Chapter Text
March TA 2944 (Rethe 1344 Shire Reckoning)
Bilbo knocked on the door of Thorin’s room at the Prancing Pony. Drogo had finally fallen asleep in his and Bilbo’s shared room and Thorin had to be back from his visit to the town Physician by now!
The door opened a crack, a single glittering eye stared at him for a second before he was allowed to enter.
“Hello Thorin! I hope you are feeling better now.” Bilbo said with a smile. Thorin looked much healthier now that his wounds had been tended to and he had eaten a proper meal and washed.
“Yes, much.” He replied shortly, his shoulders so tense that it must have pained him. Bilbo wasn’t sure what to say now – it was clear Thorin didn’t care for his company. Maybe he hadn’t forgiven him for stealing the Arkenstone? In hindsight Bilbo himself had become somewhat conflicted about his actions that night so it was no great leap to think that Thorin may still hold some resentment. Oh goodness, was he forcing Thorin to deal with his unwanted company?!
“Great!” he said far too excitedly before wishing it would be appropriate to smack himself. He had really wanted to talk to Thorin without Drogo bumbling around in the background but this was painfully awkward!
They stared at each other for longer than was comfortable. Thorin’s expression was unreadable and Bilbo’s thoughts were like a tangle of fruiting brambles – unwieldy and painful and pleasing in near equal measure. He could feel himself blushing and he was so flustered and tired that his leg began to tremble a little.
“Are you alright, Bilbo?” Thorin asked concernedly and reached out hesitantly to steady him when the shaking worsened. His grip was firm but not overly so and Bilbo looked up at Thorin and despite everything felt safe. He knew he shouldn’t – Thorin nearly killed him once! – but that awful day felt distant now that Thorin was here and so clearly in his right mind once again.
“Bilbo! Are you injured?” Thorin demanded when he doesn’t immediately respond, beginning to feel along his limbs for injuries.
“Oh no, I’m fine. It’s just my bad leg getting tired.” Bilbo said with a shrug.
Thorin’s eyebrows drew downwards like gathering storm clouds “Is that from when I…?”
Bilbo nodded hesitantly and when Thorin scowled he hastened to add “I’m a lot better now though. It’s only doing that because I’m tired and I fell on it earlier!”
His leg choose that moment to collapse fully and he fell forward into Thorin’s chest. Thorin supported him under the arms, taking almost all of his weight and Bilbo felt his face turning red from the mortification.
“Bilbo, that was years ago now! How can you stand to be around me when I’ve crippled you like this?” He cried, horrified.
Bilbo looked up at him and saw the emotions written far clearer on Thorin’s face than he’d have liked. Shame, regret and worst of all, pity. He had no need for yet more of that particular sentiment – so what if he had had to slow down a little, he could still do everything he wanted to! “I’ll thank you not to pity me, Thorin Oakenshield! I can barely take it from everyone back home and I will not tolerate you treating me like that when I killed a man for you today!!” He pushed Thorin’s hands away and took a couple uneven steps back.
Thorin stared and stuttered a little in a rather undignified manner.
“I think I’ll go to bed now.” Bilbo said crossly.
“No, don’t go!” Thorin said hurriedly and caught his wrist. Bilbo turned, a touch indignant at his dramatic exit being thwarted and Thorin instantly released him, recoiling as if burnt. Bilbo considers leaving anyway but he isn’t quite angry enough for that to truly appeal.
“I’ve missed you too, Bilbo! I missed you so much ever since the moment you fell and I realised what I had done.” Thorin’s habitual stoicism was gone, his expression open in a way that Bilbo had only rarely seen on a handful of occasions before. The silence in the room was suffocating with words neither of them wanted to say. They looked at each other instead and Bilbo wondered for a second if things wouldn’t have had to come to this if he had come up with a different solution to stealing the Arkenstone. He didn’t truly think he could have done anything better than he had but it was tempting to imagine some way that everything could have been saved without sacrifice.
“Why did you never write? Balin said he asked you about it and you refused.” He eventually asked raggedly.
Thorin looked away, his expression closed off “I thought you would be happier not hearing from me. I’m sorry, Bilbo. Truly.”
“You are an idiot.” Bilbo replied “When I heard that you were no longer King I thought something dreadful had happened! If I could have I would have marched all the way back to Erebor.”
It was Thorin’s turn to sway a little, either from exhaustion or blood loss, Bilbo couldn’t tell. Bilbo did his best to steady him but Thorin was much heavier than him and they both staggered a little “I’m not sure which of us is more the fool, all of this and you still care about me?”
“Of course.” Bilbo replied warmly (maybe a little too warmly but Thorin didn’t seem to notice) before a yawn forced its way out. He went to continue speaking but then Thorin yawned too and Bilbo realised he looked exhausted.
“Oh, I think that would be my cue to retire for the night.” He said with a grin. Thorin’s mouth twitched at the corners.
“What are your plans?” Bilbo asked with no small amount of trepidation. He wasn’t anywhere near being ready to let Thorin walk back out of his life but surely he had had a destination in mind when he had begun his journey?
“Well I’ve been working as a travelling blacksmith for the last while but as long as there are people in need of my skills, where I go isn’t particularly important.” Thorin paused before saying far more hesitantly “I… I could go to the Shire, with you? If you wanted?”
Bilbo grinned and tried not to sound too eager when he replied “Yes, please do!”
April TA 2944 (Astron 1344 Shire Reckoning)
When Bilbo stopped to talk to yet another distant relation Thorin sighed fondly, though also a touch exasperatedly. He had lost count of the number of such encounters there had been on their journey through the Shire but he was willing to bet that it would be easier to count which Hobbits Bilbo wasn’t related to in some tenuous fashion. He had always thought Dwarves were knowledgeable on genealogies but that was nothing in the face of the dedication of Hobbits.
Thorin found the Shire particularly baffling to navigate but Bilbo had told him that they were very close to Hobbiton now. If they walked quickly they might even make it to Bag End today – though that seemed like a futile hope with all this chattering.
The journey had been the slowest of Thorin’s life. When they had set off from Bree Bilbo’s leg had been paining him from his fall from the cart but he had confidently waved off their concerns. They had only made it a few miles from Bree, their pace gradually slowing to accommodate Bilbo’s increasing difficulty keeping up when Bilbo admitted he couldn’t continue. They had been lucky that a farmer on his return from market had been willing to give them a lift to Brandybuck hall where they had stayed for the next week and a half.
His own wounds were thankful for the respite he had to admit, though given how the recovery process for Hobbits appeared to involve an inordinate amount of fussing he didn’t advertise that he was injured. Drogo had been the only one pleased by the unexpected pause in their travels as he had a rather blatant fondness for one of the Brandybuck lasses and had apparently gone on this trip as an excuse to see her anyway. Bilbo however, became more ill-tempered with every day they were forced to linger with worried Brandybucks smothering him with their concern. Thorin tried to keep out of his way but he found himself drawn to the periphery of whatever room Bilbo was in.
The other hobbits didn’t avoid Thorin but they didn’t interact with him unless there was something they were curious about. They treated him with some suspicion but Thorin thought it was nowhere near enough for them to know the full story of what Thorin had done.
Eventually Bilbo lost patience at being coddled and they left despite it being clear that Bilbo, while much improved, still wasn’t fully recovered. They resumed their journey back to Hobbiton with new enthusiasm.
The Shire was pleasant to walk through – even more pleasant now that Thorin had the time to appreciate his surroundings and wasn’t setting off on a dangerous quest. It was spring and the new leaves were so green that when the sun was out it dazzled him. Everywhere he looked was more vibrant than the finest emerald, more pleasing to the eye than jade. The rivers ran clear and were full of jewel-bright fish and the verges of the roads were thick with daffodils and crocuses and other early-flowering plants Thorin hadn’t known the names for. He was beginning to understand why Hobbits didn’t care for gold and gemstones if they lived in such splendour.
His interest didn’t go unnoticed by Bilbo and he had begun endeavouring to teach Thorin their names. He suspected Bilbo found these lessons a little frustrating. Thorin had never spent much so much time looking at plants before and he found some of the differences between them impossible to spot. He could identify a primrose with confidence but when he had mistaken an early purple orchid for a bluebell Bilbo had looked rather disturbed and Drogo had laughed at him. Bilbo had tried to explain the difference to him but Thorin was still somewhat confused. He supposed bluebells generally grew taller?
Bilbo finally finished talking to the other hobbit and they began to walk towards Hobbiton once more. The sun was almost directly ahead of them and low to the horizon but as they rounded a grassy hill he could make out against the glare small cottages and doors sunk into the sides of hills and slopes. It had been three years since he last saw Hobbiton but he still recognised it.
They bid Drogo goodbye at the crossroads just inside Hobbiton before turning and walking up the hill to Bag End. When the round green door appeared Thorin saw with some surprise that the dwarven rune Gandalf had carved into the wood still glowed softly.
“Welcome back.” Bilbo said quietly and smiled. The sun was setting now and Bilbo was washed in glorious amber light.
Thorin thinks that while sometimes he misses the subterranean wonders of Erebor the Shire is going to do quite nicely.
April TA 2944 (Astron 1344 Shire Reckoning)
It had only been a couple weeks since he had returned to Hobbiton with Bilbo but Thorin thought it was going quite well. He had begun to set up the town forge, which had stood empty save from when the occasional travelling blacksmith had used it for some years since the last resident ‘smith had retired some twenty years ago.
Hobbits may be suspicious of other peoples – dwarves included – but they could acknowledge good craftmanship wherever it came from and there had been considerable interest in the business. Bilbo had been a great help introducing him to people and he had already begun receiving jobs.
He was drawing out a design for a replacement wrought iron gate for Mrs Proudfoot when he happened to glance at large clockwork timepiece and realised he was late to tea or dinner or whatever meal they were on now. He quickly tidied up his drawings and tools and left the forge. It was a pleasant spring evening – a little warm and the air still moist with the heavy rainfall from this morning.
Thorin walked up the little hill to Bag End and let himself inside. He was in the process of removing his boots when he heard voices coming from the sitting room. Distinctly unhappy voices. He didn’t consider that he was eavesdropping when he walked carefully to the door and listened, he was only concerned about whatever disagreement was occurring.
“…and now you’ve let one into your house! I can’t believe you’d be so stupid as to let a stranger – a foreigner no less – live in your house for who knows how long! I wouldn’t be surprised if you started having goblins as houseguests next, they certainly couldn’t be much dirtier!!” A voice he doesn’t recognise proclaims loudly. Thorin considered entering the room right then but then Bilbo spoke and Thorin remained where he was.
“I will thank you not to mind my affairs for me, Odo.” Bilbo’s voice is clipped and severe. “Thorin is a dear friend of mine and I find it offensive in the extreme that you would liken him to a goblin.”
“I’ll call things what they are, Bilbo. If it smells like a goblin and speaks like a goblin then I’ll bloody well call it a goblin!” Thorin ground his teeth at the insult but remained where he was.
“You’ve never even seen a goblin!” Bilbo cried furiously.
“And you have?!” Odo challenged.
“Yes!” Bilbo near howled “I have seen and done all kinds of things you couldn’t even imagine!”
“I wouldn’t have to imagine if you just told people, Bilbo! You haven’t even told anyone how you were injured.” There was a pause in the shouting match and after marshalling himself Thorin knocked on the door before entering.
Bilbo and Odo were both standing with the table bearing the remains of afternoon tea between them. The table was probably all that had separated them from scrapping on the floor but when they saw him they slipped back into distant propriety as he had hoped. Odo’s cheeks slowly flushed red at the indignity of being caught arguing.
“Is everything alright?” he asked, looking only to Bilbo for a response.
“My cousin was just about to leave.” Bilbo announced, uncharacteristically coldly.
Odo sniffed and began to make his way to the door.
Thorin escorted the Hobbit out, handing him his coat and opening the front door politely. Odo gave him a measuring look as he inserted his arms into the sleeves.
“You know what happened to him don’t you.” He said slowly.
“I was there.” Thorin admitted, holding back the unfortunate addition of ‘I did it to him’ that sits accusingly at the back of his throat.
“You won’t tell me either though, will you.” Odo sighed.
“If he doesn’t want people to know then I shouldn’t say.” Thorin said uncomfortably, it felt distinctly selfish to hide behind such an excuse. He didn’t deserve Bilbo shielding him like this. If it were anything else he could keep it secret without a qualm but this… he was covering for his own crime!
“Quite right.” Odo said and Thorin felt even guiltier “I still do not approve of Bilbo’s taste in friends but I apologise for my rudeness.” Thorin watched him go before closing the door and returning to the sitting room.
Bilbo had sat in his plush armchair, face turned away and his posture sagging and Thorin went to sit in the chair on the other side of the fireplace.
“I’m sorry you had to hear that.” Bilbo said “Since my return my cousin feels that he must protect me and I vex him supremely by continuing to associate with people from out with the Shire.”
“Well I suppose he isn’t entirely wrong in that, even if it is rather late.” Thorin said, attempting humour but falling short.
Bilbo looks up at him and says chastisingly “Thorin.”
“I would have told him what happened if it hadn’t meant betraying your trust.” Thorin finds himself admitting. “Why is it that you don’t want anyone to know?”
Bilbo makes a strangled noise “Because I don’t want them to run you out of town, you idiot!”
“I would deserve it.” Thorin says stubbornly even as the thought of leaving fills him with pure dread.
“You were ill!” Bilbo cries.
“That is a poor excuse. People do all sorts of terrible things because they were ill in some way or another and they are still blamed for their actions, why should I be any different?”
Bilbo looks stricken “I don’t want you to leave again. When I heard you had abdicated I thought something terrible had happened. I thought the entire Quest had been for naught and that you had been exiled again or killed and yet here we are, reunited against all odds. So what if I am no longer quite the same Hobbit as I once was, if I could have my health or you I know which I’d choose.”
“You never should have had to make that choice.” Thorin says and his words become quieter, heavier as they leave him. “You trusted me to see sense and I almost killed you.”
“That is true.” Bilbo agrees and Thorin winces “However, while I don’t remember much from that day but I do remember the look of your face when you tried to catch me. I don’t think you ever meant to hurt me, did you?” Bilbo fixes him with a look fierce enough to be at home on a Great Eagle.
“I don’t know. I’ve thought about that day so much that it is hard to know what I was thinking at the time.” He says raggedly.
“Thorin,” Bilbo reaches out and catches hold of Thorin’s hands in his own. They are warm, softer than his own but still a little rough and calloused and so horrifyingly small. “I’ve never held what happened against you. There are plenty days I have wished that our time together could have ended differently or that I hadn’t been hurt but I have never regretted going on the quest. I think you’ve already suffered more than enough for what happened.” Bilbo looks directly into his eyes “Instead of inviting others to criticise you, you need to start forgiving yourself.”
He stands then and gently relinquishes his hold on Thorin’s hands and just like that the tense atmosphere shifts back to normality “I’ll just check on how our dinner is coming along.” He glances at the clock and starts in horror at the time before hurrying out of the room.
September TA 2944 (Halimath 1344 Shire Reckoning)
“I understand why hobbits eat so many meals when farming is so exhausting!” Thorin groaned as he sat in the grass next to Bilbo. It was coming to the end of harvest time and every able-bodied parson was needed in the fields. The other hobbits had been sceptical at first but Thorin had worked on farms before – admittedly some decades ago – and he was physically stronger than most of them so in the end they had come to almost appreciate him.
This morning he had been helping harvest the last of the wheat and although the hottest part of the day was only beginning he was disgustingly sweaty. Bilbo didn’t seem to mind though as he only shifted closer and handed him a heavily loaded plate.
Everyone then set about inhaling their food as if it was the first food they had seen all day. Thorin still only ate three meals a day but after living off of Bilbo’s cooking he could fully understand the temptation of seven.
The hobbits finished quicker than he did and after resting a little began to tidy up. Bilbo remained sat next to him as he ate and as the sun got hotter he slowly leaned into Thorin’s side. When he finished he carefully set his plate aside and looked down a little bemusedly.
He was not used to such physical intimacy but it was far from unpleasant. He wasn’t entirely sure when Bilbo had begun to relax around him so enthusiastically as it had begun subtle at first. Their hands brushing a little more than necessary when handing each other things, momentary pats to his arm and that sort of thing. Without really noticing at all the situation had escalated to the extent that the other evening Bilbo had fallen asleep with his head in Thorin’s lap and he had barely thought anything of it at the time.
He had thought it was some sort of strange cultural difference. Maybe hobbits were by nature more cuddly than dwarves? Thorin couldn’t be that nice to hug as he was so awkwardly large and heavy in comparison to a hobbit and had none of their softness. Bilbo was probably just trying to be polite? He had considered asking Bilbo but had refrained. He didn’t want Bilbo to feel awkward or think he had made Thorin uncomfortable – which certainly was not the case! Ultimately he hadn’t asked because then he wouldn’t have to tell Bilbo the full extent of how he felt about him and face the subsequent rejection.
Then yesterday he had unintentionally seen Hamfast and Bell sat together in a very similar manner and clearly flirting and now that he had seen it from the outside it was much more clear.
Could Bilbo possibly like him back? He hadn’t been able to think of anything else since he realised.
Bilbo shifted to look up at him. “So serious!” he commented with a smile.
Thorin felt his ears flush and, before he could overthink he reached out a hand to cradle Bilbo’s cheek. Bilbo leaned into the touch, his eyes wide but not from fear and his smile widening.
Dwarves tended to show affection in ways other than kissing – it only took one incident of tangling beards with a partner to know why but in that moment that was all Thorin wanted (and besides Bilbo didn’t have any facial hair to get tangled in!). He leaned down and pressed the softest of kisses to his cheek.
Bilbo flushed a brilliant ruby red and after a long surprised moment reached up to return the kiss.
July TA 2949 (Afterlithe 1349 Shire Reckoning)
In the end their wedding was a small, quiet affair. Neither of them were from cultures where such was the norm but properly integrating their people’s wildly differing traditions and inviting a full complement of guests was far more effort than it was worth. Thorin had woken up in a cold sweat once after a dream of the Sackville-Bagginses ever meeting Dis.
They had sent invitations to only friends and their closest family, though from Thorin’s side the turnout was understandably rather poor given the great distance separating them from Erebor. Dis had come, dumping her responsibilities on poor Fili and Kili so they could ‘practice’ under the watchful eye of Balin so Thorin supposed his nightmares of her meeting Lobelia were not actually all that farfetched. With her she had brought Dwalin as her bodyguard, Bofur because he had wanted to come and Nori who had also said he wanted to come but spent too much time acting like a wet cat to be enjoying himself. Or Perhaps he was enjoying himself in the performance?
Bilbo had invited some of his Baggins and Took relatives that he was still on good terms with as well as Holman, Hamfast and their families (it was just last year Hamfast and Bell had finally figured themselves out and Bilbo was far too pleased for them).
The ceremony was as, as per everything else about their relationship, a little unorthodox. They had Bilbo’s cousin, Fortinbras Took, marry them as he had recently become the Thain and was the highest ranking person present (save Dis, but she had declined the role). They had combined various parts of both hobbit and dwarf traditions as best they could. The wedding was outdoors, despite Thorin’s many trepidations when they were planning about poor weather, and they both dressed in the best approximation of dwarven wedding robes Thorin had been able to source. With regards to the shape of the garments they were fairly good – though this was partially because Thorin had explained at length to the Shire’s best tailor exactly what he wanted. The fabrics themselves left something to be desired as hobbits used different dyes from dwarves so the robes were a significantly paler blue than was usual but they were more suitable for the milder climate of the Shire and would certainly suffice.
At the end of the ceremony the entire congregation walked up the hill to Bag End to witness the hobbit custom of a First Planting where Bilbo and he planted the oak sapling that had been Bilbo’s beloved acorn. These past few years it had slowly grown in a pot, every so often being placed in a larger pot when it outgrew the previous one and now they were finally ready to properly plant it. Their hands overlapped as they patted down the soil and Thorin tenderly took Bilbo’s hand in his own as they rose. Bilbo had an immensely pleased expression, his cheeks flushed with exhilaration. They leaned in and kissed softly and for five seconds everything was perfect.
And then somehow, despite all their careful planning everything still went wrong. Thorin broke off the kiss when he heard muttering in the crowd. He turned to see a towering figure come into view, clad in grey and pipe smoking.
“Ah, there you are Bilbo.” Said Gandalf the Grey as he blinked at them rather myopically “What’s all this then?”
“You’re gate-crashing a wedding, old man” said Hamfast rather rudely.
“Oh, I see.” Gandalf said in a tone that indicated quite clearly that he certainly did not see “Whose wedding is this?”
“It’s ours.” Bilbo announced proudly, taking hold of Thorin’s hand again. When Gandalf’s incredulous stare focused on him Thorin suddenly wished he could turn invisible. For several dragging seconds Gandalf merely sucked on his pipe before saying “Hmm… fascinating.”
He continued to make a series of interesting expressions. Thorin cringed. Bilbo smiled obliviously.
Bilbo set to instructing everyone on getting out the mountain of food he had spent the last week preparing. Thorin made to help but Gandalf fixed him with a look that pinned him in place.
“Perhaps we might take a walk, Thorin.” he suggested mildly with enough underlying steel that it became an order.
“Of course” and off they went. Thorin couldn’t help but cast a single, longing gaze back at Bilbo but his partner was focused entirely upon his own tasks.
Gandalf waited until they were out of sight of the party before rounding on him. “I thought I told you to stay away from Bilbo, not marry him!” he scolded.
“I was trying to!” Thorin protested “I was planning on never seeing him again – he saved me from brigands!”
If Gandalf hadn’t been a near-immortal wizard he likely would have sniffed contemptuously, as it was he instead continued to stare at Thorin in his most severe manner.
“Look, I know you don’t approve Gandalf but I love Bilbo and he loves me.” he tried not to sound too giddy at saying that out loud and knowing for certain that it was true “Besides there isn’t enough gold in the entire Shire to bring back my gold sickness.”
“The gold sickness came back?” Gandalf asked and almost sounded concerned.
Thorin nodded “Nowhere near as bad as the first time but yes. The destruction of the Arkenstone helped but in the end I decided it was too dangerous for me to be King of Erebor.” He felt his shoulders slump under the shame.
Gandalf’s features softened a little “Giving up power is one of the most difficult things in this world, Thorin, don’t be ashamed.” Whatever he would have said next was interrupted by a joyful shout.
“Thorin! Gandalf! There you are!” They both turned and there was their favourite person. Bilbo walked towards them and before he was fully in earshot Gandalf said quietly “I won’t stand between you two. I think someday in the future Bilbo will need someone like you at his side. Do not prove me wrong again.” And with those ominous words Gandalf brushed past him to greet Bilbo properly. They returned to the party and Thorin forgot Gandalf’s words entirely.
Thorin would only think to consider this prediction when Gandalf reappeared over fifty years later.
November TA 2980 (Blotmath 1380 Shire Reckoning)
“Hello Frodo, it’s great to finally meet you!” Bilbo says brightly to the twelve-year-old hiding behind a corner. Frodo is smaller than average for his age, thin and pale almost to the point of appearing ill and very, very shy. Its understandable given the awful shock they’ve all had with his parents dying so suddenly and it reminds Thorin uncomfortably of the few precious children that had escaped Erebor when Smaug came. He has the expression of someone whose entire world has just been tipped on its head.
They’d agreed beforehand that Bilbo would handle introductions and he appears to be doing extremely well for someone who claims to ‘not possess a paternal bone in his body’ which Thorin strongly suspects is an affectation leftover from his Bachelor days (no one that truly dislikes children spends so much time telling them stories). In the contrast Thorin certainly does care openly about children and has never pretended otherwise but Bilbo had deemed his approach a little intense for a first meeting. It is apparently not the hobbit way to swear undying oaths of protection and loyalty when adopting orphans? It seems a tad laissez-faire in his opinion but who is he to tell other people how to live their lives.
It is no matter, once Frodo has warmed up to them Thorin is going to make sure he is the happiest, best protected hobbit to ever exist. He only hopes he can avoid giving Bilbo a heart attack in the process.
From Wonders of Gondolin: Remnants of a Golden Age by Barahir of Ithilien
Chapter 8: The Elf-Smiths of Gondolin
…In TA 2941 the swords Orcrist and Glamdring were found in a Troll hoard by Thorin Oakenshield’s company. To the author’s knowledge Glamdring remains in the ownership of Gandalf the White to this day, while Orcrist was taken up by Thorin Oakenshield himself. After his abdication and the subsequent disappearance of Thorin II, Orcrist disappeared from the pages of history once more until it was found in the possession of brigands near Fornost by Aragorn II, crowned King Elessar Telcontar, in TA 3018 and gifted to Boromir of Gondor upon the forming of the fellowship of the ring. Upon Boromir of Gondor’s death in TA 3019 Orcrist was kept by Aragorn II for a time before it was passed to Faramir of Gondor and it has since been passed down his line…
An excerpt from An Introduction to Dwarven History, Volume IV: The Third Age and Beyond co-authored by Mori daughter of Sori and Galin son of Yolin.
Chapter 6: A mountain reclaimed
King Thorin II may have driven the reclamation of Erebor from the dragon Smaug (Chapter 5) but he was to become Erebor’s shortest ruler and a figure of much controversy. Thorin II was never coronated as King under the mountain, though he held the title of King of Durin’s Folk from TA 2799-2941 (a mostly symbolic position while Durin’s line lacked a physical throne). Thorin II ruled Erebor for a mere six months before abdicating in favour of his younger sister, Dis I. The circumstances of his abdication are not entirely clear, the official records of the Royal scribe Ori son of Kori state “…our King declared before all that he was to abdicate and his Sister rise in his place. He severed the braid of office without qualm and all was well in Erebor.” But no reason is given for his actions. Balin son of Fundin, Thorin II’s closest advisor wrote more candidly in his personal journals: “I wish it were not so but Thorin has decided he is unfit for the throne. It is a sorry business what happened to poor Bilbo and even sorrier that Thorin allows it to overturn his ambitions. If only Bilbo were still here!” Bilbo of course being the same mysterious individual who was part of Thorin’s Company on the Quest of Erebor.
Very little has survived about who or what Bilbo was. In some records he is known as ‘Bilbo son of Bungo’ in dwarven fashion, giving rise to the belief he was a dwarf but neither name is of dwarven origin. In original records of the Quest, however he is almost always given the Hobbit surname ‘Baggins’ which would suggest he was not a dwarf. What happened to him after Erebor has reclaimed is unclear but the remaining sources suggest it is directly related to why Thorin II abdicated. Numerous primary sources of the Battle of the Five Armies refer to some kind of incident that occurred before the Orc General Bolg’s armies arrived. Thranduil, King of the elves of Mirkwood, wrote that “Thorin has lost any slightest particle of respect I may have held for him with his dishonourable behaviour” while King Bard I of Dale said “I only wish Thorin’s cooperation could have been bought without such a steep price.” None say exactly what happened but Bilbo vanishes from all Erebor’s records after and is not recorded amongst the dead of the Battle of the Five Armies.
There is of course the Hobbit book There and Back Again supposedly written by Bilbo Baggins himself but the book takes the format of a light-hearted tale for children and contains some significant inconsistencies with other records and is likely a retrospective work of fiction. There and Back Again, unlike more reliable sources does offer an explanation to what occurred. The book claims that Bilbo traded the Arkenstone (see Chapters 3 and 5) with Thranduil and Bard to force Thorin II to cooperate in the face of an overwhelming common enemy. The author than claims that Thorin cast Bilbo out from the mountain while deep in the throes of Gold sickness. While it is clear that the author was not present for the Battle of the Five Armies as their account is wildly inaccurate and this thus casts doubt on the entirety of the book as an accurate source it is worth noting as it is all that has survived.
Regardless, Thorin II’s brief rule was uneasy with both the issues that would be expected of a Kingdom being recolonised and an extra tension of uncertain origin. Public opinion of Thorin II was far lower than it should have been and at some point the moniker ‘Oakenshield’ which Thorin II earned at the battle of Azanulbizar (Chapter 4) and remained with him through much of his life began to be replaced with less flattering names such as ‘Dragonheart’ or ‘Childslayer’ – though why this last one in particular was ever adopted even unofficially is not recorded.
After Thorin II’s abdication he remained in Erebor for a year before leaving Erebor. He would never return. A letter from Thorin II to Dis I suggests he settled in the shire and that he married a hobbit who he only refers to in the letter as ‘B’. It is tempting to assume that this mysterious ‘B’ is Bilbo Baggins but there is little evidence. The Shire records office burnt down during the scouring of the shire (TA 3018, shire reckoning 1418) and thus destroyed any evidence that may have existed.
The most tantalising of evidence is the recent discovery of a horde of gold found buried next to a sizeable oak tree in the Shire. The horde contained mainly coins from various periods in the second and third ages as well as a hobbit-sized mithril shirt and the remnants of letters written in Westron and Khuzdul that are currently undergoing restoration and research at the University of Michel Delving.
Taken from Bilbo Baggins: Thief, Hero or Myth by Isabella Took II
Chapter 10: The Rise of ‘Mad Baggins’
It is believed that the myth of ‘Mad Baggins’ was created sometime after Bilbo Baggins returned to the Shire in SR 1342. All official records from the time of Baggins’ life were destroyed in a fire in SR 1418 so the only extant documents are personal journals and letters kept by Baggins’ contemporaries. Baggins arrived back in the Shire even more fantastically rich than when he had left and in the company of a wizard – widely assumed to be Gandalf the Grey – and in a poor state of health according to a letter from Holman Greenhand, Baggins’ gardener at the time, to Hobbiton’s Doctor. It is not stated precisely what troubled Bilbo Baggins but there are numerous allusions that he was unwell in some way in the surviving sources.
Despite writing There and Back Again, an account of his journey that has been deemed at least partially fictional by the Dwarven scholar Mori daughter of Sori, Baggins allegedly remained extremely closemouthed about the events of the Quest in the years prior to the book’s publishing and displayed such eccentricities such as carrying around a small sword and occasionally in winter dressing in the dwarven style. In the year SR 1344 a dwarf came to live with Baggins. The name of this dwarf has been lost to history – in extant writings he is exclusively referred to as ‘the dwarf’, ‘Bilbo’s Guest’ and other such terms of dubious endearment. It has been speculated that this mystery individual was Thorin Oakenshield, though such theories have been proposed almost entirely on a basis of pure romanticisation, but it is likely that it was any of the members of the company.
The moniker of ‘Mad Baggins’ fully took hold in SR 1349 when Baggins allegedly married the unknown dwarf. While in the Shire homosexuality has never been outright forbidden, at this time it was viewed as a temporary, informal arrangement and marriages between individuals of different races was unheard of. For Bilbo and the dwarf to marry would have been considered highly irregular.
Remaining sources remain evenly split on opinion regarding the marriage. A letter written from Lobelia Sackville-Baggins to Odo Proudfoot is of note for having a particularly vitriolic tone, though this may be in part because it appears she was not invited.
[…]
After a tragic accident in which Drogo and Primula Brandybuck lost their lives the Baggins of Bag End came to adopt Frodo Baggins and raised him until he came of age in SR 1401. Frodo and Bilbo Baggins shared a birthday and at the end of that infamous party Bilbo Baggins allegedly vanished into thin air and neither he nor his husband were ever seen again.
This last finale in the eventful life of Bilbo Baggins is the most baffling as there is not a trace remaining of where they went after leaving the Shire that night. Bilbo Baggins was celebrating his ‘eleventy first’ birthday so it seems inconceivable that he would be able to make a trek of any significant distance.
The mystery of his literal ‘vanishing act’ and what happened after will likely never be solved and gave rise to many myths and ghost stories which will be elaborated on in the next chapter.
