Actions

Work Header

A Wizard is Never Late

Summary:

Gandalf arrives late to the ‘negotiations’ between Thorin, Thranduil and Bard at the gates of Erebor. Events take a different course and Thorin must face the consequences of his actions for the rest of his life (however long or short that may be).
Probably going to be Thorin/Bilbo – I have never written about romantic relationships but Thorin is very obviously smitten (need I say more than Mithril shirt?) and film Thorin is maybe even more so.
This story will take it’s pick of aspects from the book, the films and fanon because I don’t remember enough details from the book (it’s been about a decade since I’ve read it!) but I am not a big fan of certain decisions made in the films.

Notes:

Heyo! I've been working for this fic since February this year and I finally feel like I can start posting it. I've written most of it but expect irregular updates as the remainder is all the tricky parts!
(I am aware that Gandalf doesn't canonically make any tardy wizard comments until LoTR but I imagine it is the kind of thing he says ALL THE TIME and everyone is sick of hearing!

Most of this chapter is based of of the ramparts scene from battle of the five armies and you do not want to know how much time I have spent watching it, analysing microexpressions. I don't like that film on the whole but kudos to Richard Armitage for his performance as Thorin!

Warnings in the end notes.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Sickness

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

October TA 2941

The sight of the Arkenstone clasped in Bard’s grubby, soot-stained hand takes Thorin’s breath away. His first thought is wonder, for it is just as beautiful – no! Even more so than he remembered! All other jewels pale in comparison to the rainbows that scatter and bend in its mesmerising depths. It has been so long since he had witnessed beauty such as this, even the endless gems and gold of Erebor that had been so captivating not even an hour ago were now but a paltry imitation. Its radiance muddles his thoughts a little but Thorin realises then that everything he has done to get here, to be able to catch even a glimpse of his grandfather’s beloved treasure has been worth it and more.

His second thought is heady relief that it has finally been found for a part of him had been beginning to wonder if Smaug had swallowed it and taken it to his lakebed grave.

His third is to ponder how it came to be in Bard the Bowman’s possession. It is then that the blissful fuzziness morphs to alarm that this wonder, this dazzling stone with no equal, this… this gift from Mahal himself has somehow been removed from the mountain. It is inconceivable! There is no way that Smaug would have let the best item in his hoard go and since the foul beast’s death his company has been barricaded inside with no outsiders entering. If this had happened a day ago, before Bilbo had sweetly shown him his acorn from Beorn’s garden, then Thorin would have instantly accused one of his company of betraying him. Probably Nori. While Bilbo was the company’s official burglar, Nori was the one that he had truly suspected. He was infamous for not only his skill in his chosen profession but also the greyness of his morals and a magpie-like attraction to shiny things (even for a dwarf!).

But his encounter with Bilbo, who had been second on his list of suspects, had made him reconsider. There had been no evidence that it had been stolen and besides they had only scratched the surface of Erebor’s hoard of gold.

Thorin was reconsidering this now that he has been seemingly presented with the Arkenstone in enemy hands. He shied away from the thought, surely there must be some kind of other explanation? He thought of Gandalf’s conspicuous and continued absence and realised it must all be some kind of elaborate illusion! There was no other explanation.

“They are taking us for fools!” he proclaimed to the company.

“This is a ruse, A filthy lie!” he turned to look to Balin, hoping his most trusted advisor would agree but he only looked confused. Thorin had no time for hesitation and turned back to the army gathered outside the gates to Erebor.

“The Arkenstone is in this mountain! It is a trick-” he was just beginning to gather steam to tell Thanduil exactly what he thought of this base deception when he was interrupted.

“It is no trick” For a second Thorin couldn’t place who had spoken, only that it was one of his company but then he heard the distinctive near silent footfalls that could only be Bilbo’s as he came forward. He couldn’t bear to look at the halfling. He begged that he was hearing Bilbo wrong, that what he suspected wasn’t going to come to pass but his heart felt like it was freezing in his chest.

Any lingering uncertainty about what Bilbo had done was torn away when the traitorous halfling said “The stone is real. I gave it to them.”

And there it was. The Halfling had confessed to his treachery and all Thorin felt was disappointment. He was sure the rest would come soon, once the shock wore off but now all he felt was regret that he had yet again trusted the wrong people. Who would have thought innocent, innocuous Bilbo Baggins of the blasted Shire with his fussiness and manners would be the one to sell him out. Thorin had only suspected him before because he was an outsider, he hadn’t earnestly believed Bilbo could be capable of this. He turned to look at his burglar… or should he call him Thranduil’s burglar now?

“You…” That is all he can make himself say.

How pathetic, has the burglar also stolen your tongue, Thorin Oakenshield?

Bilbo is unapologetic, utterly unrepentant as he stands his ground. “I took it as my fourteenth share”

This display finally summons the anger Thorin had been expecting. It isn’t much yet but his temper has always been a fearsome thing once it has had time to build. “You would steal from me.” It is not a question but a vocalisation of his slow realisation of what Bilbo has done.

“Steal from you?” The burglar has the nerve to joke! Bilbo looks like him as if he has just said something funny and he is expecting Thorin to laugh with him. Bilbo continues to speak and every word makes Thorin angrier “No. No. I may be a burglar but I like to think I am an honest one.”

He pauses, beginning to look uncomfortable in the face of Thorin’s stony silence “I’m willing to let it stand against my claim.”

And Thorin cannot take it anymore “Against your claim?” the words burst out of him incredulously. Bilbo is speaking as if they have only had a minor quarrel! Does this betrayal mean nothing to him? Did he pause to consider at all before he aided Thranduil? For that matter, for just how long have they been working together? The company had been imprisoned in the sorry excuse for a King’s halls for a long time – or maybe Bilbo had never been on Thorin’s side: his kind had a disturbing fondness for elves and he had been recruited by Gandalf.

“Your claim.” His words are dripping with derision “You have no claim over me you miserable little rat!”

He threw down the bow that he had aimed at Thranduil only a couple minutes before and advanced on the treacherous halfling. Bilbo quickly took a step back, his expression growing alarmed.

When Bilbo spoke now he sounded scared. His voice broke a little and for a second Thorin was ashamed at himself for bullying the little creature before him, but then he remembered that his displeasure was more than earned and his discomfort turned to fury “I was going to give it to you. Many times I wanted to but…”

“But what thief?” he asked slowly, straining for control of his temper – though why he should do so escapes him.

The fear on the halfling’s face receded and Bilbo’s expression hardened as his posture straightened “You are changed, Thorin.” His tone is stern and accusing, so unlike the mild-mannered creature he was familiar with.

“The dwarf I met in Bag End would never have gone back on his word!” Bilbo raises his voice and takes half a step forwards. All trace of fear is gone now and at this latest insult to his honour Thorin is finished. No one gets to speak to him like this, least of all this mere spoiled rodent!

“Would never have doubted the loyalty of his kin!” Bilbo looks like he could quite happily go on insulting him but Thorin is unwilling to let himself be called disloyal by a traitor!

A traitor. That was what Bilbo Baggins was now. It hadn’t fully sunk in until now but the revelation was another wound to his already crippled stone heart. Bilbo had betrayed him and now dared to mention loyalty!

“Do not speak to me of loyalty.” His words emerged quietly but with force and he could feel a prickle of tears forming. Tears! He hadn’t cried since the death of his mother when he was still a dwarfling!

Thorin hated Bilbo for doing this to him, making him feel this way. He took several gasping breaths and stared at Bilbo’s wan face. He was looking down, refusing to meet Thorin’s gaze since receiving his condemnation and Thorin can’t see enough of his expression to tell what he is feeling. Thorin hopes he is ashamed and curses the part of him that is concerned for his burglar. It isn’t just Bilbo that disgusts him right now – his own sentimentality for the halfling is sickening! No one should be able to have such an effect on him!

It was weakness!

He needed the halfling gone!

“Throw him from the rampart!” he yells the order and Bilbo looks up at him, shocked beyond words. His company don’t move, just stare back at him as if he has ordered their own executions and not that of the traitor. He turns to look at them all but they are frozen in place, looking more like statues rather than dwarves, save Ori who is trembling like a leaf and clutching the spear he has taken from the treasury spear tightly.

“Do you not hear me!?” He cries but still no one moves. His gaze alights upon Fili, who is studiously avoiding looking at him. His heir should be jumping to carry out his orders, in fact Thorin cannot think of any previous occurrence of this strange reticence. His patience is short and in an instant he has grabbed Fili’s forearm. Fili will carry out his orders, he only needs a little encouragement!

To Thorin’s shock Balin grabs onto Fili as well and pulls him away from Thorin but this show of rebellion only makes Thorin angrier and he yanks on his heir’s arm. Fili looks terrified. His sister-son violently pulls free of his grip and stumbles over to Balin.

Thorin stares a moment longer. This was absurd, why won’t they obey him?

He turned back to the traitor. It was no matter of course, as the proverb went – no better pick than your own! He would deal with Bilbo now and then turn his attentions to his company’s squeamishness.

“I will do it myself!” Thorin was in front of the halfling in two steps and he grabbed him harshly by the lapels of his coat. The company immediately erupts into chaos, every member voicing their protest but most hanging back, unsure whether to intervene and Thorin hauls Bilbo towards the battlements.

“No!” someone – possibly Fili? – cries and tries to pull him away from the edge but he shrugs them off easily. With a heave and a roar of “Curse you!” he lifts Bilbo half up onto the battlement wall. The halfling remains oddly still in his grasp, hands hovering close to where his clothing is bunched in Thorin’s grip but not trying to free himself. He is hyperventilating and all Thorin feels is irritation that Bilbo could cower like a rabbit when ultimately he had brought this upon himself.

He hoists Bilbo further over the edge, ignoring the desperate cries from behind him. Dwalin tries to take the halfling from him and Thorin elbows him in the ribs, he has no time for their foolish protests. Bilbo is still staring up at him, his grey eyes wider than Thorin has ever seen before. In the past months he has seen Bilbo in all sorts of perilous and potentially traumatising situations and maybe it stings a little to know that of all that he is the worst. The halfling was a jumpy, anxious creature at the best of times but surely Thorin was not more terrifying than a giant spider or a dragon?

As he stared down at the Hobbit he realised that maybe he didn’t want to kill him after all – in his rage he hadn’t had a full explanation and surely there was some misguided reason for Bilbo’s treachery? Of course they would have to question the halfling at length and who knows what else he had told Thranduil! It was likely that he wouldn’t be done with the halfling for months and depending on what he said maybe execution wouldn’t be necessary? Of course some kind of punishment would be required but maybe he could just banish him or… Or what? Cut off his hands?! That was the usual punishment for serious thefts such as this, let alone the treason! He could argue that it technically wasn’t treason as Thorin had yet to have his coronation but who was he fooling, he didn’t want to hurt his burglar, let alone kill him. He had given a whole mithril mail shirt to him, of course he didn’t wish him harm! He might as well have given Bilbo a bunch of flowers and some soppy poetry like a lovesick elf and have done with it!!

But what about the gold? He has plotted against you with your enemies, he wants to force you to give it away!

Thorin shook his head against the insidious voice in his head but couldn’t think of anything to prove it wrong.

You know it’s the gold OR bilbo. Stop trying to deny it, Oakenshield!

He couldn’t. He screwed his eyes shut as if that would spare him from having to make a choice. He couldn’t possibly choose between them! He… He would decide later what to do with the thief, first he must deal with Thranduil and Bard.

He turns his focus back to the ramparts. Bilbo was still hyperventilating and Thorin was honestly surprised he hadn’t fainted yet. He takes a deep breath and begins to pull the burglar’s weight back inside. After months of the most meagre of diets and much strenuous exercise Bilbo is as light as most dwarflings but Thorin has been on the same diet and since Smaug’s death he has eaten very little. King’s don’t have time to eat it turns out, and even when there is time he has had little appetite: preferring to spend mealtimes scouring the halls for the Arkenstone. He has been thinking for longer than he initially realised and holding up most of the hobbit’s weight as he did so when he moves his arms they feel like they have been engulfed in flames. He grunts but manages to maintain his grip.

Bilbo looks utterly confused, torn between relief and expecting something worse and Thorin wants nothing more than to hug him – or punch him so maybe Bilbo’s trepidation isn’t unfounded. However, while Bilbo hangs over the edge he can do neither so he continues to pull him to safety.

He is close, so so close when his left hand cramps up. After that it is all over in an instant: his spasming hand releases its grip against his wishes and Bilbo’s full weight is being supported by his right. The worn fabric of Bilbo’s coat gives up at this final insult and with a loud ripping noise Bilbo is plummeting down. Bilbo shrieks and Thorin makes a grab for a trailing leg but his hand only closes around the halfling’s luxuriant, curling foot hair which does absolutely nothing to halt his fall.

Thorin shouts and tries to reach further but it is far too late for that and Dwalin and Fili haul him back from the edge.

He collapses to his knees and stares at the handful of Bilbo’s hair. It shines in the winter sunlight like strands of gold.

Thorin shakes himself in disgust. He has just killed someone, a friend even, and here he is admiring their hair because it looks like the treasure he has been obsessing over. And obsessing he has been: the golden haze that had tenderly wrapped around him since he entered the mountain was falling away and Thorin was suddenly disgusted with himself. For all he had promised to never be like his grandfather he had succumbed to gold sickness even easier! Thror had at least gradually become the greedy, cruel ruler that had attracted Smaug but all it had taken Thorin was one look at the hoard and he had been ensnared. How weak.

“What have I done?” he muttered to himself. The raven crown is weighing down on his head. It feels like he is being crushed under its weight and he cannot stand to wear it any longer. It has been worn by generations of Durin’s line, each greedier and madder than those before them. It has become naught but a symbol for the slow descent of his people! He pulls it off and with a shout flings it at the floor. The crown is made of obsidian and pure gold and is not meant to be treated harshly. The gold bends and dents while the obsidian shatters and Thorin feels a little freer.

The company is giving him a wide berth, many looking down at the ground below. Thorin was suddenly overcome with a morbid curiosity. It is unlikely Bilbo survived so far a drop but how did the fall kill him? It is only right that he face what he has just done. He totters to his feet and approaches the ramparts once more. Balin approaches him and gently tries to stop him.

“Step aside, Balin. I need to see.” He commands shakily.

He smiles sadly “I don’t think you do, laddie.” he shakes his head when Thorin continues toward his goal but doesn’t make any further attempts to stop him. Balin had always been able to identify a futile endeavour when he saw one.

Thorin looked down at the results of his actions and it was all he could do to stand his ground. It would be a disservice to Bilbo to look away from what his weaknesses had wrought, despite how it turned his stomach to see the red stains that stood out shockingly against the pale stone of the lonely mountain. It appeared that Bilbo had hit the highest point of the head of the statue Thorin had ordered collapsed to block off the entrance and then rolled down. He had come to rest at the end of the bloody trail, half submerged in the water and completely still save for his ragged breathing. Thorin wasn’t sure where he was bleeding from as he could see no obvious wounds, save for one of his arms which was grotesquely broken.

The elves had remained standing impassively but Bard leapt from the saddle and sprinted to the water without a second thought. Bilbo lived for now but only his head and the right side of his torso remained above the water and the hobbit was in no condition to swim. Bard plunged into the water with a loud splash and quickly swam to Bilbo’s side. He says something to Bilbo but Thorin is too far away to hear or read his lips and Bilbo weakly turns his head to look at him. Bilbo is awake! Thorin is thrilled and for a second he wonders if Hobbits simply bounce when dropped but then Bilbo is screaming and he knows that not to be the case. The heavy feeling of sickness in his stomach is suddenly more than Thorin can deal with and he bends over to vomit – though there is scarce little other than stomach acid that comes up.

“Thorin…” Balin is patting him on the back soothingly but it only makes Thorin feel worse “Maybe you should go rest, lad.”

“I am fine.” He hears himself grind out between clenched teeth “The sickness has departed and I must now make amends for the wrongs I have committed these past weeks!” he straightens and looks Balin in the eye sternly.

“Aye” is all Balin says, his voice a choked mixture of pride and sorrow, before he steps back next to his brother.

Sounds of some kind of commotion down below drew everyone’s attention. Thorin spotted a distinctive grey pointed hat approaching through the crowd at speed and grimaced. ‘A wizard is never late’ indeed! Bard has gathered Bilbo up in his arms and was slowly swimming back across the moat, careful to keep the hobbit’s face above the surface. Gandalf knelt by the water’s edge, arms held out to accept his burglar.

“I’m going down.” Thorin announces and the company scurries to find a way down. Bofur sheepishly produces a coil of rope that is already tied to a ring in the wall. He had known of Bilbo’s treachery! Thorin is angry for a second but then he remembers that Bilbo had only been acting in the interests of peace and instead accepts the rope neutrally.

Before he leaves Erebor he turns to his cousins “Dwalin, come with me. Balin, you’re in charge while I’m gone. Find what we owe the people of Laketown” he sighed heavily “…and Thranduil.”

Balin nodded gravely “Good luck Thorin.”

He nodded jerkily in return. He was going to need all the good fortune he could get having wronged a wizard. Gandalf could ruin him and his line if he so wished and even if the wizard didn’t act against him there was always Thranduil who already hated him and Bard was fond of Bilbo. Another scream echoes off the mountain and Thorin is very much inclined to believe he won’t be making it out of this alive.

With that in mind he approached his sister-sons. “Fili, Kili. In case I don’t return I want you both to know that I…” Thorin cursed his cowardice. Why was it so difficult to tell the boys that he valued them both? “I could not hope for better heirs.”

Fili nodded seriously, not expecting anything more personal from a lifetime of training for the throne but Kili was unused to such cold praise and looked lost. He kicked himself at the wording. They were both still so young and they deserved to receive the approval of their elders when they had done so well.

“I am proud of you both.” There that was slightly better, Kili smiled a little and Fili’s features softened marginally. Thorin gently knocked heads with both and then strode purposefully to the rope.

The journey down the wall was difficult as Thorin lacked the strength to hold up his weight by the arms and the second half of the descent was a barely controlled slide that left rope burn on his hands. Dwalin climbed down significantly more gracefully and they approached the gathering by the water’s edge.

As he and Dwalin arrived several elves were leaving, Bilbo carefully cradled in a litter between them. Thorin caught a glance of the hobbit as they departed, nothing more than a flash of pallid skin and bandages and he hoped once more that his faults wouldn’t lead to Bilbo’s death.

“What are you doing here, King under the Mountain?” Bard asked with uncharacteristic vitriol when he spotted them “Have you not done enough already or are you here to finish the job?”

Thorin wanted to snap back, maybe say something even worse and start a fight but Bard wasn’t the one here that was in the wrong. “I have come because I realised I have wronged you all. It is my actions that lead to the deaths of so many of your people, Lord Bard and then when you came to me for aid and to fulfil my promises I turned you away as if I fancied myself Smaug’s replacement. You have my most sincere apologies.” It went against his nature to apologise and Thorin was sure he did an awful job but it was undoubtedly the best apology he had ever given to date. When he had finished speaking he knelt in front of Bard and bowed his head in supplication, ignoring Dwalin’s shocked gasp. Thorin had never bowed to anyone in his life – none of his line had – and he felt horribly vulnerable.

“You had best value this sight, Bard” Thranduil’s oily voice made him flinch “You are not likely to see anything like it. Dwarves are too proud to bow to anyone, and their Kings are even worse!” Thorin wished to leap to his feet and tell Thranduil exactly what he thought but he held back. The one advantage of this position was that he didn’t have to see the elf King’s revolting face!

“Despite how poor relations between our kingdoms have been of late I would wish for peace between us. As we speak my company are gathering what you are owed. You will have your gold and you may keep the Arkenstone as a gesture of our good will towards the men of Dale.”

“Thank you…” Bard sounded somewhat confused and Thorin felt a hand on his shoulder “please get up, Thorin. I cannot forgive you for what you have done today but I have no intentions of holding that against your people.”

Thorin stood up quickly only to find himself eye level with the Arkenstone.

“Are you sure you don’t want it back?” Bard asked “I understand it is an artefact of great importance to your family?”

Take it! It is the most precious of Erebor’s treasures, it BELONGS in the mountain!

The stone was so much more beautiful up close. The colours were more vibrant and it seemed to glow brighter. Thorin could quite willingly lose himself staring into its depths for hours – no days!

Thorin watched his hand move towards the stone seemingly on its own before he regained his wits and staggered away from it with a cry. “I don’t care what you do with the blasted thing – give it away, chuck it in the lake for all I care but keep that cursed rock away from me! Please!”

Bard looked deeply disturbed but returned the stone to his pocket.

Thranduil laughed cruelly from the side “Gold sickness, of course! The line of Durin can’t seem to get over their obsessive love of metals and precious stones. Generation after generation you all make the same mistakes!”

Thorin ignored Thranduil’s insults and took a deep breath, this was going to be painful to say. “I would have peace with you also, Thranduil. Before I had experienced gold sickness myself I doubted your claim of Thror’s theft from you but now I understand. It is not just Dale’s riches that my company are searching for.”

He had kept his face carefully neutral throughout his speech. It was distasteful being polite to Thranduil but his people’s pride only seemed to make enemies. Of course, it was all worth it for Thranduil’s shocked expression! The elf king was utterly lost for words and opened and closed his mouth like a fish for the next five minutes. Dwalin’s shoulders were shaking with suppressed laughter.

All levity from seeing an immortal flabbergasted was gone when Thorin heard an angry shout of his name. He looked up and saw that Gandalf was rapidly approaching, staff brandished in one hand and the other rested upon Glamdring’s hilt. That itself wasn’t anything unusual but there was no trace of his usual kindly old man act.

“THORIN OAKENSHIELD!” he roared at a volume that no one other than a wizard would be capable of. Everyone nearby held their hands over their ears tightly and Thorin was surprised he didn’t start a rockslide. “Would you care to explain yourself!”

“I shall take my leave” Bard said politely but with a distinct undertone of grim satisfaction “It appears you have much to discuss with Gandalf.”

“As shall I” Thranduil agreed with a nasty smirk – it seemed he had regained use of his tongue at last then.

They departed hastily and even Dwalin retreated a fair distance so when Gandalf halted before him it was just the two of them. There were splashes of fresh blood on Gandalf’s robes and once he noticed Thorin found he couldn’t look away from them.

“How is Bilbo?” he asked tentatively.

Gandalf stiffened unnaturally and just looked at Thorin. It was only a second or two of eye contact but it was more than enough. Thorin had always known that were was more to Gandalf than what was easily seen – his father and grandfather both had told him all about wizards and how best to deal with them far before he had reached adulthood – but that was different from seeing the otherworldliness shining ominously in his eyes. Thorin felt small, a surprisingly unusual occurrence as while he may be shorter than elves and men he was tall for a dwarf and sure enough of his abilities and status that any difference in height didn’t bother him. Now though it felt like every long-buried prey instinct was screaming at him to run and hide and to never show his face before Gandalf the Grey ever again. He was trembling he realised, Gandalf was leaning over him now and it was all he could do to remain standing.

Gandalf sighed heavily to himself “What am I going to do with you, Thorin? I don’t think anyone has ever had the audacity to do something like this before. Usually when someone is under my protection fools like yourself leave well alone but you always have enjoyed playing with fire” Thorin can see the monstrous light of dragon fire reflected in Gandalf’s eyes and he shudders violently. The day has darkened significantly, or maybe Gandalf has made it so. Thorin cannot tell he only wants to be far, far away from here.

“I could do all sorts of terrible, awful things to you, Thorin. It would cost me greatly to do so but for Bilbo I would be quite willing. It is fortunate for both our sakes that we are on the same side and that you are currently irreplaceable. If Bilbo dies from this you can be sure that you won’t live for much longer, you have no right to ask after his health as if he had caught a simple cold. This is your fault Thorin and you would do well to remember it!” There is a curious smothering heat radiating off the Wizard and Thorin is abruptly reminded of Gandalf’s affinity for fire… and that while Dwarves are resistant to flames they can still burn very well if the fire is strong enough.

“I am sorry.” He dared to whisper. “I know I can never redeem myself but I really am sorry for what I did today.”

“Of course you are you foolish, foolish dwarf.” The heat died down a little and Gandalf sounded more like his usual self again but Thorin still didn’t dare look him in the eye.

A loud cawing brought Thorin’s scolding to a premature end as one of the messenger ravens had returned. Thorin held his arm out for the raven to land, which it did in a flurry of wings.

“Orcs! Orcs approaching from the west!!” it shrieked at the top of its voice.

“What?” Thorin asked incredulously.

“Ah it appears we have less time than I thought” Gandalf mused, even though Thorin was fairly certain he was not able to speak to the ravens. “Come, we must gather the others for a war council!”

Notes:

Warnings for attempted murder, some description of serious injuries, vomiting.

If you enjoyed please leave a comment :)) Hope everyone has a good day!

Chapter 2: Aftermath

Notes:

This chapter focuses on the immediate aftermath of the battle of the five armies (I copied Tolkien and skipped over much of the actual battle because no thank you!). In this AU Azog was killed by Dain at Azanulbizar as in the original lore and instead we have his son, Bolg, wanting revenge - which to me makes so much more sense (at least to me???) than what Peter Jackson did and is closer to original canon. Also that whole ravenhill signaling tower thing in the film is gone and we are sticking with the book geography because I really hated that part of the film. One last note is that I have adopted a lot of the dwarven customs head canons that are prevalent in the fandom - in particular dwarven hair cutting practices (and lack thereof) and in this case the relationship of this with grief as well as some of the hcs about Thorin's company that aren't well fleshed out.

Can I just say that Thorin is veryyyy hard to write? Like am I just projecting onto him when I say that he cares but doesn't know how to show it? Probably a bit??

Warnings for amputation, semi-graphic mentions of violent, a character having poor mental health, uh I've probably missed something...

Hope you enjoy!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

October TA 2941

Thorin hits the ground with a pained grunt. It must have been the fifth time in the last hour that he had found himself in the mud and gore of the battlefield and he is seriously risking contaminating his wounds but he isn’t willing to give up just yet. He sits up and groans when his head begins to pound.

“Thorin, you need to stop” Dwalin hobbles to his side, he hasn’t complained but his hands are clenched tightly around his crutches and he is unusually pale “None of us are in a state to continue looking today.” Thorin looks around at those of the company that were well enough to help him search. Ori was the one in the best shape with only a few scrapes and a spectacular broken nose, Dori having kept him safe in the battle that had torn through the valley the day before. There is little trace of the nervous lad that had left Ered Luin, even the slingshot had been exchanged for a battle-axe almost as large as he was. Dori is leant against his little brother heavily and really he should have remained with the healers but by that logic Thorin should have remained behind also, so he hadn’t protested. Gloin was also in relatively good health, only receiving a cracked rib and a lacerated shoulder and overall in as good fettle as could be hoped after the last couple days. Bofur was the final member of their little search party and while he was also only lightly injured but was handling the aftermath of the battle poorly. The poor lad was as pale as fresh snow and grimmer than Thorin had ever seen. While he had insisted on accompanying them he was obviously anxious to return to his injured brother and cousin.

As for Thorin himself he has lost an eye and his right hand is heavily bandaged and splinted from a stab wound through the palm, though it is his bruised ribs that are currently troubling him the most. His injuries are not particularly life threatening but they are certainly life changing. His depth perception is gone and he cannot walk without tripping over even the slightest obstacle. He has collided with the others countless times when he misjudged how far away they were, or sometimes didn’t see them at all when they were on his blind side, although everyone has so far been good enough to overlook it.

He sighs. It is foolish of them to search: the battle was over a day ago, there is almost no hope of finding Nori alive. Not that he is eager to point that out. They have been searching since lunch and now the light is beginning to fade. As their search progressed Ori and Dori have gradually become more withdrawn and Thorin worries for them as well as their brother. They had started in the area Nori had last been seen and headed away from the mountain. Most of the fallen from the victorious armies of elves, men and dwarves have already been taken elsewhere so it is only the remains of orcs and goblins and wargs that remain but it still makes the footing treacherous.

Dwalin steps closer and nudges Thorin with a crutch “Come on, Thorin. You’ve looked for him and now it’s time we went back. It wouldn’t do for our King to die now because he tripped and fell on a sword.” Thorin realises he has been kneeling in the dirt for some minutes and makes to struggle to his feet. His limbs feel like they have been fixed to the ground and he only manages to press himself further into the mud. When it becomes apparent that he isn’t going to be getting up again on his own, Bofur and Gloin heave him to his feet and they slowly trudge back to the mountain.

They are lucky enough that a passing human gives them a ride in his cart but by the time they return it is fully dark. At some point in the cart ride Thorin’s strength seems to have been stolen from him and he can barely hold himself upright. Luckily it isn’t far to the room he and his sister-sons are staying in and with the help of one of the guards at the gate he is soon being laid down on his bed. Thorin wants to check on the boys before he sleeps but finds he lacks the energy to do so. Someone is unlacing his heavy boots and removing the muddy outer layers of his clothes before pulling the blankets over him and it is so comfortable he can’t keep his eyes open any longer.

He hears Dwalin make some kind of teasing comment about his advanced years and he tries to swat at him but between his exhaustion and his wounds he misses and only hits the mattress.

“Rest well, you silly fool.” Dwalin says with a gruff kindness once he has finished laughing at his expense. Thorin grumbles a little but he is asleep before he can reply.


October TA 2941

The next morning Thorin hurts even worse than he did the day before. He sits up and clenches his teeth tightly as he gasps for breath. He hears a quiet sniffle and turns towards the other two beds in the room. Fili still lies uncannily still, deep in a coma that Oin is unsure he will return from, but Kili is awake and at his brother’s side. His tangled hair hangs limply over his face so Thorin cannot see his expression but he is clutching Fili’s hand in his. Thorin tries to avoid looking at the stump of his right arm.

“Kili?” he tries his hardest to speak gently but the lad still startles.

“Uncle! You’re awake!” Kili’s face lights up and Thorin feels the corners of his mouth turn up a little. Neither of them acknowledge the redness around Kili’s eyes.

“Indeed.” He stands and hirples painfully over to his sister-sons and sits by Kili. He is struck by how young they both are, which is odd as Thorin had his first battle when he was only 53 and yet he quails at his considerably older sister-sons facing the same ordeal. They will never be quite the same he knows, even if Fili does wake up. Thorin can’t bear to think of the possibility of Fili dying, his mind shies away from the concept and it makes him feel ill but Fili is currently beyond his help so he focuses on Kili instead. It is Kili who he must comfort now, though how he is supposed to do that escapes him.

“How are you?” he asks eventually but Kili has no chance to reply as there is angry shouting and the sound of a struggle outside.

“Stay here!” Thorin commands and leaps off the bed and charges into the corridor. He is expecting some kind of attack – maybe even treachery from one of their new allies – but all he sees are members of his company. Bifur is struggling in Bofur’s arms as Ori stands a few feet away by a part way open door, a nasty cut on his chin and his already meagre beard now lopsided. A small knife lies abandoned on the ground between a tearful Ori and the other two. Thorin approaches them and tries to figure out what had happened.

While Bifur had been injured in the battle, the main reason he had been confined to the healer’s halls was that experiencing another battle had taken him back to the confused state he had been found in the aftermath of Azanulbizar all those decades ago. Thorin hadn’t been there when the others had found Bifur on the battlefield but he had overheard Bofur telling Oin afterwards that he hadn’t recognised him and had almost attacked his own cousin. Given this knowledge Thorin’s first thought is that Bifur had attacked Ori over a misunderstanding of some sort. Thorin didn’t speak the particular dialect of Khuzdul that Bifur did (it was below his station to even acknowledge the existence of any other form of their sacred language), but he understood pieces. Enough to tell that the situation wasn’t what he had initially assumed for while Bifur’s rough voice sounded aggressive he was shouting something about hope?

Bifur elbowed Bofur hard in the face and he stumbled backwards while Bifur approached Ori, purposefully kicking the knife away from them both. Ori didn’t move from where he stood. He was obviously terrified at having woken Bifur’s wrath but he also looked ashamed. Bifur’s hands flashed between inglishmek signs almost too fast for Thorin to follow.

“How could you give up so soon?!” he signed, each movement jagged with fury.

“It has only been two days and you just decide he must be dead. No one saw what happened, there’s no body so you can’t give up yet!”

Ori flinched and looked away.

“Bofur and Bombur didn’t know what happened for weeks when… when this happened” he pointed angrily at the axe blade in his forehead “but they never gave up on me! When I returned it wasn’t to shaven faces. You disgust me!” Thorin glances at Bofur who has recovered somewhat from the blow and in a rare moment of perceptiveness sees the guilt on his face. Thorin feels his mouth pull into a scowl.

Bifur turns and storms out, grabbing one of the guard’s spears as he goes. He snarls something in his odd Khuzdul dialect back at them but this time he doesn’t catch it.

“What did he say?” he asks Bofur.

“Bifur says he’s going to find Nori” Bofur replied numbly “I should go with him…” he trails off and looks uncertain. Bombur was one of the worst injured of the company and added to that his wounds had become infected and he required someone monitor his constantly. Besides, Bofur looks like he hasn’t slept since the battle and is clearly exhausted.

“No, stay. I’ll send some of Dain’s lot with him.” He pats him on the shoulder in an attempt at comfort and looks back to Ori. At some point Dori has arrived and is fussing over Ori. The lad is now crying and Thorin considers going over to talk to the pair but he is painfully conscious of his own close cut beard and decides it that he isn’t the one to talk to Ori. His own grief had been for the state of his people and the countless fallen after Smaug and Azanulbizar but he isn’t about to go tell anyone that his suffering is more worthy than theirs. Instead he approaches the group of guards that is skulking uncertainly further down the corridor.

“Follow Bifur and assist him if he needs it but keep your distance otherwise” he orders.

They bow respectfully and leave, not running but moving swiftly though the busy passageways. He turns back to Bofur and finds he is still standing numbly in the middle of the corridor.

He grasps Bofur’s elbow and leads him into the room Thorin is sharing with his sister-sons “Rest.” He says and shoves Bofur gently towards his empty cot. Kili watches from his position at Fili’s side with interest but remains silent.

Bofur snaps out of his daze somewhat and protests “Oh! I couldn’t take your bed from you, Thorin!”

“You can and will” he says grumpily and pushes him again, ignoring how the movement pains him “I’m not going to be in need of it for some hours and you very obviously are in need of rest.”

“I need to watch Bombur!”

“I can watch Bombur!” he snaps back exasperatedly.

“But you’re the king… surely you have better things to be doing?” Thorin blinks at this. He has never been the sort to claim that any sort of task was beneath him – before Smaug he had been apprenticed to a silversmith but there was little demand for work of that nature in the blue mountains so he had spent most of his exile as a travelling blacksmith (of mediocre skill by dwarvish standards) and, when he decided to stay in Ered Luin, a miner (a perfectly respectable profession for most dwarves, but certainly not for a king!). He had even done menial work around the farms at human settlements when work had been particularly scarce! He had done whatever was necessary, no matter how ‘beneath him’ others might consider it. Most of the nobles of his people thought him far too eager to set aside his dignity but they still had treasures left over from Erebor to tide them through rough times when his family had sold theirs to feed not only themselves but also those less fortunate. He shook himself from the memories of those years of near constant hunger and weariness. Now that Erebor was reclaimed no one would have to live in poverty!

He supposes Bofur doesn’t actually know him terribly well – they never spent much time together without others during or before the quest. He had been vaguely aware of him from his time as a miner but they had certainly not known each other before they departed from Ered Luin. Thorin had never managed to figure out exactly why Bifur, Bofur and Bombur had come in the first place. They were not of Durin’s Folk, they hadn’t known anyone else in the company particularly well before the quest and they seemed very intimidated by Thorin himself. He had not enquired too closely as he had been sorely in need of them.

“A king’s job is to protect and aid their subjects to the best of their abilities.” He says solemnly and Bofur finally realises his protests are futile and removes his boots before laying himself down on the cot. Barely a minute later the sound of soft snores is filling the air.

“I had better go watch Bombur then.” Thorin says to Kili “Are you alright to stay here on your own?”

Kili makes a face that Thorin doesn’t understand and he is unsure whether to stay or not. Whenever he looks at Kili he feels immensely guilty – he had done what he had to so save him but the price had been steep.

“I’m not a child anymore, Uncle!” he says indignantly at last “Go check on the others, I want to know how they are.” he waved his remaining hand dismissively.

“Right,” Thorin said, his mouth strangely dry and his chest feeling tight. He managed to leave the room before the weakness in his legs becomes too much and he leans heavily against the wall. The corridor is less busy than before, Dori and Ori have left and there are no gaping spectators. He is sure it is quieter too but all he can hear is the ring of metal against metal and the screams of the wounded.

Thorin stabs an orc in the gut and spares a glance to check up on his company. They are cut off from Dain’s forces and backed up to the steep shale-covered slopes and cliffs below the Ravenhill in a defensive manoeuvre. There were twenty or so of Bard’s people with them too, armed with dwarven weapons after Thorin had seen the state of the weapons that had been retrieved from Laketown and scavenged from the ruins of Dale. Kili was perched slightly uphill of the rest of the group, picking off orcs with a bow he had taken from a dead elf and arrows scavenged from both sides. Thorin was rallying his small force when he heard a rumble from the cliffs behind them.

“Rockslide!” Dwalin roared and they all scattered. Tonnes of stone thundered down the slope and buried the orcs and goblins that had surged forwards when they had taken cover. Initially Thorin thought that it had been a fluke but then he saw the figures of orcs at the top.

“Kili! Shoot them!!” he gestured at the foul creatures but heard no cheery acknowledgement or whistle of arrows.

“Kili?” Thorin turned his gaze back to ground level and searched for his sister-son. The splintered remains of the elven bow poked up crookedly from the rockslide and Thorin heard himself gasp for air.

He scrambled over the rough ground on shaky legs. A pair of sturdy dwarvish boots come into view and Thorin speeds up. Kili has somehow survived and is only bruised and scraped, save from his arm which is trapped – crushed – beneath a boulder that probably weighs the same as five dwarves.

“Help! Uncle, please!” Kili begs and Thorin feels his heart constrict painfully.

He hears a loud gasp and turns to see that Fili and Dwalin have arrived. “Kili!” Fili cries and rushes to his brother’s side. He gently pushes Kili’s face away from where he has been staring at the trapped limb. Kili’s face is bone pale and a trickle of dark blood rolls from his mouth, though Thorin expects it is from him biting his tongue or the inside of his cheek. Thorin hears the cackling of the orcs at the top of the slope but before he can think of how to deal with them Fili has left Kili’s side and is racing up the treacherous slope roaring a battle cry.

“Fili! Get back, It’s not safe!” Dwalin shouts, for not only is there a chance that Fili’s weight will cause another rockslide but the orcs are already rolling more boulders towards the edge. Fili ignores them and continues his sprint, his fate is in his own hands now and Thorin realises that if he doesn’t act soon then Kili will likely also perish. If the rocks shift even a little it won’t just be Kili’s arm that is crushed. Thorin knows that there is no way they will be able to lift the boulder – it would take much more equipment, people and time than his sister-son has and even then Kili’s arm is likely too badly damaged to ever recover. He reluctantly removes his belt and winds it three times around the bicep of Kili’s trapped arm before pulling it tight. Kili groans but clearly doesn’t understand what Thorin is about to do to him. He fastens the belt once it is as tight as he can make it and turns to Dwalin.

“Give me your axe. Quickly!” he reaches a hand out pleadingly. Fili is almost at the top and the orcs are releasing the boulders. Dwalin hands Thorin his axe without a word, his expression is grim but neither approving nor disapproving. There is a shout from the top of the slope and Thorin looks up in time to see Fili disappear under the rocks. He almost allows himself to be caught up in the despair that accompanies the sight but Kili’s survival depends upon him. He raises the axe high and hopes it is sharp enough to do the deed in one blow. Kili finally catches on and begins to beg. The rumble of the rocks is almost upon them and Thorin lets the axe fall.

Kili screams but he is given no time to cope with the loss. Dwalin scoops him up and they dash out of the path of the second rockslide. The dust begins to settle and it appears the orcs at the top of the ravenhill have run out of ammunition as after heckling them for a minute they lose interest and move away. Dwalin carefully transfers Kili to Thorin’s arms and accepts his bloody axe back. Despite the improvised tourniquet Kili is losing blood faster than Thorin is comfortable with. They need to find a healer soon to tend to the wound.

“I’ll go look for Fili.” He says gruffly and sets off up the hill.

Thorin turns back to the remainder of his forces. “Upon my mark we make for the mountain!” Those that have turned to look at him go pale at the sight of Kili bleeding out in his arms but they do not falter and there is a mixture of shouts of acknowledgement in Westron and Khuzdul.

“Uncle…” Kili’s whisper cuts through all the cacophony of the battle.

“Yes Kili, I’m here.” He brushes his sister-son’s near-matted hair back from his face. Silly boy never learned how to properly use a comb! He snorts a little hysterically and frantically tries to hold his composure together. He has just maimed Kili! First he had almost murdered Bilbo and now he had crippled one of his own family. Kili was barely out of childhood, he had only been allowed to come along because Fili was going and Dis had made him promise to keep her boys safe. A fine job he’d done there! He can feel Kili’s blood dripping down his face and he wants to just fall apart then and there but they need him.

“Where is Fili?” Kili asks hazily. Thorin is screaming inside, how is he supposed to explain to Kili that his brother has most likely been crushed to a fine paste while on a blind quest for vengeance?

“He.” His voice wavers treacherously and he pauses to settle his breathing “He isn’t here right now.” Every word is a fight to get out, the deception foul on his tongue.

“He was here just a minute ago” Kili frowns at him confusedly.

“Don’t you worry about him” he soothes and Kili’s eyes close a little as he relaxes, questions forgotten in the face of his blind trust in Thorin. Thorin hates himself for the deception but the necessity of it all makes him remain silent. Kili didn’t see Fili fall and to tell him now would risk the shock killing him.

There was a clattering, rumbling noise as the shale slope shifted and Thorin looked uphill in horror-

“Thorin?” He feels a hand on his shoulder and he almost falls for a second only to feel large hands steady him. He blinks and looks up at Gandalf.

“Is everything alright Thorin?” Gandalf asks as he steps back a little.

Thorin is deeply embarrassed being seen in such a vulnerable state – it is most unseemly to show weakness to outsiders! He mumbles his thanks awkwardly, but Gandalf seems to have overcome some of his previous (very much warranted) animosity and doesn’t immediately snub him as Thorin was expecting. Neither of them know what to say for a minute and then, because Thorin just has to put his foot in it he asks.

“May I ask how Bilbo fares?” he tries to not sound desperate. Even if he wasn’t explicitly forbidden from visiting he wouldn’t dare. It would do Bilbo no good at all to see him, no matter how desperate he was to apologise. A more cowardly part of him doesn’t want to know how badly he has injured Bilbo.

Gandalf frowns and some of the hostility returns.

“He is expected to live but the elves are unsure how full a recovery he will make. Hobbits are not well adapted to falling, in fact most are too terrified of heights to venture far from the ground and their bones are much softer than a dwarf’s, but he has had the best care available on this side of the misty mountains. Once he is well enough to travel I will take him to Thranduil’s realm for the rest of the winter. I think Bilbo will have had quite enough of dwarves after this fiasco!”

Thorin nodded stiffly.

“Very well. If anyone can keep him safe it is you, Gandalf.” He said seriously. Gandalf made a harrumphing noise.

“I hope, Thorin.” His tone became threatening once more “That you understand that if you ever approach Bilbo or have any involvement with him that he has not asked for or sought out you will come to regret it.”

“I understand” Thorin says miserably before taking his leave of Gandalf to check up on the others in the company that he hadn’t just been forbidden from seeing.

Oin had never taken part in the battle and had spent the time safe in the mountain, tending to the ever-increasing influx of the wounded. He was currently tending to one of the soldiers from the Ironhills, Gloin dutifully carrying his equipment. Dori was resting in another room further along. He looked pale, his skin as white as his hair and his face slightly pinched from pain. Dori had received a nasty stab in the leg and a slice across his chest that had left him weak with blood loss, though this had certainly not been helped by the exertions of the day before. He appeared to be dozing currently and Ori was sat by his bed, writing in a notebook. The cut on his face from the earlier confrontation had been stitched closed and the blood washed away. Neither of the brothers noticed him and Thorin made sure to leave quietly. Next Thorin visited Balin and Dwalin. Balin had taken a nasty knock to the head and had spent much of the battle being trampled under the feet of friend and enemy alike. He was exceedingly lucky to have survived although he was badly concussed and had a multitude of fractured and cracked bones. He didn’t move when Thorin entered, although the lack of light in the room made it difficult to tell if he was asleep. Dwalin was undeniably awake though. His eyes gleamed in the semi-darkness and he was sat up on the other bed, crutches propped up neatly by his side. Thorin owed much to Dwalin for keeping his sister-sons safe.

When Bolg, the leader of the horde of foul beasts they had fought, and his lieutenants had cornered them on their desperate charge through the battlefield Dwalin had taken Fili and Kili and attempted to get them to safety. Thorin had initially had no idea who the orc chieftain was but Bolg had spotted the oak branch Thorin still carried and his ugly, misshapen face had broken into a smile.

Bolg had taken great glee in introducing himself and asked Thorin about the state of his family – for Bolg wanted retribution for his father, Azog’s death all those years ago at Dain’s hands during the Battle of Azanulbizar and wanted to know how many of Durin’s line he needed to eradicate. Thorin had not answered him but it was impossible to deny the resemblance between himself and Kili, who was still cradled in his arms. Thorin had passed Kili to Dwalin then and had bade he make haste for the mountain. Thorin had fought Bolg with every ounce of viciousness and skill that desperation granted him, not realising that Bolg had sent most of his lieutenants after Dwalin and the others. Bolg had taken his eye and pinned Thorin by a knife through his hand when he saw a warg slam into Dwalin from behind, its teeth closing around his leg and shaking him mercilessly but Dwalin kept Fili and Kili held close to his chest. The sight had roused Thorin enough from the shock that had been stealing over him that he had been able to aid Bard of Laketown in slaying Bolg and then he killed Warg that had been savaging Dwalin in a haze of battle rage and protectiveness. It was only when the eagles arrived and the battle was won that Thorin came back to himself.

“How are you?” Thorin asked.

Dwalin grunted grumpily “Balin was awake earlier, he’s under the delusion that he’s healthy enough to get back to work.” Thorin held back the urge to snort. Dwalin then asked about the confrontation earlier and Thorin told him of Bifur’s departure. He hummed thoughtfully and didn’t say anything else but Dwalin had always been a dwarf of few words so Thorin left him to his thoughts and checked on the last of his company.

Bombur lay alone in a small room in a fevered sleep, a damp cloth half on his forehead. The other bed lay empty – presumably it had been Bifur’s.

Thorin settled himself on the low stool by the bed and straightened the cloth.

Bombur stirred a little at the touch but didn’t wake so Thorin made himself comfortable for the long wait ahead. The rhythm of exchanging the sodden rags was simple and became mildly soporific. He didn’t fall asleep but it could not be said that he was fully alert and awake when he was unexpectedly disturbed from his trance.

“Uncle” he turned to see Kili enter the room. Thorin took a moment to regain his bearings while Kili sat on the unoccupied bed.

“I got sick of listening Bofur’s snoring so I decided to stretch my legs.” he said defensively.

“He does snore impressively loudly.” Thorin nodded and tried to smile but kept his eyes fixed on Bombur.

“I’m surprised we can’t hear him from here.” Kili attempts to joke but neither of them laugh. Silence falls heavily between them, as permeable as a cave in.

“Kili… I…” he attempts before trailing off when he realised he doesn’t know what to say. What he did to Kili he did to save him but what kind of dwarf cripples their own sister-son? An apology would be trite but he has scarce little to offer. All he has been able to do lately is apologise! His ancestors must be cursing him for bringing their line so low.

“What, Uncle!?” Kili eventually snapped “I thought I would keep you company but if you are so embarrassed by me I might as well leave!” he rose swiftly and Thorin heard a sharp pained inhale before he marched for the door.

“No! Kili wait!” Thorin turned and caught a handful of his tunic as he passed. Kili halted reluctantly but didn’t yank free.

“I could never be embarrassed of you, Kili! Whatever made you think that?” Thorin said as softly as he dared. He tosses aside his shame and looks Kili in the eyes.

“Since the battle you can barely look at me and I fought so badly. Fili and Dwalin are injured because of me! Fili still might die, and then I’d have to be your heir and everyone knows I’d be awful at that! Of course you’d be ashamed of me!” Kili’s face screwed up from all the unhappiness as he had spoken and he looked very young and uncertain.

Thorin stood slowly and drew Kili into a careful hug. “You fought admirably Kili, and even if you had not I would still be proud of you.”

“But everyone talks about how at Azanulbizar you-”

“Enough. Don’t compare yourself to what others have done; it was your first battle! Your survival was all that I hoped for.” He released Kili from the embrace and stepped back.

He still frowned but did not look as anguished as before. “Yes Uncle.”


October TA 2941

“Thorin, wake up!” Someone shakes his shoulder a little and Thorin goes from dead asleep to panicked in an instant. He pulls the knife out from where he keeps it under his pillow and staggers out from his blankets. Kili reels back, his hand held out in front of him motioning for Thorin to stop.

“Kili?” he lowers the knife but doesn’t put it down. Kili looks excited but he should have known better than to wake Thorin up like that regardless “Why did you wake me?”

“Bifur is back!”

Thorin felt a dizzying mixture of relief and worry “Is he well? Did he find Nori?” it has been some days since Bifur and Ori’s confrontation and while no one had dared say anything the mood of the company had been slowly becoming grimmer. He put the knife back in its hiding place.

Kili nodded “The healers are tending to them both right now as well as some of the guards that went with them. I haven’t seen them yet, Dwalin told me just now.” Thorin bent to hurriedly pull on his boots, Kili following his example and they stumbled through the dimly lit corridors. Those of the company that were able were already clustered around a closed door. A very intimidated guard bars everyone but healers from entering. Dori and Ori were huddled on the floor, crying and hugging each other tightly but they seemed relieved rather than grieving.

A travel stained dwarf wearing the livery of Dain’s people that Thorin vaguely recognised approached him and he realised he must be the leader of the soldiers he had sent after Bifur.

“Report.” He demanded.

“We found Nori son of Kori and returned him to the mountain. He was being held captive by a group of stragglers from Bolg’s army along with at least seven other prisoners.”

It was as Thorin had feared then. Once the first day of Nori’s disappearance had passed he had known that Nori was either dead or something awful had happened to him. As the days had passed with no sign he had expected (and to an extent, hoped) that Nori was dead as the alternatives were not something Thorin would wish upon anyone.

“At least?” Thorin asked warily, unsure if he wanted to know more.

“Many of the prisoners were dead or seriously injured and we have… reason to believe the orcs were eating them.” The soldier’s voice trembled and he held a hand over his mouth momentarily as he regained his composure.

“As soon as we found the orcs Master Bifur attacked with the rest of the party not far behind and we made sure to kill every last one of them. Of the seven prisoners still… intact we found six were already dead, mortally injured or were killed in the skirmish and the seventh, an elf, succumbed to its wounds during the journey back to Erebor. Master Nori was the only survivor.” The soldier then told Thorin more details: the location of the orc camp, the injuries that had been sustained by the group and so on. He avoided telling Thorin anything more on the prisoners, both about Nori and those that hadn’t survived. Thorin then dismissed him and he hurried off to make his report again to Dain.

Thorin approached those of his company that had gathered. Balin was up and about now, though he was leaning against the wall and was squinting with his eyes almost shut against the light so he most likely should still be in bed. Dwalin was by his side, scowling furiously which only served as more evidence that Balin shouldn’t be up.

Bofur was also present, standing alone as while Bombur was much improved he was still confined to his bed. He still looked pale and serious but appeared less haunted. Thorin stepped closer to him and gave what he hoped was a reassuring thump to Bofur’s shoulder.

“Did he tell you of Bifur?” Bofur asked, a nod of his head indicating he referred to the departing soldier.

Thorin nodded “Bifur went into a rage when he saw the orc camp and rushed in before the others were properly ready. He’s exhausted and lightly injured, and lucky not to be worse off. Though apparently his quick actions are likely to have saved Nori.”

Bofur gave a relieved laugh “Of course, I’m beginning to believe he is quite indestructible!” he tried to joke and while it was obvious that his heart was still weighed down from the horrors of the battle Thorin was glad that he finally seemed to be on his way to recovering.

Notes:

I did plan to kill one of the company but after writing notes over who would be the best choice vs who would I be willing to kill of I decided that I would have to go down the everyone lives route because while I'm here for the ANGST, major character death angst isn't the flavour I wanted.

Next chapter: yet MORE Thorin angst! (tbh that's the entirety of the fic until like chapter 6, then we get Bilbo angst!)

Chapter 3: Limitation

Notes:

HEY! So you know how I said in the comments back in January how the next chapter was just about ready to go up?? Turns out I was very mistaken! I decided to add a whole scene, then the scene wasn't working out and in the end I just decided to post it because I got annoyed. Also this chapter is LONG. I have a complete work on Ao3 that is shorter than this chapter. Aaaaaaaah.

I had a hard time with Thorin this chapter as he kind of throws himself under a few buses and is feeling very down which isn't really how we see him in canon and also this chapter is supposed to convey Thorin realising a bunch of stuff and I really hope I pulled it off!

Oh also this chapter buys into a lot of the common fanon headcanons surrounding dwarves and their hair. If you aren't familiar with this then it might seem like Thorin repeatedly makes mountains out of molehills and I would recommend you read A Dwarf's Pride by TrueRed, Nobody by Samayla or (if you want something low angst) Plaits and Weaves by ArgentAconit which I think are good examples.

Warnings for: fairly graphic torture, reference to suicidal thoughts and mentioned chronic illness (kind of?).

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

November TA 2941

It is the first time Thorin has seen the whole extent of the damage done to his face at the battle, now the best part of a month ago. Oin finally removed the bandages for good this morning and he has been so busy that it is in the evening that he has his first opportunity to just stop and look. He runs his fingers over the wide band of rough scar tissue that runs from just below his hairline to taper to a point at the corner of his jaw. The cavern made by his empty eye socket is unsettling to look at. He had known that his eye was gone and on bad nights he could almost feel its absence but up until now it has been hidden by layers of bandages and seeing it is another thing entirely. It has a peculiar finality to it – as if before he could have somehow pretended it wasn’t real or only temporary. He could laugh at the ridiculousness; he has clearly spent too much time above ground!

adjusts the hand mirror he has borrowed from what was once his mother’s rooms. As he is currently Thorin is a menacing sight, handsome by dwarven standards but skirting close to the line that divided rugged battle wounds from horrific disfigurements. He wonders what he looks like by a hobbit’s standards and then chides himself. He will never see Bilbo Baggins again!

As Gandalf had planned, and once Bilbo had been healthy enough to travel, Gandalf had bundled him into a heavily padded cart and they had left for Thranduil’s halls. There they would spend the remainder of the winter and then Bilbo would finally be able to return home to his beloved Bag End. Thorin missed Bilbo more than he missed his own eye. It had only been a week since his departure but Thorin could have easily been convinced it had been at least ten times longer, although he had not seen Bilbo since that awful day before the battle. Well, he had watched in secret from an arrow slit high in the mountain as Gandalf carried a hobbit-sized bundle of blankets and furs to the cart and then slowly rode away but that hardly counted. He had stood with his face pressed to the narrow crack long after the company had returned inside from where they had bade the travellers farewell in a less clandestine manner. So long had he watched that he felt stiff and chilled and the cart had disappeared from sight over the horizon some undeterminable time before.

It was hopeless to even entertain that Bilbo would still find him handsome. While Thorin was self-aware enough (just) to realise that he had well and truly fallen for the hobbit he had decided to leave any attempts at courting until after Smaug was defeated. Then the gold sickness had set in and while Thorin had made his intentions very clear in a dwarven manner, Bilbo was not a dwarf and clearly hadn’t understood and after that… well any dreams of having Bilbo at his side as Consort under the Mountain had been crushed by his own hand. Thorin no longer deserved to have Bilbo’s affections, as much as it hurt and Thorin didn’t doubt that if he did manage to weasel his way into Bilbo’s good graces again Gandalf would quite happily turn him into a toad or something equally undignified. Thorin wasn’t sure what wizards did to people like him – they were not inclined to acts of cruelty but generally they had no reason to be as living in near isolation didn’t give them much opportunity to experience hatred – but Gandalf cared for Bilbo like the hobbit was family.

Balin has already had a replacement eye commissioned for him but there will be no hiding it’s nature regardless of the quality of the craftmanship as what remains of his eyelid has healed malformed and twisted. He is unsure about how he feels about a glass eye – he has already objected to the diamond and sapphire creation that Balin had initially proposed. Thorin cannot risk falling to gold sickness again and stuffing precious stones in his eye socket will not help him ignore the gold’s siren call. While he is fairly sure he has remained free of gold sickness these last weeks he has been living in perpetual fear that if he relaxes it will pull him back under. No one can tell him what the likelihood of relapse is as no one has ever been able to break free in the manner he has. So Thorin decided that caution is the best path and when the Royal Wing is declared habitable again he choose himself a servant’s room. There are currently few luxuries in Erebor save from the never-ending piles of gold and jewels so it is not difficult to live simply and have very few notice. That will change when spring comes and food and trade become more plentiful but for now at least Thorin is able to live very much like the pauper-king he has been for most of his life.

The one thing the people do notice is that since… since that day upon the battlements he has not worn his Grandfather’s crown, which has been repaired – or any other crown for that matter. When some of Dain’s nobles had expressed their distaste he had told them that he was not yet coronated so to wear a crown would be presumptuous. That had held them off for a day but then they had begun to hound him for the date of his coronation. He was already King of Durin’s Folk – though without a Kingdom the title had meant very little – but he was not yet King under the Mountain. They complained that without a properly crowned monarch they would appear vulnerable to their enemies and besides what reason could there possibly be to wait? After the first week their persistence had become rather wearing so Thorin had gotten creative in his excuses. He had expressed his wish to be crowned with his sister present and she wouldn’t be arriving until late spring at the earliest, and when that failed to satisfy them entirely he had claimed that the weight of a crown would hinder his recovery. He groaned quietly as the throbbing started up once again behind where his left eye had once sat and rubbed at his face. Maybe his latest excuse contained a grain of truth.

He realised then that he had yet to put his plaits back in. They had been removed sometime during his convalescence and with his head still swathed in bandages he had been forced to let his hair fall untamed. Thorin finds his beads and a comb – the well-worn one that he brought with him on the quest, not one of the jewel-ridden monstrosities that he has seen some of the others start to use – and begins the slow process of combing his hair out in front of the fire. It takes longer than he anticipated as his right hand is still uncooperative – and is unlikely to stop being so – and his hair is tangled from neglect. He had better be careful to stay on top of that or people would liken him to Kili!

His hands move almost on automatic to section out the hair for the first plait – the one that marks him as one of Durin’s folk. The pattern has been drilled into his head from a lifetime of repetition and while his loss in dexterity gives him a little trouble the plait is soon secured with one of his beads. The next is the one that denotes him as King and while this plait is marginally simpler than the first it gives him more difficulty. He still remembers far too clearly the day when it was decided Thorin was to officially going to take his missing father’s place. Dis had woven it for him because he was shaking too hard to do it himself. This time is far from easy but nowhere near as awful as that day, though the plait comes out misshapen and frayed. He leaves it in regardless – it is doubtful he will be able to do a better job if he tries again. The next are the family plaits on the opposite side of his head: one for his parents, one for his siblings and a final one for his sister-sons, each secured with two beads – each a gift from a different member of his family. The plait showing his mastery as a silversmith comes easily too but the warrior plait troubles him so much that he leaves it out and he doesn’t even bother with the one that marked him as a veteran of Azanulbizar. He supposes there will be a plait for the battle of the five armies as it is being called, although he doesn’t know the pattern and tucks the remaining beads into his pocket. He thought putting his plaits back in would make him feel better but he feels like he is only pretending to be the old Thorin Oakenshield. It is not a pleasant feeling but he cannot afford to draw the attention that continuing to go without would bring.

His reign was not off a smooth start for a variety of reasons: the greatest being the aftermath of the battle and the lack of resources other than gold but also, regrettably, the distrust that he had earned from his treacherous actions while in the grip of gold sickness. Erebor was currently mainly populated with dwarves from the Iron Hills and very few were familiar with Thorin in the way his people in Ered Luin are and feared his line’s predilection for madness or scoffed at his weakness. Even then his failings could have possibly been overlooked given that he had reclaimed Erebor and provided many dwarves new hope but the tale of Bilbo, son of Bungo of the Shire had changed that. There was no longer one tale, but many versions – all of which were twisted fragments of what had actually happened, although even the truth was bad enough! Thorin had sold Bilbo to Thranduil as a slave, Bilbo had actually horribly died in the battle, Thorin had tortured Bilbo to death trying to learn the location of the Arkenstone, Bilbo still lived and was trapped in a cell somewhere in the mountain, Bilbo and Thorin had been secret lovers and Thorin had attempted to pitch himself over the battlements after his love when he realised what he had done…

The dwarves’ unfamiliarity with Hobbits and Bilbo’s description had also lead many to believe he was actually a dwarfling and now any the mere handful of families that had moved to the mountain made sure to keep their own dwarflings far away from him.

He sighed heavily and dragged himself to his feet. He would have to get up early tomorrow and it was no use worrying over matters he couldn’t control. Bilbo was surely recovering well and once there was enough food and some of his people from Ered Luin arrived all would be well in Erebor too.


December TA 2941

Thorin swung the wooden practice sword clumsily and sighed when he missed the practice dummy. Again. His injuries may have healed now but his right hand remained stiff and unable to grip tightly so he was having to completely relearn how to write and wield a sword left-handed on top of coping with the lack of depth perception. The only way to overcome it would be to practice but to do so in front of his subjects was humiliating. It did neither them nor him any good to be seen while weak so he had taken, much to Dwalin’s disapproval, to training alone late in the night.

Especially when he couldn’t sleep. Thorin had many reasons not to sleep: his fear of relapsing into the gold sickness, his guilt at all he had done, Bilbo’s shriek when Thorin had dropped him… admittedly it was none of these that was currently keeping him from his rest.

This evening he had paid Fili a visit. Every day since he had emerged from his coma Thorin had rejoiced for and mourned his sister-son in turn. He was deeply thankful that Fili still lived and yet it was… distressing to see him so changed. Oin had told him that given time he still could improve but that didn’t make it any easier right now! Sometimes Fili almost seemed like he had before. For brief snatches of the day he would tease Kili and complain loudly about being restricted to his bed and just generally act like the nuisance Thorin knew and had helped raise. He also still slept a lot and that wasn’t too bad either as it was true sleep, not the unnerving stillness of unconsciousness from before.

But often Fili would just sit or lie quietly, no hint of recognition or intelligence in his eyes, never moving of his own volition or acknowledging his surroundings. Sometimes he would enter this state for hours and today it had lasted all day. Other days he would suffer awful migraines that all anyone could do to help against was to make sure he was somewhere dark and quiet but worst of all were the fits. It had only happened twice so far but Thorin found it terrifying. It was a horrible combination of everything he hated about the vacant periods and the migraines and Thorin found he had very little stomach for watching Fili suffer, especially when there was very little they could do about it. Oin had sent a letter asking for advice to some of his elven colleagues that he had met after the battle but he had warned Thorin not to get his hopes up as head wounds were tricky things.

He finally landed a solid blow on the mannequin with an angry yell and it slumped over. Thorin stuck his sword into the sand that covered the ground in this part of the training halls and bent over to right the dummy when he heard the distinctive scuff of dwarven boots approaching. Multiple dwarves, approaching at speed if he heard correctly.

He reached for the practice sword. He had been visiting the training halls at night for a while now and had never encountered so much as a mouse! He had only lit a couple torches around the area he was training in and the halls were far from the reach of the still working parts of the mirror system that funnelled natural light into the mountain so he could only see his immediate surroundings. He also realised he had left Orcrist with his coat and outer tunic on the benches and hurriedly approached the side of the room.

A blur of movement had him turning and parrying the silver flash of a blade, the wood of the practice weapon sheared through as if it were a rotten stick. Thorin threw the truncated piece of wood at his attacker and reached for the knife at his belt. There was a scuff of feet from his blind side and before Thorin could turn he received a harsh blow to the head. He stumbled forward with a grunt but retained his balance, swiping with his knife to cover for the moment of weakness. The blade made glancing contact, not enough to put them off but better than nothing. He cast around to find his attackers but they were dressed in dark colours and had vanished back into the shadows. It was silent except from the heavy breathing of several people and the shifting noises of boots in the sand. Thorin looked toward where Orcrist lay but then they were upon him again. He dodged a sword thrust and an axe blow that could have removed his head and he still wasn’t sure how many there were but if he ran for it now then he had a chance-

The cudgel came out of nowhere. Thorin folded around the weapon without a sound save the whistling of air leaving his lungs. He barely noticed when he fell down on his back in a daze, pain ripping him apart and hazing his vision as his diaphragm spasmed and he struggled for air. He thought he might hear laughter and feel hands upon his body but it was hard to tell and when Thorin became properly aware of his surroundings once more he was somewhere else.

He opened his eyes to find himself now lying face-down on a stone floor. He wasn’t in the training halls any longer but at least he was still somewhere in Erebor. He moved to get up but his arms were stretched out to either side of him, metal shackles biting into his skin and Thorin wasn’t going to be going anywhere without assistance. His whole torso ached fiercely but it appeared his organs were all still intact, if unhappy at being bruised.

He heard a low whisper off to the left: “He’s awake.” and braced himself for whatever his kidnappers wanted. A hand tangled roughly in his hair, a blatant insult that made Thorin growl and tense, and his head was pulled back. One of the Dwarves that had attacked him – their faces may have been covered but they were undeniably dwarves – stared back at him, dark eyes gleaming from the eyeholes of their mask.

“Well Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror, King under the mountain” the words were spat at him derisively “it appears you are just as weak as we had heard.” There was a murmur of reverent agreement from around the room.

“You call yourself King of Kings and a mighty warrior – the hero of our time! And yet not only did you succumb to the madness that plagues your proud line of bleating lambs quicker than any dwarf that has come before but you went back on your own promises, bartered with elves and murdered a child! You do not deserve to be king under the mountain, you should have realised your weakness and handed the throne to Lord Dain as soon as the battle ended, for while you were skulking bitterly in the blue mountains he was leading his people. While you were crying over the dead he was slaying Azog and when you cried for help in a battle caused by your treachery he came to your aid!” the spokesperson, and presumably also leader, finished speaking, chest heaving from the fervour of his speech.

There were many things Thorin could have said but he found himself exclaiming: “I didn’t kill Bilbo! He’s still alive!!”

“Then where is he? What kind of dwarf brings a dwarfling on a mission like that, anyway?”

“He left with Gandalf the Grey some time ago. And as I have tried to explain, Master Baggins is not a dwarfling but a fully-grown hobbit and he wished to return to his home.” He gritted out. He didn’t actually know what Bilbo had wished, he hadn’t had the nerve to ask Gandalf if it was Bilbo’s desire to return to the Shire or the wizard’s but that was beside the point.

“Of course.” The masked dwarf scoffed “I’ve never heard of these Hobbit creatures before this nonsense and no one in this mountain has seen him alive save your company. You won’t even own up to your mistakes, Thorin Childslayer! You are not worthy of the crown and you know it! Why else would you not wear it!?”

Thorin’s rage was incandescent from this deluge of accusations. “Do not talk to me of worthiness when Dain was perfectly content to stand by and watch my people and I risk everything, never lifting finger until it suited him!” he threatened lowly “Unchain me now and I will show you just how deluded you are!!”

The leader kicked him solidly in the side and the other dwarves all bristled in indignation. It appeared they were zealous followers of Dain, although he didn’t fear they were acting under his orders. While Thorin was not particularly close with Dain they respected each other and Dain’s lack of assistance had been more to protect his own people than to slight Thorin (although Thorin was finding understanding and forgiveness were entirely separate when it came to this matter).

The leader’s tone lightened even as his grip on Thorin’s hair tightened “All we want from you is for you to renounce your claim and the claims of your sister-sons to the throne and to appoint Dain instead. Once you have promised you will do so we will let you go.” He showed Thorin a contract which he didn’t even bother to read, it was no doubt full of ridiculous demands that he would be incapable of meeting.

“I have no intention of giving in to the demands of honourless criminals that sully Erebor’s shadows” he replied haughtily.

At no point in these unpleasant proceedings did it occur to Thorin that provoking his captors would be unwise. While he had some experience of being kidnapped and held against his will he had never faced any consequences for refusing to cooperate or insulting his captors: in goblin town they had escaped before anything more than a few lashes could be inflicted and in Thranduil’s halls the elves had had little interest in hurting them. It was this lack of experience and foresight that meant that Thorin was taken aback (and a little unnerved) when his hair was abruptly released, sending his chin crashing into the floor rather painfully, and two dwarves set about cutting off the light undershirt he had been wearing.

Soon Thorin was shivering as his skin was bared to the cool air, trails of warmth trickling down his sides where the knives had nicked him. He could feel his kidnapper’s gazes upon his exposed back. Thorin was not necessarily an old dwarf but he was passing his prime now and had been in enough conflicts both big and small to acquire an impressive array of injuries. He supposed from the slightly bemused silence that while it was well known that he had fought at Azanulbizar and the battle of the five armies they must have expected him to have sat around and ordered others to risk their lives in place of his own in the intervening years so to see he was not as untouched as a babe was probably a shock.

Admittedly Thorin hadn’t been the perfect leader. He had left his people after Dis’ husband, Vili, had died but it had been to provide for his family! Leading a group of refugees did little to put coin in Thorin’s pockets and after that awful first winter after Vili’s death when they all nearly starved and Kili had been born weak and sickly he had left to find work. It was only once his sister-sons were in their thirties and healthy and well fed that Thorin had even dared attend to his duties once again. That was when he had become a miner so that he could spend more time with his people, although he had been careful to keep his occupation as quiet as he could. It would not do for the mine owners of Ered Luin to know he was working in their mines. He had been lucky with that – people preferred to gossip about how Thorin had ruffled the council of Ered Luin’s feathers or how the heirs of the line of Durin were too unruly and headstrong to make wise leaders than wonder about Borin son of Sarin, a somewhat odd, quiet fellow that was seldom seen outside of his work at the mines.

He wanted to laugh (or maybe cry) at these fools – they had bought the carefully maintained lie of the proud King-in-Exile Thorin Oakenshield who would never deign to lower himself any further than circumstance had already and added his recent misdeeds and concluded that he was a disgrace of a ruler. If Thorin had been in their position faced with the same selection of half-truths and deceptions then he would likely think the same-

Thorin was jarred out of his thoughts by a dwarf sitting heavily on his lower back. He grunted as his newly forming bruises were pressed into the stone beneath him but otherwise didn’t complain despite the feeling of breathlessness.

“You have an impressive collection of scars, why don’t we add to them.” The leader hissed as the dwarf sat on him brought something cold to the flesh across Thorin’s shoulder blades. A knife he realised when the first slow, dragging cut was made. The blade was tortuously blunt and did a poor job of parting his tough skin. Thorin gritted his teeth so he didn’t dishonour himself with every rough jerk of the knife. The dwarf pulled the knife away and hummed thoughtfully before stabbing it back into his flesh and beginning the second cut. Thorin tried to twist away but between the dwarf’s weight and the chains he could only twitch. The fifth cut crossed one of the others – Thorin was in far too much pain by then to tell which one – and he hazily began to realise that they were carving something purposeful into his back. By the eighth cut he was sure it was a word of some sort, judging by the way the dwarf was progressing from left to right but he had no idea what. The knife was now in the flesh at the centre of his back and Thorin forced himself to remain still after he felt metal scrape against bone. As soon as they had passed his spine he relinquished his fragile control over his body. His wrists were chafed and bleeding by now, though it was barely a distraction against the agony that pulled at every nerve in his shoulders. Surely it had to end soon? The last remnant of control slipped away and Thorin cried out raggedly. A haze fell over him, protecting him from the slow, jagged pain of the knife parting his flesh again and again. How could a dwarf of all peoples bear to do this to one of their fellows? Thorin couldn’t imagine what it would be like to be on the other end of the knife: to knowingly torture his fellow dwarf, or anyone for that matter!

Thorin returned unpleasantly to full awareness when he felt the dwarf get up off his back. He could feel blood and sweat flowing along his back and down his arms and sides and supressed a shudder at the pain. He had been injured in many more painful ways but for it to have been so prolonged and the feeling of complete helplessness made this worse. Never before had he been slowly humiliated like this, each layer of his resolve peeled back before being cut away.

The leader was kneeling by his side, careful to avoid the stains on the floor “What say you now to our offer?” they asked.

Thorin groaned and realised he sounded rather pitiful so he spat out a couple curses.

The leader grabbed him by the hair again “Oh how crude, your majesty! If you want to keep your tongue perhaps you should use it more wisely.” They put their hand on the knife on their belt threateningly “However, seeing as our conversation isn’t finished it is perhaps better that we don’t do that just yet. I would take your remaining eye instead but that is also still needed for you to sign our contract.” The leader tightened their grip and said in a pretence of thoughtfulness “I have always had a liking for pretty marbles.”

Before Thorin could protest there were hands pressing the unscarred side of his face into the floor. Thorin couldn’t see anything in this position and when he felt rough fingers on his cheek he panicked. The hold on his head tightened and Thorin was powerless as his glass eye was pried from his skull. It must have only taken minutes but every second that he had another dwarf’s fingers inside his eye socket was unbearable. The hands released him and he turned his head protectively so that his blind side was facing the floor. Even though he knew it was over he could still feel the fingers pressing against the soft tissues of the insides of his eyelids. Thorin was shaking and he felt nauseous but it seemed that no one noticed as they were busy inspecting his false eye.

“It’s only glass!” one cried in astonishment.

“I thought for sure it was diamond and sapphires!!” another said, sounding disappointed. They all then returned their attention back to Thorin.

“It appears that not only are you a dishonourable and weak king but you are also a miserly one.” The leader said “is parting with gold really so difficult for you that you still dress like a beggar?”

The eye was thrown down and shattered into many pieces. Thorin flinched at the proximity but he remained resolute “You may mistreat me as you wish but my answer will remain the same.” He announced and somehow his voice still sounded confident and assured despite the scratchiness from screaming.

“Well then. We’d best continue.” The leader said. They motioned one of their other followers over. handed him a tiny, slim blade and said the words that any dwarf dreaded “The punishment for murder is usually execution but a quick death is too kind for one who has killed an innocent child. There can only be one sentence: shave him.” There were several gasps around the room. To shave any dwarf was the ultimate dishonour and if done in a court of law symbolised the exile of that dwarf, but for a King… It had never happened before but he would likely have to abdicate – even if he was allowed to rule he would have to make himself scarce until his hair grew back and it would probably forever remain a stain upon his name.

He wasn’t going to sign their contract though. Thorin was unsure about the exact legalities that would surround him renouncing Fili and Kili’s claims to the throne so he didn’t want to chance that he would be signing away their birth right just because someone threatened him.

The dwarf that had been given the blade approached and pushed Thorin’s head down firmly. The knife was placed at the back of his neck and he dared not struggle as if it so much as twitched it would cut through either his hair or his spine.

“This is your last chance to stop this.” The leader told him.

Thorin tried to reach for words that would properly convey his contempt and hide his fear. They would not come, chased away by the awful pain in his shoulders and his terror at what was to come.

The knife began to move, Thorin could almost feel the loss of every strand. He resigned himself to his fate. Whatever came after, his heirs would serve Erebor well!

There was a commotion suddenly. Thorin couldn’t turn to look so he strained his ears trying to figure out what was happening. There were shouts of surprise, pain and anger in equal measure accompanied by the clash of metal against metal and the noise of a sharp blade slicing through flesh. A spray of liquid splatters Thorin and the knife is gone from the back of his head. Finally he can look and sees that his kidnappers are fighting a newcomer. Most have already fallen, probably dead judging by the shocking volume of spilled blood covering the floor. The newcomer mercilessly dispatches of the last of Thorin’s captors with a knife to the throat and approaches him.

They wear a hood that obscures much of their face but when they bend down to pick at the locks on Thorin’s shackles he sees the scandalously short reddish-brown beard on his rescuer’s chin and knows it is Nori. His right arm is freed and while Nori moves to pick the other lock Thorin gingerly reaches up to examine how much hair he has lost. There is a small bald patch at the base of his skull but overall he has been very lucky – it will be easy to hide until it has grown back, unlike the rest of what has been inflicted upon him. He has to move his arm back down to the floor when the pull on his back becomes too much.

Nori frees his other hand and helps him sit up. Thorin is hard pressed to remember exactly when the last time he saw Nori was. He had only visited him a couple times when he was recovering in the infirmary as Nori had been unable to deal with crowds and his brothers were by his side almost constantly. Then one day he had just disappeared and the only reasons anyone had known that Nori was still in the mountain were the regular disappearance of food from the kitchens and the occasional sighting of a cloaked figure that walked as quietly as a hobbit.

Physically Nori appears to be fine, maybe still a little thin from all the missed meals on the quest but his body has healed well from what Thorin can see. However, the glint in his eye is a little too feral for Thorin’s liking and when his hood is pushed back his hair is still in a sorry state: barely an inch long and Thorin tries his hardest not to stare. If Nori had been just a few minutes later he would have undergone part of the same ordeal.

Nori tugs Thorin to his feet gently and leads him away from the carnage. It must be the early hours of the morning now as the corridors are still empty and dark but Nori leads him through the gloom confidently to what initially appears to be a small cupboard full of supplies to make the torches that line the corridors. Well that was what the cupboard was but it also happened to have a false back wall that leads into a larger room behind. Nori lights a lantern and guides Thorin to sit on a low stool. This must be where he has hiding all this time – there is a pile of bedding in the corner, a respectably sized store of non-perishable foods and stacks and stacks of papers and odds and ends that Thorin doesn’t investigate any further. Nori fetches a basin of water and a bag full of bandages and ointments that had clearly been liberated from Oin.

Nori kneels on the floor behind Thorin and carefully washes his back. The feeling of cloth on the gashes is agony but Thorin can tell that Nori is trying to make this as painless as possible. He is filled with an uncomfortable amount of gratitude – he wants to thank Nori for saving him but there are no words to express the depth of what he feels. Not for the first time in his life Thorin wishes he was better at expressing his emotions. How was it that he would prefer to negotiate a trade deal – and likely do a better job of it too – than tell those important to him how much he appreciated them?

Thorin watched as Nori ran a needle through the lantern flame before threading it and moving back out of Thorin’s field of view to stitch closed the cuts closed. Thorin sat stoically still as the first few incisions were stitched, then his curiosity grew too much and he asked:

“What did they write on my back?”

Nori’s hand twitched and Thorin grit his teeth when the needle pulled painfully at his lacerated skin. The moment stretched out almost uncomfortably long before Nori silently began to stitch again. It occurred to Thorin sometime later, when Nori was reaching about two thirds through that Nori hadn’t spoken a word since he had appeared. It was odd now that he thought about it: Nori was capable of being very quiet, but he also enjoyed boasting and teasing and had a sly sense of humour that he could and would use to run rings around most of the other dwarves in the company. Thorin had heard tales in the past of people who had undergone great suffering just ceasing to talk, at all. Sometimes they would remain silent forever, sometimes (rarely) they would regain their voices but he didn’t fancy Nori’s chances if that was what had happened here. Thorin was just trying to scrape together the words for an apology when Nori finally finished his work and tied off and cut the thread. Thorin relaxed somewhat now the most painful part was over.

“Uslukhul” his voice was quiet and rough from silence and Thorin was so surprised that he spoke at all that what Nori had actually said went unheard.

“What?”

“That’s what they wrote. On your back.” Nori spoke slowly, as if Thorin were made of eggshells and not stone. Thorin was so overwhelmingly relieved to hear his voice again that it took him a moment to realise his question had been answered.

The joy from hearing Nori speak dropped away as if it had never been. They had chosen their insults well – very few words could have gotten under his skin better! Ever since Smaug had invaded Erebor in his youth, Thorin had endured many insults in this vein towards both himself and his family. To call a dwarf dragon-like was itself not a grave insult (and if the context was the battlefield it could even be a complement) but it was an insensitive thing to say to a dwarf who had lost everything to a dragon. And an even graver insult when there was some truth behind it. Thorin had grown up with his family’s dragon-like natures thrown in his face by his enemies and detractors at every opportunity and there had been nothing he could say to protest because they had been right. If his Grandfather had kept his hoarding and lust for gold under control then Smaug would never have come! Thorin clenched his fists until his right hand began to ache but he didn’t stop. When Thror had still been alive Thorin had lived in fear of him and the madness that had only persisted after they had left Erebor. He realised that although he had shaken off the madness in the end, he had been worse while in its thrall than Thror ever had been. Thror had threatened and raged but he had never actually tried to murder his family! Thorin had spent decades assuring people that he wasn’t his grandfather, but he was worse.

“Thorin.” Nori was now in front of him, looking concerned. He must have been trying to get his attention for a while as Thorin’s chest is now bandaged and he doesn’t remember that happening at all.

“Thorin, calm down!” Nori must be able to see some of the turmoil Thorin is experiencing judging by the distress on his face. He is crouched directly in Thorin’s line of sight but is careful to stay out of easy touching distance, something that Thorin appreciates greatly right now. If anyone understands how he feels presently it would be Nori. He stares into Thorin’s eyes with a look of understanding that Thorin has never from him seen before. “Don’t let what happened today to eat at you, those monsters are dead and you survived and that is all that matters.” Nori’s fingers gripped tightly at his trousers and Thorin notices that a couple fingers have healed slightly crooked.

“But they were right.” He protests.

“About what? You are the one that decided that we would reclaim Erebor and you saw that goal through. Yes, our journey was difficult and if we had stayed things would have been different but we were dying a slow death in Ered Luin anyway. The blue mountains were never meant to support so many dwarves and at some point the mine owners would have discovered that you were working for them and you would have lost any of the remaining sway you held as the leader of Durin’s Folk.”

Thorin is taken aback that Nori had known about ‘Borin’ and had never tried to hold it over him – not even when he had threatened to cut off his hands! He almost reacts aggressively to the reveal of his secret but Nori almost looks almost passionate? in his certainty over Thorin’s worth. It is a surprise that he would gain Nori’s loyalty, especially given the manner he had convinced him to join the company. He admitted he may have been a little cruel, having Balin lay an elaborate trap and then when Nori was caught by it demanding he sign on or face the traditional punishment for thievery. Arrangements such as this didn’t exactly lead to pleasant relations – he had won the displeasure of all three sons of Kori, but it had also increased the size of the company by three and as the months passed and the company had become closer any bad feelings had first softened in the face of adversity before fading to just a whisper and by the time they had reached Laketown such grievances were in the past.

“But I’ve made so many mistakes” Thorin sounds wretched even to his own ears.

“Well then all you can do is learn from them.” Nori doesn’t speak unkindly but his tone is brisk as he allows himself to fall back into his more usual manner “I’m going to go get Dwalin now and deal with any loose ends. Please stay here Thorin.”

He nods reluctantly and Nori disappears silently out of the hidden door.

Thorin sits in the small room for an unknowable period of time. His thoughts are a dark maelstrom that threatens to drag him in and he soon realises that sitting quietly isn’t going to help him. He finds the basin of water and cleans the wounds on his wrists before wrapping them in more bandages from Nori’s stash. He remembers taking a blow to the head during the struggle in the training room but when he feels with his hands there is only a slight bump and he doesn’t feel any of the symptoms of a concussion. He still has no shirt and doubts anything Nori has would fit him so he wraps himself in a blanket to stave off the chill and hide the state of his torso. The bruises have coloured nicely now, a mosaic of colours that he knows is only going to get worse over the next couple of days.

He doesn’t have much longer to wait he thinks before he hears the cupboard door open and Nori enters with Dwalin trailing after him. Nori has blood smeared on his hands that he didn’t when he left but he appears uninjured so Thorin decides not to ask.

“Thorin!” before he can protest, Dwalin is hugging him roughly. He fixes his face in what he hopes is a neutral expression to hide the pain the action brings him.

“Are you well enough to move?” Dwalin asks with no small amount of concern “If there is some kind of plot against you we should move to somewhere more heavily guarded.” He nods sharply, though when he moves to get up off the low stool he finds his bruises have developed sufficiently that he is already stiff. Dwalin catches hold of his upper arms as he staggers and smoothly pulls him to his feet before pushing aside the blanket to check his injuries.

Dwalin frowns as he takes in the bandages and the bruising “You idiot. This is the last time you wander on your own at night.” He turns to Nori “Should I be fetching Oin?”

Nori shakes his head and steps off to the side to fetch a cloak that he drops over Thorin’s shoulders.

“We should go” he says shortly before exiting the room. Thorin and Dwalin follow and they creep down the still empty corridors to the Royal Wing. As they get closer there are noticeably more guards than usual and soon Nori has disappeared as if he was never there. Dwalin escorts him to his room, where Fili and Kili are already gathered. They are both barefoot and still in their sleep clothes and very worried.

“Uncle!” Kili bounds over to his side and flutters around anxiously. Fili hovers uncertainly as well but he is a little more stoic and does so at a greater distance. His heart aches at causing his sister-sons to worry but he is relieved that it appears that the attack had only been against him.

Dwalin herds him into bed and fusses uncharacteristically which Thorin allows because he is bone tried. In the end Dwalin is satisfied he isn’t going to drop dead in the night and refrains from fetching Oin and leaves to stand guard outside and stew angrily.

“What happened?” Kili asks with youthful insensitivity “Dwalin wouldn’t explain, he just said we should stay with you tonight.” He sits on the edge of Thorin’s bed with a heavy thump that jostles Thorin unpleasantly but he doesn’t complain.

Thorin shifted on the bed, he was discovering there was no comfortable position to lie in his condition. He considers playing down what happened but his sister-sons are grown dwarves now and do not warrant any coddling and they will be worried about him whether he explains himself or not. Although he is certainly not going to give them a blow-by-blow account! “I was attacked by a group of dwarves from the Iron hills. They wished for me to abdicate and change the line of succession so that the crown would go straight to Dain.”

Kili frowned and looked upset and Thorin was glad he had left out all mention of the… torture that had been inflicted upon him. It wouldn’t do to tell him just how close it had come to Fili being King under the mountain – whether by Thorin’s shaming or death. Fili took the news much better, his eyes narrowed as he considered the situation carefully.

“Would that even have worked if you had agreed, Uncle?” Thorin attempted to shrug but aborted the motion halfway through when it pulled on his stitches. “Do you think Dain himself is involved in the attack?!”

He stifled a yawn before answering “I don’t have any reason to. They appeared to be acting independently but it remains to be seen if there is some sort of larger plot. Nori dealt with all of them but I’ll be expecting you both to be careful from now on.”

They looked surprised at the mention of Nori but Fili nodded solemnly and promised he would take care and Kili promised the same, although slightly grudgingly. Satisfied with their responses and that they were all safe Thorin finally allowed himself to fall into an exhausted sleep.


December TA 2941

Thorin woke slowly, a rarity that should have made him wary but he felt so secure in his warm nest of blankets that he felt no desire to move or think about anything particularly hard so instead he dowsed contentedly. He felt a fuzzy kind of disorientation – the kind caused by sleeping too long and left him uncertain of where exactly he was – but it was pleasant enough so he didn’t question it. There was an ache in his back but he supposed he was just getting old. He snuggled further into the blanket and suddenly every muscle was lit on fire, starting at his back and stomach and spreading outwards like the inexorable march of a conquering army.

He was no longer feeling comfortable at all but had no plans of moving again as he had no desire to discover the agony that sitting up would induce if he had any choice.

He eventually chanced opening his eyes and discovered that he was in his bed in Erebor. Fili was curled up at his side, still asleep and another dwarf – most likely Kili – was lying at the foot of the bed. He hurt so awfully because of those traitors. They had had the audacity to kidnap him in his own realm and carve him up like fresh meat.

To try and shave him as if he was the criminal…

“How are you feeling?” a voice asked, interrupting his thoughts. Thorin startled and then swallowed a curse when he discovered just how interconnected his neck and shoulder muscles were. Balin looked at him concernedly while he regained his composure “Should I be fetching Oin?” he asked.

Thorin scoffed “No, I will be fine, Balin. I am merely stiff.”

He sat up slowly in an effort to minimise both the pain and his chance of accidentally waking his sister-sons. When he was finally upright he was breathing hard and sweating but when Balin moved to help him he motioned him to remain where he was.

Thorin settled gingerly against the headboard “What time is it? Have I missed anything important?”

“It’s only late morning, don’t worry.” Balin reassured him “I’ve taken the liberty to cancel as many of your meetings and other duties today as I could.”

He almost sighed in relief but then he remembered “Wait, today is…” it took him a moment to remember what day it was and another moment to think about what was planned “What about the western sapphire mine reopening? That’s been planned for months and I can’t not show up for no good reason when work is supposed to start tomorrow!”

“Thorin, you aren’t in any condition to be walking round Erebor for hours and especially not when there could be more dwarves out to hurt you!”

“I am nowhere near injured enough to be treated as if I am made of glass!” He threw the covers aside and angrily threw himself out of bed. Standing up so carelessly was agony but he managed to stand steadily after an initial stumble and faced Balin resolutely, hoping he couldn’t see how much pain this caused him.

“Balin, please fetch me my robes.” He ordered.

“Thorin!” Balin started but he cut him off impatiently.

“This is an important public event, Balin.” He said sternly “I am perfectly aware of the risks but I cannot afford to not go.”

There was a grumble from the direction of the bed and a bedraggled Kili appeared from under the blankets with a yawn. “What’s going on?” he asked warily.

“It’s the day of the mine reopening. Wake up your brother and go get changed.”

Kili’s expression turned to sheepish panic and he near dragged his still half-asleep brother from the room. The door swung shut with a slam and once again the atmosphere in the room became tense.

Balin sighed and looked mildly upset but he acquiesced “Very well.”

He brought Thorin’s best clothes from where they had been left lying over the back of a chair the previous evening. It took embarrassingly long for Thorin to get dressed. His clothes weren’t tight fitting by any means but the range of motion in his arms and shoulders was limited and he was too stiff to bend over. Balin had to help him for the whole process but he endured the discomfort and the shame that accompanied every reminder of his injuries and how he had gotten them. The inclusion of Thorin’s heavy wolf’s fur coat was a point of brief contention but Thorin won that point too as it really was the most impressive part of the outfit.

Finally Balin stepped back from tying a wide dark blue ribbon over his empty eye-socket and Thorin was ready. There was a great silvered mirror that Thorin hadn’t yet gotten around to moving elsewhere and when he examined his reflection he was relieved to see that while he was pale and his face was mildly scratched he looked much healthier than he felt.

There was only a little time left before the ceremony so they left Thorin’s room and were joined by only Kili. He was dressed unusually smartly, though still scruffy if Thorin held him up to the standards that were expected of him at that age. Balin fussed with the way the layers of his clothes lay until they sat straight.

“Fili isn’t feeling great so he went back to bed.” Kili said a little disappointedly and they left the royal wing together.

The walk to the mine entrance felt far longer than usual and Thorin soon became acutely aware of the weight of the fur coat across his back. He grudgingly admitted to himself that Balin may have been right but there was already enough of a crowd that to remove it would be strange.

Almost the whole mountain’s populace was present, only a fraction of the number Erebor could take but still a lot of dwarves. They made a solemn crowd, watching him untrustingly despite the happy occasion they had gathered for.

The ceremony was not long – at least not by dwarven standards – though events regarding the main source of dwarven income were taken seriously. Thorin had a speech, which luckily he had written some weeks in advance so he already knew exactly what to say regardless of his late night exploits. Kili stood at his left shoulder throughout, the space where Fili was supposed to stand at his right left conspicuously empty.

Then there was the singing, the choir specially chosen to have voices that would reverberate well down the mineshaft. It sounds perfect, Thorin hasn’t heard such a satisfying – and loud – minesong since he was a child and he is filled with renewed hope. The deep resonance of so many voices reflecting off good strong stone not only raises his spirits and the remainder of the ceremony is a much more joyful affair.

He gives the new mine supervisor the finely wrought golden pickaxe with sapphires inlaid in the head that symbolised the position. Thorin has avoided looking at it as much as possible – not that it bothers him, he just wants to be cautious – so he wouldn’t be able to describe it further than that but Balin had made sure it was the right one for the mine.

The lass was not the most… traditional of choices for the role but Bofur, as Thorin’s advisor on all mining matters, had recommended her and Thorin had respected that. Some of the council didn’t like it overmuch but he was sure once the mine was running their disapproval would mostly dry up.

The new supervisor’s speech was given solemnly but with great determination and then the ceremony was over. Thorin leads the way to the great hall where there is a ‘feast’ laid out (feast being a relative term as they do not have the supplies for anything so fancy). He lowered himself into his chair and attempted to look as if he were halfway aware of the conversations around him. His entire back throbbed and he was queasy with hunger but he ignored the protests from his body and forced himself to slowly eat a bread roll so that his stomach would settle. Balin gave him a couple of concerned looks but allowed himself to be occupied in conversation in Thorin’s stead.

Thorin waited a couple hours before leaving so his departure couldn’t be interpreted as rudeness or some kind of slight. Kili thankfully anticipated that he would need help and quietly offered his arm so that he could get up. They left together, Kili wanting to check on his brother. His dedication to his sibling made the over a century old hurt of losing Frerin briefly sting but funnily enough it no longer bothered him as much as the more recent hurts he had amassed over the last year.

When they reached the royal wing, Thorin bade him goodnight before collapsing into his bed and instantly falling into an exhausted sleep.


December TA 2941

“I’m afraid I must attend to an urgent matter!” Thorin tries to hide his urgency as he abruptly stands – his chair skidding across the tiled floor – and leaves the council chambers quicker than is maybe polite. The gaudy gold necklace that the head of the Goldsmiths Guild was wearing gleams mockingly in his peripheral vision, the many cut precious stones and metals that adorn the other dwarves present glittering in concert like some kind of awful constellation of greed.

He can feel the contents of his stomach churning uncomfortably but it does not stop him from sprinting away from the council chambers once he is out of sight of the doors.

He thought he was clear of the sickness! It seemed he was still a fool.

He has been running blindly but when he has to slow he finds himself near the (now not so) secret entrance which has recently been restored. Thorin knows that after making such a dramatic departure at least Balin, and possibly other members of his company will be looking for him. He can’t go to the battlements which is where he normally goes when he is troubled but he wants to feel the outside air and it will probably take the others a while to think of the secret door. He changes course and heads for the door. He hasn’t been here since the battle but it looks much as he remembered. There are lit torches at the entrance to the tunnel and the carvings on the walls have been cleaned so he can read the Khuzdul easily. He doesn’t linger in the tunnel long, only pausing to find the key that he still keeps round his neck. There are other copies now, distributed so that they are available in case of another crisis, but he has kept the original as a memento of his father.

The key turns smoothly in the lock and the door swings open smoothly, despite being made of a tonne of solid rock. Outside the mountain it is pouring with rain but Thorin is unbothered. He strides out, making sure to prop the door open behind him as it still only opens from the outside on Durin’s day, and tips his head back to look up at the heavy grey clouds and feel the icy water pour down his face.

He feels better for being outside but still shaken. He had been close, so horrifyingly close, to turning upon an innocent dwarf just because he wore too much finery. Even the mere memory of the necklace the Guild master had been wearing was enough to summon a slithery, covetous haze that squeezes at his heart. Jealousy gripped him such that his breath was short and quick. A tremble ran through his limbs as he was overcome with rage that others could own and flaunt such riches. He was King. He was the one that had claimed back their glorious homeland while they were quaking in their homes so how dare they try to outshine him!

Yes! All of the gold is yours! Those pretenders don’t deserve an OUNCE. Take it back. Seize it. KILL THEM!

Thorin was startled by the jolt of his knees folding beneath him. The voice that he had last heard in the depths of gold sickness was gone once more. It was just him slumped in the rain, cold sinking into his bones.

The madness was not vanquished as he had hoped.

Thorin fell back to sit on the wet stone and lichen, he couldn’t continue as King like this. Thorin had known for a long time that he no longer wished to rule. Leading Durin’s Folk in their exile had been a thankless task, especially once it had fallen to him, but save from some minor hiccups at the start of his rule he had never faltered. Sometime between the easing of his madness and Bilbo’s departure from the mountain he had realised that he no longer desired the throne. He no longer felt worthy of the responsibility, a hollow shell of the dwarf he had been, but he had recognised that he was the best King available to Erebor right now. If he was to abdicate now Fili would be King and even if his sister-son hadn’t been recovering from such serious injuries he wouldn’t have dreamed of doing that to him. Fili was barely out of childhood, and while Kili was currently more physically able he had not been raised to the role the way Fili had been. To crown either of them as they were now would be to invite disaster. Dain would be next in line after the boys and he had made it clear to Thorin after the battle that he was perfectly happy with what he had. Dis being a women excluded her from the line of succession, quite unfairly in Thorin’s opinion as she had always had a head for leadership and was less hot tempered than the others in his family. He may believe himself to be an unworthy, honourless creature no better than a goblin but Thorin owed it to his company to see through what he’d started.

Now though, he would have to reconsider that assessment. If it was possible for relapses to happen then he would have to either step down or place someone in charge of assessing his mental state. It was a humiliating prospect but he had already realised abdication was not currently an option. It would have to be someone he could trust to not misuse that power and knew him well enough to notice any changes. Balin would be the obvious choice but he was unsure if even Balin would always notice in time if he continued to relapse. Thorin felt shame join the well of unbearable emotions that sat heavily inside him.

He is shivering violently now, hands painfully numb as the rain has changed to sleet. Thorin is only dressed in his council robes which, while somewhat fancier than his normal attire, are also less warm and doesn’t include his fur coat. He staggers to back to the door on frozen feet only to find that he had not propped the door open well enough and it has swung closed. He is trapped outside! The only other way into the mountain is the main entrance far below on the other side of the mountain. As tired and cold as Thorin is he stands no chance of making the steep climb down the mountain. He would almost certainly fall to his death, not that the hypothermia that awaits him if he stays here is much better. He looks up at the clouds and sees not only that the sleet shows no sign of stopping but also that dusk is rapidly approaching. He swears quietly, but with great feeling. It appears that any choices have been taken out of his hands by his own foolishness. Fili will be king tomorrow after all.

Thorin sits himself in the most sheltered corner he can find and awaits his end (or rescue!) with as much dignity as he can muster. He wonders what the others will think when they can’t find him. Dwalin will likely tear through the mountain under the assumption he has been kidnapped again. His teeth begin to chatter and he almost (almost) wishes that he had been kidnapped again rather than a victim of his own poor decisions.

When he hears the rumbling of the door opening he is half convinced it is only his over-cold mind playing tricks but then he hears footsteps and grudgingly unburies his face from where he had been shielding it against his knees. His visitor is cloaked but once again it is unmistakably Nori. The main giveaway is the shade of purple of his hood and the ends of a scarf that flap around him and was undoubtably made by Ori, a shade that all the sons of Kori seem to favour.

“Come on” Nori, gestures towards the door with a careless hand and supports Thorin as he tries to force his icy joints to move. The air inside the mountain feels blessedly warm and it is only when he starts shivering that he realises that he had stopped at all.

Nori closes and locks the door with his own copy of the key, though where he had obtained it Thorin does not question. Once the door is closed Nori pushes back his hood and unwraps the scarf from around his face. He then takes two steps closer and decks Thorin in the face. Thorin rocks back a little unsteadily but remains on his feet. The punch hadn’t been intended to knock him down.

“What are you thinking, Thorin?” Nori hisses viciously “Between those plotting against you and your own carelessness you’re going you’ll wind up dead within the month! Is this what you want?!”

Thorin is stunned by the cold and the unexpected blow to the face and doesn’t reply immediately which Nori seems to take for reticence. Nori snarls and grabs his collar roughly “Is it? Because if it is then I can save everyone a lot of bother right now” A knife appears in his hand with a flourish.

“That will not be necessary.” Thorin pushes the hand holding the knife away with a frown “Thank you for aiding me again, Nori. I will endeavour to be more careful in future.”

“You’d better.” Nori releases Thorin and returns the knife to wherever it had come. “You know” he says slyly, his fury gone as quickly as it had appeared “You could make everyone’s life easier in situations like this and appoint a spymaster.”

“And how do you know I haven’t already?” Thorin asked, an eyebrow raised.

Nori’s smile widens “Ha! That’s a good one!” he laughs “Both of us know there isn’t a dwarf in this mountain or outside it that could do the job better.”

Thorin sighs to hide any trace of the smile that is threatening to break through “And as I suspected you’ve already appointed yourself!”

Notes:

Next chapter: Dis returns to Erebor. Not sure when this'll be done as I have an unfinished section in the next chapter (writing conflict is hard!) and the chapter after that is barely written because it's giving me A LOT of problems but I shall do my best! :))

Hope everyone enjoyed and see yous all when I next reemerge from my burrow!

Chapter 4: Acceptance

Notes:

H-Hey, it's been a second or two. Hahaha. I moved and started my first real job which has kind of taken the wind out of my sails when it comes to writing. Luckily for the like 5 people who read this I broke my toe yesterday and I am now stuck on the sofa icing my foot so here's the next chapter!

This chapter is quite uncomfortable as it sits awkwardly between people deserving second chances and authority figures being accountable and I'm not sure if I've managed to stick the landing. Also Thorin just like sets his relationships with others on fire for 6k words and I personally avoid conflict like the plague so some of this probably sounds very weird because I have no idea how to write people actually expressing their grievances. Also Dis is here and I have no idea how to write her because there is no canon material. Big sad.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

April TA 2942

He runs through the halls of Erebor to the front gate, his heavy fur coat flapping around him. Thorin can already hear the rumble of the gates opening and when he rounds the final corner there is a blast of the balmy spring air. The gates are crowded as the arriving dwarves enter and those already present in the mountain rush to meet them, as Thorin is doing. He is aware he should probably be arriving at a more stately, dignified pace but he hasn’t seen his little sister for a year!

He sees her in the distance and speeds up “Dis!” he shouts and she turns. They had always been said to look similar: both with dark hair, long noses and impressive height. Dis was fourteen years his junior, although the years had worn at them both harshly and it took a careful observer to tell. Now of course people would be much harder pressed to compare them, what with the large scar cutting across Thorin’s face and the glass eye while Dis looked much the same as he recalled.

Dis’ smile dropped of her face and she pales a couple shades. The ravens had been unable to get to Ered Luin through the winter storms over the misty mountains and when spring had finally come the weather had continued to be bad. They had sent ravens of course but those that had made it back had been blown far off course and some had not returned at all. The only communication they had had was before the battle, before they had known there would even be a battle so it must have been a shock to see him like this.

“Thorin, it appears we have much to discuss.” She informs him before asking the question Thorin has been dreading “Where are my sons?”

Before Thorin has time to answer he hears a cry of “Amad!” and turns to the sound of rapid footfalls. Kili throws his arm around his mother and hugs her tightly. Thorin smiles to himself at the reunion, despite the knowledge that he will soon be in deep trouble with Dis.

Dis holds her youngest at arm’s length and looks him over “Well it appears you still haven’t learned how to use a comb” she remarks dryly, before Thorin sees the moment she realises Kili has one fewer limb than when last she saw him. Dis’ face becomes drawn and she turns back to Thorin stiffly.

“Where is Fili?” Her voice trembles subtly. She clearly dreads hearing the answer and Thorin feels wretched.

“He’s resting right now; he had another migraine this morning.” Kili tells her solemnly. His previous childish glee has vanished and he is now self-consciously trying to maneuverer himself so that the stump of his arm is facing away from his mother. Dis takes a moment to digest this latest piece of information before demanding to be taken to him.

Thorin leads the way to the Royal Wing. He had expected Dis to be weary from her long journey but seeing her sons must be giving her a second wind. Soon they are outside Fili’s door – what was once Thrain’s room and Thorin knocks gently before entering in case Fili is awake.

It is dark inside but the soft sound of Fili’s snores can be heard. Dis enters tentatively and Thorin opens the door wider so that she doesn’t trip in the dark. Thorin knows that out of the three of them Fili looks the least changed. Save from a couple small scars leading into his hairline just above the ear he was seemingly untouched. Of course, all the remaining damage was on the inside. Oin was hopeful that the migraines and strange vacant periods Fili experienced would decrease in frequency with time – indeed they had already become much less frequent, but it was still difficult. Fili was adapting poorly to having to rest so often and had a tendency of ignoring his body’s new limits.

Fili stirred sleepily when Dis reached his bed. Dis shushed him tenderly and he was just burrowing back down into his blankets when he abruptly sat upright.

“Amad!?” he exclaimed loudly and then groaned and screwed his eyes closed. He took a few slow breaths before looking again, a wide grin forming on his face.

“You’re finally here!” he said as he hugged her tightly. Kili crept into the room and joined the hug and Thorin watched from the door before reluctantly leaving. Dis would find him when she wanted to talk and it wouldn’t be right for him to intrude right now.

He let his feet wander as they wished and when he stopped he was on the battlements over the gate. He had found himself returning here with alarming frequency although he wasn’t sure as to why. This was the site of his greatest crime, surely it would be natural to avoid the wall at all costs? He wondered how Bilbo was now, he was probably in Rivendel by now. Thorin wondered how he was near daily but he knew he was unlikely to ever know. He would never see Bilbo again and he didn’t deserve to write to him, even if Gandalf had not forbade him from seeking contact. He hoped that elvish medicine would help Bilbo more than dwarvish methods had, Bilbo deserved everything after what had happened to him. Thorin would have happily given him the mountain itself if it would have helped at all!

Thorin then thinks of Dis and his sister-sons and the guilt combines and multiplies until he feels quite sick. He thinks of his plan for the coming days and is certain that it is the right thing to do.

Balin eventually found him watching the sun set over the remains of Laketown. The whole Long Lake looking more like a burnished sheet of metal than water in the warm tones of the dying light. Thorin carefully steers his thoughts away from imaging exactly what kind.

“Dis wishes to speak with you, she’s waiting in her room.”

Thorin cannot hide his grimace and while he doesn’t look at Balin he can hear the slightest huff of a laugh. “Well then I’d best go see her then.” He turns to leave.

“Thorin.” Balin doesn’t grab him by the arm as many of the company would have but his tone has much the same effect. “I know it all seems difficult right now but you do not need to fear Dis. She’s going to be furious, but you are still family. She’ll forgive you with time.”

“Thank you, Balin. I hope you are right.” he says softly and Balin’s beard shifts in the way that means he is smiling. The walk back to the Royal Wing seems much longer than normal but Thorin makes sure not to let his feet drag. Keeping Dis waiting won’t lessen her wrath.

All to soon he arrives at the door to Dis’ rooms. For a second he considers knocking but Thorin has never done so with his sister before and to start now would be to add to the distance that will no doubt lie between them when Dis hears the whole tale of the quest. He enters the room and looks around. His sister-sons had cleaned it of dust in preparation of Dis arriving but they hadn’t gotten around to replacing much of the rotted furniture. What furnishings there are have plainly come from elsewhere. Dis sits on a chest that has been dragged to a wrought metal table, a plate of food before her as well as a jug and two cups. Thorin seats himself on the other chest and pours them both a drink. Dis doesn’t acknowledge his presence until she has finished her meal. Only when the plate is clear does she look up and frown.

“Fili and Kili have brought me up to date.” she said finally “It sounds like you have been very lucky not to lose anyone along the way, both on the way here and in the battle.”

All Thorin can think of is Bilbo’s blood splattered over the stones “I know.” He chokes out and Dis looks at him sadly.

“I’m very angry with you right now.” she says, her expression becoming intense “I am furious at you for convincing me to let the boys go but I am even more angry at myself for giving in. Whatever was I expecting from your half-baked scheme?!”

She took a deep breath “And even if killing Smaug had gone entirely to plan it was stupid to believe that a dwarf of Durin’s line would be able to withstand the call of gold sickness after spending much of their life wishing for riches. We are both fools, Thorin!”

“I’m sorry” he says and the inadequacy of the words burns.

The room descends into tense silence after that. Dis is too angry to form words and Thorin too ashamed. She is clearly furious at him but she doesn’t hate him, even after all he has done! He cut off Kili’s arm, surely if anything would make her hate him it would be that?

After a minute he cannot bear to watch her stare at him and fixes his gaze on the tabletop. He should tell her of his plans while there is still time, though he fears that the revelations of the past few hours are too fresh and painful for them to talk of state. Thorin has come to realise he can be cruel sometimes, in an unthinking way – just look at his treatment of Bilbo! – but he does not want to torment his sister further under the pretence of the ‘greater good’.

He has obviously been thinking too loudly as Dis demands “What is it you are not telling me?”

Thorin swallows nervously “I am intending on abdicating.” He says “I may have reclaimed Erebor but I am not suitable to rule it.”

“What?” Dis’ fist impacts with a reverberating clang on the tabletop. He looks up almost fearfully. He has never seen her so angry before, she is utterly terrifying and for a second Thorin feels very small. She looks like Thror did in the later stages of his madness, that her fury is over her family and not gold is the only thing that stops him recoiling. “How dare you, Thorin! Fili is by no means ready to sit on the throne, he’s still recovering from his wounds and besides he is scarcely older than a boy!”

“I have changed the succession laws; Fili is no longer first in line.” He interrupted.

Dis’ eyes widened, her rage dissipates and falls away in stages to be replaced by shock “Surely not? You want me to rule?”

“You have far more experience leading than I do, and you don’t have my reputation. Who would trust a King that had publicly tried to murder one of his closest friends? All people see when they look at me is my treachery!”

“In time they’ll be able to look past that though.” Dis protested.

“In time! How long will it take though? Erebor needs allies to trade with now and that won’t happen when they don’t trust the ruler not to stab them in the back! I will not let our people starve again!!”

“Surely many wouldn’t approve of a woman as King under the Mountain?” Dis’ expression was conflicted. She had always wanted the throne far more than her older siblings but had been resigned to never sitting upon it.

“They already approve of you more than they do of me. When I changed the succession laws there were very few protests. Now that many of our people are here from Ered Luin I reckon you will have even more support. You are the one that has led Durin’s Folk best during our exile, Dis.”

“That’s not fair, Thorin. You were doing what was necessary for our survival when you left.” She scolded.

“Yes, but most people don’t know that. What they do know is that you have lead them in my place for some of our most difficult years. Our people love you, Dis!”

“I’ll consider it.” Dis eventually relented. “Give me a couple days to think this over”

That is likely the best he is going to get for now. He sighs. “Thank you. The coronation is scheduled for two weeks from now so there is a little time.”

Dis nods and that is the topic is finished. Thorin drinks some of his watery ale and makes a face at the weak taste.

“I never asked, how was the journey?” he asks feeling painfully like one of the hobbit relations Bilbo had so enjoyed complaining about.

Dis snorts a little “Well it wasn’t as eventful as I heard yours was! The weather was awful and we had some problems with flooding but there were no wargs or goblins.” She sighs “I wish I had known of the battle sooner, returning home has not been how I had imagined it.”

“I am sorry I could not get word to you.” Thorin says heavily.

Dis sighs again “I think I wish to retire, brother. I am tired from the journey and I have much to consider.”

“Of course.” Thorin rises stiffly. He wants to hold Dis close, maybe everything would feel more real if he did, but he doesn’t. Instead he leaves.


April TA 2942

“Bard, what brings you here?” Thorin asks as Bard enters the main gates of Erebor, dismounting and handing the reins of his towering horse to a waiting dwarf. He is dressed in simple clothes that are suitable for the currently rather changeable weather so Thorin expects he is not here for an overly serious matter – or at least officially. Bard’s expression is stern but that does not mean anything in itself. Thorin respects Bard but Bard is still very wary of him – and rightfully so.

Bard approaches until he towers over Thorin “I have a matter I would like to discuss with you” he looks around at the busy entranceway “I think it is a matter that would require a more private setting.” Thorin nods and they head further into the mountain, acquiring Balin and Dis on the way.

Finally sequestered in a small meeting room, Bard gets to the point of his visit “I wanted to discuss the Arkenstone’s continued presence in Dale.”

Thorin feels somewhat sick.

“I do not feel comfortable keeping it” Bard continues “is it not of great importance to dwarves?”

“It is important yes.” Dis says with a quick look at Thorin “But not for the right reasons. It is part of what drove our grandfather, Thror, to madness and you know how that ended.”

Bard recoils “Well what do we do with it then? If it’s so dangerous I don’t want it in my lands!” his hand hovers over a slight lump in his coat and Thorin realises he has it with him.

“We should destroy it.” He declares, ignoring the alarm that brings to the part of his mind where the disease lingers. The others nod in agreement.

“Fetch Dori, or perhaps Ori and one of Dwalin’s Warhammers.” He commands and Balin leaves hurriedly.

Soon enough both Dori and Ori are standing before him looking a little nervous and Dwalin stands a step behind them, the massive hammer slung on his back and an eyebrow raised.

“What’s this about then?” Dwalin asks gruffly “What need do you have of my hammer but not me?”

Thorin doesn’t answer but turns to Dori and Ori “Which one of you is stronger?” He is sure that he could find a stronger dwarf if he looked but these two were the strongest of the company and he wanted to keep this matter among those he trusted. He is sure that the massive water-driven hammers by the main forges would do a better job but they are so exposed they would likely have to close off that entire section to have any kind of privacy and that would draw a horrendous amount of attention. He wanted this done and done quickly, before he had time to hesitate.

The two brothers glance at each other before Dori answers “I believe I am, Thorin.”

“Well now all we need is an anvil, let us relocate to the forges.” They leave the meeting room and head for the small forge reserved for the royal family where they will likely have the most privacy. Thorin leads the way, for he feels like if he slows even for a moment then his resolve will break. The others straggle behind like beads on a string and soon enough he is pushing open the doors and ushering out the dwarf that tends the furnace and locking the door behind him.

Bard slowly removes a pouch from his coat. He unties the laces that hold it shut but Thorin shouts for him to stop. If they see it then they will forget their purpose.

“Balin, check that it is indeed the Arkenstone in there and put it on the anvil. Don’t take it out.” He commands.

Dwalin, Dori and Ori start and Ori gasps as they are given the first hint of their purpose here. Balin takes the bag from Bard and looks inside, his serious expression becoming one of awe.

“Balin.” Dis tries to catch his attention but he continues to stare mindlessly. It is the stone’s last attempt at saving itself.

“Balin!” Dwalin shouts and he jolts, dropping the pouch. The Arkenstone spills out and Thorin jerks away from it before he can be ensnared. Even that brief glimpse is enough to waken the dark whispers and he can feel his will wavering. The room is suddenly suffocatingly warm and his thoughts feel fuzzy and feeble. Surely they don’t need to destroy it? It was such a beautiful thing after all, couldn’t they just lock it away or hide it? There was no need to be hasty!

No! No! No! what was he thinking!? He struggles against the greed that is flooding through his veins. Sweat rolls down from his forehead though he isn’t sure if it was from the sweltering heat or the strain of remaining still. His body feels heavy and unwieldy and wouldn’t he just feel better if he turns back around? Just one more look couldn’t hurt? Could it?

There is a tremendous smashing noise and Thorin is awoken from the reverie he had fallen into.

He slowly turned around and saw that it had been done. The Arkenstone lay upon the anvil, smashed irreparably into many, many fragments. It was still beautiful but the light that had once danced in its depths and entranced him so was gone. Now it was just a shattered gemstone.

The madness still whispered at the edges of his mind but it was no worse than when he saw someone wearing an ornate broach or with excessive numbers of gold beads in their beard.

Dori drops the hammer with a terrible clang and stumbles away. He hugs his brother tightly with a shaky laugh. Dwalin seems to barely notice the mistreatment of his weapon and Balin is clearly shaken by how easily the Arkenstone affected him. Dis looks at him with approval and Bard is confused but very obviously relieved that the Arkenstone is no longer his problem.

The Arkenstone will never be anyone’s problem again.


April TA 2942

“What was it like, meeting a halfling?” Dis asks idly as she looks over some documents. They are sat before the fire in Thorin’s rooms for the evening. Thorin has been practicing writing left-handed as his right is still not dextrous enough and while he can get a scribe to write most things for him, his signature remains in an embarrassing state. He lays down his quill to turn to look at her.

“Surely you’ve met one before? Didn’t you pass the Shire on your way to Erebor?” he replies confusedly.

“Oh sure I’ve seen them in the distance but as soon as you have a large caravan of dwarves with you they disappear like rabbits into those burrows of theirs.” She waves a hand in demonstration.

Thorin thinks of what he knows of hobbits as a people and realises that much of it is extrapolated from one singular individual.

“Well to start with many hobbits would take offense at being called ‘halflings’” he grinned “they seem to be a fussy lot, although that might have just been Bilbo.”

“Well what was this Bilbo like?” she asks “I hear a lot about him from the rest of your company but you never say anything of him.” There is a glint in her eye alongside the curiosity that Thorin had expected that reminds him of a cat on the hunt.

“He… he was a valuable member of the company” he says stiffly.

Dis looks positively gleeful and remarks “How descriptive.”

Thorin glowers at her but continues “He wasn’t a warrior or a traveller by any means but he still joined us despite there being very little reason he do so for he had little care for gold. He tricked his way out of several predicaments, saved the entire company more than once and had the courage to face Smaug alone.”

“Sounds less like a rabbit and more like a fox.” Dis joked.

“I do not think Bilbo is typical of hobbits.” He says proudly and stifles a laugh. He thinks of the way Bilbo would look if told he was like either animal, indignant and scrunching his face up into one of the seemingly hundreds of different disapproving expressions he could make and feels an overwhelming fondness.

“So that is why you gave him the mithril shirt.” Thorin jerks away from where he was observing the fire to face her once more.

“I did wonder when the boys told me of it but I wasn’t sure because of the manner of his departure” Thorin flinched. The gross understatement of what had happened to Bilbo only emphasised the ugliness of it.

“I…” he doesn’t know what to say. He wants to explain the pain he had felt then, the awful vulnerability of being betrayed by the one he loved but it would seem like he was making excuses and there are none to be made for what he did.

Dis breaks the silence first some minutes later “I’ve considered what you suggested when I first returned to Erebor.” Her tone is entirely neutral, as featureless as a freshly frozen river.

“And your decision?” he asks, suddenly fighting back cloying nervousness.

“I accept.” The words feel like a physical blow but Dis still speaks “I believe that you could still be a great ruler but you are correct that Erebor cannot spare the time it would take for our people to regain their trust in you.”

He nods and gives her a very slightly strained smile. This is what he wanted but it still hurts to recognise that he has failed in his duty “Then I wish you the very best in your rule.”

Dis smiles back “You know your company are going to be furious with you when they discover that you’ve kept your plans for abdication from them.”

“I know.” He sighs “Balin and Dori know of the plan else it wouldn’t work but the rest will not be pleased.”

“You won’t tell Nori or Dwalin?” Dis asked incredulously.

“No, I’m not telling anyone that might be of a mind to try and stop this.”

Dis sighed “Well if you’re sure, but you can deal with them after they find out.”

“Fine.” He agreed with a grimace.


May TA 2942

“Good evening, Nori.” Thorin says when he enters his office to find his spymaster perched on top of the bookshelf.

Nori only grunts in response.

“Is there a problem?” Thorin asks. Nori shrugs listlessly and Thorin frowns. Nori was still far quieter than he had been before the battle of the five armies but in the months since he had become Thorin’s spymaster he had become far more comfortable in the presence of others.

Thorin sits at his desk and begins to look over the pile of documents gathered there. Maybe if he waits Nori will tell him what’s bothering him?

He looks over five petitions and a guild application before Nori speaks, his voice laden with derision.

“Did you really think you could get away with not telling me?”

Thorin looks up, alarmed.

“Nori-”

“I’m your spymaster, Thorin! When people start plotting and skulking about in this mountain its my job to know about it and you thought I wouldn’t notice?” He hissed and dropped down to the floor easily, his anger clearly displayed in his stiff posture.

“I thought you were different! I thought I could trust you but you’re just as bad as all those poncy folks back in Ered Luin that would sooner let us all starve than let their profits drop by a single coin! And all this time you’ve just been using me, being kind when I was struggling so I’d do whatever you wanted and now things have become difficult you’ll just… just pass me off to your sister without a word!?” Nori was shouting now, fists clenched tight. “We’ve come so far and you’re just going to give up?”


“I’m only doing what’s best for Erebor! Don’t you see that they all hate me?” Thorin protested “Nori, I promise I never meant for you for find out like this.”

“Then how did you mean for me to find out?” he sneered “Did you plan to tell me before your abdication or was I supposed to find out along with everyone else?”

Nori must see the guilt on his face as his expression somehow turns even uglier “I don’t know if I’m more disgusted at you or myself. You’d better pray to Mahal that there aren’t any more attempts on your life because I’m not sure I’m of a mind to stop them.”

He turns to leave then but Thorin, against his better judgement, catches his sleeve. Nori’s hand reflexively snaps down to one of the knifes at his belt. He doesn’t draw it, only half turns to face him.

“Promise me you won’t tell anyone… or try to stop me.” Thorin begs.

Nori eyes him impassively.

“I really am sorry! I only did what I thought was necessary.” he says.

“Very well, I’ll keep your secret.” He tugs his sleeve out of Thorin’s grip harshly “You’re a coward, Thorin Oakenshield. Maybe it’s for the best that you’re doing this.”

Nori leaves, the door crashing shut behind him, and Thorin collapses back into his chair with a groan.


May TA 2942

It was the night before the coronation and Thorin felt almost sick with worry.

Ever since Nori confronted him Thorin had felt increasingly conflicted – not about the coronation itself but that he was hiding his plans from those close to him. The ceremony was in the morning and the majority of his company (his friends!) still didn’t know.

He looked around at their happy faces round the table. What he had to say before the evening was out could destroy that happiness – even make them hate him – but it needed to be done regardless. Not confiding in Nori had been a mistake and he intended not to repeat it.

They were eating together in a little hall in the royal wing of the mountain. Nori was absent but the rest of the company were there as well as Dis. Nori’s empty chair had received some concerned looks from the rest of the company but Thorin didn’t think any of them knew enough to guess correctly. Those of the company that knew of his plans for tomorrow were eying him pointedly, Balin especially was shooting him beseeching looks frequently enough it was impressive no one else had noticed yet.

Thorin waited until the meal was finished and everyone had relaxed to their fullest before standing. The quiet conversations halted and every eye in the room was on him.

“My friends, tomorrow is the day we have all long awaited. The throne of Erebor will finally be occupied by one of Durin’s line again and the decline our people have suffered this past century will come to an end. However,” he paused, struggling to find the right words “I won’t be the one ruling-”

“What?!” he was interrupted by Dwalin, who also stood.

“What do you mean?” Dwalin demanded, fists clenched so his knuckles shone white “What have you done?”

“I changed the succession laws months ago to give women the same rights to the throne as men so that Dis is next in line after me. She will be the next ruler of Erebor.”

He looked around at the company. Those that had already known looked fairly neutral but the others were openly conflicted.

“Why?” Dwalin asked raggedly “I thought…” he trailed off upset.

“It’s what’s best for Erebor. No one will trust Erebor while I rule and we need to rebuild our relationships as quickly as possible! Besides Dis will make a good King, maybe a better one than me…”

“Uncle Thorin…” he turned and saw Fili and Kili looking at him. Neither of them seem to know what to say next. No one else in the room could seem to find any words either, the initial confusion being replaced by hurt and disappointment. Thorin desperately wanted to be anywhere else and made his excuses and fled for the night.


May TA 2942

Thorin fussily tucks a stay lock of hair back into place in his sister’s elaborately braided hair as they wait in the antechamber off the hall of kings. Dis slaps his hand away impatiently.

“I think I am quite ready now, Thorin.” She tells him regally. He steps back and regards her critically. The extravagant dark blue fur-lined robes that bear the sigil of Durin that Thorin had convinced Dori to make in secret suit her well and the sight brings a smile to his face.

“Oh stop standing there looking soppy” Dis flaps a hand at him embarrassedly. Thorin grins before schooling his features back into an appropriate level of sobriety when he hears the rumbling of the great doors closing. It is time for the ceremony.

Thorin steps out into the hall and it falls silent. He is also dressed richly in a less extravagant version of Dis’ attire. He begins the long walk down the hall to the dais where the throne sits. The hall is packed, and not just with dwarves, it feels as if half of middle earth is in the hall. Here for the coronation of the King Under the Mountain, only not the one they are expecting. Save from the company and a few others whose cooperation he had required no one knew what he was about to do. The prospect made him feel slightly queasy.

He passes Lord Elrond and his delegation which has merged with that of the ambassador from Mirkwood. Thranduil had declined to attend in person and Thorin took some savage glee from the thought of Thranduil’s dismay at missing his abdication.

On the other side there is predominantly men. Gondor and even distant Rohan are present in force and watch with some excitement. Bard and his people have been given a position closer to the front as a show of respect and the close ties they hoped to build. Bard looks just as grim as always but his children appear excited, if uncomfortable in their stiff formal clothes.

He is reaching the front of the hall now and dwarves from a great deal of the crowd and are stood in front of the elves and men. They have come from every remaining mountain, colony and crevice to witness the crowning of the next King of Kings and Thorin suddenly feels awfully nervous. This could go terribly wrong in so many ways.

Thorin steps up onto the dais and turns to face the crowd.

“I am honoured to at last welcome you all to the Kingdom of Erebor! We are gathered to witness the coronation of the next King under the Mountain!” There was a low murmur in the crowd, this was not how coronations traditionally went.

“But first. I must declare that I am abdicating as King of Durin’s Folk and that I renounce my place in the line of succession for the throne of Erebor.” He drew the ceremonial knife from his belt and in one clean stroke severed the plait that marked him as king. There were shouts from the dwarves in the crowd, though in the cacophony it was hard to tell if they were shocked, fearful or angry. The big folk did not understand the significance of what he had done so well but had backed up a little, away from the shouting mass of dwarves.

Thorin looked at the braid he held in his hand a little dazed. There was no going back now. To cut off his king’s braid he had irrevocably renounced his claim to the throne and with so many witnesses too! He sheathed the knife shakily before he could drop it.

Before proceedings could fully devolve into chaos the trumpets sounded and Dis entered. The crowd stilled and was silent as she walked down the hall. She looked every inch the ruler she had been born to be and Thorin felt his smile returning. At the sight of her the crowds calmed once more. She arrived at the dais and Thorin stepped down from the platform to bow deeply and offer her the severed braid, a sign that he approved of her taking his rightful place. She took it and he retreated to the front of the crowd where the company were gathered.

Balin then stepped forward with the crown held carefully between his hands. It was not the bulky lump of gold the raven crown had been but it still bore the angular lines typical of dwarven designs. It was made of mithril and many small, blue-black sapphires were inlaid in the geometric patterns that only in the vaguest sense echoed the design of a raven in flight. He had once heard Bofur say about his hat that ‘either you wear the hat or the hat wears you’ and at the time he had thought it a silly nonsensical remark but now he rather suspected it extended to crowns. The crown was beautiful and Thorin makes sure not to look at it too long in case it reawakens the sickness, but he is certain it will not diminish his sister.

He spends much of the ceremony in a daze but he is still aware that Dis gives her vows without pause and Balin places the crown on her head before Dis sits upon her throne. Then it is time for fealty to be sworn and Thorin is the first to kneel before the throne. He swears to be loyal to her and her line. He swears other things too, though the first is the most important then he returns to the crowd. Fili and Kili take his place before the throne where she names them her heirs, not that anyone was surprised at that. Then Dain goes up and then the company and many many more after. There are dwarves present from all corners of middle earth to swear fealty and soon Thorin has quite lost track of who is who.

Finally, the ceremony is over and the hall slowly empties. There is a feast in the mountain’s other massive hall and Thorin knows he should go but he instead hides behind a pillar and sinks down to sit in the shadow it casts. None of the company look for him but he doesn’t let that bother him. He needs space more than everything else right now. He touches the place his king’s braid had been and feels overwhelmed and small, weak. It is not every day one gives up on their life’s goal, their purpose.

He is no longer a King or a Prince or even a King-in-exile. For the first time he is just Thorin.

Notes:

I'm using the title 'King' as gender neutral here partially for plot reasons >:D but also because I'm headcanon-ing that as the dwarves have never had a Queen that has actually ruled rather than being a King's consort the khuzdul words are more tied to the roles than the genders. Basically I enjoy mucking up gendered language and if you know the neo-khuzdul dictionary and it says otherwise please leave me to my ignorance!

Who knows when the next chapter is coming out! It's been the hardest one to work on so far and is going to be called 'departure'. Good news for Bilbo lovers though - the chapter after the next one is massive and is from his POV (and is possibly my favourite).

Chapter 5: Departure

Notes:

Here is the next chapter! I didn't write as much as I planned but I haven't had much time to write (I moved house again and now I have a flatmate!). I don't think there are any warnings if you have gotten through the rest of this fic! It's just some regular old sad boi hours (years??).

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

April TA 2943

“Uncle! Uncle Thorin! Answer the door!!” Thorin ignores the hammering at the door and puts his hands over his ears. He doesn’t think he could bear company right now but he especially doesn’t want to have to appear strong for Fili. He listens to Fili bang on the door a while longer before there is a frustrated huffing noise. Thorin thinks Fili has lost patience but soon enough there is a grating of metal on metal and Thorin realises Fili is attempting to pick the lock. Last Thorin checked this was not something Fili was able to do – and as crown prince it should have remained that way! He sighs before rising and storming over to the door. His approach must have been heard as there are no lockpicks in the keyhole when he unlocks the door and throws it open. Fili is revealed on the other side, looking sheepish and holding some thin pieces of iron.

“What do you think you are doing?” Thorin says in his most disapproving tone, arms crossed.

“I… Uh…” Fili looks much like a dwarfling caught with his hand in the biscuit tin and shuffles his feet guiltily. He slips the tools into his pockets as if Thorin hasn’t already seen them.

“It’s Nori that’s teaching you, isn’t it.” Thorin says flatly as he pulls his sister-son into the room.

“Maybe?” Fili says, already cringing at the telling off he’s going to receive “I asked him to show me after those iron hills dwarves attacked you” he looks away “I realised that one day I will probably be king and it’ll be me that our enemies come after and I want to be able to defend myself!”

He places a hand on his shoulder, the rant that had been building stolen away by Fili’s earnestness. “I’m sure when the time comes you’ll have far fewer enemies than me and I’m glad that you are trying to prepare yourself” he then frowns “But I would suggest that in future you practice more discreetly and not by trying to break into my rooms – or anyone else’s – unless you want your mother to hear about what you’ve been up to?” Fili pales dramatically.

“Yes, uncle.” Fili says with a nod and a sheepish grin before his expression changes. Thorin can see the unspoken ‘I wouldn’t have tried to break in if you’d opened the door’ written clearly across Fili’s face but it appears that his sister-son has become quite the diplomat since the mountain was reclaimed. Instead he says, carefully: “Amad is worried about you.”

Thorin frowns and says stiffly “I am perfectly fine.”

“Well maybe you should come tell her yourself!” Fili says hopefully “It’s been ages since anyone has seen you.”

He looks down and picks at a loose thread on the hem of his shirt. If he sees Dis she will likely be wearing all her finery and he doesn’t know how well he can hold back the madness currently. Fili is dressed simply as if for arms practice so there is nothing to trouble him there but Dis surely will not be so plain. Besides, he is in no state to be walking about the mountain – he can feel his greasy hair sticking to the back of his neck and the tunic he wears is dirty. “I’m sure she’s busy. I wouldn’t want to draw her away from her work.”

Fili looks sad and says “She’s not been angry with for some time, you know. About the quest.”

“I know.” Thorin replies but doesn’t explain himself further. How does he explain what is wrong to Fili, who he has helped raise since he was little more than an infant – or to anyone for that matter? Up until a fortnight ago he was to be the King of Kings and a king must be a pillar of stability and strength. Kings cannot afford to show vulnerability or weakness. Thorin no longer knows how to let himself.

“Then why are you shutting yourself away like this? Is this about Kili and me?” Fili demands.

Thorin shakes his head “No. Such things happen in battle.”

“Then what is wrong?” Thorin thinks he is going to ask if it is Bilbo that is the problem but Fili (sensibly) once again skirts around the ever-present oliphaunt in the mineshaft. Thorin considers not answering but Fili has been far more patient with him than he should have needed to. It would be unkind to simply brush away his concern.

“I don’t know what to do, Fili.” He admits finally “I’m not needed anymore.” The rest of what he would say remains locked behind his teeth, even admitting this much aloud and to his sister-son is hard.

“Well right now you should come out of this room and see everyone, Uncle.” Fili tugs his arm lightly with a small smile “You can consider the future after you have reassured everyone of your health.”

“Fine.” He shrugs on a coat and moves to follow Fili. They stop by the royal baths so that Thorin can make himself at least somewhat presentable and when Thorin rises from the steaming water half an hour later he feels a great deal more like himself.

By now it is evening and they find Dis in her quarters enjoying a meal with Kili. There are two unoccupied places already set out so presumably this had been intended as a family dinner.

“Uncle!” Kili cries excitedly, narrowly avoiding spraying Thorin with half-chewed food.

He looks so pleased to see Thorin and Fili that his resemblance to a well-fed puppy almost hurt. Despite everything that has happened to him, Kili has retained some of his youthful glee and Thorin is unbelievably glad. He takes his place at the table and tries his best to pretend he has an appetite.

The others chatter about various light matters and while Thorin doesn’t contribute to the conversation he enjoys listening. Despite his own troubles it brings him some amount of contentment to watch the rest of his family so happy and carefree.

Then Fili asks, smiling as if he isn’t about to bring Thorin’s fragile world down around his ears, “So what are you going to write in your reply to Bilbo?”

The words hit him like a cave in and he reels in his seat as he processes them “Reply?” he asks a little incredulously.

Kili looks at him rather unimpressedly and says with the unintentional bluntness of the oblivious “You really need to get out more, Uncle!” Dis looks a complicated mixture of agreeing, embarrassed and apologetic at her youngest’s shocking lack of tact.

“A letter from Bilbo Baggins addressed to Balin arrived last week.” She tells him, speaking over Fili and Kili who had begun a whispered argument.

“I haven’t read it myself but I heard the gist is that he heard you were no longer King and was concerned for you.” Thorin received the news wide eyed and feeling a little faint.

Bilbo was concerned for him? Bilbo had gone to the bother of writing a letter and managed to find a way to get it to the other side of the world specially to check up on him?

He still cared?

He wanted to laugh at the ridiculousness – what sane being would still care about someone after being treated the way he had Bilbo. His behaviour had been shameful, disgusting, beastly and Bilbo still cared?

He laughed bitterly and stood “I’m going to bed.”

“Thorin-” Dis began, tone sympathetic, but he cut her off.

“Good night.” He said curtly and left before anyone else could try to hinder him.

The walk back to his rooms felt as if he was alternately doused with magma and ice water. He couldn’t decide if the letter had been written out of concern or the infamous inquisitiveness and need for gossip that characterised the stereotypes of hobbits. He supposed he would have a better chance of knowing if he read the letter himself but then the others would expect him to write a reply. A reply wouldn’t break his promise to Gandalf seeing as it was Bilbo that had begun correspondence but to Thorin it would still feel as if he was forcing his no doubt unwanted company upon him.


May TA 2943

“Do you really have to leave?” Dis asked quietly as she hugs him “I know you feel guilty but you don’t have to do this, Thorin.”

Dis looks just like she did all the countless times in the past when he left her behind in Ered Luin: worried and frustrated with her mouth set in a firm line. Their relationship can almost be defined by his absence and Thorin briefly closes his eyes to suppress an unexpected surge of emotion. So much has changed over the course of their lives but it appears the one constant is him leaving.

He returns the embrace “I can’t stay. Erebor has no need of me anymore and I am leaving her in the best of hands.”

Dis pulls away from him, her lips pressed tight and bloodless. Her stiff posture tells him more clearly than any words that she feels hurt and he thinks for a second that she’ll curse him as she always has previously but this time is different in yet another way. He is almost sorry she doesn’t, it would make him feel less awful about this. He supposes they have already argued enough on this in the weeks leading up to his departure. Dis didn’t understand why he has to leave – though Thorin barely knew himself. He loved Erebor, truly, but since his sickness his affection for the mountain had become an uncertain one. He still loved it but now that feeling was tainted by the knowledge of what had happened when he let that emotion corrupt him. He could never feel the same way about Erebor now without remembering what he had done and doubting himself. The mountain amplified his already crushing guilt and Thorin needed to leave. It felt like running away (and it was) but Thorin was tired of the cycle of negative emotions he had trapped himself in.

“Fine.” Her voice is too steady, an obvious façade. “You can go off and be a fool once again but you will still be welcome in Erebor when you’re ready to come back.” She steps back so that Fili and Kili frame her, the rest of the company arrayed to either side having already said their own goodbyes.

“Thank you, I’ll remember that.” The words sound empty and Thorin himself can’t tell if he means it genuinely. He adjusts his pack one final time before turning and leaving out of Erebor’s grand entrance. He turns to look once, far out of earshot so he can’t be tempted back by a call. He is too far to distinguish individuals but he fancies much of the company is still there, watching.


September TA 2943

Bree was a muddy bustling mess, just as Thorin remembered it. An unglamorous mixing point for dwarves, men and hobbits. Thorin tried not to stare at the hobbits – the first he had seen since his deplorable actions on the ramparts. Those found here were a hardier breed than those he had seen in the Shire but they still had that fussy particular way of doing things like their softer cousins. They scurried about, soft ringlets of hair shining in the sun and not a speck of dirt on their clothes despite the thick layer of mud underfoot.

Thorin caught himself staring after the hobbits that crossed his path and scolded himself. Bree was never a wise place to attract attention, despite its proximity to the Shire, and him pining over Bilbo would only bring him grief. As it was he had not fully intended on coming to Bree but his capricious sense of direction had conspired with his heart and here he was.

He was so close to Bilbo now and the thought sent both thrills of excitement and dread through him. he longed to see his hobbit again, it was an ache that had never faded in the last two years and showed no signs of starting to now. Surely with Hobbiton so close he could just go for a day’s stroll and check up on his burglar? Not meet him, just see if he was alright… No. Bilbo might see him and Thorin did not deserve to disturb his no doubt peaceful life once more. Besides Gandalf would happily skin him alive if he visited Bilbo!

He took one last long look down the road to the Shire before shaking himself and turning away, ignoring the cloying feeling of emptiness.

It would be better off for everyone if he minded his own business! Thorin turned North to the road to Fornost, and eventually Ered Luin.

He supposed it had been some years since he had last seen the sea.


November TA 2943

He stumbles down the sand dune and is hit in the face by a gust of salty, sand-filled air. Thorin sags in exhaustion and kneels in the sand. The rhythmic crash of the grey wind-pushed waves on the pale sand is nostalgic of times years past. Precious times spent with family and friends, rare outings to this very beach with Fili and Kili when they were small and watching them pile the sand into simple structures.

Today the beach is empty and the realisation drains the warmth brought by fond memories. The wind whistles shrilly through the loose pale sand. It sounds eerie, a sound reserved for the empty places where no race dares tread.

What am I doing here? He asks himself.

He has walked as far west as he can go, thousands of miles from Erebor and the actions he would forget but they still loom in his mind. Distance has not brought him the solace he sought.

He is just alone.


March TA 2944

Thorin trudges next to the wagon in silence while the humans chatter around him. After spending the winter in Ered Luin he had decided to leave at the soonest opportunity. Being in a familiar place that was not intrinsically linked with his most shameful moments was a relief but it had been terribly lonely. The small house they used to live in had been far too small for a family of four and would be considered a hovel by Erebor’s standards but now it stood empty and felt far too roomy. For that fact much of Ered Luin lay empty, much of the population having left for Erebor. Very few of the dwarves Thorin cared for had stayed behind so it had been an empty homecoming.

Eventually the first hints of spring had arrived and Thorin had joined the first caravan heading East. The humans tolerated his presence but they were a hardy lot that hadn’t survived by being trusting so he was very much held at arm’s length. They welcome his skill at arms though – not even a week ago he had fended off a trio of starving wolves and since then they had become somewhat more open.

The caravan was headed all the way to Rohan, though Thorin hadn’t quite decided if he would go with them all that way and if he did where he would go next. He enjoyed wandering more than he expected. It was the closest he had ever come to feeling free – no one depended on him now, he could go wherever he fancied whenever and no one he loved would face the consequences later. He had never experienced freedom on this scale before – he could just head off into the open country at this instant and no one would care! Often the aimlessness made him feel hollow but the rest of the time he revelled in it.

There was a small disturbance in the bushes at the side of the road, then another rustle on the other side. Thorin moved more on instinct than anything else, his hand moving to draw his sword before he was properly aware of it.

There is a whistling noise and Thorin is struck hard from behind. He falls to the ground, sword spinning out of his suddenly weak grip. He doesn’t feel any pain, only surprise and confusion as heavily armed ragged men burst out of the undergrowth on either side of the road, crying for blood.

He sits up, scrabbling for his sword with his right hand when his left one remains fumbling and weak. There are screams and shouting all around him, friend and foe blurring together so he slashes at anyone who comes too close. He can already see that the travellers are loosing the battle but there is nowhere to run – at least not for someone slow like a dwarf.

He does his best against the ever-worsening odds. There are three men facing him at once when he trips on a corpse. A line of scorching pain is scored along his side, an off-balance twisting dodge all that kept his guts inside him. The leftover momentum from avoiding the blow sends him careening into a half-collapsed wagon. His head smacks into solid wood and the last thing Thorin hears in the final flickers of consciousness is the clang of Orcrist dropping from his nerveless hand and hitting the wood planking.

Notes:

The next chapter is titled 'Bilbo' and is already written (though it needs editing still). Despite being so late in the story it is one of the first that I worked on and it is around 10k words and I am hyped about it! Sadly I have only written one scene for the final chapter so far and I still don't know exactly how I am going to end it so I might be a while! The other day I read my notes I wrote when I started this story over a year ago and I found it very interesting how different it is to what I have written.

Chapter 6

Notes:

So after the cliff-hanger I left things on last time we are having a change in pace this chapter and seeing what Bilbo has been up to all this time.

A few OCs are featured in this chapter but where possible I have used canon characters.

Mild warnings for minor character death, violence, permanent injuries and recovery from said injuries, a touch of fantasy racism (in the form of Hobbits having small town mentality), loneliness.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

August TA 2942 (Wedmath 1342 Shire Reckoning)

Bilbo sat back on his heels and sighed as he wiped the sweat from his eyes with the back of an earth-stained hand. The summer heat hung heavily in the air but he was enjoying how glorious it felt to be able to achieve something with his own hands. The sun was out, the birds were calling to each other sweetly and he was in his garden – all was well!

“Master Baggins! Where do you want to plant your new herb garden?” Holman Greenhand, Gardner of Bag End, asked as he entered the garden. His young apprentice, Hamfast Gamgee, eagerly followed behind with a wheelbarrow full of the plants that were to go in the aforementioned herb garden. When Bilbo had upped and left so suddenly last year Holman had had to find other work elsewhere so the garden of Bag End had run quite wild. Some of the plants had survived but his herb patch had been completely chocked out by weeds.

Bilbo had only arrived back in the Shire in late July, a year and two months after he had set off, and Gandalf had finally left last week. Not that Bilbo truly wanted him gone! Gandalf had proven himself a true friend, it was just that as Bilbo had recovered Gandalf’s concern had become a little smothering. He was more mothering than Bilbo’s actual mother had been when he was a faunt! By the time they arrived back in the Shire and Gandalf found that the Sackville-Bagginses had recently moved into his smial, and Gandalf had singlehandedly chased them out not only of Bag End but the entirety of Hobbiton! The latest Bilbo had heard of them they had been making nuisances of themselves while staying with some cousins in Michel Delving.

Anyway, Gandalf had chased off the Sackville-Bagginses and then hunted down Bilbo’s auctioned things and stayed for some time until he at last deemed Bilbo well enough to look after himself (he had also heard some troubling rumours from outside the Shire and Bilbo suspected that had more to do with the date of his departure in the end). So Gandalf had departed and Bilbo was now revelling in his regained independence. Of course, he was still in quite poor health, though Bilbo suspected that some of his new pains would never leave. The elven healers had been sure to impress on him just how miraculous his survival had been and though Bilbo would never be as fleet of foot or spry as he had been he was determined to enjoy this second chance.

Bilbo gestured at the bed he was currently clearing of weeds as the new location for his herbs. “I think this patch here would work well.” The old location had sufficed well enough but after experiencing the flavours of the world outside the Shire Bilbo wanted to expand his herb collection and had made sure to pester Gandalf to get him seeds whenever possible on the journey back. At the thought of seeds he unconsciously patted his pocket, not feeling the comforting lump of the acorn from Beorn’s garden and panicking for a moment before remembering that he had planted it in a little pot that he would keep by the south-facing window in his bedroom until he was sure it would survive. He was a little worried it wouldn’t grow as it was summer now but he was determined to give it the best chance it could get. He had carried it too far to just give up! Thinking of the acorn always made his thoughts drift to Thorin and that made Bilbo morose so he hurriedly brought himself out of his musings before the melancholy could take hold.

Holman and Hamfast were now lifting the plants out of the wheelbarrow and trying to figure out the best way to plant them. The mint couldn’t go next to the thyme for instance as it would strangle it but the sage was going to have to be kept in check too… They mused over the problem for some time, occasionally rearranging the herb bushes and humming thoughtfully.

After half an hour or so of musing they came to an agreement and began to plant the herbs. Holman eyed Bilbo warily when he insisted on digging but he pretended to ignore the look. He was a little achy but he could still use a spade perfectly fine thank you very much!

He had the rosemary and the oregano sorted and was moving on to the sage when the ache in his right leg began to sharpen. Bilbo stepped off the flower bed to rub the tight muscles. His right side had been injured worst and he thought it likely that it had hit the ground first (though Bilbo was glad to know very little about the injuries his fall had inflicted save from the lingering effects). Holman glanced over a couple of times but continued the planting and Bilbo was glad for it – he had without a doubt had his fill of people highlighting his limitations and fussing for quite some time. Soon enough the pain had mostly receded and Bilbo returned to planting. Hamfast seemed to be in an uncharacteristically chatty mood and began to tell Bilbo of the tall tales that were currently doing the rounds of Hobbiton about where Bilbo had been. It was a pretty blatant attempt at getting the whole story from him but Bilbo liked the lad and was in an indulging mood so he was happy to tell him hints about how accurate the rumours were.

“…and he told me that you told him that the dwarves kidnapped you because they liked your cooking so much!”

Bilbo laughed at that “Well that would be quite something! - Put the parsley a little further to the left” he paused to gesture at the spot “The dwarves already had a cook in their company and, despite most dwarves hating vegetables, he was as fine a cook as many hobbits.”

“Oh. They don’t like vegetables?” Hamfast looked quite lost for words. “Even potatoes?” Bilbo heard a quiet snort from Holman. Hamfast had only begun his apprenticeship shortly before Bilbo had left last year but apparently he had quickly shown a passionate interest in the cultivation of potatoes and other tubers.

Bilbo laughed “No they like potatoes well enough, I suppose you would get along well with them in that regard.”

He looked relieved at that before returning to considering which rumours he thought were worthy of Bilbo’s attention “Bell thinks that Master Baggins killed a dragon but I told her that was stupid! Everyone knows dragons don’t exist anymore!”

Bilbo tried keep any shock from showing on his face. He had obviously been unsuccessful though as he saw Holman narrow his eyes thoughtfully “Well of course I didn’t do that! They still exist though.”

Hamfast makes a slightly horrified ‘oh’ expression before asking “How do you know that? Did you see any?”

Bilbo feels himself begin to shake a little, he can almost smell his burnt foot hair again and without warning all the muscles in his right leg cramp up violently. The spade dropped to the ground and Bilbo followed, luckily avoiding the newly planted herbs and only getting a face full of soft shire dirt. The feel of earth on his face reminds him he is no longer in Smaug’s treasure hoard and despite the awful pain that is still shooting up his leg he immediately feels a lot better.

“Master Baggins!” Holman was at his side asking worriedly what he could do to help.

“I’ll be alright, Holman. Just done too much.” He gritted out as he carefully rolled onto his side so he could reach for his leg. He kneaded at the muscles but this time the pain and tightness barely lessened.

“Oh what did those dwarves do to you, Master Baggins?” Holman sighed “You were the most proper and respectable hobbit I had the pleasure of knowing and all it took was a wizard and a pack of grubby dwarves to ruin everything!”

Bilbo had to force himself not to scowl, after seeing so much of the world he was finding some of the prejudices of his fellow hobbits rather wearing and he didn’t appreciate their somewhat misguided sympathy so he couldn’t keep himself from replying. “They were decent folks actually, I would happily count all of them my friends even if their manners were somewhat underdeveloped!” he would go on but all he can think of is the vague fevered recollection he had of his departure from Erebor. The last time he had seen the Company they had all looked mournful but had made sure to treat him kindly. He wondered how they were doing now.

“I’m sure they were.” Holman doesn’t look at all convinced and the platitude makes Bilbo furious but he doesn’t say the retort his still quick mind formulates that makes his tongue itch at its bitterness. He was just trying to help, however much he has accidentally offended Bilbo.

Holman seems oblivious to how close he came to facing Bilbo’s ire and instead addresses his apprentice “Hamfast help me carry Master Baggins inside before he catches too much sun.”

The afternoon is indeed hot but very much past the hours where heatstroke would be a concern, though Bilbo allows himself to be carried indoors between the two gardeners anyway. He has grown unfortunately accustomed to being manhandled in the past months and has learned the hard way that sometimes it is best to accept other’s help. They brush the dirt from his feet and clothes and settle Bilbo in his bed with his cane within reach before returning to their work outside.

Bilbo lies quietly to wait for the pains in his leg to fade. He wants desperately to be healthy again but as he recovers situations like this are becoming more common when he overestimates his abilities. He listens to the sounds from outdoors: birdsong, a faint sigh of the wind in the grass and the occasional murmur of conversation. He hears someone call out a greeting to Holman and feels jealousy curdle inside him. Despite his reputation now being ruined Bilbo’s life now was settling into a close imitation of what it had been before he left: plenty of time to cook and garden (if he had the strength) with only the occasional duties to carry out with regards to his tenants or an invitation to afternoon tea.

He suspected the only reason he was being invited was to get the story of what he had done in his absence out of him – the types that were inviting him were either gossips or the sort that had some secret adventurous inclinations of their own – and while he had attended and been every inch the proper gentlehobbit he had also carefully deflected enquiries about where he had been. Bilbo wouldn’t have minded telling them of much of the journey but if he started they would winkle the whole sorry affair from him and Bilbo didn’t want the whole Shire to know about the what Thorin had done to him under the influence of gold madness… or Thorin at all really.

And that brought him to the heart of the matter. Having seen and done so much and made so many close friends returning to the Shire and the accompanying shackles of politeness and propriety was stifling. The Shire was comfortable and reassuring and familiar but it was also lonely. He had no close friends or family here and everyone in Hobbiton was too tied up in being respectable to fill the massive void Thorin’s company had left.

For the first time he properly realises that he actually misses his dwarves dreadfully. Gandalf had been shockingly stingy with details of the events after his fall and they had left while Bilbo had still been delirious from fever so he knew very little about how they fared. All Gandalf had been willing to admit was that there had been a battle, though not against the elves and men, and that all of the company had survived – though when he had said this he had looked pensive. He had refused to say anymore, insisting that Bilbo should forget about the company. It was an odd change in behaviour, though Bilbo suspected that Bilbo’s injuries had rattled Gandalf quite considerably if he was willing to look after him for so long.

He realised he was once again becoming melancholy and reached for the book he had taken to keeping by his bed for times like this. If he was to spend so much time resting he might as well get some reading done!


September TA 2942 (Winterfilth 1342 Shire Reckoning)

The knock came in the evening, just as Bilbo was washing up his plate from tea. It was an odd time for anyone to come calling and he wasn’t expecting visitors so Bilbo made sure to collect Sting as he limped to the front door. He opened the door a little and peered out and felt an intense bout of déjà vu. For there on his front porch was a dwarf! Admittedly not a dwarf he was familiar with but it was still an odd occurrence.

“Good evening” he greeted warily, though with some secret excitement “Can I help you Master Dwarf?” The dwarf had dark flowing hair, a carefully tended beard and appeared to be in his middle years. He was dressed for travel and bore an impressively large pack, though he was not as heavily armed as those in the Company had been and was clearly exhausted. He was awfully thin for a dwarf too and appeared to be alone.

“I would appreciate it if you could give me directions as I appear to have lost my way.” The dwarf produced a very ragged map and Bilbo immediately saw it was missing the section that held the Shire. “I tried asking the other halflings but none of them would talk to me and then I saw the rune on your door and I thought if anyone would help me it would be someone who lived in a burrow such as yours.” He gestured at the door and Bilbo peered at the outside of it to see that the rune that Gandalf had carved so long ago was still glowing gently. The dwarf’s choice in wording leaves something to be desired but he doesn’t seem to bear any malice towards hobbits so Bilbo decides he will look past the ‘halfling’ and ‘burrow’ comments.

“Oh!” Bilbo exclaimed before realising he was being quite rude “Please do come in Master Dwarf! I have numerous maps you can consult and you would be welcome to stay the night.” It was getting quite dark now and while the Shire was just as safe at night as at any other time it would be selfish of him not to offer his home when he had so much space.

Besides it would be lovely to have some dwarven company for an evening.

The dwarf frowns at him suspiciously and Bilbo thinks he is going to decline but he gives a little bow and introduces himself “Unnur… son of Minnur, at your service.”

“Bilbo Baggins, at yours.” He replies with a smile and ushers Unnur into Bag End.

He herds Unnur into the sitting room and leaves him to consult Bilbo’s maps while he hurries off to the kitchen to prepare a hearty supper. Bilbo is not himself particularly hungry but Unnur looks half-starved and it would be shameful if he didn’t do something to help. He sets about preparing a meal that would suit dwarven tastes: mainly meat and potatoes, though he does sneak some vegetables in where they are likely to go unnoticed. Soon enough there is stew in the oven and various dishes ready to fry or boil as required and Bilbo dashes back through his smial to air out a room for his visitor.

Soon enough they are sat at his dining table and Unnur looks about ready to cry at the quantity of food on the table. Bilbo tells him to help himself and pretends not to notice his appalling table manners. It appears that Unnur was indeed half starved as he puts away an impressive quantity of food and is still eager when Bilbo brings out the remaining cake he had made the day before.

Unnur insists on clearing up and while he does the job with less singing than previous company there is not a chip on the pottery or a bent fork to be seen and Bilbo feels perfectly content as they retire to the sitting room so Unnur can copy out the relevant sections of Bilbo’s maps. They smoke in companionable silence, the familiar harsh smell of the horrid leaf dwarves smoke making him feel nostalgic.

“Where is it you are travelling to, Master Dwarf?” he eventually asks, curious. Unnur narrows his eyes a little in suspicion but eventually answers. It has been so long since Bilbo has seen such a typically dwarvish expression and it makes Bilbo’s heart ache.

“To Erebor” he says succinctly.

“Isn’t it a bit late in the year to be travelling across the misty mountains?” Bilbo asked.

Unnur looks mulish but still replies so he cannot be as offended as he looks “I have heard that the Gap of Rohan remains open much longer than the other routes.”

Bilbo hums thoughtfully and they lapse back into silence.

“Have you done much travelling, Master Baggins?” Unnur asks after a few minutes.

Bilbo is unsure what to say. It would not be proper to tell a stranger the whole sorry tale.

“I went on an adventure once. Far to the east.” He says with a faint smile he cannot restrain as he thinks of the company. Oh how he misses them! “A most unseemly business, made me late for tea.” Bilbo says dryly and has to hold back a laugh at what past him would have thought of what Bilbo had been up to this last year.

Unnur looks bemused but is polite enough to leave it at that. Not long after he excuses himself as he has finished consulting Bilbo’s maps and plans to leave early in the morning.

Bilbo knows he should also go to bed as early for a dwarf is what a hobbit would consider an indecent time for one to be awake. Soon the sound of thunderous, rumbling snores fills his smial and the familiar sound makes Bilbo smile wistfully.

He sits and allows himself to think of other, less comfortable nights spent listening to similar snores until the fire has burned down and Bilbo finally retires for the night.

The next morning does indeed start unspeakably early and Bilbo almost falls asleep cooking the porridge. They eat once again in silence, Bilbo too groggy to make conversation and Unnur seems to be a quiet enough fellow anyway. He insists Unnur take some of the contents of his larder, knowing that the dwarf was well on his way to starving when he arrived. Unnur accepts grudgingly but insists that he will find a way to repay him someday and then he is leaving, a stocky figure disappearing round the corner and away.

Bilbo sits on the bench by his front porch when his poor leg becomes unwilling to support him any longer and stares at nothing in particular. It is rather chilly but soon the sun rises and Bilbo had forgotten in his months of convalescence how glorious it was to watch a sunrise, only he finds the sight has lost some of its splendour when there is no one else to watch it with.

He lights his pipe in the hopes that will raise his spirits but it is not the smell of Old Toby he wants right now.


November TA 2942 (Blotmath 1342 Shire Reckoning)

“Bilbo, my good friend!” Bilbo turns in surprise to hear such a familiar greeting while he carefully rubs his feet in the mat at the door of the Green Dragon. Rorimac Brandybuck is sat at a table with Odo Proudfoot and Otho Sackville-Baggins, clearly already having a merry time despite the relatively early hour.

“Rory! What a surprise!” he calls back and makes his way over through, making sure not to hit anyone’s feet with his cane in the crowded room. Rorimac drunkenly springs to his feet and enthusiastically shakes Bilbo’s hand and Bilbo is glad that someone is so keen to see him. He hadn’t planned on coming here tonight but when he had looked up at the sky and realised what day it was he had deemed himself of being in need of cheerful company.

“It’s great to finally see you again!” he beamed “It must have been over a year since we met last.” Bilbo sinks gratefully into the seat Rory offers and engages the others in the discussion of the weather that must precede all other conversation in the Shire. It seems Rory is the only one glad to see him: Odo is at best ambivalent to his presence and Otho is being his usual, awful self. Otho enquires in a rather disrespectful manner after Bilbo’s health with the cheeky remark that he should consider downsizing if he is struggling. As if!

Rory remains oblivious to the tensions and insists on getting Bilbo a drink despite Bilbo being even wealthier than ever due to the troll hoard now in his possession, but he accepts the drink graciously. The conversation turns to the usual gossip that hobbits so love. The ‘you won’t believe this’s and ‘well I never’s and ‘they did what?’s continue for quite some time before the conversation turns to some curious prodding at Bilbo’s extended absence which he fends off wearily. The conversation is then diverted by Otho boasting about the pristine state of his garden, despite it being winter and that nothing much is growing right now. What an idiot. Bilbo couldn’t help but tune him out after a while and turned to observe the rest of the room. It was busy tonight with many hobbits taking refuge from the increasingly long nights. Bilbo supposes he is here for a similar reason.

There were a couple dwarves sat on the other side of the room, one of whom Bilbo vaguely recognised as the travelling blacksmith that was wintering in the Shire. They kept on shooting looks at him when they thought he wasn’t looking and were whispering seriously to each other. It was all very odd as they didn’t look at anyone else the same way and Bilbo had never spoken to either of them. He drained his tankard and got up. The others barely noticed him leave, embroiled as they were in a somewhat drunken debate about who knew what.

He limped across the room to get a refill at the bar, pushing gently past other hobbits as he went. There was already a couple of Tooks shamelessly dancing on the table and Bilbo had a hard time avoiding flying ale and elbows. His course took him close to the dwarves’ table and he couldn’t help but overhear.

They were speaking in rapid Khuzdul but Bilbo heard both his own name and Thorin’s mentioned. The younger one stole another look across the room and seeing that Bilbo had moved and was now close to their table, jumped guiltily while the elder glowered unapologetically.

“Good evening, Master Dwarves.” He greeted them as if he hadn’t just overheard them talking about him.

“Is there a problem, halfling?” the older dwarf asked defensively, a hand straying beneath the table to where no doubt there was a weapon of some sort.

“Oh there’s no need for any of that. Durin’s day is no time for conflict.” Bilbo gave his most disarming smile “Bilbo Baggins, at your service” he gave a shallow bow and when he had straightened up again both dwarves were looking distinctly bemused.

“Frar son of Hrar and Loni son of Lori, at yours” the elder dwarf says, his expression softening a smidge but remaining suspicious as he introduces himself and his companion.

Bilbo wobbles slightly and has to steady himself against the table “Ah, may I sit with you? I find my legs struggling to hold me up.” Frar nods in assent and gestures to an empty seat which Bilbo falls into.

“Now I couldn’t help but notice the pair of you were staring at me earlier and I wondered if you had business with me.” he winces inside at his forwardness but he supposes these dwarves won’t appreciate him talking in circles.

“Business, no. We were simply wondering how common your name is, seeing as that other halfling yelled it so loud when you came in.” Frar admitted almost reluctantly.

“Oh I do suppose he was rather loud, my apologies.” Bilbo laughed “As far as I know I am the first, and only, of my name.”

“You are the Bilbo son of Bungo of Thorin Oakenshield’s company?” Loni gasps “But everyone says you are dead!”

“Dead!” Bilbo cries somewhat louder than he means to “I should think not! It’ll take a bit more than a little fall to do me in. Gracious, why would Thorin be telling people I’m dead?”

“Well I don’t know the details seeing as I haven’t been to Erebor but the rumour was that Thorin had you executed for stealing the Arkenstone, of course the rumour was also that you were a dwarfling rather than a halfling but no one really believes that this side of the Misty Mountains.” Frar shrugs.

“A dwarfing…?” he tried to wrap his head around that and failed before deciding to focus on the main issue “But didn’t Thorin try to deny it?”

“Of course he has but no one had seen you since before the battle”

“Oh. Well I must make sure the citizens of Erebor are informed of my not-dying. I don’t want Thorin to get into bother because of these rumours.”

Frar and Loni look at each other and frown. “You are aware that Thorin has abdicated?”

Bilbo grips the edge of the table tightly. “Wh-what? How? Who is King under the Mountain now then?!” He can hear a trace of hysteria in his voice.

“He abdicated at his coronation this May past and insisted that King Dis be crowned in his place.” Bilbo had to take a minute to puzzle out what month May was by the Shire reckoning and then he was aghast at the duration of his ignorance. He didn’t recall Thorin ever mentioning a dwarf by the name of Dis. Bilbo feels faint that after all they had worked for, all they had sacrificed that Thorin had failed to reach his final goal. It didn’t make sense though, why would Thorin just give up like that? Had someone forced him to? Had the gold sickness made a reoccurrence?

“You seem troubled, Master Baggins” Frar commented carefully.

“Why would Thorin abdicate? Being King under the Mountain was his greatest ambition.” Bilbo replied, trying to stop himself from wringing his hands.

“You worry for him even though he tried to kill you.” Bilbo looked up at the old dwarf. Frar’s steady gaze was free of judgement but also of understanding. Dwarves were not known for being free with forgiveness so Bilbo’s concern for his would-be killer was probably bewildering.

“Thorin was ill when… when I had my accident. He may be stubborn and arrogant and the most annoying person to ever exist sometimes but Thorin is a great dwarf who I happily followed to what I expected to be my death and I cannot imagine Erebor having a better king!” Bilbo glares at Frar and realises he has worked himself up into quite a state when he has to catch his breath. Some of the hobbits at nearby tables have stopped their conversations and are unashamedly watching and Bilbo knows that he is going to be the centre of the whole Shire’s attention for the next month at least.

“I’m sorry I didn’t mean to get angry.” He apologises to Frar and Loni with a little dip of his head.

“No matter,” Frar dismisses “it is good to hear that our once leader was not as dishonourable as we had heard.” Bilbo notices the delicate choice of wording and knows that Frar is still reserving judgement of his once king but doesn’t protest. He sees Odo approaching their table and knows this conversation will soon be ending.

“Is there any way you know of that I could get a letter to Erebor? I’ve already enquired with the Shire postal service but they said it would be quite impossible.”

“Impossible? I should think not!” Loni exclaims “There is a caravan every two months or so from New Belegost to Erebor that takes post and sometimes the ravens take more urgent messages.”

“I thank you for your assistance” Bilbo spotted Odo pushing his way over, moving with a purposefulness that didn’t bode well. He stood up stiffly “My cousin is approaching us, I’d better go. I wish you both a merry new year!” They all bowed to each other and then Bilbo left to intercept Odo.

Odo was strangely pale and more sober than Bilbo was expecting. He quickly dragged Bilbo out of the Green Dragon with scarcely a wave to an unconcerned Rory and set about giving him a scolding despite being some fourteen years Bilbo’s junior.

“What is it with you and all these dwarves?” he jabbed Bilbo in the chest with a finger and Bilbo tried not to fall. In Odo’s haste for them to leave Bilbo had dropped his cane.

“I don’t answer to you, Odo.” He frowned back.

“I know you don’t, Bilbo! You don’t seem to understand that hanging around all these unsavoury types is going to go wrong. You are just a little gentlehobbit who can barely walk unaided and at some point one of those strangers is going to realise that and then who knows what’ll happen to you!” he waves his hands up and down emphatically.

“Barely walk!? I’m mostly recovered now, and I’ll thank you to mind your own business. I was only wishing them a good New Year.” He tried to hide the way his weak leg was hurting him and puffed himself up to his full, perfectly normal height in indignation.

“Bilbo-!” Odo began only to be interrupted.

“Master Baggins?” they both turned to see Loni had followed then out. He offered Bilbo his cane politely.

“I apologise if my kinsman and I have caused you distress” he said before wishing them a good night and taking his leave. The interruption appeared to have taken the wind out of Odo’s sails and he merely grumbled a final warning before returning to the Green Dragon.

Bilbo sighed and turned to make the walk up Hobbiton hill. His outing had been rather more exciting than he had expected and he was now very ready for bed, despite the disquieting tidings he had received. He would write a letter first thing in the morning and see about getting it sent to Erebor. It would be most sensible to address it to Balin (oh how he wishes he could write to Thorin himself!) as he knew better how he stood with him and could trust him to reply. Bilbo fully expected that the letter would not be going anywhere for some months as the Shire postal service probably didn’t even know how to get to the blue mountains and going himself was out of the question: winter was well on its way and the blue mountains were over two hundred miles away, not a journey to take lightly!

In the darkness the dwarven rune carved upon his door glowed gently. It looked otherworldly and yet welcoming and Bilbo smiled to himself as he closed the front gate behind him. He reached his front door and sagged against it, grateful for the support while he looked for his keys. He unlocked the door and stumbled through Bag End, barely remembering to brush off his feet in his rush to get into bed. Soon enough Bilbo had securely tucked himself in and as his eyelids began to slide closed he began to imagine what he would write.


February TA 2943 (Solmath 1343 Shire Reckoning)

Drogo Baggins was a fine respectable lad, just entering adulthood. He was exactly what a Baggins should be: sensible, fair, maybe a tad stubborn and extremely opposed to going on adventures. Which is exactly what Bilbo would have considered himself at his age so maybe there was hope for him yet!

Anyway, Drogo was proving a quite adequate walking partner. Bilbo had decided after an autumn and a winter of mostly being confined to Bag End with a trip to the market or to tea at another’s smial proving almost beyond him that now that the days were lengthening and the weather reasonably fair that he was going to go walking. He had mentioned such to Drogo in a fit of frustration when exhaustion had forced him to unexpectedly spend the night at his smial. Drogo had been very gracious about the whole thing and the mention of going walking had made him perk up. (Bilbo rather suspected the prospect of having an excuse to visit Buckland and a certain Brandybuck lass who lived there had something to do with it). Of course, they had not quite reached trips of that length as of yet, but they would build up to it. Currently they were taking a gentle stroll to Bywater, though Bilbo was already sweating from the exertion as he tried to keep up with Drogo.

“Oh, look!” Bilbo almost walked into Drogo’s back when he stopped abruptly in front of him.

“I would if you weren’t blocking the view.” He grumbled as he stepped to the side of Drogo’s rather well-rounded figure.

“It’s one of your dwarves!” Drogo whispered excitedly, for a second sounding scandalously Tookish and Bilbo looked up with his heartbeat quickening, irrationally expecting one of the company. Of course, it was only Loni, who Bilbo had spoken to a couple more times since their eventful first meeting when his wanderings had brought him to Hobbiton. He would not say they were friends but certainly comfortable acquaintances. It appeared this would be the last meeting for some time as he was dressed for serious travel and carried a well-laden pack. Bilbo waved to him and he waved back and continued walking towards them.

“How good to see you, Master Loni!” he said as he went to clasp forearms with him.

“Master Bilbo, Master Hobbit.” He greeted Bilbo and Drogo in turn.

“Where are you off to then?” Bilbo asked curiously “I thought now that spring has begun you would be off to Bree?”

smiled “No, I’m headed for Little Delving and then I shall head for the River Lune and then New Belegost”

“Across the open country?” Drogo looked shocked and Bilbo would have laughed at his expression if he was a more forgetful hobbit.

“Indeed, there are few good roads west of the Shire and I don’t have the patience to backtrack to Bree and go north to Fornost.”

Bilbo felt the envelope that still sat in his waistcoat pocket “If it is no trouble would you take my letter with you?” he asked shyly “I have been having some trouble finding a way to get it to Erebor that I felt reliable.”

“I would be honoured to, Bilbo Baggins, burglar of kings.” Loni said proudly and Bilbo gave him the envelope, feeling like he was entrusting him with something much more important to him than the simple package of paper and ink it was.

“Farewell on the road.” Bilbo said and Loni smiled and wished him similar good fortune before continuing westward.

It was only several minutes later that Bilbo laughed out loud at what Loni had called him and the accompanying ambiguity. “Burglar of kings! Ha!” Loni had likely meant to reference his role on the quest but as Bilbo had stolen from both Thorin and Thranduil he much preferred the second interpretation!

Drogo looked confused and affronted “He just called you a burglar! What a cheeky so-and-so!” Bilbo only laughed harder and eventually had to sit down in order to not fall over. Drogo’s indignant muttering only proving to worsen the situation.

Bilbo ran out of breath eventually and the laughter died away. Drogo kindly gave him his pocket handkerchief when Bilbo realised he’d forgotten to bring one (again). He dabbed at his watering eyes delicately as he sat in the middle of the road. Drogo waited for him to regain his composure in an impressive show of patience.

“I fail to see why you think being called a criminal is so funny.” Drogo remarked once Bilbo was straight faced again.

Bilbo grinned, knowing full well he was quite setting the cat among the pigeons with this “When I joined Thorin’s company it was in the role of burglar… and burgle I did I suppose.”

“I… what? So you stole from a king?” Poor Drogo looked as if he had just been hit over the head but Bilbo couldn’t resist deepening his confusion.

“I stole from two kings, one of which was my employer. Oh, and from a dragon!” He tells Drogo cheerfully. Drogo makes a little noise of distress and hides his face in his hands.

“A Dragon?” He paused, clearly dismissing that titbit as unsalvageable before continuing “I’m seriously beginning to think that the ones calling you ‘Mad Baggins’ are right. What could possess you to steal from your employer, who hired you as a bloody burglar?!” Bilbo was somewhat taken aback by the borderline scandalous language but decided that although he was enjoying Drogo’s bafflement immensely, he should probably offer an explanation.

It was a few miles yet to Bywater and Bilbo, for the first time since returning to the Shire, began to tell his tale in earnest.


May TA 2943 (Thrimidge 1343 Shire Reckoning)

The morning Bilbo receives a reply to his letter begins much like any other. Bilbo was outside having a post-first breakfast smoke on the bench as usual and idly admiring the smoke rings he was blowing. It was so calm that Bilbo half expected Gandalf to appear and turn his life upside down again. Bilbo blew an especially large smoke ring and hoped that wherever the wizard was he was well.

Tod Noakes then appeared, puffing up the hill with the post, which was most irregular. When Bilbo had seen his empty letterbox he had assumed he simply had no post, not that it was late!

“Morning, Master Baggins.” He greeted “Sorry for the delay, I got held up dealing with one of your dwarves.” He handed Bilbo several envelopes and hurried on his way. Bilbo didn’t think much of the remark – dwarves were a rare enough sight in the Shire that the presence of any was automatically attributed to Bilbo. He was fast becoming accustomed to being told what ‘his’ dwarf had been doing and not having a clue who they were talking about.

So Bilbo shuffled through the post as he went inside and stopped, pipe slipping from between his teeth to spill its half-burnt contents across the doorstep. He barely noticed the clatter, his attention taken by the letter in his hand. It was somewhat crumpled and the ink upon the outside had run a little but there was no mistaking the dwarvish runes accompanying the Westron address.

Bilbo broke open the seal and carefully drew out the folded sheets of paper within. The paper was thicker than that produced in the Shire, presumably to better withstand dwarven strength.

Bilbo,

It is good to hear from you and I am relieved that you are in better health when last we saw you. When the rest of the company heard I would be writing to you they were indignant that they had not also received a letter from you so I have taken the liberty of letting them write a few words to you.

Regarding the matter you wrote to me about: I am truly sorry for any worry you have suffered due to our silence. Dis is Thorin’s younger sister and Fili and Kili’s mother and I can confirm that Thorin’s abdication happened peacefully and consensually. Thorin decided some time ago that he was not suited well to rule in peace and while many of us disagreed he insisted on having his way. Dis is admittedly making a brilliant king but Thorin would have also I think. I asked him if he had anything he wanted to say to you but he declined. I would not presume to speak for him but I would suggest you not take this to heart. It is clear to everyone in Erebor that Thorin deeply regrets his actions from when he had the Sickness and that it heavily influenced his decision to abdicate.

On more cheerful topics: the mountain is beginning to flourish once more, both inside and out! I dare say if you could see the once Desolation of Smaug now you would wonder if the dragon had ever existed at all! There are dwarves coming from all parts of middle earth to trade or live here, though the restoration efforts are still underway. Just yesterday the opal mines were reopened! I had quite forgotten the true splendour of Erebor in our long exile – it is truly a relief to finally be home and once again I thank you for the part you played!

Yours Faithfully,

Balin

Bilbo carefully places the top sheet aside with a smile and notes that each subsequent piece of paper bears a different hand. There is something from each of the company, save Thorin. Some have only scrawled a few sentences but Ori has written him a lengthy letter featuring beautiful illustrations of some of the wonders of Erebor. Kili and Fili share a page full of jokey anecdotes and Nori has thoughtfully included some stories about strange things he has uncovered in forgotten corners of the mountain. Dori has written to him at length about his business as a tea merchant and offered to send him samples of some of the blends he has been selling. Bofur has also made an effort despite clearly struggling with the spelling of Westron judging by the angular shapes and the extraneous letters that clutter his words but Bilbo appreciates everyone’s words to an embarrassing degree. When he has finished reading he holds the letters close and smiles in relief until his face hurts. His friends are all safe and not only that but they still wish to communicate with him!


March TA 2944 (Rethe 1344 Shire Reckoning)

They come across the wreckage near noon. Bilbo had managed to convince Drogo to accompany him to Bree – an already difficult feat as the town was treated as the edge of the world by most hobbits. They had then stayed the night at the Prancing Pony and, in a moment of restlessness (or maybe recklessness) Bilbo had suggested they take a walk north. Just for a day he had said when Drogo had refused (of course) but he had crumbled in the face of Bilbo’s wheedling embarrassingly quickly. It was maybe a little selfish but Bilbo was hungry for the unknown and he had never been north from Bree before.

So they had set out, Bilbo cheerfully and Drogo with an air of a man on his way to be hung. Bilbo was doing his best to cultivate Drogo’s sense of adventure but it was a difficult task. Bilbo had made sure before they set out that they had enough food for all seven meals as he was sure Drogo’s already limited enthusiasm would run out as soon as his stomach became empty.

So it was not long past elevenses when they came across the remains of the caravan. Bilbo had chosen their route based on it being the safest but it appeared he had been mistaken. A smashed wagon sat in the middle of the road, another collapsed half in the ditch by the side of the road. It had been a massacre – dead humans lay strewn about in a gruesome tangle. There were a few corpses that wore light armour – presumably the caravan guards – but the majority had been unarmoured and unarmed. Bilbo steps forward to investigate and stops when he hears Drogo being sick. It’s probably safest to turn back: whoever did this could still be in the area and he can’t leave Drogo but Bilbo wouldn’t be able to forgive himself if there were survivors and he didn’t check. He looks between the carnage and Drogo, torn between sense and his conscience.

Bilbo removes his rucksack and brings out Sting. He buckles on the belt and ushers Drogo into the bushes at the side of the road “I’m going to check for survivors, you stay here. I want you to run for Bree at the first sign of trouble.” He whispers and Drogo nods shakily. Bilbo considers giving him Sting and taking one of the guard’s weapons for himself but Drogo is just as likely to stab himself as an orc so he doesn’t.

He walks forward carefully, ears straining in the heavy silence. It cannot have been long since they were attacked as there are no carrion birds yet which would suggest that it was human brigands responsible. Orcs don’t travel in the day after all, though the attack has happened worryingly close to Bree. He steps over a body delicately and continues around the wagon that has slid into the ditch. One raised wheel spins slowly in the light breeze.

Bilbo stops abruptly. There in front of him, collapsed over the side of the wagon is a dwarf. Bilbo can only see their back from where he’s standing but he is certain – the figure isn’t large enough to be an adult human and no child would be that powerfully built. There are two arrow shafts protruding from the dwarf – one having just clipped their leg and another sunk deep into their shoulder but there is a faint rise and fall of their torso – the dwarf is still alive! Bilbo goes to the back of the wagon and climbs up into it. The dwarf has thick black hair streaked with white that hangs down over their face in a sweat and blood-soaked tangle.

"Hello, are you awake Master Dwarf?” He calls quietly but the dwarf doesn’t stir.

Bilbo knows it is rude to touch a dwarf’s hair but it is in the way and he needs to check on them so he very carefully pushes it aside when he feels for a pulse at the dwarf’s neck. He is relieved to find it strong and steady beneath his fingers. Bilbo then inspects them – him? – more thoroughly for injuries. A nasty bruising lump where their forehead meets their hairline appears to be the cause of the dwarf’s unconsciousness but there is also a long slash curving around his side that was still bleeding sluggishly. If the dwarf is to survive Bilbo’s first job will be to stop the bleeding. He presses his hands over the injury and the dwarf groans and tries to move away but remains unconscious.

Bilbo swallows back a bubble of panic. If the dwarf won’t wake how will he get him down off the wagon? The arrow in his leg is deeply embedded in the wood of the wagon and Bilbo doesn’t have the supplies – or training – to deal with injuries like this. And even if he can get the dwarf down and stop them from bleeding out how does he get them back to the safety of Bree? The Dwarf must weigh as much as Bilbo and then half again!

He is well on the way to panicking before the crunch of branches in the forest that surrounds the road reminds him that he cannot afford to let his guard down. If he tries to run whoever is approaching will likely see him and he doubts he can outrun them if they aren’t friendly. Best to hide then and hope that Drogo is sensible. He reaches into his pocket and brings out the ring but it slips from his fingers as if coated in butter and rolls out of the wagon. He stares dumbly after it for a second before cursing himself for his clumsiness. The sounds are drawing closer and Bilbo looks around desperately for somewhere to hide, every heartbeat sounding loud in his ears now. Whatever goods that were being kept in the wagon have been taken by the bandits and if he climbs down to find the ring he is sure to be spotted. Bilbo is on the edge of panicking again when the dwarf groans quietly. He wears an overly large travel cloak that has fallen forward in a heap next to his head and Bilbo realises that the dwarf is tall enough that if he can manage to curl himself up under it he will most likely stay hidden.

The dwarf groans again, louder and Bilbo realises he is waking up at exactly the wrong time. He shushes him and pushes the cloak aside and folds himself up as small as he can against the dwarf’s side before draping the thick fabric as convincingly as he can across them both. The dwarf’s warm body presses against him and the familiar unwashed smell is nowhere near as unpleasant as Bilbo should find it. He makes his final adjustments to the cloak and unsheathes sting. The blade isn’t glowing so at least it won’t be orcs or goblins.

He can hear voices approaching now, loud and brash. It has to be the brigands, although why they would return here Bilbo doesn’t know. The dwarf must hear them too because he mutters something in khuzdul and tries to move.

“Stay still!” Bilbo hisses and the dwarf jolts “Play dead. Please!” he whispers and after an awful pause the dwarf relaxes his muscles and lies limply once more.

They remain frozen in place for some interminably long period of time and listen to the men move around the site of the massacre. They are undoubtably part of whatever group did this as they banter back and forth and joke cruelly about the carnage. Judging by what Bilbo can hear of the discussion one of the men is an archer and they have returned from divvying up the spoils to collect his arrows.

Bilbo abruptly becomes horribly conscious of the two arrows embedded in the dwarf’s flesh.

They hold still and listen to the brigands’ inexorable approach.

“Oy, is that a dwarf there?” one of the voices is suddenly uncomfortably close. Bilbo’s hand is going numb from the strangling hold he has on Sting.

“Looks like it.” The other replies and steps closer “Ugh, I hate it when arrows get stuck.” The wagon is jostled and the dwarf hisses a breath but manages to otherwise hold still. The first arrow has been removed. Bilbo can feel his heartrate accelerating, reverberating up his throat to echo in his mouth.

“Let me borrow your knife, I’m going to have to cut the other one out.” the closer voice says and a large hand grasps the dwarf around the middle and begins to lift him off the wagon. Bilbo has to act now! They’ll realise the dwarf is alive in a moment and Bilbo is about to lose his hiding place!

Bilbo leaps out from under the cloak and stabs at the man viciously with Sting. The brigand barely has time to cry out in surprise before he is dead, Sting embedded in his eye socket to the hilt. The corpse falls back, dragging the dwarf with him and nearly Bilbo too when he tries to reclaim his weapon.

The dwarf lands on his back and yells hoarsely when the impact jostles the arrow still in his shoulder. The other brigand also yells but in fury but Bilbo barely takes notice. The dwarf’s hair has fallen back fully and Bilbo can see his face. He would know that face anywhere, despite the wide scar that now cuts across it. He is struck dumb at the sight – of all people he had never expected to see him again!

“Thorin!?” he cries but he is out of time. Bilbo dives off the wagon to avoid the bandit’s sword only to trip and sprawl on the ground. His leg jars painfully at the impact and before he can scramble away he is roughly hauled up by the back of his coat so he is eye to eye with the man.

“Well, what are you then?” the man shakes him “I would have said you were a hobbit from the look of you but everyone knows halflings don’t go further from the Shire than Bree-land.”

Bilbo resists the urge to look at Thorin. He couldn’t afford to be distracted again. “I am indeed a hobbit.” He says in a strangled voice. Bilbo would try to charm his way out of this situation but he has just killed this man’s comrade so he doubts he will lower his guard enough for any of Bilbo’s tricks to work – or have the curiosity necessary for riddles and such like to appeal. His ring is still lying somewhere on the ground under the wagon so it won’t be any use in this situation either! Sting is also out of reach and he could try and take the man’s own dagger – it was right there on his belt – but if Bilbo failed then he would likely be swiftly gutted and his hands were shaking and slippery with the other ruffian’s blood. The blood of the man he had just killed.

Bilbo hadn’t killed a man before. Only a couple goblins and a handful of unfortunate animals. A part of him was surprised by how simple it had been. It felt not much different from killing a goblin, a creature that even the most pacifistic hobbit would agree should be put out of its misery. The man had no doubt been of a horrible sort, probably not much better than a goblin but that was not the point. Why did it feel the same if one act was supposed to be so much worse than the other?

“You’re an interesting little fellow.” The bandit remarked with a grin that revealed jagged teeth “I’ve certainly never heard of a hobbit that had the guts to kill someone.” He laughed to himself and placed Bilbo back on the ground, moving one of his hands to tangle in Bilbo’s hair and pull upwards to hold him in place balanced unsteadily on the tips of his toes.

“I’m almost tempted to keep you.” he patted Bilbo’s cheek in an ugly facsimile of how a man might pet a loyal dog. Bilbo didn’t flinch away, though this was mainly because there wasn’t the give to do so in the man’s hold. He did his best to look harmless and meek despite the disgust that roiled within him.

The man hummed consideringly before shaking his head “No, I’ve seen what you’re capable of. I would be a fool to keep you around.”

“Now let me show you how killing is really done.” The sword was raised up before starting down the arc that would bring it crashing through Bilbo’s neck if he didn’t move. Bilbo lunged for the knife, bloody fingers slipping over the hilt before the man jerked him away roughly. Bilbo kicked and flailed desperately but the man was unaffected by the blows and only dragged his head back so he was off balance and his neck presented to the sword. Bilbo was running out of time, unarmed and too weak to break free. He didn’t want to die so soon after finding Thorin!

There is a pained shout from behind him and Bilbo shuts his eyes and tries not to think about what will happen to Thorin after the ruffian has finished with him. He doesn’t know if Thorin is well enough to fight the man, already wounded as he is. Then there is the sound of something whistling through the air and a fleshy impact noise before he is falling, dragged down by an awful pain in his scalp. The scent of blood clogs Bilbo’s nose. This is it: journey’s end, he thinks. How silly it is that he should survive goblins and dragons and falling from dizzying heights only to die here, less than a day’s walk from Bree on a stupid walking holiday. And immediately after being reunited with the one he had wished to see for years too! Its so unfair!

Only Bilbo isn’t dead? There is no pain and he still feels the rest of his body so he surely his head must still be attached? He remembers hearing that if a limb has been amputated you can still feel it sometimes. Maybe these are just his confused dying thoughts? He wants so open his eyes and check but he is also terrified of what he’ll find. His breathing that may or may not be real is fast and shaky but his lungs ache as if he wasn’t breathing at all, surely he can’t be imagining it? The sensations from the rest of his body smear into a dizzying rush as he panics but he doesn’t know what to do – or if he is even capable of doing anything.

“Bilbo!” a voice calls out. Thorin sounds frantic and that disturbs Bilbo from his muddle. He opens his eyes and tentatively brings a hand to his throat to find he is still very much intact. The brigand has a single arrow deeply embedded in his chest and is quite clearly dead, his hand still tangled in Bilbo’s hair. He removes the limp fingers from his head and turns as Thorin falls to his knees at his side.

Apart from the scar Thorin looks just as Bilbo remembers: piercing pale eyes, although one of them looks strangely off now, a prominent hawkish nose and those funny round ears. The aged finery of his grandfather’s that he had worn when they had reclaimed the mountain is gone once more – as are all his braids, curiously – and Bilbo is relieved. The Thorin here is more reminiscent of the one that had watched the fireflies with him in Rivendell or worried over him in Laketown than the one that had nearly killed him. He looks a little more worn, a little sadder but it is the dwarf that Bilbo –

Bilbo steers his thoughts away from that path and realises he has been staring. He smiles and opens his mouth to thank Thorin for saving him but the words are overtaken by a flood of all the anger, fear and desperation from the last hour and instead, much to his horror, he begins to cry.

Thorin looks uncomfortable and utterly lost at what to do but he doesn’t react adversely when Bilbo hugs him and clings tightly to his clothes while he sobs. He doesn’t hug Bilbo back however so Bilbo takes the hint and does his best to pull himself together.

“I missed you” he admits as he retreats. Thorin only nods and continues to look confused. Bilbo stands gracelessly, his body feels a strange combination of both too heavy and too light and Thorin reaches out to steady him when he staggers, despite being the injured one.

“We should leave this place before any more of them come back.” He says. Bilbo picks up his rucksack, finds the ring in the long grass and pulls Sting from the corpse, trying not to look too closely at the mess. Thorin looks for his sword but quickly concludes it has been taken and claims a different blade with a scowl.

Bilbo then remembers Drogo and goes to check if he has remained in his hiding place. Drogo seemingly hadn’t moved a muscle in the entire encounter and was deathly pale.

“You’re alive!” Drogo scuttles out of the bush and grabs Bilbo tightly, only to quickly release him when he sees the gory splatters on his hands and face. Thorin looks bemused but doesn’t comment.

They depart at a brisk pace to be safe and there is tense silence as they walk back along the road to Bree but once they are a reasonable distance from the wreckage of the caravan Bilbo decides introductions are in order.

“Drogo, it is my pleasure to introduce you to Thorin, son of Thrain. Thorin, this is my cousin, Drogo Baggins.” They eye each other around Bilbo.

“At your service” Thorin says with a nod the same time as Drogo extends a hand to be shaken and says “It’s nice to meet you.” Bilbo is happy that they are trying to be polite to each other but doesn’t know how to prevent the offense that will no doubt arise from Thorin ignoring Drogo’s handshake. Luckily Drogo’s reflexive politeness at being introduced to someone wears off right then and he suddenly stops walking.

“Wait! You are Thorin Oakenshield?” he asks with a look of realisation.


Thorin nods stiffly “But Bilbo said you were the king of the dwarves, what are you doing here?” Drogo looks both starstruck and disappointed. Bilbo supposes that once upon a time he had found the notion of royalty just as distant and romantic as most hobbits do. Drogo seems to have quite forgotten about the earlier trials of the day and the bounce is back in his step.

“I was for a while but now I’m not.” Thorin said shortly. Drogo makes a noise of understanding and then ruins it by making it clear that he had taken Thorin to mean his elected term had ended, as if he had been the Mayor of Michel Delving and not King under the Mountain. Thorin had been quite offended by this but unwilling to fully explain the workings of dwarvish society so it had fallen to Bilbo to explain to the best of his limited knowledge.

They stopped to eat shortly after when any respectable hobbit would have had afternoon tea. They had missed lunch and who knew when Thorin had last eaten! Bilbo hadn’t planned to be feeding an extra person but he supposed that as they had missed a meal there would be enough to feed Thorin until they could get back to Bree. They ate in hungry silence and Bilbo was just about to propose they continue on their way when he saw Thorin grimace as he moved his arm. It was then Bilbo realised he had completely forgotten about his injuries. They had just walked several miles and Thorin had given no indication he was experiencing any discomfort.

Thorin noticed him watching and his grimace was replaced by the all-purpose frown he often wore.

“I don’t have much in the way of supplies but we should treat your wounds before they fester.” Bilbo said, already digging out his last clean spare shirt from his rucksack.

“Thank you.” Thorin said stiffly with a strange expression. He gingerly peeled away his bloodstained furs and the many woollen layers beneath until even his undershirt was removed! In typical dwarven fashion, Thorin sat stone-still while Bilbo washed the wound on his side and gingerly prodded at the arrowhead still embedded in his shoulder. He sat there completely bare from the waist up and while Bilbo knew that dwarves were completely oblivious to silly hobbit notions of propriety he found it a little jarring after years of much gentler company. Bilbo tried to stay focused but couldn’t prevent himself from blushing like the reddest of tomatoes. Poor Drogo, who did not have the experience of dealing with a whole company of dwarves that would regularly bathe naked in mountain streams or elvish fountains with equal enthusiasm, was dealing rather less well and was currently humming loudly while facing the other direction.

He finished washing the wounds and then noticed a series of long interconnected scars that spanned Thorin’s shoulder blades. Bilbo had always tried not to stare when the others had been washing during the journey but he was fairly certain he would have remembered something like this. It looked a lot like how he remembered Khuzdul to look. He knew that Dwarves were much more prone to such strange practices as tattoos and piercings in their ears and suchlike – all of which to a Hobbit seemed awfully barbaric – but he didn’t think these scars came from the desire for self-adornment. They looked like they had been deep and painful and while Bilbo was curious he didn’t wish to pry about what was possibly a delicate matter.

Bilbo savaged his poor shirt severely to create makeshift wrappings that would hopefully offer some protection until they reached Bree. He then helped Thorin back into his clothes as much as he was permitted.

“Well then, on to Bree!” Drogo cried when he realised it was safe to look. The poor fellow was still very much embarrassed and a tad scandalised. Drogo couldn’t look either of them in the face without blushing enthusiastically but he made no further comment other than “I reckon we’re running out of daylight fast and I definitely don’t want to see what comes out at night!”

Notes:

Only one more chapter now! You can thank covid for this chapter as I was stuck inside this weekend waiting for a pcr test result (do not fear it was negative!). Shout out to those of you that reminded me I was sat on a fully written chapter that only needed editing!

The last chapter will be titled 'Reunion'. I haven't written much of it yet and tbh the prospect is kind of intimidating as I plan to have a Bagginshield ending but I have never written any kind of romance so we shall see how that goes! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Chapter 7: Reunion

Notes:

Oh wow this chapter was difficult to write! Just a heads up for everyone but me and sexual/romantic attraction are not talking and never really have been so I was writing some parts of this like ??? is that a thing people do? Like don't get me wrong I do enjoy the occasional romance but writing the kissing parts here made me go 'oh yuck' and it is the most chaste thing you will ever read!

Warnings: some ableism and a little bit of fantasy racism, misunderstandings.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

March TA 2944 (Rethe 1344 Shire Reckoning)

Bilbo knocked on the door of Thorin’s room at the Prancing Pony. Drogo had finally fallen asleep in his and Bilbo’s shared room and Thorin had to be back from his visit to the town Physician by now!

The door opened a crack, a single glittering eye stared at him for a second before he was allowed to enter.

“Hello Thorin! I hope you are feeling better now.” Bilbo said with a smile. Thorin looked much healthier now that his wounds had been tended to and he had eaten a proper meal and washed.

“Yes, much.” He replied shortly, his shoulders so tense that it must have pained him. Bilbo wasn’t sure what to say now – it was clear Thorin didn’t care for his company. Maybe he hadn’t forgiven him for stealing the Arkenstone? In hindsight Bilbo himself had become somewhat conflicted about his actions that night so it was no great leap to think that Thorin may still hold some resentment. Oh goodness, was he forcing Thorin to deal with his unwanted company?!

“Great!” he said far too excitedly before wishing it would be appropriate to smack himself. He had really wanted to talk to Thorin without Drogo bumbling around in the background but this was painfully awkward!

They stared at each other for longer than was comfortable. Thorin’s expression was unreadable and Bilbo’s thoughts were like a tangle of fruiting brambles – unwieldy and painful and pleasing in near equal measure. He could feel himself blushing and he was so flustered and tired that his leg began to tremble a little.

“Are you alright, Bilbo?” Thorin asked concernedly and reached out hesitantly to steady him when the shaking worsened. His grip was firm but not overly so and Bilbo looked up at Thorin and despite everything felt safe. He knew he shouldn’t – Thorin nearly killed him once! – but that awful day felt distant now that Thorin was here and so clearly in his right mind once again.

“Bilbo! Are you injured?” Thorin demanded when he doesn’t immediately respond, beginning to feel along his limbs for injuries.

“Oh no, I’m fine. It’s just my bad leg getting tired.” Bilbo said with a shrug.

Thorin’s eyebrows drew downwards like gathering storm clouds “Is that from when I…?”

Bilbo nodded hesitantly and when Thorin scowled he hastened to add “I’m a lot better now though. It’s only doing that because I’m tired and I fell on it earlier!”

His leg choose that moment to collapse fully and he fell forward into Thorin’s chest. Thorin supported him under the arms, taking almost all of his weight and Bilbo felt his face turning red from the mortification.

“Bilbo, that was years ago now! How can you stand to be around me when I’ve crippled you like this?” He cried, horrified.

Bilbo looked up at him and saw the emotions written far clearer on Thorin’s face than he’d have liked. Shame, regret and worst of all, pity. He had no need for yet more of that particular sentiment – so what if he had had to slow down a little, he could still do everything he wanted to! “I’ll thank you not to pity me, Thorin Oakenshield! I can barely take it from everyone back home and I will not tolerate you treating me like that when I killed a man for you today!!” He pushed Thorin’s hands away and took a couple uneven steps back.

Thorin stared and stuttered a little in a rather undignified manner.

“I think I’ll go to bed now.” Bilbo said crossly.

“No, don’t go!” Thorin said hurriedly and caught his wrist. Bilbo turned, a touch indignant at his dramatic exit being thwarted and Thorin instantly released him, recoiling as if burnt. Bilbo considers leaving anyway but he isn’t quite angry enough for that to truly appeal.

“I’ve missed you too, Bilbo! I missed you so much ever since the moment you fell and I realised what I had done.” Thorin’s habitual stoicism was gone, his expression open in a way that Bilbo had only rarely seen on a handful of occasions before. The silence in the room was suffocating with words neither of them wanted to say. They looked at each other instead and Bilbo wondered for a second if things wouldn’t have had to come to this if he had come up with a different solution to stealing the Arkenstone. He didn’t truly think he could have done anything better than he had but it was tempting to imagine some way that everything could have been saved without sacrifice.

“Why did you never write? Balin said he asked you about it and you refused.” He eventually asked raggedly.

Thorin looked away, his expression closed off “I thought you would be happier not hearing from me. I’m sorry, Bilbo. Truly.”

“You are an idiot.” Bilbo replied “When I heard that you were no longer King I thought something dreadful had happened! If I could have I would have marched all the way back to Erebor.”

It was Thorin’s turn to sway a little, either from exhaustion or blood loss, Bilbo couldn’t tell. Bilbo did his best to steady him but Thorin was much heavier than him and they both staggered a little “I’m not sure which of us is more the fool, all of this and you still care about me?”

“Of course.” Bilbo replied warmly (maybe a little too warmly but Thorin didn’t seem to notice) before a yawn forced its way out. He went to continue speaking but then Thorin yawned too and Bilbo realised he looked exhausted.

“Oh, I think that would be my cue to retire for the night.” He said with a grin. Thorin’s mouth twitched at the corners.

“What are your plans?” Bilbo asked with no small amount of trepidation. He wasn’t anywhere near being ready to let Thorin walk back out of his life but surely he had had a destination in mind when he had begun his journey?

“Well I’ve been working as a travelling blacksmith for the last while but as long as there are people in need of my skills, where I go isn’t particularly important.” Thorin paused before saying far more hesitantly “I… I could go to the Shire, with you? If you wanted?”

Bilbo grinned and tried not to sound too eager when he replied “Yes, please do!”


April TA 2944 (Astron 1344 Shire Reckoning)

When Bilbo stopped to talk to yet another distant relation Thorin sighed fondly, though also a touch exasperatedly. He had lost count of the number of such encounters there had been on their journey through the Shire but he was willing to bet that it would be easier to count which Hobbits Bilbo wasn’t related to in some tenuous fashion. He had always thought Dwarves were knowledgeable on genealogies but that was nothing in the face of the dedication of Hobbits.

Thorin found the Shire particularly baffling to navigate but Bilbo had told him that they were very close to Hobbiton now. If they walked quickly they might even make it to Bag End today – though that seemed like a futile hope with all this chattering.

The journey had been the slowest of Thorin’s life. When they had set off from Bree Bilbo’s leg had been paining him from his fall from the cart but he had confidently waved off their concerns. They had only made it a few miles from Bree, their pace gradually slowing to accommodate Bilbo’s increasing difficulty keeping up when Bilbo admitted he couldn’t continue. They had been lucky that a farmer on his return from market had been willing to give them a lift to Brandybuck hall where they had stayed for the next week and a half.

His own wounds were thankful for the respite he had to admit, though given how the recovery process for Hobbits appeared to involve an inordinate amount of fussing he didn’t advertise that he was injured. Drogo had been the only one pleased by the unexpected pause in their travels as he had a rather blatant fondness for one of the Brandybuck lasses and had apparently gone on this trip as an excuse to see her anyway. Bilbo however, became more ill-tempered with every day they were forced to linger with worried Brandybucks smothering him with their concern. Thorin tried to keep out of his way but he found himself drawn to the periphery of whatever room Bilbo was in.

The other hobbits didn’t avoid Thorin but they didn’t interact with him unless there was something they were curious about. They treated him with some suspicion but Thorin thought it was nowhere near enough for them to know the full story of what Thorin had done.

Eventually Bilbo lost patience at being coddled and they left despite it being clear that Bilbo, while much improved, still wasn’t fully recovered. They resumed their journey back to Hobbiton with new enthusiasm.

The Shire was pleasant to walk through – even more pleasant now that Thorin had the time to appreciate his surroundings and wasn’t setting off on a dangerous quest. It was spring and the new leaves were so green that when the sun was out it dazzled him. Everywhere he looked was more vibrant than the finest emerald, more pleasing to the eye than jade. The rivers ran clear and were full of jewel-bright fish and the verges of the roads were thick with daffodils and crocuses and other early-flowering plants Thorin hadn’t known the names for. He was beginning to understand why Hobbits didn’t care for gold and gemstones if they lived in such splendour.

His interest didn’t go unnoticed by Bilbo and he had begun endeavouring to teach Thorin their names. He suspected Bilbo found these lessons a little frustrating. Thorin had never spent much so much time looking at plants before and he found some of the differences between them impossible to spot. He could identify a primrose with confidence but when he had mistaken an early purple orchid for a bluebell Bilbo had looked rather disturbed and Drogo had laughed at him. Bilbo had tried to explain the difference to him but Thorin was still somewhat confused. He supposed bluebells generally grew taller?

Bilbo finally finished talking to the other hobbit and they began to walk towards Hobbiton once more. The sun was almost directly ahead of them and low to the horizon but as they rounded a grassy hill he could make out against the glare small cottages and doors sunk into the sides of hills and slopes. It had been three years since he last saw Hobbiton but he still recognised it.

They bid Drogo goodbye at the crossroads just inside Hobbiton before turning and walking up the hill to Bag End. When the round green door appeared Thorin saw with some surprise that the dwarven rune Gandalf had carved into the wood still glowed softly.

“Welcome back.” Bilbo said quietly and smiled. The sun was setting now and Bilbo was washed in glorious amber light.

Thorin thinks that while sometimes he misses the subterranean wonders of Erebor the Shire is going to do quite nicely.


April TA 2944 (Astron 1344 Shire Reckoning)

It had only been a couple weeks since he had returned to Hobbiton with Bilbo but Thorin thought it was going quite well. He had begun to set up the town forge, which had stood empty save from when the occasional travelling blacksmith had used it for some years since the last resident ‘smith had retired some twenty years ago.

Hobbits may be suspicious of other peoples – dwarves included – but they could acknowledge good craftmanship wherever it came from and there had been considerable interest in the business. Bilbo had been a great help introducing him to people and he had already begun receiving jobs.

He was drawing out a design for a replacement wrought iron gate for Mrs Proudfoot when he happened to glance at large clockwork timepiece and realised he was late to tea or dinner or whatever meal they were on now. He quickly tidied up his drawings and tools and left the forge. It was a pleasant spring evening – a little warm and the air still moist with the heavy rainfall from this morning.

Thorin walked up the little hill to Bag End and let himself inside. He was in the process of removing his boots when he heard voices coming from the sitting room. Distinctly unhappy voices. He didn’t consider that he was eavesdropping when he walked carefully to the door and listened, he was only concerned about whatever disagreement was occurring.

“…and now you’ve let one into your house! I can’t believe you’d be so stupid as to let a stranger – a foreigner no less – live in your house for who knows how long! I wouldn’t be surprised if you started having goblins as houseguests next, they certainly couldn’t be much dirtier!!” A voice he doesn’t recognise proclaims loudly. Thorin considered entering the room right then but then Bilbo spoke and Thorin remained where he was.

“I will thank you not to mind my affairs for me, Odo.” Bilbo’s voice is clipped and severe. “Thorin is a dear friend of mine and I find it offensive in the extreme that you would liken him to a goblin.”

“I’ll call things what they are, Bilbo. If it smells like a goblin and speaks like a goblin then I’ll bloody well call it a goblin!” Thorin ground his teeth at the insult but remained where he was.

“You’ve never even seen a goblin!” Bilbo cried furiously.

“And you have?!” Odo challenged.

“Yes!” Bilbo near howled “I have seen and done all kinds of things you couldn’t even imagine!”

“I wouldn’t have to imagine if you just told people, Bilbo! You haven’t even told anyone how you were injured.” There was a pause in the shouting match and after marshalling himself Thorin knocked on the door before entering.

Bilbo and Odo were both standing with the table bearing the remains of afternoon tea between them. The table was probably all that had separated them from scrapping on the floor but when they saw him they slipped back into distant propriety as he had hoped. Odo’s cheeks slowly flushed red at the indignity of being caught arguing.

“Is everything alright?” he asked, looking only to Bilbo for a response.

“My cousin was just about to leave.” Bilbo announced, uncharacteristically coldly.

Odo sniffed and began to make his way to the door.

Thorin escorted the Hobbit out, handing him his coat and opening the front door politely. Odo gave him a measuring look as he inserted his arms into the sleeves.

“You know what happened to him don’t you.” He said slowly.

“I was there.” Thorin admitted, holding back the unfortunate addition of ‘I did it to him’ that sits accusingly at the back of his throat.

“You won’t tell me either though, will you.” Odo sighed.

“If he doesn’t want people to know then I shouldn’t say.” Thorin said uncomfortably, it felt distinctly selfish to hide behind such an excuse. He didn’t deserve Bilbo shielding him like this. If it were anything else he could keep it secret without a qualm but this… he was covering for his own crime!

“Quite right.” Odo said and Thorin felt even guiltier “I still do not approve of Bilbo’s taste in friends but I apologise for my rudeness.” Thorin watched him go before closing the door and returning to the sitting room.

Bilbo had sat in his plush armchair, face turned away and his posture sagging and Thorin went to sit in the chair on the other side of the fireplace.

“I’m sorry you had to hear that.” Bilbo said “Since my return my cousin feels that he must protect me and I vex him supremely by continuing to associate with people from out with the Shire.”

“Well I suppose he isn’t entirely wrong in that, even if it is rather late.” Thorin said, attempting humour but falling short.

Bilbo looks up at him and says chastisingly “Thorin.”

“I would have told him what happened if it hadn’t meant betraying your trust.” Thorin finds himself admitting. “Why is it that you don’t want anyone to know?”

Bilbo makes a strangled noise “Because I don’t want them to run you out of town, you idiot!”

“I would deserve it.” Thorin says stubbornly even as the thought of leaving fills him with pure dread.

“You were ill!” Bilbo cries.

“That is a poor excuse. People do all sorts of terrible things because they were ill in some way or another and they are still blamed for their actions, why should I be any different?”

Bilbo looks stricken “I don’t want you to leave again. When I heard you had abdicated I thought something terrible had happened. I thought the entire Quest had been for naught and that you had been exiled again or killed and yet here we are, reunited against all odds. So what if I am no longer quite the same Hobbit as I once was, if I could have my health or you I know which I’d choose.”

“You never should have had to make that choice.” Thorin says and his words become quieter, heavier as they leave him. “You trusted me to see sense and I almost killed you.”

“That is true.” Bilbo agrees and Thorin winces “However, while I don’t remember much from that day but I do remember the look of your face when you tried to catch me. I don’t think you ever meant to hurt me, did you?” Bilbo fixes him with a look fierce enough to be at home on a Great Eagle.

“I don’t know. I’ve thought about that day so much that it is hard to know what I was thinking at the time.” He says raggedly.

“Thorin,” Bilbo reaches out and catches hold of Thorin’s hands in his own. They are warm, softer than his own but still a little rough and calloused and so horrifyingly small. “I’ve never held what happened against you. There are plenty days I have wished that our time together could have ended differently or that I hadn’t been hurt but I have never regretted going on the quest. I think you’ve already suffered more than enough for what happened.” Bilbo looks directly into his eyes “Instead of inviting others to criticise you, you need to start forgiving yourself.”

He stands then and gently relinquishes his hold on Thorin’s hands and just like that the tense atmosphere shifts back to normality “I’ll just check on how our dinner is coming along.” He glances at the clock and starts in horror at the time before hurrying out of the room.


September TA 2944 (Halimath 1344 Shire Reckoning)

“I understand why hobbits eat so many meals when farming is so exhausting!” Thorin groaned as he sat in the grass next to Bilbo. It was coming to the end of harvest time and every able-bodied parson was needed in the fields. The other hobbits had been sceptical at first but Thorin had worked on farms before – admittedly some decades ago – and he was physically stronger than most of them so in the end they had come to almost appreciate him.

This morning he had been helping harvest the last of the wheat and although the hottest part of the day was only beginning he was disgustingly sweaty. Bilbo didn’t seem to mind though as he only shifted closer and handed him a heavily loaded plate.

Everyone then set about inhaling their food as if it was the first food they had seen all day. Thorin still only ate three meals a day but after living off of Bilbo’s cooking he could fully understand the temptation of seven.

The hobbits finished quicker than he did and after resting a little began to tidy up. Bilbo remained sat next to him as he ate and as the sun got hotter he slowly leaned into Thorin’s side. When he finished he carefully set his plate aside and looked down a little bemusedly.

He was not used to such physical intimacy but it was far from unpleasant. He wasn’t entirely sure when Bilbo had begun to relax around him so enthusiastically as it had begun subtle at first. Their hands brushing a little more than necessary when handing each other things, momentary pats to his arm and that sort of thing. Without really noticing at all the situation had escalated to the extent that the other evening Bilbo had fallen asleep with his head in Thorin’s lap and he had barely thought anything of it at the time.

He had thought it was some sort of strange cultural difference. Maybe hobbits were by nature more cuddly than dwarves? Thorin couldn’t be that nice to hug as he was so awkwardly large and heavy in comparison to a hobbit and had none of their softness. Bilbo was probably just trying to be polite? He had considered asking Bilbo but had refrained. He didn’t want Bilbo to feel awkward or think he had made Thorin uncomfortable – which certainly was not the case! Ultimately he hadn’t asked because then he wouldn’t have to tell Bilbo the full extent of how he felt about him and face the subsequent rejection.

Then yesterday he had unintentionally seen Hamfast and Bell sat together in a very similar manner and clearly flirting and now that he had seen it from the outside it was much more clear.

Could Bilbo possibly like him back? He hadn’t been able to think of anything else since he realised.

Bilbo shifted to look up at him. “So serious!” he commented with a smile.

Thorin felt his ears flush and, before he could overthink he reached out a hand to cradle Bilbo’s cheek. Bilbo leaned into the touch, his eyes wide but not from fear and his smile widening.

Dwarves tended to show affection in ways other than kissing – it only took one incident of tangling beards with a partner to know why but in that moment that was all Thorin wanted (and besides Bilbo didn’t have any facial hair to get tangled in!). He leaned down and pressed the softest of kisses to his cheek.

Bilbo flushed a brilliant ruby red and after a long surprised moment reached up to return the kiss.


July TA 2949 (Afterlithe 1349 Shire Reckoning)

In the end their wedding was a small, quiet affair. Neither of them were from cultures where such was the norm but properly integrating their people’s wildly differing traditions and inviting a full complement of guests was far more effort than it was worth. Thorin had woken up in a cold sweat once after a dream of the Sackville-Bagginses ever meeting Dis.

They had sent invitations to only friends and their closest family, though from Thorin’s side the turnout was understandably rather poor given the great distance separating them from Erebor. Dis had come, dumping her responsibilities on poor Fili and Kili so they could ‘practice’ under the watchful eye of Balin so Thorin supposed his nightmares of her meeting Lobelia were not actually all that farfetched. With her she had brought Dwalin as her bodyguard, Bofur because he had wanted to come and Nori who had also said he wanted to come but spent too much time acting like a wet cat to be enjoying himself. Or Perhaps he was enjoying himself in the performance?

Bilbo had invited some of his Baggins and Took relatives that he was still on good terms with as well as Holman, Hamfast and their families (it was just last year Hamfast and Bell had finally figured themselves out and Bilbo was far too pleased for them).

The ceremony was as, as per everything else about their relationship, a little unorthodox. They had Bilbo’s cousin, Fortinbras Took, marry them as he had recently become the Thain and was the highest ranking person present (save Dis, but she had declined the role). They had combined various parts of both hobbit and dwarf traditions as best they could. The wedding was outdoors, despite Thorin’s many trepidations when they were planning about poor weather, and they both dressed in the best approximation of dwarven wedding robes Thorin had been able to source. With regards to the shape of the garments they were fairly good – though this was partially because Thorin had explained at length to the Shire’s best tailor exactly what he wanted. The fabrics themselves left something to be desired as hobbits used different dyes from dwarves so the robes were a significantly paler blue than was usual but they were more suitable for the milder climate of the Shire and would certainly suffice.

At the end of the ceremony the entire congregation walked up the hill to Bag End to witness the hobbit custom of a First Planting where Bilbo and he planted the oak sapling that had been Bilbo’s beloved acorn. These past few years it had slowly grown in a pot, every so often being placed in a larger pot when it outgrew the previous one and now they were finally ready to properly plant it. Their hands overlapped as they patted down the soil and Thorin tenderly took Bilbo’s hand in his own as they rose. Bilbo had an immensely pleased expression, his cheeks flushed with exhilaration. They leaned in and kissed softly and for five seconds everything was perfect.

And then somehow, despite all their careful planning everything still went wrong. Thorin broke off the kiss when he heard muttering in the crowd. He turned to see a towering figure come into view, clad in grey and pipe smoking.

“Ah, there you are Bilbo.” Said Gandalf the Grey as he blinked at them rather myopically “What’s all this then?”

“You’re gate-crashing a wedding, old man” said Hamfast rather rudely.

“Oh, I see.” Gandalf said in a tone that indicated quite clearly that he certainly did not see “Whose wedding is this?”

“It’s ours.” Bilbo announced proudly, taking hold of Thorin’s hand again. When Gandalf’s incredulous stare focused on him Thorin suddenly wished he could turn invisible. For several dragging seconds Gandalf merely sucked on his pipe before saying “Hmm… fascinating.”

He continued to make a series of interesting expressions. Thorin cringed. Bilbo smiled obliviously.

Bilbo set to instructing everyone on getting out the mountain of food he had spent the last week preparing. Thorin made to help but Gandalf fixed him with a look that pinned him in place.

“Perhaps we might take a walk, Thorin.” he suggested mildly with enough underlying steel that it became an order.

“Of course” and off they went. Thorin couldn’t help but cast a single, longing gaze back at Bilbo but his partner was focused entirely upon his own tasks.

Gandalf waited until they were out of sight of the party before rounding on him. “I thought I told you to stay away from Bilbo, not marry him!” he scolded.

“I was trying to!” Thorin protested “I was planning on never seeing him again – he saved me from brigands!”

If Gandalf hadn’t been a near-immortal wizard he likely would have sniffed contemptuously, as it was he instead continued to stare at Thorin in his most severe manner.

“Look, I know you don’t approve Gandalf but I love Bilbo and he loves me.” he tried not to sound too giddy at saying that out loud and knowing for certain that it was true “Besides there isn’t enough gold in the entire Shire to bring back my gold sickness.”

“The gold sickness came back?” Gandalf asked and almost sounded concerned.

Thorin nodded “Nowhere near as bad as the first time but yes. The destruction of the Arkenstone helped but in the end I decided it was too dangerous for me to be King of Erebor.” He felt his shoulders slump under the shame.

Gandalf’s features softened a little “Giving up power is one of the most difficult things in this world, Thorin, don’t be ashamed.” Whatever he would have said next was interrupted by a joyful shout.

“Thorin! Gandalf! There you are!” They both turned and there was their favourite person. Bilbo walked towards them and before he was fully in earshot Gandalf said quietly “I won’t stand between you two. I think someday in the future Bilbo will need someone like you at his side. Do not prove me wrong again.” And with those ominous words Gandalf brushed past him to greet Bilbo properly. They returned to the party and Thorin forgot Gandalf’s words entirely.

Thorin would only think to consider this prediction when Gandalf reappeared over fifty years later.


November TA 2980 (Blotmath 1380 Shire Reckoning)

“Hello Frodo, it’s great to finally meet you!” Bilbo says brightly to the twelve-year-old hiding behind a corner. Frodo is smaller than average for his age, thin and pale almost to the point of appearing ill and very, very shy. Its understandable given the awful shock they’ve all had with his parents dying so suddenly and it reminds Thorin uncomfortably of the few precious children that had escaped Erebor when Smaug came. He has the expression of someone whose entire world has just been tipped on its head.

They’d agreed beforehand that Bilbo would handle introductions and he appears to be doing extremely well for someone who claims to ‘not possess a paternal bone in his body’ which Thorin strongly suspects is an affectation leftover from his Bachelor days (no one that truly dislikes children spends so much time telling them stories). In the contrast Thorin certainly does care openly about children and has never pretended otherwise but Bilbo had deemed his approach a little intense for a first meeting. It is apparently not the hobbit way to swear undying oaths of protection and loyalty when adopting orphans? It seems a tad laissez-faire in his opinion but who is he to tell other people how to live their lives.

It is no matter, once Frodo has warmed up to them Thorin is going to make sure he is the happiest, best protected hobbit to ever exist. He only hopes he can avoid giving Bilbo a heart attack in the process.


From Wonders of Gondolin: Remnants of a Golden Age by Barahir of Ithilien

Chapter 8: The Elf-Smiths of Gondolin

…In TA 2941 the swords Orcrist and Glamdring were found in a Troll hoard by Thorin Oakenshield’s company. To the author’s knowledge Glamdring remains in the ownership of Gandalf the White to this day, while Orcrist was taken up by Thorin Oakenshield himself. After his abdication and the subsequent disappearance of Thorin II, Orcrist disappeared from the pages of history once more until it was found in the possession of brigands near Fornost by Aragorn II, crowned King Elessar Telcontar, in TA 3018 and gifted to Boromir of Gondor upon the forming of the fellowship of the ring. Upon Boromir of Gondor’s death in TA 3019 Orcrist was kept by Aragorn II for a time before it was passed to Faramir of Gondor and it has since been passed down his line…


An excerpt from An Introduction to Dwarven History, Volume IV: The Third Age and Beyond co-authored by Mori daughter of Sori and Galin son of Yolin.

Chapter 6: A mountain reclaimed

King Thorin II may have driven the reclamation of Erebor from the dragon Smaug (Chapter 5) but he was to become Erebor’s shortest ruler and a figure of much controversy. Thorin II was never coronated as King under the mountain, though he held the title of King of Durin’s Folk from TA 2799-2941 (a mostly symbolic position while Durin’s line lacked a physical throne). Thorin II ruled Erebor for a mere six months before abdicating in favour of his younger sister, Dis I. The circumstances of his abdication are not entirely clear, the official records of the Royal scribe Ori son of Kori state “…our King declared before all that he was to abdicate and his Sister rise in his place. He severed the braid of office without qualm and all was well in Erebor.” But no reason is given for his actions. Balin son of Fundin, Thorin II’s closest advisor wrote more candidly in his personal journals: “I wish it were not so but Thorin has decided he is unfit for the throne. It is a sorry business what happened to poor Bilbo and even sorrier that Thorin allows it to overturn his ambitions. If only Bilbo were still here!” Bilbo of course being the same mysterious individual who was part of Thorin’s Company on the Quest of Erebor.

Very little has survived about who or what Bilbo was. In some records he is known as ‘Bilbo son of Bungo’ in dwarven fashion, giving rise to the belief he was a dwarf but neither name is of dwarven origin. In original records of the Quest, however he is almost always given the Hobbit surname ‘Baggins’ which would suggest he was not a dwarf. What happened to him after Erebor has reclaimed is unclear but the remaining sources suggest it is directly related to why Thorin II abdicated. Numerous primary sources of the Battle of the Five Armies refer to some kind of incident that occurred before the Orc General Bolg’s armies arrived. Thranduil, King of the elves of Mirkwood, wrote that “Thorin has lost any slightest particle of respect I may have held for him with his dishonourable behaviour” while King Bard I of Dale said “I only wish Thorin’s cooperation could have been bought without such a steep price.” None say exactly what happened but Bilbo vanishes from all Erebor’s records after and is not recorded amongst the dead of the Battle of the Five Armies.

There is of course the Hobbit book There and Back Again supposedly written by Bilbo Baggins himself but the book takes the format of a light-hearted tale for children and contains some significant inconsistencies with other records and is likely a retrospective work of fiction. There and Back Again, unlike more reliable sources does offer an explanation to what occurred. The book claims that Bilbo traded the Arkenstone (see Chapters 3 and 5) with Thranduil and Bard to force Thorin II to cooperate in the face of an overwhelming common enemy. The author than claims that Thorin cast Bilbo out from the mountain while deep in the throes of Gold sickness. While it is clear that the author was not present for the Battle of the Five Armies as their account is wildly inaccurate and this thus casts doubt on the entirety of the book as an accurate source it is worth noting as it is all that has survived.

Regardless, Thorin II’s brief rule was uneasy with both the issues that would be expected of a Kingdom being recolonised and an extra tension of uncertain origin. Public opinion of Thorin II was far lower than it should have been and at some point the moniker ‘Oakenshield’ which Thorin II earned at the battle of Azanulbizar (Chapter 4) and remained with him through much of his life began to be replaced with less flattering names such as ‘Dragonheart’ or ‘Childslayer’ – though why this last one in particular was ever adopted even unofficially is not recorded.

After Thorin II’s abdication he remained in Erebor for a year before leaving Erebor. He would never return. A letter from Thorin II to Dis I suggests he settled in the shire and that he married a hobbit who he only refers to in the letter as ‘B’. It is tempting to assume that this mysterious ‘B’ is Bilbo Baggins but there is little evidence. The Shire records office burnt down during the scouring of the shire (TA 3018, shire reckoning 1418) and thus destroyed any evidence that may have existed.

The most tantalising of evidence is the recent discovery of a horde of gold found buried next to a sizeable oak tree in the Shire. The horde contained mainly coins from various periods in the second and third ages as well as a hobbit-sized mithril shirt and the remnants of letters written in Westron and Khuzdul that are currently undergoing restoration and research at the University of Michel Delving.


Taken from Bilbo Baggins: Thief, Hero or Myth by Isabella Took II

Chapter 10: The Rise of ‘Mad Baggins’

It is believed that the myth of ‘Mad Baggins’ was created sometime after Bilbo Baggins returned to the Shire in SR 1342. All official records from the time of Baggins’ life were destroyed in a fire in SR 1418 so the only extant documents are personal journals and letters kept by Baggins’ contemporaries. Baggins arrived back in the Shire even more fantastically rich than when he had left and in the company of a wizard – widely assumed to be Gandalf the Grey – and in a poor state of health according to a letter from Holman Greenhand, Baggins’ gardener at the time, to Hobbiton’s Doctor. It is not stated precisely what troubled Bilbo Baggins but there are numerous allusions that he was unwell in some way in the surviving sources.

Despite writing There and Back Again, an account of his journey that has been deemed at least partially fictional by the Dwarven scholar Mori daughter of Sori, Baggins allegedly remained extremely closemouthed about the events of the Quest in the years prior to the book’s publishing and displayed such eccentricities such as carrying around a small sword and occasionally in winter dressing in the dwarven style. In the year SR 1344 a dwarf came to live with Baggins. The name of this dwarf has been lost to history – in extant writings he is exclusively referred to as ‘the dwarf’, ‘Bilbo’s Guest’ and other such terms of dubious endearment. It has been speculated that this mystery individual was Thorin Oakenshield, though such theories have been proposed almost entirely on a basis of pure romanticisation, but it is likely that it was any of the members of the company.

The moniker of ‘Mad Baggins’ fully took hold in SR 1349 when Baggins allegedly married the unknown dwarf. While in the Shire homosexuality has never been outright forbidden, at this time it was viewed as a temporary, informal arrangement and marriages between individuals of different races was unheard of. For Bilbo and the dwarf to marry would have been considered highly irregular.

Remaining sources remain evenly split on opinion regarding the marriage. A letter written from Lobelia Sackville-Baggins to Odo Proudfoot is of note for having a particularly vitriolic tone, though this may be in part because it appears she was not invited.

[…]

After a tragic accident in which Drogo and Primula Brandybuck lost their lives the Baggins of Bag End came to adopt Frodo Baggins and raised him until he came of age in SR 1401. Frodo and Bilbo Baggins shared a birthday and at the end of that infamous party Bilbo Baggins allegedly vanished into thin air and neither he nor his husband were ever seen again.

This last finale in the eventful life of Bilbo Baggins is the most baffling as there is not a trace remaining of where they went after leaving the Shire that night. Bilbo Baggins was celebrating his ‘eleventy first’ birthday so it seems inconceivable that he would be able to make a trek of any significant distance.

The mystery of his literal ‘vanishing act’ and what happened after will likely never be solved and gave rise to many myths and ghost stories which will be elaborated on in the next chapter.

Notes:

I would like to add that while Thorin and Bilbo end up together at the end here if YOU personally have ever been dropped off a building by your crush and you are now considering getting together maybe don't? If I was Bilbo here I would be like NOPE.

Anyway this is farewell to all of you. I do not foresee writing anything else for this fandom however who knows if my brain will smack me with more ideas some day in the future!

Notes:

Warnings for attempted murder, some description of serious injuries, vomiting.

If you enjoyed please leave a comment :)) Hope everyone has a good day!