Chapter Text
He thought he had concealed his feelings well, what with him not being aware of them until a year and some months ago, but apparently he is an open book for his eldest daughter.
“So,” Elanor asks, making a pause in her resolute chopping of onions, “when are you going to tell him that you are in love with him?”
Sam nearly drops the bowl of peas he has been peeling.
“What?”
“When are you going to tell Frodo that you love him?” she repeats, as if it were nothing. As if Sam’s heart hadn’t stopped at the question.
“I- I- well, I never!” he says, putting the bowl of half-pealed peas safely in the table. No matter how scandalous the question, it won’t do to let good food go to waste. “I can’t believe you are asking me that!”
Elanor’s look changes somehow; she narrows her eyes and becomes suspicious.
“You do know you are in love with him, don’t you?”
And here Sam pauses for a moment -he has never admitted it out loud, and the question makes him very self-conscious. In all honesty, he even considers lying for a second, too afraid to openly acknowledge who he is, and if anyone else was asking he might. He still looks around instinctively, but of course, there’s none but them. Despite his tribe of children, right now only Ruby is home, but since her boyfriend is visiting, he doesn’t expect her to come downstairs for a good while.
So no; there’s no one else but his eldest daughter. He can do this, in her company. Perhaps he should do it, even -for himself, for her. In any case, he is going to.
“I do know it,” he acknowledges quietly.
If his heart has stopped before, now it’s beating faster, and he can’t seem to stop glancing at his daughter’s face and immediately looking away, too afraid of what he might read in her face to keep facing her and too anxious to know her reaction to properly avoid her eyes.
He has said it. Damn, he has said it. Now what?
But Elanor only nods, as if she expected it and it wasn’t a big deal.
“Good,” she says, going back to chopping. “We had been wondering.”
Well, that was almost anticlimactic.
“That’s all you have to say?” he asks, baffled. “And who is us?”
“Me and my siblings, of course. We have been wondering for years.”
He knows she is giving him answers, but he doesn’t feel like he is understanding anything any better. It must show in his face, because Elanor seems to struggle to find the right words.
“Look, it’s… I don’t know, Dad; there was always something in the way you talked about him, in the way you behaved around him. But I didn’t know what it was, exactly, until Ham came out. That’s when I started to suspect.” Her eyes are set on the knife, but she is chopping slowly now, as if she were choosing her words carefully. “After a while, I decided to talk with Ham about it, and he said he thought the same, but you never said anything, so he didn’t either.” Ham knows, then. Sam has wondered, more than once -he has concealed it, or so he thinks, but his son knows him well, and surely he knows how to recognize the signs. When had he taken notice? The first time Sam saw Frodo, after realizing he was in love with him? Some months earlier, when Sam had been toying with the idea of calling himself bisexual, even if only in his own mind? After his friend’s last visit, when he nearly confessed the way he felt? Or perhaps -and that’s a little scary- he had known before he himself knew, had read in him what Sam hadn’t had tools to properly analyse. “In time, the others told us they had their suspicions too, and now… We have all been wondering for years whether you had realized or not that you were in love with Frodo.”
“You… you…”
Sam rubs his forehead, feeling the beginnings of a headache. He grimaces and looks at the ceiling, where a song is loudly coming down from Ruby’s room; her latest boyfriend calls himself a metalhead, whatever that means. Perhaps the term implies one needs a head of metal in order to endure such a hammering; in all truth, Sam has sometimes wondered if they put those records on only to cover up some other noise that might come from the room. But that is a path of thought he would rather not take, and in any case, it seems like he will be forced to discuss his own love or sex life, and not his daughter’s.
That will definitely cause a headache, no matter what songs come from upstairs.
“We understand if you need time before you discuss this with any of us,” Elanor says, more softly. For all that she has inherited her mother’s pragmatism, she is also a kind girl, and must see that his father is a bit overwhelmed by the conversation. “But we want you to know you can.” She pauses, as if hesitating. “And we think it might be good for you if you did. With Hamfast, at least, if that makes you more comfortable.”
“I don’t know if it would,” he admits. Hamfast might relate with him better than any other of his children, of course, at least in some ways, but he is- he is so young. He belongs to this new world in which you can discover the way you are early in life, if you are lucky; a world in which you can call a man your boyfriend and feel you have a right to be treated fairly by society, even if this one still fails to do so. He doesn’t know what it is to reach your middle age without tools to acknowledge your feelings, the self-doubt it implies -he sometimes wonders if he isn’t making it up, for surely he would have known earlier, if he truly was that way? Or perhaps it’s the other way around: did he make up his feelings for Rosie? No, of course he didn’t, but he hasn’t been taught that one can be the way he is, he hasn’t known until he was in his fifties, and sometimes he feels that must be the truth. He knows it will be what anyone his age will think, if he ever tells them how things are -even among the younger, many do not believe that bisexuality exist, and see it as a phase or a deceit; among those of his age, that’s definitely the default answer. No, Hamfast won’t understand -he doesn’t know the crippling fear of explaining the world there’s a huge part of you they don’t know when they think they have had you figured out for decades, when they’ll assume you have been lying your whole life.
Frodo would know, likely. Frodo would be the best possible choice, but... at the same time, it’s a very bad one.
“Well, with any of us you might choose, really. Perhaps Rose… she is so sensible, right? She gives good advice. Or Daisy, you know, one of her best friends is a lesbian, so perhaps she might know better than us. We just… we want to help you, Dad, in any way you need.”
There’s a shine in her eyes that Sam would blame on the onions if he didn’t know her so well, or if his own eyes weren’t moist. He needs to clear his throat so he can answer.
“I know you would. You are such good kids.” They are, they truly are; the best of his life, and he is immensely relieved to know he isn’t losing them because of who he is. Because he isn’t, right? Doubt suddenly assaults his mind. “You don’t… you don’t mind…”
“What, that you are in love with a wonderful man who was here for us when we most needed him? No, we truly don’t.” She puts the onions aside and starts to peel off the potatoes slowly, a bit hesitant. “We might have done so,” she acknowledges. Judging by her face, she doesn’t like to admit it, but Sam is glad she is so honest. He wouldn’t have believed her if she had said they hadn’t, in all truth. “Some years ago, we might have. If Hamfast hadn’t… changed the way we thought about some things, made us all read and talk about it, we wouldn’t have liked it, I think. Or… if this had happened years ago, when Mum had just died, then maybe…”
Then something goes through Sam’s mind, a sharp fear that sets his heart ablaze, and he has to interrupt her.
“You do not believe I loved your Mum any less because of this, do you?” he anxiously asks. “Because I’m not… I’m not like Ham; I mean, not exactly, and what I felt for your mother...”
Truth be told, this is something he has had to struggle with, in some ways, and yet again he has always known the truth. Others would say he couldn’t have been in love with Rosie, if he has loved Frodo as he knows he has since he was a young boy; even those who accept that people like him exist -and there aren’t that many- would argue that he could not have loved them at the same time. But he knows things are not as simple, for doesn’t he love Rosie still, even if she has been dead for more than a decade now? No, his feelings for her have not changed, and if he can love both her and Frodo all the same now, he can have loved them before, when the two of them were alive.
“What? No, no. We get it.” She waves off his concern so forcefully the potato nearly flies form her hand. “Well, Tol and Robin didn’t… hum…” She pauses again, while Sam heart beats faster. Didn’t what? Whatever it is, he needs to know now. “They didn’t understand, at the beginning,” she finally says. “That you could… that it was an option to like both things. And… and they were so young when Mum died. If they had seen you together, they would have never doubted.” She clears her throat. “I could never doubt that you loved her, Dad, and anyone who says that is a fool, and blind besides.”
“Oh, Elanor.” Now he gets up and hugs her, overtaken by emotion. In spite of the conversation being about his feelings towards Frodo, it’s Rosie that his mind turns to, and he is terribly glad that she didn’t doubt her love for her, because he doesn’t think he could put it in words for his daughter to understand. “I still miss her so much, girl, you have no idea. I speak with her in my own mind every day; I don’t know if I’ll ever stop,” he confesses. “Even about… I mean… I did have some doubts about what she would have said about Frodo, that is, about me being in love with Frodo, I…”
“I think she would have been glad,” Elanor firmly says. Sam is a bit taken aback that she sounds so convinced. “She’s been dead for fifteen years, Dad. She would like you to go on and be happy again, not matter with whom. And I don’t think she would have opposed to that someone to be Frodo, of all people.”
“No,” he agrees. “Probably not.” He has reached the same conclusion, in his own dialogues with the ghost of Rosie, but he had been afraid he had been making it up for his own convenience. After all, he has not discussed this with anyone else -maybe he has wanted Rosie’s support so badly that he has distorted her memory in order to obtain it.
“So there you have it. Mom would have encouraged you to tell him, as we do.” Elanor hugs him tightly again before taking a step back and putting her hands on his shoulders. “Which leads me to ask again: when are you going to tell Frodo you are in love with him, so you can start being together and make each other happy?”
He blurts out a tremulous laugh.
“You are moving quite fast there, girl. It’s not so easy to talk about this. And you are presuming that he loves me back.”
Now Elanor is looking at him as if he was dim-witted.
“I am starting to realize why Mom was the one that asked you out, you know,” she says. “It’s written all over his face, Dad. How can you doubt it?”
*
But of course he doubts it.
All right, so he likes men and women both. And Frodo likes men, too. They have been friends for about forty years; far more than half of their lives; they have been together through battles, blood and the sheer terror of facing a heartless, inhuman empire. They have shared much, and they have a connection Sam can only half-explain, even now that he knows he is in love with that man.
None of that means necessarily that Frodo will love him back.
After all, what is him, next to Frodo? Sam is not so unconfident as he might have been in his youth; he is aware now that he is a man of some merit -a brave veteran, a writer of half-decent poetry, a good husband and father, a man whose neighbours appreciate and respect. He can accept he deserves some esteem, of course. But what is all that, really, compared with Frodo? What’s all that compared with a man who is ten times braver, a thousand times smarter, a million times kinder? He won’t even get into looks -even before he began aging, Sam could only be considered tolerably handsome, while Frodo has always been a dashing man.
When he realizes he has always thought of him in those terms he does wonder how it took him so long to see he was in love with him, but that’s another matter. In love or not, he knows who his friend is -and he doesn’t hold a candle to his radiance.
On the other hand, however, sometimes he feels like Rosie would have laughed at him for these thoughts. She would pinch his cheeks and tease him, saying he is selling himself short. She would praise him until Sam got redder than one of his tomatoes; Sam would stammer and point out all the ways in which this cannot go well -surely Frodo has someone, back in the States; yes, sure, he told Ham he wasn’t seeing anyone when that kind busybody of a son he has asked him last Christmas, but that doesn’t mean he can’t be in love with a handsome, brave, smart man like himself. And Rosie would snort at that and remind him that he had also thought he would come back from the war to find her married to some nebulous scholar in uniform with the face of a cherub, only to find out she had waited impatiently for his return.
Oh, Rosie. If she were here, he would have likely never realized he was in love with Frodo, and he would have almost surely never considered acting on it -but how he misses her. How he wishes she was here now to give him her support and her love. How he misses having that relationship with someone.
Well, then, let’s say Elanor and Rosie are right, let’s say Frodo does want him, does want to be in a relationship with him. Then what? Will he want to go live with Sam? He is not so young that retirement is inconceivable, and his inheritance would allow it. Besides, Hobbiton might be a little place, with different population and needs than San Francisco, but it’s not like they lack people who would welcome a defender. He could find work and worthy causes.
But what if he doesn’t want to abandon the ones he is currently fighting for? Would he ask Sam to go live with him in the States? The idea gives him some vertigo; except for his years in the army, he has always lived in his little town, and he is not sure how much he’d like residing in a huge city in a foreign country. If needed, he guesses he could; he can leave the farm in Young Fro’s hands, and although it would pain him to leave his children, they are not really children anymore, and therefore they would manage without him. He does hope Frodo won’t ask him to, but people who are childless sometimes do not understand how it is, that deep visceral bond. And come to think about it, how is it to ask Frodo to leave those who need him behind any fairer than asking Sam to do leave his grown up children behind?
Those are practical, logistical problems, though. There are others that make Sam’s stomach twist and turn and keep him awake at night, the first and foremost being if Frodo would want to make their relationship public. He won’t deny it sort of panics him -he has still not been able to bring up his recently found sexual orientation with his siblings, and in all truth, he isn’t sure that he ever wishes to. As for his friends and neighbours, the idea is even worse. He doesn’t think they would be attacked, which is something; as far as he knows, there have been no aggressions of such kind in Hobbiton, and his work in the farm keeps him fit enough that he would likely dissuade most of assailants. But while he can trust Pippin and Merry to be open-minded, at least, he knows if he were to openly be in a relationship with a man he’d become Hobbiton gossip for years. Not, that’s wishful thinking; for the rest of his life, most likely, and he doesn’t fancy having to explain himself over again and again, having to face comments and suspicions, having to let his little world change irremediably. But could they truly keep it secret, if Frodo came to live in Bag’s End? Maybe he should go to the States instead, after all.
And then -and Sam blushes just to think about it- there’s the physical aspect of their love. He thinks so, so often of kissing Frodo, cuddling him, holding his hand. Sometimes his thoughts slip into more lustful paths, however, and then he finds himself facing the unknown. How does one give pleasure to a man? How will it be, feeling it? Ham and Elanor have discretely left some books around, but Sam has found them rather intimidating, and not that useful altogether. He has even considered buying or renting some film, but that’s even scarier; just the thought of going to a video club or store makes him blush, and how could he ever get privacy enough to watch it? The idea of having his children walk in while he is watching such a thing makes him feel faint.
The scariest thing, however, and one he cannot change, is the fact that he is… old, and unused to sharing his body with anyone else after nearly two decades as a widower. He is nearly sixty -will he be able to learn? Will he be able to give Frodo what he needs?
But maybe Frodo is like him. Maybe he wants the physical aspects of love, maybe he wishes to openly be himself -but what he needs is to be loved, more than anything else.
In some ways, Somebody to love is what makes him decide himself, which is somewhat surprising. After all, it is hardly the first time he has heard the song; his children have loved it for the best part of the last decade, just as they love about anything Queen releases. But he has been talking with Ham about what he calls “gay anthems”, those songs that mean something for his community -their community? He isn’t sure of that. The point is Ham said Somebody to love is one of those songs. And a couple of weeks after he had commented on it, Sam listens again to the song. Not intentionally; he just happens to be gardening when the radio plays it. But he listens to it, really listens to it for the first time in years, and when he realizes it’s a gay man singing, the lyrics suddenly seem to mean something very different to him.
‘They say I’m going crazy,’ Freddy Mercury sings in his beautiful voice… crazy, because he wants to find somebody to love. Sam grips his pruner harder when he hears him proudly proclaim ‘I just gotta get out of this prison cell, some day I’m gonna be free’, because he thinks he somewhat understands; maybe he isn’t in the same situation than the character of the song, but he can relate. That’s what his fears feel like -a prison cell. Maybe he needs to get out of it, and let the world call him crazy if they must -maybe he would endure it better than he thinks, because he does have someone to love.
*
He never really misses the years of the war, not even when he nostalgically remembers how young he was. But he does miss how freely affectionate he was with Frodo back then -how they would sleep together for warmth and comfort when they camped, or how they held hands, or how they kissed each other’s forehead in goodbye when missions separated them. He wants to do all that with Frodo, every time he comes to visit, but he ends up awkwardly avoiding it, afraid to give himself away somehow, yet wishing at the same time that he did -that a single touch would tell Frodo all he needs to get off his chest.
Such magical touch never comes, of course, but his confession does have some hints of the war, because he drops it like a bomb.
It’s a night of September, and Frodo has been staying for a few days -he always comes around his birthday, since Sam insists that he celebrates it with them. They are alone in the house, Ruby staying at a friend’s and Robin and Tol having gone to a party. His children blatantly use Frodo’s presence to coax Sam’s permission to go out more often than he would usually allow, but he rolls his eyes and lets them anyway. After all, it does mean he gets to spend more time alone with Frodo, and that he craves.
September’s been colder than it usually would, and he and Frodo end up sitting close in the sofa, both of them covered by the same blanket. They watch a film, but Sam couldn’t for the life of him say which one it is -at one point he has let his head tentatively fall in Frodo’s shoulder, to which his friend has not answered, except with a deeper intake of breath and his own head dropping on Sam’s after a while. Those facts, along with his confused feelings and half formed wishes, have Sam distracted enough that the film is impossible to follow, but he will likely forever remember a commercial. It’s nothing remarkable; he doesn’t even know what they are trying to advertise. What captures his interest is the characters: an old couple that laugh and eat and dance together in their house, so domestic, so happy, so obviously in love with each other since forever that it hurts.
“Do you ever think that could be us?” he suddenly blurts outs, like the idiot he is.
He can feel Frodo’s shoulder tense against his cheek, undoubtedly startled by the question, so he lifts his own head up, dislodging his friend’s, and puts some distance between them, afraid that things are about to go awkward. But when he looks at him, Frodo just seems cautious and shy, as it’s his nature… and perhaps, or maybe Sam’s deluding himself, the littlest bit hopeful.
“Do you mean… living together?” he tentatively asks.
“I, well, yes, that too; I think about living with you all the time,” Sam says, not really explaining anything and complicating things even more at the same time. Oh, he wants to crawl under the sofa and hide there; if only his cracking joints would allow such acrobatics. “But I meant that we could be… a marriage, of sorts. If you wanted to. If we saw that it worked for us.”
Yes, he was not mistaken -it was hope that he saw in Frodo’s eyes, and now it’s spreading to the rest of his face, filling it with a happiness that makes Sam’s heart hurt and flutter and do all kind of things he didn’t even remember it could make.
“Sam,” he says, in the tone of one who desperately wants to believe, “are you asking me out?”
That’s such a juvenile way to put it that it nearly makes him laugh; he hasn’t ‘asked out’ anyone in forty years. But then, he has not felt like this in a long time either, has he?
“I guess,” he replies with a smile; he shyly takes Frodo’s hand and, to his delight, finds his own fingers gripped tightly by the other man. “What I am saying is -I am in love with you. And I think I’ve always been. I’m sorry it took me so long to realize,” he adds as an afterthought, because really, he has been rather slow.
But Frodo doesn’t seem to mind at all.
“I am not,” he replies in a tone that turns Sam’s insides into butter, so tender it is. “Those years have made you who you are, and I wouldn’t change a thing about you. You are who you are, and to me, you are perfect.”
Sam cannot really think of anything to say at that -all words have flown from his mind. it doesn’t really matter, though; he might not be a young boy anymore, and he might not know how things are done with a man, but he knows the way Frodo’s angling his head, and he answers to it without thinking -in a matter of seconds, his lips are on Frodo’s, and he feels like he might burst with happiness, and be content with it.
