Chapter Text
Following the harrowing encounter with the spirit of Thrór, Bilbo fell into the empty silence of a dreamless sleep. However, the small bit of comfort sleep offered him was quickly ripped away. As the clock struck one, Bilbo awakened, Thrór’s words echoing in his mind—Expect the first ghost tonight, when the bell tolls one.
Bilbo’s heart thudded in his chest as he waited for a minute and then two, yet no spirit ever came. No footsteps, or voices, or chains. Not even the howling of the wind outside his window or the creak of Bag End settling in the night. It was silent as the dead, if Bilbo could still think such a thing following his loud accosting by the departed. All was silent, and all was right.
Bilbo turned in his bed, adjusting his pillow to fall asleep once more when a brilliant, white light encompassed the room. It wasn’t a lantern or a fire, as it was much too bright even for that. Bilbo squinted his eyes, trying to locate the source of the light despite there being no discernable focal point that could emit such a penetrating glow. Bilbo was blinded by the brilliance as if the sun itself had descended upon him at midday.
After a few moments, the illumination receded until a figure appeared from within it, absorbing the rest of the imposing light until there was only a faint glow around them. In front of Bilbo was a young hobbit lass. Not even through her tweens, if Bilbo had to guess. And just as Thrór had, the spirit floated rather than stood, her feet hovering just off the ground as her white dress flowed around her.
“Are you the spirit Thrór spoke of?” Bilbo asked, hesitant to even acknowledge the figure staring at him from the foot of his bed.
“I am,” the spirit replied, her youthful voice wafting through the room.
“But you’re just a child,” Bilbo replied.
“I can remember far beyond your time; beyond that of even the Shire,” the spirit spoke, her diction telling of a more aged being than she appeared. “I am the ghost of Christmas past.”
“What business has brought you here?” Bilbo asked, skeptical.
Yes, he remembered Thrór’s words and warning, but he wished to hear it from the child, from the spirit herself.
“Your welfare,” she bluntly stated.
Bilbo scoffed. “A night’s unbroken rest might aid my welfare,” Bilbo shot back, “and not being attacked and scolded by spirits, that would help me plenty.”
“Your salvation, then,” the ghost answered, pivoting. “Take heed. Come.”
The wide window in Bilbo’s bedroom opened, the cold air rushing in along with the smallest gust of snow from the bank outside. Bilbo hurried to put on his dressing gown before he caught a chill and turned back to the spirit.
“I beg you, Spirit, I am a mortal hobbit and an old one at that,” Bilbo said, loathing to use his age as an excuse. “Should I go out in that cold, I shall perish before long.”
Perhaps if she believed that Bilbo could not bear such a task, she would leave him be. However, as the spirit sent him a gentle look and offered her hand to him, he knew that would not be the case.
“A touch of my hand, and you shall not fall to the elements, I assure you.”
Even though Bilbo knew he would surely regret it, he took the hobbit girl’s small hand in his own, letting her guide him through the window. Once he was through it though, his feet did not sink into the cold snow. No, as he exited his home, he began to fly alongside the spirit as she guided him well above and beyond the mortal confines of Bagshot Row.
“Spirit?!” Bilbo hollered as they flew.
“Yes?”
“Nothing,” Bilbo answered, his mind blank.
He wasn’t sure what he had tried to say, and if he attempted to speak more, he feared he would lose his meager supper. Still, even with the fear coursing through him, the Shire was beautiful. It sparkled brilliantly. All the Christmas lights twinkled as if they were their own stars that the night sky looked down upon with envy.
In the distance, a similar brilliant light glowed brightly as they flew towards it. It was not the sun, as it was still the middle of the night, and the sky had not begun to lighten yet.
“Spirit, what is that light?” Bilbo asked, “It cannot be dawn.”
“It is the past,” the spirit answered plainly.
Bilbo squinted his eyes closed as they passed through the light, trying to block out as much of it as he could and hoping he wasn’t incinerated by it. He’d had enough threats of incineration for one life.
When Bilbo opened his eyes again, it was day. He was still above the Shire, but it was different. Rather than flying away from home, he could instead see Bag End growing closer in the distance. Even odder, the Shire he flew above was changed. The old schoolhouse was standing once again even though it had been demolished a decade ago to build a new forge. The Sackville-Baggins’ front door was light yellow again instead of that garish purple it had been painted after Lobelia married Otho and moved in. They were, truly, in the past. Yet what past that was, Bilbo was unsure, and he didn’t particularly wish to find out.
Slowly, Bilbo and the spirit descended until he was at the front door of Bag End. Despite it being cold outside, his front door was open, letting the frigid air in as the smell of fresh baked pies wafted out. His father’s pies.
Just as Bilbo moved to step into his home, a gentle, familiar voice spoke from inside. Bilbo’s heart sped up as the voice grew closer until the owner rounded the corner to the door.
“... can never learn to shut the door behind them,” Bungo Baggins muttered as he walked up to shut the door before pausing. “Oh, you’re home!” He exclaimed with a joyful smile, opening his arms in greeting.
A weak whimper left Bilbo as he moved forward to hug his father, tears in his eyes, when Bungo stepped out of the doorway and moved right past him without a single glance back. Bilbo followed his father’s form to where he walked down to open the gate to Bag End. There, on the other side of the gate, stood Bilbo’s mother, Belladonna, and most surprisingly, himself. He wasn’t even a tween yet; barely taller than the gate itself. His mother was young, too. All of them were. And they were happy.
“Now, what have you brought home for me to cook with?” Bungo asked the young Bilbo as all three of them walked into the smial together, completely bypassing Bilbo and the spirit as if they weren’t even there.
“Those are my parents,” Bilbo spoke, not just to the spirit but to himself as well to cement that they were truly there, alive. “I don’t understand. Why do they ignore me?”
“These are but shadows of your past, Bilbo,” the spirit explained patiently, “They can neither see nor hear you. Come, let us go inside.”
The spirit floated into Bag End, beckoning Bilbo to follow her, and despite his soul aching at the idea of seeing his parents alive and well without being able to embrace them or even speak with them, he had to. His heart hurt at the thought, but he knew it would hurt much worse if he walked away.
A flood of memories came back to Bilbo as he walked through the Bag End of his childhood. Everything brought out an emotion from him—the bright garlands his mother had picked out, the old Christmas tree set up in the sitting room decorated with the most awful homemade ornaments, colorful paper strewn about the place from when he had undoubtedly hastily opened his Christmas gifts hours earlier.
“I know it all so well, spirit,” Bilbo said as they wandered through his old forgotten home. “The tree, the smell of the pinecone and hollyberry wreaths.” The small Bilbo ran past him with a carved dragon he held up as if it was flying. “The joy of playing with the presents Santa brought me on Christmas Day.”
Bilbo cleared his throat of the emotion trapped there before he kept moving through the smial, finally finding his parents in the kitchen. Half a feast was set out on the counters while his father stirred up something more in a bowl and Belladonna chopped vegetables beside him. He hummed while he mixed, pulling a happy smile from Belladonna.
“Do you think this will be enough food for the party?” Bungo asked after a moment.
Belladonna laughed. “With the appetite of your family, who knows?”
“And with the temper of yours, I’m not sure how many of these pies will actually make it to the table,” Bungo joked, resulting in a jab of Belladonna’s elbow into her husband’s side.
“My family would never stoop so low as to throw pies,” she corrected, “though I do have a faint recollection of my cousins lobbing dinner rolls at one another during last year’s appetizers."
“I remember it now,” Bilbo stated as his parents continued to banter back and forth. “We always held a family party on Christmas Day. All my cousins would come over, and we would play games.” Bilbo laughed as a specific memory was brought back to his mind. “I remember one year, I had accidentally sat on my cousin Lily’s wooden doll and broken its leg. The poor lass was so upset for the rest of the night. She might still hold a grudge to this day, now that I think about it. I haven’t been invited to any dinner parties of hers for a few decades at least.”
Bilbo used to love parties in his youth. He remembered all of them quite fondly. Well, most of them, but the drab gatherings Lobelia and Otho held barely counted as parties in Bilbo’s eyes.
He sighed. “I haven’t actually attended a party in quite some time,” Bilbo told the spirit. “I fear I have forgotten what they are actually like.”
“Oh, would you like to see?” The spirit asked with the slightest smile, the most emotion she had shown their whole time together.
Before Bilbo could get more than a squeak out in anxious protest, the room shifted. The kitchen, previously quiet save for a small intimate moment between husband and wife, was now bustling with people as loud conversations and jolly music flooded the smial.
"This is not what I meant!" Bilbo barked at the spirit, yet he knew she wasn’t going to listen to him.
Instead of responding, the spirit began floating away from him, gliding through the smial as if in search of something. Bilbo, with nothing else to do, followed behind her pensively. Even through the cacophony of voices and the endless amount of relatives strewn about the place drinking and making merry, a deep voice caught Bilbo’s attention. The sound of it—the person’s diction and the way it resonated through the smial—Bilbo knew who it was before he rounded the corner into the sitting room.
Bilbo stifled an exasperated groan as he found Gandalf sitting in there with a group of faunts around him. They sat on the floor as Gandalf seemed to be finishing one of his fantastical stories. A faint memory of one such tale involving an oliphaunt and a peacock came to mind, though Bilbo couldn’t remember the details of it, and now, he doubted it was a true story at all. With the wizard’s imagination, he could’ve made it up on the spot. Whatever story he was finishing up now, however, had the faunts absolutely entranced.
Next to Gandalf stood Bilbo’s mother, listening intently to the tale as well with a glass of wine in her hand. Bilbo only gathered the last tail ends of what was being said—something about a princess and a flying horse—but the story was soon over, and the children were dismissed to run about the house again, a younger Bilbo among them, he realized after the fact. Though the hushed conversation between his mother and Gandalf was much more intriguing than the happenings of a gaggle of faunts.
“He has your spirit,” Gandalf said, gesturing to where the group of faunts had run off to, and Bilbo was bright enough to gather that the wizard was talking about him.
Belladonna scoffed. “Please, he takes after Bungo much more than I,” she retorted, “They love cooking together, fishing, gardening. He couldn’t care less for adventure.” She sighed and took a sip of her wine. “It seems the Baggins side has won out.”
Gandalf gave a low chuckle, downing the full glass of wine in his hand that looked much smaller in his grasp. “And what would you call him searching the Old Forest for elves if not a sense for adventure?” Gandalf questioned, making Belladonna sputter. “I can see greatness in him. He will surprise us with his courage, I’m sure of it.”
Bilbo didn’t know what to say to that, or what to think either. It almost felt wrong eavesdropping on his mother’s conversation with Gandalf, though seeing as it was a memory that already occurred, he wasn’t sure what it could hurt. Was Gandalf right? Memories flashed through his mind—running through the Shire towards an unforgivable adventure, holding a sword against an orc in a burning forest, looking into the eyes of a great dragon.
Bilbo quickly shoved those memories away.
“No, Gandalf is wrong, as usual,” he said aloud as the wizard and his mother continued their hushed conversation. “That adventure was a one time thing, and it was…” Bilbo wanted to say terrible, awful, the worst decision he ever made, but he couldn’t; no matter how many emotions those memories conjured up, they all held something much more precious, and Bilbo couldn’t let him go.
Bilbo took a deep breath, focusing back on Gandalf’s words.
“-won’t be a child forever, Bella,” Gandalf said, “he may prefer to stay close to home for now, close to you and Bungo, but there will come a day when he will go out on his own, and when that day comes, I doubt there is any force in the world that will stop him.”
Belladonna sighed. “And when that day comes, you’ll look out for him?” She asked quietly from behind her glass.
“Assuming you won’t be there beside him for whatever trouble he gets himself into?” Gandalf joked.
“I will not be young forever, Gandalf,” she reminded him, “My adventuring days are already behind me as it is.”
“I am getting quite old in years as well, you know,” Gandalf replied.
Belladonna let out a small laugh. “We both know that you will outlive me,” she stated, “outlive Bilbo, even.”
Bilbo’s heart dropped, the memory of his mother’s death coming back to him for a moment before he quickly pushed it away, rejecting it all together. It had happened so long ago that it rarely crossed Bilbo’s mind anymore. There was no point in bringing it up now at his old age.
Bilbo looked around him as Gandalf and Belladonna’s conversation continued, watching as more people filed into the room, crowding it and suffocating him. Most of the people at the party were dead now; died a long time ago along with Bilbo’s parents. Even in a lively room stuffed with old family and friends, he was all alone with no one to talk to but the spirit of a child who didn’t seem to care one bit for his well being despite her saying the opposite.
Bilbo’s father joined the group, standing in front of the Christmas tree with a glass in his hand. The memory moved around Bilbo against his will. He didn’t want to be there, to hear more of his parents’ voices, see them without being able to touch them, say he loved them. Bungo raised his glass in the air, the action getting everyone’s attention, the room hushing into silence.
“Thank you everyone for being here, and merry Christmas,” Bungo began, getting a round of cheers from the crowd. “As you know, Belladonna and I have been holding these parties since we got married. Yes, it might be just another excuse for the Tooks to drink themselves into a stupor.” The room lit up in laughter before dying down again. “But, in truth, we hold these parties every year because we love it. We love you all; we love this time of year. Christmas is an important holiday for our family, it is a time of giving, and we want to give that love to you. Merry Christmas everyone!”
The memory was distant, fuzzy as everyone gave a round of cheers and hugged. The room dimmed around him, the chatter going silent and the smell of mulled cider and pine leaving with it.
“Where-” Bilbo began before stopping to clear his throat and wipe his eyes, finally noticing emotion that had come up to the surface. “Where are we going?”
“Not every Christmas in Bag End was one of joy and laughter,” the spirit answered.
A new memory faded in, this one much darker. The walls of Bag End were stripped bare. Even his mother’s maps were gone from the walls, the little nicknacks taken from the shelves along with the shelves themselves. The smial that had been so full of life just moments before was now barren.
“Spirit, where did you take me?” Bilbo asked, his voice quivering.
The sound of sniffling and the crackling of fire pulled his attention from the drab state of his smial to the fireplace in his sitting room and the rocking chair in front of it. It was the same one he still had back home as it was his father’s before him. Bilbo moved around to see his younger self sitting in the chair, a weak stream of tears falling down his face.
“Please, Spirit, tell me you didn’t,” Bilbo begged, knowing now exactly what Christmas he had been taken to.
“This was the first Christmas where a party was not held in this home, where no presents were opened, and not even a single decoration was put up,” the spirit stated as if Bilbo didn’t already know that.
“They had taken the nice ones,” Bilbo explained, still entranced by himself as the younger Bilbo sniffled again and wiped away a tear. “My aunts and uncles and cousins, they had descended like vultures after the funerals and taken everything they could get their hands on. The few Christmas decorations I had left didn’t seem worth putting up with no one there to celebrate with me.” Bilbo let out a shaky breath. “A Christmas for one is hardly a Christmas at all.”
“And Gandalf?” The spirit questioned.
“I never saw him again until my 50th year,” Bilbo replied with a sniffle of his own.
The spirit was silent after that, the only sound in the room being the quiet crying of both Bilbos, young and old. There was nothing more to say. The spirit had taken him to a Christmas of such sadness and mourning. Barely of age yet left alone with nothing but an empty, ransacked home and a broken heart on what his parents claimed to be a day of family and love and giving. It was all rubbish.
“Every Christmas—both joyful and sad—has been spent in this home,” the spirit finally spoke in the dreary darkness of Bag End, “all… but one.”
Bilbo’s heart dropped as his vision was pulled away from Bag End; from that lonely hearth he spent countless Christmases in front of, wallowing in his own grief and pity. It should have been a relief to get away from such memories, yet he was transported to one much worse. Even in his old age, Bilbo’s memory was quite keen, and he recalled only one Christmas away from Bag End; away from the Shire. As his nose filled with the scent of old caverns and barren tombs, the warm, wooden floors beneath his feet replaced by cold stone, his own, younger yet unmistakable, voice shakily reading aloud from a book, Bilbo’s assumptions were dreadfully confirmed.
“Please, Spirit, I beg you,” Bilbo pleaded, eyes burning with tears ready to run. “Do not make me relive this. Not this Christmas. Not here.”
Despite his desperate begging, the spirit did not respond, watching in reserved silence as the scene unfolded before them—an old memory, fixed in time and unable to be changed or mended. Even though it felt so real, nothing could be done. Not then, and not ever.
In front of him, as clear as the day it had occurred, a younger Bilbo sat on a stone floor with his back pressed against cold, carved marble—a grave; one of three. A large, dwarven book was propped on his lap as he read aloud. It wasn’t like when he would read to his mother, or to the young faunts of family members during gatherings. No, it was a sorrowful read, a solitary read as much as both Bilbos, young and old, wished it wasn’t.
Footsteps approached, and both Bilbos looked up to see Dwalin walking over. The dwarf’s face looked fatigued, pained. No one spoke as Dwalin approached. Not until the dwarf was standing right in front of the younger Bilbo, the two of them toe to toe as Dwalin stared down at him. Young Bilbo was quick to avert his gaze back down to his book. Even after all they had been through together, the harsh, critical gaze Dwalin held always made Bilbo feel uneasy.
“The others are drinking and dancing if you wish to join us,” Dwalin offered, but the younger Bilbo didn’t respond. The hobbit glared at his book, ignoring the dwarf’s words.
Young Bilbo seemed to have decided to ignore Dwalin, not giving any acknowledgement that he had even heard him speak.
After a pause, Dwalin huffed and shook his head. “Bilbo, you cannot truly believe you can stay down here forever,” the dwarf said, “Mahal’s Beard, lad, you even sleep down here most nights.”
There was another long silence where neither Dwalin nor the younger Bilbo spoke, the hobbit absent-mindedly flipping through pages of the book as if Dwalin wasn’t even there, as if he was an observer like Bilbo and the spirit were.
“I hadn’t even realized that it was Christmas when we had this conversation,” Bilbo said as he watched, struck with grief and shock. “I had lost track of time around when preparations for the battle had begun, and afterwards, it had become completely irrelevant to me until Gandalf returned to take me back to the Shire.”
Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo saw the spirit give the smallest of nods in acknowledgment, but Bilbo himself was too transfixed on the scene to say any more about it. Dwalin’s face morphed from one of exhaustion to frustration, his face twisting into a sour glare.
“You’re just going to sit here forever, ignoring me, us, your friends?” Dwalin questioned, his voice steadily rising. “It is not healthy, and it is not right. Do you think he would want– !?”
The sound of younger Bilbo’s book being slammed shut echoed through the tomb, its force silencing Dwalin and making the older, spectral Bilbo gulp. He remembered what had been spinning through his mind during that conversation: the words, the plea, that had been given him on Ravenhill—go back to your books, and your armchair. Plant your trees, watch them grow. But at that time, no matter how Bilbo tried to reason with himself, he wouldn’t allow himself to leave the mountain, leave that room for more than a moment at a time, leave him.
Young Bilbo sniffed and then cleared his throat. “I know that I did not know him for as long as you had, not even close, and I do not have the right to grieve for him as if I did.” His youthful voice was thick with emotion as he spoke. “But he was still mine. I loved him as if we had known each other our whole lives, and now the chance to live out the rest of ours together is gone.”
“Bilbo, you need–”
“Please, let me grieve in peace,” younger Bilbo cut in, his voice sharp. “Sitting here, reading, it is much better than what I have seen you do of late to deal with your grief, so do not judge me when you are in a drunken stupor every other time I see you.”
Whatever Dwalin was going to say got stuck in his throat, his mouth clamping shut. Without another word, the dwarf turned and walked back towards the doorway he had entered from and where the older Bilbo and the spirit watched. Dwalin’s face twisted into one of anguish as he left, tears pricking at his eyes, but he didn’t look back. The dwarf quietly walked out of the room and closed the door behind him. In the silence of the tomb, the younger Bilbo slowly opened his book back up and began reading where he left off.
Bilbo’s mouth had gradually dropped open as he had watched the scene unfold. He racked his memory for the next time he and Dwalin had spoken, but his mind brought him no solace, no resolution. Bilbo turned to the spirit in a panic.
“Please, Spirit, do not tell me that is the last thing I ever say to Dwalin,” he pleaded.
The spirit sighed. “I only live within the Christmases past, but there might be more to see in the present and the future—answers to the questions you keep asking yourself,” she said somewhat solemnly, “Would you like to return home now, Bilbo Baggins?”
Panic coursed through him. While he desperately wished to leave such a terrible memory, if Bilbo left now, it was set in stone. He would not be able to fix it, to do something.
“But– but wait! We need to stay and fix everything! Just let them see me, and I can explain!” Bilbo begged, though, deep down, he himself knew it was useless. What had been said was permanent; his memory was living proof of it.
As Bilbo begged, the room shifted once more until he was back in his room in Bag End. He stopped protesting once his feet were firmly on the ground and his vision cleared, yet angry tears still streamed down his face as he turned away from the spirit and looked around his room, making sure he was truly where he was meant to be. It was dark outside once again, and all his things remained as they were before he left.
Bilbo let out a shaky breath. He hadn’t wanted to leave in the first place, yet now that he was back, all he wanted was to get away. To go back to the party, to sit in solitude with his lonesome, younger self, to talk with Dwalin again. However, he knew it was useless to wish for such things. As the spirit had said, the past was set. There was nothing to be done.
“Farewell, Bilbo Baggins,” the spirit said from behind him, “You must now await the others. I have taken liberty in fixing your clock. It shall not fail you again.”
“What did you do to my clock?” Bilbo turned to the spirit, but she was gone as soon as he did, not even a wisp of her light remaining in his room.
