Actions

Work Header

Wedding Night

Summary:

As Thorin lies dying, he considers the one wish still burning in his heart. There is no more time to fulfill it, nor was there ever much hope. But things that are not possible in life may yet be possible in death.

Chapter 1: The Darkest Hour

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Thorin has long known this moment would come.

Azog’s blade, threatening to twist into him, looms over, dark and sickening, overpowering him. He won’t be able to hold much longer.

But there is still time for the shadows in his mind to take contour and form an image. A heavy door opens into darkness. A door of stone, grey and menacing, full of ominous anticipation. It is the Hidden Door, and he is the one opening it.

A year ago, while he was contemplating taking up the quest, he had heard his mother’s voice from beyond...

If you stay in the Blue Mountains, you will live a long, prosperous life. You will see your nephews’ children and enjoy the reward of your labors. If you go to Erebor, you will be remembered as a hero. But you will never live to see it restored. There is nothing for you in this quest.

This last statement he would argue with, if he had the strength. There is something he gained during this quest.

He releases Orcrist, and Azog plunges his blade into him. Now there is little time to act. Thorin rolls them over and sends Orcrist deep into his enemy’s flesh. They will both die; yet he wants to make sure his enemy dies first. It’s all in the span of a few seconds, but the order of these things - the fact that there is a first and a next - makes these moments last much longer.

Azog’s eyes lose the light, for good this time. Only then, Thorin lets go.

He stands, takes a few steps, exhales, and falls back on the ice.

He’s not supposed to be here. If death should take him, it should be elsewhere. Lying on grass, under a tree at dusk, when the first stars appear in the sky and darkness settles over the forest. A breeze blowing. A stream nearby. The birds singing their good night song. There he would lay, one with the earth, forgetting that he ever happened.

He will die. But it will not be there. It will be on top of this cold ice, on the doorstep of his home where he should have been welcomed as a king.

The Hidden Door opens again in his mind, and now he sees that it leads to a tomb.

Do not go, my son, for you shall never return. There is nothing for you there; only death.

The tomb is stretched out before him, prepared even before he set out from Ered Luin. He always knew, but always put that thought aside, to deal with later. Or never. How important life was to him... he didn’t consider. He will die, so that others should live.

Yet now there is a question. If he could choose again, what he would choose. And the uncertainty of whether life really is that good, or death that bad. If by chance there are some things that only death can bring to fulfillment.

The Hidden Door opens again, and this time the connection is seamlessly clear in his mind: the Mountain is a tomb, and he is lying in it.

Back on the ice, Bilbo runs to be at his side. Bilbo. This is what makes it all so confusing. Thorin doesn’t want to leave him behind. But he can’t ask Bilbo to join him.

Something he will take with him in death.

He asks for forgiveness. Bilbo gives it to him easily, as if there’s no question. It is all done very quickly, just like Thorin and Azog finishing each other off. Perhaps the moments that really matter, that truly make a difference in this life, are all like that. Fast, hence you can never take them in; so they just pass you by.

Bilbo doesn’t seem to want to part with him either, or even seem ready to believe that Thorin will die. Yet of all things, this should be the easiest to believe.

Bilbo holds his hand and gives him heartfeltly encouraging words, and it’s more than reassuring. It’s strange that they should part now, of all times: they have never been closer.

Something greater than death.

How? How can he die, and take Bilbo with him? Bilbo was always supposed to live. Or how can he die and remain in the world of the living, never too far?

He doesn’t know how. Yet he wants both of these impossibilities right now. He wants to meet Bilbo in death, to start with.

Another door appears in his mind, in the same great darkness as before. It is a round, green door. He hears a loud knock - his own knock - then he opens it. Maybe the way to never be parted is to go back in time and start the quest all over again. Or maybe he’ll enter a possible universe where things will play out differently. Either way, stepping through that door is a chance to meet Bilbo one more time.

But it is not any of those. Instead, the green door opens simply to let out light into his tomb. And the present stays present.

He can tell that Bilbo feels awkward, out of place. For Bilbo this position is untenable; this is not right. He hates being the one sitting up and attending to Thorin’s wound, the one who still has life left in him. Bilbo would gladly switch places, would rather be the one lying on the ice.

Don’t be afraid. We shall never be parted.

He wants to have Bilbo always near, woven into his existence, joined together with him as one. How can he want this now, when it will soon be over. How can they be together.

He hasn’t even asked, either. Except for when...

His mind stumbles and shakes, same as always when he ponders the meaning of the mithril. Like a pendulum, swinging left and right, never staying in one place, yet always returning to the center.

Protection for the battle. A marriage proposal.

The left says protection. The right says proposal. But it is neither of those.

The center has the meaning, though the other two are right too, in their own way.

When Thorin thinks of him, the mithril resembles what is revealed. It is the only thing that comes close to the person that Bilbo is; the clothing that matches his soul. This is why it was so easy to give, its meaning so simple, so clear.

Yet he cannot shake the thought of more. Because the mithril also fits him for a special event that Thorin wanted- still wants. Both of them clothed in brightness, standing together, blending. That has not come to pass.

If Thorin lived, would he ask? Would he finalize what he started?

Perhaps not. It’s not because he won’t forgive himself, or Bilbo won’t forgive him. But Bilbo’s home, his beloved Shire... Thorin would not take him from it, to place him in this cold, unfeeling Mountain. No, it would have never been possible. Thorin must accept that.

Maybe that’s why death is better.

Things that are not possible in life may be possible in death.

This is not about getting an extra hour of life and asking Bilbo Will you marry me, and Bilbo somehow instantly and magically overcoming all confusion, hurt and doubt and saying yes, and then having the right person materialize to witness to this event in a hurry. No. Even if Thorin were granted another hour, he would not do this.

No, the wedding must happen in death, not before it.

Still, Bilbo must overcome all doubt and confusion and consent to it. And it’s not clear where Bilbo stands on that front.

Thorin lifts his eyelids to meet his gaze. Bilbo is weeping, his tears falling on Thorin’s painfully useless armor.

“Is this what you wanted?”

As always, Bilbo cuts like a razor straight where it hurts. In a way, it is true. Since he didn’t do anything to prevent it, he can be said to have wanted to die. Just as he wanted - wants - to marry Bilbo. And Thorin can’t explain to himself how he could have wanted both.

“No,” he answers. “It is not. But I felt it in me, before I even began. I was warned that I would die, though the details were not made clear.”

“Thorin...” Bilbo is breaking now.

“I feel... that I must accept it,” Thorin continues apologetically.

“But I cannot!”

Thorin tries to reassure him, the effort to speak now an evident struggle. “It is not what it looks like.”

The end is near.

If you knew you would die at the end, why did you...

Bilbo’s eyes speak for him, since of course, he cannot say the word, ever.

Thorin’s eyes respond in kind; yet much remains unsaid.

I don’t know. It was something that had to do with my heart.

The real conversation is yet laid before him. How to bring it up, how to ask.

My heart...

“I don’t regret it,” he tries. “For I found something of infinite value on my journey.”

Something worth dying for?

“Something worth dying for,” he echoes Bilbo’s thought. “And dying with.”

It’s questionable whether this is the right thing to do. But there is one thing that Thorin has learned from his life, something he hoped to pass on to his nephews and followers. That there are good and bad ideas, there is doing right and doing wrong, and then there is doing something from the heart. That transcends the rest. It’s in its own category, and has nothing to do with right and wrong. Nothing.

Perhaps it would help him to know that, of all people, the person he managed to impart this knowledge to is Bilbo. This is exactly what Bilbo likes about him. Thorin taught him this without even trying, taught him about following your heart even when it seems like the wildest thing.

“Please don’t leave,” Bilbo begs him.

The green door opens again, and now Thorin sees more. It is not a door into the past, but it does promise a new beginning. It is a door to life, new life.

Thorin’s face relaxes into a smile of pure happiness. Now he is ready.

“Don’t be afraid. If you’ll have it... we shall never be parted.”

The world stops spinning for a moment, while he wills to take on the madly impossible. That, at least, is nothing new to him.

“Bilbo, my heart...”

The Eagles’ flight freezes in the air, the sound of battle cries ceases, the sun’s light never hits the ice. Only Thorin’s words manage to reach, still.

“...is yours. Forever.”

He looks Bilbo in the eyes, enough to see them widen through tears in astonished surprise, and breathes one last time.

Notes:

Some of the imagery in this chapter came from my "Everything" video, available on both AO3 and YouTube.

Chapter 2: Obscured

Chapter Text

Down by Thorin’s side, Bilbo weeps with great pain. What Thorin said... if true... He pushes back into the void, not ready for that thought.

He begs for a miracle as time advances forward, unrolling a grey shadow over the sky, every second taking Thorin further and further from him. His tears hit the still, glinting ice, and disappear too soon to make a difference.

“Don’t leave,” he implores between sobs. He sinks into himself, allowing the despair that seeks to take him. But Thorin... Thorin said he hadn’t wanted this.

The next few hours are a blur. Thorin’s body is brought into the Mountain, and the Company begin preparations for burial. Gandalf asks if today is too early to set out for the Shire.

Bilbo can’t speak of that. Bilbo can’t really speak at all.

Gandalf appears to understand. “I will wait for your word. When you’re ready.”

It would be good to run away from here. Forget this... that Thorin ever happened.

The funeral begins, sending Bilbo’s mind in a whirl of panic as he starts to realize. It’s the beginning of the end. No one and nothing can stop time.

Friends move around, silently grieving for Thorin. Bilbo can’t see or hear them. There is only one thing he sees: a trail of words that travel down as time unfolds a path from Ravenhill’s heights to the depths of the Lonely Mountain. The ice they stood on melts, space liquified while time a frozen solid, and water flows into the tomb, every drop falling over somewhere between him and Thorin, giving them one more moment. Yet no single moment could finish what was set in motion since the beginning of the quest, the night this person came into his life. And Thorin remains silent, his lips parted one final time, in question or assurance, Bilbo cannot know.

Standing by Thorin’s body, uncertainty yet lingers. How close is too close, how far is too far. What is the distance from which he can begin. To take in, what Thorin said. If he really said it.

Two forces fight inside him, each with its own reality. In one, this funeral is fake and Thorin’s words are real, and the two of them will never be parted. The other screams accept, he’s gone. Thorin is dead, his words no more than the figment of a dream, the most unreal of all. Anything seemed possible and easy to believe when Thorin was alive. Yet now he looks content, at peace, without a care; death had the final say.

But Thorin didn’t want to die. There must have been a reason, a purpose to his words. The way that Thorin looked at him, resolved, unheeding of the dark, the same as when he gave Bilbo silver steel in a moment that likewise could have held more meaning. But the dragon’s evil that lately lived in Thorin cut it short, and stole his friend from him.

Yet the mithril remains. The mithril is real, if ever so unlikely in that moment, as given by a person most fearless and determined in the face of evil. Unlikely words likewise could have been said, defying death only to embrace it moments later, no logic possible in them.

We shall never be parted.

Yes, it seemed real. If they had had more time, he may have grasped more meaning. And what followed...

The thought that Thorin felt for him something so close, so final, so eternal, is more gripping than anything Bilbo could feel. And there is not much room to feel. The thought slowly expands, grows out of bounds until it’s all around him, enfolding him with its protective glow. How Thorin loves. He wants to know. How Thorin could have loved him.

He feels a gentle pat on his shoulder.

“Laddie... The ceremony is over. Everyone has left.”

He turns his face to Balin.

“Would you like... a few more minutes with him?”

Bilbo falters, unsure. “I...”

Balin glances at his armor and nods approvingly. Perhaps he knows.

“That’s good that you’re wearing it. He would have wanted you to.”

“I would do anything he would have wanted me to,” says Bilbo. Though he can’t really see the point in that, now.

“Then your best bet is to go on and be happy. I feel sure that’s what Thorin wanted most for you.”

“For me. But what about of me?”

Balin regards him intently.

“If he told you what he wished of, that would be the way to know. But now...” He gestures helpessly towards the king’s body; words are useless.

“Balin... Do you believe he’s truly gone?”

Balin does not answer, and Bilbo sees a way.

“I want to stay with him.”

“All right. I’ll leave you with him then. But don’t be long.”

“Thank you.”

Balin leaves. An abyss opens, dark and harrowing, and Bilbo sees it clearly now. How it feels to be this alone.

It’s selfish, he thinks. He should be grieving for Thorin, lamenting the loss of him, the king he was, that noble person, so beautiful and real and most impossible. Not for himself. Who is he? Nobody. So what if he’s alone?

He wants to focus on Thorin. But the black hole about to swallow him is simply that: Thorin’s absence. Thorin is dead, and nothing can change that.

My heart... is yours. Forever.

He calls these words to mind, willing them to juxtapose over this scene of death and keep him grounded. Help him fight this blackness, find his strength.

My heart... is yours.

It seems enough, to just let Thorin be like this. Bilbo’s own feelings are too small. For how can he begin to think of what they are? He had been in the middle of it before he began. He always knew he felt something, and that to examine it would deem it downright scary if not laughable. Nothing much compared to...

...yours. Forever.

How do you respond to that when you’ve been granted but a mere glimpse into your own?

I want to know what that means. I want to feel what could have been.

There is nowhere to hide from this darkness. Even with Thorin’s body present, the tomb feels cold and empty. A leap of faith is all that’s left to try. This moment, precisely because it’s hopeless, contains hope. Because the alternative is impossible to accept.

So what can be accepted? That Thorin will come back? That one day they’ll see each other again? Bilbo’s mind searches frantically for a solution, but finds none. His quick thinking is not much help now, against this cruelest of riddles.

That even now, he is not gone?... But Bilbo feels his absence, so final, so complete.

He wants to open his mouth, to talk, to call him, Thorin, I have so much to say to you, even if there is no answer, there cannot be.

He lifts a hand to touch the stone upon which Thorin lies.

“Where did you go?...”

If you’re not here, what sense does this all make?

He silences himself in the next moment, as if he’s spoken out of turn.

* * *

Thorin is not there. With his last breath, he left at once, a short farewell to life on earth.

Down he descends, moving in dark corridors with dim lanterns on each side, through walls of stone with closed and open doors, until he reaches the Halls. His mother is there, weeping her sorrow into deep holes full of her tears that mar the silver floor. She thought she could escape the warning in her heart.

“It’s too soon. You were supposed to live, to celebrate.”

His father rises to greet him with a smile. But Thorin does not share his mirth.

“I have not come to stay.”

They stare at him with startled eyes.

“Why?”

“Where are you going?”

Thorin holds their gaze, and waits.

“I’m going to get married.”

...to hear how this must sound.

“I have come to ask for your blessing.”

His father nods. “Anything for your happiness, son.”

It comes as a surprise. His mother may have watched his life, but she does not discern his heart.

“Of course, if that is your wish,” she says with longing eyes. “A wedding! What could be more joyful? I only wish to be there too.”

“You won’t be able to,” says Thorin. “I am sorry. It will be far away from here.” In the mountains high, with the sun and the moon, the birds and the trees. And the stars.

“When will it be?”

“Two days from now.”

He needs that time. To see if he can ask him, if he can have him.

“And who will be your bride? A lovely princess, I have no doubt.” His mother’s eyes glitter with blissful hope. “A queen, she will soon be.”

“A beautiful person.” One of a kind, in body and soul. Such as I will never meet again.

His mother smiles. “A person most blessed for marrying my son. And... do you have everything ready for the wedding?”

“No. Nothing. I have nothing.”

She is laughing now. “Oh, Thorin. You always did things in your own way. I thought sometimes that time didn’t exist for you. Take care now, for though your betrothed has agreed...”

“I have not asked him yet.”

His parents turn towards each other in great wonder, and silence clads the Halls. Thorin regards them fondly.

“I have to go. You are right, there is much to do.” He bows to them with heavy grace. “Thank you.”

“Can we at least watch it?” they want to know.

“Two days from now,” Thorin repeats. “Look for my wedding in the stars.”

He lifts his eyes and effortlessly starts ascending back to earth, and it feels faster, smoother. He is relieved. He’ll soon be back; there’s no more need to leave his love alone.

* * *

Could he have hoped to have my answer?

It’s hard to think of love with death so near. Yet love or death... Thorin did not seem to fear either. Maybe Bilbo can be just as brave.

How can he hold both in his mind, how to merge the two when Thorin has moved on. How can he keep him close enough for love to be. If he could be more like Thorin in this moment... maybe the mind will open, create the space where love and death can blend.

He climbs the tomb stone and lies down next to Thorin, taking as little space as possible, in careful reverence that their bodies shouldn’t touch. He closes his eyes and ceases all movement. Only his breath holds on, barely felt or expressed, an imitation of life.

That’s better.

But as to how he feels... he still can’t bring that into view. It’s still far too removed from this cold place.

“I want to know,” he voices. “I want to know your heart.”

If you’ll have it... we shall never be parted.

There is an answer. He has it now.

“Thorin... Wherever you have gone to, I want to follow you. Even if I’m allowed only a few steps. Let me take them with you.”

The tomb is silent. Yet something now has changed. Beneath the walls a hopeful promise lies; like a blowing wind he feels it in the air.

“I don’t want to go on and be happy. Not if you’re not here.”

“I am here,” a voice of shadow trembles in the air. And time is soon forgotten.

 

Chapter 3: Transcendence

Chapter Text

The shadow climbs the walls to vaulted ceilings and splits into grey rays, translucent, projected down towards the tomb where Thorin lies, Bilbo still next to him. It’s like night falling, soft and mournful, yet peaceful all the same, the presence of this shadow he now begins to see.

His eyes look up to these strange counterparts of sunlight; he feels himself split likewise into parts. The parts align for battle against all enemies of reason, not buying this division of reality. Save for a lonely one, that has its doubts as well.

“You can’t be him.”

“Say it again,” he hears the voice. “Say what you want.”

The shadow lines are close together now, as if in waiting, there at his command.

“I want him to come back. To feel him close to me.”

The rays converge and form a whole, adjusting a few times, from vague to tall and slim, and then familiar. A contour and a stance that give Thorin away. The way he holds himself, that bearing no one in the world will have again.

A part of Bilbo wants to jump and run outside, to life. The other, barely lucid, approaches in a daze, his step a dizzy dance. The shadow moves with him and settles on the wall, and Bilbo tries to touch it in the highest place his hand can reach. But it’s just stone; he cannot feel a thing.

“The things you said...”

You as in him before he died.

“I have wondered if there was more.”

“Yes,” it whispers, coming through in waves, trickling as it saunters downwards, seeking.

“How can it be for us to not be parted?”

It hurts, it hurts that he can’t see its eyes. Whatever soul’s inhabiting this shadow, this can’t be easy. It’s full of reservations, made of caution.

“I’ve never asked if you could share my feelings. It was enough that you just... be.”

These words are so like Bilbo’s own; he must have conjured them.

“I thought we had time, too. After the battle. I was wrong.”

“Time. I would gladly give you all of mine, if you wanted it.” There is resentment in these words, that Bilbo cannot hide.

“It is what you want that matters.”

Isn’t this strange? He is alive, while Thorin is no more; yet this being acts as if it has all the time in the world, while he needs to buy time. Right there, that shows this isn’t real. It could be Thorin, yet still the fabrication of a dream. He decides.

“What I want... I suppose I want proof that this is real.”

“You will have it, very soon,” says the Thorin-like figure. And it flees.

* * *

It cannot wait.

How to make Bilbo listen not just to what he has to say, but also to what he keeps silent. How not to scare him, yet get those feelings out in the open, just enough for Bilbo to understand. How to reveal himself without reducing his love to a figment. Above all, not to force him; this Thorin will not stand for. The freedom to seek happiness in simple places, in cool rivers, sunny gardens, in tall trees, is Bilbo’s. It’s something Thorin loves in him, and will not take away.

This wish to find the balance now sends him flying to his family’s chambers, away from the tomb. He enters a dark, dusty room, carpets and curtains and an old, crippled closet, remnants of what used to be the royal bedroom.

In the closet there is a box no evil got to. In the box there are three rings. The one for him is blue, for Durin’s line, and big and Dwarvish, not made for hobbit fingers.

His hands open; he traces Bilbo’s hand in them, until he can see it, down to the last detail. He slides the ring onto one illusive finger, and the difference is made clear.

Sounds ring deep from the forge that evening, frightening to the ones who’d listen. Luckily everyone is upstairs, holding the feast of great remembrance. Bilbo is there, too, and Thorin yearns. The welding and the searing make longing all the deeper in this place.

He walks outside and scouts the Mountain top. It’s night. The stars are lit. He lifts his arms, ascends, until they reach the sky. He gathers seven stars around the ring, which form a circle, and draws a line from each. The lines converge from stars towards the ring, sending it light and matter. Now there are specks of stars in it, shining with the divine light of the world’s beginning, and Thorin pours his love into each one. This work feels like a bonding of their souls; no, the expression. That bond already exists. It must.

Back in the tomb, his form is shadow still, and one blue ring of light.

* * *

Once removed from the tomb, Bilbo resolved he imagined it all. There is only one reality. There is no Thorin anymore. It’s. Just. Him.

There is a feast. The Dwarves and Men are seated at the table. Gandalf is there too, scrutinizing him knowingly.

“The sooner, the better,” the wizard tries for a reminder. “To go home.”

He nods.

“It’s just what you need. A chance to think about all you’ve gone through during long hours. Each day a new beginning, bringing new sights, while you can witness a small change in you. It takes patience, and no ups and downs. In each stone, in every leaf and strand of grass, you will find strength, constancy; peace, ultimately. It’ll do you good.”

“Yes,” he whispers in agreement with this sensible reality. “It would.”

Would, not will. If. Yet the words linger; so easy it would be, if he could wash it all away.

Gandalf senses his hesitation. “Please humor me and get a good night’s sleep. You need it, Bilbo.”

 

He lies down on his bedroll. It is a matter of minutes before he hears the dwarves snoring in a familiar scene. All too familiar.

“Where are you going?” Bofur pierces him with his kind gaze.

I left something unfinished. He doesn’t want to lie. He wishes he could reconcile these two worlds, show his friends what he knows.

“To Thorin. I want to see him.”

“You don’t sound well, my friend.”

He and I are not finished. Bilbo thinks quickly. How best to put it without sounding mad, not just to Bofur; to himself as well.

“I’ll soon go home. And when I’m gone... I won’t get the chance again, you know. To be...”

Bofur nods, understanding catching up with him, or something like. “Yes. Yes. Of course.”

 

He finds the tomb again through hallways dark and grim, guarded with torches still; the shadow on the wall, waiting for him. It comes down, kneeling, no time to waste, and Bilbo sees the ring.

“It cannot be.”

“It is.”

“Why? What is this for?”

He feels Thorin hesitate. (Thorin? He must be mad.) Thorin wants something so much, right now, and is fighting it.

“Because you asked me how, and asked for proof. This is both.”

“This is so that we won’t be parted?”

“It’s what is needed, yes. You and me, joined in eternity.”

Bilbo’s legs melt. He reaches out instinctively, his hand moving through the immateriality of the figure before him and hitting the wall harshly.

“If... if you want.”

Maybe reality can change. Molded in ways I never knew I wished for.

“I will love you forever. No matter what. You need not feel... Being together... it’s in your hands.” And the ring is now in Bilbo’s hands, pushed by an invisible force, or maybe just the words alone.

“Thorin, this is. I...”

Lost. Lost in confusion, there’s no center, no logic there to guide him. The ring alone could steady him, the only thing that’s real. How does it feel, to hold this ring? It feels as if the ring lies at the bottom of a deep, deep sea, with green and red and blue mingled in myriads of combinations, and the clear yellow sand beneath. To grasp the ring would mean to drown in this sea, and he is lost.

Does he really know me? Do I really know him... The latter matters more.

“Take the night. And the day. To think about it.”

“Where will you be?”

“Here. I will be waiting for you.”

“Is there any way we can talk?”

“Of course.”

Because I don’t know if I love you and I don’t know how to figure it out and I thought you were dead this is nice of course it is having you here talking to you but it’s

Unreal, returns the answer. This is unreal.

Yet the ring’s there, pressed in his hands, glittering with the otherworldly beauty of the stars, a microcosm beckoning at him, take me, take me and shape this world anew.

“Do you want... to remember?” asks Thorin suddenly. Bilbo fears. It feels as if the shadow guessed his thoughts.

“What?”

“At the Hidden Door. When the sun and the moon were in the sky together. The way you looked at me. I thought...”

Bilbo kneels by the shadow. He leans his head forward and wishes to be held, for this is him; no one else can know this.

“I thought I saw something. The light in your eyes. I wondered then if you could love me.”

He breathes. He does. Remember. “I... yes. You see, what I felt then... I didn’t know who it was coming from, if it was you or me. I sensed love’s presence, and I knew we would... I mean, I thought we could...”

A rustling, like relief, like a breath long held, he hears, feels on his neck. He is close now.

“Yet we never did so much as hold hands.” He gives a wistful smile. “So this is... it’s just. A bit much, right now.”

The shadow breathes again, a powerless admission.

“I wish we had more time. To go through all the stages, you know. First this, first that.”

“I know,” the voice returns with sadness, yet Bilbo feels its hope. How he wishes he could see Thorin now; so he could read this hope upon his face, that they can do it now, all of this they can still do.

“Is there no more time? At least for me to think about it more?”

Yet Thorin sensed his wish before he spoke.

“All the time in the world, my love.”

He knows it can’t be true. If it were, Thorin would take his time. The words restore calm still, save for the tremble in his arms at the last two; he almost drops the ring.

“Please, tell me what you want.”

Who said this? Both spoke at the same time.

Now Thorin takes the lead. “Whatever you decide... follow your heart. Your happiness matters the most to me.”

This is what Thorin says; yet Bilbo knows there’s more, a wish that’s left unspoken.

“Your turn,” the shadow calls. And Bilbo knows it now, for it is his wish too.

“I want to stay here, with you, tonight.”

He places the ring at the shadow’s face, illumining it slightly, and he can see the blue in Thorin’s eyes. Then Bilbo moves the ring where Thorin’s lips would be. He presses with his fingertip gently inside the ring, and feels Thorin’s lips through, just barely there. And suddenly he sees how he could know him more. The more he never knew.

He pushes slowly through the air, hands open, until they reach the wall. He tests the ring against the stone. The form and color of Thorin’s lips are in the stone now, and Bilbo feels.

He wishes. To see more of you. To hold you.

A breeze, a breath upon the ring turns it face up. The shadow lifts its arms and points upward, and seven holes open up in the ceiling. Thin rays like lines precipitate out of these holes, proceeding from the stars above, shooting into the ring a glowing, fearful light. Something now pulls the lines, stretching the ring, while Bilbo’s hands adjust to try to hold it as it changes, moved by a higher force. Light immaterial, Thorin alone can touch.

“The power is yours, while we’re here. Anything you want is yours, my love.”

Bilbo shivers at the last two words, escaped again before Thorin could catch them. Or perhaps said knowingly this time; he cannot tell.

“Is this what you wanted? Do you like it?”

The ring is stretched as wide as Bilbo’s arms can spread.

“It is. I do.”

Thorin closes the holes above, and light diminishes, yet still remains in seven places of the ring. Bilbo guides the ring down, leaning it against the wall, and now he can see Thorin facing him. The inside of the ring, that empty space, is filled with him.

“I’m wrong,” he whispers to this dream, so limitless and free. “This is more than anything I could have ever wanted.”

And Thorin drinks the sight of him, his loving gaze infused with light of stars.

 

Chapter 4: Ascension

Chapter Text

Bilbo takes in the figure spread before him, black winding hair framing his blue eyes, a dark coat wrapped around him, endless, leaving small room for detail. It’s a blurred image, not quite solid, and Bilbo wonders at the words it said; he said.

Thorin has done so much for him. He has come back at his request, is here to stay the night with him, and talks of a strange power Bilbo knows not what to do with. Instead of taking it, he’d rather give it back.

“I want to see your desires. I want you to have this power.”

It makes more sense that way, to let Thorin be first, as always; but also, here, he’s desperately curious to see what Thorin wants. To follow Thorin through this, to see where it all leads.

“Maybe just one of them,” he hears the figure yield; anything Bilbo wants.

There’s distance still between them. Thorin now takes his hand and brings it to that space inside the ring, where Thorin can be seen. His fingertips brush against Bilbo’s palm, and other hands move in, a soft caress, their bodies meeting in that space where Thorin can be known. And Bilbo feels these fingers touching his, and he feels slowly pulled, enclosed into this circle. Then he feels Thorin’s hands undo his belt, removing his coat next, and panics at the thought. He’s not ready for this; they should at least talk first.

The coat falls to the floor. Thorin collects it, folds it neatly, setting it in a niche inside the wall. Then he beholds Bilbo again, aligned inside the ring, unfathomable yet real. Thorin approaches him, no longer touching; he just stands there and stares, and Bilbo realizes.

Because Thorin can now see what he wanted to see, the silver steel exposed, shining so brightly in this ring infused with starlight, each of its links a glowing little star. And Thorin marvels at this, undoubtedly his first desire; how heavenly his love is in this light! The long hours of journeying, so much spent on the run, dark, endless caverns hardly made for beauty, offered no comfort to his yearning. Yet in this hour, beauty is revealed so naturally, the ring a halo, giving Bilbo light. Thorin is filled with joy, and music begins pouring at this sight. He allows fingers to run on Bilbo’s glowing arms, and each stroke makes a sound, like a harp tone, soft in the solemn deepness of the tomb.

“Beautiful,” Thorin murmurs as his hand pauses over Bilbo’s heart, so tenderly. He wants to nurture and protect that special place, precious and pure and endlessly adored.

“It’s your turn to wish for something,” he speaks.

“No,” says Bilbo. It’s not enough. “Show me more of what you want.”

Thorin’s hands lift and pull at the ring, bringing about innumerable planes that stretch it on both sides until it is an empty sphere, a blue translucent globe, now lit seven times seven. The globe is big enough to hold them both inside, and Bilbo’s mithril shines anew in it. And Thorin’s delight grows.

“Please,” Thorin asks. “This night is yours.”

“More,” Bilbo says. That foreign map that’s Thorin’s mind and soul, bared in this hour, fused in these longings that he now reveals, is not something that Bilbo wants to close. He loves it all, sharing this power, Thorin’s wishes coming true before his own; Thorin’s reluctance, too.

So Thorin heeds. His hand moves past the center and reaches Bilbo’s neck, pulling him slowly closer until his head slips through. And Thorin’s lips are on his, burning; at first it’s fast and urgent, as if the world will end, or for fear Bilbo, or time itself will stop. But Bilbo will not stop him; he seems to welcome this. So Thorin tones this passion down, his fingers touching slowly now, yet not in exploration; not as if they’ve never been there before.

And Bilbo feels that Thorin has known him intimately, quite closely for a while, for all that this is a first time. He takes in every kiss and breath, every touch on his skin that craves him, asks him to be Thorin’s in moves that leave no doubt. And Thorin’s body, something otherworldly, so soft, light and ethereal, is there within his reach. In places deep inside his heart, only yesterday just a dream he’d never had or never dared to have, he feels the possibility.

“I love you.” Thorin’s mouth on his neck, fiercely clear, and real.

“Thorin,” he whispers in return. He wonders in bewilderment, how to give as much of himself as Thorin can. “Thorin.” How to live this, how to feel, what to believe right now.

Thorin feels a new wish form in him, yet tries not to give in. He’s changed his mind on count of time; he’d rather have it stop. He’d kneel down, ask his Maker right there, to freeze this moment, let them stay longer in this kiss. How fortunate, then, that it’s Bilbo’s turn, and Thorin pulls away and looks down like he’s done something wrong. “Enough,” he murmurs, “This has to be enough.”

The power’s flame returns, and Bilbo accepts to take over.

What was his wish? To hold you, he remembers. His hands on Thorin’s shoulders and slowly to his neck, beneath his hair, and higher, his fingers spread as he lifts them and take the hair with them. Then they move sideways and he runs them up and down through Thorin’s hair again. His head rests against Thorin’s chest, his eyes closed, he just wants this; he never knew he did.

“Forgive me,” Thorin rumbles. I could have stopped myself. But it’s no use, his wish to worship every inch of him exposed; he cannot take it back. “You are forgiven,” answers hair against his neck while fingers’ movements never cease; Bilbo wants more of this. Yet something tugs at him, a small discomfort, the price of living in reality. He breaks away from Thorin enough to look at him; his eyes are open now.

“I wish... we could be somewhere else. Since it seems this... night is really shaping up.” He smiles shyly; Thorin smiles back at him. “But. The others. If they don’t find me here, they’ll worry about me.”

Thorin’s hand rests briefly on his curls, stroking them lovingly. “We won’t be long,” he says. I’ll take you anywhere. Then he lifts Bilbo up in his arms and lifts his head to meet the sky. “I love this, Thorin,” Bilbo breathes in his hair. Their faces touch, suddenly dizzying, their feet above the ground, the whole globe in the air, raised by their combined power. Thorin’s hand points upward; the ceiling opens and reveals a path for them to take, that leads outside the Mountain. He senses Bilbo’s fearful awe as they keep rising. “Stay in my arms,” he says.

As they pass clouds, the globe’s roof shatters at Thorin’s command. The rest of it turns flat, unfolding a blue carpet before and under them, and Thorin burns with the desire to show him everything.

“What would you like to see? The kingdoms of the world...”

Bilbo doesn’t seem sold. “Well... Where else can we go?”

“The stars.”

“I’d like that more.”

So up they go until there’s nothing above them or below, only stars. They settle in one spot, and Thorin makes a swing out of their carpet, creating strings on each side that pull towards the stars and link to them. They sit and watch the universe, and Bilbo’s head moves into Thorin’s lap, looking up in great wonder. And now the stars are lighting Bilbo’s mithril, and Thorin is absolutely lost. How does this feel, he asks. It’s... A lot, again, and fast, years that would take Bilbo to reach this high jammed in a single night; thousands of years for this light to reach earth, available to me, within my reach.

“You wanted to talk,” Thorin gently reminds him. “There is time here, my love.”

Yes, they could talk. How they will live, if they will really be together, if he’ll be in the Mountain or the Shire, or somewhere else. But something different presses itself firmly in Bilbo’s mind, insisting for release. Betrayal. Anger, which I caused.

“I stole from you. I didn’t even say I’m sorry. Is it too late to say it now?” he tries in a small voice, faint and afraid.

Thorin regards him, love mingled with pain.

“Bilbo...” He can’t express it. “There is no need. I forgave you then. If you wish it, though, we can go over it again. So you can forgive me again.”

“And I can forgive you again,” Bilbo repeats a bit absently, as a shooting star passes by them, reminding that their doings are so feeble, so small in this vast space.

“And I. Until...”

They search each other’s eyes. How little all this matters, how far away it is. And yet it happened, its memory there still, no distance can erase.

“There will come a time,” says Thorin, gazing into that infinite space, “when neither of us will remember it quite right. We’ll ask this of each other. Was it me who betrayed you? Or was it you? And we will laugh at it.”

“That time is coming,” says Bilbo. “I feel it. I will soon forget.”

“That is forgiveness. When it fades away.”

Bilbo catches his gaze.

“You loved me even through those moments?”

Thorin looks guiltily amused. “How could I not? You left me no choice. You stole my heart, remember?”

This is so easy. Bilbo ponders, deep in thought. “I suppose that’s a part that we won’t want to forget. In a way.”

Thorin brings his hand to his lips.

“I will never forget.”

Bilbo’s heart trembles. This is so much. He could get lost in these blue eyes, more lost than he is in this multitude of stars. “It’s your turn, Thorin.”

Thorin agrees. He wishes. To feel your heart so close to mine, like this. To talk of anything. But there is more to do. He catches light from one star and breathes on it, directing it to Bilbo’s neck and back, on his skin, and lets it linger there. Then he places his head in Bilbo’s lap. From there he sends another light, and another, and constellations form on and around his love. He wishes more. I wish that you’d be mine.

“More,” Bilbo says again. And Thorin tries to guess his thoughts. Now there’s a tree among the stars. It draws closer and closer, until its branches are above their heads, and light filters through them; the air begins to smell familiar.

“More.”

Now they are resting on firm ground; a desert planet, save for this cosmic tree.

“What would you like?” asks Thorin.

“A river,” Bilbo muses. A river parts the land.

“A forest,” he continues. And it’s there.

A house. A chimney, a garden. Bilbo wants all of these.

“A Mountain, far enough to have to journey many miles, and close enough to see it from our window.” The Mountain appears in the distance, white and grey.

“...People?” Bilbo asks hazily, not sure it can be done. Thorin nods, and a family of four appears on the other side of the river, a boy and girl laughing as they throw stones in the water.

“...And a sun.”

“A sun,” says Thorin, regarding him intently. It took them long enough, but finally this new world is graced with daylight, and Bilbo’s joy turns into perfect bliss.

“Oh, Thorin. All of this...”

“...for you.”

The words sink in, in silence, as Thorin thinks.

“...Because of you.” He covers Bilbo’s hand with both of his. “It is the most wonderful thing, just this. That you exist.”

He stops, for fear he said too much again. And yet. You make me want to give you everything.

“It’s your turn, by the way,” he finishes.

“No,” Bilbo protests. “I wished for something last. The sun.”

“I wished it too. It’s your turn now.”

And Bilbo is arrested; there is nowhere to hide. His lips find Thorin’s quietly, as in a secret he won’t yet dare to tell. His fingers touch his hair again, but don’t stop there this time. He sinks them into all of Thorin’s body, and drowns himself in his soft, velvet darkness. They lose themselves in earth and water, in warmth of sun and cool of night, and seasons come and go, first snow, and the first snowdrop, and flowers in a meadow in summer and the leaves falling in autumn, and they’re still kissing in grass and sand as night will fall again. And when it’s snow something begins to fade, the colors of this world they’ve made together.

Thorin perceives the change. They need to hurry back, for soon it will be dawn. If Bilbo is found missing, this harmony is lost. The powers bestowed on him this night come with this one condition, that he should keep the world intact, free of worry or sorrow. And that means Bilbo must be returned to it, for now.

One more moment, he pleads as he feels Bilbo’s lips on his still, wanting much more. And his love senses him, is there with him. “Your wish. Last one, before it ends.”

“No.” Thorin will not go there; yet he already has.

“Thorin.” Now Bilbo wills him to, with an impatient frown.

“I...” He takes Bilbo in his arms one more time and wraps himself around him, his darkness upon his love’s light, the question pressed on Bilbo’s lips.

“Marry me. Please. It’s all I want.”

...And they begin to fall; the globe reforms itself as they slowly descend to Middle Earth through stars and clouds and morning mist, and take their place inside the Mountain with its cold ground and dark walls. The globe goes pale, hidden from sight for now, unseen by all but them.

Thorin takes Bilbo’s coat and lays it down for him. They lie next to each other, the globe surrounding them, and Thorin covers every inch of them. “Sleep now, my love,” he says, ignoring his past words, that moment gone too soon. “I’ll stay with you. They will not see me here.”

And now it all feels like a dream again, and Bilbo fears again of being lost in his own mind, alone. But his desire is still there, that formed a while ago; light years ago. And now it’s firm and grounded, and he knows.

You make me want to give myself to you.

Yet he’s afraid to answer. If he says yes, he’ll wake. For this is how dreams are, both good and bad, they end exactly at the highest point. And if he should say no... well, he’d be lying.

I’m yours.

“I will. I want to be with you.”

 

Chapter 5: Epiphany

Chapter Text

Thorin can tell the difference between dream and reality. Mainly because right now, for him, there is only reality. Death is far from a deep sleep; he’s never been more awake.

In reality Bilbo has said “yes”. The rest is silence. If Thorin could express at all what “yes” feels like, he’d not use words; he’d summon the stars together and ask them to watch over his love falling asleep, and make a crown with shapes of flowers to place on Bilbo’s head, and he would cradle this creation, this beauty, and call it mine, forever.

Bilbo’s words are music, an awakening of life in this cold tomb, while Thorin’s is a quiet joy; it’s more of a reverberation in the stone that surrounds them, a sound his graceful body shoots outside, while he remains composed and still. A music he directs without directing, where tones and voices change with the blink of his eyes.

Yes, Thorin’s lost for words. And so their sleep descends, sweet and intoxicating, as they lie gently in each other’s arms.

When Bilbo wakes, it’s nearly noon. The dwarves have come to check on him, have seen his arms projecting into space, a peaceful smile upon his lips, and thought it best to leave him to his dreams.

By day Thorin is more reserved. He worries now: he may have moved too fast, forced Bilbo to say “yes” into this magic night, with powers not his own. Perhaps Bilbo needs space, a neutral place where he’d collect his thoughts, consult his heart, figure out what he really wants.

Bilbo. His child-like look of innocence, yet knowing all too well what transpired between them. His excitement. He seems so sure, so happy.

“Bilbo, last night...”

Bilbo regards him pensively, as if concerned. Thorin does not want him to be concerned. And yet.

“I got carried away. To be with you... there is nothing in the world that I want more. But you may need more time. I have no right to spring this upon you.”

Bilbo brings fingers to his lips, with a small frown.

“Please, Thorin. Don’t.”

“I came back because you called for me. I would come again, a thousand times. But I did not want to make you want me. I...”

“But I do. I want you. And I don’t care how we got here. We’re here.”

“You have more time to think on this.”

“My answer will be the same. Tonight, tomorrow. Always.”

They both rise. Thorin shrinks the globe back to the ring he forged for Bilbo. As he does so, he assumes his immaterial form, slowly, his fingertips the last of him to vanish. Thus he stands there as shadow, glancing toward the ring.

“I believe this belongs to me?” Bilbo says resolutely, with a smile.

“Yes, it is yours. When you are ready.”

“I want it now.” I want it to be real.

The shadow slips the ring on Bilbo’s finger. Then Bilbo adopts a no-nonsense posture.

“But I’d like one more date first. The first one was... well, breathtaking, but. It is my turn to take you to a place, if there is time.”

“There is. Tonight.”

And you can tell me again, at the end of the night.

Bilbo reaches out to him, his hand touching through the shadow, yet not quite feeling nothing. The air is infused with Thorin, his joy, his music, his contentment.

“May I ask where you’re going?”

Thorin hesitates. “I have to... sort out a few details.”

“Wedding details?”

“Not quite.”

“Can you promise that you will come back?”

“Of course.”

The shadow moves away, sinking into the floor, but something like I love you, before it disappears, still lingers in the space where Thorin stood.

* * *

The truth is Thorin doesn’t know how this will work. His wish is about to come true; the wedding is on. How they will live, if he will live at all- now he can turn his mind to. So he descends again to the same place, where Mahal dwells, this time seeking to see him, receive the guarantee he hasn’t obtained yet.

“You’re late,” says Mahal as the Halls open with much anticipation.

“My Lord. I... was under the impression that my soul was allowed to linger on earth for a short while.”

“Yeah, yeah. That is old news. You’re late in asking me about your marriage, Thorin, son of Thráin. Let me understand: you went ahead and proposed to the hobbit without having a clue if you can be with him after the wedding. Don’t you think you should have run this by me first? I am your creator, you know?”

“Y... yes. I’m sorry. I just assumed - believed - that there must be a way. There wasn’t much time. There still isn’t.”

“Mm-hmm. Pardon my interference, but that mithril gift you gave him was statement enough; why didn’t you propose to him then? I wouldn’t have had to be involved at all, seeing as how you’d probably still be alive.”

“Can we not talk about that?” asks Thorin with unease.

“Fine. Let’s get to the point. What exactly do you want? And pay attention, son: everything you say here can make a big difference.”

Thorin wonders if this is a trap. Mahal seems dismissive, if not bored, but also quite amused. Perhaps he likes seeing him squirm a little. Must Thorin carefully choose words of patient wisdom? Or speak plainly, abruptly, as is his usual style?

“I want to be with Bilbo. I want to return and live with him on earth, in whatever form you deem suitable.”

To this day, Thorin has not quite figured the right measure of words. On earth, as well as in the next realm, some may receive more than others. For perhaps some are bold enough to state their wishes and persist in their request, while others, more reserved, may not think themselves worthy of this asking, though their desire burns as deeply in their heart.

Which one he is... he’s never known.

“And does either of you have a preference as to what that form might be?” Mahal inquires sternly.

“Father, I... do not have the right to ask. Whatever is pleasing to you, I will abide by. As long as I can be with him.”

“Very well. Here it is, then, and listen carefully. It is not in my power to grant you your request. Such power belongs only to Eru Ilúvatar, our Maker. He knows all things. He can see all ends where I cannot, and he loves the world better than I. To him you must bring this.”

“Thank you, Lord Mahal. Then I shall go at once.” The hours grow thin, and Thorin wonders if he’ll make it back in time. Who knows where Eru dwells?

“Oh, and Thorin? When you do see the Almighty... just ask him. Tell him what you want.”

“Yes, my Lord.”

Thorin departs, and from the depths of Mahal’s Halls he rises, seeking the pure, universal essence of the All-Maker, whose light illumines earth and heavens and everything that breathes. Needless to say, he’s never visited in such high places. How will he reach the One? Yet his spirit feels what his body cannot, and Thorin lets it guide him. Towards the light, the everlasting life that waits beyond the worlds, at the origin where the universe begins, spread across space and time, inside and all around it both at once.

They say that God knows your request before you make it. Thorin believes this. And yet, while words are not his thing, he feels their pull right now. Just ask, just ask... It is with words that one can travel to Him.

“Ilúvatar, Creator of all things, I wish to speak with you. Please. Can you hear me?”

Perhaps it’s not a matter of getting closer. He could be at the bottom of the deepest sea, and Iluvatar would still hear him; he’s growing sure of this.

“Speak, My child.”

Thorin’s eyes drift above, to a small light. It’s like a shooting star, beginning far away and ever getting closer, yet never reaches him. What finds him in its stead is love, boundless and endless, love that perceives his plight, that can reach deep inside his heart and make him and his wish seem small. Not as in unimportant; just small compared to the infinity of this.

And tears are flowing freely - he didn’t know this fleeting body could shed tears, but his soul definitely can, the two’s connection so seamlessly clear.

If people want to talk to God and still retain their senses and their clever plans, then God better be silent; for if He spoke to them, their mind may not withstand it. That must be why the Supreme Being rarely reveals Himself. For all Thorin wants now is to bow down deeply and weep before this being, and forget that he had any wish at all. Just being alive, just being- being loved like this.

“Now that I feel You... I think it is enough. What more can one possibly want?”

“But you came for more.”

“Yes,” he whispers like a secret buried in darkness long ago.

“Thorin. Are you not one who dares?” says the voice musically, contemplative and soft. “Speak now.” And there is more in Eru’s tone. There’s love. The different colors of the world, the haughty and demeaning, the funny or detached, tones people use for statements or demands, Thorin knows well. God’s tone is none of these. It’s love.

They say that God knows your request before you make it. Perhaps Ilúvatar wishes to hear the wish He’s already aware of, as stated in the color of His son.

“It’s about Bilbo. I’m in love with him. He has accepted my proposal, and I intend to marry him tomorrow, before my time on earth is up. After that...”

Thorin begins to sob now. He feels the Maker’s love all over him, covering every word with empathy and higher understanding, and knows it’s just an echo of something vastly larger, love tailored to the no one that he is, careful not to consume him.

“I don’t want to leave him. I told him...”

“...that you will never be parted.”

“Yes. I want to stay with him. As if I never died. To retake my physical form, so we can live on earth, together, as I had wished to begin with. But...”

I tend to do things in the wrong order. I should have asked You first.

He tries to pull himself together.

“But anything You grant me is enough, All-Father. Just that I’m here, and that I met him, love him... I would not be ungrateful.”

“One who dares,” Ilúvatar calls him lovingly, “I can grant you what you ask. What parent would not see their child happy? I can see that being with the one you love would give you that. But something must be given in return.”

“Anything,” says Thorin. “Anything in my power.”

You don’t have any power, he chides himself. All the power you ever had was...

Taken when I died. Yet now he feels more powerful, somehow.

“Not by you. Your betrothed, he has to give something. For you two to truly be united in marriage... for it to count as more than exchanged words, he has to be whole. To be able to join with you unhindered. And right now there is something that, in the long run, may keep him from that.”

“I’m not aware...”

“A ring,” says Eru. “He carries a ring that is evil. It will stand between him and anything as pure as love.”

“I see.”

“You do not know its powers. Indeed, it would be beneficial if Bilbo Baggins were to keep the ring. The world would be safe for quite a while, and then...” The air shifts as Eru views events unfold as if peeking through a hole into far distant realms of things not come to pass. “Well. If you two want to be together, the saving of the world will take a different course. Bilbo Baggins won’t be involved. He has to remove himself from that story, and instead weave his own, with you.”

“I know he’s attached to that ring,” says Thorin. “I’m not sure if he’d part with it.”

“Tonight, my child,” speaks Eru firmly, “there will be two chances for Bilbo to renounce the Ring. Above the tunnels of the Misty Mountains where he found it, there he must give it back, as if he’d never picked it up. Drop it from a great height, back in the depths from whence he gathered it. If he does, he can have you. All of you, returned to him as if you never died.”

Thorin reflects, unsure. This is so unexpected. How much to place on Bilbo before it gets too much.

“Ask this of him,” Eru instructs.

“Ask this of him,” Thorin repeats.

“Yes.”

“And the world...?”

“None of your concern.”

It’s hard. He was prepared to die, to sacrifice his heart’s desire for the world.

“Thank you. I will do as you said.”

He readies to depart. “Is there anything I can offer in return? How can I thank you?”

“You have felt My love.”

“...Yes.”

“Take a tiny bit of it - the love you felt - and give it to all creatures, great and small. That is what you can do, when you return. Now, even.”

“I will. I will try.”

“Goodbye, King Thorin. Until we meet again. May your marriage be blessed.”

Thorin’s words stop in his throat. It’s as if Eru knows how things will play. It is too good. Nobody is worthy of this.

“Thank you for giving him to me,” he murmurs as he watches the far light grow ever distant, slowly disappear.

 

...And the celestial bodies continue their perpetual dance, unperturbed, as if Thorin was never there, as if his love never existed. Still, no one but God knows the intricacies of the heavens’ motion, their hidden harmony. The stars, the planets, the great cosmos whole, at once begin to work, making new patterns, light and depth and contour; new shades of color spring forward, waiting to be selected, named for this occasion. A choice will soon be made, the firmament clothed red and blue, some dim, some bright...

...while Eru watched in secret, directing here and there, the preparations for the wedding of his beloved son.

 

Chapter 6: Return To Innocence

Chapter Text

He’s been sitting quietly for too long.

The same as months ago, Gandalf will wait for him, ask about leaving, home for once, is Bilbo set to go or does he need more time. And Bilbo wants to laugh with pride, so little do you know, I will be home tonight. I only have to ask.

He knows it’s madness. He’ll confront Thorin soon. Even if it breaks the spell and ends the dream, he needs to know how much of this is real.

Because should he continue, let himself fall in love, if these too-good-to-be-true meetings cease, he will be crushed.

The way things present now, he can survive. Go home, regain control of how much to remember, how close to keep to Thorin in his mind. It will be hard, but necessary, these fragile boundaries meant to keep him sane.

Even if Thorin lived, and by some twist of fate they were together, they would not be like this. This love - intense, implausible, surreal - belongs in myths and fairy tales. He’s just a hobbit, yes, he gets it, strong and brave and strangely, possibly love interest of a king, but even this is not much. Not like this story that weaves itself around them, not like this out-of-this-world Thorin, impossible to describe or to live up to.

Thorin. Returning from the dead in half-body, yet so clear and alive. The fact that all this happened, correction, that Bilbo believes all this happened can easily be pinned on lack of sleep, confusion, grief, denial... call it what you will.

He stares at Thorin’s ring, undeniable proof, a glimmer in the darkened corners of his mind. He hides it now, when others are around.

He can’t tell Gandalf to just leave alone. What if tomorrow Thorin disappears for good? What will he do? No, he needs more time.

“Something’s going on,” the wizard pries. “Don’t think I haven’t noticed.”

“What?”

“You’ve changed again. Yesterday you were deep in mourning. Yet just like that, in a matter of hours life has returned to you.”

Bilbo smiles bitterly. I guess you could call it life.

“Also, you carry something.”

He flinches. Thinks of his Ring first, Thorin’s forgotten; the rest is shame.

“I’m not sure what you mean. I’m trying to move on.”

“Indeed. Then why do you still linger here, when just last week you were pining for home?”

“I don’t miss it terribly. I thought I did, but now... You’re right, I’ve changed.”

“So you’ll be staying here?”

“I don’t know yet.”

“Bilbo... He is not coming back.”

Bilbo could laugh at him, if this same thought were not also in his mind, driving in fear, pushing him into a black, murky lake.

 

Thorin returns at midnight. He’s been delayed. Bilbo is waiting in the hallways, pacing back and forth, starting to wonder if he should just retire to the common room. Or come clean and tell Gandalf, Thorin said he’d be back. It’s late, I’m getting worried. Could you please go and find out where he is? And Gandalf would believe him, would he not?

When Thorin comes, it’s like a void gets filled. The world gains contour, streams and valleys, trees, birds and sunlight occupy the hall where Thorin’s body lies, the shadow drifting downward, bringing a new dim light, retained from his long trip among the stars.

Bilbo hands him the ring, and Thorin expands it once again. When it becomes a globe and Thorin gains full form, Bilbo crashes into him with desperate urgency.

“I have missed you,” he says hopelessly, pulling at Thorin’s coat like a reproach. “You’ve been away too long.”

“I’m sorry,” Thorin breathes.

“How long before you disappear again? How can I know that you’ve returned for good?”

“Bilbo, please...”

“Do you know what it’s like? This agony, this waiting? Not knowing if any of this is real? Fearing it could end at any moment?”

“It will not end,” Thorin says softly, and pulls him in his arms, meaning to steady, cease his frantic movement.

“When you are gone, it feels just like it did. Back on the ice.” A million years ago. “When you are gone, there’s nothing.”

Thorin stands calm and unafraid. “One more day lies between us. Until we’re married. Can you wait that long?”

“And after that?”

“I will leave no more. I’ll stay with you.”

Bilbo can finally put a name to this. He’s seduced into believing this is real. No, wrong again. He’d take this even if it wasn’t real.

How can I not give myself to this dream?

“All right.”

He breaks from Thorin’s arms and looks into his eyes.

“I’m sorry. I don’t know what came over me.”

“It’s nothing.”

“I’m making us waste time. Can we talk about our date now?”

Thorin places a kiss on his forehead in answer, lips filled with desire and the hope for happiness.

“I was thinking of a more worldly place for tonight.”

“Anywhere you’d like.”

“I’d like to go home.”

Thorin’s eyes hold pleasure now, and unconcealed surprise.

“Of course. When you’re ready.”

“I’m ready.”

Thorin commands the globe with the lift of a hand, the globe opens the ceiling and creates a path, and so begins their trip. They relive their adventure in reverse, and from outside it’s at a greater speed, yet Bilbo does not feel it. There’s time for him to take everything in, much more than when they travelled the first time. The path they took through water to reach Dale, the house they stayed at with Bard and his children, the boat ride into Laketown, the dark and creepy Mirkwood. They fly over the forest, the mystery of tall oak trees, the many tales they’ll tell, a world in itself that Bilbo makes a promise to revisit; likewise with Beorn’s house.

They reach the Misty Mountains. The globe seems to have stopped.

“What’s going on?”

It hasn’t. It’s just slowing down.

“I just thought you might like to spend a moment here. To reminisce. This was an important point in our journey.”

“Oh. Right. Well, it was a hard time. I’d lost you all, I was alone and terrified, and...”

He won’t share his secret.

He doesn’t know Thorin already knows.

Does it matter? The Ring? His encounter with Gollum? Why should he hide? And yet he feels like hiding; he - or a power from above, or one that’s trying to rule from within.

“My love...” says Thorin tentatively as he holds his hand, “I know that something happened here.”

“You’re right. Something I still carry with me. Precious beyond belief, mine to keep, full of power. Power I’ve used. Power that will not be shared or told.”

Thorin would begin addressing the topic, if he knew how.

“Bilbo, if I asked you...”

“Shhh,” says Bilbo, suddenly seized with panic. “You cannot ask. Nobody can. Not even you.”

“Not for myself. But to consider...”

“Me leaving it behind?”

Bilbo looks at him mockingly. A sudden power in him, a voice, strange and terrible, wants to humiliate Thorin, to bring him to his knees.

Who do you think you are? A specter, conjured by my mind. Such a creative mind, to bring you from the dead in ethereal form, to invent this globe so we could fly. This is all me. What makes you think I’d renounce this for you? When I haven’t even told you I love you?

Now the globe has really stopped. The one able to keep it moving has momentarily lost focus, his mind engaged elsewhere.

Bilbo stops too, with mouth wide open, refusing to believe whatever that was.

Thorin does not react; yet it feels that he heard. Oh, by all holy things, Thorin should not have heard.

His hand is still in Thorin’s, may as well be his soul, so deeply and completely the dwarf gazes at him.

“Let’s just get out of here.”

“As you wish.”

The globe starts to move again. Thorin looks ahead, reflecting silently, his eyes preoccupied as if measuring distance, or perhaps time.

The Shire soon arrives in sight. Bilbo is back to his familiar self. He steps outside the globe to greet his home, a happy smile spread widely on his face.

“Oh, Thorin. Thank you.” He leaves Thorin inside the globe, to wait.

The green door is still there, with Gandalf’s mark on it. His garden looks deserted, for it’s winter, remnants of flowers that grew months ago. Bilbo gives it a sad look, then enters.

Everything as he left it. His kitchen, study, bedroom, the room where they all sat together months ago. He hurries back outside, heart burning with excitement.

“It seems a shame that you should be confined to this small space,” he says to Thorin. “What if you were to step out?”

“Then I would be shadow again.”

“What if I wished you to be whole even outside the globe?”

Because I have the power, whispers the voice inside. I can make you whole, I can tear you apart. This dream keeps going for as long as I decide.

“I am not sure,” says Thorin. “But I’d love to hear your wish.”

Bilbo eyes him playfully for a brief moment, then turns serious.

“All right. I wish that you retained your current form after you step out of the globe.”

And I command you to step out

Something is very wrong.

Thorin steps out, unbothered. Has he heard him? He looks perfectly happy to oblige. And his form doesn’t change, but remains full, faithful to Bilbo’s wish.

“It was a joke,” says Bilbo, stupefied. “I did not see this coming.”

“I did.”

“How?”

“Because you do have power.”

There’s more. Thorin is hiding things; whether they’re good or bad, he cannot tell. And Thorin wishes he could fill him in, his viewpoint, that Bilbo’s wishes will come true tonight, your power over me is all that did it, he would say, holding him, kissing him and trying to ward off the evil taking over, I love you-

 

...but it’s not important, so he leaves it there, in the uncertain space where things are left unsaid and saved for later. For now, this smile is all that matters, his love delighted to show Thorin this small world that was always enough, that Bilbo hopes will be enough for both.

 

Chapter 7: Return To Innocence (2)

Chapter Text

“So, what are you? I can perceive your spirit more than I feel your body.”

Thorin laughs at Bilbo’s candid way.

“I don’t have all the answers. Your guess is as good as mine.”

The wicked being inside Bilbo’s mind makes note of that, files it under “more proof that Thorin isn’t really there”.

Bilbo ignores this. How happy he is here, how easy it is to forget his worries, to show Thorin what he would share with him, his life, his hopes, adventures still to come. He’s restless, goes from room to room, revealing what he holds dear, family portraits, book collection, his writings, tells Thorin little stories of his childhood, his thirst to see the world. But what tugs most at Bilbo’s heart are flowers; and while he has a few preserved, dried flowers he’s kept safely in his books, he longs to show Thorin the real thing.

“If it were summer you could see the things I miss,” he says as they walk around in his garden.

“What do you miss?”

He points to empty rows. “I miss the fragrance of gardenias. The burning gold of sunflowers. The delicate hibiscus and the lilac. But most of all, the roses.”

He lingers in a spot outside his bedroom window. “They grow right here. White, yellow, red and pink.”

“I would love to see them.” Thorin is standing behind Bilbo now, his hands gently reaching to Bilbo’s arms. “You have but to ask.”

“Let me guess. You would make them appear in an instant? You’re that good?” asks Bilbo with a laugh.

Thorin’s fingers wrap around his right wrist and guide it toward the spot where roses grew.

“You would. If you’d like... we can do this now.”

Bilbo turns to face him in great wonder. “You’re serious?”

“Yes. Think about them now. Imagine them the way they present to you, your memories of them.”

At night, the somber colors and dark spaces invite the mind to fill them in. Roses in winter are an easy choice. Bilbo is inundated, their taste, their heady scent permeating the air, he sees the morning dew, his fingers touch the petals to collect it, and Thorin guides his hand with both of his, focusing these thoughts as they travel from Bilbo’s head, through his arm, towards one single spot

until a baby rose springs from the ground, slowly and timidly. Its yellow warms the air, and Bilbo’s body shakes in Thorin’s arms

which results in more roses appearing, one by one, in all sizes and colors. Roses at his window, poking over the fence, swirling around his mailbox, adorning the house walls.

“I can’t be doing this. It must be you.”

“It’s you.”

“You mean to say these flowers would appear even without you here?”

“I can always leave,” says Thorin. “So you can see for yourself.”

“I’d rather you stayed and tried it too.”

Thorin seems unsure. “I don’t have any memories. I’ve never seen roses. I mean, really see them.”

Yet Bilbo’s flowers stand before him in silent invitation, memories to be made. So he attempts. He collects the yellow rose - the first -, lays Bilbo in the grass and kneels beside him, and brings it to Bilbo’s neck, then chin, then lips.

That is new, Bilbo thinks. Thorin’s way, as of late. To bring to life even as he imagines.

“You always have to do more than what’s asked of you,” Bilbo remarks, half-curious, half-amazed.

Thorin laughs. “That’s definitely not me.” He tears a petal, joins it to his finger, and brushes Bilbo’s forehead with it, pausing over his eyes, then moving further down. When it reaches his mouth, Bilbo parts his lips, the petal slides inside, and Bilbo tastes

while at his shoulder, a new, blue rose emerges from the ground, stroking his ear.

“Oh,” he says dizzily, “see, that was you. I’ve never managed to grow blue roses before.”

“I only gave its color. The rest was you.”

Thorin makes a necklace out of the yellow petals, strings it along his neck and kisses Bilbo’s skin through each one, and more roses spring. Bilbo’s mind is entangled with the flowers that surround them, their fragrance in his hair, their warm color infusing him with calm. The roses Thorin grows are not tall, barely reach above Bilbo’s body as it lies in the grass, for Thorin wants to see Bilbo in them. And Bilbo feels the love- he knows it is for him, but in this moment it is more, it’s stretched to include everything. And calm means also clear, to him now, what he wants, that he’s no longer led by the force of another, be it the Ring or Thorin, but by himself. He can, now

Lose myself in this dream. Be swallowed, and it wouldn’t matter. I lived.

“How do I know you’re real?” he blurts out before reason can cut in and censor him; not at all what he meant to say.

“You don’t.”

“What does it take to know?”

Thorin takes what’s left of their first rose; examines it. “Trust,” he replies. “All that is needed here is trust.”

“And what if I said no? I mean, I won’t. I already said yes. I’m just curious, that’s all.”

“Then I would leave. Go to the Halls, never to see you again.”

“And what would you do there?”

“I don’t know.”

“I don’t ever want to let you go,” Bilbo says ardently. “Yet I fear all this is a dream. I fear for you. For me. For both of us.”

“The choice still lies before you,” Thorin says. “When it is clear to you, when it feels right, you’ll know. Until then... there’s still time to change your mind.”

“I won’t.”

Bilbo now hesitates. He rises from the ground and walks among the new rose bushes, stroking them idly, distantly. He peeks inside Bag End through open windows, like a stranger invading his own home. He waits. Yes, peace- yet it feels, if he should say it, feel it, live it- it feels as if he’ll leave again this small, feeble foundation he barely returned to. Home.

He turns back and joins Thorin on the bed of flowers, kneeling in front of him.

“I love you.”

The choice is firm and clear. The point of no return.

Thorin rests his head on his chest, seeking relief, or finding it.

“My Heart,” he whispers. “I know what and how much it means.”

“Yes,” Bilbo whispers back, kissing his hair. “I’ll follow you. I’ll trust you. This.”

I love you feels like leaving. But Thorin feels like home.

His fingers create paths through Thorin’s hair, he mixes petals in, white and blue in the pale light of the moon, then he feels daring, tears more petals and sprinkles them on the ground, forming a circle around him and Thorin. “Wait here,” he tells his newly-named love, and steps outside the circle. He commands the globe to decrease, and not to his surprise, the globe decreases, returning to the form he accepts now, he wanted- his blue engagement ring. Bilbo puts it on, directs its light to the petals around, and starlight now illumines them like multicolored candles, beautiful and fragile.

The force inside him, hungry for this power, grows fiercer still, more jealous with each moment.

“I think about myself too much.” Around his neck, he feels the petals fall. “Not enough about you.” He mimics Thorin’s motion, collects them and lays Thorin on the grass, placing them on his neck. He traces the blue ring over the petals, and they turn into pearls.

“I love you, Thorin.” A soft light, the candle in his window flickers, leaves rustle in the trees, the smoke circles above the chimney in the distant light of stars. Here in this Shire Bilbo will return, press his love deep into the earth and lose himself with him, and follow him, whether in pitch-black darkness, in netherworld, regardless if this peace is made to last.

...It lasts.

The dawn comes, they’re still holding each other, their eyes searching with infinite surprise, and what they see they know not to deliver. It’s a new day, a new them.

They depart, their hands interlocked in certain promise, they are each other’s, and Bilbo will stop questioning the ever-questionable. If this is love I definitely want it. If I died tomorrow, let it be known I truly lived. And soon they’re back above the goblin tunnels, above the cave where Bilbo found the Ring, and the globe stops, this time at Thorin’s will.

 

“I need to tell you something,” he begins again.

A matter of trust, Thorin said.

“Bilbo, I... When I left earlier, I went to see a higher Power. I learned things. The object that you carry, that you found in this cave... you need to let it go.”

“What?! Why?”

“It is a work of evil that will stand between us. As long as it stays with you, we cannot get married.”

Bilbo frowns. “Yet everything you said sounded like getting married is a piece of cake. No matter; there may be a way around this. If I keep it, can we still be together? Just not get married?”

“I did not ask,” says Thorin, left in dismay by Bilbo’s quick response. “I don’t believe we can.”

“Then I don’t want it,” says Bilbo in a hurry; already he begins to change his mind.

“I must tell you though... of something more. You keeping it will result in keeping the world safe. Possibly... saving it.”

Bilbo's frown deepens. Too much too fast. The good, always the bad. “That’s hardly something to pass up, don’t you think?”

Thorin nods in agreement, heavily.

“If I were to renounce the Ring and the world falls, what good is us getting married? We won’t live to enjoy it.”

“It may not fall. It’s just that you and I won’t be involved. Others may save it.”

It feels so treacherous, these words coming from the one who dares.

“Ah. While we delve in happiness. Not fair now, is it.”

All is quiet.

“And you kept all this in when you could have told me earlier? We had a whole night to talk about it.”

Thorin looks down. “I did not want to talk about it. Not there. Not with you clothed in the beauty of your Shire. We can talk now.”

“This Ring, I’ll have you know” - Bilbo reveals it now - “helped us during our journey to the Mountain. I think it’s helping still. I commanded this globe - your ring - with it. It gives me power.”

“Our love gives power.”

“How would you feel? If you just sat idly while the world ends, because you chose to be happy with me?”

“I don’t believe,” says Thorin, “that we would play no part. Everything plays a part. And loving you is everything but idle.”

“It just... it doesn’t sound like you, that’s all.” Doubt. Doubt that it’s real, again. The Thorin that he knows was made for brave deeds, not to sit on the sidelines. He would not stop for romance when the whole world is at stake.

“Love,” Thorin carries on, “is the most powerful thing. Such a thing can help preserve the world.”

“When I think of love I hardly think of power. To me it’s the fragilest thing.”

“It does have power. Even the smallest love, to the smallest of beings, can keep evil at bay. Bilbo... did you not feel it? Our love is what helped your roses grow, I think.”

“It did,” says Bilbo dreamily, suddenly seized with the desire to let the Ring go before he caves under its magnetic pull. “When I’m with you, I feel as if the world has just begun. That we were just created, days ago. But what if you deceive me, Thorin? To throw away this Ring is asking a great deal.”

I kind of want to know... what the Ring has to say.

Bilbo thinks, or is it the Ring itself that thinks, yes, it tells him that Thorin is not real. If he should dispose of it, Thorin will disappear.

He listens.

I see. I must have conjured this Thorin-like figure with the power of this Ring.

Exactly, the Ring presses. If you keep me, you can have him for as long as you want. If you keep me, you can have this love.

But if what you say is true, all this is no more than a dream!

Just as good as real. A dream to suit your needs, for as long as you have them.

“Thorin.”

If you throw me away, he’s never coming back.

Bilbo sees himself taken down to the tunnels, while Thorin stays above, looking at him through eyes like clouds. He’s never seemed so far

“The Ring says it is thanks to it that we can be together.”

Thorin is silent

and the darkness never felt so dark.

“The Ring is saying you’re a dream.”

I don’t want this to be a dream.

“Thorin! Please, quickly, think of something I don’t know. Tell me something I couldn’t have imagined.”

He hears Thorin’s voice through the fog, clear still, just like before he drew his last breath on the ice.

“Bilbo, before the battle... I asked you to be mine. The mithril that you’re wearing... was a marriage proposal in my mind. I’m fairly certain you don’t know this, and you asked, so...”

“What did you say?...”

“By wearing it, you in a way consented to be mine. If we should part, if you keep your Ring, please remember. As long as you wear the mithril, we are bound. So there may still be hope. To meet again, one day.”

A journey full of danger, yes, and a matter of trust. One thing belongs to Thorin, to be fair: it’s never a dull moment with him. And this is him.

Bilbo takes one look at the Ring, contempt and anger rising in him as the fog gives way to light.

“Deceiver. You. Be gone now. Never engage with me again, or dare to keep him away from me.”

He drops the Ring, suddenly heavy in his hand. The Ring makes a burning noise, gives off smoke, and falls in the dark below. Bilbo staggers, follows almost- yet Thorin’s hand grips him, solid by Bilbo’s side where he retakes his place, his features clear, their globe shining bright daylight through the misty dawn.

Bilbo brings his hand up, to touch. Disbelief leaves his mind and travels through his arm, and when it reaches Thorin’s lips it stops, acknowledging. Real. Him.

“So. Mithril. No, I did not know that. And you were right, I certainly could not have conjured that.”

“I know,” says Thorin. “Our friends teased me to no end back then. They were sure you had no clue about its meaning.”

“How in the world could you propose and not tell me?”

 

...They laugh, words exchanged that could belong to either, “I’m sorry I doubted you” and “I was not myself”. And as the globe resumes its even motion, the last barrier between them is removed - two foolish beings who will risk Middle Earth’s fate only to wish that they could keep it safe, hold it together through the miracle of love.

 

Chapter 8: Temptation

Chapter Text

Some believe that, during our earthly life, the body is a cage that keeps the soul imprisoned, hindering its progress, its ascension to the Good, the Truth. For some, when the soul exits the body, only then, it is released. It moves on towards knowledge, freedom, closer to perfection.

Bilbo does not believe these things. He may have, once, though in his case the comforts of the body, like good food, were nothing but conducive to reading, learning, reaching a higher plane. Yet he may have readily agreed that the soul, in the end, is all that matters, while humbly conceding that detachment from the body is an achievement reserved for a more elevated race, like Elves, and not for simple Hobbits like himself.

Yet upon meeting - seeing - Thorin, Bilbo saw a harmony of soul and body he’d never entertained before. For the first time, he wondered if by chance the soul and body are made to be together, and what one could do in one's life to blend them.

After meeting Thorin, certainly as of late, he may have also thought that at least in this case, when the soul departs, it is deprived.

That thought still lingers now, the second morning after that senseless, inconceivable event of death. It lingers now, when Thorin is, and yet is incomplete. His soul is within reach, transparent, like a glass window open before Bilbo. But Thorin’s body is not all that it could be. His body is light, ethereal, like a soft garment that is clothing Thorin’s soul, matching it, complimenting it... yet lacking.

It’s not important, though. It’s him, if in a new way, and what matters is to keep him there. That Thorin should not dis...

The thought tries to insert itself, and Bilbo fights to keep it out. He imagines this thought turn into smoke and float into the air, until it disappears.

After their brief night in the Shire, they rest side by side, in silent contemplation. Now and then Bilbo dozes off, then wakes up to see if Thorin is still there. There is no real rest here though, not when he knows they have to part again.

Bilbo watches him. Thorin looks a lot like he did that first night, when he stood by the fireplace and sang in Bilbo’s house, turning its mood from light-hearted to solemn. Thorin’s dark coat, colored in black and blue, his eyes, his hair... they paint a picture. The handsome, loving prince who walked straight from a dream like he was made to answer Bilbo’s wishes. He was like that before; but he was also more. Is it that now the pipe is missing in his hand, or that the sword is missing at his side?

Come to think of it, I can’t imagine this new Thorin even wielding a sword. He’s way too peaceful in this body.

Perhaps in this new body the warrior is gone. The one who can be blunt, not great with words, clumsy at times, but also fiercely passionate and fearless. It’s that component that made Thorin feel more real than anyone Bilbo has ever met.

Then this half-body, ethereal and imperfect, starts talking, and Bilbo leaves his musings.

“Bilbo, listen to me. You’ll need your strength today. Get some rest while it’s still morning. But don’t rest for too long. You’ll need to focus.”

“Focus,” repeats Bilbo. “On...”

“On our connection. All we’ve created these two nights together, and before. The way it seems we’re destined for each other. Think of me. Keep my memory with you, and don’t let go.”

This sounds as if you’re dead and you’ll stay dead, thinks Bilbo bitterly. As if I need to keep some sort of vigil.

“I am dead,” Thorin offers calmly. “It is thanks to you, in part, that I came back. Your wish to stay with me. Your active mind, your thoughts converging towards me. All of this helps to keep me here.”

Bilbo blinks in surprise. Is that all? Then if I lose my focus you may disappear. What if I can’t focus hard enough?

“Your faith in me. In us,” finishes Thorin, decisiveness in this statement. “It is important that you believe in what’s to come.”

He rises. It is time.

“Don’t go,” Bilbo breathes.

“Don’t be afraid. I will come back. I will.”

“I love you.”

Thorin gazes at him, intensity unspoken. His eyes are just the same as always, the light of stars in them shining with brightness, that part of him is unchanged and unmistakably alive, even more alive now, when Bilbo pushes him to the wall, the same wall where Thorin’s shadow first descended days ago. Thorin attempts to hold him, but Bilbo pins his arms onto the wall and kisses him, his heart burning to clarify something he cannot say. He’s not used to imposing reality on anyone, much less that anyone should be real for his sake. Yet what he can’t express in words he wants to with this kiss, to seal Thorin’s reality for good, to own it.

“There are things you’re not telling me.”

There's more Bilbo would want to say. Do you really believe that this can be, or can we say you don’t know, you just hope? He’d want to punish Thorin somehow, for not being real, no, for not reassuring him enough that he is. For being too cold and mysterious and calm.

“There are things I don’t know,” Thorin replies. “But as for you and I... It will happen. Tonight. You need not doubt it.”

Bilbo kisses him one more time, then puts his palms over his face, his fingers pushing against Thorin’s forehead, his cheeks, down to his neck, as to assert a claim. And as his fingers feel the soft materialness of this skin, Bilbo feels dreams must be different; this is not a dream. Thorin has kept his promises, there’s nothing left to do but follow through, follow this magic thread to its conclusion, and believe.

“Go now,” says Bilbo, his tone resigned. “I’ll wait for you tonight.” Go while I still believe enough to let you go.

Thorin nods in agreement, and exits fast, the shadow sinking to the floor, going far once again, while Bilbo’s arm remains outstretched, his hand extended toward where it touched him, longing, unfulfilled.

The day begins.

* * *

...Bilbo is dreaming.

In his dream, Thorin does not come back. Bilbo waits, midnight comes and goes, and nothing. Many days pass by. He remains stuck in this one place, the Mountain, where he can hope to see Thorin again, for fear that leaving would diminish any hope of his return. Gandalf soon departs. The dwarves, Bilbo’s friends, do not begin to understand; they simply carry on. A statue he becomes, almost, like long-gone kings of Erebor, lost in his mind, spinning in circles, demanding what he missed. Until one day Thorin appears again, pale like a ghost, and Bilbo cannot speak. His face unfazed, no longer moved... he is not sure.

Then Thorin speaks. He’s come just to say that all he wanted was for Bilbo never to forget him. That is why he appeared to him shortly after his death: to strengthen their connection, to ensure it endured.

“I knew, at the time of my death, that you weren’t in love with me. Perhaps you were close; I do not know. I wanted you to love me. I would have done anything to make you love me. So I pleaded to be allowed a little more time, just so I could leave a proper imprint in your soul. When you finally said those words to me, that night in the Shire, I knew my wish was realized, and I could rest in peace.”

Bilbo finds his words at last. “You said you would marry me.”

He knows he sounds absurd. This is absurd.

Thorin is silent. Bilbo thinks he understands. It was part of leaving an imprint, to get him to imagine, to wish for such a thing. It was part of making him fall irreversibly in love. A wedding... Not actually attainable, just a practical means to an end. Makes sense.

“I would have,” Thorin speaks eventually, and as he does, his figure starts to fade. “Unfortunately there was no more time.”

And just like that, he’s gone, and Bilbo’s mind freezes in shock. Then he feels something changing, as if with Thorin’s ghost part of the world has gone; the dream disintegrates.

“You didn’t have to go to all those lengths to “make me love you”!” he screams to no one. “I would have loved you anyway! I did so before all this - it would just have taken me longer to realize it! You didn’t have to deceive me like this!”

“Bilbo,” a no-nonsense voice rises from somewhere around the tomb, that’s where he is, right, he’s at the tomb again talking to an illusion that he couldn’t hold on to.

“Bilbo, you were dreaming. Of nothing good, I venture to presume.”

It's not Thorin; still, there is hope.

“You’ll only exhaust yourself more this way.”

Gandalf beholds him with that annoying look that says I know everything and more that you don’t know. Bilbo hates that. I get it, you can read my mind, but could you just use words already and tell me what you know

It appears Gandalf heeds, for once.

“Bilbo... I can’t begin to imagine what you must be feeling right now,” he says in a grave, sympathetic tone. “You know... Some believe that after death a person’s soul lingers on earth for a short while, and that only on the third day it truly leaves this world. There are accounts of people who were able to see one’s soul shortly after one’s death; when this occurs, it gives us time to transition to being without those who left. It gives us time to say goodbye.”

Outside his control, Bilbo’s hands move up, suddenly on a mission to reach his ears.

“So understandably since the third day has arrived for... for Thorin, this must be incredibly difficult for you.”

They have reached his ears, and covered them, and Bilbo can’t hear anymore.

But he’d like to know more. Has anyone ever come back. Not for a day or two, but more. For a life. He doesn’t ask; he fears Gandalf’s answer.

“So, stay here if you wish, for the rest of the day. But know that it’s the last. If he has shown himself to you in any way, it is to ease your shock, give you a bit more time, but also to say the last goodbye. You need to let him go, Bilbo.”

He nods. He’s good at lying. All the same, Gandalf may know, may be able to see through it, that Bilbo not only doesn’t believe this is the end, but also dares to hope for something greater.

“I’ll come to check on you again after midnight.”

“That won’t be necessary. I’m perfectly fine. Good day to you,” Bilbo says sharply. And just as Bilbo did so, he thought he saw a raised eyebrow, a slight surprise on the wizard’s face.

The rest of the day is spent as Thorin guided, in a sort of focused meditation, where memories of them brush against the forefront of his mind in an austere, non-romantic way. Two silhouettes at first, later two dots that represent their souls connected, always close to each other, are all they are in his mind's exercise, which, he tries to remember, is what’s needed now. Thorin said Bilbo’s wish to never part is a factor in this strange, would-be miracle. A foreign thought, and quite a leap for Bilbo, the one not used to viewing himself as a cause; anyone but him.

He struggles in the evening. He forgot about breakfast, lunch or dinner, and now hunger is coming back to him. He’s feeling weak. He could go upstairs and ask for food, yet fears the distraction of other people will break his concentration. So he remains there, in the dark, silent tomb, soon to drift toward sleep again, at the foot of the stone where Thorin’s body lies.

 

...The dream he had continues with him in the Shire, all alone. Thorin is gone forever, and Bilbo is sentenced to continue living.

He feels the loneliness, the emptiness of this dream. Nothing happens in it; it’s mainly just a feeling that stays with Bilbo, seeping into his core. A feeling of emptiness perpetually reflected by the world around. The houses, trees and flowers are lonely, colorless, devoid of life. In this desolate place Bilbo is doomed to exist, dimmed by the absence of a person that took the world with him.

The dream feels so real that when Bilbo wakes up, this feeling is in him. Thorin will not come back. He is convinced now. The dream is a foreshadowing of his life that starts tomorrow. Today, even. There will be no change. His time with Thorin was real, and rather wonderful, but it’s probably all they could have. Thorin gave him hope, something to hold on to, but ultimately, this has to be the end, as Gandalf said.

Focus, he thinks. Thorin told me to focus. I’m pretty sure this doesn’t count.

It’s hard to focus, the memories of him and Thorin marred by the greyness he has witnessed in his dream, internalized, now. Bilbo needs something else, a new device that can cut through this fog. Something that Thorin said...

Only I can bring him back. No, that’s not quite what he said. I don’t know if he can come back or not. But if he were to come back, it would be for me.

It’s not enough.

What Gandalf said... Is it time? Maybe Thorin will come for a brief moment, for a last goodbye? Or maybe they already had it? No. Neither. Nothing in what transpired between him and Thorin was, or will be goodbye. Gandalf must be wrong.

He takes out Thorin’s ring to look at it. The ring... All day Bilbo struggled, wanting this ring on his finger, to show it off and say to everyone, Look! Does any of you know what this means? Tonight I will marry your king!

He did put it on a few times. The next moment he was drenched in doubt; took off and hid the ring. Then on again, then off, a few more times. For who could validate such a statement? They would just think him mad. Yet he needs validation: the weakness in his body becomes weakness of the mind, a mind that can no longer rely on itself.

This must be an ongoing test; the ring can help, perhaps. The ring has mass, weight, color. It has been constant, always present. Thorin presented it as proof that this is real.

“Thorin,” he calls softly, almost like calling his own mind, to bring it back along with Thorin’s name.

“I don’t want to live in a world that you’re not in.”

The ring is lifeless, though. It has no power. It can’t help beyond providing a reminder of their brief time together.

“Yet in my dream, I was. And it was not unbearable. It was just... nothing.”

In my dream, I knew you wouldn’t return. But that was not the worst. The worst was that I was not allowed to delude myself. I couldn’t hope.

“If for whatever reason you don’t come... I want to at least be able to hope. And to remember. To live as if you were...”

Live like a madman? He frowns; pushes the thought away.

I will spend the rest of my life thinking of you. Hoping to see you again one day, even if I were to know that that can’t be.

I will spend the rest of my life waiting for you, even if I have no reason left to believe you will come.

Nothing is unbearable - well, except for this thing itself, that nothing is unbearable.

For all that he's tried for encouragement, this last thought is the most hopeless he's had. But this was not what Thorin told him to do, was it? No, he was supposed to believe. Not to plan for insurance in case Thorin didn’t come back. He sees it now: his mind has given up believing. His back-up plan has undermined his trust.

You asked me to believe. I did, for what, like an hour? If that.

What is it, to believe? How does one do it? Can one choose to believe, or is it something that just happens?

Either way, it has to be genuine. And I don’t genuinely believe this right now, when I myself feel I will disappear.

“Thorin...” he says, defeated, looking down in half-shame. “I do believe. I've always believed in you. But I also doubt. It’s both of them at once. I want to believe more fully. But for that... to be ready to be with you in the way that you promised... to believe completely in what's to come... I need your help. Help me.”

He sighs, relieved. That was the truth. He lets the seconds pass, then rises from the floor, leaning his back against the tomb. He should go, soon.

“You’re ready now.”

He turns and sees. Thorin stands behind him, on the other side.

A revelation. For both, not just for Bilbo. Thorin seems equally amazed.

“You love me.”

Bilbo smiles. That took a while. “You think?”

“I didn’t know it fully until now.”

“So... it sounds like I passed whatever test this was? Yet I can’t fathom how.”

“Faith is not perfect. But love can be. What you lost through lack of faith you made up with your love. It was enough.”

“Are you saying you watched me?”

“No,” says Thorin. “I felt you.”

He takes Bilbo’s hand in his, and Bilbo feels his hurry, that he doesn’t want to linger for too long. They take just one moment, for Bilbo to perceive Thorin dressed in dark, regal clothes, holding a white robe and two crowns in his hands.

“So, we’re really going to do this?”

“Yes, we will. Come with me. It is time.”

 

...And they begin to walk towards the hallway, leaving the empty tomb. And in this hand he holds Bilbo can feel Thorin's body and soul pulsing together, two in one. The Thorin, the way he knew him always, has come back to the real world, for real is the way Thorin has revealed himself. Bilbo could not have dreamed him in this way. In this hand that he holds, he feels the life returned to Thorin fully, the life that vibrates through his body now, the same body that was alive before, then died... Life flowing out of him, reaching into his One, giving itself so Bilbo can live, too.

 

Chapter 9: Midnight

Chapter Text

When they reach the Mountain top, Bilbo’s breath is caught.

A small forest unfolds in his sight, leaves rustling in the wind, birds perched on branches, the sound of water drifting from a spring, elements gathered solemnly here, nature in waiting illumined by light that spreads across the soil and rock from torches, lanterns and distant stars of white, red, grey and blue.

With a raised hand, Thorin lowers the firmament, and the stars draw closer, inundate their view, their light growing brighter. A veil of red and blue, delicate and transparent, stretches two-fold above a nearby rock, clothing the sky in the same fabric Thorin’s coat is made of, the fabric of the white robe in his hands.

Nature, the cosmos itself, is quietly alive; Bilbo perceives the stillness that surrounds.

“There’s no one here. And yet I feel a distant presence.”

Silence turns to laughter, happy voices he hears from the skies above. He lifts his head to look in fascination.

“We’re not alone. My parents,” Thorin says. “I can discern their figures. Mahal is there with them, and my brother.”

Bilbo looks down in sadness. “I can only hear them. I’m glad. But my parents... I wish they were here too.”

“They are,” says Thorin. “Bilbo. Listen.”

Two familiar voices float from afar, break from the universe’s sound to settle closer, and Bilbo hears Why yes, darling, what did I tell you, that’s our son over there! A hobbit getting married to a king, king Baggins, what a notion! Bilbo is not sure if they’ve properly been brought up to speed, but there they are, present and distant, watching.

“They are. Thank you,” he murmurs faintly, more a question of what wonders will he learn through this night, only Thorin can answer.

Thorin. He’s leading this ceremony, it appears; there is no one else. He lays the two crowns on the rock and holds out the robe, and the white Bilbo saw at first becomes infused with colors everchanging.

“I thought about green, for you. And yellow,” Thorin says softly. “Like your home. But...”

Bilbo echoes his thought. “...It should be red.”

The robe in Thorin’s hands turns to the color Bilbo wore on their journey, the red that runs into the blue, softly and harshly until there are no more edges, and they can feel it has already started, their new path together as one whole. Green and yellow are here, too - under the sky, in the branches that move with the breeze, the dark trees. In the small bouquet of flowers placed on this rock, fresias, magnolias, roses, flowers of Spring and Summer, in a small, round stone-shaped thing that could stand for a vase - and Bilbo understands. Thorin brought a bit of the Shire to him here and tried to blend it with the beauty of his Mountain, their harmony complete.

“I love this, Thorin,” he speaks against the breeze, to his love’s delight.

What can he offer to the earth below, the skies above? He reaches in his pocket and wonders if the acorn he found in Beorn’s garden, that he carries still, can be of any use. His fist closes around it.

Thorin dresses him in the robe, clothing that flows in waves and ripples of red light, both hiding and revealing the mithril underneath, a new identity that falls on him like nightfall, thin, delicate and surreal.

“Where did you get it?”

“It is not of this world.”

Thorin cannot say, yet, that when he saw his Maker one more time, a few hours ago, Mahal graced him with gifts rare beyond measure. He cannot say yet that these coats were made at the beginning of the world, in the presence of Eru himself; that when the Valar sang the first vision of the world, their voices merged so well with their own creation that the music left behind traces of fabric in the void.

And now Bilbo can see Thorin’s blue coat is of similar make, if thicker: a fabric that reflects the stars that glisten bright and dim, the lanterns shimmering in the trees, the torches burning high. Bilbo wonders if his own coat shines like this, if it could blend with the light of the universe.

“Yours is much brighter. Yours reflects the sun.”

How can there be a sun- yet Bilbo sees it now. The sun is in the sky, far and low in the distance, setting below the clouds as the moon rises, slowly and quietly passing by, bathing Thorin’s coat in its pale, silvery glow, while Bilbo’s red blends with the sun’s yellow orange light.

“It lingers longer in the sky tonight. For you and I.”

“For us,” Bilbo murmurs against this new surprise, his voice extinguished like a fire that burned too bright for this world. Waiting for the miracle of us, a mirror just like that night, brought there together to face this mystery eternal, to unfold this plan that was set in motion at the beginning of all things.

“Bilbo.”

Thorin turns towards him.

“Before we do this... I will say some words.”

His gaze pierces Bilbo’s insides, fierce and burning, and Bilbo realizes. Nothing could have prepared him for this moment.

“To make you see that part of you that I see, to see yourself the way that I see you.”

Thorin takes a deep breath, fighting to stay collected, keep his balance; his voice is shaking with emotion.

“When we met... I will not talk of how I misjudged you; for it has no place on this night. Let it be said I did not expect you to come with us that morning. No one would have blamed you for deciding against unknown danger. I myself did not trust the wizard; why should you? And yet you followed.”

A game of truth or dare, only it’s both at once. Trust it to Thorin to tell it like it is and dare me to do the same.

“When we stopped in Rivendell, I expected you would remain there for the peace it offered, as I sensed your relief and pleasure. You did not feel the longing for the Mountain and its treasure as we did. Your longing, I perceived, was of a different kind. And I said, let it be. Let him stay here, for there is nothing for him in this quest. And yet, again you followed.”

Does Thorin really know how it all went? For Bilbo’s heart was hidden from everyone’s view, even himself, for a while.

“After my harsh words in the Misty Mountains, I felt the pain in your voice as you were leaving. I was most surprised. I thought you’d be relieved, not sad, to know that I allowed you to go back, and you’d see your chance. Yet you ended up rejoining us after we were split, and this time, despite hearing my careless words again, you showed yourself and finally spoke to me.”

It took a while for me to see what I must have wanted.

“Bilbo... I wish I could begin to voice what your words did to me. I will only say I was in love with you then, and when you saved my life before the next sunrise, I had to stop myself from showing you how I felt.”

Finally, Bilbo sees it. It’s all coming out, the answer to this puzzle, Thorin’s feelings, this overflow of unstoppable force Bilbo was once terrified of, that now commands the stars seductively, all for him, to burn in love and desire’s name; when did they begin, why, how.

“From that moment on, I dreamed of you. Of us. It gave me strength and renewed focus for our quest. I doubted myself many times, that I’d be able to offer you a home, that I could make you happy. I let it be a dream, for the most part.” Thorin’s eyes gleam with new, unhindered passion. “Yet when I found the mithril in the armory of my Fathers, I had to act, to embrace this vision for myself, of the two of us together, and try to make it real in the courting traditions of my people.”

Bilbo smiles here, a bit amused, for it’s still mindblowing how someone can propose with a shirt and a few scarce words, you’re going to need this, put it on.

“It was only when the Arkenstone was revealed, when you told me, on the ramparts, where you stood, attempting to protect my honor and our Company’s lives when, in my weakness, I...”

Bilbo’s hand lifts of its own accord, reaching toward the edges of his eyes to brush that watery mist away. Good tears, Bilbo hopes. They have to be good tears.

“Only then I truly saw the vision realized: what you would be, if you ruled by my side. Because you went against my word when you perceived its flaw; you took charge, decided to change course when I could not. That was what a good, noble king would do: put his people first, at the expense of his own safety. In your case, at the risk of your life.”

Bilbo closes his eyes, overwhelmed.

“Thorin, I don’t... I don’t know about all this.”

“Such loyalty, such courage... It showed me, once again, that, unworthy, by now cursed as I was, I was not wrong to want you. You were - you are - the One.”

Words left unsaid, what paradoxes lie in him, how Thorin couldn’t hold on to this wave of light, and instead evil forces imprisoned and possessed him as he fell further down the spiral into black holes that almost swallowed him, yet it is in such moments, when darkness takes control, that we can see each other for who we really are. Bilbo knows this more than anyone. For it was in the same darkness that he grasped the radiance, the fullness of Thorin’s being.

Thorin covers his hand like a prayer, open and tender, barely touching, still unsure if he should, if he will ever have the right to

“And then...”

I don’t want to go there.

“You tried to save my life, after I almost took yours.”

No, Bilbo shakes his head, frowning in protest. I did nothing.

“It’s painful, I know it well. Laden with pain was the path by which I reached clarity in my darkness, pain whose memory I will bear with me in eternity. But you must see how, even at my lowest, you left me no choice but to fall in love with you,”

almost there, Bilbo’s hand moves downward and rests quietly pressed against Thorin’s heart

“and to do so again and over, every time you revealed yourself to me.”

and Bilbo feels the fire within him, terrible, unforgettable.

“I have nothing to offer, but myself I offer to you freely and completely. You are the one I trust, I need, I want. I will love you until the end of time. My love for you will never die, if time itself should end. Bilbo...

...my heart is yours. Forever.”

There is a question here, unspoken, though the answer was given long ago. The truth is laid before them, all these words Thorin has said are working now, weaving this new thread in the fabric of space and time, the bonding of their souls, now, if Bilbo could-

“You... Your heart, all that you offer... I will have it. All of it, with your pain. And I certainly hope that this “forever” that you speak of can come true. Because I want it too.”

Thorin releases a breath long withheld, he takes the smaller crown, a delicate thing wrought of mithril, adorned with tiny flower gems, and places it above Bilbo’s head in slow, careful movements, as he chants above him, Ulkhud bin-aznân, rûzud ra nûlukh, irzêd ikhthuzul, ’ala nurt binzann, and once the crown rests on his head Bilbo sees his reflection in Thorin’s eyes, the sun’s warm glow descending on him full and bright.

Then Thorin releases him, his gaze never wavering from his face, mesmerized by the dance of lights and shadows cast by the brilliant crown.

“You rehearsed this, didn’t you?”

“More times than I can count.”

In Mahal’s forges, where Thorin’s day was spent, crafting, with every strike of the hammer his mind getting clearer.

It’s not quite fair, is it. Bilbo hasn’t had time to prepare amid his less than pleasant struggle with unbelief, hunger, need for sleep. What can he say to match this grand discourse?

Keep it simple. You don’t need to match anything. Just be yourself. Can’t you see he loves you for who you are?

“Well. As for me... how best to sum it up.” He smiles playfully. When in doubt, tell the truth. “Here is what I’m going to say. This whole journey, perilous to begin with, for me was a rollercoaster, in no small part thanks to you. That you were hot and cold towards me was one thing, but your reactions to our various encounters on the road were... how to put it. Illogical? Unpredictable? Suffice to say, if this adventure left me at times unsettled, second-guessing, terrified... well, you can bet your attitude did the same. But.”

The paradox of Thorin, the tension that seeped into him, never alone, for the resolve was there also, always together, how they worked in him. How they will settle like a balm, healing, restoring perfect peace, in time.

“At the same time, wherever I was, if you were there with me, I felt safe, protected, strong despite myself, and unafraid. I felt like I could be invincible. Which is strange, considering a spirit so unyielding and uncompromising such as yours cannot always expect to win, for it lacks reason. And yet you won in me, when I saw how your heart spoke for you, in every single act it burned for everything with impossible courage and passion. Your heart did not need reason. So in the end, I can say that I liked your way, wild and infuriating as it was. It made me want to be more, to walk with you close to the edge of danger. You speak of my loyalty and courage; if indeed you saw those in me, you were seeing a reflection of yourself. A good attempt, I hope, though nothing,” his fingers trace lightly, daringly against Thorin’s chest where his wound lies, “compares to the real thing.”

Thorin looks like he’s ready to go to war with this last statement. But Bilbo isn’t done.

“As for the love part. Well, first I should say my thoughts were nothing like yours. Is this person right for me, would he make a good Baggins who could rule Under the Hill...” He laughs. “It wasn’t like that at all. I think I ran from my feelings as much as I ran from this adventure; until I couldn’t anymore. You are...”

You’re close, but for Yavanna’s sake, slow down or you’ll ruin it.

“It’s hard to pinpoint when I fell in love.” I haven’t stopped, for that matter. It’s happening even now. “I can show you glimpses of it here and there. If you look at the whole maybe you get a picture. I know of one such moment that made things clear to me. I only wish I had acted, then.”

Do you want to go there? Do you want to know?...

Judging by the flicker in his eyes, yes, Thorin does.

Bilbo opens his fist. The acorn is revealed once more, and they step into the memory together.

Thorin’s gaze descends upon it in amazement, then back to Bilbo’s eyes, piercing through him yet not seeing it all; the moment when the truth obscured the lie.

You’ve carried it all this way.

I’m going to plant it in my garden. In Bag End, says Bilbo with a shy, hesitant look.

Then Thorin’s eyes tear up. There’s sadness for himself, a river overflowing, yet he tries to smile for Bilbo’s little happiness, as if with this sad smile he can will such a thing into being. His eyes betrayed him in that moment, and Bilbo saw beauty unseen before, that didn’t know where to hide.

It’s a poor prize to take back to the Shire.

And it stops

“Here,” Bilbo says. “Right here.”

Pause over this, stay in this moment so it is made clear, if he can make it clear.

“You were fighting a horrible evil. I was the one - perhaps the only one - who could help you get better. And here I was, telling you I’m leaving soon, good luck with all this, the madness and the gold and all this emptiness and desolation that you never mentioned to me when you shared dreams of home. How did my words feel to you in that loneliness, when I knew you didn’t want me to leave? You could have captured me and held me prisoner, like you did with the gold. And yet, you were ready to let me go, with... of all things, with love. So. Yes, there’s loyalty and there’s courage, and then there’s this. In you.”

And every time I see it, I need

“So let me tell you now. I’m not going anywhere. I’ll stay with you.”

Bilbo kneels. The soil beneath his hands parts slightly sideways, and he drops the acorn in that small empty space between him and Thorin. The soil moves back, settling in place, covering the seed, and Thorin’s memories fall over it with his tears, like falling rain.

Here.

He rises and his lips meet Thorin’s, a fleeting, almost unreal kiss, just like this moment, meant to take away all of Thorin’s worries and pain, to soothe and heal him, for the madness he didn’t foresee and for the wounds that haven’t happened yet, for the pain of death and their bitter parting. “I love you,” he whispers as his lips kiss away the last of tears, his love’s lips entreating him like a lifeline to come back and stay forever and ever, and they’re back in the present

...the kiss dissolves, he’s drifting away from Thorin only just, while Thorin’s hand tries to keep him close, fingers searching his lips ghostly, ensure they were there

“Thorin... you are everything. So much that I do not know what you would need in me - but whatever it is, it is yours, if you’ll take it.”

...to hold on and seal the memory of the most beautiful words Thorin has ever heard.

“I will.”

Thorin presses the remaining crown into Bilbo’s hands and kneels. Not his grandfather’s. This is different; lighter. For a kingdom that’s not from this world.

Bilbo kisses the crown reverently, sets it on Thorin’s head and marvels at its intricate design of silver stars, and Thorin chants again, Ilúvatar, Adadmâ, imhid ’ala ashhân ni khulthu ra ai-kâmin, amrâl hiyumul akyâl ra amrâd, ’ala zann hikhthuzul,...

...Then slowly rises, and the clock strikes midnight like a shadow, unseen inside the Mountain cold. And now Bilbo can see the figures in the sky watching from beyond, like portraits grave and solemn, in utter silence. A shift in their mood soon occurs and they start stirring; could it be that it’s done, this hour everlasting.

“Does this mean you are mine now, Thorin II Oakenshield?”

“Yes,” Thorin speaks. “I am yours, and for you alone I have returned to life.”

 

...For the first time in many years, Bilbo feels pure happiness, like an innocent child running wild through the fields, bathing in rivers, blending with grass and flowers, hands in the sky, moving with the wind, his skin kissing the sunlight, joyful and carefree. Thorin’s hands cup his cheeks with blissful adoration as he savors that special place where Thorin longs to be, the joy in his love’s freedom; its expression. And Bilbo kisses him in a blinding haze, the sun and moon’s beams shooting around them like spears, and they run together, lost in the meadows, flowing with the rivers, burned with the moon and sun’s light, and Thorin tastes the freedom and endless wonder of being alive once again, for him - his One, pressed against him, light as the air, alive and warm, and loved.

 

Chapter 10: One

Notes:

I am deeply grateful for all the support this story has received. Thank you all so much for staying with it to the end, and thank you for all kudos and your wonderful comments! I hope you enjoy this last chapter ❤️

Chapter Text

Midnight.

An orange trail in the sky down below, a figment of the sun.

The view is beautiful.

Thorin uncovers a wooden plate on the rock, revealing bread, butter, nuts and strawberry jam, and three bright red apples. They’re from Yavanna’s orchard; she brought them to the Halls for him to take.

“She wanted you to have them. One for each day that you had to endure in that dark solitude, waiting.”

By now Bilbo should no longer be surprised.

“Do you see how this is all too much?”

“It is. But it’s just for tonight. Life will return to normal soon.”

They sit, eat in silence, contemplating the serenity around them. They recall the words on either side, how much was left unsaid, promise of things to come.

Then Thorin joins their hands. They kneel before the rock, place a kiss on its surface and rest there in reverence. A wind blows, and they feel a warm hand above their heads remove their crowns. When they lift their eyes, only the flower vase remains; the crowns have disappeared.

They stand, and Thorin guides them away from the rock, towards the small forest. They sit near a tree, the sounds of trickling water getting closer.

He waits for a few moments. The stars retreat, dimming in the distance, taking the voices’ renewed, lively chatter with them. The lanterns’ lights go out, the sun disappears under the horizon, the waters cease their murmur, everything goes quiet for a moment and the night is still, so still, save for the torches that still burn around them.

They behold each other; the space between them. Too much space. Thorin wonders, vaguely, if he should suggest Bilbo rest after two restless nights.

Bilbo’s fingers trail across the collar of his coat. “May I?” Thorin nods silently. Bilbo parts his coat, his fingers stretch his shirt down, and Bilbo stares at Thorin’s chest and touches where the wound from Azog was inflicted. The wound is still there, healing but present, its red a reminder of agony and pain. Not the most attractive part of coming back to life, Thorin thinks.

“The body I had these last two nights was something idealized. More beautiful, perhaps. This one is not as... flawless.”

Or perhaps he’s mistaken.

“It’s yours. I like it better if imperfect- Oh, blast it. It’s not imperfect. It’s... what I’ve been waiting for.”

The unrealness of it. That they should talk like this in the stillness of this summer-winter night, where nothing makes a sound.

“So quiet... It feels like we’re alone. The only people in the world.”

Together like this, just the two of them, underneath the stars.

“We could drift away. Be elsewhere.” Everywhere.

“Anything you want.”

“Thorin...”

I want to know your heart.

“I want to feel you. To feel as if I am you.”

And that heart takes hold, determined but held steady by love’s presence and the nature’s patient rhythm, as Thorin takes in Bilbo’s radiance gleaming through his robe and the mithril underneath. He leans down into Bilbo’s space and kisses him softly, gently, then more roughly as his hands undo his robe and take it off, and Bilbo’s mithril is revealed, once again; and Thorin feels the return in his earthly body more completely, what he knows of himself, lust and dark desire, passion boundless and blinding. His lips, his tongue caress Bilbo’s skin, every kiss filled with endless adoration. “I love you so much,” his voice shakes as he takes Bilbo in his arms, his hands surrounding him, feeling him, wanting him. How could it feel to be with his One after long months of pining and the wrenching separation, to finally have Bilbo, undress him, possess him, love him to the end.

What is it like to no longer feel that touching is a fragile dissolution, an illusion... yet the body Thorin had before tonight, the body Bilbo felt these last three days - fleeting, immaterial, unreal - knew patience, perfect rhythm, to withstand eagerness and achieve control, and it somehow knew everything Bilbo liked... something this earthly body yet does not.

Yet last night, in the Shire... when Thorin touched him, the leaves, the flowers and the wind had touched him; the stars the night before. And Thorin’s body had felt like the wind, then, like he could surround Bilbo from any side and wrap the night around him. All of these elements are here again tonight, the universe, nature quietly alive... His spirit breaks through his body’s shield and reaches to them, and Thorin is the wind, the soil beneath, the stars caressing his love’s figure in their infinite motion, and he’s filled with the wonder of it all. Bilbo, his, the first time, his lips are on every inch of his skin and Bilbo’s pleasure reverberates through Thorin’s body and he doesn’t see, he doesn’t hear, just feels his love’s body against him and knows, through the sky and trees, what it wants, how it wants, Bilbo’s pleasure, its feeling on Bilbo’s skin as much as on Thorin’s lips, distinct from his own at first, until they feel as one. And the stars’ infinite motion, nature, rivers, the sky, the torches’ fire, burning, he is them; one with the earth, with the universe, with him.

“I want you...” Thorin hears as he feels his body pushed down to the ground in a gentle, slow motion. His head leans back and he sees the stars... It’s beautiful... He spreads his arms and relaxes in a smile.

...To die forgotten, buried in the earth, the wind rustling in the trees, the birds singing their good night song, the water flowing in the pale light of the moon... Is that how he would die? Where... Not above Bilbo’s house; a little farther, by the endless river. And the soil where he’d lie would renew with great vigor, promise of new seeds that will grow, and he would live in them.

But he is not in the Shire, is he? He is not... His love above him, entirely unexpected, astonishing, like a surprise too good to be true, Bilbo caressing his hair and kissing the scar on his forehead, breathing so much purity, Thorin must be confusing what is real - where, where am I... Immobilized, the only thing he can move are his hands, the hands that forged the crowns and Bilbo’s blue ring are wielding Orcrist again - ice, neverending, freezing - he has to die, there is no other way, yet his love’s fingers trail across his hands and remove the sword with silent determination and Thorin’s hands are forged anew in perfect peace

and he wants to say Farewell and take back heavy words, oh, to forget the bitterness, the resentment and the fear, to be forgiven... no more commands and battle orders, no more mistakes and no apologies - his love’s mouth pressed against his own, softly taking and giving - something so beautiful, so soft that tries to tell him without words, Don’t move, don’t leave

and his body, no longer fragile and ethereal but wounded and imperfect, that walked through fire, drowned in gold, that smashed through ice, that flickered in bright darkness and then died, is made strong again in his love’s hands as Bilbo kisses the wound close to his heart and holds his body as if he could heal him should Thorin wish to stay, and somehow this, for the realness and imperfection of it makes Bilbo want him more.

Where am I going... sinking... down below, deep beneath the Mountain, back into the tomb... no, it’s not there, it’s just like he imagined, to be one with the earth and forget that he ever happened... He’s sinking in the earth, Bilbo’s skin still on his, alive... “Cover me,” Thorin pleads, and Bilbo covers him with his body while never stopping touching and he loses himself in his love’s skin. Surrender... Azog above him, holding him prisoner with no chance to escape, Mahal give me time before it’s over... surrender... “I love you,” he hears the sounds - pleasure, undenied, love for him, impossible. “Thorin,” comes the voice again from another place, “My Thorin, I love you...”

The brief dream before dying, what else could this be, but he will not die, he married and this is love, and for all that he’s waited for it for so long, he’s afraid to receive it.

He’s never dreamed of receiving it. In his fantasies it was always him, Thorin leading Bilbo in fierce, passionate love, showing him how wanted he is, the meaning of everything... but instead it is Thorin taking love from this place of light.

He wakes, comes back, fully himself now, he starts moving against Bilbo, cupping his face, placing needful, greedy kisses on his neck, captures his mouth, he devours him, then rises and pins Bilbo to the ground; he longs to touch, to possess, to give. Thorin’s tongue rolls on the shell of his ear, sucks on his neck and his collarbone while they rock together and Bilbo moans in pleasure, and they crave each other jealously, with desire so intense and unrestrained, that they feel nothing is enough and will not be enough. The present is all they have, just this moment, everything lived for the sake of now, with no urgency and no thought to move on, and every time their bodies meet feels like nothing can tear them apart. And Bilbo loves this, to offer himself to this overwhelming feeling of Thorin on him, on all of him; how Thorin loves.

“Azyungel”, Thorin whispers. “My pure, my beautiful love. Love that transcends, love that never ends.”

They feel their bodies together pressed against each other, every part of them touching the other’s, a whole that sets the universe in motion, the planets moving in harmony and contentment, the cosmos restored to its peaceful rhythm on this night where nothing can go wrong; and the wounds of the world begin to heal.

The vase of flowers on the rock leans and falls down, the water spills in the earth and the flowers are carried by the wind to the place where Thorin has Bilbo on the soft, moist ground, his hands pressing Bilbo’s into the soil as they rock together. The flowers float slowly in the air and dissolve into petals, and petals fall on Bilbo’s hair, and Thorin kisses them away. And more flowers descend, joined by tiny drops of light diffusing from the stars like tears of joy, a cold light that drizzles like water on Thorin’s skin, and starlight flowers roll off Thorin’s hair and rain on Bilbo’s eyes and lips, flowing down until they reach the mithril. And the mithril shatters in a million pieces, its links spread all over Bilbo’s body, infusing Thorin’s skin with warmth, and Thorin drowns in that light; together they sink, and darkness exists no more.

“Amrâlim-ê. Ulkhud-ê. Akyâl-ê,” and Bilbo wants to respond, because all of a sudden he can understand all these words, My love, my light, my life, and the words Thorin chanted earlier, light without darkness, sun and moon, glowing eternally, this day without night, and now he hears a word that he can’t comprehend but he knows it means One, and for a moment he’s afraid of what it means

“Thorin, Thorin...”

a voice is heard from somewhere, above or below, inside or outside.

“Thorin, who am I?”

“Thorin,” he hears the echo of the voice inside.

You are me.

“I can’t...” he says, or wants to before he dissolves into One, and Thorin is him, and he is Thorin, dark, fierce, possessive, jealous and protective and now Bilbo can feel all of these, how Thorin feels, from inside him, as if being him; he is him. Reason is silenced, there’s just passion, this blinding force, this power that can have, could have taken everything, is everything and yet all it wants is him; it consumes him.

 

...Bilbo does not wake from this dream. There he remains, forever kept in his lover’s arms, safe, protected, and never alone again, while Thorin ever seeks a new way for light to fall in love with darkness and merge, softly and violently, and split, and crave and seek each other once again, a million times, and be complete for longer than an instant until they split and merge again, as One, to the end.

* * *

...The tomb lies empty. The Arkenstone and Orcrist rest on it, shining in the pale, subdued shadows, defeated by the light of the morning that finds its way into the tomb, filtering through strange holes in the roof.

“He didn’t want them after all,” say the dwarves, silently pondering over what cannot be yet said.

He is not here.

A letter lies between the sword and stone. Balin opens it and hands it to the wizard. It reads

Dear Gandalf,

I have seen him one more time. Whether it was for a last goodbye or not, only time can tell; time I am grateful for. Be it as it may, I’m going on a long, long holiday.

Tell my friends I understood something, finally, of the things that happened; something they knew before I did. And if anyone should care to hear what I know now, tell them I have seen death, have known love, and lived through both, and I wish the whole world could be made better for it.

Until we meet again,

Your friend

Bilbo Baggins

* * *

...The edge of the world.

Seven weeks later, Thorin takes them there, one last trip in their beautiful blue globe, now Bilbo’s wedding ring; the real ring of power. One last, before it’s time.

There is endless water, and the Undying Lands lie across, on the other side. And Thorin says “Bilbo, we can... If you want, we can go there.”

He does not mention the Ring; how Bilbo’s sacrifice impressed quite a few people up above. All Bilbo needs to know is he is welcome to stay in that realm, with Thorin, should he choose.

“We’ll live in bliss, never to be parted. We’ll never age or suffer. We’ll be happy forever just as we are today. I will dream my dreams, and you will write your stories. And we will live in them.”

Bilbo’s body shakes with exaltation, his face mesmerized by this otherworldly dawn, the sun rising over the Sea. Could it be true.

“And if we choose the world?”

“Then we will live in it. We’ll be together; we will part, too, though never for too long. We’ll find each other again. Our bond will survive through the ages of the world. But there will be aging, separation, grief. We will feel the guilt of withdrawing ourselves from the world’s fate, or even try to intervene in it when that guilt hits too hard. And, Bilbo... in time, you may regret you parted with your Ring, and may resent me for it. So life in the world, I’m afraid, will be, what was that word you used. A rollercoaster?”

They regard each other uneasily, their adventure brought to the front of their minds. Well. They survived it, after all.

“And you, my Thorin? How will you be?”

Thorin smiles fondly. “Stubborn, illogical, unpredictable. I will drive you crazy sometimes. But I’ll find my way back to you, every time. And I will always love you.”

“Which one would you prefer?”

Do you think the world needs us at all?...

“I’ve always liked the world. I’d choose it over any paradise. But for you, my love, I would choose the Undying Lands, for there is nothing I want more than your happiness. Please understand that I would follow you. Your choice is mine - you are my choice. I cannot make it alone.”

“No,” Bilbo agrees, and his hands lift to touch Thorin’s face as if to immortalize him, and he claims his lips with that urgent longing, that they should be not just eternally in love but immortal, untainted, forever young, and their lips crash against each other a million times as the waves break below them, and the edge of the world drifts away towards the Sea, then pushing inward, back into the world, rocking them back and forth in soft, airy motion. And when the rock they stand on floats towards the Sea they kiss in light, and when they drift back into Middle Earth they kiss in darkness. And they contemplate the illusion, for there is not really a choice but one answer, whose name they know, they’ve already lived through it just as they’ve already been forever young, untainted and immortal.

 

...The acorn Bilbo planted on their wedding night grew on top of the Lonely Mountain. And everyone who dared to climb that high and enjoy the view marveled that an oak tree could grow there, surrounded by strange flowers shaped like stars. And few remembered that a tree just like that existed in Bag End, above Bilbo’s home. But those who did never forgot the hobbit from the Shire who traveled with them, and how their king loved him; for of that they knew before Thorin himself had revealed. And Thorin’s love passed into legend with him, no one knowing if it ever was fulfilled.

To this day it is not known where Bilbo and Thorin are. But the globe is still spinning, and Middle Earth is still safe, if broken and imperfect, and they say that a soul bound perfectly in love by another could make that difference in a world threatened by all-consuming evil. A soul who wanted to exist in the world when it could have been in the arms and glory of his heavenly Father, or in blissful paradise by the Sea. And blessed is that world if two such souls did choose to live in it, watch over it however near or far, and offer it the smallest portion of their love.