Chapter Text
“The soft overcomes the hard;
the flexible conquers the stiff;
the immaterial penetrates the solid.
This is why there is great advantage
in stillness and silence
over movement and speaking.
But few ever obtain the advantage,
for few practice stillness and silence.”
(Tao Te Ching)
Thorin woke up in the morning after resting for a few hours. Bilbo had taken over watching Fili and Kili during the night, and was now sleeping, while Tauriel was making the rounds between the two Princes. Seeing her figure overflowing with happiness, Thorin remembered his realizations from the night before. Kili had not waited long at all to court Tauriel properly. As a result, Tauriel was aware of Kili’s love. Kili had less to offer than the great King Under the Mountain, and yet Kili had made impressive strides in a matter of days, while Thorin had had eight months of journeying with Bilbo within easy grasp and was still at square one. With a sigh, Thorin acknowledged to himself that he needed to step up his game and find a way to be more overt in his intentions towards Bilbo.
He recalled a conversation he had overheard during their quest, where Bilbo was telling Bofur about the importance of food in Hobbit courting habits. He started fantasizing about bringing Bilbo breakfast, and wondered if this was the right move if one wanted to court by Shire standards. If it was, he could pretend not to know of it – well, in fact he didn’t know of it. What was I trying to think? he wondered, confused by his own reasoning. That’s right. Breakfast.
Emboldened, he eagerly went to the dining hall, hoping he could just grab some food and return to the healing room in time to surprise Bilbo whenever he woke up... only to run into Thranduil, whose gaze was fixed on him from the head of the table, the only person in the room.
The two ate in silence for a while. Thorin was pondering how best to address the Arkenstone, when Thranduil broke the ice. “I was glad to hear one of your nephews is awake now. Though I imagine there is more that you are here for than either of them. You have learned that your precious jewel is with me. You wish to retrieve it.”
“I have honored my word to Bard,” said Thorin, reaching into his coat pocket. “Here. I have his message to you.”
To King Thranduil of the Woodland Realm
King Thorin has given the people of Laketown a sizable portion of gold and silver, that is most certainly enough for our present needs. I therefore declare he should retake possession of the heirloom of his House, that your Esteemed Majesty is currently keeping per our agreement in Dale. Please return the Arkenstone to King Thorin upon reading this message.
With our deepest thanks,
Bard of Laketown
“Well, well… I confess these new developments are not quite what I expected. I am wondering, though… as dear as I know it is to your heart, if I might persuade you to leave the Arkenstone with me,” said Thranduil, sipping his wine with elegant movements.
Thorin choked on his coffee. “Excuse me?”
“I confess I find myself loath to part with it. It is the most beautiful jewel I’ve ever laid eyes on. I’ve been seduced by its beauty; it holds power over my heart now. I’ve come to finally understand your longing for it, O, King Under the Mountain... your blindness to everything else. I’m surprised you didn’t ask for it as soon as you got here.”
“There are other, more beautiful things,” Thorin murmured, suddenly lost in thought, looking at an archway that let sunlight in.
“As it looks like you are no longer in the grip of it, I wonder what I might spare so that you’ll leave it with me for a while longer. You needed it to slay the dragon and reclaim your kingdom. You hardly need it now. You won back the Mountain, and your kin have come to your aid even without it.”
“But it belongs to my people. It will belong to my heir one day. I don’t claim it only for myself, but for the entire line of Durin!”
“I understand its value to your people. And yet… its beauty… its purity… it fits better here, in an Elven realm. I would give you other riches, other treasures, in exchange for it.”
Thorin gave him a threatening stare. Then he cleared his throat. “I’m afraid this is not up for negotiation, unless you wish to blackmail me as we both know you’ve done before.”
“No,” said Thranduil calmly, as if the very idea was below him, and then pinned him with a sharp gaze. “Answer me this one question. How did you come back to life and make such a quick recovery?”
“I cannot. We are a secretive race, and this is something worth keeping a secret. I am sorry to disappoint you. Is there something that ails you?”
“I lost my wife many years ago,” the Elvenking said unexpectedly. “I tried to bring her back many times. I spent years entreating the Valar to return her to me. I never received any response. Yet you… How did you do it?”
Thorin frowned in puzzlement. He couldn’t begin to see where Thranduil was going with this.
“King Thranduil. You had some time with your wife, I assume. A long life. Possibly several Dwarven lifetimes, if you know what I mean. I don’t think you see how lucky you are. You may want to hold on to that, though I grant you, no amount of time spent with the one you love could be enough. Yet you had time to confess your love, get married, have a life together. And you will see her again, unlike some lovers who don’t get the chance to share an afterlife.”
“Ah. You care for the Halfling, I see. It’s touching,” Thranduil observed in passing, his thoughts elsewhere.
Thorin looked at him with doubled menace. He had learned early in life to be wary of others, and was good at concealing his feelings, yet in this moment he had come close to revealing them, to Thranduil, of all people! How could he not notice that? How could he let it happen?
“How in the world did you get the Valar to allow you to come back?” the Elvenking insisted.
“Perhaps they really wanted to see the Arkenstone back where it belongs… in Erebor,” Thorin said with a smirk.
“And they needed you to come back for that? The easiest thing would have been to let you die. Then I’m sure one of us would have returned it to you, placed it in your tomb with some words of remorse and be done with it.”
“Ah, but it’s not easy to part with it, is it?” Thorin bit back. “What difference would a dwarf’s life make?”
“You’re not going to answer my question,” said Thranduil defeatedly. He was now wearing the same sorrowful look that Thorin had spotted earlier. “Then I have no choice but to keep the Arkenstone for now. I feel that there is more to it than meets the eye. It is far too precious to be just a stone, and the way I feel when I’m around it... it whispers to me to take a chance. I need to see if I can use its enchantment. If I can figure out how to unlock its power, it may help bring her back...” Thranduil closed his eyes, a dreamy state settling over him.
So that’s what this is all about, Thorin thought bitterly. Mahal help me. For all his spite, a strange feeling moved inside him, which he needed a moment to recognize: a small measure of pity. He was beginning to see that he, Thorin, hopelessly in love with a hobbit whom he had wronged terribly, and whom he had almost lost forever, was at an advantage when it came to love. He had some hope, to be with Bilbo at some point or at least to be around him, while they were both alive. Thranduil had no more hope; at least, not in this lifetime. Yet it felt strange to feel pity for Thranduil, of all things, and Thorin pushed the feeling away with a scowl.
He then thought of Bilbo and his ring. He had but to ask, and Bilbo would put it on, find the Arkenstone, and steal it back for Thorin. Although he did not exactly like this idea, the thought of Bilbo warmed Thorin’s heart so completely that he forgot about the Arkenstone for a moment.
Thranduil looked intrigued by his silence. Then Thorin spoke. “I do not wish to continue this conversation at the present moment. One of my nephews lies unconscious still. I hope for things to improve for him, and then perhaps I can talk to you again, with a clearer mind.”
“Would you use the Arkenstone? If all else fails? To help Fili regain consciousness?”
Thorin continued to gaze absently at the archway infused with the color of sunshine. “I would not make such a decision alone,” he said. “I’m a warrior. I know nothing of magic. I would need someone to counsel me.”
“The Halfling? Is that who you would ask for counsel? Well then perhaps I will ask him!” Thranduil shouted. His demeanor became cold, and a threatening look of greed and jealousy descended upon his face. And now Thorin was no longer calm and collected, as uncertainty and insecurity pushed in. He had always felt a certain kind of betrayal at the thought that Bard and Thranduil had the Arkenstone, his possession, and that Bilbo had been the one to offer it to them. Yet he knew that the betrayal that cut deeper was simply that Bilbo seemed, from the moment that Thorin had banished him from the Company, to belong with them. With Thranduil, in particular. Bilbo already liked Elves and many things Elvish; Thorin felt sure that nothing seemed more natural to him than to seek refuge with the Elven camp. With the person who had laid an army on his doorstep, the same person who had kept a king and his Company imprisoned against any laws of dignity. The person who had refused to offer help during…
Don’t go there. Thorin shook with fear at what this memory could bring. It sounded almost like Thranduil could tap into some of his thoughts… did he have that power? More importantly, did he have something to offer Bilbo that would make his company preferable?
Thorin was now standing, and as Thranduil moved closer to him, it did feel like Thranduil could sense some of his fears. But what Thorin did not expect was that he himself was now able to read Thranduil’s thoughts. Before he could react, Thorin suddenly thought of Bilbo being offered a nice warm bed, an armchair, Elvish books, music, relaxing company, a garden, sunshine… and he realized that Thranduil was having this very thought at this very moment. He was thinking of offering all of this to Bilbo, in exchange for his presence and counsel, for his ability to spy unseen... for his... his loyalty.
Thorin felt his forehead sweating as anger started bubbling inside him. The possessiveness, the jealousy, the incredible insecurity he had felt so many times on the subject of Bilbo Baggins, the complete unwillingness to share him with anyone, all of it was back, and Thorin found himself unable to push any of it away. He realized why he hadn’t wanted Bilbo to come to Mirkwood with him. It wasn’t because Bilbo needed rest in order to heal. It was because he didn’t want him anywhere near Thranduil, near Elves in general. He felt his mind darken, while Thranduil stood there and studied him, looking both curious and pleased with himself. Mahal, Thorin called. You were right to ask me if this is worth it.
Mahal may have been listening, for the very next minute Thorin’s mind changed, and he thought of Bilbo’s words, I belong with your Company. He chose not to dwell on Bilbo’s later I belong where you are, for there was some insecurity in that too, that maybe he had taken Bilbo’s meaning too far, and stood to lose a lot if he believed there was love in those words; and Thorin did not want Thranduil to sense that insecurity. So instead he focused on Bilbo’s evident love for the Company, the twelve loyal dwarves who had followed him into many perils and seen him through the end of the quest, and whom Bilbo had risked his friendship with Thorin for. My Company is in Erebor, and Bilbo is part of it. There is no such Company in your realm, Woodland King, nor will there ever be, he thought with newfound confidence, hoping that, if Thranduil really was reading his thoughts, this was what he would find.
Thranduil gazed at him with knowing satisfaction. “Still, I can ask him,” he said softly, and Thorin perceived the obscurity of his words, ask him for counsel or ask him to stay in Mirkwood?, and that Thranduil knew that such obscurity was the last hammer blow that was going to break him...
Thorin felt the anger begin to take him over. He tried to steady himself, ATKÂT! roaring in his heart, but the anger was roaring louder. He made as if to reach for Orcrist, which (perhaps fortunately) was nowhere within his grasp. Bilbo, his mind called helplessly. I need you. Now. But Bilbo wasn’t there. Bilbo was probably still sleeping. And when Bilbo wasn’t with him, Thorin knew he was prone to making mistakes. Just like when he mounted on Ravenhill. When he sent Fili and Kili to scout the tower. When he fought Azog on the ice. Yet you always came to my rescue, just as I would always come to yours. I need rescue now. There’s nowhere to hide from the claws of this...
Thranduil continued to stare at him silently, and Thorin realized that the Elvenking was reading his thoughts in real time, as they were being formed in his mind. So full of power was he, and indelicate, you would call him, Thorin thought to Bilbo with a somber smile. What would Bilbo say if he were present? Clearly, a Dwarvish insult was probably not going to cut it; it would only further upset this formidable enemy!
It was at this moment that it dawned on Thorin that he could try to think in Khuzdul. Then Thranduil won’t know what he was thinking! He could try to call to Bilbo, he could try to still himself. Quickly, he thought, milmal- ’erekhmi astu. Kunh i’ti astu, markhulkhud?...
* * *
...Bilbo slept, and in his dream he thought he heard Thorin calling out to him repeatedly. For the first few times, it felt like Thorin’s words were being intercepted and couldn’t reach him. Then Thorin called out to him in Khuzdul, and this time Bilbo heard him perfectly. Only, he once again didn’t know what the word meant. Markhulkhud. It was not in the love section he had found in the little dictionary, nor did it ring a bell as a friend term. Part of it was in the battle section, if he recalled correctly. Shield, he thought it meant. Shield something. He smiled through the dream. I like that, I would very much like to be just that for you, Thorin, if you’ll let me. Yet Thorin continued to call to him with urgency, and now Bilbo knew he needed help and wanted to be by his side. He found himself standing in an archway that let sunlight in, and saw Thorin and Thranduil having a confrontation, the silence between them cutting like a knife. Bilbo put his ring on, and wondered how he could reach Thorin, who was standing, his tense back turned to him. Your shadow gives you away, Halfling, he thought he heard Thranduil speak. I’m here for Thorin, he replied, feeling a surge of courage, I would give myself away for him...
As soon as he said that, he saw his shadow morph into an oak leaf of bright green. Thorin, he whispered. Thorin, I’m here. Look at me. Yet Thorin did not turn, and Bilbo knew that he had to address him in Khuzdul, as that was how Thorin had called out to him. And he had a choice between love terms and friendship terms, and didn’t know which to choose. So instead he just looked at what he felt in that moment, and what he felt was courage, an abundance of it. He remembered this word too belonged in the battle section of the blue notebook. It was the perfect word for Thorin, the one who showed me what real courage is, no, not just showed me, he gave it to me. Zangel, he called out to Thorin, overwhelmed with the truth of it all. In the next moment Thorin turned towards the archway and saw the green oak leaf, and he started walking towards it, his demeanor now relaxed. Then the leaf turned black, and turned into smoke as if scorched. Bilbo shivered, and instantly reached for his ring. He took it off, and the smoke gave way to light, and he woke up in that moment, looking in distress at his clutching hands...
* * *
...Zangel, Thorin heard, and as he turned towards the sound he saw an oak leaf of bright green. He thought about the fact that it was the middle of winter, and leaves of such beautiful green could not just be lying around. And he gazed at it with eyes full of wonder, searching for his love in that green that reminded him of the tree in the Erebor he had dreamed of, the tree that he would have wanted to grow for Bilbo, if only he would stay... And he understood what that leaf meant, and his anger melted into something else, something that Bilbo was giving him just now, something that Thorin had only very little of... that he should not have dismissed. And he forgot about his urge to reach for Orcrist and moved towards the archway to reach for the oak leaf instead, a part of me, he smiled in relief, a part of me that is him. Yet as he leaned down to touch it, the leaf turned to black smoke, and the smoke vanished, and Thorin sensed a darkness threatening to take over his love, and wanted nothing more than to rush to find him...
“Feel free to ask Master Baggins for counsel,” he said to Thranduil, satisfied to hear his voice go back to neutral. “Now if you would excuse me, I must attend to my nephews.” He turned away, exiting the room through the archway, and marveled to see it now filled with glorious light.
“The birds they sang
At the break of day
Start again
I heard them say
Don’t dwell
On what has passed away
Or what is yet to be
Yeah the wars
they will be fought again
The holy dove
She will be caught again
Bought and sold
And bought again
The dove is never free
Ring the bells that still can ring
Forget your perfect offering
There is a crack, a crack, in everything
That’s how the light gets in”
