Chapter Text
The acorn lay in Thorin’s pocket, protected for now.
Thorin would not sleep tonight. Whatever this evil was, that had taken hold of his love, he sensed it was not over. He needed to watch over him.
He glanced carefully towards the floor where he had dropped the ring earlier. When he didn’t see it, he leaned down at the edge of the bed to look under. The Ring lay under his bed (How did it get there?), and it felt like it was staring back at him, and Thorin felt afraid. Instantly, he reached for the ring and picked it up, then exited the room in a hurry.
“Dwalin. Wake up.”
Dwalin got up with a groan, axe in his hand at a moment’s notice. Thorin gestured at him and he followed without question back into Thorin’s room.
“I need you to watch over Bilbo while I step out for a few minutes. He should not be alone.”
“Step out? You can’t wait until the morning?”
“No. There is something I need to take care of now.”
“Say no more. Happy times, I trust?” Dwalin inquired with a grin as he pointed towards the bed. “Or just drunk hobbit?”
A bit of both, I believe, Thorin thought uneasily. “I’m not really sure what’s going on,” he said with a frown.
“He didn’t listen to you, did he? He had to drink from the forbidden cup. I thought he might. That hobbit can never stay out of trouble for too long. I take it you’re not complaining though; it looks like it worked out for the best.” Then he eyed the burned holes in Thorin’s shirt, which, due to the darkness in the room, he couldn’t quite make out. “Though I’d say that’s a bit rough for a first night together,” he said, half intrigued, half amused.
“Oh, that... It’s not what you think,” said Thorin. “Listen, I need to go now. Stay with him and don’t let anyone in!”
He rushed outside and went to the garden, and kneeled before the statue and the Arkenstone. “I need to know what this is,” he said, pulling the ring out of his pocket. “It... I think it’s affecting him. Regularly. And it has definitely hurt him tonight, as well as me. Can you tell me?”
The Arkenstone made a rattling noise as if agitated, and for a brief moment, even the statue looked like it changed its expression to one of fear. EVIL, the Arkenstone’s light spelled on the tree branches.
“Can I get rid of it?”
HE WON’T LET YOU. HE WILL WANT IT BACK.
“Should I give it back to him?” asked Thorin.
The Arkenstone did not give a direct answer. DON’T LET HIM BRING IT TO EREBOR.
“Why? Because its evil is too great?”
YES. AND YOU WON’T HAVE ME THERE.
“What if I took you with me? Would you be able to hold the ring’s evil at bay?”
POSSIBLY, the Arkenstone answered.
“I don’t know what to do with it right now,” said Thorin. “I don’t want it near him. He needs to recover after all he’s been through tonight. I’m going to leave the ring here for now. I hope it won’t hurt anyone while I think of something.” He stood and walked towards a bush with round red flowers, that he was sure he would recognize later, and buried the ring at the bottom of it. “One more thing...” he addressed the Arkenstone again as he walked back, “I have his acorn with me. It got burned by the ring, and I want to make sure it can still grow after what happened tonight. Will you help?”
AS YOU WISH, SON OF THRAIN, the Arkenstone wrote, and Thorin could feel its love through its beautiful rays of light.
“Thank you,” he said with a bow. “I will return later. Thank you,” and this time he glanced at the statue with gratitude.
He returned to the palace, feeling deeply troubled; as the door to his room appeared in his field of vision, he stopped to take a moment and hold his focus on it. He straightened his posture and grasped his sword, and conjured the image of Smaug attacking Erebor and himself standing before his grandfather’s army, giving his order. Only instead of the dragon, the image of Bilbo walked through the door and came into view, saying, Oh, Thorin. Now that we’re both awake, I’m most anxious to apologize. You see, I had two glasses of wine last night, and I’ll tell you, that stuff is strong. It really did a number on me. So... whatever I said, or did... please just know that it wasn’t me and it won’t happen again, all right?
Thorin held himself steady, eyes blazing, unflinching, every bit the warrior that he was. “No apologies are necessary, Master Baggins,” he said out loud. “Please think no more of it.” It is I who should apologize, he silently added. I took advantage of you in a fragile state. He moved towards the door proudly, feeling like he overcame the hardest obstacle of this day. He’d live through the rest of it.
Only, he didn’t reach the door.
“You know, you’ve officially lost your mind,” Dwalin intoned from the shadows. “I came out for a quick smoke and here I am, relaxing with my thoughts, and what do I see. The great Thorin Oakenshield, a living legend, reduced to...” - he stared helplessly as if words were useless - “this.”
“Dwalin... How is he?”
“Sleeping like a baby. He looks quite happy, by the way.” Thorin tried to smile with some semblance of relief.
* * *
Bilbo was sleeping.
In his dream, he still had the ring on, and wouldn’t take it off no matter what Thorin said. Then Thorin took off his coat and draped it over Bilbo’s back, and brought him close, creating a shield of warmth aroung him with nowhere to escape. And Thorin kissed his curls, and his forehead, and his lips, and while they kissed Thorin found his hands, and his fingers touched the ring. Bilbo was startled, but the way Thorin was kissing him was so passionate and complete and overpowering that it took over everything else, and Bilbo let him continue to touch his ring, and leaned into the kiss, and felt Thorin move his ring, and didn’t resist and instead pulled Thorin closer... and he didn’t know when the ring came off, and he began to feel calmer, and the calm brought a feeling of exhaustion; he didn’t want to go to sleep, yet he couldn’t fight it much longer. And as they lay in bed he heard Thorin say, I wish we could stay in this moment, and then peace descended upon Bilbo again, just like the first time. And as he drifted off to sleep he searched for yet another dream, another way that this could have happened...
...He woke up to find Thorin sleeping next to him, his back turned, his hair within Bilbo’s reach, and touched it tentatively a few times, marveling that he could do this freely now...
Wait a second. What?
Oh. That’s right. Because... last night.
Two things stood out for Bilbo as he began to remember: one was something unbelievable and far away: that Thorin had said he loved him. The other was the realization that the ring was not with him, at which he jumped in an uncontrolled motion. He looked on the nightstand, then on the floor where he had stood with Thorin earlier, and when he didn’t see it he got out of bed at once; only to be met by Balin’s inquisitive pair of eyes, staring at him from the other side of the room.
“Hey, laddie.”
“Goodness. Balin. I didn’t know you were here,” he whispered.
“Thorin asked me to watch over the two of you while he slept,” said Balin. “He himself watched you the whole night.”
“Why?”
“He was worried about you. But even a stubborn Dwarf like this one needs his rest every now and then; he crashed not long ago.”
“Balin...” said Bilbo as he began to feel the awkwardness of the situation, “did Thorin look... happy at all? I mean, was he all right with me sleeping in his room?”
Balin laughed. “Well, he hasn’t kicked you out yet, has he?”
At that moment they heard a knock on the door, and an Elf maid stepped in, carrying a tray with what looked like a delicious feast. “Breakfast for King Thorin,” she said with a suave voice. Then she stopped in confusion, taking in the sight of Bilbo and Balin, and the trashed Thorin on the bed. “Oh, I’m sorry. I hope I didn’t interrupt anything.” She left the tray with Balin, bowed and stepped out.
“Bilbo, you can go ahead and eat this,” said Balin. “I am certain Thorin would offer it to you.”
“Thank you, Balin,” said Bilbo and began eating immediately, though careful to leave some of the food untouched. “Does Thorin always get served in his room like this?”
“Not that I know of,” said Balin. “I’m just as perplexed as you are.”
At that moment Thorin stirred and almost fell out of bed, and Bilbo rushed to his side. Seconds later, he was bringing the breakfast tray to the bed, and offering some food to Thorin in a loving gesture. “I guess that’s my cue to leave,” Balin muttered and left the room.
Thorin didn’t look rested at all, and his face was full of worry. “Something happened to you last night,” he said, looking like he was trying to assess how Bilbo was feeling. “Would you mind telling me about your time with Thranduil?”
So Bilbo told him almost everything: how he drank the wine and got to talking with the Elvenking, how he found out what the wine’s intended effect was, and how the conversation went downhill pretty fast. He carefully omitted Thranduil’s speculations about Thorin’s reasons for keeping Bilbo with him.
“So, it was meant to heighten a person’s greatest weakness,” Thorin reflected, deep in thought.
“Correct. Apparently, mine is my inclination to lie. So every time I gave him an answer, he took the opposite to be the truth. At some point he asked if my ring helped bring you back to life... and I said no, and he took that as a yes. After that, it was clear, he wanted my ring. So I put it on and fled, and came to you. And I couldn’t tell you what was happening to me. Thorin, I’m so sorry.”
“Your greatest weakness... is your inclination to lie?” Thorin asked, his voice trembling.
“It... sort of is. Thranduil actually offered his opinion on the matter. I think he’s right. I acquired this tendency while journeying with you all. Ever since the goblin tunnels, since I lay hands on the ring.”
Thorin struggled to process all this, feeling like he was hit with a hammer. “So... the wine made you less than... truthful, which you already were. I wonder what Thranduil’s goal was with all this.”
“Well... He never actually came to look for me, so I think all he wanted was to scare me. And... I think he wanted me to lie to you, Thorin.”
“And... did you?”
“I was able to resist the urge to lie for some of the time, thanks to Thranduil himself. He told me what the wine did, and with that knowledge I was able to defend myself against the spell. I don’t know why he would reveal something this helpful to me. Perhaps his greatest weakness is his tendency to brag! I got the same vibe from Smaug back in Erebor. But anyway...” he averted his eyes from Thorin, “there were things I couldn’t say to you last night.”
The question is which things, Thorin thought. Perhaps you only pretended to be... comfortable with certain aspects of last night. He remembered how Bilbo had said Nothing when asked what he was afraid of... Perhaps all you wanted was to tell me to stop, or to never start in the first place. Yet he was horrified at the prospect of asking for clarification, and instead told himself there were more pressing things to think about, with Bilbo’s well-being at the top. It was real, Bilbo. For me, what we had was real.
* * *
“Anyway, I’m very curious to know how the wine affected you, Thorin.”
“I... I neglected you,” said Thorin sorrowfully. “I should have protected you from Thranduil.”
“Oh. That’s it?”
Thorin looked unsure and afraid. “It is possible that it made me eager to fulfill your every wish; I mean, more eager than I already am.”
“Oh.” Now it was Bilbo’s turn to ponder, and he felt quite distraught. “That’s... a weakness to you?” His mind began to put things together in a panic. He was all too aware of what the wine had done to him; was it possible it made Thorin say and do things he didn’t mean...? Bilbo had pressed him with pointed questions; perhaps Thorin guessed where he was going with them? What if Thorin somehow sensed Bilbo’s need to hear those words, that Thorin loved him, a need rapidly increased by his unsettling meeting with Thranduil? What if Thorin told him just what he wanted to hear, simply because he wished it?
But the things that followed... it was impossible to suspect them of being anything less than genuine. Bilbo had felt Thorin’s love through every pore of his being. His heart, his soul was filled with that love. It had to be real! No, the problem lay elsewhere, the problem still standing was that he had not said what he wanted to say...
“That didn’t come out right. I don’t know what the wine did to me, Bilbo. All I know is I couldn’t say no to you; but that’s already true, most of the time. Other than that, I really was myself. I am so sorry I didn’t protect you,” and Thorin buried his face in his hands.
“No, this was all my fault. I was curious about the wine. I got both of us in trouble when I asked to taste it. Thorin... do you have any idea where my ring is?” he asked abruptly.
So Thorin told him about his little dialogue in the garden and the finding that the ring was evil, leaving out the part about the ring bringing evil to Erebor.
“And where is it now? Can I have it back?”
“Bilbo... the ring... it caused you harm last night. Thranduil’s wine by itself was not evil; it was just a trick meant to manipulate us. But the ring... it is not the first time I see this. I don’t want the evil I sensed - that I saw- around you last night to return. I think it is best you stay away from it for now.”
“For how long?” asked Bilbo uncomfortably.
“Until... until we can talk more. There are things I want to know from you, without the presence of the ring. But first, I really think you should rest some more.”
“Do you want the ring for yourself, Thorin? Is that what this is?”
“No, Bilbo. I would never take something of yours.”
“Hmmm. All right. I could use more rest,” said Bilbo, his voice not completely free of suspicion.
Then the Elf lady came again, this time requesting an audience with both Thorin and Bilbo on the Elvenking’s behalf. Thorin told her Bilbo would be unavailable, and that if Thranduil would condescend to talk to him alone he should come to Thorin’s room. Then he asked Fili and Kili to walk Bilbo to his room and keep him company while he sorted out his thoughts and prepared for Thranduil’s potential visit.
* * *
My greatest weakness.
This did not sound right. Love could not be a weakness.
Yet his love for Bilbo was making him weak. And needy. Without Bilbo around him... he knew. Something he couldn’t admit to himself. He had felt it when he’d thought it was the end and he’d stay in Mahal’s halls while Bilbo would go on living a comfortable life.
And he had this love to thank for not thinking straight. Being ready to leave the treasured jewel of his kingdom behind. Being now ready to endanger his kingdom by bringing this person with him, who carried great evil, just to have Bilbo with him. At times he had even contemplated leaving the kingdom in someone else’s care and going back to the Shire with Bilbo; but that was not what duty and honor dictated. No, he had promised to do the right thing, and pursuing such a selfish goal was not it.
Yes, it was a weakness.
“King Thorin. A pleasure to see you, as always.”
Thorin’s eyes shot daggers at Thranduil. “Spare me the niceties. What you did last night to Master Baggins... you’ve sunk to the lowest of the low, even by Elven standards.”
“Yes, yes. I’m aware I went a bit too far,” said Thranduil unexpectedly. “I fell victim to the spell of my own wine, which I enjoyed in the company of the lovely Mister Baggins. It enhanced my greatest weakness. I long to see my beloved wife, and... well, the Halfling possesses the solution to that. His ring, I have finally worked it out, can provide what I desperately need, and as I realized that, I got very greedy for it...”
“Just to be clear, you’re saying your greatest weakness is your need to see your wife? Or your greed for a powerful object?”
Thranduil sighed. “In my longing to see her, I have a tendency to stop at nothing just so I could achieve this goal. And that tendency got out of control last night.”
“But why did you want us to drink in the first place?”
“Ah. It is of no matter now. It didn’t work, anyway. Let me get to the point.”
“By all means, do,” said Thorin disdainfully.
“I’m actually proud of myself for coming up with what should be the easiest choice. I will let you take back the Arkenstone, and relinquish any claim on Mister Baggins, if only he leaves the ring with me. Of course, I won’t complain if he chooses to stay also, in which case he can keep the ring.”
“Easiest? Neither Master Baggins nor the ring are in my possession. The only thing I can offer you is the Arkenstone. I’m guessing you have completely lost interest in it?”
“The Arkenstone will remain here if Mister Baggins leaves with you and with... the ring. However, I’m sure you can ask your loyal friend to part with the ring; he won’t refuse you this favor. After all, it is thanks to him that I have the Arkenstone... perhaps this way he can finally pay you back for... you know, stealing from you.”
Thorin pondered. Getting rid of the ring would be convenient, no doubt; then he’d get the Arkenstone back, and no evil would come to Erebor. Yet he needed to be careful not to let the Elf penetrate his thoughts...
“It is not mine to give or to even ask about,” he said carefully.
“Very well. I will ask him then.”
“You will STAY AWAY FROM HIM,” Thorin growled. “I am warning you. If you seek to see Master Baggins while he is recovering from his horrible experience of last night, which you caused...”
“Fine, fine,” Thranduil waved him off impatiently. “What shall I do if he seeks me though?”
“Enough!”
Thorin did not mean to shout, certainly not during a dialogue with another king. He cleared his throat and headed for the door. “This conversation is over. I would ask you to get out of here, but it’s your palace, so... I will see myself out. While you’re at it, feel free to ransack my room. Maybe you’ll find something else of value you might want.”
“Oh, no, I won’t bother,” said Thranduil coolly. “I know your greatest treasure is not in this room.” And he left before Thorin could give a reply.
* * *
Thorin spent the rest of the day at Bilbo’s side, watching as the hobbit regained some of his strength. When Bilbo asked what Thranduil had wanted, Thorin only said Nothing important. Thorin asked the Elf maid to bring elevenses, lunch and afternoon tea, so Bilbo ate in Shire style for a good part of the day, and became more and more overwhelmed, to him all this being very clear in its meaning as a courting maneuver; combined with last night’s events, he couldn’t deny the evidence that Thorin really loved him was piling on! Still he couldn’t ask, because he hadn’t yet figured out how to ask, if Thorin’s declaration had been genuine.
They had just finished dinner when Bilbo asked again about the ring, and Thorin found that, while he still had much to talk about, he couldn’t stall anymore on the unpleasant subject. So they walked to the garden together, and Thorin thought and thought how to distract Bilbo from the ring in the few moments he had before he needed to return it. He reached for the acorn in his pocket as one last attempt to change the subject. “Did you want this back, too?” he said as he opened his hand.
As they both looked at it, they were astounded, for the acorn had sprouted while in Thorin’s coat pocket. And they didn’t know why; while Thorin may have thought the Arkenstone was responsible, that it had worked its magic needing no further entreaty from either of the two, Bilbo had another theory; and so moved was he at the sight of the acorn, that he forgot about the ring and took the fruit from Thorin’s hand and enclosed it in both of his, and whispered secretly, I’m not surprised and then out loud, “Now I’m really going to have to plant it, and soon”. “It seems a shame you’re so far away from the Shire,” Thorin said, and Bilbo gave him a thoughtful look, wondering if he should tell Thorin his theory or wait until he could be sure he was more than a weakness to him-
As they walked back to their rooms, Bilbo remembered that he was supposed to have one more meeting with Thranduil before leaving. He had not worked out what to say to the Elvenking on the subject of how to deal with the pain of losing his beloved. So Bilbo brought this up with Thorin, asking him if he had an opinion on the matter. To which Thorin replied, “Yes, I certainly do. In fact why don’t you let me meet with Thranduil and share my thoughts, of which I have plenty. You need to stay away from him; I’ll be happy to handle this for you.” And Bilbo looked at him in shock. “You have things to say about losing the one you love? I didn’t know you had experience in this area.” “I didn’t say the experience was mine,” Thorin clarified, “though I came close too, in a way. I will see him tomorrow over breakfast and get this over with, and if you feel sufficiently recovered we will leave Mirkwood the day after.”
Bilbo felt quite discouraged and thought of retiring to his room with a short good night so he could weep over the possibility that the voice in his dreams was right after all and Thorin did have a One who was waiting in Mahal’s halls - there was no other reason Thorin could have any advice to offer Thranduil! And Bilbo lost all interest in talking of his love - a good thing I didn’t say anything, then - when Thorin turned towards him as they reached the door to his room and said, “Would you mind if I stayed with you tonight?”
Bilbo lifted his eyes to look at him, happy to replace sadness with confusion. “Oh. There’s no need. I’m feeling better now,” and Thorin tried again gently, “I can’t leave you out of my sight. Please. I will sleep on the floor; just let me be around you.”
“Because you’re worried about me. Is that it? You really don’t need to be.”
“I do,” Thorin protested weakly. “But I won’t insist any further; forgive me,” and he moved away while still looking at Bilbo with much concern. “Good night, Master Baggins.”
Bilbo watched him carefully, trying to see behind those eyes- nothing, but steeled determination. He bid him good night and the door closed between them.
Bilbo took a few minutes to get ready for bed, then lit a candle on his nightstand and took a deep breath. Then he started pacing restlessly back and forth around the room. He finally sat at his table and wrote on a piece of paper, In the halls of the Woodland Realm, there lived a hobbit. A very confused and unsettled hobbit. Then he laughed at himself and threw the paper away.
It was strange, being without the ring.
Stranger than being without Thorin?
Then he realized he was waiting. Waiting to hear sounds coming from the other room, as they usually did, every night. The sound of Thorin composing his music on the harp... But the walls were silent now.
He felt the urge to run to the room next door and check if Thorin was all right. No. That Thorin was there. All of a sudden he felt so alone.
Why am I going there... This is highly improper, not to mention I will look desperate. I am not going there.
Yes, I am. He wanted to spend the night here, for Yavanna’s sake! So why can’t I...
Because I don’t know what really went on last night. If he meant the things he said.
But I can ask for his company. I can ask him to stay with me. Even if it wasn’t real.
He opened the door before he could feel any more thoughts come in, and saw Thorin sitting against a wall in the hallway, a blanket spread on the floor under him, his sword ready in his hand.
“No, no, no. You can’t do that,” Bilbo said, almost panicking at the sight. “If you think this will help me sleep well, you’re wrong.”
“You can’t tell me what I can’t do,” Thorin replied defiantly.
Bilbo laughed. “You’re right. But this is not productive, Thorin.”
“Then what is? Would you mind telling me what I can do? What is acceptable to you?”
“That you stay with me tonight,” Bilbo said softly. “And that you don’t sleep on the floor. And since your bed is larger than mine, I would prefer that we sleep in your room. And that... you rest too, Thorin; you’re completely trashed.”
Thorin nodded in happy submission, and they moved towards his room with great hopes for clarity.
