Actions

Work Header

Love Is A Shield

Chapter 20: Return

Summary:

During their journey back to Erebor, Bilbo reflects on his time in Mirkwood while Thorin revisits childhood memories and questions his ability to handle the responsibilities of what’s to come. As they reach the Mountain, they also reach a decision concerning the fate of the ring.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

As they walked out of the garden, Thorin and Bilbo saw Thranduil approach with an inquisitive look, that turned to stupefied upon seeing their interlocked hands. All parties came to a halt, and Thranduil spoke.

“I hear you are leaving today, King Thorin. Since it’s clear you are not letting go of Mister Baggins, it’s probably too much to hope that I may gain possession of his precious ring. Alas, at least the Arkenstone is still here.”

“Indeed,” said Thorin. “And it will remain here for the time being. I sincerely wish it will aid you in your purpose, and I thank you for restoring my nephews’ health. May your days be blessed. By the way... you now have three precious things in your garden, King Thranduil. One of them is yours; may you cherish it as it is fit.”

While Bilbo wondered if the Elvenking really understood which object Thorin had meant was his, Thranduil gazed into the distance and saw the proud, tall oak tree arisen from the ground. “What is the meaning of this? I don’t recall ordering any additions to the garden.”

“For you, King Thranduil,” Bilbo said sweetly. “Something to add to the magic power that already exists in your garden. I thank you for your hospitality and for...” He had to bite his tongue not to add for bringing me closer to Thorin. “When you do get your wife back, let us know. I would love to meet her. As for me and you, may we meet again as friends!”

“You seem confident that she’ll come back,” Thranduil remarked.

“I have seen a lot of miracles in the last few weeks,” said Bilbo.

Thranduil bowed to them slightly, with a pained expression on his face. They responded in kind and watched him enter the garden and go straight to the oak tree, and it was a while until anyone could tear him away from the sight.

They left for Erebor an hour later. Tauriel joined them; she was going to continue to supervise the young Durins’ healing as well as pursue her romance with Kili. Their departure was uneventful, except that they all noticed Thranduil’s absence and heard Elves around them whispering that their King’s demeanor today was stranger than usual. He seemed a bit gone, his gaze was lingering in the distance, he looked confused and lost, as if he had forgotten something really important. Yet Thorin and company paid no mind to those last minute observations; the Lonely Mountain was waiting for them. And while the Dwarves and the Elf in the Company seemed ecstatic to be received in its embrace, Bilbo began reflecting on his time in Mirkwood.

He had obtained what he had wished for: a night with Thorin. And what a night it had been! It was strange how remembering it allowed for only fleeting bits and pieces...

He could remember the smell of the air, so fresh, so new, mixed with the smell of an actual tree growing, the stem, the leaves emerging before his eyes as Thorin’s hair was blocking some of the sight; the light of the Arkenstone, the statue that seemed to have moved briefly; the acorn grown in a matter of seconds while he and Thorin had kissed in that glow; Thorin’s voice as if presiding over the miracle, steady and full of so much certainty, assuring him that this was real...

The first time they had kissed, in Thorin’s room... Bilbo had not been completely sure it was real. But this... There was no trace of doubt.

It wasn’t just that this time a tree had grown right then and there - a tree that was still there in the morning to witness - that ensured that their closeness had not been merely a dream; and not just that their closeness was, Bilbo thought, part of what had led to that miraculous occurrence. No, what made it believable beyond any doubt was that he, Bilbo, had been different this time.

He had no longer been double-minded; no longer unsure or torn. He knew his own mind this time, while the first time he had been almost consumed by the power of the ring, and thus only half himself. Thankfully, another half had stepped in and helped him feel whole, but still... he could not deny the presence of shadows and doubt that carried into the next few days...

Yet last night, free of the ring for a few days as he had been, he had stepped out of the shadows and embraced the light, and realized the fullness of his love for Thorin. He let it manifest wholeheartedly, with utmost sincerety, even at the risk of being rejected (a danger he was all too happy to laugh at now); and no more wine-related questions or doubts did he have afterwards! No, it was there, Thorin and him, whatever they were now, they were more, and he knew it was, in part, because he had been honest with himself.

It felt so good! He had to stop and wonder if it still felt this way now that the ring was back in his pocket, with no idea where it was going to end up other than that Thorin had a plan. No idea, other than knowing that he couldn’t leave Thorin now.

Will he be able to keep his resolve to part with the ring, if Thorin asked it?

One thing that Bilbo was not entirely happy about was that these days he never had any time to rest properly and process what was happening to him. And this time, oh, how he would have liked to perhaps have a few more days in Mirkwood, just so he could stare at the beautiful oak tree and remember each moment spent with Thorin in its presence! As it was, they were on the go again, just as they had been almost as soon as Thorin had woken up after the battle; another rush, and the same feeling that life was too busy to be savored in its full flavor.

I’m not complaining, though, he thought prudently. When I get to Erebor, there will be more such moments, and I’ll have plenty of time to remember things properly.

You have time to change your mind, Halfling, he heard Thranduil’s voice from during one of their conversations, when he once again had refused the Elvenking’s offer. Perhaps when the coldness of Erebor’s walls sufficiently freezes your skin, or when you find yourself bored in your Shire, far from adventure and good company, we shall have words again!

He shuddered. Maybe Thranduil was right and he won’t survive in the Mountain. It was true, the first time he had set foot in that Mountain he had been less than thrilled. It was cold, dark and unwelcoming, a nasty clockless, timeless hole he had called it. All he could think of for comfort was his beloved Shire. It’s not natural. You need sunlight. You need warmth. And Thorin can hardly provide these things, as he’ll be swamped with work. You know this, Bilbo Baggins. He won’t have time for you. As he contemplated these thoughts with much apprehension, he told himself that surely Thorin’s gold madness had added to that uneasy feeling the first time around; it will be different this time. Warm and sunny Erebor may not be, but having a happy and healthy Thorin next to me will be enough.

Will it? he heard that voice, his own voice that liked to create trouble, though with good intentions, a voice that liked to examine all possible scenarios, to be thorough and prepared, and leave no stone unturned - he laughed at the pun - well. I’m going to follow my heart and that is that; we can ask questions later.

But the doubt didn’t stop there. Returning to the Mountain could bring about another kind of... Thorin’s madness returning was still a possibility, a certainty if the voice in his dreams was to be believed, which would render this journey the beginning of his worst nightmare.

You are changed, Thorin!

The Dwarf I met in Bag End would have never gone back on his word!

He would have never doubted the loyalty of his kin!

At least the Arkenstone was out of the way, for now. If he were honest, he’d admit he was relieved at that, though Thorin had already proven that he cared more about him than about a stone! His mind clearly was no longer in its grip. So much was different, and he trusted Thorin this time. But... the Arkenstone being out of the way hadn’t stopped Thorin’s madness the first time.

I won’t let him fall again, Bilbo thought. And Gandalf... Gandalf removed the spell…

Supposedly . Gandalf sometimes says one thing and does another, you know this by now.

I will protect him. But what power did he have?

I love him.

You love Thorin Oakenshield. But that Thorin may be gone as soon as he enters the Mountain.

Our love  will protect him. It will protect both of us. I’ve never experienced anything more powerful.

 

“Bilbo, can I have a word with you?”

It was evening. They had stopped to camp for the night, and Thorin had gone in search for firewood, when he saw Balin approach him with his usual good cheer.

“How are you?” he asked simply. “You’ve gone through a lot these past few months.”

“I’m afraid, Balin,” Bilbo decided to cut to the point quickly. “Let’s just say the Mountain did not seem friendly the first time I... visited. Yet Thorin... I remember how happy he was when he opened the Hidden Door and entered. He is like that again now, I can feel it; his anticipation, his eagerness is certainly contagious! And yet... I’m not a Dwarf, you know. I’m just a little apprehensive as to how this Mountain is going to feel to me.”

“The evil has retreated, Bilbo. All is safe now in Erebor, and rebuilding will give us much to look forward to. You’ll see, it will be an adventure in itself, if you choose to stay to witness it. Or even to help us with it,” Balin added with a wink.

“I will surely stay for some of it,” Bilbo replied.

“I know you were feeling homesick a lot during our quest,” said Balin. “I imagine you still long for your cozy Shire?”

“Not as much. It’s really not that. It’s just... I still worry about Thorin. As bad as that Elvenking was at times, I feel like Thorin had a bit of a reprieve there. Erebor is a whole different story.”

“Do not worry, Bilbo. Thorin and the Mountain are deeply connected. They will protect each other; and thus our people will be protected as well, which is what he will be most focused on.”

“But the gold...” Bilbo began hesitantly. “The gold is still there, Balin. Aren’t you afraid of what it can do to him?”

Balin did not give a straight answer. “We’ll all watch for the gold’s effects on Thorin, and act at once if we see anything off. We’ll take better care of him this time, Bilbo; we’re much better prepared.”

Thorin was back soon, and just like Balin he approached Bilbo and inquired how he was doing and if he was ready to see Erebor again. This gave Bilbo an opportunity to ask him something that had been pressing in his mind.

“Thorin, do you think… Do you think your life will change a whole lot once you get there? I mean, you’ll have lots of responsibilities and worries. Restoring your kingdom… watching over your nephews, welcoming newcomers, treating with allies… I wonder if I’m even going to see you.”

“You are welcome to take part in all of those. If you don’t wish it, I would have you relax and study whatever you like. I’ll do whatever I can to make sure you’ll feel comfortable in the Mountain. As for how my schedule will be…”

“Wait. You would share your responsibilities with me?”

“I would, if you’ll have them.”

“But would you want me to…”

“I wouldn’t impose anything on you. In an ideal world…” Thorin stopped suddenly.

“In an ideal world…?” Bilbo insisted, waiting patiently for a response.

“There is much that I want to share with you.”

“Thanks, Thorin. I don’t know what makes you so confident in me. I will think on it.”

Thorin turned from him and looked for a long moment at the fire that was just being started, and Bilbo wondered at the sudden change. He wanted to hold him and not let go for a long time, yet he was not ready to do that with Balin and Dwalin around. So he went and sat by the fire and joined in the singing, laughter and conversation that soon ensued among the Company.

* * *

Thorin was going home.

This was not new; he had gone home once. Very recently. He had felt that thrill, a vivid memory in his mind. And he knew a certain blindness surrounded him that first time around. To have the chance to do this again...

There was a legend that Thorin and his siblings had read in his youth, in which a young prince left his parents’ home in search of youth without aging and life without end. During his journeys, he met and fell in love with a beautiful princess who lived with her two sisters in a heaven-like place. Come and live with us, the three women invited him, and you will find what you seek. He went with them, and for years unnumbered he lived there in perfect peace and marriage bliss, without aging a day. There was only one thing he needed to remember: to never set foot in a place called the Valley of Tears, or else a dangerous longing could take over him... And one day, due to a careless oversight, he did venture there, and was hit with the desire to see his parents and his childhood home again.

His wife and sisters-in-law immediately perceived what was wrong, and he didn’t bother denying the feeling consuming him. He begged them to let him go and see his parents’ house one more time; in vain did they insist that he would find nothing there, since the years had long passed since anyone was even alive in his father’s kingdom. The prince’s heart was set on going home, with a longing impossible to fend off. I will not linger there, he promised. I will come back very shortly.

He set out on his journey, and the more he was approaching his childhood home, the more he was aging. When he finally got there, he found a house in ruins, full of dust and spider webs, and no living beings. There was much desolation and sadness upon the land, and his eyes were small now and he could barely see, and his beard, white as snow, reached the floor. He came across an old chest and was curious to look inside, so he opened it. A small figure, like a charicature, jumped out of the chest and said, I’m so glad you came; for if you had delayed another minute, I myself would have perished. And thus death took him...

Thorin contemplated this legend during his present journey home. Oh, it was so obvious: Finding love while on a quest, then not being able to hold on to it due to a careless oversight, then death finding him...all of that had been his story, without a doubt. How fortunate that by Mahal and Yavanna’s grace he had been given another chance! And he let himself remember more, the image of his childhood home resurfacing in his mind, his brother and sister happy and carefree...

“I wouldn’t set out on such a journey to begin with,” Frerin had said. “I wouldn’t leave my parents’ home for some elusive dream. Talk about a cautionary tale. Look how it turned out. The prince didn’t get the home and lost the princess in the end!”

“I would,” Dis had countered. “Thanks to his journey, the prince found more than he had hoped for: not only endless life, but love as well. True, he lost both in the end, but I heard it said that it’s better to have loved and lost than to not have loved at all! At least he can say that he tried and was successful, even if through his own carelessness he wasn’t able to keep those gifts.”

“What do you think, Thorin?...”

Carelessness. Does that word not describe you, son of Thrain?

“I already know who my love is,” he had said, pointing to his then-sword. “And I trust our Maker would give us something close to life without end if we really wanted it. He made us to endure. Leaving home willy-nilly like that... I don’t think so. Not for me.”

“You think you know who your love is,” Dis responded again. “Maybe the prince in the story thought the same initially; and he wouldn’t have known any better had he not taken a chance and gone on his journey.”

“You have a point, sister,” Thorin had conceded affectionately. “I wouldn’t take much stock in this story, though; for all we know it’s an Elvish tale disguised as a Dwarvish legend, designed to confuse us with some circular logic. I know very well what’s in front of me.”

His home away from home had been the Blue Mountains; he had made a life for himself and his people there. What had been missing? It wasn’t Erebor, the place with chambers filled with golden light, the greatest kingdom in Middle Earth. But to Thorin it was more than that. Just like for the prince in the story, it was his true home. Yet when he had seen the remains of his dead kin two months before, he couldn’t shake the feeling that he’d end up like the prince in the legend...

Will he die before the restoration is complete? Or cave to the gold madness? Then it would be better to stay away from the Mountain, wouldn’t it?

Did he have what it took to keep evil away from the Mountain?

As he felt his love’s hand on his, a reminder of the soft that overcomes the hard, he realized that the prince’s tale was Bilbo’s story, too. Did Bilbo find love during his journey? Was he happy to have left his home? What will he find when he gets back, or perhaps he won’t want to go back if only...?

The person who could give him “youth without aging and life without end”, the person who was an endless source of renewal and growth within him, who had been with him during the entire quest, by his side even as he beheld the bodies of his kin... He had not cherished this person properly. He had been too engrossed in his purpose, so taken with it that he all but missed his own feelings. A careless oversight, that almost led to his downfall.

But now... he wasn’t going to fail again. His treasure of all treasures, his heart- no one else could claim this title; he was certain he knew whom it belonged to. And yet it remained a difficulty to balance the passion he felt for this person and the burden of dealing with this home. Was it really a home that Thorin could offer him? Or just desolation and decay, the complete opposite of youth without aging and life without end, which were much more likely to be found in the safe, idyllic Shire? Too many unanswered questions. My actions, he thought. The answers lie in my actions...

* * *

It was evening when they reached the gates of Erebor, and Thorin was quick to send his fellow travelers inside while he and Bilbo remained there to discuss the fate of the ring.

“I am going to list three options,” he spoke to Bilbo in a low, even voice. “Here is the first: We send ravens to the Shire with the ring, and they’ll drop it down your chimney in Bag End. My father indicated that the world will be safe if the ring stays in the Shire; your house is empty, and you once told me that you like to think your parents’ spirits guard that house, protecting it with their love. I trust that no evil will come to it. And Bilbo... if you should want to return home one day, you will have the ring again.”

“What if I’m not comfortable with this? Having the ring in no one’s possession is a bit risky. I’m not saying the ring can grow legs and leave my house, but still...” said Bilbo, beginning to feel very uneasy.

“Then we can give it to my cousin Dain for safe-keeping until you wish to go back to the Shire. My father indicated that the ring would cause trouble in the hands of an Elf or a Man; he said nothing about Dwarves. I don’t think we are so easily corrupted. I would trust Dain fully, and he will not stay in the Mountain. He’ll be leaving in the next few days; in the meantime we’ll have time to explain the situation to him.”

Bilbo was quiet. It hurt to see how difficult it was to part with the ring. I would part with the ring so I can join you in Erebor, he had said to Thorin in Mirkwood. Then what had changed?? Oh. I didn’t have the ring on me when I said that. I was free. While now... it’s back. I can feel this need to hold on to it.

“What about your third option?”

“The third and last resort is we enter the Mountain as we are.”

“So you are ready to risk the fate of your Mountain? The fate of your people? I am surprised at you, Thorin.” Do you see? The evil has already started to do its work in you. That’s the wrong answer, Thorin. And I suspect if your father is right, the ring is partly to blame. I am partly to blame for your carelessness.

“I hope it won’t come to that,” said Thorin. “I defeated the gold madness after all. The thing is, Bilbo... we can try to enter as we are, and see what happens, and if the ring does cause trouble we can always send it to the Shire as I suggested, or give it to Dain. Those options remain. The reason why I’m entertaining this idea, despite my father’s warning, is...” he fidgeted uncomfortably and stopped, searching for words, looking a bit lost.

“What is it?”

“I... You recall how badly I wanted the Arkenstone, and how... upset I was when I learned that...” he couldn’t continue.

“That I took it from you, and all that?” Bilbo tried to be helpful.

“Right. The point is... even if you did have my interest at heart, and did what you did with purely noble intentions... I still would have preferred if you had just given me the Arkenstone and let me do as I saw fit. You see... it was mine. That’s how I perceived it, and I’m not saying that I was right. And so... I try to put myself in your situation. You view this ring as yours. You are attached to it. It may bring evil, just like the Arkenstone may have brought to me. And I, out of purely good reasons, want to protect you and others from it. That is all well and good, but I don’t want to decide for you. You should be the only one to decide, because it is yours. And if you decide to keep it, then so be it.”

That stung, Thorin finally telling him like it was. Bilbo gave a quiet sigh. Would he never be free of this? Yet. Thorin really did have a point.

“Thank you, Thorin. I see what you are saying. Perhaps giving the ring to your ravens is a good idea. But I’m telling you,” and now Bilbo’s face became fierce as if facing a menacing invisible enemy, “my cousin Lobelia Sackville-Baggins probably watches my house like a hawk as it is. If the ring winds up with her in my absence...”

“I’ll have your house watched too,” said Thorin. “I’ll order my ravens to remain outside it, and if anything suspicious happens they will report back to me, not to mention they will know where the ring is and will be able to retrieve it if need be. As for your cousin... I can’t imagine the ring will do much harm through her. It sounds like Hobbits are not affected in the same way as Elves or Men.”

“Oh, she’s evil all right,” said Bilbo, unconvinced.

...In a close, somewhat less complicated possible universe, the ravens were summoned and the ring was sent away from the Mountain. Things were peaceful for a while in the Shire after the ring arrived and was dropped down the chimney at Bag End. Until three months later, when Bilbo was declared dead and an auction was initiated, upon which Lobelia ransacked the house looking for silver and gold, and her eagle eyes caught sight of the ring in the fireplace, and she immediately seized it. In the commotion caused by the auction, the ravens did not notice this detail, and since Lobelia exited Bag End peacefully at the end of the day, they didn’t suspect anything. It was later, when things of value started disappearing systematically from other hobbits’ homes, and eventually capable Shire detectives were able to identify the not-always-visible thief, that the ravens were able to put two and two together and regretfully informed Thorin of the unhappy developments. How things played out between Bilbo and Lobelia if he decided to return home and get his ring back, whether Lobelia Sackville-Baggins, declared “Wanted: Notorious Bandit” was ever caught by the Shire police, and perhaps more importantly, whether the destruction of the world was kept at bay in the Shire or brought about sooner by Lobelia’s actions, all of this belongs in another story that will be told another time.

In our story, Bilbo and Thorin continued debating for a while longer, and eventually concluded that giving the ring to Dain was the most sensible solution. Interestingly, a way in which the world in our story is similar to the one described above is that the ravens were actually summoned and sent to the Shire, albeit for a different purpose: Bilbo wished to have his baby acorn planted there as soon as possible. So he instructed the ravens as to the exact place he wanted the future tree to grow in, placed the acorn in a small pouch and gave it to the ravens to carry to Bag End. Thorin marveled at this rush, and was quite curious to know the reason for it. “Since we were just about to send an evil thing to my homeland, and then changed our minds, why not send a good thing instead,” Bilbo divulged, trying to explain his rationale while it was obvious he was keeping a part to himself. Then he reflected with some emotion, “We always try to fight evil. To identify problems and try to remove them. But how about just doing something good, just like that, with no clear purpose other than just to do good? Perhaps your ravens can stay there for a little while and observe,” he said enigmatically, “if anything curious happens...”

And so, after sending the ravens on their way with the acorn, they entered the Mountain, and found the rest of the Company leading various endeavors, of which cooking a big welcoming feast was an important one. Rooms had been prepared for the king and the company that traveled with him, and Bilbo was happy to discover that now he was the temporary owner of a cozy room with an armchair, a fireplace, books and a nice big bed. He was amazed to learn that this had all been ordered by Thorin through correspondence from Mirkwood!

While Thorin became engaged in conversation with Dain as soon as dinner started, Bilbo spent the rest of the evening enjoying the feast and catching up with Bofur, Ori and Gloin. The lively atmosphere he found in the Mountain looked promising, and he forgot his worries and truly enjoyed himself fully, infinitely grateful for such happy times. At the end of the feast, though he seemed not even nearly finished talking to Dain, Thorin came up to him, asking if he could walk him to his room. So they went together, and Thorin stayed with him for a while, wanting to make sure everything was to Bilbo’s liking.

Bilbo beamed at him with much gratitude for such a splendid evening, but soon deflated when he heard Thorin say, “I have to go soon. The Company, Dain and some of his dwarves are waiting for me. We have lots to discuss. I’m afraid this will take up the better part of my night.”

“I understand, of course.”

“Fili and Kili are located next door from you, and Balin and Dwalin are on the other side. If there is anything giving you trouble, anything at all, you only need go to one of them. Or to me, of course; I am next door from the boys, though as I said, I may not be there tonight, unfortunately.”

“Thanks, Thorin,” Bilbo said, words that sounded dull and empty. No doubt, spending nights together here in the Mountain was out of the question. There were probably guards on every corridor close to the king’s quarters, who would see Thorin go to Bilbo’s room and not leave until the morning... which was probably unacceptable, thought Bilbo with a sigh. Not that it was granted that Thorin would even want to do such a thing! A terrible need took hold of him, to never let Thorin go...

“I will see you at breakfast,” Thorin continued, seemingly oblivious to his uneasiness. He took Bilbo’s hand and brought it to his lips in a solemn gesture, his eyes full of uncertainty, and Bilbo saw a small chance.

“Inmi e, Thorin,” he said boldly as he looked deeply into his love’s eyes.

Thorin leaned down and put one arm around him in a gentledwarfly manner, the other still holding Bilbo’s hand. “Where,” he said with a smile as he began kissing him, “did you learn this word? I certainly did not teach it to you.”

Bilbo knew where he had learned the word, but didn’t want to share that with Thorin. “I... Well, you definitely taught me a thing or two about it,” he said, happy to have found an easy escape.

“Albuth anum astû,” came Thorin’s reply, and Bilbo could not quite make out the meaning, but did not argue with what followed it. Thorin stayed a little longer, and at some point removed his blue coat and offered it to Bilbo. “You should have this,” he said. “For tonight.”

“No,” said Bilbo with some concern. In his mind, that coat was still infused with the Arkenstone’s light, and he was not going to have Thorin part with it. “No, Thorin. You already gave me something precious to wear. I want you to wear the coat, even at night if possible.” It will protect you.

Thorin wrapped the coat around Bilbo anyway, and they stayed like that for a minute, glued perfectly together with no space left between them. Then Bilbo lay in bed, and Thorin watched over him until he looked like he was ready to fall asleep. Then Thorin let go of his hand and whispered, “Soon, my heart. I will be able to do this properly. I can only pray that what I’ll have to offer will be acceptable to you.” And he took his coat and left the room to go where his duties awaited, with hope in his heart that the Mountain would make a suitable home for his love.

Notes:

I’ve written a fast-paced one-shot piece called Stealing Beauty that explores Lobelia Sackville-Baggins’ dealings with the ring and Bilbo and Thorin’s efforts to retrieve it in the alternate universe where the ring is sent back to the Shire. Please feel free to check it out; I hope you enjoy it!!