Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

A Hobbit Christmas Carol

Summary:

~ A hobbit twist on A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens ~

Years after the quest, Bilbo has grown into a mean and selfish hobbit, living out his days alone in a cold and empty Bag End. The townspeople say he’s never been the same since returning home from that convoluted quest with nary a friend by his side, but Bilbo has never been one to listen to the gossip that floats around the Shire. Not about himself, his tenants, or his own gardener, Hamfast, and his sickly son. Bilbo’s never cared for others outside himself, especially around the holidays, and why would he start now?

…

On a lonely Christmas Eve, Bilbo is given a grave warning and told he will be visited by three spirits who will lead him through the Christmases of his past, present, and future. He must learn to live a selfless life, or he shall never see the green hills of Yavanna or feel the comforting embrace of those who have passed on without him, chained to his fate for all eternity.

Notes:

Hello! This story has been a brain child of mine since November, and I'm so excited to finally have it done and published for A Hobbit Christmas in July (the Christmas event I'm hosting). I took a lot of inspiration from The Muppet Christmas Carol, including some characters and matching dialogue, since I grew up with that version and it is one of my favorite Christmas movies. Thank you so much to my betas skatesfullofsunshine and Onebillionblorbos for editing and storyboarding with me. Please heed the tags and enjoy! <333

Chapter 1: Thrór’s Ghost

Chapter Text

As soon as a quick knock hit Bilbo’s door, he set down his quill with a frustrated huff. He had half a mind to ignore them, whoever it was, but he knew they would just come back later. Standing from the desk in his study with a groan, Bilbo opened his window to where his gardener was working in the planter just below.

“Hamfast Gamgee,” Bilbo greeted through the window.

The gardener looked up with a bit of surprise. “Yes, sir?”

“Who is at my door?” Bilbo questioned.

He watched the gardener take a step back from the planter and lean around the side of the house before retreating once again and leaning in towards Bilbo.

“Looks to be Mister Applegate, sir, one of your tenants,” Hamfast explained a bit hushed, “Probably wanting to discuss the months of rent he still owes you after his little Gwen got sick during the harvest. Terrible plight, I must say. The gossipers will talk your ear off about it if you let them.”

Bilbo huffed.

He knew quite well the gossip of the Shire. Even with as little excursions as he took down to the market, he couldn’t get far enough away from that week’s topic of interest.

When another round of knocking reached his ears, Bilbo left the window, wrapping himself tighter in his coat as he made his way to his door. He grumbled to himself as he reached for the door handle. He had a prediction of what was going to come out of the hobbit’s mouth first as soon as he opened the door—given the day of his untimely visit—and Bilbo loathed to hear it.

“Merry Christmas, Mister Baggins,” Mister Applegate greeted with a smile before Bilbo could finish opening the door, eliciting a deep, unfettered sigh from within the hobbit.

“Mister Applegate,” Bilbo greeted back, “Could I ask the reason for your inopportune visit to my smial?”

The younger hobbit rocked back and forth on his feet nervously even as he stood tall, chin up. “Mister Baggins, I was hoping to discuss my back rent if at all possible, sir.”

Bilbo huffed, not wanting to deal with something on such a day, but he was having a difficult time recalling the state of Mister Applegate’s accounts at the top of his head at the moment. So, with much internal fuss, Bilbo stepped back to let the hobbit in.

“I will look at my books to see the state of your affairs, and we shall get this matter settled once and for all,” Bilbo stated, “I was generous when your daughter fell ill, but I will tell you, my leniency has its limits.”

Bilbo pulled the appropriate file from his desk as he sat down with Mister Applegate seated across from him nervously. Hamfast was still right outside the window, but Bilbo didn’t pay he or Mister Applegate any mind as he looked over the file. It was quite uninteresting, really, and no wonder Bilbo couldn’t recall the details of the account. Mister Applegate had simply stopped paying his rent during the harvest. Then, three months ago, they had come to an agreement that Mister Applegate would pay extra per-month for rent, with interest, until his debt was settled. He had gotten back on track and paid well until this last payment, which put him back into heavy debt.

A clean cut case, Bilbo reckoned. He closed the file, putting it back in his drawer as Mister Applegate shook nervously across from him.

“Please, Mister Baggins, I know you’re very angry about this, and I didn’t mean to fall behind on the rent. Yavanna knows, it being Christmas and all,” Mister Applegate whined, “That and, of course, little Gwen. Her lungs aren’t right still. The doctor takes his share, don’t he? It’s all just been too much. Oh, please, you must hear me, sir.”

That was enough of that. Bilbo stood, shooing the hobbit out of his smial as he continued to try to justify his poor financial status. Still, with all his excuses and whining, Bilbo wasn’t going to have any of it. He didn’t have to listen to it, so he wasn’t going to. It was a waste of time for him and for Mister Applegate.

“I expect you out by new years at the latest,” Bilbo stated blankly, opening his front door and shoving the younger hobbit out.

“Please, sir, only a moment more of your time–” Mister Applegate pleaded before he was cut off, the door slamming in his face.

Bilbo turned and made his way back to his study, promptly sitting and drafting up eviction notices for Mister Applegate and a few other neglected tenants to be sent out the following morning. He didn’t know why he had waited until now to do so, but he was grateful to Mister Applegate for bringing it to his attention.

“Mister Baggins?” Bilbo heard from the doorway, and he looked up to find Hamfast tentatively waiting there with a bundle of letters in his hand. “The mail came as I was working out front, so I thought I would bring it to you.”

Uninterested, Bilbo went back to his eviction notices. “Read them to me, Hamfast,” he instructed as he worked.

Hamfast went through the letters one by one, most of them being dismissed by Bilbo only a few words in as junk from his relatives or people asking for charity—two things he didn’t care to hear about in person or in letters.

“I think this one’s from that tall fella that used to do the firework shows at parties a couple decades back,” Hamfast said, the words an immediate damper on Bilbo’s mood.

“Just tell me who it says it is from, Hamfast,” Bilbo instructed with a grumble, uninterested in what that meddling wizard had to say if it was, in fact, from him.

“It is a letter from Gandalf the Grey,” Hamfast explained, “Should I add this to your pile to respond to? I forgot you and him went on that adventure when–”

“No,” Bilbo was quick to respond, “You may throw that one away. I am not interested.”

“Are you sure? You and he were the talk of the Shire when I was a lad, if I remember correctly,” Hamfast added, doubling down and making Bilbo’s blood boil.

“You are always talking about wishing to put more coal in the furnace on days like this,” Bilbo said, voice gruff. “How about you start with that as some tinder first thing tomorrow morning?”

“T– tomorrow?” Hamfast asked, “Why, but that’s Christmas, sir.”

“And?”

“I was hoping to spend the day with my family,” Hamfast explained, his breath the slightest bit shaky. “No one will be working tomorrow.”

“The weeds in my garden will be working, no doubt,” Bilbo rebutted, still unwilling to look up from his documents. “And the cold will continue to break through my new greenhouses if you don’t finish the winterization. Those will not wait.”

“But–”

“Christmas is a very busy time, Hamfast,” Bilbo replied, “People preparing feasts, giving parties, spending all their money on frivolities. It is unnecessary and nonsensical. Why, with the money it takes to put on the festivities around the Shire, one might say the holidays are a time of loss rather than of merriment and joy.”

There was a pause where Hamfast stood there silently as Bilbo wrote, still wholly unamused. Bilbo was fed up. First with Mister Applegate and then with Hamfast Gamgee—it seemed more and more like the residents of the Shire didn’t care at all for hard work despite it being the backbone to a proper, functioning society.

“Sir, my family is expecting me there. Little Sam still isn’t–”

“Your family is expecting you to provide for them, not sit at home twiddling your fingers and singing Christmas carols!” Bilbo spat with a huff, cutting off the gardener one final time. “So, either show up early tomorrow morning ready to work, or do not show up at all! You’re dismissed, Hamfast.”

The gardener stammered for a moment or two before turning to leave. Only when Hamfast’s back was to Bilbo did the old hobbit look up to watch him go. Once the gardener was well and gone, closing the door behind him, Bilbo shook his head and muttered to himself. He seemed to be the only one to recognise the foolishness of Christmas, of spending above one’s means, of putting so much importance on spending time with loved ones and helping others. Bilbo knew well how useless such matters were in the end.

A small voice outside his home caught Bilbo’s attention, and he stood to find a little faunt waiting at his gate, waving as Hamfast approached him and greeting the hobbit loudly. Bilbo recognised the little one; not by familiarity but because his description had been on the lips of every gossip monger at one time or another for the past year or so.

“Sam!” Hamfast exclaimed, patting his smallest son on the head as he crossed through the gate of Bag End and latched it in place.

“Hello, father,” the little faunt greeted, “I thought I would walk you home.”

They ambled together for a moment before the conversation got too quiet for Bilbo to catch, though it sounded lively. After a few more hobbled steps, Hamfast picked up little Sam and placed the faunt on his shoulders, using one hand to keep the lad in place as the other grasped Sam’s small crutch.

Sam had always been a small, rather sickly child from what Bilbo had heard. Though it wasn’t until a year or so ago that poor nutrition and constant sickness gave way to fatigue in the lad, and he had begun using his little crutch. Still, even with his ailments, the little fellow was as happy as could be. Bilbo sighed, watching Hamfast and Sam walk down Bagshot Row as they spoke animatedly to one another.

Once Hamfast had well and truly departed and the sun began to set, an eerie silence filled Bag End. There was no humming, no bird chatter outside or distant footsteps walking down Bagshot Row. Bilbo busied himself to keep the uneasy feeling at bay, but once he had nothing else to do, he left his study. The hobbit’s old bones ached as he made his way through the smial to his bedroom, his body reminding him just how aged it was. Though, despite his age, Bilbo was on edge, his nerves alight and feet ready to bolt as the eerie feeling increased the longer he walked through the smial with nothing but a candle to light his way.

As he opened the door to his bedroom, the small flame in his hand not being much of a guide, a dark figure appeared suspended near his wardrobe. Bilbo jumped with a yelp, his old bones feeling youthful once again for the single, adrenaline filled moment. Fear coursed through him only for a few seconds though, before a realisation took over him, and Bilbo huffed in annoyance as he walked over.

“Oh, my best dressing gown,” Bilbo muttered as he set down his candle and took the robe from where it hung on the corner of his wardrobe door.

It was the nicest one he owned despite it being quite old. The patchwork design was still well enforced, though some of the brighter colors had faded the slightest bit. The once deep red tones were closer to a salmon, but it was still just as nice. Besides, there was no reason to spend money on a new one when the old thing worked just fine.

With the fear completely out of his system, Bilbo put on his night clothes quickly and wrapped the lovely dressing gown around him before the cold got to him. Afterwards, he wandered back downstairs for a late supper by the fire as he did many evenings.

When there was no one to serve at a formal table, it was much simpler to eat by himself in the comfort of his rocking chair. So, with some cold cuts of meat on bread, along with a simple tea, Bilbo sat in front of his small fire with his meal. The bread was stale, the tea sugarless and the meat awfully salty, but Bilbo ate anyway in the silence of Bag End.

The eeriness still followed him, though he ignored it as best he could—as he did with many bothersome things in his life. Christmas was a dismal time of year, so a feeling of unease was nothing to be alarmed by. Besides, after being foolishly startled by his dressing gown, Bilbo refused to be frightened by anything else—be it a vase, tapestry, or bookshelf.

Around him, the smial creaked and settled, the sound hauntingly similar to someone shuffling through the distant, echoing halls. Bilbo quickly brushed away that thought, taking another bite of his meal. No one would be in Bag End at such an hour other than him. No one would dare break into his home. Not even the fat fellow, Santa Claus himself.

The light in the room dimmed, and Bilbo looked down to find his fire quickly receding despite there being plenty of wood in the fireplace. Then, the creaking came again, louder and more persistent. A small clinking noise—gentle and airy—caught Bilbo’s attention as it slowly got closer to him in the darkness of Bag End. Bilbo was alight with fear once more, his body unable to move from his chair despite his mind screaming at him to run, start up the fire again, yell; just do something. Anything to dismiss the blinding terror coursing through him.

The sound got closer and closer, whoever or whatever it was approaching at a terribly slow pace. Just when Bilbo thought no one and nothing would actually show, the noises only being the product of an old hobbit’s overactive imagination, a figure appeared in the doorway to his sitting room. As they approached, stark clarity of their appearance hit Bilbo, a name almost spilling from the hobbit’s mouth before he quickly stopped himself.

There was a dwarf standing in his home. Well, not exactly standing. As the dwarf moved to halt before Bilbo, the hobbit found that the dwarf’s feet did not touch the ground. Instead, they were suspended above it as if floating in water, chains dragging behind them in the air from where they wrapped around their forearms and ankles.

What did some ghostly apparition want from Bilbo? Why did they look so eerily similar to someone Bilbo had not laid his eyes on in decades? The one person Bilbo wished so desperately to have again yet loathed to see in the appearance of this figure. The reminder brought pain to Bilbo’s chest, almost enough to distract him from his shuddering fear as he sat before the spectral figure.

“Bilbo Baggins,” the entity muttered, their voice gruff. “Son of Belladonna Took and Bungo Baggins.” It was not a kind greeting, nor a greeting at all.

“Yes.” Bilbo gulped. “Who are you?”

“I am Thrór, Son of Dain,” the spirit replied, voice booming. “And you, Bilbo Baggins, must heed my words.”

Bilbo’s brows furrowed as he thought, a bout of confusion plaguing him. Thrór was a familiar name to him, but he was sure he had never met the dwarf in front of him, if the spirit was a dwarf under the rattling of chains and dark aura. He wracked his brain, pulling from past memories to trace the name. Finally, a phrase; a title, spoken by many, though one he hadn’t heard in quite some time came to the forefront of Bilbo’s mind—Son of Thráin, Son of Thrór, called Oakenshield—and he gasped.

Stumbling out of his rocking chair, Bilbo quickly stood and backed away from the spirit, recognition dawning on him. Yes, the spirit looked an uncanny amount like the great statue back in Erebor and even more like another Bilbo wished not to remember. Still, even with the resemblance, Bilbo could not believe it. Thrór was dead, and ghosts simply did not exist. They couldn’t. Yes, the dwarf was floating but– well, it was impossible. It was all impossible.

“It looks like you, as I have seen you carved in stone, but I don’t believe it,” Bilbo said, shaking his head. “I can’t believe it.”

“Why do you doubt your senses?” Thrór asked.

“Because… well, because a little thing can affect them,” Bilbo reasoned, not just with the ghost but himself as well. “A slight disorder of the stomach can make them cheat. You may be a bit of undigested beef. A blob of jam. A crumb of cheese.” Bilbo pointed at the spectral figure as he backed away towards the far wall of his sitting room. “Yes, there is more of gravy than of grave about you!”

Thrór let out a low laugh. “More of gravy than of grave?” He questioned. “My, you are more of a hobbit than I gave you credit for, being tied to my grandson and all.”

“Do not speak of such things,” Bilbo growled out, “You do not know of me or my life, so do not pretend as though you do and mock me for it. Now tell me of your business here or leave my home.”

Thrór moved forward towards Bilbo, his chains rattling as he did so.

“I have come to warn you, Bilbo Baggins,” Thrór stated gravely, “If you do not change your ways forthwith, you will end up like me.”

Bilbo looked the dwarf over. Yes, he was clearly dead, but to what the spirit was referring to, Bilbo was unsure.

“H-how do you mean?”

Thrór sighed then gestured to the chains that bound him, a grave heaviness settling on his shoulders despite his weightless appearance.

“I have never returned to the halls of my maker, never felt the comforting embrace of my kin who have passed on without me.” Thrór’s face twisted into one of grief and pain. “I am cursed to live beyond the bounds of death for all time, never to see the world rebuilt, as the Valar have made it so.”

“Why is that?” Bilbo questioned.

“Greed, Bilbo Baggins,” Thrór uttered, “My greed consumed me just as your grief and resentment consumes you now. I was bitter, selfish, and lost sight of what truly mattered. My actions in the pursuit of gold caused my kingdom to fall and many lives to be lost.”

“But– but that was the gold sickness,” Bilbo argued, “From the- the Arkenstone, yes? The king’s jewel. The Valar cannot fault you for that.”

He had seen the same thing happen in real time—the way gold could infect the mind of even the most caring and honorable of dwarves. The Valar had no right to punish Thrór because of a sickness of the mind.

Thrór paused for a moment then shook his head, his face contorted in shame. “Even after I lost the Arkenstone and the wealth of Erebor, my selfishness remained. My heart was forever hardened, and it led to my own death and the death of my son and grandson. The gold did not do that, just as the grief you hold does not justify what you do now. Your actions will lead to your own ruin if you follow the same path as I.”

Bilbo listened, he heard what the ghost had to say, but he could not believe it. He knew the stories of Thrór, knew how the fallen king had led his people to their deaths at the Battle of Moria, but if what he said was true about Bilbo following the same path to ruin, then there was no hope.

When Bilbo did not immediately acknowledge what Thrór said, the dwarf spoke again.

“You will be haunted by three spirits,” Thrór explained, his tone as cold as he was.

“Haunted?” Bilbo’s voice wobbled, his mind still reeling from the spectre’s earlier admission. “I’ve already had enough of that.”

“Without these visits, you cannot hope to avoid the path I tread,” Thrór added, “Expect the first ghost tonight, when the bell tolls one.” He didn’t leave room to argue, yet Bilbo still did.

Panic surged through Bilbo. What Thrór was saying could not be true. If Bilbo was to continue on as he was, he would never see the Green Hills of Yavanna? He would never see his parents again? Fíli, Kíli… Bilbo couldn’t bear such a cruel fate, so it was not true. He refused to believe such a ridiculous lie. In fact, the ghost of Thrór before him probably wasn’t even real at all, so therefore, his warning could not be real either. If Bilbo just went to bed, his awful nightmare would simply go away.

“That is rubbish, and I will not believe it,” Bilbo argued, cursing himself as his voice wobbled again. “You are just some spectral delusion brought on by fatigue and indigestion, and I will not listen one bit to your nonsense ramblings, so good night, and go away.”

Bilbo turned to walk back to his room, ready to sleep away the odd vision, when something wrapped around his foot dragging him back from his attempt to escape. Bilbo yelped, looking down to see a chain pulling him towards an enraged dwarf—a sight all too familiar to him.

“Son of Belladonna Took and Bungo Baggins, heed my words!” Thrór commanded from where he floated above Bilbo as the hobbit cowered on the ground. “When dawn breaks on Christmas morning, you must learn to live a selfless life, or you shall be chained to your fate as I am now!”

The room shook as Thrór spoke, his voice rattling the very earth under and around them. Bilbo closed his eyes tightly and covered his ears, pleading in his mind for the spirit to spare him from his mighty wrath. The world felt as though it was bearing down on him with all its strength. Bilbo’s body shook as he sobbed, the fear overwhelming his senses.

“Change!”

Following Thrór’s final command, a shrill howl echoed through the room for just a moment before ceasing completely. Everything stilled, and once Bilbo found the strength to open his eyes, he was greeted with the warm light of a brightly burning fireplace and a cold, empty smial as if Thrór had never been there in the first place.