are pianos so heavy?” Dwalin asked Gandalf, gasping for breath when he and Thorin brought the piano into Bilbo’s room. They had just finished arranging the piano per Bilbo’s standards, but that was a breeze compared to the hard work of lugging it up the stairs in the first place.
“How heavy did you think they would be?” Bilbo said, laughing a little bit to himself.
“Lighter than this,” Thorin huffed, hoping his tone didn’t come off as rude. He was so out of breath that his words came out more as a gasp than his usual voice. His muscles ached from the work, but that was not a feeling unfamiliar to him. Working with his hands as a blacksmith made him accustomed to the feeling of sore arms, but not so much being out of breath. None of the work he created was quite so heavy and he especially never had to brace himself to carry such heavy objects up a flight of stairs.
“Thank you for helping me move it up here,” Bilbo said, clearly ignoring Thorin’s comment. “I wouldn’t have been able to do it myself.”
“It’s no trouble,” Dwalin said. “Right, Thorin?” He eyed Thorin.
“Yeah, it’s no trouble at all, really,” Thorin said.
***
A few days later it came time for Thorin’s first individual lesson with Bilbo. Thorin was not sure what to expect from having a private lesson with Bilbo. When he thought about it he realized the two of them had not spent time alone in a room together. There were always other people around, but this first lesson would be the first time they were alone together and Thorin just wasn’t sure how it was going to go. They were cordial enough with each other up until now because there were always other people around—even though it seemed to be no secret they hadn’t initially warmed up to each other, even as Bilbo got along with the rest of the family—but who knew if that would change behind closed doors.
Thorin was in his room with Dís until it came time for the predesignated time for his lesson with Bilbo. He kicked Dís out of his room and while she went down the hall to go talk to Balin and Dwalin instead, Thorin made his way for the guest room where Bilbo was.
Thorin knocked on the door and heard a faint, “Come in,” from the other side. He opened the door and entered the room with slow steps, almost as if he were hesitating along the way. There was a small bench in front of the piano.
“Take a seat,” Bilbo said, gesturing to the bench. “I’m going to sit here to start.” He was sitting on the foot of the bed, just a few feet away from the bench. It was a big enough room that there was space for the piano, but it was also still small enough that they couldn’t fit any more chairs for Bilbo to sit at besides just the foot of his bed. It seemed to suffice, though, and Thorin assumed it was probably more comfortable to sit there than on the bench.
Thorin felt out of place sitting on the bench, looking at the piano. He supposed it was because this was still all so unfamiliar with him, and when he thought about it, much of what Bilbo explained to him, Dís, and Frerin last week didn’t seem to stick. He was sticking it out for their sake to be a good brother to them and support them—especially Dís, since it was she who wanted to do this in the first place—and help Fundin out by doing this, since he was letting Bilbo stay here as a favor to Gandalf. It was all intertangled with the fact that he wasn’t sure if he was going to be able to rise to the challenge of actually learning this instrument from scratch. From what he knew so far from Bilbo’s explanations, it was a lot more complicated than merely putting your fingers to the keyboard.
“Alright, I’m going to continue with the basics now that we have the piano here,” Bilbo said. “Today I mostly just want to go over the basics of all the notes and make sure you’re starting to get familiar with the keyboard itself. Does that sound alright?”
“Yeah, that’s fine,” Thorin said.
“Great. By the way, don’t worry if you’re still figuring out all the theory I went over with you last week. I know it can be a lot to take in at once, but it’ll make a lot more sense when you’re actually playing so you’ll be able to apply it there.”
That reassured Thorin, even if only a little bit. At least it wasn’t just all in his head that he was struggling to pick up on everything so far.
“To start, you can see on the piano that there are black keys and white keys. I’m only going to teach you about the white keys for now. I’ll get to the black keys soon, so don’t worry about that for now. Actually, why don’t you scoot over so I can help you through the notes on the keyboard?”
Thorin paused, but he relented and scooted. It wasn’t like he was going to be able to say no. The bench was so small that it was a tight fit for both of them to sit on the bench, even in spite of Bilbo’s small stature. Thorin started to feel a little claustrophobic but swallowed the feeling.
Bilbo ran through a quick explanation of the notes and where they fell on the keyboard. The notes ranged from A to G and they were laid out on the keyboard in order, with each key having its own specific spot relative to all the other keys. Bilbo had some basic sheet music prepared and demonstrated how each note corresponded with a note on a certain line of the music.
“Didn’t you mention something about clefs?” Thorin asked, feeling a bit nervous as the tightness of the situation set in. He was physically uncomfortable feeling so squeezed to fit on this bench, but more so because he was sitting on it next to Bilbo than anything else.
“Oh yes,” Bilbo said, lighting up a little bit, clearly happy that Thorin managed to remember at least that little bit of last week’s lesson. “There’s two kinds of clefs we use in piano music: treble and bass.” The sheet music in front of them already had the two clefs printed onto the lines, so Bilbo pointed each one out. “Generally the right hand plays treble clef and the left hand plays bass clef, so that’s why you see them stacked like this on the music, but don’t worry about playing with two hands yet.”
“Right, I’m gonna have to figure out how to play with just one hand first,” Thorin remarked, smiling a little bit.
“Exactly.” Bilbo laughed and Thorin felt a little more comfortable.
Bilbo went on, identifying all the notes on the piano relative to where they would fall on the sheet music. He only stuck to explaining the treble clef to begin with, which was more than enough for Thorin to follow because he already thought it was going to be a challenge to memorize all the details. Every note corresponded to a spot on the lines of the sheet music, but it was different for bass clef compared to treble clef. All along the way, Bilbo had Thorin play each of the keys so he could familiarize himself with the sounds they all made, insisting that associating the sound and the placement of the key would make it easier to learn at every step of piano playing. Thorin thought he was starting to get the hang of treble clef, but bass clef was not sticking as well.
“Why don’t we end the lesson here for today?” Bilbo suggested once he noticed how Thorin seemed to hit an end point with how much he was going to be able to take in for the day. “You’ve done a good job so far.”
Thorin thought this was a bit of a stretch, but he agreed to finishing anyway. He wondered how much of this would stick with him for the next couple days, until Bilbo decided he should have another lesson.
“Since you’re all just starting out, I’ll let you know when I think we should have another lesson,” Bilbo explained. “Ideally music teachers like to keep lessons at once a week, which is what I’d like to do as well once I think you have the hang of things and can handle practicing on your own in between lessons and everything, but since you’re still learning the very basics I think we should meet a little more frequently than that.”
“That’s fine,” Thorin said. “Just let me know when you want to have another lesson. You know my work schedule already.”
“Alright, well, I’ll see you later,” Bilbo said. Thorin rose from the bench and headed out of Bilbo’s room. In the back of his mind, he knew figuring out piano would be an uphill battle, and one he was not sure if he was entirely looking forward to facing.
***
Thorin had two days of work after his first lesson with Bilbo. The morning of that second day, Bilbo asked him if he would be ready to have another lesson the following day, and Thorin said yes. In his mind, he was begrudging to continue going along with it, but he tried to keep something of a positive attitude on the outside. Maybe if he faked it he could make it, like the saying always went.
Thorin struggled to sleep that night. He was usually a heavy sleeper who could sleep through even some of the more stressful events in his life, but on this particular night he couldn’t find the way to turn his brain off. He wasn’t sure why he was so antsy about this lesson with Bilbo but he was worried he wasn’t getting the hang of it. He recalled a moment at dinner that night of Dís and Bilbo talking about how she was picking up piano surprisingly quickly. He knew he shouldn’t compare himself to his sister, who was the one who wanted these lessons in the first place, but it still bothered him that he couldn’t wrap his head around music in general.
His fears seemed confirmed during his lesson with Bilbo the next day. It was in the evening, so he managed to trudge through an entire day at work with no problems arising over the course of the day. It was a relief, something in his life to reassure him of everything unfolding around him and keeping him grounded.
Then came the evening. Bilbo picked up with the lesson right where they left off last time. Bilbo ran through the basics of bass clef again, but Thorin still wasn’t getting the hang of it. Bilbo seemed to notice this and moved on.
Thorin couldn’t help but appreciate how Bilbo seemed so patient in dealing with him, even though he knew the two of them still weren’t overly fond of each other. That didn’t matter at all. Bilbo was masking his own feelings in favor of getting the job done and Thorin could respect an attitude like that.
“Here, I have some music I want you to try playing,” Bilbo said, pulling some sheet music out of a folder. “It’s only for one hand, so you can go ahead and use only your right hand to play. It’s also in treble clef so we can focus on making sure you have treble clef down before we try to move onto bass clef.”
This made Thorin nervous. He felt like he was being put on the spot, and he still didn’t understand the whole concept of rhythm well enough to be able to actually play anything proper, and banging random notes on the keyboard certainly didn’t count as “proper.” He didn’t think he was ready to play actual music anytime soon.
But of course Bilbo would try to push him out of his comfort zone. How was he going to get anywhere and make any substantial progress if he didn’t at least try to push those boundaries?
At first Thorin was proud of himself as he managed the first and then the second keys on the keyboard. It was a start and better than nothing, but after struggling through the first measure—and that was with some help from Bilbo along the way—he felt like he was going to lose his footing. The first measure was just quarter notes so it was easy enough to do the math in his head of how to count out the beats. He knew Bilbo explained the other beats to him already, but his memory was failing him.
He spent the rest of the lesson running through the first couple of measures over and over again with Bilbo. Bilbo didn’t want him to move forward with the rest of the music until he got this beginning down. That way he would have some foundational understanding before he tried to play anything else. Thorin understood where he was coming from, but he also couldn’t help but be frustrated with the whole situation. He felt like it was so simple that he should have been getting it faster.
The lesson dragged on for about an hour before Bilbo finally called it and let Thorin finish for the day.
“We’ll pick up in a couple days again,” Bilbo said. “You’re off to a good start.”
Thorin scoffed, but his attempt to keep that to himself failed and Bilbo picked up on it.
“No, really, you are,” Bilbo insisted. “You just need to keep working at it.”
“You’re probably right,” Thorin said, doing his best to remain enthusiastic on the outside even though it conflicted with his internal feelings.
***
As the days passed, work felt like a familiar place for Thorin. He knew what he was doing when he worked on refining weaponry, mostly axes for the miners who worked alongside his cousins in the mines. As Fundin taught him, there was something comforting about being able to work on weaponry with his own hands like this, as opposed to the mass-produced tools made in factories nowadays. It was the personal, hand-crafted touch to these weapons that made them so special. Thorin appreciated every step of this crafting process and the customers appreciated it, too. It was such a stark contrast in comparison to the unfamiliar territory of music, one Thorin was struggling to wrap his head around.
When his mind drifted to thinking about piano, he tried to remind himself learning music was like training to be a blacksmith. He wasn’t any good the first time he picked up the tools, but over time he got used to the way they felt in his hands and then he got comfortable using those tools to create something. This was what Bilbo did, but with piano. And Bilbo’s job in all of this was trying to encourage him to reach that more successful point.
Thorin felt exhausted at the prospect of continuing to play by the time his time for his next lesson came around, but it wasn’t like he was going to be able to get out of it anyway. This time he struggled a little more through the music. It was starting to click a little better this time, but only as Bilbo pushed him through all of it.
“I just don’t get why this is so hard,” Thorin grumbled after playing through the first two measures for what felt like at least the fifth time in a row.
“It’s not supposed to be easy,” Bilbo said. “Especially as you’re starting out.”
“Why do I have to keep playing this little bit? Why keep playing it over and over again instead of doing the rest of it?”
“You need to have a good grip on these first couple measures before you can keep going. You’re having trouble keeping up with the rhythm and it’s only going to get harder if you don’t get a better feel for it early on.”
Knowing he wasn’t going to be able to put up a fight, Thorin decided to just continue playing per Bilbo’s instructions. Thorin had to give it to Bilbo: he was stubborn as a teacher. He wasn’t going to let Thorin give up so easily.
After a few more tries, Bilbo sighed. “It looks like you’ve done enough for today. I know you’re frustrated, so I’ll let you finish early. How does that sound?”
This caught Thorin off guard. Thorin was starting to get more aggressive as he got frustrated, but Bilbo was doing his best to keep his cool.
“That’s alright,” Thorin said, drawing out the words as though he were anticipating this becoming a trick question on the spot.
“Thank you, by the way,” he said on his way out of the room. “I know you’re doing a lot between teaching me and also teaching my siblings the same things.”
***
Thorin had lost track of the days and forgot that the next day was Saturday. He worked most Saturdays, but he forgot that he had this particular Saturday off until he woke up and realized Fundin was not in a rush to leave for work. In fact, Fundin was sleeping in that day and it was Thorin who had woken up for nothing.
When Fundin woke up later in the morning, he had a project ready for Thorin. He wanted to go through some old stuff they were accumulating in the garage and decide what to get rid of and he recruited Thorin to do it, since their work schedules were almost always identical—they both worked the days their shop was open, and it was only occasionally that Fundin worked extra days while giving Thorin the day off. He had wanted Balin and Dwalin to help somewhere along the way as well, but that was contingent on his sons’ own work schedules, which were also flexible and usually did not line up with Fundin and Thorin’s.
It would prove to be a long afternoon, but Thorin appreciated it. He had no idea what stuff was hidden packed away in the dark corners of this garage and whatever they found, it surely would be interesting.
Once Fundin and Balin were awake, they made their way to the garage to start the work of sorting through everything. There was so much stuff that they had to divide and conquer to stand a chance of getting through it all. Thorin liked the work. It was quiet enough—something he found comforting and welcoming considering how noisy working in the shop could be on busy days—and he could keep to himself and stay in his own head. It was the way he liked doing things; that was why working as a blacksmith ultimately suited him so well and he took to the work so quickly.
The initial sorting process was solitary work. Thorin organized all the stuff he pulled off the shelves with the knowledge that they would all decide as a group what stuff they would keep and what stuff they would discard. Thorin pulled all the boxes off the shelves of one wall of the garage over the course of about an hour. Dwalin ended up joining and helping Fundin with one wall’s worth of boxes. Once the four of them all pulled everything down from the shelves, they started to open everything up to see what was inside.
In the first box Thorin opened he found a book with his mother’s name scribbled onto the front.
“What’s this?” Thorin asked, calling for Fundin’s attention. Fundin came over and looked over Thorin’s shoulder, studying the book to see if he could recall what it was.
“Oh, that,” Fundin said, sounding a little shocked. “That is your mother’s diary.”
Thorin turned to look at Fundin, but Fundin kept a poker face that gave away no indication of emotion behind the words. It was a simple declaration of what the item was. “She kept a diary?”
“To be honest, I forgot we had that in the boxes,” Fundin said. “If not, I would have showed it to you sooner. I have no idea what she wrote in that, but I’m not surprised that you’re curious about it. Whatever she wrote, I’m sure it’s plenty interesting.”
“Can I read it?
“Of course you can. I don’t see why not.”
Thorin barely remembered his mother. All he had were faint memories of a woman from his very early youth, a woman who colored the background of his earliest memories. But nothing more than that. He was six when she died, so in his mind he should have been old enough to remember her. Right? But why didn’t he? Was the loss so hard on him that he blocked out that early portion of his life? All he had left to work with was a fuzzy recollection at best. Finding this diary would be a once-in-a-lifetime chance to look into the life of a mother he couldn’t remember.
***
Thorin, Balin, Dwalin, and Fundin spent the rest of the morning sorting through the boxes. They gave up around lunchtime, when Fundin declared they ought to stop for the day. If they continued on for too long, then they would probably end up overlooking some stuff they would or wouldn’t want to get rid of and make the wrong call about what to do with it. They would figure out another time to finish sorting through the rest of the stuff and in the meantime, they had a ton of other errands they would have to work on for the rest of the day.
Thorin was happy to help around the house with the rest of the day, much like he was any other day. But in the back of his mind he was starting to get curious and antsy about what he would find inside the diary. For all he knew, it could either be the most boring or the most exciting thing he had ever read and he wouldn’t know until he opened it up and started reading.
It was by coincidence that Fundin invited Gandalf over for dinner over that night. It was a spontaneous decision prompted by the fact that the old man happened to be in town on that day. Bilbo seemed to be happy that Gandalf came by, even if his arrival was unannounced until the day of. After dinner Balin and Dwalin took Frerin out to see a movie at the town’s only movie theater while Thorin and Dís kept to themselves in their rooms. Fundin and Bilbo stayed in the dining room to catch up with Gandalf.
Thorin tried to put Bilbo out of his mind and not think about what Bilbo was probably telling Gandalf about him and how his lessons have been going so far. He wanted to worry more about this diary of his mother’s that had been in this house the entire time he had been living here, but he had simply not known about. Who knew what he was going to learn about his mother and likely his father too. It was a rather large book with at least a few hundred pages so there had to be a lot of stuff to glean from all of it.
There was nowhere to start but the beginning, so that was what he did. The first entry in the diary was dated a few days after his birth. Judging from how big this book was, it could cover all of his life until his mother’s death. That was a lot of life he had felt like he missed out on and the thought of that overwhelmed him. He was curious, of course, but, like Fundin, he had no idea what he would find in those pages. For all he knew it covered the details of her pregnancies with Frerin and Dís and life with a young Thorin, a life he couldn’t even remember from his own perspective, let alone comprehend from the perspective of his mother. And Fundin never talked about his parents, so he was going into this diary blind. He took a moment to collect himself before he dove into the first words of this first entry. There was no going back now.
The first entry was dated a few days after the day Thorin was born.
I just gave birth to Thorin a few days ago, but with how much I’ve been sleeping it doesn’t feel like it’s been that long. I figured now would be a better time than ever to start writing in this diary though. I want to remember all of this crazy adventure I’m about to go on. My first son and he’s such a beautiful boy! I haven’t seen Thráin so happy since Erebor fell.
Thorin paused. He heard vague stories about Erebor when he was growing up. All the people in Ered Luin told the children the story, sort of like a fairytale among the community. The story was always the same: the people of Erebor were lost to the dragon Smaug, who took over the island. There was no word of people surviving the attack and the island was presumed lost forever to the dragon. Thorin always asked more questions about the story, but no one was ever willing to tell more about it. He once found an old newspaper in the garage with the news of Erebor’s fall as the big headline of the day, so he knew it was a real event, but Erebor was off the coast of Wales, hundreds of miles to the south of Ered Luin. Why would his father care about Erebor’s fall?
He didn’t think about it too much and kept reading.
The day Erebor fell was truly devastating. I will never forget the sights of everyone running through the front doors of the mountain, fleeing for their lives. We were lucky we were able to fill all our life boats and sail them across Dale and back to fill them up again with more people waiting. Thráin had insisted I was one of the first to be evacuated across the water, even though I refused to be separated from him for any amount of time. He stayed behind to make sure all the survivors got across the water before he brought himself across on one of the last boats. I spent all that time anxiously pacing back on forth at the port of Dale, staring across the horizon, waiting to see him arrive on one of the boats. I will never forget how relieved I was when I finally saw him again.
So his father had been a hero in this attack he knew barely nothing about, in an event he had no idea his family had been involved in.
Perhaps it is Thorin’s greatest advantage that he can manage to separate himself from this reality, even without realizing what he is doing. Sometimes I have to pause and remember this is Thráin’s heir. I truly hope he grows up looking up to his father and that he will grow up to be just like him.
Heir? What was this about Thorin being an heir? This was the first of him ever hearing about being an heir to anything.
That was the end of the first entry and the rest of the first page was blank, but Thorin didn’t want to read more now. One entry was enough for today. But he couldn’t get the one entry out of his head. Surely this whole “being an heir” thing was related to the whole Erebor thing. They had to be connected. There was no way this was a coincidence.
Thorin wasn’t sure what to make of this new information, but there was a tugging of reason inside him telling him to push against this and get to the bottom of it. He was going to go talk to Fundin about it. He didn’t stop to think about how Gandalf was over for the evening as he went down the stairs. He wasn’t thinking about anything except how this information was bugging him and that there was something Fundin never told him about his childhood.
Thorin’s heart sank when he got to the kitchen and saw Bilbo and Gandalf still at the table with Fundin.
It was too late to go back now, though. Thorin was still reeling and he wasn’t going to be able to stop thinking about this until he got it out of his system.
“What is it, Thorin?” Fundin asked.
“In my mother’s diary,” Thorin started, “the first entry mentioned my father being devastated about the fall of Erebor and something about me being an heir to something. What is that all about?”
Bilbo looked confused by all of this, but Gandalf looked to Fundin and his silence felt telling. There was something there.
Fundin sighed. “Sit down, Thorin. There’s a lot to tell you and it’s about time I told you all of it from the beginning.”
