Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

The Price The Gods Decree

Summary:

Dwarves have Ones, their perfect partner gifted them by Mahal and they love only once. Hobbits also only love once, their partner being termed a Heart-Mate. But Dwarves and Hobbits are also secretive about their most personal matters and sometimes, not knowing how another race works can be a serious problem.

When rumours circulate that the Prince Consort of Erebor is spending an excessive amount of time with the Miner Bofur, the suggestions of an affair take on a life of their own. Reaching the ears of the King, a humiliated and jealous Thorin confronts his husband in Council and a misunderstanding morphs into something catastrophic. But neither partner realises the true price of what they have done...

Notes:

Another story? Well this was an idea that kept nagging at me about a catastrophe stemming from rumours, a misunderstanding and some serious stubbornness issues. Add in some panthy angst and this is the result. I have taken artistic license with Ones, Heart-Mates and all other sorts of soul-mate mythology because I can.

As always, the Hobbit was written by Professor J R R Tolkien. The rights to the films belong to New Line Cinema, Warner Brothers and MGM. I own nothing except an over-active imagination and a propensity for messing up our heroes' lives...

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Rumours and Lies

Chapter Text

ONE: Rumours and Lies

 

There were rumours, of course. But then, there were always rumours in Erebor and though the vast majority of them were utter stuff and nonsense, a wise spy always kept his ear to the ground, so when Nori heard the same rumours being repeated and amplified-and, more importantly, modified as ‘new information’ became available, he started to feel alarmed.

 

Sitting in a corner in a rather run-down tavern close to the smelting district, packed to the rafters with dwarves who were determinedly relaxing-meaning drinking, singing and exchanging raucous tales-he found himself first hand hearing the rumours for himself.

 

“They’ve been seen again.”

 

“Who?”

 

“You know! The Prince and his fancy bit.”

 

“Oh. You still banging on about that rubbish?”

 

“It ain’t rubbish. My cousin’s friend Wynto who guards the ramparts saw him up there, staring south and waiting for him to return.”

 

“There are a hundred reasons why he could be on the ramparts! That ain’t proof of nothing.”

 

“Maybe not. But considering what happened here, why would he come up here of not for a very good reason.” There was a pause. “And his fancy bit arrived that afternoon. He was first to greet him.”

 

“Bet his husband wasn’t too pleased.”

 

“You know the Company have an odd way of behaving. In public they all act proper but behind closed doors…well, who’s to know what they got up to on that Quest. Long road, lonely nights, I’d not be surprised if…”

 

“Shhh! Walls have ears! And speaking like that of the Consort is officially treason!”

 

“And cuckolding the King ain’t?”

 

Nori felt his blood run cold, because that was the first time he had heard the allegations spoken aloud.

 

“No one has seen nothing!” the second speaker insisted. “Everyone knows the Prince and that miner are good friends. Always have been. Mahal, the miner is friends with almost everyone anyway…”

 

“I spoke to a meat delivery dwarf-Gurin, his name was-and he said that he saw them huddled together in Master Gwillim’s Bakery.”

 

“Halflings and their stomachs. And you are still making mountains out of pebbles.”

 

“When Master Dori came, looking for them, they leapt apart as if scalded!”

 

“Could have been talking about something personal…”

 

“Now you’re getting the idea.” The first speaker was sounding smug. His friends sighed and Nori sipped his ale because his throat was dry. 

 

“Get yer mind out o’ the gutter! There are a hundred different things that could have caused that.”

 

“Here’s the clincher. My cousin’s sister’s neighbour saw the pair of them embracing in the Prince’s rooms!”

 

“They’re friends.”

 

“You keep telling yourself that. Everyone knows by now. I’m shocked the King hasn’t heard.”

 

“Maybe he’s too smart to listen to scurrilous gossip.”

 

“Or maybe he doesn’t want to believe that his One would throw it all away for some bit on the side…”

 

“Well, he’s a Halfling. They don’t understand the ways of our people.”

 

Nori had heard enough and drained his ale, then rose, his face concealed by his hood. He pushed his way through the jovial throng, ducking under a flying mug of ale and breaking out into the half-lit alley behind the little tavern. He found his heart was pounding and he felt completely unnerved. And he knew it was stupid because he shouldn’t listen to the talk of dwarves in their cups but it was clear that it had gone beyond just a rumour. Half the mountain were convinced that the rumour was true and that meant that it had gone beyond being a nuisance to an existential threat to the happiness and peace of mind of two of his dearest friends. He straightened his shoulders. He had work to do.

 

Over the next few days, he exhausted himself seeking witnesses, cataloguing rumours and talking to the rest of the Company. And far from being reassured, what he found made him feel worse. For in the wrong hands and before biassed eyes, the tale he uncovered would look incriminating. And of course, there could be an entirely innocent explanation…but that would probably not be enough. Because ultimately, this was about the marriage of the King of Erebor, Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thrain and the Prince Consort, Bilbo Baggins, son of Bungo. And Thorin was a dwarf through and through-which meant possessive and jealous. 

 

The only people that Nori couldn’t ask were Bilbo and Bofur, the subjects of the gossip, because that would tip them off that he was onto them. His brothers had been suspicious when Nori had started poking around though Dori had accepted the explanation that he had heard of a potential threat to the Crown Prince. Ori, however, had been less convinced and Nori had wondered where his innocent young brother had gone-but he knew, They all did. The Quest had changed them to a dwarf, gaining them all recognition and respect but earning it with hardship, danger, imprisonment, war and madness. Ori had seen battle, been injured, thought he had lost a brother and the King and his nephews. It was enough to make the most innocent harden his heart-but Ori had remained good-hearted and decent, optimistic but realistic. And he was smart and dedicated to his King.

 

“If you suspect something, you need to talk to Bilbo,” he advised his brother. “You know that he hates being left out and really feels upset when we refer to something strictly a secret of our people. There’s sure to be something he can offer to help…”

 

Nori nodded absently. Ori was smart but so was Bilbo and the pair were close. Yet Ori was engaged to the King’s best friend, General and bodyguard, Dwalin so no one in their right mind would believe that a dwarf who was engaged to his One would possibly betray him with another being-it just didn’t happen. The problem was that Bilbo was a Hobbit and no one knew much about Hobbits-except the lack of shoes and beards and the plentiful meals. Nothing was known about their courting habits but it was certain that they could not have Ones, for that was a gift from Mahal to his Khuzd children. And that made the stories of Bilbo’s unfaithfulness more believable. Especially as Bofur did not seem to have a stable partner either.

 

It was inevitable that the rumours should finally make their ways to the ears of the King-Nori knew Erebor too well to hope for the gossip to die down naturally when it was becoming clearer that someone was stirring things. It was obvious that someone-and Nori had a short-list of possible candidates for that distinction-had been watching Bilbo, probably for some considerable time in the hope that the outsider non-dwarf would slip up badly enough to justify petitioning the King to remove him from his authority and roles that he wielded as the Prince Consort and stand-in for the King when Thorin was absent. How the observer must have thanked Mahal when he found something that looked so appallingly incriminating that could not only remove Bilbo from power but also possibly from his much-disliked marriage to the King. There had been immense resistance  from traditional dwarves and the Council of Lords to their King-who wouldn’t have earned a second look when he was the hard-working and noble ruler of Ered Luin-was now much sought by the Lords and noble and rich families as a prize to be captured by sons and daughters…once the inconvenient Hobbit was out of the way.

 

Nori had heard from one of his informants in Lord Sulgan’s household that Thorin was going to be ambushed with the news and he ran full pelt to the Council meeting…to find himself barred from entry. Rather than argue the toss and use his authority as the Spymaster-which he hated to use-he left and used the tunnel, wasting a precious five minutes. But the Council meeting was calm when he sneaked in the back, staying behind a column and catching his breath. Bilbo wasn’t in the Council today, because he was working in the Library on a special project-but Dwalin and Balin were, as were the Princes. Kili looked bored almost to death, for Council was dry and dull, with the Lords arguing minutiae for the sake of arguing and in the hope they could claw a tiny advantage over a rival. There was much shouting, more insulting and very little actually decided. Fili paid more attention, because he was Thorin’s Heir and this would be his duty, some time many decades in the future. Thorin himself was scowling, his face glowering at the Lords as they sniped at each other over allocation of training facilities for their personal guards.

 

“ENOUGH!” Thorin bellowed, slamming his fist down on the stone council table. There was a reduction in the noise level, though the Lords didn’t shut up entirely. “The schedule laid out by Dwalin is entirely fair and this debate is over!” He took a breath and looked over at Balin, his Steward and Vizier. “Balin-what is next on the agenda?”

 

The old dwarf lifted his magnifying glass and peered at the crabbed writing on his sheet. He was perfectly capable of reading his own runes and the list was perfectly legibly but he played up to his appearance of the age with aplomb. With his tufty hair white and long, perfectly groomed white beard, he had the appearance of a benevolent Uncle and if his opponents underestimated him, they did so at their own peril. Balin son of Fundin was always polite and amiable, loyal to Thorin and the House of Durin beyond any question and the most skilled and ruthless politician and diplomat in Erebor. But even he was no omniscient.

 

“Lord Sulgan wants to raise a complaint about the Prince Consort,” he read in a bored voice. Thorin’s scowl intensified as he sat back in the Throne. Every few weeks the Lords tried this and the King had taken to treating the occurrences with the contempt they were usually worth. Most of the time, Bilbo was present to fight his own corner, his back covered by his husband and his friends. Wearily, Thorin waved a hand for him to proceed.

 

Sulgan was on older dwarf but not less consumed by ambition for it. His family had not suffered as badly as most after the fall of Erebor, for he and his kin had moved to the Iron Hills and continued their comfortable lifestyle. None of them had contributed to the reclamation of Erebor but they had returned once things were up and running and had demanded the restoration of their rights and privileges. And because of some archaic laws, Thorin had been forced to reinstate the Lords to his Council-though he appointed people he trusted to the major offices. And that meant the Company. But he was still obliged to listen to them. Sulgan was squat and arrogant, his rounded middle straining a gold belt and his rich fur-trimmed velvet robes and his heavily braided and beaded grey-streaked reddish beard wobbled as he spoke.

 

“I wish to know what his Majesty is doing about the fact that the Prince Consort is conducting an illicit affair with the miner Bofur?” Sulgan asked loudly. 

 

There was a silence sufficient to hear a pin drop. Nori rolled his eyes.

 

“Now he decides to be succinct,” he groaned.

 

“On what basis do you make this allegation?” Thorin said in a freezing voice. He had slowly straightened up and his scowl would make the bravest dwarf shrink in fear. Sulgan didn’t even flinch.

 

“My men have been watching the Halfling for some time,” he said without shame. “He has no place among us.”

 

Dwalin grimaced. He recalled the King saying the very same words, up in the Misty Mountains, shortly before the Hobbit had saved his life. Thorin’s jaw tightened and the King straightened up slightly.

 

“You are wrong,” Thorin said coldly. “He earned his place in Erebor when he riddled with a dragon and saved the Company from folly. He has proven himself again and again.”

 

“And yet now, he betrays you-just as he betrayed you by stealing the Arkenstone,” Sulgan said bluntly. There was silence as the King rose to his feet. Fili and Kili shared a look.

 

“My husband would not betray me,” Thorin said. 

 

“I’m sorry-but we have witnessed several occasions where he and the miner spent considerable time alone in the miner’s house-or in his apartments when your Majesty was otherwise engaged. They had illicit meetings. They emerged dishevelled. It has been going on for a year.”

 

Thorin gave a small broken sound.

 

“And who knows of this?” he asked tonelessly.

 

“Majesty, I believe the entire mountain knows,” the Lord told him smugly.

 

“But Bilbo would never…” Kili began.

 

“Then there will be a simple explanation,” Thorin said icily.

 

“Uncle-you know this is not possible,” Fili told him but Thorin looked up.

 

“Isn’t it?” he asked, the pain edging his voice obvious. 

 

“Of course not.” Thorin's head snapped up as he heard Dwalin’s voice. He shook his head.

 

“Nori-did you know anything of this?” The King’s tone was stern and the Spymaster emerged, his face carefully neutral.

 

“Rumours are rife through the mountain, many quite detailed,” he said quietly. “Everyone knows someone who has seen something. Though whether they have seen anything that could possibly be of any consequence is debatable. And no one has seen anything actually happening.”

 

“At this stage, it doesn’t really matter,” Thorin said quietly. His fists had curled so tightly that his knuckles were white and his breathing was swift and harsh: he looked as if he was only just hanging onto his temper. “How long have they been laughing at me behind my back?”

 

“Majesty, I don’t…” Nori said, bowing.

 

“HOW LONG?” Thorin roared, turned to the Spymaster with fury in his eyes. It was the pent-up rage at being denigrated, humiliated and scorned for most of his life as a homeless Heir to Erebor, a King without a Kingdom, a Prince of nothing that was boiling up now. Here in Erebor, he was home. He was King. He should be safe from scorn, protected from humiliation and he at least expected his loyal friends and subjects to tell him if there was something happening that could threaten his pride and his honour. Yet the Lords had known and just watched, his Spymaster had uncovered the details and his people had been laughing at him.

 

“Some months I believe,” Nori admitted. “There are always rumours about you and Bilbo, ever since Erebor was reclaimed. Many scurrilous and they have claimed the Hobbit has betrayed you with about every dwarf in Erebor since you were married. Bofur is a favourite and there has never been a scrap of evidence that such a liaison has occurred. He’s a sociable dwarf and was friendly with Bilbo ever since the start of the Quest-even before the King’s eyes fell on the Hobbit. Bilbo sees him only as a friend-not one of the Company has noted anything different.”

 

“Somebody has,” Sulgan put in, his tone hard. “What do you expect? The Halfling is not a dwarf: he cannot have a One and cannot understand our ways, Majesty. Maybe it is the way of Halflings to love more than one-or have casual flings with others. You cannot trust him.”

 

“He is a Hobbit, not a Halfling,” Fili stated angrily. “He is half of nothing.”

 

“No-he is the whole of this issue,” Sulgan sneered. “Making a fool of your Majesty, dishonouring the entire Line of Durin by his promiscuity…by his betrayal.”

 

“Loyalty, Honour, a willing heart…I can ask no more…and from him, no less…” Thorin murmured and then looked up. “Fetch my Consort!” Two guards ran off as Balin walked forward, seeing Sulgan sit-in smugly down and enjoying the chaos he had caused. He as everyone knew that trust was a fragile thing, easily broken and very difficult to rebuild. 

 

“Thorin-don’t let your pride overcome your sense,” the old dwarf murmured. “The wizard said your pride would be your downfall. You let it overcome your sense in Mirkwood: don’t let it allow you to make another mistake.”

 

“My friend, in this I cannot only act as my heart tells me…but as a King must,” Thorin said coldly. “The King is the symbol of Erebor. And as such, he cannot be made a fool of or betrayed. And being betrayed by my spouse could well be deemed treason.”

 

“And you know Bilbo would never betray you,” Kili said urgently as even Dwalin winced.

 

“He already did,” Thorin pointed out.

 

“And you both moved past that,” the younger Prince said urgently, snatching a glance at his brother. Thorin’s words made him worry. “You forgave him. He forgave you for trying to kill him. You got married. He is your One!”

 

“Enough!” Thorin slumped back into his chair. “Enough,” he added more quietly, his brow furrowed and eyes dark with pain. “No more words until Bilbo arrives.”

 

Balin looked worriedly at his brother as Dwalin settled by the King, his arms folded across his chest and eyes fixed on the door. Thorin was glaring at the door with a ferocity was that frightening. Certainly, none of the Lords dared say another word while Balin shared a look with Nori, accusing him of not sharing the intelligence. And matters didn’t get any better when the guards raced back saying that Bilbo could not be found in the Library. Immediately, Thorin’s face darkened with anger and he demanded the guard be sent out for his husband. Dwalin winced and gave the order, not disobeying his King, though he wished his friend would stop and think. But Thorin was being the King now and would not listen to a word of advice: his wounded pride and aching heart would allow no counsel to deter him from his course. Until finally, Bilbo was escorted in.

 

The Hobbit was dressed casually, his shirt rumpled and waistcoat unfastened. His curls were messed and he was out of breath as he stared at his husband and then at the Council.

 

“Was I supposed to be here?” he asked lightly. “I apologise-I really thought I had given my apologies because I had this project and…”

 

“Why were you not in the Library?” Thorin demanded, his eyes glaring at the Hobbit. Bilbo straightened up and he frowned at the King’s tone. He did not appreciate being treated like a prisoner or a suspect and he did not like his husband’s tone. On their marriage, Thorin had sworn to treat him with respect in public, though they may disagree in private and Bilbo had made the same vow.

 

“Because I was hungry and went to find a snack,” Bilbo told him without any title or honorific. His tone was clipped and angry. “Is that a crime yet?” Thorin leaned forward.

 

“You have been spending time with Bofur,” Thorin said bitterly. Bilbo blinked then looked towards the Princes and then Balin.

 

“Is he serious?” he asked.

 

“ANSWER THE QUESTION!” Thorin bellowed. Bilbo started before he glared at his husband.

 

“You obviously knew the answer before you asked the question, your Majesty, so why do you need my word to confirm it?" he asked sarcastically.

 

“Why?” Thorin snapped. Fili was looking pained and Kili distraught. Even Dwalin was looking carefully neutral. Balin’s eyes were shining with grief.

 

“Bofur is one of my closest friends-and I imagined you were,” Bilbo said evenly, squaring his shoulders and inspecting the dwarf King. Thorin had cut an impressive figure, even from the moment he entered Bag End and insulted his host. Now settled in Erebor, he looked magnificent, his grey-streaked raven hair still simply braided and framing his handsome face. A faded white scan cut down the right of his forehead and crossed his eye, though his gaze had remained a clear grey-blue. His beard was now long and a single braid hung down. Magnificent robes of deep Durin blue and black sheathed his imposing form and he carried himself with absolute regality and assurance. Bilbo looked even more unimpressive in comparison.

 

“And what were you doing with him?” Thorin demanded. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Excuse me?” he said, his tone suddenly sharp. “Have you heard yourself?”

 

“Did you hear me?” Thorin demanded, his eyes narrowing. “I asked you a question, Halfling!”

 

“And I told you years ago that I am half of nothing,” Bilbo snapped. “You learned to at least call me by my name-and by the correct name of my people. What has changed?” 

 

“I learned of what people have been saying,” Thorin snapped. 

 

“People have been saying things about me from the moment Erebor was reclaimed,” Bilbo told him. “I suspect you do not know a tenth of the scurrilous lies and rumours I have had to endure since remaining here and especially since we married. I never bothered you no matter how hurtful the words. What has changed now?”

 

“I want to know what you and Bofur have been doing?” Thorin demanded. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Ah,” he said, his tone ambiguous. “So finally a rumour that may not be flattering to the great King  surfaces while all the other ones undermining me have been allowed to circulate so long they become the truth. Suddenly it’s a national emergency when a rumour affects Thorin.”

 

“What have you and Bofur been doing?” Thorin repeated through gritted teeth. The Hobbit took a deep breath, his shoulders squared.

 

“Do you trust me, Thorin?” he asked quietly.

 

“I want an answer.”

 

“So do I-and I think my question is more pressing and more important,” Bilbo told him. “So maybe you should answer me, your Highness.” The title was sarcastic and Thorin stiffened.

 

“Many people have seen you spending time with a miner, a commoner who you share a close friendship with, emerging looking dishevelled and happy,” Thorin said in a cold, fierce voice.

 

“You are jealous,”Bilbo said incredulously. “Thorin-do you trust me?”

 

“You are my husband and you should know that the vows you swore…”

 

“So the truth is that you don’t trust me,” Bilbo announced quietly. “You believe rumours and not the word of your husband.”

 

“You are not a dwarf!” Thorin yelled. “You do not understand how we think and feel. You do not understand how we love.”

 

“Of course not,” Bilbo said, his tone flat. “I am, after all, a Hobbit. Not a dwarf, even though I have lived with you, saved your lives, fought orcs and wars and faced death and a dragon for you. But apparently that doesn’t count. The fact we fell in love didn’t count. The fact I would never betray you…”

 

“YOU ALREADY HAVE!” Thorin’s face was filled with fury and Bilbo started then stared at him.

 

“So you lied,” he said flatly. “You said you forgave me, that you understood why I took the Arkenstone to Bard and Thranduil. Because I wanted to stop a war and save the lives of the dwarves I loved. But now it comes out that you never forgave me and you have been stewing on it all these years. You don’t trust me. It was all a lie.”

 

“Just tell me what you were doing and I will understand,” Thorin said urgently, his voice deep with pain. “Please…”

 

“No,” Bilbo said sharply. “No-you have no right to plead with me to reveal what I was doing when you have betrayed everything that I thought we stood for. You listen to gossip and put the worst possible slant on what you imagine you heard.”

 

“Bilbo…” The King’s voice cracked and the Hobbit drew himself up now in indignant rage. 

 

“And would you believe what I said or would you only accept some salacious tale of debauchery and adultery, Thorin? Because that is what you expect. Or is it want?”

 

The King stared at him in shock.

 

“You should not be using such a tone to me when your life is in peril here,” he said in surprise.

 

“Is it?” Bilbo asked him sharply. “You have already admitted that you do not trust me and have never forgiven me for the Arkenstone debacle. You have no proof that I have done anything because there is none. I know that. You should know that as well.”

 

“Then tell me what you were doing to spend so much time with him?” Thorin yelled. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“You’re jealous,” he said, then exhaled. He looked at the Princes, seeing both looking upset and Balin close to tears. Dwalin looked stoic which usually meant he was deeply unhappy. Thorin looked furious-but also hurt. And the venue this confrontation had occurred told Bilbo who had stirred up the rumours and made sure that the King was wounded and angry enough to circumvent his common sense and his love for Bilbo. But love without trust and without respect was not worth the name because it could never work.

 

“Please-just tell me,” Thorin said in a pained voice.

 

“No.” Bilbo lifted his chin. “If you do not trust me, Thorin Oakenshield, there is no point in continuing.” 

 

“So be it,” the King said and straightened up. “Accused of adultery and refusing to defend the accusation, my Consort Bilbo Baggins, is banished from Erebor. He may return when his innocence is proven.”

 

Bilbo walked forward, past the Council Table until he stood mere feet from the King. He quietly pulled his wedding ring off and placed it on the floor, then tugged the bead from the marriage braid in his hair and put it inside the circle of the ring. He stared at the dwarf King, reading anger on his face but desolation in his eyes.

 

“If there is no trust, after everything I did and showed to you, then there will never be enough reasons to stay and you will never accept my innocence,” he said. “And there will never be any reason to return to a King who has betrayed me far more than I could ever betray him. Goodbye, your Majesty.” He gave a small bow, then turned and walked from the room. Fili stared after him then at his Uncle.

 

“You can’t do this!” he exclaimed. Kili was at his side.

 

“You have to go after him!” he added.

 

“I cannot,” Thorin said. “He only had to speak and…”

 

“And what, Uncle?” Fili asked him flatly. “You believe him? Or don’t? What will you ask then? Witnesses? Confining him to his rooms? Or only going out with a chaperone? Maybe you should have thought of that when you sent him in to steal from Smaug.”

 

“The dragon didn’t try to date my husband,” Thorin muttered. 

 

“Uncle…please…if you let this happen, you will regret it for the rest of your life! He’s your One. You love him.” Kili’s eyes were shining with tears. Thorin nodded. 

 

“But I have to protect the authority of the King,” he said sternly.

 

“Against what?” Fili asked. “Gossip and innuendo. No one has seen anything.”

 

“Not true, young Prince,” Sulgan said condescendingly. “My man, Gowron, saw them…”

 

“Doing what?” Fili snapped. “Bring him here. I wish to examine him.”

 

“Alas, he is away on urgent business and…”

 

“And the other dwarves you sent to spy on Bilbo?” Kili asked shortly. “What about them?”

 

“Well…”

 

“Very convenient,” Fili said sarcastically. “A man who is mysteriously unavailable and others who saw nothing. On the day you suddenly decide to confront the King about this matter.”

 

“A day chosen as the only one over the the two months where the Prince Consort has been absent and unable to defend himself against your lies!” Kili’s eyes were glittering in anger.

 

“I resent the slander, young Prince…” Sulgan began but Kili took a single pace forward.

 

“No,” Kili told him bluntly. “The burden is on you to prove these foul accusations against the Prince Consort. And while your men seem to have seen nothing and the only one you claim was a witness to impropriety is mysteriously absent. So I call you a liar until you prove otherwise…my Lord.” The title was sneered, reminding the Lord that the dwarf before him may be younger but he was senior in terms of his title. Then he turned and walked from the room without a backwards glance at the King. Fili glared at Thorin then ran after his brother, his hand on the hilt of his sword. Thorin looked up at the Council.

 

“Satisfied?” he asked, sharply. Then he gestured. “GET OUT!”

 

As one, they rose and scurried towards the door, the smug expressions on their faces still obvious as they left until the door slammed shut behind them and only Balin, Dwalin and Nori remained. Thorin was resting his face in a hand, his features concealed by the curtain of his hair.

 

“Say what you need to,” he murmured in a weary voice.

 

“It was ill done,” Balin told him plainly. 

 

“I had no choice,” Thorin said, his voice grim.

 

“There is always a choice,” Balin told him honestly. “A choice to be a husband and a partner. A choice to be reasonable. A choice to hear your One without prejudice instead of confronting him in front of the Council like a condemned traitor. Instead you chose to be your father and grandfather, to put pride before decency and family. You chose to believe unfounded gossip and rumours instead of the word of your husband.”

 

“I cannot have the entire mountain laughing at me!” Thorin shouted.

 

“Well, you’ve just confirmed the rumours now so I’ll wager they’re laughing their arses off,” Dwalin noted gruffly. Thorin glared at him.

 

“All he had to do was speak to me!”

 

“After you had accused him in front of the Council, more or less telling him you believed them over your Consort and then demanded he proved his innocence. You should have made them prove their accusations!” Balin’s voice had risen.

 

“He was being stubborn,” Thorin growled.

 

“Nothing like a certain King I know,” Dwalin grumbled. “You know how stubborn Bilbo can be.”

 

“All you had to do was behave like a husband not an offended prideful King,” Balin told him. 

 

“There was no choice,” Thorin said bleakly. “Not for me. I am the King.”

 

“You’re a fool,” Balin condemned him.

 

“They’ve been watching Bilbo for years,” Nori revealed. “They claim to have known this for months. Yet why now unless, as Kili said, they had to wait until Bilbo was not here because he would have dismembered them verbally the moment they opened their mouths with this dung. All Sulgan’s men are in the mountain, by the way. But no one has seen anything different or suspects any impropriety.” 

 

“Can you find out what they know and who Sulgan is working with,” Balin asked as the Spymaster nodded. “They have been trying to ensure the King is available for years. It looks like they have got their wish.” But Thorin had risen slowly, walking hesitantly towards the small pieces of metal on the ground. Then he dropped to one knee and tenderly picked up the ring and bead.

 

“No,” he said hoarsely. “They have not. Bilbo is my One, no matter what passes between us. And I will never love or wed again. They have failed in their objective to free me to marry one of their offspring.” Then he rose and walked to the door, his hand closing tightly round the precious momentos. “Send for Bofur. I need to speak to him as well.” Balin looked at his brother as the King reached the door.

 

“Watch him. Closely,” he murmured. “This is a terrible mistake and I pray that he realises it before it is too late.” Dwalin grunted.

 

“It already is,” he said.