Chapter Text
It had now been a month of living in the Woodland Realm, and as the two young Durins were well on their way to a full recovery, Thorin began to think about going home.
Since Thranduil had not brought up Bilbo or the Arkenstone since their meeting in the garden, Thorin assumed that the Elvenking was going to keep the stone longer and try to experiment with it further. Perhaps Elrond could be persuaded to help with translations, since he was well-versed in runes... but this was not Thorin’s concern.
Fili and Kili continued snooping around the halls trying to collect important information, and soon learned that Thranduil was pulling all the stops in his effort to create a truly special brand of wine. Details were scarce as to what he would use this wine for, or what properties it would have to have, but it was clear that he was targeting something big, since he himself was no longer enough as a testing subject. He was now testing different wine combinations on willing inhabitants of the Woodland Realm, and that resulted in a good few Elves plastered on the floor, in need of some medical attention. When this reached Bilbo and Thorin’s ears, they feared the Elvenking was really trying to send someone to the halls of Mandos so he could get his wife back. However, Tauriel and Legolas, who were watching over the state of said Elves, assured them that it was nothing serious; the wine was harmless and the Elves in question were just a particular brand of woozy.
Since the healing chamber was not nearly empty anymore, Thorin’s room, the largest of all guest rooms, became the place for the Company’s gatherings. That is where they were now, making plans for departure and discussing their last days in Mirkwood.
“So, Thranduil has encouraged more people to sign up for testing different kinds of wine,” Fili reported.
“Apparently he supervises the sampling closely. He brings the subjects to the throne room and watches the effects of the drink on them himself,” Kili added.
“I wonder what he’s looking for,” said Bilbo with great apprehension.
Balin stepped in eagerly. “Well. If I may be permitted to guess, it’s obviously an elixir meant to heighten the senses. The Elvenking is going to take the Arkenstone’s offer to bring his wife back for an hour before we leave. One cannot blame him for wanting to be fully prepared to have the most pleasurable experience possible with his beloved,” he uttered very articulately, as if there could be no other explanation.
“I’d say he’s not doing a good job so far,” said Fili. “If all we see are elves passed out in the halls... that’s nothing special. It was like this the last time we were here, as I recall.”
“Perhaps he saves the best samples for himself,” said Dwalin. “Getting high every night. That’s why we barely see him at dinner anymore.”
“Hmm. An elf getting high,” said Thorin skeptically. “I don’t think it’s that easy for them. Needless to say, everyone,” he eyed them with a no-nonsense look, “you are to stay away from any sort of wine the elves may offer. We have but a few days left; for those of you who are inclined towards the drink, make an effort to abstain. For those of you who are curious” - he looked sharply at Fili and Kili - “This is not a good time to try new things. There is a time and a place for everything, and it’s called Erebor, whenever it is fully restored. As for you...” - his tone softened as he looked at Bilbo - “I don’t think any words are necessary.”
“No,” Bilbo said, though his mind was far from being in perfect agreement. All throughout this meeting, he had been thinking.
Stay close to me at all times, and I will stay close to you, Thorin had said to him after their last meeting with the Elvenking, in the garden. Together we are strong against him. If he finds one of us without the other, he may be able to manipulate our minds. We have to be careful. Bilbo agreed, though all this staying close to Thorin was making him want more and more of him, in ways that he wasn’t sure were... acceptable. Thorin was so attentive towards him, always asking about his needs and eager to comfort him, and all the protectiveness he offered, combined with their Khuzdul sessions, which seemed like such a special, intimate experience Bilbo had grown to crave... all of this Bilbo found very attractive, and he felt like he couldn’t take much more of it without knowing something for certain. Out of caution, he had planned on waiting, but this was tantamount to torture!
Yet how can I tell you how I feel? he considered as he addressed his love in the secrecy of his mind. How, without the risk of being rejected? Oh, Thorin, I would not want to cause any awkwardness in our friendship, or lose it altogether! Yet that may happen if I blurt out my feelings and you’re not ready to reciprocate, or talk about them... I can’t lose you, Thorin, even if all we can have is friendship.
That is when a thought inserted itself into his mind. The wine. I could drink some of Thranduil’s special wine; then I could try to get Thorin alone (which is not difficult these days); then I could confess my feelings to him. If he reciprocates them, I will be in heaven. If he doesn’t, I’ll blame it on the wine; I’ll tell him it was probably something like an elixir of love, that would have been just as effective with Dwalin, or Balin... whichever person I happened to run into. And hopefully he’ll understand and look past it. This way I don’t have to worry about creating a rift between us.
But Thorin did not want him anywhere near Thranduil or his wine. And Bilbo did not want to disrespect Thorin’s wishes. So he resolved he wasn’t going to ask for the wine or look for an opportunity to try it. If the wine presented itself... that was another story.
Present itself it did, for the next day, Fili and Kili came to him to report that Thranduil had finally obtained the exact combination he was looking for, tested it repeatedly and declared himself pleased. They also carried a message for Bilbo: tonight, at dinner, Thranduil was going to offer Bilbo the special drink. “Did he say what it’s for?” Bilbo insisted. “No, he didn’t,” Fili replied. “But Balin is probably right; what else can it be, other than a drink meant to exalt the senses so the person can get maximum pleasure with his loved one?”
“Well,” Bilbo said, “I’m not sure Thranduil needs that. He missed his wife so much, he doesn’t need any sort of aid for his happy sensations when he sees her. Plus, we don’t know if he’s really going to get her back for an hour. He may decide to keep the Arkenstone here and study it further.”
“I envy you, Bilbo,” Kili sighed. “I for one would love to try it. Things have not progressed much between Tauriel and me, to be honest. She’s always busy, I’m still recovering, and it’s not easy to do anything under Uncle’s eagle eyes. What I would give for a special night with her.”
Fili chimed in with some words of wisdom. “Speaking of, I know someone who needs it more than Bilbo, and even more than you, Kili.” Kili gave a big grin of agreement. “Bilbo, a word of advice. If you do taste the wine, please take pity on Uncle and share it with him.”
“Or even better, give him your glass altogether,” Kili suggested, and both brothers chuckled and left Bilbo to his own devices.
Despite reacting with a frown, the thought kept playing in Bilbo’s mind, an elixir that heightens the senses, how I would like that, it is one chance, after that we leave this place and that is it, I won’t have a better opportunity to tell Thorin I love him once we get to Erebor and I’m surrounded by busy dwarves! Even if Thorin does not feel the same, perhaps he could try the drink too and we can have some fun for one night... a night which I sure will never forget.
You have changed, Bilbo Baggins, he chided himself. What is wrong with you?
This place is to blame. I don’t feel like myself here. Sometimes I have thoughts that are not fully my own. I don’t know where they come from...
Yet one thing he did know for sure is that he was tired of being torn.
He had been torn on whether to give Thorin the Arkenstone after taking it from Smaug.
Torn again when Thorin was lying at death’s door and he didn’t know what would be acceptable to say to him; what he should feel for him.
Torn whether to tell Thorin that the Arkenstone could grow dead plants overnight, for fear this would make his madness return.
Torn again, on whether to use Thorin’s beloved language that night in the garden, under Thranduil’s eye. It had been such a difficult moment! He had wanted to read the Arkenstone’s runes in order to try to diffuse Thorin’s anger; yet reading them meant exposing them to Thranduil, who could be peering into his mind at any time. Thankfully, Thorin handled the situation excellently. Yet I... I was torn once again, and a lot of good that did me...
What Bilbo disliked most about some of those instances was that they put in question his loyalty to Thorin. And his honesty.
Honesty. As soon as the word formed in his mind, he involuntarily looked at the place in his coat where a certain object was hidden.
And perhaps more than anything... during this adventure I was torn... a few times... on whether I should use this ring or not.
A feeling of loneliness came over him. He longed for certainty. He longed for home. What did he have here, in Mirkwood? So far away from the Shire, in an unfriendly environment, with a host that changed on a whim, with little sun and warmth...?
And what will I have in Erebor? It will be worse; Thorin will be busier than I’ve ever seen him. He may forget about me. And that’s the best case scenario. Worst case, he’ll succumb to the madness again.
He sighed and reached for the acorn in his coat pocket to examine it one more time, and remembered how Thorin had said Plant your trees, watch them grow as he was bidding him farewell. He had looked at Thorin incredulously. Do you know what this acorn means to me, Thorin? Clearly not. If you did, you would also know that I can’t do this without you. And yet he had still given Thorin an imperceptible nod, as if he would try...
My love for him. This is what this acorn means to me. I picked it up in Beorn’s garden. Yes, I do believe that is when I... started falling in love with him; after the Carrock. I want to plant my tree and watch it grow. But it needs... well, it needs some help. I am lucky that Thorin didn’t die; or else I would be faced with something impossible. But, the Valar be blessed, my love is right here. Yet I still can’t grow it the way I want.
My love... How long before I can call him that?
I can’t ask this of Thorin. To deliver me from being torn; to be my certainty, to be my home. To do more for me than he is already doing. Unless he wants to.
And suddenly he knew: he had to do something, even if it partially meant going against Thorin’s wishes. He had to find out where the two of them stood. And the only way to know was for him to make the first move, as clearly Thorin wasn’t going to make one! So he decided he was going to ask him openly about trying the wine. I don’t have to do this behind his back. Instead I will be honest and simply ask Thorin to let me have one glass. If he says no, I’ll just drop it; but I have to try.
That evening at dinner, Thranduil came over to Thorin and Bilbo’s table, bringing two glasses of wine with him. “For my honored guests,” he said in a sugary voice. “You’d make me a happy elf if you tried it. I’ve been working on it tirelessly these past few weeks. I daresay I’m pleased with the result. I have been inspired by the latest events - some of them bordering on the supernatural - to try to create something special. I wish to part with both of you in friendship and gratitude, and this is the best I can offer.”
It was hard to decline, Bilbo found. If nothing else, his manners dictated he should at least pretend to be interested. Then Thranduil leaned closer to Bilbo and whispered, “The wine in your glass is even more... special. More potent. Do not be afraid to try it,” and gave Bilbo a you can trust me look. Then he went back to his seat, and Bilbo was left with the glass in front of him and with the urge to drink, imagination running wild as to how the wine might help him speak eloquently to Thorin about his feelings.
“Thorin,” he said, carefully shifting his gaze between the dwarf and the wine, “it is perhaps rude not to try the drink offered by our host.”
“Do you want to try it?” Thorin asked simply.
“I do, very much. I am so curious to see its effects. I was going to ask you to let me try it. I know you’re against it, but... One cannot deny that our host has excellent taste in wine, or so I heard the guards say... last time we were here.”
“I can hardly refuse you anything, Master Baggins, but I’m really opposed to this. We don’t know what this elf is trying to achieve, and it may very well involve one of us. He wants you to stay here; I fear that this wine is a trap.”
“So what are you suggesting? That we leave the glasses untouched?”
“Precisely,” said Thorin, unmoved.
“How about we each have just a sip? Just to show our host that we’re drinking. That way we won’t look rude. Then we can excuse ourselves from the table and take the drink to our rooms, and say we want to consume it there. And once there, we throw it down the drain.”
“Are you sure about this? This is not my way of doing things.”
“Yes, Thorin. I want to try it. And... I wouldn’t mind it if you tried it with me.” He smiled at Thorin shyly, as if he was asking him out on a first date. This had an immediate effect, for Thorin looked smitten and acquiesced promptly.
“Very well. We’ll do it your way. But just one sip, Master Baggins.”
“Thank you, Thorin,” Bilbo murmured, trying to look somewhat composed and not betray that deep inside he was preparing himself for the possibility of heavenly bliss.
And they each had a sip, right at a moment when the Elvenking was looking at them, and ate their dinner, which seemed tastier than ever. They both declared the wine to be quite exquisite, and Bilbo felt all the hope and anticipation of good things to come. Then he noticed something. After said sip, Thorin seemed considerably more relaxed than earlier, and the loving gaze directed at Bilbo was unmistakable. Yet that was nothing compared to hearing Thorin speak.
“Bilbo... sometimes I find myself wondering... why I keep denying you things. When all I want is to fulfill your every wish.”
“You haven’t denied me anything.”
“You said you wanted to drink the wine. I want you to enjoy it to the fullest, Bilbo. Please, drink it all, but stay close to me. Don’t go anywhere near that elf, and it should all be fine.”
“Of course, Thorin. Where am I going to go?”
“And I’ll tell you something else. You said you wouldn’t mind if I drank, too. I see now that I have been too close-minded. It should be so easy to at least try to make you happy, yet I always seem to throw obstacles in my own way. Of course I’m going to drink with you.”
Happy that Thorin was all right with both of them drinking, though also perplexed by the sudden change, Bilbo did not wait to be told twice. Oh, Thorin, he thought, a few more shots of this wine and I’ll be able to tell you how I feel. You cannot know how long I’ve waited.
It wasn’t actually that long, was it? Yet it felt long. It felt like a thousand lifetimes.
As he drank, however, Bilbo couldn’t detect any change in his state of mind. The wine seemed nothing out of the ordinary, certainly nothing that would heighten the senses or induce someone to loosen their tongue. However, across the table from him something was happening. The more they drank, the more relaxed Thorin seemed to be, and the more eager to offer Bilbo the moon. Is there anything else you’d like? Can I bring you some more food? How about a walk in the garden after dinner? which made Bilbo wonder what exactly this wine was supposed to do and why it was acting only on Thorin and not on him...
“Was the wine to your liking, Bilbo?” Thorin asked after they finished drinking, a wide grin spread on his face.
“I... yes, it was.”
“Would you like another one?”
“Another... drink?” Hmm. That is weird. I thought he wanted me to stay away from the wine. I sure couldn’t say no to another glass; I can only hope the next one will have more of an effect.
Why can’t you just say what you want to say to Thorin and be done with it? a more practical voice demanded.
Because if I tell him I love him and he doesn’t feel the same way, I plan on blaming it on the wine. Yet I know that my wine is not... special. So I can’t legitimately blame anything on it. I would be lying to Thorin. I. Can’t. Lie. To. Him. Again.
“I would love another one, but I’m not sure how to get it, other than ask Thranduil in person,” Bilbo said, feeling a bit dejected after feeling hopeful.
“That’s all right,” said Thorin aimably. “I’ll go ask him myself. It will be my pleasure to bring you another glass.”
“Thorin, no. You shouldn’t go near him; he may taunt you again. I don’t want him to ruin your evening. Let me go,” Bilbo said, thinking of how Thorin may react to Thranduil under the wine’s influence. At least he, Bilbo, was still sober!
“If that is your wish,” said Thorin, once again with unexpected calmness.
Sober or not, this would have been a good moment for Bilbo to take a close look at the change in Thorin, as surely the latter would not have allowed him to move in Thranduil’s direction unaccompanied. Unfortunately, instead of continuing to ponder, Bilbo was eager to go and get another drink. This was the perfect time, Thorin seemed to be in a great mood, the stars had finally aligned! So he all but ran to Thranduil who was seated at the head of the table, and asked if he may have another glass of wine.
“Certainly,” said Thranduil. “The wine I offered you is from my personal stash, which I keep in my throne room. Why don’t we go there now and get you some more.”
Bilbo looked undecided. I can go with him, he thought to himself, get the drink and be right back. He looked towards Thorin and gestured to him that he needed to go with Thranduil, and Thorin responded with a grin and gestured back something like No hurry, take your time. So Bilbo went, a bit uneasy but determined to get the desired drink.
Once they got to the throne room, Thranduil poured him a glass, and once again, motivated by rules of politeness, Bilbo drank a sip right away before saying, “Now can we go back to the dining hall?”
“How about enjoying the wine with me?” Thranduil asked.
“Oh. I suppose Thorin and I can sit with you at the table,” said Bilbo. “I always hoped that the three of us could be friends.”
“I meant drink it here, just the two of us,” said Thranduil, pouring himself a glass.
“Oh.”
Thranduil moved towards him. “Don’t be frightened, Halfling. Try it. It won’t harm you; I won’t harm you. Please, sit down.”
“What do you want from me?” Bilbo asked, feeling very uncomfortable.
“I’d like to talk to you,” said Thranduil. “While we both enjoy our wine.”
“Speaking of that, the wine you gave me wasn’t that... potent. I honestly didn’t feel any difference from regular wine. Though I must admit, it was delicious.”
“This one here is very potent,” Thranduil reassured him. “There must have been a mix-up earlier. It’s possible King Thorin wound up with the glass meant for you.”
“Oh.” Bilbo thought of how easy-going Thorin was at the dinner table; no doubt, under the influence of that special wine! Things certainly looked promising with that particular Thorin; who could blame Bilbo for wanting to catch up? “Thank you, King Thranduil, I’m happy to drink this. You are most generous. Now what did you want to talk about?” he said, finally settling down into an armchair.
As he did, it occurred to him that he sometimes liked being in the Elvenking’s company. Thranduil was not all bad, and in some respects Bilbo was feeling really lonely in the Woodland Realm. He wished he had someone to talk to about his feelings, and about being torn all the time, and Thranduil seemed very bright and perceptive, if only he wasn’t such a... Bilbo decided to stop his string of thoughts there, and hoped that he would not regret this conversation.
“Finally,” said Thranduil with satisfaction. “I get to have my answers. Let’s start at the beginning. What is it about you that makes you so valuable?”
“I was not aware that I was,” said Bilbo.
“Well. This shirt you’re wearing,” the Elvenking pointed to Bilbo’s mithril, “is made of the rarest and most precious material in Middle Earth. This is not something to be given away lightly, especially by a Dwarf. They are obsessed with precious metals. Yet King Thorin saw fit to gift it to you. And I don’t even think you needed it...” he said, scrutinizing Bilbo carefully. “You were already protected. So, why did he give it to you?”
Bilbo shrugged. “I’m sure it had to do with the battle.”
“I don’t think so, Halfling. I imagine it was more like a thank-you gift for something you may have accomplished for him. But to move on... the Arkenstone. First, you were able to take it from Smaug. How? If that dragon had wanted to, he would have turned you into a pile of ash before you even had a chance to get close to the jewel. There must be something you said to him, or more likely did... something that no one else could come up with. And then, you kept the Arkenstone on you, and hid it from your king. That was disloyal enough in itself, but then you gave it to me and Bard, which is nothing short of high treason. I can assure you, if someone directed such an offense at me, they would be banished without any chance for recourse. And yet, your king forgave you almost immediately. Why?”
“I don’t know about the almost immediately part. How could you even tell such a thing?”
“I live and breathe, Mister Baggins. If you ask me, he forgave you right then and there, even as you were descending from the rampart to join us. The question is, why?”
“He... You know, you make a good point. I don’t know why he forgave me.”
“There’s no doubt in my mind it’s because there’s something about you. Something I have not yet perceived in the light of day. If King Thorin values you so - just the other day he said he’d summon his cousin’s army just to get you out of here - that can only mean that there is good in you beyond anything that he, at least, has ever seen.”
“Or perhaps he’s just being a good friend,” Bilbo offered humbly.
Thranduil smiled generously. “This is what I like about you, Halfling. This air of innocence you have about you. You lighten up even the darkest of hearts; and certainly the heart of a tired and bored elf like myself. But I digress. Let’s talk about how the dwarf king was brought back to life. You had something to do with it, no doubt.”
“No. Not at all,” Bilbo said, and now, just as he gulped a good helping of wine, he began to see something very clearly. He found it very, very easy to lie. In his heart of hearts he felt he must have had something to do with the fact that Thorin had not died. Yet his response to Thranduil was the opposite. It wasn’t just because he was wary in the Elvenking’s presence. There was more: he felt compelled to lie, to lie for the sake of lying!
“Which translates to yes, I’m afraid. I know you’re lying. Tell me how you did it.”
“I had nothing to do with it.”
“And there’s one more piece of the puzzle. You carry something that makes you invisible, do you not?”
Bilbo choked on his wine. Now the Elvenking was overstepping. “I carry nothing.”
“Mmm. Another yes. Very good, Mister Baggins. It must be something very light, that you can carry with you at all times, in your pocket most likely. And if I were to venture a guess, it is with the help of this object that you brought your king back to life.”
Bilbo felt compelled to say yes! just for the sake of lying again. Yet if I lie, Thranduil will want the ring for himself. I can’t have that. The ring is mine.
“No!” he said, marveling at the urgency of his reaction.
“Which is another yes,” said Thranduil, not aware that for once he was wrong. “I know every answer you’re giving me is a lie. You see, this drink is made to enhance a particular weakness in each person; their greatest weakness. And yours, Halfling, is your inclination for dishonesty. You find it easy to lie. You weren’t always like this, I believe. I can’t imagine such a tendency being developed in a place like the Shire. It is during your adventure with the dwarves that you must have acquired experience with lying and hiding, and now you can’t stop.”
“And you wanted me to drink so I can be more dishonest? Why?” Bilbo asked in deep confusion.
“To protect you,” said Thranduil. “You wanted to confess your feelings for the dwarf. You love him, it is plain as day. My drink will keep you from making such a mistake.”
“A mistake?” Bilbo asked doubtfully, a river of sadness pouring in his heart, yet he tried to hide it with a nonchalant smile. “Perhaps you’re right.”
“Yes, a mistake, because he doesn’t love you. He certainly values you as his greatest treasure. But he doesn’t love you.”
“And you know this... how?”
“If he does, why does he never tell you? Why do you have to resort to a wine scheme in order to try to say something to him? He was at death’s door, and beyond. If he loved you, one would think that as soon as he’d come back he’d want to declare his feelings for you. No, he keeps you around because he has seen your great worth, and no doubt used it for his own advantage once or twice. You will make a great asset in his kingdom, especially since, save for the incident with the Arkenstone, you appear to be incapable of saying no to him.”
Oh. Bilbo had not thought about that. That made sense, for sure! Wow, what a fool he had been.
“Such worth,” Thranduil repeated. “If there is such value in you, I want it here, in my kingdom. I can’t put my finger on what it is, though.” Bilbo widened his eyes with fear at the way Thranduil said those last words. “Actually... I think I can. Put it on my finger.”
Bilbo did not hesitate. He reached into his coat pocket, felt the Ring on his fingers, and put it on just as Thranduil signalled his guards to seize him.
They didn’t reach him in time. He disappeared, and fled in horror as he heard Thranduil’s voice trailing behind him, I know where you are! You can’t hide from me! And for the first time in Mirkwood, the thought of Thorin did not bring him reassurance that everything would be fine in the end.
“Under your spell again
I can’t say no to you
Crave my heart and it’s bleeding in your hand
I can’t say no to you
Shouldn’t have let you torture me so sweetly
Now I can’t let go of this dream
I can’t breathe but I feel
Good enough
I feel good enough
For you
Drink up sweet decadence
I can’t say no to you
And I’ve completely lost myself and I don’t mind
I can’t say no to you
Shouldn’t have let you conquer me completely
Now I can’t let go of this dream
Can’t believe that I feel
Good enough
I feel good enough
It’s been such a long time coming
But I feel good
And I’m still waiting for the rain to fall
Pour real life down on me
’cause I can’t hold on
To anything this good enough
Am I good enough
For you to love me too?
So take care what you ask of me
’cause I can’t say no”
