Chapter 1: Thrór’s Ghost
Chapter Text
As soon as a quick knock hit Bilbo’s door, he set down his quill with a frustrated huff. He had half a mind to ignore them, whoever it was, but he knew they would just come back later. Standing from the desk in his study with a groan, Bilbo opened his window to where his gardener was working in the planter just below.
“Hamfast Gamgee,” Bilbo greeted through the window.
The gardener looked up with a bit of surprise. “Yes, sir?”
“Who is at my door?” Bilbo questioned.
He watched the gardener take a step back from the planter and lean around the side of the house before retreating once again and leaning in towards Bilbo.
“Looks to be Mister Applegate, sir, one of your tenants,” Hamfast explained a bit hushed, “Probably wanting to discuss the months of rent he still owes you after his little Gwen got sick during the harvest. Terrible plight, I must say. The gossipers will talk your ear off about it if you let them.”
Bilbo huffed.
He knew quite well the gossip of the Shire. Even with as little excursions as he took down to the market, he couldn’t get far enough away from that week’s topic of interest.
When another round of knocking reached his ears, Bilbo left the window, wrapping himself tighter in his coat as he made his way to his door. He grumbled to himself as he reached for the door handle. He had a prediction of what was going to come out of the hobbit’s mouth first as soon as he opened the door—given the day of his untimely visit—and Bilbo loathed to hear it.
“Merry Christmas, Mister Baggins,” Mister Applegate greeted with a smile before Bilbo could finish opening the door, eliciting a deep, unfettered sigh from within the hobbit.
“Mister Applegate,” Bilbo greeted back, “Could I ask the reason for your inopportune visit to my smial?”
The younger hobbit rocked back and forth on his feet nervously even as he stood tall, chin up. “Mister Baggins, I was hoping to discuss my back rent if at all possible, sir.”
Bilbo huffed, not wanting to deal with something on such a day, but he was having a difficult time recalling the state of Mister Applegate’s accounts at the top of his head at the moment. So, with much internal fuss, Bilbo stepped back to let the hobbit in.
“I will look at my books to see the state of your affairs, and we shall get this matter settled once and for all,” Bilbo stated, “I was generous when your daughter fell ill, but I will tell you, my leniency has its limits.”
Bilbo pulled the appropriate file from his desk as he sat down with Mister Applegate seated across from him nervously. Hamfast was still right outside the window, but Bilbo didn’t pay he or Mister Applegate any mind as he looked over the file. It was quite uninteresting, really, and no wonder Bilbo couldn’t recall the details of the account. Mister Applegate had simply stopped paying his rent during the harvest. Then, three months ago, they had come to an agreement that Mister Applegate would pay extra per-month for rent, with interest, until his debt was settled. He had gotten back on track and paid well until this last payment, which put him back into heavy debt.
A clean cut case, Bilbo reckoned. He closed the file, putting it back in his drawer as Mister Applegate shook nervously across from him.
“Please, Mister Baggins, I know you’re very angry about this, and I didn’t mean to fall behind on the rent. Yavanna knows, it being Christmas and all,” Mister Applegate whined, “That and, of course, little Gwen. Her lungs aren’t right still. The doctor takes his share, don’t he? It’s all just been too much. Oh, please, you must hear me, sir.”
That was enough of that. Bilbo stood, shooing the hobbit out of his smial as he continued to try to justify his poor financial status. Still, with all his excuses and whining, Bilbo wasn’t going to have any of it. He didn’t have to listen to it, so he wasn’t going to. It was a waste of time for him and for Mister Applegate.
“I expect you out by new years at the latest,” Bilbo stated blankly, opening his front door and shoving the younger hobbit out.
“Please, sir, only a moment more of your time–” Mister Applegate pleaded before he was cut off, the door slamming in his face.
Bilbo turned and made his way back to his study, promptly sitting and drafting up eviction notices for Mister Applegate and a few other neglected tenants to be sent out the following morning. He didn’t know why he had waited until now to do so, but he was grateful to Mister Applegate for bringing it to his attention.
“Mister Baggins?” Bilbo heard from the doorway, and he looked up to find Hamfast tentatively waiting there with a bundle of letters in his hand. “The mail came as I was working out front, so I thought I would bring it to you.”
Uninterested, Bilbo went back to his eviction notices. “Read them to me, Hamfast,” he instructed as he worked.
Hamfast went through the letters one by one, most of them being dismissed by Bilbo only a few words in as junk from his relatives or people asking for charity—two things he didn’t care to hear about in person or in letters.
“I think this one’s from that tall fella that used to do the firework shows at parties a couple decades back,” Hamfast said, the words an immediate damper on Bilbo’s mood.
“Just tell me who it says it is from, Hamfast,” Bilbo instructed with a grumble, uninterested in what that meddling wizard had to say if it was, in fact, from him.
“It is a letter from Gandalf the Grey,” Hamfast explained, “Should I add this to your pile to respond to? I forgot you and him went on that adventure when–”
“No,” Bilbo was quick to respond, “You may throw that one away. I am not interested.”
“Are you sure? You and he were the talk of the Shire when I was a lad, if I remember correctly,” Hamfast added, doubling down and making Bilbo’s blood boil.
“You are always talking about wishing to put more coal in the furnace on days like this,” Bilbo said, voice gruff. “How about you start with that as some tinder first thing tomorrow morning?”
“T– tomorrow?” Hamfast asked, “Why, but that’s Christmas, sir.”
“And?”
“I was hoping to spend the day with my family,” Hamfast explained, his breath the slightest bit shaky. “No one will be working tomorrow.”
“The weeds in my garden will be working, no doubt,” Bilbo rebutted, still unwilling to look up from his documents. “And the cold will continue to break through my new greenhouses if you don’t finish the winterization. Those will not wait.”
“But–”
“Christmas is a very busy time, Hamfast,” Bilbo replied, “People preparing feasts, giving parties, spending all their money on frivolities. It is unnecessary and nonsensical. Why, with the money it takes to put on the festivities around the Shire, one might say the holidays are a time of loss rather than of merriment and joy.”
There was a pause where Hamfast stood there silently as Bilbo wrote, still wholly unamused. Bilbo was fed up. First with Mister Applegate and then with Hamfast Gamgee—it seemed more and more like the residents of the Shire didn’t care at all for hard work despite it being the backbone to a proper, functioning society.
“Sir, my family is expecting me there. Little Sam still isn’t–”
“Your family is expecting you to provide for them, not sit at home twiddling your fingers and singing Christmas carols!” Bilbo spat with a huff, cutting off the gardener one final time. “So, either show up early tomorrow morning ready to work, or do not show up at all! You’re dismissed, Hamfast.”
The gardener stammered for a moment or two before turning to leave. Only when Hamfast’s back was to Bilbo did the old hobbit look up to watch him go. Once the gardener was well and gone, closing the door behind him, Bilbo shook his head and muttered to himself. He seemed to be the only one to recognise the foolishness of Christmas, of spending above one’s means, of putting so much importance on spending time with loved ones and helping others. Bilbo knew well how useless such matters were in the end.
A small voice outside his home caught Bilbo’s attention, and he stood to find a little faunt waiting at his gate, waving as Hamfast approached him and greeting the hobbit loudly. Bilbo recognised the little one; not by familiarity but because his description had been on the lips of every gossip monger at one time or another for the past year or so.
“Sam!” Hamfast exclaimed, patting his smallest son on the head as he crossed through the gate of Bag End and latched it in place.
“Hello, father,” the little faunt greeted, “I thought I would walk you home.”
They ambled together for a moment before the conversation got too quiet for Bilbo to catch, though it sounded lively. After a few more hobbled steps, Hamfast picked up little Sam and placed the faunt on his shoulders, using one hand to keep the lad in place as the other grasped Sam’s small crutch.
Sam had always been a small, rather sickly child from what Bilbo had heard. Though it wasn’t until a year or so ago that poor nutrition and constant sickness gave way to fatigue in the lad, and he had begun using his little crutch. Still, even with his ailments, the little fellow was as happy as could be. Bilbo sighed, watching Hamfast and Sam walk down Bagshot Row as they spoke animatedly to one another.
Once Hamfast had well and truly departed and the sun began to set, an eerie silence filled Bag End. There was no humming, no bird chatter outside or distant footsteps walking down Bagshot Row. Bilbo busied himself to keep the uneasy feeling at bay, but once he had nothing else to do, he left his study. The hobbit’s old bones ached as he made his way through the smial to his bedroom, his body reminding him just how aged it was. Though, despite his age, Bilbo was on edge, his nerves alight and feet ready to bolt as the eerie feeling increased the longer he walked through the smial with nothing but a candle to light his way.
As he opened the door to his bedroom, the small flame in his hand not being much of a guide, a dark figure appeared suspended near his wardrobe. Bilbo jumped with a yelp, his old bones feeling youthful once again for the single, adrenaline filled moment. Fear coursed through him only for a few seconds though, before a realisation took over him, and Bilbo huffed in annoyance as he walked over.
“Oh, my best dressing gown,” Bilbo muttered as he set down his candle and took the robe from where it hung on the corner of his wardrobe door.
It was the nicest one he owned despite it being quite old. The patchwork design was still well enforced, though some of the brighter colors had faded the slightest bit. The once deep red tones were closer to a salmon, but it was still just as nice. Besides, there was no reason to spend money on a new one when the old thing worked just fine.
With the fear completely out of his system, Bilbo put on his night clothes quickly and wrapped the lovely dressing gown around him before the cold got to him. Afterwards, he wandered back downstairs for a late supper by the fire as he did many evenings.
When there was no one to serve at a formal table, it was much simpler to eat by himself in the comfort of his rocking chair. So, with some cold cuts of meat on bread, along with a simple tea, Bilbo sat in front of his small fire with his meal. The bread was stale, the tea sugarless and the meat awfully salty, but Bilbo ate anyway in the silence of Bag End.
The eeriness still followed him, though he ignored it as best he could—as he did with many bothersome things in his life. Christmas was a dismal time of year, so a feeling of unease was nothing to be alarmed by. Besides, after being foolishly startled by his dressing gown, Bilbo refused to be frightened by anything else—be it a vase, tapestry, or bookshelf.
Around him, the smial creaked and settled, the sound hauntingly similar to someone shuffling through the distant, echoing halls. Bilbo quickly brushed away that thought, taking another bite of his meal. No one would be in Bag End at such an hour other than him. No one would dare break into his home. Not even the fat fellow, Santa Claus himself.
The light in the room dimmed, and Bilbo looked down to find his fire quickly receding despite there being plenty of wood in the fireplace. Then, the creaking came again, louder and more persistent. A small clinking noise—gentle and airy—caught Bilbo’s attention as it slowly got closer to him in the darkness of Bag End. Bilbo was alight with fear once more, his body unable to move from his chair despite his mind screaming at him to run, start up the fire again, yell; just do something. Anything to dismiss the blinding terror coursing through him.
The sound got closer and closer, whoever or whatever it was approaching at a terribly slow pace. Just when Bilbo thought no one and nothing would actually show, the noises only being the product of an old hobbit’s overactive imagination, a figure appeared in the doorway to his sitting room. As they approached, stark clarity of their appearance hit Bilbo, a name almost spilling from the hobbit’s mouth before he quickly stopped himself.
There was a dwarf standing in his home. Well, not exactly standing. As the dwarf moved to halt before Bilbo, the hobbit found that the dwarf’s feet did not touch the ground. Instead, they were suspended above it as if floating in water, chains dragging behind them in the air from where they wrapped around their forearms and ankles.
What did some ghostly apparition want from Bilbo? Why did they look so eerily similar to someone Bilbo had not laid his eyes on in decades? The one person Bilbo wished so desperately to have again yet loathed to see in the appearance of this figure. The reminder brought pain to Bilbo’s chest, almost enough to distract him from his shuddering fear as he sat before the spectral figure.
“Bilbo Baggins,” the entity muttered, their voice gruff. “Son of Belladonna Took and Bungo Baggins.” It was not a kind greeting, nor a greeting at all.
“Yes.” Bilbo gulped. “Who are you?”
“I am Thrór, Son of Dain,” the spirit replied, voice booming. “And you, Bilbo Baggins, must heed my words.”
Bilbo’s brows furrowed as he thought, a bout of confusion plaguing him. Thrór was a familiar name to him, but he was sure he had never met the dwarf in front of him, if the spirit was a dwarf under the rattling of chains and dark aura. He wracked his brain, pulling from past memories to trace the name. Finally, a phrase; a title, spoken by many, though one he hadn’t heard in quite some time came to the forefront of Bilbo’s mind—Son of Thráin, Son of Thrór, called Oakenshield—and he gasped.
Stumbling out of his rocking chair, Bilbo quickly stood and backed away from the spirit, recognition dawning on him. Yes, the spirit looked an uncanny amount like the great statue back in Erebor and even more like another Bilbo wished not to remember. Still, even with the resemblance, Bilbo could not believe it. Thrór was dead, and ghosts simply did not exist. They couldn’t. Yes, the dwarf was floating but– well, it was impossible. It was all impossible.
“It looks like you, as I have seen you carved in stone, but I don’t believe it,” Bilbo said, shaking his head. “I can’t believe it.”
“Why do you doubt your senses?” Thrór asked.
“Because… well, because a little thing can affect them,” Bilbo reasoned, not just with the ghost but himself as well. “A slight disorder of the stomach can make them cheat. You may be a bit of undigested beef. A blob of jam. A crumb of cheese.” Bilbo pointed at the spectral figure as he backed away towards the far wall of his sitting room. “Yes, there is more of gravy than of grave about you!”
Thrór let out a low laugh. “More of gravy than of grave?” He questioned. “My, you are more of a hobbit than I gave you credit for, being tied to my grandson and all.”
“Do not speak of such things,” Bilbo growled out, “You do not know of me or my life, so do not pretend as though you do and mock me for it. Now tell me of your business here or leave my home.”
Thrór moved forward towards Bilbo, his chains rattling as he did so.
“I have come to warn you, Bilbo Baggins,” Thrór stated gravely, “If you do not change your ways forthwith, you will end up like me.”
Bilbo looked the dwarf over. Yes, he was clearly dead, but to what the spirit was referring to, Bilbo was unsure.
“H-how do you mean?”
Thrór sighed then gestured to the chains that bound him, a grave heaviness settling on his shoulders despite his weightless appearance.
“I have never returned to the halls of my maker, never felt the comforting embrace of my kin who have passed on without me.” Thrór’s face twisted into one of grief and pain. “I am cursed to live beyond the bounds of death for all time, never to see the world rebuilt, as the Valar have made it so.”
“Why is that?” Bilbo questioned.
“Greed, Bilbo Baggins,” Thrór uttered, “My greed consumed me just as your grief and resentment consumes you now. I was bitter, selfish, and lost sight of what truly mattered. My actions in the pursuit of gold caused my kingdom to fall and many lives to be lost.”
“But– but that was the gold sickness,” Bilbo argued, “From the- the Arkenstone, yes? The king’s jewel. The Valar cannot fault you for that.”
He had seen the same thing happen in real time—the way gold could infect the mind of even the most caring and honorable of dwarves. The Valar had no right to punish Thrór because of a sickness of the mind.
Thrór paused for a moment then shook his head, his face contorted in shame. “Even after I lost the Arkenstone and the wealth of Erebor, my selfishness remained. My heart was forever hardened, and it led to my own death and the death of my son and grandson. The gold did not do that, just as the grief you hold does not justify what you do now. Your actions will lead to your own ruin if you follow the same path as I.”
Bilbo listened, he heard what the ghost had to say, but he could not believe it. He knew the stories of Thrór, knew how the fallen king had led his people to their deaths at the Battle of Moria, but if what he said was true about Bilbo following the same path to ruin, then there was no hope.
When Bilbo did not immediately acknowledge what Thrór said, the dwarf spoke again.
“You will be haunted by three spirits,” Thrór explained, his tone as cold as he was.
“Haunted?” Bilbo’s voice wobbled, his mind still reeling from the spectre’s earlier admission. “I’ve already had enough of that.”
“Without these visits, you cannot hope to avoid the path I tread,” Thrór added, “Expect the first ghost tonight, when the bell tolls one.” He didn’t leave room to argue, yet Bilbo still did.
Panic surged through Bilbo. What Thrór was saying could not be true. If Bilbo was to continue on as he was, he would never see the Green Hills of Yavanna? He would never see his parents again? Fíli, Kíli… Bilbo couldn’t bear such a cruel fate, so it was not true. He refused to believe such a ridiculous lie. In fact, the ghost of Thrór before him probably wasn’t even real at all, so therefore, his warning could not be real either. If Bilbo just went to bed, his awful nightmare would simply go away.
“That is rubbish, and I will not believe it,” Bilbo argued, cursing himself as his voice wobbled again. “You are just some spectral delusion brought on by fatigue and indigestion, and I will not listen one bit to your nonsense ramblings, so good night, and go away.”
Bilbo turned to walk back to his room, ready to sleep away the odd vision, when something wrapped around his foot dragging him back from his attempt to escape. Bilbo yelped, looking down to see a chain pulling him towards an enraged dwarf—a sight all too familiar to him.
“Son of Belladonna Took and Bungo Baggins, heed my words!” Thrór commanded from where he floated above Bilbo as the hobbit cowered on the ground. “When dawn breaks on Christmas morning, you must learn to live a selfless life, or you shall be chained to your fate as I am now!”
The room shook as Thrór spoke, his voice rattling the very earth under and around them. Bilbo closed his eyes tightly and covered his ears, pleading in his mind for the spirit to spare him from his mighty wrath. The world felt as though it was bearing down on him with all its strength. Bilbo’s body shook as he sobbed, the fear overwhelming his senses.
“Change!”
Following Thrór’s final command, a shrill howl echoed through the room for just a moment before ceasing completely. Everything stilled, and once Bilbo found the strength to open his eyes, he was greeted with the warm light of a brightly burning fireplace and a cold, empty smial as if Thrór had never been there in the first place.
Chapter 2: The First of Three
Chapter Text
Following the harrowing encounter with the spirit of Thrór, Bilbo fell into the empty silence of a dreamless sleep. However, the small bit of comfort sleep offered him was quickly ripped away. As the clock struck one, Bilbo awakened, Thrór’s words echoing in his mind—Expect the first ghost tonight, when the bell tolls one.
Bilbo’s heart thudded in his chest as he waited for a minute and then two, yet no spirit ever came. No footsteps, or voices, or chains. Not even the howling of the wind outside his window or the creak of Bag End settling in the night. It was silent as the dead, if Bilbo could still think such a thing following his loud accosting by the departed. All was silent, and all was right.
Bilbo turned in his bed, adjusting his pillow to fall asleep once more when a brilliant, white light encompassed the room. It wasn’t a lantern or a fire, as it was much too bright even for that. Bilbo squinted his eyes, trying to locate the source of the light despite there being no discernable focal point that could emit such a penetrating glow. Bilbo was blinded by the brilliance as if the sun itself had descended upon him at midday.
After a few moments, the illumination receded until a figure appeared from within it, absorbing the rest of the imposing light until there was only a faint glow around them. In front of Bilbo was a young hobbit lass. Not even through her tweens, if Bilbo had to guess. And just as Thrór had, the spirit floated rather than stood, her feet hovering just off the ground as her white dress flowed around her.
“Are you the spirit Thrór spoke of?” Bilbo asked, hesitant to even acknowledge the figure staring at him from the foot of his bed.
“I am,” the spirit replied, her youthful voice wafting through the room.
“But you’re just a child,” Bilbo replied.
“I can remember far beyond your time; beyond that of even the Shire,” the spirit spoke, her diction telling of a more aged being than she appeared. “I am the ghost of Christmas past.”
“What business has brought you here?” Bilbo asked, skeptical.
Yes, he remembered Thrór’s words and warning, but he wished to hear it from the child, from the spirit herself.
“Your welfare,” she bluntly stated.
Bilbo scoffed. “A night’s unbroken rest might aid my welfare,” Bilbo shot back, “and not being attacked and scolded by spirits, that would help me plenty.”
“Your salvation, then,” the ghost answered, pivoting. “Take heed. Come.”
The wide window in Bilbo’s bedroom opened, the cold air rushing in along with the smallest gust of snow from the bank outside. Bilbo hurried to put on his dressing gown before he caught a chill and turned back to the spirit.
“I beg you, Spirit, I am a mortal hobbit and an old one at that,” Bilbo said, loathing to use his age as an excuse. “Should I go out in that cold, I shall perish before long.”
Perhaps if she believed that Bilbo could not bear such a task, she would leave him be. However, as the spirit sent him a gentle look and offered her hand to him, he knew that would not be the case.
“A touch of my hand, and you shall not fall to the elements, I assure you.”
Even though Bilbo knew he would surely regret it, he took the hobbit girl’s small hand in his own, letting her guide him through the window. Once he was through it though, his feet did not sink into the cold snow. No, as he exited his home, he began to fly alongside the spirit as she guided him well above and beyond the mortal confines of Bagshot Row.
“Spirit?!” Bilbo hollered as they flew.
“Yes?”
“Nothing,” Bilbo answered, his mind blank.
He wasn’t sure what he had tried to say, and if he attempted to speak more, he feared he would lose his meager supper. Still, even with the fear coursing through him, the Shire was beautiful. It sparkled brilliantly. All the Christmas lights twinkled as if they were their own stars that the night sky looked down upon with envy.
In the distance, a similar brilliant light glowed brightly as they flew towards it. It was not the sun, as it was still the middle of the night, and the sky had not begun to lighten yet.
“Spirit, what is that light?” Bilbo asked, “It cannot be dawn.”
“It is the past,” the spirit answered plainly.
Bilbo squinted his eyes closed as they passed through the light, trying to block out as much of it as he could and hoping he wasn’t incinerated by it. He’d had enough threats of incineration for one life.
When Bilbo opened his eyes again, it was day. He was still above the Shire, but it was different. Rather than flying away from home, he could instead see Bag End growing closer in the distance. Even odder, the Shire he flew above was changed. The old schoolhouse was standing once again even though it had been demolished a decade ago to build a new forge. The Sackville-Baggins’ front door was light yellow again instead of that garish purple it had been painted after Lobelia married Otho and moved in. They were, truly, in the past. Yet what past that was, Bilbo was unsure, and he didn’t particularly wish to find out.
Slowly, Bilbo and the spirit descended until he was at the front door of Bag End. Despite it being cold outside, his front door was open, letting the frigid air in as the smell of fresh baked pies wafted out. His father’s pies.
Just as Bilbo moved to step into his home, a gentle, familiar voice spoke from inside. Bilbo’s heart sped up as the voice grew closer until the owner rounded the corner to the door.
“... can never learn to shut the door behind them,” Bungo Baggins muttered as he walked up to shut the door before pausing. “Oh, you’re home!” He exclaimed with a joyful smile, opening his arms in greeting.
A weak whimper left Bilbo as he moved forward to hug his father, tears in his eyes, when Bungo stepped out of the doorway and moved right past him without a single glance back. Bilbo followed his father’s form to where he walked down to open the gate to Bag End. There, on the other side of the gate, stood Bilbo’s mother, Belladonna, and most surprisingly, himself. He wasn’t even a tween yet; barely taller than the gate itself. His mother was young, too. All of them were. And they were happy.
“Now, what have you brought home for me to cook with?” Bungo asked the young Bilbo as all three of them walked into the smial together, completely bypassing Bilbo and the spirit as if they weren’t even there.
“Those are my parents,” Bilbo spoke, not just to the spirit but to himself as well to cement that they were truly there, alive. “I don’t understand. Why do they ignore me?”
“These are but shadows of your past, Bilbo,” the spirit explained patiently, “They can neither see nor hear you. Come, let us go inside.”
The spirit floated into Bag End, beckoning Bilbo to follow her, and despite his soul aching at the idea of seeing his parents alive and well without being able to embrace them or even speak with them, he had to. His heart hurt at the thought, but he knew it would hurt much worse if he walked away.
A flood of memories came back to Bilbo as he walked through the Bag End of his childhood. Everything brought out an emotion from him—the bright garlands his mother had picked out, the old Christmas tree set up in the sitting room decorated with the most awful homemade ornaments, colorful paper strewn about the place from when he had undoubtedly hastily opened his Christmas gifts hours earlier.
“I know it all so well, spirit,” Bilbo said as they wandered through his old forgotten home. “The tree, the smell of the pinecone and hollyberry wreaths.” The small Bilbo ran past him with a carved dragon he held up as if it was flying. “The joy of playing with the presents Santa brought me on Christmas Day.”
Bilbo cleared his throat of the emotion trapped there before he kept moving through the smial, finally finding his parents in the kitchen. Half a feast was set out on the counters while his father stirred up something more in a bowl and Belladonna chopped vegetables beside him. He hummed while he mixed, pulling a happy smile from Belladonna.
“Do you think this will be enough food for the party?” Bungo asked after a moment.
Belladonna laughed. “With the appetite of your family, who knows?”
“And with the temper of yours, I’m not sure how many of these pies will actually make it to the table,” Bungo joked, resulting in a jab of Belladonna’s elbow into her husband’s side.
“My family would never stoop so low as to throw pies,” she corrected, “though I do have a faint recollection of my cousins lobbing dinner rolls at one another during last year’s appetizers."
“I remember it now,” Bilbo stated as his parents continued to banter back and forth. “We always held a family party on Christmas Day. All my cousins would come over, and we would play games.” Bilbo laughed as a specific memory was brought back to his mind. “I remember one year, I had accidentally sat on my cousin Lily’s wooden doll and broken its leg. The poor lass was so upset for the rest of the night. She might still hold a grudge to this day, now that I think about it. I haven’t been invited to any dinner parties of hers for a few decades at least.”
Bilbo used to love parties in his youth. He remembered all of them quite fondly. Well, most of them, but the drab gatherings Lobelia and Otho held barely counted as parties in Bilbo’s eyes.
He sighed. “I haven’t actually attended a party in quite some time,” Bilbo told the spirit. “I fear I have forgotten what they are actually like.”
“Oh, would you like to see?” The spirit asked with the slightest smile, the most emotion she had shown their whole time together.
Before Bilbo could get more than a squeak out in anxious protest, the room shifted. The kitchen, previously quiet save for a small intimate moment between husband and wife, was now bustling with people as loud conversations and jolly music flooded the smial.
"This is not what I meant!" Bilbo barked at the spirit, yet he knew she wasn’t going to listen to him.
Instead of responding, the spirit began floating away from him, gliding through the smial as if in search of something. Bilbo, with nothing else to do, followed behind her pensively. Even through the cacophony of voices and the endless amount of relatives strewn about the place drinking and making merry, a deep voice caught Bilbo’s attention. The sound of it—the person’s diction and the way it resonated through the smial—Bilbo knew who it was before he rounded the corner into the sitting room.
Bilbo stifled an exasperated groan as he found Gandalf sitting in there with a group of faunts around him. They sat on the floor as Gandalf seemed to be finishing one of his fantastical stories. A faint memory of one such tale involving an oliphaunt and a peacock came to mind, though Bilbo couldn’t remember the details of it, and now, he doubted it was a true story at all. With the wizard’s imagination, he could’ve made it up on the spot. Whatever story he was finishing up now, however, had the faunts absolutely entranced.
Next to Gandalf stood Bilbo’s mother, listening intently to the tale as well with a glass of wine in her hand. Bilbo only gathered the last tail ends of what was being said—something about a princess and a flying horse—but the story was soon over, and the children were dismissed to run about the house again, a younger Bilbo among them, he realized after the fact. Though the hushed conversation between his mother and Gandalf was much more intriguing than the happenings of a gaggle of faunts.
“He has your spirit,” Gandalf said, gesturing to where the group of faunts had run off to, and Bilbo was bright enough to gather that the wizard was talking about him.
Belladonna scoffed. “Please, he takes after Bungo much more than I,” she retorted, “They love cooking together, fishing, gardening. He couldn’t care less for adventure.” She sighed and took a sip of her wine. “It seems the Baggins side has won out.”
Gandalf gave a low chuckle, downing the full glass of wine in his hand that looked much smaller in his grasp. “And what would you call him searching the Old Forest for elves if not a sense for adventure?” Gandalf questioned, making Belladonna sputter. “I can see greatness in him. He will surprise us with his courage, I’m sure of it.”
Bilbo didn’t know what to say to that, or what to think either. It almost felt wrong eavesdropping on his mother’s conversation with Gandalf, though seeing as it was a memory that already occurred, he wasn’t sure what it could hurt. Was Gandalf right? Memories flashed through his mind—running through the Shire towards an unforgivable adventure, holding a sword against an orc in a burning forest, looking into the eyes of a great dragon.
Bilbo quickly shoved those memories away.
“No, Gandalf is wrong, as usual,” he said aloud as the wizard and his mother continued their hushed conversation. “That adventure was a one time thing, and it was…” Bilbo wanted to say terrible, awful, the worst decision he ever made, but he couldn’t; no matter how many emotions those memories conjured up, they all held something much more precious, and Bilbo couldn’t let him go.
Bilbo took a deep breath, focusing back on Gandalf’s words.
“-won’t be a child forever, Bella,” Gandalf said, “he may prefer to stay close to home for now, close to you and Bungo, but there will come a day when he will go out on his own, and when that day comes, I doubt there is any force in the world that will stop him.”
Belladonna sighed. “And when that day comes, you’ll look out for him?” She asked quietly from behind her glass.
“Assuming you won’t be there beside him for whatever trouble he gets himself into?” Gandalf joked.
“I will not be young forever, Gandalf,” she reminded him, “My adventuring days are already behind me as it is.”
“I am getting quite old in years as well, you know,” Gandalf replied.
Belladonna let out a small laugh. “We both know that you will outlive me,” she stated, “outlive Bilbo, even.”
Bilbo’s heart dropped, the memory of his mother’s death coming back to him for a moment before he quickly pushed it away, rejecting it all together. It had happened so long ago that it rarely crossed Bilbo’s mind anymore. There was no point in bringing it up now at his old age.
Bilbo looked around him as Gandalf and Belladonna’s conversation continued, watching as more people filed into the room, crowding it and suffocating him. Most of the people at the party were dead now; died a long time ago along with Bilbo’s parents. Even in a lively room stuffed with old family and friends, he was all alone with no one to talk to but the spirit of a child who didn’t seem to care one bit for his well being despite her saying the opposite.
Bilbo’s father joined the group, standing in front of the Christmas tree with a glass in his hand. The memory moved around Bilbo against his will. He didn’t want to be there, to hear more of his parents’ voices, see them without being able to touch them, say he loved them. Bungo raised his glass in the air, the action getting everyone’s attention, the room hushing into silence.
“Thank you everyone for being here, and merry Christmas,” Bungo began, getting a round of cheers from the crowd. “As you know, Belladonna and I have been holding these parties since we got married. Yes, it might be just another excuse for the Tooks to drink themselves into a stupor.” The room lit up in laughter before dying down again. “But, in truth, we hold these parties every year because we love it. We love you all; we love this time of year. Christmas is an important holiday for our family, it is a time of giving, and we want to give that love to you. Merry Christmas everyone!”
The memory was distant, fuzzy as everyone gave a round of cheers and hugged. The room dimmed around him, the chatter going silent and the smell of mulled cider and pine leaving with it.
“Where-” Bilbo began before stopping to clear his throat and wipe his eyes, finally noticing emotion that had come up to the surface. “Where are we going?”
“Not every Christmas in Bag End was one of joy and laughter,” the spirit answered.
A new memory faded in, this one much darker. The walls of Bag End were stripped bare. Even his mother’s maps were gone from the walls, the little nicknacks taken from the shelves along with the shelves themselves. The smial that had been so full of life just moments before was now barren.
“Spirit, where did you take me?” Bilbo asked, his voice quivering.
The sound of sniffling and the crackling of fire pulled his attention from the drab state of his smial to the fireplace in his sitting room and the rocking chair in front of it. It was the same one he still had back home as it was his father’s before him. Bilbo moved around to see his younger self sitting in the chair, a weak stream of tears falling down his face.
“Please, Spirit, tell me you didn’t,” Bilbo begged, knowing now exactly what Christmas he had been taken to.
“This was the first Christmas where a party was not held in this home, where no presents were opened, and not even a single decoration was put up,” the spirit stated as if Bilbo didn’t already know that.
“They had taken the nice ones,” Bilbo explained, still entranced by himself as the younger Bilbo sniffled again and wiped away a tear. “My aunts and uncles and cousins, they had descended like vultures after the funerals and taken everything they could get their hands on. The few Christmas decorations I had left didn’t seem worth putting up with no one there to celebrate with me.” Bilbo let out a shaky breath. “A Christmas for one is hardly a Christmas at all.”
“And Gandalf?” The spirit questioned.
“I never saw him again until my 50th year,” Bilbo replied with a sniffle of his own.
The spirit was silent after that, the only sound in the room being the quiet crying of both Bilbos, young and old. There was nothing more to say. The spirit had taken him to a Christmas of such sadness and mourning. Barely of age yet left alone with nothing but an empty, ransacked home and a broken heart on what his parents claimed to be a day of family and love and giving. It was all rubbish.
“Every Christmas—both joyful and sad—has been spent in this home,” the spirit finally spoke in the dreary darkness of Bag End, “all… but one.”
Bilbo’s heart dropped as his vision was pulled away from Bag End; from that lonely hearth he spent countless Christmases in front of, wallowing in his own grief and pity. It should have been a relief to get away from such memories, yet he was transported to one much worse. Even in his old age, Bilbo’s memory was quite keen, and he recalled only one Christmas away from Bag End; away from the Shire. As his nose filled with the scent of old caverns and barren tombs, the warm, wooden floors beneath his feet replaced by cold stone, his own, younger yet unmistakable, voice shakily reading aloud from a book, Bilbo’s assumptions were dreadfully confirmed.
“Please, Spirit, I beg you,” Bilbo pleaded, eyes burning with tears ready to run. “Do not make me relive this. Not this Christmas. Not here.”
Despite his desperate begging, the spirit did not respond, watching in reserved silence as the scene unfolded before them—an old memory, fixed in time and unable to be changed or mended. Even though it felt so real, nothing could be done. Not then, and not ever.
In front of him, as clear as the day it had occurred, a younger Bilbo sat on a stone floor with his back pressed against cold, carved marble—a grave; one of three. A large, dwarven book was propped on his lap as he read aloud. It wasn’t like when he would read to his mother, or to the young faunts of family members during gatherings. No, it was a sorrowful read, a solitary read as much as both Bilbos, young and old, wished it wasn’t.
Footsteps approached, and both Bilbos looked up to see Dwalin walking over. The dwarf’s face looked fatigued, pained. No one spoke as Dwalin approached. Not until the dwarf was standing right in front of the younger Bilbo, the two of them toe to toe as Dwalin stared down at him. Young Bilbo was quick to avert his gaze back down to his book. Even after all they had been through together, the harsh, critical gaze Dwalin held always made Bilbo feel uneasy.
“The others are drinking and dancing if you wish to join us,” Dwalin offered, but the younger Bilbo didn’t respond. The hobbit glared at his book, ignoring the dwarf’s words.
Young Bilbo seemed to have decided to ignore Dwalin, not giving any acknowledgement that he had even heard him speak.
After a pause, Dwalin huffed and shook his head. “Bilbo, you cannot truly believe you can stay down here forever,” the dwarf said, “Mahal’s Beard, lad, you even sleep down here most nights.”
There was another long silence where neither Dwalin nor the younger Bilbo spoke, the hobbit absent-mindedly flipping through pages of the book as if Dwalin wasn’t even there, as if he was an observer like Bilbo and the spirit were.
“I hadn’t even realized that it was Christmas when we had this conversation,” Bilbo said as he watched, struck with grief and shock. “I had lost track of time around when preparations for the battle had begun, and afterwards, it had become completely irrelevant to me until Gandalf returned to take me back to the Shire.”
Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo saw the spirit give the smallest of nods in acknowledgment, but Bilbo himself was too transfixed on the scene to say any more about it. Dwalin’s face morphed from one of exhaustion to frustration, his face twisting into a sour glare.
“You’re just going to sit here forever, ignoring me, us, your friends?” Dwalin questioned, his voice steadily rising. “It is not healthy, and it is not right. Do you think he would want– !?”
The sound of younger Bilbo’s book being slammed shut echoed through the tomb, its force silencing Dwalin and making the older, spectral Bilbo gulp. He remembered what had been spinning through his mind during that conversation: the words, the plea, that had been given him on Ravenhill—go back to your books, and your armchair. Plant your trees, watch them grow. But at that time, no matter how Bilbo tried to reason with himself, he wouldn’t allow himself to leave the mountain, leave that room for more than a moment at a time, leave him.
Young Bilbo sniffed and then cleared his throat. “I know that I did not know him for as long as you had, not even close, and I do not have the right to grieve for him as if I did.” His youthful voice was thick with emotion as he spoke. “But he was still mine. I loved him as if we had known each other our whole lives, and now the chance to live out the rest of ours together is gone.”
“Bilbo, you need–”
“Please, let me grieve in peace,” younger Bilbo cut in, his voice sharp. “Sitting here, reading, it is much better than what I have seen you do of late to deal with your grief, so do not judge me when you are in a drunken stupor every other time I see you.”
Whatever Dwalin was going to say got stuck in his throat, his mouth clamping shut. Without another word, the dwarf turned and walked back towards the doorway he had entered from and where the older Bilbo and the spirit watched. Dwalin’s face twisted into one of anguish as he left, tears pricking at his eyes, but he didn’t look back. The dwarf quietly walked out of the room and closed the door behind him. In the silence of the tomb, the younger Bilbo slowly opened his book back up and began reading where he left off.
Bilbo’s mouth had gradually dropped open as he had watched the scene unfold. He racked his memory for the next time he and Dwalin had spoken, but his mind brought him no solace, no resolution. Bilbo turned to the spirit in a panic.
“Please, Spirit, do not tell me that is the last thing I ever say to Dwalin,” he pleaded.
The spirit sighed. “I only live within the Christmases past, but there might be more to see in the present and the future—answers to the questions you keep asking yourself,” she said somewhat solemnly, “Would you like to return home now, Bilbo Baggins?”
Panic coursed through him. While he desperately wished to leave such a terrible memory, if Bilbo left now, it was set in stone. He would not be able to fix it, to do something.
“But– but wait! We need to stay and fix everything! Just let them see me, and I can explain!” Bilbo begged, though, deep down, he himself knew it was useless. What had been said was permanent; his memory was living proof of it.
As Bilbo begged, the room shifted once more until he was back in his room in Bag End. He stopped protesting once his feet were firmly on the ground and his vision cleared, yet angry tears still streamed down his face as he turned away from the spirit and looked around his room, making sure he was truly where he was meant to be. It was dark outside once again, and all his things remained as they were before he left.
Bilbo let out a shaky breath. He hadn’t wanted to leave in the first place, yet now that he was back, all he wanted was to get away. To go back to the party, to sit in solitude with his lonesome, younger self, to talk with Dwalin again. However, he knew it was useless to wish for such things. As the spirit had said, the past was set. There was nothing to be done.
“Farewell, Bilbo Baggins,” the spirit said from behind him, “You must now await the others. I have taken liberty in fixing your clock. It shall not fail you again.”
“What did you do to my clock?” Bilbo turned to the spirit, but she was gone as soon as he did, not even a wisp of her light remaining in his room.
Chapter 3: The Second of Three
Chapter Text
The clock chimed loudly, causing Bilbo to shoot up with a gasp. The time read two in the morning—an hour past the first spirit’s arrival. He waited for a moment, then two, and yet, no apparition of any likeness appeared in his room. No light; no sounds other than the wind howling outside. With a grumble, Bilbo moved to roll over and go back to bed when a sudden faint, warm light from under the doorway caught his eye, and a distant humming reached his ears.
Knowing that something, spirit or not, was downstairs in his smial burning the midnight oil, both figuratively and literally, pulled an annoyance from Bilbo that he could not ignore. In a huff, he grabbed his robe and creeped down the stairs, foregoing a candle to light his way.
As he made it to the bottom of his staircase, Bilbo found that he didn’t need a candle anyway. The lights throughout his smial were all lit, illuminating it fully. Curious, Bilbo wandered towards the faint humming sound, now accompanied by shuffling and rummaging around. Nerves flooded Bilbo. There was definitely someone or something in his smial, and it sounded and felt much more real than the previous two apparitions.
Bilbo turned the corner and stumbled in shock, stifling a gasp and curious yet scared of what he found rummaging through his large pantry. The man, for it was clearly a man by stature, had a long, fiery red beard that immediately reminded Bilbo of a younger Gloin. As Bilbo got closer to the open pantry though, the man spotted him and smiled—something that was distinctly not like Gloin, if Bilbo recalled correctly.
At first, Bilbo was inclined to assume the man was the second spirit sent by Thrór, and he still wasn’t convinced the man wasn’t, for why else would a stranger be in his smial on Christmas Eve? But unlike Thrór and the first spirit, the man was not floating or had an eerie aura following him. His feet were grounded to the floor as he walked around Bilbo’s home.
“Come in, and know me better, hobbit,” the man greeted as he passed through, carrying a great wheel of cheese.
Quite astonished that there was a stranger in his house, and that said man had taken a block of cheese, Bilbo followed after him as the man made his way to the dining room and sat down at a large feast. The hobbit-sized chair creaked under the man’s weight but thankfully did not break. Bilbo would have definitely sent him a bill for that if it had.
“Come in, and know me better, hobbit,” the man said again, gesturing to the seat across from him, though Bilbo did not move to sit. After a moment, the man continued. “Did I already say that?”
Bewildered, Bilbo replied, “You did, yes,” with full disbelief and scepticism in his voice, though he was well aware the strain of the night had left him beyond niceties.
“I am the Ghost of Christmas Present!” The man jovially greeted, and Bilbo’s suspicions were confirmed: the delusional dreams that haunted him in the night were far from over. “This is the night before the dawn before the day of Christmas! Did I tell you that I am the Ghost of Christmas Present?”
“Yes, indeed you did,” Bilbo affirmed once again with a tight, frustrated smile.
“Come in, and know me better, hobbit!” He repeated again, just as happy to greet Bilbo as the first two times.
“You’re a bit absentminded, Spirit,” Bilbo commented.
“No, I am a large absentminded spirit,” the spirit replied with a booming laugh, “Compared to a being of your stature, anyway. Isn’t that right, Bilbo Baggins?”
“Yes, I suppose so, Spirit,” Bilbo replied, though he was quickly growing tired of their back and forth conversation on top of the spirit calling him small, though indirectly. “Now, may I ask what you are doing here? If Thrór sent you, I’ll tell you now that I am wholly uninterested. The horrors I witnessed earlier in the night were enough to put this old hobbit halfway into his grave, so no more, I say, no more.”
While the spirit was much less eerie than the first—quite joyful, really—Bilbo did not trust the ghostly being and was fearful of what was to come if he continued on as he was.
“Well, of course! I am the Spirit of Christmas Present!” The spirit said again, “Have you ever noticed that everything seems wonderful at Christmas?”
Bilbo shook his head, chuckling incredulously. “No, I cannot say that I have,” Bilbo replied, though before he said anymore, he paused, thinking back to what the first spirit had shown him. “In truth, Spirit, perhaps I’ve never understood Christmas. At least, not for a long, long time.”
The spirit stood from the table, abandoning the feast as he walked up to Bilbo, hunched over as he was in the hobbit-sized smial.
“Before this day is done, you will.”
Before Bilbo could get a single note of protest out, a large hand rested on his shoulder, and the warmth and comfort of his smial faded away to be replaced by frigid cold, though while he had been greeted at night by the spirit, it was now well into the morning.
“I welcome you to Christmas morning!” the spirit announced.
Looking around, Bilbo found himself outside of Erebor, the large mountain towering over him in the near distance. His stomach filled with dread. He did not want to be back at the mountain again. Not after what the first spirit had shown him. While still quite youthful in spirit, Bilbo was old in years, and he was unsure how much heartache he could take. There was a reason he had not faced most of his old friends in so many years; a reason he had rather harshly and abruptly distanced himself. It was too much then, after losing his love, and it was still too much years later.
Besides, why should he care what they all were doing for Christmas half way across Arda without him?
“Please, spirit,” Bilbo begged, “I do not wish to see what they do in my absence; see the mountain as it is now without him. Take me home, I beg you.”
In response, the spirit gave a kind, almost pitiful smile and turned to look down the path that led away from Erebor. Bilbo followed the spirit’s gaze to find a tall figure further down the path walking towards them, headed towards Erebor.
Bilbo huffed. “Gandalf,” he grumbled, though his immediate annoyance with the wizard was quickly replaced with confusion. “What is he doing here on a day such as this?”
“Just watch,” the spirit solemnly replied, falling in step behind Gandalf as the wizard passed by them.
With no choice other than to follow, and his curiosity getting the better of him despite his worry, Bilbo chased after the two taller beings. The three of them made their way into the mountain, Bilbo and the spirit trailing behind Gandalf as he turned down a few different grand halls.
Erebor was no longer the crumbling, empty place it had once been when Bilbo had stayed there. Each corridor was warm, bright, lined with garlands of crystal, metal, and pine. People were bustling about the place, merry as they went on their way. Dwarves of all kinds happily celebrating together in the once desolate mountain. What had once been a place of death was now lively and full of happiness. A happiness that Bilbo had never seen there before; that his love had only dreamed of.
Gandalf reached large doors at the end of a long corridor and quickly opened them, light and laughter spilling from the room. Laughter that was all too familiar to Bilbo. Even as Gandalf stepped into the room and was greeted jovially by the dwarves inside, Bilbo stopped and gulped. A gentle hand rested on his shoulder, and he looked up to find the spirit smiling down at him with wrinkles slowly forming at the corners of his eyes.
“Christmas Day will not wait,” the spirit said, “and neither should you.”
“What lies beyond those doors, will it hurt me?” Bilbo asked, nerves rushing through him.
The spirit hummed for a moment. “I do not know what lies beyond the here and now,” he finally replied, “but I do know that when hurt, healing will soon follow.”
With one final, kind smile, the spirit led Bilbo forward, the two entering the room together. The room was loud, though not crowded as Bilbo was expecting. Instead, a group of older dwarves sat around a large fireplace all drinking and laughing at the far end of the grand room. As Gandalf approached them, the dwarves rose from their seats, greeting the wizard with wide smiles. As soon as they had turned towards Gandalf, and subsequently Bilbo and the spirit, blunt recognition washed over him, and his heart leapt in his chest.
“Why, it’s my friends,” Bilbo exclaimed, the sight of them making him momentarily forget that ‘friend’ was no longer quite accurate. “Dwalin, Balin, the Urs, the Ris, Oin, Gloin. And is that little Gimli? Though not quite that little anymore.”
Bilbo laughed. He remembered meeting Gimli when the young dwarf, along with a group of others from Ered Luin, had returned to the mountain right before the thaw when Bilbo was still stuck there. The dwarf, a spitting image of his father, had grown from barely coming up to Bilbo’s waist to now being much taller than him and larger, too. His beard was full and braided, a sign that Gimli had come of age, and Bilbo had missed it. He had missed it all.
The sight of his friends, greying as Bilbo was, filled him with a deep ache, a feeling of longing that couldn’t be quelled. Yes, he had pushed them away, he had been the one to sever such rich friendships, but that didn’t mean he didn’t miss them—no matter how much he tried to convince himself otherwise.
“They are all here together,” Bilbo said aloud, “for Christmas.”
He observed the group as they all settled into their seats once again, making room for Gandalf on one of the large sofas. Dwalin patted Gandalf on the back as he sat, handing the wizard a mug of ale.
“Gandalf, good of you to join us,” Dwalin said, “We were unsure if you received our letters.”
“Your letters are the only ones I have been receiving of late,” the wizard replied, taking a sip of his mug only to make the slightest of faces and put it down, pulling his pipe out instead. “This time of year, I am usually in the west, but I could not pass up an opportunity to see you all on such a lovely day.”
Bilbo hummed. He had no clue the whereabouts of the wizard most of the time. It always seemed to be at random when he would make an appearance in the Shire. He had only assumed that stopping by Erebor would have been much the same—unplanned and unexpected on the part of his hosts.
“Where have you been on your travels as of late?” Balin asked.
“Yes, tell us, Gandalf,” Bombur added, “We have all been quite comfortable here, not up for much travel with the mountain doing so well.”
“Oh, here and there,” Gandalf responded nonchalantly, blowing out a ring of smoke. He seemed hesitant, Bilbo could tell, though the wizard always seemed to be holding something back, keeping his cards close to his chest—even around friends.
“Have you… seen Bilbo at all during your travels?” Bofur hesitantly asked, the question followed quickly by a smack on the back of the head by Bifur.
Bilbo was taken aback. He had not anticipated being brought up at all in their conversation, though he should have expected it. He was, in fact, the only party member missing from their gathering. Well, the only living one, though Bilbo was quick to flush that line of thinking from his mind.
Gandalf sighed. “Yes, I saw him during the Shire harvest season when I was passing through on my way to the Blue Mountains.”
“Oh, yes, I remember that visit,” Bilbo said, though they clearly could not hear him. “Gandalf had come to bother me while I was working, so I shooed him away. Has it really been that long?”
“And…?” Oin asked after a pause in their conversation, all of them clearly waiting for the wizard to tell them more.
Gandalf took a long drag of his pipe, blowing it out heavily with a sigh. It was as if a weight had been set upon the wizard’s shoulders.
“Bilbo is…” He seemed to search for the correct words for a moment before sighing. “Our burglar has not been well as of late,” Gandalf admitted, unable to hear Bilbo’s protest that he was in perfect health.
“Is the lad sick?” Dwalin asked, clearly concerned. “Hobbits only live for so long.”
“No, Dwalin, Bilbo is quite healthy,” Gandalf corrected, “It is a sickness of the mind, rather. His grief has consumed him, molding him into a hard-hearted, stubborn, selfish hobbit. It is concerning, to say the least.”
Bilbo scoffed. “Well, that’s just a blatant lie. I am quite reasonable.”
He watched the spirit give him a sideways glance, but nothing was said as they watched on.
“Grief?” Gimli asked, eyes wide.
“Yes, my dear Gimli, grief,” Gandalf affirmed with a nod. “When someone loses their One, it takes a toll on them. A weight of unimaginable pain and sorrow. Since Bilbo has no kin to care for anymore, no one to hold dear in his One’s absence, that loss has grown into a ferocious beast.”
“Aye,” Balin added, solemnly. “There’s nothing in nature that freezes your heart like years of being alone.”
“Well, that is plainly untrue,” Bilbo argued with a scoff, “I see my dear cousin Drogo quite regularly as he stops by my smial for tea every two weeks or so. Yes, I might not see him as much since his union with that Brandybuck lass and the birth of his son, but he is in no way absent from my life.”
The spirit sighed from next to him, the tall man folding his arms, but he still refrained from commenting. Similarly, a silence stretched on in the room as Gandalf blew out another plume of smoke, the cloud morphing into three distinct figures before dissipating.
The wizard hummed inquisitively. “Still, I see now there is still hope for our friend,” Gandalf finally said, “Death comes in threes, yet so does life. Perhaps Bilbo will turn over a new leaf. I recently sent him a letter, though I do not know if it has been received yet, that I hope may help.” The wizard hummed again before shaking out his pipe and stashing it in his staff. “Enough of that, though. It is Christmas, so please, drink and make merry. We are here to celebrate, are we not?”
The room quickly picked up in energy again, the group all jovially chatting and laughing once more. Their conversations shifted to things of lesser importance—food, royal dignitaries, treaties, children, funny anecdotes, and games—yet Bilbo was still intrigued. He yearned to be there with them, to be able to contribute to the conversation and for them to actually hear him, to laugh with Bofur, chat with Bombur, apologize to Dwalin and to them all.
Why hadn’t they sent him an invitation to the party? It was exceptionally rude for the whole company to gather together, plus Gimli, yet neglect to extend an invitation to their burglar.
“You know why you did not receive an invitation, don’t you, Bilbo?” The spirit asked, the question rhetorical and almost taunting.
Yes, Bilbo did know. Of course he did. Bilbo’s mood soured once more. He turned to the spirit and glowered.
“If I am not permitted to join them, to right this wrong I cannot truly experience, please take me home,” he commanded to the greying spirit, his appearance now closer to Gandalf than a young man.
The spirit sighed, resting a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder. “I shall take you back to the Shire, though there is still more of the day to behold.”
Bilbo’s feet left the cold stone of Erebor as he was brought to a place even colder. The sun was low on the horizon, and the layer of snow covering the ground made Bilbo shiver. Once his vision fully cleared, and he figured out where the spirit had taken him, Bilbo huffed.
“This is not my home,” Bilbo said, stomping his foot.
“This is the Shire,” the spirit replied, “and I don’t think Bag End has been home for many Christmases. I have brought you to a home. One that truly understands the meaning of Christmas.”
Bilbo’s protest halted as a tired looking Hamfast walked by, little Sam on his shoulders. He watched as father and son walked through a small gate, through a beautifully cared for, winterized garden that rivaled Bilbo’s own, and up to a homely smial, opening the door to a familial greeting.
“Wouldn’t you like to follow them?” The spirit asked.
Bilbo glared slightly and stepped forward instead of giving a proper response, following Hamfast and Sam into the smial with tainted, annoyed interest. Bilbo had never given much thought to the Gamgees. He knew Hamfast had a rather large family, that he loved his wife and his children, but with no family of his own to relate back to, Bilbo had never been bothered enough to pay attention to the gardener’s ramblings when they both happened to be in the front garden together.
Inside the Gamgee home, Bilbo was surprised by what he saw. The smial was much smaller than Bilbo’s own, the doorway sharing a space with the kitchen, dining area, and sitting room. Children ran around the space, chasing one another. A small, pitiful tree sat in the corner with a few handmade ornaments hung on the sturdier branches.
Despite its appearance, the home was full of life. All of Hamfast’s children were swarming him right in front of the door, each one vying for his attention and saying how much they missed him, each one greeting him with “Merry Christmas.”
“Kids, please go set the table for dinner,” Hamfast’s wife, Bell, if Bilbo remembered, said as she walked up to the group. “The kids have been in a frenzy waiting for you to return home,” she said to her husband with an embrace and kiss on the cheek once the children had dispersed.
“You know Mister Baggins insisted I work today,” Hamfast replied with a sigh.
“It isn’t right,” Bell replied with a huff, turning away from her husband and back to whatever she was doing in the quaint kitchen as the kids continued to set up the dinner table. “How does he even know if you were there? You never see the fellow—that recluse.”
Hamfast shrugged. “He is lonely, Bell, and bitter,” Hamfast said to Bilbo’s defense, though Bilbo himself did not appreciate being described in such a way.
“I am not lonely or bitter,” Bilbo argued, spitting the words, though knowing well that no one could hear him other than the aging spirit next to him. “Wanting to live as I–"
“Nevermind what I say, then,” Bell said, unknowingly cutting Bilbo off. “This is a day of celebration and family, not bickering over your work which supports us.” She turned, placing a small roast on the table. “Christmas dinner is served.”
All the kids save for one sat down to wait patiently for the meager dinner. Bilbo watched as the last Gamgee child, Sam, hobbled over to his chair and was lifted onto it by his father, his cane resting against the wall next to him. The family quickly dug into the meal, each of them taking an equal portion, though each one much too small for any regular hobbit.
It was a meal befitting one, maybe two at most. More reminiscent of many of Bilbo’s own private meals as of late.
“Such a meager feast,” Bilbo said aloud to the spirit.
“But very much appreciated,” the spirit replied.
Bilbo sighed. “I pay Hamfast quite conservatively–”
“To Mister Baggins,” Hamfast interjected, raising his old glass filled with only water. Bilbo was taken aback by his own name, once more, being spoken by the Gamgee family. “It only seems right that I should lift a glass to my employer. I give you Mister Baggins, the founder of the feast.”
Bilbo could tell the gardener meant the toast genuinely and humbly, a gentle smile on his face. However, Bell held a sour expression.
She huffed. “If I had him here, I would give him a piece of my mind to feast upon,” she said, “and I bet he would choke on it.”
“Bell, it’s Christmas Day,” Hamfast gently reminded her.
“Well, I suppose that on the blessed day of Christmas, one must drink to the health of Mister Baggins even though he is odious, stingy, wicked, unfeeling, badly dressed–”
Before she could say more, a small voice interrupted her, a child’s hand raising a small glass. “To the founder of the feast, Mister Baggins,” Sam announced, and like his father, he meant it genuinely. “Yavanna bless us, every one.”
“Do they really hate me so?” Bilbo asked the spirit as the family somewhat begrudgingly drank to him and began eating their meal.
The spirit, however, gave no answer. Together, they watched the family eat their meal, speak of love, of memories, and of the joy of family. Kindness and happiness emanated from them in a way Bilbo had not felt himself since his parents were still around. For a family that had close to nothing, they were in many ways much more fortunate than Bilbo. With their meager feast in a small, cramped home, they had so much more than Bilbo could ever dream of.
As their meal came to a close, Bilbo watched little Sam move to stand. However, as the small fellow stood, he wavered in his step and fell, hitting the ground hard and taking his crutch with him. Both Bell and Hamfast were quick to their feet, helping Sam stand up and getting him situated on their small sofa with a glass of water. He looked frail. Much frailer than his kindness and outgoing nature would have others believe.
An indiscernible feeling crept up inside Bilbo as he watched the small child catch his breath, Sam’s weak form shaking a bit despite protestations he was fine.
“Spirit, tell me if Sam will live,” Bilbo requested, unsure of what prompted such a morbid question.
“That is the future,” the spirit explained gently, “My realm is the present.”
The spirit pushed off the wall he had been using to stay upright, age fatigue slowly taking him. Once more, he set a gentle hand upon Bilbo’s shoulder.
“However,” the spirit added, “I can see a vacant seat and a crutch without an owner. If these shadows remain unaltered, I believe the child will die.”
It was not the answer Bilbo wanted to hear. He wished he had not asked. However, like the rest of what he had seen thus far, he could not take back the question or the answer.
“Come,” the spirit beckoned as Bilbo’s vision of the scene before him began to fade, “My time grows short.”
His eyes did not leave Sam until he was fully taken away, finding himself outside the home, far away under the Party Tree with the empty expanse of field in front of him. Together, they stood in the darkness of the night, the only light being that of the moon and the faint glimmer of Christmas lights from downtown Hobbiton in the distance.
“Spirit, you have grown old,” Bilbo said to fill the silence as the spirit moved towards the Party Tree’s aging trunk.
“Indeed I have,” he replied, sitting at the base of the tree with a heavy sigh. “My time in this world is very brief. Once the bell tolls for the last time, I shall die.”
As he said that, the sound of the town bell could be heard faintly in the distance, marking the start of the end of Christmas Day.
“Now?” Bilbo asked the decrepit spirit, panic in his voice. “But, Spirit, I have learned so much from you!”
Yet nothing Bilbo could do or say stopped the terrible bell from ringing. The spirit began to glow as Bilbo begged, his body slowly fading.
“Oh, Spirit, do not leave me!” Bilbo exclaimed.
“I think I must, in fact,” the spirit replied with a comforting smile, “And now I leave you with the Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come.”
“You mean, the future?” Bilbo asked as the spirit continued to fade, his body merely a wisp of what it once was. “Must I?”
“Go forth, and know them better, hobbit,” the spirit said in farewell, his smile being the last thing Bilbo saw before the final bell rang out and the spirit was gone for good.
Chapter 4: The Last of Three
Chapter Text
A fog descended upon the field, covering the entire area in a chilling haze. Struck with terror, Bilbo ran around to the back of the Party Tree in a futile attempt to hide from what awaited him in the mist. The first spirit had been eerie but not threatening, the second had been welcoming and joyful, if not overly so. Whatever aura followed the third spirit, the Spirit of Christmas Yet To Come, held a malice that Bilbo did not wish to meet.
Bilbo hugged the backside of the tree, catching his breath and not daring to look around it. Without the hands of the spirits keeping him tethered and whole, his aging body had immediately become fatigued from fear and the speed at which he had fled from the fog.
It covered the field, enveloping Bilbo’s legs up to his knees. Yet, after fully catching his breath, Bilbo still did not hear anything within the fog from where he stood. Holding his breath, Bilbo leaned around the side of the tree to catch a glimpse of what it held, yet even through the dark, he could not see anything awaiting him.
Bilbo breathed out, turning to lean his back against the tree when a tall, hooded figure shrouded in darkness appeared on the other side of him. Bilbo shrieked in fear, heart pounding. The being was slender yet so intensely tall. Taller than anyone Bilbo had ever met before; tall enough Bilbo worried they might hit their head on the branches of the tree if they were not careful. It did not appear like the spirits before it, yet that was all Bilbo could assume it was.
It did not appear as a young child or a joyful man. This spirit, this being, it felt different—terrifying yet familiar. Not just a guide to the Christmas Yet To Come, but the one to bring about the end of what has been and the things not yet come to pass. A malice, Bilbo had called it, though now that didn’t feel quite right.
“Am I in the presence of the Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come?” Bilbo asked, his voice wavering in fear.
The spirit leaned forward slightly, its darkness creeping further towards Bilbo as it stared with an unseen gaze beyond its black hood. Which, in its own way, was an answer all on its own.
“Spirit, I fear you more than any spectre I have yet met,” Bilbo continued, looking up at where the apparition’s eyes were sure to be. “Despite my fear, I am prepared to follow and to learn, with a thankful heart, should you lead me to Christmas’ future.”
Bilbo was done running from what he knew he couldn’t. He had begged the other two spirits to leave him be, but he was through doing so. The kindness of the last spirit and the guidance of the first had brought a confidence in Bilbo he had not seen possible before.
“Will you not speak to me?” Bilbo timidly added after a moment of quiet staring.
The spirit moved forward and then around the tree, eliciting a small squeak of fear from Bilbo before they extended one long arm and pointed out into the distance. Bilbo leaned around the side of the tree and followed the spirit’s finger to see Hobbiton as their intended destination.
“Oh, yes,” Bilbo added with a nervous chuckle, “the night is waning fast. Lead on, Spirit.”
The spirit began walking away out of sight, yet Bilbo held back. He had already learned so much from the last two spirits, yet they had shown him what was set in stone. Would his future be much the same? Could he change what he was bound to see? He still feared for what he was going to witness in the Christmas Yet To Come, but it could not hurt him. At least, that was what he told himself as he finally turned from the Party Tree to join the spirit.
As soon as his hand left the rough bark, the sun shone brightly onto the field, blinding Bilbo momentarily. The fog receded, and when Bilbo could finally see the spirit in full clarity, he was perplexed. The dark, terrible figure that had come to guide him had changed. Without the shroud of darkness and fog, the spirit’s hood looked to be a deep forest green color rather than black, as Bilbo had first assumed. The hood was quickly pulled back to reveal long hair, a gentle smile, and pointed ears.
“Shall we?” The elf spirit asked, holding out a delicate hand for Bilbo to grasp.
The fog had receded, and with it, all apprehension inside Bilbo about the spirit. He was not sure if the dark facade had been a test of strength or bravery, but if it was, he had surely passed.
Bilbo quickly took the spirit’s hand, strength filling him once more to ease his journey through the harsh cold of Christmas. They walked in silence as they made their way towards Hobbiton, the world eerily quiet on Christmas morning.
However, once they were in town, the streets quickly became crowded with people. It didn’t even seem like Christmas at first as people went about their business as normal. If not for the holly wreaths and “Merry Christmas” being hollered by every passerby, Bilbo would have thought it was any other day. Especially with the gossipers about.
Well, they were called gossipers, though that wasn’t an official title. It was mostly just the older folks whose children were all grown, so they felt they had nothing better to do than to waste the day away gossiping about whatever was going on that week. Others participated in the gossip, of course, but things really only got around when the gossipers shared between one another and then brought it back to their family units, though they would tell the news to anyone who would listen.
Usually Bilbo would try to ignore them when he was in town, as he did everyone, but this time, he listened intently as he and the spirit passed by them, trying to catch a hint of what they were talking about. The gossipers stood together, rather amused at whatever the hot topic was. While they were in the Christmas Yet To Come, Bilbo did not know which Christmas that could mean. He was old, yes, but he was sure he had a good few years left to go. Perhaps the gossipers could give him some insight into what future he beheld.
“No, I don’t know much about it, either way,” a short, older lady spoke to the group, shaking her head. “I only know he’s dead.”
“He’s dead?” Bilbo asked, “Who’s dead?”
“When?” Someone else asked, obviously not being able to hear Bilbo’s question.
Only then did Bilbo notice that the first older lady he came across wasn’t just a stranger but his own cousin, Lily. The one whose doll Bilbo had accidentally sat on and broke when they were children.
“Last night, I believe,” Lily replied.
“Wonder what he died of,” a tall, slender old fellow added, “I never thought he’d go.” He laughed, the others following with their own chuckles, including Lily.
“Well, I don’t know or care why he’s gone. I’d just like to know what he’s done with his money,” someone else in the group said.
“Wouldn’t we all? He didn’t give it to me,” the tall fellow added on, leading to another round of laughter.
“Well, it’s likely to be a cheap funeral,” Lily said, everyone nodding in agreement. “I don’t know a single soul who would go to it.”
“Who- who is she talking about?” Bilbo asked, turning from the group to the spirit as they watched the gossipers themself, not acknowledging Bilbo.
A sick feeling bubbled up inside of him as the conversation fizzled out and went onto a new topic, one of much less interest.
“I know one of them, Spirit. Lily, she’s my cousin, my old playmate. Of what old wretch does she speak?” He pressed again.
The spirit finally looked down at Bilbo, giving him a gentle, sympathetic look. “I am merely your guide,” they answered, “You must see it for yourself in the Christmas Yet To Come.”
They beckoned Bilbo forwards, pulling on his hand, and together they walked through Hobbiton and all the way to the beginning of Bagshot Row. That road, too, was as busy as could be. Many people were walking down the road towards Hobbiton, and by extension, towards Bilbo and the spirit. Every person seemed to be carrying something different as they passed by. One person with a large basket of well made pots and pans, another with a cart of fine liquor, someone else with a bundle of maps and prints.
“My, where are they getting these lovely things, Spirit?” Bilbo asked, marvelling at the possessions headed down towards the market. As he spoke his question though, anxiety and suspicion crept up inside him alongside his curiosity.
“Are those…?” Bilbo asked, taking a second glance at someone walking by holding a few brass candlesticks quite similar to the ones on his table at home. He quickly shook off the unasked question and kept moving with the spirit.
Just up the road, another fellow came walking towards them holding a folded set of curtains identical to the ones hanging in Bilbo’s own bedroom. “Now, those… I–” Bilbo said as they, too, passed, unable to form a coherent sentence, being struck with confusion and disbelief as he was. “Surely they can’t be.”
Despite his old age, Bilbo dropped the spirit’s hand and hurried up the hill towards Bag End in a panic. At the top of the hill, folks stood around and watched as Bilbo’s own items were being auctioned off at his front door.
“Patchwork robe, sold to Mister Boffin of Eastfarthing,” the auctioneer said, and Bilbo watched as his favorite dressing gown, the one he wore now, was handed off to a random Boffin. Not family, not someone who cared about him or who he cared for back. A stranger and nothing more.
“Now, you give that back this instant,” Bilbo demanded, climbing the front steps to his home and reaching to pull the robe from the Boffin’s grip, but his hands refused to grasp it.
Giving up but still ready to defend his property, Bilbo stepped past the auctioneer into his home. It was bare of all decor and homely goods, the only items still there being put into baskets and crates in the hall to be taken to auction. Rage coursed through Bilbo. Loss, too, if he could call it that. In his old age, he never cared much for Bag End, an opinion that had grown like weeds in him since his parents’ deaths. Seeing it now though—barren, devoid of life, lonely—it filled him with a longing he couldn’t quite place. He never really knew what he had.
The loud voice of the auctioneer brought Bilbo back to where he was, and he turned to see what next item was being sold to one of his greedy neighbors.
“Next up for auction: this silver shirt made of some sort of metal alloy by my reckon, maybe elf made, sturdy,” the auctioneer announced, holding up something Bilbo recognized all too well, though he hadn’t laid eyes on it in quite some time.
The nerve of them! His neighbors, his family, and even the folks he never met, all using his misfortune for their own gain. He had used a word to describe them before, and he found it fitting now: vultures, through and through.
“How dare you!” Bilbo yelled, reaching for the mithril in the auctioneer’s grasp, yet he could not touch it no matter how hard he tried. “Give that back! Do you know who gave that to me?! How dare you! How dare you all come onto my property and take my things, sell them on the side of the road like it’s all just a bunch of rubbish!” Bilbo heaved, unable to take in enough air in his blind rage.
Once again, no one heard him, and no one cared. The bidding began. One after another, people bid on Bilbo’s most precious possession. When it sold, he didn’t catch the final bid over the sound of his own protest, though price was irrelevant. Someone who Bilbo recognized immediately was handed the shirt from the doorstep. It was someone Bilbo had spoken to only a day prior, in his time, and someone he never expected to see stealing something so precious. Mister Applegate turned and began walking back down the steps to leave with a large smile on his face.
“That isn’t yours!” Bilbo shouted at Mister Applegate, voice hoarse as he chased after what was rightfully his. “That shirt is mine! It was a gift from– from-” Bilbo began to yell, but he couldn’t get the words to come out.
A wet sob left him instead, startling even himself. Struck with grief, Bilbo stopped his futile chase and crumpled on his front steps, not feeling the impact on his old bones over the ache of grief.
“Please,” he quietly begged, “it’s all I have left of him. All he gave me.”
A hand rested on his shoulder, and Bilbo looked up through his tears to find the elf, the last spirit, crouched down and looking at him with an almost pitiful gaze.
Right past the spirit, Mister Applegate exited the gate, letting it slam behind him as he walked happily down Bagshot Row, the one thing Bilbo cared for most held firmly in his grip. The sound of the gate shutting echoed the same as Bilbo’s door slamming just a day prior. Sheer clarity took hold of Bilbo, and he gasped, fresh tears coming to his eyes.
“I understand, Spirit,” Bilbo began, “The case of this unhappy hobbit is my own. His death is my death. And the vultures descend upon my house now, not even waiting for my body to grow cold before they take all that I have. All that I am.” He paused for a moment, sniffling. “Yet I, too, am the vulture. Not with goods, but with spirit, with kindness and goodness. I have taken as they, too, take from me now. Not out of carelessness or spite, but as recompense for my misdeeds.”
The world around him was drowned out as Bilbo stared at the once-terrifying and eerily familiar spirit above him, and the spirit stared back. Bilbo’s head reeled. He understood now, what the journeys the spirits took him on were meant to teach him, how they were meant to heal him, but it still did not feel right. How could such grief and pain be synonymous with healing? Did the spirits choose what Bilbo had seen and felt, what he felt now, or were they just as surprised as him as the night was unveiled?
“Please, Spirit, let me see some tenderness connected with this world, or I’ll be haunted by this terrible sight forever,” Bilbo pleaded, praying that if the spirit had any control over what he was shown, they would show him mercy.
Surely there was someone in the Christmas Yet To Come who felt joy on a day meant for just that; joy Bilbo could feel too. Someone somewhere who could lift his spirits and bring him comfort in this future he could not live.
“Tenderness and love are seldom joyful in this world,” the spirit stated, though they did so with the gentlest of smiles, bringing Bilbo hope.
The spirit let go of Bilbo’s shoulder, stood, and held out their hand. Just as Bilbo took it and was lifted from the steps, he was brought to a new area in the Shire; one he quickly recognized as right outside Hamfast Gamgee’s house.
“Yes, Spirit,” Bilbo agreed, wiping his eyes as best he could. “A place of joy and laughter. Thank you for bringing me here.”
At second glance though, Bilbo noticed the once beautiful, tended-to garden in front of the home was overgrown with weeds, many of the fall plants still in the ground, dead and rotting where they lay. Hamfast, the sensible and caring gardener that he was, would never let his garden stay in such a state. Panic flooded through Bilbo at the sight.
“The garden,” Bilbo stated solemnly, “It has not been tended to in some time.”
“No, it hasn’t,” the spirit agreed, gesturing towards the home.
Getting the hint, Bilbo walked up to the smial, peering through the front window. In the kitchen stood Bell as she chopped vegetables, her eyes red and puffy with the occasional tear running down her cheek. Her eldest son approached her.
“Mother,” Bilbo heard him gently call, the faunt’s voice sounding much sadder and meeker than the last time Bilbo had heard it.
“It’s just the onions, makes my eyes teary,” Bell replied, sniffling. “Do you know when your father will be home? He should be back now.”
“I think he’s walked a little slower these past few evenings,” another one of her children replied, her voice just as wobbly and quiet as her older brother’s.
Bilbo’s attention was pulled away as he heard footsteps coming up the path to the home. He turned to see Hamfast opening the gate and trudging up the pathway to the front door. Like his family inside, Hamfast looked broken. Like a droplet of rain or a small gust of wind was all it would take to make him burst into tears.
Bilbo watched Hamfast pause at the door, his hand shakily hovering over the knob. The gardener looked much older and weaker than Bilbo had ever seen him before. Hamfast let out a small sigh, wiping away a tear that had begun trailing down his cheek, then opened the door.
“Hello, my dears,” Hamfast greeted, his tone loving but a far cry from sounding happy.
His children hurried to greet him, though none acted surprised or overjoyed as they had the first time Bilbo witnessed Hamfast returning home on Christmas Day. Bell quickly redirected the children to their chores, pulling her husband aside in front of the window Bilbo watched from. The two had a hushed conversation.
“I stopped by the churchyard on the way home,” Hamfast said, his voice gentle yet tired. “It will be lovely, Bell. I picked a spot for Sam where he can see…” Bell began to cry softly as Hamfast spoke, making him pause for a moment to wipe her tears. “It’s a spot on the hill. You can see the Party Tree in the distance, and it’s near the fields where the wildflowers grow. Sam, he–” Hamfast’s voice wavered.
“Sam always loved picking those wildflowers in the spring,” Bell interjected, turning away to wipe the last of the tears from her eyes. “It will be perfect,” she quickly said before walking back to the kitchen. “Come on, children. Let’s get the table ready for dinner.”
As the table was set, Bilbo noticed there was one less chair pulled up. It had been placed in the corner alone, a little crutch propped up beside it. Bilbo’s heart ached with grief for the small faunt; he could not bear the sight any longer. He turned and looked up at the spirit beside him, tears of his own clouding his vision.
“Oh, Spirit, must there be a Christmas that brings this awful scene?” Bilbo asked fervidly, “Surely something can be done to save little Sam and the Gamgees from such a fate.”
The spirit looked at him with a kind yet calculating gaze, as if they were working through something in their own mind. After a moment, they held out their hand.
“I have one more place to show you.”
Bilbo reached up, grasping the spirit’s hand and praying that he was taken somewhere kinder and more hopeful than the last. Together, they walked through the rolling hills on the outskirts of Hobbiton, the sun settled deep in the sky, turning the clouds shades of pink and orange.
He didn’t know where they were going, following the spirit blindly as they led Bilbo further and further away from home until they came upon a gate, and Bilbo finally recognized where they were. He had not been there since his parents had died, and he hadn’t planned to ever return.
“You brought me to the cemetery?” Bilbo asked, though he was not as upset as he thought he would be.
While the sun was low in the sky, it was still light outside, adding a bit of warmth to the otherwise chilly Christmas Day. He looked up to the spirit, finding them looking down at him with a supportive gaze.
“As I said, there is something else I must show you. Though more importantly, there is something you must understand.”
The spirit then looked forward again, stepping through the gate. Bilbo followed behind them with his hand still firmly grasped in theirs. Once they neared the far edge of the cemetery, Bilbo realized where they were going, noticing a freshly-dug plot at the top of a hill.
“Yes, Spirit,” Bilbo said, letting go of the Spirit’s hand to walk on his own. “Thank you for taking me here.”
With his hand released, Bilbo steadily climbed to the top of the hill himself, wishing to see what was there. It was a desperate attempt to help ease his aching heart, he knew. Perhaps if he saw the loveliness of the young faunt’s grave, some part of him would be healed. He could only hope.
Bilbo’s breath left him at what he found. He had known what to expect, yet it was nonetheless jarring to stand above.
“This is where he shall rest,” Bilbo stated, looking down at the little dug out plot on the hill.
The small headstone read “Sam Gamgee, Beloved Son.” The stone it was carved on was plain; much plainer than most in the cemetery. It wasn’t marble or granite. If Bilbo had a dwarf there, then perhaps they could say what it was made of.
Bilbo sighed.
Alone, he could not give any accurate name to the stone before him other than what he could see compared to the others; compared to what he had picked out for his parents. The stone was cheap, Bilbo could clearly tell, though that did not make it any less important. If anything, knowing that such a poor family had taken the time to have a headstone carved, quaint as it was, and to pick a spot with so much care, it showed much more importance than any extravagant tomb ever could.
For a moment, he thought about how nice it could be to buy a bench that could be placed beside Sam’s grave. He, or whoever, could sit and watch the view, perhaps speak to the young lad, though Bilbo quickly shook off the thought. He was not going to be around for such a future as things stood now.
The spirit had taken him to see Sam’s grave, but why? Was it to show Bilbo that what was to happen could not be changed, or was it to show him that it could be?
“Spirit, could I– ?” Bilbo began, turning around to find the space behind him empty.
Far in the distance, the spirit stood at another grave, their hood up and covering their face once again. In the time he had taken at Sam’s grave, the sun had fully set. The cemetery was now bathed in the gloom of dusk. An eerie fog covered the valley below him where the spirit stood.
“Spirit?” Bilbo hollered, his voice wavering, yet the spirit did not reply.
They were deathly still, staring at a singular, lonesome grave. A sinking feeling settled in Bilbo’s gut. He desperately wanted to run away, to wake up from whatever horrible nightmare the journey had quickly morphed into, yet he couldn’t.
Despite his mind and body arguing with him, he began walking towards the spirit, towards his fate. Whatever was there, it was the end of a journey. It was the end of the Christmas Yet To Come, and Bilbo had to see it, or all of the spirits visiting him, showing him such sadness, kindness, and grief, would be all for naught.
Bilbo wasn’t sure what had caused the shift in the spirit; why they had returned to the shadowy facade they wore when Bilbo had first met them, but it terrified him. Knowing who the spirit was underneath somehow made it worse. He knew what the spirit could be, yet he was stuck with what they had become.
“There is one more thing I must know, isn’t there, Spirit?” Bilbo asked, “Coming here was not about seeing where Sam would be laid to rest at all, was it?”
The spirit turned to Bilbo for just a moment, finally acknowledging his presence, before turning once more to the grave they stood above, pointing to it, yet Bilbo could not obey. His feet would not lead him towards what he already knew was there. A grave far from the others, freshly filled yet quickly abandoned, could mean only one thing.
“Why must you show me this?” Bilbo demanded, turning back to the spirit. “I understand, Spirit. I am the hobbit who must die a lonely death. My death as it stands now will be mocked, my belongings sold off and stolen. No… no friends to visit my– my grave… or the comfort of my love beside me in death.” Tears pricked the corners of Bilbo’s eyes. “What purpose does showing me this serve?!”
Again, the spirit pointed, unmoving and silent. Finally, Bilbo turned around.
The grave before him read, “Bilbo Baggins” along with his birth and death dates, and nothing more. He remembered the graves of his parents, both made of a nice marble with “Beloved Wife and Mother” and “Beloved Husband and Father” on the headstones, respectively, as Bilbo had decided. Yet his stone, the same cheap stone that Sam’s had been carved from, said nothing of the sort.
“Has anyone visited me on this day?” Bilbo asked, though he knew the answer already.
His grave was abandoned, no footsteps leading up to it nor flowers resting on top.
Bilbo thought back to the company, seeing them all together in Erebor. If they knew of his death, would they visit? Would they mourn him? Gandalf had not even stopped to pay his respects to Bilbo’s mother at her funeral despite how close the wizard claimed them to be; there was no hope he would visit Bilbo after the state in which he left their relationship.
“I was told once that dwarves hold special importance to being buried beneath the same stone. As often as possible, that is. It is why, after the battle, Tho– the three of them were all laid to rest together,” Bilbo explained aloud, “I never wanted to be buried here in the Shire, even if that is what he wanted for me. He wanted me to return home, to my books and my armchair, yet those things are not a part of who I am anymore. They haven’t been since I ran out my front door that day.”
Bilbo sniffled, wiping away stray tears as they ran down his face. He had never spoken so openly about what, and who, he had lost. Not to the company, or to Gandalf, or to anyone in the Shire. None of them understood.
When he had returned to the Shire, people had asked him where he had gone. Many had understood that he had gotten mixed up with a dwarven fellow, though no one knew the details. That, of course, then led to a wildfire of gossip unable to be contained.
In retrospect, Bilbo knew that was where his separation from the rest of hobbit society had begun. Barely anyone asked for clarification on what had happened, and to the few who did, he couldn’t bring himself to actually acknowledge what he’d gone through. So, he let the rumors and gossip win. It was easier than reliving such a terrible memory over and over again.
“I left him, like he had left me, and I have never been the same since, Spirit,” Bilbo admitted, “I see that now. I see how my suffering has then led me to causing the suffering of others; to not care for others as I did not even care for myself.”
Memories of his own cruelties and hatefulness rolled through his mind, each misdeed worse than the last—how he had treated Hamfast, Mister Applegate, Drogo, Gandalf, the Company. He had hurt them all, and he had not seen it, or simply not cared, because of his own selfish, callous grief.
His mind was brought back to Thrór words, what the dwarf had told him and the warning Bilbo had been given—I have never returned to the halls of my maker, never felt the comforting embrace of my kin who have passed on without me… you must learn to live a selfless life, or you shall be chained to your fate as I am now. Bilbo’s body felt like it was crumbling beneath him, the realization finally dawning on him of what his actions could lead to, and why Thrór had been the one to warn him.
“I’m so sorry, Spirit,” Bilbo blubbered, and he meant it. “I do, truly, understand now what Thrór had tried to tell me.”
Bilbo couldn’t believe how idiotic he had been to forget.
“Please, Spirit, tell me,” Bilbo begged, staring at his own name etched into stone. His legs wobbled under his own weight. “If I die as I am now, will I see him again? Will I be with… with my other half once more?”
Bilbo heard the spirit sigh in response, though it could have just as easily been the wind. “No,” they replied, voice even. “If you continue on this path of selfishness, you will never see him again. Your loneliness and grief will follow you from one world to the next, chained to you for all eternity.”
“But these events can be changed,” Bilbo steadily replied, the smallest bit of hope coursing through him. He peeled his gaze away from the stone, turning to look up to meet the spirit’s eyes with equal parts terror, sorrow, and ferocity. “A life can be made right.”
The spirit remained silent, unmoving, so Bilbo continued.
“I am not the hobbit I was. Why would you show me this if I was past all hope?” He asked, quickly wiping his tears away before they froze on his cheeks, yet more fell right after. “I will honor what you have taught me.”
Bilbo turned back to his own grave, staring at it once more and reading the letters, few as they were, again and again. His name had meant so much to him before. He was the son of Belladonna Took and Bungo Baggins, and he wore that proudly. And yet, now his name held nothing to be proud of. In death, he was not cherished by anyone, not even his kin. A loud sob wracked Bilbo’s body, his tears falling harder than before.
“Please, Spirit, can I remove the name that marks this lonely grave?” He asked, voice hoarse and pleading. “Can I return to the stone, to… Thorin, once I make things right?”
The name rolled off Bilbo’s tongue like hot tea, scorching him as his tears did. It was the first time he had allowed himself to say his name—Thorin’s name— aloud since he had been taken from him. It felt like every time that name was uttered, Bilbo was back on that icy cliff, clinging to the lifeless body that once was his love. He hadn’t been able to bear even the thought of Thorin, but being so close to death, quite literally looking at it straight on, everything felt much more clear.
It was silent for a long moment, the cold seeping into Bilbo’s bones as he waited for a reply from the stoic spirit behind him. For a moment, he was unsure if they were even there anymore; if he had been left at the doorstep of his death to wander alone, just as Thrór said he would.
Then, in the bleakest of moments, a hand rested on his shoulder—a gesture that Bilbo had not wished for many times before, but now he found it a comfort even from the spirit as they were now, shrouded in darkness.
“Yes,” they finally replied, the response sounding like a relief to themself as well.
Chapter 5: The End of It
Notes:
I drew the spirits for fun as a better visual representation of what I was picturing while writing this. You can also see it on my Tumblr (all-things-hobbit). I hope you like art and the end of the story! This fic is like a baby to me, and I poured so much of my heart into it and my event while taking summer classes and having a lot of things going on in my personal life, so it's a miracle it even got done at all, really. Enjoy!
Chapter Text
A clock loudly chimed, startling Bilbo enough that he turned from the grave to where the sound behind him emanated. Where the spirit once stood was now Bilbo’s own clock, in his own room. Bilbo blinked then turned back around, anticipating to see that damned headstone once more, yet his bed lay in its place. He was back in his room, the familiar walls circling him in on all sides and the early light of Christmas morning peeking through his curtains.
A blissful, relieved sigh left him. Bilbo patted his body down, making sure he was wholly there and laughing to himself as he did so.
“I’m back. Oh, thank you, Thrór, for giving me this second chance.” Bilbo let out a gleeful, appreciative chuckle. “It’s Christmas morning, and my life lies before me, still able to be changed!”
All of his belongings were as they had been. No Boffins wandering off with his dressing gown, for it was still firmly on his body; no one carrying his curtains away. He looked around from his mithril shirt for a moment before it dawned on him where he had kept it since he had brought it back.
As quickly as his aging body would allow, Bilbo rushed down the stairs and through the hall to a wooden chest. He hesitated only for a moment before lifting the lid, finding what he had hoped to be there.
“A token of our love,” Bilbo said, echoing the words Thorin had told him when he was first given the mithril.
He ran his fingers along it, feeling the sleek thread-like mail, before he turned to his little sword, Sting, beside it. He remembered being given that blade by Gandalf after their harrowing encounter with the trolls. He could still smell them if he thought hard enough.
“Gandalf,” Bilbo whispered to himself, more and more realizations dawning on him. “Dear Yavanna, his letter!”
Gandalf had written him a letter. Bilbo knew that for a fact. He scurried around his house, not finding his mail anywhere useful. Not on the table, in the kitchen, or in the front hallway. According to Gandalf himself, that letter was quite important, and yet Bilbo had idiotically given it to Hamfast and told the gardener to burn it! Had he already burned the letter, or was he waiting for the morning? The morning Bilbo was currently living.
“Oh, dear Hamfast!” Bilbo said, scurrying around his smial desperately looking for both the letter and a coat to go find his gardener, completely forgetting his fawning over the mithril for a moment. “Where is he? Where’s the letter?!”
“Are you calling for me?” A voice called distantly from Bilbo’s study.
Bilbo hurried over to his study, equal parts panic and excitement surging through him.
“Hamfast?” Bilbo asked, finding the room empty.
“I’m right here, Mister Baggins,” Hamfast’s voice sounded through the open window.
Bilbo rushed over and leaned his head out the window, finding Hamfast right where he had left off the day before in the garden.
“Hamfast, there you are!” Bilbo hollered at him with a smile, “Merry Christmas! Come inside!” He left the window to run to the door only for the right thing to dawn on him, and he ran back to the window. “Wait, no! No, don’t come inside!”
“Don’t?” Hamfast asked, looking very confused.
“No, just go home. Leave your tools where they are,” Bilbo loudly replied, his smile still plastered on his face.
“Go– go home?” Hamfast asked, “A– Are you firing me?”
Bilbo shook his head to quickly dispel any worry in the younger hobbit. “No, no, nothing of the sort. It’s Christmas, Hamfast. Please, go enjoy it with your family. I am sorry I have taken you away from them for so long already.” He waved the gardener away.
Very slowly, as if unsure of himself, Hamfast dropped his tools and started walking away, looking back at Bilbo as if waiting for the old hobbit to change his mind.
“Oh, wait, wait!” Bilbo yelled, stopping Hamfast in his tracks, though he was glad he remembered when he did. “The letter. The one from Gandalf that I told you to burn. Do you still have it?”
Bilbo watched carefully as Hamfast sighed, walking back towards him until they were practically face to face through the window, though Hamfast didn’t meet Bilbo’s gaze.
“As a matter of fact, I do, Mister Baggins,” Hamfast gently said, reaching for something in his pocket.
Bilbo almost jumped with glee as the gardener pulled out the letter from Gandalf, offering it to him.
“It didn’t feel right burning such a thing,” Hamfast explained, “So, I just held onto it in case you happened to change your mind.”
He almost seemed ashamed of himself as he said it, pulling a poignant guilt from Bilbo that pooled in his stomach and made it impossible to ignore.
“Thank you, Hamfast, truly,” Bilbo said, taking the letter. “Now, please, go home to your family. And if it is alright with you, might I stop by later with gifts for the children and the extra pay I owe you?”
Hamfast looked at him then, stark shock written on his face.
“Extra pay?” He asked, breathless.
“I have recently discovered that I have been grossly undervaluing your hard work for quite some time, so if you’ll allow it, I would like to give you that extra money.”
“Mister Baggins, is this about Sam?” Hamfast questioned, clearly concerned. “I saw you watching us as we walked home yesterday, and if you are under the impression that my little one or my family are in need of charity–”
“Oh, dear no, no,” Bilbo said, quickly shutting down Hamfast’s assumption. “Yavanna knows I don’t care for charity—or I didn’t used to—but I do wish to set things right, and you are one of the many whom that is owed to. Though I would also like to meet young Sam, that happy, young lad, along with your other children.”
Hamfast gave him a hesitant, unsure look before sighing, seemingly giving up on his questioning.
“If you are sure, Mister Baggins,” he said at last, finally backing down. “I’m sure they’d all be delighted to meet you.”
“Please, call me Bilbo,” he replied happily, “Now go, enjoy Christmas with your family. I’ll be along sometime later today.”
Hamfast gave a grateful nod before backing up and exiting the gate without putting away his tools. He slowly walked down Bagshot Row, still looking a bit perplexed but happy as well. Once the gardener was out of sight, Bilbo closed the window and left his study entirely.
In his sitting room, Bilbo lit the fireplace and then took quite a few moments to get comfortable in his armchair. He huffed after fluffing the decorative pillow for the third time.
“What am I doing?” Bilbo reprimanded himself, “Just read the sodding letter.”
Still, worry bubbled up inside of Bilbo as he sat down for the final time and ripped the seal on the envelope. Unfolding the letter, Bilbo cleared his throat a few times, looked around, and talked himself out of making tea twice before finally looking at the words written. Glancing it over, Bilbo found that the letter was quite short. Only one piece of parchment, and the words only took up a part of that space.
‘Bilbo,’ it began.
‘There are a great many things I wish to apologize for and something I must explain. While doing so in person would have been proper, especially given the reason for my apology, I felt that a letter would allow you grace, so you may respond in your own time, should you choose to at all. I have sprung enough surprises on you, and in both our old ages, perhaps it is time for that particular habit to be laid to rest.’
“Well, this is definitely a first,” Bilbo said aloud, now more than ever wishing he had a tea to sip on while he read, though he couldn’t bear the thought of leaving the letter partially unread to fetch some.
‘I do not regret choosing you as the company’s burglar, for your piece in that quest was integral to its success. However, it was unfair for such devastating responsibility to be thrust upon you with no forewarning. I showed up after twenty years, unannounced, and without sending you so much as a letter in my time away. While you did not like it, you invited me and thirteen strangers into your home, fed us, and pledged to help us with an impossible quest, though it took you some time to get to that point.’
Bilbo laughed slightly. “Invited,” he muttered, remembering that unsavory night. “You all almost crushed me when you fell through the doorway unannounced and then proceeded to take over my home.”
‘What you have not been told is why I stayed away for so long. It is for the same reason you stay away from Erebor, why you fled the first chance you got and have refused the kinship of the company ever since. Of all my years upon this land, I have never found a kinship, a bond, quite like the one with your mother, Belladonna. Not dissimilar to the strength in bond between you and Thorin, though still distinctly different. When she died, I felt myself unable to step into a home where she no longer resided. I knew that you were left alone, and despite that fact, I could not push through my grief to support you through your own.
Grief, my dear friend, is one of the purest expressions of love. And, like love, it can make people do things gravely unlike themselves. It can morph into a hideous beast, and that beast, when left unchecked, can consume you, as it once consumed me. I was stuck, unable to move forward or recognize the young, lonely hobbit that I had left behind; it kept me from being there for you despite the promise I had made to your mother long ago to always look out for you.’
Bilbo sniffled, wiping away a single tear from his cheek.
‘That promise, like this apology, is long overdue, and you clearly do not need my protection any longer. Still, I leave you with a few words of wisdom and the hope that you will, someday, forgive me. I implore you to recognize the grief within yourself. Do not abandon those that need you as I had abandoned you, and do not abandon yourself either. You lost your love, yet that does not make you less worthy of love and happiness now. I wish you well, dear friend. You know where to find me.
Gandalf the Grey’
Bilbo let out a wet laugh. “I am definitely reading this a day late,” Bilbo said to himself.
Though, if he had entertained the letter the previous day, he more than likely wouldn’t have taken any of the wizard’s words to heart. He was self aware enough to realize such a thing, even if it pained him to think of himself as that stubborn and blind. Still, it was a sign of growth; that he had recognized the beast within him, as Gandalf had described it, that his grief had become.
He understood the wizard’s words now. Bilbo had held so much resentment towards those around him for being left alone in Bag End after his parents died, and Gandalf especially, after remembering how close his mother and the wizard had been. What Gandalf did, leaving Bilbo to grieve alone and going against his promise to Bilbo’s mother, was not okay. Yet, Bilbo could not find it in himself to be mad when he had done nearly the same, if not worse.
Like Gandalf, Bilbo’s grief was the reason for his poor behavior, for shutting everyone out and taking from all those he could, yet it could not be his excuse. It did not erase all the hurt he caused, just as Gandalf’s apology did not erase the years that Bilbo spent in Bag End alone. Bilbo forgave Gandalf, but he could not forgive himself, and he would never ask for the forgiveness of others. All he could do now was do better, right as many wrongs as he could, and live a life of joy, selflessness, and love.
Bilbo stood from his chair, his mind made up. Writing Gandalf back could wait—as could writing to the rest of the company, which he intended to do at some point. Today was Christmas, a day of giving, and he was not going to waste it away wallowing in shame and regret.
He quickly got dressed before pulling together a few things, including plenty of money, and stuffing it all into a large basket. If he could, Bilbo would’ve bought new toys, but the only shops open on Christmas would be for food, if that. Hoping at least the butcher’s was open, Bilbo stepped out his front door, enjoying the refreshing cold breeze that hit him.
Looking around at the morning, Bilbo’s heart seized in his chest as he recognized someone in the distance. Walking down Bagshot Row was none other than Mister Applegate.
“Yes, perfect,” Bilbo muttered to himself, quickly walking down his front steps to chase after the younger hobbit.
“Mister Applegate!” Bilbo hollered as he walked towards the fellow as fast as his old legs could go. “Please, a moment of your time, good sir!”
Mister Applegate looked back, fear and apprehension marring his face, and it looked like he was fighting with himself over whether he should run away or walk towards Bilbo instead. Luckily, the hobbit did neither, standing still as he waited for Bilbo to catch up.
“Mister Baggins, please, I know I need to be out of my home. I was just going down to the market to–” Mister Applegate began, but Bilbo was quick to cut him off.
“You will do nothing of the sort.”
“Wh– what? Don’t go to the market or don’t move out?” Mister Applegate asked, his voice shaking.
“That is right, my good sir. You will not be leaving your home,” Bilbo clarified with a smile, “Your debt has been settled, and your rent has been lowered effective immediately. So please, go home to your family and enjoy the holidays.”
“But…” Mister Applegate began, though he couldn’t seem to find his words.
“My actions yesterday were cruel, and I apologize for my behavior.” Bilbo set down his basket of things to rest a hand on Mister Applegate’s shoulder. “You are an honest worker and a good person. You can be my tenant for as long as you wish.”
“I don’t understand.”
Bilbo took his hand off Mister Applegate’s shoulder, slowly bending down to pick up a bag of coins from his things.
“I don’t expect you to understand—Yavanna knows I don’t—but I am being sincere.” He held out the bag for the younger hobbit. “Please, take this as a Christmas gift. Use it to buy a nice Christmas dinner and something for little Gwen, or you may spend it however you see fit.”
Mister Applegate tentatively reached for the bag before hesitating. “Mister Baggins, I don’t think I can accept your gift,” he argued, “It’s too much. I’m grateful for everything, but I’m not looking for handouts.”
Bilbo huffed, though it was good naturedly, and he hoped that it showed on his face. He thought for a moment, taking Mister Applegate’s request to heart and knowing that he still needed to make right all that he had done wrong for so long.
“Well, how about this: you said you were going down to the market, and so am I,” Bilbo reasoned, “Perhaps you’d like to accompany me and allow me to buy a roast for your family. The food market and butcher shop should still be open even if it is Christmas.”
It was practically the same offer Bilbo had given him before, just the money would be leaving Bilbo’s hand instead of his, but at least Mister Applegate seemed to be considering it.
After a long pause, Mister Applegate let out a sigh. “You know, Mister Baggins? I think I will take you up on that offer.”
Bilbo’s smile grew, and he patted the younger lad on the back before picking up his basket to go down to the market. Mister Applegate walked alongside him, not another word passing between them until they got to the bottom of Bagshot Row and turned into the main square of Hobbiton.
“Do you like fine things?” Bilbo asked out of the blue, his mind going back to when the Mister Applegate from the future had bought his mithril shirt, which Bilbo held only the faintest of ire for, though he was sure that would soon fade.
“How do you mean?” Mister Applegate asked.
“Jewelry, silver, gold, gems—the luxuries of life that few hobbits care for and can nary afford,” he explained.
After another moment, Mister Applegate nodded. “Indeed I do, sir,” he explained, though he still seemed rather apprehensive. “My dad was a smith, you see, and a good one at that. He was trained in the towns of men down south, learning from the best—even dwarves. He gave me my appreciation for such things.”
Bilbo hummed in reply.
“Why do you ask?” The younger hobbit asked, though Bilbo was not sure how to respond.
It was difficult to explain, and if he tried, he doubted that Mister Applegate or anyone else would believe him. Instead, as they approached the food stores, he pivoted.
“Were you ever trained?”
“In smithing?” Mister Applegate asked, and Bilbo nodded. “Indeed I was, though I’ve never worked in a smithy after my father’s late passing.
Mister Applegate looked around the busy market as if worried someone would overhear. Which, in Hobbiton, was quite likely to happen.
“You should,” Bilbo said absentmindedly as he stepped into the butcher’s shop with Mister Applegate following behind him.
“Really?”
“Of course, why not?” Bilbo asked somewhat rhetorically, “I’m sure that Newt Brandybuck would be more than happy to have an extra hand, and it will pay well. Or, if you’d rather, I would like to personally fund your own start-up smithy. I know many dwarven smiths personally who I could reach out to for advice.”
Bilbo looked back to find a deep red blush painting Mister Applegate’s cheeks.
“That’s generous of you, sir,” he replied rather awkwardly, stuttering as he did so. “Might I think on your offer?”
Bilbo nodded. “Of course, of course.” He turned back to the few roasts left in front of him. “Now, which one do you think looks best for your family?”
Together, they both picked out their own roasts, Mister Applegate insisting that his be a more modest size since his family was much smaller than the Gamgees. Bilbo was sure to stop by a few extra places to grab spices, herbs, and vegetables to add to both of their meals before the two were making their way through the market to go their separate ways.
“Bilbo Baggins, is that you?” Someone asked, and Bilbo turned to find a familiar face practically grimacing at him.
“Lily! Merry Christmas, dear cousin!” He greeted with a smile, finding her in a group of gossipers just as she had been in the Christmas Yet To Come.
The old hobbit gave him a once over, her eyes calculating.
“I rarely see you in the market, especially not on a day such as this. Are you planning to celebrate for once?” She meant it in a pointed way, Bilbo could tell, but he was too happy to see her and make things right to care.
“Indeed, I am celebrating with the Gamgees this lovely Christmas,” he answered with a smile.
“The Gamgees?” She repeated back to him.
“Yes, Hamfast Gamgee, my gardener, and his lovely family,” Bilbo clarified, “They were so kind to invite me to celebrate with them, though next year, I think I might have them over at Bag End instead.” Another thought crossed Bilbo’s mind, and he raised his voice louder. “In fact, all of you should join me at Bag End next year for a grand holiday feast.”
“Wait, what?” She asked, more bewildered now than judgemental. The others around her gave similar astonished sounds.
“There hasn’t been a Christmas party held at Bag End since we were both tweens, Lily, and I think it is time for that to change,” he reasoned, “Don’t you think so? Christmas is about sharing love and joy, and it is about time that I begin doing so. And, I shall do so for the rest of my days with a thankful heart.”
Lily sputtered for a moment. Her and the others surrounding him seemed rather confused, and Mister Applegate looked a bit uncomfortable. Bilbo leaned in close to her then, with what he hoped was a genuine look on his face.
“And, Lily, I’m sorry about your doll all those years ago,” Bilbo apologized sincerely, “I didn’t mean to break it.”
Lily froze in place, staring at him with an odd look on her face that Bilbo could not discern. When she finally moved, she leaned towards Mister Applegate, speaking to him in a hushed tone.
“Is Bilbo okay?”
Mister Applegate shrugged. “I decided not to question it,” he replied in a similar hushed tone, “though his mental capacity seems to be strong as far as I can tell.”
“Of course it is!” Bilbo interjected, a smile still on his face as he laughed incredulously at their concern, though he couldn’t blame them. Such a stark switch in demeanor would have anyone worried. “It’s just that it is Christmas, for Yavanna’s sake! It is a time for joy and giving, is it not? So be grateful, cousin!”
Lily turned back to Bilbo, smiling then and laughing. “There’s the cousin that I remember. I missed your tenacity.” She moved forward to pull Bilbo into a quick hug, being careful of all that Bilbo was carrying. “I don’t know what happened to you, but I am grateful, and I forgive you for the doll, though I hope you know that I am still expecting a replacement gift.”
She meant it in jest, Bilbo could tell, but he would fulfill that expectation regardless.
Bilbo stepped back, readying himself to be on his way as it was getting decently late in the day, and there was still more to do.
“As you should, dear cousin!” Bilbo shot back, “And Merry Christmas!”
He then turned and walked off with his heavy basket in hand, Mister Applegate following behind as they finally left the market. Once they were out of the main square, the two quickly split ways with the promise of having lunch the following week to discuss Mister Applegate’s finances in more detail and to make their new arrangement official.
Bilbo was in high spirits as he walked the rest of the way to the Gamgee’s home by himself. However, as happy as he was, he was also worried. He had been terrible to Hamfast. He knew it, and Hamfast’s family knew it. His wife, at least, had said so outright. And, trying to make things right now did not erase all of the terrible things Bilbo had done in the past, forcing Hamfast to work long hours and paying him nothing for it, keeping him from his family on holidays. Bilbo half expected them to refuse him at the door, and he couldn’t blame them for that.
Still, he had to try. He was done running from his feelings, and he couldn’t eat the whole roast he bought by himself. It was the largest one the butcher had.
Taking a deep breath, Bilbo walked up to the door and knocked before taking a few steps back. The quiet chatter he had heard inside when he walked up ceased, and it was only a few moments before the door was opening, Bell on the other side with a thin smile.
“Mister Baggins,” Bell greeted, her tone sharp. “Lovely of you to stop by.” Her eyes wandered to the large basket Bilbo was carrying in front of him with both hands. The heavy roast had taken a toll on his strength. “What’s this?”
Bilbo smiled. “Well, I wasn’t going to stop by without something for the family. I brought a large roast for dinner and gifts for the children.”
Clearly taken aback, Bell stammered for a moment, making worry bubble up inside Bilbo, so he back tracked.
“Of course, if you would rather have Christmas dinner alone, I’m more than happy to hand this basket over to you and be on my way.”
The door opened wider, Hamfast stepping out from where he had clearly been eavesdropping on the other side.
“Oh, nonsense,” he said, motioning for Bilbo to follow them into the house. “You are welcome in our house. Bell is just a little surprised, is all, and has forgotten her proper manners. Please, come inside before your arms fall off from carrying all that.”
Hamfast stepped out of the way, allowing Bilbo to walk into the homely smial and see it in the flesh for once instead of as a spectral memory. He set down the basket on their table as directed, paying more attention to the six small children all patiently standing in front of the fireplace with their best Christmas clothes on.
“Are these them?” Bilbo asked, so overjoyed to meet the faunts in person that he was close to breathless.
“Yes, these are my lovely children,” Hamfast replied, walking over to his kids and introducing each of them by name, ending with Sam at the end.
“I’ve heard a lot about you, Sam,” Bilbo said, smiling down at the faunt. “I’ve seen you waiting outside my gate for your father to get done working. If you’d like, you’re more than welcome to wait inside from now on and get a snack while your father finishes up his work.” Bilbo looked around at the family, his eyes finally landing on Hamfast. “Although, I do plan to have you not work so late most days, so you may spend more time with your family, and as I had told you earlier today, your salary will be raised. You have done so much for me, Hamfast, and never once have you complained. Your repayment for such kindness is long overdue.”
Hamfast smiled at him, the two sharing a long moment between them. They had worked alongside each other for a long time, both learning so much about one another without even realizing it. Hamfast had worked for Bilbo when he got married, when he had each of his children, and he hoped that Hamfast would continue working for him for the rest of his life and keep taking care of Bag End well after Bilbo was gone. If any hobbit loved Bag End as much as Bilbo did, it was Hamfast.
Bilbo cleared his throat to flush out the emotion that had bubbled up inside of him. “However, we can save business discussions for another day. Today is Christmas. We should be celebrating.”
He turned away, eagerly opening the basket to start taking things out. Once the roast was pulled out and set on the table, the children’s eyes went wide, all of them rushing over to look at it.
“That is the biggest turkey I’ve ever seen,” Daisy, one of the middle children, said as she practically drooled over it.
“Now, it still needs to be cooked,” Bilbo explained before turning to Bell. “Is that okay? I grabbed it on such short notice. I’m more than happy to help prepare the meal, though I admit I’m a little rusty. Baking is more my forte.”
Bell smiled, shaking her head, and Bilbo could see the slightest bit of wetness in her eyes. “No, it– it’s wonderful, Mister Baggins. Thank you.”
Sending her a grateful smile, he turned back to the gaggle of faunts gathered around him. Except, when he did, Bilbo found their previous spot unoccupied. The whole lot of them had scurried over to the other side of the room, Sam grabbing something from under their quaint Christmas tree, before they all came rushing back with Sam trailing behind them.
When they were all in front of him again, Sam held up what he had grabbed, and Bilbo’s heart swelled. It was a soft package wrapped in brown paper, little children’s drawings decorating it.
“A gift? A gift for me?” Bilbo asked, gently taking the package from little Sam after a nod from the faunts.
They all stared at him with hopeful eyes as he slowly and carefully undid the paper. His hands shook slightly, the joy of receiving a gift being too much for him. Still, when Bilbo finally got the paper undone, he reverently set it off to the side and revealed a lovely red scarf.
“Oh, my,” Bilbo muttered, feeling the soft woolen material.
“It’s nothing new,” Bell added, making Bilbo turn to where she was hovering in the kitchen, Hamfast at her side. “When the children heard of your generosity, they wished to get a Christmas present for you. That scarf was Hamfast’s fathers.”
“Hobson?” Bilbo asked, looking at the scarf again.
He had known the old roper well when they were both much younger. They had been friends, even, and it was the reason why Bilbo had hired Hamfast in the first place as a gardener. The scarf was in such good shape despite it being rather old.
“And we colored the paper!” Little Daisy yelled, pointing to the discarded wrapping neatly folded on the table.
Bilbo gave her a warm smile.
“Thank you,” he said, looking at each of them and then to Bell and Hamfast. “Truly, this means so much.”
Tears blurred Bilbo’s vision as he put the scarf around his neck, wanting to wear it despite him being inside, before he took the folded wrapping paper and tucked it into his pocket so he could take it home and frame it. The scarf and its wrapping was not much for someone of wealth like Bilbo, yet it meant everything to him. It was the first Christmas gift Bilbo could recall receiving in a very long time. He couldn’t truly remember the last time he was given a present for Christmas. It might have been even before his parents died.
“I actually have something for you children,” Bilbo replied, remembering what else he had brought with him.
“More than the roast?” Halfred asked, and Bilbo nodded.
“Yes, more than the roast.”
Bilbo hurriedly turned and reached into the basket the roast had been in, pulling out the toys from his own childhood he had previously forgotten he had brought.
They weren’t new, but they were nice, and they had meant a lot to Bilbo in his youth. With no children of his own, he was glad to give them to a family that had so little, though he was determined to change that.
“These are for us?” The oldest, Hamson, asked, and Bilbo nodded.
“Of course they are,” he confirmed, “These were mine when I was your age, and now you may have them. Though I promise next year, I will get you brand new toys and plenty of sweets.”
He picked up a small carved dragon, bending down as far as his old body would allow to meet little Sam at eye level, and held it out to him. The faunt stared at it with wide eyes before grabbing it to inspect.
“This was given to me for Christmas too, Sam, a very long time ago,” Bilbo explained.
“It’s a dragon,” Sam stated, “Thank you, Mister Baggins.”
“Please, you may all call me Bilbo from now on if you wish,” he replied with a smile. He paused for a moment, watching Sam study the carved dragon before an idea popped into his mind, and Bilbo began speaking before his heart could catch up to what he was actually saying. “You know, I once met a dragon. Tricked a dragon, really.”
All the children stopped looking at the toys then, their gazes all moving to him in silent question. Bilbo looked back at them, seeing the wonder in their eyes and contemplating whether he was ready to tell the story he had kept guarded for so long, so scared that if he spoke of it that his nightmares would never cease.
But, thanks to the spirits, Bilbo did not feel so afraid anymore. He took a deep breath, readying himself to tell the story he hadn’t dared tell before, but one he was no longer scared of reliving. After what he had witnessed before Christmas Day, spinning a fairytale for the children, as Gandalf had once done for him, could not hurt.
“Indeed, many years ago when your parents were little, I went on an important adventure all the way across Arda to a lost dwarven kingdom carved out of a lone mountain,” he explained, trying to play up the story as much as possible for the children’s imaginations. “A ferocious dragon had taken over the kingdom, and it was my job to take it back.”
“You?” Little Sam asked, his voice full of curiosity, and Bilbo nodded. “But you’re just one person. How did you defeat a dragon?”
Bilbo moved over to the Gamgee’s old sofa and sat down, waiting for the children to gather around him. He stole a glance to where Hamfast and Bell watched from the kitchen as they prepared the Christmas feast before he turned back to the kids with a grateful, joyful smile.
“Well, if you want to hear that story, we have to start from the beginning,” Bilbo began, his mind pulling him back in time just as the spirits had. “In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.”
