Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

Wedding Night

Summary:

As Thorin lies dying, he considers the one wish still burning in his heart. There is no more time to fulfill it, nor was there ever much hope. But things that are not possible in life may yet be possible in death.

Chapter 1: The Darkest Hour

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Thorin has long known this moment would come.

Azog’s blade, threatening to twist into him, looms over, dark and sickening, overpowering him. He won’t be able to hold much longer.

But there is still time for the shadows in his mind to take contour and form an image. A heavy door opens into darkness. A door of stone, grey and menacing, full of ominous anticipation. It is the Hidden Door, and he is the one opening it.

A year ago, while he was contemplating taking up the quest, he had heard his mother’s voice from beyond...

If you stay in the Blue Mountains, you will live a long, prosperous life. You will see your nephews’ children and enjoy the reward of your labors. If you go to Erebor, you will be remembered as a hero. But you will never live to see it restored. There is nothing for you in this quest.

This last statement he would argue with, if he had the strength. There is something he gained during this quest.

He releases Orcrist, and Azog plunges his blade into him. Now there is little time to act. Thorin rolls them over and sends Orcrist deep into his enemy’s flesh. They will both die; yet he wants to make sure his enemy dies first. It’s all in the span of a few seconds, but the order of these things - the fact that there is a first and a next - makes these moments last much longer.

Azog’s eyes lose the light, for good this time. Only then, Thorin lets go.

He stands, takes a few steps, exhales, and falls back on the ice.

He’s not supposed to be here. If death should take him, it should be elsewhere. Lying on grass, under a tree at dusk, when the first stars appear in the sky and darkness settles over the forest. A breeze blowing. A stream nearby. The birds singing their good night song. There he would lay, one with the earth, forgetting that he ever happened.

He will die. But it will not be there. It will be on top of this cold ice, on the doorstep of his home where he should have been welcomed as a king.

The Hidden Door opens again in his mind, and now he sees that it leads to a tomb.

Do not go, my son, for you shall never return. There is nothing for you there; only death.

The tomb is stretched out before him, prepared even before he set out from Ered Luin. He always knew, but always put that thought aside, to deal with later. Or never. How important life was to him... he didn’t consider. He will die, so that others should live.

Yet now there is a question. If he could choose again, what he would choose. And the uncertainty of whether life really is that good, or death that bad. If by chance there are some things that only death can bring to fulfillment.

The Hidden Door opens again, and this time the connection is seamlessly clear in his mind: the Mountain is a tomb, and he is lying in it.

Back on the ice, Bilbo runs to be at his side. Bilbo. This is what makes it all so confusing. Thorin doesn’t want to leave him behind. But he can’t ask Bilbo to join him.

Something he will take with him in death.

He asks for forgiveness. Bilbo gives it to him easily, as if there’s no question. It is all done very quickly, just like Thorin and Azog finishing each other off. Perhaps the moments that really matter, that truly make a difference in this life, are all like that. Fast, hence you can never take them in; so they just pass you by.

Bilbo doesn’t seem to want to part with him either, or even seem ready to believe that Thorin will die. Yet of all things, this should be the easiest to believe.

Bilbo holds his hand and gives him heartfeltly encouraging words, and it’s more than reassuring. It’s strange that they should part now, of all times: they have never been closer.

Something greater than death.

How? How can he die, and take Bilbo with him? Bilbo was always supposed to live. Or how can he die and remain in the world of the living, never too far?

He doesn’t know how. Yet he wants both of these impossibilities right now. He wants to meet Bilbo in death, to start with.

Another door appears in his mind, in the same great darkness as before. It is a round, green door. He hears a loud knock - his own knock - then he opens it. Maybe the way to never be parted is to go back in time and start the quest all over again. Or maybe he’ll enter a possible universe where things will play out differently. Either way, stepping through that door is a chance to meet Bilbo one more time.

But it is not any of those. Instead, the green door opens simply to let out light into his tomb. And the present stays present.

He can tell that Bilbo feels awkward, out of place. For Bilbo this position is untenable; this is not right. He hates being the one sitting up and attending to Thorin’s wound, the one who still has life left in him. Bilbo would gladly switch places, would rather be the one lying on the ice.

Don’t be afraid. We shall never be parted.

He wants to have Bilbo always near, woven into his existence, joined together with him as one. How can he want this now, when it will soon be over. How can they be together.

He hasn’t even asked, either. Except for when...

His mind stumbles and shakes, same as always when he ponders the meaning of the mithril. Like a pendulum, swinging left and right, never staying in one place, yet always returning to the center.

Protection for the battle. A marriage proposal.

The left says protection. The right says proposal. But it is neither of those.

The center has the meaning, though the other two are right too, in their own way.

When Thorin thinks of him, the mithril resembles what is revealed. It is the only thing that comes close to the person that Bilbo is; the clothing that matches his soul. This is why it was so easy to give, its meaning so simple, so clear.

Yet he cannot shake the thought of more. Because the mithril also fits him for a special event that Thorin wanted- still wants. Both of them clothed in brightness, standing together, blending. That has not come to pass.

If Thorin lived, would he ask? Would he finalize what he started?

Perhaps not. It’s not because he won’t forgive himself, or Bilbo won’t forgive him. But Bilbo’s home, his beloved Shire... Thorin would not take him from it, to place him in this cold, unfeeling Mountain. No, it would have never been possible. Thorin must accept that.

Maybe that’s why death is better.

Things that are not possible in life may be possible in death.

This is not about getting an extra hour of life and asking Bilbo Will you marry me, and Bilbo somehow instantly and magically overcoming all confusion, hurt and doubt and saying yes, and then having the right person materialize to witness to this event in a hurry. No. Even if Thorin were granted another hour, he would not do this.

No, the wedding must happen in death, not before it.

Still, Bilbo must overcome all doubt and confusion and consent to it. And it’s not clear where Bilbo stands on that front.

Thorin lifts his eyelids to meet his gaze. Bilbo is weeping, his tears falling on Thorin’s painfully useless armor.

“Is this what you wanted?”

As always, Bilbo cuts like a razor straight where it hurts. In a way, it is true. Since he didn’t do anything to prevent it, he can be said to have wanted to die. Just as he wanted - wants - to marry Bilbo. And Thorin can’t explain to himself how he could have wanted both.

“No,” he answers. “It is not. But I felt it in me, before I even began. I was warned that I would die, though the details were not made clear.”

“Thorin...” Bilbo is breaking now.

“I feel... that I must accept it,” Thorin continues apologetically.

“But I cannot!”

Thorin tries to reassure him, the effort to speak now an evident struggle. “It is not what it looks like.”

The end is near.

If you knew you would die at the end, why did you...

Bilbo’s eyes speak for him, since of course, he cannot say the word, ever.

Thorin’s eyes respond in kind; yet much remains unsaid.

I don’t know. It was something that had to do with my heart.

The real conversation is yet laid before him. How to bring it up, how to ask.

My heart...

“I don’t regret it,” he tries. “For I found something of infinite value on my journey.”

Something worth dying for?

“Something worth dying for,” he echoes Bilbo’s thought. “And dying with.”

It’s questionable whether this is the right thing to do. But there is one thing that Thorin has learned from his life, something he hoped to pass on to his nephews and followers. That there are good and bad ideas, there is doing right and doing wrong, and then there is doing something from the heart. That transcends the rest. It’s in its own category, and has nothing to do with right and wrong. Nothing.

Perhaps it would help him to know that, of all people, the person he managed to impart this knowledge to is Bilbo. This is exactly what Bilbo likes about him. Thorin taught him this without even trying, taught him about following your heart even when it seems like the wildest thing.

“Please don’t leave,” Bilbo begs him.

The green door opens again, and now Thorin sees more. It is not a door into the past, but it does promise a new beginning. It is a door to life, new life.

Thorin’s face relaxes into a smile of pure happiness. Now he is ready.

“Don’t be afraid. If you’ll have it... we shall never be parted.”

The world stops spinning for a moment, while he wills to take on the madly impossible. That, at least, is nothing new to him.

“Bilbo, my heart...”

The Eagles’ flight freezes in the air, the sound of battle cries ceases, the sun’s light never hits the ice. Only Thorin’s words manage to reach, still.

“...is yours. Forever.”

He looks Bilbo in the eyes, enough to see them widen through tears in astonished surprise, and breathes one last time.

Notes:

Some of the imagery in this chapter came from my "Everything" video, available on both AO3 and YouTube.