Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

The Truth About Their Love

Summary:

This story takes place during the making of the Hobbit movies. Thorin, Fili and Kili died per the events of the Hobbit book, and are still in Mahal’s Halls where Tolkien left them. Fili and Kili get word that these movies are being made on Earth. As interest in the Hobbit trilogy increases among the Dwarves in the Halls, some begin to examine the complex mystery of Thorin’s feelings for Bilbo, which he has never revealed.

Meanwhile, on Earth, Mulder and Scully, passionate fans of the Hobbit book and observant viewers of the movies, ponder and debate whether Bagginshield is real. One of them is more invested in finding out the truth than the other...

Chapter Text

Earth, Dec. 2011

“Hey, Scully,” said Mulder as he took a first sip of his morning coffee while glancing at a particular newspaper clipping that lay on his office desk. “Something interesting caught my attention earlier. A certain book that you and I know well, that we - quite exceptionally - share a passion for, is going to be made into movies!”

“Which book? Could it be How To Perform Ten Autopsies in One Day and Still Eat Your Dinner?” asked Scully.

Mulder smiled indulgently. “No. The Hobbit.”

“Oh yeah... Your favorite book since you were a ”wee lad“, as I recall.”

“Precisely. Anyway, the first movie is going to come out a year from now. I am curious to see how the relationship between the two main characters will play out on screen.”

“They had a relationship? Do tell,” said Scully, always prepared to be bewildered in Mulder’s presence.

“Well... I’ve always thought that there was more between Thorin and Bilbo than Tolkien let on,” said Mulder.

“Like what? You don’t mean romance, do you?”

Mulder gave her a giddy look. “I’ve never been able to figure out what it was. It is possible that Tolkien was sowing some seeds of love between them.”

“Look, Mulder, I know X-files these days are hard to come by, and settling into our boring domestic life is not really doing it for you, but this... I like the Hobbit book just as much as you do, and know it inside out. Believe me, there is no romantic love in it.”

“Bilbo and Thorin always read like an odd puzzle to me. Bilbo didn’t marry, was obsessed with his adventure for what we know of the rest of his life. Thorin as a Dwarf can love only once, and Tolkien says he had no wife... So there was potential for love between them to grow. I want to know if it did. Maybe it did, and Tolkien just didn’t tell us. Do you see how interesting this is?”

“I suppose it could be interesting,” said Scully. “But this reasoning applies to any two characters who have stayed single all their life. You can pick Bilbo and Gandalf and wonder if there was any love between them that Tolkien secretly knew about.”

“That aside,” Mulder continued, “in many Tolkien writings you get a clear idea of how it ends for the characters, especially if they had an important role. Thorin and Bilbo are left in a kind of limbo. I mean, sure, we know one is dead and the other sailed to Valinor, but beyond that? It feels like the end of their story has not yet been written.”

“And why is that? Because neither of them ended up with a partner? There are other things in life... or afterlife, or whatever,” said Scully, looking slightly bored.

“I see clues in Tolkien’s text that indicate that at least Thorin was in love with Bilbo. But he never said it. Maybe Tolkien tried to say it for him.”

“You can’t just go looking for ”clues“. This is not an X-file, Mulder. If you want to get my attention, show me a scene that makes me all warm and fuzzy inside.”

“All right, Scully, I’ll play,” said Mulder, trying to pretend that he hadn’t been hoping for this all along. He pulled the Hobbit book from one of his desk drawers - an old copy with many markings and notes made by a younger and just as passionate iteration of his self - and opened it towards the end. “There is a scene where Bilbo and the dwarves are walking through Erebor, and Bilbo complains about the place. There, Thorin says, Don’t call my palace a nasty hole! You wait till it has been cleaned and redecorated! You see, Thorin was hoping Bilbo would stay in Erebor.”

“Maybe he just wanted to set an ignorant Hobbit straight about his kingdom. You take things too literally, Mulder.”

Mulder stared at her incredulously. “Me? I don’t think so. What about the fact that when Bilbo gives the Arkenstone away, he calls it ”the heart of Thorin“? That’s the thing he has stolen, you see? The author must see where these two statements lead; he is trying to tell us something here.”

“Sophistry. The Arkenstone and Thorin’s heart are not identical. Bilbo is using a metaphor. He has stolen the Arkenstone, which he calls “the heart of Thorin”. It doesn’t mean that it is. It is just a way to say that Thorin really values that stone.”

“Yeah, but Tolkien was a poet and narrator, not an impeccable logician,” said Mulder. “While he was aware he could not really draw the conclusion that Bilbo stole Thorin’s heart, the beauty and force of this argument must have not escaped him. Here’s another one. How about the fact that when Thorin is dying, he wants to see Bilbo?”

“So what? He did Bilbo wrong; he wants to apologize.”

“But he does more than apologize. He wants to tell Bilbo that he’s special.”

“This is just how Tolkien viewed Bilbo, as someone special. He has other characters, such as Gandalf and Thranduil, praise him when they realize he is giving up his share of the treasure in order to prevent a war. At the end, Tolkien wants to show us that even a stubborn dwarf like Thorin, with his one-track mind obsessed with gold, has seen Bilbo’s true worth.”

“But Tolkien has already shown us that. We already know that Thorin thinks Bilbo is special.”

“Really? Where?”

“In the scene where Thorin gives Bilbo the mithril. Thorin is in gold madness during this scene, and yet is happy to part with an extremely valuable item. He wastes no time in doing so, either. It is odd, unless he...”

“It is not odd. He says something about payment. His madness comes and goes; this could be a favorable moment for him to make the first step towards paying Bilbo for his rendered services.”

“You might think so. Thorin does say, Here is the first payment of your reward. And we know that Bilbo’s reward was supposed to be one fourteenth share. But pay attention to what Thorin says in the scene on the ramparts, where he’s enraged that Bilbo gave away the Arkenstone. For it [the Arkenstone] I will give one fourteenth share of the hoard in silver and gold [...] that shall be accounted the promised share of this traitor, and with that reward he shall depart. He doesn’t say, “I’ve already given this traitor a super expensive mithril coat, so I will subtract that from his one fourteenth share.” If the armor were part of the payment, Thorin would either ask for it back and promise a whole one fourteenth share, or let Bilbo keep it and promise to give less. Yet he doesn’t mention the mithril at all.”

“He does mention it though, in the same scene,” Scully countered. “Right when he banishes Bilbo, he tells him to hurry, for although Bilbo is wearing armor, Thorin can shoot at his feet. Or something like that.”

“Very good, Scully. Tolkien is letting us know that Thorin has not simply forgotten that he gave Bilbo the mithril. He has not forgotten, but he’s not counting it as payment. Which only strengthens my opinion in this matter.”

“Which is what? Bring out your big guns, Mulder,” said Scully with an eye-roll.

“That it was not payment at all. It was a gift.”

Scully seemed impressed there for too brief a moment. “Mmm-hmm. So Thorin gifted him the mithril. Maybe it was a token of appreciation, because he grew to hold Bilbo in very high regard towards the end?”

Mulder looked very pleased. “I think you’re hitting closer to the truth, Scully.”

“But it’s not enough to make him in love.”

“But you see it was a gift.”

“Mm-maybe. It’s certainly the only example you gave that is not just little conjectures that sound like a fangirl’s wishful thinking.”

“Thanks, Scully,” said Mulder, with more fondness than gratitude at her high praise.

 

Mahal’s Halls, same day

In the Halls of Mahal, it was that day of the year, designated by the Maker himself, when all the dwarves got to do something utterly out of the ordinary. In each dwarf’s room there was a painting hanging on a wall that represented a world of that dwarf’s choosing. Every year on this day, removing the painting from the wall revealed an opening one could look through and view that world. And one did look through, for each dwarf was allowed to watch closely what was happening in a chosen place of their favorite world, for a few hours, after which the hole in the wall would be magically sealed until the same time next year.

Fili and Kili, the young warriors of Tolkien’s book The Hobbit, who had bravely fought and died in the Battle of Five Armies along with their uncle, the great Thorin Oakenshield, had been in the Halls for many years now, where they were to dwell until the world was remade. This time may have seemed terribly long and boring for the two brothers if not for the above mentioned privilege that Mahal, their loving creator, had bestowed upon his children. Fili and Kili found that, of all the worlds available to watch, their choice as of late was one called Earth, and their favorite place on Earth was the FBI Headquarters in Washington, D.C., where two special agents worked, sometimes lived, and often times had heated disagreements.

It was this last point, as well as the topics of their conversations (well, and maybe Kili had a crush on Scully), that interested Thorin’s nephews. Mulder and Scully’s work always involved unresolved cases that no one else wanted to deal with, events bordering on the supernatural, whose explanation did not fit Earth’s standards. Fili and Kili loved the way Mulder and Scully went about examining their cases, one’s unusually creative leaps in thinking against the other’s unforgivingly scientific reasoning. But the best part was that most of those cases remained unresolved, providing Fili and Kili with many days of pondering over the mystery still left in each case, thus making each year of their afterlife, if not pleasant, certainly much easier to bear.

Upon enjoying this year’s special day, Fili and Kili were surprised to find out that Mulder and Scully’s cases were dwindling, and that instead, a certain story called The Hobbit was the subject of their conversation. You can imagine how great their surprise was, and as soon as their watching time was over they were eager to share the news with the most important dwarf in that story. Thus they barged into Thorin’s room with two big, enthusiastic grins.

“Uncle,” said Fili, “there’s something sensational happening on Earth as we speak! They’re making movies about us and our journey to Erebor!”

“We’ve just witnessed a conversation on this topic that was more than a little interesting,” said Kili.

“Whatever happened to those two FBI agents you usually watch?” asked Thorin. “Master Mulder and Mistress Scully, who dabble in unexplained phenomena?”

“We have been watching them. And guess what: this year’s X-file is you, Uncle,” said Kili with utmost satisfaction. “They were talking about you.”

Thorin laughed bitterly. “I can’t imagine. You two always say that I’m pretty easy to piece together. I’m no puzzle material.”

“It’s not just you,” Fili tried to clarify prudently. “It’s also the hobbit who travelled with our company. We’ve just watched a dispute over the relationship between the two of you.”

“To cut to the chase,” said Kili impatiently, ignoring his brother’s nervous gesturing, “the dispute was whether you were in love with our hobbit!”

“Do you want to give them a shout and tell them how it was?” Fili couldn’t resist adding, though he could ballpark the severity of their blunder.

They were pushing it; it was well-known that no one could reach out and actually be heard in another world. Fili and Kili, who had no notion of their uncle’s ever having been in love with anyone, were just hoping for a small bit of fun.

“I’m not in the mood for your silly jokes,” Thorin grumbled.

“Anyway,” said Fili, “this in-love business is nothing but wild speculation. I haven’t seen any evidence for it during our quest. You and the hobbit were just friends, nothing more.”

“But consider,” said Kili, always the one to tackle a riskier angle, “what if Thorin is just the kind of person who won’t give any indication about his feelings? Or... what if his feelings themselves are a bit of a puzzle?” he said with wide, intrigued eyes.

“All right. What if? That doesn’t prove anything,” said Fili with an impassable demeanor.

“No, it doesn’t. But it leaves room for interpreting his character... and certainly makes one eager to see how a certain Uncle will act in the movies...”

“Speaking of which, what do the film makers say?” asked Thorin. It was clear he was doomed to listen to this conversation for a long while.

“Nothing that we’ve heard. They’re probably keeping quiet on the subject.”

“How nice. Why don’t we take a page out of their book. Good night, boys,” and he showed them the door unceremoniously.

As he watched his nephews exit his room, Thorin sighed with great pain as the memories flooded his mind, along with new images he had just seen earlier that day. For Thorin’s less imaginative choice, for some years now, was, invariably, watching one place in Valinor, the Undying Lands of the Elves. His favorite location to watch was something akin to a hole in the ground, where there lived a hobbit named Bilbo Baggins. Today, Bilbo had been engaged in small activities: he smoked his pipe, watered the plants in his garden, took a walk with Frodo, cooked dinner, and settled down in his armchair for a bit of reading.

As newly-acquired memories of Bilbo mixed with old ones, Thorin marveled that new hope could still rise within him. In a land far away, the process of making a movie had been initiated, no doubt by some knowledgeable and sensible people. And two fans of the highest caliber were taking an interest in Thorin’s feelings. All those persons, each in their own way, may have inadvertently set the wheels in motion for something much bigger: the forging of a link betwen Bilbo and himself, after all these years. A connection that Thorin could bring himself to hope would reach and be felt on both sides. If Bilbo even remembered him...