Actions

Work Header

A Routine Haunting

Chapter 9: Indecision

Notes:

Tags have been updated.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

The first thing Bilbo and Thorin saw, upon rushing out of the spare room at the sound of Lobelia’s scream, was Lobelia herself practically somersaulting into the pantry. Seconds later, a barrage of apples, cheese wedges, and chicken legs made its way toward the kitchen. Whatever she was defending herself against must have been terrifying indeed, if it caused her to waste food and make a mess of the house at the same time.

As Lobelia was executing her attack, another scream—manlier, but still rather shrill—came from the kitchen. Otho, they presumed. With a glance, they decided they had better do something. If they couldn’t spend their afterlife at their leisure, they should at least use their ghostly abilities for good. The fact that Frodo could be in danger may have sped the decision along a bit.

Into the kitchen they ran, and they quickly understood why Lobelia felt so compelled to wage pantry warfare. It was Smaug, as they suspected, but they weren’t quite expecting him to look so … well, Smaug-like. The disguise he had used when they first encountered him in the map had been abandoned in favor of his dragon form, yet he had scaled himself down to be just small enough to punch his jagged snout through the kitchen window. Shattered glass covered the floor below, and the plaster around the window frame cracked with the pressure of his jaw as he spoke.

“Sssso rude of you not to invite me to your little dinner party,” he said with a slither of his tongue.

Otho was a lump in the middle of the floor, peeking between his fingers at the intruder. Whether he had fallen there out of fear or been knocked over, they couldn’t tell. Frodo and Lotho, meanwhile, were slowly backing out of the kitchen with wide eyes. Unfortunately, they hadn’t anticipated that Smaug’s tail would come crashing through the parlor window behind them, blocking their escape.

“Not sssso fassst,” he hissed.

Otho took the dragon’s brief distraction as an opportunity to pick himself up and flee—but he wasn’t fast enough to avoid having the sleeve of his jacket scorched as Smaug vomited a stream of fire into the room. It was strategically positioned to light the kitchen hearth in a crackling blaze.

The dragon laughed through his teeth. “You looked a bit chilly.”

Bilbo decided he had seen about enough of this: “Smaug! Smaug! Smaug!”

But it didn’t have the effect he was expecting. In fact, it only made the dragon laugh even more maliciously. The ghosts watched as he proceeded to wrap his red-gold tail around Lotho’s middle. The boy cried out in terror and attempted to free himself. Frodo, seeming to think Bilbo and Thorin had something to do with this, shouted for them to stop.

Bilbo furrowed his brow. Why hadn’t it worked?

The answer was simple, of course. In the panic, he had forgotten one key detail about their reinvented enemy. Fortunately, in the time it took him to realize his mistake, Thorin corrected it.

“Pryftan! Pryftan! Pryftan!” he bellowed.

The effect was almost instantaneous. With a furious roar that faded into silence, the dragon vanished, leaving behind only a cloud of smoke, a messy kitchen, and a pair of broken windows. Lotho, upon realizing he was free of the creature’s clutches, ran screaming from the room in search of his mother. Frodo had a similar reaction, only his screaming was directed at the ghosts.

“Why are you doing this?” he demanded, and then, before they had a chance explain, he shook his head. “Just leave me alone!”

Frodo rushed off in the direction of his bedroom, and Thorin and Bilbo saw nothing to do but return to the spare room. On the way, they passed Lobelia throwing a fit in the pantry as Lotho clung to her waist and Otho brushed the soot off his jacket.

“He could have killed someone,” Bilbo said when the door was closed.

“But he didn’t,” Thorin pointed out. “I shall despise that dreadful beast until my dying day—” Bilbo raised his eyebrows “—or, indeed, much longer than that. But this could finally be enough to scare them off for good.”

“And take Frodo with them, when he’s angry with us,” Bilbo sighed. “Perhaps we should have just stayed in this room from the start.”

They paused their speculation when they noticed a familiar glow coming from the map on the table. Hurrying over, they discovered that Smaug’s likeness had returned, an angry red which threatened to set the entire map aflame.

The dragon’s thunderous voice emerged as if he hid beneath the table. “How dare you meddle in my haunting!” he boomed.

“I’m not particularly fond of the Sackville-Bagginses,” Bilbo admitted, “but you could have killed them!”

“What a pity that I didn’t,” Smaug hissed, before his voice settled into an ominous simmer. “The child in black, however, could prove useful. I sense he is in possession of something very preciousss.”

Bilbo lurched forward and grabbed the map with both hands, shaking it as if to fling Smaug out of existence. “You leave him alone, you —”

He was cut off by a sudden gust of wind, as he and Thorin were instantly transported to a new place, where Bilbo no longer held the map and Smaug was nowhere to be heard in the vast hall which surrounded them. They soon realized they had been here before. The enormous presence of Mandos, staring at them disapprovingly from his throne, was the most obvious hint.

“I must say I am very displeased with how you have handled things,” he said with a hurricane of a sigh. “Not only did you conjure Pryftan against my warning, but you have allowed Lotho to discover your highly confidential instructions.”

This time, it was Thorin holding Bilbo back from spitting on the Vala’s toes. “We did nothing of the sort!” the hobbit objected. He was angry enough already from his conversation with Smaug, without being accused of giving away a book he remembered reading not half an hour before.

It did not cross his mind that perhaps he should not be arguing with an all-knowing being.

“Never trust the living,” Mandos said simply. “It would not do to have a routine haunting such as yours providing evidence that there is existence after death — which, in most cases, there is not. Therefore, you must recover the instructions and expel these troublesome inhabitants immediately.”

“But how?” said Thorin. “We’ve tried everything.”

“Yes, so I had noticed.” Mandos pinched the bridge of his immense nose. “Might I suggest, now that the living are convinced of your existence, that you make yourselves appear as ghastly as possible?”

Bilbo and Thorin exchanged a glance. They were rather tired of trying to frighten people and simply wished to be themselves again. But if one last fright was required before they could rest in peace, they had better make it count.

After a moment’s consideration, Thorin squared his shoulders and planted his boots and brought his hands to his face. As his thick fingers got to work, he proved just what fine craftsmen the dwarves were. When he removed his hands, Bilbo gasped to glimpse what he had created.

Thorin had somehow managed to rearrange most of his facial features. His beard blended with the hair on his head, and his eyes sockets had been replaced by his mouth, which revealed two eyeballs resting on his tongue. His nose had been turned upside down, and his wide forehead — eyebrows included — had taken the place of his chin.  

Even Mandos appeared disturbed by the sight. “Quite impressive,” he said, before turning to Bilbo.

“How am I supposed to top that?” the hobbit wondered, looking askance at Thorin and hoping he would be able to put himself back together once the job was done. He noticed Mandos raise an eyebrow at him. “Oh, very well.”

Bilbo did the first thing he could think of, hooking a forefinger into each corner of his mouth and tugging until he created a dreadful smile which stretched his cheeks twice as wide as his head. He enlarged his teeth to go with it, and pulled his tongue from his mouth until it was as long as a maypole ribbon, dragging on the ground.

“Enough,” Mandos cut in, shuddering. “That will be quite adequate, I am certain of it.”

Bilbo shrugged, and he and Thorin made their way down the long corridor to the halls of waiting for the halls of waiting, contemplating how best to go about their final haunting.

Before the dwarf could pull the curtain aside, Bilbo grabbed his sleeve. “Thorin, are we sure we want to do this?” he asked, but it was incomprehensible due to the current state of his tongue, so he temporarily reigned it into this mouth and repeated himself.

Thorin lowered his eyebrows — the equivalent of raising them, considering the present organization of his face. “We don’t have a choice.”

“Don’t we?” Bilbo wondered, and shook his misshapen head. “I don’t want to leave Frodo all alone with those dreadful people.”

 


 

Frodo sat cross-legged on his bed with a stack of papers and a pot of ink balanced in front of him. He pulled the hood of his black cloak over his head, and wiped a fallen tear off the top sheet before pressing the tip of his quill against it.

I am alone, he began.

No, that didn’t properly capture it. He crumpled the page and tossed it on the floor, dipping the quill in the pot and starting over again.

I am utterly alone, he wrote, tracing over the added word several times for emphasis. It would have to do. By the time you read this, I will be gone, having jumped

Here he stopped, conjuring a quite pathetic image from his choice of verb. He struck through it and tried again.

having jumped plummeted off the Brandywine Bridge.

With a sniffle, Frodo signed his name and blew on the ink before stuffing the letter into an envelope and sealing it with wax stolen from Otho’s desk. He stole toward the spare room, passing Lotho raiding what was left of the pantry while his parents assessed the previous evening's damage.

“I’ve invited Mr. and Mrs. Bulge back to Sack End this evening,” Lobelia was telling Otho, trying out her newly coined name for the house. “This should convince them.”

Frodo was glad he wouldn’t be around to see it. He knelt outside the spare room, prepared to slide his note under the door, but stopped when he noticed a strange glow coming from inside. He rose, turning the knob and peeking his head around the door.

“Hello?” he called into the room — empty except for the light radiating from the table. He stepped inside. “Bilbo? Thorin?”

“They’re gone,” a sudden voice cut through the silence, and Frodo jumped. The voice — and the light  — seemed to be coming from the map on the table.

Frodo gulped. “Where did they go?”

“The other ssside,” the voice hissed, and Frodo realized where he had heard it before.

“It’s you." He began backing toward the door. "The dragon.”

“Very perceptive,” said the voice. “Oh, don’t leave so sssoon. I believe I can give you sssomething you seek.”

Frodo stopped, hand on the doorknob. “You can?”

“There is sssomeone. Someone on the other side. You wish to sssee them.”

Frodo rushed forward and leaned over the table, one hand on either side of the map. “You can help me?”

“Yesss, but first you must help me.”

“How?”

“Release me,” the voice said, as if it were as simple as snapping one’s fingers.

Frodo hesitated. It was very likely this dragon could not be trusted — he was a dragon, after all. But the idea of seeing his parents again, of falling into their arms and hearing their voices once more, was powerful enough to rise above all other thoughts, and he said, “What must I do?”

The dragon sounded pleased. “You must say my name three times.”

“Your name? What is it?”

“I cannot tell you.”

Very helpful, Frodo thought, glancing down at the map for clues. “‘The Desolation of Smaug,’” he read aloud. “Are you Smaug?”

“I was once known as Smaug, but now I go by another name. Perhaps I can give you a clue. There is a book on the windowsssill. Turn it to page two hundred and forty-nine.”

Frodo narrowed his eyes, but did as he was told, glancing at the book’s spine. It was about insects indigenous to the Shire.

“Find the first letter of the fifth word,” the dragon told him.

The word was pollinate. “P,” said Frodo.

“Very good. Now turn to page ssseventy-ssseven. Find the second letter of the twenty-second word.”

Frodo counted with his finger. The twenty-second word was trap. “R.”

This went on and on, until Frodo had spelled Pryftan. He said it aloud. It felt wrong in his mouth, somehow.

“Yesss,” came Pryftan’s  voice from the map. “Now say it twice more.”

Frodo took a breath. “Pryftan.”

“Once more,” the dragon said, and Frodo squeezed his eyes shut and thought of his parents as his lips formed the first letter.

“Stop!” shouted a familiar voice from behind him. But when he turned, they were not familiar faces.

Two horrible creatures were entering the room through a hole in the wall, surrounded by a greenish fog. Frodo screamed and fell over onto the floor in his scramble to escape.

“Frodo, wait!” said the one with a jumbled face. “Don’t be frightened. It’s just us.” And he twisted his features back into place. The other immediately followed, placing one hand on either side of his face to put his wide mouth back to normal.

“What’s happened?” Bilbo asked, once Frodo could tell it was him.

Frodo stood up from the floor and brushed the dust off his sleeve. “Pryf —” he began, but Bilbo lifted a warning finger, and he cut the word short. “He said he would help me find my parents.”

“Frodo, your parents are dead,” Thorin said gently.

He looked away. “I want to be dead, too.”

“No," said Bilbo. “Frodo, your parents wouldn’t want that. They would want you to live a full life, even if they can’t be with you.” He glanced at Thorin. “And if it’s any consolation, you can visit us here any time you want.”

“I thought you wanted to scare us away.”

“We’ve decided we want you to stay,” Thorin said. “All of you, if that’s what it takes.”

There was something about these words which compelled Frodo to step forward and wrap his arms around the dwarf’s middle, pressing his cheek against his chest. He hadn’t known what to expect from hugging a ghost, but he was surprised to discover that he could feel it. It wasn’t as solid as when he would hug his mother or father, but there was something more than emptiness, and he could have sworn he sensed Thorin place a hand on his head.

The moment was interrupted by the sudden sound of Otho and Lotho approaching the room. The ghosts took their position behind the door, and Frodo crouched behind the nearby armchair.

“Now, what is it you’re looking for, my boy?” Otho asked as they opened the door, hiding Thorin and Bilbo from sight.

Lotho was holding Instructions For the Newly Expired open in his hands. “It says we need personal items.”

“Ah, here.” Otho picked up the book on insects and held it up triumphantly.

“Personal and important,” Lotho added, and his father deflated.

“Well, we sold just about everything at the auction.” Here Otho seemed to remember something, and Frodo could see his smirk all the way from his hiding place. “Except…” he began, and suddenly hurried from the room.

Lotho waddled after him. “Wait for me, Father!”

The ghosts emerged from behind the door, and Frodo stood up to meet them.

“What was that all about?” asked Bilbo.

“I don’t know, but I can go find out."

“We’ll be right here when you get back,” said Thorin, and Frodo knew they would be.

Notes:

*shows up two years late with Starbucks* Hey guys! Long time no see. This fic was haunting me (pun intended), so I figured I should buckle down and get it finished.

I kept Frodo's note the same as Lydia's, as I couldn't imagine improving upon it.

Thanks for reading! I can't say for sure when the next chapter will be up, but fingers crossed it won't be too far off.