Actions

Work Header

Baggins of The Shire

Chapter 10: Chapter 9 - In the Shadows of Mirkwood

Notes:

This chapter has a lot of the previous version and was originally beta-ed by Livingmeatloaf.

Chapter Text

They walked in single file. The path itself was narrow and wound in and out among the trunks. Soon the light at the gate was just a little bright spot far behind, and the quiet was so deep that their feet seemed to thump along while all the trees leaned over them and listened. Occasionally, a slender beam of sun that had the luck to slip in through some opening in the leaves far above, and still more luck in not being caught in the tangled boughs and matted twigs beneath, stabbed down thin and bright before them. But this was seldom, and it soon ceased altogether.

 

The nastiest things they saw were the cobwebs, dark dense cobwebs with threads extraordinarily thick, often stretched from tree to tree, or tangled in the lower branches on either side of them. There were none stretched across the path, but whether because some magic kept it clear or for what other reason they could not guess.

 

It was not long before they grew to hate the forest as heartily as they had hated the tunnels of the goblins, and it seemed to offer even less hope of any ending. The nights were the worst. It then became pitch-dark, so black that you really could see nothing. The only thing they could see were gleaming eyes in the darkness around them.

 

To Bilbo’s growing anxiety, they did not have the time or chance to continue with his sword training, it was too dark at night and they had to get as far as possible on the track at day. So he tread along with the others in darkness with a sword that he didn’t quite know how to use, feeling not safe at all.

 

But from time to time, Thorin would have him march right behind him. Bilbo could feel warmth radiating from his fur covered back, reminding him of home and safety. This made Bilbo long for his home but at the same time made him long to walk nearer to Thorin. As he felt that both were impossible, Bilbo silently kept walking, savoring whatever warmth he could get from a safe distance.

 

Days followed days, and still the forest seemed just the same. The food began to get low even though they were extremely careful with their provisions. Kíli managed to shoot a squirrel down, but when they cooked it, it tasted horrible and gave them all a bellyache. They were thirsty too, for they did not have much water, and in all the time they had seen neither spring nor stream.

 

This was their state when one day they found their path blocked by running water. It flowed fast and strong but not very wide, cutting right across the path. The thin river was black and a foul feeling radiated from it. Beorn had warned them not to touch any water that they might encounter inside the forest and they started to see why. But they also had no means to cross the water without coming into contact with the stream.

 

Bilbo stared at the blurred outline of the far bank wishfully as some of the others moaned in despair. He traced the banks with his eyes when he noticed there was an odd curve to one part of the silhouette. Bilbo narrowed his eyes, the curve looked a lot like the mast of a small boat.

 

“There’s a boat!” Bilbo pointed out into the gloom, “There’s a small boat on the far bank!”

 

The dwarves hurriedly gathered on the bank near him and glared at the spot Bilbo was pointing to. Kíli, with his sharp eyes, was the first one who saw it.

 

“There is a boat indeed!” he shouted gleefully.

 

Some of the others saw it as well  and the others that did not trusted the eyes of the ones that did. So, they fastened a large iron hook to their longest rope and had Fíli threw it to the boat. The boat was hooked after two tries and they were all soon on the far bank safe across the enchanted stream.

 

Thorin looked most relieved, as all of them had crossed safely without any incident. He praised Fíli for his good throw, and also Kíli, Óin, and Glóin for pulling each load of dwarves across the stream. Lastly he turned to Bilbo.

 

“You have sharp eyes Bilbo, thank you for spotting the boat!” said he as he patted him on the back.

 

Bilbo was strangely pleased by the comment, though he felt like a fauntling that was being praised for completing his first Lithe dance. But it made his heart lighten and the forest didn’t seem so dark anymore. So they marched again with higher spirits, lighter packs and emptier stomachs meaning they had to guard their provisions even more carefully.

 

About four days after the enchanted stream, they came to an area of the forest where most of the trees were beeches. They were at first inclined to be cheered by the change, for here the shadows were not so deep. Yet the light only showed them endless lines of straight grey trunks like the pillars of some huge twilight hall. Two days later, they found their path going downwards and before long they were in a valley filled almost entirely with a mighty growth of oaks and they grew weary again.

 

That night they ate their very last scraps and crumbs of food, so next morning when they woke the first thing they noticed was that they were still gnawingly hungry. At that moment, Balin saw a twinkle of light in the forest. They saw the light was in front of them and to the left of the path, so they headed closer to it. When at last they had drawn level with it, it seemed plain that torches and fires were burning under the trees a good way off their track.

 

There were many people there, elvish-looking folk, all dressed in green and brown and sitting in a great circle upon sawn sections of felled trees. There was a fire in their midst and there were torches fastened to some of the trees around. They were eating and drinking and laughing merrily. The smell of roasted meat was very enchanting and they were very hungry.

 

Most of the dwarves begged Thorin to let them ask for food from the elves, especially Bombur who had not felt full since they left Beorn’s house and Dori who was worried sick about his littlest brother Ori. Bilbo understood Thorin’s hesitation, for those were the very same elves that turned their back to them decades ago. 

 

Then he saw Thorin look at his nephews and Bilbo followed Thorin’s line of sight. Fíli and Kíli were silent even though they were obviously hungry. Throughout their journey, Bilbo had learned that young dwarves needed more sustenance than the older ones. But they did not join the pleading. To resist the temptation Kíli held his brother’s arm so tightly that his knuckles had gone white and Fíli definitely would sport an impressive bruise after this.

 

Thorin sighed in defeat.

 

“Fine, we’ll go and ask whether they are willing to share their food.”

 

So they walked silently so they would not spook the elves, making their way toward the circle and off the path. In their hunger, they had forgotten Gandalf’s advice to not leave the path. When they almost reached the edge of the circle, Thorin halted them.

 

“We can’t go all rushing forward. We should send someone to try to talk to them first.”

 

The company nodded and murmured their agreement.

 

“Someone who didn’t look threatening would be best,” said Nori while eyeing Dwalin.

 

Dwalin grunted in irritation but acknowledged Nori’s point.

 

“I suggest we send Bilbo,” recommended Balin.

 

Thorin hesitated but Bilbo felt a need inside him to be useful again for the company.

 

“I don’t mind,” said Bilbo.

 

Thorin gave him a searching look; Bilbo did not know whether he found what he was searching for but finally he said,

 

“If you say so,” and he moved aside so Bilbo could proceed toward the circle.

 

Bilbo walked until he reached the very edge of the circle and took a deep breath, hesitation suddenly overcoming him. But then he felt a presence behind him.

 

“I hope they wouldn’t do anything nasty to you,” said Bofur as he pushed Bilbo into the circle.

 

Bilbo stumbled forward into the full blaze of the fire and torches. But before he could say anything, out went all the lights again bringing sudden and complete darkness. He lost consciousness as if an enchantment had been put upon him.  

 

When he came into consciousness, he felt something touch him.  Something like a strong sticky string was against his left hand, and when he tried to move he found that his legs were already wrapped in the same stuff, so that when he got up he fell over. He instinctively drew his sword, then the great spider, who had been busy tying him up while he dozed, came from behind him and came at him. But Bilbo was ready, he stabbed one of its legs and while the spider retreated back in surprise, Bilbo cut the web that tangled him.

 

“What are you? Why do you have a sting?” the spider hissed and clacked, sending chills down Bilbo’s spine as it came at him again.

 

Bilbo struck it with his sword right in the eyes. Then it went mad and leaped and danced and flung out its legs in horrible jerks, until he killed it with another stroke. Bilbo was panting heavily and poked the dead spider with his sword to make sure it was really dead. He looked at his sword which was covered in black viscous liquid,

 

“I shall name you Sting after all,” murmured Bilbo, remembering his conversation with Thorin back at Beorn’s house.

 

He wiped his sword on the grass and sheathed it. He looked around but he couldn’t find any other member of the company nor any other spiders. Just ahead of him, Bilbo noticed a place of dense black shadow ahead of him, dark even for that forest, like a patch of midnight that had never been cleared away. As he drew nearer, he saw that it was made by many spider-webs one behind and over and tangled with another.

 

He put on his ring, just in case, though he disliked the odd feeling that he got when he was wearing it.  Creeping in closer, as silently as possible, he saw a great many spiders huge and horrible sitting in the branches above him. Standing behind a tree, he watched and listened to a group of them for some time.

 

One of the fat spiders ran along a rope until it came to a dozen bundles hanging in a row from a high branch. Bilbo was horrified, now that he noticed them for the first time dangling in the shadows, to see a dwarven feet sticking out of the bottoms of some of the bundles, or here and there the tip of a nose, or a bit of beard. In the silence and stillness of the wood he realised that they had captured the dwarves.

 

The spiders looked like they were about to eat the dwarves. Bilbo noticed there were many stones lying in what appeared to be a now dry little watercourse. As he mentioned in Bag End in the beginning of the journey, he was very good with his sling. Bilbo remembered the rude songs that had aggravated the dwarves when they entered Rivendell and a plan formed inside his mind.

 

He gathered as many sharp stones as possible and equipped with two of his most trusty weapons, his sling and his words he was ready to attack. He saw a spider crawling towards the biggest and roundest bundle. 

 

‘Must be Bombur,’ Bilbo thought. 

 

He spun his sling and with a flick of his wrist he launched the sharp stone, smacking the spider right on the head, causing instant death. The next stone went whizzing through a big web, snapping its cords, and taking off the spider sitting in the middle of it, another dead. After that there was a deal of commotion in the Spider-colony, that was when Bilbo dashed off to another tree and sang the most insulting song he could muster at the heat of the moment.

 

“Lazy Lob and crazy Cob 

are weaving webs to wind me. 

I am far more sweet than other meat, 

but still they cannot find me!”

 

The spiders were enraged and followed him into the forest while Bilbo dashed between trees until he had gone as far as he dared. Then he quickly stole back to release the dwarves from their tangled mess. He was halfway done when the spiders came back and he had to fend them off while the released dwarves opened the cocoons containing the other dwarves. They worked a tad slow for there was still spider poison in their systems.

 

As soon as all of them were released, they found their weapons at the base of a nearby tree and fought the spiders. But they couldn’t do much, for it was dark and they were weak with hunger and poison and the spiders were many. Already, the giant arachnids were weaving their webs all around the small clearing, spanning the spaces between trees to thwart their escape. In the end, Bilbo could think of no plan except to let the dwarves in on the secret of his ring.

 

“I am going to disappear and lure them away,” explained Bilbo, “You must keep together and make in the opposite direction, towards the place where we last saw the elf-fires."

 

The company was curious about how Bilbo would disappear, but the situation was dire and they all agreed with his plan, even more so after they saw him slip on his ring and disappear right in front of them. And off Bilbo went, singing rude songs and leading the spiders away while the dwarves scurried off to relative safety.

 

“Here am I, naughty little fly; 

you are fat and lazy. 

You cannot trap me, though you try, 

in your cobwebs crazy. ”

 

When Bilbo snuck back to where the elf-fires were, the dwarves were already there. There must have been some remaining trace of elf-magic on the ground for the spiders dared not draw near. When they saw Bilbo, the dwarves showered him with questions about the whole disappearing business. So Bilbo told them everything, from when he fell to the creature Gollum's cave, the riddles game and how he got the ring as a present for winning it, and lastly until he snuck out and found them again.

 

One by one, the dwarves slowly drifted off to slumber as Bilbo told his story, as they were still weak because of the spider’s poison. When all of them had fallen asleep, Bilbo kept watch and counted the dwarves.

 

“Fíli and Kíli,” he murmured to the two figures huddled together.

 

“Balin and Dwalin, that makes four,” he sighed to the bald head that rested on white beard.

 

“Dori, Nori, and Ori, that’s seven,” he muttered to the three figures in knitwear.

 

“Óin and Glóin,” he mumbled to the red and white hair that clashed as they slept while sitting back to back.

 

“Bofur, Bombur, and Bifur, that’s twelve!” said he at last to the two figures curling around a much rounder one, feeling satisfied that everybody was here.

 

Then realization dawned on him. He shook Dwalin awake and demanded,

 

“Where is Thorin?!”

 

The dwarves woke up groggily, roused by the ruckus Bilbo made, but they quickly became alert when they realized their leader was missing. After a round of questions, it became clear that no one had seen their leader after he jumped into the middle of the second elf-fires. Bilbo felt an overwhelming sense of dread creep into his mind, for this meant that either Thorin was captured by the elves or he was eaten by the spiders.

 

While the company argued amongst themselves whether or not they should head back to the spider’s nest and try to find Thorin there, a sudden flash of light momentarily blinded them as many torches appeared around them, like hundreds of red stars. Out from the trees leapt Wood-elves with their bows drawn and spears ready to thrust, calling the dwarves to halt. All of the Company members were easily captured for they couldn’t put up a decent fight even if they wanted to. All except for Bilbo, who had slipped on his ring without thinking and was pushed aside by one of the dwarves.

 

Bilbo was surprised and bewildered but silently followed the elves and the rest of the bound and blindfolded dwarves, hoping that Thorin was with the elves as well and not in the spiders’ stomachs.  He followed them through the forest, to the bridge, and past the gate of the king. That brought them to a small and well built passage, lit with torches all along the sides. Bilbo took a deep breath, enjoying the much cleaner air around him.

 

They were brought before the Elvenking, and though he looked grimly at them, he told his men to unbind them, for they were ragged and weary and there was no escape through his enchanted doors for those who were brought inside. King Thranduil questioned them long and searchingly about their doings but the dwarves were as tight lipped as ever. They were surly and angry and they had not forgotten that the Elvenking had abandoned them, they may never forgive.

 

Bilbo briefly entertained the idea of making himself known and negotiated with the Elvenking. However he did not have a leg to stand on this side of the Misty Mountains. He doubted Thranduil would care for the words from the leader of the hobbits, seeing how poorly he treated the dwarves that used to be his neighbour. He also did not know the elves enough to find the right way to push for his desired outcome. The best plan for now is to remain invisible and to observe .

 

Bilbo felt very amused throughout the questioning, for it seemed that King Thranduil was not very skilled at questioning people. The dwarves were tired and starving, questioning them should have been as easy as making a seed-cake. Bilbo almost let out a chuckle when the Elvenking sent them away in frustration and told the guards to put them in separate cells and to be given meagre food and drink until they were willing to talk.

 

The invisible hobbit followed the guards carefully and silently as they placed each dwarf in their cell. The halls were dimly lit so Bilbo did not worry so much about the shadow he might cast. Bilbo took note of all their twelve cells in different places of the palace. Clearly this place was not built to house so many prisoners in separate places, as some of the cells were not cells at all.  

 

Glóin was locked in an old broom cupboard. Bilbo knew this for he saw the elves clearing the room of some ancient looking cleaning supplies before they locked Glóin inside. Bifur was locked in a small spear closet near the kitchen and poor Ori was put in some sort of an attic. After he knew where all twelve of them were being kept, Bilbo snuck back to Balin’s cell.

 

“Mister Balin,” Bilbo whispered as he took off his ring after making sure no one else was there.

 

“Bilbo!” said Balin, “Good to see you alive and well!”

 

“What do we do now?” asked Bilbo urgently.

 

“I’m afraid I haven’t the slightest clue,” said Balin, “Though I was hoping we would know what happened to Thorin, the Elvenking didn’t mention him earlier.”

 

“Well I could sneak around and try to find out...” suggested Bilbo.

 

“You understand Elvish?” asked Balin.

 

“Conversational Sindarin, yes. The elves here have a different accent than Imladris elves but I still understand what they say, more or less,” Bilbo explained.

 

Balin looked fairly impressed,

 

“If that is so then please do, Bilbo,” he said.

 

“Do you have any message to the others?”

 

“Just tell them not to lose heart.”

 

Bilbo nodded then his stomach growled, and he realized that he was very hungry. Balin chuckled at the sound while Bilbo felt a little embarrassed.

 

“Here laddie, you can share with me,” said Balin offering his untouched plate.

 

It was not much, but it was more than what they had eaten on the few last days before their supplies ran out. But Bilbo knew that Balin must also be very hungry and he didn’t have the heart to eat his share,

 

“It’s alright, Mister Balin, I’ll just sneak to the kitchen,” said Bilbo even though he was not sure he could manage to poach anything from the elves.

 

“If you say so,” said Balin, “Stay safe,Bilbo.”

 

Bilbo put on his ring and left Balin’s cell. He wandered for a while before he realized that he had no idea where the kitchen was. But Bilbo Baggins was quite a lucky hobbit for an elf holding a jug and a plate passed him. Bilbo followed him silently and the elf did lead him to the kitchen. There was another elf, who seemed to be the cook, inside the large room. Bilbo snuck into the pantry and took a loaf of bread as he listened in to their conversation.

 

“ Han mauya annoes nin Naugrim,” said the elf with the jug.

 

Bilbo recognized some of the words, annoes - give food and Naugrim which was one of the unpleasant names given for dwarves. It was likely that this elf was the one that responsible for feeding the dwarves.

 

“Ma pen?” asked the cook.

 

“I min gador-dad,” answered the other.

 

‘Gador-dad, prison-below, a dungeon?’ Bilbo perked at the mention. 

 

None of the others were locked in a dungeon, it could very well be Thorin that the elves were talking about. Bilbo quickly finished his bread, he wasn’t full yet but there might not be another chance, and followed the elf whose jug was now full of water and plate was filled with bread and some meat.

 

He walked silently behind as the elf went down two flights of stairs, the halls becoming darker and darker as they went deeper down, into the eerily silence of the underground chambers. Finally they reached a heavy oak door. Bilbo stayed back as the elf unlocked the door, went in, and replaced the jug and plate in his hands with empty ones. Throughout the process, the prisoner inside didn’t say anything and Bilbo couldn’t see who was inside for he dared not get too near; thus, Bilbo couldn’t be sure who was inside.

 

But the elf had clearly said a dwarf, so who else could it be? Bilbo decided to risk it and went to the door after the elf left and the echoes of his steps were no longer heard.

 

“Thorin! Is that you?” Bilbo whispered to the keyhole.

 

There was no answer.

 

“Thorin?” Bilbo tried again.

 

“My ears hadn’t deceived me,” came the answer from inside, “Is that really you, Bilbo?”

 

Bilbo felt his knees go weak with relief for he could not mistake who that voice belonged to.

 

“Yes! I’m so glad that you are here!” cried Bilbo, “We thought you were eaten by the spiders!”

 

“Spiders? What spiders?” asked Thorin, for he was captured after he fell asleep under the elven enchantment when he stepped in the second elf-fires - much like Bilbo, other than Bilbo was captured by a spider and not the elves - and thus knew nothing of the giant spiders.

 

So Bilbo sat down, leaned his back on the door, and told Thorin about how they were captured by giant spiders, how they escaped but only to be captured again by the elves. As Bilbo recounted the story, he became more and more aware of Thorin’s presence behind the door, and his heart started to beat faster. When he finished his story Thorin said,

 

“You saved them, Bilbo. Thank you.”

 

His voice was soft like a low rumble of the wind, coloured with relief and endearment. Bilbo felt his face flush and his heart was so loud he could hear it in his ears.

 

“Y-you’re welcome,” said Bilbo, willing himself to calm down.

 

Silence reigned upon them, stretched on like the woods, and Bilbo felt his heart was impossibly loud.

 

“Is there any message you want to send to the others?” asked Bilbo when he couldn’t bear the awkward silence anymore.

 

Thorin hummed in answer and then said,

 

“Please tell them that I am safe and not to reveal anything about our journey.”

 

“Understood,” said Bilbo.

 

“And also that we need to find a way to escape from here,” added Thorin.

 

“Is there anything else?” asked Bilbo as he stood up and got ready to leave.

 

“Just one more thing,” said Thorin, “Will you come back?”

 

Bilbo froze like a goat before a troll. 

 

His breath caught as he forced a small “Yes” out of his mouth. And he all but ran away from the door, up the two flights of stairs, and found a small dark corner where he sat down, knees to his chest, trying to rein his erratic breathing. He calmed down a tad, not much but he could think a little more clearly.

 

‘What was that?’ thought Bilbo. 

 

His mind repeated the events that had happened in the dungeon, the moment that he and Thorin shared. Bilbo felt warmth blooming inside him and found himself smiling fondly.

 

‘ Oh no, ’ He froze, the smile on his face contorting into exasperation. He shook his head as hard as possible, as if he could shake the feeling out of his mind if he tried hard enough. He hugged his knees and rested his head on them as he thought, ‘This can’t be happening.’

 

As Bilbo snuck around the palace to deliver Thorin’s message to the dwarves, he became more and more resigned that it had happened, and there was nothing he could do about it . Bilbo tried to ignore it at first and focused on his task at hand.

 

Balin was very much delighted that Thorin was alive and well. Dwalin agreed vehemently that they should not tell the elves anything.  Glóin cried in despair that they could never escape from this place. Óin couldn’t seem to hear him at all and after he tried to talk as loud as he dared, he gave up and called it a day for it was already very late.

 

The next day Bilbo found that he couldn’t ignore it as everything reminded him of Thorin. Bilbo saw him in Fíli’s eyes as he worriedly asked about his brother and asked Bilbo to pass a message to him. He felt his hand when Nori patted him on his back through the bars as he gave Bilbo some tips for sneaking around. He recognized Thorin’s smile in Kíli’s when he brought him not only his uncle’s message but his brother’s as well. He even heard Thorin’s voice slightly when Bifur answered him in rumbling Khuzdul from inside the closet.

 

As the night fell, Bilbo snuck into the empty kitchen and stole some food. After he ate, he wandered around to find a dark and remote place to rest. As he wandered, lost in his own thoughts, his feet brought him down the two flights of stairs to the heavy oak door.

Bilbo stopped right in front of it, holding in his sigh as he didn’t want to alert Thorin of his presence. He pressed his ear to the door and could hear a slight rustling and footsteps from inside. That night, Bilbo slept in front of the door with his ear pressed to it, letting the slight noises lull him to slumber, invisible and alone.

 

The next morning, he was woken up by the footsteps echoing towards the dungeon. He quickly got up and hid himself in a dark corner. As soon as the elf was inside Thorin’s cell, Bilbo snuck back upstairs and went to the attic where Ori was being kept. Luckily the door had no lock but just a latch so Bilbo slowly undid the latch and snuck in, leaving the door slightly ajar so he would not be locked inside. Ori let out a strangled yelp when Bilbo took off his ring and appeared from the thin air.

 

“Mister Baggins, you ruined my sketch!” said Ori.

 

“Never mind that,” said Bilbo, “I have a message from Thorin.”

 

Bilbo told him the message, Ori listened carefully as he twirled the charcoal in his hand unconsciously. Bilbo watched as Ori made a complicated twirl and an idea struck him.

 

“Ori, can you write out the message so I can show it to Óin?” asked Bilbo.

 

Of course Ori could do it, he was an aspiring scholar after all. So Bilbo left the attic with a small note tucked in his pocket. He carefully put the latch back as they agreed that it was better not to raise any suspicion for the meantime. He passed the note to Óin, then assured Dori that his brothers were perfectly fine, then promised Bombur he would try to sneak some more food for him, and lastly he went to Bofur’s cell. Bofur listened to the message then he took one good look at him and queried,

 

“What troubles your mind, Bilbo?”

 

Bilbo gaped at him in surprise

 

“Is it really obvious?” he asked.

 

“Not really,” said Bofur, “I just have a good eye for things like that.”

 

Bilbo nodded but he didn’t answer. Bofur was a dear friend, but his predicament felt too personal to be shared comfortably.  And as if Bofur could read his mind, he said,

 

“It’s fine if you can’t tell. Maybe I could tell you a story to ease your mind?” Bofur offered.

 

Bilbo shook his head and Bofur hummed knowingly. They sat in companionable silence for some time and after a while Bilbo started to feel silly for mulling about it. Bofur seemed to sense his mood shifting, gave him a pat on the back, and gave him a supportive smile. At last, he left Bofur’s cell, went back to the kitchen to steal dinner, and waited for the elf that would bring Thorin’s food.

 

“ Ha sí?” the elf asked as he came in the kitchen.

 

“ Né,” answered the cook shortly as he gave the jug and plate to the elf.

 

“ Hannad,” the elf grumbled as he carried them out.

 

Bilbo followed him again but this time he followed the elf inside Thorin’s cell. It was a medium sized room, as big as his bedroom in Bag End. It was very bare and lit with two torches. He snuck into a dark corner and waited until the elf had left and locked the door behind him before he took off his ring.

 

“Bilbo Baggins!” exclaimed Thorin. “It’s good to see you.”

 

Bilbo smiled nervously in reply.

 

“Have you got any news?” asked Thori.

 

Bilbo didn’t know much besides the fact that the meals were given twice a day, once at dusk and once at dawn, other than that they mostly left them alone. But when he told Thorin, the dwarf king looked a little relieved for the dungeon was very deep and dark, and Thorin had lost track of time; now he had a means to keep track of its passing.

 

“You might as well stay here at night then,” said Thorin after a while, “No one ever comes down here other than to deliver the meals. We could continue with your… training.”

 

His mouth agreed with Thorin’s suggestion before his mind caught up with the repercussions. But even if it had, Bilbo wasn’t sure that he would have declined. On one hand, night after night locked in a room with Thorin, while on the other hand, night after night locked in a room with Thorin.

 

They quickly fell into a routine where Bilbo would sneak around gathering information or passing messages to the other dwarves during the day, then sneak back into Thorin’s cell to train and rest during the night. Thorin wanted him to practice sparring but they couldn’t spar with only one sword, so Bilbo had to make do with stance, guard, and striking drills.

 

After a week or two of this sneaking sort of life he got to know his way around the palace very well and he held his sword with much greater ease. He also was a great deal calmer, for Thorin didn’t seem to feel or act any differently towards him, so it could not go anywhere.

 

In the meantime, Bilbo did learn a few useful facts. For instance there was one door that was not secured with magic, a trap door that led into the Forest River that flowed to the Long Lake. The elves used it to dispose of empty barrels. Also, the elves would have a feast in the forest in a few days time, leaving the palace almost empty. Based on those facts, Bilbo and Thorin hatched a plan.

 

They would sneak out when the elves were out partying and hide inside empty barrels until the elves came the next morning and dropped them through the trapdoor. They would ride inside the barrels until they reached Laketown, where the barrels would be refilled.

 

“But who’s going to pack in the last one?” asked Thorin.

 

“I won’t be packed inside,” said Bilbo, “I will keep the ring on and cling to a barrel. We need someone to let all of you out when we reach Laketown anyway.”

 

There was also the problem of rendering the remaining guards unconscious. Dwalin was more than happy to show him some places that he thought could render an elf unconscious if hit hard enough. With the details and precision of his description, Bilbo started to suspect that he had thought of doing this many times before. More useful help came from Nori, who had a bottle of sleeping draught with him.

 

“One drop for men, three drops for dwarves, so I say around one third of a bottle for elves,” instructed Nori when he gave it to Bilbo.

 

Bilbo took the bottle gingerly and decided that he didn't want to know why Nori knew such things or even how he had the draught when all of their gears were confiscated when they were caught.

 

The night before the feast, Bilbo was so nervous he couldn’t sleep. He tossed and turned in his corner, trying to rid his mind of the images of hundreds of ways their plan could go wrong.

 

“Are you cold?” asked Thorin.

 

“No, not really,” Bilbo answered skittishly, “I’m fine.”

 

But a heavy fur coat was draped over him.

 

“Sleep, we’ll need our strength tomorrow,” said Thorin as he stalked back to his own corner.

Bilbo tugged the coat closer to his body and took a deep breath. It smelled musty and had a tang of sweat but it calmed him down all the same. Bilbo quickly nodded off, dreaming of strong hands and warm embrace.

 

The next morning he was woken up by Thorin himself. He heard echoing footsteps in the hall outside and realized that he had slept in. He quickly got up and tidied himself, making sure that his sword was on his belt and the sleeping draught was in his pocket. He gave Thorin his coat back and thanked him. Right as Bilbo was about to put on his ring, Thorin said,

 

“Bilbo...I was wondering...”

 

“Yes?” Bilbo looked at the dwarf curiously.

 

“Would you consider staying in Erebor after all this?”

 

Bilbo felt the calm that he had painstakingly gained these past two weeks fly out the window. He wanted to choke Thorin for his bad timing but the footsteps were getting closer and he could hear the key turning inside the lock so he muttered his answer and quickly put on the ring. The elf came in and looked around suspiciously.

 

“Who are you talking to?” asked the elf, “I’m sure I heard more than one voice!”

 

“Nobody in particular,” answered Thorin without missing a beat, “Or to be more accurate, myself.”

 

The elf looked at Thorin as if he had lost his mind but he didn’t pursue with further questioning. He muttered something that Bilbo was sure translated into ‘crazy dwarf’ and changed the plate and jug, and did not notice Bilbo slip out.

 

The first thing he did that day was visit Fíli’s cell. He followed the elf who was bringing food for the dwarves closely and as soon as the elf went away, Bilbo pulled off his ring and stared at the young dwarf through the bars with a very serious expression.

 

“What does it mean, when a dwarf asks you to stay at Erebor after all this?”

 

Fíli’s face lit up with excitement.

 

“Uncle asked you that? Finally!” said he.

 

“I didn’t say... What do you mean by ‘finally’?” spluttered Bilbo.

 

“That’s not important,” Fíli shrugged off his question, “What did you say?”

 

Bilbo froze at the question before answered with a soft voice,

 

“I said that I would, if I had a reason to stay.”

 

“Really? You would?” asked Fíli in surprise.

 

“He didn’t ask me if I could,” said Bilbo.

 

Uncomfortable silence befell them.

 

“I should go,” said Bilbo and he put on his ring and left before Fíli could say anything else.

 

Before he got too far Bilbo cursed for he hadn’t told Fíli that the plan was going to happen that night. He considered going back but decided against it. So he went around to inform the others and saved Fíli for last. When he was at last back in front of Fíli’s cell, he quickly passed the information and, thankfully, Fíli said nothing about their earlier exchange.

 

As the sun went down, Bilbo watched as the evening meal was taken to the prisoners. The elves rode out for an autumn feast, leaving only the head guard and a young elf with yellow hair in the palace. The chief guard stood guard near the cellar while the young elf stood guard near the attic where Ori was kept.

 

Bilbo crept in slowly and tipped one third of the sleeping draught into the head guard’s jug. The guard took a few mouthfuls and very soon the chief guard’s head bobbed up and down sleepily. He fought to stay awake for a short time, but laid his head on the table and fell fast asleep. When the hobbit tried to do the same to the young elf, a loud sound startled him and he poured what was left inside the bottle in the elf’s jug. Bilbo hid himself quickly behind a shadow and watched as the elf drank his water and dropped down in an instant.

 

Bilbo approached the elf warily, wondering if he had put in too much. But the elf was still breathing and though he would sport a bump on his head after he woke up, he looked otherwisely fine. So Bilbo left him on the floor and went on to his task.

 

He hurriedly freed the dwarves and led them to the cellar, where barrels were already standing in rows in the middle of the floor waiting to be pushed off. They quickly found thirteen with room enough for a dwarf in each. In fact, some were too roomy, and as they climbed in the dwarves thought anxiously of the shaking and the bumping they would have to endure inside the casks. Bilbo did his best to find straw and other stuff to pack them in as cosily as could be managed in a short time.

 

Dawn was nearing and only a minute or two after Balin's lid had been fitted on came the sound of voices and the flicker of torch lights. The guards had arrived to roll the barrels down the trapdoor. And so they did, one by one, the guards seemed to be still under the influence of the festivity’s wine for they didn’t notice that the barrels were heavier than they should be. Bilbo caught hold of the last barrel and was pushed over the edge with it. Down into the water he fell, into the cold dark water with the barrel on top of him. And off they floated away from the shadows of Mirkwood.