Actions

Work Header

A Wizard is Never Late

Chapter 3: Limitation

Notes:

HEY! So you know how I said in the comments back in January how the next chapter was just about ready to go up?? Turns out I was very mistaken! I decided to add a whole scene, then the scene wasn't working out and in the end I just decided to post it because I got annoyed. Also this chapter is LONG. I have a complete work on Ao3 that is shorter than this chapter. Aaaaaaaah.

I had a hard time with Thorin this chapter as he kind of throws himself under a few buses and is feeling very down which isn't really how we see him in canon and also this chapter is supposed to convey Thorin realising a bunch of stuff and I really hope I pulled it off!

Oh also this chapter buys into a lot of the common fanon headcanons surrounding dwarves and their hair. If you aren't familiar with this then it might seem like Thorin repeatedly makes mountains out of molehills and I would recommend you read A Dwarf's Pride by TrueRed, Nobody by Samayla or (if you want something low angst) Plaits and Weaves by ArgentAconit which I think are good examples.

Warnings for: fairly graphic torture, reference to suicidal thoughts and mentioned chronic illness (kind of?).

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

November TA 2941

It is the first time Thorin has seen the whole extent of the damage done to his face at the battle, now the best part of a month ago. Oin finally removed the bandages for good this morning and he has been so busy that it is in the evening that he has his first opportunity to just stop and look. He runs his fingers over the wide band of rough scar tissue that runs from just below his hairline to taper to a point at the corner of his jaw. The cavern made by his empty eye socket is unsettling to look at. He had known that his eye was gone and on bad nights he could almost feel its absence but up until now it has been hidden by layers of bandages and seeing it is another thing entirely. It has a peculiar finality to it – as if before he could have somehow pretended it wasn’t real or only temporary. He could laugh at the ridiculousness; he has clearly spent too much time above ground!

adjusts the hand mirror he has borrowed from what was once his mother’s rooms. As he is currently Thorin is a menacing sight, handsome by dwarven standards but skirting close to the line that divided rugged battle wounds from horrific disfigurements. He wonders what he looks like by a hobbit’s standards and then chides himself. He will never see Bilbo Baggins again!

As Gandalf had planned, and once Bilbo had been healthy enough to travel, Gandalf had bundled him into a heavily padded cart and they had left for Thranduil’s halls. There they would spend the remainder of the winter and then Bilbo would finally be able to return home to his beloved Bag End. Thorin missed Bilbo more than he missed his own eye. It had only been a week since his departure but Thorin could have easily been convinced it had been at least ten times longer, although he had not seen Bilbo since that awful day before the battle. Well, he had watched in secret from an arrow slit high in the mountain as Gandalf carried a hobbit-sized bundle of blankets and furs to the cart and then slowly rode away but that hardly counted. He had stood with his face pressed to the narrow crack long after the company had returned inside from where they had bade the travellers farewell in a less clandestine manner. So long had he watched that he felt stiff and chilled and the cart had disappeared from sight over the horizon some undeterminable time before.

It was hopeless to even entertain that Bilbo would still find him handsome. While Thorin was self-aware enough (just) to realise that he had well and truly fallen for the hobbit he had decided to leave any attempts at courting until after Smaug was defeated. Then the gold sickness had set in and while Thorin had made his intentions very clear in a dwarven manner, Bilbo was not a dwarf and clearly hadn’t understood and after that… well any dreams of having Bilbo at his side as Consort under the Mountain had been crushed by his own hand. Thorin no longer deserved to have Bilbo’s affections, as much as it hurt and Thorin didn’t doubt that if he did manage to weasel his way into Bilbo’s good graces again Gandalf would quite happily turn him into a toad or something equally undignified. Thorin wasn’t sure what wizards did to people like him – they were not inclined to acts of cruelty but generally they had no reason to be as living in near isolation didn’t give them much opportunity to experience hatred – but Gandalf cared for Bilbo like the hobbit was family.

Balin has already had a replacement eye commissioned for him but there will be no hiding it’s nature regardless of the quality of the craftmanship as what remains of his eyelid has healed malformed and twisted. He is unsure about how he feels about a glass eye – he has already objected to the diamond and sapphire creation that Balin had initially proposed. Thorin cannot risk falling to gold sickness again and stuffing precious stones in his eye socket will not help him ignore the gold’s siren call. While he is fairly sure he has remained free of gold sickness these last weeks he has been living in perpetual fear that if he relaxes it will pull him back under. No one can tell him what the likelihood of relapse is as no one has ever been able to break free in the manner he has. So Thorin decided that caution is the best path and when the Royal Wing is declared habitable again he choose himself a servant’s room. There are currently few luxuries in Erebor save from the never-ending piles of gold and jewels so it is not difficult to live simply and have very few notice. That will change when spring comes and food and trade become more plentiful but for now at least Thorin is able to live very much like the pauper-king he has been for most of his life.

The one thing the people do notice is that since… since that day upon the battlements he has not worn his Grandfather’s crown, which has been repaired – or any other crown for that matter. When some of Dain’s nobles had expressed their distaste he had told them that he was not yet coronated so to wear a crown would be presumptuous. That had held them off for a day but then they had begun to hound him for the date of his coronation. He was already King of Durin’s Folk – though without a Kingdom the title had meant very little – but he was not yet King under the Mountain. They complained that without a properly crowned monarch they would appear vulnerable to their enemies and besides what reason could there possibly be to wait? After the first week their persistence had become rather wearing so Thorin had gotten creative in his excuses. He had expressed his wish to be crowned with his sister present and she wouldn’t be arriving until late spring at the earliest, and when that failed to satisfy them entirely he had claimed that the weight of a crown would hinder his recovery. He groaned quietly as the throbbing started up once again behind where his left eye had once sat and rubbed at his face. Maybe his latest excuse contained a grain of truth.

He realised then that he had yet to put his plaits back in. They had been removed sometime during his convalescence and with his head still swathed in bandages he had been forced to let his hair fall untamed. Thorin finds his beads and a comb – the well-worn one that he brought with him on the quest, not one of the jewel-ridden monstrosities that he has seen some of the others start to use – and begins the slow process of combing his hair out in front of the fire. It takes longer than he anticipated as his right hand is still uncooperative – and is unlikely to stop being so – and his hair is tangled from neglect. He had better be careful to stay on top of that or people would liken him to Kili!

His hands move almost on automatic to section out the hair for the first plait – the one that marks him as one of Durin’s folk. The pattern has been drilled into his head from a lifetime of repetition and while his loss in dexterity gives him a little trouble the plait is soon secured with one of his beads. The next is the one that denotes him as King and while this plait is marginally simpler than the first it gives him more difficulty. He still remembers far too clearly the day when it was decided Thorin was to officially going to take his missing father’s place. Dis had woven it for him because he was shaking too hard to do it himself. This time is far from easy but nowhere near as awful as that day, though the plait comes out misshapen and frayed. He leaves it in regardless – it is doubtful he will be able to do a better job if he tries again. The next are the family plaits on the opposite side of his head: one for his parents, one for his siblings and a final one for his sister-sons, each secured with two beads – each a gift from a different member of his family. The plait showing his mastery as a silversmith comes easily too but the warrior plait troubles him so much that he leaves it out and he doesn’t even bother with the one that marked him as a veteran of Azanulbizar. He supposes there will be a plait for the battle of the five armies as it is being called, although he doesn’t know the pattern and tucks the remaining beads into his pocket. He thought putting his plaits back in would make him feel better but he feels like he is only pretending to be the old Thorin Oakenshield. It is not a pleasant feeling but he cannot afford to draw the attention that continuing to go without would bring.

His reign was not off a smooth start for a variety of reasons: the greatest being the aftermath of the battle and the lack of resources other than gold but also, regrettably, the distrust that he had earned from his treacherous actions while in the grip of gold sickness. Erebor was currently mainly populated with dwarves from the Iron Hills and very few were familiar with Thorin in the way his people in Ered Luin are and feared his line’s predilection for madness or scoffed at his weakness. Even then his failings could have possibly been overlooked given that he had reclaimed Erebor and provided many dwarves new hope but the tale of Bilbo, son of Bungo of the Shire had changed that. There was no longer one tale, but many versions – all of which were twisted fragments of what had actually happened, although even the truth was bad enough! Thorin had sold Bilbo to Thranduil as a slave, Bilbo had actually horribly died in the battle, Thorin had tortured Bilbo to death trying to learn the location of the Arkenstone, Bilbo still lived and was trapped in a cell somewhere in the mountain, Bilbo and Thorin had been secret lovers and Thorin had attempted to pitch himself over the battlements after his love when he realised what he had done…

The dwarves’ unfamiliarity with Hobbits and Bilbo’s description had also lead many to believe he was actually a dwarfling and now any the mere handful of families that had moved to the mountain made sure to keep their own dwarflings far away from him.

He sighed heavily and dragged himself to his feet. He would have to get up early tomorrow and it was no use worrying over matters he couldn’t control. Bilbo was surely recovering well and once there was enough food and some of his people from Ered Luin arrived all would be well in Erebor too.


December TA 2941

Thorin swung the wooden practice sword clumsily and sighed when he missed the practice dummy. Again. His injuries may have healed now but his right hand remained stiff and unable to grip tightly so he was having to completely relearn how to write and wield a sword left-handed on top of coping with the lack of depth perception. The only way to overcome it would be to practice but to do so in front of his subjects was humiliating. It did neither them nor him any good to be seen while weak so he had taken, much to Dwalin’s disapproval, to training alone late in the night.

Especially when he couldn’t sleep. Thorin had many reasons not to sleep: his fear of relapsing into the gold sickness, his guilt at all he had done, Bilbo’s shriek when Thorin had dropped him… admittedly it was none of these that was currently keeping him from his rest.

This evening he had paid Fili a visit. Every day since he had emerged from his coma Thorin had rejoiced for and mourned his sister-son in turn. He was deeply thankful that Fili still lived and yet it was… distressing to see him so changed. Oin had told him that given time he still could improve but that didn’t make it any easier right now! Sometimes Fili almost seemed like he had before. For brief snatches of the day he would tease Kili and complain loudly about being restricted to his bed and just generally act like the nuisance Thorin knew and had helped raise. He also still slept a lot and that wasn’t too bad either as it was true sleep, not the unnerving stillness of unconsciousness from before.

But often Fili would just sit or lie quietly, no hint of recognition or intelligence in his eyes, never moving of his own volition or acknowledging his surroundings. Sometimes he would enter this state for hours and today it had lasted all day. Other days he would suffer awful migraines that all anyone could do to help against was to make sure he was somewhere dark and quiet but worst of all were the fits. It had only happened twice so far but Thorin found it terrifying. It was a horrible combination of everything he hated about the vacant periods and the migraines and Thorin found he had very little stomach for watching Fili suffer, especially when there was very little they could do about it. Oin had sent a letter asking for advice to some of his elven colleagues that he had met after the battle but he had warned Thorin not to get his hopes up as head wounds were tricky things.

He finally landed a solid blow on the mannequin with an angry yell and it slumped over. Thorin stuck his sword into the sand that covered the ground in this part of the training halls and bent over to right the dummy when he heard the distinctive scuff of dwarven boots approaching. Multiple dwarves, approaching at speed if he heard correctly.

He reached for the practice sword. He had been visiting the training halls at night for a while now and had never encountered so much as a mouse! He had only lit a couple torches around the area he was training in and the halls were far from the reach of the still working parts of the mirror system that funnelled natural light into the mountain so he could only see his immediate surroundings. He also realised he had left Orcrist with his coat and outer tunic on the benches and hurriedly approached the side of the room.

A blur of movement had him turning and parrying the silver flash of a blade, the wood of the practice weapon sheared through as if it were a rotten stick. Thorin threw the truncated piece of wood at his attacker and reached for the knife at his belt. There was a scuff of feet from his blind side and before Thorin could turn he received a harsh blow to the head. He stumbled forward with a grunt but retained his balance, swiping with his knife to cover for the moment of weakness. The blade made glancing contact, not enough to put them off but better than nothing. He cast around to find his attackers but they were dressed in dark colours and had vanished back into the shadows. It was silent except from the heavy breathing of several people and the shifting noises of boots in the sand. Thorin looked toward where Orcrist lay but then they were upon him again. He dodged a sword thrust and an axe blow that could have removed his head and he still wasn’t sure how many there were but if he ran for it now then he had a chance-

The cudgel came out of nowhere. Thorin folded around the weapon without a sound save the whistling of air leaving his lungs. He barely noticed when he fell down on his back in a daze, pain ripping him apart and hazing his vision as his diaphragm spasmed and he struggled for air. He thought he might hear laughter and feel hands upon his body but it was hard to tell and when Thorin became properly aware of his surroundings once more he was somewhere else.

He opened his eyes to find himself now lying face-down on a stone floor. He wasn’t in the training halls any longer but at least he was still somewhere in Erebor. He moved to get up but his arms were stretched out to either side of him, metal shackles biting into his skin and Thorin wasn’t going to be going anywhere without assistance. His whole torso ached fiercely but it appeared his organs were all still intact, if unhappy at being bruised.

He heard a low whisper off to the left: “He’s awake.” and braced himself for whatever his kidnappers wanted. A hand tangled roughly in his hair, a blatant insult that made Thorin growl and tense, and his head was pulled back. One of the Dwarves that had attacked him – their faces may have been covered but they were undeniably dwarves – stared back at him, dark eyes gleaming from the eyeholes of their mask.

“Well Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror, King under the mountain” the words were spat at him derisively “it appears you are just as weak as we had heard.” There was a murmur of reverent agreement from around the room.

“You call yourself King of Kings and a mighty warrior – the hero of our time! And yet not only did you succumb to the madness that plagues your proud line of bleating lambs quicker than any dwarf that has come before but you went back on your own promises, bartered with elves and murdered a child! You do not deserve to be king under the mountain, you should have realised your weakness and handed the throne to Lord Dain as soon as the battle ended, for while you were skulking bitterly in the blue mountains he was leading his people. While you were crying over the dead he was slaying Azog and when you cried for help in a battle caused by your treachery he came to your aid!” the spokesperson, and presumably also leader, finished speaking, chest heaving from the fervour of his speech.

There were many things Thorin could have said but he found himself exclaiming: “I didn’t kill Bilbo! He’s still alive!!”

“Then where is he? What kind of dwarf brings a dwarfling on a mission like that, anyway?”

“He left with Gandalf the Grey some time ago. And as I have tried to explain, Master Baggins is not a dwarfling but a fully-grown hobbit and he wished to return to his home.” He gritted out. He didn’t actually know what Bilbo had wished, he hadn’t had the nerve to ask Gandalf if it was Bilbo’s desire to return to the Shire or the wizard’s but that was beside the point.

“Of course.” The masked dwarf scoffed “I’ve never heard of these Hobbit creatures before this nonsense and no one in this mountain has seen him alive save your company. You won’t even own up to your mistakes, Thorin Childslayer! You are not worthy of the crown and you know it! Why else would you not wear it!?”

Thorin’s rage was incandescent from this deluge of accusations. “Do not talk to me of worthiness when Dain was perfectly content to stand by and watch my people and I risk everything, never lifting finger until it suited him!” he threatened lowly “Unchain me now and I will show you just how deluded you are!!”

The leader kicked him solidly in the side and the other dwarves all bristled in indignation. It appeared they were zealous followers of Dain, although he didn’t fear they were acting under his orders. While Thorin was not particularly close with Dain they respected each other and Dain’s lack of assistance had been more to protect his own people than to slight Thorin (although Thorin was finding understanding and forgiveness were entirely separate when it came to this matter).

The leader’s tone lightened even as his grip on Thorin’s hair tightened “All we want from you is for you to renounce your claim and the claims of your sister-sons to the throne and to appoint Dain instead. Once you have promised you will do so we will let you go.” He showed Thorin a contract which he didn’t even bother to read, it was no doubt full of ridiculous demands that he would be incapable of meeting.

“I have no intention of giving in to the demands of honourless criminals that sully Erebor’s shadows” he replied haughtily.

At no point in these unpleasant proceedings did it occur to Thorin that provoking his captors would be unwise. While he had some experience of being kidnapped and held against his will he had never faced any consequences for refusing to cooperate or insulting his captors: in goblin town they had escaped before anything more than a few lashes could be inflicted and in Thranduil’s halls the elves had had little interest in hurting them. It was this lack of experience and foresight that meant that Thorin was taken aback (and a little unnerved) when his hair was abruptly released, sending his chin crashing into the floor rather painfully, and two dwarves set about cutting off the light undershirt he had been wearing.

Soon Thorin was shivering as his skin was bared to the cool air, trails of warmth trickling down his sides where the knives had nicked him. He could feel his kidnapper’s gazes upon his exposed back. Thorin was not necessarily an old dwarf but he was passing his prime now and had been in enough conflicts both big and small to acquire an impressive array of injuries. He supposed from the slightly bemused silence that while it was well known that he had fought at Azanulbizar and the battle of the five armies they must have expected him to have sat around and ordered others to risk their lives in place of his own in the intervening years so to see he was not as untouched as a babe was probably a shock.

Admittedly Thorin hadn’t been the perfect leader. He had left his people after Dis’ husband, Vili, had died but it had been to provide for his family! Leading a group of refugees did little to put coin in Thorin’s pockets and after that awful first winter after Vili’s death when they all nearly starved and Kili had been born weak and sickly he had left to find work. It was only once his sister-sons were in their thirties and healthy and well fed that Thorin had even dared attend to his duties once again. That was when he had become a miner so that he could spend more time with his people, although he had been careful to keep his occupation as quiet as he could. It would not do for the mine owners of Ered Luin to know he was working in their mines. He had been lucky with that – people preferred to gossip about how Thorin had ruffled the council of Ered Luin’s feathers or how the heirs of the line of Durin were too unruly and headstrong to make wise leaders than wonder about Borin son of Sarin, a somewhat odd, quiet fellow that was seldom seen outside of his work at the mines.

He wanted to laugh (or maybe cry) at these fools – they had bought the carefully maintained lie of the proud King-in-Exile Thorin Oakenshield who would never deign to lower himself any further than circumstance had already and added his recent misdeeds and concluded that he was a disgrace of a ruler. If Thorin had been in their position faced with the same selection of half-truths and deceptions then he would likely think the same-

Thorin was jarred out of his thoughts by a dwarf sitting heavily on his lower back. He grunted as his newly forming bruises were pressed into the stone beneath him but otherwise didn’t complain despite the feeling of breathlessness.

“You have an impressive collection of scars, why don’t we add to them.” The leader hissed as the dwarf sat on him brought something cold to the flesh across Thorin’s shoulder blades. A knife he realised when the first slow, dragging cut was made. The blade was tortuously blunt and did a poor job of parting his tough skin. Thorin gritted his teeth so he didn’t dishonour himself with every rough jerk of the knife. The dwarf pulled the knife away and hummed thoughtfully before stabbing it back into his flesh and beginning the second cut. Thorin tried to twist away but between the dwarf’s weight and the chains he could only twitch. The fifth cut crossed one of the others – Thorin was in far too much pain by then to tell which one – and he hazily began to realise that they were carving something purposeful into his back. By the eighth cut he was sure it was a word of some sort, judging by the way the dwarf was progressing from left to right but he had no idea what. The knife was now in the flesh at the centre of his back and Thorin forced himself to remain still after he felt metal scrape against bone. As soon as they had passed his spine he relinquished his fragile control over his body. His wrists were chafed and bleeding by now, though it was barely a distraction against the agony that pulled at every nerve in his shoulders. Surely it had to end soon? The last remnant of control slipped away and Thorin cried out raggedly. A haze fell over him, protecting him from the slow, jagged pain of the knife parting his flesh again and again. How could a dwarf of all peoples bear to do this to one of their fellows? Thorin couldn’t imagine what it would be like to be on the other end of the knife: to knowingly torture his fellow dwarf, or anyone for that matter!

Thorin returned unpleasantly to full awareness when he felt the dwarf get up off his back. He could feel blood and sweat flowing along his back and down his arms and sides and supressed a shudder at the pain. He had been injured in many more painful ways but for it to have been so prolonged and the feeling of complete helplessness made this worse. Never before had he been slowly humiliated like this, each layer of his resolve peeled back before being cut away.

The leader was kneeling by his side, careful to avoid the stains on the floor “What say you now to our offer?” they asked.

Thorin groaned and realised he sounded rather pitiful so he spat out a couple curses.

The leader grabbed him by the hair again “Oh how crude, your majesty! If you want to keep your tongue perhaps you should use it more wisely.” They put their hand on the knife on their belt threateningly “However, seeing as our conversation isn’t finished it is perhaps better that we don’t do that just yet. I would take your remaining eye instead but that is also still needed for you to sign our contract.” The leader tightened their grip and said in a pretence of thoughtfulness “I have always had a liking for pretty marbles.”

Before Thorin could protest there were hands pressing the unscarred side of his face into the floor. Thorin couldn’t see anything in this position and when he felt rough fingers on his cheek he panicked. The hold on his head tightened and Thorin was powerless as his glass eye was pried from his skull. It must have only taken minutes but every second that he had another dwarf’s fingers inside his eye socket was unbearable. The hands released him and he turned his head protectively so that his blind side was facing the floor. Even though he knew it was over he could still feel the fingers pressing against the soft tissues of the insides of his eyelids. Thorin was shaking and he felt nauseous but it seemed that no one noticed as they were busy inspecting his false eye.

“It’s only glass!” one cried in astonishment.

“I thought for sure it was diamond and sapphires!!” another said, sounding disappointed. They all then returned their attention back to Thorin.

“It appears that not only are you a dishonourable and weak king but you are also a miserly one.” The leader said “is parting with gold really so difficult for you that you still dress like a beggar?”

The eye was thrown down and shattered into many pieces. Thorin flinched at the proximity but he remained resolute “You may mistreat me as you wish but my answer will remain the same.” He announced and somehow his voice still sounded confident and assured despite the scratchiness from screaming.

“Well then. We’d best continue.” The leader said. They motioned one of their other followers over. handed him a tiny, slim blade and said the words that any dwarf dreaded “The punishment for murder is usually execution but a quick death is too kind for one who has killed an innocent child. There can only be one sentence: shave him.” There were several gasps around the room. To shave any dwarf was the ultimate dishonour and if done in a court of law symbolised the exile of that dwarf, but for a King… It had never happened before but he would likely have to abdicate – even if he was allowed to rule he would have to make himself scarce until his hair grew back and it would probably forever remain a stain upon his name.

He wasn’t going to sign their contract though. Thorin was unsure about the exact legalities that would surround him renouncing Fili and Kili’s claims to the throne so he didn’t want to chance that he would be signing away their birth right just because someone threatened him.

The dwarf that had been given the blade approached and pushed Thorin’s head down firmly. The knife was placed at the back of his neck and he dared not struggle as if it so much as twitched it would cut through either his hair or his spine.

“This is your last chance to stop this.” The leader told him.

Thorin tried to reach for words that would properly convey his contempt and hide his fear. They would not come, chased away by the awful pain in his shoulders and his terror at what was to come.

The knife began to move, Thorin could almost feel the loss of every strand. He resigned himself to his fate. Whatever came after, his heirs would serve Erebor well!

There was a commotion suddenly. Thorin couldn’t turn to look so he strained his ears trying to figure out what was happening. There were shouts of surprise, pain and anger in equal measure accompanied by the clash of metal against metal and the noise of a sharp blade slicing through flesh. A spray of liquid splatters Thorin and the knife is gone from the back of his head. Finally he can look and sees that his kidnappers are fighting a newcomer. Most have already fallen, probably dead judging by the shocking volume of spilled blood covering the floor. The newcomer mercilessly dispatches of the last of Thorin’s captors with a knife to the throat and approaches him.

They wear a hood that obscures much of their face but when they bend down to pick at the locks on Thorin’s shackles he sees the scandalously short reddish-brown beard on his rescuer’s chin and knows it is Nori. His right arm is freed and while Nori moves to pick the other lock Thorin gingerly reaches up to examine how much hair he has lost. There is a small bald patch at the base of his skull but overall he has been very lucky – it will be easy to hide until it has grown back, unlike the rest of what has been inflicted upon him. He has to move his arm back down to the floor when the pull on his back becomes too much.

Nori frees his other hand and helps him sit up. Thorin is hard pressed to remember exactly when the last time he saw Nori was. He had only visited him a couple times when he was recovering in the infirmary as Nori had been unable to deal with crowds and his brothers were by his side almost constantly. Then one day he had just disappeared and the only reasons anyone had known that Nori was still in the mountain were the regular disappearance of food from the kitchens and the occasional sighting of a cloaked figure that walked as quietly as a hobbit.

Physically Nori appears to be fine, maybe still a little thin from all the missed meals on the quest but his body has healed well from what Thorin can see. However, the glint in his eye is a little too feral for Thorin’s liking and when his hood is pushed back his hair is still in a sorry state: barely an inch long and Thorin tries his hardest not to stare. If Nori had been just a few minutes later he would have undergone part of the same ordeal.

Nori tugs Thorin to his feet gently and leads him away from the carnage. It must be the early hours of the morning now as the corridors are still empty and dark but Nori leads him through the gloom confidently to what initially appears to be a small cupboard full of supplies to make the torches that line the corridors. Well that was what the cupboard was but it also happened to have a false back wall that leads into a larger room behind. Nori lights a lantern and guides Thorin to sit on a low stool. This must be where he has hiding all this time – there is a pile of bedding in the corner, a respectably sized store of non-perishable foods and stacks and stacks of papers and odds and ends that Thorin doesn’t investigate any further. Nori fetches a basin of water and a bag full of bandages and ointments that had clearly been liberated from Oin.

Nori kneels on the floor behind Thorin and carefully washes his back. The feeling of cloth on the gashes is agony but Thorin can tell that Nori is trying to make this as painless as possible. He is filled with an uncomfortable amount of gratitude – he wants to thank Nori for saving him but there are no words to express the depth of what he feels. Not for the first time in his life Thorin wishes he was better at expressing his emotions. How was it that he would prefer to negotiate a trade deal – and likely do a better job of it too – than tell those important to him how much he appreciated them?

Thorin watched as Nori ran a needle through the lantern flame before threading it and moving back out of Thorin’s field of view to stitch closed the cuts closed. Thorin sat stoically still as the first few incisions were stitched, then his curiosity grew too much and he asked:

“What did they write on my back?”

Nori’s hand twitched and Thorin grit his teeth when the needle pulled painfully at his lacerated skin. The moment stretched out almost uncomfortably long before Nori silently began to stitch again. It occurred to Thorin sometime later, when Nori was reaching about two thirds through that Nori hadn’t spoken a word since he had appeared. It was odd now that he thought about it: Nori was capable of being very quiet, but he also enjoyed boasting and teasing and had a sly sense of humour that he could and would use to run rings around most of the other dwarves in the company. Thorin had heard tales in the past of people who had undergone great suffering just ceasing to talk, at all. Sometimes they would remain silent forever, sometimes (rarely) they would regain their voices but he didn’t fancy Nori’s chances if that was what had happened here. Thorin was just trying to scrape together the words for an apology when Nori finally finished his work and tied off and cut the thread. Thorin relaxed somewhat now the most painful part was over.

“Uslukhul” his voice was quiet and rough from silence and Thorin was so surprised that he spoke at all that what Nori had actually said went unheard.

“What?”

“That’s what they wrote. On your back.” Nori spoke slowly, as if Thorin were made of eggshells and not stone. Thorin was so overwhelmingly relieved to hear his voice again that it took him a moment to realise his question had been answered.

The joy from hearing Nori speak dropped away as if it had never been. They had chosen their insults well – very few words could have gotten under his skin better! Ever since Smaug had invaded Erebor in his youth, Thorin had endured many insults in this vein towards both himself and his family. To call a dwarf dragon-like was itself not a grave insult (and if the context was the battlefield it could even be a complement) but it was an insensitive thing to say to a dwarf who had lost everything to a dragon. And an even graver insult when there was some truth behind it. Thorin had grown up with his family’s dragon-like natures thrown in his face by his enemies and detractors at every opportunity and there had been nothing he could say to protest because they had been right. If his Grandfather had kept his hoarding and lust for gold under control then Smaug would never have come! Thorin clenched his fists until his right hand began to ache but he didn’t stop. When Thror had still been alive Thorin had lived in fear of him and the madness that had only persisted after they had left Erebor. He realised that although he had shaken off the madness in the end, he had been worse while in its thrall than Thror ever had been. Thror had threatened and raged but he had never actually tried to murder his family! Thorin had spent decades assuring people that he wasn’t his grandfather, but he was worse.

“Thorin.” Nori was now in front of him, looking concerned. He must have been trying to get his attention for a while as Thorin’s chest is now bandaged and he doesn’t remember that happening at all.

“Thorin, calm down!” Nori must be able to see some of the turmoil Thorin is experiencing judging by the distress on his face. He is crouched directly in Thorin’s line of sight but is careful to stay out of easy touching distance, something that Thorin appreciates greatly right now. If anyone understands how he feels presently it would be Nori. He stares into Thorin’s eyes with a look of understanding that Thorin has never from him seen before. “Don’t let what happened today to eat at you, those monsters are dead and you survived and that is all that matters.” Nori’s fingers gripped tightly at his trousers and Thorin notices that a couple fingers have healed slightly crooked.

“But they were right.” He protests.

“About what? You are the one that decided that we would reclaim Erebor and you saw that goal through. Yes, our journey was difficult and if we had stayed things would have been different but we were dying a slow death in Ered Luin anyway. The blue mountains were never meant to support so many dwarves and at some point the mine owners would have discovered that you were working for them and you would have lost any of the remaining sway you held as the leader of Durin’s Folk.”

Thorin is taken aback that Nori had known about ‘Borin’ and had never tried to hold it over him – not even when he had threatened to cut off his hands! He almost reacts aggressively to the reveal of his secret but Nori almost looks almost passionate? in his certainty over Thorin’s worth. It is a surprise that he would gain Nori’s loyalty, especially given the manner he had convinced him to join the company. He admitted he may have been a little cruel, having Balin lay an elaborate trap and then when Nori was caught by it demanding he sign on or face the traditional punishment for thievery. Arrangements such as this didn’t exactly lead to pleasant relations – he had won the displeasure of all three sons of Kori, but it had also increased the size of the company by three and as the months passed and the company had become closer any bad feelings had first softened in the face of adversity before fading to just a whisper and by the time they had reached Laketown such grievances were in the past.

“But I’ve made so many mistakes” Thorin sounds wretched even to his own ears.

“Well then all you can do is learn from them.” Nori doesn’t speak unkindly but his tone is brisk as he allows himself to fall back into his more usual manner “I’m going to go get Dwalin now and deal with any loose ends. Please stay here Thorin.”

He nods reluctantly and Nori disappears silently out of the hidden door.

Thorin sits in the small room for an unknowable period of time. His thoughts are a dark maelstrom that threatens to drag him in and he soon realises that sitting quietly isn’t going to help him. He finds the basin of water and cleans the wounds on his wrists before wrapping them in more bandages from Nori’s stash. He remembers taking a blow to the head during the struggle in the training room but when he feels with his hands there is only a slight bump and he doesn’t feel any of the symptoms of a concussion. He still has no shirt and doubts anything Nori has would fit him so he wraps himself in a blanket to stave off the chill and hide the state of his torso. The bruises have coloured nicely now, a mosaic of colours that he knows is only going to get worse over the next couple of days.

He doesn’t have much longer to wait he thinks before he hears the cupboard door open and Nori enters with Dwalin trailing after him. Nori has blood smeared on his hands that he didn’t when he left but he appears uninjured so Thorin decides not to ask.

“Thorin!” before he can protest, Dwalin is hugging him roughly. He fixes his face in what he hopes is a neutral expression to hide the pain the action brings him.

“Are you well enough to move?” Dwalin asks with no small amount of concern “If there is some kind of plot against you we should move to somewhere more heavily guarded.” He nods sharply, though when he moves to get up off the low stool he finds his bruises have developed sufficiently that he is already stiff. Dwalin catches hold of his upper arms as he staggers and smoothly pulls him to his feet before pushing aside the blanket to check his injuries.

Dwalin frowns as he takes in the bandages and the bruising “You idiot. This is the last time you wander on your own at night.” He turns to Nori “Should I be fetching Oin?”

Nori shakes his head and steps off to the side to fetch a cloak that he drops over Thorin’s shoulders.

“We should go” he says shortly before exiting the room. Thorin and Dwalin follow and they creep down the still empty corridors to the Royal Wing. As they get closer there are noticeably more guards than usual and soon Nori has disappeared as if he was never there. Dwalin escorts him to his room, where Fili and Kili are already gathered. They are both barefoot and still in their sleep clothes and very worried.

“Uncle!” Kili bounds over to his side and flutters around anxiously. Fili hovers uncertainly as well but he is a little more stoic and does so at a greater distance. His heart aches at causing his sister-sons to worry but he is relieved that it appears that the attack had only been against him.

Dwalin herds him into bed and fusses uncharacteristically which Thorin allows because he is bone tried. In the end Dwalin is satisfied he isn’t going to drop dead in the night and refrains from fetching Oin and leaves to stand guard outside and stew angrily.

“What happened?” Kili asks with youthful insensitivity “Dwalin wouldn’t explain, he just said we should stay with you tonight.” He sits on the edge of Thorin’s bed with a heavy thump that jostles Thorin unpleasantly but he doesn’t complain.

Thorin shifted on the bed, he was discovering there was no comfortable position to lie in his condition. He considers playing down what happened but his sister-sons are grown dwarves now and do not warrant any coddling and they will be worried about him whether he explains himself or not. Although he is certainly not going to give them a blow-by-blow account! “I was attacked by a group of dwarves from the Iron hills. They wished for me to abdicate and change the line of succession so that the crown would go straight to Dain.”

Kili frowned and looked upset and Thorin was glad he had left out all mention of the… torture that had been inflicted upon him. It wouldn’t do to tell him just how close it had come to Fili being King under the mountain – whether by Thorin’s shaming or death. Fili took the news much better, his eyes narrowed as he considered the situation carefully.

“Would that even have worked if you had agreed, Uncle?” Thorin attempted to shrug but aborted the motion halfway through when it pulled on his stitches. “Do you think Dain himself is involved in the attack?!”

He stifled a yawn before answering “I don’t have any reason to. They appeared to be acting independently but it remains to be seen if there is some sort of larger plot. Nori dealt with all of them but I’ll be expecting you both to be careful from now on.”

They looked surprised at the mention of Nori but Fili nodded solemnly and promised he would take care and Kili promised the same, although slightly grudgingly. Satisfied with their responses and that they were all safe Thorin finally allowed himself to fall into an exhausted sleep.


December TA 2941

Thorin woke slowly, a rarity that should have made him wary but he felt so secure in his warm nest of blankets that he felt no desire to move or think about anything particularly hard so instead he dowsed contentedly. He felt a fuzzy kind of disorientation – the kind caused by sleeping too long and left him uncertain of where exactly he was – but it was pleasant enough so he didn’t question it. There was an ache in his back but he supposed he was just getting old. He snuggled further into the blanket and suddenly every muscle was lit on fire, starting at his back and stomach and spreading outwards like the inexorable march of a conquering army.

He was no longer feeling comfortable at all but had no plans of moving again as he had no desire to discover the agony that sitting up would induce if he had any choice.

He eventually chanced opening his eyes and discovered that he was in his bed in Erebor. Fili was curled up at his side, still asleep and another dwarf – most likely Kili – was lying at the foot of the bed. He hurt so awfully because of those traitors. They had had the audacity to kidnap him in his own realm and carve him up like fresh meat.

To try and shave him as if he was the criminal…

“How are you feeling?” a voice asked, interrupting his thoughts. Thorin startled and then swallowed a curse when he discovered just how interconnected his neck and shoulder muscles were. Balin looked at him concernedly while he regained his composure “Should I be fetching Oin?” he asked.

Thorin scoffed “No, I will be fine, Balin. I am merely stiff.”

He sat up slowly in an effort to minimise both the pain and his chance of accidentally waking his sister-sons. When he was finally upright he was breathing hard and sweating but when Balin moved to help him he motioned him to remain where he was.

Thorin settled gingerly against the headboard “What time is it? Have I missed anything important?”

“It’s only late morning, don’t worry.” Balin reassured him “I’ve taken the liberty to cancel as many of your meetings and other duties today as I could.”

He almost sighed in relief but then he remembered “Wait, today is…” it took him a moment to remember what day it was and another moment to think about what was planned “What about the western sapphire mine reopening? That’s been planned for months and I can’t not show up for no good reason when work is supposed to start tomorrow!”

“Thorin, you aren’t in any condition to be walking round Erebor for hours and especially not when there could be more dwarves out to hurt you!”

“I am nowhere near injured enough to be treated as if I am made of glass!” He threw the covers aside and angrily threw himself out of bed. Standing up so carelessly was agony but he managed to stand steadily after an initial stumble and faced Balin resolutely, hoping he couldn’t see how much pain this caused him.

“Balin, please fetch me my robes.” He ordered.

“Thorin!” Balin started but he cut him off impatiently.

“This is an important public event, Balin.” He said sternly “I am perfectly aware of the risks but I cannot afford to not go.”

There was a grumble from the direction of the bed and a bedraggled Kili appeared from under the blankets with a yawn. “What’s going on?” he asked warily.

“It’s the day of the mine reopening. Wake up your brother and go get changed.”

Kili’s expression turned to sheepish panic and he near dragged his still half-asleep brother from the room. The door swung shut with a slam and once again the atmosphere in the room became tense.

Balin sighed and looked mildly upset but he acquiesced “Very well.”

He brought Thorin’s best clothes from where they had been left lying over the back of a chair the previous evening. It took embarrassingly long for Thorin to get dressed. His clothes weren’t tight fitting by any means but the range of motion in his arms and shoulders was limited and he was too stiff to bend over. Balin had to help him for the whole process but he endured the discomfort and the shame that accompanied every reminder of his injuries and how he had gotten them. The inclusion of Thorin’s heavy wolf’s fur coat was a point of brief contention but Thorin won that point too as it really was the most impressive part of the outfit.

Finally Balin stepped back from tying a wide dark blue ribbon over his empty eye-socket and Thorin was ready. There was a great silvered mirror that Thorin hadn’t yet gotten around to moving elsewhere and when he examined his reflection he was relieved to see that while he was pale and his face was mildly scratched he looked much healthier than he felt.

There was only a little time left before the ceremony so they left Thorin’s room and were joined by only Kili. He was dressed unusually smartly, though still scruffy if Thorin held him up to the standards that were expected of him at that age. Balin fussed with the way the layers of his clothes lay until they sat straight.

“Fili isn’t feeling great so he went back to bed.” Kili said a little disappointedly and they left the royal wing together.

The walk to the mine entrance felt far longer than usual and Thorin soon became acutely aware of the weight of the fur coat across his back. He grudgingly admitted to himself that Balin may have been right but there was already enough of a crowd that to remove it would be strange.

Almost the whole mountain’s populace was present, only a fraction of the number Erebor could take but still a lot of dwarves. They made a solemn crowd, watching him untrustingly despite the happy occasion they had gathered for.

The ceremony was not long – at least not by dwarven standards – though events regarding the main source of dwarven income were taken seriously. Thorin had a speech, which luckily he had written some weeks in advance so he already knew exactly what to say regardless of his late night exploits. Kili stood at his left shoulder throughout, the space where Fili was supposed to stand at his right left conspicuously empty.

Then there was the singing, the choir specially chosen to have voices that would reverberate well down the mineshaft. It sounds perfect, Thorin hasn’t heard such a satisfying – and loud – minesong since he was a child and he is filled with renewed hope. The deep resonance of so many voices reflecting off good strong stone not only raises his spirits and the remainder of the ceremony is a much more joyful affair.

He gives the new mine supervisor the finely wrought golden pickaxe with sapphires inlaid in the head that symbolised the position. Thorin has avoided looking at it as much as possible – not that it bothers him, he just wants to be cautious – so he wouldn’t be able to describe it further than that but Balin had made sure it was the right one for the mine.

The lass was not the most… traditional of choices for the role but Bofur, as Thorin’s advisor on all mining matters, had recommended her and Thorin had respected that. Some of the council didn’t like it overmuch but he was sure once the mine was running their disapproval would mostly dry up.

The new supervisor’s speech was given solemnly but with great determination and then the ceremony was over. Thorin leads the way to the great hall where there is a ‘feast’ laid out (feast being a relative term as they do not have the supplies for anything so fancy). He lowered himself into his chair and attempted to look as if he were halfway aware of the conversations around him. His entire back throbbed and he was queasy with hunger but he ignored the protests from his body and forced himself to slowly eat a bread roll so that his stomach would settle. Balin gave him a couple of concerned looks but allowed himself to be occupied in conversation in Thorin’s stead.

Thorin waited a couple hours before leaving so his departure couldn’t be interpreted as rudeness or some kind of slight. Kili thankfully anticipated that he would need help and quietly offered his arm so that he could get up. They left together, Kili wanting to check on his brother. His dedication to his sibling made the over a century old hurt of losing Frerin briefly sting but funnily enough it no longer bothered him as much as the more recent hurts he had amassed over the last year.

When they reached the royal wing, Thorin bade him goodnight before collapsing into his bed and instantly falling into an exhausted sleep.


December TA 2941

“I’m afraid I must attend to an urgent matter!” Thorin tries to hide his urgency as he abruptly stands – his chair skidding across the tiled floor – and leaves the council chambers quicker than is maybe polite. The gaudy gold necklace that the head of the Goldsmiths Guild was wearing gleams mockingly in his peripheral vision, the many cut precious stones and metals that adorn the other dwarves present glittering in concert like some kind of awful constellation of greed.

He can feel the contents of his stomach churning uncomfortably but it does not stop him from sprinting away from the council chambers once he is out of sight of the doors.

He thought he was clear of the sickness! It seemed he was still a fool.

He has been running blindly but when he has to slow he finds himself near the (now not so) secret entrance which has recently been restored. Thorin knows that after making such a dramatic departure at least Balin, and possibly other members of his company will be looking for him. He can’t go to the battlements which is where he normally goes when he is troubled but he wants to feel the outside air and it will probably take the others a while to think of the secret door. He changes course and heads for the door. He hasn’t been here since the battle but it looks much as he remembered. There are lit torches at the entrance to the tunnel and the carvings on the walls have been cleaned so he can read the Khuzdul easily. He doesn’t linger in the tunnel long, only pausing to find the key that he still keeps round his neck. There are other copies now, distributed so that they are available in case of another crisis, but he has kept the original as a memento of his father.

The key turns smoothly in the lock and the door swings open smoothly, despite being made of a tonne of solid rock. Outside the mountain it is pouring with rain but Thorin is unbothered. He strides out, making sure to prop the door open behind him as it still only opens from the outside on Durin’s day, and tips his head back to look up at the heavy grey clouds and feel the icy water pour down his face.

He feels better for being outside but still shaken. He had been close, so horrifyingly close, to turning upon an innocent dwarf just because he wore too much finery. Even the mere memory of the necklace the Guild master had been wearing was enough to summon a slithery, covetous haze that squeezes at his heart. Jealousy gripped him such that his breath was short and quick. A tremble ran through his limbs as he was overcome with rage that others could own and flaunt such riches. He was King. He was the one that had claimed back their glorious homeland while they were quaking in their homes so how dare they try to outshine him!

Yes! All of the gold is yours! Those pretenders don’t deserve an OUNCE. Take it back. Seize it. KILL THEM!

Thorin was startled by the jolt of his knees folding beneath him. The voice that he had last heard in the depths of gold sickness was gone once more. It was just him slumped in the rain, cold sinking into his bones.

The madness was not vanquished as he had hoped.

Thorin fell back to sit on the wet stone and lichen, he couldn’t continue as King like this. Thorin had known for a long time that he no longer wished to rule. Leading Durin’s Folk in their exile had been a thankless task, especially once it had fallen to him, but save from some minor hiccups at the start of his rule he had never faltered. Sometime between the easing of his madness and Bilbo’s departure from the mountain he had realised that he no longer desired the throne. He no longer felt worthy of the responsibility, a hollow shell of the dwarf he had been, but he had recognised that he was the best King available to Erebor right now. If he was to abdicate now Fili would be King and even if his sister-son hadn’t been recovering from such serious injuries he wouldn’t have dreamed of doing that to him. Fili was barely out of childhood, and while Kili was currently more physically able he had not been raised to the role the way Fili had been. To crown either of them as they were now would be to invite disaster. Dain would be next in line after the boys and he had made it clear to Thorin after the battle that he was perfectly happy with what he had. Dis being a women excluded her from the line of succession, quite unfairly in Thorin’s opinion as she had always had a head for leadership and was less hot tempered than the others in his family. He may believe himself to be an unworthy, honourless creature no better than a goblin but Thorin owed it to his company to see through what he’d started.

Now though, he would have to reconsider that assessment. If it was possible for relapses to happen then he would have to either step down or place someone in charge of assessing his mental state. It was a humiliating prospect but he had already realised abdication was not currently an option. It would have to be someone he could trust to not misuse that power and knew him well enough to notice any changes. Balin would be the obvious choice but he was unsure if even Balin would always notice in time if he continued to relapse. Thorin felt shame join the well of unbearable emotions that sat heavily inside him.

He is shivering violently now, hands painfully numb as the rain has changed to sleet. Thorin is only dressed in his council robes which, while somewhat fancier than his normal attire, are also less warm and doesn’t include his fur coat. He staggers to back to the door on frozen feet only to find that he had not propped the door open well enough and it has swung closed. He is trapped outside! The only other way into the mountain is the main entrance far below on the other side of the mountain. As tired and cold as Thorin is he stands no chance of making the steep climb down the mountain. He would almost certainly fall to his death, not that the hypothermia that awaits him if he stays here is much better. He looks up at the clouds and sees not only that the sleet shows no sign of stopping but also that dusk is rapidly approaching. He swears quietly, but with great feeling. It appears that any choices have been taken out of his hands by his own foolishness. Fili will be king tomorrow after all.

Thorin sits himself in the most sheltered corner he can find and awaits his end (or rescue!) with as much dignity as he can muster. He wonders what the others will think when they can’t find him. Dwalin will likely tear through the mountain under the assumption he has been kidnapped again. His teeth begin to chatter and he almost (almost) wishes that he had been kidnapped again rather than a victim of his own poor decisions.

When he hears the rumbling of the door opening he is half convinced it is only his over-cold mind playing tricks but then he hears footsteps and grudgingly unburies his face from where he had been shielding it against his knees. His visitor is cloaked but once again it is unmistakably Nori. The main giveaway is the shade of purple of his hood and the ends of a scarf that flap around him and was undoubtably made by Ori, a shade that all the sons of Kori seem to favour.

“Come on” Nori, gestures towards the door with a careless hand and supports Thorin as he tries to force his icy joints to move. The air inside the mountain feels blessedly warm and it is only when he starts shivering that he realises that he had stopped at all.

Nori closes and locks the door with his own copy of the key, though where he had obtained it Thorin does not question. Once the door is closed Nori pushes back his hood and unwraps the scarf from around his face. He then takes two steps closer and decks Thorin in the face. Thorin rocks back a little unsteadily but remains on his feet. The punch hadn’t been intended to knock him down.

“What are you thinking, Thorin?” Nori hisses viciously “Between those plotting against you and your own carelessness you’re going you’ll wind up dead within the month! Is this what you want?!”

Thorin is stunned by the cold and the unexpected blow to the face and doesn’t reply immediately which Nori seems to take for reticence. Nori snarls and grabs his collar roughly “Is it? Because if it is then I can save everyone a lot of bother right now” A knife appears in his hand with a flourish.

“That will not be necessary.” Thorin pushes the hand holding the knife away with a frown “Thank you for aiding me again, Nori. I will endeavour to be more careful in future.”

“You’d better.” Nori releases Thorin and returns the knife to wherever it had come. “You know” he says slyly, his fury gone as quickly as it had appeared “You could make everyone’s life easier in situations like this and appoint a spymaster.”

“And how do you know I haven’t already?” Thorin asked, an eyebrow raised.

Nori’s smile widens “Ha! That’s a good one!” he laughs “Both of us know there isn’t a dwarf in this mountain or outside it that could do the job better.”

Thorin sighs to hide any trace of the smile that is threatening to break through “And as I suspected you’ve already appointed yourself!”

Notes:

Next chapter: Dis returns to Erebor. Not sure when this'll be done as I have an unfinished section in the next chapter (writing conflict is hard!) and the chapter after that is barely written because it's giving me A LOT of problems but I shall do my best! :))

Hope everyone enjoyed and see yous all when I next reemerge from my burrow!