Actions

Work Header

Love Is A Shield

Chapter 11: Tempest

Summary:

Thorin tries to express his feelings for Bilbo in a number of ways, not all of which are successful. Thranduil attempts to persuade Bilbo to stay in Mirkwood. His interactions with both kings leave Bilbo very confused.

The lyrics at the end are from the song "The Heart of You" by Anna Calvi, written by Andrew Wyatt.

Chapter Text

Bilbo, here in the Woodland Realm, Thorin thought as he made his way back to the healing room. Bilbo who had said I belong where you are. But he had lied to Thorin before, had he not? He had deceived him! Thorin began to see that Thranduil had sown doubt into his mind. It was bad enough that the Elvenking had the Arkenstone; he just had to hint at something else he might take from Thorin. How long before he and the hobbit fell out again? How long before Bilbo switched sides?

He may switch sides anyway, even without us having a fight, he thought. This was what he was worried about, that no matter how hard he’d try to regain Bilbo’s respect and hope to secure his love in time, the hobbit would still be drawn to a different world. He also did not feel that he could ever really hope to have his love returned. He had not forgotten how much he’d wronged Bilbo, and for Dwarves forgiveness was not easy to grant. As he felt that Bilbo was slipping through his fingers again, Thorin once more was overcome with pain and regret.

Yet he couldn’t stay long in those thoughts. There was much to do. Fili. The Arkenstone.

The Arkenstone.

As soon as he entered the healing room, all dark thoughts vanished. He glanced at his nephews, content to see both in Legolas and Tauriel’s capable hands. Kili’s bed was now moved immediately next to Fili’s, and Kili was holding his brother’s hand fiercely. Thorin gave a hasty nod to Legolas and Tauriel and rushed to Bilbo’s bed. Without a word, he sat by him and wrapped him in his arms.

“Thorin?” asked Bilbo tentatively. “Where have you been?”

“You’re all right,” said Thorin with relief. “I felt… I was worried about you.”

“I’m all right now,” Bilbo said, smiling. “I meant to tell you... I had a dream. You were calling to me.” Then he pulled away for a moment and looked into Thorin’s eyes. “Did you, Thorin? Did you call to me while you were with Thranduil? I can’t tell if any of it was real.”

“I did,” said Thorin, pulling him back into the hug and tightening his grip around him. “And I believe you heard me. I felt your presence there.”

“Don’t you find that strange? That I can reach you while I’m dreaming?”

“I would find it stranger if you couldn’t,” Thorin murmured, closing his eyes and breathing in the air in his love’s space. He contemplated saying more. There was some evil around you, too. Yet he didn’t want to cause Bilbo to worry, not now of all moments. As he continued to hold Bilbo in his arms, peace settled over him. He thought of Thranduil and the Arkenstone, and for the first time really understood that the stone did not have power over him anymore. Something else, someone much more precious had complete hold of his heart. And he wanted to say this to Bilbo, that he was precious beyond measure to him. “My Rakl’aban,” he heard the word come out... It sounded soft and beautiful, and perfect for its new meaning.

“Hold on,” Bilbo said. “Don’t tell me what it means. I ought to know this one. Stone something. Ah, never mind,” he changed, suddenly remembering he was not supposed to know any Khuzdul. “I don’t know what that means.”

“It means my Arkenstone.” As Thorin spoke, he realized this, for all his good intentions, may not have been the best name to call his beloved. And right he was, for Bilbo pulled away immediately with a raised and very confused eyebrow.

“Oh. Did you ask Thranduil about it?”

Thorin sighed heavily and buried his head in his hands, wishing he could just sink into the floor. “He won’t return it to me. He wants it for himself.”

Bilbo’s eyes widened with shock, fear and something more. “No,” he said. “It cannot be.”

Thorin was silent. As he took in the reality of his blunder, he now saw it was not the only way he was failing in his courting quest in one single morning. Distracted as he had been by Thranduil’s conversation, he hadn’t had a chance to get food for Bilbo. “Master Baggins, allow me to get you some breakfast,” he said. His voice was filled with hesitation, yet with renewed courage and determination he got up and left the room abruptly. He was going to find breakfast for Bilbo, whatever it took, if only to keep him from visiting that accursed dining hall and run into Thranduil. He returned in triumph a few minutes later, carrying a tray with fruit, cake and tea.

“Oh goodness, Thorin, you are a king, you should not be serving me,” said Bilbo, though the joy in his eyes at the sight of the food and the person offering it spoke differently.

“I want to,” said Thorin, looking at Bilbo fondly. “I’m glad you’re here with me, Master Baggins.”

“Me too, Thorin. I would not be anywhere else.”

“Is that really true?”

Bilbo laughed. “Thank you for bringing breakfast. That’s very considerate of you.” He began eating immediately.

I guess breakfast doesn’t really count as a courting tactic for Hobbits, Thorin thought. There must be some other daily hobbit meal I need to target. Yet he had more pressing things to deal with. “Bilbo,” he began. “How do you like it here in Mirkwood?”

“Hmm? I haven’t really had time to look around. It’s not quite the place for me. I very much prefer Rivendell.”

Thorin bit his lip hard. This wasn’t easy. “What if you were invited to stay here? What would you say?”

“Invited? By whom?”

“By this elf king, who else? He seems to entertain the idea that you might be of some use to him.”

“Surely you wouldn’t like me to… Thorin, where is this coming from?”

“Answer me. What would you do if you received such an invitation?”

“It depends. Would you be staying too?”

“No. I would stay only to see Fili and Kili recovered. Then I’d return to my duties in Erebor.”

“Then I wouldn’t stay either. I would go with you.”

“Is it that simple, Master Baggins?”

“Yes, it is. That simple.”

They stared at each other. Bilbo tried to smile. “Thorin… Let me talk to Thranduil. About the Arkenstone.”

“No!” Thorin did not mean to shout.

“Then what would you have me do?”

“I won’t have you do anything. I don’t control you.”

Bilbo eyed him with much confusion. Perhaps if he had known the challenges his meeting with Thranduil brought to Thorin’s mind, he would have reached some understanding. As it stood, though, he knew nothing of what had transpired between the two kings at breakfast. If all he thought was that Thorin was downright angry about the Arkenstone business, no one could fault him.

But Thorin’s mind was differently engaged. This was not going well, that much was clear, and it’s all that smug elf’s fault, he thought, feeling caught in a loop of Thranduil’s words. The Elvenking had suggested that he could ask Bilbo for counsel on the matter of using the Arkenstone to bring his wife back. And Thranduil had thought of offering Bilbo a place to stay in his Woodland Realm; at least, that was what Thorin had sensed upon Thranduil moving close to him.

He’ll take Bilbo from me, he thought. He’ll take him unless I do something. But I don’t know what to do.

This was true, if anything was. Thorin was not the keenest blade for an axe in love matters. He thought he’d shown how much Bilbo meant to him. He had held him in his arms repeatedly and had pressed their foreheads together, gestures that, for the excessively private Dwarves, were reserved exclusively for family and lovers. He had gifted Bilbo the mithril shirt, the second most valuable object in his kingdom and the most valuable that he had had access to at the time. Granted, this had been just the beginning, as Thorin had planned to give Bilbo many more tokens of his affection whenever the time presented itself. However, what he had given was already pretty telling of his intentions!

And yet the things he had done didn’t seem to move the hobbit much. What if Thranduil came up with something better – admittedly not for the purpose of winning Bilbo’s heart, but his loyalty, his allegiance, which was equally troublesome? Something that would be enough for Bilbo to remain in Mirkwood?

Thorin pondered for a minute. The biggest source of his insecurity was the moment when he had grabbed Bilbo by the collar and almost threw him from the rampart. He believed he wouldn’t have actually done so – it had been a moment of blind fury, just one moment, and then his love for the Halfling took over and he released him – but it had been no doubt enough to cement Bilbo’s opinion of him. Despite the words of forgiveness exchanged between them, he could not expect Bilbo to overlook that; while Thranduil, whatever one might say, had not shown this level of anger. Quite the contrary, for all the wine that he drinks, his capacity for restraint is impressive, Thorin thought spitefully.

So Thorin decided to talk about the sickness he had been under before the Battle of the Five Armies, and hoped that Bilbo would see him in a better light.

Bilbo had finished eating when Thorin started talking. “There are things I need to tell you. About… my desire for gold. And for the Arkenstone. And for…” He stopped suddenly. Bilbo felt a rush of panic, and immediately shook his head as if this wasn’t needed at all, I know, Thorin, you don’t need to go there. “My mind changed when I entered the Mountain,” Thorin continued unperturbed. “It became wrapped in that gold. I couldn’t see anything else. I wanted it all. I didn’t want to share it with anyone, though I could have given some to Bard to rebuild his town, in time... under better circumstances. And I became obsessed with the Arkenstone, as you know.” He stopped again and looked down, clenching his fists and wishing for this memory to be different, different...

Bilbo placed a hand on one of his fists, touching lightly, and Thorin continued. “I know you tried to rescue me. Your company always made me feel lighter. Happier. But I couldn’t be reached. I was too far gone. Then you showed me that acorn you were holding. When I heard you talk of going home to the Shire and planting it, I was the happiest I’d been in a long time.” And the saddest, when you clarified where you wanted to plant it. “All I wanted was to make sure you’d be able to do that as soon and as safely as possible. I wanted you to survive the battle. And yet, when you presented me with the opportunity to avoid battle altogether, I chose it anyway. I put you in danger, directly, and threatened to take your life. Bilbo, I cannot fathom how you are still here, after all this.”

Thorin thought this was going rather well. This could not be wrong. He was off to a good start in expressing his feelings.

“I can,” said Bilbo. “Thorin, we’ve already talked about this.”

“But I will say that I really meant it when I told you, go back to your books and your armchair… I want you to be happy, and free. Free of this, whatever this adventure has become. I will not keep you in Erebor against your will.”

“Well, you regret those things you did to me, right?” said Bilbo.

“Of course. I told you, if I can help it, you will never see me like that again.”

“What if I were to tell you that I don’t want to go home? That I want to stay, at least for now?”

“Stay in Erebor?”

“Yes. Stay in Erebor.” Bilbo searched his eyes. “Assuming I’m welcome, of course.”

“Is this because I almost died and you’re worried about me? If it is... you need not worry.”

“It is not. The fact that you nearly died made me realize some things. I don’t see myself going home. Not now.”

Thorin raised his head and looked at Bilbo as if he saw him for the first time. “What did you realize?”

But Bilbo wasn’t going to say any more. The Took was done for the day, at least in the matters of love. Which was perhaps good, because in the next moment two things happened at the same time: the door opened and an elf peeked in the room and addressed Bilbo, “King Thranduil requests your presence, if you are not otherwise occupied,” and Fili stirred for the first time. Bilbo looked at Thorin with caution, as if anticipating his disapproval. Thorin grunted, let out a foul string of Khuzdul, then he squeezed Bilbo’s hand tightly and released it. “You can go if you wish,” he said. “I must attend to Fili.”

Bilbo looked at the elf, then at Fili, then thought for a moment. “Thorin,” he whispered reassuringly. “I will go and talk to the Elvenking. It’s only polite. I'll be back as soon as I can.”

He walked out of the healing chamber, his mind spinning. A lot had happened in the last few days. He gave the Arkenstone to Bard and Thranduil. He parted ways with the Company of dwarves, and rejoined Gandalf. He watched the Battle of the Five Armies, and saw how Thorin eventually charged into battle with his loyal twelve. He watched Fili fall on Ravenhill, followed by Thorin after his defeat of Azog. He heard him say farewell to him. He fought desperately to bring him back. And after some days had passed, Thorin did come back.

And now they were here, in Mirkwood, and Thranduil had the Arkenstone, and would not give it back to Thorin. Strangely, this part almost brought relief to Bilbo. He had been worried about Thorin retrieving the Arkenstone. All he knew was that before the stone really entered the picture, he and Thorin had had a good thing going, and that Thorin’s desire for it seemed to have really messed with the dwarf’s mind. Yet he also knew how much the Arkenstone meant to Thorin, how much he hated Thranduil, and that he, Bilbo, had given it away. He couldn’t deny the feeling of hope growing in his heart, though. The Arkenstone was trouble; better it should stay with Thranduil, he resolved himself with a stubborn frown.

But that was not all that Bilbo still needed to process. Sometime during those days, he had told Thorin he loved him. Granted, Thorin couldn’t hear him... or could he? He didn’t seem surprised I could reach him from my dream earlier. And it was sometime during those days that Bilbo felt something so strong, so genuine for Thorin, stronger than anything he’d ever felt before. He hadn’t known if it really was love. And he didn’t know how Thorin felt about him. Thorin, whom he had hurt and betrayed...

There was a lot of confusion to be felt, for sure. Yet Thorin had held him in his arms with so much warmth, offered him so much comfort, and it was clear he cared about his happiness! There was a lot to be hopeful for, though Thorin had not said anything about love. True, there was the breakfast he had just brought him. A courting tradition by Shire standards, but surely Thorin doesn’t know that, Bilbo thought dismissively. He probably just did it out of friendship. And then there was the talk they had just had. It sounded like Thorin wouldn’t have minded if Bilbo had gone back to the Shire. If he wanted to be with Bilbo, that would probably be the last thing he would say to him...

Did he, Bilbo Baggins, want to fall in love? I’d never thought I’d fall in love until after I met you, Thorin, he mused. I’d have been comfortable living without it. But falling in love was one thing, and falling in love with Thorin was another. Did he want to fall in love with Thorin? I don’t want to if you don’t, he spoke to the person of his dreams, yet even those words that built a wall around himself he spoke with love, so much love that... I guess it’s too late for that thought.

“The King’s Halfling,” Thranduil said with a smirk as he stood up from his throne, and at once Bilbo felt that he was being held under close scrutiny. “A puzzling little thing. A pity that he couldn’t see your true worth. But perhaps there are some who can.”

“King Thranduil,” Bilbo bowed hesitantly. “I have good news. Prince Fili woke up just a few minutes ago. I trust that we should not trespass on your kindness much longer. I’m sorry, what did you say?”

Thranduil continued to study him. “Essentially, that it’s a pity that King Thorin chose the Arkenstone over you. I myself feel you are worth more, incomparably more than a shiny trinket. But to each his own. Anyway, all is well that ends well, right?”

“Thorin was sick! If you ask him now, anyone in his Company is worth more than the Arkenstone!”

“Perhaps,” Thranduil allowed gracefully, “though that still means that he can bend one way or the other, in a most unpredictable and,” he made as if to hide his disgust, “unpleasant manner. Tell me, Halfling, what do I have to do in order to keep you here, as part of my kingdom? Is there anything you would like? What is the Arkenstone of your desire? You have but to name it.”

“My home is in the Shire,” Bilbo answered. That technically wasn’t true anymore, but he wasn’t going to share that with Thranduil. “I thank you, but I fail to see what use I would be here anyway.”

“You would be of use to me. Word has spread of your intelligence and cunning, of the great spirit you showed during the dwarves’ quest. What you did for your friends, and for a king who could not see beyond his own desire… It did not escape my notice.”

“Oh. No… See, a lot of those times I was just lucky, that’s all.”

“Mmm. Yes, I believe you were. Lucky, or you must have had some help,” Thranduil nodded at him knowingly. "I wonder…” Yet he didn’t press. “I would still like to know what you desire most.”

“Well, for a while I thought I really desired to go on an adventure. Then one night it knocked on my door! While I was on the road with Gandalf and the dwarves, there were many times I only wished to be back home, with my books and my armchair.” Then Thorin died – no, he almost died, and I wished for nothing more than for him to live – and after that… after that… I’m too tired to wish for anything anymore. He didn’t mean to have that last thought, and wondered curiously where it had come from. And he noticed that though he didn’t say some of these words out loud, it felt like Thranduil knew about them too. “Well, the bottom line is, we don’t always know what to wish for,” he closed. “And I’m certainly not sure what to wish for at this moment.”

“I see. So you will follow King Thorin into the Mountain? Is that your plan?”

Bilbo felt a pang of fear. Of course he’d planned on following Thorin anywhere, but there was something in the way the Elvenking spoke that reminded him of the unpleasant voice’s words he had heard in his dreams. He resolved not to dwell on that though, and as he didn’t like the idea of Thranduil being right or knowing so much, he opted for a half-truth. “My plan is to return to the Shire, as soon as the weather gets better and the roads are fit for travel. Until then, yes, I’m probably going to stay in Erebor.”

“And has the King Under the Mountain attempted to persuade you to stay… longer?”

No, as a matter of fact he doesn’t seem to mind if I leave! As Bilbo’s mind struggled in frustration, he felt he was no longer in unison with Thorin. Something of what they had had before this meeting, the connection he had felt during his dream... was breaking. “No,” he answered. “He said I could go as I wish.”

“Very well, little Halfling. Here is what I propose. As you may know, I have his precious Arkenstone. I wasn’t planning on giving it back to him, but I will do so if you remain here until the spring, or whenever you decide to return to the Shire.”

“What?! The Arkenstone is his birthright! You have no right to it!”

“Well, it’s not like I stole it from him,” Thranduil smirked with malicious generosity, clearly enjoying Bilbo’s horrified look. “It simply came to me. But I understand the King’s love and longing for it. So I am prepared to let it go, in exchange for you, seeing as how this won’t bother him.”

Bilbo slapped himself on the face, bewildered. Perhaps I am dreaming still, he thought, though this is too weird even for a dream. “Why would you part with the Arkenstone when just a few minutes ago you wanted it for yourself?”

“Because now that I finally get to see you, meet you... I perceive you are of greater value,” Thranduil replied. “Even magical, perhaps. My kingdom needs more magical things.”

“Have you asked Thorin about this? Oh, never mind, I don’t know why I ask! This is preposterous!”

“Well, he said he won’t keep you by force, right? You can go as you wish. And it does seem as if you could use some rest and healing. We would provide that during your stay here, I assure you.”

“But I don’t wish to stay here!”

“Oh? And why not?”

Bilbo was silent. Because I want to be with him, he thought, unaware that he was making it easy for Thranduil to penetrate his thoughts as he had done with some of Thorin’s earlier. Though now it doesn’t feel like the right thing to do anymore; not at the cost of the Arkenstone; not if I’m betraying him again. Yet staying here I’d be betraying... someone else. Or both of us, he added after some more thinking.

“I assume you want to go to Erebor because you think the dwarves are your only friends. But you have friends here too, don’t you know that?” And now Thranduil’s expression was soft and seductive, his voice like velvet, and Bilbo felt enchanted and tipsy for a moment. “Let me… let me talk to Thorin,” he said with some effort. A sudden wave of relaxation came over him, and he wanted nothing more than to lie down on a couch and stare at a window with a glass of wine in hand.

As he struggled to focus, he realized that he and Thranduil had been moving for a while. They were now outside, walking toward the forest, and the Elvenking was leading him to a secluded area. “I want to show you something,” he said to Bilbo, pointing to a space that held some withered plants and scattered trees on what looked like barren soil. A circular stone structure rested in the middle of that place. “This used to be a garden back when we…” Thranduil paused with some difficulty and sighed heavily. “Now everything is faded. But I will make this garden grow once more, and offer it to you. If you should decide to stay in my kingdom, I anticipate a garden will bring you much pleasure.”

“Oh,” Bilbo said, his voice a mix between perplexed and very, very skeptical. “I hate to ask, but how are you going to grow a garden in winter? Especially since nothing seems to be growing around here.” That was uncalled for. What did you say that for, Bilbo Baggins?

Thranduil laughed, this time a genuine laugh, and for the first time Bilbo saw his open-heartedness, and it reminded him of some rare occasions when Thorin had laughed in a similar manner at something he’d said. This time I made a blunder though, he thought with amusement, happy that his mind returned to Thorin. Your bad manners must be rubbing off on me.

“How indeed,” the Elvenking echoed mysteriously. And as they walked through the forest in silence, Bilbo’s mind started spinning again, and he wondered how something so simple like the attempt to prevent a war and save the lives of friends could ever become so twisted. Or how something so disturbing he had witnessed, been a part of and thought was over, could be happening all over again.

 

"There is a darkness

A heaviness that is concealed

Inside these boundaries

Inside a plain of frozen fields

There are no weapons

No sharpened blows to be sustained

No, only malice

And the tapping of the rain

 

But there’s a dream I keep

In a world so dark and deep

The one true paradox

I’m terrified to meet

There’s a dream I keep

I go in when I sleep

There’s nothing they can do

No one will keep me from the heart of you”