Chapter Text
The thing about stereotypes is that, even if you know they are lies, they have lived in your mind far too long for them to be easily dispelled. That’s why, if he had known some of his children were a homosexual, Sam would have perhaps thought it was Rose -fiercely independent Rose, who has never liked cooking or sewing and whom they have never known to date anyone, focused as she is in her career-, or maybe Pip, who worships David Bowie’s music and has spent the last decade wearing heeled boots and velvet suits of outrageous colours and even sometimes painting his eyes with sparkly shadows. Somehow, he wouldn’t have suspected it of Hamfast, who loved rugby and studied engineering and even had dated a couple of girls before moving to London for his studies.
Yet it is Hamfast who sits with him during one breakfast and quietly tells him he’s in love with a boy.
‘Are you sure?’, Sam does not say, which he can only be glad of; he doesn’t think that would have been a very kind question. ‘Since when are you gay?’ comes close to being asked, but he pushes it away; that’s an equally ugly answer to such a confession. “Thank you for trusting me with this,” is what he finally answers, pleased at the firmness of his voice and his calm demeanour. He is not exactly calm inside -he is in turmoil. Hamfast has a right to love whoever he wants, and he’ll fight anyone who tells him otherwise -but oh, how he wishes he loved in a different way. How it pains him to know that his son will be so unfairly subjected to other’s people hate and contempt.
“You are not… that is…” the boy still looks apprehensive, which definitely won’t do. Sam reaches forward to pat him on the arm and feels some tension melting away. Good.
“I am glad you are dating someone you love,” he says. That much is true. “And I am glad that you knew you could tell me.” That’s even truer. His boy only has one parent, and he deserves to know he’ll always support him.
Hamfast seems immensely relieved that he is reacting so well. He is glad he can give him that, because in other aspects he is totally lost.
“I think you’ll like him when you meet him,” his son tentatively says. “If… if you want to meet him.”
“Of course I want to,” Sam firmly says. “Introduce us next time I go to London, if you want, or maybe you could bring him here.”
“It’s much better if you come to London, I think,” Hamfast quickly says. “I mean… bringing him here can be… the neighbours…”
The neighbours will want to know everything about him, yes, which will mean either introduce him as Hamfast friend, and having the poor boys pretend to be someone they are not, or make them, and the whole family, face the scorn of the village. The first option would make things much easier for his father and siblings, no doubt; so much easier that Sam’s ashamed to wish for a second Hamfast will choose to do so, if he ever does bring his boyfriend to Hobbiton. But that’s an unfair, a deeply unfair thought. Whatever he chooses to do, his family will back him, as they should. Sam hasn’t raised them to act in any other way.
“It’s settled then,” he says in the lightest tone he can find. He smiles, and if it’s not his best, Ham smiles back, so it must not be his worse, either. “I’ll go there in a couple of months, and then you can introduce me to your bo- your boyfriend.”
There, it’s said; he stuttered a little, but not terribly so, and Ham’s smile only grows. Sam’s sweating slightly, to be honest; he wants to do what’s best for his son, but he truly has no idea how to. Nothing has prepared him for this conversation, and he vaguely wonders whether Rosie would have fared better. He tends to think she would, when his children baffle him, but he does realize that’s a matter of idealization, more than reality. Rosie was an excellent mother, but she died ten years ago; at this point, he knows them better than she ever did.
“He’s been wanting to meet you, although he was apprehensive, too,” Ham says. “But I said that you would take it fine; that you had friends that were… like us… and you have never minded.”
“Ah.” Suddenly, Sam remembers all those hours Ham spent next to Bilbo’s armchair when he came to die four years ago, and he starts to suspect what might it be that they had been talking about. If he provided his son with some kind of guidance, he can only be grateful for it; it’s better than imagining poor Ham trying to come to terms with the way he was and not knowing who he could turn to. “Yes, old Bilbo was like you, as was Mister Thorin, and believe me, I’m quite proud to call myself a friend of them.”
“George was quite impressed when he learnt they were friends of yours,” Ham says. He must notice Sam’s surprise, because he elaborates. “They are known, you know, among… us. A referent, in a way.” That does make sense, he guesses. As a musician and a novelist, they must be quite famous, and they had lived together for so long, after all. “But I didn’t mean Mister Bilbo, you know. I was talking about Frodo.”
“Frodo?” He must have suspected, somehow, because it doesn’t shock him, not really. He remembers now that sweetheart that never existed, the way in which his friend related to Bilbo, their shared love for some classics -Ham has always been disproportionally interested in Achilles and Plato and Alexander the Great, come to think about it. “Frodo is… like you? Did he tell you that?”
“You didn’t know?” His son seems horrified. “Fuck, I never meant to out him. It’s just… the way he spoke, he seemed to think you knew!”
“Language,” Sam absently says, because homosexual acts will be tolerated in his house, but swearing will not. His mind is busy analysing the rest of the Hamfast’s declaration, though. Frodo thought he knew? Goodness, what had he been missing all those years? Had Frodo ever tried to talk to him about those matters, and he hadn’t realized? Had he failed to be there for him when he needed him? After all he had done for him, Sam would never forgive himself if he had.
“Please, don’t ask him about it,” Ham says, his eyes full of concern. “It’s not… it’s not nice to have this kind of conversation, if you don’t choose to. And I shouldn’t have told you without being sure you knew. It’s not done.”
“Not done, uh? Is that a rule?”
“Well, sort of.” Ham seems hesitant, but not closed off. That’s good. Sam needs him to know he can keep confiding in his father.
“Do not worry, son. I won’t say a thing.” After all, he can only hope Frodo knows he can tell him openly, as well as Ham had known. If he doesn’t, he will when he comes and finds his son’s love acknowledged and respected. He puts a hand in Ham’s arm and squeezes it affectionately. “Do you want to tell me some more rules, so your old man doesn’t make a fool of himself when he meets that George?”
“Anything you want to know,” Ham promises.
*
He has been reading a lot since Ham ‘came out’, as young people say. If he is to help his son, he better be informed; the world seems to be intent in making his boy feel bad about being himself, and facts and solid arguments seem to be the only way to make some people change their minds. Sam feels like it shouldn’t be -his son is a wonderful person, can’t they all see? Who cares what he chooses to do in bed, who he loves?-, but there is so many misconceptions about his kind that information is sometimes the only shield he can use to shelter him from other people’s contempt. So read he does, and as he reads, he learns.
He hadn’t known there were people who went both ways, for instance.
Well, that isn’t exactly true. He had heard about it. But, just as there are many misconceptions about those who prefer their own gender, there seem to be many about those who have no preference, although they are different. Sam has heard homosexuals called monsters, perverts, unnatural, predatory, effeminate, weak; some are kinder, or so they think themselves to be, and call them sick. Bisexuals, for that seems to be the term, are considered sex-obsessed, untrustful, attention-seeking, fleeting in their affections and compulsively unfaithful. Truly, when one hears so many terrible words applied to a collective, why would one feel the desire to learn about its members? Better to keep away from them, surely.
But when he doesn’t keep that distance… when he reads, when he listens, when he talks with some of Hamfast’s friends… then he learns. And he finds himself thinking what they say is terribly familiar, in a way. Not all of it, of course; they are from a different generation, after all, and being young in the eighties is so different from being young during WWII. But there is one kind of story that he can always relate to: the one he privately labels The Special Friend.
Because everybody has friends, but not everybody has The Special Friend. That one whose hand you want to take. That one whose forehead you want to kiss. The one you want to hug and never let go, the one whose skin you want to feel against yours for hours. A friend whose hair you want to comb and caress, a friend you shared a bed with, or a sofa, and whose lingering smell in your clothes and sheets and furniture makes you inexplicably happy. When those young boys and girls tell those stories, sometimes they explain how they felt explicit, obvious desire for such friends; sometimes they say they didn’t. Some of them realized immediately that their special friendship was something else, even if they had been taught that something else was impossible, wrong. Some didn’t think anything about it, and years and years later, suddenly, put the pieces together and discovered they had been in love.
Sam is definitely among the later, he has found out.
In some ways, he thinks he should freak out more about this. So, so many bad things are said about those who are like him -but then, he knows it’s not true, so why should he doubt himself because of this? Society would consider this as a redefinition of his personality, a change in who he claims to be. But it isn’t, not really. He is still Samwise Gamgee, farmer, WWII veteran, father of thirteen, widow of Rosie Cotton, neighbour of Hobbiton, football fan and secret writer of poetry. He is who he is, and he also is, or has been in love with Frodo Baggins.
He thinks he should freak out, because that’s what is expected, but actually, things sort of make sense better know. He makes sense better know, because he knows who he is better. Not that he is ready to tell a soul -hell, no; he needs more time to think about this, and he’ll freely admit he is terrified of how people might react if they find out. But now he knows. And that’s good. That’s as it should be.
*
1983, however, is possibly the worse year of the century to realize you might harbour tender feelings for one of your own sex, and it becomes even worse as months go by. Not that ever was a good moment, probably; Sam doesn’t think those who realized years ago had it easy in any way. But while the world’s never been welcoming to such news, there has been a nonetheless obvious change during the past decades; his own family is testament to that, for Sam can only snort and praise the Lord that Ham has never had to reveal his preferences to his grandparents and their siblings. His son’s siblings have been supportive, and his aunts and uncles accepting, if awkward. Not every young boy has been so lucky, Sam’s aware, but still, it’s obvious that the seventies have been a more favourable moment for being known as homosexual that the forties were.
Things change in the eighties. Things take a bad, bad turn in the eighties.
The world is immersed in a conservative wave, that’s no mystery, and so many things they had been taking for granted seem to be now under discussion. But as if recession, wars breaking and many countries falling under dictatorship weren’t enough, God seems to have decided to make things even harder for homosexuals.
Well, not God -Sam won’t claim he is an overly religious man, nor he would presume to know His mind in any case, but he cannot believe such a thing is possible. So many evil deeds go unanswered in this world; any kind deity would not decide to punish people for something they did not choose. Still, that’s exactly what people are saying: that men who love other men went against the laws of God, or those of science if they want to think themselves a bit more progressive, and now they are being punished by it.
It sickens him than anyone could be so cruel. That illness, that HIV, is killing people in increasingly high numbers. Things are not yet awful in the UK, but the news that come from the US are terrifying. And it’s a vicious disease, often fast to kill and terrible to endure for the most -and impossible to cure, or that’s what it seems. Who could be so ruthless to think that’s what someone deserves, no matter what they had done? Not that loving someone or feeling desire for them should be something to be punished, in any case, bur even if it were, who could think being annihilated in such a way is somewhat fair? What kind of monster thinks such a thing?
And it’s not even as if men who bed other men were the only targets -logically, a disease does not care for that; it spreads as it can. But Sam’s old enough to know some are always ready to poison other’s minds and make things difficult for those they don’t like -he remembers all too well what the British Union of Fascists said about Jews and other victims of their hatred, before war began and they were made to stop. The things that were said back then weren’t logical, either; even a young boy from a little backwards village could tell, because you only needed a fair, kind heart to understand that. But like now, hate seemed to overcome all logic.
In this case there’s also a component of fear, perhaps. It’s not yet clear how the disease is spreading, and many choose not to take any risk by rejecting all contact with homosexuals, just in case. Ham is deeply embittered by this, as it should be normal -he is losing friends to this pandemic, is panicked that he and George will lose their jobs too, and is subjected to the judgement of many who he had thought accepted him as he was. Even Sam will admit, to his shame, that his first panicked reaction to the news had been asking if he could in any way have acquired it. If his own father, who would give anything to help and support him, asked that out of concern, he cannot imagine what others are telling him and George, what they assume of them, how they might be avoiding and ostracizing them.
Frodo can imagine, of course -he knows for a fact. He is obviously exhausted in one of his visits, and all the news he has of his job are awful. He often apologizes when he tells Sam sad stories of cases he is involved in, but his guest keeps encouraging him to get them off his chest, which he obviously needs. Yes, things are clearly terrible in the States, and Sam has been wondering for months how Frodo was coping. Not very well, it looks like.
“It’s simply awful,” Frodo declares sadly. “There’s so many families losing their jobs and being evicted from their homes. Some never really recovered after the oil crisis, and therefore this now just hits twice as hard.”
Sam nods in agreement; the crisis is being very hard to swallow for everyone. Goldilocks and his husband will likely have to close their shop, Pip’s unemployed, and Primrose’s talking of moving to the city, where she might have better chances at getting a job. He has never been so glad to work in a farm -it’s a hard work, and he’ll never be rich, but he can live off if, and he knows his children will never starve, at least.
“The government says economic growth has been re-established,” he bitterly states. “But common people sure aren’t seeing it.”
“No, they are not,” Frodo agrees. “And now there’s cocaine running like crazy in the streets, or some imitation or mix of it -and where there’s drug there’s crime.” He massages his forehead and sighs tiredly. “Some neighbourhoods have serious problems with it, either because of the drug or because of the crime, or both. Most f them are neighbourhoods that had previous problems and tried to either forget them or make some money dealing, of course, so it hits the poor all the harder. Racism in the US being as it is, that’s often areas inhabited by black people, and as you might imagine, that’s an added problem for them when they must face police or a trial -they are as biased as anyone else, or perhaps more.” He shakes his head. “It’s just so bad, Sam. It is as if people were hardening their hearts, and some seeds of hope I had harboured have been stomped down when they were but sprouts.”
He is so obviously dismayed it makes Sam’s heart hurt. It’s not just that Frodo despises the present, he realizes, it’s that he fears for the future. He is afraid of how the world will be when this is over, if it’s ever over; the combined crises they are living are changing their society, and he clearly doesn’t think the changes are for the best.
“Is anyone giving you a hard time?” he asks at one point, and cringes inwardly. He has wondered for months, yes, for his thoughts turn to Frodo often, but he hadn’t been meaning to ask. They have never openly acknowledged the fact he knows about his friend’s sexuality, after all. Then again, he supposes he could choose to read the question as a reference to his job and activism -lawyers can get their share of harassment because of their job, too. He half wishes he will, so they don’t have to address the subject, but at the same time he feels… well. Like maybe it’s about time they do. Perhaps they should. So he boldly adds, “for who you are.”
Frodo pauses for a moment, looking at him intently. He seems hesitant, and Sam is a bit hurt by it; surely Frodo knows he can confide in him, doesn’t he?
“No, Sam,” he finally says. “Well, some, maybe, but I know how to defend myself. I’m in good health, I own my home, I’m white, and I will not stop having clients for who I am. I’ll be alright.”
All of that is true, of course, but it is not enough to appease Sam’s concerns. All that will protect Frodo, but it will not help him if someone goes for him.
“Do you have friends? People to turn to if you need any help, people who’ll hear you out if your work becomes too much? Somewhere to run to, if you ever were under threat?” He takes his hand. “Because if things go bad, you can always come here, you know. This is your home, if you want it.”
“This is your home, Sam,” Frodo corrects with a soft tone and a small smile. “I wouldn’t want to impose in such a way.”
For half a second, Sam is about to confess his feelings. His heart pounds heavily in his chest and adrenaline runs through his veins while he struggles to find the right words, but he pauses, unable to get them right. There’s so much he needs to say, and it is such a tangled web. He wants to confess his love for Frodo, as a part of him had wanted to proclaim it since he realized of his feelings -but while he is perhaps the only person in this world he is completely sure that will not turn away from him if he does so, he could well turn them down, and that would hurt immensely, and probably hurt their friendship too, which is a risk he doesn’t want to take. Not, it is better if he holds his tongue; Frodo would be kind in his rejection, he is sure, but things would inevitably turn awkward.
And even if the impossible happened… even if he did want Sam’s feelings, he might want to know why he took so much time to acknowledge them; worse yet, he might think Sam had known all along and chosen not to tell him, to live a normal happy life with a wife instead of being honest with him. He doesn’t think he will, not really; Frodo is well aware of his feelings for Rosie, and surely he will forgive how slow Sam has been in noticing this, for he has never begrudged him for not being as bright and smart as he is. But what if everything goes well, and Frodo loves him back, but then wants to make it public? Will he understand that Sam’s terrified of telling his own children, his siblings and friends? Will he be offended by his reluctance to be open about it?
Probably not, but he can’t be as sure as he would like to, and anyway it seems like he has taken too much time to reach his conclusions. Frodo grips his hand tightly and then lets it go, clasping his own together and letting them fall under the table, beyond Sam’s reach.
“In any case, I have to get back,” he declares, lowering his gaze with what seems great sadness. “I can help people there, even it’s just a small thing.”
“It’s not a small thing,” Sam says. He lowers his own gaze, although in his case it’s mostly due to shame -here he is, afraid of many things, and yet he thinks his concerns are laughable. His friend, his beloved, is out there, fighting for those who have bigger reasons to fear: people who cannot fed their families, people who are harassed because of their skin, people fighting an addiction to drugs, people who are dying among the scorn and the indifference of those who think they somehow deserve it. “No help is small when you need it and it’s sincerely offered.”
