Chapter Text
“… no. No, no! Don’t- Billy! Bi- Billy!”
Billy violently threw himself out of bed – legs entangling with his sheets in the near pitch blackness of his room – heart thundering double-time as adrenaline flooded his sleep addled system. Cursing wildly as he staggered to a near standstill, Billy reached down and tore at his cheap sheets, finally managing to kick himself out of the clinging fabric. Moving faster than his still sluggish mind could follow, he gracelessly slammed into his closed bedroom door before gathering the wherewithal necessary to realise he needed to open it, hands fumbling for the doorknob. He yanked it towards himself – barely avoiding breaking his own nose against its surface – and dashed out into the hall, urgency, confusion, and lung squeezing fear sending him careening into the opposite wall before he righted himself.
A quick mental scan of the house revealed no intruder – or interdimensional monster of any kind – but then Maxine let out another goddamned awful wail of misery and Billy’s focus was soundly diverted back to getting to her right the fuck now.
He noted only distantly that light was shining out from beneath Neil and Susan’s closed door, and their muffled voices barely registered above the sounds of his own rapid breathing as he sprinted the few steps needed to make it to his sister’s bedroom.
Giving absolutely no thought to knocking, Billy threw open Maxine’s door with enough force to send it banging hard against the wall before its momentum had it swinging back towards him, not that he noticed. Within half a second he’d crossed the room – nearly tripping over his sister’s carelessly discarded school bag – and crouched by Maxine’s bed, one hand fumbling for her bedside lamp while the other hovered uncertainly over her twitching shoulders. She tossed and turned, and the realisation that she was only having a nightmare – not being mauled to death by monsters or killed by a burglar – had an odd mixture of pity and relief rushing through him, as well as a sharp burst of frustration, because of course Maxine had fucking nightmares. Billy hardly ever slept through the night, and while he was used to his own fucked-up brain rebelling against him, his little sister doubtlessly wasn’t.
Calmer now that he knew she wasn’t in any true danger, Billy flicked on her bedside lamp – wincing at the pained twisting of her tear-stained face – and hesitated only for a moment before resting a hand on her closest shoulder and giving her a solid shake. “Maxine, wake up.”
Never one to follow instructions – especially when Billy was the one giving them – his sister jerked her head away from the sudden light blaring at her but didn’t wake, a high-pitched whine escaping from her trembling lips. Rolling his eyes even as an uncomfortable sense of empathy began overwhelming the panic in his chest, Billy gently loosened a thick lock of her long red hair from where it had wrapped around her neck. Nightmares sucked – that was just simple fact – and he understood how tightly they sometimes clawed at you, unwilling to let you escape until they’d had the opportunity to properly traumatise.
Wanting to spare her as much suffering as possible – resigned to the fact that he couldn’t truly protect her from her own subconscious – Billy was about to give her another, more aggressive shake when the sound of heavy footfalls had him instinctively tensing up.
By the time Maxine’s ajar bedroom door was once again roughly shoved aside and his dad’s large bulk darkened the empty frame, Billy was standing – feet shoulder width apart, spine militarily straight, and hands curled into loose fists by his sides – in the centre of the room, placing himself firmly between Neil and his sister without thought or hesitation.
“What the fuck’s going on in here?” Neil all but growled, the last dredges of sleep adding an extra layer of roughness to his already typically low voice. The man was pissed – that much was obvious even without his psychic abilities – and Billy silently cursed Maxine’s goddamned awful timing. Of course, the one night in weeks that Neil went to bed relatively sober was the night that Maxine had a screaming nightmare. Of fucking course. Considering his enduringly shitty luck, Billy honestly didn’t know why he was surprised.
Susan materialised a step behind and to the left of Neil, silent and therefore easily ignored.
“Nothing, sir. Maxine’s just having a bad dream.” Billy explained, speaking through the anxiety tightening his guts into uncomfortable knots and meeting Neil’s disdainful sneer head on. He kept his voice only marginally louder than a whisper and his posture as non-confrontational as he possibly could – because no matter how heart-wrenching it was to continue listening to his little sister’s distraught whimpers, Billy did not want her waking up to see him and Neil having a standoff in the dim light of her bedroom – figuring that if he could placate the man, then maybe just this once he'd lose interest and leave them be. “I was gonna-"
Neil took a threatening step closer, his harsh gaze darting down to Maxine’s tear-stained face before lifting once more to his son, sickly green eyes narrowing into a truly chilling look of visceral loathing. Billy was used to Neil looking at him like he was worth less than the shit on the bottom of his shoes, but this was different, and it sent an uneasy shiver down his spine. The glint in Neil’s eyes wasn’t one that Billy immediately recognised – it was obviously malicious, but also uncharacteristically patient – a fact which immediately sent his mind racing and his instincts going haywire, because he wasn’t used to not knowing when it came to Neil. Surviving his childhood had necessitated that Billy become an expert at reading and adapting to Neil’s often violent moods, which was why this new variation of his dad’s usual contempt was so goddamned harrowing.
How was he supposed to properly brace himself – to anticipate and counter – if he didn’t know what the fuck Neil wanted, or didn’t fully understand why he was so furious? When it came to his dad, ignorance was anything but bliss. Hell, it had the potential to be a fucking death sentence if Billy wasn’t careful.
Swallowing thickly – ignoring the powerful urge to duck his head and back away – Billy tentatively stretched out his sixth sense, barely hiding an anxious wince when a razor sharp feeling of disgust and… nonsensically protective anger pierced into his head.
Using a deceptively blasé tone that had Billy’s heart stuttering nervously, Neil asked, “What’d you do to her, boy?”
“I- what?” Billy snapped incredulously, belated realisation and stomach sinking dread pitching his voice louder and sharper than he meant it to be. He wanted to look back at Maxine to assure himself that she was still alright – still asleep – but didn’t dare to take his eyes off Neil for even a fraction of an instant, not when he seemed to genuinely believe that Billy was the cause for his sister’s current distress. Neil was a piece of shit human being and an even worse father, but he liked to pretend that wasn’t the case when it came to Maxine. He favoured her in ways that once upon a time Billy hadn’t even been able to imagine, just because she was younger, and a girl, and not Daniella’s child. The man actually held some twisted form of affection for her – a fact that used to burn Billy up with seething jealousy before he outgrew his delusional desire for his dad’s approval – and if Neil thought for even a moment that he’d done something to hurt her… The criss-crossing scars across Billy’s back flared with phantom pain, a light sheen of anxious sweat breaking out across his skin as his heart kicked into a higher gear. The situation was rapidly spiralling out of control – whirling inexorably towards violent and dangerous territory – and he needed to reign it in before shit hit the fan, hard. “Nothing! I didn’t-"
“Billy…” Maxine mumbled, sleep weakened voice trembling with sorrowful fright.
Oh, shit.
Neil lunged – Maxine’s quiet whine rendering him completely unwilling to listen to Billy’s denials – and he realised a fraction of a second too late that he was so unbelievably fucked.
He made no attempt to evade or fend off Neil’s first punch – knowing that fighting back would only make things loud – feeling the man’s broad knuckles effortlessly split the vulnerable skin of his lower lip. Billy kept his feet firmly planted beneath him even as his head was whipped to the side, refusing to falter beneath the force of the blow and hardly feeling the pain through the chaos of his rushing thoughts. His number one priority needed to be getting Neil the fuck out of Maxine’s bedroom, preferably while his little sister was still obliviously – if not peacefully – unconscious.
Rousing from whatever horrors plagued her sleep, just to be greeted by the sight of Neil making a mess of Billy’s face? It was a mortifying possibility – not to mention the fact that it would probably scare the shit out of her – and one that Billy wanted to avoid at all costs.
Hopefully Neil would realise – sooner rather than later – that knocking him around when Maxine could wake up any second and witness it was a really fucking bad idea. No doubt the night would still end with fresh bruises painting Billy’s skin, as well as some new – and probably deep – lashes over his back, but so long as the overdue beating happened literally anywhere other than Maxine’s bedroom, Billy would endure it with gritted teeth and well-practiced silence.
Too bad hope didn’t do jack shit, and what he wanted never fucking mattered.
Before Billy had the chance to swallow his pride – right alongside the pooling blood in his mouth – and plead for Neil to just please listen, the man was swinging his thickly muscled arm once again, expression twisting with an ugly mixture of brutal relish and revolted contempt. This time his dad kept his fingers uncurled, slamming the palm of his hand against the side of Billy’s head and shoving. “Outta my way, boy.”
Not even Billy’s most solid footwork could have weathered the sheer brute force of Neil’s violent push, and he was sent staggering into Maxine’s small desk, tripping over her school bag as he went. The rattling thuds of his body colliding with Maxine’s sturdy furniture was fucking loud, and though Billy didn’t see it – eyes squeezed shut and breath heavily laboured as he tried to recover from a sharp desk corner to the liver – he heard his sister gasp awake, and felt her brief but powerful surge of fear-shock-confusion.
Gritting his teeth against the litany of strained curses piling up on his tongue, Billy straightened up out of his pained hunch and did his best to think past the heavy sense of foreboding weighing him down. With his sister awake, Billy honestly had no idea what the hell was going to happen next, and that was a fucking terrifying realisation.
Shame had him avoiding Maxine’s piercing stare – he’d sworn to himself after the clusterfuck in the Byers front yard that she would never again be forced to witness his dad’s mean bullshit play out – leaving him to warily eye Neil, uncertain as to how the man was going to try and spin this.
Neil tucked away his violence with an ease that both disturbed and impressed Billy, smoothing out his cruelly animated expression and easing his posture into something unintimidating, or as unintimidating as a man of his considerable bulk could possibly be. When he spoke his voice was so artificially soft Billy almost wanted to gag, and his reassuring smile was just as fake, if not more so. “Max, you were having a nightmare. Don’t worry, Billy was just leaving.“
When Maxine began to wordlessly kick off her sweat damp blankets – her movements jerky and filled with uncoordinated hostility – Billy made the mistake of finally turning his head to meet her desperately searching gaze. Her pale blue eyes widened at the sight of his bloody lip – which he instinctively lifted a hand to cover up – and her tear stained cheeks were quick to darken from their sickly pallor with an absolutely furious flush of red.
Kicking limbs having fallen still – for now – Maxine shifted her focus briefly towards her mother, who was stillstanding silently in the doorframe, her shadowed silhouette as haunting and useless as a ghost. Bitterly disappointed, his sister aimed a nasty sneer – which she’d undoubtedly learned from Billy – at Susan before fearlessly turning it on Neil. “Get out of my room.” Maxine demanded, voice shaking despite how hard she was obviously trying to force it to be steady and commanding.
Neil nodded easily, reaching out and snagging Billy’s right wrist in a mercilessly bruising grip. “’course he will, Max.” He assured with the subtlest of smirks, completely misunderstanding the red-head’s demand. Tightening his hold even further – forcing Billy to hide a wince of discomfort as the bones in his wrist began to shift threateningly – Neil stared him down with well masked derision, sickly green eyes promising vicious punishment the moment Maxine was out of the way. “Billy, get-"
A wave of overwhelming hatred flooded the room – the emotion so viscerally and familiarly intense that Billy briefly mistook it for his own – and not even half a second later Maxine was shoving herself out of bed with an almost animalistic snarl. She crossed the small amount of space between herself and Neil with impressive speed – sidestepping her schoolbag without faltering for even a moment – and once she was within range she started whaling on the man with all of the strength her skinny arms could muster. “Let him go! Let him go!”
“Max!” Susan cried, her voice weak and easily drowned out by her daughter’s shrill screeching. Still, the woman didn’t move to intervene – didn’t move to protect her fucking flesh-and-blood daughter – fear keeping her rooted in place as she watched the unfolding scene with a shaking hand pressed over her mouth.
Neil stared down at Maxine’s ineffective thrashing – at any other time the slack-jawed, stupefied look on his face would have provoked a smug sense of amusement in Billy, but right now all he could feel was shock-numbed horror – completely unharmed by her nearly feral attempts to hurt him.
“I hate you! Don’t touch him!” Yelling her fury with teeth bared, nose leaking snot, and red-rimmed eyes pouring tears, his little sister looked a thoroughly concerning blend of enraged, devastated, and completely fucking batshit insane. “You’re a monster. Let Billy go!”
Maxine’s strikes were clumsy at best – devoid of all the technique Billy had so painstakingly taken the time to teach her – and she only got in about four blows with the sides of her white-knuckled fists before he was able to shake off his stunned disbelief and fucking move, you useless piece of shit.
Shock had loosened Neil’s hold on his wrist, which allowed Billy to yank himself free with only minimal effort and a brief spike of pain. He roughly shoved himself between them – petrified that this was the moment that his dad decided Maxine was no longer exempt from his cruelty – thoughtlessly exposing his back to Neil as he grabbed both of his sister’s fisted hands and held them together against his stomach, sending her a wild-eyed, nearly pleading glare that went completely ignored. Panicked and pained and knowing that he only had a very limited amount of time to calm Maxine the fuck down before Neil lost what miniscule amount of patience he possessed, Billy hissed a quiet but desperately vehement, “That’s enough, Maxine. Stop.”
“No!” Maxine howled – voice cracking around a sob – fighting against his restraining hold as she tried to dart around him, to go at Neil again. If nothing else, Billy had to admire her sheer fucking balls, even as he cursed her sheer fucking stupidity. She managed to contort herself until she could peer around Billy, locking gazes with Neil once more. His sister’s pale blue eyes were simultaneously burning and colder than fucking ice, months’ worth of pent up hatred, anxiety, and festering helplessness distorting her voice almost beyond recognition as she all but screamed in Neil’s face. “Get out! Leave us alone! You’re a- a disgusting excuse for a father! Fuck you, you make me sick! Get out, get out!”
Ears ringing – the hairs on the back of his neck standing up straight as Neil’s shock violently transformed into nearly incoherent rage – Billy ducked forward a millisecond before his dad lifted a hand and attempted to grab a fistful of his short hair, curling his arms around Maxine’s thin form and bodily hauling her back towards her bed, as far from Neil as she could possibly get while the man’s large frame was blocking their only viable exit.
“Neil, please.” Susan whimpered from the doorway.
“What, woman? You heard your dear little Max.” Neil stated, vitriol coating his words and creasing his features into something truly vile. Gone was the twisted affection – and tolerance – he’d always held for Maxine, replaced with the forbidding disdain that Billy had grown so used to weathering. Keeping his little sister tucked within the relative safety of his shadow – she’d abruptly stopped struggling at the sound of Neil’s mocking tone, finally having realised that her manic behaviour had put them both in danger – Billy quickly spun to face Neil, locking down the instinctive and intense wave of fear that threatened to send him cowering as the man slowly advanced towards them. “What was it you called me, Max? A monster? A disgusting excuse for a father?” Quicker than Billy could anticipate, Neil grasped his jaw in one large hand, calloused fingers digging into his skin almost hard enough for his blunt nails to draw crescent shaped wounds. “You been telling stories, boy?”
Swallowing thickly – mind racing as he tried to come up with a response that wouldn’t make everything ten times worse – Billy tried to open his mouth. “I-“
“Shut the fuck up. I’m not interested in your damn excuses.” Neil shook his head, tutting disappointedly and squeezing Billy’s jaw tighter. “Respect and responsibility, Billy. How many times, huh? How many times are you going to make me teach you? I always knew you were one stupid sonofabitch, but this?” He grinned, the expression devoid of humour and all teeth. “What happens next? That’s on you, boy. You just had to open your big mouth, whining like a bitch to the only person in your pathetic life who’s got no choice but to tolerate you. Now poor little Max is gonna have to learn what you couldn’t, and she’ll have nobody to blame but you.”
Eyes burning as his heart tried to beat up and out of his damned throat – terror unlike anything he’d ever felt before leaving him breathless and dizzy – Billy was too distracted by his own deplorable weakness to realise that Maxine was darting around him and lunging for his dad again.
She extended her neatly clenched fist in a soundly formed arch this time, wordlessly delivering a fucking solid punch directly to Neil’s crotch.
The man wheezed in sudden agony, one hand moving to instinctively brace his freshly bruised balls while the other – fingers unlatching from Billy’s already bruising jaw – lifted to backhand Maxine hard across the face.
Mind-numbing fear transforming into ferociously protective fury in an instant, Billy reached out his sixth sense and dug it with ruthless determination into Neil’s fucked-up psyche, circling it around the nausea inducing jumble of pain-disbelief-disappointment-anger-eagerness-aggression he found there and squeezing until the potent emotions – and the intentions driven by them – were extinguished.
Billy curled an arm around Maxine’s heaving shoulders and tugged her against his front – holding her there with a rigid firmness that ensured she wouldn’t be delivering any more nut shots, no matter how well-deserved – watching unblinkingly as Neil’s arms fell limply by his sides, sickly green eyes growing dull as his mind was forced into empty stillness. This time the man didn’t bleed from anywhere other than his left ear, and Billy didn’t know whether he should feel relieved by the fact that he’d apparently gotten better at forcing his way inside other people’s heads, or regretful that his mental intrusion hadn’t spilled more of Neil’s blood.
How fucking dare he try to hit Maxine. How fucking dare he.
Concentrating as best he could through the bloodlust and the steadily building ache in his head, Billy tightened his psychic hold on Neil’s stalled mind and willed it to become pliable. Even with over a month between attempts, it felt notably easier the second time around – which was about as relieving as it was disturbing – though he wasn’t sure if that was because his mental abilities had improved somewhat since the shitshow in the Byers’ front yard, or because Neil’s mind was just… weaker, now. Like breaking it once had made it more susceptible to being broken again.
Deciding that he really didn’t give a shit either way, Billy refocused. When he spoke his voice was low and his tone was bitingly severe, leaving absolutely no room for anything other than complete and perfect compliance. “Go outside, and don’t come back into the house until I fucking let you.”
Billy was more prepared for the way his dad just stood there in the wake of his psychic voodoo this time, wiping absently at his light nosebleed as he withdrew from the chaotic swirl of energy coursing through Neil’s rapidly rewiring brain.
After another few moments Neil’s eyes regained their lucidity, and he blinked rapidly before narrowing them into a cutting glare. Billy braced himself for more taunting – unsure how the man’s mind had adapted itself around his command – but Neil only scoffed before turning on his heel and wordlessly walking out of the room, the rhythmic sound of his stomping footsteps eventually changing into the metallic rattle of the front door as it was unlocked. Neil moved outside – the door shutting with a faint squeak and a solid thud behind him – and the heavy quiet left in his wake was broken only by the miserable sounds of Maxine’s badly supressed crying.
Billy was vaguely aware that Susan was still standing in the doorway – and that he probably should care that she’d just witnessed her infamously antagonistic husband bow to his demand without first launching into a fit of homicidal rage – but he couldn’t summon enough mental energy to spare the pitiable woman more than a passing thought. As far as he was concerned, Susan could go fuck herself. Billy had much more pressing priorities, number one among them being to make sure her fucking daughter was alright.
Pushing thoughts of both Neil and Susan out of his head, Billy clasped his hands on Maxine’s shaking shoulders and gently turned her to face him, barely withholding an empathetic wince when he was confronted with his little sister’s crumpled up, splotchy as all hell, snot and tear-streaked face. Maxine really was ugly when she cried, but even he knew better than to try and crack a tasteless joke at a time like this. “Shit.” Billy muttered instead, his fingers agitatedly fidgeting against the soft material of her long-sleeved sleep shirt as he tried – and failed – to think of something suitably consoling to say. “Uh, you’re okay, shitbird. Neil’s go-oof-"
Maxine crashed into him with all the force of a speeding truck, smearing snot and tears all over his shirt as she clenched her arms around his waist. The sudden embrace startled him badly enough that he actually staggered backwards, falling with an uncomfortable grunt – that desk corner he’d taken to the liver was going to leave one hell of a fucking bruise – when the backs of his legs met the side of her bed. “Jesus Christ, Maxi- hey. Hey! What the fuck are you…”
Before Billy had the chance to do anything – like stand back up, or push her clinging form away, or actually return her desperate hug – Maxine was releasing her tight hold around his midsection, though instead of pulling away his sister proceeded to do her level best to fucking strangle him. With both arms looped around his neck – her increasingly inconsolable sobs ringing deafeningly close to his ear – Maxine didn’t hesitate to climb into his lap, spindly legs hooking around his waist as she effectively anchored him to the edge of her mattress.
More dumbfounded than he could ever remember being – what in the fuck was even happening right now? – Billy blinked unseeingly over Maxine’s shoulder, his hands hovering over her shaking back as he tried to decide if he was going to allow her to continue clinging like a limpet, or if he was going to force her away, his skin already beginning to prickle beneath the onslaught of very fucking unexpected contact.
His little spitfire of a sister – prideful and fierce and always so determined to be tougher than she truly was – had never acted this way before, so… frantically, alarmingly childlike. Maxine might whine and stomp her feet like a spoilt little kid on occasion, but whatever this was? This blubbering, snot stained mess that was currently deposited in his lap? It was so far removed from her typical bitching and moaning that Billy hardly recognised her. Maxine had never sought – no, near violently fucking demanded – such overt physical comfort from him before, yet here they both were, one bawling her goddamned eyes out while clinging like a frightened baby, and the other quietly freaking the fuck out, thoroughly confused and way out of his comfort zone.
Billy could feel how hard she was trembling – could sense how shaken she truly was, emotions a jumbled vortex whipping unseen through the air around her – and all at once he was reminded that his sister was only thirteen-years-old. No matter how mature she tried to act, Maxine was barely even a goddamned teenager yet.
In the end there really wasn’t a choice – even he wasn’t that much of a heartless asshole – and Billy reluctantly settled himself into Maxine’s desperate hug, shoving aside his apprehension before lightly resting his hands on her back, patting awkwardly. He cleared his throat, tonguing at his freshly split lip for a few seconds before daring to speak. “Maxine… c’mon. Neil’s gone, okay? You don’t need to cry anymore. You’re safe. Everything’s fine.”
If anything Billy’s words seemed to upset her more – because of fucking course they did – Maxine’s entire body shuddering with the forcefulness of her near hysterical bawling. He’d never heard her cry so hard before, and every heart-rending sob that erupted from her throat was like a knife to Billy’s stupidly soft heart, stabbing and twisting with merciless precision. It hurt, to hear and feel her so completely overcome with anguish, and Billy vainly tried to swallow down the panic welling in his clogged up throat, worried that she was going to work herself up to the point of hyperventilation.
If Maxine passed out he was going to kill Neil, fuck any and all consequences. Hopper would probably help him get away with it, anyway.
Figuring that talking hadn’t helped, Billy stopped pussyfooting around and finally returned his sister’s embrace with equal strength, locking his arms over her back and squeezing her to his chest, like he might be able to stop the frenzied barrage of relief-terror-misery-pain-dread-relief-relief-fear-relief from spilling over and overwhelming her if he just held on tight enough.
By some miracle it actually seemed to work – Maxine’s awful sobbing beginning to lose some of its momentum, her body no longer wracked with such violent tremors – and Billy dared to lightly begin smoothing a palm down her long red hair, taking care to avoid snagging his fingers in any tangles.
When he’d been young and upset and his mom still had the patience to deal with him, she used to run her fingers through his hair, arranging his curls into increasingly ridiculous styles in an effort to make him stop snivelling. Her gentle ministrations had always made him feel better, so while Billy highly doubted that he’d be able to replicate her success – his scarred hands weren’t practiced at any kind of tenderness – he genuinely had no fucking idea what the hell else he could try.
Seriously, what was with all these kids getting upset while he was the only asshole around? First Will, then El, and now Maxine. If one of the other little nerds decided to have a breakdown in his vicinity Billy was getting in his Camaro and driving the fuck away, speed limits be damned.
He accidently made eye-contact with Susan – who he’d completely forgotten was still fucking standing in the doorway – and sneered on reflex, briefly lifting an arm to aggressively wave her away, mouthing fuck off for good measure. Billy didn’t care that the downtrodden woman was crying. He didn’t care that her regret was powerful enough for him to sense from across the room. Neil had moved to hit Maxine – he’d tried to hit Maxine – and Susan had done nothing to protect her child. Nothing.
Even on her worst days, his mom hadn’t ever hesitated to place herself between Billy and Neil. She’d done her best to protect him for as long as she could stand to, and when she’d reached her limit… well, Billy didn’t blame her for leaving, even if he wished she could have endured taking him with her.
After witnessing his mom’s suffering, Billy had never expected Susan to step in on his behalf – truthfully hadn’t even really wanted her to – understanding that her priority was to keep Neil’s aggression aimed away from herself and Maxine, and relieved that at least he wouldn’t have to carry her pain on his conscience. He hadn’t ever truly begrudged her inaction before, but to allow herself to be nothing but a bystander as Neil raised a hand against her own daughter?
Beyond being disgustingly pathetic, it was straight up fucking neglectful, and Billy wouldn’t forgive her for it.
Susan made no attempt to reprimand him or defend herself, merely lowering her tear-bright eyes from Billy’s heated glare and silently shuffling out of sight.
Maxine’s sobs slowly petered out into shuddering gasps and disgustingly wet sniffles, and Billy felt himself cautiously start to relax, the anxiety that had been keeping his chest tight finally beginning to loosen its grip. His sister was still coiled tightly around him – her closeness surprisingly tolerable despite the constricting quality of her grasp – but as the seconds ticked by Maxine seemed to… unwind, almost, her fingers slowly unclenching from his shirt and her legs relenting in their attempt to separate his goddamned vertebrae.
Billy sighed into the quiet left in the wake of her loud crying, tugging lightly at a lock of her hair and feeling a pang of disquiet when she didn’t react to the teasing. “Maxine… listen to me. You’re safe-"
“I know that.” She interrupted, and the completely exhausted rasp of her strained voice – she sounded like she’d just gargled a cup full of fucking glass – had him holding back a wince. His sister kept her head on his shoulder, face turned away so that he couldn’t see her expression. “That’s not- I know that. God, you’re so…”
Scowling – immediately assuming that she was about to insult him – Billy pulled at her arms, huffing in annoyance when Maxine merely tightened her strangle hold around his neck. “So what? If you’re gonna be a little bitch about it then get the hell off-"
“You died!” Maxine yelled shrilly, anger – and something disturbingly like grief – threatening to send her regressing back into a wailing mess.
Billy’s hands fell slack against her narrow shoulders, confusion once again furrowing his brow as he struggled to make sense of her eardrum piercing outburst. He didn’t doubt that waking to the sounds of his dad roughing him up a little had been frightening – enraging too, considering the fact that she’d physically attacked Neil, twice – but at no point had Billy been in any danger of actually dying. “Calm down, shitbird. I’m not dead-"
Maxine shook her head vigorously, breathing turning choppy once more. “You were. I- we were back in the tunnels. The demo-dogs were dragging you-“ She hiccoughed wetly, shamelessly using his shirt – which was already damp with snot and tears – as a tissue. “They were ea-eating you, and you were screaming. There was so much blood, Billy, and you- you yelled for my help, but I was stuck. I couldn’t move, or speak, or do anything. Steve- he saved you, and we all got out, but then… then Neil was there. He- he-" Maxine choked on a keening sob, clenching her arms around his neck with renewed vigour.
Able to imagine a lot of horrifying things that Maxine’s nightmare-version of his dad could have done to her nightmare-version of him, Billy grimaced in uneasy sympathy, cupping the back of her neck in his palm and squeezing lightly. He felt an uncomfortable stab of guilt twist his guts – he might not have any control over his sister’s subconscious, but ultimately it was Billy’s bullshit that had added fuel to what sounded like a pretty goddamned intense nightmare – silently cursing himself for failing to properly shield his sister from the horrors of not one, but two fucked-up dimensions.
Billy opened his mouth to speak – a pathetically inadequate I’m sorry sitting on the tip of his tongue – but Maxine’s tear-thickened voice silenced his hesitant attempt. “He just- grabbed you, and threw you to the ground. Steve was suddenly just gone, I couldn’t move, and…” She shuddered, voice dropping to a weak, croaking whisper. “Neil hit you, again and again and again and again-"
“I’m not dead, Maxine.” Billy tried to interrupt, heart clenching and stomach flipping at the pure, haunted emotion in his sister’s gruesome recollection. She sounded utterly petrified – grief-stricken – and for the first time he stopped to truly consider what his death would do to her. What it would have done, if that car hadn’t swerved at the last moment, or those demo-dog shits had succeeded in ripping him apart. If this was how she reacted in the wake of a mere bad dream, Billy couldn’t fathom the reckless heights her chaotic emotions might reach if he actually up and fucking died.
It was a deeply confronting – not to mention weirdly painful – realisation to have, that Maxine would be genuinely wrecked by his death. Growing up, Billy had never placed much value on his own life, never treasured or took real joy from it. He’d learned that life was a thing to be endured, and that if he held out long enough, maybe there’d be a moment of reprieve from the near constant pain of his pointless existence.
The concept of suicide had originally entered his fucked-up little head at the tender age of nine, when he’d spied the fin of a shark amongst the waves and considered paddling towards it, rather than away. After that it had kind of just… stuck, mostly as whispers in the back of his mind, though on particularly bad days those thoughts would swirl more aggressively, demanding to be heard. He hadn’t summoned the courage to actually attempt until just about five months ago, and when he’d woken up in that sterile hospital room his emotions had been so blunted by drugs that to this day Billy still didn’t know if he’d been relieved or disappointed to have failed.
Only in brief, often dismissive flashes had he contemplated how his death might affect Maxine. He’d always just assumed that she’d be glad to be rid of him, especially in the turbulent months leading up to their move to Hawkins. They’d barely been on speaking terms – which was entirely Billy’s fault – and their arguments had been quick to turn fucking mean, both bitter and unwilling to back down.
The interdimensional mess he and Maxine had stumbled into had exhaustively disabused him of that belief – for whatever reason, his little sister really did give a shit about him – and now… for the first time since he was nine-years-old, Billy was wholly and deeply glad to be alive.
“…ouldn’t stop, Billy. Your face… I couldn’t recognise you anymore. You were already dead- you’d stopped struggling ages ago, but Neil wouldn’t stop, and I still couldn’t move-"
“Hey, that’s enough. Quit thinking about it, shitbird. It was just a stupid nightmare.” Billy said, clearing his throat when his voice shook with supressed emotion. Shoving his own discomfort aside – this wasn’t about him – he gave Maxine’s nape another faint squeeze, gently knocking his temple into the back of her head. “I’m right fucking here, aren’t I? And Neil’s outside freezing his bruised balls off. You’re- I’m alright, Maxine. Really. You can stop freaking out.”
Maxine let out an annoyed huff – which Billy counted as a resounding win – and dug her chin into his collarbone in retaliation. “I’m not-“ She sniffled, then exhaled a sigh that still quaked a little around the edges. “Okay, I was freaking out, and still kind of am, but I can’t help it! Having that dream, then waking up and seeing that you were bleeding and Neil was right there- I was…” His sister hesitated for a long moment, seeming to war with herself before finally admitting, so quietly that Billy had to strain his ears to hear. “I was scared, okay? Really scared, and so- so angry I felt like I couldn’t breathe. Neil’s dangerous, Billy-"
“No fucking shit-"
“I’m serious!” She snapped, reeling backwards just so that she could level at him a glare that at any other time probably would have been impressive, but now just looked bloodshot and kind of pathetic. Her gaze flickered from his split lip to the faint bruises forming over his cheeks and jawline, anger flushing her already splotchy face with even more red. “Clearly Hopper isn’t enough to make him stop hurting you anymore-"
“Tonight was different, Maxi-"
“What does that even mean?”
Billy groaned, running a hand through his hair before gesturing impatiently towards the empty space beside him. This conversation was already worsening his headache – from where his sister summoned the audacity to be so goddamned pushy while covered in snot, he had no idea – and every word Maxine spoke blasted her stale ass breath directly in into his face, which was rapidly diminishing both his sense of leniency and patience. “If you’re okay enough to bitch at me, you’re okay enough to get the hell off. You’re breath’s fucking rank.”
Flushing an even brighter shade of red – Billy honestly hadn’t thought it was possible – Maxine scrambled to completely disentangle herself from him, nearly falling backwards onto the floor in the process. Eventually she settled herself beside him on the edge of her bed, holding her arms tightly across her chest and staring resolutely down at her socked feet. Petulantly, she muttered, “Your breath stinks.”
Smirking faintly, Billy shrugged a shoulder and gave her side a light elbow. “At least I don’t have snot on my face.”
“You- urgh.” Maxine wiped the back of her hand beneath her nose, doing more to smear the mess around than to actually clean it off. She was quiet for a long moment, slowly relaxing out of her rigid posture as her hands fell to fidget aimlessly in her lap. Shooting him a suspiciously curious sideways glance, his sister asked, “What do you mean, tonight was different?”
Billy shook his head, already regretting saying anything. “Don’t worry about that-"
“Billy.”
He met her shamelessly expectant stare with nothing but an arched eyebrow and a mocking smirk. “Maxine.”
“Tell me!”
“You don’t need to know, shitbird.”
Maxine scowled, red-rimmed eyes brimming with a sheen of frustrated tears as her lips began trembling finely. “I do. Tell me why it was different. Please.”
“Fucking- fine.” Billy said through gritted teeth, looking away from her despondent face while silently – but vehemently – cursing himself for being such a weak-willed bitch. He tongued at his swollen lip, trying to frame his answer in the most harmless way possible. “You were crying in your sleep, so I came in to wake you up. Neil followed, and there was a- misunderstanding. He got pissed. That’s it.”
“What misunderstanding?”
“He thought I was hurting you.”
“Why would he-"
“That doesn’t matter, alright?” He cut in sternly, unwilling to go into any further detail. Knowing that it was her sleep-addled plea of his name that had tipped Neil’s irate suspicion into wanton violence would only make her feel shittier than she already did, and that was the last thing Billy wanted right now. His shirt was covered in enough teary snot to last him a lifetime, thank you very fucking much.
When Maxine opened her mouth to argue he shot her a look, continuing to speak only when she resealed her lips into a disgruntled pout. “It really doesn’t. Neil’s always looking for a reason to-“
“Was it my fault?”
Ruthlessly crushing the surge of irritation flaring to life in his chest, Billy sucked in a breath and responded with a sharp, “No. Look at me.”
Slowly, Maxine did as he ordered, and he felt his annoyance die a swift death when confronted with the fresh tear-tracks sliding down her freckled cheeks. Sighing heavily – feeling a grudgingly fond and inappropriately timed smile tease at his lips – Billy curled an arm around her shoulders and tugged her lightly against his side in what he hoped was a comforting manner. His sister’s overly bright ice-blue eyes widened at the gesture, and he was relieved to see her distress abate somewhat when he gave her a squeeze. “You were sleeping, Maxine. Nothing that happened was your fault. Except Neil’s bruised dick and balls. Feel free to take credit for those.”
His sister snorted – which was exactly the reaction he’d been aiming for – and managed to grin a little, the expression small and tired but real all the same. “I hope it hurt.”
“You bet your ass it did. It was a good shot.”
Maxine’s smile widened, eyes glinting with pride rather than tears. “Yeah?”
“Yeah.” Billy agreed, though his faint smile was quick to flatten into a far more unamused line. She clocked the slight shift immediately, shoulders regaining some tension as she warily frowned up at him. Satisfied that he had her undivided attention, he continued, tone deathly fucking serious. “But if you ever do some dumb shit like that again, I’ll take your skateboard and set it on fire. Do you understand me?”
Maxine pulled away with a disappointed grimace – Billy did nothing to stop her, allowing his arm to fall from around her shoulders with a pang of regret that he ruthlessly buried – gesturing angrily to his face and arm. “Are you serious, Billy? He hit you, he was grabbing you! I couldn’t just do nothing!”
“Nothing is exactly what I expect you to do, shitbird. Like you said, Neil’s fucking dangerous.” He tugged down the right sleeve of his shirt, instinctively trying to hide the aching bruises he could already feel settling in around his wrist. There wasn’t anything he could do to cover up his stinging lip or stiff jaw – not that there was much point, considering the fact that Maxine had seen Neil cause his mild injuries – and Billy couldn’t wrap his head around the fact that his sister still didn’t seem to fully comprehend how close she’d come to sporting the same injuries, or worse. If he hadn’t had the power to force Neil to stop before he’d had the chance to reel his arm back all the way… it made him feel fucking sick to even consider how much uglier the situation could have gotten. “I can handle him. You can’t. Tonight would have gone a lot differently if my brain wasn’t so fucking weird, and your recklessness would have made it that much worse, for the both of us.”
Maxine ducked her head down and brought her legs up, hugging her arms tightly around her own shins and burying her face in her knees. It was obvious that she recognised the harsh truth in his words – the tautness of her posture and the guilty shame grating against his sixth sense made that abundantly clear – but Billy needed to hear a verbal confirmation, to know that her uselessly protective stubbornness wouldn’t come back to bite them both in the ass, again. “Do you understand me, Maxine?”
“Yes, alright? I get it!” She snapped, looking back up to shoot an embarrassed glare at him. The tears welling in her eyes dampened the fierceness of the expression, though that hardly mattered when Billy already felt like the world’s biggest asshole. “Hitting him was stupid, but- I don’t regret it. I wasn’t gonna let him treat you like that without doing something. I couldn’t.” Maxine lifted her chin and resolutely set her shoulders, meeting his flat stare head-on. “I’m not sorry, Billy. If I had the chance, I’d punch Neil in the balls a thousand, no, a million times for every horrible thing he’s ever done to you.”
Finding himself suddenly unable to swallow past the stinging tightness in his throat – or see clearly through the inexplicable blurring at the edges of his vision – Billy blinked his burning eyes once before quickly turning his head away from Maxine’s doggedly earnest expression. Jesus fucking Christ, he was not about to cry over this mushy shit, what the fuck was wrong with him? So what if Maxine’s absurdly grave declaration was the first time in his shitty life that someone had verbally labelled Neil’s abuse as what it was? Horrible. And so what if nobody since his mom had tried so hard to protect him, or even just believed he deserved protection in the first place? Billy was frustrated with his sister for being so irresponsible with her own safety, afraid that her dumbass would do it again, and pissed the hell off because she wasn’t fucking listening to him. He steadfastly wasn’t touched, or grateful, or fighting back pathetically overwhelmed tears.
Fucking hell, maybe he needed a solid beating. That’d give him something real to cry about.
“Billy…” Maxine murmured tentatively, something shocked and vaguely awestruck in her quiet tone. “Are you crying?”
Immediately mortified, Billy mercilessly dug the heels of his palms into his wet eyes – hard enough to make himself see spots – and quickly shook his head. “No.” He denied, aggressively clearing his throat when his voice came out slightly strangled. “Fuck off, shitbird.”
“Oh my god, what’s wrong? Is your face hurting?” Maxine rocketed up onto her feet, all but jittering in place with anxious energy. “It’s your face, right? I’ll go get you some ice-"
Billy curled his fingers around her forearm before she had the chance to take more than a single step away, blinking his vision back into focus and feeling idiotically relieved when no tears spilled through his already damp eyelashes. The deep scowl he aimed at her worked wonders to smooth out the worried furrow between her brows, and Maxine didn’t put up any kind of resistance as he lightly tugged her back down to sit beside him. “My face is fine-"
“Actually, it looks pretty messed u-"
“Maxine.”
Cringing at his sharp tone, his sister fell still and silent.
Biting back a longsuffering groan, Billy ran a hand through his short hair – tugging at the lightly curled ends in a vain effort to get his fucking head on straight – before all but collapsing forward to rest his elbows on his knees, exhausted and embarrassed and uncertain as to how he was going to get it through Maxine’s stubborn skull that her safety was just more important than his. “Can you just- listen to me for a second?”
Perhaps sensing that Billy’s tenuous composure was hanging on by a thread, Maxine merely nodded, lips pressed into a pensive line.
“Alright,” He muttered, blowing out a heavy breath and restlessly rolling his shoulders. If threats against her most treasured belongings hadn’t cut it, then Billy would try a different, more truthful approach, no matter how his skin crawled and his insides cringed at the thought of doing so. When he wasn’t high as a kite honesty didn’t exactly come naturally to him, it never had and Billy doubted it ever would. Lying was so deeply ingrained in him at this point in his shitty life – he’d learned how to keep secrets before he could fucking walk – that truth often got caught in his throat, his deep-rooted reticence almost always keeping the words from escaping. There was vulnerability in telling the truth – which was already a good enough reason to avoid it at all costs - and at the end of the day it was just so much easier to lie.
Regardless, Billy refused to be a coward. After everything that had happened tonight – everything his little sister had done for him, as well as everything she’d been forced to see and hear – Maxine deserved more than his typical hard-ass bullshit. His sister might not be the smartest, and she was definitely more reckless than she could ever hope to successfully back up, but she was a good kid – better than Billy by miles – and he trusted her not to spit his rare sincerity back in his face.
Swallowing his pride, Billy reluctantly turned his head and met her needlessly concerned expression. “Look, I appreciate where you’re coming from, shitbird, I do. I understand that it’s probably… difficult for you, to see Neil being such a dick-"
“It’s a lot worse than just difficult, Billy. It’s-"
“If you’d let me finish.” He cut back in, gaze narrowing into an impatient glare.
Maxine huffed and rolled her eyes – clearly unimpressed – but wisely kept her mouth shut.
“As I was fucking saying. I get why you tried to intervene, alright? And I’m sorry-"
“Why the hell are you sorry-"
“Maxine I will fucking gag you.”
“Fine!” She bit out, though she made absolutely no effort to shift her incredulous expression.
Inhaling and exhaling a deliberately slow breath – praying to a god he didn’t believe in for some much needed patience, because holy shit his sister was being annoying as fuck right now – Billy gave up on the majority of what he’d wanted to say and just skipped straight to his point. “My priority is keeping you safe, dipshit, and I can’t do that if you try to punch Neil in the dick every time he does something that upsets you. It's not worth it, and all it’s gonna do is piss him off, which isn’t good for either for us.” He straightened up – wincing slightly as his bruised middle gave a sharp cramp – and clamped a hand down on Maxine’s shoulder, waiting until she met his stern gaze before continuing. “So, I need you to promise me you won’t ever do that again, and I need you to fucking mean it, Maxine.”
His sister didn’t immediately launch into another round of impassioned protests – which, considering her penchant for acting first and thinking hardly ever, was very uncharacteristic of her – and instead of the indignant anger he’d expected to see, she looked… oddly sad, though still mulishly obstinate. “It was worth it.”
Billy blinked, thrown by the non-sequitur. “What?”
“Punching Neil in the dick.” Maxine explained, sounding more serious than Billy could ever remember her being. “Even if he’d punched me back for doing it. It was worth it to make him let go of you.”
“Jesus Christ, no it fucking wasn’t.” He rubbed a hand roughly over his face – potent exasperation and an aggravating flush of warmth suffusing his chest when he sensed the truthfulness of her foolish statement – hardly registering the discomfort radiating from his lip and jaw. “Maxine, listen. I don’t need you to try and protect me, alright? I can handle-"
“You don’t believe those things he said, right?” She cut in, pale eyes suddenly wide and expectant.
Wondering where the hell that question had sprung from, Billy gave her a deep scowl. “What the fuck are you even talking about?”
“What Neil said, about your life being pathetic, and that I only- tolerate you.” Maxine answered, her words sharpened with an almost fraught edge. “You know that’s complete bullshit, right Billy?”
The part about his life being pathetic was undoubtedly true – apart from recently helping to kill a bunch of interdimensional pests, he’d survived almost eighteen years without doing a single thing worth remembering – and just a few months ago he wouldn’t have hesitated to believe the rest of Neil’s cruel taunt as well, but now… well, now he knew better. As strange as it was, Billy didn’t doubt that Maxine genuinely cared about him, and he hadn’t for a good while now. “Sure.”
Maxine eyed him dubiously – clearly unsure whether she should believe him – before slowly nodding her head in acceptance. “Good.” She murmured, exhaling a tense breath and tucking her fidgeting hands beneath her thighs, eyes flicking away from his face like she was suddenly too self-conscious to look at him. When she spoke again her tone was almost painfully sincere, and her eyes were bright with a nervously teasing glint. “I know that you don’t need me to protect you, and I know that you can handle a lot of shit, Billy. But… we’re family, and I’m gonna look out for you whether you like it or not.”
Recognising his own words being parroted back at him and unable to stop a fondly amused scoff from escaping his throat – since fucking when was his bitchy little sister so disgustingly sappy? – Billy reached out and tugged her skinny form back against his side, using his free hand to give her a well-deserved noogie to the top of her head. “You cheeky little shit.”
Maxine let out a startled squeak, grinning even as she cursed him out and vainly tried to yank his knuckles away from her vulnerable scalp. “Stop, you jerk! You’re gonna knot my hair!”
“Newsflash, Maxine, your hair’s already a fucking riot.” He smirked, tapping his knuckles against her skull in a brief staccato rhythm – vaguely surprised he didn’t hear an echo – before lowering his arms and allowing her ample room to escape from him. To his surprise his sister stayed right where she was, knocking her shoulder against his upper arm and sticking her tongue out at him. Billy returned the gesture with an added flash of teeth, reaching out and flicking the tip of her nose. “You look ridiculous.”
Bringing one hand up to protect her nose from further attack, Maxine lightly jabbed at his thigh with the other. “You’re an asshole.”
“Uh-huh.” He agreed easily. “I still need you to promise me, shitbird. No more stupid heroics.”
“I can’t, Billy. Well- I could, but…” Maxine shrugged helplessly, lifting an arm and wriggling her fingers towards his temple. “It’d be a lie.”
Lighter mood souring in an instant, Billy barely managed to lock a deeply frustrated groan behind his clenched teeth. Why did his sister always have to be so goddamned difficult? “Fucks sake, Maxine. You get that it’s harder to protect you if you don’t give a shit about trying to protect yourself, right? I-"
A humourlessly sarcastic laugh spilled from Maxine’s mouth, the sound sharp enough to cut through Billy’s words and silence him. “Oh, that’s rich coming from you. It sucks, doesn’t it? Feeling so helpless, and- and scared-"
“Who said I was fucking scared-"
“I did, because I’m scared all the time!” Maxine all but exploded, hands clenching in her lap as her ice-blue eyes blazed, effortlessly pinning Billy in place with the raw, heart wrenching honestly he could see shining there. Struck speechless, he could do nothing but watch as more tears spilled down his sister’s flushed cheeks, her face twisting with misery. “I feel sick with it, Billy! First it was the monsters, the junkyard. I thought you were gonna die, you jerk! Your leg got seriously messed up, but it’s like you didn’t even care. The Lab was somehow worse, and then Neil, and the tunnels, how you passed out after and wouldn’t wake up… Even after El closed the gate and all the demo-dogs died, I was still scared. I couldn’t even feel relieved when you came home from the hospital, because Neil was at home, and I- I didn’t want him to hurt you.” Maxine paused to duck her head down and scrub at her eyes, sucking in deep, shaking breaths in an effort to keep the emotional quiver in her words from devolving into full blown sobs. “I know I don’t stand a chance against Neil, and I know that he could really hurt me if I make him angry enough, but it’s my turn to care about you more than I care about myself. You’ve protected me for years, Billy, so even if it’s useless, and dangerous, and it makes you mad, I’m gonna do everything I can to protect you.” Her efforts not to cry began to fail then, voice cracking around soft, exhausted hiccoughs and wet sniffles. Feeling his own eyes burn with welling tears – far too focused on Maxine to be embarrassed by them – Billy dared to rest a finely trembling hand between her shoulder blades, his feather-light tough becoming more solid when she leaned almost desperately into the contact.
Like his tentative attempt at comfort had afforded her some courage, Maxine looked back up into Billy’s face. Whatever she saw there – vibrant blue eyes made even brighter by the sheen of tears held within them, soft in a way they so rarely were – cleared some of the desolate sorrow from her flushed features, and a few moments later the corners of her lips curled up just enough to be called a wobbly smile. “So… I can’t promise not to do shit like that again, because I will, because you’re my idiot brother and I love you.”
Feeling like Maxine had just sucker punched all the air from his seizing lungs – nobody had told him they loved him and genuinely meant it since he was seven years old and his mom was tucking him into bed for the last time – Billy blinked in unadulterated shock and just… stared. His sister shifted restlessly beneath his wide-eyed gaze, her small smile quickly fading into a pinched, disheartened frown. “Uh, sorry. I don’t know why I said tha-"
“Shut up.” Billy choked out, twisting his upper torso towards her and all but yanking her into a hug, unpractised but too overwhelmed to give a shit. He banded his arms firmly around her shoulders – pressing a thoughtless kiss to her knotty hair – and gently rested his chin atop her head, a few lonely tears sliding down his face when he squeezed his eyes shut. “Just- shut up. Don’t be sorry.”
Maxine all but headbutted his chest in her rush to hug him back, skinny arms squeezing around his ribs as she descended into another round of – thankfully less aggressively distraught – crying. Billy let her soak his shirt without complaint, too busy trying to swallow around the stinging lump in his throat and breathe through the painful hitching in his lungs to even pretend to be bothered by it. Shit, after a speech like that she could cry on him for as long as she fucking needed to.
How could he not have realised how frightening it would be for Maxine to go through every fucked-up thing she had, to survive viciously blood-thirsty monsters, and then be forced to go home and live with one? Fucking hell, Billy had always known he was a selfish piece of shit, but to be so unbelievably self-centred that he hadn’t even noticed how much his little sister was struggling? How scared she was of her traumatic memories, of Neil? It was unforgivable – a serrated stab of self-loathing making his lungs seize tighter and his throat ache – and Billy mercilessly bit at his split lip, fighting a losing battle against the tears managing to escape from his tightly shut eyes.
Fucking hell, Billy was such a monumentally shit brother. When it really mattered – every time it fucking mattered – he felt like he was just… constantly failing her, and it was beginning to seriously piss him off. Their relationship might have been practically non-existent up until recently, but now that they were actually getting along – mostly – Billy wanted to do better by her. He wanted to be a better brother, which was a galling realisation that immediately etched a grimace onto his face. How the fuck was he supposed to do that?
“I’ll take care of it, alright? I’ll- damnit.” He cut himself off with a harsh breath, lifting a hand from Maxine’s back and wiping impatiently at his wet eyes. Clearing his throat, Billy tried again. “I’ll protect us both.”
Maxine nodded, her forehead pressing into his sternum. “H-How?”
He tapped his fingertips against her temple in silent answer, a rushed but hopefully viable plan coming together in his head. If he wanted to avoid receiving a new layer of scars across his back – and keep Maxine from witnessing any more of Neil at his worst – the only path forward was for Billy to use his telepathy. In addition to further and far more deeply embedded Jedi mind-tricks – ones that wouldn’t fade or break no matter how Neil’s natural mind fought against them – he was turning over the possibility of just… erasing Neil’s memories of the last hour, figuring that the violent consequences of Maxine’s screaming nightmare could be avoided entirely if his dad believed that he’d slept through the night uninterrupted. If Billy could successfully supersede both Neil’s intentions and emotions – if he could override an interdimensional shadow’s psychic network and take temporary control – then surely it wasn’t outside the realm of possibility when it came to his freaky psychic bullshit to just… remove things from a person’s mind. Like memories, or the desire to beat the shit out of his son.
Changing the memories themselves sounded way too fucking difficult – Billy cringed at the thought of spending any amount of time picking through the most complexly personal parts of Neil’s brain, uninterested in seeing himself from his dad’s unforgiving perspective – but erasing them seemed like an easier, less risky alternative. Once the memories were gone – which would eliminate the immediate risk Neil posed to Maxine – he could turn his focus towards ensuring that the man never tried to hurt his little sister, and by extension Billy, ever again.
Once Maxine’s quiet cries quieted once more into intermittent sniffles – which were still grossly wet – he gave her once last squeeze before placing his hands on her narrow shoulders, gently pushing her an arm’s length away, and peering down into her thoroughly blood-shot eyes. She looked really fucking awful – face red and swollen from crying, fresh tears and snot smeared on her freckled skin, and red hair an absolute shitshow – but Billy found that he was endeared rather than disgusted, fondness surging powerfully within his chest. Though he’d never considered admitting it – a few months ago he’d firmly believed that Maxine wouldn’t ever think of him as anything more than her unwanted step-brother – Billy loved his annoying shit of a little sister. Despite their frequent arguments and general impatience for each other’s various forms of bullshit, she’d managed to carve herself a place in his weak heart years ago.
If she could blurt out I love you without hesitation despite the fact that their – often contentious – relationship had never revolved around such overtly, disgustingly affectionate words or actions before, then Billy could, too. It was just three small words, one syllable each. Considering some of the things he’d accomplished recently – banishing the lingering echo of a dead teenager, flattening a decent chunk of woods, and enduring Henderson’s overly excited rant about the potential uses for psychometry without using the curly-haired nerd’s own hand knitted scarf to gag him – telling Maxine that he loved her too should be simple. Easy, even.
Clearing his throat, he said, “I- um.”
Shit, why was this so fucking hard?
Maxine frowned, pulling up the collar of her shirt and using it to wipe ineffectually at her face. “What?”
Billy swallowed thickly, trying and failing to unstick the words from inside his throat. Frustrated with his own inability to say three little fucking words – seriously, this wasn’t goddamned rocket science. Why couldn’t he just say it? – and aware that his stuttered silence was beginning to freak Maxine out, he waved a dismissive hand and schooled his expression into something less constipated. Billy stood and carefully stretched his arms up above his head – hiding a wince when his liver gave an unappreciative ache – casually avoiding his sister’s gaze. “It’s- nothing. You should try and go back to sleep.”
“No way.” She denied immediately – acting as if she hadn’t just stifled a jaw cracking yawn against her shoulder – shooting him a grimacing look that very clearly communicated how stupid she thought his suggestion was. “Can’t I just hang out in your room for a while?”
“What? No.”
“C’mon, Billy! I’ll just sit at your desk and- I don’t know, do homework or something.”
“It’s the middle of the night. On Christmas break.”
“So? Mrs Keaton’s a grinch who gave us way too much algebra to do.”
“Not my problem you suck at maths, shitbird.”
“Please? I’ll be so quiet you won’t even know I’m there.”
Billy was sorely tempted to continue refusing her – highly doubting that he’d be able to get any sleep if Maxine was loitering at his desk – but he could sense her steadily mounting unease, and he could see how she kept glancing back at her ruffled sheets like they were going to jump up and strangle her. His typically independent little sister was afraid to be alone, and even more afraid of falling back asleep. After a particularly brutal nightmare Billy was the same way, though more the latter than the former. He’d gotten used to being alone a long time ago.
Billy couldn’t find it within himself to leave her, especially not after the emotional rollercoaster she’d just forced him on. “Fine, you clingy little shit, but I’m kicking you the hell out if you make so much as a peep, understood?”
Grinning like a cat who just got the crème, Maxine bounced up onto her feet and darted over to her discarded school bag, rifling through it before yanking out a pencil case and a couple of slightly ratty notebooks. Billy stepped around her with a roll of his eyes, silent feet carrying him out of her bedroom.
Susan was standing slouched against the wall a couple of metres further down the hallway – effectively blocking their path to Billy’s room despite her thin frame – and she jolted upright when Billy strode into her line of sight. His cold glare halted the woman in her tracks when she moved to take a step closer, but to her credit she didn’t retreat, simply stood there in the relative darkness of the hall – wearing pyjamas that were far too threadbare to offer much warmth – and waited.
Billy turned back towards Maxine, who was busy pulling tissues from the box on her bedside table and wiping at the lingering snot on her face. “Hey.” He murmured, continuing only when she looked up to meet his gaze. “You wanna talk to your mom?”
“Um.” Her features creased with a juxtaposing mixture – that was fucking painful to witness – of longing and reluctance, pale eyes darting to the hallway beyond Billy in silent question. When he dipped his chin down in answer, Maxine hesitated for a long few moments before giving her head a resolute shake, nose scrunching in faint distaste.
Maxine and Susan had been relatively close when Billy first met them – something that had made him ache with bitter jealousy and anger – but that closeness had steadily been whittled down by a toxic combination of Neil’s draining influence and Susan’s sheer passivity. Now the pair of red-heads barely seemed to speak to each other, and when they did their conversations were almost always dull and short-lived, Maxine too resentful and Susan too weak to bridge the ever widening gap between them.
Understanding perfectly why Maxine didn’t want to speak with her, Billy waved her on. “Go to my room. I’ll be there in a minute.” He cut a sharp glance back towards Maxine’s mom, smiling pleasantly. “Susan and I are gonna have ourselves a little chat.”
If the circumstances were different Maxine would have vehemently protested being sent away – hating to be excluded, especially when she suspected that the conversation might involve her – but tonight his sister didn’t so much as hesitate before darting into the hallway, moving past her mom without even the slightest acknowledgement, and disappearing into Billy’s bedroom. Maxine closed the door nearly all the way shut behind her, and he didn’t doubt that the sneaky shit was doing her best to eavesdrop.
Susan watched her daughter go with an expression drenched in regret, reaching out but utterly failing to put in the effort required to make contact. Billy watched the pathetic display without an ounce of pity, folding his arms and cocking his head to the side. “What do you want, Susan?”
Her attention whipped back towards Billy fast enough that he was surprised she didn’t snap her own neck, outstretched arm dropping back to her side like the fact that she’d tried to reach out for her daughter was something to be ashamed of. “I-“ Susan cleared her throat when her voice came out in a croak, straightening her meekly bowed spine and meeting Billy’s narrowed stare with only minimal apprehension. “I wanted to make sure Max was alright.”
“She’s fine.” Billy lied flatly, sensing that at least the weak-willed woman was telling the truth. “Anything else?”
“Yes. I wanted to say thank you, Billy. For-"
Incredulous anger swiftly overriding the tenuous sense of composure he’d been managing to hold together, Billy barked out a harsh crow of laughter. She wanted to fucking thank him? For what, doing her goddamned job for her? “I’m gonna stop you right there, Susan. Your gratitude means less than nothing to me, got that? I don’t want to hear your empty bullshit, so why don’t you go get back in bed and pretend this never happened? Turning a blind eye’s what you’re best at, right?”
Susan wilted shamefully, pale features crumpling. “I’m sorry, Billy-"
“I’m not the one you should be apologising to.” Billy snapped harshly, utterly uninterested in accepting the woman’s piss-poor attempt at soothing her own conscience. It was years too late for Susan to dare offer him an I’m sorry, no matter how sincere the apology might be. “Your husband nearly hit Maxine tonight, and you did absolutely fuck all to try and stop him.”
Susan collapsed back against the wall, guilt-ridden tears welling up as she began to tremble finely. “I know, I know…”
“Fan-fucking-tastic. Guess I won’t have to spell out how much of a failure you are as a parent.” He shook his head, scoffing disdainfully as she refused to meet his gaze. Billy had fucking warned her, the first time they’d met. With Maxine busy in the McDonald’s play area and Neil using the restroom, he’d taken the opportunity to tell her that his dad was a bad man – that neither she nor her daughter would be happy with him in their lives –but Susan either hadn’t believed him, or she’d been too desperate for stability in the wake of her divorce to care overmuch for things like goodness, or happiness.
The first time she’d witnessed Neil smack him around – he’d failed to mow the lawn to standard before heading down to the beach for the afternoon – Billy had watched horrified realisation dawn on her pale face, and for a fraction of an instant he’d been stupid enough to actually hope. That she might do something, or even just say something. That she might help him, like his mom used to.
Susan had turned away, quickly striding out of the living room and escaping into the backyard. His left eye might have already been half-way to swelling shut, but Billy had still caught sight of the smooth mask of wilful ignorance she hadn’t fucking hesitated to put on. He remembered the absurd feeling of betrayal that had surged to life in his aching chest, followed swiftly by self-loathing so potent he’d nearly been sick with it. Neil had shoved him aside in favour of chasing after his new wife, and Billy had been left lying on the carpeted floor, desperately wondering what was so wrong with him that nobody cared.
Jesus, he remembered crying so hard in bed that night he really had thrown up. Trying to clean his sheets without waking up the rest of the house had been a nightmare, but he’d gotten through it, just like he always did. In pain, and alone.
Billy refused to help Susan shoulder her well-deserved shame and guilt, and he felt absolutely no pity for her, regardless of the fact that he understood why she was the way she was. She’d made her bed years ago, and a cruelly vindictive part of Billy hoped that she suffered as she was forced to lie in it.
Impatiently, he asked, “Are you done now?”
“Does- does she hate me?”
“She doesn’t trust or respect you.” Billy shrugged, watching dispassionately as Susan visibly winced. “But hate… well, why don’t you stop standing on the sidelines and find out for yourself?”
Sniffling – wiping uselessly as her leaking eyes – Susan gave a reluctant nod of her head. “I will.” She fearfully shifted her gaze past Billy and further down the hall, towards the front of the house. “Neil… he’s going to be-"
“I’ll take care of Neil.” He interrupted, hoping that the woman wasn’t thinking clearly enough to wonder how. The last thing he needed was Susan sticking her nose into his reckless – not to mention incredibly fucking supernatural – plan of action, which amounted to him psychically jumping into her husband’s head and erasing the last half an hour from his memory, assuming that was even possible. “Just- don’t ever mention what happened tonight, and I’ll make sure he doesn’t either.”
Content to remain ignorant – which had Billy’s jaw clenching with irritation even as relief loosened his shoulders – Susan nodded haltingly. “Okay. Will- will you be alright?”
“Like you give a fuck.” Billy spat unforgivingly. She didn’t get to pretend to care about him, not now, not after four years of silent complicity. He understood her reasoning and didn’t blame her for prioritising herself and Maxine, but that didn’t mean Billy was going to let her pretend to his fucking face that her shallow concern was anything other than a weak attempt at easing her own guilt.
Susan cringed, though her freckled features creased with determination – the expression immediately recognisable from all the countless times he’d seen it on Maxine’s face – a moment later. “Billy-"
“I don’t want to hear it, Susan.”
She obviously had more to say – brows furrowed, pale eyes conflicted, and lips pursed – but she kept quiet, instead slowly turning on her heal and walking towards the bedroom she shared with Neil. The door closed behind her with a soft click, and Billy exhaled a long sigh into the sudden empty darkness of the hall, running a hand through his short curls before passing it over his face, wincing when his split lip and fresh bruises made their complaints.
What a fucking mess.
Billy shoved open his subtly ajar bedroom door without giving any warning, smirking faintly when Maxine stumbled back with a startled curse and an annoyed glare. Billy merely raised his eyebrows in silent reprimand – if she was so eager to eavesdrop, then she needed to be better at it – and his sister subsided with a pout, moving over to stand awkwardly by his desk. She grabbed the back of his desk chair and spun it for a moment, lips twisting pensively. “So… that sounded kinda tense.”
“We’re not talking about it.” He replied flatly, stepping further into his room and jamming his socked feet into the first pair of shoes he saw, which were his too small runners. Billy’s issues with Susan were his, and his alone. He wasn’t about to discuss them with the woman’s daughter, uninterested in contributing to the deterioration of their relationship. Susan had her problems, but up until tonight she’d done a good enough job at keeping Maxine safe, if not happy.
After losing his own mom – the indescribable pain of it – Billy didn’t want to see his sister do or say anything that she couldn’t take back.
Shoes mostly secure – he didn’t care enough to tie them up, just wanted to protect his feet from freezing when he went outside – Billy looked up to meet Maxine’s confused gaze. “Stay here, shitbird. I’ll be back.”
Maxine stood up in a rush, tense and wide-eyed. “Are you- is it Neil? What’re you gonna do? I’m coming with y-"
“Like hell you are.” Billy cut her off, raising a hand in a sharp motion when she opened her mouth to argue. “No, shut up. I need to concentrate, and I can’t do that if you’re leaking anxiety all over the place-"
“Leaking- you can read my emotions? Billy, you didn’t tell me you could do that!” She all but shrieked, holding her hands tightly against her temples, as if that would stop his telepathy. His sixth sense had a bad habit of tuning itself into whatever strong emotions were nearby, like some kind of fucked-up defence mechanism, or something. When he’d asked El about it she’d shrugged – never having experienced the same difficulty when it came to her own telepathy, which she explained was always on, just in a very mild capacity – and told him that he needed to find a balance, whatever that cryptic bullshit meant.
Billy brought a finger up to his lips, cursing himself for opening his damn mouth. Maxine would never let him hear the end of this now, and he was already sick of her theatrics. “Can you keep your fucking voice down?”
Wincing – eyes briefly darting to the hallway beyond his room – she continued in a whispering hiss. “That’s an invasion of privacy, Billy! Not cool!”
“Oh fuck off, Maxine. It’s not like I want to feel your teen angst.” He snapped back in a low murmur, poking between her eyebrows and sneering when she jerked her head backwards with an offended scowl. “I’m working on it, alright? This telepathy shit’s got a mind of its own.”
Maxine eyed him suspiciously, hands still pressed to her temples. “You promise you’re not doing it on purpose?”
Billy rolled his eyes, “Yes, Maxine. I promise. I don’t wanna be in your head any more than you wanna be in mine.”
“Well… good, then.” She muttered, slowly lowering her hands and shifting a little bit awkwardly on her feet. “Uh, about Neil-"
“I’ll take care of Neil.” Billy assured easily, steady in the knowledge that one way or the other – either via memory wipe or sheer psychic brute force – Neil would be leaving Maxine alone regarding everything that had happened tonight, screamed obscenities and nut shot included. “Don’t worry about it.”
Tentatively, Maxine sought to clarify, “You’re gonna use your powers?”
Billy clicked his tongue, “I just told you not to worry about it.” He pointed at his desk, its surface cluttered with a stack of new cassettes – Metallica, Whitesnake, KISS – a few school books, an array of lead pencils of varying lengths, and a lot of eraser shavings. “Sit your ass down. I’ll be back in a bit.”
“Wait!” His sister rushed around him and planted herself in the doorway, feet shoulder width apart and skinny arms spread wide. Maxine’s pale eyes darted between his nervously, unease written into every line of her slight frame. “Wait. Whatever you’re gonna do, will you be okay? You passed out for like four hours at Hopper’s the other day, and after the tunnels-"
“Jesus- Maxine, quit stressing.” He smirked faintly, bemused – and reluctantly warmed – by her genuine concern, even as it pricked at his pride. Billy wasn’t weak, or delicate, and he sure as shit wasn’t going to pass out every damned time he used his fucked-up powers. “I know what I’m doing.”
She arched an eyebrow, not budging an inch. “You just said you couldn’t properly control your telepathy.”
“I said it had a mind of its own-"
“Which is exactly what I just said.”
“Is fucking not.” Billy griped, irritated. “I can control it. It just takes a bit of concentration-"
“Then you should control it all the time! I don’t want you to know what I’m feeling!”
“Trust me, shitbird. I don’t need to read your mind when your pale ass turns that red-"
Making an intelligible sound of aggravation, Maxine sent a retaliatory jab at his midsection, face flushing an amusing shade of pink. Usually Billy would let it land – unconcerned by her half-hearted attacks and trusting that she’d never lash out at him intending to do genuine harm – but her loosely curled fist was heading in the general direction of his fresh bruise and Billy was not keen on being hit in the same spot twice within the span of twenty minutes.
He caught her fist before it could connect, though he was quick to let go when she startled and shot him a wide-eyed look. “You’re fine, Maxine. I’m just- never mind.” Billy waved a hand, itching to escape from beneath his sister’s abruptly scrutinising gaze and eager to get this psychic bullshit with Neil over and done with. “Can you move already? I’ve got shit to do.”
“What’s wrong?” She demanded to know, narrowing her eyes at his midsection like she might suddenly develop x-ray vision if she just stared hard enough. “Did Neil hit you somewhere other than your face? Have you got bruised ribs again?”
“I’m fine.” Billy groused, reaching out and grasping Maxine’s extended wrists. He forced her arms back down by her sides, shifted his grip to her shoulders, and then proceeded to physically move her out of his way. Maxine allowed his manhandling with all the grace of someone who knew they weren’t strong enough to fight against it – that, plus the fact that she was now unnecessarily concerned about injuring him – pouting and dragging her feet as much as she could. Once she was standing to the side of his door rather than in front of it, Billy gave her a sly grin and a solid pat on the head. “Stay.”
“I’m not a dog, you giant asshole.”
Billy snorted, nodding in agreement. “You got that right. A dog would be way better behaved than you.” When she hissed out an affronted screw you – eyes narrowed in a glare and shoulders tensed up – his snort transformed into a brief but real chuckle. “You’re more like a feral kitten, anyway.”
His sister’s annoyance faded somewhat at the sound of his laughter, her glare softening back into a vaguely displeased – and very grudgingly amused – look. “You’re hilarious.” She snarked, looking him up and down before tapping her chin in a theatrically thoughtful pose. “If I’m a cat, then you’re a… raccoon! With rabies. You’ve even got those dark circles under your eyes, too.”
Taken off guard – a fucking rabies riddled racoon, seriously? – Billy blinked down at her for a long moment before cracking a reluctantly impressed grin, feeling both proud and offended by how quickly she’d fired back. He’d undoubtedly make her regret her cheek at some point in the near future, but for now he’d let her enjoy her little victory, not above admitting that her comeback had been a good one. “Whatever, shitbird. I’ll be back.”
Elated grin dimming in an instant – it was not often that Maxine could keep up with him when it came to exchanging insults – his sister reached out a hand and snagged the hem of his shirt, once again stopping him from leaving. Her gaze was searching when Billy met it, and quietly fear-leaden. “You’ll be careful, right?”
“’course.” Billy didn’t hesitate to answer, for once in his life planning to be exceedingly cautious. He absolutely could not afford for his psychic fuckery to fail, not when Maxine’s wellbeing was on the line.
His sister nodded, though her lips were still pursed unhappily. “If you’re not back in ten minutes, I’m coming out to make sure you haven’t gotten one of those… what did Dr Owens call them? Anu- enema…”
Slapping a hand over his swollen mouth to smother the unattractive cackle that jumped up his throat – an enema, Jesus H Christ his little sister could be so hilariously stupid – Billy shook his head incredulously and clarified, “An aneurysm?”
“Yeah, that.” Maxine frowned, eyeing his smirk dubiously. “What’s so funny?”
“I dare you to ask your science teacher what an enema is.”
“What is it?”
“I’m not fucking telling you.”
His sister just rolled her eyes, clearly deciding not to engage with his deliberately vague teasing. “Whatever, Billy. I was serious, though. If you’re not back in ten minutes I’m coming after you.”
Highly doubting that his latest foray into Neil’s disgusting mind would take longer than five minutes – unless he really did have an aneurysm, in which case he’d be too busy dying to give a shit – Billy flicked his wrist dismissively. “Ten minutes. Fine.”
He made to turn away, but tension on his shirt made him stop and look down, sighing in exasperation when he saw that Maxine was still holding onto him. Billy shot her an unimpressed glance and arched an eyebrow. “You gonna let go, or what?”
“Oh.” His sister was quick to release him, freckles cheeks flushing with embarrassment. She ducked her head down and clasped her hands in front of her, fingers threading and fidgeting. “Sorry.”
“Maxine, look at me.” Billy ordered quietly, heartstrings tugging at the uncharacteristically meek display.
After a brief hesitation his sister did as he said, and he held her pale stare with a serious one of his own. “You don’t need to worry, alright? I’ve been dealing with Neil for longer than you’ve been alive, and now I can squeeze his brain with a fucking thought.” When Maxine still didn’t look convinced – brows drawn down and lips pressed into a tense line – Billy sighed, disappointed but not entirely surprised. Bracing himself for a negative answer – or worse, a lie – he bluntly asked, “Do you trust me?”
“Yes.” Maxine answered easily, truthfully.
Billy didn’t let himself smile, but his stupid heart felt about three sizes too big within his chest and it was a very near thing, cheeks stinging with the repressed urge. “Good. Then trust me when I tell you that I’ll be fine.”
“Your definition of fine isn’t exactly the best, Billy.” She quipped, some of the sombreness surrounding her lifting as she managed a slight smirk.
“It’s good enough.” Billy retorted, grasping her closest shoulder and giving her a light push towards his desk. “Now sit down and do your homework. I’ll be back in a bit to see how much of a dumbass you are.”
His sister rolled her eyes, even as she moved to collapse into his uncomfortable desk chair. “Yes mom.”
Giving the ends of her hair a light tug – snickering as she cursed him out – Billy turned on his heel and left his bedroom without looking back, relaxed expression tightening into something ruthlessly calculating as he rolled out his shoulders and clenched his hands into white-knuckled fists by his sides. For Maxine’s sake – but also for Susan’s, and even his own to an extent – he couldn’t fail.
He wouldn’t.
Billy shoved open the front door, stepping out into the moonlit front yard with a shudder of both cold and unease. Neil was standing just beyond the porch – bare feet steeped in the light layer of snow coating the grass – and at the sound of the door creaking open he turned to level Billy with a mocking sneer. The sickly pallor of his skin took some of the menace from the expression, as did the snow collecting in his hair and facial scruff. When Neil spoke his voice shook subtly with repressed shivers, and Billy had to bite at his freshly split lip in order to keep himself from smiling with cruel satisfaction. “You got something to say to me, boy?”
A powerful sense of resentment burned through him – roaring past his ears and sending his heart into double-time – heating his rushing blood to the point that he hardly even felt the frigid winter breeze brushing over his skin and through his clothes. He walked forward until he was standing almost toe to toe with Neil, dread curdling in his stomach even as he forced himself to look up and meet the man’s hateful green eyes.
“Fuck you.” Billy spat viciously, taking a fraction of a moment to savour the way his dad’s stern features twitched with shocked rage before steeling his resolve and mercilessly launching himself into Neil’s head.
