Chapter Text
Bilbo was beginning to doze off when the sound of the door closing as Thorin made his way out of the room woke him. It took him a while to figure out where he was, a new environment, a nice, big, comfortable bed, a warm fireplace, a dark room with no windows...
And Bilbo began to realize that this was his first night in Erebor, and his mind began to settle at a slower pace, more patient, more desiring to stay in one moment and take it in, to catch his own thoughts and meditate on them, and to eternalize his memories as if putting a picture in a frame; and he found that he finally had that time he had wished for, to reminisce about the last few weeks, to figure things out, but more than anything to relive those moments... As he let out a deep exhale he began to think of one person, to remember him and the two of them together in an unfiltered, unrestrained way, in no particular order, with the hope of deciphering what it all meant...
He could still feel Thorin’s presence inundate the air, Thorin sitting by his side waiting for him to fall asleep, his head buried in the sheets, kissing his hand, reaching for his heart, or was it his voice softly rumbling something about heart
...I would rather be without the Arkenstone than be without you.
They are in Mirkwood, sitting outside the palace, and Bilbo is shaking after having met with Thranduil one on one the first time. Thorin brings Bilbo’s head to his chest and starts tracing a pattern on his back, up and down... Bilbo presses his head against Thorin’s heart, and is suddenly feeling better; it appears Thorin is the one who is unsettled now. He places his hands on Thorin’s chest and can now feel his heart calm. Trust is the name of this moment, trust, always, he hears in his mind, words that sound as if they are being formed in Thorin’s heart this time, trust, to the end. Bilbo looks at him in astonishment, and it feels like the sun and the moon are shining on the Hidden Door all over again, and that it is going to open once more... But it is Thorin’s heart that opens, somehow, and lets Bilbo hear its sounds, yet in the next moment Thorin calls him my heart sound, does that mean that all that Bilbo hears is himself? No, that cannot be, for Thorin’s heart is an open heart, not a mirror in which all one can see is oneself; it is a portal one can peek through and maybe see something new...
Was there a time when I opened his heart?...
...It is the night of their first kiss, and Bilbo manages to write what he wished to write on Thorin’s chest, Give me your love in Khuzdul. The last rune touches the place of Thorin’s heart, and Bilbo feels something happening in his own heart, like a door opening. We will use paper... until Khuzdul enters here, Thorin had said during their first lesson as he touched Bilbo’s heart.
Perhaps all this means that now both of their hearts beat in Khuzdul. Is that all?...
Thorin tries to help him take off the ring; Bilbo’s hand closes in a fist and does not release the pressure until Thorin speaks the right words, something about light, and the sun, and about Thorin’s unwavering desire to protect him. Only these words can penetrate through the cold wall that surrounds the ring...
And now it’s their last night in Mirkwood, and he is trying to get the statue to open its stone fist and let the light of the Arkenstone shine on Thorin. And only his words - not just love, but also the desire to protect Thorin against any upcoming evil in Erebor (or are they one and the same thing?) - manage to get it to open.
You’re never alone, and you have nothing to fear. The tree’s branches and leaves are shielding you against all evil. And the sun is shining its light on your skin, warm and bright. Just as you like it. Just like the light I have seen in... in your soul.
Thorin’s hand moves across Bilbo’s chest until it finds his heart. Didn’t Bilbo do the same thing only minutes earlier? Only Bilbo could not speak, so he wrote instead. But the language was the same.
Let it in, Bilbo. Let the light in .
And the stone melts around the fist, and the hand opens, and now he is back in Thranduil’s garden, touching the Arkenstone affectionately. Please shine your rays on him and infuse him with your light, and let these words penetrate him deeply. Create a shield to protect him against all evil. Let them enter, and with them, please, let my love in.
The Arkenstone makes a sound, perhaps approving of his use of Khuzdul, and shines brighter rays, and glowing blue runes start pouring onto Thorin’s hair and back...
I would maybe count Khuzdul as a magical thing, thought Bilbo. If Khuzdul entered my heart on our first night together, it must have made me stronger. And Thorin... Khuzdul had already been in his heart for a long time; yet when I said those words to him that the Arkenstone wrote with runes, maybe he got my version of Khuzdul, filtered through me, somehow. And... maybe that made Thorin even stronger... because... well I want to say because I love him. Just like he made me stronger because he loved me, when he said Let the light in...
Did I just say he loved me? Hmmm... he was just trying to shield me from the ring. To get me to take it off before it could cause any more harm to me.
And I... I was just trying to protect him with those runes before he got to the Mountain and possibly bad things started happening.
Or maybe love is a shield, he continued. That is certainly how our love started. With me shielding him from Azog and his Orcs. And with him - I wish, I hope - with him perhaps being extra grateful for that.
...He sees Thorin being carried by the Eagle to safety, and trembles in fear as he wonders about his condition. All he wanted was a nice adventure, a story he could bring back to the Shire to tell whoever would listen, and surely he, Bilbo Baggins, flying on top of an Eagle was something beyond all expectation in its spontaneous thrill... so naturally Bilbo would want to savor this moment and record it in his memory so he could tell it to others when the time came. And yet here he is, unable to think of himself, so deeply is his mind consumed with the unconscious dwarf who right now is being shifted slightly in the Eagle’s claws in some sort of adjustment move, and Bilbo reacts, reacts as if he were being carried by an Eagle and is afraid of falling... as if he were Thorin except conscious...
...You are changed, Thorin! The Dwarf I met in Bag End would have never gone back on his word! He would have never doubted the loyalty of his kin! Oh, yes, he speaks those words, but even as he hears them come out he knows there is something wrong.
He is acting as if he were Thorin. That part doesn’t feel wrong, but as he says these words, he feels them bounce off of their intended recipient and come back to him, and now they are about him. He looks at Thorin with uneasiness. I knew I didn’t think this through, but this is really strange. Yet all he sees is someone very hurt, who seems to have simply valued him as a true friend and is now betrayed. Of course, there is the Do not speak... to me... of loyalty! but Thorin doesn’t look like he has any intention to throw Bilbo’s words back at him. Maybe he already did, though, when Bilbo wasn’t looking; for how else can he explain this “off” feeling, it is I who have changed, in equal measure, it is I who would have never gone back on my word and yet I violated the terms of the contract I signed that was given to me in good faith in Bag End. As for loyalty... well Thorin treated me like family, he made me feel included in the Company and trusted me blindly at times... and while I wouldn’t exactly call him “kin”, the fact remains I doubted his loyalty to his loved ones, only to be proven wrong later when he charged out of the Mountain. Oh, Thorin... bitter is this cup that I have to drink as I remember it all, but take solace in that when I said these words, it’s very clear I was talking about myself too... I was talking about me, us, Thorin, us, me...
One person? No, not one. They were two, and very different at that. And yet...
...He is dreaming that Thorin needs his help while in a meeting with Thranduil that is quickly going south; he thinks of Thorin as the embodiment of bravery and names him zangel, only to see Thorin take a different form of courage moments later...
True courage is knowing when to spare a life, Gandalf had said when he had given him the small blueish sword. In other words, pity, as far as Bilbo and Gollum were concerned, as it turned out later.
I found something. In the goblin tunnels.
What did you find? Gandalf had asked, scrutinizing him with suspicion.
My courage.
He had faltered before the all-seeing eyes of the wizard, but had remained strangely truthful. The word courage was not used to tell a lie. His brand of courage turned out to be pity for his enemy, and it was something that Bilbo had found in the goblin tunnels. Now, in the halls of the Woodland Realm, saying the word courage amounts to so much more: almost as if he’s acting from within Thorin or as if Thorin is him for a moment. Now Bilbo calls Thorin courage of all courage in Khuzdul, meaning the courage that Thorin is made of, that enables him to confront Smaug directly and taunt him, or go face Azog alone with only an oaken branch for protection, or not even that because hey, who needs a shield on icy ground... inadvertently giving him his own brand of courage: knowing when to take pity on an enemy. I gave him my own version of Khuzdul, again, just by saying that word, thought Bilbo and now he was completely intrigued. He forgot his anger. He took pity on Thranduil and turned away. Words. Words. Hold. Power. Naming something and giving it a different meaning... the word did not bounce off of Thorin and returned to him, but permeated Thorin with the meaning that it held for Bilbo, the sound of the word finding its echo...
...They are in Thranduil’s garden again, and as they lift their eyes and turn their gaze toward the planting spot just a few inches away, they see a stem emerging out of the ground and becoming taller and taller, and now it’s getting wider and it’s no longer a stem but a trunk, and branches start emerging, spreading like arms upwards and to the sides, and growing leaves and fruit. They take a few steps back to behold the miraculous sight, and Thorin now stands behind Bilbo, holding him and speaking in his ear, Remember this, Bilbo, his words betray a sense of urgency, You see this... The Arkenstone has given life. And it can do so again. It can give life again. Please, remember...
Why are you telling me this?
You may need this... in another world, and Bilbo strongly suspects that Thorin has more to say in that moment, that he is keeping to himself.
...It’s that dreamy night again, and Thorin is kissing him for the first time. Bilbo is left to put together this puzzle. How to describe how this feels to him. Thorin’s lips touch his once, twice...
Love me. I want you to say you love me. And I want it to be true.
And it is. He can feel it. There is no doubt, Thorin loves him. He feels it in the way Thorin kisses him. There is so much.
He places his hand below Thorin’s ear and feels him tremble. He runs his finger down, and now Thorin is kissing him very passionately.
I want you-
But Bilbo is too exhausted to go there. Maybe in the morning, if they should be the same in the morning.
Thorin’s lips on his neck, on his ear...
I want it, Thorin. I want you.
At first Thorin was kissing him slowly and carefully, perhaps sensitive to the possibility that Bilbo does not actually want this and will want to put a stop to it. It seems that Thorin was waiting for something, maybe for Bilbo to set the tone, which he is trying to just now. What am I to you, Thorin? he asks hoping to make this night real, My love, he hears Thorin rumble, You’re my love...
...This night forever, now it’s their last night in Mirkwood, they were watching the tree grow a moment ago but now they are kissing briefly before Thorin retakes his position behind Bilbo and turns him towards the tree again. Now they see the first fruit appear on one of the tree’s branches, and Bilbo turns to him for a second. You still think the Arkenstone did it? and touches Thorin’s face in amazement...
What else could it have been? Thorin asks as he holds him up and starts moving them towards the tree, and Bilbo wants to answer, in fact he is doing something with his hands, wanting to point to Thorin in a not very subtle gesture, and opening his mouth to speak. But he can’t get any words out, for Thorin is kissing him again, stifling any sound or movement. Now Thorin is leaning him against the tree, pressing his hands down, immobilizing him, and now it’s pretty clear that Thorin likes to focus on just kissing at first, he wants no distractions, no touching, just to feel Bilbo’s lips on his, to taste them and only them, completely, again and again. Oh, how Bilbo wished for this, how he wished it even as he tried to hide from it! But It. is. here, and he will not wait, and Thorin lifts him up again, I don’t want any space between us, he says as he wraps Bilbo’s legs around him. I knew Thorin was passionate but nothing like this; I thought he may want to take things a little more slowly based on how rigorous those Dwarven courting procedures seemed. Thorin’s hand touches the nape of his neck, stroking his curls while his head is buried in Bilbo’s chest, exploring the mithril gently with his lips. Tell me, Thorin moans violently, tell me what was needed for your tree to grow, and now he is biting the mithril links, Your love, Bilbo hears himself say, though it’s not clear who is speaking these words because there is only one person here...
He called me “my love,” thought Bilbo with great puzzlement at the symmetry lying before him. “My love” meant me in that instance. And when he asked me what the tree needed for growing, I answered “your love”, meaning the love he has for me. The tree grew from my acorn, which to me personally means “my love”, the love I have for Thorin. And which also, because of the oak thing, is a symbol for Thorin himself, and therefore also means “my love”. How to begin to wrap one’s mind around this mystery... a mystery in this symmetry, he said to himself and smiled... literally, for the former word was an anagram of the latter, if imperfect...
Was there a time when I moved into his heart?...
He is back in Thranduil’s garden, the Arkenstone waiting for him to pronounce his words to Thorin. Here’s what I want to say, he says to his two kind, patient witnesses. Thorin... I feel you. You’re in everything I see. In the air that I breathe; in every stone, in every river and in every leaf. In this garden and in this light that is now shining on you; and in the Mountain itself that is so dear to you. And in this tree that has not yet grown, and in the stars above it. I feel you...
...They are in Dale now, on the morning of Thorin’s waking on the third day after the battle. They are sensing each other’s presence in a new way. He is feeling what Thorin is feeling, hearing his thoughts as they are forming, from within... As he takes in this moment, he and Thorin holding each other close, it feels as if Bilbo’s body is leaving him. Thorin brings one hand up to his shoulder, and begins to stroke the links of his mithril shirt one by one, repeatedly. Bilbo’s fingers go from touching Thorin’s hair to his eye, to his temple, and his cheek, as if he still can’t believe this is real. With every touch, Thorin trembles, his eyes blink in wonder, and small tears reach Bilbo’s fingers. Yet instead of feeling Thorin’s tears on his fingers, Bilbo feels tears streaming from his own eyes, and feels a touch on his own eye, his temple, his cheek, and soft fingers running through his hair. As he brings his hand to his eyes, there is nothing there, no tears, and as he looks down he sees Thorin’s hands still touching his shirt. And now he knows that he is feeling what Thorin is feeling. He breathes, and wonders if this is what it’s like for Thorin to breathe, and if he were to say something, would it be him or Thorin. I feel you, he lets out...
That must be it. That is when I started living in him. The feeling that he can hear what Thorin is thinking from inside of him, his thoughts as they are forming from within... that was when it all started and it had persisted, manifesting here and there, fleetingly and not always in a straightforward way, but always growing...
...Back against the tree, Thorin lets Bilbo slide down and now lies on top of him, holding their hands on the ground and looking like he wants to do one hundred things at once; later they roll over and now Bilbo is on top and is running his hands on Thorin’s chest and his fingers touch his skin through the holes in his shirt and Bilbo wants to kiss his skin through the holes, but as his fingers are touching he feels a burn, maybe this wasn’t such a good idea, he thinks, and much curiosity inserts itself in this game, I wonder if I can at least peek through them...
He peeks through the holes, and the holes are suddenly filled with blue light that looks like a bright tunnel, and Bilbo’s eyes eagerly follow that path to a different world, in which he sees himself deep beneath the Mountain, attending what appears to be a funeral. Thorin is lying on top of cold stone, runes surrounding his tomb, which speak of the mighty son of Thrain who is now passing into legend, and grief-stricken dwarves behold him one last time...
Bilbo sees himself at Thorin’s side, dumbfounded and tearful. You may need this... in another world, he hears Thorin say once more. And this time Bilbo can hear the rest of Thorin’s thoughts as they are being formed...
In another world, I die. And I am buried deep within the Mountain, holding the Arkenstone in my hands. And you... you will be there by my side, and there will be no comfort for you. A glimmer of understading will pass through your tear-stained eyes. Then, only then, you will know what you didn’t have time to grasp before: that you felt something for me, something that will now become all-consuming. And you will wish that I could rise from the tomb, but will be so preoccupied with your grief and newfound revelations that you won’t realize that there is a way- there is a way to bring me back, right then and there. All you’ll have to do is talk to the Arkenstone, tell it what you want, and give me your love.
Yet Thorin is afraid to say this out loud, so close are the boundaries between different worlds at this moment. He feels within himself that this is part of the blessed gift they are receiving in the form of the growing tree: that it brought some worlds closer, such that if you were not careful you could step from one to another. And words - words hold power - could make that happen. The image of the tree growing before their eyes and Thorin’s deep, resonant words as he holds Bilbo would have to suffice. A strong memory would perhaps penetrate through the walls between worlds at another time. When it is needed.
But it will be just for an hour, if what the Arkenstone said to Thranduil is correct. You will be alive again just for an hour. And then I will be alone again, Thorin... Bilbo addresses Thorin’s voice urgently, deeply troubled.
You will know then that I love you, Thorin comforts him. An hour will be more than enough for me to say that to you; to make you feel my love.
It won’t be enough, Thorin. It won’t be...
Then you will find a way. When you know that I love you, you will find a way to be with me again.
...The Bilbo in the funeral scene does not hear this. Only the Bilbo who is watching him through the portal created by Thorin’s shirt does. There is a way, the latter Bilbo whispers into the scene. There is a way to bring him back, right here and now. All you have to do is talk to the Arkenstone, tell it what you want, and give him your love.
The Bilbo in the funeral scene draws closer to Thorin and makes as if to touch the Arkenstone, yet stops himself. The dwarves will see and misinterpret this as a sign of disrespect, he thinks. I must be hallucinating. What are you waiting for? Just do it, you idiot! the more-or-less-actual-world Bilbo shouts in disillusionment as he continues to gaze through the portal. It turns out he has said these words out loud, for Thorin lifts Bilbo’s head from his chest and studies him in surprise. Are you sure...? he asks - hopefully or skeptically? - and Bilbo wonders what meaning Thorin may have gleaned from his words. Oh. Thorin, he says with much relief, lifting his hands to feel them on his love’s face and lips, I didn’t mean you. I wasn’t talking to you. And I absolutely don’t sound like Gollum either, he finishes to himself only.
They stare at each other for one long moment. Do you know what just happened? he asks his love silently, with wondering eyes. And he hears his love’s voice in his mind, speaking through Thorin’s eyes. Words... Words there is so much more to than meets the eye.
Remember this. The Arkenstone gave life. And it can do so again. And when it does... it may not be for just an hour. All you’ll have to do is talk to the Arkenstone, tell it what you want, and give what is needed.
What does it need, Thorin? What will it need to bring you back?
Your love...
Bilbo took in a deep breath as he reached a stopping point in his stream of thoughts. These things really happened, he thought. I can see it now. I mean, not Thorin dying. That part we managed to avoid. But the rest, the rest is true. He didn’t die; instead, he found love. A love... that lives now in his heart. I’m no genius, but based on everything I’ve recollected here, I think it is both logical and common sense to say that... he loves me.
He was in Erebor now. And he was... not just in love with its King Under the Mountain. He was madly, drunkenly, fiercely and possessively in love. He had reached that point where any world where they were not together was no longer acceptable. Which meant that this world, he thought as he looked around in the intolerably empty room, this world would need to suffer some changes. Soon. Soon... Now.
