Actions

Work Header

The Truth About Their Love

Chapter 2

Notes:

I would like to thank two people who made this story possible in its current form:

JuniAsat, whose thoughtful exchange of comments with me about the detectability of Bagginshield inspired me to conceive this story, and

hobbitfan, whose valuable input encouraged me to take this story in an “inexplicably” awesome direction :))

I am very happy with how this is turning out! Thank you both so much!!!

Chapter Text

Earth, Dec. 2012

The first Hobbit movie had come out. The theaters were full and everybody was buzzing with excitement. Mulder and Scully waited a few days for the commotion to die down a bit before they went to see it themselves. Now they were back in Mulder’s office, sipping coffee and going over movie highlights.

“I thought there wasn’t supposed to be any hint of romance between Thorin and Bilbo,” grinned Mulder.

“There isn’t.”

“No? Not even in that hug scene? That was pretty intense.”

“Sure it was intense. They’ve just barely escaped with their lives. This is a turning point for them: Bilbo has proven himself, Thorin is now accepting him into his Company after harshly misjudging him. They are on their way to friendship after a rocky start. It’s all very dramatic, especially the way Thorin acts there," Scully rolled her eyes, "but I don’t detect any love.”

“It is very subtle, I grant you, and very difficult to place,” said Mulder.

“Love is not visible in either of them. Bilbo’s expression is first one of surprise; then he looks happy and relieved, which can be attributed to the fact that the Company members are reacting positively to the hug.”

“That’s all you have on Bilbo? I get the feeling his experience here is quite exhilarating. He is on a high.”

“Bilbo appears to be torn all throughout the movie. He’s not sure he wants to go on the adventure, then he’s not sure he wants to stay in the adventure. When Thorin hugs him, he is happy, but I would say still a bit reserved,” said Scully.

“Yeah, he’s the skeptic of the two,” said Mulder. “But Bilbo reaches a resolution there at the end. He was previously torn, because he missed his home, the place he left behind. After the hug, I think his concept of home changes entirely, and there is no more need for being torn.”

“So now he views Erebor as his home?”

“No, not Erebor. To him, home is a person now. The person in front of him. That person makes the adventure all worth it.”

“Uh-huh. Speaking of Thorin, I don’t see love in his expression either. He is only apologetic, and grateful that Bilbo saved his life.”

“Well, maybe a little too grateful,” said Mulder.

“He can be “a little too grateful”; it doesn’t mean anything. That Thorin looks to be a mess of contradictions at every corner. He can be really fierce, and charismatic, but he can also get really angry or have a serious meltdown, all in the span of ten minutes. If you want to go by him in discerning romance, good luck; he will change in the next moment,” said Scully dismissively. “For example, look at him in the Misty Mountains scene. That’s pretty insensitive of him to say that Bilbo should never have come. But not to worry, he’ll soften a few minutes later when he hears Bilbo leaving...”

“He talks like that because he is terrified at the prospect of Bilbo losing his life in this perilous journey. He didn’t want Bilbo to join them. He hopes that Bilbo will turn around and go home.”

“Maybe he wants him to go home because instead of being useful, Bilbo is one more burden for him,” said Scully.

“Perhaps. Or maybe he’s already started to feel something special for him. Either way, when Bilbo doesn’t go home, but instead rejoins them after Goblintown, Thorin is very puzzled. That’s why he asks, Why did you come back? He knows he tried to get Bilbo to go back home, or to Rivendell, which he saw Bilbo liked. He is wondering what he missed. And when Bilbo delivers his answer, Thorin knows he is in trouble. He is falling in love.”

“That sounds like something right out of a soap opera. He cared about Bilbo all along, but instead of being nice to him he acted like a jerk-face, in the hope that he would save both of them the heartbreak! Boo-hoo! And now that he realizes how heartfelt and generous Bilbo is, the floodgates are open and Thorin can no longer deny his emotions! Sorry, Mulder. I’m not buying it.”

“It’s not like that. His feelings are more likely growing in a steady progression. Thorin seems to be big on loyalty. He has kept his oaken branch for so many years, since the battle of Moria. That shows he is loyal himself. And he has said he values loyalty in others. I personally think that loyalty, in his case, could be a basis for falling in love, especially with someone who is consistently showing him his despite being under no obligation.”

“But Mulder, these are all speculations. As I said earlier, there is nothing in these characters’ expressions that shows that they are falling in love. Not even in Thorin’s.”

“I agree,” said Mulder while lifting a finger, a smile playing at the corner of his lips. “This is precisely what’s puzzling: that the love is not tied to any of their expressions, and yet it is there. It’s something over and above them.”

He clicked a few times on his laptop, and a screenshot of The Hug popped on his screen. “Look at this picture. Normally love would be expressed as an emotion, visible on people’s faces or in their body language. Here we don’t even see their faces, but we know from other screenshots that Bilbo expresses surprise and then relief, and some happiness, while Thorin is grateful and apologetic. And while their bodies fit nicely together, there is nothing in them that expresses love, specifically, either. And yet, it’s in the air.”

“Mmm. Let me guess. It’s detectable only to a select few, you among them?”

“It is detectable. You either see it or you don’t.”

“If it’s in the air, you should be able to point to its location. Where is it? Where in the air?”

“I don’t know where it is. It’s... out there.”

“Where?” pressed Scully in a very severe tone.

“I can’t say exactly where. Maybe you can’t see it. Maybe you can only feel it. An ineffable quality that comes with the viewer’s experience.”

“Well, I’m a viewer, and it’s not coming with mine,” said Scully. “But don’t let me stop your inquiries into the paranormal nature of love.”

“Good, because I was just about to ask, where is this quality coming from? The fact that we’re experiencing something that feels like love, even if we don’t see it?”

“Why do I have the feeling that you already have an answer?” said Scully.

“Because you know me all too well,” said Mulder, glossing over her sarcasm. “It’s possible that quality is there because of Thorin. Because he is in love with Bilbo by now.”

“But if the love is not visible anywhere on him, then it can’t be said to be coming from him at all! It’s more likely it’s coming from you, because you believe that he is in love. It’s all in your mind, Mulder.”

“Maybe you’re right, and it’s not coming from him. Maybe it’s coming from Tolkien himself. Perhaps he really intended for these two guys to fall in love. Wherever he is, he surely knows that these movies are being made. Perhaps his spirit is directly intervening, showing us how Thorin fell in love with Bilbo and that by the time they reached the Carrock, he was deep in it.”

“So the love quality that you are blessed to perceive is actually Tolkien’s ghost, making an appearance in the air?”

Mulder smiled graciously. “Of course not. I’m only saying maybe Tolkien put it there. That je ne sais quoi. That would explain why it’s not visible. It’s an otherworldly quality.”

“More likely Tolkien is rolling in his grave,” said Scully. “Perhaps he would not mind if Bilbo and Thorin looked like they’re falling in love for one tiny second. Which they are not! But to say that his spirit is placing an ineffable quality on screen in the air around them, that’s really... out there, even coming from you. Forget for a minute whether there even is such a thing as his spirit; surely he’d have better things to do with himself?”

“Not if he was really invested in their relationship all along,” said Mulder.

“Oh. So you’re saying he may have been a “closet shipper”?”

Mulder laughed. “I love how you tell it exactly like it is, Scully. I confess I don’t know what to say, though. Not yet. We need to wait and see how things play out in these movies.”

“All this speculation because of one hug, Mulder? People do hug, you know? Friends, acquaintances... even online it’s a thing now.”

“It’s all going to come to light now, you’ll see, Scully. Something I suspected long ago. Mark my words, nothing will be the same for them after this hug.”

“Or for us,” Scully lamented with a big yawn. “It’s going to be a loooong year.”

 

Mahal’s Halls, same day

On the same day, Fili and Kili watched The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey with great interest, joined by Balin, whom they’d managed to persuade it was worth his time. After also attending Mulder and Scully’s debate about The Hug, the brothers eagerly sought their uncle, who was once again lost in reverie and memories.

“All right, Thorin. We’ve just watched you and Bilbo locked in a hug of epic proportions,” said Fili.

“...mostly because you take up most of the screen in it,”, completed Kili.

Fili gave him a warning frown. “And apparently some people find it quite... romantic.”

“But the romance part of it is displayed via... unorthodox methods. It’s way too complex for us to understand. But oh, it’s there,” Kili said with a wink.

“Really?” asked Fili, unconvinced. “Or you’re just ready to believe whatever comes out of that Mulder’s mouth?”

“Not at all,” said Kili, who had his own views on the matter. “You know how I know the love is there? Because Uncle never hugs anybody.”

“In gloomier news, Thorin,” Fili continued, “it appears the hobbit is not entirely reciprocating. He is more reserved with his emotions, at least according to Agent Scully.”

“Which could be due to the fact that you’re all over the place and a walking mess...”

“Kili, could you shut up? Anyway, it was a nice hug, Uncle,” said Fili, and once again, Thorin knew he could be looking at a long night ahead of him.

“A hug,” he said absently. “What’s so special about this hug?”

“Well laddie,” Balin took a confident turn. “It’s you. It’s like all your shields are down.”

“Including your famous oaken branch, which you lose pretty much right before this hug,” said Kili.

At this, Balin’s eyes became fierce. “That is no coincidence if you ask me! I’ve known the great Thorin Oakenshield for a lifetime and some, and I can say one thing with utmost confidence: when all his shields are down, then, and only then, can his heart be opened.”

“...except Bilbo becomes your shield, you see,” observed Fili.

“Hence you acquire the epic name of Bagginshield,” Kili chimed in looking very pleased. “Don’t worry, we won’t tell anyone, even if it’s too good to keep secret.”

“That word is not in the movie. Don’t listen to him, Uncle!”

“We’ve never had such a moment,” said Thorin, turning to Balin. “There is no way for me to know how I would react. Who cares about a made-up hug shown on a screen, if it’s not the real thing?”

“But in your heart...” Balin said, scrutinizing Thorin closely and choosing his words carefully, while gently signalling Fili and Kili to leave the room. “Maybe you know something in your heart.”

Thorin looked down, thinking deeply, not even noticing his nephews departing.

“Balin,” he said unexpectedly, “I’ve never asked you this, but... You told me you visited Master Baggins after my death in the battle. Do you happen to know what he did with the mithril I gave him?”

“Everybody knows,” said Balin. “It’s part of the tale of the War of the Ring. He gave it to his nephew, Frodo.”

“I mean, before that,” said Thorin. “When Bil... when Master Baggins was still in the Shire. Did he mention the mithril at all when you saw him?”

“Oh. He loaned it to a museum,” said Balin. “That’s all I know about that time.”

“That’s that then,” said Thorin resolutely. “Thank you, Balin. Tell the boys I appreciate the update. I wish to end this conversation.”

“Maybe revisit it next year?” asked Balin hopefully as he made his way to the door.

The mithril shirt was a bit of an unexplained phenomenon in itself, for all that Thorin knew about the War of the Ring. Other dwarves had “subscribed” to that epic story and had been keen on following its developments every year, some watching for Sauron in Mordor, others for Frodo and his companions (or, as they would rather say, Gimli and his companions), others for Saruman in his black tower, and many of them for badass warrior Eowyn. They informed each other of every piece of the story and delighted in putting the puzzle together.

The mithril armor had been present, to great effect, in the events that led to the destruction of the Ring. It was known that Frodo had worn it during the quest for Mount Doom, that he had lost it and regained it after Gandalf retrieved it from the Mouth of Sauron at the Black Gate. However, what became of the mithril after the War of the Ring remained a mystery, a truth that Thorin never gained access to. Did Bilbo and Frodo carry it with them across the Sea? If they did, why wasn’t it anywhere in sight?

He had watched Bilbo every year: first while the hobbit was still in Middle Earth, and now, while he lived in Valinor. When Bilbo was still in the Shire, it was clear that he enjoyed remembering his adventure with the dwarves; but whether he held any special feelings for any of them was impossible to detect. Thus, how Bilbo treated the small treasure that Thorin had given him became the only thing that could have made a difference, the only hope Thorin could hold on to. If what Balin said was true... If Bilbo didn’t value it enough to keep it in his own home, and all he did was loan it to a museum... Thorin laughed at his own stupidity. Of course, Bilbo had moved on with his life, not to suggest that he had ever been stuck to begin with. Only he - Thorin - still dwelled on something that could never be...

“Thorin? Maybe revisit this next year?”

He shook his head, not knowing if in answer to this question or in dismissal of the hope he still felt within himself, and tried to hide his tears from Balin.