Actions

Work Header

What We Owe To Each Other

Chapter 4: Well, that could've gone better

Notes:

This is a fairly intense chapter, and definitely a turning point for our Durin siblings.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

     The table was set, and dinner was quickly coming together. Their rooms smelled of garlic and roast, and there was a pit where Thorin’s stomach should be. Bilbo had already banished him from the kitchen after he caught Thorin sneaking pieces of fried potato, leaving the dwarf to sit in the sitting room and sulk.
     While it had sounded like a fine idea when Bilbo proposed it the day before, the prospect of spending a meal being cordial with his sister made him want to run. It wasn’t that he didn’t want to try, he knew from experience that it never worked. They had tried before. Dis used to invite him around all the time when her husband was still alive, and even with Vili there to mediate, they still had tension.
     Vili had been the only one who could get away with locking the two of them in a room and making them apologize. Thorin could recall many moments when he would be yelling at his sister, and Dis would be yelling back, and Vili would just sit back and smile until they ran out of steam.
It was good luck that Fili inherited his father’s disposition. Thorin knew that he wasn’t easy to deal with, and to have his Heir be of a calmer demeanor was a blessing straight from Mahal. Still, Fili shouldn’t, and wouldn’t, be forced into the mediator position that his father willingly took up.
     So it would fall on Thorin to keep the peace. It should’ve always been his, and Dis’s, responsibility. But they had been young, and dumb, and stressed out, and Vili had been an easy crutch when being in the same room was arduous.

     The kitchen door opened, and Bilbo called for him from beyond the doorway. The smell of food strengthened, filling all of Thorin’s senses. Thorin quickly rejoined his husband in the kitchen, where he was handed a pan of potatoes. The steam wafted through the air as Thorin brought it out to the table. Bilbo brought the other pans, following quickly behind him.

Thorin watched his husband put the finishing touches on the table, and a thought began to trouble him.
“Bilbo?”
“Yes, dear?” Bilbo asked, his eyes meeting Thorin’s from across the table.

     “Should...should an argument break out tonight. I don’t want you to interfere.” Thorin said. He placed a hand on one of the chairs, taking the top into a tight grip as he spoke.
     “I hardly think that there will be-” Bilbo walked to join Thorin on his side of the table. He brought a hand up to Thorin’s shoulder, and the warmth of it radiated through Thorin’s arm.
     “Please. Promise me. This is something I need to deal with alone.” Thorin said again, and he didn’t keep the pleading out of his voice. Bilbo squeezed his shoulder reassuringly.
     “I promise, but only if you tell me what happened later so you don’t bottle it all up.”
Thorin gave a sigh of relief. “Deal.”

 

xXx
Dis

      She hesitated in front of the stone door. Did she really want to deal with her brother? Could she? A large part of her wanted to run and hide in the kitchens, under the comfort of quiet and Bombur. Dis knocked anyway.
     The door swung open, and Thorin stood on the other side. His smile seemed stilted, and he waved her in without a word.
Good. Thorin looked as awkward as she felt.

      The room was warm, and smelled of cooking. She quickly spied the chicken roast, and potatoes, on what she assumed was their dining table. Bilbo stood nearby, hands on his hips. He had a frown on his face, but as she walked to the table, it was quickly replaced with a smile.

      “Dis! I’m so glad you came!” Bilbo said, and his genuine demeanor put her at ease. He waved her to the head of the table, insisting that she was the honored guest of the evening.
     Dis felt her cheeks flush. She was well accustomed to stiff gatherings, of respectful nods, letting her know that she was important. But Bilbo’s simple statement, and smile, took her aback.
It had been a long time since anyone, outside her two boys, was genuinely happy to see her.

She quickly realized it was just her who had arrived on time.
“Have you not seen the boys yet?” She asked Bilbo, as he handed her a glass of mead.

      Bilbo raised an eyebrow and shook his head. Dis sighed. The one time she left them to get somewhere on time, and they didn't show up. Fili had, on her arrival at Erebor, given a respectful lecture on how grown up her boys were. So she was trying, slowly, to relinquish her old habits. But she was stubborn, and her habits were just as stubborn.
     A knock on the door interrupted her thoughts, and she gave a sigh of relief. That had to be them. Youthful voices at the door confirmed her suspicions, and she tried to let the tension out of her body. It was going to be fine.

      “Your amad beat you here.” Thorin chided as he let the boys into the room. Kili quickly bounded over to Bilbo, pulling the hobbit into a tight hug. Fili came in just as steady, but slower than his younger brother. He found Dis, and gave her a brief hug before taking the seat behind her.
“Haven’t you heard, being late is fashionable!” Kili laughed, his right arm draped around Bilbo’s shoulders.
     “I don’t think you understand what that means.” Bilbo rolled his eyes, but Dis could see that he was fighting a smile. Kili shrugged, before slinking off to sit with his brother. Soon they were all seated, Bilbo to Dis’s right and Fili to her left. Thorin snorted when Bilbo very pointedly took the seat, but took the one next to his husband without comment.

      The food was passed around, and Dis took a healthy portion of everything. She remembered her conversation with Bombur, and did not want to cause any offenses to Bilbo’s cooking. They had talked a bit the night before, and while she hadn’t gotten any real conversation out of him, he had certainly made her laugh. If anything, they needed some levity in the family that wasn’t Kili’s poorly timed puns.

     She looked up at the sound of a voice. Bilbo was smiling just as cheery as before, and she felt that she had missed something. Dis blinked at him, and he repeated himself.
“I said, what do you think of the food?”

Dis hesitated before answering, trying to remember what Bombur had told her.
     “Wow...this is good.” She said slowly, smiling as pleasantly as she could. Bilbo nodded and returned to his food, but Thorin was watching her. He almost looked...amused? Dis raised an eyebrow at him, before turning to her son.

     “So, Kili, how have you been? Any news with Tauriel?” She asked, and tried not to grin as Thorin’s face twitched in the corner of her eye.
Kili flushed, and glanced hesitantly between his uncle and Dis.
     “Uh….I’m working on a courting gift.” He said quickly, nearly losing the meaning of his words. Dis knew this tactic, considering Kili had been using it since he was 7 and barely talking. He was trying to hide the bite in the blur of it. But she and Thorin had long grown immune to his trick.
     “A courting gift.” Dis repeated, looking over at Thorin, a warning in her voice. Thorin didn’t meet her eyes, and she could see the tension building up in his shoulders.

     Kili nodded. “I’m hoping that she understands the traditions. I’ve been trying to drop hints without...telling an elf our secrets….” His voice trailed off nervously. Dis nodded, her eyes still focused on Thorin’s.
     “I’m sure that you can tell her. This is, after all, a unique situation.” She said. Thorin’s face tightened, and the familiar lines formed along his brow.

     “Yes, well, Balin explained everything to me! I’m sure he’d do the same for Tauriel.” Bilbo piped in encouragingly. Thorin opened his mouth, but no noise came out. Dis watched in surprise as Thorin seemed to force himself to relax, pulling on a thin smile instead.
     She quickly spied why. Bilbo had Thorin’s hand in a tight hold, and he kept leaning in to whisper things into Thorin’s ear. Interesting.
     She opened her mouth again, preparing another barb. But Bilbo caught her gaze, and shook his head slightly. Dis raised an eyebrow, but complied. It would be interesting to see how long this could last.

     “Have Balin talk to her.” Thorin’s gruff voice came out, a sharp contrast to the mask he wore as a face. But Kili nodded, and smiled at his uncle, before turning to talk to his brother.
     Dis continued to watch the couple curiously. Bilbo’s hold on Thorin’s hand continued, but the whispering stopped. As she watched, he brought Thorin’s hand up and gave it a small kiss before letting go, returning to his own meal. Without his constraint, Dis expected something. Anything. But Thorin just sat there, eating.

     “How are the renovations progressing?” Dis asked, breaking the long silence. Fili’s face lit up, and he quickly began to give a list of all they had done. His excitement was infectious, and soon the whole table was smiling as they listened to the crown prince.
     “We found old rooms full of old relics, stuff that Smaug didn’t seem to care about or maybe didn’t know existed. That’s where we found a bunch of tapestries!” Fili rambled on.
     Dis nodded encouragingly as her eldest took a pause to breath. It was refreshing, hearing about Erebor through young eyes. Where she could only see destruction, Fili could see history, and renewal.
     “So we put the tapestries back where we could best guess they went. So the one about the 7 Fathers will be in the main court, just above where Uncle’s throne is-,” Fili continued.

     A small thump drew Dis’s attention to her youngest. Kili was slumped forward, his chin in his hand. The young dwarf was undeniably bored. Dis couldn’t help but smile at the gesture. To see her boys have the luxury of boredom was wonderful.
     “And then we found some old armor, including a royal set of archer’s armor, which I thought Kili could use. It’s got lots of embroidery, and baubles, just his style” Fili said, nudging his brother good naturedly.
     “If I can ever shoot well enough again to dare wear it.” Kili said jokingly, nudging his brother back.

The room froze while the brothers laughed obviously.

Dis’s heart twisted, and her voice came out strangled.
“I’m sure you can shoot just as well as you did before, Kili.” She smiled at him, but her heart wasn’t in it.

     Kili’s eyebrows drew together in annoyance. Fili immediately quieted down, but he was poised as if to jump to his brother’s defense.
     “Amad, you know that I can’t, and it will take time before I can again.” Kili said quietly. Fili quietly glared from his brother’s side. Kili’s gaze was serious, and Dis knew that she had made a mistake.
     “Anyway, what were you saying about the tapestries again?” Kili started again, his voice cheerful again.
“You need to stop doing that, Amad.” Fili spoke finally, ignoring his brother’s question.

“What?” Dis blinked back at her son. Fili’s glare narrowed, and he put down his fork.

“Pretending that everything is the same as before. Like we’re still pebbles.” He said.

“I’m not pretending anything-” Dis said back.

     “You flinch every time either of us mention our injuries. The other day you scolded me, in front of our people, as if I was 45 being caught with the cookie jar. We’re grown up, Amad.”
     Fili stood at the table, fury making his voice loud. Kili tried to pull his brother back down, but Fili pulled his elbow out of his younger brother’s grip, and continued to rant.
     “You act as if we haven’t fought in battle, as if we didn’t survive for two years without you!”
     Dis’s eyes widened, and something cold coiled in her stomach. Fili had never spoken to her in such a way before. Her little boy, her little lion, was furious, and she couldn’t do anything.

“You shouldn’t have even been in that battle, if Thorin-,” Dis snipped back. She tried to keep her voice level, but it was quickly rising.

“Fili, don’t-” Thorin began, but was quickly cut off. He slumped back in his seat, his mask of indifference replaced with confusion, and anger.

“Don’t blame Uncle. We chose to go on that quest.” Fili snapped back. His hands gripped the table, and his knuckles were turning white. Kili was gone from his side.

“You were hardly old enough to make such a decision, and look what it got you! Both of you!” Dis’s voice had raised to full volume, and Fili winced at the noise.
     “Of course, when you do acknowledge our wounds, you can’t see the progress we’ve made. You can only see the damage.” Fili sneered at her.
     The plates in front of them quickly disappeared, and Bilbo disappeared with them. Not that anyone really noticed. But Dis could’ve swore she heard Thorin whisper a thanks to Mahal.

     “Because you were damaged! You were hurt and no one was there to protect you.” Dis cried back. How could they not see how she felt? How any mother would feel?
“We protected each other! Had Uncle and Kili not been there, had Bilbo not been there, I would be dead. We would all be dead, and you would have no one.”

Dis’s throat constricted. Did he think she didn’t know that? It seemed the silence she gave was what Fili needed.
“Amad,” He said, the edge leaving his voice, “It is better we were permanently hurt than dead. Would you wish us dead but whole in your memory?”

     “How dare you.” Dis whispered. This was all wrong. Her sons didn’t get mad at her. Thorin, he got mad. She could handle that. But her pride and joy was taking Thorin’s side. The man who got them nearly killed.
This was all Thorin’s fault.

     “This is all your fault.” Dis choked, turning to Thorin. The king turned to her in surprise evident across his face, and no words came from his lips.
     “We were fine, before you decided that you needed to retake Erebor. Before you decided that your own ego was worth a suicide mission, worth my boys lives.” Dis snapped at her brother. Thorin still just sat there. It was infuriating.

“How selfish to take my boys- my-” Dis’s voice broke

“Selfish? When have I ever been selfish?”,Thorin finally snapped back, “Everything I’ve done has been for my people.”

“Your people-” She sneered back. Never for anyone but his people. Oh praise the good king, who left his family in the cold but warmed the feet of his people.

“I did it for you. For your sons.” Thorin thundered, shoving back his seat and standing up to face her. “I did it so you could live as we once did, in the home of our ancestors.”

“When did I ever ask it of you?” Dis retorted. “It was bad enough that you were hardly present for most of my life, but then you take the rest of my family with you.”

      He knew how much her sons meant to her. Vili had been gone hardly a day before Dis refused to let either of them out of her sight, something that Thorin had actively encouraged by taking over anything outside the house, down to bringing the groceries.

“Amad, please-” Fili tried. He sounded anxious, and desperate. Dis couldn’t feel bad for him. Her son had started a fire, and he could watch it burn.

“No Fili, you’ve said enough.” Thorin said, glaring at his sister. Fili made a noise, but didn't try speaking again.

“Dis. I did all I could. While Adad was half-crazed, who fed you? Clothed you?” Thorin spit out as he began to pace the room, “When Amad died, who sat by your bed so you could sleep?” Thorin asked.

“Oh please, you were hardly there. Not when our parents died, not when Frerin died.” Dis growled. “I was a child left to behave like an adult.”

     She had been left to wander into medical tents, where she befriended dwarves who quickly died on her. Dis learned to wrap wounds when she should’ve been playing with her friends, if she had ever had any. Where she had seen things that made battle-hardened warriors queasy.

“I was a child, just like you. But I had to step in instead of Adad, instead of the adults who should’ve.” Thorin said.

“I didn’t make you!” Dis snapped. As if she could ever make Thorin do anything, let alone for her.

Thorin stared at her with dead eyes. The room felt cold, and Fili had also disappeared from the room, likely after his brother.

“I don’t regret taking care of you. I regret that there was no one who was old enough who could. I regret a lot, but I am not bitter that I took care of you the best I could. I’m sorry that you are.” Thorin said, his tone softening into what could only be described as sadness.

Thorin left the room, leaving Dis with her anger.

Notes:

Thank you for reading! I hope y'all enjoyed it!

Can you feel the thorin projection from me? Cause I sure can.
ALSO
There is now a Bilbo pov for this scene in part 3 (it says part 4 on my end idk) of my What We Owe to Each Other series, if anyone is interested. The poor hobbit can never catch a break, shocker.