Actions

Work Header

Notices in the Paper

Chapter Text

Trial of the Age

The criminal Bilbo Baggins will be tested TODAY.

Upon whether the mysterious Bilbo Baggins, said to be a resident of Hobbiton, is a bona fide person, or whether he is a myth used to assist in the perpetration of a fraud and a crime shall be only one part of the interesting case to be heard before the Thain, today.

Of course everyone knows the tale by now, the dastardly theft of the prize cufflinks. If you want to hear the hobbit answer for his crimes, attend the trial and see first hand!

-Tookland Daily Observer



Bilbo stood before the Thain’s court, shifting his weight from foot to foot, trying to look calm and collected as Adalgrim read out the charges against him. The hobbits who stared back at him from the gallery were hobbits he’d grown up with, attended parties with. He was related to more than half of them. They were peering at him with looks of morbid curiosity.

“I admit,” Adalgrim said as he reached the end of the charges, “the Bilbo Baggins I knew who lived in Hobbiton would never have done such a thing, but this hobbit? I’m not so sure. If he is Bilbo then he’s very changed. Would the old Bilbo have gone off wandering and trouble making? Would he have told children stories of his misdeeds and made a sport of teaching them to follow in his footsteps? Would the old Bilbo we all knew, the quiet bookish predictable fellow, would he have married a Dwarf?” Bilbo’s head snapped around and he felt himself overwhelmed with protective fury. It was only the promise he’d made to Thorin that he would not shout out curses at anyone during the trial that kept him silent.

“He is changed,” Fortinbras said slowly, “undeniably changed.”

“Is it against hobbit law to change?” Thorin asked, his voice deceptively light. Bilbo blinked and turned to look at him. Fortinbras considered the question.

“No, it is not,” he said and shifted his attention to Bilbo, “Well Bilbo, what have you to say for yourself? How do you answer the charges?”

“I may seem to be changed,” Bilbo said quietly. He paused, frowning, trying to remember everything that he wanted to say and how he wanted to say it. “Yet, I remain Bilbo Baggins. I am what I have always been. The outlandishness and the strangeness have always been a part of me. My Took side, don’t you know. But it was buried before. I tried so hard to be tidy and fit myself into the place made for me in Hobbiton. It’s just that I’ve seen now that there is more to life than being a good little fellow. And there are things and people worth taking a risk for.” He paused once more and looked at Thorin. Thorin gazed back, looking extremely proud. Bilbo went on, “that is the change you are seeing.”

“I wonder then, if you still fit into that place made for you in Hobbiton,” Adalgrim said, “you may no longer be suited to life in the Shire.”

“The Shire is big enough for all sorts,” Fortinbras said in a low voice, “even those whose hearts have learned wildness.” The court room was silent. Fortinbras continued, “Bilbo, how do you answer the charges of theft against the Tooks?”

“I am not guilty of theft against the Tooks. I did not steal the diamond studded cufflinks,” Bilbo said.

“Very well then,” Fortinbras sighed, “We will break for luncheon and then meet once more to hear each side.”

Bilbo let out a breath and took a seat. The soft murmur of conversation rose, but Bilbo felt very unhappy. He wished they could just get it all over with.

Thorin came and sat beside him and Bilbo took his hand. They sat together in silence, neither feeling much like eating. Bilbo lifted his head and was about to speak when movement caught his eye.

Saradoc was walking quickly up to the Thain’s bench, Frodo bounding along behind him. As Saradoc addressed the Thain he bent and lifted Frodo up and set him against his hip so that Frodo could speak to the Thain as well.

“What’s this?” Thorin asked softly in Bilbo's ear.

“I’m not certain,” Bilbo said quietly.

The Thain raised a hand and the guards at the back went suddenly to the doors and shut them. A hush fell over the gathered hobbits.

“My good hobbits,” Fortinbras said, and paused, nodding to Thorin, “and my good Dwarf,” he added, “I ask your indulgence for just a moment. Please remain in your seats. Now,” he motioned to the nearest guard. “Please hold Mr. Grindorol Bracguirdle.”

Grindorol sat bolt upright, sputtering.

“What is this?” he demanded.

“I beg your pardon, Grindorol,” Fortinbras said, “but we must search you.” The guard and Adalgrim both moved in.

“Oh this again?” Grindorol cried, “I see that you still haven’t anything better to do than hassle me, Adalgrim Took!”

“That’s right,” Adalgrim said.

“Well! This is an outrage, but go on then! Search me once more and a hundred times more! You’ll not find anything. You’ve got the real crook there,” he pointed to Bilbo. “Just who has made this claim against me?” his eyes went to Saradoc and Frodo.

“Never you mind it,” Fortinbras said, “and we’ll hassle you as often as we like while you’re in Tookland and showing yourself to be a nuisance. Go on Adalgrim.”

Bilbo watched, just as riveted as the rest of the crowd. What was this? What was Frodo up to? He looked over at the boy, who met his eyes and gave him an indecipherable look. It only made Bilbo more curious.

“When this is finished I will haul both of you before the Mayor,” Grindolrol said nastily as Adalgrim searched his pockets, “I am a citizen of the Shire. I do not lose all my rights just because I venture into Tookland.”

Adalgrim’s back straightened and he drew his hand out. The hobbit was quivering.

“Adalgrim?” Fortinbras called. The jailer opened his hand, and there in his palm were two small twinkling cufflinks.

The room erupted into cries.

Frodo Baggins, you clever clever child! Bilbo thought. He didn’t understand what he was seeing, or how Frodo could have possibly intervened, but in his heart he knew the boy had a hand in it.

“No, this is,” Grindorol was sputtering in disbelief, “this is incorrect! Impossible!”

Adalgrim stepped up to the Thain’s bench and put the cuff links in Fortinbras’ hand. The Thain held the little links and stared at them. He rolled his sleeve up, and placed one of the links into the little button holes. There was an audible snap as the link fastened itself.

“The diamond cufflinks of the Old Took have returned!” Fortinbras cried. The room erupted into cheers. Fortinbras stood up, scowling down at Grindorol.

“Do you want to tell me why the Old Took’s cufflinks were in your pocket, Mr. Grindorol Bracegirdle?”

“I will not stand for this defamation to my character!” Grindorol cried, “slander! Foul slander!”

“Oh hush,” Adalgrim barked at him, “you are a liar and a cheat. And worse,” he turned to Bilbo, “you’ve made me admit that Bilbo Baggins was right.” He took his hat off and made a little bow to Bilbo.

“I’ve been framed! The cufflinks were planted there!” Grindorol howled.

“Oh poo Grindorol,” Adalgrim barked, “Bilbo has been locked up since the party. You’re not suggesting he’s done this? And his husband, begging your pardon Mr. Oakenshield, he doesn't seem like the sort to do much sneaking up on a hobbit.”

Grindirol sputtered in indignation. Then his eyes moved to Frodo.

“That. That child!” Grindorol cried, pointing at Frodo. Bilbo felt himself stiffen, nearly ready to leap across the table if Grindorol took a step toward Frodo. “He’s behind it! He’s a little reprobate, ask anyone. And he’s been keeping bad company with Bilbo Baggins, learning the foul trade of thievery. It’s him or his Uncle Bilbo that stole the links and then this child, he’s planted the links on me, I tell you! It’s a conspiracy! A Baggins conspiracy!”

Fortinbras paused and glanced down at Frodo. Frodo looked up, and he was the perfect picture of an innocent babe. Bilbo watched him in admiration. Fortinbras was, however, unimpressed.

“Frodo Baggins is indeed the accuser against Grindorol. Now, Master Frodo, I know your reputation and your deeds, so don’t give me an act, lad.” He paused as Frodo regarded him. “You told me the other night that you stole the cufflinks,” the Thain said severely, “were you telling the truth?” The perfect innocence fell away and Frodo met his eyes, regarding the old hobbit. The boy shook his head.

“I was not, sir. I told you an untruth that night.”

“I understood that. You did it to protect your Uncle.”

“Yes, sir.”

“Because you lied, I have a hard time deciding if you are truthful now. What you say is very suspect, because you could still be trying to protect your Uncle, do you understand my dilemma?”

“Yes, sir.”

“If I may,” Saradoc said quietly. The Thain nodded.

“Frodo may have a reputation,” Saradoc said, “but I believe him in this. He really is a good boy. He cares very deeply for those close to him, to the point of doing foolish things sometimes, yes, but he remains a very good lad. I think he understands how important it is that he tells the truth to you now.”

“Very well,” Fortinbras paused then looked down at Frodo again. “Did you or your uncle steal the cufflinks from the treasury and frame an innocent hobbit as he claims?”

“No, sir.”

“Oh, that boy is a liar!” Grindorol shouted.

“You will not speak of my ward that way!” Saradoc said angrily.

“Everyone knows he’s a horrible little wiley creature. The whole reason you Brandybucks came here was to seek help with his insolent thieving ways.”

“I believe him,” Saradoc said. Thain Fortinbras was silent for a moment.

“Frodo Baggins is not on trial here,” he said, “incidentally, I believe him as well, though I should never trust him to keep out of our mushroom meadows,” he growled down at the boy, “I would trust him in all other ways. He tells the truth in this.”

Frodo took a breath, a flush of joy in his face. Fortinbras turned his attention to Bilbo.

“Bilbo Baggins, you are free to go.”

“Thank you, Thain,” Bilbo said.

“Come along,” Adalgrim gripped Grindorol’s shoulder and tugged him along. “You can have Bilbo’s cell until it’s time for your trial!” he said cheerfully.

“Thank you all!” Fortinbras called, “Trial adjourned!”

The crowd began to murmur once more, excited by all the action.

Bilbo wasted no more time; he bolted down to the front where Saradoc and Frodo stood near the Thain’s bench.

“Frodo, lad,” Bilbo cried as Frodo ran to him. “Whatever has happened?” he asked, delighted.

“Frodo came to me a little while ago,” Saradoc said, “and told me that he’d seen Grindorol outside the Great Hall after second breakfast. He said he watched him take a pair of some small jewelry from his coat pocket and admire it. He said it shone and sparkled in the same way that his Uncle Thorin’s diamond bracelet sparkles, so he knew what Grindorol held must be diamond!” Bilbo blinked, feeling mystified. He was missing some piece of the story still. “I had to wait until there was a break in the trial,” Saradoc said apologetically, “they wouldn’t let us in, you see. But I knew that we must report what Frodo saw.”

“Thank you,” Frodo said, looking up at Saradoc, “for believing me, and for speaking up for me.”

“Of course, Frodo,” Saradoc said, and picked him up once more, embracing the boy. “You did very well, lad.” Frodo smiled faintly.

“Thank you,” he said.

⁂

The crowd dwindled eventually, though it took a very long time. Bilbo stuck around, busy receiving congratulations. Saradoc, Esmeralda- who had joined them at this point- and Frodo lingered as well, as Saradoc retold his and Frodo’s part in the whole drama. Frodo grew tired of this quickly and made his way to Thorin, asking to be picked up so that he could listen to all the hobbits congratulate Bilbo. Among one of the last groups of well wishers were Eglantine and Paladin Took.

“Hello there Paladin!” Bilbo said happily, “I had meant to welcome you back, but well, I got a little busy.”

“Busy! Ha!” Paladin laughed heartily, “I like that. And you're going to welcome me back? I should be welcoming you back! I hear you’ve been out to all sorts of places. I’m really very jealous and I want to hear all about it and all about this fellow!” Paladin said looking up at Thorin. “I hear you are a king.”

“He’s King Under the Mountain and a lot of other titles besides,” Bilbo sniffed, “show some respect, you silly hobbit.” Paladin laughed.

“If you are a friend of Bilbo’s then you may call me Thorin,” Thorin said.

“I’m very pleased to meet you,” Paladin said. Thorin turned to Bilbo.

“Was this the hobbit who you said was a childhood friend of yours? Who might be able to provide some proof of your identity?” he asked. Bilbo nodded.

“I’ll tell you the whole sordid tale,” he said to Paladin, “when we have a moment, that is. I am hoping you can give me a bit of help with another matter.”

“Oh yes, I heard about your difficulty!” Paladin cried enthusiastically. “My wife and I puzzled through the question for quite a long time, but I believe I have the solution!”

“What?” Bilbo blinked, startled.

“Fortinbras!” Paladin called. The Thain turned and blinked at him. “I have something to report, regarding the identity of this hobbit.” Fortinbras brightened. The cluster of hobbits he’d been speaking with excused themselves, leaving, as Fortinbras approached the small group.

“Ah, so at last, a witness on behalf of Bilbo Baggins,” Fortinbras said, “very well, what is the proof?” Paladrin grinned and turned to Bilbo.

“Oh cousin Bilbo, if that is your real name,” he chuckled, “there was a certain nickname I gave you when we were tweens- one I crafted after discovering a certain item in your possession.” Bilbo went still and the smile dropped off his face. “It was a nickname that- as far as I know- only you and I knew, because you threatened to pummel me if you ever heard me call you that. Is that right?”

“Damn it,” Bilbo growled under his breath and turned to Thorin. “Take Frodo away. Please.”

“No! I want to hear!” Frodo protested.

“I promise I’ll give you a full account someday,” Bilbo said.

“When?” Frodo asked suspiciously.

“In twenty years time,” Bilbo said, “go on!”

Thorin and Frodo exchanged a look.

“Is he joking?” Frodo asked.

“I doubt it,” Thorin said as he walked out, “Come, we’ll go and look at the gardens.”

Bilbo waited until Thorin and Frodo were firmly gone then he stepped closer to Fortinbras and muttered the name under his breath.

“Speak up, I’m an old man,” Fortinbras complained. Bilbo gritted his teeth. The old man was doing this on purpose he suspected.

“Dildo Baggins,” Bilbo said. Fortinbras blinked then snorted and Paladin beamed. “Yes, very funny Paladin,” Bilbo growled in disdain, “the absolute height of tween humor.”

“Is that it?” Fortinbras asked. Paladin nodded.

“That’s it! That’s what I called him!” he crowed.

“What’s a dildo?” Saradoc asked.

“I’ll explain it to you later,” Esmeralda said.

“Alright, Bilbo, I believe you,” Fortinbras chuckled.

“You should open a shop,” Eglantine cried, “Dildo Baggins Emporium.”

“Finest straps this side of the Water!” Paladin snorted.

“A useful tool for every hobbit’s hole!”

“You two think you're very clever,” Bilbo glared at them.

“Oh this is a sex thing, isn’t it?” Saradoc asked.

Bilbo was too thoroughly disgusted with all of them to find any of it the least bit funny.

“So can I have my name back?” Bilbo asked. Fortinbras nodded.

“I’ll have the proclamation made up in the morning, ready for a seal.”

“Thank you very much!” Bilbo said. “And I mean that to all of you. I’ll be in a better humor about the whole thing later on and I promise a magnificent party to thank you all. But for now, I think I’d like to just go have a bit of quiet time with my husband. Thank you all once more!” he made a small bow and went quickly out.

“Fucking Tooks,” Bilbo hissed under his breath as he passed out into the hallway. Though he cursed them, his good humor was beginning to return and Bilbo felt himself smile. He didn’t quite understand it all just yet, but his fortunes had completely turned around in the space of a an hour. Besides Paladin, he thought he had another hobbit to thank for that turn in fortune.

⁂

Bilbo found Thorin and Frodo in the east gardens, admiring the clematis.

“Frodo Baggins,” Bilbo called. Frodo turned back.

“Yes sir?”

“I have several questions for you, lad. But first, what was all that about your Uncle Thorin’s diamond bracelet?” he asked pointedly. Frodo went quiet.

“Yes, I was surprised to hear I have such a thing,” Thorin said good naturedly. Frodo’s gaze went to his toes.

“Come on then, lad, how did you do it?”

“Do what?”

“Don’t play innocent,” Bilbo chuckled, “You are very good at it, but I can see through that act of yours. When Grindorol was searched he had no idea those cufflinks were in his pocket, did he? I think we have you to thank.”

“Frodo!” Thorin cried. “You lied to your Thain?”

“I did not!” Frodo cried fiercely. “He asked if me or Uncle Bilbo stole the links and we didn’t, and he asked if I framed an innocent hobbit for the crime- and again I didn’t!”

“But you had a hand in this,” Bilbo pressed. Frodo dug his toes in the dirt. “Come on, lad.”

“Well. I did ensure the links would be found in his pocket,” Frodo admitted. “But he had them! I wasn’t framing him for a crime he didn’t commit!”

“You found them? My dear boy, where were they, and how did you manage it?” Bilbo asked.

“It wasn’t much,” Frodo demurred. Bilbo gave him a look. “I did what you said, I observed the situation before I plunged in.”

“Good thinking,” Thorin said cautiously.

“I noticed that Grindorol wore the same pair of britches for two days in a row,” Frodo said, “and he’s a dandy so I thought it was a bit out of character. So I broke into his room last night and stole his britches off the chair where they were hung, ready for wearing the next day.” Thorin groaned.

“You broke into his room?” he asked. Frodo blinked, looking far too innocent.

“Not just that, I searched those pants while I was there, and soon enough I found the cufflinks- or rather, felt them- sewn into a small pouch on the inside of the back waistband.”

“That’s why he wasn’t caught when he was searched!” Bilbo said, pleased.

“I knew I couldn’t just steal them- it would look as if I or perhaps more probably, that Uncle Bilbo had stolen the cufflinks after all, and that I was merely returning them.”

“What did you do then?”

“I had to think a bit- I tried to plan ahead, the way you taught me. I retreated for the moment, and gathered supplies. I found two small pebbles and I took bits from my Aunt’s sewing kit. I returned to Grindorol’s room and got to work. I cut the thread from his improvised pocket and retrieved the cufflinks. I pocketed them and put the pebbles in their place. I sewed the pocket back up, careful to mimic his work. Then I left and I waited until this morning.

Grindorol has second breakfast in the Great Hall each morning. The Great Hall is a wonderful place for pickpocketing, at least for a pickpocket like myself. No one pays any attention to a small hobbit crawling around on the floor or slipping by guests. But instead of taking something from his pocket, I planted the cufflinks in his jacket pocket. He didn’t feel a thing, thanks to my burglar training.”

“You clever clever child!” Bilbo breathed in admiration.

“I only had to hope he wouldn’t put his hand in his pocket,” Frodo smiled, “but as he had nothing there, I had to hope he wouldn’t have reason to reach inside, and the cufflinks are small things luckily, so he would not feel them otherwise.

Then it was only a matter of waiting until he came to the trial, as I knew he would, to gloat over his bad work. I had to get the help of my Uncle Saradoc in approaching the Thain to report Grindorol, for I doubt the Thain would have taken action on only my words. At least Uncle Saradoc was good enough to accompany me. I also think it was very lucky that Mr. Adalgrim was there, for he seems to have a particular dislike for Mr. Grindorol and was all too eager to urge the Thain to have Gridorol searched one more time. And Grindorol didn’t protest too much, you noticed - as he had no reason to fear their search, or so he thought.”

“Frodo, you are simply amazing,” Bilbo said.

“We are very appreciative,” Thorin said, “and we would not be where we are now without your valiant efforts, but dear child, you took some risks.” Bilbo nodded and took a seat on the garden bench, peering at Frodo.

“I think that’s the reason you kept us in the dark about this, isn’t it?”

“I didn’t take more risks than I usually do,” Frodo said softly.

“Oh I think breaking into a known criminal’s bedroom while he was there asleep, and twice, counts as taking more risk than your dalliances in mushroom fields,” Bilbo said.

“Oh. Maybe,” Frodo said quietly, “so, should I have told you?”

“I wish you had,” Bilbo said gently.

“But then you would have stopped me,” Frodo murmured.

“Have we stopped you before?” Bilbo asked. Frodo pondered this and shook his head.

“But this is a bit different.”

“It’s possible that we might stop you from doing something terribly dangerous, but I think for this,” Bilbo paused, “I think we would have taken steps to make sure you were safe. We recognize that you have talents, and cleverness, and daring as well as great determination. But I think we would have preferred that you did not do this alone. I could have been there with you, invisible and ready to get you out of there if he woke.”

“Oh,” Frodo said softly.

“If there are things we can do to help protect you, then we will. Always,” Thorin added.

“We co-conspirators have to look out for each other,” Bilbo smiled. Frodo laughed lightly.

“Agreed!” the boy said, adding, “so don’t worry Uncle Bilbo, I’ll always find a way to fix your messes.”

“You cheeky little thing!” Bilbo growled as Frodo giggled and hugged him.

“Can we have luncheon?” he asked.

“Yes!” Bilbo cried, “come on, let’s have luncheon. A very good luncheon. I am suddenly ravenous!”

Together the three of them walked out of the garden. The weather promised to be nice and Bilbo was so looking forward to a golden afternoon outside and in the company of Thorin and Frodo.