Actions

Work Header

Love Is A Shield

Chapter 5: In A Dawn So Very Dark

Summary:

Bilbo has a second dream, in which he is told that Thorin will turn into a dragon if he lives.

The lyrics at the beginning are from the song "There Is A Kingdom" by Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds, which I thought fits well with Bilbo's feelings for Thorin in this chapter.

Chapter Text

“Just like a bird that sings up the sun

In a dawn so very dark

Such is my faith for you

Such is my faith

And all the world’s darkness can’t swallow up

A single spark

Such is my love for you

Such is my love

 

There is a kingdom

There is a king

And he lives without

And he lives within

...And he is everything”

 

Sleep did not prove fortunate for Bilbo. He kept waking up, worried about leaving Thorin unattended for long. Every time he woke, he took a look at Thorin, ensured he was still breathing, and then tried to go back to sleep. This would be so much easier if I were actually sleeping right next to him, he thought. I could hear or feel his breath. But no matter. I don’t suppose that will ever happen. He tried to be content, to cherish those moments, but it was getting harder and harder, as the lack of rest was finally taking its toll on him. Finally, he succumbed to sleep once again, and hoped it would last until the morning just this time. Thorin would be all right, he had to be…

Towards the morning, Bilbo had another dream that featured the knowledgeable entity that had poured so much doubt into him just the night before. This time it appeared as a shadowy figure, and sounded more confident than ever. “Bilbo Baggins, you make an admirable attempt on behalf of your friend. Clearly you care about him a great deal.”

Bilbo wanted to challenge it right away, as he had many questions and doubts. Yet instead – perhaps due to being as tired as he was in real life – he only replied: “I do. As I hope you do too. After all, earlier you seemed to care about his fate.”

“Most certainly, my dear Halfling. That is precisely why I have come a second time: to warn you that, if Thorin Oakenshield does come back to the world of the living, it will not end well for him.” Bilbo shivered with horror, and the being seemed to take pleasure in that. “I’m talking about the gold sickness, of course,” it said gravely. “As you know, that malady lies upon his family, and it has already taken him once. If Thorin is allowed to wake up and go back into that mountain, the sickness will take him again. And this time there will be no cure. The only reason he snapped out of it is that there was a battle happening on his doorstep. It awoke his sense of duty. After all, it was his cousin’s army getting slaughtered. Not to mention it awoke his lust for battle. He is a warrior; he will not flee from a fight. But now, there is no battle anymore. He will have to face the gold sickness without an opportunity for heroic deeds. Who, or what, will pull him out of it this time?”

Bilbo took his head in his hands. This was a problem, and the being seemed to have already guessed his answer.

“You think you can pull him out, Mister Baggins? I wish you could. But I’m afraid this particular sickness is rather powerful. There is little that a simple Halfling like you could do. It wasn’t you who did it the first time, you know that. The sickness will destroy him. He will either die or become one like Smaug, his predecessor.”

“That’s impossible!” Bilbo shouted. “Thorin is nothing like Smaug!”

“Is he not? He will not part with a single coin! He almost killed you! He was fine with having war when he could have had peace! He promised treasure to the people of Laketown and then refused to give it to them, even though one of theirs slayed Smaug. You think this mindset won’t return? You are such a child, Bilbo Baggins!”

“I cannot claim to understand all that passed in his mind,” said Bilbo heavily. “I confess I do not understand it all. He and I will need to have a talk one day.”

“That’s right, because you didn’t have a talk, did you? With the battle and his wounds, there was no time for a talk! So you’re just guessing that he is of sound mind now, after leading his nephews into a death trap! You’re just guessing based on a few words he had for you as he was dying!”

“I am not guessing,” Bilbo said determinedly. “Thorin came out of the Mountain, when he could have stayed there. He could have sent his Company only, but he wanted to fight along. And he went after Azog. This is something that a good king would do. He didn’t have to do it. His words to me only reinforced that he was well again.”

“You’re right, but don’t forget that there was a battle. A chance for him to act, to break out of his cage. Don’t you think that had something to do with it?”

Bilbo considered. He was tired, so tired. He didn’t want to argue anymore. “What is your point? That Thorin should just be going to the halls of his Maker?”

“My point, Mister Baggins, is that Thorin Oakenshield stands to die a good, heroic death, that would make his enemies green with envy, the kind of death that, actually, only an enemy would try to stop. And that if he lives, he will most likely become a dragon himself. He will lock himself in that mountain and live with the gold, and no one will dare enter for fear of what they will find there. That gold is cursed, and Thorin, son of Thrain, is powerless against that curse.”

“But there are ways to remove the curse.” Aren’t there? Bilbo wondered. Bilbo Baggins, are you stupid? he chided himself. Do you really think this… thing will give you tips on how to cure Thorin? But it had worked before, hadn’t it? Even when facing someone shady or downright malicious, Bilbo had found that it was helpful to ask questions and even reveal some of himself. It had worked with Gollum, enough to get him to talk and buy Bilbo time, even if that meant putting up with some nastiness.

“Really? Do you know any?” the figure laughed, unperturbed. “By all means, continue to labor at your friend’s side. Friend, right? You’re being a good friend. Nothing selfish about it? You don’t want any of him for yourself?”

I am not alone in wanting him to live, Bilbo thought. The Company is with me. And yet, uncertainty was creeping into him. What did he want for himself? Anything? Just to be around Thorin, he thought. He just knew that his world would fall apart without Thorin in it. He didn’t know why; he hadn’t had the time to piece it together. His attempts at expressing his love for Thorin had not come out of firm awareness. It was more of a visceral reaction, something Tookish that took him. He wanted to pour an inexhaustible amount of good over Thorin, so he could save him, and the most good that one could find in this world was love. And... it had felt like the right word to match his feelings. As for how deep his love was, what form exactly it took, Bilbo could not say. What he knew for certain was that he needed Thorin to live.

“His presence in the world is something priceless, that cannot be replaced,” he said finally. “That is all I know. As it happens I am not the only one who wants him to live.”

“His presence will soon become something so vile and dangerous that you and all his other friends will only seek to extinguish! And when you finally do so, there will be no dignity in his death; it will only be confirmed that the curse of Durin’s line lives on in him!”

Bilbo felt all energy leave his body. If this was a dream, he hoped it would end soon. If this was how he would sleep from now on, tormented by figures with persuasive voices, placing the heaviest burdens on his shoulders, then he would gladly forgo sleep next time. If it was real... well, he could still put an end to it; he just needed to find the right words.

“All I know is,” he finally said, “that I betrayed Thorin once. I thought I was acting in his best interest, and yet I missed some things that turned out to be important. What I did hurt him more than I could have predicted. I betrayed his trust. All I can say is that, if I were not to try my hardest to help him live, I would feel like I’m betraying him again.”

The shadowy figure was gone in a heartbeat, and Bilbo woke up shivering. He looked at Thorin, who was still sleeping, and put a trembling hand on his shoulder. Then he turned around and ran out of the tent as fast as he could.