Chapter Text
"This blue's a swirling ocean,
The green: the ambition,
The red is the guilt,
There's a lot of red...
The yellow is my sunshine,
Comes out on odd occasion,
Barely enough
To keep you around"
Thorin’s mind awoke as the cracks in the ice and in the walls began to form the sound of a regular beat, and a muffled voice began to sing softly. The song echoed from his mind into the world, shaping it vaguely, just barely. Blue, silver and grey began to dance in his darkness, and he heard the muffled voice singing of happiness that had never been meant for him, and of regret and loss beyond measure. Contemplative and seemingly detached, the voice seemed to be taking in the fading of the world, his own voice, he realized, making an attempt at accepting his fate. He had tried to use the same tone earlier, when he had parted with someone, with his…
Above his voice rose another. A second voice, beautiful, with a harp-like sound, filled with so much longing, was asking him to stay.
Thorin did not know whom the voice belonged to. But it was full of love, more love than he deserved. And he wanted to fulfill its request, right then and there, but he had no power. If he could stay, it would be by someone else’s grace, through the force of someone else’s prayer, as he himself was spent.
And then something happened that Thorin did not expect. His vision changed. There was no longer ice cracking in a dark, cold winter. Instead there was a bench in front of a round green door, and a Halfling with a restless, frowning face was sitting on it, writing on a piece of parchment. And there were tears on the parchment, quiet and resigned, and it felt as if that person would never be happy again.
Thorin approached him and said: “What’s wrong? Why are you crying?” and the hobbit stared at him in bewilderment, paused to gather his breath and then said, “I must be dreaming. It cannot be, for you died long ago,” and his voice sounded much like the voice Thorin had heard earlier, beautiful and harp-like, but broken this time… Thorin moved closer and said, “It is undoubtedly a dream, but why can’t it also be real?” And the Hobbit reached towards him, and Thorin saw himself fade, but could still see the creature in front of him, sinking in despair and letting out a scream, “I’m sorry! I didn’t mean to say you died! Of course you didn’t, you are with me always! You just startled me, that is all!” and then begged for Thorin to return, and Thorin wished he could reach him-
And then Thorin was back in the song of cracked ice and blue and silver sky and stone, where he could still hear the two voices now mingled together. And he realized that the harp-like voice belonged to this creature, and that it was not yet a voice consumed by grief and despair.
Do I have a choice here? he wondered. To prevent this? I would gladly do anything, anything at all, so that he would be at peace, be happy. But… it is not up to me. I did much wrong, I have much to suffer for. This is not my choice to make. But let the suffering be all mine. And then something in him clicked. His mind turned to his Maker, and spoke thus to him:
“Lord Mahal, I am not worthy of making this request, but if there is any choice allowed on my part, please, let me try to fix things. I can’t go back in time, but if I could still be in the world now, at present, I would try to act better. I would not fail you, or my family, my beloved nephews, and the one whom I must have wronged so much, this person who will cry endless tears because of me now.” He could not remember more than this.
Then Thorin heard the ice being remade whole, and the blue and silver began to shine in the darkness, eventually giving way to green, yellow and red, and the song ceased. And he knew that the yellow was his sunshine, the green was his ambition, and the red was the guilt. There was a lot of red. And the voice of his Maker was silent.
* * *
Thorin was lying in the makeshift bed, unconscious, yet still breathing. Despite his efforts, Gandalf was skeptical that a spell would keep him alive, and kept eyeing Bilbo curiously. Elrond finally arrived and treated Thorin’s wounds with a combination of medicine and Elvish incantations, and then pronounced that they just needed to continue to treat him and let time do the work.
Then Elrond turned to Bilbo. “It is a miracle that he survived. Do you know what happened? I am at a bit of a loss.”
Love, Bilbo thought. No, that’s not what happened. Time. I didn’t love him enough. I need to do more. But to Elrond he just said, “There was time for him to be saved. The Valar must have intervened.”
“Mister Baggins, if you can, please stay with him. I need to step out. I’m going to be back shortly.” Then Elrond gave him a knowing look. “And, Mister Baggins… whatever it is that you did, if you did… keep doing it.” Then he was gone.
Bilbo sighed with relief. It’s working, he thought. He was exhausted, but did not want to sleep. I need to be awake for him, he thought. Every second that I am awake, I can try to fight for him to be alive. I cannot rest yet. Later. Later.
He moved closer to Thorin and kneeled beside him.
“Thorin, it’s going to be all right. You are going to come back.”
Thorin had seemed peaceful earlier, when he was dying. He had asked for forgiveness and said farewell to Bilbo. When Bilbo had assured him that he was glad to have shared in his perils, a peaceful smile spread over Thorin’s face. It seemed that Thorin was dying in peace. So why not let him go?
Bilbo had always deferred to Thorin; almost never said “no” to him, or even thought no to him. He would have always followed him, to the ends of Middle Earth! But what did Thorin want now? Could it be that Thorin wanted to die? No, it didn’t look like Thorin wanted anything. It only seemed like he was going to accept his fate. It looked like Thorin, for once, was going to follow.
So for a moment Bilbo allowed himself to think of what he wanted. What he wanted was for Thorin to live.
It didn’t feel wrong. And the soothing voice that had spoken at exactly the right time… surely it was someone good, right? It had to be. So he continued to pour words of love for Thorin. Because that was what Keep doing what you’re doing amounted to.
“You know… When you walked into my house that night… I thought it was something out of one of my books. When you sang that song… I knew then that I would follow you. And you weren’t even very nice to me! But I saw how you were trying to protect your people and the quest, and you were right in assessing me. Your manner, that’s another story- that certainly could use some work!” he laughed. “I liked you, Thorin, from the start. I don’t see how anyone wouldn’t. I took one look at your Company to see that they would have all followed you wherever you’d lead.
And then I heard the story Balin told… And I met with trolls, and I messed up so badly. But you came to rescue me and laid down your weapons to save my life. I felt like I could never repay you for that, or for saving me again in the Misty Mountains. Then in Rivendell, I learned more about you as we walked together and listened to Gandalf’s conversation with Elrond. Oh, Thorin, there was no time or disposition for me to understand it all. I wish I had – I still don’t understand this gold madness completely – I feel really terrified and stupid when I think about it. But at that moment, all I knew was that you were there with me, and for some reason I was granted this privilege, to be by your side while you were taking in what they were saying about you and your family. I’m not sure I was worthy of it, and yet you let me share in your burdens and your sorrow for that one moment. Who wouldn’t be crushed under this burden, going on a suicidal quest with thirteen companions? Who wouldn’t be ready to cave in at the sight of that smug Elvenking who denied you access through his land and yet, as soon as he heard of your escape, marched towards Erebor to claim his jewels by force? And yet you… Thorin, I know you can’t hear me, but believe me, I saw it all, I know who you are… I fell in love with you for all this, and more that I don’t know how to describe, but I will try, I will try my best now, Thorin…”
And so Bilbo continued into the evening, and at some point Elrond returned, and once again was pleased to see that Thorin was better than expected. And at that point, Bilbo decided to take things a step further and introduce some Khuzdul in his words to Thorin.
