Actions

Work Header

What We Owe To Each Other

Chapter 5: The Sun and Moon

Summary:

Fili and Kili have some insight.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

     Thorin walked. He had no direction, and no idea where he was. The edges of his vision blurred as he stumbled along, and any sound was muffled. There was no clearing of his head, no epiphany of justice as he went.
     He simply walked.

     At some point he removed his boots, and let the cool touch of stone calm him. A quiet voice in his head reminded him of his duties, and he avoided the busy areas. His people didn’t deserve to see their king in such distress, and certainly not over their beloved princess. Because she was. Despite everything Dis claimed, she was loved by their people, and had he fallen, she could’ve easily taken his throne.
     Hell, she could take his throne now. He saw the way their people looked at her. If the arkenstone had been a person, she would’ve been it. But she spoke to him as if she was unloved, as if no one cared for her. Did she not know how totally loved she was?
     Thorin always assumed she had friends around her, advisors and near family to keep her company. But the way she talked….had she been as lonely as he was?

     He didn’t know when he arrived, but he found himself in a courtyard. A row of benches sat in the middle of it. He took a seat, unaware of the other dwarf in the room. As his senses began to return to him, he realized where he was. It was his mother’s courtyard. Her familiar plots of land, the gentle sculpting of the ground into pathways, all leading to the center where he now sat.
     He stared at the small sculpture in the center. It was her family's crest, from before her marriage into the royal family. Frerin had once said that it helped center her, when their father’s family was too much for her. It was a refuge for her, and later for both Thorin and Frerin. He wondered briefly if Dis ever knew about it, and he felt a pang as he couldn’t recall.
     A sniffing sound broke him out of his thoughts.

     He turned his head slightly, and a flash of brown drew his eyes. He exhaled as he recognized who it was. Kili sat on a bench, further out from the circle where Thorin sat. His back was turned, and his shoulders slumped, and the sight made Thorin want to run.
     He didn’t. Louder and louder voices scolded him for his reaction, for causing such distress in the family he swore to protect. Protocol from an old life resurfaced, reminding him of his failures all over again.
     Kili didn’t look like he knew that his uncle was there. Wrapped up in his own mind, Thorin could easily approach him. But Thorin knew that his nephew had quick reflexes, and had taken to stabbing when surprised. It was a remnant of the battle, and everyone knew to give him a wide berth.

     “Kili?” Thorin called softly from his seat. The lump of his nephew didn’t move, didn’t even flinch. Thorin called his name again, louder this time. Kili shifted, raising his head so his good eye could look over his shoulder. When he saw who it was, he dropped his head.
“What do you want.” Came a harsh voice. It wasn’t Kili, and it was Kili, all wrapped up into one big mess of pain.

     Thorin’s throat tightened. It wasn’t fair of him, to yell in front of Kili and then expect him not to be mad. But he had hoped. He had hoped that the little boy who looked up to him was still there, and the angry young man that he caught glimpses of between court meetings and family dinners was temporary.
     But Thorin knew better than most of how long anger could linger. Kili and Fili were like the sun and the moon, but Kili and Thorin had always been similar. It scared Thorin, the first time he saw Kili’s anger. He and Fili had been fighting over a toy, and Fili had shoved him, and Kili had just...started screaming. He smacked and yelled and cried until Dis broke them apart.

     Children screamed. Children got angry and fought and did all the stupid things you can’t do as a functioning adult. But Fili didn’t fight like Kili did, he didn’t scream like he did, everything about him was subdued compared to his brother.
     Thorin didn’t know if it was natural, or if Fili was thrown into a role too big for him, but it happened nonetheless.
     Fili had anger. It was slow burning, patient, and righteous. He didn’t yell over perceived slights. It came out in a roar, and subdued just as quickly.
     But Kili could burn like the sun.

     “I shouldn’t have yelled in front of you.” Thorin said.

     Kili made a disgruntled noise.

“I’m sorry.” Thorin tried.

“You keep saying that.” Kili said as he shifted, turning so that his side was now facing Thorin. His good eye peeked out, glaring just above his uncle's head.

“I mean it.” Thorin moved to join Kili’s section of the courtyard, finding a bench across from his nephew to sit on.
     “You mean everything you say. Doesn’t mean it helps.” Kili sniped from his seat. He was curled around himself now, his knees folded up in front of him and his arms crossed.
Thorin sighed.

“I thought it would be better.” Kili said. His voice was getting stronger with every passing word. “I thought if. If we claimed Erebor. That you two wouldn’t be so mad all the time.”

Thorin watched him as Kili uncurled from himself.

     “Why can’t you two ever just listen to each other. Why do you constantly bring up old grudges? It’s like you two don’t even want to get along.” Kili was standing now, gesturing outwards aggressively with his arms. His eyes were cold as they watched for Thorin’s reaction.

     “I tried when she first arrived. I don’t think she wants to get along.” Thorin responded. He stayed in his seat, giving Kili the room to move about. Idly, Thorin traced the lines along his hands, his head hung down.

“She gave up.” Kili snorted.

Thorin looked up in surprise.

     “You have no idea, do you?” Kili said, giving Thorin an angry once over, and walking away. He began to pace, and Thorin braced himself for the storm that was coming. “You have no idea about how hard she tried, over and over, just to get nothing in return?”.

     “She tried for years, Thorin.” Kili kicked the bench, and Thorin nearly winced at the abruptness. “Years! I got to watch as you shot down invitation after invitation to join us, to eat with us, even ignoring her when she was talking directly to you.” Kili said lowly. He had begun pacing the pathway in front of Thorin, the need to move clear across his body language.
     Thorin felt cold. He had faded memories of a happier Dis, trying to badger him into a meal or asking him to watch the boys. Still...he didn’t remember this.
“She used to tell me stories about you.” Kili shoved at one of the empty pots along the walkway, and Thorin tensed as it fell over with a loud thump.

Thorin winced, but Kili shook his head.
     “Not like that. She told how you protected us. How much you loved us, and the battles you fought for us.” Kili explained. Despite his words, his voice still rang with barely concealed rage.
Thorin blinked at Kili. He didn’t know that. That Dis, at some point, had believed in him.
     “I don’t know if she believed it, but she desperately wanted us to.” Kili continued. His pacing was aggressive, as if he was trying to wear a hole in the stone.
     “She’s a good mother.” Thorin offered quietly. Kili spun on his heel to face Thorin, and angrily pointed at him.
     “You should tell her that sometime.”
     “I’m sure she knows.” Thorin said. Didn’t she? Dis had to know. Thorin respected her above all others, and he had always admired her ability to survive. Didn’t she know? Maybe, Thorin thought with a growing horror, maybe she really did think he had left her all alone on purpose.

     “You always assume people just know. She has no idea what you’re thinking.” Kili sneered, before turning away from Thorin and pacing once more, “When you took Fili with you for the day, and it was just me and Amad. She would cry.” Kili paused, his voice catching. “She thought I didn’t know, at first. Eventually we both knew that I knew. We just never talked about it.”
     “I’m sorry.” Thorin said. It was all he could think. He didn’t know how to fix anything.

     “Stop saying that!” Kili snapped, slamming a hand down on the arm of the bench beside him. “You’re always saying that, and I know you mean it, but sorry doesn’t fix anything! Sorry doesn’t fix the fact that you shot down her every attempt of understanding and wish to reconnect. You’re sorry, and, Uncle, that’s the first step, but you have to realize there’s more to it than that. You have to--,” he paused, breathing heavily. His eyebrows narrowed as the attempt to find words failed and let out a frustrated growl.

     “You’re complaining about her shooting down your attempts at reconnecting with no self awareness, and it’s infuriating to watch.”

     Kili slumped back on to the bench heavily, as if the air had left him and put his face into his hands.
     Thorin stared in shock. Never before had Kili spoken to him in such a way. There had been moments, where Kili had snapped at him, but this was beyond childhood tantrums. Thorin shook his head. It wasn’t a tantrum. Kili was right.
     Thorin considered reaching out to him, offering comfort of some kind. But something told him otherwise, and he left the courtyard behind, Kili included.

 

xX Dis Xx

     “Amad?” Fili said softly. Dis sat at the table, still as a statue. She stared at the spot where Thorin had last been sitting, and couldn’t pull her eyes away. Her mind simmered, and her tongue felt like lead.
     “Go away.” She finally managed, barely moving her mouth. She stood stiffly, and walked to the corner of the room where a small sitting couch sat. There she sat, still staring straight ahead.
     A warm presence found her right side, and gold hair filled a corner in her vision as Fili pressed into her side. He fiddled with the braid that flowed down the side of her head, the only one that lay single from the rest on that side.
     “I thought I told you to go away.” She snapped. But her voice only came out sounding hollow, and Fili stayed beside her. She could practically hear the gears turning in her son's head, but no words came out, so they sat in silence.
     The dinner table had been cleared sometime between civil conversation and now. But one lone glass sat there, and Dis sighed. It wasn’t fair to Bilbo. He had been practically glowing when she agreed to come to dinner, clearly hoping to fix their families' mess the way he had fixed so many other things.
     “He’s not selfish.” Fili finally let out. She didn’t have to ask who. Dis grunted in response, still focused on the lone glass across the room.

“Amad,” Fili tried again, “He loves us.”

“I know.” Dis finally spoke. Thorin loved all of them, but it was no comfort. It only showed his own blindness to those he cared for.
“I know you say it’s not my place, but,” Fili sighed, “you two are getting nowhere.”

Dis didn’t respond.

     “I know...I know he wasn’t there for you. But he’s right. We wouldn’t have survived without him.” Fili said. He sighed, and pulled his head off of her shoulder. “You can’t keep blaming him for doing what was needed.”

     Dis bristled. Fili knew nothing of what had been needed. He had hardly been a thought when everything started. He hadn’t seen the pain that they went through, he didn’t know about those first cold nights. He had no idea what it was like to be unable to talk to your brother. But maybe. Maybe he was right. She couldn’t imagine where she would be had Thorin not stepped in when
     Of course, she wouldn’t wish any of it on him either. She tried to relax her shoulders, and calm her mind, so that when she spoke she wouldn’t break any further familial ties. And for once in a long time, she listened to Fili.

     “Thorin has changed. Whatever crimes you still hold him to, they were not committed by the dwarf that dined with us tonight.” Fili said. He leaned back in the seat next to Dis, turning slightly so that he could still see her. Dis copied the move.
     “Pretty words.” Dis said. She crossed her arms, waiting for what defense her eldest could come up with now.
     “I learned from the best.” Fili sighed, running his hands through his hair. “But it’s true. Thorin changed, especially after we took Erebor. First the arkenstone, then the battle. He-”
     “What does the arkenstone have to do with anything?” Dis asked sharply. When she had asked Balin about it, the older dwarf had told her it was lost in the lake when Smaug attacked Esgaroth. But the way her son spoke...something else clearly happened.

      Fili stood up, and she was reminded, once again, of how like his father he was. He looked her in the face, and offered his hand.
     “I think you need to talk to Bilbo.” Fili murmured, and Dis let her eldest son lead her out of the room.

Notes:

Whoo this took me about 3 weeks, and I was only able to finish it because of my best friend sitting down and helping me edit. But, its progress! I hope you enjoyed this, and I hope to work on the next chapter soon. As always, comments and kudos are appreciated! Thank you for reading!