Chapter Text
“My son... I need to speak with you.”
They are in an old, abandoned fortress, somewhere Thorin never thought to look before. The figure emerges from the shadows and approaches, looking bruised and battered, and Thorin shakes with horror.
“Father... Is that really you?”
“We don’t have much time. There is something you need to know.”
“Where are you? All these years, I’ve searched in vain... Please, tell me,” Thorin begs in anguish.
“Listen to me, Thorin. You will be going to Erebor soon. I warned Gandalf that you should not be allowed to enter while the dragon and the One were both in the Mountain. Yet you did, and I know it did not go well for you. By the grace of Mahal, I have come to warn you myself this time. The Mountain is in danger, if you allow that thing to be brought there again. You are in danger.”
“The ring? Is that what you speak of? But the spell... it is believed that Gandalf removed the spell.” Or rather, it is hoped that he did.
“But you cannot know for sure, can you? I wouldn’t take any risks, my son. That dragon sat there for too long. The ring would only enhance the power of the evil already present there, and it is you who are the most vulnerable, most likely to be affected. Remember the strain of madness that runs deep in our family.”
“Then what must I do?”
“The person who carries it... perhaps he can just go back home. Take the ring with him.”
“But the ring is not good for him either!” Thorin cries. “And I can’t...” He stops, swallowing bitterly.
“It is a lesser evil to leave the ring with him,” the figure replies smoothly. “Or so I am told by higher powers. My son... you asked for a chance to make things right. Our Maker has granted it to you. Now, our people need you; it’s time to think of your duty to them.”
“What if the ring stays here, in Mirkwood?” Thorin asks, a glimmer of hope flying by.
“That would be better than bringing it to Erebor, but it needs to remain in the same person’s keeping.”
“Why? Why can’t someone else have it, such as the ruler of these lands?...”
“The ring’s evil is not strong against the person who carries it now. Not as strong as it would be in the hands of an Elf or a Man.”
“So I need to leave him here as well,” Thorin concludes with words that taste like poison. The figure is departing now, only smoke and shadows, disintegrating slowly. “Father! How did you know that I asked for a chance... and how do you know about the ring?”
“Because I love you,” Thorin hears, and is left to ask Where are you again and again, no closure and no relief in his heart for the fate of his father...
The figure is gone; yet Thorin can still hear a voice. Only it sounds different now, nothing kind, concerned or reliable like the one earlier. “The ring is hurting your Master Baggins,” the voice echoes Thorin’s feelings eagerly. “You can protect him. Leave it in Mirkwood, son of Thrain, and you can still take him with you.”
“Who are you?” Thorin asks, troubled and agitated, trying to discern if anyone is moving through the shadows of the old fortress. “How do you know him?” Then he feels a dark, cold shadow fall upon him, a clear sign, perhaps, of what would befall him if... He shudders, and tries to chase it away with a swing of his arm.
Then he feels a light touch on his chest, and soft fingers running through his hair, and the sweet and caring voice of his love fills the air with a whisper, It’s just a dream, Thorin...
* * *
Bilbo is awake.
He has done well this evening. He has managed to switch Thorin from his protective role to a more passive one, while he, Bilbo, took control. That resulted in Thorin finally getting some rest, and Bilbo having some time to reflect on the situation. Well... not that Bilbo hasn’t tried to rest, too, but. It’s not exactly easy to fall asleep next to the person he’s madly in love with, when just last night said person spoke passionately of love and kissed him!
So, yes, Bilbo finally has a chance to reflect, and he begins, in order, with item number one. It is clear that Thorin is not eager to say those words again. Whatever his reason for saying them last night, he has retreated back behind those walls I know all too well. Perhaps he’s waiting for Bilbo to say something (and who can blame him?) or perhaps... Ugh. You’ve been over this already, Bilbo sighs in utter discouragement. At any rate, if things are to move forward, it is Bilbo who needs to get them going. Which... he tried last night, and let’s just say he doesn’t possess the incentive to try to confess his feelings again; if anything, last night’s events taught him to be even more cautious than he already was! This is what you get for thinking you can initiate things, Bilbo Baggins. How do you like it now? Drinking that wine was not a good recipe for saying I love you; no pun intended. Bilbo stifles a laugh. But seriously, all you do is get in trouble.
For the most part he has been comfortable loving Thorin from a safe distance, where he could tell himself it’s all right if Thorin doesn’t love him, because Thorin is alive, and is his friend, and that is more than anyone could ask for. But now... Thorin has said the words, and what came after was something out of a dream. And while Bilbo would now be fine with waiting longer to confess his feelings, he certainly doesn’t want to wait anymore to have that with Thorin.
So. Item number two. The moments he shared with Thorin last night are in a category of their own, and as good as a love statement as any. While he is not ready to try again with words, he wants, he desperately wants that closeness again. And he is aware that things are far from being clear. Thorin’s One, dead or not, is still a grey area that needs to be dealt with; Thranduil’s game is not over, and Bilbo senses that Thorin is hiding the Elvenking’s latest ploy from him; and even assuming Thorin is Oneless for the time being, Bilbo still doesn’t know if he has a chance with him... Yet all these pieces are rapidly extinguished under the flame of his desire to just take Thorin in his arms right now, and forget all these complicated matters...
He briefly wonders if he could pretend to be dreaming. Right now. And try to get close to Thorin. And if Thorin doesn’t welcome that closeness, he can blame it on...
No. He sees the trace of cunningness in this plan, and shakes himself mentally. No. This is what gets me in trouble. My greatest weakness. No. I will be truthful. I want this with him. I will not be afraid to admit it; if it’s not well received, I’ll apologize and never try again. But admit it nonetheless.
He doesn’t want to know if Thorin is awake. If he looks at him closely and finds out that he is, his resolve will fade and he’ll lose his courage. He is so, so scared he’s going to do the wrong thing.
But before he can do anything, Thorin’s hand is moving as if chasing something nonexistent, and Bilbo sees he looks troubled and afraid. And now Bilbo can tell that Thorin is sleeping and must be having a bad dream. Instinctively, he brings one hand to Thorin’s chest, and starts caressing his hair with the other, whispering to him that it’s just a dream, and feels Thorin calm down almost instantly. He moves up until he is at Thorin’s level, and looks at him carefully. He wants to kiss him, and it feels like stealing.
His fingers find Thorin’s forehead, his temple, his cheek; he moves his hand slowly, resting it briefly in each of these places, and then he places a kiss on each of them. Thorin tilts his head back slightly, his face peaceful and happy, and it looks like he’s still sleeping.
“It feels like I’m stealing,” Bilbo murmurs, half to himself. “I don’t want to steal from you. I’ve never wanted to.”
“You can’t steal what is already yours,” he hears Thorin say dreamily. And these words... are the answer to everything, and an everything in itself. Bilbo can’t express how comforting they are, and he breaks into a small laugh as his heart fills with happiness. All of a sudden he feels perfectly content; this is more than enough. He rests his head on Thorin’s chest and breathes in this moment, we are here, he is alive, he is my... he is... possibly, maybe... he... is... mine.
...Bilbo soon fell asleep, and in his dream he heard the voice of the shadowy figure who had visited him while Thorin lay at death’s door; the voice was back, and eager to remind him that Thorin’s One was in Mahal’s halls. “You will learn all about it soon enough, Bilbo Baggins. Your friend will meet with the Elf King this morning. I encourage you to attend their meeting, so you can see that there is only one reason why he would have any knowledge to impart on the Elf on how to deal with the loss of his loved one; the reason is that his One is...”
“I don’t believe you,” Bilbo jumped in. “You said Thorin never met his One. So how could he know that his One is dead, let alone feel the sorrow of such a loss?”
“He can,” the voice answered. “Dwarves feel these things. Their connection with their Ones is very strong, whether they meet or not. Without his One, he feels incomplete, that is a given; if his One is dead, it’s even worse. Regardless, I would say to you that this is your chance to return to a peaceful and comfortable life. You can remain in the Woodland Realm, under the loving protection of King Thranduil, or return to your Shire. You have been warned. The Dwarf king doesn’t love you; you are wasting your time chasing him.”
“Right, and he’s going to the Mountain where he will turn into a dragon,” Bilbo interrupted again unceremoniously. “Uh-huh. I will not leave him, even if he does have a One. That doesn’t mean I’m chasing him.”
“A One that he still hasn’t met, thanks to you!” the voice shrieked.
“That may be, but Thorin is not unhappy to be alive!” Bilbo retorted. “If he feels the loss so keenly as you say, one would think he’d be quite miserable to find himself alive! But he seems happy enough! Pardon my directness, but I really don’t think you have your facts straight.”
“Then why do you think Thorin Oakenshield has offered to speak with Thranduil on such a delicate subject? The Elf lost his wife, and has no closure, no memory, can’t bring her back... and your friend is eager to offer him counsel.”
“Maybe it’s because he... he has known loss in his life... more than once. And lack of closure,” Bilbo replied, suddenly remembering the stories he had heard during their journey. How Thorin’s brother and grandfather perished in the battle of Azanulbizar, and how Thorin never found his father; never learned if he was dead or alive. How strange, to remember all of this now, in an instant, exactly when it was needed. It was as if those memories had not been available to him before, yet now he could feel them with clarity and much intensity, as if they were happening right then. “Loss of family, not loss of his love. Not loss of his... One.” He desperately wanted to say more - something like Because he is mine - but stopped himself.
The voice paused for a while, and Bilbo felt proud at this small victory. Then it resumed. “There is no peace awaiting you in Erebor, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire,” it finished, firm and unwavering. “Remember my words. You will need to decide soon.” And with that it vanished.
Bilbo woke up late in the morning, feeling alone and cold with no Thorin beside him; and he felt overwhelmed by the words of the voice in his dream. In the light of day, they made the most sense. What had passed during the night, the sleeping Thorin and his dreamy words, Bilbo’s shaky resolve and his somewhat confident attitude towards the unpleasant voice, were all shattered; and he felt mad at himself, not for the first time. How could you possibly think that there could be something between you and… him? Yet the voice of reason inside him wanted to argue that perhaps Thorin was over the person he had loved; that maybe he could love again; or maybe that person wasn’t worth his love.
Yet he knew that Dwarves loved only once! Only in his mind, in his childish delusions, fueled by the thrill of an unexpected adventure, initiated and led by this person, this Thorin, could such wild ideas exist. And yet he felt that he had something unique to give to Thorin, and felt a stubbornness about not giving up. He knew very well that so many others could see Thorin, and who would not be taken with his handsome figure, his bravery, his skill in battle, his loyalty? He could have ruled kingdoms from that healing tent in Dale, drugged up and half asleep, and everyone would have still marveled at his majesty. So how could Bilbo, a hobbit from the Shire with nothing much to recommend him, hope to secure his affections?
Not that Bilbo could articulate it exactly, but he just felt like he knew Thorin better than anyone. Perhaps because he had seen him in so many different circumstances, and different parts of Thorin had made an appearance here and there. But it was more than that: he felt that he could see Thorin in a way that nobody else could see him. In a way that made him follow him unconditionally; that made him stand between him and Azog, with only a letter opener in his hand; that made him rejoin the Company even upon hearing Thorin’s disdainful words, when he still had a chance to turn back... Was all of this for nothing?
But I betrayed him, Bilbo thought bitterly. That was where it all ended, all that could have been. I couldn’t follow him into that madness; that was the only place I couldn’t go. I knew I stood to lose a lot… and yet I did it to save his life. Regardless... maybe that’s why nothing can ever grow between us.
Then how did he expect to be loved by Thorin?
I’m not expecting it. I was just hoping for some hope. Well. I guess the voice in my dreams was right. Still, I can be his friend; that alone still means the world to me. At least I won’t have to put up with seeing him love and marry another, and luckily he’s not one to reminisce about his lost love, thank goodness!
Hope threatened to insert itself again, as he decided he would actually like to go and see Thorin face Thranduil. Bilbo was in dire need of some clarity. He generally had a low tolerance for uncertainty and dwelling on nonsense, and was getting impatient to reach a resolution. Perhaps it could turn out that what Thorin had had with that person was not really love; or maybe Thorin would share some really effective methods for getting over a lost love! If, however, it turned out that Thorin really had a One, then Bilbo would know to stop hoping for good.
He rushed out the door to the dining hall, and found Thorin and Thranduil seated at the table, their conversation slow going.
“Ah. The person I was hoping to see”, said Thranduil. “Your king seems to think your presence is not necessary.”
Thorin got up and moved towards Bilbo. “You should not be here.”
Bilbo briefly forgot why he was there as he looked deep into those beautiful eyes. “I just wanted to be with you,” he said, and was amazed at his own boldness. As Thorin stared back at him, Bilbo felt his uneasiness. It also felt that Thorin was looking through him, at someone else, an invisible person in the room...
“I am eager to hear what both of you have to say,” Thranduil said, looking quite amused. “This will be a very interesting morning.”
“Let me begin,” Thorin said with determination. “For the grief and sorrow that you’ve felt for so many years, I am most sorry, King Thranduil. As I said before, the consolation lies in the certainty that you will see your wife again when you die. A fate that, sadly, is not reserved for all couples. You can also take solace in your son; you were fortunate to have him before you and your love were parted. I would think that a child can serve as a reminder of your One; that you could see her in him. But it is not for me to say. We Dwarves place great value on children, and kin in general, so for me this is an important point.”
Bilbo frowned in astonishment. Thorin was being very diplomatic. Forget it, he was actually being nice and compassionate! To... Thranduil, of all people! Bilbo never believed that it was even possible for Thorin to be tactful, let alone apologetic and humble as he was now!
“To come to the real point though, you asked Master Baggins what he would do in your situation. And while he is thinking up an answer for you, I can give you one of my own.”
“That is all well and good, but what if I’m not interested in what a dwarf would do, even a kingly one such as yourself?” Thranduil asked, again quite amused, but curious at the same time.
Thorin smiled indulgently, and Bilbo thought that not only Thorin fancied himself superior, but he was also being mature about it!
“That’s all right,” Thorin said passionately. “I am not about to offer insight on what I would do. I’d probably be just as crushed as you are, and end up a useless good-for-nothing, guilt and shame grinding me slowly every day. It’s Master Baggins’ way of doing things that I will focus on, that obviously interests you.”
“Impressive. You seem to know this Halfling quite well.”
“Thorin,” Bilbo interjected. “What…”
“Master Baggins,” Thorin continued unperturbed, “is a creature who likes balance and comfort. He does not take himself very seriously. While he surely would be deeply hurt at such a sad and untimely parting, he would likely manage to laugh at himself after a while, and say to himself this is all a bunch of nonsense. And he would, in time, return to his comforts, and add much to them in ways that are special and meaningful. I think he would write about his loved one. And he would spend much time trying to get the account right. He would also create stories and songs and share them with others. He would keep good company, nurture the young and inspire them with his stories. Master Baggins also has a love for languages, so I would expect he would occupy some of his time learning them and translating works of value so that others can read them.”
Thorin paused for a moment, eyeing Bilbo wonderingly, as if he sought approval not only for having those thoughts, but also for sharing them. He must not have detected a single trace of disapproval, and happily went on. “And he would continue to enjoy life’s simple pleasures, because as I said, he is a creature of balance. Too much grief creates an imbalance, which I believe in time Master Baggins would consider a bit ridiculous. And the simple joys of life would provide that... balance. His garden. Growing things… I think he would like that,“ - Thorin paused to smile in contentment here - ”And reading his books. And he would…” and here Thorin struggled for words, as emotion seemed to inundate him in a hurry, “maybe he would do all these things imagining he’s doing them with that person, or for that person. I’m not sure on that one.”
“And would he move on, eventually?” asked Thranduil. “You’re sure making it seem like he wouldn’t be having such a hard time.”
Thorin pondered for a while, with a resigned look on his face. “Why don’t we ask Master Baggins, since he is right here,” he said with a trembling voice.
“Good idea. You heard the question, Halfling. Would you move on, eventually? Would you find love again, perhaps, or at least look for it?”
Bilbo stared absently for a while. Such a long speech… Where had that come from? Did Thorin just make it all up? I didn’t say the experience was mine, he had said. Then whose is it? Are you taking about mine? With so much detail and eloquence?
“Never,” he said, continuing to gaze in the distance. “I would not, in a million years, be able to forget this person or to feel less intensely towards h… them.” And as he said those words, he saw Thorin shoot him a look - alarmed? suspicious? hopeful? - Bilbo could not name it, but it felt like their souls were once more passing each other by and touching briefly…
“Do you agree with your king’s account of your dealings with grief then, Halfling?”
“I… don’t know. I have never been in that situation, so I don’t know what I would do. What Thorin said about my love for languages and for simple joys… all of that is accurate. I also love my parents a lot, I treasure their memory. My father built my house as a gift for my mother; I love it and everything in it. My homeland… These things certainly occupy my mind. And I do have a curiosity for traveling and seeing new places. But whether all this would mean anything to me… in that situation... I cannot say. Perhaps Thorin knows me better than I know myself. I just think not all he said is perfectly plausible. I think I would spend much time figuring out what this person meant to me, remembering them in every way. If I were to write an account of them, and… well... if they died, I would probably be so grief-stricken over it that I’d put off finishing my book, and try to tell the story in a way so that they don’t die. Or… if they die at the end then maybe I would... skip the end and start writing it over and over again, from the beginning. Because that would be the only way to keep them alive. And that way I would never reach the end. I’m afraid it would take a very long time to finish such a book.”
Now Thorin shot him a definite look of alarmed surprise, and now Bilbo knew this was a world, this was a world in which things were happening as described! Thorin seemed as if he knew he had died in another world, and maybe, just maybe... as if he knew that Bilbo had loved him, and that he was inconsolable in his grief for him...
I’m imagining things, Bilbo thought. For once, it’s a good thing I haven’t had breakfast yet, or I would bet this Elvenking spiked my tea with something.
As if he could tell that Bilbo’s mind turned to him, Thranduil began speaking. “We Elves don’t have much patience for the simple joys of life. Time passes so slowly for us, it would be pointless to enjoy little moments. Sure, I pour myself a glass of wine and enjoy it just as much as the next Elf,”- Bilbo and Thorin exchanged a funny look here - “but it doesn’t occupy my mind in the slightest. I could just as well not do it. My grief is still there; I feel it just as I feel the passing of time. I feel it moving, going ever on and on, and with every second it makes its way in and around me.”
“Do you ever fight it?” Bilbo asked.
“I do, sometimes. When it becomes too much to bear.”
Neither Bilbo nor Thorin asked for specifics, though they could probably picture an angry Thranduil throwing glasses of wine to the floor and screaming in pain. They may have been very sorry and sad at the thought. If they also pictured the Elvenking’s recent imprisoning of a certain Company of dwarves on a whim, they did not voice that out loud either.
“King Thorin,” Thranduil finally said after some pondering, “I am now curious as to what you would do. I am intrigued by your account of this Halfling, who no doubt is precious to you, if you put so much thought into an experience he hasn’t even had. It makes me wonder what your account of yourself would be. Though I don’t presume you would know much of matters of the heart, I confess the approach you attributed to Mister Baggins just now is hard for me to relate to. While admirable and respectable, I fear I have little in common with him. It may be that I have more in common with you.”
“Mahal forbid. I thank you for this honor, great King,” Thorin smirked with his usual sarcasm. “You are right, I have little to offer on this matter. What I do know for certain is that I would always love my One, no matter where I am, whether in the Halls of my Maker, under my sacred Mountain or wandering the endless paths of Middle Earth. I suspect I would be restless wherever I was. I’d spend much time trying to build a bridge that can connect me with my One. We Dwarves are largely wedded to our crafts, so forging a connection - though I don’t know what material could be used - would probably come naturally to me. Other than that, I would focus on keeping that love in my heart, untainted and pure.”
Frantically, Bilbo tried to remember if he had ever noticed Thorin busy with forging a connection with his One, visible or not, during the quest. But he could not conjure any such memories. Maybe this happened long time ago, he thought. Maybe he’s not so focused on it anymore.
“But none of this guarantees that I’d succeed in anything,” Thorin continued with some bitterness. “I’d probably end up breaking my materials and my tools, and cursing every five minutes. And I’d end up brooding in a corner for the rest of my af… life. I’m afraid the help I can offer is limited.”
All right, Bilbo smiled sadly, not an encouraging thought at all. This sounds a lot more like Thorin.
“This sounds a lot more like me,” Thranduil echoed in his own way, and he and Thorin looked at each other in disbelief, while Bilbo stood transfixed. “This is why I want to bring my wife back. Simple joys of life are doing nothing for me. Like you said you would, King Thorin, I try to forge a connection. And it goes nowhere. The love I have for her is pure, always in my heart, and it will never be tainted. But that doesn’t help. The only thing that would help is bringing her back.”
Then, unexpectedly, Thranduil looked at Bilbo with extreme fondness. “However, I would still exchange the Arkenstone for you, Halfling. Your presence in my kingdom would be most valuable to me. With your talent for languages and your passion for reading, you’d be of great value to my kingdom. You could communicate with other races on my behalf, and your counsel and charming diplomacy would be trusted by many. In addition, you’d be employed for reading, translating, compiling, and traveling every once in a while. And you’d be of great value to me... In time, perhaps you’d make me forget my misery, even teach me to deal with my sorrow in your way, which is new and very refreshing to me. Do you see how much good you’d be able to do here, and receive in return?”
Thorin looked alarmed and ready to give a warning. “King Thranduil,” he said, heading for the door impatiently and gesturing to Bilbo to do the same. “You’re going too far.”
“Let the Halfling answer,” said Thranduil. “Do you find my offer agreeable, Bilbo Baggins of the Shire?” and now his voice was soft and warm, reminding Bilbo of his armchair at home, his cozy fireplace, a nice warm cup of tea… And he started feeling tipsy again, head spinning, sweet summer wine was now in his cup, and his head was falling back slowly, and he began to smile with contentment.
Contentment, he thought. That’s what I’ve been missing. The Elvenking can provide this for me. While Thorin - nothing but misery; I’ve had enough. He doesn’t love me anyway. He clearly loved before; he’s just not saying it directly because it’s not Thranduil’s business, or mine, for that matter. And Dwarves. Love. Only. Once.
Take it, he heard a voice compelling him. His hand involuntarily reached in his pocket, seeking the ring. But the ring was not there anymore. Where was the voice coming from?
He doesn’t love me, Bilbo repeated in his mind. But I love him. Thranduil’s offered delights are not worth it to me if he won’t be here with me. And suddenly he became afraid of having this thought, as it seemed Thranduil caught hold of it as soon as it was formed; and Bilbo tried to push it out.
“Your offer is very agreeable indeed,” he answered plainly. “But there are things that are worth to me more than all the books and languages of the world. Things that… unfortunately, your kingdom does not… cannot provide. I don’t see it being a home for me.” And he dared to look at Thorin, the Took side of him not caring what anyone thought, even if Thorin were to have a One, he still meant everything to Bilbo and that was that. Thorin met his eyes, and it felt as many times before that they were in unison, that Thorin knew some of what he meant, and was happy with it, and grateful, but no, neither of these spelled love, Bilbo reminded himself...
“So you don’t accept. Very well,” Thranduil said, looking unsurprised and eager to move on. “In that case, allow me to present my final offer.”
“No. You will not,” Thorin interjected rapidly. “If you have something more to say, say it to me alone. Bilbo, you need to leave this room. Now.”
“Is that so?” Thranduil asked. “What is it that you fear?” He advanced close to Thorin, and Bilbo knew what he was going to try to do, and moved between them.
“Do you not see that Master Baggins has gone through enough? Where is your heart?” Thorin implored, almost, while Bilbo stood there, wondering how he could shield him. “Go, Bilbo... you do not need to hear this.”
Bilbo nodded. “I’ll see you soon, I hope,” and he began walking towards the door, hesitantly.
“The ring,” he heard Thranduil behind him. “If you leave the ring here, both you and the Arkenstone are free to leave with your king.”
He turned and met Thorin’s gaze, full of darkness and dismay.
“You love him, don’t you?” Thranduil continued. “You love him and betrayed him. You owe him this much. It should be simple.”
Bilbo moved towards him, fury in his eyes, and it felt like now it was just the two of them in the room.
“Bilbo... I don’t care that you betrayed me. I have forgiven you. You owe me nothing,” he heard an almost nonexistent Thorin from far away, worlds between them.
“He may have forgiven you. But he is not returning your love in kind. Only this way... only if you prove to him... show him the magnitude of your love... only then he will love you.”
“Not even then,” Bilbo spoke faintly, feeling the words slipping away from him. “I’m afraid Thorin’s heart is given elsewhere, and has been for some time. So, another one of your pathetic schemes fails, King Thranduil. I feel really sorry for you.” As he spoke, he felt himself drifting away from Thranduil, after having come so close to him just moments before. He didn’t dare look at Thorin anymore. Now the three of them were three dots in space, forming a giant triangle that kept getting bigger...
“As far as my own heart, it is tied to this ring. I will not part with it. If Thorin... if he wants his Arkenstone back, then I will take your earlier offer. I will stay here. You are right, I owe it to him. But I don’t think you understand; even if I’d never betrayed him, I would want to do this for him.”
...He wants to say more, but something protective and unbelievably determined stops him. We are done here, he hears hazily, and feels strong arms lift him in one effortless movement, and now he is being carried away from the room in a hurry. He doesn’t struggle one bit, and the next minute he is in the garden, the sun shining on his face when Thorin releases him.
He watches Thorin move a few steps away from him, looking like he’s preparing for a duel, and words fall down on him like thunder. “Tell me that you don’t believe what you just said.”
“What?”
He hears Thorin sigh with frustration. “Exactly, what.” There is no mistake: Thorin is upset. “Where can I begin? You said your heart is tied to this ring. And something else, that I think I know where you’re going with. You still think I value the Arkenstone more. You think my heart...”
“No, Thorin,” Bilbo pleads, a desperate attempt at bringing comfort. “I was just trying to dodge Thranduil’s trap. He was trying to read my mind. So I just said some things.” So much for being truthful, he laments silently. Something I can never be.
Thorin looks at him in disbelief, and Bilbo presses his advantage. “But you... you didn’t want me to hear Thranduil’s offer. Why?” he asks pointedly, and it’s enough to hear the thunder reverberate through the garden again.
“Do you think I don’t know what he’s done to you? Along with this adventure, with all of its perils? Me, in my madness? The battle? And if we add the ring to this mix... Do you think I don’t know? You’d be torn in making this decision, as you’ve ever been since you set foot outside the Shire, and it would wear you out! I won’t let you suffer because of me again, even if I have to decide for you!”
“And what would you decide?” Bilbo asks almost inaudibly, and suddenly finds himself kneeling on the grass. He needs the support of the earth beneath him.
“I have not decided,” Thorin answers in an equally soft tone. He kneels with Bilbo and looks around, taking in the garden with its paths and trees and flowers, as if he’s trying to figure out where they are. Where they are in relation to the Arkenstone, to the ring, to the world. To the Mountain, to the Shire, to home. Where they are.
“I’d say love was a magical thing
I’d say love would keep us from pain
Had I been there, had I been there
I would promise you all of my life
But to lose you would cut like a knife
So I don’t dare, no I don’t dare
’cause I’ve never come close in all of these years
You are the only one to stop my tears
And I’m so scared, I’m so scared
Take me back in time, maybe I can forget
Turn a different corner and we never would have met
Would you care
I don’t understand it, for you it’s a breeze
Little by little you’ve brought me to my knees
Don’t you care
No, I’ve never come close in all of these years
You are the only one to stop my tears
I’m so scared of this love
And if all that there is, is this fear of being used
I should go back to being lonely and confused
If I could, I would, I swear”
