Actions

Work Header

Notices in the Paper

Chapter Text

A Case of Kitchen “Crookery”

Last evening, Mr. Proudfoot, our esteemed Great Smial cook, thought he heard a mid-night prowler in his kitchen- though it was only seven-o’clock- as he sat in his office, making the weekly orders. He got up to see who or what it was. The culprit was a Mr. Grindorol Bracegirdle, the scoundrel lately reported on in this paper! He tried to hide something- no doubt one of Mr. Proudfoots scrumptious baked goods- in his pocket and then made his escape. He also attempted to hide his face but it was a lost cause- Mr. Proudfoot recognized the silly hobbit. Let us print it plainly: Mr. Bracegirdle, if you want a pastie you’ve only to ask. You don’t need to resort to greedy prowling! After all this isn’t Bree.

-Tookland Weekly Observer



“But my husband has an alibi,” Thorin said forcefully, “he was at the party for Paladin Took, witnessed by many.”

“From seven o’clock onward, yes,” came Adalgrim’s voice, “but the cufflinks went missing between noon, when the guard passed through to make their checks and nine o’clock, when the evening guard made their rounds.

“Oh dear, it doesn’t sound as if Thorin is getting very far with him,” Esmeralda observed. She and Saradoc were seated outside Bilbo's cell. Further up the hall, Thorin was speaking with Adalgrim, who had lately been appointed jailer by Fontinbras. He had now taken up station in the old constable office.

“So you don’t have any real evidence that you’re innocent?” Esme said, turning back to Bilbo, “And what will you do if you’re found guilty?”

“Well I’m not going to stay here,” Bilbo said.

“Alright, but-”

“I’m still working on a plan,” Bilbo mused, “I’m thinking of escaping and running off to Buckland. He can only arrest me if I’m in the Shire.”

“You silly hobbit, Bilbo,” Esmeralda said. Saradoc groaned.

“There’s treaties,” he said unhappily. “Do not make me have to deal with extradition treaties!”

“Didn’t he offer you banishment?” Esme asked, “take that, and then you can live freely in Buckland.”

“But that’s admitting that I’m guilty- which I’m not- and also-”

“If you’re banished from the Shire you’ll most likely be banished in Buckland too,” Saradoc warned.

“What? I thought you were your own fiefdom?” Bilbo protested. “Are you going to let the Thain tell you to-”

“Bilbo, stop trying to start a war,” Esme growled at him.

“It’s a moot point- banishment is only an option if the cufflinks are returned. And I can’t return what I don’t have.”

“What a riddle,” Saradoc commented. Bilbo sent him a scathing look.

“He got the idea from that pretty little display near the kitchen of course!” came Adalgrim’s voice, “Advertising our anniversary showing of the cufflinks. And besides, of course he knew of them, they were his grandfather’s prize possession.”

“Ah! Impossible hobbit!” came Thorin’s raised voice. Bilbo perked up.

“He’s finally said that to someone other than me,” he said smiling.

“Congratulations,” Saradoc said.

⁂

Bilbo walked down the tunnel, dejected. He was invisible and had just spent the last two hours rummaging through Grindorol’s belongings. He’d found no trace of the cufflinks. He found Thorin, stationed at the cell, keeping a watch out for anyone who might have tried to come down to find Bilbo absent.

“No luck?” Thorin asked as he closed the gate and locked it once more. Bilbo flounced down and took off the ring.

“No luck,” he confirmed. They sat together in silence.

“Let’s think it though, step by step,” Bilbo said slowly, “alright, so last evening, after we told him off, Grindorol comes back here, fuming and confounded by the way we ran verbal circles around him.”

“Hm.”

“So, he walks back toward his room, scheming all the while, racking his brain for a way to get back at me. And what does he see? That display near the kitchens, advertising the exhibition of the cufflinks and other treasures of the Tooks. Well! There’s a prize, the most important item to the Tooks. No hobbit would ever consider stealing such a thing- except for a wild hobbit, polluted by the ideas of the Outside.”

“Hmm.”

“So, how would our friend Grindorol manage such a heist? Have I underestimated him?” Bilbo paused, “well, yes. I think I must have. He is a rather bad cheat, but he is enough of a cheat to fool most hobbits. And the treasury, for all the valuables locked in there, are only protected by a single locked door. More to keep people from wandering in. So Grindorol simply picked the lock.”

“That’s all?”

“Yes. You see,” Bilbo drew a roll of fabric from his coat pocket and let it fall open, “I discovered these in his room.” Thorin stepped close to the bars, peering at the roll. Small pieces of metal were fitted into delicate pockets in the roll.

“Lock picks.”

“Exactly.”

“Despite what you say, it looks as if there is at least one other burglar in the Shire,” Thorin said shaking his head.

“Oh I never said hobbits don’t pick locks. It’s a fairly common skill actually.”

“I don’t think I understand.”

“Hobbits are nosy and devious,” Bilbo nodded, “often it’s for sneaking in places to listen to private conversations, and as I said, there is a bit of burglary when it comes to food- slipping into some hated relation’s larder to steal the choicest bits of cheese and mushrooms and wine is fairly common. Oh yes, lock picking is a skill of many a young naughty hobbit.”

“So he picked the lock and broke into the treasury” Thorin said, “but where is the proof?”

“Well, I thought this roll of lock picks might do.”

“But if it’s a common skill…”

“Yes. There is that,” Bilbo sighed and took a seat. After a moment he resumed his narrative. “So he picks the lock, steals the cufflinks, and he makes his escape through the kitchen, located across from the treasury. He made his mistake there. He didn’t want to be witnessed at the scene of the crime, so he avoided the regular hallways, and he thought the kitchen would be deserted as the kitchen staff have their dinner at seven, it should have been deserted. But the old cook was up there doing the accounts and he was witnessed by the cook putting something in his pocket. The cook of course drew the wrong conclusion- that it was the regular most hobbity crime of food pilfering.” Bilbo paused shaking his head, “We have his means and motive and opportunity,” he muttered, “but we don’t have the key piece of evidence- the cufflinks themselves!”

“Do you suppose we could bring what we have to the Thain, might it be enough?” Thorin asked.

“I suppose it will have to be. But I think without the links, our case is not very strong. Everything that we have is circumstantial,” Bilbo sighed, “and I have searched that room from top to bottom. I don’t know where the links are, but he’s not hiding them there.”

“Perhaps he keeps them on his person,” Thorin mused. “We could have him searched.”

“We’ll hope that works.”

⁂

It did not. The search was carried out- Thorin’s insistence to Adalgrim made sure that it happened, and Grindorol was thoroughly searched, without prior warning, by the Hobbitry-in-arms. But the search was fruitless. Thorin reported all this to Bilbo, later in the day while Adalgrim brought him his tea.

“Where could the cufflinks be then?” Bilbo fumed.

“He must have hidden them somewhere. Some place of safekeeping.”

“We can’t search all of Tookland,” Bilbo groaned.

“I admit,” Adalgrim said as he closed the gate and bolted it once more, “he is a hobbit of bad character and I suppose I thought there was a chance he had them. But alas, without the links, Fontinbras will not arrest him.”

“Oh but he’ll arrest me!” Bilbo cried.

“You made your bed, Bilbo Baggins,” Adalgrim growled at him.

“So did he! He’s a damn liar and you know it.”

“But what motive does he have? He can’t sell those links, they’d be instantly recognized. Your motive is much more likely.”

“But it’s madness. And besides, he does have a motive. Framing me!”

“It’s a lot of trouble and risk just to frame you.”

“He did it, Adalgrim.”

“I’m really not convinced that he could. It would take a real burglar to break into the Treasury and escape without notice.”

“It takes one correctly sized lockpick and a bit of skill,” Bilbo sighed.

“I shouldn’t offer up that knowledge as your evidence,” Adagrim said.

⁂

They were out of time. The inquest would begin the next day. That evening, Bilbo sat in his cell, back against the wall, leaning against the bars, his arm out, holding Thorin’s hand. Frodo dozed in his lap.

“We’re just going to have to do the best we can,” Bilbo said quietly into the cold silent air. Thorin leaned down, pressing himself to the bars in an effort to get closer to him. Bilbo pulled his hand up and kissed it.

“We can’t even convince Adalgrim though,” Thorin whispered.

“Hm. Well. Maybe Fontinbras will listen,” Bilbo said, but he didn’t believe it.

“If they convict you, have you given any thought to where we might go?” Thorin said very quietly. Bilbo blinked, trying not to cry. As much as he tried to pretend otherwise, he was scared of the idea of never being able to live as a free hobbit in the Shire. And he was deeply wounded that he would never set foot into the home that his father had built and blessed him with. He could never make memories there with Thorin. He could never make memories there with Frodo.

“Buckland,” Bilbo whispered. “I know Saradoc has said some discouraging things, but when it comes down to it, I don’t think he’d really send me back to face prison. I think if he was forced to then he would at least give me a warning and enough time to flee. I think we could be safe there for a time.”

He felt Frodo curl tighter into a ball and glancing down, saw tears rolling down his cheeks. He put his free arm around Frodo, holding him close.

“It’s alright, lad,” he murmured gently, “whatever happens, it will be alright.”

“I want you to be able to go home,” Frodo whispered. Bilbo put his hand on Frodo’s head and said the only thing he knew to say.

“It will be alright. Everything will be alright.”