Chapter Text
Thorin found himself on the cracking ice once again. For the first time since he had parted with Bilbo, he could see more than just inside his mind. He saw that he was not alone. A beautiful golden-haired Lady was looking upon him with a warm, kind smile, and when she spoke Thorin felt all the coldness in his soul dissolve. “Child of my husband,” she said, and now Thorin knew it was Lady Yavanna, “you have been presented with two possibilities, two worlds to choose from. In both of them, you will go to my husband’s Halls after your fight with Azog. You have seen how Bilbo Baggins will be in each world. I offer no comment on that. My question to you is, which world would you choose for him?”
“My Lady.” Thorin bowed with respect, carefully choosing his words, even though this was madness, all of it, could not be real, or if it was, perhaps it was a joke in very poor taste. “It seems to me that in the first world, Bilbo will grieve me deeply, not be able to move on with his life, long for my presence, hope to see me in dreams… and in the second world, he…” Thorin struggled. “He will find a way for himself, quite easily, and will be comfortable and content, and enjoy a very long and prosperous life… and I don’t think a single thought of me will be part of it. So it seems to me that… that perhaps in one world he loved me, and in the other he didn’t- though I can’t be sure that he ever did.”
Yavanna continued to look at him carefully, as if wanting to penetrate his deepest thoughts.
“So it comes down to whether I choose that he should love me or not,” Thorin continued. “But that is a choice that only he can make. So how can I pick one of these worlds? It will come down to whatever Bilbo feels for me.”
“Oh, but you do have some power in that, don’t you think?” Yavanna smiled at him with encouragement.
“To make him love me? My Lady… I would not wish to argue this point. You see, all I did was alienate Bilbo from me.”
“Perhaps. You’re overthinking things, dear child. All I ask is, if you had the power to choose, what would you choose for Bilbo? A life where he can’t move on, and lives like a shadow, but a life in which he loves you? Or a life that is content and comfortable, full of small joys, though perhaps not happiness, yet a life in which he might not love you?”
“Can you tell me, Lady Yavanna? Can you…?”
“If he loves you? I cannot. I do not know the hearts of my children so completely. If he were to reveal the secrets of his heart to me, I would know. But he hasn’t done so.”
Thorin thought of the sad, despairing Bilbo in Bag End, clinging onto him, eyes full of tears, flowers withered in his garden, no friends, no company. And he thought of the other Bilbo, who had visitors and friends, was highly respected, told tales of his adventure with the dwarves, composed many beautiful songs and poems and shared them with others in peace and harmony. “I would wish for Bilbo to be happy,” he said. “I would choose the second world for him. If you can grant this to him, Lady, a good life… that would mean a lot to me.”
As soon as he said those words, his soul felt like it was breaking in two, with a finality that he had felt earlier, after his farewell to Bilbo, when all that had been left were the crashing sounds around him. It’s a world where he doesn’t love me, he thought bitterly, and just in that moment a tiny memory popped into his mind. He recalled the ring on Bilbo’s desk, and Bilbo’s frantic face when he saw it, and the way he took it immediately in his hand, then put it in his pocket, then breathed a sigh of relief… There is something, something here… Yet Thorin could not name it, and a heaviness fell upon him as he looked into Yavanna’s eyes with all hope for Bilbo and with none left for himself.
“Very well, child. I shall reflect on your answer. Now it is time for you to go to my Lord husband’s Halls.”
“Thank you, my Lady.” This is it, Thorin thought. My love, my only One, my everything. He is far away from me, and he does not, will not, did not… Which one of those he meant, and what he meant with it, he couldn’t bring himself to think, and he felt himself falling.
“One more thing,” Lady Yavanna turned towards him. “Should I see Bilbo Baggins, as I will one day, would you like me to give him a message from you?”
“Tell him…” Words Thorin’s mind had never put together before suddenly flowed into him, and he felt the urge to say them out loud. He stopped himself and considered intensely for a long while.
“That ring of his… I would tell him to be careful. It may be dangerous. All gold sometimes is. Tell him to take care that the ring should not corrupt his heart. His beautiful, noble…” and now Thorin was sinking into the ice, and it was all he could do not to say what he really wanted to say.
“Is this all? Nothing about love?” she inquired with a puzzled look.
“My Lady, you said that I may have power over his feelings. I doubt that, but if your words are true, then if I send him a message of love he might… I might shatter something in him. Because I will be dead. And then he might turn into the person I saw in my first vision. So I won’t do that. Though I do not know that I’m doing the right thing,” he muttered, wishing for this trial to end before he could change his mind. “Thank you for your kindness, Lady Yavanna. You have been… most gracious.” Tears were welling in his eyes now, tears falling over the ice, but the ice didn’t melt, and instead it seemed like it was looking at him in triumph, as Azog had done earlier. I must have messed up again, he lamented. But Thorin had no more energy to put into this thought, and before he knew it, the scenery changed and he was in Mahal’s halls, for real this time.
“Ah, finally. Thorin, son of Thrain, is here,” said Mahal with a spring in his voice that had not been there when he had spoken in Thorin's vision. “My child, you have been expected after your last confrontation with Azog, but it seems you were delayed. By something, or someone.”
“Lord Mahal.” Thorin bowed deeply. One moment, he thought. That is all I have. I will try to get through this moment and nothing more. He had had enough of everything.
“My child, I had no intention of sending you back. My wife, however, informs me that in light of your answer to her, she would have me let you return to the world of the living. She says you know of what I speak. Apparently you did something selfless, which appears to have sat well with her. No surprise there. She cares about that hobbit of yours deeply.”
“My Lord,” Thorin whispered like a shadow. “Your wife… spoke to me. I didn't think this could be...”
“I know. You, selfless? My most stubborn and arrogant child? Ah, but she sees where I cannot. I will let her have this one. The matter is settled; you will return now. And take care, don’t walk into peril so easily next time, or I will not be so… relaxed about it.”
“My Lord, you said I was delayed in coming here. How? How is it possible?”
“I haven’t looked into it,” Mahal said, looking slightly bored. “I will only say I wasn’t the one who delayed you. Perhaps you have some friends in high places. By the way, before you go, I’m just curious, does that hobbit of yours love you? You seem so invested in him. Do you think he is worth it in the end?”
“I do not know if he loves me,” said Thorin. “I wouldn’t if I were him. But he always managed to surprise me.”
Mahal laughed. “Well said, my child. Now get out of here.”
“Thank you, Lord Mahal. Please thank Lady Yavanna for me. She will have my eternal gratitude. I will never forget.” After saying these words, Thorin felt himself breathe for the first time in a very, very long time. “He is... more than worth it,” he completed his answer to his Maker, and they exchanged a smile as if they understood each other perfectly.
Mahal disappeared, and Thorin was taken back to the ice on Ravenhill. He felt a touch of warmth on his hair, his face, and his hands, and his eyes started to open slowly. As he beheld the sun rising over the ice, he heard a new song, and felt Yavanna's presence in that beautiful voice that moved up with the sun and melted all the ice in his head, the voice of kindness and generosity that had led him out of the darkness for good. And he saw the stone his mind had painted earlier, and in the burning sun the flowers grew bigger and brighter, and he smiled at how whimsical they were in their simple beauty. As he lifted his hands and tried to bring them together in prayer and gratitude, he woke up in a bed, and as he looked up he saw Elrond look upon him with care…
