Chapter Text
Steve’s parents weren’t going to be in town for his graduation ceremony.
The soon to be Hawkins High graduate pretended their absence didn’t bother him – insisting there wasn’t much to celebrate anyway, considering his barely passing grades – but Billy could tell how much it hurt him to know they didn’t care enough to be present for what was literally a once in a lifetime event.
Despite having spent most of his time in Hawkins with at least one overly emotional idiot in close proximity, Billy still wasn’t any good at offering comfort, his words escaping with a clumsy bluntness that made him sound like even more of an uncaring dick than he really was. He’d tried to console the senior’s resigned misery – actually, legitimately tried – but Steve made the already difficult task practically fucking impossible by refusing to acknowledge in the first place that he was resignedly miserable. After a circular conversation that went fucking nowhere, Billy had let Steve’s conspicuous as fuck change of topic slide with nothing more than a narrow-eyed look, only half listening as he started bitching about not being rehired as a lifeguard over the summer.
A job that Billy’s surfing background and falsely pleasant interview personality had cinched with ease, though he’d very magnanimously refrained from shoving that fact in the senior’s face. For now.
The thought of Steve walking across that shoddily constructed stage – in front of his entire year and their obnoxious families – to accept his diploma without a single person there to support him made Billy’s heart twist behind his clenching ribs.
Steve deserved so much fucking better than that. Deserved better than to be brushed aside and ignored, as if graduating high school didn’t matter. As if he didn’t matter. If the neglectful pieces of shit who called themselves his parents weren’t going to put in the effort to make sure Steve knew he was valued, then Billy would.
Besides, it wasn’t as if he was unfamiliar with stepping up when parents failed to actually fucking parent.
Getting Maxine and her collection of dweeb friends on board with attending was surprisingly easy. All Billy had to do was casually mention the Harrington’s absence in front of Maxine once, and she’d all but jumped on the unvoiced invitation. Eager to embarrass Steve in front of a sizable crowd but mostly just pissed on his behalf – the angered rant she’d gone on sparking pride in Billy’s chest – his sister had taken it upon herself to skate to Lucas’ house that very afternoon, who’d then used his walkie-talkie to communicate the date and time with the other nerds.
Henderson and Will took no convincing, while Wheeler – to the surprise of absolutely no one – whined about how stupid he thought the idea was before reluctantly agreeing. El had been bitterly disappointed when told she couldn’t attend, but Will’s request for help with the decently sized sign he was making helped to ease her bad mood.
Billy had caught a glimpse of the half-finished, glittery eyesore while dropping Maxine off to Hopper’s cabin one morning, and the thought of Steve’s face when he saw the finished product had him grinning for the majority of the drive back to Cherry Lane.
After hearing from her asshole of a little brother that Steve’s parents weren’t going to be around, Wheeler senior decided she also needed to be there for the ceremony, which all but guaranteed her creeper boyfriend’s presence as well.
Irritated but aware that Steve would be glad – if a bit awkward, the overly forgiving dork – to see them, Billy didn’t complain, though the smirk Maxine aimed his way after breaking the news made it clear she knew exactly how he felt about the development.
Cheeky little shit.
Despite Maxine’s heated protests, he left deliberately late to pick up Lucas on the day of the ceremony. Arriving early enough to hear whatever outdated piece Mrs Delaney had selected for the band to play - or worse, the bland as fuck speeches - was not on his agenda for the day. After finding a park they made their way to Hawkins High’s gymnasium, Billy’s pace remaining sedate no matter how aggressively his sister tried to convince him to move faster. They entered through one of the creaking sets of double doors built into the back of the gym, both its drawn-out squeak and Maxine’s mortified hissing drowned out by Principal Higgins’ echoing, droning monotone.
As Billy had known they would be, all of the fold-out seating was already taken, which left them to join the small crowd forced to stand at the very back of the hall. Maxine and her little boyfriend were quick to locate the other three nerds, darting over to join their huddle in front of Wheeler and Byers.
Billy stood a safe, plausibly deniable distance away – stance casual and hands tucked into his pockets – not wanting to be associated with the odd collection of social pariahs. The kid’s loud whispering was already drawing disapproving backwards looks from the people seated in front of them, and Billy exhaled a silent breath of laughter as Bitch Wheeler failed to quiet them, cheeks pink as she grimaced apologetically.
It was humid enough inside the gym that Billy actually pitied all the seniors stuck wearing their long, ugly as fuck dark-green robes, though that didn’t stop him from finding mean-spirited amusement in the guy’s sweat slick faces and the girl’s smudged make-up. With a graduation cap obscuring his conspicuous as fuck head of hair it took Billy a few moments to find where Steve was standing in the line of seniors against the right wall, and his amusement sharpened into something far harsher when he noticed Tommy ‘The Drunk Driver’ Hagan beside him.
Considering the seniors were lined up in alphabetical order it only made sense that the former friends were standing nearly shoulder to shoulder, yet Billy couldn’t help the way his temper spiked at seeing that petty little jealous bitch in such close proximity to Steve. They were both refusing to look at the other, posture stiff and expressions uncomfortable – not that he gave a single fuck about what Hagan was feeling – and suddenly Billy wanted this whole thing over not because it was hot and overcrowded, but because Steve being forced to share such prolonged close proximity with the guy who’d not only tried to run them off the fucking road a few months ago, but also called him a fag? It wasn’t right, especially not today.
Billy’s fingers twitched, energy prickling restlessly beneath his skin as he fought down the urge to try and replicate El’s bladder trick on the freckled shithead.
Once Higgins was finished trying to bore everyone to death with his bullshit platitudes about the future, Ms Kelly stepped up to the podium and began calling the graduates forward to collect their diplomas. Cheers from friends and family members went up for each student as they walked the stage, but nothing was anywhere near as loud as the overexcited holler Henderson let out when Steve’s name was finally announced. “Hell yeah! Go Steve!”
Momentarily stunned by Henderson’s enthusiasm but unwilling to be outshined, Maxine, Lucas and Will each shouted their own eager exclamations, clumsily holding up the glittery poster they’d made between them and waving it through the air.
“Woohoo!”
“Congratulations!”
“Totally never doubted you!”
Byers senior clapped his hands with a quirked smile – apparently immune to public humiliation – while Wheeler just shook her head with a helpless laugh, raising her arms and clapping her own hands loudly above her head.
Mike didn’t contribute, looking for all the world like he wished the floor would open up and swallow him whole.
Billy was vaguely aware that the collective focus of the entire gymnasium was now turned towards Steve’s overly enthusiastic fan club, but he was too focused on Steve to pay much attention to the mixture of amusement and mild confusion being aimed their way. The senior had frozen halfway up the stairs leading to the temporary stage, head turned towards the cheering kids with his eyes blown wide and his jaw hanging open. Steve’s shock was quick to shift to a giddy sense of delighted awkwardness, face reddening at an impressive rate as his gaze zeroed in on the sign they were waving around like idiots.
HAPPY GRADUATION STEVE!
Flashing his pearly whites in a beaming grin, Steve tore his gaze away from the glittery monstrosity and scanned the back of the gymnasium until he found Billy’s amused smirk among the crowd. Arm twitching by his side like he wanted to wave but realised Billy wouldn’t appreciate the attention doing so would draw, Steve instead cocked his head, absently blowing his cap’s tassel out of his face as he did so.
Expression giving nothing away, Billy held Steve’s expectant stare and shrugged, pretending like he had no idea what the senior was silently trying to ask.
“Steve?” Ms Kelly prompted, smiling pleasantly as she waved for him to continue his walk towards Principal Higgins, who was impatiently holding out his diploma.
Flushing all over again – sending a charming, undaunted smile towards his fellow graduates when a chorus of chuckles and mild heckling broke out – Steve hopped up the steps and strode with perfect confidence across the stage, spine straight and broad shoulders rolled back. He accepted his diploma with an eager nod and a hearty handshake, turning to aim yet another blindingly bright grin towards Maxine and the nerds when they let loose some more obnoxiously supportive shouting.
Billy exited the gym as soon as Steve found his designated seat and planted his ass down on it, itching for a cigarette and uninterested in watching the rest of his friend’s year receive their own diplomas. The kids immediately moved to follow – equally as bored by the ceremony now Steve’s part was done – while Wheeler and Byers trailed more slowly after them, clearly more affected by the censure of the observing staff members.
Sucking in a deep lungful of fresh air, Billy moved a good few metres away from the gymnasium’s double doors, not wanting to be caught in the rush of people once the ceremony concluded. He leant his back against the wall – kicking his right leg back to rest the sole of his boot against it – fetching his cigarettes and lighter from his pockets. For reasons he couldn’t fathom, Maxine and the nerds chose to crowd around him rather than Wheeler and Byers, which was both irritating and strangely satisfying.
Will carefully rolled up the poster he and El had spent so much time on, smiling when the younger Wheeler gave his shoulder a pat. “Do you think Steve liked it?”
Maxine scoffed, “Did you see his face? He freaking loved it, don’t worry.”
“Of course he did, we’re awesome.” Henderson nodded, pudgy cheeks rounding further as he turned towards Billy with a sly smile. “This was a great idea.”
Billy arched an eyebrow, blowing a plume of smoke in the curly-haired dweeb’s direction and smirking at the way his nose scrunched up in disgust. “Wasn’t mine, Henderson.”
The kid waved a hand through the foggy air between them before levelling him with a disbelieving stare. “Uh-huh, so you just coincidentally happened to mention to Max that Steve’s parents were still gonna be out of town for his graduation?”
“Yep,” Billy deadpanned, taking another drag of his cigarette. Feeling benevolent, he turned his head away to exhale his next breath of nicotine laced smoke.
“Right,” Lucas said, folding his arms and drawing the word out doubtfully.
Maxine rolled her eyes. “Careful, guys. Billy’s deathly allergic to being called nice- hey!”
Clamping his smoke between his teeth, Billy looped an arm around his little sister’s neck and tugged her against his side, rubbing his knuckles against the top of her head in a ruthless noogie. “You say something, shitbird?”
She struggled in vain to free herself, spitting like a furious kitten as she kicked at his shins and sent a flurry of half-hearted jabs at his stomach. Giving up after a pathetic fifteen seconds of flailing, Maxine changed strategy, prioritising trying to protect her scalp. “You’re messing up my hair. Let me go!”
Grinning tauntingly, Billy flicked his bemused gaze between the dorks, who were all watching his sister’s plight with varying degrees of sympathy. “What, nobody’s ballsy enough to try and help her?”
“We’re not dumb enough to get in the middle of-” Lucas cut himself off, hand lurching in a gesture that encompassed both Hargrove siblings – Billy pressing a palm to Maxine’s forehead, holding her flushed face upright so she couldn’t bite into his forearm – as he grimaced like he’d just been dared to place himself between a pair of wild animals. “That. Max understands.”
“Some boyfriend you are,” Maxine muttered, ceasing her efforts to sink her teeth into the fabric of Billy’s button down with an annoyed grumble. She hid her amusement at Lucas’ wariness behind a scowl that immediately prompted him to wince with uncertain guilt, the boy clearly unsure whether she was joking or not. “You all tackled Steve when he was going to splash El in the pool!”
Wheeler shook his head. “That’s way different. Steve’s a giant pushover, and Billy’s-”
“Capable of turning our brains into jelly with a thought!” Henderson interrupted with a warning glance at his gangly friend, smart enough to cut him off before he had the chance to say something Billy would make him regret. The sour shitheel huffed but didn’t try to continue speaking, instead spinning on his heel to stare impatiently at the closed gym doors. Once Henderson was satisfied Wheeler wasn’t about to sign his own death warrant with whatever bitchy comment he’d been about to spout, he turned his focus back to Billy and Maxine with a chipper, unconcerned smile. “Besides, it’s not like you’re actually hurting her, or anything.”
Maxine scowled harder, curling her fingers around the forearm Billy still had locked over her collarbones. “My pride it hurting.”
Billy snorted, making absolutely no move to release the snarky little shit. “You’ve got yourself a lame bunch of friends, Maxine.”
“I know,” she sighed sullenly, ducking her head to hide her grin when said lame friends all squawked their vehement protests.
Shaking his head with a fond smile – wisely refusing to rise to either of the Hargrove’s bait – Will stepped forward and lightly tapped Billy’s elbow. “Could you please release our zoomer?”
“And why should I do that, baby Byers?”
“Um, because your cigarette’s about to burn your lips?”
Having forgotten the thing was still hanging from his mouth, Billy released Maxine’s forehead – stomping lightly on her foot when she shamelessly took the opportunity to chomp down on his arm – and snagged what remained of its smouldering form between his fingers. The cigarette was nearly down to the filter, and Billy sucked in one last lungful of smoke before flicking it to the ground, flipping Nancy off when she voiced her disapproval loud enough for him to hear. “Alright, nerd. I’ll make you a deal.”
Will tilted his head – his godawful haircut swaying with the movement – dark eyes glinting amusedly. “I’m listening.”
Brows lifting at the unexpected sass, Billy couldn’t help but grin. “You draw something for me, and I’ll let Maxine go.”
“What do you want me to draw?” The boy asked eagerly, thin fingers twitching like he was already itching to wrap them around a pencil.
Maxine groaned and knocked her head back against Billy’s upper arm, having quickly realised gnawing on his arm wasn’t worth enduring the stale taste of old cotton. She shot Will a somewhat pleading look. “Can you please just agree? Ideally before everyone comes out and sees this idiot holding me hostage!”
“Oh- right,” Will tried to look serious, though the twitching of his mouth immediately belied his attempt. He held out his hand towards the junior, cheeks faintly pink. “I agree to your terms.”
“So long as you don’t try to make him draw anything- weird.” Wheeler was quick to cut in, glaring up at Billy suspiciously.
Billy ignored his snippy interjection despite being morbidly curious as to what a kid like Wheeler – who’d been through some truly fucked-up interdimensional bullshit – classified as weird, reaching out and gently clasping Will’s small hand within his own in a firm shake. Billy already had an idea of what he wanted the kid to draw, but like hell was he going to ask him in front of all his loudmouthed friends.
Maxine ducked out of his hold the fucking second he loosened it, running her fingers through her easily knotted red locks and scowling prissily. Billy rolled his eyes at his sister’s dramatics, and then rolled them again when Lucas gave her a smitten little smile and assured her that her hair still looked pretty. Maxine pretended not to care, but the blush colouring her pale cheeks instantly gave away her pleasure. Billy sneered in mild disgust at the scene, unable to decide whether he wanted to barf or demand they break up immediately. Doing neither – exercising his self-control mostly for Maxine’s benefit – he lit yet another smoke and listened with half an ear as the kids began chattering about random shit Billy didn’t care about.
Over the next twenty minutes Billy went through two more cigarettes, trying to shore up his fraying patience as the dweeb’s conversation turned to harmless but irritating bickering. Maxine switched between mediator and shit stirrer as she pleased, and the wicked smirks she discreetly sent Billy’s way whenever she successfully riled Henderson or Wheeler did wonders to keep his temper on the mellower side.
Even without the free entertainment Maxine provided, all he had to do in order to combat his mounting desire to leave was imagine the way Steve’s expression would crumple with disappointment – and it was a strange thrill, to know with such certainty that Steve would be disappointed – when he realised Billy hadn’t bothered to stick around.
Enough people had disappointed him today. Billy wasn’t going to be one of them.
Sensing the crowd within begin moving towards the exits, Billy pushed himself up out of his casual lean against the side of the gymnasium. He watched impassively as everyone filed outside, the mingling graduates easy to spot in their ridiculous outfits.
Stella spotted Billy from her place amongst a family of similarly featured blondes, foundation-covered cheeks flushing a barely visible red when he shot her a lazy wave and an even lazier smirk. Heather had demanded his presence at the party she was throwing to celebrate the mouthy bimbo’s long awaited departure from the cheer squad - a party that, for once, he was genuinely eager to attend - and Billy was already planning to drag Steve along with him when he went.
“Is that the girl who tried to ask you out a few months ago?” Maxine asked, giving Stella a thoroughly judgemental once over as she took a half-step to the left, placing herself in front of Billy like some kind of pint-sized shield. Which was fucking stupid, because why would he need protecting from a small-town cow like Stella? It wasn’t like the older girl was going to approach him, anyway. Not after he’d humiliated her at Tina’s New Year’s party, and definitely not while he was surrounded by a group of loud, weird as fuck middle-schoolers.
Steve better appreciate the hit his social standing was going to take after this.
Billy just hummed in answer, planting his palm on the crown of his sister’s head and bodily moving her aside, ignoring her swatting hands. He vaguely recalled a brief run-in with Stella by his Camaro early into their move to Hawkins, but he didn’t think she’d ever been bold enough to actually ask him out. Ask for sex, sure, but never for a date.
He wasn’t the kind of guy anyone would ever want to take home to meet their parents.
Maxine huffed, ducking out from under his hand. “She still wears way too much mascara.”
“And you’re still a little bitch,” Billy grinned, tone approving.
A few freshly graduated seniors – mostly the small clique of heavily made-up girls who’d gravitated towards Stella’s beckoning hands and shrilly whispering mouth – aimed dubious glances Billy’s way, no doubt wondering firstly what he was doing there, and secondly why he was tolerating a bunch of children invading his prized personal space.
A year ago he would have sent the nerds crying to their moms without a shred of remorse, valuing how he was perceived by those around him far above their infantile little feelings. Now? Billy was confident his reputation could weather some gossip, and shared traumatic experiences meant that he actually kind of cared about the shitheads – Will more than the other three, and Wheeler’s whiny ass least of all – currently surrounding him.
It was like he’d caught some creepy, reversed version of Stockholm syndrome, or something.
“You’re lucky,” Henderson muttered, somewhere between resigned and wistful as he did his best not to make it obvious that he was staring. “Nobody that pretty would ever ask me out.”
Maxine and Lucas both winced, awkwardly patting the curly-haired dweeb on each of his slumped shoulders.
Will cast Billy a nervous look before turning his gaze back to Stella and her small posse of unrepentant gossips, fidgeting in place. “I think they’re talking about you.”
“People usually are,” Billy replied with deliberate nonchalance, forcing levity into his voice and an arrogant grin onto his lips. Truthfully a large part of him itched to escape the unwanted attention – skin prickling as his jaw clenched with subdued irritation – but he’d long since accepted that Stella’s particular brand of scrutiny was the price he paid in order to avoid more probing, more revealing kinds of attention.
The smallest of the nerds relaxed somewhat, taking Billy’s posturing at face value.
“They’re probably dying to come over here.” Lucas stated with a dumb smile, slinging an arm over Wheeler’s bony shoulders and putting on a self-important air. “But we’re just- way too intimidatingly good looking.”
Wheeler scoffed, though the corners of his lips curled upwards. “Right. Totally.”
“Not intimidating enough. Shit.” Henderson hissed, reaching to pull down a cap he wasn’t wearing. He patted his curls in a panic, looking like he was moments away from darting over to where Nancy and Jonathan were standing so he could hide behind them. “They’re walking towards us! Abort, abort!”
Billy exhaled a silently surprised sigh, fetching yet another cigarette as he watched Stella and her friends begin making a beeline through the crowd towards him. Judging by the coldly determined expression on her face she wanted to pay him back for the embarrassment he’d so casually subjected her to at Tina’s party. Stella could hold a fucking grudge – which was something Billy could reluctantly respect – and the nerds had provided her with the perfect opportunity to try and settle it.
“She looks pissed,” Lucas pointed out, slightly uneasy but mostly just confused.
“No shit, genius,” Wheeler muttered, weathering the annoyed smack Lucas gave his chest with a monotone ow.
Will tensed nervously, shrinking in on himself as his fingers twisted together. “Why is she angry at you?”
The junior shrugged a shoulder, lighting his latest cigarette and taking a long, preparative drag. Hoping to ease the boy’s obvious anxiety, Billy ruffled his unfortunate bowl cut. “I forgot her name a couple of times. Don’t worry about it, pipsqueak.”
Maxine snorted, though her amused grin was quick to shift into an apprehensive glower as she waved off the subtly smoggy air left in the wake of his exhale. “You seriously shouldn’t smoke so much, Billy.”
He ignored her complaining with practiced ease, tucking his lighter away and stepping forward. The dweeb squad might be annoying as hell - Will as always the exception - but Billy wasn’t about to let Stella and her hangers-on ambush the kids with whatever catty bullshit they no doubt had sitting primed on their tongues.
Wheeler would probably handle the confrontation fine, and Lucas was decent at hiding his discomfort, but Henderson was liable to become emotional and Billy wanted to avoid having to deal with that at all costs.
Babysitter senses tingling, Steve appeared out of fucking nowhere between Billy and the rapidly approaching ex-cheerleaders. He granted Billy a fleeting but incandescently happy smile – the junior felt the ridiculous need to squint against the sheer brightness of it – before spinning to face his would-be hecklers. He held his arms out in greeting, still tightly clutching his diploma in his right hand. “Ladies! Wow, you all look incredible.”
Billy’s jaw twitched, teeth grinding as he folded his arms and blew out a heavy plume of smoke. Steve’s words were only partially honest, yet he still felt an unignorable thrum of pique whip through his chest to hear them spoken.
With the charm dialled all the way up to eleven the three girls standing at Stella’s sides didn’t stand a chance, cheeks turning rosy as they batted their lashes and made unsubtle adjustments to their product stiff hair. Stella was far from immune, though she managed to make less of a fool of herself than her supposed friends. Simpering, the ex-cheerleader flicked her gaze over Steve’s shoulder, eyes narrowing when she saw Billy’s bored expression. “Thanks, Steve. If you’d excuse me for a second, I wanted to have a quick chat with Billy.”
“Oh, sure. He’s always such a popular guy.” Steve chuckled – the light-hearted sound ringing emptily in Billy’s ears – feet remaining planted exactly where they were. “You might have to put a pin in that for now, though. Your parents are trying to get your attention.”
Sure enough, the pair of bleach blonde adults Stella had left behind were directing expectant stares their daughter’s way. Her mom’s tightly fitted shirt put her unnaturally round tits on full display, and she pretended – badly, pride in every haughty line of her face – not to notice the gawking men around her as she beckoned Stella back. Her dad seemed more interested in meeting Steve’s gaze, flashing too-perfect teeth in a bland smile that the freshly graduated senior returned without sincerity.
Some of Steve’s parents’ asshole friends, probably.
Stella glowered as her friends each oriented themselves back towards their gathered families, clearly already anticipating her compliance. For a moment Billy thought she’d simply turn on her ridiculously tall heels and leave without another word, but then she smiled, blinking innocently as she cocked her head at Steve. “I’m sure they can wait a few minutes. I couldn’t help but notice your parents aren’t here, Steve. Why not?”
With his back to him Billy couldn’t see Steve’s face, but he could see the way his broad shoulders flinched like he’d just been hit, spine curving as he ducked his head and ran an uncomfortable hand through his hair. His posture screamed shame-sorrow-embarrassment almost as loudly as his flailing mind, and Billy stalked the few steps needed to place himself by his side in a fucking instant. One hand coming up to press against the older boy’s lower back – the touch shifting from absentminded to deliberate when he felt some of the tightness wracking through Steve ease – Billy plucked his cigarette from his lips with the other. Blowing smoke in Stella’s face, he discarded the butt on the ground between them with a blasé smile, casually tucking both hands into his jeans pockets despite the powerful desire to keep a palm held protectively over Steve’s spine.
Anger disguised behind mild curiosity; he ignored the ex-cheerleader’s pissy glare and spoke up into the tense quiet her pointed taunt had created. “I gotta ask, Stacey. How many boob jobs did it take your mom to look like that? I’m guessing at least three.”
Steve snorted, shooting Billy an incredulous grin that he was quick to try and smother into a slightly less obvious smile. Behind them Henderson failed to quiet his high-pitched giggle, Wheeler muttered a grudgingly impressed damn, and Maxine let loose a low whistle that was quickly echoed by Lucas.
Will remained silent, too uneasy to find any amusement in the confrontation unfolding before him.
Far less entertained – the pushy blonde was fucking fuming, nostrils flared and lips pressed into a dark red line – Stella flicked her permed hair over her shoulder with a sneer. “I wasn’t talking to you, Hargrove.”
“Huh. I thought the whole reason you came over here was to talk to me.”
“Well- you’re wrong,” She lied, flustered but determined to save face. “I have nothing to say to a nobody like you.”
“Ouch,” Billy brought a hand up to his chest with a sigh. “Sarah, you’re breaking my heart.”
Just like he’d known it would, his casual use of the wrong name sent her into a spiral of furious disbelief, the girl unable to wrap her insipid little head around the fact that someone – someone like Billy, who’d spent his first few weeks in Hawkins smiling and flirting and doing whatever it took to fit in with the popular assholes – had the gall to show such blatant and repeated disrespect. Especially in front of her friends. She pointed a rigid finger at his chest, the sharp tip of her perfectly manicured nail digging into his chest. “You know my name’s Stella!”
Those close enough to overhear her pitchy shout all turned to stare, which immediately had Stella backing down with a humiliated flush. She hissed something at her equally as embarrassed friends, and Billy was cruelly pleased when the blonde refused to meet either his or Steve’s eyes before she turned to stride away, doing what she could to salvage what was left of her pride.
She might have succeeded, if Billy hadn’t simultaneously snapped both the high heels off her offensively pink shoes.
Stella collapsed like a poorly stacked house of cards, letting out a startled squeal as her heels failed to take her weight, breaking away from the soles of her shoes like they’d never been connected at all. With absolutely no fucking chance of finding her balance in time to remain standing – arms pinwheeling uselessly as she tried to latch onto her friends for stability – Stella fell flat on her back. Hard.
There were gasps from the spectators around them, pity and surprise and a growing undercurrent of amusement swirling through the air. Billy revelled in it.
He peered down at Stella impassively, studying the ugly combination of her red face, agape mouth – the wind having been well and truly knocked out of her – and rapidly tearing eyes. Her nameless friends were quick to kneel and begin struggling to pull the stunned girl up, and despite the shot Stella had so ruthlessly taken at Steve’s absent parents, the fancy-haired softie didn’t hesitate to rush forward and help as well.
The damage was already done by the time they got Stella back on her feet, muffled snickers and whispers sending the stuck-up blonde hobbling awkwardly towards whatever dubious comfort her bleached, plastic, denture-wearing family could provide. Her shoulders shook with each of her badly stifled sobs, yet Billy felt nothing for her besides merciless contempt, glad she was so wretchedly dejected on what should have been a memorable day for a myriad of other, happier reasons.
It was her own fault, for daring to try and use Steve’s shitty parents against him.
Someone tugged on his sleeve, and when Billy looked down he was met with Henderson’s overexcited blue stare. In a whisper that really wasn’t a goddamned whisper, the kid asked, “Did you do that?”
Billy planted a hand atop Henderson’s head with a mild sneer, roughly tousling the dork’s hair. “Keep your fucking voice down, curly.”
“It was, right? That was so cool!” Henderson gushed, for once unbothered by having his riot of curls messed with.
Lucas gave another quiet whistle, looking up at Billy with cautious awe. “It was kinda… harsh?”
“No way,” Maxine disagreed, glaring at Stella – who was surrounded by her fretting friends and family, plus Steve – with obvious scorn. “Did you hear what she said to Steve? She totally deserved it.”
Will gave a tentative nod, too polite to go so far as to voice his agreement.
Wheeler crossed his arms and gave Billy a flat look, acting like he didn’t give a shit about anything he’d just witnessed. “Remind me not to piss you off.”
The junior scoffed, “You piss me off by breathing, sourpuss.”
Steve returned from the tensely formal conversation Stella’s parents had pulled him into with a deeply relieved sigh – unknowingly saving Wheeler from opening his snarky mouth and pissing Billy off even further – tucking his graduation cap beneath his arm before trying to return some bounce to his comically flattened hair. “I don’t know why they think I know anything about my dad’s business portfolio-”
“Congrats on graduating, Steve!” Henderson steamrolled over him, launching himself forward with impressive speed before wrapping both arms tightly around Steve’s middle.
Complaint immediately forgotten, Steve eagerly returned the nerd’s enthusiastic embrace, patting over his shoulders and – far gentler than Billy had a minute ago – ruffling his hair. They pulled apart and immediately launched into an absurdly choreographed handshake, both grinning from ear to ear and radiating an honest kind of happiness that had Billy kindly biting back the scathing remark crawling up his throat. The odd pair looked utterly ridiculous, but he wasn’t about to ruin Steve’s rapidly improving mood by pointing that out.
He’d give Steve plenty of shit for his childish theatrics later. For now, Billy contented himself by looking over at Maxine, who was grimacing with second-hand embarrassment as they concluded their handshake with some kind of… mock lightsabre duel?
Jesus Christ.
As Henderson reluctantly moved aside to allow Lucas and Will to offer their own congratulations – Steve accepting the former’s fist-bump and the latter’s brief hug with genuine delight – Bitch Wheeler and her creeper boyfriend stepped forward, though they remained a few metres outside of their uneven circle.
Because he knew how much it would piss Wheeler off, Billy moved back to stand beside them. She refused to so much as glance in his direction, though Byers didn’t hesitate to meet his condescending smile with a lopsided one of his own. “I like what you did. With Leavy.”
Billy’s brows furrowed, “Who?”
Byers blinked, confused by his confusion. “Leavy. Stella Leavy?”
“Oh,” He’d never bothered learning the cow’s last name. “Don’t know what you’re talking about, Byers.”
“Uh-huh. Alright.” His fellow junior hummed, seemingly content to leave it at that despite very clearly not believing him. “Hell of a coincidence then, huh?”
“Yeah,” Billy replied flatly, ignoring the restless energy surging up his spine, down his arms, and settling in his flexing hands. Byers had witnessed him use his psychic bullshit multiple times since last year, and though Billy was fairly certain his fellow junior wouldn’t out him as a supernatural freak – not so long as doing so also posed a threat to El – that didn’t mean he wanted to talk to the creep about it.
Talking about it meant acknowledging that people he didn’t trust knew things about him that could quite literally destroy his life – which he was actually starting to enjoy, for fucks sake – and it was better for everyone involved if Byers shut his mouth before Billy stopped ignoring the violent itch in his knuckles.
Maxine gave Steve a short side-hug as she ribbed him good-naturedly over how he’d reacted to their cheering, while the younger Wheeler offered nothing but a nod and a moderately sincere congratulations, clearly unwilling to be any friendlier with his sister’s ex. Unoffended by the black-haired kid’s reticence, Steve just chuckled bemusedly and nodded back.
Holding none of the same reservations as her brother, Nancy approached the freshly graduated senior with a wide smile and open arms. “I knew you could do it.”
Steve’s smile gained a slightly bashful edge, “Thanks, Nance.”
The pair hugged, Wheeler straining up on her tiptoes to throw her arms around Steve’s neck while his palms came to lightly rest on her upper back.
Expression unconsciously falling into a blank mask as a vicious mess of something swirled to life in his chest, Billy gritted his teeth and looked away – missing the sudden and excited look of shared understanding passing between Maxine and Will – throwing a sharp elbow into Byers’ side. “You okay with that?”
“What, Nancy and Steve? Of course.” Byers answered with naive honesty, shrugging. “They’re friends.”
Billy arched an eyebrow, wondering how someone who’d doubtlessly been bullied throughout the entirety of his school life – at home too, if the rumours about his dad were true – could still be so pathetically trusting. “Never heard of once a cheater, always a cheater?”
“Cheating?” His fellow junior frowned, casting Billy a puzzled look. “Nancy didn’t cheat on Steve.”
“Is that what Wheeler told you?”
Byers’ frown deepened, annoyance bleeding into his expression. “Are you trying to screw with our relationship? Why would Steve be so chill with us if- if they were still together when…” He trailed off, raspy voice losing some of its confidence as he noticed his girlfriend’s hand lingering on Steve’s elbow.
“Because he’s better than both of you,” Billy stated bluntly, fetching another cigarette and preoccupying himself lighting it. “Keep a close eye on your girl, Byers. She’ll drop you the second she gets bored.”
“Hey, thanks for coming, Jonathan.” Steve cut in before Byers could respond, unexpectedly shrewd brown eyes darting between the juniors before he came to stand beside Billy. “I appreciate it.”
Byers nodded a little belatedly, aiming a scrutinizing, squinty-eyed glare Billy’s way before directing his attention to Steve and attempting to pull on a smile. “Uh- yeah. Congrats, man.”
They shook hands like a pair of awkward old men, and the moment their arms dropped Byers retreated towards his girlfriend, who was locked in some kind of squabble with Henderson and her brother.
“What were you guys talking about?” Steve asked curiously, knocking his shoulder against Billy’s with a wry smile.
Feeling unreasonably provoked by the innocuous question – the memory of Bitch Wheeler’s tight hold around Steve’s neck replaying in his head – Billy’s lips sharpened around a spiteful smile. “How stupid you look in that ugly fucking curtain.”
“It’s a robe, you dick. You’ll be wearing one this time next year.”
“Like hell,” Billy scoffed, turning his head away to exhale a lungful of smoke. Even if Hawkins High’s graduation ceremony hadn’t turned out to be unnecessarily long-winded and boring as fuck, he’d never had any intention of wasting time attending his own.
Steve took his graduation cap from beneath his arm and tried to place it on Billy’s head, yelping when the junior smacked his arm aside and jabbed a retaliatory hand into his ribs. “Okay, okay!” He fiddled with the tassel, lips twitching upwards as he tried and failed to school his expression into something more serious. “I just thought it’d suit you-”
“I’ll shove that fucking thing so far up your ass-”
Steve laughed, the sound lively and mirthful and genuine, and Billy felt what was left of his misplaced aggravation wither up and die in the wake of it. He watched raptly as Steve’s unapologetically loud sense of happiness played out across his handsome features – warm eyes crinkled endearingly at their outer corners and rosy cheeks bunched around the edges of his wide grin – momentarily forgetting about the cigarette hanging from his own mouth. Gone was the sorrow that had been dogging him for the past couple of weeks, replaced by a simple but all-encompassing cheerfulness that Billy felt goddamned proud to have had a hand in creating.
He might be utterly dogshit at offering any kind of comfort – too impatient, too dismissive, too harsh – but he wasn’t so socially inept that he couldn’t manipulate a few kids into making sure Steve wasn’t alone on his big day.
“Thank you, Billy.” Steve murmured, breaking the junior from his uncharacteristically sentimental musings.
Cursing under his breath as his still smouldering cigarette fell from his parted lips, Billy blinked up at the older boy in mild confusion. “For what?”
“For helping me out with Stella, and for- you know, getting everyone here today. I-” He cleared his throat, and Billy was distantly horrified to notice the way his voice trembled at the edges. “You were right, before. I was… really bummed out about my parents not being here-”
“No shit.”
Steve gave his shoulder a light shove, still smiling despite his exasperation. “Can you not? This is hard enough to say without you being a dick.”
“What else is there to say? Your parents suck, so you were moping about it. End of story.” Billy laid out succinctly, uncomfortable with the disgustingly emotional direction their conversation was taking and wanting to dissuade Steve from continuing. He was briefly tempted to deny having tampered with Stella’s shoes – the other boy’s genuine gratitude settling uneasily beneath his skin – but knew that Steve knew him too well by now to fall for such a boldfaced lie. Though… “Who said I organised this little fieldtrip, anyway?”
“My parents don’t suck. They’re just- really busy people.” Steve muttered with a frown, tone nowhere near as confident as he clearly wanted it to be. Billy wasn’t sure who he was trying to convince, and the fact that the junior’s first instinct wasn’t to mock Steve for his pitiable sense of loyalty – to people who did not fucking deserve it, blood relation or not – was yet another damning sign of how dangerously far he’d dug his way under Billy’s typically defences.
Steve rolled his eyes when Billy’s only response was to arch a silently dubious eyebrow and blow out another puff of smoke, continuing only after he’d run a steadying hand down his face. “Nance might have thought to bring the kids, but I never told her about mom and dad not being able to make it back in time.” He shrugged, pale skin taking on a subtle blush. “You’re the only person I told about that, so…”
For a brief moment Billy considered just… getting the fuck over himself and being honest. He considered swallowing past the inexplicable tightness in his throat and admitting that Steve’s quiet, lonely misery had made him feel goddamned miserable, and not just because his telepathy allowed him to quite literally feel it. What would Steve say, if Billy admitted to goading Maxine into dragging her friends along, which in turn had also led to Nancy and Jonathan’s attendance?
What would Steve think, if Billy told him how much he’d fucking despised the thought of him being alone today, knowing exactly how it would have broken his soft heart?
“Maxine’s the one who convinced the dorks to come, and Wheeler invited herself. Same with creeper Byers, I guess.” Billy said, taking a short drag of his smoke before stamping it beneath his heel. He forced himself to smirk before glancing up to meet Steve’s patient gaze – whiskey brown eyes warm and way too inconveniently perceptive – knowing his cocky façade was all but useless against him but putting it on anyway. “I’ll admit to fucking up Stella’s heels, though.”
Steve released a quieter, completely unsurprised laugh, hesitantly extending an arm like he wanted to sling it around Billy’s upper back but wasn’t sure if he should. After a brief moment of indecision he instead moved to place a hand on Billy’s closest shoulder, lowering his hand only when the junior didn’t offer any kind of protest. “You’re such an asshole,” he said, shaking his head with a cautiously amused grin.
Once upon a time Billy would have bared his teeth and snapped out something pointedly waspish in response to being treated so delicately – he wasn’t some weak little bitch – but now he felt only a brief stab of frustrated shame, faint gratitude he refused to acknowledge, and a frankly bizarre amount of relief.
The last thing he wanted was for Steve to think, because of Billy’s pathetic overreaction in the pool, that he had to start holding back his casual, friendly touches. After he’d finally gotten used to Steve’s natural handsiness – or mostly used to it, barely ever flinching even when he reached out unexpectedly – Billy dreaded having to learn how to once again go without that freely given, blissfully painless, grounding contact.
Steve’s large hand squeezed once, shifting slightly higher towards the side of Billy’s neck before he dropped it back to his side. “If I try to thank you again, can you please just say you’re welcome, like a normal person? I know you know I’m being honest.”
“You’re welcome,” Billy drawled in a lifeless monotone, cracking a grin when Steve released a long-suffering groan and smacked himself on the forehead with his diploma. Eager to change the subject, he asked, “Wanna go get high at the quarry later?”
“Definitely,” Steve breathed out, nodding vehemently. “Today has been stressful-”
“Get over here, Steve!” Henderson demanded, pitchy voice rising gratingly above the general hum of other people’s conversations.
“You’ve seriously gotta start telling that dunce no, pretty boy.”
Steve waved a dismissive hand, smiling indulgently as he moved towards the group of eagerly – suspiciously – waiting middle-schoolers. “Dustin’s fine.”
“Dustin’s a little shit who thinks you’ll do anything he tells you to.”
“No he doesn’t.”
“Yes he fucking does, Stevie.”
The chubby dork in question held out an impatient hand. “Can I read your diploma?”
Billy cut him a sharp look. “Manners, dickhead.”
“Please,” Henderson added dutifully.
“Uh, sure.” Like the gullible, trusting fool he was, Steve handed it over without hesitation.
Maxine and the nerds all bent their heads together to read it, giggles and snorts erupting almost immediately.
Narrowing his eyes with overdue wariness, Steve placed his hands on both Henderson and Lucas’ shoulders, prying them apart just enough to join them in peering down at his diploma. “What?”
Wheeler looked up, doing absolutely nothing to try and hide the shit eating grin spreading across his annoying face. “Your middle name’s Gabriele?”
“Give that back!” Steve demanded, face flushing as he reached down and snatched the paper out of Henderson’s stubby hands. The kids continued to snicker, which prompted the freshly graduated senior to give each of them a solid whack to the head with his rolled up diploma. “What’s so goddamned funny, huh? It’s a family name!”
Billy smirked, tugging at the ends of his little sister’s long red hair. “Gabriele’s better than Rosalie, right Maxine?”
“Oh my God, shut up!”
