Actions

Work Header

Baggins of The Shire

Chapter 11: Chapter 10 - The Course of True Love Never Did Runs Smooth

Notes:

In which Bilbo was sick, Thorin was worried, and there is enough angst to feed thirteen dwarves.

Similar to previous chapter, this chapter has a lot of the previous version and was originally beta-ed by Livingmeatloaf.

Chapter Text

The ride was arduous and the river was rough. Bilbo managed to keep his head above the water but the water made the barrel slippery so Bilbo clung to his barrel as tight as he could, fearing that he might lose his grip every time the rapids jarred and tossed him around. He watched as the sun rose up in the sky and he got colder and colder even though it was a bright sunny day. By the time the sun started to go down, Bilbo was shivering and his hand had cramped around his grip. When night fell, Bilbo saw there were people on the look-out on the banks. They quickly prodded and pushed all the barrels together into the shallows and, after counting them, they roped them together and left them there until the morning.

 

He stiffly released his grip from his barrel and waded ashore; a man stood guard over the barrels so Bilbo couldn’t release the dwarves. Bilbo scuttled closer to the man’s fire. Luckily, it was dark so the guard didn’t notice Bilbo’s weak shadow or the dark wet patch that was growing around where the hobbit sat. He was hungry but he dared not go into the huts that he saw for he surely would leave some wet trails and footprints and he didn’t want to leave the dwarves. So he slept lightly that night, partly because he was cold, another part because he was hungry and because he feared he might be found out.

 

Morning came in a blanket of soft grey light, and there was a merry racket down by the river. The people were making up a raft of the barrels, and the elves would soon steer it off down the stream to Lake-town. Bilbo’s clothes had dried overnight but he felt stiff and chilled all over. There was no space on the make-shift raft where Bilbo could stand without being trampled, so he waded back into the cold water with determination and clung to the rope that tied the barrels together.

 

The ride was much smoother than before and the rope turned out to be a better grip but the water was just as cold. Poor Bilbo was chilled to the bone and shaking badly. Luckily the rush of water hid the sound of his teeth clacking. Still, his arms and shoulders were very sore and only by willpower and sense of self-preservation did Bilbo manage to keep his grip and his head above the water as another day passed.

 

It was dark when they reached Laketown. True to its name, it was not built on the shore but right out on the surface of the lake, protected from the swirl of the entering river by a promontory of rock which formed a calm bay. The night had fallen and the elves of the raft and the boatmen went to sup in Laketown. This meant Bilbo had to release the dwarves now for soon men would come up from the South and take some of the casks away, and others they would fill with goods they had brought to be taken back up the stream to the Wood-elves' home.

 

Bilbo’s head was pounding and he was very cold. He stumbled on his every other step as he cut loose a barrel and pushed it to the shore.  Out came Thorin when he opened the top; he was dry but he tripped out of his barrel to the shore because his limbs were numb after the prolonged time in the cramped barrel. He lied groaning on the shore as feelings came back to them and his limbs felt like they were poked by thousands of pins and needles.

 

“Help me! We have to be quick,” said Bilbo, or so he thought he said. What actually came out of his mouth was a slurred mumble.

 

Thorin looked at him with concern while still sitting on the muddy beach, rubbing life back into his feet. It would be a while until Thorin would be any help, so Bilbo left him and got back to work, cutting loose another barrel while his head felt like a scrambled egg and his breath was getting ragged. 

 

Out came Kíli when he opened it, more or less smiling with only a little stiffness in his limbs.

 

Kíli recovered much faster than Thorin, who was still groaning on the ground, and by the time Bilbo released the next barrel - which happened to contain Fíli - he was on his feet and helping his brother out of the barrel. Fíli was not much worse for wear than Kíli, with only an additional bruise or two.  

 

Bilbo was about to go and release another barrel when he tripped on his own feet and landed on his bum. The ground on the shore was soft, cushioning his fall. Thorin, who had finally recovered, got up and said,

 

“Rest for a while, Bilbo. We will release the others.”

 

Bilbo nodded but the movement made his head dizzy. He blinked hard to get his vision cleared and saw Thorin talk to his nephews, and soon the three of them waded through the shallow water, knocking and calling the dwarves’ names to find the right barrels to release.

 

He watched as Balin stumbled out and cracked his joints and Dwalin rubbed on a bump on his forehead. Glóin and Óin were less knocked about but a little water had leaked in their barrels so now they were trying their best to dry their clothes. Bofur turned out to be seasick and he threw up whatever was left in his stomach as soon as he was out of his barrel. Bifur was perfectly fine and was fast asleep when they opened his barrel.

 

His vision starting to blur again, Bilbo closed his eyes and scrunched his face, willing the blur to go away. When he opened his eyes again, Dori, Nori, and Ori were sitting on the shore slapping their arms and rubbing their legs while the other dwarves were trying to help Bombur get unstuck from his barrel.

 

‘I should get up and help them’ , thought Bilbo.

 

So he did. But suddenly, the world tilted around him and he fell down again, this time on his face. The damp mud was cold on his cheek and it felt so nice. The dwarves shouldn’t be too angry if he closed his eyes for a while. Just a little while and he would get up and help them.  As Bilbo drifted off, he could hear an exclamation from the dwarves.

 

‘Has something happened? I should get up and see…’

 

But his eyelids felt like they were made from lead and his body refused to move at his will. Then he felt something heavy and warm draped around him, there was some shuffling, and he was floating in a warm cocoon.  He felt a rush of cold wind on his face.

 

‘Am I flying? No one ever told me that hobbits could fly! Maybe Mum just forgot, like how she always forgot to tell Father where I’ve been when I snuck out to the woods.’

 

Suddenly they came to a halt, he was no longer flying but he thought he was still floating. He hoped he would not suddenly drop down. He heard some clattering and people shouting, though he could barely hear what they were saying through the thick fog inside his head.

 

“....in peace...your arms...” said an unfamiliar voice.

 

“...have none...your master...worn...injured...” said another rumbling voice, a familiar one.

 

‘That’s not true!’ Bilbo thought with his fuzzy head.  

 

He had two arms and they were perfectly fine, the trolls didn’t rip them off. He must move them and tell Thorin that so the shouting would stop for it was hurting his head. Bilbo tried as he might but only managed to shuffle a little and whimper. At that, the cocoon around him tightened and the disagreement stopped. Bilbo hummed and curled himself tighter inside the cocoon; it seemed he had somehow managed to put his argument across.

 

They were moving again and he was flying again! Bilbo started to think that maybe the flying had something to do with the dwarves. Thorin would look very grand if he could fly, his coat would go all swishy behind him. Bilbo wanted to giggle at the image of Thorin flying with his coat fluttering behind him like a great cape but when he opened his mouth the air was cold on his dry throat and he fell into a coughing fit.

 

His cocoon burst and he was dropped down onto a soft surface. Then there were hands, big and calloused, starting to take off his clothes. Bilbo tried to struggle because he liked his clothes and he just fixed that waistcoat! But the hands were strong and unyielding, and the familiar rumbling voice hushed him.

 

“...wet...chest cold...” was all Bilbo could make out.

 

‘Of course my chest is cold now,’ thought Bilbo. But a warm sheet was pulled up and covered him from his toes to his cheeks. The hands caressed his forehead softly, they felt cold and nice, and Bilbo quickly drifted off to sleep.

 

He opened his eyes and he saw a wooden ceiling. He blinked, and the ceiling was still there. He turned his head to the right and saw Thorin, who was only wearing a tunic and a pair of trousers, his mail and coat strangely absent. He was soaking something in a basin; he lifted it up and Bilbo saw that it was a napkin. The dream he had before was already lost from his mind. Thorin pressed the water out from the napkin and folded it, then turned to Bilbo.

 

“Go back to sleep,” said Thorin as he put the napkin on Bilbo’s forehead.

 

‘What a nice dream,’ thought Bilbo as he did as told and fell into a dreamless sleep this time.

 

When he woke up again, he was very confused. The last thing he remembered clearly was Bombur getting stuck in his barrel and his head pounding as if someone took a hammer and hit it from the inside. Right now, his head didn’t hurt and he was inside a wooden room. The ceiling was very high unlike the one in Bag-End. The bed was also much larger than he was used to.

 

He looked around and the size of the furniture confirmed his suspicion that he was in a room built for men. This meant they had arrived safely in Laketown. He also saw a figure sitting beside his bed, his head resting on folded arms that lay on the edge of Bilbo’s bed. Thorin was only wearing a tunic and a pair of trousers and was snoring lightly, his dark 

mane tied up in a ponytail and his braids spread on the bed.

 

Bilbo noticed that his throat was parched and realized that he was very thirsty. He could see a water basin on top of the drawers beside his bed but he couldn’t find a jug or a cup in sight. He was about to wake Thorin up when the door opened.

 

“Ah Bilbo, you’re awake!” said Balin quietly as he closed the door behind him.

Bilbo nodded and eyed the water jug in Balin’s hand hopefully. And as if he could read his mind, Balin poured out a cup and handed it to him.

 

“Here, you must be thirsty.”

 

"Thag you very buch," said Bilbo with a raspy voice.

 

He sipped the water slowly and cleared his throat.

 

“How long?” he asked.

 

“Two nights have passed since we were released from our barrels and it’s almost noon today,” answered Balin.

 

Bilbo nodded and took another sip.

 

“Are we in Laketown?”

 

“Aye, we had a very warm welcome and a large house was given to our company,” explained Balin.

 

“And...” Bilbo glanced at the dwarf that was still sleeping at his bedside, “Thorin?”

 

“Thorin has hardly left your side since we arrived here,” Balin smiled. “He helped Óin nurse you through your fever.”

 

Bilbo looked at the sleeping dwarf fondly, his hand moving to touch him while the other hand still held his cup. He touched Thorin’s braids’ ends and caressed them between his fingers gently, feeling the coarse hairs rubbing against each other.

 

‘This isn’t fair,’ thought Bilbo, ‘how could I pretend that I felt nothing when you are so kind?’

 

“I see that his feelings are returned,” said Balin simply.

 

Bilbo retracted his hand as if he touched a hot surface. He turned to Balin and opened his mouth to retort but the sudden intake of breath sent him into a coughing fit. Balin quickly rushed to his side, took the cup from his hand, and patted his back. The commotion woke Thorin; Bilbo saw him watching him as his cough receded into wheezes.

 

“You’re awake,” said Thorin.

 

Bilbo just nodded, unable to say anything for he was still wheezing.

 

“How are you feeling?” asked Thorin.

 

“Better,” Bilbo wheezed, “Tired but better.”

 

Thorin nodded.

 

“Rest. I’ll call for Óin.”

 

And he left the room. Bilbo watched his back as he caught his breath until the door closed and it was no longer visible. Balin watched him and from his face he could tell that the old dwarf was excited .

 

“He cares for you a great deal, Bilbo. But I’m afraid his pride would hinder him from courting you until we reclaimed Erebor,” said Balin as he shot Bilbo a meaningful look with a glint of teasing in his eyes.

 

Bilbo sighed in despair; how come the dwarves thought this was exciting and amusing? It was not, it was suffocating and hopeless and they should know exactly why. But Balin still nursed a small smile on his lips and it grated Bilbo’s nerves badly. There was an angry light in Bilbo’s eyes and his kindly face grew hard.

 

“Are you saying that I should pursue him?” asked Bilbo calmly. “And condemn both of us to a life pining for each other from the opposite ends of Middle Earth, never to move on?”

 

Bilbo watched as all traces of amusement left Balin’s face, replaced by weariness and resignation.

 

“It was already like that for Thorin, for, us dwarves only love once and never again.”

 

Now Bilbo felt slightly guilty, but was it so wrong to want to have the possibilities of loving someone else and moving on for himself? 

 

‘But how likely would that be, with you knowing someone you love this much will continue to love you and only you?’ his mind supplied very unhelpfully.

 

“And I always think that both of you will find a way,” continued Balin, “Maybe you could stay in Erebor--”

 

“If we came out of this journey alive, I have to go back to the Shire,” Bilbo cut him off, “You of all people should know that, Mister Balin...”

 

Before Balin could say anything else, the door opened. In came Thorin, carrying a teapot and a cup, and Óin, bringing a satchel of assorted medicines and medical supplies. Óin quickly came to his bedside, checking his pulse and temperature and other things while Thorin stood back and exchanged looks with Balin.

 

“Don’t just stand there, laddie,” scolded Óin, pulling out his brand-new ear trumpet, “Come and give Mister Baggins his tea!”

 

Thorin just nodded. He poured the tea into a cup and handed it to Bilbo. Bilbo took a sip and almost spat it out again.

 

“What is this?”

 

“My original concoction,” said Óin, “Fenugreek, ginger, turmeric, and pepper!”

 

Bilbo eyed the cup warily and, against his better judgement, he took another sip. It still tasted as bad as before.

 

“Do I really have to?”

 

“Aye,” said Óin, “It will be good for your chest!”

 

Bilbo took a deep breath and finished his cup in a few large gulps. He coughed and choked after that and soon he was snorting snots and coughing out phlegm. Thorin watched him like a hawk while Óin tutted approvingly.  Óin took out a jar of salve that smelled like garlic and turpentine and instructed him to rub it on his chest. The concoction was vile and the salve was foul but they worked like a charm. Bilbo recovered quickly, in a few days he was right as rain.

 

On the days when he was recovering and confined to the bed, Thorin would come with Óin as he did his checkups and watch Bilbo closely. He would ask a question or two and then leave with Óin again. Bilbo was confused but he was mostly relieved that he didn’t have to have awkward conversations with the dwarf.

 

They stayed for a fortnight in Laketown and Thorin seemed to avoid being alone with him at any cost. He would excuse himself to talk to the town’s Master or another member of the company. So Bilbo was left with Balin’s words getting heavier in his mind, eliciting turmoil inside him.

 

They left Laketown in three large boats, laden with rowers and many provisions. In two days’ span, they rowed right up the Long Lake and passed out into the River Running. Now they could all see the Lonely Mountain towering grim and eerily vast before them. The peak was hidden in the clouds and its foot spanned wide. The air was dour and silence reigned, broken by no bird or sound except that of the wind in the crannies of stone. It was a wearying journey, and a quiet and stealthy one. Bilbo knew that they were drawing near to the end of their quest, and that it might be a very horrible end.

 

‘Soon I have to face the dragon’, thought Bilbo.

 

That should be enough to distract him from his internal turmoil.

 

They reached the skirts of the Mountain without meeting any danger or any sign of the Dragon other than the barren wilderness he had made about his lair. The Mountain lay dark and silent before them and ever higher above them.

 

Thorin sent out a scouting expedition to spy out the land to the South where the Front Gate stood. For this purpose, he chose Dwalin, Fíli, and Kíli. Bilbo went with them, for he wanted to put some distance between himself and Thorin.

 

They marched to the foot of Ravenhill; from there they could see into the wide valley shadowed by the Mountain's arms, the grey ruins of ancient houses, towers, and walls scattered on the barren land.

 

"That is all that is left of Dale," said Dwalin, "The valley used to be covered with green on the mountain's sides and at its heart the town was bright and rich."

 

Bilbo looked at the burnt remnants of the town, picturing its look once upon a time. Then he longed for the Shire. It was just past mid-Autumn, the trees would be bright with colours, the farmers would be preparing their land for the winter, the marsh would be covered with thick fog, and the markets would be full of pumpkins and mushrooms, Bilbo could even smell the fresh earthy smells from the stalls. Oh how he loved the Shire! And how proud was he to be its leader!

 

They strode along the riverbank to the south until they reached a great rock. Peering past the rock, they could see a cavernous opening between the arms of the Mountain. There was a watergate and through the lower bars water ran, but they also could see steam and dark smoke emitting ominously.

 

The valley was eerily silent and nothing moved in the waste. All four of the scouting party shuddered, and Dwalin decided that there was nothing else they could do over there and they should head back to camp.

 

On the way back, Bilbo took one last look at the ruins of Dale and made up his mind. He would help the dwarves as promised. Then he would return to the Shire, to his people, to his home, and Thorin would become the leader of another ally for the Shire. That and nothing more and it had to be enough.

 

Bilbo’s face set in grim anticipation: he couldn’t deny what he felt for Thorin therefore this would be hard . But he will do it for he is the Baggins and a good Baggins will endure any hardship for the welfare of hobbitfolk. The Shire came first and would always come before any personal whim Bilbo might have at the moment and he should stop looking for any loophole that might exist right now .

 

Thorin was waiting for them when they reached the camp. Bilbo felt his chest constrict at the sight of the dwarven King, already his mind racing for excuses that may let him be together with Thorin. Bilbo shooed the thought away, repeating his resolution like a mantra inside his head. He could do this, he must do this.

 

Bilbo stayed back as Dwalin immediately reported their findings and they discussed its possible meaning. They agreed that the dragon was still alive and guarding its hoard and that it was wise to approach the mountain from another direction rather than the front door. Thorin eyed Bilbo worriedly as he listened carefully to the other dwarf. Bilbo tried to smile reassuringly but it came out akin to a grimace.

 

When the discussion was over, Bilbo hurriedly went away to help the others pack but Thorin called after him.

 

“Bilbo, are you alright? Are you still unwell?”

 

Bilbo took a deep breath.

 

‘I will not act on my feelings. The Shire is and will always be my first priority.’

 

He repeated that in his head three more times before he answered.

 

“I’m fine. Thank you for your concern.”

 

“If you’re feeling up to it, I was wondering if you wanted to continue your sword training. We haven’t tried sparring,” said Thorin.

 

‘I will not act on my feelings.’ Bilbo thought forcefully.

 

“Can’t Dwalin or somebody else spar with me?” asked Bilbo.

 

“They can, but none of them had the grasp of swordsmanship and your ability as well as me. Or are you saying that I’ve been a bad teacher?” asked Thorin hotly, his eyes narrowed.

 

‘The Shire is and will always be my first priority.’

 

“I didn't mean it like that. I was thinking that you had spared enough of your time for my training,” Bilbo answered smoothly.

 

“My time is free for me to use as I see it fit. And I see it fit to fulfil my promise to teach you how to use your sword,” said Thorin, “So your answer is?”

 

“If that is the case then...” Bilbo hesitated

 

‘I will not act on my feelings. The Shire is and will always be…’

 

“I would really like that.”

 

‘ Oh bugger it! ’

 

“I’ll see you this afternoon after we move our camp, then,” said Thorin.

 

‘Sideways and twice over!’

 

Bilbo nodded and went to pack his belongings. He could feel Thorin’s eyes boring into his back and he tried his best to ignore him.  It had been decided that they would move the camp to one of the Lonely Mountain’s western spurs. They moved quickly and settled their new camp before sundown.

 

After Bilbo finished unpacking, he took his sword and headed to the clearing eastward from their camp. All the way there Bilbo convinced himself that he needed the training and he definitely did not accept Thorin’s offer just to spend more time with him. When Bilbo arrived at the clearing, Thorin was already there and he was doing a series of drills with a sword given to him by the men of Laketown.

 

Bilbo was mesmerized. It was a familiar drill, one of the drills that Thorin had taught him, but in Thorin’s hand the movements looked sharp and strong, twisting and turning like a rapid current. It was a pity that they couldn’t retrieve their weapons from the elves. Bilbo wondered how amazing it would look if Thorin was using Orcist. Thorin saw Bilbo and lowered the sword; he gestured for Bilbo to come closer and Bilbo did.

 

“We’ll warm up with several drills,” Thorin instructed, “I’ll be joining you because I need to get used to this sword.”

 

Thorin pulled the first stance. Bilbo unsheathed Sting and followed his stance.

 

“We’ll start with the second stance and guards drill,” said Thorin.

 

Bilbo nodded and they moved together in a rhythm. Step after step, stance after stance, and guard after guard. They breathed in sync as movements flowed through their bodies. They went on like that for another drill and another drill until Bilbo felt sweat forming on his back.

 

“Very good,” said Thorin when they finished their drills.

 

Bilbo thanked him and watched him closely for further instruction. His breath was slightly ragged and his heart was racing. Being so close to Thorin and so in tune with him felt so right. Bilbo wanted more, he wanted so much more even though he knew he couldn’t, even though he promised himself he wouldn’t.

 

“Now for the sparring, first you will come to me with all you have and we will work from there,” Thorin instructed.

 

Bilbo sheathed his sword and prepared to do just that. It would be a good way to vent his frustration without fearing he would inflict any damage.

 

“Why did you sheath your sword?” asked Thorin.

 

“Aren’t we going to spar?” Bilbo asked back.

 

“Aye and therefore, why did you sheath your sword?” asked Thorin again.

 

Bilbo frowned. Thorin wanted them to spar with an unsheathed sword?

 

“But one of us might get hurt,” Bilbo voiced out his concern.

 

“The weight and balance of a sword differs greatly whether it is sheathed or not. Also I won’t let that happen,” said Thorin. “Don’t you trust me?”

 

Bilbo felt his breath catch. Thorin’s blue eyes gazed at him, piercing and demanding, and Bilbo couldn’t find a reason not to trust this dwarf with his well being, with his life, with everything. So Bilbo unsheathed his sword again and settled into the stance he was most comfortable with.

 

“I do,” said Bilbo, looking straight into Thorin’s eyes.

 

“Remember your strikes and guards drill. Do not hesitate.” Thorin raised his sword and held his gaze. “Ready?”

 

Bilbo nodded.

 

“Go.”

 

And they clashed. Thorin blocked his first strike with ease, sending vibrations down the length of both of their swords. Bilbo was startled by the force but quickly brushed it off and swung his sword for another strike which Thorin blocked effectively too. Bilbo continued to make blow after blow, looking for an opening but failing to find it. Thorin blocked his blows with a calculating look and finally he deflected one particularly vicious blow to his chest and said,

 

“Defend yourself.”

 

And he started to attack. Bilbo was overwhelmed. Thorin came on strong and fast and Bilbo didn’t have time to think, he just instinctively pulled defensive guard after guard.  But Bilbo felt Thorin relent a little whenever he started to feel too overwhelmed then continue as soon as Bilbo composed himself a little.

 

They continued for a while and Bilbo started to fall into a rhythm when Thorin suddenly struck hard and close. Bilbo barely had time to block it and Thorin was so close to him. He could feel the dwarf’s breath hot on his face as blue eyes trained on him mere inches from his own. Bilbo staggered back, his sword still raised, and eyed Thorin warily.

 

Bilbo felt like a startled animal and felt the urge to dash away far from Thorin. But Thorin lowered his sword and straightened his back. The urge to flee subsided and Bilbo lowered his sword too.

 

“You used the strikes and guards effectively,” said Thorin. “You are quite agile but lacking in strength.”

 

“Thank you,” said Bilbo.

 

There wasn’t much he could do about strength but he definitely could take pride in his agility. The sun was almost down and the clearing was bathed in golden light, illuminating Thorin’s profile. Bilbo felt a twinge inside him and a treacherous thought crept up inside his mind.

 

‘If we’re going to part either way, why can’t we give it a go and enjoy it while it lasts?’

 

Bilbo shooed the thought away for it was selfish and unfair to Thorin. Bilbo also wasn’t sure he could let go when the time came.

 

“I think that’s enough for today,” Thorin’s voice broke him out of his reverie. “Shall we continue tomorrow?”

 

“Yes,” answered Bilbo.

 

They headed back to camp together, walking much closer than necessary. Bilbo’s heart skipped a beat every time Thorin’s arm brushed his shoulder. He wanted to pull away but at the same time he wanted to draw closer. Bilbo ignored Balin’s knowing look when they reached the camp and took his serving of dinner from Bombur. He sat near Bofur and Ori and let his thoughts drift while the dwarves' chattering washed over him.

 

For days, they toiled in parties searching for paths up the mountainside and in the afternoons Bilbo would come to the clearing to train. The training would always start with drills and after that Thorin would spar with him. Sometimes Thorin would pause the fight to correct him or advise him to make some moves more effective and then they would resume.

 

To Bilbo’s relief they were not always alone. Sometimes Balin and Dwalin or Fíli and Kíli would join them in the drills and the others would also spar on the clearing around them. But when they were alone it always felt very intense and intimate to Bilbo and it frayed his resolution fast. Bilbo realized he was fighting a losing battle with himself and hoped they would find the door soon and so put an end to his training.

 

Finally, Bombur found the path to the secret door unexpectedly one day. He was gathering herbs for dinner when he found a bunch of crocus growing not too high on the mountainside. Bombur was excited: he had heard rumours about the delicacy of saffron made from Erebor’s crocus. There was a slope not too far from the bunch and Bombur tread it carefully, but when he reached out to pick the flowers he slipped and landed on (and broke) some rough steps going upwards.

 

The others were excited and they followed those weathered steps with high spirits. The dwarves found traces of a narrow track, often lost, often rediscovered, that wandered on to the top of the southern ridge and brought them at last to a still narrower ledge, which turned north across the face of the Mountain. Looking down they saw that they were at the top of the cliff at the valley's head and were gazing down on to their own camp below.

 

Silently, clinging to the rocky wall on their right, they went in single file along the ledge, until the wall opened and they turned into a little steep-walled bay, grassy-floored, still and quiet.The entrance was hidden from below because of the overhang of the cliff and unseen from afar because of it small size. It was not a cave for it was open to the sky above; but at its inner end a flat wall rose up that, at the lower part, was as smooth and upright as a master mason's work, but without a joint or crevice to be seen.

 

The company was sure that they had found the door but they could not find a way to open it. It was the beginning of the first week of autumn and the sun began to sink. When they were about to give up, Bilbo heard a sharp crack behind him. There on the grey stone in the grass was an enormous thrush. Crack! It had caught a snail and was knocking it on the stone. Crack! Crack!

 

Bilbo watched the grey stone curiously as the sun sank lower and lower. It sank into a belt of reddened clouds and disappeared. The little moon was rising from the horizon. Evening was coming on. Then, suddenly, a red ray of the sun escaped like a finger through a rent in the cloud. A gleam of light came straight through the opening into the bay and fell on the smooth rock-face.

 

The old thrush, who had been watching from a high perch with beady eyes and head cocked on one side, gave a sudden trill. There was a crack. A flake of rock split from the wall and fell, leaving a keyhole about three feet from the ground.

 

"Thorin!” cried Bilbo, “Where’s the key?”

 

Thorin hurried up and held the key to Bilbo questioningly. Bilbo pointed to the keyhole and urged,

 

“Hurry! Try it now while there is still time!"

 

Thorin stepped up and drew the key on its chain from round his neck. He put it to the hole. It fit and it turned! Snap! The gleam went out, the sun sank, the moon was gone, and evening sprang into the sky. The door swung open slowly without being pushed; it seemed as if darkness flowed out like a thick vapour from the hole in the mountain-side, and deep darkness in which nothing could be seen lay before their eyes. The mouth of the tunnel led in and down.

 

Bilbo eyed the darkness warily. It was time to hold his end of the contract.