Actions

Work Header

What We Owe To Each Other

Chapter 6: A hobbit and his sister in law

Summary:

So the most obvious lack of canon compliance starts to show in this chapter, beyond the whole the Durins didn't die thing. Bilbo has things to say....which some of you may like, others might like it less.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

     They found Bilbo in his garden. It was evening, but that did not matter, as his garden was entirely light by glowing gems. It had been a wedding present from Thorin, that much Dis knew, and Bilbo clearly cherished it.
     His figure was crouched over a plant, where little green tomatoes were growing. Dis counted four as Bilbo stood up and turned to face them. His face was grim set, and his stance guarded. He kept his steady gaze on Fili, not even flickering her way, and Dis tensed her shoulders as she prepared for another fight.
     “What do you want?” Bilbo asked. His voice was strained.
     “I need you to talk about Thorin.” Fili responded. He nodded towards Dis, which left her feeling like a kid about to be scolded, but she held her tongue. She wanted this to go well. Whatever this was.
     “What about him?” Bilbo said. He eyed her suspiciously. He wiped the dirt from his hands onto his trousers, and sat on the stone path that they stood on. With one hand he indicated them to do the same, and soon they were all seated.
     “I just want you to tell her about the Thorin you know. Not his public persona, or what you’ve heard.” Fili said, in what Dis assumed was an attempt to be reassuring. It seemed to work, as the suspicion in Bilbo’s eyes died down and a look of understanding took its place.
     “I’ll tell you what I know.” He agreed, and leaned back to rest his hands behind him.

     “You’ll tell me the truth? No hiding anything?” Dis said. She practically demanded it, and expected Bilbo to bristle at the implication of her lack of trust. But Bilbo was not a dwarf, and just nodded thoughtfully.
     “I will tell you what I believe to be the truth.” Bilbo said, “What I see. And-” Bilbo glared at her for a moment, then repeating with Fili, “Without any unhelpful comments from either of you.”

     “Let me start from the beginning.”

     “Your brother showed up late to a party I didn’t know I was hosting, and then proceeded to insult both my abilities as a host and as a functioning adult. He was rude, and full of himself, and stunk of weeks of travel.” Bilbo said flatly.
     Dis let out a surprised snort. She hadn’t expected...that much honesty. But she kept her mouth shut as he sent her a warning glance.
     “I didn’t want to go on the journey. Sure, Thorin was a very attractive dwarf, despite...everything, but I’m not so foolish to run off for a pretty face.” Bilbo said, “But then he had to sing, and it got stuck in my head, and so there I was, running off for a pretty face and a deep voice.”
     She would hardly call her brother attractive, and Dis didn’t stop her laughter this time, with Fili joining in, and Bilbo cracked a smile.
     “Yes, well, you can blame my mother for that. She was a Took.”

     Dis filed away a mental note to ask him later what the hell a Took was.

     “He hated me for the first half. Thought I didn’t have anything to offer, and frankly, that was an honest appraisal,” Fili made a noise of disagreement, but Bilbo waved him away, “No, it's true, I had no skills that helped us, other than being generally small and getting in the way. Sure I got us out of the whole troll situation, but I was also the one that got myself caught, so-”

     “Troll...situation?” Dis asked. She had only heard the secondhand story from her sons, and she was starting to get the feeling that they had left some things out as she wracked her brain for any mention of trolls.
     “Your sons lost our ponies to some trolls.” Bilbo said. “Anyway, he wasn’t too excited about me, and I was trying to fight a crush on the most emotionally stunted dwarf I had ever met.” Bilbo sighed, “I always did have to go after the unavailable ones.”
     Fili snorted, and Dis decided that she liked Bilbo. She also filed away the fact that both of her sons had managed to cause trouble, and to ask some very pointed questions later.

     “Then...well then we got caught by the goblins, and that was a whole mess, and I nearly got killed by a creature that lived under them. Then...well then Azog happened.”
     This part Dis knew well. Kili told anyone who would listen that Bilbo was brave, constantly citing his brave defense against Azog. But Dis already knew that Bilbo had to be brave to marry her brother.
     “I don’t remember how it happened, but I was standing in front of Thorin, scared witless, and stabbing at anything vaguely orcish. I was terrified. Then the eagles were there and we were safe.” Bilbo smiled softly. “Then, then he apologized to me for the first time.”
     Dis nodded along. She didn’t recognize this either, and she eyed her son accusingly. Fili smirked back at her, before leaning forward to whisper loudly. “You forgot the hug.”

     Bilbo flushed. It was rather cute, even if he still was an odd looking thing.
     “Yes, Well, he hugged me after he apologized.” He quickly elaborated before Fili could, which was smart, considering how much Fili liked to tease. Dis roughly nudged Fili in the side, and a wolfish grin slid off his face. Bilbo picked absently at his pants as they waited for more.
     “We started talking after that. I started joining him on his watches, and he often walked beside me. All my previous notions of him were pretty much shown wrong, in one way or another. Although, I still stand on the fact that he can be very rude when he wants to be.” Bilbo shook his head, and Dis couldn’t remember the last time she’d seen someone so affectionately annoyed.
     “I had always thought he was a brave fighter, and all those great things that I’m sure you're tired of hearing about your brother. But it’s true. He’s protective, and brave, and puts others before him to a fault, and while he’s not naturally kind, he’s not needlessly cruel.”
     “That's because he always has a reason when he’s mean.” Fili quipped.
     “What did I say about unnecessary comments?” Bilbo raised his eyebrows at Fili, and then shook his head. “Yes, he has the capacity for cruelty. Everyone does. But, he’s trying.”

     “Anyway, by the time we reached Mirkwood we had a pretty good understanding of each other. He listened to me rattle on about gardens and poetry and nosy relatives, and I listened when he talked about Erebor, and smithing, and his family.” Bilbo smiled.

     Dis fidgeted in her seat as she listened. It wasn’t that she didn’t want to know how her brother and Bilbo got together, it was just that she couldn’t see the point. Where was the change? Bilbo had said it himself, that all of the qualities he admired in Thorin were things she had heard many times before.
     “I’ve heard about the quest before. I don’t understand what your point is.” She said. Fili nudged her in the side with his elbow, but she wasn’t easily swayed like Kili, and ignored him.
     A glare crossed Bilbo’s face before he could quickly school his expression to neutral again.
     “Did you want my perspective, or not?” He snipped, standing up. Suddenly he was towering over them, and perhaps now Dis understood how Bilbo was on even ground with Thorin. Bilbo turned away from them, heading back to the plant that she had seen him tending to before.
     Fili stood up and followed Bilbo, waving a hand to indicate Dis to do the same. They carefully sat by Bilbo’s turned back, and watched as he fiddled with the ties that kept the tomato plant to a thin piece of stone sticking out of the ground. Bilbo turned around and jumped when he noticed them. He snorted again, before sighing and sitting down in front of them. He fiddled with his waistcoat pocket, leaning on his other arm.

     “You know that we were captured by the Mirkwood elves, correct?” He asked.
     Dis nodded. Balin had told her what she needed to know for dealing with the Elves, and while she didn’t have the deep hatred her brother harbored for them, she still wasn’t a fan.
     “Thorin was kept separate from everyone else in the cells. It took me a week just to find him. But that's when I got to see the other side of him. He was beaten down to his core self, half starving, and I fell in love with him. Of course, I only realized that much later, but still.” Bilbo lifted up his head, smiling softly.

     Dis raised an eyebrow at him. It all sounded too picture book. How could Thorin, asshole of the century, manage to get someone so...level headed. And generally nice. It was bittersweet that she could lose her own love so soon after their meeting, being as safe as they were, and Thorin tromps off on a deathwish quest with his and they both survive.

     “I brought him extra food when I could. And he...he just talked. He apologized, again, for the way he treated me before. Actually,” Bilbo laughed, “He tried to fit an apology in every time we talked. For a week straight. It was exhausting.”

     Dis nodded in understanding. It was...unnerving to just have Thorin say sorry. It was even worse when he expected it to just fix everything. Long ago she would’ve said that an apology from him would mean the world, but now it just made her uncomfortable.
     “One time I finally snapped back at him.” Bilbo sighed, and a shadow passed over his face as he leaned forward, his hands clasped in front of him. “I asked him, ‘Are you sorry for your actions, or are you sorry that I proved you wrong by being useful?’”
     Dis’s eyes widened. The hobbit was braver than she thought. Thorin’s anger alone was enough to deter something so plainly spoken. But Bilbo wasn’t done speaking, so she pushed her thoughts to the side.
     “After he froze for a frankly dramatically long time, he said back, and I’m quoting, “I was wrong to behave that way to you, or anyone. I’ve been wrong about a lot of things.” Bilbo smiled, and unclasped his hands, splaying them out. He stared down at them for a moment, before letting them go limp and looking back up at them. “That’s when I knew that he wasn’t the jerk I thought he was.”

     Dis cleared her throat, bringing two sets of eyes to her.
     “Did he say...what else he was wrong about?” She asked quietly. Any previous anger was long gone, and she felt drained to the bone. But her curiosity was alive and well, and so she raised her chin and stared Bilbo in the face.

     Bilbo stared back with a knowing look.

     “I think you should ask him yourself.” He said simply. Dis glared at him, but he just smiled back, clearly enjoying her annoyance. Hobbits were weird.
     “Anyway, after we got out of Mirkwood and into Esgaroth, I got really sick. Stuck in bed, mild fever, cold chills sick. We were stuck there for an extra week because of me, making us precariously close to Durin’s Day. I knew, by then, that I was a part of the group, but...I still worried that Thorin would leave me behind.”

     Fili made a noise of anguish and scooted closer to Bilbo, pulling the hobbit into a tight side hug. “We never would’ve left you behind.”

     “Because you needed me to sneak in Erebor, or because you cared?” Bilbo asked dryly, although not unkindly. He smirked slightly at the face of despair that Fili made, only to regret it moments later when the prince hugged him even tighter.
     “Anyway, Thorin didn’t leave me behind. Instead, he stayed with me nearly every day, and talked my ear off. You wouldn’t think, looking at him, that he likes to talk. But he does.” Bilbo chuckled.
He tried in vain to shake off Fili’s vice-like grip, much to Dis’s amusement. She just shook her head sympathetically.
“I learned long ago that Fili is the only one who can remove himself from another’s person.” She said.

     Bilbo sighed before finally giving in. He rested the side of his head against Fili’s, smiling slightly at Dis as the prince just snuggled in closer.
     “I got better after that week, obviously, but I never forgot the general...kindness that Thorin showed while I was unwell, and the cheer that he brought me that no one else could. It was the first clue that I was hopelessly head over heels.”
     Dis snorted at this. She could’ve picked any moment through his story where he had been clearly infatuated, but something about the glare he was sending her way was saying he wouldn’t appreciate hearing that. So instead she sat in silence as she waited for him to continue.

     “After...after Smaug, Thorin was different. Meaner.” Bilbo said quietly. Dis stilled as she listened. She hadn’t heard this part of the story before.
     “He didn’t care about rest, or food, and he thought everyone else should do the same. That damn stone,” Bilbo muttered, mostly to himself, before continuing, “The arkenstone was twisting everyone, but him the most. I could break through to him, sometimes, and Thorin likes to tell me that I was the only voice he remembers from that time.”
     Dis tightened her fist around the fabric of her pants. She knew, immediately, what Bilbo was trying to tell her. Thorin had fallen to the curse that plagued her family, and somehow survived it.
     Fleeting memories of her grandfather filled her mind. She had hated him then, for being so captured by a shiny stone that he could not feed his own family. Now, she hated him more, now that she knew someone could survive it.

     “He finally broke of it, but not before I was banished from Erebor for giving Bard the Arkenstone.”
     “And nearly killed.” Fili grumbled, and Bilbo shot him a glare.

     Dis narrowed her eyes. She knew what lengths the sickness could pull at someone, and twist them into something else. Violence had always been a sad possibility, but nothing she ever recalled actually occurring.
     “What do you mean?” She asked.

     Bilbo sighed. “I didn’t want to tell this part. It won't help prove my point.”

     “You promised to tell me the truth,” She pointed out, “And if it’s truly forgivable, it won't hurt your case.”
     “I hate how logical you are.” Bilbo snorted, but seemed to agree. His jaw tightened, and he stared at something above her head, as if to brave through it, “Before I was banished, we were standing up on those ramparts above the gate. It was revealed that I had given away the Arkenstone, and Thorin held me over the walls, threatening to kill me.”

     “That miserable, little, Sauron-cursed-,” Dis hissed as she hastened to get to her feet. “I’ll kill him. You hear me- I’ll-”
     “Dis.” Bilbo stepped forward and put his hands on her shoulders as if to push her to the ground, and in her shock she let him.      “He apologized. Profusely. He also tried to give up his crown, and then disappeared for a week as some sort of self punishment, the fool-” Bilbo grumbled before setting narrowed eyes on her, “And I’ve forgiven him time and again.”

     “He nearly killed you, Bilbo. We have laws in place for such things.” Dis said. She grew more angry as she realized Fili hadn’t said a word, and didn’t look concerned at all.
     “How could you let them get married?” She sniped at Fili. He blinked at her, but didn’t answer. Instead, he shifted uneasily as he glanced over at Bilbo, who was turning a deep shade of red.

     “No one. Lets me do anything.” Bilbo hissed. Dis stilled as she looked at the irate hobbit in front of her. Perhaps the Durins weren’t the only ones with tempers.
     “You listen to me right now. Thorin made me promise not to interfere, and the only reason I’m saying this is because you asked me. I married Thorin because I love him, and because I know that he was not himself during those first weeks here. I understand-” And at this his right hand goes into a waistcoat pocket, fiddling with something. A twisting of unease began to unleash itself in Dis’s stomach, although she could not place why.
“I understand the power of dark magic, and he’s told me that he was fighting it as much as he could.”

     “Likely story. My grandfather-”
     “I know about Thror. But Thorin isn’t your grandfather, and the gold sickness isn’t coming back.” Bilbo interrupted her.
     “How do you know that-”
     “Because I know my husband. He is constantly on watch. He refuses opulence. Have you noticed how he dresses? No gold, not even silver. He avoids the treasury, and he makes Balin deal with any major transactions.” Bilbo spoke almost reverently, and Dis twisted uncomfortably in her seat,      “And he has made me promise to leave him the minute I think the sickness is returning, and find Dwalin so that he can either yell it out of him, or kill him before he can harm me, or anyone else.”

     Dis swallowed any words that wanted to escape. Snide remarks would get her nowhere with this child of the west. He had the strangest ability to deflect anything she shot at him with a smile, and didn’t rise to meet any challenge she gave him. It should’ve been obvious from the start not to treat him like a dwarf, but old habits die hard.
     Then his words began to sink in. With every word that Bilbo spoke, she had grown more and more uncomfortable. This Thorin that he saw...was it really the same dwarf? Who was the blind one? The one who had met him with untarnished eyes, or the sister who had grown bitter years ago?

xX Thorin Xx

     Thorin floated through the rest of the evening until he found himself in his rooms. He didn’t know if it had been 5 minutes or hours since he had spoken to Kili, the only sense of time within the room was a small window in Bilbo’s study. He peaked in, seeing the study empty, and the darkening sky through the window. Only the early stars were peaking through.
     Thorin wandered back through the rooms till he hit the kitchen, and made two cups of tea. He hadn’t liked tea much, but Bilbo always liked it when he drank it with him, and was always talking about the health benefits of the different herbal types. So Thorin drank the leaf water without complaint, in return for Bilbo’s company.
     Then, he built the fire up in their sitting room, and waited for his husband to return.

     Bilbo did return, eventually, about two hours later. He found Thorin fast asleep in his armchair, and two cups of cold tea on the table in front of him. He gently woke his husband and helped him into bed, before crawling in beside him.
     Any conversations could wait.

Notes:

I'm on a roll with these chapters, and I'm really starting to enjoy Dis's pov. I feel bad for poor Bilbo, dealing with the hardheaded Durins...maybe one day I'll write a bit of his pov for this. I hope you enjoyed it! As always, comments and kudos are appreciated!