Actions

Work Header

The Price The Gods Decree

Summary:

Dwarves have Ones, their perfect partner gifted them by Mahal and they love only once. Hobbits also only love once, their partner being termed a Heart-Mate. But Dwarves and Hobbits are also secretive about their most personal matters and sometimes, not knowing how another race works can be a serious problem.

When rumours circulate that the Prince Consort of Erebor is spending an excessive amount of time with the Miner Bofur, the suggestions of an affair take on a life of their own. Reaching the ears of the King, a humiliated and jealous Thorin confronts his husband in Council and a misunderstanding morphs into something catastrophic. But neither partner realises the true price of what they have done...

Notes:

Another story? Well this was an idea that kept nagging at me about a catastrophe stemming from rumours, a misunderstanding and some serious stubbornness issues. Add in some panthy angst and this is the result. I have taken artistic license with Ones, Heart-Mates and all other sorts of soul-mate mythology because I can.

As always, the Hobbit was written by Professor J R R Tolkien. The rights to the films belong to New Line Cinema, Warner Brothers and MGM. I own nothing except an over-active imagination and a propensity for messing up our heroes' lives...

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: Rumours and Lies

Chapter Text

ONE: Rumours and Lies

 

There were rumours, of course. But then, there were always rumours in Erebor and though the vast majority of them were utter stuff and nonsense, a wise spy always kept his ear to the ground, so when Nori heard the same rumours being repeated and amplified-and, more importantly, modified as ‘new information’ became available, he started to feel alarmed.

 

Sitting in a corner in a rather run-down tavern close to the smelting district, packed to the rafters with dwarves who were determinedly relaxing-meaning drinking, singing and exchanging raucous tales-he found himself first hand hearing the rumours for himself.

 

“They’ve been seen again.”

 

“Who?”

 

“You know! The Prince and his fancy bit.”

 

“Oh. You still banging on about that rubbish?”

 

“It ain’t rubbish. My cousin’s friend Wynto who guards the ramparts saw him up there, staring south and waiting for him to return.”

 

“There are a hundred reasons why he could be on the ramparts! That ain’t proof of nothing.”

 

“Maybe not. But considering what happened here, why would he come up here of not for a very good reason.” There was a pause. “And his fancy bit arrived that afternoon. He was first to greet him.”

 

“Bet his husband wasn’t too pleased.”

 

“You know the Company have an odd way of behaving. In public they all act proper but behind closed doors…well, who’s to know what they got up to on that Quest. Long road, lonely nights, I’d not be surprised if…”

 

“Shhh! Walls have ears! And speaking like that of the Consort is officially treason!”

 

“And cuckolding the King ain’t?”

 

Nori felt his blood run cold, because that was the first time he had heard the allegations spoken aloud.

 

“No one has seen nothing!” the second speaker insisted. “Everyone knows the Prince and that miner are good friends. Always have been. Mahal, the miner is friends with almost everyone anyway…”

 

“I spoke to a meat delivery dwarf-Gurin, his name was-and he said that he saw them huddled together in Master Gwillim’s Bakery.”

 

“Halflings and their stomachs. And you are still making mountains out of pebbles.”

 

“When Master Dori came, looking for them, they leapt apart as if scalded!”

 

“Could have been talking about something personal…”

 

“Now you’re getting the idea.” The first speaker was sounding smug. His friends sighed and Nori sipped his ale because his throat was dry. 

 

“Get yer mind out o’ the gutter! There are a hundred different things that could have caused that.”

 

“Here’s the clincher. My cousin’s sister’s neighbour saw the pair of them embracing in the Prince’s rooms!”

 

“They’re friends.”

 

“You keep telling yourself that. Everyone knows by now. I’m shocked the King hasn’t heard.”

 

“Maybe he’s too smart to listen to scurrilous gossip.”

 

“Or maybe he doesn’t want to believe that his One would throw it all away for some bit on the side…”

 

“Well, he’s a Halfling. They don’t understand the ways of our people.”

 

Nori had heard enough and drained his ale, then rose, his face concealed by his hood. He pushed his way through the jovial throng, ducking under a flying mug of ale and breaking out into the half-lit alley behind the little tavern. He found his heart was pounding and he felt completely unnerved. And he knew it was stupid because he shouldn’t listen to the talk of dwarves in their cups but it was clear that it had gone beyond just a rumour. Half the mountain were convinced that the rumour was true and that meant that it had gone beyond being a nuisance to an existential threat to the happiness and peace of mind of two of his dearest friends. He straightened his shoulders. He had work to do.

 

Over the next few days, he exhausted himself seeking witnesses, cataloguing rumours and talking to the rest of the Company. And far from being reassured, what he found made him feel worse. For in the wrong hands and before biassed eyes, the tale he uncovered would look incriminating. And of course, there could be an entirely innocent explanation…but that would probably not be enough. Because ultimately, this was about the marriage of the King of Erebor, Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thrain and the Prince Consort, Bilbo Baggins, son of Bungo. And Thorin was a dwarf through and through-which meant possessive and jealous. 

 

The only people that Nori couldn’t ask were Bilbo and Bofur, the subjects of the gossip, because that would tip them off that he was onto them. His brothers had been suspicious when Nori had started poking around though Dori had accepted the explanation that he had heard of a potential threat to the Crown Prince. Ori, however, had been less convinced and Nori had wondered where his innocent young brother had gone-but he knew, They all did. The Quest had changed them to a dwarf, gaining them all recognition and respect but earning it with hardship, danger, imprisonment, war and madness. Ori had seen battle, been injured, thought he had lost a brother and the King and his nephews. It was enough to make the most innocent harden his heart-but Ori had remained good-hearted and decent, optimistic but realistic. And he was smart and dedicated to his King.

 

“If you suspect something, you need to talk to Bilbo,” he advised his brother. “You know that he hates being left out and really feels upset when we refer to something strictly a secret of our people. There’s sure to be something he can offer to help…”

 

Nori nodded absently. Ori was smart but so was Bilbo and the pair were close. Yet Ori was engaged to the King’s best friend, General and bodyguard, Dwalin so no one in their right mind would believe that a dwarf who was engaged to his One would possibly betray him with another being-it just didn’t happen. The problem was that Bilbo was a Hobbit and no one knew much about Hobbits-except the lack of shoes and beards and the plentiful meals. Nothing was known about their courting habits but it was certain that they could not have Ones, for that was a gift from Mahal to his Khuzd children. And that made the stories of Bilbo’s unfaithfulness more believable. Especially as Bofur did not seem to have a stable partner either.

 

It was inevitable that the rumours should finally make their ways to the ears of the King-Nori knew Erebor too well to hope for the gossip to die down naturally when it was becoming clearer that someone was stirring things. It was obvious that someone-and Nori had a short-list of possible candidates for that distinction-had been watching Bilbo, probably for some considerable time in the hope that the outsider non-dwarf would slip up badly enough to justify petitioning the King to remove him from his authority and roles that he wielded as the Prince Consort and stand-in for the King when Thorin was absent. How the observer must have thanked Mahal when he found something that looked so appallingly incriminating that could not only remove Bilbo from power but also possibly from his much-disliked marriage to the King. There had been immense resistance  from traditional dwarves and the Council of Lords to their King-who wouldn’t have earned a second look when he was the hard-working and noble ruler of Ered Luin-was now much sought by the Lords and noble and rich families as a prize to be captured by sons and daughters…once the inconvenient Hobbit was out of the way.

 

Nori had heard from one of his informants in Lord Sulgan’s household that Thorin was going to be ambushed with the news and he ran full pelt to the Council meeting…to find himself barred from entry. Rather than argue the toss and use his authority as the Spymaster-which he hated to use-he left and used the tunnel, wasting a precious five minutes. But the Council meeting was calm when he sneaked in the back, staying behind a column and catching his breath. Bilbo wasn’t in the Council today, because he was working in the Library on a special project-but Dwalin and Balin were, as were the Princes. Kili looked bored almost to death, for Council was dry and dull, with the Lords arguing minutiae for the sake of arguing and in the hope they could claw a tiny advantage over a rival. There was much shouting, more insulting and very little actually decided. Fili paid more attention, because he was Thorin’s Heir and this would be his duty, some time many decades in the future. Thorin himself was scowling, his face glowering at the Lords as they sniped at each other over allocation of training facilities for their personal guards.

 

“ENOUGH!” Thorin bellowed, slamming his fist down on the stone council table. There was a reduction in the noise level, though the Lords didn’t shut up entirely. “The schedule laid out by Dwalin is entirely fair and this debate is over!” He took a breath and looked over at Balin, his Steward and Vizier. “Balin-what is next on the agenda?”

 

The old dwarf lifted his magnifying glass and peered at the crabbed writing on his sheet. He was perfectly capable of reading his own runes and the list was perfectly legibly but he played up to his appearance of the age with aplomb. With his tufty hair white and long, perfectly groomed white beard, he had the appearance of a benevolent Uncle and if his opponents underestimated him, they did so at their own peril. Balin son of Fundin was always polite and amiable, loyal to Thorin and the House of Durin beyond any question and the most skilled and ruthless politician and diplomat in Erebor. But even he was no omniscient.

 

“Lord Sulgan wants to raise a complaint about the Prince Consort,” he read in a bored voice. Thorin’s scowl intensified as he sat back in the Throne. Every few weeks the Lords tried this and the King had taken to treating the occurrences with the contempt they were usually worth. Most of the time, Bilbo was present to fight his own corner, his back covered by his husband and his friends. Wearily, Thorin waved a hand for him to proceed.

 

Sulgan was on older dwarf but not less consumed by ambition for it. His family had not suffered as badly as most after the fall of Erebor, for he and his kin had moved to the Iron Hills and continued their comfortable lifestyle. None of them had contributed to the reclamation of Erebor but they had returned once things were up and running and had demanded the restoration of their rights and privileges. And because of some archaic laws, Thorin had been forced to reinstate the Lords to his Council-though he appointed people he trusted to the major offices. And that meant the Company. But he was still obliged to listen to them. Sulgan was squat and arrogant, his rounded middle straining a gold belt and his rich fur-trimmed velvet robes and his heavily braided and beaded grey-streaked reddish beard wobbled as he spoke.

 

“I wish to know what his Majesty is doing about the fact that the Prince Consort is conducting an illicit affair with the miner Bofur?” Sulgan asked loudly. 

 

There was a silence sufficient to hear a pin drop. Nori rolled his eyes.

 

“Now he decides to be succinct,” he groaned.

 

“On what basis do you make this allegation?” Thorin said in a freezing voice. He had slowly straightened up and his scowl would make the bravest dwarf shrink in fear. Sulgan didn’t even flinch.

 

“My men have been watching the Halfling for some time,” he said without shame. “He has no place among us.”

 

Dwalin grimaced. He recalled the King saying the very same words, up in the Misty Mountains, shortly before the Hobbit had saved his life. Thorin’s jaw tightened and the King straightened up slightly.

 

“You are wrong,” Thorin said coldly. “He earned his place in Erebor when he riddled with a dragon and saved the Company from folly. He has proven himself again and again.”

 

“And yet now, he betrays you-just as he betrayed you by stealing the Arkenstone,” Sulgan said bluntly. There was silence as the King rose to his feet. Fili and Kili shared a look.

 

“My husband would not betray me,” Thorin said. 

 

“I’m sorry-but we have witnessed several occasions where he and the miner spent considerable time alone in the miner’s house-or in his apartments when your Majesty was otherwise engaged. They had illicit meetings. They emerged dishevelled. It has been going on for a year.”

 

Thorin gave a small broken sound.

 

“And who knows of this?” he asked tonelessly.

 

“Majesty, I believe the entire mountain knows,” the Lord told him smugly.

 

“But Bilbo would never…” Kili began.

 

“Then there will be a simple explanation,” Thorin said icily.

 

“Uncle-you know this is not possible,” Fili told him but Thorin looked up.

 

“Isn’t it?” he asked, the pain edging his voice obvious. 

 

“Of course not.” Thorin's head snapped up as he heard Dwalin’s voice. He shook his head.

 

“Nori-did you know anything of this?” The King’s tone was stern and the Spymaster emerged, his face carefully neutral.

 

“Rumours are rife through the mountain, many quite detailed,” he said quietly. “Everyone knows someone who has seen something. Though whether they have seen anything that could possibly be of any consequence is debatable. And no one has seen anything actually happening.”

 

“At this stage, it doesn’t really matter,” Thorin said quietly. His fists had curled so tightly that his knuckles were white and his breathing was swift and harsh: he looked as if he was only just hanging onto his temper. “How long have they been laughing at me behind my back?”

 

“Majesty, I don’t…” Nori said, bowing.

 

“HOW LONG?” Thorin roared, turned to the Spymaster with fury in his eyes. It was the pent-up rage at being denigrated, humiliated and scorned for most of his life as a homeless Heir to Erebor, a King without a Kingdom, a Prince of nothing that was boiling up now. Here in Erebor, he was home. He was King. He should be safe from scorn, protected from humiliation and he at least expected his loyal friends and subjects to tell him if there was something happening that could threaten his pride and his honour. Yet the Lords had known and just watched, his Spymaster had uncovered the details and his people had been laughing at him.

 

“Some months I believe,” Nori admitted. “There are always rumours about you and Bilbo, ever since Erebor was reclaimed. Many scurrilous and they have claimed the Hobbit has betrayed you with about every dwarf in Erebor since you were married. Bofur is a favourite and there has never been a scrap of evidence that such a liaison has occurred. He’s a sociable dwarf and was friendly with Bilbo ever since the start of the Quest-even before the King’s eyes fell on the Hobbit. Bilbo sees him only as a friend-not one of the Company has noted anything different.”

 

“Somebody has,” Sulgan put in, his tone hard. “What do you expect? The Halfling is not a dwarf: he cannot have a One and cannot understand our ways, Majesty. Maybe it is the way of Halflings to love more than one-or have casual flings with others. You cannot trust him.”

 

“He is a Hobbit, not a Halfling,” Fili stated angrily. “He is half of nothing.”

 

“No-he is the whole of this issue,” Sulgan sneered. “Making a fool of your Majesty, dishonouring the entire Line of Durin by his promiscuity…by his betrayal.”

 

“Loyalty, Honour, a willing heart…I can ask no more…and from him, no less…” Thorin murmured and then looked up. “Fetch my Consort!” Two guards ran off as Balin walked forward, seeing Sulgan sit-in smugly down and enjoying the chaos he had caused. He as everyone knew that trust was a fragile thing, easily broken and very difficult to rebuild. 

 

“Thorin-don’t let your pride overcome your sense,” the old dwarf murmured. “The wizard said your pride would be your downfall. You let it overcome your sense in Mirkwood: don’t let it allow you to make another mistake.”

 

“My friend, in this I cannot only act as my heart tells me…but as a King must,” Thorin said coldly. “The King is the symbol of Erebor. And as such, he cannot be made a fool of or betrayed. And being betrayed by my spouse could well be deemed treason.”

 

“And you know Bilbo would never betray you,” Kili said urgently as even Dwalin winced.

 

“He already did,” Thorin pointed out.

 

“And you both moved past that,” the younger Prince said urgently, snatching a glance at his brother. Thorin’s words made him worry. “You forgave him. He forgave you for trying to kill him. You got married. He is your One!”

 

“Enough!” Thorin slumped back into his chair. “Enough,” he added more quietly, his brow furrowed and eyes dark with pain. “No more words until Bilbo arrives.”

 

Balin looked worriedly at his brother as Dwalin settled by the King, his arms folded across his chest and eyes fixed on the door. Thorin was glaring at the door with a ferocity was that frightening. Certainly, none of the Lords dared say another word while Balin shared a look with Nori, accusing him of not sharing the intelligence. And matters didn’t get any better when the guards raced back saying that Bilbo could not be found in the Library. Immediately, Thorin’s face darkened with anger and he demanded the guard be sent out for his husband. Dwalin winced and gave the order, not disobeying his King, though he wished his friend would stop and think. But Thorin was being the King now and would not listen to a word of advice: his wounded pride and aching heart would allow no counsel to deter him from his course. Until finally, Bilbo was escorted in.

 

The Hobbit was dressed casually, his shirt rumpled and waistcoat unfastened. His curls were messed and he was out of breath as he stared at his husband and then at the Council.

 

“Was I supposed to be here?” he asked lightly. “I apologise-I really thought I had given my apologies because I had this project and…”

 

“Why were you not in the Library?” Thorin demanded, his eyes glaring at the Hobbit. Bilbo straightened up and he frowned at the King’s tone. He did not appreciate being treated like a prisoner or a suspect and he did not like his husband’s tone. On their marriage, Thorin had sworn to treat him with respect in public, though they may disagree in private and Bilbo had made the same vow.

 

“Because I was hungry and went to find a snack,” Bilbo told him without any title or honorific. His tone was clipped and angry. “Is that a crime yet?” Thorin leaned forward.

 

“You have been spending time with Bofur,” Thorin said bitterly. Bilbo blinked then looked towards the Princes and then Balin.

 

“Is he serious?” he asked.

 

“ANSWER THE QUESTION!” Thorin bellowed. Bilbo started before he glared at his husband.

 

“You obviously knew the answer before you asked the question, your Majesty, so why do you need my word to confirm it?" he asked sarcastically.

 

“Why?” Thorin snapped. Fili was looking pained and Kili distraught. Even Dwalin was looking carefully neutral. Balin’s eyes were shining with grief.

 

“Bofur is one of my closest friends-and I imagined you were,” Bilbo said evenly, squaring his shoulders and inspecting the dwarf King. Thorin had cut an impressive figure, even from the moment he entered Bag End and insulted his host. Now settled in Erebor, he looked magnificent, his grey-streaked raven hair still simply braided and framing his handsome face. A faded white scan cut down the right of his forehead and crossed his eye, though his gaze had remained a clear grey-blue. His beard was now long and a single braid hung down. Magnificent robes of deep Durin blue and black sheathed his imposing form and he carried himself with absolute regality and assurance. Bilbo looked even more unimpressive in comparison.

 

“And what were you doing with him?” Thorin demanded. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Excuse me?” he said, his tone suddenly sharp. “Have you heard yourself?”

 

“Did you hear me?” Thorin demanded, his eyes narrowing. “I asked you a question, Halfling!”

 

“And I told you years ago that I am half of nothing,” Bilbo snapped. “You learned to at least call me by my name-and by the correct name of my people. What has changed?” 

 

“I learned of what people have been saying,” Thorin snapped. 

 

“People have been saying things about me from the moment Erebor was reclaimed,” Bilbo told him. “I suspect you do not know a tenth of the scurrilous lies and rumours I have had to endure since remaining here and especially since we married. I never bothered you no matter how hurtful the words. What has changed now?”

 

“I want to know what you and Bofur have been doing?” Thorin demanded. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Ah,” he said, his tone ambiguous. “So finally a rumour that may not be flattering to the great King  surfaces while all the other ones undermining me have been allowed to circulate so long they become the truth. Suddenly it’s a national emergency when a rumour affects Thorin.”

 

“What have you and Bofur been doing?” Thorin repeated through gritted teeth. The Hobbit took a deep breath, his shoulders squared.

 

“Do you trust me, Thorin?” he asked quietly.

 

“I want an answer.”

 

“So do I-and I think my question is more pressing and more important,” Bilbo told him. “So maybe you should answer me, your Highness.” The title was sarcastic and Thorin stiffened.

 

“Many people have seen you spending time with a miner, a commoner who you share a close friendship with, emerging looking dishevelled and happy,” Thorin said in a cold, fierce voice.

 

“You are jealous,”Bilbo said incredulously. “Thorin-do you trust me?”

 

“You are my husband and you should know that the vows you swore…”

 

“So the truth is that you don’t trust me,” Bilbo announced quietly. “You believe rumours and not the word of your husband.”

 

“You are not a dwarf!” Thorin yelled. “You do not understand how we think and feel. You do not understand how we love.”

 

“Of course not,” Bilbo said, his tone flat. “I am, after all, a Hobbit. Not a dwarf, even though I have lived with you, saved your lives, fought orcs and wars and faced death and a dragon for you. But apparently that doesn’t count. The fact we fell in love didn’t count. The fact I would never betray you…”

 

“YOU ALREADY HAVE!” Thorin’s face was filled with fury and Bilbo started then stared at him.

 

“So you lied,” he said flatly. “You said you forgave me, that you understood why I took the Arkenstone to Bard and Thranduil. Because I wanted to stop a war and save the lives of the dwarves I loved. But now it comes out that you never forgave me and you have been stewing on it all these years. You don’t trust me. It was all a lie.”

 

“Just tell me what you were doing and I will understand,” Thorin said urgently, his voice deep with pain. “Please…”

 

“No,” Bilbo said sharply. “No-you have no right to plead with me to reveal what I was doing when you have betrayed everything that I thought we stood for. You listen to gossip and put the worst possible slant on what you imagine you heard.”

 

“Bilbo…” The King’s voice cracked and the Hobbit drew himself up now in indignant rage. 

 

“And would you believe what I said or would you only accept some salacious tale of debauchery and adultery, Thorin? Because that is what you expect. Or is it want?”

 

The King stared at him in shock.

 

“You should not be using such a tone to me when your life is in peril here,” he said in surprise.

 

“Is it?” Bilbo asked him sharply. “You have already admitted that you do not trust me and have never forgiven me for the Arkenstone debacle. You have no proof that I have done anything because there is none. I know that. You should know that as well.”

 

“Then tell me what you were doing to spend so much time with him?” Thorin yelled. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“You’re jealous,” he said, then exhaled. He looked at the Princes, seeing both looking upset and Balin close to tears. Dwalin looked stoic which usually meant he was deeply unhappy. Thorin looked furious-but also hurt. And the venue this confrontation had occurred told Bilbo who had stirred up the rumours and made sure that the King was wounded and angry enough to circumvent his common sense and his love for Bilbo. But love without trust and without respect was not worth the name because it could never work.

 

“Please-just tell me,” Thorin said in a pained voice.

 

“No.” Bilbo lifted his chin. “If you do not trust me, Thorin Oakenshield, there is no point in continuing.” 

 

“So be it,” the King said and straightened up. “Accused of adultery and refusing to defend the accusation, my Consort Bilbo Baggins, is banished from Erebor. He may return when his innocence is proven.”

 

Bilbo walked forward, past the Council Table until he stood mere feet from the King. He quietly pulled his wedding ring off and placed it on the floor, then tugged the bead from the marriage braid in his hair and put it inside the circle of the ring. He stared at the dwarf King, reading anger on his face but desolation in his eyes.

 

“If there is no trust, after everything I did and showed to you, then there will never be enough reasons to stay and you will never accept my innocence,” he said. “And there will never be any reason to return to a King who has betrayed me far more than I could ever betray him. Goodbye, your Majesty.” He gave a small bow, then turned and walked from the room. Fili stared after him then at his Uncle.

 

“You can’t do this!” he exclaimed. Kili was at his side.

 

“You have to go after him!” he added.

 

“I cannot,” Thorin said. “He only had to speak and…”

 

“And what, Uncle?” Fili asked him flatly. “You believe him? Or don’t? What will you ask then? Witnesses? Confining him to his rooms? Or only going out with a chaperone? Maybe you should have thought of that when you sent him in to steal from Smaug.”

 

“The dragon didn’t try to date my husband,” Thorin muttered. 

 

“Uncle…please…if you let this happen, you will regret it for the rest of your life! He’s your One. You love him.” Kili’s eyes were shining with tears. Thorin nodded. 

 

“But I have to protect the authority of the King,” he said sternly.

 

“Against what?” Fili asked. “Gossip and innuendo. No one has seen anything.”

 

“Not true, young Prince,” Sulgan said condescendingly. “My man, Gowron, saw them…”

 

“Doing what?” Fili snapped. “Bring him here. I wish to examine him.”

 

“Alas, he is away on urgent business and…”

 

“And the other dwarves you sent to spy on Bilbo?” Kili asked shortly. “What about them?”

 

“Well…”

 

“Very convenient,” Fili said sarcastically. “A man who is mysteriously unavailable and others who saw nothing. On the day you suddenly decide to confront the King about this matter.”

 

“A day chosen as the only one over the the two months where the Prince Consort has been absent and unable to defend himself against your lies!” Kili’s eyes were glittering in anger.

 

“I resent the slander, young Prince…” Sulgan began but Kili took a single pace forward.

 

“No,” Kili told him bluntly. “The burden is on you to prove these foul accusations against the Prince Consort. And while your men seem to have seen nothing and the only one you claim was a witness to impropriety is mysteriously absent. So I call you a liar until you prove otherwise…my Lord.” The title was sneered, reminding the Lord that the dwarf before him may be younger but he was senior in terms of his title. Then he turned and walked from the room without a backwards glance at the King. Fili glared at Thorin then ran after his brother, his hand on the hilt of his sword. Thorin looked up at the Council.

 

“Satisfied?” he asked, sharply. Then he gestured. “GET OUT!”

 

As one, they rose and scurried towards the door, the smug expressions on their faces still obvious as they left until the door slammed shut behind them and only Balin, Dwalin and Nori remained. Thorin was resting his face in a hand, his features concealed by the curtain of his hair.

 

“Say what you need to,” he murmured in a weary voice.

 

“It was ill done,” Balin told him plainly. 

 

“I had no choice,” Thorin said, his voice grim.

 

“There is always a choice,” Balin told him honestly. “A choice to be a husband and a partner. A choice to be reasonable. A choice to hear your One without prejudice instead of confronting him in front of the Council like a condemned traitor. Instead you chose to be your father and grandfather, to put pride before decency and family. You chose to believe unfounded gossip and rumours instead of the word of your husband.”

 

“I cannot have the entire mountain laughing at me!” Thorin shouted.

 

“Well, you’ve just confirmed the rumours now so I’ll wager they’re laughing their arses off,” Dwalin noted gruffly. Thorin glared at him.

 

“All he had to do was speak to me!”

 

“After you had accused him in front of the Council, more or less telling him you believed them over your Consort and then demanded he proved his innocence. You should have made them prove their accusations!” Balin’s voice had risen.

 

“He was being stubborn,” Thorin growled.

 

“Nothing like a certain King I know,” Dwalin grumbled. “You know how stubborn Bilbo can be.”

 

“All you had to do was behave like a husband not an offended prideful King,” Balin told him. 

 

“There was no choice,” Thorin said bleakly. “Not for me. I am the King.”

 

“You’re a fool,” Balin condemned him.

 

“They’ve been watching Bilbo for years,” Nori revealed. “They claim to have known this for months. Yet why now unless, as Kili said, they had to wait until Bilbo was not here because he would have dismembered them verbally the moment they opened their mouths with this dung. All Sulgan’s men are in the mountain, by the way. But no one has seen anything different or suspects any impropriety.” 

 

“Can you find out what they know and who Sulgan is working with,” Balin asked as the Spymaster nodded. “They have been trying to ensure the King is available for years. It looks like they have got their wish.” But Thorin had risen slowly, walking hesitantly towards the small pieces of metal on the ground. Then he dropped to one knee and tenderly picked up the ring and bead.

 

“No,” he said hoarsely. “They have not. Bilbo is my One, no matter what passes between us. And I will never love or wed again. They have failed in their objective to free me to marry one of their offspring.” Then he rose and walked to the door, his hand closing tightly round the precious momentos. “Send for Bofur. I need to speak to him as well.” Balin looked at his brother as the King reached the door.

 

“Watch him. Closely,” he murmured. “This is a terrible mistake and I pray that he realises it before it is too late.” Dwalin grunted.

 

“It already is,” he said. 

Chapter 2: The Departure

Notes:

A/N: I have been amazed by the feedback so far.Thank you. Of course things have to get a lot worse before there's a chance they can get better...

Chapter Text

TWO: The Departure

 

Kili found Bilbo in his room, packing. Bifur had made Bilbo a replica of the leather Shire-style pack he had lost in the Goblin caves when they fell, which was an excellent facsimile of the one he had left Bag End for the Quest with and Bilbo used it whenever he travelled on official Erebor business. But now, clothes were spread over the bed, being ruthlessly inspected then discarded. Quietly he took spare breeches, three shirts, a waistcoat, warm smallclothes, a whole pile of handkerchiefs and, wrapped in cotton, his wedding outfit. He took his Ring and strapped Sting to his waist. And tears slid down his face all the while.

 

He didn’t even look up as Kili burst into the room, panting.

 

“You can’t go, Uncle Bilbo,” he said and flung himself in a hug around the Hobbit. Quietly, Bilbo allowed himself to be wrapped in strong dwarvish arms, feeling warm and protected. He found he was shaking and Kili’s breathing was hitching as well.

 

“There’s nothing I can do,” the Hobbit murmured softly. “Your Uncle is King and he has banished me.”

 

“At least stay until we can round up the rest of the Company to say goodbye,” Kili begged him. Bilbo pulled back slightly and a small smile lifted his lips. 

 

“I’m not sure being banished includes a farewell tour of all your friends,” he commented dryly. “I rather think your Uncle wants me gone. At least he hasn’t sent the guard to remove me…yet. I’d like to maintain some shred of respectability.”

 

“But where will you go?" Kili asked him, watching him pick out his favourite cravat and pull his coat on. Bilbo stared at the shelves and reached out to grasp a red leather bound book and slipped two pieces of paper inside. He tucked it into the pack.

 

“Where I should have gone after the Battle,” Bilbo said quietly. “The Shire.”

 

“Home,” Kili realised. But Bilbo shook his head, his smile terribly sad.

 

“No,” he said quietly. “It hasn’t been my home since I ran out of Bag End and went off with a bunch of terribly ill-mannered dwarves and their rather rude and incredibly regal leader. But it’s all I have left.” He patted Kili’s shoulder. Then the door burst open and Bofur erupted into the room, accompanied by Fili, who had run to find him. The miner looked utterly unbalanced, his easy smile missing.

 

“Bilbo!” he gasped. “What happened?” Bilbo shrugged.

 

“My husband proved that he doesn’t trust me,” he said tartly, though his face was pale. “There are apparently rumours about us. People seem to think we are having some sort of illicit liaison. People have been spying on us.” He sighed. “On me.”

 

“But there’s nothing to see,” Bofur said in bewilderment. “Yer Thorin’s One and he’s yours, isn’t he?” Bilbo nodded.

 

“Though apparently because I’m not a dwarf, it doesn’t count,” Bilbo said sadly. “Nothing I have done to show Thorin that I love him and would do anything for him matters. Nothing I have shown him matters. Because it always goes back to the Arkenstone.”

 

“Did you tell him?” Bofur asked. Bilbo shook his head. 

 

“I am not justifying myself when my husband doesn’t trust me,” Bilbo said. “He should know I would never betray him. But if he doesn’t trust me, then I am not going to try to beg him to forgive me for something I haven’t done.” He looked up. “But I release you from your vow, Bofur. Your family is here. And that dwarrowdam you like…Milania?” A small smile lifted Bofur’s mobile lips.

 

“Aye, she’s a real peach,” he murmured and then sighed. “But if I speak to the King, won’t that exonerate you?” Bilbo gave a shake of the head.

 

“It’s not about something that never happened-it’s about trust,” Bilbo said. “Even if I was proven innocent-which I am-it’s too late because Thorin has shattered what we had.” Bofur frowned.

 

“Don’t you love him?” he asked.

 

“Terribly much actually,” Bilbo said and then nodded. “But without trust, it’s nothing. I will love Thorin to the day I die but he broke us.” Bofur caught his arm.

 

“Then how will you get home?” he asked. Bilbo sighed.

 

“I’ll catch the ferry from Esgaroth to Mirkwood,” he said. “I’ll see if King Thranduil would be willing to lend me an escort at least to Beorn’s. After there…well, we’ll see.” Bofur scowled and then glanced at the Princes.

 

“I’ll take yer home,” Bofur said. “And first I need words with that King.”

 

He stormed out, his normally amiable expression replaced with an unfamiliar one of anger. Fili stared after him.

 

“I’m sorry, Bilbo,” he sighed. “I just thought…” Then the Hobbit moved forward and hugged him.

 

“Thank you,” he whispered. 

 

-o0o-

 

Bofur stormed into the Throne Room and found Thorin alone, save for Dwalin standing guard at a discreet distance. It was a testament to how serious Bofur looked that Dwalin folded his arms and scowled at the miner. But he stepped back and let the miner storm forward to the shape sitting alone in the throne, under the empty hollow where the Arkenstone used to sit before it was buried deep under the mountain once more. Thorin looked up and his eyes flickered with anger.

 

“I sent for you,” he said listlessly.

 

“You needn’t have bothered,” the miner snapped. Thorin gave a grim smile.

 

“I see you have no respect for your King,” he said gruffly.

 

“Not really deserving of respect right now,” Bofur snapped. Thorin’s eyes narrowed and he sat more upright. “I followed you from Ered Luin on a Quest no sane dwarf would go on. When all yer fancy dwarf Lords and nobility wouldn’t touch yer with a barge pole. When they all laughed at you for your insanity and foolishness in dreaming of Erebor when you should be satisfied with Ered Luin. And somehow, we survived and Erebor was reclaimed. But we would have been dead or lost along the way many times over if not for Bilbo.” 

 

“It’s none of your business,” the King growled.

 

“If you’ve been listening to the rumours, apparently it is,” the miner taunted him. “You know you’ve got it all wrong.”

 

“Then what were you doing together?” Thorin demanded, rising to his feet. Bofur stared fearlessly into his eyes.

 

“I don’t need to justify what I do with my friends,” he said with dignity.

 

“TELL ME!” Thorin roared.

 

“Did you even give Bilbo the respect of speaking with him in private or did you haul him up like a thief and shout at him in front of the Council?” Bofur asked him. Thorin’s glare was answer enough and the miner shook his head. “You’re an idiot. He loves you. He would not do anything of that ilk.”

 

“Then tell me what he is doing!” Thorin yelled.

 

“I swore an oath and it will not break it,” Bofur said with a sneer. “Do you even recall your marriage vows? The Oath you took to your One?”

 

“Don’t speak to me of my husband…” Thorin snapped.

 

“Aye, well you don’t need to think or see him ever again,” Bofur told him bluntly. “Did you assign anyone to accompany him or did you just send a Hobbit alone into the wild?” He stared at the King with contempt. “I’ll see him home. I guess I’m banished from here anyway, right? So much for having a fourteenth share of the treasure and a home for life. You never gave Bilbo his share and you take mine back. Yer grandfather would be proud.”

 

Then he turned on his heel and stalked from the throne room, leaving the King staring after him. There was shouting but Bofur no longer cared. All he wanted was to get out of the mountain and try to work out what to do next.

 

-o0o-

 

Somehow, word got round and by the time Bilbo had persuaded Fili and Kili to let him go and had made his way down with them to the gates, there was an honour-guard. All of the Company were there, save Thorin and Dwalin-and that only because Balin had ordered his brother not to leave his King alone for a second. Ori was almost in tears, pressing a book into Bilbo’s hands and hugging him fiercely.

 

“Make sure it finishes,” Bilbo murmured in his ear, hugging the scribe back and accepting the scarf wound around his neck. Dori pressed a package of fine teas into his hands and Nori hugged the Hobbit as well, promising to find out who set this up and stop them. He also slid a slender throwing-knife into the Hobbit’s hand. Gloin hugged Bilbo and promised he would bring ‘wee Gimli’ to see him. Bilbo knew Gloin’s son-a typical tween and hoped that Gloin would wait a few decades before inflicting a sulky teenager on the Hobbit. Oin gave him a bag with his best ointments and herbs for the journey. Kili wrapped his own wolf-trimmed cloak around Bilbo while Fili gave his bedroll and fur to sleep on. Then Bofur arrived, his pack over his shoulder and a full pouch of dwarvish pipeweed at his hip. He grinned, resting his mattock on the ground.

 

“Well, you didn’t think I would leave you to travel alone?” he said with a wink. 

 

“But this is your home,” Bilbo protested. The miner shrugged.

 

“Even if I wasn’t thrown out, I was a miner and I can find work anywhere,” he said cheerfully. “Friends, however, are harder to come by. True friends, that is.” Then there was a commotion as a cart pulled up. Sitting on the seat were Bombur and Bifur, with Bombur’s wife and children seated in the back with barrels of food and packs. The Hobbit blinked.

 

“Oh no no no no…” Bilbo said in distress, waving his arms. “You can’t. Bombur-you are the Head Chef and your home is lovely and…”

 

“And you are my friend and Bofur is my brother,” Bombur said. He was usually a dwarf of few words but there was steel in his voice. “And I would not stay in a place that treats the pair of you so appallingly. We have money now so we can set up a comfortable home and business back in Ered Luin.” Then Bifur jumped down and walked forward, his pack over his shoulder. He offered a stream of Khuzdul that Bilbo couldn’t follow.

 

“He says something similar,” Bofur grinned.

 

“Only with more profanities, if I know your family,” Bilbo commented and then turned to Balin. He gulped. “I’m going to miss you awfully,” he admitted and hugged the old dwarf. “You’ve been so good to me. Please watch over Thorin. No matter that he is an idiot, he’s my idiot and I still love him. Take care of him.” Balin nodded, his face melancholy.

 

“Aye, laddie-that I will,” he said. Bilbo nodded and looked around.

 

“Tea is at four and you are all most welcome any time,” he said. “You don’t even need to knock!” There were a few watery smiles, the unspoken acknowledgement that it was unlikely that visit-with knock or without-would ever happen. Bilbo nodded and then turned and walked out through the gates. There was a pause and then Bofur and Bifur followed with Bombur driving his cart after them. The rest of the Company watched as the little party crossed the road and headed towards Dale, growing smaller and smaller until they were lost in the crowds on the road.

 

High up on the ramparts, Thorin watched as his husband and three of the Company left Erebor. The Quest had not broken them and nor had his Dragon Sickness, though he had certainly behaved worse. The business of their lives after the reclamation had not prevented them all spending time together-but one hour of Thorin’s stupidity had shattered those bonds and now the family Ur and his own beloved were gone. He said nothing but his eyes never moved from the smallest shape until he was finally swallowed by the workday throng on the road.

 

“You’re a fool,” Dwalin told him.

 

“That seems to be the general consensus,” the King murmured.

 

“All you have to do is go after him and apologise,” Dwalin told him.

 

“He wouldn’t accept it,” Thorin said bleakly.

 

“Well he certainly won’t if you don’t even try,” his friend snapped. Thorin leaned forward, his hands on the stone wall, his eyes still fixed where he had last seen the Hobbit. 

 

“But I didn’t trust him,” the King said. “I believed the rumours. I dishonoured him and myself. I allowed myself to be manipulated. And there is a small part of me that still needs to know what they were doing. I imagine…” He stopped and closed his eyes.

 

“You know that’s goat crap,” Dwalin told him bluntly. “He may be a Hobbit but he’s yer One and he is as devoted to you are you are to him.” But Thorin closed his eyes.

 

“I think I may be going mad,” he murmured. “I keep seeing that image, over and over.”

 

“No, but you’ll wish you were,” a familiar voice snapped and the King looked up as his sister stalked onto the ramparts. “And I thought I’d find you skulking up here. Coward!” It gave  Dwalin no small satisfaction to see his friend, Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thrain and King of Erebor, scramble backwards as his sister Dis advanced with an especially evil look on her face. “What have you done?”

 

“What was always going to happen,” Thorin said bleakly. “I managed to drive my Hobbit away. I am surprised he lasted this long when I never deserved him. He should have left after the Battle and gone back to his own kind. I tried to kill him. How could anyone forgive that?”

 

“HE DID!” Dis snarled and punched him. Taken by surprise, Thorin staggered back and almost lost his feet. Staring up at her incredulously, he breathed hard and looked into her angry face.

 

“He should not have-because what I did was unforgivable,” Thorin said, straightening up. “I knew then he was my One and yet my addled mind sought to kill him.” He grimaced. “I had not suspected him of anything because he was my One and when I felt the betrayal, it was so much worse.” He closed his eyes. “But when I think of him, I see golden stands in his hair and feel he is more precious than any gem…and then to hear from that…piece of shale that my husband actually has feet of clay…”

 

“His heart is golden,” Dis said slowly, her expression calculating. “The rest of him…is Bilbo. Kind, decent, loyal Bilbo.”

 

“I hear the whispering sometimes, that I need to protect him or he will be stolen from me,” Thorin said haltingly. “That he is the greatest treasure of Erebor and in that, my heart agrees. And I hate myself and tell my heart to let him go because he does not belong to me. I never attempt to stop him seeing anyone. I never restrict him from doing anything he wishes. He is his own being and that is why I love him. But Bofur…”

 

“He was the first to be friendly towards the Hobbit,” Dwalin confirmed.

 

“While I was cruel and dismissive,” the King said quietly. “I insulted him almost the moment I saw him, thinking him weak and useless. I ensured he felt awkward and unwelcome. I even told him he had no place among us-yet he saved my life not long after. I had misjudged him so badly and he proved me wrong over and over. And I knew what I was doing because I felt the Pull, felt in my heart he was the One and I did not want it. Until I realised that Mahal is far wiser than I and had paired me with One who was more than my match, stubborn and brave and smart. But Bofur was always there, amiable and friendly and Bilbo seemed to prefer his company and I…” His fists clenched.

 

“You are a dwarf, possessive and fiercely jealous,” Dis murmured staring at him.  A sick suspicion was growing in her stomach. “And worse than most because you suffered from Dragon Sickness.” 

 

“I never deserved him and when he forgave me after the Battle, I was waiting for him to see me as I truly was,” Thorin said. “But whenever I saw him with Bofur, I felt a curl of jealousy sometimes so strong I felt sick. But he had as much right to be here as any of the Company, he fought for Erebor when almost everyone here didn’t. And Bilbo likes him. It is his choice. And I have to respect that.”

 

“But you didn’t trust him,” Dis said in an exasperated voice. 

 

“When Sulgan said the words all I could feel was the need to possess Bilbo, to tear him from whoever he was with and never let him out of my sight again,” Thorin murmured. “And I saw what they implied…I keep seeing it. And now it is all I can see.”

 

“He loves you,” Dis told him, her blue eyes filled with pity. Thorin spun away, his hands pressed against his face. 

 

“I am a foolish old dwarf who is jealous of his friend and who believes the lies of a subversive Lord over the One I love,” he said. “He is better off without me.” There was a pause.

 

“Does he know?” Dis asked in a strange voice.

 

“Know what?”

 

“That you still suffer from Dragon Sickness?” Her voice was icy. The King shook his head.

 

“I am the only one who knows,” he said in a voice filled with self-loathing. 

 

“And now us.” Dwalin met the Princess’s eyes and read her concern. She shook her head.

 

“I never go to the Treasury, I wear no gold, I fight every second of the day but I know my greatest treasure is Bilbo, not the gold,” the King said quietly. “And I know I wronged him-but I know he deserves better than me.” Dis closed her eyes and sighed.

 

“Thorin, he is your One,” she repeated. “You have sent him away. It will be painful for you to be parted from him because you rejected the bond.” The King nodded once, still looking away.

 

“I know. I deserve it.”

 

“And Bilbo? Does he deserve it as well?”

 

“He is a Hobbit,” Thorin sighed. “I have to hope they do not react as dwarrow. He will be safe in the Shire.”

 

“What?” His sister stared at him. “You didn’t assign him guards to see him safely home? Did you deliberately try to kill him or are you just the most thoughtless, vindictive rock-headed dwarf on Arda?” He looked up and she punched him. This time he went down as Dwalin sighed.

 

“Dis…”

 

“Do not open your mouth!” she snapped. “You watched him make an ass of himself and you didn’t stop him! None of you did! And don’t tell me you didn’t want to punch him as well!”

 

“Of course I did!” the big warrior admitted without shame. “But he had one point in his favour. He is the King. Whoever spread the rumours undermined his authority and that of Bilbo. If he did nothing, they would be in real danger of usurping him. Now, he has acted decisively while Nori investigates. And then we can clear his name…”

 

“You don’t understand,” Dis growled. “You disbelieved him. You did not trust him. He trusted you enough to marry you, though you tried to kill him. But you still cannot forget he handed that cursed stone to the ElvenKing and Bard to try to stop a war. If my One had said anything similar, I’d have killed him myself!” Thorin rose.

 

“Enough,” he said softly. “I have forfeited all rights towards my One, as I expected from the moment he accepted me. I will continue to serve my people.” Dis stared at him.

 

“What about your heart?” she asked, her tone sharp. He looked up.

 

“Reclaiming Erebor cost me my Honour and my mind. It should have cost my life but for the wizard. I am the King. If it costs my heart to give the remainder of my life to my people, then it is the Will of Mahal. It is all I deserve for my crimes.”

 

“Mahal save me from idiotic brothers,” she growled. The she spun on her heel. “I can’t stay here with you. I may have to kill you for your stupidity. Bilbo never betrayed you and you gave your love away for a lie. Think on that, you rock-brained clothead!”

 

And she stormed off. But the King rose slowly to his feet.

 

“My sister imagines I don’t know any of that,” he said tonelessly. “In fact, I know what I have done. But I still feel the jealousy and until I know what they were doing, I will never know peace.” Then he gave a bitter smile. “And I sent away the only two people who could tell me. So you see, Dwalin, I have already constructed my own prison and my own punishment.”

Chapter 3: Outcasts and Fools

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

THREE: Outcasts and Fools

 

People stared when Bilbo finally reached the Shire, accompanied by four adult dwarves and three small dwarf pebbles. Steadily, he walked on, nodding to the staring Hobbits as the strange party walked by and slowly made their way through Hobbiton and up The Hill to Bag End. Bilbo had written to the Thain when he decided to remain in Erebor to ensure that Bag End was looked after for when he returned to visit his family. The Thain, his cousin Fortinbras, had written back explaining that Lobelia Sackville-Baggins had been trying to get Bilbo declared dead so that she could claim the Smial but his letter had just come in time. The planned auction of the Smial and its contents for the following week was cancelled and Hamfast Gamgee was appointed caretaker. It was said that Lobelia could be heard almost the whole way to Tuckborough when she found out her ambitions were thwarted. 

 

But Bilbo had hoped to return home with Thorin and the boys, showing them his home and introducing them to his relatives. A small part of him had wanted to show off his regal and handsome husband and had wanted to hear Thorin’s honest opinion of his fussy and small-minded relatives…but that would never happen now. Instead, Bilbo had returned home after three years with a stinking chest of gold that he had retrieved from the Troll Hoard, a host of memories and a broken heart. Yet Bag End was still there and as he walked up to the familiar green circular door, he felt some of the tightness in his chest ease. No matter that his heart had remained in the East, Bag End was where a Baggins belonged and though he ached to be in Erebor, this would have to do.

 

He pushed the door open and sniffed. The air smelled musty but the place was dusted-not up to Bilbo’s standards, of course, but enough so that he wouldn’t have to scrub the place from top to bottom. Sighing, he walked through the lobby and rested his pack in the main parlour, next to his armchair. He had toyed with the idea of bringing his most treasured things from the Shire to Erebor and had hoped to plan a trip to do just that-but now he was glad he hadn’t got round to it. Wearily, he turned to see Bofur hovering just inside the front door. The dwarf looked rather embarrassed.

 

“Come in,” the Hobbit said, his Hobbitish instincts as a host roused. “I’ll have to nip out for a bit of shopping but I’m sure I can…” The miner shook his head with an apologetic smile.

 

“I’m not staying,” he said honestly. “Bombur, Lilli and the pebbles need to get under stone as soon as possible and we can make good distance today by sundown. The sooner we get to Ered Luin, the sooner we can start to rebuild.”

 

Bilbo felt his heart drop and guilt curl around his stomach.

 

“I am so sorry,” he murmured again. “You should have told him. You shouldn’t have had to give up your home over this.” But the miner was philosophical. 

 

“What kind of friend would I be if I left you to carry the blame for the plan we both hatched?” he asked. “Or let you travel home halfway across the world on your own? I’ll be fine, Bilbo. And don’t think ye’ll see the last of me. I’m only a week away and I don’t forget my friends.” Then he hugged the Hobbit and turned with a jaunty wave, pacing out of Bag End and walking to hop up onto the cart with the other. Bilbo watched as the cart rocked its way down the Hill and swung round the corner to vanish from sight.

 

Bag End was quiet as Erebor never was, for there was always noise. Even in the night, the walls vibrated slightly with the hum from the forges and the creaks of the mountain as she moved. Dwarves only seemed to have one volume, which was shouting. Bag End was far too quiet and Bilbo wondered if this was what Thorin had felt like as the Dragon Sickness had overwhelmed him, the sensation of something being entirely wrong… And then he pulled himself up. He would never know, could never ask and would never see his husband again. Thinking about him only clawed at the gaping wound in his heart.

 

So he went to the bathroom, kicked the pipes until something happened, ran the water until it was clean and then ran himself a nice hot bath. He soaked off the dirt of the road and steadfastly refused to think about his friends, left behind. He was a Hobbit, practical and rounded and he would not fall apart because he had been exiled from his home and those he loved. He had survived the loss of his parents, the suspicions of his fellow Hobbits and the polite disinterest of his own family. He would survive the loss of his home, his friends and his Heart-Mate.

 

He sighed and closed his eyes, sinking under the surface to rinse his hair once more. Dwarves and their secrets! He had lived with them for more than three years and though they were polite, they were tight as a gnat’s chuff, so to speak. They kept their secrets even from one who had married into their race. But despite their secrecy, he had picked up a few things. Such as that dwarves loved only once in their lives-and they were utterly devoted to their mate, known as a One. Not all dwarves found their Ones and some did not acknowledge the bond, choosing to devote themselves to their craft. The bond with a One was akin to a Soul-Bond and no dwarf would ever betray their One. Ending a marriage was an absolute disgrace.

 

But dwarves, in their damnable secrecy, had never bothered to enquire about Hobbits-probably because they didn’t care. Though Thorin should have asked because he was married to Bilbo and surely, the manner of his husband’s devotion should have been of importance? But Thorin had never asked, just accepting Bilbo’s words of love and devotion. Yet Hobbits weren’t as different as  dwarves would imagine, for Hobbits loved only once as well, terming their chosen mate their ‘Heart Mate’. It was what had killed Belladonna when Bilbo’s father Bungo had passed. Her bond severed, she had chosen to fade and in a season, she had joined him in Yavanna’s Green Fields. Left alone, Bilbo had decided never to find love or at least never accept a Heart-Mate because he did not want to suffer the pain his Mother endured at the loss of his father. Yet all his carefully-planned self-preservation had gone out of the window when an entirely rude and far-too-handsome dwarf King had walked through his door and called him a grocer. And though he had managed to stave off the Longing-mainly because Thorin had been so unpleasant to the poor Hobbit-when he had seen Thorin about to die, he had surrendered. Saving Thorin’s life from Azog, earning that hug on the Carrock and allowing himself to dream had landed him…here. 

 

He surfaced and clambered out. He would not fade because he knew in his heart that he was worth more than the mistrust of a stupid jealous Dwarven King. He was worth respect, honesty and love-and Thorin had not delivered two out of three. And he was no longer certain about the other. If you loved someone, you didn’t accept the word of a dried-out evil dwarf Lord who had been trying to break up your marriage since you finished saying the vows. So Bilbo would survive and he would grieve as if he his husband had died…because imagining Thorin was dead was the only way to endure the loss. So he closed his heart and rejected the Bond and hated himself for it.

 

In the Market, clad in perfectly clean though slightly musty clothes, Bilb was aware of eyes on him. There was less suspicion about the gold he was using but he knew his accounts in the Bank of Michel Delving were full for his tenants had been paying their rents while he was away. He would need to catch up with property portfolio, visit his family and explain to the Thain what happened. So he bought essentials, ordered a delivery of more bulky goods to refill his pantry and made his way back home with the eyes of his neighbours on him. Turning back, he gave a little wave and then made his way up home.

 

It was time be a perfectly respectable Hobbit once more.

 

-o0o-

 

Life in Erebor was tense. That was the only word for it. Thorin’s temper-always prone to be prickly-had been impossible since the Prince Consort had been banished. Sulgan had been shaved and banished for insisting the King had to wed now that he was free of his marriage to the Halfling. Balin swore that most of the mountain had heard their King bellow that he was a Hobbit and Thorin was still married. That Thorin would never marry another and that suggesting anything else was treason. Since then three other Council members had been banished and everyone was walking on eggshells. No one mentioned Bilbo and his friends-and the whole Company, when they could-avoided their King. 

 

Thorin looked terrible, for he was barely sleeping. He had lost weight, for his appetite was non-existent and he had to be reminded to eat. When he did sleep, his dreams were fractured, the image of Bilbo accusing him with his eyes as he walked into the wilds haunting him. And along with that, ever-worsening images of Bilbo meeting a horrific end excoriated him with guilt so that he awoke crying for forgiveness. But he couldn’t salvage the situation because he had done it to himself. In the end, Balin had written to the Thain of the Shire, who had confirmed that Bilbo had returned to the Shire alive, though he was largely ostracised and viewed with suspicion by his neighbours. It was another guilt that weighed down the King.

 

Fili and Kili found excuses not to spend time with their Uncle and only Balin and Dwalin spend any period of time with the King. It was obvious that Balin was trying to support the King, though he found it hard to look Thorin in the eye when he recalled that Bilbo should be sitting at the King’s side while Dwalin performed his duties with his usual reliability but he did not offer his usual camaraderie to a King who knew he had made a mistake but was too proud of the office of Kingship to rectify his error. And the news that Thorin still struggled with Dragon Sickness also worried the brothers and Dis. But the King did nothing out of the ordinary, just sleep-walked through the duties of Kingship without any joy or even hope. It was rather tragic to behold.

 

Six months after Bilbo was banished, Balin found that Open Court was interrupted by a frantic messenger who had run all the way from the Gates with an announcement: that one Kilian son of Vilian had arrived at Erebor and was looking for the Prince Consort. There was an audible intake of breath and the old Adviser gave a sad look.

 

“You should probably tell him that the Prince is no longer here and that all queries should be directed to the Shire,” he said. Panting. the messenger ran off.

 

He returned not long after, red in the face and drenched in sweat.

 

“He says that his mission is for the King, just that the Prince Consort, his sponsor, had asked to be notified of his arrival when he dispatched him so that he could accompany Kilian on delivering the prize.”

 

“What prize?” Balin muttered and then looked at Thorin. “Majesty-I think you should see him.” The King waved a hand dully, his eyes dark with weariness.

 

“As you wish,” he said slowly as the messenger panted off again and eventually returned with a retinue. The leading dwarf was squat and weather-beaten, his grey-streaked brown beard simply braided in a Stiffbeard style and his armour had seen better days. A weather-beaten cloak flapped behind him as he advanced, then he bowed low before the King. Behind him, six dwarves bore a wooden sarcophagus that was beautifully carved with runes and reliefs that could only be the work of a master-craftsman and a smaller wooden case lay across the top of the wooden coffin.

 

“Kilian son of Vilian, also known as the Stonebreaker, at your service, King Thorin,” he announced in a gravelly voice. Frowning, the King inclined his head and inspected the newcomer.

 

“Kilian the Tomb Robber,” he murmured. The dwarf looked up.

 

“I have been known as that by unenlightened and jealous rivals who have less than one tenth of my archeological and historical knowledge and acumen,” the dwarf replied. Then he straightened up. “I apologise if my timing is awkward. I was instructed to ask for the Prince Consort when I arrived since he and his colleague, the miner Bofur as well as Scribe Ori were the ones who sent me on this mission.”

 

There was an awkward silence and Balin stared then jerked his head. Dwalin took off at a sprint to find his betrothed, knowing that Ori held information about the whole affair that he could have shared months earlier-and that he would need Dwalin to protect him from the wrath of a heartsick King. But he met Ori in the hallway, already heading for the Throne Room. The warrior grabbed his arm.

 

“How did you…?” he asked in shock.

 

“I left standing orders that I was to be called the moment Kilian arrived,” the Scribe told him, cool as ice. “I am a part of this and Bilbo asked me to see this done. If it is the last favour I am permitted to do him, then I will not fail.”

 

“But what is the favour?” Dwalin asked him, staring into his eyes.

 

“Peace,” Ori said with a little knowing smile. “It’s Bilbo all over.”

 

“The King will be furious,” Dwalin warned him. Ori looked unconcerned.

 

“Then that is his problem,” he said calmly. “I guess they are waiting for you?”

 

Thorin was glaring as they walked back in, the Scribe completely calm despite the obvious anger of the King. He glared at Ori but Kilian spoke first.

 

“Master Ori-I am sorry we are late,” he said. “You and the Prince Consort were frighteningly accurate in your predictions but the terrain was far less hospitable than we had anticipated and even with Master Bofur’s assistance, it was incredibly lucky we found the tomb at all…”

 

“Explain yourself NOW or I will have you thrown out of Erebor,” Thorin growled, his eyes narrowing. The archaeologist gave a small bow, then gestured to the sarcophagus.

 

“Prince Bilbo wanted to do something both to bolster the reputation of Erebor and for you personally,” Kilian explained. “He related tales of the loss of Borin son of Durin the Deathless and how it was a terrible sadness to your family that his tomb was unknown and that he rested alone in an unmarked grave. He listened to tales of the heroism of your ancestor and of his deeds and magical weapons and resolved to look through every record he could to find clues. He and Scribe Ori searched the entire ancient archives and even some of the oldest records in Rivendell to piece together what objective evidence there was of the legend. They worked for a year and finally developed a working hypothesis, placing his tomb close by the northernmost limits of Ered Luin, not that far from the Icebay of Forochel. It was land uninhabitable and inimitable to our kind, devoid of life and still shattered from the War of Wrath, two Ages ago. But using Master Baggins’ scholarship and insights, I was able to narrow the search.”

 

Thorin stared at the dwarf and his eyes slid to the sarcophagus. If he looked, he could recognise the workmanship and his gut churned in guilt. He didn’t even notice Dis, Fili and Kili slip in the back of the Throne room to stare at the scene. 

 

“Master Bofur travelled to join us and his stone sense was invaluable in locating the void where the tomb was hidden,” Kilian admitted. “The rocks had been crushed and twisted as the world was broken and remade: it was a miracle that the area hadn’t fallen into the sea with the rest of Beleriand. It took us months to dig it out to preserve what there was there-and finally we found the unmarked tomb marked only by the Axe Vengeance and the Sword Orc-Splitter.” He gestured to the smaller box. “We raised the bones of Borin son of Durin I with all honour and brought him home to be interred in the stone with his distant kin.” He gestured. “Master Bofur made the sarcophagus and the box for the weapons and Prince Bilbo was insistent that this would show that your reign was favoured by Mahal and would grant the forebear, whose lost tomb clearly grieved you, a chance to be finally laid to rest with the rest of his Line.”

 

Thorin rose, his face ashen.

 

“He planned this…” he murmured.

 

“Bilbo and Bofur helped draw up plans for a tomb,” Ori explained quietly, pulling out a large sheet of rolled parchment. “They spent many hours over them-when you were not around, of course, because your husband could hardly surprise you if you were present while he planned his gift.”

 

Thorin made a choking noise.

 

“He brought Borin son of the Deathless home to sleep with us here in Erebor,” he whispered.

 

“He asked if maybe it would be better if he was left in Ered Luin but I was able to reassure him that Ered Luin is traditionally the home of the Broadbeams and the Firebeards and that the Line of Durin in that time resided in the Misty Mountains, in Khazad-dûm. And even the Prince Consort understood that attempting to return him there would be futile and suicidal. That lying with his kin here would be an honour for Borin.”

 

“And for Erebor,” Balin murmured, speechless. He glanced over at the King and saw Dis’s eyes widen with comprehension.

 

“This is why he would not speak,” Balin muttered, are or less to himself. “He was determined to preserve the surprise.”

 

“If only someone had trusted our Hobbit instead of behaving like an orc,” Dis said aloud. Thorin walked slowly forward and rested his hand on the carved wood. Carefully, he opened the smaller box to see the legendary Axe and Sword of Borin, weapons of such power and lethality that they were recognised in their own right. Taking a slow breath, he reached out and his fingers brushed the metal that had been buried for thousands of years. The metal was cool and the edge as keen as the last day it had been used. His hand hovered over the hilt of the sword, recalling tales of its great deeds and then he closed his hands. He, of all people, was undeserving to hold it after what he had done. Reverently, he closed the box once more.

 

“Master Ori, I will approve your plans,” he said in a broken voice. “And I cannot offer sufficient thanks for my gratitude at your role in this magnificent honour you have done for Erebor.” The Scribe sighed.

 

“The honour was intended for you, Highness,” he said. “All your husband ever wanted was to bring you joy. He could tell all was not right-he suspected it was because his presence gave those of ill will a chance to speak against you and blame his presence for any and all mishaps that befell the Kingdom. Bringing such honour upon Erebor would ensure that no one could ever blame you for any misfortune by your choice of mate.”

 

Thorin turned away, walking slowly to the throne, his shoulders slumped. 

 

“Master Kilian, you have brought great honour and I will honour any outstanding duties and responsibilities of my Consort’s contract with you,” he said, turning to face the room. “Balin-please escort Master Kilian and his retinue to the Sixth Store Room, within the Treasury and ensure that the remains of Lord Borin are locked safely from all interference. Ori-please assist him and ensure that the finest stonemasons and craftsmen are set at work at once to construct the tomb you have deemed worthy of our ancestor.”

 

“Your Majesty,” the two named dwarves said and bowed low, then led Kilian and his party from the Throne Room. Thorin remained still, staring after them.

 

“Court is adjourned for the day!” he announced. “Everybody-get out. NOW!” The roar at the end had the waiting dwarrow scuttling for the entrance, many of them already muttering in shock and awe at the legendary ancestor who had been found and brought to Erebor. Every dwarfling knew some of the tales of Borin son of Deathless, a fearless adventurer and hero of the past whose untimely death and secret burial had been a bitter end to such magnificent tales. Bearing enchanted weapons forged by the hands of Durin the Deathless himself and blessed by the King and Queen of Doriath before the end of the First Age, it was news that would sweep the Mountain. And inexorably linked to that was the name of the Prince Consort, who had made it happen for the King he loved.

 

When the doors slammed, Thorin staggered forward and collapsed to his knees, his head bowed and shoulders shaking with grief and despair.

 

“What have I done?” he choked, sobs almost making it impossible for him to speak. He had spent part of every night wracked by guilt so bitter he had felt he may die from it, his sleep fractured by nightmares so vile they robbed him of any rest and the pain in his heart was constant, searing and all but unbearable…and yet this was worse. He had demanded proof, proof that Bilbo refused to give-partly due his own anger at the accusation and the lack of trust it implied but also because he had spent years constructing this most magnificent of gifts that Thorin’s enemies and their crude machinations would have ruined. And what could Bilbo have said at that time? Would Thorin have believed that his Hobbit was trying to dig up a legendary dwarf from the dawn of their race? Had the tomb even been found at that time or would Bilbo’s defence have been limited to plans…plans which would have sounded wild blue-sky tales that the jealous, angry King would have scoffed at?

 

“Realised what a fool you are now?” a cold voice asked. Dís. It could only be Dís who ignored his orders to clear the room. He felt a fresh bout of despair wash over him, his sight almost blinded by tears.

 

He nodded.

 

“I already knew,” he managed to grunt, his voice almost unintelligible. “Why didn’t he tell me? He must’ve known our marriage was more important than this…”

 

“Would you have believed him?” Dís asked bluntly. “You were angry and hurt. Your pride was wounded. You were not thinking straight. The jealousy and rage from your Dragon Sickness had clouded what little sense you actually possess. You would have laughed in his face.”

 

Thorin almost felt as if he couldn’t breathe because her words echoed his own vicious self-recriminations.

 

“You are correct,” he gasped, the tears finally running out and leaving him feeling hollow and exhausted. He hadn’t wept since he had been a tiny pebble. He had not wept when his mother fell to the dragon or Frerin died in his arms or when they fled from Erebor. But he wept now for his own foolishness that cost him his heart-and the knowledge that a far better being than he had been hurt in his cruelty. He remained on his knees, his shoulders slumped and head hanging forward. Suddenly a hand found his shoulder.

 

“Nadad, I wish I could help you,” his sister said, her tone suddenly gentle. “But this is a disaster of your own making and only you can try to make this right.”

 

“It can never be right because I betrayed him,” Thorin sighed. “I didn’t trust him. I hurt him. I brought up…” He choked on one last sob. “He will never forgive me.” Dís shook her head and then walked back to slump into the throne, looking down on her kneeling brother. And he knew he should object because technically what she was doing was treason but in practicality, she was his co-Monarch, though she only took Court under protest and preferred to pull the strings from behind the scenes.

 

“Lulkhel. There is no better term,” she told him unnecessarily. “But it suits you, Lalkhûn. And if you want to wallow in your own misery, you can. You can stay here and be a terrible King, a tyrant who yells at decent people for no good reason, a King who hates Erebor because he knows that it cost him the person he loves above all…” Thorin looked up, his face twisted into a scowl.

 

“I reclaimed Erebor for our people,” he said dully. “I honoured the wishes of Adad and Sigin’Adad. I expected to die on the Quest. I expected us to fail. And it should have happened if not for a Hobbit. I made too many mistakes and I deserved to die.”

 

“You lived-though you almost got my sons killed,” Dís reminded him. “The Kingdom is stable. We are now blessed and honoured. But you are dragging everyone down, Nadad. You cannot spend the rest of your life snarling at your subjects like a warg with a sore paw. They do not deserve your ire.”

 

“They…” he began and then stopped. 

 

“Gossip is part of any Dwarf Kingdom, Nadad. They will always dissect every action you take and every detail of your relationship,” his sister told him. “But they did not make you react how you did. That was all you, Lulkhel. Your wounded pride, your anger, your stupid and irrational feelings of betrayal, the anger you never fully let go from the Battle. You wronged your husband and you know that. And he responded the only way he could. Now you know the truth, it makes your betrayal that much worse.”

 

“I know,” he confessed. 

 

“Then what are you going to do about it?” Her tone was hard.

 

“Nothing,” he said in a defeated voice. “There is nothing I can do.” 

 

Dis rose to her feet.

 

“I should kill you where you cower,” she told him in an icy voice, her eyes flashing with rage. Thorin’s head snapped up and her stared into her eyes.

 

“That would be a mercy,” he admitted.

 

“One you will never deserve,” she told him icily. “You have literally thrown away your One, the other half of your soul and you will do nothing to try to remedy the situation. Yet if I was in the same situation-bearing in mind I would never be so stupid as to not trust my Amrâlimê anyway-I would crawl on my belly and do whatever it took to win him back. But I will never get that chance, Thorin. And I should kill you for not grasping it while you still have the option.”

 

“He will never forgive me,” Thorin told her.

 

“He certainly won’t if you don’t try,” she shot back. “You won back a Kingdom that was occupied by a dragon after crossing half of Arda and being pursued by the bane of our Line. How can you baulk at facing a Halfling?”

 

“He’s half of nothing and more than I,” Thorin replied in the same defeated tone. “And he could make Smaug look reasonable and accommodating.”

 

“I’m not saying it will be easy but I am saying that Erebor cannot suffer your wounded heart and anger at your lot any longer,” she told him bluntly. “So you will lead the ceremony for reburying Borin son of the Deathless and then you will go seek your husband.”

 

“I cannot.” Thorin’s tone was clipped and angry. “I am the King-and no matter how you wish to interfere, Dis, I must serve my people and rule Erebor.”

 

“Well, you are not serving them very well by shouting at them,” Dis told him brutally. “Last Court, you called all but three of the applicants idiots, dismissed every complaint before they got more than a sentence in and threatened to exile three of them for being irritating.” She paused. “Not that they weren’t but Open Court is to allow everyone equal access to bring complaints to the King. And you are behaving so badly there are new rumours circulating. Rumours that you are not fit to rule.”

 

Thorin’s head snapped up and he stared at her, his brow furrowed. 

 

“What?”

 

“Nori and Balin have been tracking the rumours and dissatisfaction is rising at your rule,” she told him. “Your behaviour is beyond the pale. It is not their fault that you were Lulkhel. Either you should start behaving like a proper King and hide your pain-as you have the rest of your life-or you step down.” 

 

Thorin slowly raised his hands and covered his face, his breathing ragged once more.

 

“I will remain until Borin, son of the Deathless, is laid to rest,” he said in a toneless voice. “I will endeavour to rehabilitate my reputation until then. And afterwards…I will head west to the Shire. To see if I can ever earn forgiveness from Bilbo.”

 

There were muffled noises and he guessed that his nephews hadn’t gone far and were eavesdropping. Against all reason, he felt the smallest of smiles curl his lips.

 

“You and Balin will assist Fili in ruling,” he announced, listening for the obvious groan that came from the space behind the throne. He wasn’t disappointed. “I will write to you of my progress. But if I have not returned within five years, you can assume that I have abdicated and you can Crown Fili.” He looked up and saw his sister speechless. It was that tiny stab of triumph, accompanied by the slightest easing of the searing pain in his chest that told him he had finally made the right decision. Unsteadily, he rose to his feet and walked to grasp his sister’s shoulder, pulling her close and resting his forehead against hers. “Thank you, Dis,” he whispered. She snorted.

 

“You are Lulkhel. But you are my Lulkhel and if I can bring you back to the happiness you deserve, then I have saved my purpose as your sister,” she told him softly. “You are the only person who believes that you do not deserve happiness. Just for once, having saved our people, reclaimed our home and restored our Kingdom, allow yourself to do whatever is necessary for your own happiness.”

 

Thorin closed his eyes.

 

“What if he doesn’t forgive me?” he whispered. She smiled.

 

“Then you have to be a Son of Durin and stubborn as the mountain,” she told him gently. “Now start behaving like a King and make preparations to go and win back your Hobbit.”

 

Notes:

Khuzdul:

Lulkhel - Idiot of idiots (or fool of fools)

Lalkhûn -idiot (or fool)

Nadad - brother

Adad - Father

Sigin’Adad - Grandfather

Amrâlimê - my love (beloved)

Chapter 4: Pride and Misunderstandings

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

FOUR: Pride and Misunderstandings

 

The Shire hadn’t changed at all, Bilbo realised. It was as if he had walked out of his door one day and back the next for all the difference there was. There were a few new relationships and a little gossip to catch up on but honestly, he was the main gossip for the first year after his return. And it hurt, being stared at and muttered about behind his back (though not quietly enough to prevent his keen hearing from picking up the hated ‘Mad Baggins’ epithet). But Bilbo had his neighbour and friend, Hamfast Gamgee and Belle, his wife, who were down to earth and treated how they found-and they always found Bilbo polite, friendly and generous with his bakes. A number of his younger cousins also saw him as rather a hero, having gone off on an adventure. And he shared his tales with them, telling his young and eager visitors of trolls and stone giants, of goblins and orcs, of skin-changers and giant bees and Eleven Kings and one very scary dragon. And of course, he spoke of his dwarves, his friends who lived the other side of the world. And he said that he came home because he was a Hobbit among dwarves and missed the Shire too much to stay away.

 

His more respectable and older relatives treated him as if he had contracted some particularly unpleasant and malodorous complaints and avoided coming anywhere near him, excluding him from family gatherings and celebrations. But some questioned why he should be punished when he had come home so he was still invited to some weddings and of course, all the festivals and High Days that formed the rhythm of life in the Shire. And he was always generous and imaginative when he gave gifts. Of course, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins spent months claiming that Bilbo Baggins was dead and that some cursed changeling had returned in his place and was even now despoiling Bag End which should rightfully be hers. And while some of the more venal and petty-minded Hobbits could sympathise with her complaints, everyone soon grew weary of her unrelenting bile and her words were tuned out.

 

Over the cold Yule period, he was delighted to receive guests: Bofur, Bifur and Bombur and his family all came over to spend the season with their friend. Bofur had been good as his word and had written as well and it warmed Bilbo’s heart to have a Smial full of noise, bad manners and dwarvish cheer. Hamfast and Belle, his cousins Drogo, Dora and Dudo Baggins and Adalgrim, Sigismund and Flambard Took and their families all spent some time with Bilbo over the holidays and met his dwarvish friends. And though there were some raised Hobbitish eyebrows about the dwarves’ manners (and some hands over young ears at some of Bofur’s rather racier stories), the Hobbits recognised fellow beings who enjoyed good food, family, good ale and good cheer. And the presence of his few tolerable Hobbit relations and his dwarves eased the loneliness and ache in Bilbo’s chest.

 

He also received a steady stream of letters from Erebor, with some arriving mere days after he had returned to Bag End. Balin and the Princes were the most frequent correspondents but Dis and Tauriel wrote as well along with all of the others-all save, Thorin. Even Dwalin wrote, an unusual occurrence, explaining how sorry he was that Bilbo had left and that he would have stopped Thorin if he could. 

 

“He’s an idiot. You know that and so do I. He and I are warriors and we don’t do long talks about feelings. But he’s also a King and the rumours had half of Erebor laughing at him. Maybe if he was told in private, he could have coped. But that orc-bait Sulgan announced it in Council and humiliated him. His pride took over and you know how well that always works out. He knows how much he has hurt you and himself. But he can’t stop being a King. He is sorry. And so am I. I know Ori misses you and so do I. Honestly, Thorin is like a warg with a hangover so I may need to come for a visit before I hit him over the head and brain him with his own crown…”

 

Smiling as he read the words and mentally imbuing them with Dwalin’s gruff voice and dry intonation, he allowed himself, just for once, to imagine Thorin. He had studiously avoided considering the King because the subject was too painful. But he could imagine Thorin in Erebor, his famous temper permanently bad due to shame and guilt and hurt and how unpleasant that would be. He rested the letter down. He didn’t need to imagine: he had been on the receiving end of that temper for all of the Quest until he had saved Thorin’s life from Azog and been apologised to on the Carrock. Ori had told him later that he had never heard of Thorin apologising to anyone before-at least, not publicly-so he appreciated the gesture all the more. And he knew, from loving and being married to the King, that his pride was still an issue. He had heard Gandalf warn the dwarf in Rivendell and he had seen it in Mirkwood when Thorin’s pride and still-smouldering grudge against Thranduil had condemned the dwarves to eternal captivity in the ElvenKing’s dungeons. 

 

“Oh Thorin,” he sighed as he folded up the letter and placed it in the drawer of his desk with the others he had received from the Company. “You are your own worst enemy. I can only hope Dis and the boys will get through to you. Erebor doesn’t deserve your wrath.” He shrugged and a Tookish surge of bitterness washed through him. “Sulgan though…well, you can do what you want to that snake.”

 

Spring brought a new cycle of gardening and Bilbo was determined this year to ensure his garden was in shape and see if he could coax his prize-winning tomatoes back to their former glory. The previous year he had been far too late to grow anything suitable to enter into the Hobbiton and Shire Shows but this year, he was determined that he would reclaim his legacy as Bilbo Baggins, Grower of Unmatchable Tomatoes. He would be an entirely proper Hobbit who grew wonderful vegetables, baked extremely well and was a superb host. And if he hosted dwarrow as well as Hobbits, then that was no one’s business but his own. 

 

Spring was gently warming into Summer when he heard rumours from Bessie Bolger that there was a new blacksmith in Bywater, a dwarf who had taken up the old forge and was willingly taking any and all commissions. She was fairly vague about the details, save he was polite but taciturn and seemed to be on his own. And Bilbo listened politely and absolutely definitely told himself that he did not need to go and investigate. That it was probably some simple dwarf who was doing what Thorin had done when times were desperate in Ered Luin and was working where he could find employment. That he absolutely did not need to see if he could befriend the newcomer because he missed his dwarves fiercely. And he lasted all of two days before he found himself heading out for Bywater market ‘for a change’ as he told himself unconvincingly. 

 

It was a short walk of only a mile or so and it was a pleasant day when Bilbo set out. The sun was brilliant in the cloudless sky but dew was still gleaming on the grass and there were a few early bluebells and pink bells in the verge was he ambled along. Up ahead, the market was in full swing and he smiled and was polite to the stallholders as he worked his way around, buying some quality produce as he slowly approached the forge.

 

Smoke was curling from the chimney and the hatch was open, a few hobbits coming and going to speak with the blacksmith. Bilbo watched a middle-aged Matron pause and obviously flirt with the  unseen dwarf and leave with a smile on her face. Curious, he walked round so he could get a better view through the hatch.

 

The forge was neat enough, the space a little gloomy but the dwarf was working hard hammering a spade into shape. Bilbo stared, seeing a powerful shape hammering away. The dwarf had a long dark mane streaked with silver and was dressed in dark colours. It was only when he turned that Bilbo stared, ducking back after a moment, his heart pounding.

 

The dwarf was Thorin.

 

But how could Thorin son of Thrain, King Under the Mountain, be here in Bywater? How could he be a blacksmith when he was ruling the Kingdom of Erebor? And why?

 

The Matron he had seen earlier walked past Bilbo, her primrose yellow dress contrasting with her simple straw bonnet trimmed with blue and white ribbons. She was a little plump and had a ready smile.

 

“Master Lulkhel!” she called and he looked up. Resting his hammer down, he turned to give her his attention and nodded.

 

“Mistress Gardenia-how may I be of service?” he asked and Bilbo felt a shiver run down his spine. 

 

Oh, he had missed that baritone voice and his heart ached that the dwarf King was here in the Shire and hadn’t come straight to him. What was Thorin’s plan? Was this some other revenge or some plan to entrap and punish Bilbo some more for the temerity of taking Thorin at his word? And why wasn’t Thorin still in Erebor? Had there been a coup? Was he on holiday? Had Dis finally kicked him out?

 

Why hadn’t he come to see Bilbo?

 

The Matron was fluttering her lashes at Thorin and Bilbo found an unfamiliar curl of jealousy tighten in his chest.

 

“Oh, I think you know, you tease!” she tittered as the dwarf gave a slight sigh.

 

“Mistress Gardenia, I regret that I do not understand,” he said honestly. She looked at him.

 

“I gave you a bouquet of daisies and asters,” she told him. He frowned and Bilbo understood his confusion because he knew dwarves far better than ‘Mistress Gardenia’ obviously did…

 

Thorin doesn’t understand the language of flowers. He’s a dwarf. And you won’t find a more dwarvish dwarf than Thorin. Except maybe Dwalin-though even he worked out how to court Ori without half his family haranguing him.

 

“And I am very grateful,” he said carefully. “They made the forge and my living quarters look far merrier…” Gardenia stamped her foot, her carefully pinned up mahogany curls starting to escape from the knot.

 

“Do you not understand what  am talking about?” she asked and Thorin sighed, reluctantly shaking his head.

 

“I gave you some very nice treacle tarts and meat pies,” she told him. “Did you not understand that as well?” By now, Thorin was looking very uncomfortable.

 

“Were they not gifts?” he asked and the turned to the battered metal box under the counter. “I can pay you for them if that was what was expected? I apologise for misunderstanding the nature of our transaction…” By now Gardenia was almost bristling with fury. 

 

“No, you stupid dwarf!” she spat. “I was asking you if you fancied walking out with me.” Thorin’s eyes widened and then he adopted the familiar practiced expression that Bilbo recognised as the one he used when dealing with Thranduil, an experience he always found distasteful. 

 

“I apologise most humbly, Mistress Gardenia,” he said in a regal and polite tone. “I did not understand your intent.  We dwarves do not give food or flowers as a mark of affection.” His voice hitched and Bilbo hoped that he was thinking back to all those times when his husband had made him special treats and was realising what he had meant. “I am flattered by your words. Yet while I am far from home, I cannot reciprocate your affections and so, I must respectfully decline.”

 

She stared at him.

 

“What?” she spat. “You are turning me down? Don’t you know who I am?” Thorin’s brow furrowed.

 

“I regret that I am a newcomer to the Shire and I am unfamiliar with your familial ties,” he admitted. Gardenia drew herself up in anger.

 

“I am a Proudfoot and am the only daughter and heir of Waldemir Proudfoot of Harbottle!” she sneered. “You’d know that if you were a proper Hobbit and not some rude and ungrateful dwarf!” Then her eyes narrowed. “The people around here won’t like that you led me on and were toying with my virtue! You can forget anyone treating you like anything other than a hired hand and outsider, Master Lulkhel!” Then she turned on her heel and marched away, leaving Thorin staring after her with resigned expression on his face. He looked up-and then he froze as his eyes fell on Bilbo. And Bilbo really hoped he hadn’t imagined the instantaneous look of relief and joy that flickered across his gaze before he blinked and then forced himself to look impassive.

 

“Bilbo…I mean, Master Baggins!” he said, the warmth in his voice unmistakable. Seen and suddenly filled with annoyance that he felt like he had to hide in his own homeland, the Hobbit marched forward, his expression set.

 

“What are you doing here?” he hissed. Thorin looked taken aback at the tone-but only for a second. He gave a small smile.

 

“It is good to see you,” he said warmly.

 

“Is it?” Bilbo snapped, every moment of hurt and outrage at the injustice rising in his throat in an inexorable tide.”That’s rich, considering the last words you said to me were ‘So be it. Accused of adultery and refusing to defend the accusation, my Consort Bilbo Baggins, is banished from Erebor. He may return when his innocence is proven.’” Thorin winced.

 

“What I did then I was not proud of,” he said quietly. “I know I betrayed your trust.”

 

“You betrayed everything!” Bilbo yelled at him. “Why didn’t you write?”

 

“I expected any letter to be burnt.” The words were toneless.

 

“Then why didn’t you come to see me?” Bilbo yelled. Thorin drew himself up.

 

“I expected this welcome,” the King explained. “It is richly deserved, after all. After the magnificent gift that you gave to Erebor, to me, I truly realised the depths of my failure and utter…” 

 

“And what is this Lulkhel nonsense?” Bilbo demanded, cutting him off fiercely.

 

“It is a name I deserve,” Thorin said, hurt flashing in his eyes. “I would not use my own name. Some would know and it could bring distractions.” Bilbo glared at him. 

 

“Distractions?” he snapped. “What are you doing here at all? Who is ruling Erebor?” Thorin dipped his head.

 

“Erebor is safe,” he assured the Hobbit. “My sister and Balin are assisting Fili…”

 

“So you dumped the whole thing on him and swanned off…” Bilbo began but Thorin finally lost his patience.

 

“It was always for him!” he snapped, his eyes flashing with anger. “I was never meant to survive the Quest. The odds were always that we would lose-or I would die. A miracle meant I survived-and that was a gift I never deserved. And I am no longer worthy of the Throne. My family have sent me here to see if anything could be salvaged.”

 

“They can stop wasting their time. Nothing can!” Bilbo snapped, still furious. Thorin swayed as if struck but he took a deep breath and blinked once, raising his practiced mask.

 

“Then I beg your pardon, Master Baggins,” he said in a carefully neutral voice. “I will endeavour not to intrude upon your privacy.” Still fuming, Bilbo glared at him.

 

“Go home, Thorin,” he snapped. “There is nothing for you here.”

 

“Nothing remains for me in Erebor either,” the dwarf said quietly. Giving a snort of exasperation, Bilbo turned and stormed away, leaving his (former?) husband watching him with sad eyes and a clenched fist. He remained still and straight until Bilbo had rounded the corner, when he staggered and leaned heavily against the wall of the forge. The pain had tightened to an iron band around his chest and he closed his eyes and tried to breathe through it. Even though he had banished Bilbo, he had never rejected the bond-but Bilbo’s words had devastatingly confirmed that he did. And Thorin was not a young dwarf, having lived a hard and dangerous life, a life marked by privation, disappointment and hardships. Perhaps if he was younger, he could endure the rejection better but as he was…? He shook his head and straightened up. He still had time and the worst was over. Bilbo had seen him and he had reacted exactly as Thorin had expected. Now, he could concentrate upon proving he wasn’t the ogre he had shown Bilbo-and maybe salvaging something.

 

-o0o-

 

Bilbo studiously avoided Bywater after that, even diverting when he had to visit his Aunt Belba, who had married Rudigar Bolger and had been widowed a couple of years earlier. Her sons Mengo and Holgo visited the old Hobbit daily but Bilbo was a regular visitor as well. She had been his father’s favourite sister and she loved his lemon and thyme cakes so, laden with a basket of baked treats, he made his way round for tea.

 

When he arrived, he was a little dismayed to find his Aunt Linda also there. Belba’s younger sister had married Bodo Proudfoot and though she was also in advanced years, she was very proper and never wasted an opportunity to gossip. She had given Bilbo an especially hard time on his return and he almost retreated-but Belba saw him at the window and waved him in. By the time he had made his way to the parlour, she was up, her white-haired shape wrapping him in a tight hug.

 

“It’s so good to see you!” she told him, her brown eyes sparkling with enjoyment. “Linda popped round but I’m sure she can tolerate you-after all, your lemon and thyme cake is the finest in all Four Farthings!”

 

Linda had snorted. She shared her sister's eyes but had a pinched look about her. However, she was a guest and swallowed her objections to conform to Hobbit norms. After all, she was a Baggins and there was no victory in complaining about her nephew when she was as bad a guest. But she knew that Bilbo took after their older brother in his baking and only a fool turned down Bilbo’s bakes.

 

In fact, Bilbo had found himself having rather a good time. Belba was a good hostess but she had appreciated the lemon and thyme cakes, along with the strawberry tarts and the cherry-chocolate gateau. Belba had brought him up to speed on family gossip and after her third tart, Linda had loosened up and begun to spill Proudfoot gossip as well.

 

“Gardenia is still furious,” she continued, helping herself to another slice of the lemon thyme cake. “Being led on by that dwarf.” Belba looked up over her cup of tea.

 

“Oh, I hadn’t heard that,” she said, sipping away. “Word was he is a sober and polite creature.”

 

“Really?” Linda sneered. “Who said that? He’s a wretched creature. She gave him a bouquet which he accepted and gifts of food which he ate…but he turned her down. He even offered to pay for the food!” Belba tutted.

 

“Why would she even ask a dwarf?” she asked. 

 

“He’s an ugly creature,” Linda said spitefully. “While Gardenia is rather a catch. She’s nicely plump, comes from a fertile family and she’s rather well-off. Cousin Waldemir left her very comfortable and she thought he would be exotic.” She leaned closer to her sister. “You know what they say about dwarfs.” Belba cackled and reached for her pipe, clamping it between her teeth. 

 

“Aye,” she agreed as Bilbo felt vaguely uncomfortable. These pair were maligning an entire race he happened to be rather fond of and an individual he had loved. Still loved? Or at least had liked enough to marry…

 

“Insatiable!” Linda chuckled. “Always at it, strings of lovers wherever they go…they say their women have beards so you can’t tell them…”

 

“Was Gardenia even sure it’s a male?” Belba asked. 

 

“Apparently so-she checked out the merchandise,” Linda shared in a smug voice. Bilbo inspected his cake, feeling his stomach turn. This was the sort of gossip he had endured in Erebor and it was unpleasant to hear it reversed. “Maybe he thought he could mess with her and not have to bother with any niceties…”

 

“Well, they’re all grasping, greedy creatures. Maybe he’s after her money?” Belba suggested. Bilbo swallowed. 

 

No, he owns enough treasure to buy the Shire, he thought.

 

“He is a dwarf,” he said. The two older Hobbits stared at him.

 

“That’s what we said,” Linda said superiorly.

 

“No,” he sighed. “Dwarves don’t even know there is a language of flowers. They know nothing. He will have seen a pretty piece of vegetation, not a declaration of intent to court.” The two Hobbitesses stared at him.

 

“What?”

 

“But how…”

 

“How can they declare intent to court…?” Linda asked in a disbelieving tone.

 

“They give gifts,” Bilbo told her bluntly. “Usually made of gold or gems. They are creatures of the rock, not of green fields and living things.”

 

“Bilbo should know-he ran off with a bunch of them!” Belba put in, puffing her pipe through clenched teeth.

 

“Yeah…now tying the name Baggins to the term ‘Mad’!” Linda complained.

 

“Let’s be honest-Belladonna would have been amused and is certainly watching and laughing her ass off in Yavanna’s Green Fields!” Belba chuckled. “Young Bilbo going off on an adventure.”

 

“Belbs! Keep to the point. That nasty dwarf led Gardenia on…” Linda insisted.

 

“And to them, food is food,” Bilbo added firmly. “He would have seen a kind gift, not a declaration of intent.” 

 

“What kind of soulless creatures are they?” Linda sneered. “They don’t understand food and flowers? And they’re all promiscuous!” Bilbo stiffened. It echoed the accusations that had been levelled at him and he knew that Thorin was faithful. His pride and his honour would allow nothing different-a reason why his reaction to the unfounded rumours had been so extreme. He knew from Ori that his plan had been fulfilled and that Borin son of the Deathless had been returned to Erebor and interred with huge Honours into the tomb that Bilbo and Bofur had designed…but for Thorin to be so maligned roused the protective instincts he felt whenever anyone bad-mouthed his dwarves.

 

“Actually, they love only once,” he said quietly. “Many never find their One…what they refer to their Heart-Mate as…and not all recognise the bond. But they are faithful until death to their beloved.” Linda snorted.

 

“Well, that blacksmith isn’t married,” he said. “No sign of a wedding ring…”

 

But he was still wearing his wedding braid, Bilbo realised, rerunning his memory. It had been about the only one he had retained.

 

“Typical,” Belba agreed. “A rogue…” Bilbo rose suddenly.

 

“He is married,” he said sharply. “The braid in his hair shows that. He actually has a ring-of iron-but that is a sign of his house and his craft.”

 

“How would you…?”

 

“Because I married a dwarf!” Bilbo snapped. Both old Hobbitesses stared at him. “I married a dwarf.”

 

“Where is he now?” Linda sneered. Bilbo turned away.

 

“He showed he did not trust me,” he said angrily. “So I left him.” There was a pause and then Belba achingly rose to her feet, wrapping him in a warm hug. To his shock, Linda joined in as well.

 

“Oh Bilbo,” Belba sighed. “I am so sorry. It is so distressing when you find your partner isn’t what you believed.” Quietly, the younger Hobbit nodded. Linda gently stroked his curls.

 

“I’m sorry,” she said. “Looks like Gardenia had a lucky escape.”

 

“Dwarves are very secretive about their customs and culture,” he murmured. “I thought I understood him. But he didn’t understand me. He didn’t trust me…”

 

“Then he’s a fool,” Belba said firmly. “You are a fine Hobbit, Bilbo.”

 

“But I think he needed a dwarf,” Bilbo sighed. “He doesn’t understand Hobbits.”

 

“You said they only love once,” Linda murmured. “So you are the only love he will ever have. He’s the fool in letting you go and not learning about the one who owns his heart.” She kissed his curls. “Now did I tell you what Gurdo Proudfoot got up to at the Spring Races?”

 

But as he walked back towards Bag End, he glanced down at the Forge. There was still smoke curling from the chimney and he wondered why Thorin had come. He would have come straight to Bilbo if it had just been for a talk. Somehow, the ridiculous dwarf had chosen some sort of penance for himself but it was no longer Bilbo’s problem. Thorin had broken their bond by not trusting his husband.

 

His stupid heart would have to continue yearning for his lost love.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Lulkhel - idiot of idiots (or fool of fools)

Chapter 5: Hope and Rejection

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

FIVE: Hope and Rejection

 

 

Summer deepened and the days were filled with plenty to keep Bilbo busy. His garden needed tending and his tomatoes were coming along well. There were weddings every week and parties and other events to keep him busy. The Shire was in bloom and for a Hobbit, the world was at its best. There was plentiful fresh food, lots of company and gardening to keep him busy. And sometimes, when he was sitting in the shade under the oak tree by his home, he wondered how warm it was in the forge-before he schooled himself and forced himself not to complete the thought. That Thorin chose to be in the Shire, working like an itinerant blacksmith instead of home in Erebor was his choice. It wasn’t for Bilbo to worry about him.

 

One morning in late May, he emerged from his front door to check the morning and found a small bouquet laid on his doorstep. It was simple, tied with plain string and there was no note. But to a Hobbit, the flowers spoke eloquently enough. White Clover - Think of me; Bluebell -humility; Chamomile - patience in adversity and a purple hyacinth for sorrow. Bilbo picked the flowers up and sniffed them: they were fresh and the scents were beautiful as well. Quietly, he walked down and saw, amid the fast-evaporating dew, the marks of booted feet. And then he sighed. 

 

Thorin had brought him the bouquet speaking in a language he clearly didn’t know but had gone to pains to learn. Hobbits were less secretive than Dwarves and it was likely he would find someone to teach him the basics. And also, thinking about it, how to recognise the flowers, since his husband hadn’t been able to recognise anything except a few trees and knew flowers only by their colours. He had worked out that red meant passion or love and when he did give Bilbo flowers, there was a preponderance of red and white. Fortunately he had never really misstepped but Bilbo had wished that Thorin had asked his husband about the flowers more. Of course, amid his anger and hurt at how things had ended, Bilbo had forced himself to remember that Thorin was affectionate, tactile and incredibly patient. He showered his husband with gifts and indulged his interests, so their rooms were littered with books on ancient languages and maps, Bilbo had a Hobbitish wardrobe and they entertained far more than Thorin would have chosen…but he played the host with good grace. There were even doilies… And he did adore his Hobbit.

 

Bilbo blinked and he almost flung the bouquet to the ground but something stopped him. Thorin was here, alone and isolated and he knew that Bilbo was beyond angry at him. But he had stayed and was tentatively reaching out again. This was an attempt at an apology. It wasn’t anywhere near enough but he would accept the bouquet because it was thoughtful. So he went inside and placed the flowers in a nice vase that sat on the kitchen table. And somehow, that day felt all the better for knowing that he had been given flowers by his husband.

 

Bofur arrived unexpectedly a week later and Bilbo greeted him eagerly. The miner was his usual cheery self and it eased something in Bilbo’s heart to see him unchanged. He regaled the Hobbit with tales of Ered Luin and how Bifur and Bombur were getting on. In return, Bilbo shared the Shire gossip and carefully brought up the subject of Thorin. Bofur was very quiet and thoughtful after he had heard the tale and considered before speaking.

 

“He has an ulterior motive being here,” he agreed as he stared at the window. “I am not sure why he’s here. He rejected you, didn’t he?” 

 

Bilbo rolled the events of that day round his head: in truth, he had rerun every word a thousand times and had dissected every nuance.

 

“No,” he said quietly. “He banished me but he always referred to me as his Consort. He gave me the chance to return. I was the one who told him that without trust, there was no point us being together. I removed my ring and marriage braid and left the beads on the floor before leaving.”

 

Bofur stared at him, then exhaled.

 

“Ah,” he said. “That would be it.” This time, it was Bilbo’s turn to frown, even as he rose from the kitchen table and refilled the kettle for a fresh cup of tea. 

 

“What?” he asked irritably. The last thing he needed was Bofur getting all mysterious on him. “You dwarves and your secrets…” Bofur leaned forward and drained his ale.

 

“What do you know of Ones?” he asked. Bilbo threw his hands up in exasperation.

 

“Very little considering I am a One,” he grumbled. Bofur managed a grin at that.

 

“Aye…unfortunately, it seems being one doesn’t gift yer with the knowledge,” he said philosophically. “Dwarf relationships don’t really break down. Only very rarely because when you meet your Soul-Mate, nothing could make you doubt them.” Then he winced. “Not if you’re sane, anyway…” 

 

“Well, we know Thorin has had issues in that department…” the Hobbit sniped and as he said the words, a pang of guilt hit him. What if it was true? What if Thorin wasn’t well, if the Dragon Sickness had left a lasting legacy? According to Oin and Ori, no one had ever recovered from the affliction so Thorin’s case was unique. No one knew what the long-term effects would be. 

 

“Aye, well in the few cases where the bond is broken by rejection, it can cause pain for the rejected partner,” Bofur said. Bilbo frowned. 

 

“That’s not me,” he realised, grimacing. “I rejected Thorin when I walked away, didn’t I?”

 

“Maybe,” Bofur said. “I can go speak to him, ask him what he’s doing…” But Bilbo shook his head.

 

“No,” he said quietly. “I will deal with it. In my own time. I don’t want any unpleasantness marring your visit.” then he grinned. “So what shall we have for dinner?”

 

Bofur stayed a week and accompanied Bilbo to a wedding where he danced and sang and generally acted like the sociable being he was. Bilbo actually saw Thorin at the back, his tall shape unmistakeable, but the dwarf ducked his head when he saw Bilbo staring at him and retreated. A flash of insight told him that Thorin had maybe hoped to speak with him but had stood down at the sight of Bofur and part of Bilbo was pleased at that…but a small part was disappointed that his former husband hadn’t the courage to proceed anyway. Though he knew that he was liable to be sent away and maybe his pride didn’t invite the certain public humiliation…

 

Life got busy and Bilbo pushed the concerns to the back of his mind. The bouquets resumed, always proclaiming love, regret, longing and sorrow and the Hobbit secretly enjoyed the gifts though he knew that the tentative approach could not come to anything because their issue had not been love but trust. And nothing had done had shown Thorin trusted him any more: in fact, now he came to think of it, wasn’t Thorin’s presence a huge red flag? He was literally here in the Shire, watching Bilbo and making sure he wasn’t getting on with his life! Angry and spiteful, he tossed the latest bouquet onto the compost heap and bustled around his day, feeling just a little unsettled. It wasn’t his fault that Thorin couldn’t take ‘no’ for an answer!

 

But sometimes, he still shopped in Bywater Market because Mistress Salvia Dunhaven made the most exquisite cheeses and Bilbo did have a very soft spot for a sharp, well-matured hard white cheese. Especially the ones she made with cranberries, walnuts or seeds incorporated. And if he happened to look over to the Forge-well, it was natural to see how the newcomer was doing. Certainly, the Forge always seemed to be busy and there was a steady stream of Hobbits going to the hatch to bring new items for repair or replacement, collect their repaired items or enquire about work. And Thorin always dealt with them politely and reasonably. The market traders never had a bad word to say about him.

 

“Say what you will, that dwarf has always been most decent,” Salvia said to Bilbo apropos of nothing. Probably because she had noted his eyes always drifted to the Forge whenever he visited for cheeses (which he had four times in the last two weeks). “Helps all of us set up our stalls and always runs out to help us take ‘em down quick if the weather turns inclement. Never a rude word and keeps himself to himself.”

 

“I am pleased to hear it,” Bilbo forced himself to say. He didn’t want to hear about Thorin’s life in the Shire because he was not interested. Not at all.  Salvia gave a wide grin.

 

“You always check on him as if he’s about to run out of there waving a battle axe,” she noted smugly. “And I defer to your expertise since you ran away with a hoard of ‘em a few years back.”

 

“Thirteen. And one wizard,” Bilbo said absently, watching Thorin carefully bend forward to be eye level with a faunt sent by his Da to purchase a bag of nails.

 

“I’m not sure what you sense about him but he doesn’t seem dangerous to me. Is he?”

 

“No. He’s entirely honourable,” Bilbo told her, turning away. “He just reminds me of someone I once knew.”

 

“Ah.” Salvia’s grin was knowing. “I take it your friendship with that person didn’t end well?” Bilbo swallowed.

 

“It ended on a stupid misunderstanding worsened by pride, stubbornness and some scurrilous and unfounded rumours,” he said briskly. "Thank you, Mistress Dunhaven. I need to get back to bake some fresh poppy seed biscuits to go with these excellent cheeses. I know I will be looking forward to them at tea time.” She pressed a small package into his hand.

 

“Try the truffle variation,” she said kindly. “I only keep it for my best customers. And you look like you need cheering up.”

 

When little Ivy Underwood got herself lost in Bindbole Woods, Thorin was there with the search crews and found the tiny faunt by going closer to the racing stream than any sane Hobbit would go. Seeing him emerge damp, muddy and triumphant with the precious child in his arms caused a brief surge of pride in Bilbo’s heart, for whatever his motives, the dwarf’s presence had saved that child. The river was rising after the recent rains and she would certainly have been swept away. Hobbits treasured their children but they could not have known that dwarves treasured children even more, for so few were born: Thorin would have willingly risked his life to save a child of any race. But it was noticeable that after a few perfunctory thanks and a couple of claps on the shoulder, the dwarf was left behind as the Hobbits went off to celebrate the safe recovery of little Ivy. Because he was close to the back of the group-though still included-Bilbo saw Thorin’s shoulders slump and his head bow for a moment before he erected his practiced facade and made his way back to the forge. An unfamiliar pang of guilt shot through Bilbo then, for Thorin did seem to be very alone. Even in a Company of dwarves, Bilbo was welcomed by Bofur and Ori and Balin, who tucked him under their wings and reassured him even when Thorin was being a complete arse. But Thorin had no one and Hobbits were even more insular and slow to trust. 

 

Watching the retreating figure, Bilbo pondered that maybe was part of the reason he had been so hurt. He had trusted Thorin-not once but twice. The first time was, of course, when their friendship developed after the Carrock and the dwarf King had opened his heart and shared with the Hobbit. It had been flattering especially to be included in every part of Thorin’s life. The boys had loved it, already jokingly calling him Uncle Bilbo to the growling disapproval of their real Uncle. And they had grown closer, especially in Mirkwood where Bilbo has spent a fair few nights sitting by Thorin’s cell, talking to the dwarf and trying to stop him sinking into depression at his own failure and stupidity. Thorin was prone to blame himself and brood-Bofur had joking referred to him as ‘his Royal Broodiness’ back in Erebor-and Bilbo had realised that a long life filled with hardships, disasters and failures had scarred the King more than he would reveal even to his own kin. Bilbo was certain that Dis knew-she had asked him to watch over her ‘idiot brother’ when they had married-but even Thorin was bad at acknowledging his own self-loathing. It was obvious that the King had relied on Bilbo’s visits to keep his spirits up enough to endure the captivity. And when they had escaped, there had been another of those warm, all-encompassing hugs and the whispered words ‘thank you’ in Bilbo’s ear. And he had felt then that he would do anything for Thorin if he could stop him falling so low again.

 

But then there had been Erebor and that immense treasure, infected by the bile and greed of Smaug that had afflicted all of his dwarves-but Thorin fastest and far the worst of all. And Bilbo had been conflicted because he knew and trusted that Thorin would not hurt him-but he could not  get through to the dwarf he was growing to love and could see him sinking further away. And perhaps he had been foolish, trusting a mentally-ill dwarf not to lash out but he had trusted Thorin-and his violent reaction to finding out that Bilbo had taken the Arkenstone had shattered Bilbo’s trust. Hanging over the ramparts, the hatred and fury in Thorin’s eyes had been terrifying and Bilbo had been shaking as he had clambered down the rope to return to Gandalf.

 

But he had still cared for Thorin and when the Battle came upon them-a Battle Bilbo’s treason had failed to prevent, though he had stopped the forces of Men, Elves and Dwarves from destroying each other before the orcs arrived-he had plunged in to try to protect his friends. And racing up to Ravenhill, feeling as if his heart would burst, he had found them fighting. Fili and Kili were badly wounded, possibly dying and Dwalin was fighting half an army of goblin mercenaries on his own as Thorin battled Azog. And as Bilbo watched, he saw his dwarf go down, injured and exhausted. And his heart had almost stopped as he watched Thorin pull his sword away and allow Azog to strike a lethal blow to allow him his own chance to finally kill the murderer of his grandfather, brother and father-and possibly his nephews and himself. Azog had died and Bilbo had been almost too late, saying his farewell but flagging down the eagles. And when Thorin had been saved, Bilbo had stayed. He had accepted Thorin’s heartfelt apologies and assurances that the Dragon Sickness was gone. And Thorin had never given him any reason to doubt…until the day that he had confronted Bilbo into front of the Council. And then, hurt and angry, Bilbo had realised his trust had been misplaced and he had walked away.

 

He glanced in the direction that Thorin had vanished. The hurt was still bubbling there, anger at being betrayed once more. Yet Thorin had never renounced his love and had intended his banishment to be temporary. And before, he had allowed his friendship and concern for his dwarf to take him to Thorin’s side in the Battle. This time, he had allowed anger to rule because he had not perceived any danger to the King and he had walked away. And in doing so, he had given up on their friendship as well as their marriage. 

 

Then Bilbo shook himself. Thorin’s lack of trust had shattered everything and this time, Bilbo could not expose himself once more. He would have to harden his heart to the dwarf and realise that any solitude and isolation was Thorin’s choice. He would not be so unhappy himself if he had been a proper Hobbit and had not trusted the King a second time.

 

But there was that little pang of guilt that jabbed him every time he saw Thorin either in Bywater Market or at any of the many gatherings and events that took place that summer. Thorin attended many of them, always at the back, usually alone and always gazing at Bilbo with undisguised longing and sorrow in his eyes. It began to irritate the Hobbit because he was worried that some of his more astute relatives would realise that there was something between Bilbo and ‘Master Lulkhel’ the dwarf blacksmith. Honestly, Bilbo wanted to go and yell at him sometimes but Hobbits were generous hosts and it wasn’t done for guests to argue. Even if one of them was largely unwanted and isolated.

 

Gardenia Proudfoot made sure she continued to spread rumours about Thorin which didn’t help him either. Whenever word got round that he was helpful or generous or that he had performed some useful local service, she would launch a fresh set of rumours about his dishonourable conduct and that would scupper any chances of acceptance. The fact that she was now walking out with Jumbo Freshfield didn’t seem to dampen her vindictiveness against the dwarf who had rejected her and Bilbo found himself feeling sorry for Thorin. He had been the subject of enough rumours in Erebor to know how unpleasant it was to have everyone gossiping about you but at least he had his friends there to comfort him. Thorin endured alone. 

 

So against his better judgement, he had travelled down to the forge one evening, knowing that Thorin didn’t rent a smial or room in the Green Dragon Inn. Almost turning round three times, he had finally made it to the door and had rapped on the wood firmly. 

 

There had been nothing for a long moment and Bilbo had almost turned away before he heard the bolt slide back and the door open. Thorin had looked out for a blank moment before he tried to control his surprise. He had unconsciously smiled as well.

 

“Bilbo…I mean, Master Baggins…” he said, his deep voice betraying his shock. “To what do I owe this honour?” Bilbo shuffled his feet. Thorin had shed his tunic and was only in a loose shirt and his leather trousers, his heavy boots of course ever-present. He looked tired and worn to Bilbo’s eyes.

 

“I brought you…” He gestured to his basket. Thorin gave a small smile.

 

“Food?” he checked. Bilbo rolled his eyes. 

 

“This is just food. No ulterior motive or meaning. It is not a proposal or offer or anything. Are we clear?” he said firmly. Thorin nodded.

 

“Perfectly,” he said and accepted the basket. “Thank you. I…”

 

“Enjoy,” Bilbo said and turned away. He heard Thorin’s sharp intake of breath.

 

“You aren’t going to stay?” he asked, the hope in his voice painful.

 

“I think not,” Bilbo said firmly. “Think of this as a thanks for the flowers.”

 

Thorin’s face closed and he lifted his chin regally.

 

“They required no repayment,” he said stiffly. “It was the only way I could talk to you.” He swallowed. “I assume this is not a reply.” Bilbo shook his head.

 

“Enjoy the food,” he said quietly and turned and walked away. 

 

That night, he found himself unable to sleep, the expression on Thorin’s face haunting him. There had been an instant when he had made clear that he wasn’t making any time to spend with the dwarf that the hope in Thorin’s eyes had vanished and a flash of pain had replaced it-before the mask was back up. He knew that Thorin was isolated and even letters delivered by raven were poor substitute for time spent in the company of someone agreeable. And memories surfaced, of nights spent by the fire, Thorin exhausted after a day of meetings and dealing with the complaints of his people but able to relax in the company of the one he loved. And there had been times spent with the Company or with Thorin’s family, the Princes goofing around and Dis smiling at their antics…and even Tauriel smiling serenely as she watched her love banter with his brother. It was relaxed and warm and homely…and Bilbo still missed it. But Thorin didn’t even have the comfort of family as Bilbo did and he could not tell anyone who he was or why he was in the Shire. For whatever reason he had deemed that the penance of isolation, worsened by seeing the One he loved who had rejected him over and again, was the correct one for his transgression. And Bilbo’s private anger at his perceived wrongs had him maintaining the distance, even when his heart was screaming for him to offer an olive branch to the lonely King. So he tossed and turned and sleep eluded him until the dawn was already warming the sky.

 

In the morning, the basket was waiting on his doorstep, the plates scrubbed clean and neatly stacked within. A small bunch of rosemary, sweet woodruff and willow and a single deep crimson rose was resting by it. Bilbo rubbed his aching head and snatched the basket, resting the bunch on the table and wondered what he could do. He could ask the Thain, his cousin Fortinbras, to ask Thorin to leave the Shire but there was something that was stopping him. His presence made Bilbo uncomfortable because Bilbo was feeling guilty, not because he was going anything threatening. Though a bouquet saying ‘remembrance, humility, sadness and mourning’ was a good way to make the Hobbit feel worse. After all, Thorin had banished Bilbo when all Bilbo had done was plot and plan to recover his lost ancestor to bring honour to his Kingdom. And he had listened to scurrilous gossip that had impugned Bilbo’s character when he would never betray his husband…

 

But Thorin had never renounced his marriage. He had remained married to Bilbo despite the rumours, despite the facts that-apparently-half of the mountain was laughing at him for being cuckolded. It had been Bilbo who had rejected Thorin and stormed off, leaving the mountain without a further word to his husband, despite the pleas of the Princes. Bofur had seemed concerned that it was Bilbo who had done the rejecting and Bilbo muttered a generic curse against all things dwarvish for their ridiculous secrecy. The only dwarf in more than two hundred miles was the subject of Bilbo’s ire and there was precisely no chance that the Hobbit could walk up to his former husband and ask what it was that he was missing. 

 

‘Remembrance, humility, sadness, mourning.’ 

 

Thorin wasn’t known to be eloquent but the bunch of vegetation spoke of a wounded heart, mourning his marriage and begging for another chance. The fact he was remaining as a poor smith in the Shire, alone and isolated, spoke volumes of his resolve. He was the most stubborn dwarf Bilbo had met-but the Hobbit knew that he was Thorin’s equal and he would not surrender so weakly. And what had Thorin shown him that could persuade Bilbo to trust him again? What had he shown Bilbo at all, except his willingness to step back from the trappings of royalty, by leaving the Kingdom he had dreamed of regaining for 170 years and all his family behind? He had not spoken of their shared past, not even used his own name and he was isolated and clearly finding it hard. So why didn’t he just go home? Why did he insist in tormenting himself?

 

But after that morning, here were no more bouquets. 

 

Summer peaked with a run of weddings and Thorin lurked at the back, nursing an ale and being perfectly polite to anyone who approached. A few daring Hobbit lasses asked him to dance and he gravely obliged, attempting not to tread on any feet and being quietly laughed at by the watching Hobbits for his ignorance of their customs, dances and celebrations. Bilbo watched, feeling guilty but not enough walk forward to rescue Thorin’s dignity. But the dwarf was useful for breaking up any scuffles between drunken Hobbits and Bilbo guessed he was asked to come along for that reason alone. But he never approached Bilbo, seeming content to watch the Hobbit as he laughed with his relatives and danced when the music started.

 

The harvest started and suddenly days were long and the population were all occupied in getting food in for the winter. Bilbo’s garden was productive and he began to harvest his own produce, setting to work baking and drying but also pickling and preserving where he could. He got up early and picked blackberries by the basketful, for he loved the fruit and knew it was one of Thorin’s favourites…and then he shook himself. It was foolish to waste free bounty because it reminded him of his former husband. So he harvested to keep busy and restocked his pantry once more.

 

The West Farthing Harvest Show was a grand affair and almost everyone entered something in one of the categories. Bilbo’s tomatoes won as he had hoped and he got an honourable mention for his squash and cucumbers, though he was delighted that Hamfast won both categories. Bilbo’s lemon and thyme cake was also a winner as expected and he felt a surge of pride at the congratulations of the many Hobbits who approached him as the champion. Thorin hung back, though he bowed his head when Bilbo looked up and the Hobbit favoured him with a happy smile.  Looking around, Bilbo saw that Thorin had also won a prize for a beautiful set of garden tools he had made and looked around for his dwarf to offer his congratulations but he seemed to have vanished. He only saw him again when the winning exhibits were being auctioned off to fund the Benevolent Fund for Elderly Hobbits, a group who visited elderly and lonely Hobbits in the winter. Thorin bought both of Bilbo’s winning lots, paying well over the odds. That had Bilbo thinking, for Thorin had worked hard and had few expenses-not that he was short of money. He was the King of Erebor, the richest Kingdom on Arda. But the thought that Thorin had been determined to own his produce had him confused. Thorin didn't even like vegetables and would discreetly push tomatoes to the side of his plate in Erebor. It made little sense.

 

Harvest was over and the last days of summer started to fade into the warm days of early autumn when a letter arrived from Fili. Bilbo had been shocked at the sleek raven tapping its beak patiently at his kitchen window but he was well-enough versed in raven post to let it in, thank it for its efforts and feed it a bowl of meat and sausage pieces before collecting his letters. Then he sat in the parlour with nice cup of tea, a warmed cheese scone and read his letter.

 

Dear Bilbo,

 

It was good to hear from you once more. I am so glad your tomatoes won their class as you expected. I had every faith that you would succeed again (Kili bet against you! But Tauriel was on your side.). 

 

I know that you mentioned Thorin was in the Shire. Have you spoken to him yet? You haven’t mentioned anything since that first letter and that gives me cause for concern. We know how stubborn and stupid Uncle can be but none of us doubts his love for you. Your rejection is incredibly painful for him and in the end, he had to come after you. I hope you have patched things up because he is not a young dwarf and his time is limited.

 

Erebor prospers. Kili and Tauriel are still planning their wedding and Amad is interfering as usual. It will be a long time before she feels able to step back but at least Kili and Tauriel talk so of there is any point of contention, they decide between themselves and provide a unified front to Amad. Ori sends his love-he and Dwalin are still courting but everyone is starting to bet when Dwalin will make his proposal gift. If it’s not soon, I fear Dori may threaten Dwalin!

 

Please come back and visit us. All the Lords have been shut up-Uncle banished half of them in the months after you left and was like a warg with a sore paw. I hope he’s calmed down now he’s closer to you.

 

Please be kind to Uncle. It’s hard to give your whole heart to someone and have them then reject it.

 

Your friend,

Fili.

 

Bilbo snorted. Fili was far more sober than he had been on the Quest, the combination of surviving being impaled in Azog’s blade and a fall that should have killed or crippled him coupled with three years of observing the job of King making him grow up. He was still warm and had a wicked sense of fun but he was also more adult at times. And this seemed to be one. It implied that Thorin wasn’t writing home and Bilbo sighed. He would have to seek to the dwarf again.

 

A series of thunderstorms confined him to the Hill and Hobbiton for a few days and when he made his move, the autumn rains had set in. The temperature had dropped and the breezes had begun to lash the trees. The leaves were starting to look tired and everything was looking grey and washed out. In a break between the showers, Bilbo trudged along the muddy roads to Bywater and rapped on the Forge. Thorin opened the door, controlling his face and bowing slightly.

 

“Master Baggins,” he said formally. “How may I be of service?” Bilbo sighed and huddled in he shade of the roof, for it was beginning to spit.

 

“Have you written to your family since you arrived?” he demanded. Thorin’s brows dipped and he scowled.

 

“I  have had no news to given to them,” he said flatly. 

 

“They worry about you!” Bilbo argued, trying to hold onto his temper. This was the downside of knowing Thorin: the stubbornness and the way he stated something as if it was the end of the argument, not a starting point.

 

“I am aware of that.”

 

“And I am sure they miss you,” Bilbo said, pulling his collar up. It was drizzling now. Thorin stepped back and gestured to invite him in. Cautious, he advanced only so he was just inside the open doorway, with Thorin standing back in the gloom.

 

“And I miss my sister and my sister-sons,” the King said quietly. “I will miss them for the rest of my life. But they understand why I have to be here.”

 

“And why do you have to be here?” Bilbo demanded angrily. Thorin blinked and tried to look reasonable.

 

“Because you are here, of course,” he said as if it was obvious.

 

“But you have a home and a family in Erebor!” the Hobbit protested.

 

“And a One who resides in the Shire,” the dwarf told him. 

 

“A One who you banished!” Bilbo sniped. Thorin thinned his lips and took a slow breath through his nose.

 

“You banishment and that of the Family Ur was rescinded,” he said impatiently. “You may return to Erebor whenever you wish.”

 

“And when was I supposed to learn of that?” he asked. Thorin looked exasperated.

 

“I would have thought you would understand when Ori wrote to you of the success of your scheme,” he said. “When I found out what you had been doing…and understood why you did not wish to share details of your meetings with Bofur…” 

 

Bilbo saw red.

 

“So that is the reason why you are here?” he snarled. “Guilt because you realised you made a mistake? Nothing about realising that it was your lack of trust that would have driven me away, no matter what you decreed! And you don’t realise what you did.” Thorin gave a bitter laugh.

 

“Oh, I realise,” he said bluntly. “I realise that my jealousy about my husband drove you away. I realise that my stupidity led the One I love, my heart, to leave me. I realise that I was already blessed to be given a second chance after my unforgivable behaviour on the ramparts and I threw that away in my pride. And I realise that living in Erebor without you isn’t an option. If you were a dwarf, you would understand.”

 

“But I am not a dwarf!” Bilbo yelled. “You keep saying this. Bofur did the same thing when I spoke to him and…” Thorin froze.

 

“You discussed our situation with him?” he asked in a freezing voice. 

 

“Well, no one explains anything and you dwarves never talk about your Ones or culture or anything that may make sense!” Bilbo shouted. “Bofur is my friend! Of course I asked him because he was the only dwarf I knew I could talk to about it.”

 

Thorin flinched and looked as if someone had just stabbed him.

 

“I see,” he said in a strangled voice. “I understand. I apologise. But you shouldn’t worry about me, Master Baggins. I will endeavour not to trouble you for the remainder of my time here.”

 

“You’re impossible!” Bilbo snapped. “Just write to your family!” Then he turned and walked out into the rain to begin the muddy walk home. Thorin leaned against the wall, his arms folded across his chest, trying to ignore the pain. 

 

“I have no need,” he said quietly, “because when the time comes, they will learn of my fate from you.” And then he slammed the door against the storm.

Notes:

A/N: I know our heroes are behaving like idiots. Both are stubborn and proud. And both have reasons that to them seem perfectly reasonable and will become evident as we go on. But yes, they are behaving like idiots...

Chapter 6: Nothing Left

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

SIX: Nothing Left

 

Bilbo saw almost nothing of Thorin as autumn progressed. He studiously avoided Bywater and stuck to Hobbiton market. The few fine days, he walked in another direction as he rambled and went to visit his cousins in Tuckborough and Buckland for periods of a few weeks. And then it was the run up towards Yule, a time of baking, of invitations, of buying and making and wrapping presents and of decorating Bag End for the guests he was expecting.

 

He wrote to Fili and recounted the conversation with Thorin, expressing his frustration at Thorin’s intransigence and his own confusion what he was doing in the Shire still. It was obvious he was not welcomed as he should have been and was isolated and alone. His reasoning made no sense to Bilbo, an ignominious action from one of the greatest Kings in Middle Earth. But he was still waiting for an answer when Bofur, Bifur, Bombur and family arrived for the Yule season, moving in and bringing cheer and warmth to Bilbo’s home. Hamfast and Belle came over and the six days of the Yule Festival-which culminated in the two days of Yule itself-were filled with warmth, good cheer and laughter. The weather was icy and fresh though snow was expected around the new year. Other relatives visited over the holidays, meeting Bilbo’s dwarves and sharing meals, drinks and Yule cheer.

 

On the morning of the second day of Yule-the first day of the New Year-Bilbo was sipping his morning cup of tea and enjoying a few moments of peace and quiet before the guests awoke and began to fill the smial with chaos once more when he heard a heavy thumping on the door. Muttering, he tightened the belt of his trusty dressing gown and opened the door-to find Thorin standing there. The dwarf looked pale and thinner than Bilbo remembered but he was dressed in his fur-trimmed coat and he bowed regally. Bilbo frowned.

 

“Thorin!” he exclaimed. “What are you doing here?” A pang of guilt washed over him simultaneously for he had quite forgotten Thorin among the busyness of the holidays. He had forgotten that Thorin was alone-but then, he could not invite the dwarf over since Bofur would hardly welcome the King who exiled him from the mountain he had helped reclaim. The dwarf looked pained. 

 

“I came to wish you a good New Year, Master Baggins,” he said quietly. Then he fumbled under his coat and brought out a bouquet-but it was not made of vegetation. The flowers, perfectly rendered and delicately detailed to perfection, were all made of iron and copper. A metal ribbon apparently held them together, though delicate welding actually achieved the aim. There were veins on the petals and leaves and small thorns on the stems of the roses. The dwarf held it out to him. “There are no flowers this time of year,” he added.

 

Bilbo reached out and took the gift. It was cold, for it was freezing outside, but he saw delicately rendered roses and salvia, both tinted with a reddish hue and the unmistakeable shapes of heliotrope. He opened his mouth but Thorin was quicker.

 

“You are well?” he asked, his voice hesitant. Bilbo nodded. 

 

“Um, yes. Fine. You know me. Unless I’m hanging off a barrel racing down rapids with elves and dwarves and orcs fighting all around me, I never sicken,” he said with a small smile. Thorin nodded. 

 

“I am glad,” he said, looking awkward. Bilbo glanced around.

 

“I would invite you in but…well, Bofur and his family are staying…” he said.

 

“And I would not be a welcome guest,” Thorin rumbled, nodding. “I understand. I wish you well, Master Baggins.” Bilbo nodded and gestured.

 

“Um yes. Thank you for the bouquet-it really is splendid. It must have taken you ages…” he babbled, feeling there was something he was missing. Thorin nodded.

 

“You should know that there is nothing I would not do for you,” he said honestly.

 

“Except trust me,” Bilbo snarked, regretting it the moment the words left his mouth. Thorin nodded.

 

“I trust you implicitly,” the King said. “I always did. I just wish I could take back those words, wish that my mind had been clear and my pride less overweening on that day. But I am who I am and I am a son of the Line of Durin. I know Fili will make a better King than I ever could be.”

 

“Thorin-go home,” Bilbo said in exasperation. “You’re only torturing yourself here. There’s nothing here for you.” Giving a smile that was entirely fake, the King nodded.

 

“I know that, Master Baggins,” he said with a sigh. “But for me, there is no choice.”

 

“Then have a good New Year as well,” Bilbo said and reached for the door.

 

“I doubt if I have one good year left in me but…thank you,” the dwarf said, then turned away. His shoulders looked slumped but he still strode proudly down the frosty lane, his breath coming in little clouds as he retreated. Sighing, Bilbo closed the door and returned to his tea, which was cold, But he looked at the beautiful flowers that Thorin had made, a bold declaration that even the dumbest Hobbit could read: I love you, forever mine and eternal love and devotion. He shook his head as Bofur ambled in, his hat still jammed on his head and his clothes rumpled.

 

“Was there someone here?” he asked tiredly. “I thought I heard voices….” Bilbo poured him a fresh cup of tea and nodded.

 

“Thorin came to the door,” he said honestly. “But I sent him away.”

 

“What did he…?” Bofur asked, frowning.

 

“He came to wish me a Happy New Year,” he admitted. “And he gave me those…” He gestured to the iron flowers. Bofur stared and whistled through his teeth.

 

“That is masterful work,” he commented. Bilbo nodded, pouring his own tea and sat opposite, placing a plate of scones and a pot of jam on the table.

 

“I thought it was very good,” he acknowledged.

 

“No-that is the work of a Master Craftsman,” Bofur repeated. “There were rumours that Thorin had completed a Mastery in weapons crafting but it looks like he’s an Iron Master.”

 

“And that’s a good thing?”

 

“It’s rare and unique among the Royals,” Bofur commented. “They all tended to focus in jewellery and gold but there were rumours that even when he much younger, Thorin was terrified of Dragon Sickness and would never consider any Mastery but iron.” Bilbo stared at it.

 

“It is a declaration of love,” he said as Bofur frowned. 

 

“You are his One,” he said. “Just as Milania is mine. I have made my proposal gift to give her when I get back to Ered Luin.”

 

“And you better write to me as soon as you propose and tell me what she says!” Bilbo told him eagerly, banishing the unease in his stomach and the sense of guilt he felt. He had undervalued what a dwarf would recognise as being a peerless gift, dismissing it like any other mathom. But it was clear it was something that Thorin had poured his heart and soul into. He would have to go down the next day and thank the dwarf properly for his thoughtful and magnificent gift. Then he turned his attention back to his guest and continued his breakfast.

 

But the next day, blizzards struck, trapping the Hobbits in their homes for eight days and blanketing the Shire in waist-high snows. Trapped in their homes, families huddled together and made the best of it, eating leftovers and scrounging what food they could. Younger able-bodied Hobbits went out once the storms had finished to help the Shirriffs to dig out the roads under crystal blue skies. And as they came round, Bilbo treated them to warm drinks and biscuits he had baked. It was no hardship since Bilbo had stocked both his pantries to the brim before Yule and still had plenty.The Shirriffs were grateful and shared the news. No one had died though there were a number of colds and several Hobbits had slipped and sprained various limbs. The Green Dragon was full of stranded Hobbits-so full they had turned away the dwarf blacksmith who had come looking for a room when the blizzards started. Bilbo frowned and felt his sense of unease and guilt flare up accompanied by something that he never thought he would feel so strongly against his own people. Balin and Dis had told of the way the dwarves had been treated by the other races after the fall of Erebor, how they had been driven out and excluded, to face the cold and hunger and wild animals on their own. How Thorin had not forgiven Thranduil for not helping the dwarves as they fled Erebor and for driving them from the borders of Mirkwood as well. But for his own people to turn away Thorin from a warm Inn in a blizzard…

 

“Bloody Gardenia Proudfoot,” he muttered. “I know exactly why they thought it was acceptable to  turn someone away. And he lives in that forge-with only thin boards between him and the weather.” The he looked at the Shiriff. “Are the roads open to Bywater?”

 

“They will be, Master Baggins,” Gordo Turnberry confirmed, handing back his now empty mug of tea. “I wouldn’t advise travel…” Bilbo stared into his face.

 

“You don’t understand,” he said firmly. “They turned him away.”

 

“The dwarf?”

 

“He lives in the forge,” Bilbo said angrily. “He was freezing and he sought warmth. And we turned him away. What kind of hosts are we?”

 

“Well, the Green Dragon was packed…”

 

“And there wasn’t room for one more-even just to sit by the fire and not freeze to death?” he snapped. “Yavanna! I never thought I would see the day when Hobbit hospitality failed and condemned someone to freeze!”

 

“But it’s only a dwarf…” Gordo said.

 

“He’s my friend!” Bilbo blurted out. “And I need to check he is alright.” The Shirriff frowned. 

 

“I know Regimund Overton and his patrol are over Bywater way,” he said. “If you need any help, they will be available.” Bilbo nodded his thanks, guilt and concern roiling in his stomach. The roads were still too bad for the dwarves to return to Ered Luin but at least he knew they were safe in Bag End. Absently, he washed the mug up, found his warmest coat and cloak, wrapped a scarf around his neck and ears and mittens on his hands. And then he loaded his pack with a couple of warm blankets, a flask of hot tea and some bread and pies. Without pausing, he headed out and began the walk to Bywater. 

 

In fact, the roads were much better than he had hoped and there was a cleared path all the way to Bywater Market-but the Forge was still half-buried in snowdrifts and Bilbo stared in despair. Until he recalled Gordo's words and went looking for the Shiriffs and some of the volunteers. Shortly afterwards, the Hobbits dug their way to the door of the Forge and Bilbo hammered on the door.

 

There was no answer.

 

Hammering and cursing. Bilbo finally realised that the door wasn’t locked and managed to get the swollen wood open enough to slide though-and then he paused. The space was cold and his breath continued to come in clouds as he cast around, seeing a humped shape at the back of the forge. Kicking the door open a little more to allow more light in, he realised the shape was a dwarf, huddled on a low cot with blankets and his coat on top. It was Thorin.

 

He ran forward and then crouched. Pausing, he leaned closer.

 

“Thorin!” he hissed then shook the huddled shape. “THORIN!”

 

A horrible hacking cough was the only reply as blue eyes fluttered open, glassy with fever but Thorin’s brow furrowed and his lips parted in a slight smile.

 

“Bilbo,” he whispered, his voice hoarse. Moving so some of the cold light lit his face, Bilbo realised that the dwarf King looked terrible. He had lost weight and was so ashen he was almost grey-except for the red spots on his cheeks. There were deep shadows under his eyes and his hair was stringy and lank. He had cut his beard so it was as short as when he had been on the Quest. 

 

A sign of grief or shame…

 

“Thorin,” the Hobbit whispered and rested a hand on his forehead. “Yavanna-you’re burning up.”

 

“I am well,” Thorin rasped, the words deteriorating into a horrible hacking cough that left him gasping for breath. 

 

“You can’t stay here," Bilbo said, casting around.

 

“It’s alright,” the dwarf said hesitantly, lying back and smiling. “I wish I could take back my words from that day and from the ramparts. I wish I could be worthy of the trust you gave me. But I am only…a foolish old dwarf who still struggles from Dragon Sickness…and is terrified that he has lost his One. But perhaps this is for the best. Perhaps this is just the death I escaped on Ravenhill.” He closed his eyes. “Go home, Bilbo. Leave me to go home…”

 

“No,” the Hobbit said. “No-you’re coming with me.” He stroked the hair off Thorin’s face and felt the dwarf’s face press briefly against his palm. Thorin’s lips were cracked and dry and his eyes sunken as he looked up wearily. 

 

“If you wish, Amrâlimê,” he rasped and tried to sit up. Bilbo looked round to the Shirriffs as the dwarf slumped back, another bout of coughing racking his shape. 

 

“Get a cart!” he called. “We have to get him up to my home!”

 

“But he’s a dwarf!” one protested.

 

“And he is my friend!” Bilbo snapped, feeling a weight lift from his chest at the words. He had been stubborn-far too stubborn. And he had been cruel to his friend, cutting him off and isolating him because he had been hurt by Thorin’s words and actions well over a year ago. He knew that Thorin was sad, alone, sorry. He had humbled himself, living as a poor smith among Hobbits, experiencing the isolation that Bilbo had felt among dwarves-but without the Company who had supported and helped Bilbo. The Hobbits had gossiped about Thorin, treated him as an outsider and rejected him when he desperately needed their help-while Bilbo had been at least respected as one of the heroes who had regained Erebor. 

 

I doubt I have one good year left in me…

 

“You listen to me, Thorin Oakenshield!” Bilbo hissed. “You are not going to die on me, you hear? I will kill you if you leave me after this ridiculous overdramatic nonsense!”

 

But Thorin had lost consciousness, his rasping breathing too fast for Bilbo’s liking. It took three Hobbits to half-drag the dwarf to a waiting cart. Bilbo piled the blankets over him as well as his coat and the spare blankets he had packed. Then he cast around and grabbed Thorin’s meagre pack, Orcrist and his knives, which were resting neatly against the wall and the tin box containing his money-which Bilbo could barely lift. Once they were all in the cart, two burly Shiriffs willingly hauled it through the cleared roads and up towards Hobbiton and the Hill. Closing the door to the Forge, Bilbo stared at it and wondered if he had waited, if it would have become Thorin’s tomb.

 

The journey took entirely too long for Bilbo’s liking and Thorin remained unconscious throughout. Bifur and Bofur were in the parlour when Bilbo arrived and despite everything that had happened, it took little persuading for them to lift the ailing King and carry him into Bilbo’s bedroom. Both looked grim but neither argued as the Hobbit placed Thorin’s packs and possessions in the cloak area and gave the King his own bed. Thorin was mumbling, his skin scorching and coughs wracking his form. Immediately, Bilbo set to work brewing willowbank tea and mint and menthol poultices to wrap around his chest. He bathed Thorin’s forehead with cold compresses and dribbled water over his cracked lips. Bombur took over cooking duties, making warming stews and casseroles while Bilbo continued nursing his former husband. Day and night, Bilbo left him for only the most basic of functions, making do with a quick wash in the sink and a change of clothes. He slept in the chair and was ever-present to see to Thorin’s needs, no matter how long it took.

 

After three days and nights, his fever was a little lower. Belle Gamgee had been to fetch Hibiscus Underhill, the best herbalist in the West Farthing and she had agreed with his actions, while giving him additional teas for the chest infection and pain and a linctus for the dwarf’s raw throat. 

 

“Care and consideration is what he needs,” she advised. “Everyone needs someone and he is alone here.” But after she had gone, Bilbo gently wiped Thorin’s face and leaned closer.

 

“I’m not allowing you to die,” Bilbo told the unconscious dwarf. “I am not having to explain to Dis how I let you die from neglect when you were telling me you needed me. And I was too stubborn and angry to see or hear it. I really have spend far too long with dwarves. I have quite forgotten how to be a Hobbit.”

 

“Saved…me…” Thorin rasped, his eyes opening a slit. He was still struggling to breathe and he still looked awful. “They turned me away…” Bilbo groaned.

 

“I am so sorry…” he whispered, catching Thorin’s scorching hand and squeezing it. The dwarf squeezed back, his expression peaceful.

 

“I am old and cannot endure the Rejection,” he said haltingly, another bout of coughing robbing him of his air. 

 

“What rejection?” Bilbo asked, his mind sliding back to their first conversation in the Shire…

 

“Go home, Thorin. There is nothing for you here.”

 

“Younger dwarrow…can survive the pain of Rejection by their Ones…but I am not strong enough…” the dwarf managed. “I lived most of my life without my heart. The time with you as my One was my happiest…” Bilbo leaned forward, curling his hand behind Thorin’s neck and leaned his forehead against the dwarf King’s.

 

“Why didn’t you tell me?” he whispered. “Why didn’t you trust me?”

 

“I did,” Thorin breathed. “But I…did not want…you to feel you had to accept me…through guilt. I love you. I said…there was nothing I would not do for you. Including…dying…”

 

“I don’t want you to die, you ridiculous dwarf,” Bilbo muttered. 

 

“There was nothing for me. You rejected me. No love. No friendship. You avoided all contact. You rejected my advances and my attempts to communicate. I could not survive that.”

 

“You kept hinting…and of course, no one else of your ludicrous, stupid, self-important, we’re-so-secretive race would tell me either!” Bilbo snapped, keeping his forehead pressed against the dwarf’s. The close contact seemed to be helping Thorin’s breathing.

 

“Pain was easier…when I was closer to you…” Thorin admitted. “So I was going to spend whatever time I had…here…”

 

“You idiot,” Bilbo groaned. “Why did no one tell me about this?”

 

“Because I am…a fool…” Thorin murmured, savouring the contact. “And it was shameful. Only the…worst of dwarves are rejected by their Ones.” Bilbo sighed.

 

“You are far from the worst, Thorin,” he told the dwarf.

 

“But I tried to kill you,” Thorin whispered. “I did not trust you. I threw away our love. I deserve this.”

 

“You were jealous…possessive…and you over-reacted,” Bilbo murmured. “I should have seen it before. I am so sorry. You still have it, don’t you?”

 

Thorin closed his eyes.

 

“Yes,” he murmured. Bilbo pulled back and rested his hand against Thorin’s hollow cheek.

 

“And here?” he asked. The King exhaled and shook his head slightly.

 

“My mind is as clear as it was on the Quest,” he admitted and gave in to a bout of coughing. Bilbo helped him take a few sips of water and another glass of cold willowbank tea. 

 

“Rest,” the Hobbit told him, seeing his eyes already closing. “I will be here.”

 

But Thorin was already asleep.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Amrâlimê - my love

Chapter 7: A Few Truths

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

SEVEN: A Few Truths

 

He found Bofur in the kitchen, pouring himself an ale and Bilbo declined the offer in favour of a nice cup of tea. The miner was smiling but there was a vague shadow in his clear brown gaze and Bilbo found himself feeling guilty for bringing Thorin into Bag End…even though he had no options. Silently, he sat opposite his friend at the table and waited for Bofur to speak. He wasn’t usually shy in expressing his opinion but Bilbo knew he had been put in a very difficult position.

 

“I don’t blame you,” Bofur said at last, his tone thoughtful. “You couldn’t leave him to die any more than I could.” He sighed. 

 

“I know,” the Hobbit admitted. “I knew something was wrong-I could feel it.” He unconsciously laid his hand flat on his chest. “All through the blizzards, I knew I needed to get out there…” The dwarf inspected him slowly, his eyes sad.

 

“You still love him,” he realised. Bilbo sipped his tea.

 

“I think I have some oat and raisin biscuits in the pantry,” he said and made to rise. Bofur exhaled slowly and watched him. Bilbo was a brave and generous friend but sometimes, he was rather slow to acknowledge what was there. So he watched as the Hobbit carefully arranged biscuits on the plate and came back, resting it down on the table. Then he sat down again. Bofur sipped his ale and watched his friend. 

 

“I guess that means you’re not really ready to talk…” he commented. But Bilbo sighed.

 

“I was furious at Thorin…and I am still a bit annoyed, to be honest,” he admitted, taking a biscuit and neatly snapping it in half. “The problem was never that I did not love him.”

 

“He’s Thorin Oakenshield,” Bofur grumbled. “Despite his looks, he has charisma by the bucketload, he cannot stop being a King no matter what he does. No one could take our eyes off him even when he was suicidally running at Azog after the Goblin Caves. Even my Mam never gave me a second look but Thorin Bloody Oakenshield commands every room he walks into. How could you not still have feelings for him?”

 

Bilbo rolled his eyes, then refilled his cup from the pot, dropping a spot of milk in and stirring carefully. He dunked the next half of his biscuit.

 

“You and the rest of the dwarves forgot to ask me what Hobbits do when they are in love,” he said testily. “You are always so keen to hint about your Ones-without explaining everything that I need to know. But Hobbit courting and marriage customs never featured. Not even Thorin asked and I was married to him.”

 

“Was? Past tense?”

 

Bilbo gave a sad smile.

 

“I left my wedding ring and my marriage bead behind,” he said. “As far as I was concerned, publicly humiliating me and declaring that he did not trust me was a statement that our union was over. So I left the symbols of our marriage behind and had to close my heart to him. You said I rejected him but there was nothing else I could do.”

 

“Do you know what Rejection means?” Bofur asked.

 

“No!” Bilbo snapped. “No I don’t because of your blasted secrecy!” The dwarf gave a groan and drained his ale. 

 

“Alright,”  he sighed. “I’m only telling you this because you are married to a dwarf and because you are a One.” Bilbo folded his arms and glared. “Being a dwarf who finds his One isn’t a simple business, Bilbo,” Bofur sighed. “It is a wondrous gift from Mahal, the most precious of all things a dwarf can own. Mahal crafted our Ones specially for us, the perfect partner who completes our heart and soul. But that isn’t just words-when a couple recognise the bond, especially when it is accepted and formalised, there is a physical change in both dwarrow as well. Their wellbeing is tied to the other and they are stronger and healthier together.”

 

“You mean you have to stay close or you become unwell?” Bilbo asked with a frown, wishing he had been told this before he married. 

 

“Not usually,” his friend told him, a small smile lifting his lips. “Dwarrow travel and sometimes, you have to be many leagues from your One. Perhaps for many months. But that love, that connection keeps you warm and fills you with hope and certainty that your One will come back, that you will be reunited… There are tales of dwarrow who knew the instant their One fell, when that connection was severed, even though they never knew of it at the time.”

 

Bilbo frowned.

 

“You mean magic?” he asked suspiciously. But Bofur gave a shrug. 

 

“It is the way we were created,” he said. “Just as dwarrow love only once and will never love again if they are rejected.” Then he pressed his lips together and looked unhappy.

 

“There’s more,” Bilbo realised.

 

“Normally, no dwarf would reject his One,” Bofur admitted. “He could be angry, they could argue, they could even separate but they would never reject the other because they know what it would do.”

 

“What would it do?” Bilbo’s tone was exasperated. 

 

“Rejecting your One would sever the bond and leave the separated partners in trouble,” Bofur said.

 

“He means that each would feel constant, searing pain in their heart that worsens the further you are from your One,” Bombur said, walking in and refilling his brother’s flagon of ale. He poured himself one and sat by Bofur. “It is a discussion that we all have with the StoneSeers prior to marriage.”

 

“Then why didn’t I get it?” Bilbo asked, feeling angry, hurt and bewildered. He had travelled halfway across the world, lived through every possible danger, almost got killed countless times, been cold, hungry and miserable, faced a dragon and fought a battle with his dwarves…but they still treated him as an outsider. Even when he married their King.

 

“Your face says you know why,” Bofur said in an apologetic voice. “StoneSeers will never even acknowledge an outsider. They are the most devout of Mahal's followers and interpreters of His Will.”

 

“And no one thought that quietly filling me in would be helpful. Maybe?” Bilbo asked sarcastically. 

 

“Maybe everyone else thought someone had done it,” Bombur offered.

 

“Certainly Thorin should have told you,” Bofur added shortly. Bilbo snorted.

 

“Not the best at explaining anything,” the Hobbit commented. “So being apart from Thorin after rejecting him causes him pain?” There was concern in his voice and the dwarven brothers shared a look.

 

“Not exactly,” Bofur said.

 

“Yes,” Bombur put in, elbowing him. “But more than that. A searing constant pain in the chest that is worse and worse the longer he is from the One he loved…and the further he is from him.” He shrugged. “I am astonished he lasted as long as he did.” Bilbo’s eyes widened.

 

“What does that mean?” he demanded. “And no more prevaricating. I’ve had it up to here with you clot-headed secretive mealy-mouthed dwarves! Explain it all. Clearly. Now!”

 

“When a dwarf is Rejected by his love, the bond with his One is cut,” Bofur explained. “You remember I said that dwarrow are stronger and healthier when they are with their Ones? The opposite is true. If a dwarf if rejected by his One, especially after he is married and their bond is formalised, then he suffers. There is the constant searing pain in the chest. There is the feeling of distress, loneliness and shame. Sleep becomes less restful and eventually the dwarf will be almost unable to get any rest. There will be nightmares and moodswings…” 

 

“Not that anyone could tell with certain dwarf Kings…” Bilbo muttered. Bombur gave him a severe look that caused him to snap his mouth shut and feel a little ashamed. Bombur was a quiet dwarf and was generally jolly as well-but he was also thoughtful and as a dwarf married for several decades with his beloved dwarflings, this was no joking matter to him. 

 

“And as time passes, the dwarf will weaken,” he continued, taking over from his brother. “In terms of strength but also in terms of will to live. He will become susceptible to illness and vulnerable to bandits and any of the normal dangers of life. His stamina will diminish and he will be unable to work. And finally, he will sicken and die.”

 

“WHAT?” Bilbo felt the world tilt around him.

 

“A young dwarf may be able to resist Rejection for many decades, though he would always bear the pain of rejection and, of course, he would never love again,” Bofur said. “But he could dedicate himself to his craft and for many, that would be enough to overcome the fading from rejection. They are always a little…odd…but some of the finest and most dedicated crafters in history have been rejected and choose to fill the gap with creating.”

 

“But an older dwarf like Thorin-especially one who has lived such a hard life-could never hope to survive Rejection,” Bombur added. “He would have known that, the moment you removed your Marriage Bead.”

 

“Then why did he banish me if he knew it would cause him so much pain?” Bilbo asked, his voice distressed.

 

“Because he is Thorin Oakenshield,” Bofur said. “The King.”

 

“And his damnable pride overrides everything that is of value in his life,” Bilbo said bitterly. “Our love, our marriage, the fact I would never knowingly hurt him…and yet, I end up doing it. The Crown meant more to him than his husband. The fact that people were laughing at him over a lie was more important than finding out the truth and caring for the one he loved. I bet he never even thought I would walk away, just sit there are take it like the lesser being I am…”

 

“Never…lesser…” Everyone looked up to see the sagging shape of Thorin leaning against the arch of the doorway into the kitchen. Bilbo started and stared at him, seeing the King’s face twisted with effort. Then he was up and at his dwarf’s side, helping Thorin into the chair he had just vacated.

 

“You should be in bed,” he told the ailing dwarf. 

 

“I think…this is more important,” Thorin said wearily. He still looked exhausted and gaunt, the shadows under his eyes dark like bruises. “Carry on. I think…I need to hear this…” Pulling up another chair, Bilbo perched on the cushion and exhaled in exasperation. “But the truth is, I never thought. I was angry and hurt…and foolish. Balin and the boys tried to stop me…but all I could see was the people of Erebor-and those Lords-laughing at me.”

 

“You know it was a lie, just malicious gossip…” Bilbo told him sharply. The King nodded, resting his hands flat on the table to steady himself.

 

“My heart knew that but my pride and honour…and all those worthless virtues…shouted louder,” he said miserably. “And my mind, clouded as it was…with residual Dragon Sickness, listened. My heart knew that my One-my fierce, sarcastic, brilliant, generous, kind, brave One-would never suffer such an insult without reacting…and I think I knew I would lose you. But it is what I have always deserved, since I held you over that drop and felt the overwhelming urge to kill you.” He lifted his chin. “You should never have forgiven me, Ghivashel. I never deserved it. And when we married, I always guessed…that I would do something heinous enough…to drive you away. I just hoped…that you would not suffer…as a dwarf would suffer from such a rejection.”

 

“You dwarves still know nothing about Hobbits,” Bilbo told him irritably. “All I’ve heard is about your Ones and how you manage to mess things up and have gotten yourself in such a pickle you are probably going to die from being Rejected. But no one has asked if I am alright or what happens with Hobbits. Because if you had, none of this would have happened at all!” The three dwarves frowned.

 

“What…do you mean?” Thorin asked hesitantly. He was trembling slightly and Bilbo had to stop himself from gasping his hand and giving a reassuring squeeze as his heart was telling him to.

 

“Hobbits are created by Yavanna, creatures of green growing fields and plants and earth and life,” he said. “They are not too different from you dwarves-who were created by Yavanna’s husband, Aüle-who you know as Mahal. We like food and family and good cheer. We value home and security. But you are creatures of stone and metal while we are softer. But another way we are similar is in that though we may have dalliances and fun when we are younger, we also only love once. And the one we love is called our Heart-Mate. No Hobbit could ever betray their Heart-Mate for another, no matter what inducements were offered. It doesn’t mean we don’t have close friends-Hobbits have huge extended families and very wide circles of friends and confidantes which is different to you secretive dwarves-but it does mean we would no more consider committing adultery than you would consider propositioning Thranduil.”

 

All three dwarves pulled a face that eloquently expressed their distaste of the very idea.

 

“You say it is very rare for a dwarf to be Rejected by his One,” Bilbo continued, now looking into Thorin’s eyes. “It is even rarer for a Hobbit. When a Hobbit loses his Heart-Mate, he fades. I watched it happen to my mother when my father died. She barely lasted a season, no longer wanting to go on without the other part of her Heart-and not even her son was enough to make her stay.” He paused and swallowed in grief at the words, then composed himself again. “And the only-the only way a Hobbit can stand a chance of avoiding that fate is to reject the bond and close their heart to the one they lost, almost as if they had never existed and certainly as if the relationship never was. And I did not want to fade, to die because of the stupidity and mistrust you showed me when I was innocent of everything you accused me of. So I rejected the bond, closed my heart to you and decided to survive, to go home and try to forget that I ever married the King of Erebor. But then, after not even communicating or offering any sort of apology, you just turned up here. Of course you never came to see me-I had to find out on my own. And I found you in the Shire, acting as if nothing had happened between us and playing at being a blacksmith.”

 

“I am a blacksmith,” Thorin said quietly.

 

“You are the King of Erebor!” Bilbo told him bluntly. “The Heir to the Line of Durin, leader of the Company, King Under The Mountain.”

 

“And for many years, I travelled and worked in the towns of men as a blacksmith to earn to support Dis and the boys,” the King said quietly. 

 

“Longer than I have been alive,” Bilbo grumbled and then stared as Thorin made no reply until a vicious bout of coughing had him doubled up and gasping for breath. He nodded slightly. 

 

“I spent many decades travelling, working and being alone among others,” he said haltingly, struggling to breathe. “I was isolated and abused and treated like nothing. But I knew why I did it: back in Ered Luin, Dis was waiting with my sister-sons, needing my help. And no matter how alone and desolate I feel I knew they were waiting. That I could endure what I was suffering because I had my family waiting for me at home.”

 

“And now…” Bilbo murmured.

 

“I wait for the end because I have lost the only gift Mahal ever gave me,” the King murmured. “I am Rejected. And I could no longer rule Erebor because I was no longer fit to rule. My family remain because they are who I risked it all for. Because they must rule the Kingdom for me.” Bilbo sighed.

 

“You are the King,” he murmured. “But I hurt you.” Thorin shook his head.

 

“Master Baggins, the fault is mine. The penance is mine-and it is justly deserved. There is no fault on your part…”

 

“Firstly, what is this ‘Master Baggins’ nonsense? It’s Bilbo, you rock-headed dwarf!” the Hobbit snapped. “And secondly, I never realised that by protecting myself from losing my Heart-Mate at the end of our marriage, I was hurting you. That I was killing you.”

 

Thorin gave a grim smile. 

 

“Mahal does not forgive,” he murmured. “Justice for my attack on you on the ramparts…”

 

“Enough!” Bilbo said shortly. “Enough of that nonsense! Thorin-I forgave you. Without hesitation and with understanding because you were ill. I fell in love with you during the Quest and I was prepared to give you another chance. I knew what you are like. You are moody and broody and have a temper and that damned pride and all that dwarvish secrecy…but you are also kind and tender and loving and thoughtful and when you were being my husband, you were perfect for me. You were my friend as well as my lover and I never regretted that. But you betrayed my trust by how you reacted. Maybe I over-reacted. But you never asked questions about my customs either…”

 

“I assumed…your kind were as secretive as my own,” Thorin murmured shamefacedly.

 

“You should have asked,” Bilbo scolded him. “Hobbits talk. We discuss things. We don’t confront first and last.” Thorin hung his head.

 

“I am sorry,” he murmured, then doubled up again in another paroxysm of coughing. He looked grey and ashen after it died down. Then he looked up. “Bofur, Bombur-the exile of your family has been rescinded. I should never have blamed you for my own stupidity. You have my humble apologies.”

 

Bilbo rolled his eyes at the stilted, formal language but Bofur looked thoughtful.

 

“You know, you didn’t apologise for being stark raving mad with Dragon Sickness on the ramparts-you just asked us to follow you ‘one last time’,” he said dryly. “You admitted you were wrong when you underestimated our Bilbo on the Carrock. But I think this is the first time I have ever heard of you uttering an actual apology.” 

 

Thorin stared flatly at him, the effect ruined by another bout of coughing.

 

“Kings don’t apologise…much,” Bilbo guessed as Thorin managed a weak nod. That last bout had drained all his air and he was shivering. Quietly, the Hobbit rose and found the rug he usually kept in a box in the parlour for cold evenings and wrapped it around the dwarf King’s shoulders. “You are impossible, Thorin. Stubborn as a rock and proud as…as…I don’t even know anything that is as proud as you! And you have a terrible temper and tend not to listen…but you would do anything for your people and you are stupidly brave and honourable even to your own detriment. You are an idiot…but you are still my idiot. I don’t want anything to happen to you…”

 

Still struggling to breathe, Thorin nodded.

 

“What was that name you use here?” Bilbo asked him thoughtfully, seeing him lean back in the chair. He was clearly exhausted and he wasn’t sure where Bofur stood on this but he now understood why Thorin was in the Shire. He just hoped the dwarf would understand why Bilbo had done what he had done.

 

“Lulkhel,” he managed to rasp. Bofur snorted and Bombur burst out laughing. Bilbo frowned, once again excluded from the joke.

 

“What? You said it was the name Dis gave you…” he said irritably. Bifur entered, laughing hard and made a comment in Khuzdul. Even though the axe had been removed from his head after the Battle, he still could not recall how to speak Westron. And though Bilbo had picked up a few words of the secret language, he still didn’t speak enough to understand the rapid words. “WHAT?”

 

“It means Idiot of Idiots,” Thorin muttered, his head bowed. His voice was still rough and he sounded exhausted. It shocked the Hobbit how little stamina he had, that a few minutes of admittedly emotionally-charged conversation had worn him out. “My sister’s idea of a joke. I agree that my name should remain in Erebor.”

 

“So the Hobbits have been calling you…basically the Biggest Idiot in Existence…since you arrived here?” Bilbo asked, his voice breaking slightly. Thorin nodded. “Oh Yavanna…” he whimpered and began laughing as well. And then he grasped Thorin’s shoulder. “You really set out to humiliate and humble yourself, didn’t you?” Another nod. “Oh Thorin…” There was sympathy in his tone and the King gave a sigh.

 

“Your people were as insular and xenophobic as my own,” Thorin rasped. “I was slandered, gossiped about and ostracised because I did not understand the ways of Hobbit courting.” He looked up. “But I should have. You have shown how inadequate and how selfish and foolish I have been. I never deserved you and all that befalls me is only justice from Mahal.” Bilbo took his hand then, squeezing it and feeling Thorin squeeze back. The skin was still abnormally warm, even for a dwarf, and another coffin cough had the Hobbit wincing. 

 

“I am so sorry,” Bilbo said gently. “You did not deserve that. Let’s get you to bed to rest and when you are feeling a little stronger, maybe we can have a longer talk.” Bifur helped him up with a reassuring murmur of Khuzdul which Thorin absently replied to and then he was helped back to Bilbo’s room. the Hobbit stared after him.

 

“You still love him,” Bofur said and there was a warmth in his voice which was more like the Bofur of old. “And he loves you. Bless me but he does seem to be trying to change. Maybe there is some hope for him.”

 

The Hobbit sighed.

 

“Somehow, he has to find a way to make me trust him,” he said and blinked. “That will be the key.”

 

“If he survives this, I am sure he will succeed,” Bofur grinned. “An apology from a King. That is something that Milania won’t believe!”

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Ghivashel - treasure of treasures
Lulkhel - idiot of idiots

Chapter 8: Rallying Round

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

EIGHT: Rallying round

 

Thorin's fever rose again and Bilbo spent hours refreshing the cold compress on the dwarf King’s forehead. Sometimes it was clear that the King was suffering nightmares and the Hobbit could only watch helplessly as Thorin thrashed and shouted and pleaded in Khuzdul. Whatever troubled his mind was beyond the limits of Bilbo’s dwarvish.

 

But word had seemingly gotten round that Mister Baggins had rescued the dwarf from his frozen forge and Hamfast came round two mornings later, looking worried. Apparently there was gossip and even more comments about Bilbo’s fragile ‘propriety’ that was being rapidly eroded under the torrent of rumour. And chief among the culprits was, of course, Gardenia Proudfoot. 

 

“It’s a right business, Mister Bilbo,” he commented as Bilbo pulled him in and fed him a cheese and hazelnut scone and a cup of tea. “She’s been spreading all sorts of rumours about the dwarf and now she’s going after you.”

 

“Oh?” Bilbo sipped his tea. Thorin had suffered another restless night and his chest was still problematic. It was taking longer than Bilbo had guessed for the King to start to improve and he was considering writing to Oin, using one of the Ravens that regularly visited Bag End with letters from his friends in Erebor. Ori wrote to him at least weekly and the others corresponded frequently as well so there was never a shortage and Bilbo wondered if the Dwarvish Healer could recommend any potions beyond those Hibiscus Underhill had suggested to improve his condition. Bilbo had seen Thorin bounce back from injuries before, including the near-fatal wounds from the Battle of the Five Armies, as the Battle had been come to be called. Maybe there was something to this Rejection theory, if it had weakened his friend enough that being frozen and getting pneumonia was taking so much effort to fight off.

 

But maybe Thorin wasn’t fighting as hard as he could. Everything he had said indicated that he had given up any hope of winning back Bilbo’s affections. He had taken Bilbo’s angry comments at the unexpected arrival in the Shire of Thorin-under an assumed name, what utter rot!-as negating any prospect even of a cordial friendship in the future. It was clear that Thorin deeply regretted his intemperate and summary actions and had bitterly castigated himself for his foolishness. And in true Thorin style, he had worked out the hardest possible penance that would result in his death and had carried it through with absolute dwarvish determination. There was something terribly tragic about his acceptance that he could do nothing right-Bilbo cringed at how cruel he had been when visiting Thorin with the food and the cessation of the bouquets following that day that had spoken of how hard the dwarf had taken his words. And, unbidden, Dis’s words from just before the wedding came back to him.

 

“I ask you only one thing, Master Baggins. Take care of my brother’s heart. You and I both know he is impossible at times-stubborn and prideful and swift to anger and judge. He often looks beyond what is there to what is not and takes altogether too much blame upon himself for wrongs and disasters that are not of his making. Yet I know that he is loyal and brave and kind and would give everything he has for those he loves. His life has been hard and scarred by tragedy but after every one, he has got up and made the best of what he has left and what additional duties he has ended up with. Yet he has never loved before like this, never surrendered his heart and his very being to another and that gives you a unique power over him. So be kind to my idiot brother because though he is capable to being the most exasperating being on this world, he is also one of the most dear to me and I would hate to see him hurt because of misunderstanding or foolishness. I trust you, Master Baggins. Please do not disappoint me.”

 

He winced. Maybe if she or any of the dwarves had bothered to explain why he has such a ‘unique power’ over Thorin or what being a One meant for a dwarf, then maybe he could have avoided reacting so angrily. And maybe not, since the lack of trust had wounded Bilbo to the core and he had reacted as any Hobbit would. But maybe he would not have walked away so readily if he knew that the risk was that he could kill his husband by his rejection. He shook himself in irritation as there was a loud ring of the bell. And again. 

 

Rolling his eyes and muttering dire curses on uninvited and impatient visitors, Bilbo stomped through and wrenched open the door-to come face to face with the unwelcome shape of Gardenia Proudfoot and her beau. Bilbo wracked his brain to dredge up the name Jumbo Freshfield and he looked a pasty, almost globular article with unfashionable brown pants and jacket and a very plain grey waistcoat. There was a rather dull look in his eyes and Bilbo felt a surge of annoyance that Gardenia considered this…lump in any way an alternative to Thorin. Then the Hobbitess herself spoke.

 

“Master Baggins-are you going to leave me on the doorway like some ruffian orc?” she asked shrilly. He frowned and a wholly inappropriate image stuck in his head.

 

“Are you sure you aren’t related to Lobelia Sackville-Baggins nee Bracegirdle?” he blurted out. She stared at him. “I think the answer is…no. I would rather not have you in my home. I have a patient and…” Gardenia sneered.

 

“Ah yes-you took in that nasty dwarf,” she said superiorly. “Why did you do that? You know how he treated me!” Bilbo stared at her and allowed his guilt and his exasperation to take over.

 

“What?” he asked in a freezing voice.

 

“You saw how he led me on-don’t pretend that you weren’t there in the market and…”

 

“And what I saw said far more about you than about the dwarf,” Bilbo snapped. She stared.

 

“I clearly gave him a…” she began but he cut her off.

 

“You are a Hobbit while he is a dwarf,” he said shortly. “Dwarves are creatures of stone and rock. They love precious metals and gems. They craft magnificent, amazing, unbelievable things from those cold substances and they work hard because their creator made them to work. To a dwarf, flowers are pretty and colourful…but that’s it. There is no language or communication in a bunch of weeds. So he saw nothing but a pretty gift.”

 

“And the food?” Gardenia sneered.

 

“Is food,” Bilbo said. “A kind gift, not a declaration of proposal.”

 

“Oh…Master Baggins knows because he spent years living with the nasty smelly monsters and he understands them…” she scoffed.

 

“More than you,” he retorted. “And Lulkhel is brave, hardworking and loyal. He is already married, by the way-any dwarf would have seen that. There is a marriage braid in his hair, capped by a bead given him by his One, his Heart-Mate.”

 

“Then why did he…?”

 

“He didn’t,” Bilbo told him. “You wanted him to show off like an exotic pet. And you didn’t find him attractive-he was just a fancy to be displayed, used for your amusement and then discarded. And humiliated, though you have done that to him ever since.”

 

“How dare you…” Gardenia spat. Bilbo leaned forward slightly. 

 

“You couldn’t let it go, could he?” he asked. “Every time he did something worthy of praise or being accepted, you made sure everyone knew how hurt you were by his supposed rejection…when he never understood he was even being asked anything. Even when you were going out with Jumbo here, you still vindictively hounded him, making sure he was isolated.”

 

“I resent…”

 

“So do I!” Bilbo snapped, interrupting again. “I resent you making our people look like spiteful, vicious little goblins, determined to be cruel to a creature alone and a long way from his home. I resent you poisoning the minds of the Shire so much that when Th…Lulkhel asked for help, when the blizzard started and he knew that the forge would be too cold, he was turned away. He has no kin he could stay with, no family-his only option was the Green Dragon and they wouldn’t even give him a seat by the fire. He nearly died, a couple of hundred yards from an inn where everyone was warm and well-fed. And for that, you should be utterly ashamed!”

 

“Now wait a moment…” Jumbo blustered.

 

“Shut up, porky!” Bilbo snapped. “You’re no better. None of you. Do you have any idea that when they lost their home to a dragon, the dwarves of Erebor wandered across Middle Earth, despised and rejected by all? No one would give them shelter and many died from cold and hunger and wild beasts. These are people! People with a history dating from before Men woke, people who fought for good against evil, who love fiercely and once and treasure their families above their own safety.”

 

“Anyone would think you preferred them to your own people!” Gardenia spat, her eyes vicious. 

 

“When you’re the Hobbit in question, it isn’t even close,” Bilbo retorted. “Choosing between a spiteful snake who makes Smaug the Dragon look like a kindly Uncle or a dwarf who is brave, selfless, loves his sister-sons, would sacrifice his life for his people and surrendered his heart because he valued his role and was an idiot for listening to gossip instead of his One…I take the child of Mahal every time”

 

“Then maybe it would be better if he died!” Gardenia sniffed. 

 

“How can you say that, you heartless witch?” Bilbo snarled.

 

“Now, I’m not taking that…”Jumbo protested and began to move forward, to find Sting pointing at his middle. Bilbo glared as the fat Hobbit backed away and Gardenia gave a little shriek. 

 

“You try to invade my home, you insult me and him and you act like an orc-and believe me, I’ve met and killed more than a few so I know what I am talking about!” Bilbo told her furiously. “But mostly, you made our people as bad as those across Arda who rejected and cheated and were cruel to the dwarves when they needed succour and kindness. You felt no empathy for a being alone, a being who was here because he made a terrible mistake and was willing to spend the rest of his life making up for it. And now I don’t even know why you’re here, except to be spiteful and gossip and I think, try to persuade me to turf the poor creature out before he is healed.”

 

“He’s gone quite mad!” Gardenia squeaked, trying to retreat but Jumbo was trying to cower behind her.

 

“No, I am perfectly sane-more’s the pity!” Bilbo growled, lowering the blade. “You didn’t deny it, by the way. So why is your pride so important that you want another creature, alone and isolated and desperately ill, to die because you were rejected? You are a shame upon all Hobbits!”

 

Gardenia bristled at that and glared at him.

 

“And you, Mad Baggins?” she sneered. “You know what you are?” Bilbo stared into her face.

 

“Yes,” he said bluntly. “I’m his husband.”

 

And then he slammed the door in her face.

 

He leaned against the wood for a long moment, sliding the bolt into place just to make sure the doughy Jumbo didn’t get any any ideas of bravery-not that it was likely. He was more likely to urgently need a change of pants than he was to force his way into Bag End. But he sheathed Sting and restored it to its spot behind the door and turned to the kitchen, desperately needing a fresh cup of tea. But a thunderous banging on the door began and he turned, his fists clenched in fury. 

 

“If you think this clot-headed farce is funny, Gardenia Proudfoot, then I will show you exactly how Mad a Baggins can be!” Bilbo yelled and wrenched the door open-to face a mildly surprised Dwalin and a grinning Ori. Behind him, a tall shape swathed in a long green cloak hung back with the ponies…as Kili walked forward, a grin on his face.

 

“I think they really don’t want that!” he commented and flung a hug around the surprised Hobbit. “We heard he was up here…and I think everyone down the Hill heard you declare that Master Lulkhel is your husband!”

 

“I…” Bilbo stared and then blinked. “What are you doing here? Aren’t you supposed to be back in Erebor?”

 

“When Fili got your letter before Durin’s Day, he was so worried he ordered us to come and check on Thorin ourselves,” Dwalin admitted gruffly. 

 

“Because letting him come all this way on his own when he is in real danger and calling himself Idiot of Idiots is such a great way to show your concern!” Bilbo snapped. Dwalin scowled but there more than a hint of chagrin.

 

“You think anyone can stop Thorin the he gets some damned fool ideal in that stubborn head of his?” he asked gruffly. “You are the only one…and maybe Dis. But as he was coming for you, there was no power on Arda that would prevent him making it here-even if he had to fight two Azogs and another Smaug.”

 

“The Hobbits further down in town said he was ill and was staying up here with you,” Ori added, smiling at his friend. “How is he?”

 

“Still very feverish and weak,” the Hobbit said and then sighed. “Come in, all of you. Is that Tauriel?” The tall shape pushed her hood back to reveal the serene features of the flame-headed elf, smiling gently at him.

 

“It is good to see you again,” she said as she secured the ponies and walked up to the door. Bilbo stood back.

 

“Mind your head,” he warned. “My home isn’t designed for Big Folk-and Gandalf always has problems with the chandelier…” He winced as she almost knocked into it and ducked away gracefully. Kili carefully hung up his cloak and didn’t wipe his muddy boots on Belladonna’s Glory Box this time. “Boots off-you dwarves and your clodhopping heavy boots. The weather is awful and I don’t want mud pounding into my rugs.” There must have been something fierce enough about him that made even Dwalin bend down and wrestle his heavy mud-encrusted boots off. Only then did Bilbo take them into the kitchen and treat them to some proper Hobbitish hospitality, with tea, cakes, biscuits and cheese.

 

“He never wrote,” Kili murmured, sitting next to Tauriel with the sort of adoring look that Bilbo recognised from his own early days of marriage. The pair weren’t wed yet but Tauriel wore a Promise Braid-a sign of her engagement-in her long flaming red hair that matched the one in Kili’s rather wild locks. “Not once. We only knew he arrived alive because of your letters.”

 

Bilbo blushed.

 

“I tried to get him to reply but he said he would only write when he had news,” he explained and cringed inwardly at the implication.

 

“So he wasn’t getting very far with you,” the warrior guessed.

 

“I don’t think he knew how,” Bilbo murmured. “He said hello to me when I went to introduce myself to the new blacksmith…and we argued. he said he did not come to me when he arrived because he expected to be shouted at…he looked defeated. But…” And then he gave a small smile.

 

“What?” Ori’s expression was rapt and he was already making notes, so not even Bilbo had the heart to object.

 

“Then he gave me flowers,” he said almost to himself. Tauriel, seated on a chair far too small for her, nodded.

 

“Flowers with meaning,” she nodded with a small smile.

 

“What, flowers can have meaning?” Kili’s voice was confused.

 

“A whole language, Amrâlimê,” she assured him. “Everything from ‘I love you’ to…”

 

“Sorrow, regret, humility, despair,” Bilbo murmured. “He was pouring his heart out to me in a way he knew I would understand. He learned about flowers and their meanings for me.”

 

“He was doing what he could to show you how sorry he was,” Ori murmured. 

 

“Without saying the word,” Dwalin sighed. 

 

“He has apologised-and to Bofur,” Bilbo admitted. “But he’s not getting better as quickly as he did after the Battle.”

 

“After the Battle, he had us and you and the Kingdom to anchor him to life,” Kili replied. “Here…well, he thinks he has lost you and he has been Rejected.” He took a deep breath. “Has anyone actually explained what that means…?” Bilbo glared at him.

 

“Well, one of you Lulkhels could have mentioned it before I stormed off and left my husband in terrible pain and despair, condemned to death because he had lost the other half of his Heart!” he snarled. “Bofur told me-probably because I was ready to go after him with Sting! But not one of you asked me why I left.”

 

“Why did you leave?” Ori asked. Bilbo rolled his eyes and rose, pouring himself a fresh cup of mint and elderflower tea. Tauriel glanced up at him and then looked away.

 

“He showed he could not trust me and he didn’t make any apology,” Bilbo said. “Losing the trust of one that you love, your Heart-Mate, is devastating for us. I could either apologise-which I wouldn’t as I had done nothing wrong-or leave. And in leaving, I had to protect myself. Losing my Heart-Mate could cause me to fade and the only way I could survive was to reject him and harden my heart. But I would never have left had I known I was putting Thorin at risk.” 

 

Tauriel sighed.

 

“Dwarvish secrecy at its worst,” she sighed. 

 

“But he was here, trying to make it up to you,” Kili argued.

 

“He barely spoke to me and we argued a couple of times,” the Hobbit admitted. “I was still angry and hurt and he was too proud to explain why he was in the Shire. I kept telling him to go home, that there was nothing for him here. I wanted him not to be alone-but I realise he thought I was telling him there was no hope. He gave up. He wished me Happy New Year…but told me he didn’t have another year. I didn’t hear him. I didn’t realise what he was saying.” He covered his face. “But he is alive and he is my friend and I…don’t not care about him…”

 

Tauriel rested her hand on his shoulder and then quietly rose.

 

“Take me to see him and see what I can do,” she offered, Bilbo glanced at Dwalin and Kili but the two both deferred to him.

 

“He’s your husband,” Kili reminded Bilbo. “You just declared it to a horrible Hobbit who will no doubt spread it all over the Shire, if what you told us about how gossipy your people are is true. So you may as well make all the decisions that are yours by right.” The Hobbit turned to Dwalin.

 

“He is my best friend…but he loves you and he would rather die alone here than be away from you a moment longer,” the warrior said. “He has given you the right to decide his fate. Be kind, Bilbo. That’s all I ask.” Ori nodded as well, an unusually serious expression on his face. The Hobbit rose.

 

“Then let’s see if you can help him when I cannot,” he murmured.

 

Thorin was restless when they arrived in Bilbo’s bedroom, his skin unusually pale and sheened with sweat and his breathing was as raspy and harsh as Bilbo remembered it. Quietly, he padded to Thorin’s side and took his hand. Instinctively, the King clutched at it.

 

“Thorin,” Bilbo said gently, leaning close and stroking damp tendrils of hair off his forehead. Bleary blue eyes fluttered open. “We have visitors. Dwalin, Ori, Kili and Tauriel have come from Erebor. Tauriel is going to help me tend you.” Silently, the dwarf shook his head and shut his eyes. The elf swallowed.

 

“Sire…” she began but he shook his head more obviously.

 

“No,” he croaked. “Leave me.” Bilbo actually stamped his foot, exasperated.

 

“Thorin Oakenshield, Lulkhel and my absolutely exasperating husband, you will cut out this overdramatic dwarvish nonsense!” he snapped, planting his hands firmly on his hips. “You will allow Tauriel to treat you, you will do what she says and then, when you are better, we will have a proper talk about all of…this!” He waved his hands around irritably as Thorin forced his eyes open once more. He looked utterly exhausted and he was struggling to breathe but there was a light in his eyes that hadn’t been there before. Bilbo realised it was his use of the word ‘husband’…

 

“Bilbo…" he croaked. 

 

“My house is full of dwarves once more, my carpets are a mess and I will have to send Dwalin, Bombur and Bifur out to go pick up a whole heap of food because I will be feeding eight adult dwarves, three dwarflings, an elf and myself,” Bilbo carried on. “But I am not having you lying here wallowing in misery and trying to die dramatically. Your nephew has made his way here, your other nephew and sister are ruling your Kingdom for you and your best friend and his husband to be are waiting outside, worried about you. Tauriel?” The elf gave a small smile.

 

“I would not advise arguing with him in this mood,” she commented. The King gave a sigh.

 

“I have tried but I have yet to succeed,” he confessed. “As you will…”

 

Thorin reached out with his hand and acquiescing, Bilbo took it and felt the firm but careful grasp of the King, driven by a need for comfort and reassurance as he entrusted himself to a member of the race he had despised almost all of his life. And though he knew Tauriel was a friend, it went against everything he felt. Especially when she used part of her own energy to ward off the infection that was ravaging his lungs and lower his fever finally to normal. Able to breathe more easily, he allowed himself to drink a tea she brewed and swallow a linctus and then he dropped back to sleep.

 

Kili was waiting for Dwalin and Ori had already gone shopping with the entire Family Ur for food and if he hadn’t been so discombobulated, Bilbo would have worried for the innocent Hobbits in Hobbiton Market. But knowing what he did of Gardenia’s machinations and his own people’s treatment of the outsider, he reckoned they deserved it. Silently, the Prince accompanied Bilbo to the parlour and they sat down as Tauriel went to brew some herbal tea.

 

“What can Uncle do to make it up to you?” Kili asked quietly. “Because if he cannot win you back, he will die.” Bilbo sighed, exasperated.

 

“This isn’t another Quest,” he said heavily. “Thorin can’t charge in without planning anything or thinking anything through, wave Orcrist around and kill a few goblins and suddenly it’s all sorted.” Kili frowned.

 

“Are you sure?” he asked in a concerned voice.  “Because Uncle really isn’t that good at any other way of dealing with a problem. If it’s not a ‘run in and chop something up’ problem, he’s pretty…well, useless.”

 

“And yet, he gave me bouquets and he attended many of the parties,” Bilbo murmured. “He didn’t do anything wrong but some spiteful people made fun of him anyway.”

 

“And you left him alone,” Kili said. “He must have been desperately…” Then he paused. “He must have despaired.”

 

“And I never knew,” Bilbo sighed. “I still care for him-and I felt so angry every time someone said something about him. When I heard he had been turned away from the Green Dragon, I knew I had to find him. He’s an idiot-but he’s my idiot.”

 

“Amad said something similar,” the Prince revealed. “When he realised what an utter fool he had been. He wept, Bilbo-and he hasn’t done that all the time I can recall. He’s lost so much…but realising that he had thrown away…it broke his heart. He was impossible after you went but once he decided he would leave Erebor and come to spend what time he had left near you, he calmed and the people began to love their King once more.” 

 

“He forgot how to be King Thorin without you,” Tauriel said, placing a mug of steaming blackberry and thyme tea in front of Bilbo. “He could only resent the Kingdom that had cost him his love.” 

 

“You did declare he was your husband,” Kili pointed out. “You didn’t have to do that. You could have left him as a sick dwarf who is just being helped by a kind Hobbit.”

 

“But he is my husband,” Bilbo said, the truth of the words seeping into his voice. “I have missed him. And seeing him always hurt, clawing at the wall I put around my heart to protect me. I still love him. But he has to find some way to persuade me to trust him again.”

 

Tauriel reached out and her hand slid over the table to grasp Kili’s. The adoration in the dwarf prince’s gaze warmed Bilbo’s heart and he found himself yearning for Thorin’s presence once more...and then he pulled himself up. He wasn’t sure if weakening his heart would expose him to the risk of fading for there was no roadmap for the path he was walking. There had never been a Hobbit who married a Dwarf before and their race’s different reactions to the problem spoke of maybe it wasn’t planned by their creators… Yet Yavanna who had created the Hobbits was the wife of Aüle, who had crafted the dwarves. And Bilbo had to hope that they would be able to work things out, that Yavanna was kind enough to a foolish Hobbit and an equally foolish dwarf who still loved each other and wanted to work things out. If only Bilbo could trust his heart to a dwarf who did not trust his husband.

 

He rested his face in his hands. He really needed Thorin to improve because they desperately needed a talk.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Amad - mother
Lulkhel - idiot of idiots
Amrâlimê - my love

Chapter 9: A Tentative Truce

Chapter Text

NINE:  A tentative truce

 

He slept in the parlour, curled up on the couch because Thorin was sleeping deeply in his bed and as he seemed to be resting quietly, Bilbo was restless but somehow, he felt safer now he had half of the Company here with him, as well as Tauriel and Bombur’s family. The parlour was cool but wrapped in a fluffy blanket and lying in front of the banked fire, Bilbo allowed himself to listen for various snores and snuffles. Kili and Tauriel had been given Bifur’s room-the dwarf had insisted-and he was now sharing with his cousin, Bofur. Dwalin and Ori had settled in the far parlour and bedded down, just glad to be safely in the Shire. The door was bolted and the night was dark, though the bluish reflections of the moon off the remaining patches of snow lit the room eerily. But soothed by the snoring of his dwarves, Bilbo slept.

 

He woke to the sound of footsteps and as he started up, he saw a tallish shape stumble towards the kitchen. Instantly, the Hobbit was up because he recognised that shape and he intercepted Thorin as he reached the kitchen. Gently, he rested a hand on the dwarf King’s arm.

 

“Thorin-what are you doing up?” he asked and the dwarf swayed but steadied himself.

 

“I was thirsty,” he murmured, “and I was hoping not to disturb you, Master Baggins…”

 

“Bilbo,” the Hobbit sighed. “I thought we had got past this Master Baggins nonsense. I did, after all, announce to Gardenia Proudfoot that you were my husband.” But instead of looking pleased, there was hurt in Thorin’s eyes.

 

“Now you toy with my affections and my name, Bilbo,” he said quietly. Bilbo wheeled away and paced across the passage, then back. 

 

“There is nothing further from the truth,” Bilbo said in exasperation. “I was absolutely furious how she and the rest of them were gossiping about you. And then she came up here and started insulting me and insulting you and calling you a nasty dwarf and a monster and I was not having that! Because I know, despite how stubborn and rash you are, that you are kind and determined and brave and heroic and terribly selfless and ridiculously dramatic and would give everything up for someone you loved. I wasn’t going to let her badmouth you any more. So I claimed you as my husband…which is true.”

 

Thorin stared at him, his back resting against the wall and arms folded across his chest-though the gesture looked very defensive.

 

“But you handed back my bead…” he murmured. He frowned and gave a wince, his hand rotating to press against his chest, causing Bilbo to look closer.

 

“Thorin-I cannot pretend not to be hurt by that the fact that you clearly did not trust me and believed the lies of Lords who had been trying to undermine me since Erebor was reclaimed,” he said calmly. “But I do care for you and I want to see if there is anything we can do to regain what we had. I-I just don’t know how…” 

 

“Neither do I…” Thorin muttered, his tone wretched. Bilbo sighed and beckoned and they headed into the kitchen. The fire in the range was giving a reddish light and Bilbo swiftly lit a couple of candles. Blinking away any residual sleep, Bilbo made the dwarf a cup of tea and himself one as well and then he stared at the shape sitting opposite. This was it: just the two of them in the quiet smial an hour before the late winter dawn, the only sounds the crackle of the fire and the snores of the others. 

 

Thorin sipped his tea, coughing slightly. He looked dishevelled and weary still, his face gaunt and eyes haunted but he was breathing more easily and it was clear that his fever had finally broken. And he was still looking desolate and wary. 

 

“I’m sorry,” Bilbo said honestly, his eyes never straying from the dwarf. “I didn’t know about the Rejection thing because you never told me. You never asked me about Hobbit courting.” Thorin bowed his head.

 

“I was so grateful for your forgiveness, that you would ever want to be near anywhere close to someone who tried to kill you…I did not want to offend you,” the King said wretchedly. “All I wanted was for you to be happy. Because I knew that Erebor was not the Shire, was not full of green, growing things and gardens and your family so I wanted to enjoy your presence as long as I could. But when Sulgan spoke, I felt such…jealousy. And part of me was screaming because I know you…but the rest was acting like a wounded boar.” He sighed. “And so I knew I could not stay there.”

 

“Kili told me you were alienating the people of Erebor by your actions,” Bilbo said.

 

“I didn’t care because they had cost me the only thing I cared about,” Thorin grumbled and slowly rotated the mug in his hands. “So leaving there under cover of darkness, travelling alone under an assumed name…it was no more than I deserved. And as I travelled further from Erebor and her tainted gold, my mind cleared and I could think straight again. And I wondered how I could possibly ever win back your trust.”

 

“You managed it before,” Bilbo reminded him. The King ghosted a smile, sipping his tea. It was strong and warm and eased the constant scratching of his throat. 

 

“You were receptive and had already formed friendships with the rest of the Company,” the King told him quietly. “You wanted to trust your travelling companions. But I did not. I saw you as weak and fussy and unsuited to the journey. I did not trust you-with anything. I always saw the worst of you. And I was harsh. Yet you did not give in and quit and instead, you stuck with us-even sneaking out of Rivendell, where I was certain you would stay.”

“I signed a contract,” Bilbo said automatically. 

 

“But you did not leave us in the Goblin Tunnels and then, when Azog attacked, you saved my life and I finally saw what lay beneath the Hobbit exterior: a heart of diamond, beautiful and strong and priceless. I knew I had misjudged you and I had to apologise…many of them have never seen me admit I was wrong…”

 

“Not a very good thing to admit,” Bilbo reminded him. Thorin gave that hint of a smile, his eyes thoughtful.

 

“The King is expected to be right and even if he is wrong, it is discreetly forgotten,” he reminded his friend.

 

“Except that is how dictators and tyrants rise, imagining they are always right and never listening,” the Hobbit retorted. The King’s shoulders slumped.

 

“Aye,” he conceded. “But once I started to trust you, I could not stop. And my heart ran away with me and decided you were my One…and once that determination is made, I was lost.” He bowed his head. “I could never win back your trust. Mahal knows how I ever managed to win it in the first place…”

 

“You know, you were determined and brave and no matter how desperate things were, you managed that little incline of the head you do so well and give a regal look and act the King,” Bilbo told him. “Even in Mirkwood, grubby and starved and covered in cobwebs, you still verbally tore Thranduil to shreds. You’re magnificent and it was then I realised that though he has thousands of years on you, Thranduil will never be a greater King than you.”

 

“You are biased,” Thorin told him.

 

“You were always royal and aloof but when we sat by the fire and chatted, you revealed who you were under all those trappings of history and duty…that was the dwarf I fell for,” Bilbo reminded him. “And after the Battle, I knew you had overcome the Dragon Sickness to come out and fight. I was so proud of you and so relieved that you survived that I was willing to give you a chance to be the King you were always meant to be…and if I ended at your side, well, my heart wasn’t averse the that…”

 

Thorin sipped his tea and then rested the mug down on the table.

 

“I wondered how I could win your trust back and eventually realised I could not,” he said. “I couldn’t even talk to you without us arguing. And the pain was worse whenever we did. I tried to tell you of my sorrow and abject humility in the face of your gift but I was not good enough at your language of flowers to speak clearly…”

 

“You did well,” Bilbo reassured him and patted his hand gently. “I just wasn’t ready to hear yet. I was still angry. Because I didn’t just lose you-I lost the Company, my friends and Erebor. I lost chats with Bofur, cooking with Bombur,  those afternoons reviewing stupid petitions with Balin, time with Ori in the Library, drinking tea with Dori…and I had to come back here, where they call me Mad Baggins because I ran away with dwarves.”

 

“I am sorry.” Thorin’s voice cracked with misery but Bilbo grabbed his hand. 

 

“You are my friend, Thorin,” he said seriously. “And I never wanted any ill to befall you. To learn I may have killed you and certainly caused you pain makes me feel sick. I am still not sure where our marriage is going…but I am willing to give you a chance to earn my trust back. And I am your friend. Will that ease your condition, at least a little…?”

 

Thorin nodded. He looked up, his eyes shockingly clear and honest.

 

“I will gratefully take whatever scraps you can spare me, Bilbo,” he said hoarsely. “When I came here, I never expected to even spend time like this with you again. As time passed, I knew I had lost you and resigned myself to perishing here. For you to save me and allow me this time…” Bilbo sighed.

 

“Over-dramatic dwarf,” he complained. “You should have come to me when you were freezing. When they turned you away…” But Thorin gave a smile of such sadness it broke his heart.

 

“I could not,” he said. “You had the others here and I would not impose my unwanted presence upon you…”

 

“Oh Thorin…” the Hobbit sighed and took his hand. “I would never turn you away in need. You know that.”

 

“That is why I could not come,” Thorin murmured. Bilbo squeezed his hand. 

 

“Stubborn rock-headed dwarf,” he complained. Thorin chuckled.

 

“I met my match in you,” he admitted as the Hobbit allowed himself a smile.

 

“Must be why I get on so well with all you dwarves,” he commented. “Oh Yavanna. Gardenia Proudfoot is going to make my life here a nightmare…”

 

“I could always go slay her?” Thorin suggested, a hopeful note entering his voice. “A Quest to reclaim your Honour and slay a dragoness…”

 

“Thorin Oakenshield…you are not slaying Gardenia Proudfoot!” Bilbo told him sternly.

 

“I could also throw in that cousin of yours…Lobelia Sackford-Baggins?” Thorin added enticingly.

 

“Sackville-Baggins and tempting though that is, the answer is still no,” the Hobbit repeated firmly. “You are just going to have to win me back the old fashioned way.”

 

“Flowers?” Thorin asked warily. The Hobbit cast his glance at the metal flowers Thorin had given him for Yule, outlined by the finest of pink lights from the impending dawn as they sat in a crystal vase on the windowsill.

 

“You know, you are really going to have to learn about Hobbit Courtship habits,” Bilbo told him smugly. “But those are utterly beautiful. And Bofur told me they are the work of a Master?” Thorin nodded.

 

“I earned my Mastery many decades ago,” he admitted. “And then spent my skills making nails and repairing kettles and plough-shares. I was ashamed to admit to anyone in any Guild because I had fallen so low, paid a pittance and sneered at by Men who possessed a tiny fraction of my skill. Yet I do not regret a moment that I spent working in such mean circumstances because that put clothes on the boy’s bodies and food in their bellies. My humiliation was nothing compared to their lives.”

 

“Oh Thorin, you are such a mass of contradictions,” Bilbo sighed. “You let your pride rip our marriage apart but you gave it up willingly to save your family.” Wearily, the King bowed his head.

 

“I had no choice-and I never regretted what I did for them…” he murmured. “Maybe…Tharkûn was right. About my pride…” Bilbo stared at him and found a small smile on his lips.

 

“And maybe there is hope for you yet,” he murmured, then glanced at the window. The trickle of watery pinkish golden light was spilling in as the hesitant winter dawn broke. “Now how about some breakfast?”

 

-o0o-

 

Dwalin had set out after second breakfast to check over the Forge in Bywater and keep it working while Thorin recovered. The King had offered to accompany him but Bilbo, Tauriel, Kili and Dwalin himself had offered to sit on the King until he saw sense. It was the first day his fever had broken and his lungs were still recovering and though the snow had mostly melted, the air was very cold and damp so even standing at the door had Thorin doubling up with a fit of coughing that had him gasping for breath. So Dwalin had tramped out alone, wrapped up in his cloak and headed for the Forge, ignoring the curious look of the Hobbits and determinedly not scowling fiercely at them. Thorin had worked hard for his tentative acceptance and Dwalin would not jeopardise it, no matter how angry he was at the Hobbits who had left his friend to die.

 

His anger redoubled when he reached the Forge, for the door swung open and it was clear someone had been rooting around inside. Bilbo had made sure that all of Thorin’s possessions and his money had come back with the ailing dwarf but the thought someone had rifled through the Forge in search of some leverage against the King made his fists itch. So he pushed the hatch open and allowed the watery winter light to flood the space, then looked around. He smiled and walked to the tools, laid out neatly exactly as Thorin did in every forge he worked in. Dwalin had travelled and worked with his King for many seasons, for Dis and the Princes were his cousins as much as Thorin was, and he was very familiar with Thorin’s way of doing things. And he had seen his friend work late to finish an order that the Man who owned the forge had taken, hoping for the dwarves to fail and have their wages reduced for the failure. Or seen him swallow his pride as he was taunted and humiliated by creatures without a fraction of Thorin’s skill. The constant drizzle of name-calling and sneers was enough to make a dwarf want to kill something but Thorin-never the most temperate of dwarrow-had clung onto his temper and bowed his head, storing every insult for the day when he would need to determination to drive him on to his impossible goal of reclaiming Erebor.

 

“I say! You! Dwarf there! What are you doing in the Forge?”

 

Dwalin looked up to see a middle-aged Hobbit in a fancy red brocade waistcoat, a warm dark blue coat and the strange cut-off trousers the Hobbits wore, standing at the hatch and peering challengingly at him. The creature was short, plump and had a reasonable set of mutton-chop sideburns, the nearest to facial hair that Dwalin could recall seeing. 

 

“Tidying up,” the warrior said disinterestedly and glanced around. He could see that the little pail of nails had been tipped over. Who stole nails?

 

“And why are you here? Isn’t that other fellow…Lalkhen or something…supposed to be here?” The Hobbit’s voice was affected and rather entitled but his dark eyes were narrow and mean.

 

“Master Lulkhel is ill,” Dwalin drawled, hanging his cloak from the hook and looking around for fuel for the forge. As he expected, there was none, for Thorin would have burnt all the fuel he had to stay alive. “Some selfish bastard halflings wouldn’t allow him floor room in the inn during the blizzards and he almost froze to death. Fortunately, he has friends who found him before it was too late.” The Hobbit looked offended and planted his fists on his hips.

 

“I hardly see there is any need for such language!” he blustered.

 

“He almost died,” Dwalin growled. “Every need, I think.” He turned and walked towards the Hobbit who retreated a step, even though he was the other side of the counter. “It’s easy to be offended and pompous when you’re sitting in your home with a full larder and a good fire. But you should be offended that a guest in your land was turned away from an inn in the blizzard where he sought shelter. He offered to pay for a chair or a spot on the floor…but he was turned out into the blizzard to freeze. His nearest family was a thousand miles away! I thought you Hobbits were supposed to be good hosts and hospitable. Bunch of mealy-mouthed hypocrites, if you ask me.”

 

“I…do you know who I am?” the Hobbit blurted.

 

“No,” Dwalin said easily. “Now I won’t be doing any commissions yet but I’ll take orders while I tidy up and order more fuel. You got anything you want doing?”

 

The Hobbit gaped like a fish and then turned and stomped away. Dwalin chuckled. He was going to enjoy this.

 

He had tidied the place up and checked which orders were outstanding (none-Thorin had finished everything in an attempt to keep warm) and then had ordered fuel and iron urgently from the Bree merchant. As he watched the Raven flap away, he had bolted and locked the Forge and then headed back up to Bag End, stopping at the market to pick up some biscuits (his weakness) and some honey and treats for the others. Half a pig completed his purchases as he stomped back up the Hill with his goods. 

 

The others had chopped enough wood for half the Hill and were distributing it to the other Hobbit holes without hesitation as the afternoon grew grey. The chimney in Bag End was smoking nicely and warm light spilled through the windows. Kili gaped as he saw the half pig but Dwalin didn’t mind: he fancied some nice pork and crackling and knew that Thorin was partial as well. He imagined the Hobbit was pretty handy with a roast and would be able to do justice. But he didn’t expect to find Bilbo explaining to Thorin precisely how to peel an apple properly to get the peel off in one piece for some childish game. 

 

“Gotcher some food,” the warrior grunted as the dropped the half-pig on the table and was rewarded by Bilbo squeaking in indignation. Thorin jumped and severed his peel and glared at his friend causing Dwalin to burst out laughing. Bilbo sighed.

 

“We’ll try another day and at least we can use the apples for apples sauce for the roast,” the Hobbit said. “You couldn’t find a ready-butchered one, could you?” Dwalin chuckled.

 

“I’m sure Bombur would do it for you,” he offered. 

 

“I can butcher a pig-it just makes a mess and I was rather hoping to get some laundry done today,” Bilbo protested. Dwalin clapped him on the back.

 

“I’ll ask Bombur to sort this, you do your laundry and I’ll have a word with this lunkhead here,” the warrior said. Bilbo glanced up to see Thorin square his shoulders, as if preparing himself for an unpleasant duty.

 

“We can try this another day,” he conceded. “But you are not to harangue him, Dwalin. He’s only just recovering and he needs his rest and no stress…” There was that fiercely protective note to his voice once more. The warrior nodded curtly.

 

“Promise not to break him,” he said and grabbed Thorin’s arm, yelling a request for Bombur in Khuzdul. He hauled the dwarf King all the way to Bilbo’s room and shoved him in, then slammed the door. Thorin backed up a couple of paces and folded his arms across his chest, inspecting his friend. The bed was rumpled and the room smelled stale with sweat and illness, adding weight to Bilbo’s desire to do some laundry. 

 

“Say what you will,” Thorin said reluctantly. Dwalin gave a shrug.

 

“I’ve been to the Forge,” he said. “Someone had broken it. A bucket of nails was knocked over.”

 

Thorin frowned and then his face fell. 

 

“Bilbo’s ring,” he murmured. “I left it under there when I…well, I don’t recall what I was doing. I had run out of fuel by then, I was so feverish I almost couldn’t think and I guess I thought it was safe. I have his bead…I’ve been holding it ever since I arrived back here but the ring…”

 

“I didn’t see it,” Dwalin told him. “Someone stole his ring.” Thorin sighed and turned away.

 

“How can I hope to win him back if I have lost his ring?” he sighed. “It’s hopeless…”

 

“You never said that when our people were scattered, marginalised and hopeless,” Dwalin told him. “You were always sure that you would lead us back to Erebor. No matter the distance, the dragon, the orcs and goblins and the fact no one would support us, you knew it would happen. And you succeeded. Why is winning back the trust and love of the One you love harder than that?”

 

“Because this time, I lost it,” Thorin said. “Now I lose his Ring. Maybe Mahal is telling me that I am a foolish old dwarf who has thrown away his one chance.”

 

“I heard that yer head is now clear, since you’re so far away from the Treasury,” Dwalin said and his friend nodded reluctantly. “So why are you still saying such stupid things? If Dis was here, she’s punch you in the gut.”

 

“Thank Mahal for small mercies,” Thorin muttered but eyed his friend carefully.

 

“Oh, I’m not about to hurt you when you’re still so weak,” Dwalin sneered, watching Thorin merely bow his head in acquiescence. And he hated that his friend accepted the taunt: the Thorin he had known all his life would have responded with an equally barbed comment but this one facing him was much more…defeated. “And yer s’posed to tell me I’m an orc’s backside for even thinking such a thing.”

 

“You are right though,” the King murmured. “I should have told him. I should have trusted him. I should have told the StoneSeers to go to Mandos’ Halls and made sure my One knew what any dwarf would have been told. Perhaps then he would understand…”

 

“You both would,” Dwalin muttered and looked at his friend. “I’ll help you in the Forge when yer up on yer feet again while you work out how to properly court your Hobbit.” Thorin groaned.

 

“I need to tell him,” he murmured and nodded. “Now.”

 

Dwalin watched as he walked to the door and went off in search of his estranged husband…and then he followed, meeting Ori on the way. The Scribe looked up at his husband and frowned.

 

“What have I missed now?” he asked. Dwalin grunted.

 

“Our gracious King, Lulkhel the Broody, has managed to lose his husband’s wedding ring,” he said. “Or more correctly, it was stolen from the Forge.” Ori frowned and then glanced in the direction that Thorin had walked. 

 

“I’m not even going to ask all the obvious questions,” he said and hurried after to find Thorin hanging back as Bilbo harangued Bombur about the mess he had made chopping up the half-pig. In fact, he had only taken off the legs and had trussed it to spit roast over a fire his brother and cousin were building in the garden. Then the Hobbit looked up and saw the King, the expression making his heart flutter with anxiety. 

 

“Thorin?” he asked as the King sighed.

 

“I have a confession to make to you-because I do not wish you to think I am holding any more secrets or withholding vital information from you, Bilbo,” the King said warily. Bilbo glanced over at Bombur, who was finishing trussing the pig and then grabbed Thorin and led him to the parlour. He suspected various dwarves were listening but then, his romance had always been public with the entire Company invested in their relationship. Bilbo took his seat and Thorin sank onto the couch, his back straight and chin lifted, looking like the King he was.

 

“Thorin, you are worrying me,” the Hobbit said as the dwarf closed his eyes for a moment.

 

“I am sorry,” the King said. “I should have told you about the way my people love. I should have explained everything you did not know because you aren’t a dwarf. The StoneSeers, the guardians of the most precious secrets of our race, forbad me to share with you, under threat of not recognising my right to rule. That could have been problematic while we were rebuilding…but less so now I’ve banished the three most didactic and traditional StoneSeers and ensured that Kili and Tauriel have been accepted by them. I should have told them to go to Morgoth when they tried to stop our marriage.”

 

Bilbo stared at him. He had known there had been opposition from the more traditional elements in their people but that they had threatened to try to take the throne from Thorin for loving him… Thorin misinterpreted his silence.

 

“I know I was wrong to keep that from you,” he sighed. “And I know you must be angry…" Then he squared his shoulders once more. “When I came to the Shire, I brought your bead and your ring, because I could not bear to be without them. The bead is always with me and usually the ring…but in my fevered state, I hid it in the forge, under the bucket of nails.” Bilbo frowned. “When Dwalin checked the forge, it was gone. It may just be a petty thief or someone with a more serious agenda. But I do not want you think that I would ever give away or relinquish anything of yours without a fight to the death…” The Hobbit looked at the intensity in Thorin’s eyes and the determination in his voice.

 

“Even when you were delirious, you tried to hide it,” he realised as Thorin hung his head. “You think someone is trying to cause trouble?”

 

“There are those who do not want me to remain here and would do anything to turn against me someone who has shown kindness to me,” the dwarf said. “I am certain of it.” He blinked. “But I will accept whatever you decree…” Bilbo stared at him.

 

“What would I decree?” he asked stubbornly. “You were ill and had every right to believe that something you left concealed in a locked up forge would be safe. This is the Shire, not one of the Man realms! But someone broke in. I will have to report it.” Thorin opened his mouth but the Hobbit was looking especially annoyed. “Dwalin-you come with me. Thorin-you will stay here because I am not having you suffer a relapse just because you want to be a hero.” Then he paused and rested his hand on Thorin’s. “And in case you worried, I am touched that you keep my ring and bead. And I am mad someone stole the ring you kept. It is not your fault.” He smiled and then rose. “Come on, Dwalin. I’ll take you to the Shirriffs. Whoever planned this probably won’t expect it.”

 

Then Thorin watched them leave and groaned. He was still none the wiser what he could do to win back his husband. But at least Bilbo hadn’t told him to leave or yelled at him and for Thorin and his battered heart, that could only be a positive.

Chapter 10: Unwelcome Visitors

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

TEN: Unwelcome visitors

 

It was over a week later when Thorin was still pondering on his quandary. The family Ur had finally set out back for Ered Luin, though Bofur had indicated that he would not be averse to moving back to Erebor. Bifur had sat down and had a long talk with Thorin, respectful to the Prince he had followed to Azanulbizar and the King he had accompanied to Erebor but leaving Thorin in no doubt that he did not agree with Thorin’s actions. The King had listened quietly, granting the warrior the time he needed to get his anger off his chest and then he had apologised. He had, of course, not made any allegations against Bifur or Bombur but both had loyally given up their places in the Lonely Mountain to be with the wronged cousin and he apologised for the fallout of his actions, as he had apologised to Bofur. And finally, the warrior had forgiven the King.

 

Thorin’s improvement was slow. The pain in his heart had lessened with Bilbo’s acknowledgement of friendship but it was still a constant ache as his love was near and yet so far away. Bilbo was caring and kind but there was still that distance between the two that hurt Thorin…yet he maintained his facade because it was a skill he had learned before Erebor had fallen, concealing his emotions behind the mask of Royalty. He was beginning to chafe at the inactivity but Bilbo was annoyingly correct when he told the King that the cold, damp late winter air wasn’t good for his chest. Every time he had tried to go out, he had doubled up with coughing and had struggled to breathe. Tauriel and Bilbo had both told him that he was improving but he had become quiet and gloomy as the days passed and he remained confined inside.

 

The doorbell ringing when Bilbo was out caused him to pause. Dwalin and Kili were at the Forge and Tauriel and Ori had accompanied Bilbo to the market. He did consider not answering but in the end, his desire to do something-anything-for Bilbo overrode his misgivings. So he opened the door and bowed his head in greeting.

 

“Master Baggins is currently at Hobbiton Market,” he said. “May I take a message?”

 

He found himself facing three Hobbits-the front one had something of Bilbo around the eyes and his brown hair was curled and neat. His clothing was stylish and obviously expensive. The other two Hobbits were the officious Hobbit from the market who had met Dwalin (who the warrior had described in exacting detail and who Thorin recognised for he had encountered him before in any case) and a dark-haired female with mean eyes, a ridiculous hat perched on top of her curls and a deep red and yellow gown and a spotted red umbrella. 

 

“No-you can let us in to wait for my cousin,” the central Hobbit said. Thorin folded his arms and glared.

 

“I believe it is custom to give your names when you visit,” he said gruffly.

 

“What would a nasty rough dwarf know about manners?” the female hissed. A nasty suspicion formed in Thorin’s mind and he narrowed his eyes. The officious Hobbit looked at her and nodded.

 

“And yet, Mistress Sackville-Baggins, you are fully aware under your own customs that you should offer your name when visiting,” Thorin said. She stared at him and hissed.

 

“I’ll bet my Mad cousin had been…” she began but the central Hobbit raised a hand.

 

“Lobelia, that is enough,” he said. “The dwarf, Master…” He looked up, his brown eyes questioning. Thorin bowed.

 

“Lulkhel of Erebor, at your service,” he forced himself to say. “And you are?” The Hobbit raised an eyebrow.

 

“Fortinbras Took, at yours,” the Hobbit said cheerfully. “I assume you have heard of me?” Thorin sighed and nodded, then reluctantly stood back.

 

“Please enter, Thain Took,” he said smoothly, watching them closely.

 

“My cousin trusts you alone in his home?" Fortinbras asked guilelessly, carefully wiping his feet. Thorin glared at the Sackville-Bagginses-Lobelia and her husband, Otho-until they did likewise and then he escorted them into the parlour.

 

“He does,” Thorin says and then he offered a slight, self-deprecating smile. "Though he does not trust me to entertain. I am afraid I would be thrown out should I dare to attempt a pot of tea.” Fortinbras stared at him-and then burst out laughing.

 

“They say your kind have no sense of humour,” he commented as Thorin uneasily sat in Bilbo’s chair. “How do you know my cousin?”

 

“All the dwarves of Erebor know of Master Baggins,” he said clearly. “He is a national hero for he was one of the small group who reclaimed our home for us.”

 

“He ran off with a group of nasty brutish dwarves,” Lobelia sneered. “How could he…?” Fortinbras raised a hand. 

 

“I would be interested to hear-from the dwarvish point of view, if you may,” the Thain said. “Would you indulge us, Master Lulkhel?” Thorin took a deep breath and coughed, the spasm passing sooner than it had two days earlier, then nodded.

 

“The Company of Thorin Oakenshield came to the Shire under the advice of Tharkûn, the wizard you would know as Gandalf the Grey,” Thorin said. “He recommended a Hobbit for a covert task-to penetrate Erebor and sneak past the dragon who drove our people from our home. He suggested Master Baggins. He was approached-and he said no.” He looked up. “But he changed his mind, for he caught up with the Company only a half-hour after they had left and joined the Quest. They met many dangers-trolls and goblins, orcs and wargs. But they also met allies, visiting Lord Elrond at Rivendell and being saved from doom by the Eagles. They got lost in Goblintown and were captured in Mirkwood. And along the way, the intelligence and courage of Master Baggins saved the Company.”

 

There was a small smirk on Fortinbras’s lips.

 

“His mother’s blood,” he commented and looked up. “Bilbo is a Took on his mother’s side. We are more adventurous than most Hobbits and while Lobelia is utterly mortified, I am heartened that Bilbo took his chance.” He waved Thorin on.

 

“Master Baggins rescued the dwarves from the ElvenKing’s dungeons…” Thorin began.

 

“I knew it!” Lobelia spat. “Criminals, the lot of them!” Fortinbras saw Thorin’s mouth flatten in a suppressed scowl.

 

“And why were they locked up?” the Thain asked.

 

“The Company were lost, short of food and water and they were attacked by giant spiders,” Thorin said slowly. “Master Baggins saved them from being eaten but the Elves captured them for trespassing off the pathway…and being dwarves in the ElvenKing’s Realm. Bilbo freed us.”

 

“You were on the Quest?” Fortinbras noted and Thorin nodded, internally kicking himself for revealing the fact. He had to hope that Bilbo hadn’t told the names of all the dwarves in the Company to this Hobbit…though he guessed that his husband had been reticent in going into much detail, if Lobelia and Gardenia’s reactions were typical for the Shire.

 

“We reached Laketown and were welcomed…on condition we would pay for the poor weapons and board we were offered,” he said. “Then we travelled on and finally made it to the mountain on the very morning of Durin’s Day. Bilbo never gave up hope even when the sun set and the hidden keyhole did not appear. But the last light of Durin’s Day-the moonlight-fell on the door and he called us back in time. The door opened and we entered.” He took a deep breath. “He riddled with a dragon and survived but Smaug came out to kill the Company. When he could not get to us, he attacked Laketown and was felled by the grandson of King Girion of Dale, Bard the Bowman. The dragon was dead and Erebor was in the hands of the Company.”

 

“I sense the tale isn’t over,” Fortinbras said. Thorin bowed his head.

 

“The treasure of Erebor is the greatest in the world but it had lain under a dragon for a hundred and seventy years and a sickness lay upon it,” Thorin looked up. “All the dwarves were afflicted to a greater or lesser extent, by Dragon Sickness, an unnatural love of gold and treasure to the exclusion of all else. It stops you doing anything but looking at and being with the treasure-including eating, drinking and sleeping. And it invokes a jealous, possessive madness that would make every dwarf spend his life and that of everyone he loved to protect the gold.

 

None were worse affected than Thorin, now King of Erebor. He broke oaths, threatened his Company and descended into absolute madness. He sought the King’s Jewel, the Arkenstone, which was lost in the Treasury and which would enable him to command all seven families of the Dwarves. But Bilbo knew that he should not get it, for it would certainly make his insanity irretrievable. The Men of Laketown-which was destroyed by the attack of the dragon as well as the forces of the ElvenKing who had just turned up drawn by the treasure-had arrived at the Gates of Erebor and were threatening war on the thirteen dwarves and one Hobbit. It would have meant the destruction of the Company and Bilbo’s friends. So during the night, he took the Arkenstone to Bard and King Thranduil, as a surety against the gold Thorin had promised the Men of Laketown to help rebuild and for the White Gems of Lasgalen, which King Thror had cheated Thranduil of, a hundred and eighty years ago.”

 

“A brave act,” Fortinbras commented.

 

“He should never have interfered in the affairs of the other races,” Lobelia commented shrilly. 

 

“He returned to Erebor and when Bard and Thranduil showed Thorin the jewel, he owned that he was the one who had taken it. He was banished for his actions, fleeing the threats of the King, Yet Thorin raged and threatened and refused to bend, choosing war over relinquishing a single coin of the treasure. But as all looked lost, the forces of Lord Dain of the Iron Hills arrived to support Thorin…and before any senseless conflict could break out, the orc armies of Azog the Defiler, the bane of the Line of Durin and Bolg, his vile spawn attacked. A huge battle ensued but Bilbo would not abandon his friends. He followed the King and his nephews, the Princes Fili and Kili and their cousin Dwalin up to Ravenhill and warned them that it was a trap. Azog attacked and Fili and Kili were gravely wounded-all thought they had been killed. Thorin fought mortal combat with Azog and slew him but earned terrible wounds. Yet the Eagles arrived along with Skinchanger Beorn and the forces of evil were defeated.”

 

“Good gracious,” Fortinbras commented. “Cousin Bilbo really did have a busy time.”

 

“And he should have come straight home after all that nastiness,” Otho commented prissily, dabbing at his nose with his handkerchief as if the very mention of Battle was noxious. 

 

“He stayed because he was asked by the King,” Thorin said softly. “The King, who hovered on the brink of death for many days, begged forgiveness of him, for his words and deeds. The madness had left him and he saw now that Bilbo only sought to save lives and the Company in particular and invited him to stay. So he did, helping rebuild the home of the dwarves. But in the end, he was called home, as we all are. But I and every dwarf in Erebor owes him a debt that can never be repaid.”

 

“Thank you, Master Lulkhel,” Fortinbras said, ignoring the snorts of derision of the Sackville-Bagginses. “I think we have undervalued Bilbo quite badly.”

 

“I’ll remind you of that at the next Took family gathering,” Bilbo said from the doorway. 

 

“I insisted we were admitted,” Fortinbras said quickly. “Your friend was happy to keep us on the doorstep because we failed to introduce ourselves and he would not permit strangers into your home. He also did not inflict his tea on us…” Bilbo smiled.

 

“Then you had a lucky escape,” he admitted. “On the Quest, we had to keep him away from the cooking fire. The Company all knew that his cooking skills almost rated as badly as his navigational ones.” Lobelia snorted and Otho, at her side, looked outraged. “Now, if you will excuse me, I will get you some refreshments. If you would help me…?” He looked pointedly at the dwarf and Thorin rose, bowing his head regally to the seated Hobbits.

 

“If you will excuse me…” he said and the followed Bilbo out of the parlour and round the corner into the kitchen. Bilbo was waiting, glaring at him.

 

“Not the selection of visitors I would have chosen,” he commented, filling the kettle. Thorin reached for the biggest pot and placed the tea caddy by Bilbo’s side, waiting for his instructions. 

 

“I had little choice if I didn’t want them hanging around on your doorstep or worsening your reputation,” Thorin said quietly. “And when they asked of the Quest, I removed all references to burglars, romance or anything scandalous. And no weddings.” Bilbo looked up. “Your private life is your own, Bilbo, and I will not compromise it. I am afraid I let slip I was on the Quest simply because I did not want to undersell your heroism.”

 

“I’m afraid Hobbits don’t really set much store on that sort of thing,” Bilbo sighed, spooning the tea into the pot. “If I had set up a baking circle, taught you all manners and introduced waistcoats into Erebor, they may be more interested…but not much.” But he shook his head when Thorin reached for the tray. “You’re still coughing a lot and I don’t want to lose this. Bring the biscuits please-if they get dropped, it’s less of a disaster as I have more batches-some even Dwalin doesn’t know about…”

 

“I doubt that,” Thorin muttered. “He’s like a warg after a dwarf when it comes to biscuits.”

 

“I’m not sure I like the allusion but I get your drift,” Bilbo said as he lifted the loaded tray and headed into the parlour. Pausing to wait until Bilbo had left the room, Thorin doubled up with coughing, leaving him gasping and resting his hands on the table while he got his breath back. Then he lifted the tray and walked in.

 

“That sounds nasty, Master Lulkhel,” Fortinbras said amiably as he entered and rested the plate down. Bilbo was serving tea with aplomb and the biscuit platter went round slowly. Thorin sipped his tea and sat on the seat by the window while Bilbo faced his relatives. He would leave when asked but he felt guilty that he had let them in.

 

“I am much improved, Master Took,” he said clearly.

 

“He was turned away from the Green Dragon, Fortinbras,” Bilbo said tartly. “Standards there have dropped.” The Thain frowned and Lobelia looked triumphant. “Really? You are siding with turning away a being in a blizzard?”

 

“You know I don’t condone that, Bilbo-but some of our neighbours are not so decent,” the Thain said pointedly, earning him scorching glares from Lobelia and Otho. “And that is the reason why I am here…” Bilbo folded his arms and glared at them.

 

“Have I committed some crime, Forti?” he asked sarcastically. “Hosting dwarves without a license? Being sociable with other races? Saving lives recklessly?”

 

“I think it may be far too late for the last one,” Fortinbras shot back with a wry smile. “But yes, I have had complaints from Gardenia Proudfoot…”

 

“Can you have a word with her?” Bilbo asked miserably. “All she does is follow Th…Lulkhel around and tries to poison everyone against him. She came up here when he was here, deathly ill, with the intent of persuading me to cast him out…to die! That kind of vindictiveness cannot be tolerated, Fortinbras!”

 

“She claims…”

 

“I think everyone in the West Farthing knows what she claims,” Bilbo interrupted. “And I can tell you now, it’s utter nonsense. He didn’t know the language of flowers or what she was trying to do…to him, flowers are just pretty. Food is just food. And he would see no ulterior motive there.”

 

“Why?” the Thain asked.

 

“Two simple reasons. One-he isn’t into the lasses, so to speak. But more importantly, he’s already married. And like Hobbits, a dwarf who has met his Heart-Mate, that they call a ‘One’, will never consider another romantically. They love only once.”

 

“So she was chasing a married dwarf who wasn’t even attracted to her,” the Thain checked, a smile lifting his lips.

 

“That’s the size of it,” Bilbo told him bluntly. “And everything she claims about him ‘leading her on’ is utter tosh! He’s pretty much ignorant of any Hobbit courting rituals. And she wasn’t coming close to any Dwarvish declaration of intent.” The Thain frowned.

 

“Which is…?”

 

“They talk, discuss the future, families and so on,” Bilbo explained. Thorin stiffened, wondering how much Bilbo would reveal. But he trusted his husband to be discreet about his people’s ways and remained silent, sipping his tea and staring at the floor. “They also give specific gifts to signal intent-but they are dwarvish things like weapons and metal, not food and flowers. To them, they have meaning. To us…they’re just unusual mathoms. Fluttering eyelashes at a dwarf and giving him a bunch of Heliotrope would just confuse him and make him wonder if you were unwell.”

 

Fortinbras burst out laughing again even as he reached for an orange and lemon biscuit.

 

“So she really was talking a totally unknown language to him,” he chuckled. “No wonder she was so annoyed and he was so surprised. It really is a pity our people are so insular and set in their ways because from what I have observed of Master Lulkhel, he seems sociable but reserved and polite. And of course, he enjoys food and drink like the rest of us.” Bilbo stole a look over at Thorin, who was still looking pale and thinner than he ought.

 

“He’s a good dwarf and a generous and brave individual,” he said. “He would do anything to help because that is the way his people are made.”

 

“Gardenia was also making a very strange claim about you,” the Thain asked him sternly. “Something about already being his husband?”

 

Bilbo put his cup down more firmly that he would normally risk with his mother’s best crockery but nodded.

 

“Lulkhel and I are married,” he said clearly. “We have had some issues last year so we were taking some time apart. Against my expectations, he came here because dwarves don’t tolerate parting from their loved Ones well and I was not happy at all when he turned up. Especially when he tried to keep his distance to respect my space. We both have some issues we need to deal with-which are cultural and private. But I would not allow him to die and her cruelty to him was beyond acceptable.”

 

“So you are separated,” the Thain mused. “Do you have a wedding band…?”

 

“I gave my bead back to Th…Lulkhel when I came home,” the Hobbit said shortly. 

 

“Does he have another name?” Otho asked pointedly “You’ve nearly called him something else a couple of times now.” Bilbo sighed.

 

“When you are married, you use terms of endearment and mine are in Khuzdul, the dwarf language,” Bilbo said. “Having him here has confused me. I know he wanted to try to make up to me and win me back and I am not averse to him doing so. But the last thing I want is nosy relatives interfering…”

 

“And did you actually threatened Gardenia’s young man?” Fortinbras asked. Bilbo scowled.

 

“That pig-faced lump of lard?” he asked sharply. “Yes-he thought he could force his way in and try to intimidate me. I wouldn’t have stabbed him…much. And I doubt I would have hit anything important through all those layers of flab. I’m not that good a swordsman.”

 

Thorin snorted, expressing his opinion. Fortinbras cast him a side-eyed look.

 

“I think Master Lulkhel disagrees,” he said.

 

“He faced Azog the Defiler when Thorin made a suicidal charge at him during the Quest,” the King said evenly. “He slew the orc about to take the King’s head and caused Azog and his white warg to back off…” Fortinbras burst out laughing again.

 

“I will make a point to tell Jumbo that he had a lucky escape and that he really shouldn’t try to force his way into another Hobbit’s homes,” he said with a twinkle in his eye. “It’s shockingly bad manners-which I am going to publicise, since he’s whining about your ‘unprovoked attack’-and in the wrong house, could lead to serious injury. And I was thinking about Widow Chubb, by the way, when I say that. She keeps a scythe in her parlour, Yavanna only knows why, but she would go after any intruder and I doubt she would stop until they were in pieces or running for their lives.”

 

“Bilbo! Otho and I are most displeased with the way you are conducting yourself!” Lobelia cut in, clearly deciding that her point of view was not being put forward strongly enough. “Hosting these nasty, crude dwarves here is not to be allowed. They will damage Bag End and destroy the fixtures. And since we are your heirs, it’s our right to show an interest in the property we are going to inherit and must stop you damaging it…”

 

Bilbo burst out laughing. She drew herself up indignantly.

 

“I hardly see what…” she began to bluster but Bilbo stopped laughing immediately.

 

“You are not my heirs and you will never inherit Bag End,” he told her ruthlessly. “I am Master of Bag End and it is my property, built by my father for my mother. And while I live here, I will decide what I do with my own property and who I decide to host here. Neither you nor anyone else can tell me who I invite into my home. Is that clear?”

 

“I have never been so insulted in my life…” Lobelia began.

 

“You should get out more,” Bilbo cut in. “I’m sure you could be if you tried.”

 

“But Otho is your cousin and as such he is your heir…” Lobelia protested angrily.

 

“I have other cousins-ones who did not try to claim Bag End while I was away travelling,” Bilbo told her coldly. “When Erebor was secure, I wrote to Forti here and he told me that you tried to get me declared dead when I had been gone a month. A month! Most unattached Hobbits visit their relatives for longer than that in the summer! So I know exactly where I stand in your affections! And Odo Proudfoot and Falco Chubb-Baggins are as closely related to me as you are, Otho-but I don’t see their wives pocketing my silver spoons! I have other cousins who have treated me well since I returned from my adventures and I am grateful to them, for the rest of you have treated me like an orc and a pariah! So as of my last birthday, Drogo Baggins is my heir. He’s of age, he’s decent and hardworking and he visits me to spend time with me, not lecture me on how I am a disgrace to the name Baggins.”

 

“Beyond the Shire, the name Baggins is respected and honoured among the Elves of Mirkwood and Rivendell, the Men of Dale and the Dwarves of Erebor and the Iron Hills…” Thorin put in. “You may find that if you meet any outside your race, you will be the disappointment of the family Baggins, not Bilbo.”

 

“Well, we’re in the Shire now and…” Lobelia began spitefully. Fortinbras raised a hand peremptorily.

 

“And the laws of Shire inheritance apply-which means that a Hobbit can nominate his own heirs. And he has stated in front of witnesses-both his lawyer and me, by the way-that he wishes Drogo Baggins to inherit Bag End. You already have a home, Lobelia. Why do you covet Bilbo’s?”

 

“Because it should be mine!” she spat. “Not belonging to some insane disgrace of a Hobbit who runs away with a bunch of dwarves-barely better than animals, if you want my opinion-and comes back here claiming to have married one of the nasty brutes! And not just one-no, he married a male! It’s downright unnatural, if you ask me!”

 

“No one did,” Fortinbras cut in. “And there is no law against such unions in the Shire, Lobelia. The only problem are the prejudices that lurk in your own heart.”

 

“Lady Yavanna made us Heart-Mates so we can wed and produce fauntlings!” Lobelia sniped. “To pretend that a union with…another male…is in any way equal is just disregarding the gifts of Yavanna. No good will come of it and I wouldn’t be surprised if the pair of you aren’t cursed for your unnatural lusts!” Her face expressed her revulsion and she rose abruptly. “I won’t stay near this revolting creature a moment longer.”

 

“Oh thank Mahal,” Bilbo said deliberately. “Goodbye, Lobelia. I hasn’t been a pleasure so you do understand you aren’t welcome to come back here. Ever.” She froze and stared at him but Otho had already opened his mouth.

 

“How dare you speak to my wife like that?” he spat. “You disgrace! Your father would be spinning in his grave at the disgrace you have brought on our name. I can say now that everyone in the Baggins family will ignore the fact you even live. You will not be welcome at any family get-togethers. And we’ll make that ridiculous Belba see the error of her ways and cut you off as well. You will have no one!”

 

“He will always have me!” Thorin snarled and rose, walking steadily towards the pair who were crowding Bilbo. “Now I believe you have been asked to leave. You can either turn and exercise that option now or I will ensure that you do so.” Instantly, the pair turned on him.

 

“And no one cares what you want, you disgusting perverted creature!” Otho sneered but Thorin grabbed him by the collar and Lobeila by the arm and propelled them to the door. Still protesting, cursing and spitting, they were propelled out the door and Lobelia’s umbrella tossed out after them. But he had barely slammed the door behind them when he doubled up, coughing at the exertion. Fortinbras shared a concerned look with his cousin.

 

“Far be it for me to tell you your business,” he said clearly, “but I would get someone to look at that. It doesn’t sound good.” Bilbo looked at him, eyes narrowed slightly.

 

“That’s improving,” he said dryly. The Thain inspected his cousin carefully.

 

“Gardenia really wanted you to throw him out?” he checked in a thoughtful voice. Pausing and exhaling heavily, Bilbo nodded. 

 

“Her vendetta is dangerous,” he said quietly. “Her hatred for someone who was never interested in her is making her forget everything that makes her a Hobbit.” The Thain rose, his expression determined.

 

“I’ll see myself out,” he said as he eyed Thorin. “And Bilbo? Whatever you decide, you know you have my support. But…” He paused. “Love is rare, true love moreso. And while differences may seem important, time with one you love and who loves you is priceless because, as your mother knew, that time can end abruptly and far too soon.” Then he walked confidently out, closing the door behind himself. The King looked up warily, still breathing hard after the paroxysm. 

 

“I don’t need you throw my relatives out,” Bilbo said sternly as the dwarf closed his eyes. “But I am grateful that you did. I was thinking about getting Sting.”

 

“I could have lent you Orcrist,” the King managed and then straightened up. “I do not mean to intrude…” Bilbo stared into the pale face and sighed.

 

“I’m rethinking the Quest idea,” he said quietly. “Do you fancy slaying two dragons, one of them with an umbrella?” Thorin gave a small bow of the head.

 

“You know that I will do anything for you, Bilbo,” he said quietly. The Hobbit stared at him and sighed.

 

“That’s a lot of power to hand to anyone,” he admitted. “Just stay here. I don’t want to think of you leaving Bag End and staying anywhere else. I don’t want you hurt, Thorin.”

 

The King raised his chin and nodded.

 

“Be honest with me, Amrâlimê,” he said slowly. “Is there any hope?”

 

Bilbo stared at the space above his mantlepiece, at the pictures of his parents hanging there and then he sighed.

 

“My mother lost my father and losing her love caused her to fade within the season,” he said. “Dis has told me how the hollowness of losing her husband still haunts her at nights.” Thorin blinked: that was something she had never shared with him, no matter how close they were. He swallowed. “And Balin has spoken to me of when his wife perished in the fall of Erebor. He feels it even now.” The Hobbit shrugged. “I am lucky that you live-you almost didn’t, twice over. So I need to realise how fortunate I am…and consider how I could possibly consider rejecting the amazing chance my Maker has given me-a chance my mother and Dis and Balin would never turn down. But Hobbits need trust as well as love in a relationship.”

 

“I understand,” the dwarf said heavily. 

 

“No-I have declared you are my husband,” Bilbo said. “I want to give you a chance, Thorin. I-I just need to know that you trust me. I cannot risk my heart and my life unless I know for sure.” The King gave a small incline of the head, closing his eyes for a second.

 

“I do, utterly,” he said clearly. “But somehow, I will prove it to you.”

 

“I hope so,” Bilbo said, “because I would like to go home.” The King stiffened and the animation fell from his face.

 

“You don’t need to wait,” he said. “Your banishment was revoked. You can return any time.”

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Amrâlimê - my love

Chapter 11: Fading

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

ELEVEN: Fading

 

The weather got colder again, as if conspiring to keep Thorin constrained within Bag End and frustrated. His chest recovered far slower than he had imagined-but then, he had neglected himself to a degree that would normally end in death and it had only been the determined efforts of Bilbo and Tauriel than had spared him that fate. Even though Bilbo had claimed him as his friend and had admitted to being his husband, the lack of a formal reconciliation had only partly eased the gnawing pain in his chest and the exhaustion that lay on him like a heavy hand. But weak and miserable as he was, he chafed at the idleness and ended up puttering around the smial, getting under Bilbo’s feet and just making things worse. 

 

So he retreated to the spare room he had insisted on moving into when his fever was broken-only because Bilbo would not permit him to move back to the Forge or the Inn-and brooded. Every action in his life was ruthlessly dissected and every foolish, prideful or reckless act was castigated. He had done so much wrong and had never deserved to succeed. His whole life was on litany of failure, starting from the dragon and working on. He covered his face with his hands and tried to push back the memories-but the dam was broken.

 

Mahal, he had been leading the guards trying to protect the Gates of Erebor that fateful day when Smaug burst in and they had been swatted aside like gnats. He had saved Thror but others of his family had been trapped in the mountain and he had ended up shepherding what remained of his people away from their home, ragged and singed and shocked. And with his grandfather’s faltering sanity and his father’s shock, he had been forced to lead. And there had been mistakes and failures. Dwarves had died from exposure or hunger or disease. Infants died before their time. the elderly and frail succumbed. It had all been on him because there was no one else who had stood forward, especially not the pompous Lords who had stolen off like thieves in the night to relatives in the Iron Hills, leaving the commoners to their fate. They had wandered, hopeless and desperate, always cheated and sneered at until the catastrophe of Azanulbizar had shrunk the remains of his family down to himself, Dis, young Fili and her unborn son. So the ragged remnants of the Longbeards had finally gone to Ered Luin and Thorin had worked himself to the bone, trying to build a life for what was left of his people. But always, he thought of Erebor, of home, of the promise he had silently made as they fled from the gates of the Lonely Mountain: one day he would bring them home.

 

Yet he had led a small band of neither the best nor brightest who had followed him with courage, honour and a willing heart while the other Lords had scorned him and refused. Even a Hobbit had been more willing than his own cousin and somehow, despite Thorin rather than because of him, they had succeeded. But his mind had become fogged by Dragon Sickness and madness-though it had mostly lifted to allow him to lead them in the Battle. And even after, when he had recovered from his horrific wounds, it was always there, like a nagging buzz at the back of his mind. Bilbo had seemed to ward it off-or maybe he had switched his illness to considering Bilbo as his treasure rather than gold and gemstones. But finally, it had overcome him and it had cost him everything he cared for…

 

He wrapped his arms across his chest, trying to ignore the burning pain. Brooding and moping made it worse but then, no one had ever accused Thorin of being wise. Reckless, brave, stubborn-those he would own-but sage? Never a word applied to the Line of Durin.

 

A knock on the door made him start and he looked up as Bilbo poked his head round the door, frowning as he read the King’s face.

 

“Are you alright?” he asked automatically. 

 

“I am well,” Thorin lied. Bilbo moved into the room and stared at him.

 

“You look like you’re moping…or at least brooding,” he noted as Thorin sighed. The dwarf forced his face back into the practiced mask that he wore in Erebor. 

 

“There is little more I can do, Bilbo,” he said awkwardly. “I am under your feet, I cannot go to the forge because I cannot breathe in the cold and I am a mere nuisance.” He sighed. “I tried to help around your home but I only anger you. Yet you will not hear of me staying anywhere else.” The Hobbit stared at him and then walked to sit by him on the bed, staring at the larger shape at his side.

 

“I’m not going to say I understand because I don’t, fully,” Bilbo said, his voice honest. “But I know it must be hard. You are the King and have been since you were far too young. You have always been in control of your fate…” But the dwarf gave a bitter laugh.

 

“I’ve rarely been in control of my fate,” he said gruffly. “My fate has controlled me. And yet, when the wizard brought us here before the Quest, I told him I would not guarantee your safety, nor be responsible for your fate. Yet you were responsible for our safety and ensured that our fate was not to be a footnote in history as a failed mission to reclaim the mountain.” Bilbo looked away, clearly uncomfortable at the praise.

 

“But you have been able to contribute and have been involved in decisions about the Kingdom…whereas here, you are a visitor,” Bilbo sighed. “But you have Dwalin, Kili, Ori and Tauriel here for you…” Thorin looked pained.

 

“My sister-son is in love with the Elf and they are quite nauseating,” he said. “Dwalin is a good friend but he is out working. I feel as useless as the day Smaug took Erebor. I am no help to you.” Bilbo looked at him.

 

“Can you peel potatoes?” the Hobbit asked him suddenly. Thorin blinked. “I need some peeling. It would be a help. If you don’t mind, that is…”

 

Thorin stared at him. He was being asked to do work that was the tasks of the menials in the kitchens when he was actually a King…but Bilbo was asking him and it was a relief to be asked for anything by the one he loved. He rose.

 

“I would be delighted,” he said honestly and waited for Bilbo to lead. The Hobbit rose and gave a small smile.

 

“Come on then,” he said. “Those chips aren’t going to make themselves.”

 

But cooking with Bilbo was a stopgap measure because he still had no idea how he could demonstrate that he trusted Bilbo. The fact that he would trust his life to the Hobbit didn’t seem to be enough because his words had shattered what they had, that intimate understanding that had grown between them since he had woken after the Battle. And while he had dreamed since that fateful day when the Dragon came of being King, his heart had pushed all that aside when he had fallen in love because his goals had changed. Being King was his duty but the only thing he wanted was his husband.

 

When the weather finally improved again, he headed out-though not without the Hobbit fussing. His coat had been cleaned and brushed and Ori had knitted him a ridiculously long scarf that the Hobbit wound round and around his neck before Bilbo would allow him out. The air was crisp and clear on a sparkling late winter morning and when he took a deep breath, the air caused him to cough but the spasm passed swiftly and he was no longer gasping for breath after. So he smiled at the Hobbit and walked down the path from the green door. 

 

Yet he was unable to enjoy the Shire, no matter how gorgeous the morning. The weak sun held no warmth and the brightness was almost dazzling but he strode heavily and steadily as he walked in the direction of the Forge. There were eyes on him, watching him without sympathy and when he looked up, the Hobbits ducked back. And under his breath, he cursed Gardenia Proudfoot for whatever she had lied about this time. His newfound knowledge of the language of plants-incomplete and imperfect as it was-told him that she had been blatant in her proposal and that a Hobbit would certainly be rather scandalised by her behaviour. But as a dwarf, he wouldn’t-couldn’t-have understood. Not that he would ever find someone like Gardenia attractive. And then Bilbo’s words floated back and he frowned as he walked. 

 

Hobbits prefer to talk things through…

 

A proper Hobbit would have talked to him and made their intent obvious-after checking he was available and interested. A proper Hobbit would not have mounted a vicious campaign against the outsider to isolate and ostracise him-but vanity…well, that he could understand. Not that he had much vanity for his looks, for he was not considered anything other than plan or worse by his own people. No he suffered from vanity of his Line, of his Throne, of his people and would exult in those against any competition. How many times had he sneered at the Elves, knowing that their kind-at least in ages past-had skills the equal of or maybe superior to his own people. Mahal, he carried an Elvish sword forged in Gondolin! (And it was the finest blade he had ever seen or wielded). How he had defended Erebor against criticism even when he knew that Thror’s actions had been reprehensible. And now…he had allowed his pride and vanity in his position and dignity as the King to overcome his duties as a husband.

 

No wonder it was hopeless.

 

He stopped and stared ahead, almost unseeing. How could he possibly hope to regain Bilbo’s trust when the Hobbit was pleasant and caring but had made it clear that he had hardened his heart against the dwarf? Hobbits, it seemed, faded far more easily than dwarves and the fracture in their relationship threatened Bilbo’s life as much as it did Thorin-but Bilbo had taken the steps he needed to in order to protect himself. Thorin didn’t even know if that could be reversed because there was no lore on inter-species relationships. Except what his heart told him. And Thorin’s heart told him he had probably thrown away his last chance.

 

He made his way to the forge and found his cousin there already, the fire lit and the room already reasonably warm. It was almost certainly Bilbo’s work, ensuring that Thorin didn’t have an icy cold forge to go into when he returned to work and he smiled inwardly at the Hobbit’s concern. Dwalin looked up.

 

“You dragged your lazy carcass out of the house at least, did yer?” the warrior asked, his grin showing he was relieved to see his friend out at last but there was an inflection in his voice that showed he was still worried. Thorin took off his coat and the scarf and hung them up on the nail at the back of the door, starting to roll up his sleeves. 

 

“Couldn’t let you wreck the place while I'm gone," Thorin replied, glancing around. The place was still set up as he preferred it and Dwalin was heating some metal in the fire.

 

“I dunno,” Dwalin grinned. “Market traders seem to have taken to me. That baker woman makes a tasty cinnamon and raisin biscuit…” 

 

“They’ll soon realise feeding you biscuits is a straight route to bankruptcy,” Thorin retorted.

 

“You’re a fine one to talk about straight routes,” Dwalin taunted him, pulling the iron out of the fire and tapping it lightly with a hammer. “Did you get lost, twice?”

 

“Will you ever let that drop?” Thorin asked him dryly. Dwalin chuckled.

 

“Maybe in a century,” he replied and then his face fell slightly. “The traders have been asking about you as well.” Thorin glanced up.

 

“What are we making?” he asked.

 

“Lock,” Dwalin answered. “Simple three bar. They seem to be friendly. Asked me every day how you were doing. Not all these hobbits are prejudiced.”

 

“Hmm,” Thorin muttered. “But…”

 

“There's talk in the market as well,” his friend revealed. Thorin started hammering out another piece of metal from the fire, the strokes even and regular. He didn’t want to mention his chest felt tight with the smoke from the fire and the scent of hot metal.

 

“Yes?”

 

“There’s a new rumour that you’ve been courting another Hobbit,” Dwalin revealed. “I sent Ori round to chat to the stallholders and listen in. It’s in Hobbiton Market as well.” The King looked up and then shrugged.

 

“I haven’t,” he said flatly and continued hammering.

 

“But Bilbo…”

 

“Knows who and what I am,” Thorin continued, lifting the metal up with a pair of tongs and frowning, before putting it back in the fire. “He will not believe it.”

 

“Look, you need to tell him that you love him…” Dwalin was staring at him.

 

“He knows. We’ve talked.”

 

“Then…” The warrior was starting to look exasperated.

 

“The problem is not that of love but my foolishness gave him cause to think that I did not trust him,” Thorin reminded his friend. “But I have no idea how to demonstrate such.”

 

“Start by showing him that you love him,” Dwalin growled. “I even worked out how to do it-but of course, I’m not an emotionally-stunted son-of-a-dragon…” Thorin shook his head.

 

“I’ve given him flowers,” he said and then Dwalin did walk forward and glare at him.

 

“Imagine he was a dwarf,” he hissed.

 

“This wouldn’t be happening if he was a dwarf,” Thorin reminded him.

 

“It shouldn’t be happening anyway!” Dwalin snapped. “And wouldn’t if you weren’t such a stubborn ass that you didn’t think to ask yer Hobbit about his own side of things. He is your One but you are whatever a Hobbit calls it…”

 

“Heart-Mate,” Thorin murmured. 

 

“Whatever they call it, the One you love wants to be shown it, not treated to some expert pining and grumpy looks,” Dwalin told him bluntly.

 

“What can I give Bilbo?” Thorin hissed. “He is home among his kind-who he doesn’t actually like that much. He wants to go back to Erebor. I’ve told him that he can return. But I am not sure that he believes me.”

 

“And why wouldn’t he?” Dwalin asked him. The King covered his face with his hands.

 

“I have let him down one time too many,” he sighed. “I fear he will never trust me. Maybe if you took him back so he could see his friends once more, he would be happy.” Dwalin stared at him. 

 

“You talk like you aren’t coming,” he said and Thorin looked up, his eyes haunted.

 

“The fading has slowed but not stopped,” he said quietly. “The journey is long and at the end…there is still nothing for me. I will not be travelling again.” Dwalin froze and his eyes flooded with concern.

 

“Thorin…” he said softly. The King quietly fished the now-red metal from the fire once more.

 

“Without my One, without my heart, I may just arrive home to die,” he said emotionlessly. "Bilbo rejected me and though he has offered me friendship, it is not enough. It is close to two years since…I broke our marriage. Not many last this long after Rejection: I should be grateful.”

 

“You have to tell him,” Dwalin urged. But the dwarf King shook his head.

 

“To what end?” he asked. “He still loves me but he does not trust me and without that, he will not consider anything more.”

 

“Then court him! Show him that you care and love and trust him,” the warrior urged him. But Thorin lifted his chin and locked his fiercest gaze on his friend.

 

“You cannot tell him,” he said firmly. “I will not make him feel obligated to accept me out of concern for my wellbeing. He wishes to return to Erebor and see his friends. If he wishes to go, you and Ori must accompany him.”

 

“But…”

 

“Swear!” The tone was that of the King and after a long look, Dwalin slowly bowed his head.

 

“As you wish, Your Majesty,” he murmured. Then Thorin bowed his head.

 

“But I could still use your help in courting him,” he murmured he turned back to the metal.

 

He was more aware of the accusing eyes on him, the expressions of the Hobbits varying between shocked, disgusted and scornful. There were whispers in the market, some stallholders refusing to serve him and he wanted to yell at them that the accusations were lies-whatever they were. He was a dwarf, a creation of Mahal who was bound to his One and could no more be unfaithful to his husband that he could turn into an Elf. But Hobbits didn’t know that and it was clear they didn’t care. And while he had endured stoically before, there was a part of him that desired to defend his honour. But while he was Rejected, he had none. In the eyes of dwarves, he really was without honour for he had been Rejected by the one perfect gift Mahal had given him. And though he was a King, it meant nothing.

 

He took to avoiding the market except the couple of Hobbits who had always been open and welcoming. Dwalin and sometimes Kili worked with him in the forge and there were moments when he could recall teaching Fili and Kili basic forging when times were hard and he couldn’t afford the fees for any apprenticeships. Kili was deft and when he concentrated, he was reasonably skilled at fine work. Thorin had completed his Mastery and it eased his heart to teach his nephew tricks and tips he himself had learned from his Master which would stand his nephew in good stead when he needed to forge. He guessed that Kili was humouring him since why would the Prince-and first Heir to the Crown Prince-ever need to know how to deal with poor quality ores as he had learned during their wandering days? But concentrating on teaching distracted him from everything else.

 

As the days lengthened and the temperatures rose, snowdrops and crocuses poked through the muddy ground and buds enlarged on the  branches, almost ready to burst into leaf. Thorin made and remade a number of small gifts, items for the kitchen that would make Bilbo’s life easier that he took to leaving in the kitchen when Bilbo wasn’t looking. He mended everything he could find in the smial and generally did everything he could to contribute. He helped in the kitchen and answered the few Ravens that arrived with questions from Fili, Balin or Dis but he never gave any news of himself because there was none. Bilbo remained amiable but distant and Thorin was beginning to give up hope. 

 

Until a morning when the early blossom was starting to burst out and the yellow flowers of the forsythia bushes were glowing like drops of sun in the hedges. Bilbo burst in and stormed towards Thorin, his face flushed with anger and humiliation.

 

“I have been harangued in the Market and in the Green Dragon for taking up with an adulterer,” he said furiously. “Did you know there was someone alleging you had been courting them?” Thorin looked up and nodded.

 

“I was aware of the rumours,” he said gruffly. “Though none were spoken in my hearing.”

 

“I can assure you that they have been spoken in mine!” Bilbo spat. “I’m being accused of stealing another Hobbit’s betrothed. And no one credits that we are married…they don’t see a ring or braid and the Hobbit in question supposedly has a ring…” Thorin stared at his husband and bowed his head.

 

“I explained that it had been stolen,” he reminded Bilbo and the Hobbit stared at him, then slowly sat down. 

 

“Dwalin found it stolen,” he amended. “And I know both of you are honest. Whatever this girl is saying, it must be a misunderstanding…” He looked up. “Or something darker.” Thorin gave a small incline of the head. 

 

“I cannot ask you to trust me,” he said, “but…”

 

“Thorin, I trust you,” Bilbo said. “I trust you to act with honour. I trust you to act like a King. I trust you to be cursed by your pride. I trust you to be a dwarf. But you are honest and faithful and you keep your word.”

 

The King closed his eyes and rose, turning away. 

 

“I broke my word-and yours-and almost caused a war,” Thorin said bitterly. “Did you forget?” There was an awkward pause and then Bilbo rose to walk to him.

 

“No,” he said quietly. “I will never forget everything that happened then. But I also know that the dwarf speaking those words was sick. You had Dragon Sickness and were not in your right mind. How could I blame someone who was ill? The dwarf who broke his word wasn’t Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thrain, King of Erebor. He isn’t the dwarf who faces me now.”

 

“He is,” Thorin said flatly. “The Sickness twisted what lies within me but I spoke those words. I am to blame.”

 

Bilbo looked up into his eyes.

 

“I forgave you,” Bilbo said. “I hold to that. You made right what you had done when your mind returned. You ruled Erebor with honour and honesty. You always acted in the best interests of your people…even to your own detriment.”

 

“You were the only thing I ever did for myself, the only thing I did that was against the will of my people…well, some of them…” Thorin revealed slowly, his voice reluctant. “But know that I would give everything up for you. If, as it seems, I cannot be both your husband and the King, then Erebor can have a new ruler.”

 

“But it needs you, Thorin,” Bilbo told him bluntly. “You are the King. You reclaimed it. You ruled Ered Luin. Fili is just young and needs your experience to guide him.”

 

“He has Dis and he has Balin,” the King told his Hobbit. “Erebor no longer needs me.”

 

“And the Lords on the Council?” Bilbo asked him.

 

“I banished most of them after you left,” the dwarf said without shame. “It was all that they deserved.” Bilbo looked unimpressed and planted his hands on his hips.

 

“I can see why Dwalin wanted to hit you with your Crown,” he admitted as the King bowed his head.

 

“There really is no hope then, is there?” Thorin said quietly. “I just cannot meet your expectations, Bilbo. I am no longer able to be the husband that you expect or deserve. I cannot rule without you. And I seem incapable of winning your trust. All I do is disappoint you.” Then he turned away and went to his room. 

 

But he could not sleep, the effects of Fading robbing him of the peace of sleep and any rest he could achieve. So he lay, staring at the curved ceiling of his room and allowing his mind to spin where it would. And he found himself taken back to the discussion he had endured with the StoneSeers before he had married his hobbit. 

 

“You defy Mahal’s Will and insult our race,” DeepSeer Haunor growled, looked through the slits in his hood. The StoneSeers traditionally covered their faces, symbolising their loss of identity to the honoured spiritual role among their folk and the DeepSeer was the most senior of their number. The King had stiffened, knowing that there would be opposition but hearing it so bluntly was like a blow to the gut. 

 

“Yet he is my One and thus to not accept this gift is a graver insult to the Maker,” he had replied.

 

“Arrogance to presume you understand the complexities of…” StoneSeer Agulal cut in.

 

“Yet he is my One and I will marry him,” the King told him, talking over the developing diatribe. “So you can do your duty and inform me of my duties as Mahal requires or you can allow your prejudices to overcome your duty and fail Mahal and your King.”

 

There had been a palpable wave of hostility at the words and Thorin had lifted his chin, staring them down.

 

“As you wish, we will explain the duties and perils of bonding to your One, bearing in mind your chosen partner is not Khuzd and is not blessed by Mahal,” Haunor conceded. “But he is not Khuzd and cannot know our ways. We will not speak with him and there will be no preparation, no purification before the Union. And if you break this prohibition, we will ensure that all know your reign is not supported by Mahal, is not backed by the will of our Maker.”

 

Thorin had stared anthem, aching to roar at them that they had crossed Arda, facing stone giants and goblins and trolls and orcs and elves and one very live dragon and had reclaimed the mountain. If that was not a sure sign they were blessed by Mahal, then nothing was.

 

But he held his tongue because he needed this. He needed to hear the words of the Seers because he wanted to do right by Bilbo, to honour him as he should when all he had offered to the other half of his heart on the Quest was doubt, mistrust, danger and betrayal. How his Hobbit could have possibly offered forgiveness and accepted Thorin’s proposal still bewildered the dwarf, for his own people would have never forgiven such a transgression. Deep in his heart, Thorin knew that he did not deserve such forgiveness but he was greedy and desperate so he accepted the undeserved chance.

 

And Erebor needed it as well. The Kingdom was newly won and Thorin’s hold on the throne precarious. He was supported by Dain and dwarves from the Iron Hills but the rest of the Longbeards from Ered Luin were months away and there would be little he could do if the StoneSeers, who had arrived one morning from the Iron Hills. declared his rule invalid. He suspected Dain would rubbish the decree but how many of the Iron Hills dwarrow would listen? How many would insist that Dain took the throne instead of a King who had been disowned by their Maker? And having won the Kingdom for his own people and his sister-sons, how could he put his own happiness and desire ahead of their needs?

 

So he bowed his head and accepted the edict. And then he had listened to the words they spoke to every prospective couple-except there was only one there, for his partner was forbidden to hear. And Thorin understood the risk he took, the dangers of betrayal and rejection as well as the benefits of being in love and loved in return. And he knew in his partner, he had a unique bond, for there had never been a pairing of dwarf and hobbit before. But he asked the question anyway, because Thorin knew his life was one litany of failures.

 

“If he rejects me?” The words were as hesitant as he had ever heard and for a moment, Haunor was silent.

 

“If you are rejected, King Thorin, you will wither and die. Every benefit of the bond will leave you and instead, you will experience pain in your broken heart, weakness and despair. Slowly, you will fade. Eventually you will not be able to concentrate, nor sleep nor do anything. Your body will break down and you will succumb. Maybe madness will take you first, maybe not. But the condition is irrevocable.”

 

“There is no stop, no reversal if I could win back his love?” The words were desperate and the silence that greeted his plea telling.

 

“There is no reversal, my King,” Haunor repeated coldly. “You may manage to patch up your friendship but once a bond is broken by rejection, there is nothing that can be done. Friendship may slow the progression but you will be wracked by doubt and jealousy and fear. Despair will dog you. You will consider ending your life. Maybe that would be kindest. Because if you manage to repair your differences, you will still fade. Your One will watch you fade, watch you slip away, falling into a coma and eventually surrendering your life, no matter what he feels. And he will know that the death you suffer is his fault due to his actions. So even if there seems to be hope, there is none. And maybe, pushing him away and sparing him the grief and guilt would be best. Because if you are rejected, you will die. Within two years, your life will end. And there is nothing that you can do about it.”

 

And it was then that he finally realised what he had done. His desperate need to be near Bilbo had been a pure act of selfishness. It eased his pain-the pain he had earned by his own actions-but he had slowly wormed his way back into Bilbo’s generous heart. Maybe only as a friend and not as a lover but he had risked Bilbo-he knew that now. What the Hobbit had revealed about his own race's response to rejection was chilling and he thanked Mahal that he had not formally rejected Bilbo: he had never deserved it. But the StoneSeers had been unequivocal: no matter how they patched up their relationship, what was happening to Thorin was irrevocable. And if he and Bilbo grew closer, then it would be far, far worse for his husband when the dwarf died. And he would be responsible for the pain, grief and guilt that Bilbo felt. So, even though it went against everything his heart yearned for, he knew what he had to do. He just hoped that Bilbo-kind, generous, decent Bilbo-would understand.

 

Somehow, he managed to avoid Bilbo for the next couple of weeks, leaving before even First Breakfast and arriving back after Dinner. He bought food in the markets when he could and Dwalin brought him snacks but he once more needed reminding to eat and he became more and more reclusive. He still left gifts for Bilbo but never waited to see what the Hobbit thought. If he sometimes took the odd bread roll or meat pie, then he always made sure it wasn’t the last. But he tried to keep away from Bilbo-at least from his conscious presence, since all he seemed to do was cause the Hobbit upset and tear away the last shreds of his own hope. Dwalin seemed at a loss what to say to him and even Kili was unsure how to rouse his Uncle from despair. To his eye, Thorin’s hair held more grey and his eyes were sunken and dulled. So the Prince pulled Bilbo aside with Tauriel and sat in the garden, staring at the daffodils that were just opening their white and gold flowers in the early spring sun.

 

“I’m worried about Uncle,” the Prince said without preamble. “He won’t leave Bag End because you asked him to stay-but he’s like a ghost. He’s given up.”

 

“Your Uncle never gives up,” Bilbo told him plainly. “He believed you could retake Erebor despite there being a dragon ensconced inside. He believed he could get there with thirteen dwarves only. He believed he could hold the mountain against two armies with just the Company. And he led that insane charge into the fray against thousands of orcs when Dain’s hundreds of men were getting overwhelmed. And he turned the tide with that move…even though it was clearly futile and insane. He would never give up.”

 

Tauriel pursed her lips and arched an eyebrow. "I have to agree with Kili,” she said slowly. “His behaviour speaks of shame and resignation. He is avoiding you but it is only hastening the fading.” Bilbo stared at her.

 

“He’s what?” he demanded. “I told him we were friends! He said that would help and…”

 

The pity in Kili and Tauriel’s eyes had Bilbo’s hackles rising and he stared at them.

 

“He wouldn’t…” he growled and looked at them. Kili’s face fell.

 

“You know my Uncle better than most,” he sighed, “and you know that he is an absolute sucker for ridiculous self-sacrificing moves. He is Rejected by his One and Balin told me that only a reversal of that Rejection could alter his fate. And he would not want you to feel you had to accept him back. He wanted you to have a free choice.”

 

“Instead, would I only find out when he was dead?” Bilbo snapped. “And why didn’t he trust me by telling me?”

 

“Because he loves you,” Tauriel said sadly. “He would rather you were happy and free to make an honest choice than felt you were being blackmailed by his inevitable deterioration to take him back.”

 

“You said without trust that you had nothing,” Kili pointed out. “But you still won’t trust him. So he believes you have nothing and there is no hope. He is just going through the motions for the last months of his life.”

 

“What?” Bilbo’s expression was distraught now.

 

“Dwarrow rarely last more than a couple of years after being Rejected-and Thorin wasted much of his first year in Erebor and then travelling here. He is already weakened and soon, it will have passed the point of no return.” Kili glanced over at Tauriel. “We were supposed to go back after a few months but I can’t leave him now. We will stay…until the end.” Bilbo blinked and then glanced at Tauriel. Her serene expression was wavering with sorrow in her calm green eyes. 

 

“That idiot!” the Hobbit snapped. "Why didn't he tell me everything? You dwarves and your damned secrecy! It's hints here and the odd word here and not one of you tells me what I need to know and everything there is to know about this Rejection thing! I thought he was supposed to show he trusted me!” Kili rose then, his face uncharacteristically angry.

 

“Yet you don’t trust him either!” he accused the Hobbit. There was a moment when the angry Hobbit rounded on the Prince but Kili wasn’t backing down. “Trusting someone doesn’t mean you get to know every secret of their heart, you know. My Uncle has spent his life hugging many secrets tight and concealing them in his heart because people couldn’t be allowed to know. Who would follow a King who was mad? Or fight a battle with so little chance of success? Who would follow a Prince who betrayed his King by revealing these things to his people, even though it would be fairer if they knew? He has known when food is short, when times were desperate and his people were on the brink of starvation. And he had to project a good face, always being positive. He has spent his entire life concealing secrets because that has been his lot. You have to acknowledge that he is an old dwarf and after a life fighting to survive, dedicating himself to protecting his people and always suppressing anything he wanted, you have to allow him some agency.”

 

“No chance of that not happening,” Bilbo grumbled. 

 

“And yet you seem now to be equating trust with knowing everything,” Tauriel pointed out. 

 

“Thorin decided that he did not want you to feel you had to accept him and renew your vows out of a sense of obligation,” Kili continued. “He would rather you had your choice of your fate rather than you married him merely out of duty. Trapping you like that in a union that he knew you did not want would destroy him. He would rather die with dignity, knowing that you had a free choice.”

 

“But if I don’t know what the risk is, how can I have a free choice?” Bilbo argued. “I have to know that one of my choices will condemn him to death in a couple of months.” He looked up. “If that is the case…” Kili nodded.

 

“It is likely to be,” he sighed. “I’m sorry, Bilbo. I know he wanted it kept a secret but he trusted you with his heart when you married. He gave you the power to kill him by simply leaving him. My Uncle never does anything by halves and when he committed to you, he committed totally and irrevocably. He trusts you to keep his secrets here-which you have done.”

 

“But in Erebor…”

 

“He was ill!” Kili snapped. “He still suffered from Dragon Sickness!” Bilbo stared and sank back into his seat, aghast. “I’m sorry-I didn’t mean to say but I overheard Balin and Amad talking. He’s suffered ever since the Battle-nowhere near as severe as before or disabling but he still hears the whispers of the gold and feels the possessiveness. It was why he overreacted when he heard the accusation. It was wrong and stupid and very Thorin but he couldn’t help himself. And I think now that he feels as possessive of you as he did of the gold-maybe more. And admitting that to anyone was a terrible shame-because you know how his actions haunt him.”

 

Bilbo glanced towards the pulled curtains in the window of Thorin’s room and recalled the dwarf’s words when he was ill, which Bilbo had listened to carefully but perhaps not understood as deeply as he should. Kili’s words raised the suspicion to much worse levels, confirming that his husband had truly been suffering alone ever since the Battle without feeling able to tell his husband for fear of losing him irrevocably in falling once more into the ailment that had him threatening to kill his beloved Hobbit. And when Thorin had spoken, there was an edge of self-loathing in his voice, along with terrible shame…

 

“I know,” he murmured. “He told me he had been suffering when he overreacted but to known he had been fighting it ever since the Battle…” And then a few fragmented moments reared in his memory: Thorin staring into the fire, his hand absently stroking the hilt of Orcrist; his refusal to ever enter the Treasury and his reluctance to ever wear gold and the New Crown he had commissioned from mithril and silver. The occasional possessive look in those expressive eyes. 

 

The words at the Council, the reaction the exact mirror of the reaction to the loss of the Arkenstone…

 

“I should have seen,” he added. “He should have told me, the idiot, but I should have known. I trusted him that he was cured. To know he felt he could not speak to me…” He rose and paced backwards and forwards, careful not to damage the daffodils. He felt ill. The illness that had gripped Thorin and had him threatening to kill the Hobbit had been there all along…yet he had never felt unsafe with his dwarf. He had trusted his husband…now Thorin needed that trust more than ever. 

 

He looked up at the oak tree. A symmetry between the pair that remained unspoken: Bag End existed in the shadow of the oak tree and Thorin’s life had been saved by that oaken branch long before Bilbo’s birth and that act had coloured his identity ever since. But Thorin was strong and steady as the oak, never bowing, no matter what storms battered it…

 

…until this one, final storm that threatened to break him. A storm Bilbo could avert…if he wanted to. And losing Thorin was unthinkable.

 

“What can I do?” he asked. Kili and Tauriel shared a look.

 

“Spend time with him,” the Prince said. Tauriel nodded.

 

“He is dying of a broken heart,” she confirmed. “You are the owner of his heart. Only you can mend it.” Then she looked up. “But his pride and his shame are the obstacles. If you care for him, you have them to contend with.”

 

“And my own,” Bilbo murmured with honesty. “But I stole the Arkenstone to save his life. And yours, of course. But Balin said that giving him the Arkenstone would make him worse, maybe lose him forever. So I risked my life to get it away.” He sighed. “He forgave me for taking what he valued most because he understood my reasons. He should have understood I would not betray him like that. But maybe…I should forgive him as well.” He sighed again. “You think I would not risk everything for him?”

 

“But your trust issues?” Kili asked. Bilbo pressed his lips together and looked serious. Then he looked sternly at the couple, noting their hands twined together. If such ancient rivals as a dwarf and an elf could fall in love, there was still hope. Though how he could communicate that to Thorin in such a way that the prideful King would accept the reassurance was another matter…

 

“I think it’s time I took some steps to reassure myself and then I need to work out how to learn to trust this infuriating, stubborn, stupid, self-sacrificing idiot of a dwarf,” he murmured.

Notes:

A/N: I know it's a bit frustrating for you. I am frustrated as well at how stubborn this pair are being. I've tried to explain why they are acting as they do-Thorin's thoughts here are typical for His Royal Broodiness. And Bilbo will explain more of his qualms later on. But we are approaching the home straight. Thanks for sticking with this story!

Chapter 12: To Fight For Him

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

TWELVE: To fight for him

 

It was hard because Bilbo started waking earlier-he was never an early bird to start with-to ensure he was up when Thorin quietly made his way from his room and towards the door. But the King started to meet a tired-looking Hobbit, wrapped in his familiar dressing gown, with a brown paper-wrapped package of food for breakfast that he carefully pressed into the dwarf’s hands. The first morning, Thorin had averted his eyes and gravely thanked Bilbo. The Hobbit had quietly wished him a good day and watched him go. And he had understood what Kili had meant about the King’s appearance. Thorin was looking tired and weighed down and the streaks in his raven hair were wider. He looked older and tired and the whispers of disquiet grew louder in his heart. It solidified his resolve to stand forward and do what he should have done before.

 

So dressed in his finest and looking every inch the proper Hobbit, Bilbo set out into the fine spring morning, walking down the Hill after a hasty First Breakfast towards Tuckborough. It was quite a walk but one that needed to be done so he arrived at the Great Smials in good time. His cousin Fortinbras saw him immediately and what he heard had the Thain frowning deeply.

 

The Thain dispatched his cousins to start making enquiries because they weren’t Bagginses, they were Tooks and were working for the Thain. Bilbo was promised that he would be kept up to date but as he watched the older Hobbit walk out of the door (with a packed snack for the walk home) Fortinbras was worried. What he had heard and was hearing was starting to sound very un-Hobbitish and concerning. A proper Hobbit didn’t behave like that!

 

But Adalgrim, Flambard, Sigismund and his own son Ferumbras reported back and all of them were disappointed and reasonably angry at the tales they had heard.

 

“There’s a rumour that has been going round that the dwarf has been abusing young hobbit women,” Adalgrim reported, sitting opposite his cousin and munching on a slice of very acceptable lemon drizzle cake. Fortinbras frowned and rested his teacup down on the applewood table. 

 

“What?” he said in a distressed voice. “How many?”

 

“Uncertain,” Adalgrim said, his voice thoughtful. “It’s all rumours, light on details but heavy on innuendo. Everyone is certain that it is true.”

 

“Why?” Fortinbras asked shortly.

 

“Because it’s several people making the accusation,” Sigismund told him, refilling his teacup. “Always more powerful than one.”

 

“But no one is, are they?” Fortinbras pointed out simply. “No names, no specific instances. Just rumours. And rumours are a bad way to run a country.”

 

“Always worked in the Shire so far,” Flambard reminded them.

 

“Not for anything important,” the Thain said gravely. “Gossip is the currency of normal social interaction but most of our fellow Hobbits can discern the difference between scurrilous rumour and factual reporting of events. The gossipmongers will stir things up but we who wield the power always seek corroboration before acting on anything that we hear. Because what they are alleging does require action.”

 

“You’re right,” Ferumbras said, looking at his older cousins. “If you drill down, ‘everyone knows’ something but no one actually does. No one can give a name or a time or an instance. It’s generalised character-damaging.”

 

“Most of the Hobbitwives and the market merchants-even those in Bywater-want the dwarf locked up,” Sigismund added. “Things could get ugly.”

 

“They already are,” Flambard added. “There’s the news that he gave a ring to a younger Hobbit as well. That’s been going since a couple of weeks after Yule.”

 

“When he was seriously ill, having been turned away from the Green Dragon and left to freeze in his forge,” the Thain said grimly. “I’ve met him-and seen how prejudiced our people are against him. And I cannot see he has done anything wrong…except perhaps bruise the feelings of one Gardenia Proudfoot.” He frowned. “Find the person who alleges the dwarf gave her a ring. And bring her to me. I want to speak to her myself-without any other Hobbits interfering.”

 

It took another three days before the stern shape of Flambard escorted a pretty youngish Hobbit lass into the parlour at Tuckborough. Her light brown hair was winsomely styled into a knot at the back of her head with curls framing her pleasantly round face, her green eyes sparkling and her ruby lips offering a shy smile. She was dressed in a pretty flowery dress with a blue shawl and blue ribbons in her hair. She bobbed a tiny curtsy.

 

“Mimosa Grainfellow, at your service, your Thainship,” she said, her voice light and laughing. “I am honoured to talk to you.” Fortinbras gestured for her to take a seat and poured her a cup of tea. She accepted it prettily and sipped it gently, licking her lips as she looked up with big, innocent eyes. The Thain sat back.

 

“Why are you claiming that the dwarf, Lulkhel, gave you a ring?” he asked. Her eyes widened in hurt.

 

“Because he did,” she said and gave a little giggle, covering her mouth with her hand. She was wearing little lace gloves, crisp and white and elegant. The Thain blinked and focussed on her.

 

“When? How?” he asked. She gave a little giggle. 

 

“Well, you know what they say about dwarves…” she began.

 

“No,” the Thain said flatly. “I don’t listen to rumours and lies. So answer the question, Mimosa.” She pouted, her eyes flashing with a swift and brief blaze of annoyance that she quickly hid. Then the simpering mask was back up-and Fortinbras was certain now it was a mask. 

 

“Well, it was in the lead up to Yule,” she said. “He began to court me. Ohh, he was very passionate. Kissing my hand, murmuring sweet nothings in that lovely deep voice of his, promising to marry me and sweep me away to one of those dwarvish settlements…” The Thain tilted his head and watched her. He was certain now that she was lying and that everything was an act. The real question was…why?

 

“Did your parents know?” he asked. She looked up, her eyes wide and innocent.

 

“You know how protective Hobbit parents get,” she reminded him. “They wouldn’t hear of me stepping out with a dwarf. So we’re going to elope-but he gave me this ring as a promise.”

 

“Just a ring?” Fortinbras asked, his voice deepening.

 

“Of course-what else would he give me? A cake?” she laughed lightly.

 

“And what else did he do?” the Thain asked. 

 

“He promised me gold and gemstones-not that I care for that sort of thing,” she giggled. “He said he wants to spend the rest of his life with me and have lots of faunts.” The Thain nodded gravely.

 

“So who else knows about this, Mimosa?” he asked her sympathetically. "I take it your mother doesn’t know-and your sister, Monbretia, wouldn’t approve. Maybe…a cousin?” She fluttered her eyelashes and flapped her hands.

 

“They would be so judgemental, when dear Lucky and I are so happy,” she simpered. Fortinbras was caught between the desire to shout at her for her lies and slap her for being so obvious. Instead, he hooked his thumbs under his braces and thought for a moment, allowing her to stew. As expected, she filled the silence. “I told my cousin and she may have told some other people.”

 

“Most of the Shire,” the Thain noted. “And did you not speak to Lulkhel to ask if he wanted his name dragged through the gossipmongers…?”

 

“Well, if he wants to live among Hobbits, what does he expect?” she retorted slightly tartly. 

 

Aha-the mask slips, the Thain thought. “May I see the ring?” he asked and she giggled, then fished it out of her pocket, handing it over.

 

“It’s beautiful,” she said happily. “Look he’s even carved our initials, L and M, inside…”

 

Fortinbras looked up.

 

“Is this it?” he asked aloud as a shape appeared from behind the door. Bilbo had been wearing the Ring just to make sure but he had it slipped in his pocket as he walked forward and accepted the little gold band, carved with dwarvish runes inside and out. He nodded.

 

“The runes read ‘A dwarf that takes a husband must guard him as his greatest treasure’,” Bilbo said. “That symbol is an intertwined rune reading B and T-Lulkhel’s true name and mine. This is the ring that was stolen from the forge while Lulkhel was fighting for his life against pneumonia. The writing inside reads ‘Amrâlimê’.” Mimosa glared at him.

 

“That’s utter fantasy,” she said irritably. “How can anyone know what that means and even if he is telling the truth?” 

 

The door opened and Kili walked in-but he looked totally unlike his normal appearance. He was cleaned up and dressed in fine and clean clothes, his hair actually neat and his Promise Braid obvious. He looked at the Thain and offered a small bow. 

 

“May I present Prince Kili, one of the Heirs to the Throne of Erebor,” Bilbo said. “You know of Erebor, don’t you?” Mimosa pouted and shook her head.

 

“I don’t care for foreign lands,” she spat.

 

“And yet your ‘Lucky’ comes from Erebor,” Bilbo told her shortly and handed the ring to Kili. The Prince accepted it reverently. “Highness, could you please read the runes on this.” Kili looked up.

 

“Are you sure, Bilbo?” he asked. “These were carved by Uncle for you and you alone. He…”

 

“Please,” Bilbo said, an edge of impatience entering his voice. Sighing, he peered at the Ring though he had the keenest sight of all the dwarves of Erebor.

 

“This is beautiful work,” he murmured. “Superb precision on the runes. ‘A dwarf that takes a husband must guard him as his greatest treasure’. That’s terribly romantic. The rune is an entwined B and T-your joint rune. I know Uncle has it tattooed over his heart.” 

 

“I saw,” Bilbo grumbled. Kili peered inside then smiled.

 

“Amrâlimê. My love,” he read and handed the ring back to Bilbo. “Uncle will be relieved that you have found it.”

 

“What’s this ‘Uncle’ nonsense?” Mimosa spat as Bilbo closed his hand around the ring. 

 

“Maybe you don’t know your ‘Lucky’ as much as you think,” Fortinbras told her in an impatient voice.

 

“Notwithstanding that Lulkhel means ‘idiot of idiots’,” Kili added, staring at the Hobbitess flatly.

 

“It’s the name my husband took when he left home to come after me to try to make amends,” Bilbo added.

 

“Well, he won’t be because he’s engaged to me now!” Mimosa spat. Kili stared at her and then walked across the room then back. He loomed over her and gave a Thorin-worthy glare.

 

“I am not sure why you imagine this lie will gain you anything but you should know that Bilbo Baggins and the dwarf you malign and dishonour both have defenders who will protect their reputations against callow lies and pathetic imaginings,” he said in a very unfamiliar, hard tone. Mimosa squeaked. “Who asked you to carry on this lie, Mistress Mimosa? If you tell the truth now, you will not face any severe consequences.” 

 

Looking up at him, she laughed in his face.

 

“You think you can do anything to me, your Highness?” she taunted him. “There are no Kings-or Princes-in the Shire.”

 

“Actually, there are currently both here,” Bilbo muttered.

 

“In fact, the Shire is bound by a number of Treaties and Contracts with other peoples and kingdoms,” Fortinbras told the young Hobbit, seeing the defiance in her eyes falter as he spoke. “And we have close ties with Erebor-isn’t that true, your Highness?”

 

“Yes,” said Bilbo as Mimosa gaped. “And my dear, you don’t know your ‘Lucky’ at all. Because his name isn’t Lulkhel-it is Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror, King of Erebor and my husband.” He listen to her gasp with a small sense of triumph before continuing. “That makes me the Prince Consort Under The Mountain. Kili is Thorin’s nephew-and my nephew by marriage and by heart.” The Prince gave a broad grin.

 

“Irak’Adad,” he murmured and bowed his head, a hand pressed over his heart.

 

“Namad’Inùdoy,” Bilbo replied. Then he smiled at Mimosa with utterly cold eyes. “Now who told you to lie about and dishonour my husband?” he demanded.

 

“He isn’t…” she began feebly.

 

“Thorin is a dwarf-and I am his One,” Bilbo told her angrily. “That is a Heart-Mate. He can no more betray me with you than breathe solid stone. He avoids gold and gems because he once suffered from Dragon Sickness. He is not attracted to females and he knows enough of Hobbits that the way to our hearts is through food and plants. He would never offer you gold and gems. He would never offer you anything. Your tale is a lie from first to last. So unless you tell me right now who put you up to his, I will ask Kili to have you extradited to Erebor and then you can see some real dwarves, as opposed to the imaginary one you have been supposedly courting!” 

 

“And I will permit it,” Fortinbras told her. She paled finally and her hands trembled. 

 

“Cousin Gardenia,” she said quietly. “I don’t want to leave the Shire. Please don’t make me go anywhere else and have to deal with any nasty foreign creatures!” She took a quick breath and licked her lips. “She asked me to tell the story and gave me the ring-a couple of weeks after Yule, once the storms had settled. So I have been. I mean, he’s only a dwarf and…”

 

“And what?” Bilbo asked her furiously. “He has feelings like anyone. You are lying about him, painting him to be a sort of faithless lover, when nothing could be further from the truth. He has left his home and his people to be with me because he loves me. And seeing your lies hurt him and turn people against him is cruel.” He lifted his chin. “So your lies will be exposed. You can be called Mad and Deranged and a Liar. You can have people look at you as if you have a disease. You can have people cross the road to avoid you and refuse to speak to you or serve you or even look at you in the Market. And you will deserve every moment for the pain you have caused my husband.”

 

She burst into tears, sobbing loudly and piteously. But not one of those there moved to comfort her. Finally, Flambard, who had remained quietly in the corner, came over and escorted her out, having seen her shrink from the overconfident coquette to a miserable and scared young woman, fearing the consequences of her actions.

 

“You can’t ruin her life,” Fortinbras told his cousin and then frowned at Bilbo’s flat glare. “But I will publicise the fact that she is a liar and a fantasist. That she made it up and stole the ring. That Lulkhel is already attached and devoted to his spouse.” 

 

“And an apology?” Bilbo asked. The Thain sighed.

 

“She isn’t sorry,” he sighed. “She’s only sorry for herself that she’s been caught and has to face the consequences. Because she knew that eventually, the dwarf would be driven from the Shire and the rumours would die down. And she could just go on as usual, having ruined another being’s life.”

 

“And the rumours won’t die down any time soon-because Hobbits believe there is no smoke without fire somewhere,” Bilbo sighed.

 

“And you used Uncle’s name,” Kili muttered. 

 

“Gardenia is getting beyond vindictive,” Bilbo continued, turning to his cousin. “And she’s dangerous. If this was a dwarf settlement, someone would come after her. You can’t allow her to do this to others.” The Thain suddenly looked tired and all of his sixty-eight years.

 

“I know,” he murmured. “I’ll speak to the Heads of Families and the Mayor of Michel Delving,” he added wearily. “We will stop her. I think Odo Proudfoot will not be happy that she’s dragging the family name down.”

 

“You have the vote of the Head of the Baggins Family,” Bilbo murmured, still idly moving the wedding ring in his palm.

 

“And the Tooks,” the Thain added. He offered Bilbo his hand. “I’m sorry, Bilbo. It never should have got this far.”

 

“I know-but that goes for most of this,” the former burglar said softly. “I knew I could trust him. I knew he would never betray me.” Then he looked at Kili. “I just need to know that he trusts me as well.”

 

“He trusts you with his life, his secrets, his heart,” Kili murmured. 

 

“I know,” Bilbo murmured. “But I don’t know why but that hasn’t been enough.” He sighed. “Somehow, I will have to find enough…and what I am missing…because I do love him and I will not lose him. Not again.”

 

-o0o-

 

Spring warmed and Bilbo split his time between his dwarves and his garden. Thorin remained elusive though he smiled at Bilbo in the mornings and accepted his food parcels with a grave nod of the head. He said nothing except polite thanks but he brought home flowers that once again spoke of sorrow and love and longing. The gifts continued, small items that were useful or pretty or just thoughtful. But Thorin had built a wall that Bilbo despaired of ever breaching, stepping back from the husband he clearly thought he no longer deserved. And Kili’s revelations had caused Bilbo to stop and consider Thorin’s actions.

 

So he sat in his garden, tired but satisfied with grubby hands and knees from where he had been weeding and looked over his beds of vegetables, the shoots poking bravely through the soil. The early greens and radishes were already up and his carrots were looking strong. His garden was looking much better than it had the previous year, a spell of love and care all that was needed to bring he neglected space back to health and beauty. He smiled and glanced over at the early perennials, little white and pink flowers dotting the bed. It had been his mother’s bed, the plants exotics that she had collected on her travels-but then, she had been very adventurous for a Hobbit. Almost every other Hobbit had scorned her, for they hated anything that was not traditionally of the Shire. Hobbits were solid and steady and predictable: it was all but unheard for a Hobbit to try anything new and it always caused a scandal. Gossip was unforgiving and never forgot. Such a faux pas could follow a Hobbit for years…

 

Which made the actions of a respectable Hobbit like Gardenia Proudfoot even more incomprehensible. And the reaction of his neighbours. For why would they tolerate her apparent courting of a wandering dwarf and his supposed rejection without a peep also confused him. There was something going on that he was missing-and Fortinbras as well. The Thain was as perplexed as Bilbo at the aberrant reactions of his fellow Hobbits but he still had his son and cousins digging into her business. Tooks didn’t like mysteries-especially when it caused the Hobbits to not behave like Hobbits.

 

Bilbo frowned. Belladonna would have had plenty to say about the way her neighbours and kin were treating the isolated dwarf and her son. Though she would have been proud at how adventurous her son had become-even with the unusual choice of partner and how turbulent and fractured his marriage had become. 

 

“A marriage is like a garden, Bilbo,” she had said as she had weeded and trimmed her beloved bed. Even fading, she had still tended the bed, almost the only thing that brought smiles to her pallid features. “It always needs work. A little weeding here, some dead-heading there. Don’t allow problems to fester. Shed light on dark areas. Refresh old or worn-out areas. Sometimes try something new. If you neglect it, the roots will die from lack of water and the soil will become depleted so the plants will grow weaker and eventually they will fade. Neglecting even the smallest things can eventually allow the whole thing to deteriorate and one morning, you will awaken to chaos and find it is ruined.”

 

“Plants or marriages?” he had asked naively. Belladonna had smiled then, one of the last that he could recall her offering.

 

“Both, my dear Bilbo,” she had said.

 

But somehow, his marriage had broken. And of course, Thorin had been at fault-because of the way he had confronted Bilbo and demonstrated that he did not trust his husband. That was Thorin all over, racing into things without thinking, without diplomacy-because to Thorin, that was just a collection of meaningless syllables-and without understanding the damage he would cause. But Thorin, the rock-headed idiot that he was, had been fighting Dragon Sickness and his mind was not thinking clearly. Not that he had told his husband, of course, because openness and sharing were also words Thorin wasn’t very good at…

 

…except much of the time, he was. He was kind and generous, affectionate and protective and would do whatever he could to ensure that his husband was happy. And maybe he didn’t do much about the rumours that had plagued Bilbo-but had Bilbo shared them with Thorin either? Bilbo’s own pride had driven him to believe that he could cope, that he could rise above the persistent whispers and looks, despite the hurt and anger and bitterness they had definitely caused. And maybe his husband had known from Nori and maybe not…but Bilbo should’ve shared his concerns and his anger as well. And Thorin always allowed Bilbo to pursue his interests, even spending some lonely evenings alone, or helping Bilbo build that huge rockery that resembled a small Erebor in his garden but which Bilbo hadn’t the heart to remove because his husband had personally moved every stone and rock to Bilbo’s command…

 

…but Thorin’s accusations had hit a nerve in the worst possible way when he had hauled Bilbo up in the Council. He had faced slights and accusations every day since he had arrived in Erebor-especially since the rest of the dwarves of Erebor had returned to the mountain. And Thorin’s intemperate demands had hit that nerve and roused the stubbornness of a score of generations of Tooks. So when Thorin had banished him, rather than getting Dis or Balin to talk him down, Bilbo had exploded and ended their marriage. And he had stormed off and been clinging to his anger ever since.

 

Thorin had come to the Shire when he had realised the extent of his stupidity-and there had been proof of what Bilbo had actually been doing. But he hadn’t written or asked for forgiveness. No, in true Thorin ultra-dramatic style, he had abandoned his kingdom and travelled to the Shire alone and incognito, using a name that was an insult. But he hadn’t come to Bilbo-no, he had hung back, suffering but knowing he would be met with bitter anger and rejection because Bilbo was still angry and hurt…as he had every right to be. Any apology would be rejected and slapped down because Bilbo wasn’t ready to hear it. But Bilbo was also stubborn and he had consciously avoided his estranged husband and left him alone among strangers. And Thorin had tried, learning to speak with flowers and trying to tell Bilbo what he felt, what his upbringing and temperament would not allow him to easily say. And Bilbo had slapped him down, again and again.

 

Until he had almost lost him. Seeing Thorin so vulnerable and sick had raised all sorts of terrible memories of the aftermath of the Battle, when Thorin, Fili and Kili had all hovered far too close to death for far too long. And this time, Thorin hadn’t been fighting to stay because he believed that he had lost Bilbo for ever. Even Elvish magic hadn’t cured him, merely slowing the deterioration down and Bilbo had become aware that there was a risk he could lose his husband anyway. And Thorin had believed, after their last stupid pointless spat that even Bilbo didn’t understand, that his last chance was gone and he was simply marking time to the end.

 

“But I don’t want to lose him,” Bilbo murmured. “He’s exasperating and hotheaded and ridiculous and overdramatic but he’s honourable and kind and generous and loving and brave and stupid but he’s my idiot.”

 

He loved Thorin. That had never been in doubt. But did having Thorin prove his trust count more than having him alive? And Thorin trusted Bilbo with his identity, his heart, his Kingdom when the King was away…

 

…and he had been ill. Was ill? Was he still ill?

 

He had seemingly given up but he still left Bilbo gifts and flowers that spoke more eloquently than Thorin himself had ever managed of his heart. And each bouquet was filled with apologies. But until now, Bilbo had just looked at the apologies and had not truly acknowledged them. Yet he had allowed Thorin to be maligned, ostracised and excluded. And now there were much more serious and unfounded allegations against him that may drive him away-and in his current state, that could prove fatal. Bilbo had finally acted and had felt a warmth in his chest at defending his husband. It seemed that dwarves were not the only protective ones…

 

“It always needs work. Don’t allow problems to fester. Shed light on dark areas…”

 

“We need a proper talk,” he decided and rose, heading into the smial to clean up. "It's time I acknowledged what my heart knows. I love him. My heart is his and only his-and he needs to understand that. No running this time-we have to work this out.”

 

It was time he found his dwarf and had a proper talk to him.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Irak'Adad - Uncle
Namad'inùdoy- sister-son
Amrâlimê - my love

Chapter 13: All That Matters

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

THIRTEEN: All That Matters

 

A hammering on the door roused him from his preoccupation as he dressed in clean clothes suitable for going out in. Muttering about people who were unable to use a simple bell, he stomped to the door and opened it-to find two familiar shapes facing him. Dori gave a small bow but Nori started forward, grabbed Bilbo’s arm and hauled him back into the entrance hallway, leaving his older brother to close the door behind him.

 

“Is he here?” he asked in a low voice. Bilbo frowned.

 

“Who?” he asked.

 

“Thorin,” the Spymaster hissed, looking around. Bilbo stared at him, wondering if his friend had gone mad-and then recalling this was exactly how he tended to act in Erebor. The number of times he had popped up into the Royal Apartments at odd hours, talking very much like this and spilling details of some desperate plot were too numerous to mention-but Thorin had always taken them in his stride. His calmness in the face of Nori’s urgently whispered intelligence had been at odds with his reactions to some of the more irritating Lords and he had always taken the former thief’s advice seriously. Maybe it was because he trusted Nori as one of the Company or perhaps because he was aware that his choice for Spymaster was very good at his job. 

 

“What’s wrong?” he asked, shaking Nori’s hand off and staring at him. The thief’s eyes flashed.

 

“They’re going to kill him,” he said. Bilbo stared at him.

 

“They just need to wait and that will happen anyway,” the Hobbit said quietly as the dwarfs stared at him.

 

“He still hasn’t made up to you?” Nori asked, his tone exasperated. “Fili is worried-why he sent me. Us.” He cast a jaundiced look at Dori, who frowned.

 

“It’s good to see you, Dori,” Bilbo said with a smile. “And you, Nori.” He glanced at the pair. “Ori is out, by the way.” As expected, Dori’s face fell. 

 

“I hope he does have a chaperone when he’s with Dwalin and…” he began fussily as Bilbo felt himself smile. Some things never changed.

 

“I’m sure they’re behaving themselves,” he tried to reassure the dwarf but Dori still looked disapproving. 

 

“This wouldn’t happen in Erebor,” he grumbled.

 

“We’re not in Erebor,” Nori reminded him as Bilbo folded his arms and stared at him.

 

“I think you need to explain right now what is going on,” he said firmly, his eyes narrowed. There was an edge to his tone that reminded the pair of dwarves of the Crown Prince who they had all missed. The former thief sighed.

 

“No Hobbit hospitality?” he asked. Bilbo glared at him.

 

“You grabbed me and barged into my house. Do you think you deserve hospitality?”

 

“We’ve just come from Erebor and you are a Hobbit of the Shire…” Nori suggested.

 

“I’ve been exposed to terribly bad dwarvish manners for far too long,” Bilbo told him tartly and then he relented. “I’ll put the kettle on and then you can tell me what is happening.”

 

Over a pot of tea, a large ale for Nori and a plate laden with oat and raisin biscuits, lemon cup cakes and flapjacks, the Ri brothers explained that they had been dispatched by Fili and Balin to come to the Shire to warn their friends there of the threat to the life of their King.

 

“But why couldn’t you send a Raven?” Bilbo asked, perplexed. Dori sipped his tea and sighed.

 

“Over the last six months, Ravens have been going missing,” he said. “Roac has reported that five have vanished completely and four more have been attacked and their messages stolen. Even his own son, Groac, was shot by an arrow. He barely survived.”

 

“Communications between the Shire and Erebor have been especially affected,” Nori added. He frowned and munched a flapjack. “We think enemies have been looking for Thorin. It would fit with the narrative.”

 

“What narrative?” Bilbo was looking concerned. 

 

“Rumours have been swirling around Erebor that the King has stepped down because he is mentally ill since losing his husband,” Dori sighed.

 

“That his mind is lost,” Nori added. “And that he is unfit to rule. Therefore there is a growing groundswell to demand his removal as King and the coronation of King Fili.” The Hobbit frowned.

 

“I didn’t think that monarchies worked like that,” he commented.

 

“They don’t. But we know who has been starting the rumours.” Nori’s smile was wolfish. “Sulgan. Ever since he was banished from Erebor, he’s been agitating through his agents, his kin and his business partners to be allowed back and to get Thorin removed as being unstable.”

 

“Where is Sulgan now?” Bilbo asked quietly. 

 

“No one knows,” Dori said flatly. 

 

“He’s not in Dale, Esgaroth or the Iron Hills,” Nori added. “There are rumours of Ered Luin but he’s wealthy enough to buy anonymity and most of our people have left there now so there are fewer who would choose loyalty to Thorin over the lure of coin.”

 

“That doesn’t mean someone is planning to kill him,” Bilbo pointed out.

 

“Except someone is always trying to kill him,” Nori reminded him. “And there are whispers of people trying to recruit for a mission-in Erebor and Ered Luin. The location of the Shire was mentioned as well. No one should know where Thorin is…unless they intercepted letters to you or the Company that referenced him. We have kept it absolutely confidential in Erebor.” The Hobbit sighed.

 

“I see your point,” he murmured and then rose. “I was going out to speak to him anyway-I’m sure he’ll be very happy to see you.”

 

“Probably not,” Nori muttered. “We left Oin in the Green Dragon with our ponies. He muttered something about buying some herbs in the market in case he needed them. We can pick him up on the way.”

 

“Why is Oin here?” Bilbo asked suspiciously. But Dori gave a small sad smile.

 

“We know the King is fading,” he revealed. “Fili told the Company once Kili, Dwalin, Ori and Tauriel left for the Shire. He had no idea what they would find but he wanted us to be prepared…if there was bad news. Oin is the finest healer in Erebor: he may have something to help the King.”

 

“I am the only one who can help the King…hence the need for a serious talk,” Bilbo admitted as they reached the door. It was a pleasant afternoon as they stepped out and headed down the Hill, though Bilbo was aware of the unfriendly and concerned eyes on him. There were an unusual number of Hobbits tending their front gardens, all having a breather as the dwarves and Hobbit walked by. And he heard the mutters about ‘unwelcome guests’ as they reached Hobbiton Market and found Oin buying half the herb stall up, chatting quite amiably in the Hobbit in charge over various uses for the wares. But he swiftly extricated himself when he saw the others and stowed his purchases in his pack as he walked to join them, unselfconsciously hugging the Hobbit.

 

“Good to see you,” he said gruffly. “You’ve been missed, laddie.” Bilbo smiled.

 

“I haven’t missed your potions,” he admitted. “At least Hobbits make medicines that taste good.” Oin chuckled.

 

“But do they work good?” he asked as they headed out on the road to Bywater. On the way, Bilbo explained how Thorin had come to the Shire under an assumed name and worked the Forge in Bywater, how he had not sought out Bilbo and how their dance around one another had been awkward with misunderstandings, stubbornness and stupidity on both their parts. Dori was interested to hear that Dwalin was working in the forge and that Ori had been talking to Hobbits and gathering tales of their history while the Prince spent his time between the Forge and with Tauriel.

 

When they reached the Bywater Market, there were more eyes on them. Bilbo headed straight for the Forge, hearing the clanging of metal on metal and hoping that Thorin would be there and that they could possibly have that talk. He was determined to convince the dwarf that he was loved and that there was still hope. But when they arrived in the Forge, they found Dwalin hammering what looked like a new shovel into shape with Ori making notes from a variety of pieces of paper that he had jotted on during his discussion with the local Hobbitwives about local lore and legends. Nori glanced at his brother then stood back as Dori surged forward and wrapped his youngest brother in a bear hug, scattering his papers. The young scribe huffed and protested but still hugged back, pleased to see his family. But Bilbo glanced around, his sharp eyes seeing no sign of Thorin. 

 

Dwalin looked up.

 

“He went for a walk,” he said gruffly, his eyes dark with emotion. The Hobbit shook his head, a treacherous thread of suspicion almost prompting him to say ‘with who’ but instantaneously wiped the thought away. Rumours and lies were insidious but he knew that Thorin was true. An idiot, to be sure, but true. And his idiocy now extended to not believing there was any hope, even when Bilbo had told him that he wanted to try. 

 

“He’s gone to practice,” Ori revealed, finally breaking free of Dori’s fussing. Dwalin stared at him.

 

“Why wouldn’t he…?” he asked, his tone hurt. Ori looked embarrassed.

 

“He told me that he preferred to practice alone, since he doesn’t want to be shamed by his weakness,” Ori said quietly. There was a maturity and sadness in his voice that indicated the conversation had been longer and more painful than that-and once again, Bilbo felt a stab of pain that his husband couldn’t manage to trust the Hobbit with his innermost thoughts. And, by the look on Dwalin’s face, he wasn’t alone in this.

 

“Do you know where he is?” Bilbo asked, urgently. Nori was inspecting him, his sharp eyes assessing the near-frantic tone in the Hobbit’s voice. Suddenly, he was feeling a terrible emptiness in the centre of his chest, an anxiety that was almost all-consuming. Ori nodded.

 

“I’m sorry, Bilbo-but I had a look through all your Shire maps,” he explained. “Thorin wanted some rock, maybe a cave system. I found a small one in Bindbole Woods. He’s been going there every day for the last two weeks, practicing so that he will not be completely shamed when he faces Mahal in His Halls. And I think…” His voice choked. “I think he is preparing his tomb. He wants to stay here with you. He doesn’t want to go home to Erebor. Not if it means being buried far from you.” 

 

Suddenly, Bilbo felt his eyes burning and the deepest shame possible washing over him. Was this what Thorin had felt, after he had recovered from the Dragon Sickness and realised the depths he had plumbed? Was this how his husband suffered when he looked at Bilbo and recalled holding him over the ramparts, spitting poisonous hatred and promising to kill the Hobbit-the person he loved above all others? This had gone on for far too long. But Dwalin spoke up.

 

“I’ve lost my patience,” he said and walked up to Bilbo. There was disappointment in his eyes. “First it was about him being an idiot. Then it was about him being unable to say an apology right. That I can respect and understand. A dwarf should be responsible for his own actions and we know Thorin has his own view on how to do things and usually it’s how not to do them. And, to be honest, much of it is self-sacrificing and insane and backwards because he never believed he deserved you after that day on the ramparts. But he is dying, Bilbo. And while it was about trust in the beginning, now I think it’s just about stupid pride and anger.”

 

“Can you blame me?” Bilbo snapped. “He broke his word to me, twice. He broke my trust-twice! Do you know how it feels, to be utterly humiliated, to be threatened with death by the person you trust more than anyone in the world?”

 

Dwalin looked at him and then nodded. 

 

“You weren’t the only one who was affected by his madness,” he said gruffly. “I loved him as a brother. And I knew what had befallen him-but he would not listen to me either. He threatened to kill me.”

 

“You weren’t held over the ramparts and banished,” Bilbo snarked. “While all of you watched. And then you watched again while he humiliated and banished me. You see my problem in just accepting Thorin’s apology? Never seems to last…” 

 

“Sometimes, you have to let go the anger and see what is important,” Dwalin told him slowly, his fist clenching. Bilbo was as stubborn as his Shield-Brother. “He nearly died then and you forgave him. You gave him a second chance.”

 

“He was sick,” Bilbo said. “And he was genuinely sorry.”

 

“And this time he was also sick and he nearly died,” the warrior pointed out. Closing his eyes, Bilbo exhaled slowly.

 

“That’s why I’m here,” he said. “And it was incredibly hard to just forgive him again, because I’d heard the contrition before and then seen how it panned out. Everything I believed we had, every trust and consideration and respect vanished in an instant and it was devastating.”  He walked over to the hatch and looked out over Bywater Market. “I knew of a Hobbit once-her husband used to drink Hobbit moonshine. Far too much moonshine, I’m afraid. And though they were Heart-Mates and loved each other very much when they married, he was violent to her, hitting her, screaming at her, making her feel afraid and worthless. But she loved him. So she forgave him because he said he was sorry. And I believe, at the beginning, he was sorry. But perhaps, not sorry enough because he hit her again. And she kept forgiving him because she loved him-but though he said the words, he never changed. He never stopped drinking or thought of her when his temper flared, just carried on the same and kept hitting her. In the end, she left him but it broke her and she faded by Harvest.” 

 

He looked up to see the shock and pity in the dwarves’ eyes. Tales of abusive relationships, though rare, were heard of in dwarvish settlements as well. 

 

“But Thorin understood. And he already decided, after he recovered, that he didn’t deserve a second chance. He understood what he had done too well because even though Thorin isn’t wonderful at discussing feelings, we did talk. A lot. And he understood what I needed and felt in our marriage. But even though he left Erebor to be with me, avoiding the gold and the jewels, changing the circumstances and narrative, he had decided he would never deserve a second chance. And to be honest, I needed to think about it too. I needed to hear from those who love him-you and Kili and even Tauriel-that he has changed. I don’t want to be another Honeysuckle Vinewood.” 

 

Then he took a deep breath. “But I love him more than anything and it has been hurting my heart so much to see him unhappy. I thought I was safe because I hardened my heart against him but seeing him and being with him reminded me of what was most important. Because sometimes, you have to almost lose something to know how much you value it. I need to find him.” He sighed. “He has to understood he is forgiven.”

 

“I’m coming with you,” Dwalin told him, arching an eyebrow. “Knew you’d get there eventually.”

 

“And we need to get there sooner rather than later,” Nori added. “There’s a threat against him.” Ori stared.

 

“Sometimes, you can’t buy a break,” he murmured. “Thorin isn’t really friends with luck.”

 

But they all  closed up the Forge and headed for Bindbole Woods, for the area Ori had found for Thorin which Bilbo knew. It was a nice clearing that would be filled with bluebells later in the Spring and would have offer ample room for the King to run through his exercises. Bilbo had watched his husband practice with Orcrist many times and was always fascinated by the grace and power Thorin showed whenever he demonstrated his moves. Oin was muttering about idiot Kings and Dori and Nori were arguing but Ori walked alongside. The Hobbit looked up.

 

“He really felt he couldn’t come to ask me?” he asked as the Scribe looked a little embarrassed.

 

“He specifically asked me not to tell you,” he admitted. “He worried you would think he wasn't committed to you by trying to find some decent rock…” Bilbo frowned.

 

“Why?” he asked in confusion. “He’s a dwarf. I know you feel happier, safer when you are under rock. I wouldn’t have minded if it made him feel better.”

 

“Thorin sees things through the prism of Thorin,” Ori told his friend, glancing at his betrothed. “Dwalin is similar. Being a warrior is a very black and white existence. Kill or be killed. Friend or foe. With or against. And he has decided he has lost all chance of winning you back so he knows he will die of his Rejection. I think he was told it was irreversible so that his crime could not be forgiven by Mahal, even if you came round. In his heart, he has lost hope, even though what I was told and what I have read indicate there is always hope. His heart is broken and what those StoneSeers said to him made sure it stays broken. He…embraces it even.”

 

Bilbo frowned.

 

“He wouldn’t…” he mouthed.

 

“Never!” Ori said fiercely.

 

“He is no coward!” Dwalin snarled. 

 

“The King will see his life through to the most bitter of ends,” Dori added as the Hobbit stopped and stared at them. They were dwarves and they knew their own people. They had known Thorin so much longer than he had and sometimes he wondered if he knew the King at all. But Ori patted his arm. 

 

“That’s something that is the most heinous crime in our people,” he told Bilbo. “We endure because life is usually hard and most often cruel and unfair. If we had been made to give up and surrender out lives so easily, our race would have died out many centuries ago.”

 

“If he had wanted to kill himself, he would have found an orc pack and charged them,” Dwalin added gruffly. “It would have been a senseless death worthy of a Warrior King.” Bilbo resumed his tramp into the woods, the words rolling round his head.

 

Warrior King. And that was what Thorin was and had been since the moment his father vanished and landed the stewardship of his people on his far-too-young shoulders. He had always been aware of the duties and responsibilities of his line, trained as a warrior since he could walk and had given up everything for his people-including every dream he had. He had risked his life on the foolhardy Quest that not one of his allies would support and against all reason, he had succeeded. But the costs had been high and even when Erebor had been reclaimed, the only thing he had asked for himself-a choice of husband-had been met by dismay, resistance and even suggestions that the King was insane for considering a partner outside of his race. The last had cut too close to home but Thorin had forged forward his his typical stubbornness and had married his Hobbit. The same Hobbit the Lords had spent the next three years trying to undermine and who they had finally succeeded in removing.

 

But Thorin had always remained immensely proud of his warrior prowess and he had worked every day to maintain his skills. He practiced, he maintained his weapons and he trained with others. But all the time in the Shire, he had been alone with no practice partner and he had been gradually Fading and weakening. It must have been intolerable.

 

As the trees rose above them, Bilbo took a deep breath. The sense of life was stronger in the woods, the scents of moss and earth rising above the perfume of wood anemones and narcissuses. The fresh green leaves had just come out and the entire wood looked new and fresh. Tiny white and blue flowers poked out from among the tufts of grass that were carpeting the woodland floor as the party advanced. But Bilbo was suddenly calm because his heart had won. The anger and hurt had dissipated and all those conversations, those discussions with his friends and examining his heart had finally made him see what was there. Thorin was Thorin-proud, brave, self-sacrificing, stubborn, determined but always devoted to those he loved. And Bilbo was sure, with the terrible price that they were both paying for not talking and acting in anger and from pride, that neither would be so stupid again.

 

If only he could persuade the dwarf to agree.

 

But as they wandered through the forest, there was an alarming peace and quiet that was at odds with a dwarf practicing. Bilbo frowned, for Thorin could not be described as stealthy and yet there was no sound. Unnerved, he accelerated his walk and almost skipped round the corner to break into the clearing.

 

But there was no sign of a dwarf King, though the grass and first shoots of the bluebells were trampled under heavy bootprints. But the ground was also scuffed up and there were cuts and chops in the trunks of the beeches and oaks. And lying abandoned in the middle of the clearing was Orcrist, the edge grimy and looking as if there was dried blood smeared on the wickedly sharp blade. Bilbo stared as Dwalin raced forward and lifted the sword, smelling the edge and grimacing.

 

“Dwarf blood,” he spat. 

 

“I told you that there was a plot,” Nori hissed.

 

“Yeah? Well, telling us yesterday would have been much more useful!” the warrior snarled.

 

“We came here as quickly as we could, considering the security situation has deteriorated at home,” Dori sneered. 

 

“What?” Dwalin snapped, rising to face the tailor. Dori was the strongest of all the dwarves in Erebor but Dwalin looked furious enough not to care.

 

“Sulgan’s men are causing trouble in the mountain and spreading all sorts of mischief,” Nori continued. “Rumours that the King is insane. That he has abandoned his people to become a Halfling.”

 

“That’s rubbish!” Dwalin snarled. 

 

“Well, technically, he has abandoned Erebor to come and live with the Hobbits…” Ori piped up.

 

“None of Sulgan’s men-or his relatives-are permitted in Erebor,” Dwalin added. “Thorin banished ‘em all until the End of Days.”

 

“Yeah, that was the standard duration of banishment once Bilbo left,” Dori added.

 

“Anyway, they’re challenging the legality because you aren’t there to throw them out and Balin is struggling with the Scribe who replaced you,” Nori said sharply, looking at his brother. 

 

“But a Raven…”

 

“That’s the other problem,” Nori cut in. “Communications between Erebor and the Shire are almost severed. Someone has been bringing down the Ravens. And of course, our Captain hasn’t been there to look into it…” Dwalin turned on him.

 

“And all those other officers and guards in Erebor? Are they just for decoration? And anyway looking into stuff like that is meant to be the SpyMaster’s job-or ain’t you up to it?”

 

“Enough!” Bilbo yelled, glaring at the dwarves who were all squaring up to one another. He was just as shocked and horrified by Thorin’s absence but standing here shouting wasn’t helping.

 

“Quite,” a calm voice said as Tauriel walked into the clearing with Kili trotting up behind. Both had their bows slung across their backs, looking as if they had been practising. Kili stopped when he saw Orcrist and turned to the group.

 

“Where is Thorin?” he demanded. 

 

“Gone,” was Dwalin’s grim reply. Kili frowned as Tauriel circled the clearing, her keen eyes raking the ground and pausing to crouch down. 

 

“There were four of them,” she murmured. “Tracks head in that direction.” She lifted a bent piece of grass and smelled delicately. “Maybe half an hour or so-no more.” Kili peered at the footsteps. 

 

“Good quality dwarvish boots,” he muttered. “Got the mark of Gulli on them.” Bilbo frowned. “Best bootmaker in Erebor.”

 

“So what are really expensive Ereborean boots doing in the Shire?” Bilbo asked. Dwalin turned and walked to stand by the Prince.

 

“You said they wanted to kill him,” he growled, talking to Nori. “Sulgan?”

 

“Pindil, Drooz and Riolvin as well,” Nori asked as Bilbo stared.

 

“That's half the Council!” he exclaimed. 

 

“They all wanted Uncle to marry their daughters or relatives and didn’t have the sense to shut up when he told them he would never marry again-or even consider anyone,” Kili murmured. “So he banished them when they refused to be quiet. They’re all rich and well-connected. And vengeful.”

 

“And probably here,” Bilbo said, glancing in the direction the steps went. “They’re heading for the caves…”

 

At that, the others ran past him and he paused then ran after them, pausing to scuttle back and grab Orcrist, then ran after them again.

 

-o0o-

 

Thorin sat bolt upright, his head pounding from the blow he took to the back of the head. His hands were tied behind his back and he was sitting on the rocky ground, his back to the uneven rocks of the Bindbole cave system, made of the sandy-grey rocks of the Shire. He had been surprised to find rocks here but it had been a relief and he had spent the first afternoon on his knees, his hands flat against the rough surface, feeling the rock. It wasn’t one of the grand mountain chains, one of the homes that Mahal himself had constructed for his children, to nurture and protect them when they woke, but it was solid rock, extending down a long way into the very roots of the land and somehow, it felt…familiar.

 

There were a few caves here, many tiny spaces just worn through by the little streams of the Shire but there were enough tunnels to make Thorin feel a little more at home-and one really good space where he had decided to plan his tomb. But now he was a prisoner here, taken by dwarves who should not be here but for malice and vengeance. And while being killed was probably preferable to dying in bed of Rejection, dying at the hands of these particular dwarves would be rather vexing.

 

He blinked and focussed his attention back on the dwarves who had taken him like an amateur…or a pathetic dwarfling in his first lesson. He had completely lost his edge and had been easily overpowered by the attackers. They could have killed him instantly but instead, they had brought him here and were planning far worse. Especially when Sulgan had appeared, flanked by his elder son, Hulgan and his Master-at-Arms. The Lord had looked especially smug.

 

“Thorin,” he sneered.

 

“I am still your King,” Thorin had growled, allowing anger and pride to swell through him. It gave him a jolt of energy that countered the increasing lethargy he was fighting. He couldn’t tell these dwarves-or Bilbo. Sulgan snorted.

 

“You banished me, Thorin,” he sneered. “I think you forget your place! I am the scion of one of the oldest families in Erebor and Ered Luin…” But the King lifted his chin with a scornful look.

 

“I am directly descended from Durin the Deathless, the first of our race,” he told the other dwarf disparagingly. “No one on Arda has an older or finer pedigree than I do. And if I banish you, then you are banished.”

 

“Unless you are insane-as rumours say you were when the gold addled your mind,” the Lord sneered.

 

“I have spent over a hundred and twenty years in the service of my people, ruling them, securing them two homes and ensuring there is security and prosperity. The only thing I asked for myself was opposed by you for your own political ends. But when my husband left, I resolved to finally secure my own future and came here for him. I am not insane: my mind has never been clearer.”

 

“And yet, we will persuade the others that you have lost your mind,” Sulgan sneered. “My younger son is there, whispering in ears. And your behaviour here won’t be lost on them…when they learn of it. After all, your grandfather was mad as a goblin…”

 

“And your son should not be in Erebor, on pain of death!” Thorin retorted. “He should be slain…”

 

“Yet my men are seeking your precious Halfling,” Sulgan said softly, prowling back and forth in front of the prisoner. “He’s been rather difficult to locate. He doesn’t stray far and there are often others with him-or watching him. Including you. Does he know?”

 

“He is my husband. I would watch over him while we are estranged,” Thorin said proudly. “And it is treason that you lay hand on me, no matter where we are.”

 

“You think because you won back Erebor by luck, you have the right to command us?” another squat Lord challenged him. His bulbous features were unpleasant his his reddish blond hair was ridiculously curled and braided. Thorin met his angry outburst with his most scornful and aloof expression.

 

“Every member of your family declined to come on the Quest, Lord Pindel,” the King said. “Loyalty, honour and a willing heart were all that was asked. Your family possesses none of those. None of your families. So when you conspired to drive away my husband, I deemed you had no place in the Mountain he was pivotal in winning back. Why should you benefit after driving him away?”

 

“You banished him,” Sulgan sneered.

 

“And you spread lies about him,” Thorin said in a voice dripping with hatred. “For years. You harried my Consort and my only regret is that I did not banish you before you had a chance to drive a wedge between us.”

 

“Such flighty creatures, Halflings,” a very fat and red-faced dwarf sneered. His eyes were small and mean and his grey beard was simply braided into one long braid tucked into the wide silver-studded belt straining around his ample waist. “I’m surprised he lasted as long as he did.”

 

“He is worth a thousand of you, Lord Riolvin,” Thorin snapped. He made to scramble up but a guard pressed the edge of his axe against Thorin’s throat.

 

“Now, now…your Majesty…we don’t want any unpleasantness…” Sulgan sneered. “Just wait quietly while we bring your Halfling to you and then we can reunite you.” Thorin glared but bit his tongue, swallowing the insult he longed to roar at the Lord. No one would hear if he was slain but he was in no hurry to die if Bilbo was in danger. He could only hope that his friends would protect his husband and prevent them slaughtering his love.

 

“You have no desire to unite us,” he ground out through gritted teeth. Sulgan stopped and laughed at him.

 

“I do…in death,” he said cruelly. “I want you to watch me slay your pet Halfling. I want you to see your precious husband take his last breath, drowning in his own blood. And then I will kill you, making look as if you slaughtered your husband in a fit of rage. After all, here with his own kind, all will believe that he is certain to find one more suited to him than a wretched, insane dwarf!”

 

But Thorin took a slow breath.

 

“Balin said you were a dangerous politician but you are a petty, venal little dwarf who aims too far above his station,” he said evenly. “I trust my husband implicitly. He would no more betray me than I him. He is cleverer than you, more loyal and he actually has a place in Erebor. Your men will never capture him and your plan will fail. And I will see every member of all your families driven from Erebor and Ered Luin and any who are within either slain for the traitors they are!”

 

“How pathetic, that you cling to that little ferret, even now…” Pindal scoffed. He gestured to his men and one danced forward, kicking the dwarf King in the middle. Bent forward in pain with the breath knocked out of him, Thorin glanced up as Pindal nodded and his men hauled the King up. 

 

“I weary of these games,” he sneered. “You may want to torment him but what if it takes time to get the Halfling? How long are we to keep him here? There are others in the Shire-Dwalin, Kili, even the Elf!-and if they locate us, then all is lost. Best to end him so Fili is rightfully King and then we can insist he takes a spouse of proper Noble line.” He nodded to the nearest dwarf. “Kill him!”

 

But before he could take a step, Pindal stiffened and jerked backwards, his back arching as a blade erupted through his chest. It was pulled free, covered with blood as the Hobbit appeared and slashed at the midriff of the dwarf to Thorin’s left. Wounded, the dwarf staggered back, allowing the Hobbit to clumsily slice through the ropes around Thorin’s wrists. The dwarf to his right fell back, an arrow protruding from his throat. 

 

“Take this,” Bilbo said, pushing Orcrist into the King’s hand. “I can barely lift it.”

 

“You should not be here,” Thorin said in a dazed voice.

 

“Well, I am so I trust you to keep me safe,” Bilbo said. “After all, you just declared your faith in me to these maggots. I would rather that you made the declaration directly to my…”

 

“Bilbo-duck!” Thorin yelled and used one hand to push the Hobbit’s head down as he parried a blow that was meant to decapitate the Consort-Under-The-Mountain. Another dwarf fell, pierced by an arrow and then, with a roar, the Company arrived. Tauriel was fighting with her knives while Kili was slashing and stabbing with a sword. Dwalin was showing no mercy with his axes, one of which he had given to Ori and Dori was wielding a mace to terrible effect. Nori was fighting with knives and an axe while Oin whirled his staff around viciously. Sulgan edged round the chamber, his son at his side. They were trying to flank Thorin and as the King parried another attack at his head, Hulgan-a young version of his father-grabbed at Bilbo and hauled him back.

 

Immediately, the King rounded on him and sliced deep into his right arm, causing him to scream in pain and allow Bilbo to stumble forward-but in that moment, Sulgan got his hands on the Hobbit, pressing his axe against the Hobbit’s neck.

 

“HOLD!”

 

The entire Company froze, though most of their enemy was defeated. Sulgan looked over at his son and jerked his head for the younger dwarf to rise to his feet.

 

“You are going to let us go with our prisoner and then we will release him,” the Lord said. 

 

“No,” Thorin said calmly. “You will take me.” He lowered Orcrist. “You will release my husband.” Sulgan gave a nasty smile.

 

“I don’t think so,” he said. “The Halfling is a much more powerful lever…”

 

“Once again, you’re behind the times, Lord Sulgan,” Bilbo said utterly calmly. Internally, he regretted not wearing his Mithril shirt but to be fair, he had given up wearing it a fortnight after arriving back in the Shire. It was beautiful and very weapon-proof but no one had tried to stab him until now-not even Lobelia with her umbrella. Hobbits tended to solve conflicts with a sharp word and exclusion from the best parties, along with cutting gossip. Mithril was little protection against being ostracised and referred to as ‘Mad’ and today, it wouldn’t protect his neck either. “I divorced King Thorin and though he is very sweet visiting here to try to win me back, this is hardly likely to entice me back to a bunch of ill-mannered and horribly violent dwarves!”

 

Thorin gritted his teeth against the stab of pain the declaration should cause him-but he felt nothing. A slight wave of dizziness swept over him but he blinked it away easily and shifted his weight and he stared at his Hobbit once more, not understanding what had changed. The Lord glared at the Hobbit and as he frowned, a knife buried in his elbow. Bellowing in pain, the axe moved as Thorin lunged forward, grabbing the blade with his hand and wrenching it away. But as he wrestled, he cried out as a sword drove into his back. But he never let go of the axe, would never let Bilbo be harmed, no matter what it cost him. He didn’t budge when the blade was wrenched out as Dwalin almost cut Hulgan in half and nor did he waver when Tauriel and Kili made sure Sulgan would get no second chance. And it was only when the treacherous Lord collapsed back, his eyes staring lifelessly at the roof that Thorin released the blade and slumped to his knees.

 

Bilbo was at his side in a second, grasping his hand and looking distraught at the deep cuts in the skin from the axe blade.

 

“Oh Thorin…” he whispered. “Your hand…” The King looked up, his blue eyes dark with pain and weariness. 

 

“You are still my husband,” he said haltingly. “My heart will always be yours-in this world and the next. And this is a fitting end, saving my Âzyungel from the treachery of those who would sunder us. If I could choose an end, this would do well.” Bilbo shook his head.

 

“I didn’t mean it,” he said urgently. “I love you, you stupid, stubborn dwarf! I was trying to get him to let me go…” He turned his hand over and showed one of the presents Thorin had made him, a beautiful pocket knife that he had slipped up his sleeve. The King smiled painfully.

 

“So you did keep them,” he said gruffly. 

 

“I love every single one,” Bilbo insisted. “And I am so sorry I’ve been stubborn. I trust you. I trusted you to save me. I trust you to be Thorin Oakenshield. I trust you to love me. And I have to trust you to fight to stay with me.” Thorin was going pale and Oin was fussing with his wound. Tauriel was kneeling at his side, while Kili knelt at Thorin’s other side. Dwalin and Nori checked the other dwarves but not one was moving. 

 

“Lay him down,” Oin instructed as they pulled Thorin to a lying position on his side. Bilbo was wrapping his hand tightly in his silk neckerchief and looking gently into Thorin’s eyes.

 

“You are not rejected, Thorin,” the Hobbit said urgently. “You are my husband and I love you. I want you. I have protected your honour and I have set to rights the lies being spread about you by Gardenia’s cousin. I forgive you. I just wish you would forgive me…” Thorin gave a small smile.

 

“You are forgiven,” he breathed. “You have no reason to be sorry. I wronged you. I deserved everything…”

 

“Then you deserve this,” Bilbo said and leaned in to kiss him. He rested his hand on Thorin’s cheek and sighed. “I want my braid back-but only if you are willing.” The King nodded and fumbled at his belt, awkwardly revealing from a small pouch the beautiful bead he had given to his husband at their wedding and which had never left his person for a moment since Bilbo took it off. 

 

“Amrâlimê,” he mouthed as he clumsily tried to braid it into Bilbo’s fine hair, hampered terribly by his bandaged hand. In the end, the Hobbit helped him but the familiar weight was back. Quietly, the King lifted Bilbo’s palm and pressed a light kiss onto it.

 

“Now listen to me, Thorin son of Thrain,” Bilbo told him sternly. “There is going to be no dying or dramatic gestures or anything. You are going to get better and then we are going spend some quality time here…and you are going to meet all the relatives I actually like. Of which there are literally several.” He looked up and met Oin’s eyes-just for a second because the Healer was looking grim.

 

“We need to get him back to your home,” he said. “I’ve padded it-it will last for a short while but it needs proper medicine…” Bilbo stared at them.

 

“It’s a fair way to Bag End,” he said in a concerned voice. “We’re the far side of Bywater and well into the woods…” 

 

“I will find a horse,” Tauriel volunteered. “We can travel back more swiftly…” Dwalin and Dori already had the dwarf King almost hanging between them, the wadding at his back already starting to look like blood was oozing through. He nodded and the Elf sprinted from the cavern, making her way assuredly and far faster than any of them could hope to. There was something to be said for long Elvish legs. The rest of the Company followed, armed and wary in case any of the enemy were still on the loose with Bilbo surrounded. And the Company were moving quickly, only breathing in relief as they burst out into the bright afternoon, the soft sounds of the birds familiar overhead and punctuated by the thud of iron-shod dwarven feet. 

 

They had been stumbling along determinedly for five minutes when there was the thud of hooves and Tauriel galloped in, sitting bareback on a grey horse. She pulled up and extended her arm.

 

“Come with me, your Majesty,” she invited him but Thorin shook his head.

 

“I think I’ll stay with my Ghivashel,” he said gruffly, his face ashen. “I won’t leave him. I…I don’t think I can…” Bilbo advanced, his eyes stricken. 

 

“Thorin-if you stay here, you’ll die-and I don’t want to lose you,” he said softly. Thorin ghosted a smile. “Please-go with Tauriel. Let her and Oin treat you. I will be back as soon as I can. Wait for me!” 

 

“I will try,” the King whispered as Dwalin boosted him up into the Elf's arms. Then Oin scrambled up behind her.

 

“Go,” Bilbo murmured, watching her nod-then accelerated away, speeding through the trees. The Hobbit grabbed his bead, feeling the familiar hard object bite into his palm.

 

“Let’s go,” Dwalin said. “Let’s just think Azog is after us again. We can run back to your home. It’s closer than Beorn’s house was…”

 

“And we were a lot fitter and had walked halfway across Arda by then,” Bilbo grumbled. “I may have regained a few pounds since then…” But he began to run with then, finding Dori and Ori at either side of him as the entire group accelerated to a run. When they burst out of the woods, they garnered outraged and disgusted looks from the Hobbits who were quietly minding their own business. There were mutters and whispers as they sped through the Bywater Market and hared off back towards Hobbiton. All the while, Bilbo was seeking for his husband with his heart, praying to Yavanna and Aüle, her husband, the creator of the dwarves, that Thorin would hold on. And knowing if he lost Thorin, he would not wish to remain either. So, surrounded by his friends and ignoring his own people, Bilbo ran through Hobbiton and finally up the Hill to his home.

 

The horse was idly nibbling at his early leafy vegetables but Bilbo didn’t care as he sprinted up towards the door. Hamfast was hovering anxiously by the door as the dwarves barrelled in-and though he was frantic to see what had happened to his husband, he needed to reassure his friend.

 

“Master Bilbo-what is happening?” the gardener asked worriedly. Ham’s eyes were wide in concern at what he had witnessed. “Master Lulkhel was wounded-that Elf was almost carrying him into Bag End…”

 

“He’s wounded,” Bilbo told him urgently. “Dwarves from Erebor were here, looking for him. They aimed to hurt me, then kill me and then kill him.”

 

“But why, Mister Bilbo?” Hamfast asked, leaning close to the Hobbit. Bilbo sighed.

 

“Lulkhel is my husband,” he said. “Except he is really named Thorin son of Thrain, King of Erebor. And the Lords who managed to cause the trouble between Thorin and I were banished from the Mountain and came here for revenge. I’m not sure they expected to find Thorin here but he saved my life.”

 

“Wait…you’re married…to the smith?” Hamfast’s voice was confused and then he nodded. “Knew there was something funny going on, if you’ll pardon my presumption, Master Bilbo. That must have been very serious falling-out.” 

 

“It was,” the Hobbit murmured, his eyes drifting to the door. Fortunately, the gardener took the hint.

 

“Give him my best for a quick recovery,” the gardener said. “My Belle will be shocked there’s a King in the neighbourhood…”

 

Patting his friend on the shoulder, Bilbo headed in, his entire body tense with anxiety. There was blood on the floor and he could hear the voices up ahead. Thorin was sprawled prone on the bed in the spare room, his shirt removed and Tauriel and Oin bandaging the wound. They had clearly been stitching it and Oin had packed it with herbs that he had raided from the pantry and the garden. The place was a mess and his husband was lying very still. But the Company parted when he came through and Dwalin and Kili very gently rolled the King onto a drift of pillows and pulled the blanket up to cover him. He looked very pale and was breathing shallowly.

 

“Thorin?” the Hobbit asked, surging forward to grasp the King’s hand. Thorin’s eyelids flickered and opened wearily, the depths dark with pain. But his lips moved into a small smile.

 

“Amrâlimê,” he rasped wearily. “I have been waiting…”

 

“Oh no, you are not doing the deathbed scene once more,” the Hobbit told him urgently. “I had enough of that on Ravenhill. You have stopped bleeding and you are reconciled with me. I am not letting my husband go-because if you die, you will take me with you. I had to open my heart to reach for you-and it is impossible to repeat the manoeuvre. You go and I will fade. So I am trusting you with my life-again. You saved me in there-your poor hand looked terribly cut-and I know you will not give up.”

 

Thorin gave that small, serene smile and nodded.

 

“My Ghivashel,” he murmured. “Please stay. You saved me as well. I will never leave you.”

 

“You better not,” Bilbo said, hooking his foot around a small stool and hauling it closer. “Now we are going to finish cleaning you up and then I am sure Oin will have some absolutely shockingly-awful tasting potions to take…” The King inclined his head slightly, eyes wide as he struggled against the welcome call of darkness.

 

“You truly know…how to encourage a dwarf,” he groaned but his hand tightened around Bilbo’s. His other was bandaged tightly. 

 

“Look, there must be something to it because he helped keep you alive after you charged Azog in the Misty Mountains…” Bilbo told him sharply. Thorin swallowed.

 

“I suspect Gandalf had something to do with that,” he admitted.

 

“And again when you charged him on Ravenhill,” Bilbo added.

 

“He had killed my sister-sons,” Thorin murmured. “I knew I could not let him live. If I was to die, I would rid the world of his scourge and save the rest of the the Company and Dain’s soldiers.”

 

“And Oin needed help from Gandalf and Thranduil to save you then,” the Hobbit sighed. He pulled Thorin’s hand up to nuzzle it. “I know you have to be you but I would rather have you alive than have you being a dead legend.”

 

“I have missed you,” Thorin breathed, his eyelids fluttering with weariness. “I have missed being with you, hearing you scold me, feeling your touch, bathing in your love…”

 

“And that sounds like some terrible deathbed goodbye,” Bilbo said urgently, rising to lean over the  dwarf. “Look at me, Thorin. I am not letting you go. I need you to focus on me and on staying with me.” The dwarf flickered a slight smile.

 

“Aye, my Mizimel,” he mumbled. Bilbo fussed and pulled the blanket up to his chest, then added another blanket.

 

“You’ve lost a lot of blood that I really should clear up-but I am not leaving you, you hear?” he said, looking down on the pallid face. Thorin looked wearily up, his hair fanned over the pillow, the marriage braid obvious by its uniqueness.

 

“Talk to me,” he whispered. “Let me hear your voice. Please…”

 

And Bilbo sat down, his hand twining round the dwarf’s larger paw. His heart was stricken because those six words spoke of so long in silence and loneliness, close to but horribly apart from the being he had pledged his soul to. And, of course, the choice had been Thorin’s because it was always Thorin’s-the stubborn idiot-but it had been an appalling torture he had put himself through, alone among hostile Hobbits, angering his Hobbit husband without realising what he could do to alleviate the problem. And he had not realised that perhaps he only stood a chance when Bilbo was ready to listen. But he had kept trying, though he had almost given up. In his heart, he had thought he had lost Bilbo and thoroughly believed that he had deserved to lose him. And a part of Thorin, a part Bilbo never realised he would ever see, had even welcomed the end because he had been so miserable and in pain and desolation. 

 

But Bilbo was not going to let his husband die. Not now his own stupid, angry and resentful heart had finally agreed that it needed Thorin. The Shire was not enough, not by a long shot. He needed a regal dwarf with a propensity for brooding, a temper and a still residual prejudice against Elves, not some fussy small-minded Hobbit. And the Consort-Under-the-Mountain was not going to give in without a fight.

 

So Bilbo started to talk, started to speak openly about his heart and his feelings. He started at the beginning, about why he left Bag End and abandoned his respectability with his home for a journey into the wilderness with thirteen horribly bad-manner dwarves…especially their aloof and unwelcoming King…

 

When Tauriel looked in one them three hours later, Thorin’s eyes were closed but there was a little smile on his pale lips and he was still breathing. Bilbo had made it to Rivendell in his recitation of the journey, his voice low enough for it to be private between them-unless you had Elvish hearing.

 

“…and I have never heard anyone be so rude to a host when turning up unannounced. After all, it was clear they did save us from the Orc pack and all you could say was your grandfather had never mentioned Lord Elrond in an incredibly rude way! As if he would mention every honoured guest who ever walked through the Halls of Erebor to you when you were still such a young dwarf, if I recall…”

 

The others had cleaned the smial and made food-not to Bilbo’s standard but Belle Gamgee from next door had come up with a hotpot and had overseen Dori and Nori warming it in the oven. She had also made some chicken broth ‘for the invalid’ and some cakes and biscuits ‘because poor Master Dwalin will be quite starved without Bilbo’s baking’. Bilbo had sat back as Thorin’s wounds were checked and had dribbled the soup over his pale lips before wrapping him up and watching him given a sleeping draught. And then the Hobbit had finished his own portion of hotpot and then continued with the story.

 

In the night, they were woken by cries and shouts in Khuzdul and Thorin fought and wrestled as his fever spiked. Bilbo held him close but to took Dwalin and Dori to hold him down as Oin gave him an additional draught. Dwalin muttered words in his ear of the secret language, calming the frantic King down and finally allowing him to relax and slip back into sleep. Oin checked his wounds and had to put an additional couple stitches in to stop some oozing from where his struggles had ripped the stitches. And Bilbo felt horribly guilty that he hadn’t been able to stop his dwarf from hurting himself…

 

As Thorin lay quietly, his body radiating heat from his fever and cheeks flushed, Bilbo had castigated himself savagely, for allowing this to happen and for wasting so much time with the dwarf he cared for. He had done the right thing in protecting himself, leaving Erebor when he had been banished and refusing to take his husband’s ridiculous accusation lying down. Hurt and angry, he had left, losing his home and friends in the process. And when Thorin had returned, it had been an opportunity for reconciliation…except Thorin hadn’t come to see him or apologise straight off…and that had roused his anger and stubbornness. So he had hardened his heart and put the pair of them through a prolonged dance that had weakened and hurt Thorin. And though he had deserved some of the discomfort, Bilbo had never wanted him hurt or dying. But here he was-and though others had wounded Thorin, it was still Bilbo’s fault.

 

Thorin hovered on the brink of death, wracked by fever and weakened by blood loss and the effects of his Rejection. Sometimes, he was delirious and cried and roared in Khuzdul, at times angry and defiant and other times sad and grieved by the terrible losses he had endured. Sometimes, he spoke to people who weren’t there-most often his dead brother and though Bilbo knew how much Thorin had missed Frerin, it was only now, with all his defences lowered, that he understood. And maybe the angry Bilbo who had met his husband in Bywater Forge would have accused his husband of keeping secrets from and not trusting his husband, but Bilbo recognised old pain from loss. What he would have given for an hour with his parents, asking them all those things he desperately needed advice on, his husband most of all. So he mopped Thorin’s clammy brow and whispered words of reassurance and love to him.

 

But the days passed and again, Thorin lingered in the twilight. Kili was informed by Oin and Tauriel that his Uncle was fighting but perhaps not as hard as they would have expected. The King was at the end of his strength, enduring a period of Rejection that would already have ended most other dwarves… So the Prince spent time with his Uncle, talking quietly to him and reminiscing about his childhood and how much he and Fili owed Thorin. Dwalin spent time as well with his friend and Shield Brother, not saying much but occasionally insulting him and threatening to train him to within an inch of his life when he finally returned home. 

 

The others supported Bilbo, trying to keep his spirits up, even as the King remained sunken in his illness. And Oin didn’t shy from being honest to their host in explaining that Thorin was still hovering right on the brink. The wound had been severe and was infected and the King was fighting with all he had…but he was still alive, which was a small miracle of itself. Now they just needed to pray and trust to their King’s innate stubbornness in bringing him back to his husband.

 

-o0o-

Notes:

Khuzdul

Amrâlimê - my love

Ghivashel - treasure of all treasures

Mizimel - jewel of jewels

Âzyungel - love of all loves

Chapter 14: For the Life of The King

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

FOURTEEN: For the Life of the King

 

 

The party drew far more attention than usual as they rode along the East Road. They had drawn suspicious looks as they had ridden through Whitfurrows and Frogmorton and when they had turned off into Bywater, there had been something of a commotion. Leading the group were two figures riding assuredly but wearing cloaks and hoods, shadowing their faces while the rest of the party comprised twenty dwarves-at-arms all dressed in the magnificently decorated and embossed iron armour of Erebor. All were heavily armed with axes, pikes and swords and dressed for a long journey. But as they travelled through the Market, a familiar shape emerged, her eyes filled with disgust.

 

“Not more of the wretched creatures!” she exclaimed to the round and pasty Hobbit hanging onto her arm. His eyes darted from dwarf to dwarf, lingering on the weapons with distinct trepidation that was not shared by his companion. “We have enough with that nasty, deceitful Lulkhel. I can’t see why he’s still allowed to be here.”

 

The party abruptly stopped and the leader wheeled round, blue eyes narrowing in the shadows of his hood.

 

“Pardon me, Mistress Hobbit, but why do you malign the dwarf Lulkhel?” he asked in a controlled voice. 

 

“I suppose you would try to defend him,” the she-Hobbit spat. The traders in the Market were all focussed on her now, watching with fascination and not a little horror-though whether horror at her words or her actions in facing down a score of armed dwarves was to be seen. “He’s a nasty thing who led me on, lied to me and then turned me down. He’s hung around like a bad smell even when I have tried to get my fellow Hobbits to drive him out…”

 

“Excuse me, Madame,” the second hooded dwarf said in a determinedly amiable voice. “I am certain there has been a misunderstanding. He would never court you or have any intention towards you. It must just have been a cultural misunderstanding…”

 

“You know, that wretched Mad Baggins said the same-and look at him!” the female Hobbit spat. “He ran off with a bunch of you nasty smelly creatures! And now he’s housing that Lulkhel and his friends in Bag End. I heard Lulkhel was ill again-maybe this time he’ll do the decent thing and die to rid us of his presence…”

 

There was a metallic sound and suddenly the Hobbit found herself facing a sword, held steadily in the hand of the first dwarf. The pikes of the soldiers were all pointing at the Hobbits and the female squeaked while the chubby male’s pants darkened embarrassingly. 

 

“Mind how you speak, female,” the leader said in a cold voice.

 

“I will not!” she spat, sounding slightly watery. “This is the Shire, the home of Hobbits, not for nasty, evil, treacherous, lying dwarves…”

 

“You know not of what you speak!” the first dwarf snapped and tossed his hood back. Durin-blue eyes looked from a face calmer than it had been with braided blond moustache and beard and golden hair neatly styled. “I am Fili son of Vili, Crown Prince of Erebor. The dwarf you malign is my Uncle, Thorin son of Thrain, son of Thor, second of that name and King under the Mountain and Lord of Erebor, the richest and most powerful dwarf Kingdom on Middle Earth!”

 

The Hobbit opened her mouth wordlessly.

 

“Thorin could buy you and your Shire a hundred times over and still have a Treasury the envy of all other Kingdoms. The individual you call ‘Mad Baggins’ is his husband, Prince Bilbo, the Prince Consort. Their wedding was attended by nobility the like of which you could not imagine. Dain, Lord of the Iron Hills, Lord Elrond of Rivendell, Lady Galadriel of Lothlorien, King Thengel of Rohan, the Steward of Gondor, King Bard of Dale, Thranduil the ElvenKing of Mirkwood…all celebrated the union of my Uncle and Bilbo Baggins. So I will not listen to you, Madame, maligning my Uncle and his spouse!” Fili’s voice was steely and the soldiers lowered their pikes a little more, causing her to squeak and retreat, cursing all dwarves. Balin looked over at the Crown Prince.

 

“That may have been overkill, laddie,” he commented in his  best 'disappointed uncle’ voice. But Fili wasn’t deterred or even apologetic. 

 

“You haven’t read what Kee has written about how some of the Hobbits here have treated Uncle,” he said grimly. “And I suspect that was the one who caused it all. I have no idea what she holds against our people but it is clearly vitriolic.” Balin sighed.

 

“I understand laddie-but we’re not in Erebor now,” he advised the Prince. “We are a guest in this land and throwing our weight around won’t help us at all.” Fili inclined his head in that little gesture that Thorin had perfected over the decades. Balin felt a strange surge of recognition in the movement.

 

“Then can I dispatch you to speak to the Thain Took in Tuckborough to explain our presence while I join my brother in Bag End,” the Prince said, his concern finally leaking into his calm tone. “Kili’s Ravens have been very alarming and I…I cannot imagine how I would cope if we did not arrive in time…”

 

“Your Uncle is made of sterner stuff than that, laddie,” Balin said with a serious look in his eyes. “But just to be safe, go and see him. I’ll take half the guards to at least look like the escort to the King! Can you find your way to Bag End?”

 

Fili laughed.

 

“I’m not Thorin and I do actually possess a sense of direction,” he chuckled. “Only Thorin could get lost here, twice.” Balin nodded and yelled some orders while Fili sheathed his sword and kicked his pony on, trotting along the road towards the rise of the Hill and the oak tree at the top that marked the site of Bilbo’s home. And in there was his Uncle, his King, his de-facto father who had raised him, sick and weakened and wounded. And though he was receiving excellent care-for Oin and Tauriel were both skilled in their own ways-he was still at risk. He just hoped that Thorin would have finally got some news to report-and hopefully, the reconciliation that Erebor was praying for. 

 

Fili could not understand the complexities of the relationship between his Uncle and Bilbo but he did know that Thorin could be stubborn, temperamental, rigid and ridiculously dramatic with a tendency to bear a grudge while Bilbo was smart, sarcastic, equally stubborn and very determined. Both had a tendency not to communicate as well as they should and failed to recognise what was in front of them-the Company had been literally tearing their hair out as the pair had danced around each other after the Arkenstone debacle and everyone had recovered from the Battle. What was obvious was that they pair loved each other and to Fili, that should be enough. The fact that it didn’t seem to be was a sadness to the Prince as he witnessed two people he cared for hurting each other through stubborn pride.

 

He dismounted at the door of Bag End and secured his horse, asking the soldiers to wait down the hill at the Inn-the Green Dragon, if he recalled-since he suspected Bilbo would not welcome a hoard to dwarvish guards tramping mud into his Smial. And he doubted the noise would do his Uncle any good. So he walked to the door and raised his hand to bang on the wood-but it opened to reveal the much-missed face of his brother. In a second they were embracing, murmuring words of welcome and relief in Khuzdul, for this was the longest they had ever been separated from each other. For a few moments, they just remained there, before pulling apart and entering the lobby. Kili closed the door quietly and sighed.

 

“How’s Uncle?” his brother asked.

 

“No better,” the younger Prince admitted, his expression concerned. “I don’t know if it is because he was so far gone with the Rejection or because he had given up, but he’s not rallying. Oin is looking pretty grim and even Tauriel is worried.”

 

“But he has reconciled with Bilbo?” Fili checked. Kili nodded sadly.

 

“They both held out as long as possible-Uncle was even actively avoiding Bilbo after their last discussion, Mahal alone knows what they said! But Bilbo seemed to have sorted his head and his heart out and was actually on the way to the Forge to talk Thorin into trying again…when of course, he found him gone.”

 

“Damn Sulgan!” Fili growled. 

 

“Mahal’s problem now,” Kili said cheerfully. “Tauriel and I saw to that. Pindal is gone as well…”

 

“And Drooz is in jail in Ered Luin, having been apprehended under our Treaty for Treason,” Fili added. “All of Sulgan’s men and his son have been removed from Erebor-shaved and shamed, in case they didn’t recall that the terms of banishment by Thorin applied to them all.” There was a harshness in his voice that Kili didn’t especially like but he felt equal anger at the Lords and their families and entourages who had worked to try to kill Bilbo and Thorin.

 

“So they’re safe?” Kili checked. The Crown Prince removed his cloak and overcoat and hung it up on the neat line of hooks in the hallway. 

 

“They’re never safe but the enemies who were targeting them are defeated,” he said and then he sighed. “Can I see him?” Nodding, the younger Prince led them through Bag End, past Ori who was knitting and Dwalin who was sharpening his axes for the thousandth time this week. No one seemed surprised that the Prince had arrived, merely that it had taken so long but Fili nodded, silently promising a proper reunion later. And then Kili led him into the room, pausing to look at his Uncle.

 

Thorin was lying still in the bed, appearing pale and thinner. The flush on his cheeks from the fever was obvious and Oin was peering at his wound, which was being cleaned. Bilbo was helping Tauriel hold the King on his side, leaning close to the dwarf and murmuring words to him. As Oin nodded and allowed them to roll him back, Bilbo briefly pressed his forehead to that of the King and whispered a couple of words.

 

Thorin didn’t respond. 

 

Fili glanced at his brother, seeing devastation in his eyes. There was something there that told the older Prince that he had been holding onto far more hope than the situation seemed to own and that hope was now waning in light of what he had just seen. Shocked and saddened, Fili had known that his Uncle was sick but seeing the reality was worse than he had imagined. Like Kili, they had missed Thorin’s dance with death following the Battle, for they had been hovering on the brink themselves and had the scars to prove it. When they had finally woken, Thorin had been on the road to recovery, projecting the strong and proud image that he always had-and if he was feeling weak or unwell, he never showed his sister-sons. But to see him so diminished, so unresponsive, broke their hearts. 

 

“Come in, boys,” Bilbo said in a low voice and the Princes rushed forward, each taking a hand and pressing it to their faces. Fili was distressed to see the stitched wounds across his Uncle’s palm and the Hobbit explained how Thorin had acquired them, heroically saving Bilbo’s life, even before they were properly reconciled.

 

“Why didn’t you?” Fili asked as the Hobbit brought them mugs of ale and a plate of snacks, knowing they would want to spend some time with their Uncle. Shaking his head, Bilbo sighed.

 

“I find that spending so much time with you terribly mannered dwarves has engendered some very dwarvish traits in me,” the Hobbit said, his eyes straying fondly to the figure lying silently in the bed. “I may have been a little stubborn normally but I was so ridiculously stubborn in clinging to my anger and hurt at how Thorin betrayed me, at how he didn’t trust me when I love him with all my heart. And what he said to me would count as a rejection in the terms of Hobbit love. Being betrayed and not trusted by your Heart-Mate is as devastating to a Hobbit as your Rejection is to you. So I had to cling to the anger and protect myself by rejecting him and ending the marriage. And it became a defence, the anger, to protect me from someone who had betrayed me before, who had tried to kill me and who had shown he did not trust me. I had to fight my heart because it still loved him…but my mind was angry and hurt and I had to rationalise those.”

 

“So what changed?” Fili’s voice was calm but wary.

 

“I almost lost him,” Bilbo admitted. “He was so sick after the New Year and I realised that no matter how exasperating Thorin is, he is my dwarf and I couldn’t imagine a world where he wasn’t in it, living safely and proudly as the King he was born to be. I wanted to protect him from everything that threatened him-I just didn’t realise that I was the greatest threat because there were still misunderstandings, still his ridiculous propensity for dramatic gestures and his decisions that he had lost me forever. I was having to get up before dawn just to meet him because he was leaving Bag End so early to avoid me! But fortunately he and I have friends who did everything they could to support us-and Kili and Tauriel were able to talk some sense into me. I finally analysed what had happened and listened to my heart and to my mother. I decided what was important…a day too late…”

 

“He lives,” Fili reassured the Hobbit. “And while he lives, he will do everything he can to return to you."

 

Bilbo left them then, allowing them time to be with their Uncle. They had been his sister-sons for longer than he had been alive, a relationship through hardship and loss that Thorin had maintained despite every other demand on his time. That they had followed him on a doomed Quest was inevitable and that they would leap forward and accompany him on the suicidal ride up Ravenhill was just as predictable. It was only fitting that they should be here, no matter the outcome.

 

But when the night was dark and the Smial silent but for the snores of the dwarves, Bilbo couldn’t sleep. Balin had arrived late in the afternoon and Bilbo had been delighted to see his friend-along with being horribly guilty at the circumstances, knowing they had no come for him but for Thorin. Accompanying him was a familiar shape-Gimli, Gloin’s son-who had been part of the group of soldiers but who was travelling on behalf of his father, who as Master of Coin, was remaining in Erebor with Dis while the rest of the Company left. There were nine of the original Company here now, all for the ailing King and hosted by his estranged and now reconciled husband. But somehow, Bilbo felt a stranger in his own home, feeling accusing eyes on him for making Thorin wait so long when he had needed to follow the demands of his own heart. And he did feel guilty, though there was blame on both sides. Honestly, none of them had a clue how exasperating Thorin could sometimes be…

 

And then he pulled himself up in that thought. It was unworthy because Bilbo knew he was stubborn and a little set in his ways as well. He wasn’t a young Hobbit, middle-aged really, and he was a fussy and opinionated creature. He liked his home just-so and insisted on doing things the Hobbit way…and Thorin had gracefully allowed him free rein. The King of Dwarves had ensured that his husband was happy and had whatever he needed-and Bilbo had done his best to fit in, helping where he could, attending whatever meetings he needed to and offering support and counsel to the King. Thorin relied on Bilbo, especially when dealing with other races, for Hobbits were polite and sociable, unlike dwarves who tended to be secretive and defensive. Together they made a good partnership and it was only their mutual stupidity, pride and anger that had broken them.

 

He walked into the bedroom and found Thorin, for once, alone, for Bilbo had insisted on claiming the night shifts. Sometimes, one of the others kept him company but mostly, it was just him and Thorin, sitting beside the ailing dwarf, hands clasped and waking draped over the edge of the bed, his neck and back aching something fierce. But now, he wondered if he was just making things worse. Was he forcing Thorin to stay when his heart yearned for oblivion? Was he condemning the King to a twilight existence, clinging to a body broken and failing because of his own selfishness? Bilbo knew nothing about the effects of Rejection on dwarves and whether or not it could be reversed, but he knew that he loved Thorin and did not want to imagine letting him go-not without a fight. 

 

And as he stroked the King’s hair and nuzzled against his face, the words of a conversation with Bofur came back to him, crystallising everything in his mind…

 

“Being a dwarf who finds his One isn’t a simple business, Bilbo. It is a wondrous gift from Mahal, the most precious of all things a dwarf can own. Mahal crafted our Ones specially for us, the perfect partner who completes our heart and soul. But that isn’t just words-when a couple recognise the bond, especially when it is accepted and formalised, there is a physical change in both dwarrow as well. Their wellbeing is tied to the other and they are stronger and healthier together.”

 

“You mean you have to stay close or you become unwell?”

 

“Not usually. Dwarrow travel and sometimes, you have to be many leagues from your One. Perhaps for many months. But that love, that connection keeps you warm and fills you with hope and certainty that your One will come back. There are tales of dwarrow who knew the instant their One fell, when that connection was severed, even though they never knew of it.”

 

“You mean magic?”

 

“It is the way we were created. Just as dwarrow love only once and will never love again if they are rejected.”

 

“Normally, no dwarf would reject his One. He could be angry, they could argue, they could even separate but they would never reject the other because they know what it would do.”

 

“Rejecting your One would sever the bond and leave the separated partners in trouble. When a dwarf is Rejected by his love, the bond with his One is cut. You remember I said that dwarrow are stronger and healthier when they are with their Ones? The opposite is true. If a dwarf if rejected by his One, especially after he is married and their bond is formalised, then he suffers. In terms of strength but also in terms of will to live. He will become susceptible to illness and vulnerable to bandits and any of the normal dangers of life. His stamina will diminish and he will be unable to work. And finally, he will sicken and die.”

 

“So we are better together, my King,” he murmured, looking on the familiar, handsome face. “And though I have forgiven you, do you believe it? Did you just think it was a kind act to a dying dwarf? Because I can tell you now-it was not. I would not say the words unless I meant them. You are ridiculous and oblivious and overdramatic and lots of other adjectives that people who don’t understand dwarves would never credit you with. I love you totally and utterly, Thorin. I will never love anyone else-have never loved anyone else. And you are the other half of my heart and soul. So whatever it takes, I want you with me to the end of my life. And I want that to be many years away…”

 

Seeing no response, Bilbo sighed and then stroked a few stray strands off Thorin’s forehead.

 

“I’ve been sleeping by you for days now and not a twitch,” he murmured. “I know the others are concerned-and Oin is very worried. Of course, he doesn't say anything, just mutters at everyone and is extremely grumpy but we can all tell. And I don’t know how you dwarves work-not really. I don’t know how this Rejection works because no one has ever had a case like ours. And we’ve been stubborn and oblivious and too proud to be sensible. But I absolutely definitely don’t want you to leave me.” Then he walked round to the other side of the bed, removed his waistcoat and slipped his braces off from over his shoulders. After checking his pockets, he slid onto the bed and lay down by the motionless dwarf’s side, rolling onto his side and gently curling into the side of the ailing King, while taking care not to jostle him for fear of aggravating his wounds. “So I need you to remember that I am here, waiting for you, my husband.” He nuzzled into Thorin’s neck and rested a hand over his heart. “If you leave me, I will not linger without you-my poor heart would never survive losing you. So you need to fight for us both, Thorin. I am here and waiting, my Ghivashel. I love you. Now come back to me.”

 

-o0o-

 

He awoke warm and relaxed, a feeling of rightness and peace washing all over him. For a long moment, his mind struggled to place what had changed and memories of mornings waking in the cold air of Erebor swirled around him. And then he realised that he was sleeping in his own bed-technically his own spare bed-curled up against the warm and solid shape of Thorin. He could feel the slow and steady rise and fall of the dwarf’s chest against his head and the arm curled around him was just tight enough to make him feel…

 

Arm?

 

Bilbo's eyes snapped open and he raised his head a couple of inches to look up at the dwarf King lying against him. Thorin’s face had a little more colour and the unnatural flush in his cheeks had faded. The body was dwarvish warm but no longer scorching with fever and he felt himself smile as he laid his head down again.

 

“If this is a dream, Ghivashel, let me not wake,” the King murmured hoarsely through dry lips. 

 

“It’s no dream, just an…experiment,” Bilbo said quietly and felt the King tense. “Now listen to me before you get all offended and find some other way to torture yourself and try to die on me. When I asked about Ones, I was told they were better and stronger together and at risk when parted, especially by rejection. It’s not the same in Hobbits and I’m not sure how your rules apply to Dwarf-Hobbit pairings. But I have forgiven you and I love you and I don’t want to lose you, you exasperating dwarf.”

 

“I am thankful to hear…” Thorin murmured wearily. “But I was told…once rejected by a One, the bond was lost forever…”

 

“You never rejected me,” Bilbo reminded him. “And I ended the marriage because of your behaviour. I hardened my heart to protect myself from fading…but I still loved you. The love never goes but the effects of losing your love are as severe for Hobbits as for dwarves. But you returned and when I finally realised that our love was more important than pride or hurt…and that you did trust me, as you showed many times…then I needed you back. And I was told the bond made you healthier and stronger.”

 

“But…I was told it was irrevocable…”

 

“You Lulkhel!” Bilbo scolded him. “After you recovered in the New Year, you didn’t believe that I would want you back! You believed someone rather than the truth in your own heart. You kept on fading, though you didn’t tell me! And I was upset but I understand why…once I twisted my brain round to the ridiculous convoluted self-sacrificing Thorin way of thinking. I love you-and I have been trying to show you…”

 

“Food…” Thorin murmured.

 

“When I said to Sulgan that I wasn’t your husband, I watched you,” the Hobbit murmured. “You expected pain, didn’t you. Did it hurt?”

 

“No,” the King murmured, his voice a little confused. “A little dizziness but no pain.”

 

“I think you had started to believe there was hope,” Bilbo said softly. “That I was speaking the truth that I loved you and wanted to try again.” Frowning and blinking slowly, Thorin nodded.

 

“I wanted so much for it to be true…and when you said the words, I expected the pain…but my heart knew they were not true, that you said them only to trick that rukhsel Sulgan…” Thorin murmured slowly.

 

“I assume that’s an insult?” Bilbo asked him with a half-smile.

 

“Orc of orcs,” the King replied with satisfaction.

 

“So the worst orc of them all…even worse than Azog?” Bilbo checked.

 

“In this, I think, yes…” the King decided with a sigh. The the Hobbit’s face fell.

 

“I probably deserve that title,” Bilbo murmured in shame. “I have hurt you before. Many times-and worse, I didn’t even understand that I was doing it…” But the King’s hand, still bandaged heavily, tightened slightly around his waist as he made to draw back. 

 

“All is forgiven,” Thorin murmured. “It was my choice not to explain to you. You did not understand.”

 

“I wish I had,” the Hobbit said honestly. “I was angry at you but I never wanted you harmed or injured by anything I did. But I now understand that you did not want me to feel beholden to you and lose my choice in whether to forgive you or not.” He sighed. “I think you began to understand I wanted you back…that I needed you back. A world without you in wasn’t conceivable. But it wasn’t enough. You still lost ground, day by day because what I had done to you was so advanced. So I did the only thing I could think of. And being here with you…” He smiled. “Your fever has broken. You are awake.”

 

“I wanted to return but when I felt you in my arms, I knew I had to return,” the King said gruffly. “I could feel you with me, like a warmth drawing me close. And all the pains and hurts faded as I came closer…until I found you in my arms.” 

 

"And you're not going to fade any more? You're not going to thoughtlessly die on me just for dramatic effect?” Bilbo checked. Thorin managed that small smile that always made his husband's heart flutter.

 

“I feel…normal…” he said slowly, relief in his eyes. “I…”

 

The door to the room opened and two heads poked round, one fair and one dark.

 

“Uncle!” Fili said with relief.

 

“Uncles!” Kili amended as the pair surged into the room, launching onto Thorin and hugging him fiercely. Bilbo still winced at the groan as they squeezed out as they impacted on the King.

 

“You’re alive!” Fili gasped with relief.

 

“When…? How…?” Thorin murmured, his brow furrowing. 

 

“While you were sick,” Bilbo explained. “He just turned up-having threatened Gardenia in Bywater Market.” The King gave a satisfied smile and closed his eyes, lying back into his pillows. 

 

“Ah. Good,” he concluded as Bilbo curled into him. Undeterred-though far too old and large to try it-the Princes managed to wrap themselves around their Uncles. Fili snuggled into Thorin’s other side while Kili wrapped himself round Bilbo and still managed to keep contact with his Uncle as well. The Hobbit huffed-though not too hard because this brought back pleasant memories of Erebor as well.

 

“Well, I must say…at least you have removed your boots,” he commented, burrowing his head into Thorin’s neck. “Are you alright there, Amrâlimê?” Thorin nodded slightly. “Anything you need?” Checking and finding the pain in his chest was completely gone, Thorin smiled.

 

“I have everything I need right here,” he murmured and fell back to sleep.

 

Oin found them about an hour later, piled together on the guest bed and for a moment, he smiled. To his expert eye, Thorin looked better, with more colour in his skin and lips, his breathing easier and the unhealthy flush in his cheeks and sheen on his skin of fever absent. Bilbo was sleeping against the King with the boys wrapped around them. But he needed to check out the King and so he lifted his ear trumpet and rattled it across the bars of the brass bedstead. The ensuing racket had the Princes starting, Fili falling out of bed in a heap, Kili leaping up like a scalded cat and Thorin starting and tensing. Bilbo put a hand over his ears.

 

“You could have just said ‘wake up’, Oin,” he commented grumpily. “Not as if you could sneak up on anyone with those clodhopping footsteps…”

 

“Aye, well that wouldn’t have made any of these move,” the Healer replied.

 

“You just needed to say ‘orcs’ rather quietly and that would have woken Thorin,” Bilbo replied, sitting up and stretching. “Works every time.”

 

“That’s not funny,” the King murmured grumpily, his eyes opening again.

 

“It is,” Fili said from the floor. 

 

“We tried it on the Quest and…you remember that time when you almost cut Ori in half when he was offering you a bowl of broth for breakfast?”

 

“I thought Dori was actually going to kill you,” Fili added, clambering up.

 

“Nori did prank us after that,” Kili noted with chagrin.

 

“Which you thoroughly deserved. Poor Ori was jittery for about a hundred miles after that!” Bilbo told them, reluctantly extricating himself from Thorin’s embrace. “Sorry, Thorin. But Oin does need to check your wounds.” He leaned forward and pressed a small kiss onto the King’s forehead. “I’ll fetch you some breakfast once I freshen up…”

 

He glanced back when he reached the door and Thorin’s brilliant smile made his heart jump, a feeling of rightness, of warmth and safety and belonging settling on him. 

 

Everything was going to be alright. 

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Lulkhel - idiot of all idiots
Rukhsel - orc of orcs
Amrâlimê - my love

Chapter 15: The Price The Gods Decree

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

FIFTEEN: The Price The Gods Decree

 

 

Of course it wasn’t all plain sailing because Thorin had been fighting for days, his reserves depleted and he was very weak. But his fever had broken and his mind was clear. Even his sword wound appeared to be healing better than it had. The Princes were delighted and Oin was shocked at the proof of the power of the bond between Ones. Thorin still ate little and slept much of the time, marshalling and regaining his strength. But every day he was a little stronger and his wounds faded slowly. Oin had Dwalin and Balin help Thorin regain his strength and mobility, for with the best will in the world, Bilbo was not strong enough to really support the King as he took his first very shaky steps, though he stayed with his husband as Thorin began his recovery. And as he sat by his husband’s side, he wondered what he could say to try to explain why he had reacted how he had.

 

But he need not have worried. Thorin seemed determined to talk, to make up for all those desolate hours of silence and his words came from the heart. He apologised abjectly, begged forgiveness for his lack of faith, his pride and his jealousy. He also explained that when he was fading, he felt as if he could never hope for reconciliation until he honestly believed it was impossible. And while he savoured every moment with his beloved Hobbit, spending too much time only tormented him with what could not be.

 

Bilbo scolded him soundly for that, apologising for his own slowness in working through his own issues and recognising what his own heart had been trying to tell him. He confessed that he had clung to his anger and hurt and feelings of betrayal for far longer than he should and he guessed that there was still some residual anger at the scene on the ramparts feeding into that. Quietly, he admitted that he had completely forgiven Thorin for his actions, because he had been ill, but he still had occasional nightmares about that moment-and the Battle. Yet he was not afraid of Thorin and trusted him with his life. 

 

For his part, Thorin confessed that he had missed the Hobbit every second since he had left Erebor, feeling as if part of himself was missing. He apologised humbly for not asking enough about Hobbit relationships and made sure to check every detail of the way Heart-Mates related to one another and what he should and should not do. Then, he explained about Rejection and how he had no idea if it could be reversed-but it certainly felt as if he was stronger and less hopeless than he had been. As King, his upbringing had been very regimented, and had included a lot of lore and religion to ensure that he honoured his direct ancestor, Durin the Deathless, and Mahal, who had created their race. Bilbo confessed that he had been made aware that the StoneSeers would not have supported Thorin’s reign if he had broken dwarvish secrecy and explained what a normal dwarf would be told before marriage-which had prompted a wry smile from the King. He admitted that he had no idea what a normal couple would be told, for his own encounter with the StoneSeers had been a short lecture on how he was disgracing his people with his choice of Consort and how when he was rejected, it would be permanent. And he had not covered Rejection in anything he spoke to his husband about because…well, he was hoping that it would never come to that.

 

There had been happier talks as well, reminiscing about the Journey and life back in Erebor and the antics of the Princes. The Company had all spent time with Thorin and he had been touched by their care and attention-even moreso when the Ur family arrived, tipped off by the arrest of Lord Drooz in Ered Luin and the news of the deaths of those Lords exiled from Erebor who had made the attempt on the lives of King Thorin and his Consort. They had not expected to find nearly the entire Company there and there had been a lot of joyous reunions amid the more serious business. Finding that Thorin had been so close to death had been a shock to all and Bifur, Bofur and Bombur had not delayed in offering their wishes for their King’s speedy recovery. 

 

Time passed and as the daffodils withered, the later Spring flowers burst into life and the hedgerows filled with May and Elder flowers. Bluebells carpeted the woods and the entire Shire was green and full of life. Thorin grew stronger slowly while life adopted a new rhythm. Dwalin and the Princes worked the Forge, Dori took it upon himself to make new clothes fit for a King while Balin liaised with the Thain and did a little business in securing contracts with the Shire. Ravens kept coming from Erebor, filling the King and the Princes in with events back in the Mountain and there was an unspoken urgency that began to build in the Company. Everyone knew that they couldn’t remain in the Shire forever, that the Kingdom needed its rulers and the senior officers. Bilbo personally felt that if they never returned, Erebor was in excellent hands with Dis, though he knew as well that she would dispatch kidnappers or assassins if they failed to return-probably some of each, knowing the Princess.

 

It was only when he found Thorin standing in the back garden, slowly circling Orcrist in very basic exercises that Bilbo realised that his husband was progressing faster towards full health. His scars were an angry red but no longer needed dressing and the Hobbit was relieved that Thorin was looking and feeling more like himself. But not wholly, for he was quieter and more introspective than ever. Ever attentive to his husband, he was clearly making a great effort in asking if he did not understand anything and checking how his Hobbit was feeling. Bilbo would have found himself getting annoyed if he had not understood this was Thorin’s way of showing that he was trying to understand those things he had so woefully failed to learn. There were flashes of the King, of the regal facade and the practiced indifference when he was asked things in his capacity as King of Erebor but mostly, he was Thorin, Uncle and husband. 

 

Fortinbras visited on a sunny late Thrimidge day where the cuckoos were singing across the water in the woods and the breeze was warm and laden with the scents of the early roses. Half the Company were out practising weapons or shopping while Thorin-who had finished a strenuous weapons practice session with Dwalin half an hour before and was dozing in the parlour-and Bilbo, who was preparing lunch, were essentially alone in the smial.

 

The Hobbit had welcomed his cousin warmly and had shown him into the parlour while Thorin had woken abruptly and recreated his impassive facade even as he wondered why the ruler of the Shire was visiting. It was clearly not a social call, for Bilbo would have been forewarned and all of Thorin’s instincts were roused. But he watched as Bilbo played host and then ensured that his visitor had tea and snacks before sitting beside Thorin on the couch, offering his husband a wary glance.

 

“I’m sure you’re wondering why you’re here,” Fortinbras had said, his eyes sweeping over the couple. “I have several things I need to impart to you.”

 

Bilbo tensed and wondered if he was going to be exiled from the Shire. At least that would be a record, being thrown out of both lands where he had ever lived. He wondered if maybe he could apply to Lord Elrond to move to Rivendell…

 

“Your Highness, I am pleased to officially make you acquaintance,” the Thain said as Thorin stiffened then inclined his head.

 

“Sir, I travelled under an assumed name and had no expectations of any treatment other than that given to any traveller to the Shire,” he said honestly.

 

“Your family and friends seem happy to thrown your name around,” Fortinbras pointed out. Thorin grimaced.

 

“For that, you have my apologies, Thain Took,” he said gravely. “They were under orders to respect my anonymity, since I travelled here as the ‘fool of fools’ for my treatment of my beloved husband.”

 

“I may have been one of the offenders,” Bilbo admitted. “Kili certainly was. And Fili. We’re proud of you and everything you have achieved. You are only King of Erebor because you went on a crazy Quest no one would support you in, crossed Middle Earth, took back your home from a dragon and defended it against the armies of Orcs that Azog and Bolg brought to slay you and your line.”

 

“And yet, in the Shire I am Lulkhel, the dwarvish smith,” the King noted dryly. Fortinbras frowned and sipped his tea. 

 

“You mentioned you had mistreated your husband…Bilbo?” he asked, steel entering his voice. Bilbo grimaced: the accusation was a serious one in the Shire. To his credit, Thorin shook his head and looked utterly embarrassed. 

 

“I listened to rumours and lies-my own stupidity and jealous possessiveness would not allow me to act like a husband and instead, I confronted him and after he refused to answer my questions, I banished him,” he explained. “He, Bofur and Ori-the young dwarf with all the knitted clothes-had hatched a plan to locate and restore an ancient ancestor to Erebor, to be buried among his kin. They succeeded but accepted my anger and banishment in order to preserve the secret. I was thoroughly shamed and dishonoured when the remains arrived, laying bare the depths of my depravity in failing to trust my husband whose only thoughts were to grant me this gift and honour my Kingdom. After that, I could not stay in Erebor. I had to come to my One.”

 

“One?”

 

“The dwarf equivalent of a Heart-Mate,” Bilbo explained. Thorin nodded.

 

“The perfect mate crafted for us by Mahal-the husband of your creator, Yavanna, who I guess was involved in our unique tale,” he explained slowly, clearly struggling with explaining secrets of his race to an outsider. “Bilbo broke our marriage when he left, removing his marriage bead and ring, rejecting me. I suffered as I deserved from his rejection, isolated and alone. And I endured the gossip and lies that led me to be ostracised and my character assassinated. It was an eloquent way for Mahal to repay me for my crimes. And all the time, I could not work out how to even apologise. Every encounter with Bilbo just angered him.”

 

“I had to close my heart to save myself, Forti,” Bilbo sighed. “It was only when I got close to losing him that I understood what was happening-and it took a lot of introspection and some scolding by the others to get me to re-evaluate what i was doing.”

 

“I had given up and was awaiting my end,” Thorin continued. “Except that some enemies came to kill both me and Bilbo. And the Company arrived just in time to save us…but I was injured. I was just content that Bilbo was safe.”

 

“I wanted him back desperately and accepted him back,” Bilbo admitted. “It’s been a long road getting him back to health.”

 

“Yet in our reckoning, you are no longer married,” the Thain reminded him. “I would recommend getting that regularised in the near future.” Then he looked at the pair. “Unless you are returning to Erebor…” Bilbo looked up and nodded.

 

“I think…the Kingdom will be relieved to have you back,” he said, glancing at the King. “And the Shire will be relieved to have no resident dwarves.”

 

“Young Mistress Mimosa Grainfellow has relocated to Bree after having to renounce her allegations that Lulkhel was engaged to her,” Fortinbras revealed. “And Gardenia Proudfoot has been told that she will be ostracised from the entire Proudfoot clan if she persists with her persecution of Lulkhel. But there is definite disquiet at having so many dwarves suddenly living in Hobbiton…” Bilbo looked outraged.

 

“Surely you can’t be serious and condone…” he began but the Thain sighed and shook his head.

 

“Our people dislike change and are wary of outsiders,” he reminded his cousin. “And while you and your friends are always welcome in the Shire, sometimes, it is better for people to be back where they belong…” Thorin lifted his chin and nodded.

 

“Of course,” he said evenly. “My people would never outstay their welcome…” But Bilbo was almost vibrating with anger.

 

“You know that when they lost the mountain, Thorin’s people were driven across Middle Earth, always ostracised and run out of towns and villages. You could at least try to make it sound like you would prefer we all left!” His voice had risen and Thorin quietly rested his large hand on Bilbo’s.

 

“I understand his meaning,” he reassured his husband. “He is correct: we should return. And if it keeps the peace with his people, I take no offence.” But there was a shadow in his eyes that had Bilbo promising silently that he would need another talk with his husband. The Thain, however, seemed satisfied.

 

“And are you planning to return there?” he checked. Bilbo nodded. 

 

“Balin has been planning it for the last couple of weeks, securing supplies and planning when we can leave. We can’t delay too long if we are to return to Erebor before the snows arrive…” he explained. “It will be good to go back, to be honest. I’m not sure I fit the Shire any more…” Fortinbras shook his head.

 

“Your home is always here-and I will resist all attempts to steal it from you,” he promised. Then he reached for another biscuit. “Now I have some family gossip to fill you in on…”

 

-o0o-

 

Things seemed to move in a blur after that. The weather remained good and Bilbo pottered in his garden, recalling his mother’s devotion and determined not to neglect it, even though his heart was turning back to Erebor once more. Thorin remained a constant, seeming desperate to spend time with his Hobbit and willingly assisting with unskilled jobs in the garden, though Bilbo knew his interest and abilities in the pastime were both limited. The Company trained and prepared with a good heart and better humour, making all meals raucous, hilarious homely affairs that made Bilbo smile for all the appalling manners on display. 

 

Bilbo had started to pack, looking round the smial and deciding to take some things that he wanted to have with him, for he had not returned to Bag End at all since he ran out on the Quest. This time, he was determined to take some books, maps, more proper Hobbit clothes, some good quality wine, a few decent mathoms, a whole barrel of decent Old Toby pipeweed… Yes, when he returned, he would have enough Hobbitish things to keep him going if he never returned to the Shire. He had offered to buy his own additional pack horse but Balin had explained, looking around the sheepish faces of the Company, that everyone had been shopping and that the Company as a whole would be bringing half a dozen pack horses for all the extra luggage they would be returning with. And, of course, Bombur’s family and their cart of belongings would be accompanying the group. 

 

Rumours started, that the dwarves would finally be leaving the Shire and there was a general sense of relief among the Hobbits-at least some of them. In the Green Dragon, old Tolman Youngwhistle, the landlord, was bemoaning his profits when his dwarvish customers left, for the dwarves were good drinkers and always blended in the local drinkers with good cheer and excellent humour. Most of the traders in Bywater Market likewise were sad to see the dwarves going and a group made their way to Bag End to say farewell in person to ‘Master Lulkhel’ and wish him a safe journey. Thorin had been honestly touched by the kindness and had acted as an imperfect but genuine host-assisted by Bilbo-so they left filled with tea, scones and cakes and determined to ensure that the dwarves’ reputations were talked up and they were remembered kindly and generously for all they had contributed.

 

There was sadness as well for Bilbo found himself having to reassure a number of his cousins and neighbours that they would not be forgotten and that he would return one day. His younger Took cousins were especially upset, for they had determinedly kept him company after his return and had grown close to their adventurous and kind cousin. Hamfast and Belle were very saddened as well and Bilbo had baked up a storm for them, showing his affections and gratitude for all they had done in true Hobbitish fashion. Hamfast had promised to look after Bilbo’s garden as if it was his own and especially his prize-winning tomatoes. Thorin had picked up the cues from his husband and had presented Hamfast with a whole new set of gardening tools and Belle with new pots and pans for her kitchen, which the couple had been honestly touched at receiving. 

 

Forelithe was almost spent and the Midsummer celebrations were close when the Company had finished their preparations and were ready to depart. Their goodbye feast had been an especially memorable affair reminiscent of the Unexpected Party over six years earlier, eating out Bilbo’s pantry and drinking deeply of his cellar. Cousins, friends and family were all invited and when the Hobbit had rolled into bed beside his husband, he had been tired, happy and every-so-slightly drunk. He had mumbled a goodnight and curled against Thorin before he dropped asleep.

 

He woke alone, eyes snapping open and hand patting the empty and cold space where the solid warm shape of his husband should be. Guessing that Thorin may just have stepped out for a glass of water, Bilbo waited, wanting to snuggle up to him again, for all it was a warm night, but after a few minutes there was no sign and Bilbo, slightly cross, found himself awake in the bluish moonlight spilling between the curtains. With an exasperated sigh, he sat up and padded to the door, listening for any sounds of movement-but all he heard were the cacophony of snores that marked the presence of the Company. So he pushed the door open and padded silently through his home, his eyes straying to the gaps where things he had packed were missing. The place still seemed homely, even though he was about to leave because it was his home: he just had a better, truer home to go to with his dwarves back in Erebor. But Bag End would always be waiting for him.

 

After a few minutes, he was staring to feel worried, for he couldn’t locate Thorin. He was nowhere in the smial and peering through the window into he garden failed to reveal any hide nor hair of the dwarf King. Finally, he walked to the front door and found it unlatched, so he pulled on his dressing gown and emerged into his front garden, his eyes sweeping over the moonlit space and finding a shape sitting slumped on the bench. Bilbo paused, for Thorin was bowed forward, his hands clasped and hair covering his face. His entire posture looked completely defeated and Bilbo wondered what was wrong. Quietly and very cautiously, he walked down the steps towards his husband.

 

“Thorin?” he asked softly. “Are you alright?”

 

The dwarf didn’t move and Bilbo’s sense of foreboding worsened. He rested a hand on his heart and concentrated but didn’t feel anything coming over his Heart-Bond-not always a reliable indicator but he had analysed their previous interactions and had realised that he had felt various unpleasant sensations when Thorin was unwell. 

 

“Thorin?” he repeated. Finally the dwarf looked up and Bilbo recoiled, shocked at the expression on the King’s face. He had seen Thorin regal, proud, angry, bitter, resigned, jealous, paranoid, hurt, happy, affectionate, determined, shocked, distraught, relaxed, peaceful and triumphant but never ever as utterly defeated as he saw him now. He looked as if he hadn’t slept at all, the shadows under his eyes like deep bruises and his eyes looked as desperate as they had when the couple were sundered and he was experiencing Rejection. Anxiety settled on him. “What’s wrong?”

 

The King took a shuddering breath and Bilbo realised with terrible foreboding that the King had been weeping silently. He scurried forward and knelt before Thorin, taking his hands and staring into the familiar proud face. 

 

“I…can’t…” Thorin murmured thickly. Bilbo sighed, almost feeling impatience but reminded himself that this was Thorin Oakenshield, a dwarf who had lived his life apart from his people because that was expected and who had really never learned to confide in anyone because that was how he had been brought up. He had been trying really hard because Bilbo had insisted, in one of their long and frank talks about what they needed to do in order to move forward and try again in their marriage. Nodding wordlessly, Thorin had promised to try, reminding the Hobbit that if he was slipping, to remind him not only of the talk but of the consequences. The humility and almost desperation had made Bilbo uncomfortable but he had agreed to the terms.

 

“Can’t what, Amrâlimê?” he asked gently, deliberately using the dwarvish term. Thorin had always been very free in his use of dwarvish terms of endearment and secretly Bilbo had loved the attention. He tended to use Shire terms of affection but sometimes, when he used dwarvish terms and gestures, he could see the delight and deep affection in Thorin’s expressive eyes. The dwarf took a shuddering breath and looked up.

 

“I cannot return,” he explained. Bilbo frowned.

 

“Return? You mean to Erebor?” he checked. Thorin nodded, the experienced mask settling on his features in a way that Bilbo hated, for he knew that the King was trying to conceal his true feelings. “But you are the King. You have to return!” Thorin flinched as if he had been struck, turning away slightly and closing his eyes.

 

“Erebor will have a new King, one who is better suited to rule her,” he said evenly.

 

“Fili? He’s only young and has a lot more to learn…”

 

“He has had three years of watching me rule and learning how the Mountain works,” Thorin said. “He will have Dis and Balin to advise him-and the rest of the Company. He has been trained from his youth and he is a fine and decisive leader. He will make a good King.”

 

“But you reclaimed Erebor! That was the point of the Quest…”

 

“And it was a success-thanks in no part to you, Ghivashel,” Thorin told him honestly. “Erebor was reclaimed. My people have their ancestral home once more. The Mountain is rebuilt and repopulated. Life is settled and good for all. I am not needed.”

 

Bilbo felt irritation explode in his throat, trying to remind himself there was something going on that Thorin hadn’t explained. Getting angry wouldn’t persuade Thorin to open up any quicker.

 

“But you are wanted, Thorin,” he said with forced patience. “You are the King. Their hero! So many look up to you, respect you, trust you. Leaving the throne to Fili would weaken Erebor-no slight on him, of course-because he does not command the same respect as Thorin Oakenshield, hero of Azanulbizar, ruler in Ered Luin, King of Erebor, son of Thrain, grandson of Thror. You are the King they want!”

 

“But not the King they need,” Thorin said quietly, his voice deeply shamed. “After you… ‘left’ Erebor, I behaved appallingly. I no longer cared because the Kingdom had cost me the only person I truly cared for. And yes, I know it was my own actions and failings that actually did the damage-Mahal, I know!-but it was the manipulations of my Lords and the gossip of my people against me and my Consort that harmed you and allowed me to react so badly.”

 

Bilbo stared into the familiar face. Thorin was forging ahead with his confession with the expression of one who was walking to his execution. He gave Thorin’s hands a squeeze.

 

“There were rumours and discontent in the Mountain at my performance, that I had gone mad-again-and that I should be removed. Balin and Fili explained that the agents of Sulgan and Prandil were spreading rumours that I was unfit to rule and should be removed from the throne, in favour of Fili. And though I ruled better after I realised what a Lalkhûn I was, I knew I was not giving them my attention and heart-because it belonged to another who was far away.”

 

“Well, I will be back now, Ghivashel,” Bilbo told him. “All will be well.”

 

“No, it won’t,” Thorin sighed and bowed his head. There was a look of utter defeat there.

 

“Thorin?”

 

“If I go back there, I will have to fight it again-every moment of every day,” he said softly. “I will have to resist with all my strength lest I slip and once more lose you by my actions. And I cannot…I cannot risk that.” Bilbo felt his heart shudder in sorrow, starting to understand.

 

“You mean the Dragon Sickness?” he asked. Thorin nodded ashamedly.

 

“My mind is clear here and I am myself once more…but I know when I return, when I reach Esgaroth or at least Dale, the pressure will return, the whispers and the sensations and the desire. Oh, the desire to go to the Treasury and lose myself in that magnificent treasure, to look at the gold and marvel and let the rest of the world fall away, for nothing else matters but the gold. And it will take every ounce of my strength to fight for every second of every day to resist it until the day I die. And if I slip…” He looked up, his eyes filled with a fear that Bilbo had never seen before. “If I slip, I may harm you. I nearly did once, the most shameful and dishonourable action of my life. I still cannot believe that I was forgiven by your for my actions on the ramparts…or that you are willing to consider me your husband once more. But if I go back…I know I will slip one day. And I will lose everything.”

 

“Oh Thorin,” Bilbo said, his heart shuddering with pity. “You should have said.”

 

“How could I?” the King asked softly. “How can I look the coward before you, flinching at the duty to return to my home? I know you have missed your friends in Erebor for so long, that you feel dislocated here and long for the Lonely Mountain. I cannot deny you that. But perhaps, I should stay here and you should go. I can…caretake your Halls and…” His voice trailed off. “And live and die alone where there is a memory of you.”

 

Bilbo’s eyes burned with tears at the words and he launched himself forward, wrapping Thorin in a tight hug. The King wrapped his arms around the Hobbit, his powerful arms holding him close and burying his head in Bilbo’s neck.

 

“You ridiculously over-dramatic dwarf,” Bilbo murmured, his own eyes shimmering with tears. “Why do you have to decide to do things the worst possible way?”

 

“For me, here is no choice,” the King mumbled. “I fell further than I thought was possible. I thought I had conquered it and earned my redemption in the Battle. If I had died on Ravenhill, then my life would have been complete-but I lived and I had to deal with the consequences of my actions, to work at earning redemption for threats of war and broken oaths and attempts to kill my own One. I am a disgrace as a dwarf! And I found that the gold was still talking to me, every minute of every day. And it was easy, when my guard was down, to dwell on the hoard and feel the pull of the treasure, to feel the apathy and madness start to overwhelm me. So I fought a silent battle every moment to remain…me. And I didn’t always succeed but I always had to fight. And I realised that I had won Erebor but my penance, my sentence from the Gods was that it was not for me. I found my people their home but sacrificed my right to live there.”

 

“But you have me there,” Bilbo murmured.

 

“Amrâlimê, my greatest fear is that I will hurt you if I fall,” Thorin said and then he seemed to shrink into himself. “When I fall. I have proven I cannot resist. I have proven I am as weak as my father and grandfather. Please don’t make me go back. Please don’t make me fear every day for what I could do to you.”

 

“Thorin, you’re not dangerous,” Bilbo tried to explain, pulling back and little to look into the King’s face. “In Erebor, you trusted me above all others and only turned on me when I stole the Arkenstone and was stupid enough to return and try to explain my reasoning to a mentally-ill dwarf. You were absolutely not in your right mind and that you can be so afraid of returning tells me that you are thinking absolutely clearly now.”

 

“But I won’t be if I return,” Thorin said in a defeated voice. The Hobbit pulled back and sat next to him on the bench, his hand wound with the King’s. Thorin absently raised his hand and kissed Bilbo’s knuckles. “I cannot ask you to give up your dream of returning, of being with your friends once more. I will stay here and you go home.”

 

Bilbo stared at him.

 

“Thorin-what would the distance do to you after all that Rejection experience?” he asked carefully. “I know you suffered with the distance between us after I left.”

 

“It is unknown,” the King said softly. “No one has ever survived such a long and severe period of Rejection.” He stared at the ground and scuffed it with his boots. 

 

“But…” Bilbo prompted him, feeling him trembling through their grasp.

 

“Oin warned me that I am likely to be more vulnerable to the adverse effects of the Bond,” Thorin admitted with reluctance. “Separation may be more problematic.”

 

“No more trips away without me then,” Bilbo murmured and then looked at his dwarf, seeing the shame in his eyes. “Oh…”

 

“I will not take Erebor from you,” Thorin said quietly. “But I cannot return. You have earned your place with them, Bilbo. There would be no mountain without you. My pride and stupidity, my rashness and weakness would have led us to failure many times over. If anyone deserves their place in the Mountain, it’s you.” 

 

“But it is your home, your Kingdom,” Bilbo said, the sense of foreboding finally tightening around his stomach. 

 

“I reclaimed Erebor…but not, it seems, for me,” the King said with infinite sadness. “My own weakness has earned me the anger of Mahal and my penance is the Price the Gods decree. I will not return to my home and I will spend my remaining days in the Shire.”

 

Bilbo stared at him and almost wanted to shout at him. It was clear that Thorin had been struggling with this for days and weeks, wracked by misery and impossible choices that would harm one of them, no matter which way they chose. And the King had decided that he could not ruin this husband’s dreams of returning to Erebor, no matter how much the cost was for Thorin. And it seemed, the cost Thorin had decided he had to pay was exile and a lonely death.

 

But did he truly understand the depths of Thorin’s despair and sacrifice? Over the years, Thorin had confided that he had dreamed of returning home to the Lonely Mountain for the entire one hundred and seventy years of the occupation by the dragon. Not one day had passed without him feeling the longing to stand once more in the Halls of his people, surrounded by the stone of Erebor. Yet Erebor was tainted for Thorin by the legacy of the dragon, with the madness to which his line was exquisitely susceptible and which had turned the noble and proud King into a monster. Reclaiming his home had transformed from his dream to his worst nightmare and his actions-dishonourable, violent, paranoid-haunted his nightmares ever since. The aftermath still cast a long shadow in his relationships with his friends, his family and the Company…but especially with his husband. Thorin had been fighting a silent, secret battle for three years until he had lost spectacularly and lost the thing he cared for most. Was it any surprise that he did not want to risk another slip? That he did not want to lose his mind once more and risk committing some heinous crime that would end it for him, losing his honour, his love and his life?

 

But what Thorin implied was grave. He could not even approach Erebor for fear of falling once more-and if he refused the journey, Bilbo’s absence would probably end his life, finishing off the Fading that he had endured for far too long. Maybe he could travel to the East but remain beyond the reach of the cursed gold…but where would that be? The ruins of Laketown, itself a testament to the consequences of the Quest and reminder of Thorin’s dishonour in reneging on his word to the displaced people? In Mirkwood with Thranduil who would torment his guest constantly with reminders of his failure and weakness? In a hut in the wilds, staring in the direction of his husband who lived in luxury in Erebor? He could not go to the Iron Hills, for that would raise too many questions and some there would not welcome his presence. And otherwise…everywhere else was too far.

 

So what was Bilbo to do? If he left without Thorin, the dwarf would probably die alone in the Shire. If he travelled and left Thorin along the way, how would the King cope, alone in the wilds, waiting for his husband who was living in peace and luxury in the Mountain.

 

But the other alternative was…not to go. Never to return to Erebor, never to walk through the mountain, browse the amazing markets, stop to chat with the shopkeepers, spend time cooking with Bombur in the kitchens. Never to return to the Library and continue his researches into ancient dwarvish history and see if he could find any mention of his own people in other races’ records. Never to sit chatting with Ori about his latest knitting. Never to practice again with Dwalin. Never to wake again with the boys burrowing into the bed. Never to spend time with Dis discussing family…

 

He looked over at Thorin, who looked sunken in despair. His hand was still trembling and he looked almost broken. The King had made his choice, choosing to give up his life to allow Bilbo to do what his heart most desired and return to Erebor, leaving his husband behind to his fate. He had not even told Bilbo because he wanted his husband to have the choice to do what he wanted, when he had seemed so excited at the prospect of finally travelling again. If Bilbo insisted, Thorin may travel-but he would be condemning his husband to utter misery and fear, fear that he would slip once more, fear that he would fail his people and fear that he would harm his home and his husband.

 

Bilbo couldn't do that.

 

Thorin had given up almost everything for his people and had been willing to sacrifice his life-had almost sacrificed his life-to save the Mountain. He had asked for only one thing: his choice of husband and had faced down every opposing voice to proceed with his marriage. The loss of his husband had clearly hit Thorin hard if the reports Dwalin, Balin, Dis and Fili were correct and his appalling behaviour had spoken of a broken heart. Moving to the Shire had been his only option and he had suffered there, fading and behaving with ridiculous determination not to reconcile if it compromised Bilbo’s freedom. Bilbo’s own stubbornness hadn’t helped and it had only been crises that had brought them together. And now, reconciled and finally looking content with his lot, he was willing to throw it all away to allow his husband his desires.

 

But a marriage was a partnership, a dance of give and take. And Bilbo had seen his friends, spent time with them staying at his home for many happy weeks. And maybe the entire Company was not there but it was very close. And out of Bilbo’s desires, Thorin was at the top of the list and his safety and happiness were Bilbo’s primary concerns. He could not force Thorin to return and live in fear for the rest of his days. For Thorin to admit to fear must mean the agony he was facing at the choice was…intolerable. He had friends in the Shire, he had a comfortable home and plenty to occupy him. And he could still travel, with his husband, to visit new places. Maybe not Erebor but he had options. And crucially, his husband was still at his side. 

 

He stretched up and pressed a kiss on Thorin’s cheek, feeling the bristle of his beard under his lips and catching the salty edge of tears. How bitter and desolate must his husband have felt to weep? Thorin had endured the worst of times and he had faced them with stoicism and courage. He must have truly believed that this was the end and that he would finally and irrevocably lose his husband.

 

But he had finally told Bilbo, trusting his Hobbit with the simple truth and fearing the response.

 

“You silly dwarf,” he said softly. “Did you believe that I would leave you?”

 

“I cost you Erebor when I banished you,” Thorin managed gruffly. “I could not ask you to give her up forever.”

 

“You never needed to ask,” Bilbo said, feeling the disappointment evaporate even as he spoke the words. “I choose you the moment I agreed to marry you. I opened my heart to you. If I lose you, I would not last, I think. Erebor is a place where our friends and family live, but they can visit. Your health and safety and happiness is everything to me, Thorin. I would never ask you to return if you did not want to and I could never leave you. You are exasperating and idiotic if you thought I would ever leave you and make any choice other than you.” He turned Thorin’s face to look at him, staring into the shocked eyes. “I love you. I’m not sure you understand exactly what that means.”

 

Thorin laid his hand on Bilbo’s cheek and leaned in for a soft kiss. 

 

“My Sanâzyung,” he whispered. “I…have no words for your actions. I am not worthy of you…” Bilbo gave a small smile.

 

“Mahal made you for me as Yavanna made me for you,” he reminded the dwarf. “So now we have to decide what we do about this.”

 

Thorin nuzzled his hair.

 

“What do you suggest?” he asked gruffly.

 

“Get dressed,” Bilbo said. It was still dark but the short summer night was coming towards its end and the eastern sky was already warming a faint yellow with the approaching dawn. “I think that neither of us will sleep again tonight. So we can get up, I’ll make some tea and a light First Breakfast and then, before the others stir, we need to head for Tuckborough. I need to speak to my cousin.”

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Lalkhûn -idiot
Lulkhel- idiot of all idiots
Sanâzyung - perfect (true) love
Amrâlimê - my love
Ghivashel - treasure of all treasures

Chapter 16: New Beginnings

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

SIXTEEN: New Beginnings.

 

The Company woke to find a plate of freshly baked scones, two loaves ready for the oven and some biscuits marked ‘for Dwalin’. And a note that explained that Bilbo and Thorin had needed to run an errand and that they would explain when they returned.

 

There was a certain amount of grumbling, for the dwarves were ready to be on the road. Secretly, all looked forward to returning to their homes in Erebor, to the comforting feel of stone around them and the security of being among their own kind. The welcome had not been as warm as Bilbo had shown them and a few were disappointed with how some of the Hobbits had behaved, though they acknowledged that many-Bilbo’s neighbours and friends and some cousins included-had been very welcoming. And Ori and Balin had reminded them that the welcome a group of Hobbits visiting Erebor could expect would be less warm and far more suspicious than anything they had experienced.

 

It was midmorning before the pair returned, walking up the Hill hand in hand and chatting quietly. To Dwalin’s eye, Thorin looked more relaxed and though tired, some of the tension had eased from his friend’s shoulders. It was as if a terrible weight had been lifted from him and as he completed the thought, he guessed what they were going to tell the Company. But he filed into the Parlour with everyone else and found a corner to lean against, folding his arms across his chest. Immediately, his betrothed leaned at his side, looking worried.

 

“You know something,” Ori murmured, his eyes concerned. Dwalin cursed that his One was so perceptive, a smart and observant dwarf underestimated by almost everyone. The warrior raised a bushy eyebrow. 

 

“I ain’t heard nothing for definite,” he murmured back. “But Thorin looks much more relaxed.”

 

“He’s relieved to be finally heading home?” Ori guessed and then frowned. “There’s more than that…” Bilbo stood in the doorway, with Thorin at his side and looked over the assembled Company. He knew that this would be the last time that they would all be together, for it was highly unlikely that all could be spared from their duties once more just to visit their friends so he looked across the room, fixing the image in his memory. 

 

“Thorin and I have been to see the Thain, Fortinbras Took, this morning,” he began. “I-we-realised there was something incredibly important that we had forgotten in our haste to pack up.” He scanned the room. “In the eyes of the Shire, I am no longer married and as a Hobbit, that isn’t really an acceptable state of affairs.”

 

“In six days, Bilbo and I will be getting married by the Party Tree,” Thorin announced. “And we would wish you all to be there.” He looked over the group, dwarrow he had known for decades and who were the only ones with the courage, loyalty and honour to follow him on the Quest. “I know it is a great imposition but I wish to ask if you would delay your journey home for a week to celebrate with us. I promise that it is the last thing I will ask of you, my friends.”

 

“What’s the hurry?” Nori asked, sighing. He had been receiving a steady stream of Ravens and knew that there was plenty for him to be looking into once he returned to the Lonely Mountain. 

 

“He’s not coming back,” Dwalin said evenly, staring directly at his friend and Shield-Brother. “That’s it, isn’t it?”

 

Thorin nodded, his head held high.

 

“I cannot return to Erebor,” he said honestly. “It has only been since I was here in the Shire that I recognised how impaired I was by the Dragon Sickness. How hard I had to fight, every single moment, just to function as I did. And it was easier when Bilbo was at my side but it was still painfully wearing and if I even slipped a little…” He stopped and his eyes were pained. “I became that creature who would have attacked homeless Men, women and children and spent my friends’ lives in a futile war over a cursed hoard. The monster who would have thrown his One to his death without a second thought.”

 

“But you are long over the Dragon Sickness,” Dori pointed out. 

 

“I never fully recovered,” Thorin told him honestly. “I concealed it from everyone. I only revealed it to Dwalin, Balin and Dis after Bilbo was banished. In my right mind, I would not have reacted so…but I was weak. And I do not have the courage to fight any longer.” Then he turned and looked at the oldest dwarf there, his eyes filling with determination. “Balin, I need you to draw up the Orders of Abdication.”

 

There was an absolute uproar as everyone was on his feet, protesting and shocked. Fili and Kili rushed the King, shouting at him urgently while the rest of the Company crowded round as well. Only Dwalin hung back, his eyes knowing and resigned, looking up to meet Bilbo’s regretful expression.

 

Finally they calmed down, for Thorin was unable to answer any questions while they were all shouting at him and protesting. The King looked calmer and more self-assured than he had any time since the beginning of the Quest, his eyes warm and filled with hope once more. He still carried himself regally-Bilbo believed that would never stop-but the tension in his shoulders was missing. Thorin rested his hands on Fili’s shoulders’ looking into his nephew’s eyes, his face apologetic.

 

“I am sorry, Fili, that I could not put this off for longer but I have not been the King that Erebor deserves for some time,” he said, his deep voice honest. “I know that you will be a great King, the fresh start that Erebor deserves, not tainted by the shadows or failures of the past. You never knew Thror, you did not suffer from the Dragon Sickness-merely normal gold lust-and you were brought up away from Erebor You can see the Kingdom with new eyes. Allow your Advisers to advise-but the final choice is always yours. Put your people before your own personal needs but never let them dictate matters of your heart. And find your One. The risk is always worth the reward.”

 

The Crown Prince stared up-then flung a warm hug around his Uncle.

 

“Irak’Adad,” he murmured. “I will miss you.”

 

“You have Kili and Tauriel,” Thorin reminded him with a slight grimace. “Both of them will advise you well. Your mother and Balin and Ori will be thoughtful and wise supporters. Dwalin is the best General a King could wish for. Gloin will keep a tight rein on the Kingdom’s finances. And only appoint to your Council those whose loyalties you can be certain of. They need not always agree with you-in fact, you should appoint those whose opinions you don’t always align with but who you respect to be honest and in the service of the people-all of the people, not just their own interests.”

 

“I understand,” Fili said as the King turned to his younger nephew.

 

“Kili-I cannot say how proud I am of the dwarf you have become,” he said honestly. “Loyalty, honour, a willing heart-you exemplify all of them. And while I may not have chosen your One, you have been adamant in her defence and a One can ask no more. She was made for you and she completes you. Never let her go. Always fight for your heart.” He glanced up at the Elf, her eyes wide with surprise at his words. “And look after him. He is impetuous, rash and headstrong…but he is most dear to his mother’s heart and mine. I know you will protect him against himself and allow him to still be Kili. And I think your presence will make our Kingdom a better place.”

 

She felt her throat thicken then and wondered how life would have been different if Kili had fallen that day on Ravenhill. She bowed her head.

 

“Thank you, Sire,” she said. 

 

“You’re talking as if we’re about to run off and leave you,” Bofur piped up, inspecting the tall shape. “There’s a wedding in the offing and if this is to be our goodbye to you, then I at least will remain to see my friend Bilbo settled once more.”

 

“Anyone who needs to leave today can go-I bear no on any ill will because you have travelled halfway across the world to be with Bilbo and I when we needed you the most,” Thorin said. But every dwarf rose to his feet. Balin looked around and then gave that small avuncular smile he had perfected.

 

“Laddie-you think a single dwarf here is missing your happy day, you have misread this Company,” he chuckled. “Any party will have this lot fighting to be first at the ale barrel! So I think we need to unpack the ponies, refill your pantry and decide what we need to do to make this wedding of yours happen in six days.” Bilbo smiled and nodded. feeling a surge of warmth in his chest.

 

“I will need help from Bombur and anyone else who can assist in the kitchen preparing the sweetmeats and the cake and I’ll need Balin and Ori to make lists of things we need to secure from the markets for the big day. Dori-I trust your taste in decorations. Belle and Hamfast and Tauriel will be able to help your with the flowers and which ones should be used for the crowns…”

 

“Flowers for crowns?” the tailor asked with a frown. 

 

“Oh yes,” Bilbo grinned. “In the Shire, flowers have meaning. And crowns are only of flowers, not cold metal and stones…” There were a room full of cynical looks, save for Bilbo, Tauriel and Thorin, who was smiling.

 

“So the last Crown I wear will be of weeds, not gold,” he said with resignation. “A fair bargain, I believe, given my personal history and crimes.”

 

But as the Company scattered to attend their various jobs and unpack the ponies, Dwalin pulled the King aside and they retreated into the spare room that had been Thorin’s sick room.

 

“When were you going to tell me?” the warrior asked gruffly. Thorin sighed.

 

“I only told Bilbo last night,” he confessed slowly. “I have known ever since I recovered, ever since the decision was made to return to Erebor that I could not go. But how could I ask that of Bilbo? All he has spoken of has been returning, of the Library and the Market and of being among our people. But returning…would mean resuming a fight I can only lose and which will only lose me everything. I will be destroyed by it and in the process, I will damage Erebor and may harm Bilbo.” The warrior looked at his friend and read the shame in his voice.

 

“You wouldn’t,” he said solidly, though he recalled the shape sitting on the throne while the Battle raged outside of the barricaded Erebor. He recalled the soft voice, talking to barricading themselves in the deepest levels with the treasure and of the waste of dwarrow lives as necessary for such a treasure.

 

A treasure like this is worth all the blood that can be spilled to protect it…

 

The shape bearing the face and voice of his closest friend, of his Shield-Brother, the dwarf he trusted most in the world…but which seemed to have the soul of a dragon with no care for any honour or decency, only the gold. He blinked, recalling his own words.

 

You sit here wearing a Crown…and yet you are lesser now than you have ever been…

 

You were always my King.

 

“I understand,” he found himself saying, feeling a jolt of pity and a flicker of pride and admiration for his friend. Part of him felt that his friend was dodging the fight, choosing the coward’s way out…but the longer he thought on it, the more he realised how hard it was for Thorin to admit that he could not return home, could not win his fight against the constant siren call of the gold and that one day, he would fall again. And the only hope he had, the only thing that was best for his people and those he loved was to renounce the home he had dreamed of retaking and the throne that was his by right. How much courage did it take to admit a weakness when the King was never weak? “Takes a lot more courage than they realise to say that you cannot do it and that Erebor would be better without you.”

 

“I am going to miss you,” Thorin murmured, hugging the warrior tightly.

 

“You’ll get fat and lazy without me,” Dwalin told him. “Where will I get a practice partner as good as you? There isn’t a swordsman that side of the Misty Mountains your equal.” He gave Thorin a flat look. “And if you mention that pointy-eared, leaf-eating, tree-shagging, elk bothering…”

 

“I wasn’t about to mention the Elvenking,” Thorin smirked. “Though the standard of insults has dropped since I left Erebor.”

 

“Fili and Dis don’t even insult him properly when talking about the Elves,” Dwalin sighed. “I had hoped you would stand by me for my wedding. Doesn’t seem right if you are not there…” Thorin chuckled.

 

“I know,” he murmured. “I mean, what do you need for a wedding? Beads, gifts and those you care for…” The warrior’s brow furrowed for a moment, then cleared.

 

“Six days…and Bilbo said he has some gold and silver from that troll hoard we found…” he mused.

 

“Apparently he and Bofur dug up the ‘long term deposit’ Nori, Gloin and Bofur buried the first time we were there,” the King admitted. “Along with another few chests worth and a pile of ancient weapons that he has down in the root cellar. You are welcome to whatever you need…” Dwalin winked.

 

“I think I need a word with my Betrothed,” he said and clapped Thorin hard on the shoulder. “You don’t mind if we…?” The King smiled.

 

“I think nothing would make Bilbo happier…” he said.

 

-o0o-

 

 

There had been mixed responses to the news that the Company would be remaining in the Shire for a week more. Overwhelmingly, there were good wishes at the impending nuptials and excitement at the prospect of an extra party on the Eve of Lithe. Many of his relatives immediately sent their confirmation at the invitations that went out that afternoon, delivered by a hoard of faunts who had taken to Bofur during his stay and had listened to his tales with wide eyes and open mouths. Bilbo and Ori had written them once the Hobbit had gone through his list of food with Bombur and Balin and after Tauriel had gone round with Bilbo and Thorin to Hamfast to explain the change of plans. Fortinbras had already given his confirmation since he would marry the couple but the whole Took clan had promised to attend. Many of the Baggins relatives had declined, with Lobelia and Otho Sackville-Baggins sending the invitation back with a message scratched on the back that had Bilbo tossing it into the fire with a short bout of muttering about ‘hypocritical orc-like relations’. But Drogo, Dudo and Dora and their families had accepted and old Aunt Belba as well, adding a note that she was looking forward to meeting Thorin. 

 

Dori, Nori, Bifur and Bofur set to work on the decorations, making sure the bunting and banners strongly featured the Durin Blue colours of Thorin’s line, along with the green of the Shire. Crowns and oak leaves featured widely, along with axes and quills for Dwalin and Ori, who had approached Bilbo about being wed at the same time. Bombur had baked an enormous cake with three layers and tables full of cakes, pastries and pies, assisted by Bilbo. There were salads and quiches and bread rolls by the score. Plates of fruit were also prepared along with meat pate and hardboiled eggs. And there would be a couple of hog roasts for good measure to ensure no one went hungry. And the dwarves offered to provide music with each playing his instrument. 

 

Thorin stared at his reflection in the mirror, the tunic, breeches and shirt sewn by Dori were magnificent in deep Durin blue and embroidered with silver around the cuffs and collar showing the signs of the Line of Durin, oak trees and swords. Bilbo wore very Hobbitish dress with a matching deep blue coat, gold waistcoat and cream shirt and deep grey cut off pants. By mutual agreement, they had handed each other their marriage bead to put into each other’s hair and then the Hobbit looked up at his husband’s eyes.

 

“Are you sure, my handsome husband?” he asked cheerfully. Thorin nodded.

“I am a little concerned about the Crown,” he admitted. “From the moment I put on the Raven Crown… I was the worst King ever…”

 

“I am sure that somewhere in the east, there must have been a madder and much less effective King,” the Hobbit told him plainly. “I think I read about one in the Orocani…King Madrigal…I believe he made a lump of coal his Lord Chancellor…”

 

“Fortunately, I had Balin,” Thorin replied and gave a small smile then turned his head to look at the item on the dressing table. “But I have no idea how to wear one…” Bilbo inspected the Crown which Belle had made, reading the sentiments he and Thorin had agreed when they agreed the composition. Myrtle for good luck and love in a marriage, ivy for affection, friendship and fidelity and oak for strength formed the base with red roses for love and purple heliotropes for devotion woven into the base. Motioning the King to perch on the edge of the bed, Bilbo gently brushed a strand of hair off his face and then reverently perched the crown on his head, adjusting it to make sure it was level. There was an identical crown for Bilbo in his room to put on once Thorin and Dwalin had headed down. 

 

“You look splendid,” the Hobbit said. Thorin looked deep into his eyes, his expression solemn.

 

“When Balin placed the Raven Crown on my brow following the reclamation, it did not mean as much as this construction of leaves and flowers,” he said gravely. “For this is a sign of my wedding to the one I love and the life I have earned with him.” Throat curiously thick, Bilbo swallowed and gently brushed the errant strand of black hair off Thorin’s face.

 

“Have you got everything?” His voice wavered and Bilbo hoped the dwarf hadn’t noticed. Nodding very cautiously, the King patted the little pouch on his belt and then turned for the door.

 

“I am ready,” he said in his deep voice.

 

“You sound as if you’re about to face an orc horde,” the Hobbit noted. “It’s just my friends and family-and yours…” Thorin sighed.

 

“That’s what I’m worried about,” he said, adjusting Orcrist on his hip. The Thain had been scandalised but Bilbo had reassured him that a dwarf would never consider marrying an unarmed dwarf-for how was he to protect his new spouse? Shaking his head, Bilbo chuckled.

 

“You and Dwalin need to go first so I can finish getting Ori ready,” he pointed out as Thorin made for the door, pausing to look back.

 

“Don’t be late, Amrâlimê,” the King said softly. “My heart already misses you.”

 

“Well, we’re also missing you and you two are late,” Kili said, sticking his head round the door. “Balin is having kittens which is a really strange concept. I need to get back to Erebor before I pick up any more of these Shire sayings…”

 

“Ridiculous sappy dwarf,” Bilbo told him with a smile in his voice. “Off with you. It’s considered bad luck to see your spouse ahead of the wedding…at least if you’re marrying for the first time…” Taking the hint, Thorin allowed himself to be hauled off by his younger nephew and soon the Hobbit heard the door close heavily as the two and Dwalin left for the Party Field. Then he made his way down the smial to the room where Dori was fussing over Ori. The young scribe was looking harried and looked more relieved than Bilbo would have credited when he poked his head round the door.

 

Ori was resplendent in bronze and green coloured tunic with proper brown leather trousers and not a hint of any knitting on him. Bilbo looked at him and winked, handing over a blue handkerchief.

 

“Take this,” he said. Dori frowned.

 

“That won’t match his colour scheme and I really don’t see…” he protested.

 

“Something old-your beads. Something new-the new clothes. Something borrowed-Dwalin’s axe as your weapon. And something blue…” He waved the handkerchief. “To bring you luck…”

 

“A Hobbit tradition?” Dori frowned. Bilbo nodded. 

 

“Never get married without it,” he said. “I checked Dwalin and Thorin before they left. And I’m covered-blue coat, new shirt, my Mum’s cream scarf as a cravat and my old trousers from my last wedding.” Then he walked over to the flower crown. “Ori-you look wonderful. Dwalin will be knocked over. But we are getting late and…”

 

“He must look perfect,” Dori said, undoing and redoing one of the scribe’s braids. “I will not have anyone saying he looks poor or scruffy because of our family…” Bilbo rested a hand on his arm and sighed.

 

“Breathe, Dori,” he said quietly. “Ori looks amazing and no one here knows anything about your history. They see a richly dressed dwarf marrying another richly dressed dwarf in a crown of ivy, myrtle and yarrow with red gladioli and red roses woven in. The flowers mean integrity, strength, victory and love and the vegetation is for affection, friendship and fidelity, good luck and love in a marriage and everlasting love.” Dori looked at the Hobbit for a long second then hugged Bilbo.

 

“And yours?” he asked. 

 

“Same old, same old-you know: strength, affection, love in marriage, friendship and devotion,” he said and reached for his own crown. “Now is everyone ready?” Ori allowed Dori to fuss and fiddle with his crown and then nodded.

 

“Thank you,” he mouthed as they set out, leaving Bag End and then walking slowly down the Hill towards the Party Tree. It was only a few minutes walk but Bilbo felt his spirits lift. The sky was gin clear, a high cerulean arch and the Shire was an intense green. The bunting and ribbons and banners showing the standard of the House of Durin and Erebor fluttered in the lightest of breezes above a large crowd of Tooks, Brandybucks, Bagginses, Bolgers, Proudfoots and of course, Gamgees mixed with the Company, Bombur’s family and Bofur’s Promised, Milania. Arches wound with ivy and roses marked the beginning and end of the walkway between the banks of seats. Through the far arch, where Balin and Fortinbras stood, side by side, Thorin and Dwalin stood under the shadow of the Party Tree, both peering back at their partners. 

 

Heart soaring, Bilbo watched as Ori walked down the aisle by Dori then made his own way on his own, smiling and nodding at his friends and family. Each found his partner and both the Thain and Balin conducted a joint Dwarvish and Hobbit wedding service for the two couples under the sun of the Shire. Bilbo couldn’t tell you afterwards exact details, only the feeling of rightness as Fortinbras wrapped the cloth around their hands, binding them and Balin made them repeat the sentences in Khuzdul that they had said at his wedding in Erebor to meet the dwarvish traditions as well. Thorin spoke gravely and clearly as he repeated the words and Bilbo hoped his accent wasn’t too embarrassing. Fili stood behind Thorin as Kili stood behind Bilbo as their protectors while Bifur stood behind Dwalin and Nori protected his younger brother’s back as the wedding ceremony continued. Both couples exchanged their own vows in Westron, promising love and devotion and then braided the marriage beads into their partner’s hair. All traditions met, the Thain announced that both couples were married in the eyes of Yavanna and her husband Mahal. 

 

And then cheers rang out and petals were thrown over the newly-wedded couples. Both were mobbed by well-wishers and Bilbo clung to Thorin’s hand as he glanced up. The King was looking utterly happy, his eyes only for his husband, though he took a moment to congratulate and hug his best friend Dwalin and his new spouse. Then there were songs and dancing and food and cake and more food and very much merriment. Fili and Kili seemed to be having a contest over who could offer the most embarrassing stories about Thorin while Fortinbras shared some tales from Bilbo’s childhood, courtesy of his Aunt Mirabella and Aunt Belba. The talk which made the most impression, though, was Balin as he stood, his eyes twinkling with good cheer. 

 

“This is a day I never thought I would see, with my brother finally following his heart and my dear friend and King reuniting with his Hobbit,” he said. His eyes swept the table of dwarves and Hobbits, all pleasantly full and with a mug of something alcoholic in hand. “And though this is not the traditional site for a dwarvish wedding, all you need for a proper wedding is two people who love each other and hopefully, friends and family who wish them well. This Company has stuck together in the worst of conditions, crossing Middle Earth and facing trolls and orcs and wargs, Elves, stone giants, goblins, eagles, skin changers, men, one very large dragon, sickness and war. Loyalty, honour and a willing heart were the only qualification for the Quest and these brave adventurers-thirteen dwarrow and one Hobbit-have forged bonds that have lasted across time and distance and every challenge.”

 

“You forgot one wizard!” a voice boomed and a grey-clad figure shambled across the field, between the tables, his rather crooked pointy hat and staff unmistakeable. Bilbo jumped up.

 

“Gandalf!” he said and ran forward, embracing the wizard. “I sent a raven but it returned, not having found you.” The wizard gave a chuckle, his smile genuine as they made room for him on the top table and Drogo placed a plate of food and a large tankard of ale in front of him.

 

“A wizard is never late or early,” he said, gesturing to his cart that was parked by the edge of the field. “He arrives exactly when he means to. And in honour of your wedding, I have brought some of the fireworks that you recalled so fondly from your childhood.” Bilbo winked, his hand twining with Thorin’s.

 

“I’m glad you’re still in business,” he said. “Now let us bring you up to speed with what has been happening…”

 

Once the food had settled, the band struck up and there was dancing and drinking. Snacks were donated by the guests and everyone found extra little corners for the pastries, cakes, flapjacks, sandwiches, quiches and biscuits and cheese that filled the tables. Bilbo and Thorin danced for an hour, lost in each other’s presence but even they finally needed to sit down.

 

Fili, Kili and Tauriel settled by them, handing over cool non-alcoholic drinks as they caught their breath.

 

“I think it’s going rather well, Uncles,” Fili commented, his gaze sweeping across the field. The others were all enjoying themselves and even the soldiers were having a good time. Gimli was showing off how well he could drink and Bofur was dancing on a table, reprising the song about ‘the Man in the Moon’. 

 

“At least everyone seems to be having a good time and no one is causing a fuss,” the Hobbit commented. “Not a Sackville-Baggins in sight.” Fili chuckled. 

 

“She did corner Kili and Tauriel in the market and gave them a mouthful of abuse for being in the Shire,” he admitted. “Tauriel just towered over her and Kili looked through her. I was very proud of him.” They all sat back and watched as Gandalf let off his fireworks. There were flashes and bangs and explosions of every colour. Gold flowers and green bursts ringed the field and everyone oohed and ached at the spectacle. A red dragon erupted and circled the party field before exploding above Bag End. Cheers filled the field and there was rousing applause and a swarm of faunts almost mobbed the wizard. Thorin caught Bilbo’s hand.

 

“I must make the announcement,” he said gravely and then rose, banging on the table with a tankard.

 

“Friends, family, Shire inhabitants, Gandalf and our gracious hosts,” he announced, his voice dominating proceedings. “I am truly honoured that you have chosen to share our nuptials with us. It has been the proudest day of my life to stand here and declare my vows before you all-especially to stand by my honoured friends Dwalin and Ori as they shared their day with us.” Then he looked up. “Today is also a landmark day. As of midnight, I will abdicate the Throne of Erebor, which will pass to my sister-son, Fili son of Vili. I had to make a decision between my husband and my Kingdom and while almost all of my life has been dedicated to my people, I have reached the point where there is nothing more I can give them that would be of any value. If I returned, I would never be the King they needed or deserved. I have ruled our people for over a century and taken us from a wandering homeless group of refugees to a comfortable home in Ered Luin and finally to reclaiming our Kingdom. It is time they have the King they deserve and need and a new King for a new era is the best and last thing I can do for Durin’s folk.”

 

He looked over the field, at a hundred faces, many of whom he didn’t know but who had wished them all well.

 

“My Company, though, insisted that today was the last day of my rule, for they felt my husband deserved to be married to a King, to be a Prince once more. And so it has come to be. As I renounce my titles, he remains the Consort-Under-the Mountain until Fili takes a spouse. I will remain with my husband in the Shire, but when my friends return home, part of my heart will be with them. I wish them all safe journey, prosperous and long lives and that they may one day return to the Shire. Now I bid you, enjoy the rest of the festivities!”

 

Bilbo snuggled up against him.

 

“It was nice of the Company to do that-not necessary but very kind,” the Hobbit smiled, looking up into his husband’s eyes. Thorin pressed a small kiss to the side of his forehead.

 

“I think they would do more, if they could,” he said, feeling Bilbo squirm round to face him. Thorin was still wearing his flower crown, though Bilbo had lost his while dancing. 

 

“I have all I need here with me,” he said and leaned in for another kiss.

 

-o0o-

 

The next morning, the Company were up relatively early with a lot of sore heads between them. Bilbo had buzzed around, making breakfasts and gallons of strong black coffee to try to revive the hung over dwarrows. But the most surprising event was when Fili stumbled into the kitchen, looking exhausted. The Company had all returned before midnight, for they knew that they had a long journey ahead and the newly married couples had wanted a relatively early night so they had not been together when the Letters of Abdication took effect. But as Fili entered the kitchen, Thorin rose and took two steps towards his nephew, before he dropped to one knee and bowed his head. 

 

“Zabdûn men,” he said in a deep voice, his right hand laid flat over his heart. “I pledge my sword and my honour to you.” The new King stared at the bowed shape of his Uncle, the dwarf who had always been his King since his birth. The others all fell to their knees as well, every head bowed. Even Kili and Tauriel knelt and the new King realised that this was very real, that everything had changed. Lifting his chin, Fili inclined his head in that very ‘Thorin’ gesture. 

 

“Rise, my friends-none of you ever need to bend a knee to me or bow,” he said, then walked to his Uncle. “Irak’Adad-you never need bow to me. Ever. Everything I have-every thing we have as a people-is there because of you.” He hugged his Uncle powerfully. “I am going to miss you terribly.” 

 

“You are going to have to keep Kili in line without me,” Thorin murmured in his ear. “But always remember how to laugh. Hold those you love close. And say sorry to your mother for me.” Fili tightened the hug for a second.

 

“I am certain she will come to see you herself, once we are back,” the new King muttered. “You may wish to hide.”

 

“Or allow my fierce Hobbit husband to protect me,” the former King told him wryly. “After all, I am but a simple blacksmith now…” Dwalin squinted at him.

 

“Yer still the hero of Azanulbizar and King of Erebor who led that charge in the Battle Five Armies,” the warrior told him. “An enemy turns up and you’re leading a suicidal charge in an instant! Simple blacksmith my behind!” Ori chuckled and winked at Bilbo.

 

“If we ever need break, we’re coming back here for the comedy value,” he promised, sitting beside the Hobbit. “And I’ll send you the latest translations from the Library…” Bilbo poured him a cup of tea, watching Thorin talking seriously to his sister-sons and bantering with his Shield Brother. 

 

“He’s going to miss the boys and Dwalin worst of all, I think,” he murmured. “Don’t stay away too long.” Ori gave a small smile.

 

“I’ll be back before you know it,” he promised.

 

But it was with a thick throat and eyes that watered in the slight breeze that he stood by his husband, hugging each of his dwarves in turn. It was almost impossible to let the Princes go and Bilbo felt his heart crack a little at seeing them mount. Balin got a long hug as well, along with promises to write and Bofur gave him a big hug which Thorin stared at then shook his head, wishing Bifur and Bombur a safe journey. And finally, Dwalin gave him a powerful hug.

 

“Look after His Broodiness for me,” he said simply. “He loves you with all his heart but his heart is dwarvish and he will miss his people. You are his everything now: I know you will be enough because you two do love each other. You’re just stubborn and proud. Remember that isn’t more important than your One.”

 

“I have learned that now,” the Hobbit said with a sigh. “But he deserves safety and security and a home. And if he cannot return to the one that he won, then he shall have mine. And I will fight anyone who says he doesn’t have the right to be here.”

 

“There’s the Hobbit from Ravenhill,” the warrior chuckled and looked around, as if fixing the day in his memory. He winked at Ori before he looked back at the Hobbit. “I will be back. Yer biscuits are too good to go without forever.” Then he turned away with a wink and swung up into the saddle. Bilbo stepped back and found Thorin’s arm wrap around his middle.

 

“Safe journey!” the former King called, his eyes sweeping over his Company. “And Fili-if Kili says something is a ‘great idea really, it will be awesome’, don’t do it…” The were laughs that echoed down the road as the Company looked to their leader. Fili raised his hand.

 

“Move out!” he called and both he and Kill gave one last grin to their Uncle, both managing a synchronous bow of the head in farewell then turned away and started down the road. Bilbo felt the dwarf tense against him as they retreated and he found Thorin’s hand and squeezed. But the former King remained motionless until they had rounded the corner and vanished from sight.

 

“You alright?” he murmured, looking up. There was sorrow and resignation in the handsome face but Thorin managed a small smile.

 

“I am where the Gods say I should be,” he said honestly. “I know my father and grandfather would rail at this outcome and see it as a defeat but I do not. Because I won. I won the Kingdom. I regained the home for my people. My family are still alive and safe. And though I have fallen to Dragon Sickness and deserved nothing save the exile I will embrace, I have been blessed in regaining you. And if that is a penance, then I accept it with a glad heart!” Bilbo stared at him, utterly sideswiped by the honest and intense declaration.

 

“You…you just can’t go round saying such things and not expect me to  tell you that you, Thorin Oakenshield, are the most dramatic, romantic and dear dwarf in the whole of Arda…”

 

“Master Bilbo! Master Thorin!” Hamfast’s voice interrupted them and both looked up, their lips an inch from each other. Bilbo blushed. 

 

“Ham,” he mumbled and jerked back, his cheeks on fire.

 

“Master Hamfast,” Thorin rumbled, lifting his head and squaring his shoulders. “How may we help you?” The other Hobbit ambled forward and leaned on his fence, a grin cracking his face.

 

“I’ll wager you’ll be glad for a little quiet time after the kerfuffle of yesterday,” he said amiably. Thorin nodded, his face controlled.

 

“Indeed,” he replied as Bilbo buried his face in Thorin’s chest at the implication. Hamfast chuckled.

 

“Looks like being a warm day,” he added. “I’ll do a round watering the garden for you both later. Won’t do to have those prizewinning tomatoes wilting.”

 

“We are most grateful,” the dwarf said. Ham peered at Bilbo.

 

“He okay?” he asked. Thorin nodded.

 

“I believe he is rather embarrassed at the implication we may spend the time today in more intimate pursuits,” he replied. Ham grinned.

 

“Ah that would be the Hobbitish sense of propriety-and Mister Bilbo is a very proper Hobbit,” he noted.

 

“Or I was until I ran away with a bunch of dwarves and married their King,” Bilbo mumbled. Then he looked up. “And I have no regrets at that.” Thorin gave him an adoring look that had Hamfast clearing his throat.

 

“Aye-my pea plants need a bit o’ attention…right now, I think,” Ham gabbled with a knowing grin. “I’ll pop over later Master Bilbo, Master Thorin, to do that watering…” And he vanished as Thorin leaned in to kiss his husband.

 

“We’ll have to invite them over to dinner to apologise for embarrassing Ham,” Bilbo mumbled when they parted. Thorin chuckled and leaned his forehead gently against his husband’s. 

 

“At least they are unlikely to gossip about our behaviour," he murmured. Bilbo shook his head.

 

“No-the rest of the neighbours will do that for us,” he said in a resigned voice. “If not calling for our arrest for crimes against public decency…”

 

“Truly? We have not even kissed in public…”

 

“But Hobbits don’t kiss in public…except the happy couple at a wedding or if one of you is under ten…” Thorin grinned.

 

“Ah-but I am a dwarf,” he said smugly. “And my people do embrace public affection…”

 

“Oh bother,” Bilbo sighed. “We are going to cause so much gossip…” Thorin stilled and looked at him, his eyes growing serious.

 

“You know that I would never wish to cause any shame or damage to your reputation,” he said honestly. The Hobbit hugged him.

 

“I trust you,” he said with a smile. “And unless we are doing something very naughty very publicly,  I don’t think it will be harmed… So don’t you stop those lovely hugs and handholding and kisses because honestly, what is the point of having a wonderful husband if you can’t touch him?”

 

“Wonderful?” Thorin asked softly.

 

“Well, I did marry you twice,” Bilbo told him with a twinkle in his eye. “In fact, I think it may be time for me to start writing my memoirs…including my account of running off with thirteen dwarves including their very rude and pompous and regal and handsome King…”

 

“…who called you a grocer, if I recall rightly,” Thorin admitted with a wry grin as they turned back to the house.

 

“I admit I was a little annoyed but then, I was mentally calling you ‘a pompous ass’ so I suppose it was fair. Though all that stuff about being incinerated was a little much…”

 

“Standard dwarvish contract…though Balin did tone down the funeral section…” Thorin explained. Bilbo chuckled as they walked up to the entrance of Bag End. He may have lost Erebor but he had regained his husband and if this was where they stayed, as long as they were together, Bilbo would be content.

 

“Life in the Shire is never going to be the same,” he said as the green door closed behind them.

 

 

(And they lived happily together for the rest of their days).

 

The End.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
Zabdûn men - my King
Irak’Adad - Uncle
Amrâlimê - my love

Notes:

A/N: This started out as a one-shot. Whoops. 50k words in and I realised it was getting a little long...not so much a one shot as a thermonuclear explosion...so I've chopped it into more manageable bites. Enjoy!