Actions

Work Header

A Routine Haunting

Chapter 10: Negotiation

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Frodo found Lobelia in the dining room, setting so many flowers on the table he wondered how they would fit the food. 

“Ah, there you are,” she said when she saw him. “Now, have you convinced those ghosts of yours to show themselves?”

“They said they’ve chosen to let us all stay here, but they won’t play whatever stupid games you have planned.” 

They hadn’t said as much, but Frodo wasn’t about to give them up. 

“You watch your tone,” Lobelia said with a pointed finger. “No matter, we don’t need you anyway. Lotho found a very interesting book in that spare room of theirs, and they’ll come out whether they want to or not.”

Frodo’s mind flashed to pages in the instruction book. “What are you going to do?” 

At that moment, Otho and Lotho entered the room, each carrying an object Frodo had never seen before. 

“I knew it was a good idea to keep that chest from the study,” Otho said, laying his item down on the table.

Frodo came closer to examine it. It appeared to be a shirt of chain mail, but it was nothing like what Frodo had seen illustrated in any book. Beside it, Lotho placed a large key on a leather strap. 

“What are these?” Frodo asked.

“Personal items. Personal and important, I’d wager,” said Otho, crossing his arms proudly.

“You’ll never be able to do it,” said Frodo. “Lotho can’t even remember to water his pipe-weed. You expect me to believe he can summon the dead?”

“We’ll see who’s right at dinner, won’t we?” said Lotho, sticking his tongue out.

Frodo shook his head. “No. I’m not even going to let you try it.” 

He made a grab for the book, but Lotho was taller than him, and he held it over his head and out of reach, laughing.

“I’ve had quite enough of you,” said Lobelia, and Frodo found himself being lifted off the ground and carried down the hall under her arm.

“Hey! Put me down!” he cried, trying to wriggle out of her grasp.

Lobelia opened the door to the guest room and threw him inside. 

“We can’t have you spoiling another dinner party,” she said before slamming the door. 

Frodo heard the lock turn. He ran to the door and pounded on it, shouting for her to let him out. It was no use, of course, but admitting defeat against Lobelia Sackville-Baggins was simply not an option.


Night fell, and Bag End’s ghosts sat in the dark of the spare room, wondering what to do with themselves now that there was no longer any haunting to be done.

“What could be taking Frodo so long?” Thorin wondered, pacing back and forth near the door.

Bilbo, meanwhile, was sitting in his armchair trying to remember the taste of roast chicken. “Perhaps it’s that pesky time problem again. Two weeks feels like two days, two minutes feels like two hours…”

Thorin pressed his ear to the door. He was met by an eerie silence, cut through suddenly by the sound of distant chanting. He couldn’t make out what they were saying, but it didn’t sound good. 

“I think I should go see what’s going on,” he said.

Bilbo was about to tell him that perhaps that wasn't a very good idea, when they both noticed something peculiar — as Thorin reached for the doorknob, his hand appeared to pass directly through it. 

“Thorin, what’s happening?” asked Bilbo, standing up and hurrying over.

He could actually see the door through Thorin’s body, as he seemed to become more and more transparent by the second. Bilbo reached out to touch the dwarf’s arm and discovered that his hand went through him as though he were made of nothing but air. 

Thorin’s eyes were frantic. He opened his mouth to speak Bilbo’s name, but no sound came out, and before either of them could fully comprehend what was happening, he vanished completely, and Bilbo was left alone.

“The buried, dead and slain, rise again!” Lotho cried, as Thorin found himself floating above the dining room table. 

The room was lit by dozens of candles, and below him the Sackville-Bagginses clasped hands with Mr. and Mrs. Bulge. Thorin glanced down at himself and was shocked to discover the key to Erebor dangling from his neck.

“It worked!” Lobelia gasped. “I told you he could do it, didn’t I? My Lotho is just the most brilliant boy.”

“Where’s the other one?” Mrs. Bulge wondered, as she stared up at Thorin with a mixture of horror and curiosity.

At this very moment, Bilbo was standing beside the door in the spare room, trying again and again to grasp the knob, and failing each time. He held up his hand, which was fading like smoke from a dying fire. 

Bilbo thought for certain that he was being taken to the halls of waiting — Mandos’ punishment for not expelling the Sackville-Bagginses, no doubt. His heart ached to realize that he would likely never see Thorin again. 

Well, he thought, closing his eyes as he felt himself fade completely, at least I’ll be with my parents.

So imagine his surprise when he opened his eyes to discover Lobelia Sackville-Baggins staring at him from the head of the dining table. He jerked his head to the left and was immediately relieved and confused to see Thorin hovering beside him. 

“I knew it would fit,” Otho said below them.

Bilbo cast his gaze downward, where his mithril shirt was hanging over his clothes. 

He was furious. To think that not an hour ago they had actually committed to living peacefully with these people. Bilbo opened his mouth to give them all a piece of his mind, but he found that he couldn’t speak.

Beside him, Thorin’s anger had already faded as he felt himself becoming weaker and weaker. It was as if his spirit was decomposing to catch up with his body, wherever it was buried.

It wasn’t long before Bilbo had the same feeling. He and Thorin turned to look at each other and were shocked by what they saw. Both of their faces had turned gaunt and wrinkled, and their bodies were becoming thinner and thinner under their clothes.

Bilbo reached for Thorin’s hand, but it crumbled into dust beneath his fingers. After a moment, his own hand started to disintegrate. They stared helplessly into each other’s sunken eyes, which were the only halfway-recognizable parts of them left.

“What’s happening to them?” Mr. Bulge asked with disgust.

“Lotho, dear, do something about this, won’t you?” Lobelia requested. “They’re falling apart all over my dining table.”

Lotho flipped through the book in front of him, apparently at a loss for what to do next. There seemed to be no hope for the ghosts as they continued to wither away in midair, still wearing the items that were so important to them.


Frodo tried for the hundredth time to break down the guest room door, but he was only a little hobbit, and the thing wouldn’t budge. He had also tried to open the room’s single window, but it was practically glued shut after being painted.

He knew he had to get out. According to Instructions for the Newly Expired, summoning spirits was extremely unpredictable, and it could have dangerous consequences for the dead. Lotho of all people was certain to muck it up.

It seemed he only had one choice. 

Frodo lifted a heavy candlestick off the bedside table and plunged it through the window, shattering the glass. He covered his hand with his sleeve to remove the remaining shards before lifting himself up to crawl out. It was a tight fit, but he made it, falling onto the grass outside and immediately springing to his feet to hurry around to the front of the house. He shoved through the door and ran as fast as he could toward the dining room.

Frodo stopped in his tracks when he saw what was happening.

Bilbo and Thorin were nearly unrecognizable — decrepit and hollowed-out like corpses. Thorin’s hair had gone completely white, and Bilbo’s bare feet had shriveled up below the hem of his trousers.

“Do something!” Frodo shouted. “They’re dying!”

“They can’t die,” Mrs. Bulge pointed out, disturbed as she was. “They’re already dead.”

“Lotho,” said Otho nervously, “I think it may be time to put a stop to this.”

“I can’t!” cried Lotho, banging his fist on the table in frustration. “I don’t know how!”

Everyone continued to sit there uselessly, staring up at the dwindling ghosts. If no one else would do anything, Frodo would just have to take care of it himself.

So he did the only thing he could think of, and he sprinted to the spare room, where he lifted the map off the table and shook it. The red dragon glowed, and a familiar voice boomed in Frodo’s ears.

“Yesss?” it asked. “Have you reconsidered my offer?”

“Help them,” Frodo demanded. “They’re falling apart. Please, you have to save them.”

“Hmm,” Smaug rumbled. “Perhapsss I could be of some assistance, if you give me sssomething in return.”

“Like what?” Frodo asked, for he couldn’t think of a single thing he had that a dragon could possibly want.

“You are in possession of something very preciousss,” the dragon replied. “You once kept it in your pocket, but now you’ve hidden it away. Retrieve it for me in exchange for my help.”

Frodo’s stomach dropped as he realized Smaug was talking about his magic ring. The one that Bilbo had warned him not to put on. At the ghost’s request, Frodo had put it somewhere secret. Giving it to a dragon probably wouldn’t be very wise.

And yet what other choice did he have? He couldn’t let them disappear. They were the only ones who made this place feel like it could be a home. If they vanished, he would be all alone again.

Frodo swallowed. “Very well. I’ll give you the ring.”

“Excccellent,” Smaug purred. “Now, you know what to do.”

In one rushed breath, Frodo shouted, “Pryftan, Pryftan, Pryftan!”

As soon as he uttered the final syllable, the map flew out of his hands and landed on the floor, where it rattled violently, radiating a bright golden light. Frodo watched in fright as the map and its frame split in half. A set of claws emerged, attached to a veiny dragon’s wing. Smaug gradually burst forth like lava from a volcano — first his wings, then his horny head, then his scaly body. Last was his long, whipping tail.

Frodo had never seen a dragon in its normal habitat, but he felt confident that this wasn’t Smaug’s original size. He seemed to have shrunk himself just enough to fit into the room, but still not enough to quell Frodo’s fears.

Smaug blinked his fiery yellow eyes before soaring out of the room and down the hall. Frodo chased after him, but he wasn’t fast enough to witness whatever it was the dragon did to cause Mr. and Mrs. Bulge to run screaming out the front door.

When Frodo arrived in the dining room, he discovered all three Sackville-Bagginses tied to their chairs by long green vines, which had apparently grown out of the many flowers adorning the table. They stared with wide eyes at the dragon, who no longer looked like a dragon at all. He had taken the guise of a man in a gold robe, his face obscured by a hood. He reached his bony red hand toward the book on the table, closing it with one long-nailed finger.

All at once, as if a spell was broken, Bilbo and Thorin collapsed in a heap on the table. If Frodo had known it would be that easy, he certainly wouldn’t have made a deal with a dead dragon.

But as it was, Smaug expected him to retrieve what he promised.

Frodo glanced at the ghosts currently struggling to sit up. They still appeared wrinkled and worryingly breakable, but the color seemed to be returning to their faces. Perhaps it was a gradual process.

“Run along,” Smaug prompted from beneath his hood. “Fetch me my new trinket.”

Suddenly, Frodo had an idea. He thought back to when Smaug first attacked Bag End. Thorin had shouted his name three times to get rid of him. Perhaps he could do the same now.

“Pryftan!” he cried once, and immediately found himself unable to open his mouth again.

“None of that,” said Smaug, wagging a disapproving finger. “Now, I shall not asssk you again. Retrieve the ring for me.”

Frodo was terrified. He couldn’t speak, and no one else in the room was able to help him. Smaug had stuffed the Sackville-Bagginses’ mouths with flowers, and the ghosts were still recovering from the earlier experience.

He stood his ground at first, determined not to let the ring fall into the hands of a villain. But it wasn’t long before he felt himself moving involuntarily toward his hiding place. Smaug seemed to be using some sort of magic to compel him.

Frodo tried to resist it, but he couldn’t stop himself from leaving the room and walking through the kitchen, in the direction of the front entrance. Smaug followed closely, a menacing presence at his back.

When they reached the parlor, Frodo heard a familiar voice behind him.

“Pryftan!” Thorin shouted, and was immediately silenced.

Soon after, Bilbo made his own futile attempt. “Pryftan!”

Frodo didn’t hear either of them again. Since he couldn’t make himself turn around to look, he wasn’t sure if Smaug had forced their mouths shut or made them disappear entirely.

He continued his unwanted walk into the entrance hall, straining his legs against the movement to no avail. When he reached the umbrella stand beside the door, he found himself leaning down to reach all the way to the bottom, where he’d hidden the ring in an envelope under Lobelia’s umbrellas.

Just as his fingers touched the paper, Frodo heard the front door of Bag End swing open, and he was suddenly able to turn his head. He looked in the direction of the noise, where Thorin was standing beside the open door.

Beyond, Frodo did not see the Shire. Rather, he saw a bright blue sky, under which was a vast expanse of yellow sand. 

“Here, you witless worm!” shouted the dwarf.

At that moment, an enormous, faceless serpent emerged from the sand and burst through the door — and the surrounding wall with it. Frodo gasped to realize that Bilbo himself was riding the creature as if it were a pony, looking half-determined and half-terrified.

Bilbo leapt off the serpent’s back just before it opened its many-toothed mouth and devoured Smaug whole where he was standing. After swallowing, the beast plunged through the tiled floor, disappearing into the abyss.

Frodo backed up against the wall to avoid falling into the gaping hole the giant worm had left behind. He stared, speechless, at the ghosts who had just saved him. Thankfully, they looked to be back to their old selves — that is, not falling apart.

“Right,” said Bilbo, adjusting his waistcoat. “That should do it.”

“Well done, Master Baggins,” said Thorin with love in his eyes.

Out the front door, the landscape was back to normal, with the nightly lanterns flickering all the way down the hill. Bag End, on the other hand, was looking a little worse for wear. 

“Help!” came a voice from the dining room. “Someone please help us!”

Frodo and the ghosts hurried down the hall to investigate. Lotho had managed to spit the flowers out of his mouth and shout, but he and his parents were still tied to their chairs.

“Just a moment,” Thorin told them before briefly disappearing into the kitchen to retrieve a cooking knife.

Lobelia’s eyes threatened to burst out of her head as Thorin approached her. She attempted to speak, presumably in protest, but her voice was muffled.

“Have no fear,” Thorin assured her. “I am only trying to help you.”

He carefully cut the vines and removed the flowers from her mouth. For quite possibly the first time in her life, Lobelia looked like she was at a loss for words. She watched with fascination as Thorin moved on to release her husband and son.

“Th-thank you,” Otho said nervously when the dwarf freed him.

Lobelia and Lotho echoed his gratitude. Perhaps looking the spirits in the eye, rather than simply imagining them, had shamed them into being decent. It seemed they were now permanently able to see the ghosts who inhabited their home — without the assistance of bedsheets. 

That was sure to make things interesting.

“Now,” said Bilbo, turning to Frodo, “perhaps we should discuss moving that ring of ours to a safer place.”

Notes:

This fic was aptly titled, since it’s been ROUTINEly HAUNTING me for three years now. So I finally decided to just suck it up and finish the damn thing for my own peace of mind.

The final chapter will be an epilogue.