Chapter Text
‘Bilbo, if you realised that there were orcs on the borders of Buckland, why did you not come straight to me?’ Gorbadoc Brandybuck asked his fellow hobbit as soon as Master Baggins had finished explaining the purpose of their visit.
Thorin could see that the hobbit was visibly stymied by this question, and he resisted the urge to sigh. This was the problem with kingdoms that had no clear leadership. In Ered Luin, if there was a problem then a petition was made either to Thorin, or to Balin as Thorin’s Steward. There was none of this confusion over who was owed what fealty by whom.
Of course, there were always those who completely ignored the rules for reasons of their own… but Thorin was refusing to think about them right now. He had pressing concerns in the here and now, and that problem had been dealt with.
‘Gorbadoc, is that really the most important issue at the moment?’ Master Baggins asked, without a hint of deference. Thorin had to hand it to the hobbit – he was equally rude to every figure of authority that he came across. It made Thorin view his own introduction to Master Baggins in a slightly different light.
He was still annoyed, but it was no longer the annoyance of one who felt singled out for ill treatment.
‘The key point here,’ Master Baggins continued, ‘as Prince Fíli so aptly pointed out to the rest of us recently, is that there are orcs on the borders of Buckland and something needs to be done about them. Going home meant that I could bring the dwarves here with me to help with the problem. That makes it a good choice, surely?’
Thorin heard a snort behind him, and then a voice pointing out, ‘That sounds very impressive, until you realise that he did not know we were coming.’
Thankfully the voice was Bifur’s, and so the Master of Buckland understood not a word of what was said. Even so, Bombur spoke for Thorin as well when he muttered to his cousin, ‘This is not the time, Bifur.’
‘In Buckland, we appreciate it if our guests speak a language all can comprehend, King Thorin,’ Gorbadoc Brandybuck informed him acidly. Thorin raised his eyebrows and stared the fellow down. He would not be lectured by this hobbit as if he were a wet-behind-the-ears pup.
‘Bifur can speak no language other than Khuzdul, Master Brandybuck,’ he retorted. ‘The axe in his head, earned in defence of our people, has made very sure of that. I will not ban him from speaking simply because he cannot be understood by other races.’ Even if I am of the opinion that a general ban on speaking might be a good thing at the moment, Thorin added in his own mind.
The Master of Buckland was not easily discomfited. Rather than pursuing the topic any further, he changed tack entirely.
‘You wish for assistance in defeating this orc pack, then?’
‘No,’ Master Baggins countered, with what little patience he seemed to possess. ‘I wish for one of your Bounders to accompany us. They will bear witness to the existence of the orcs and their defeat, to ensure that there are no wild tales flying around afterwards, but need take no part in the fighting. You know what the Shire is like, Gorbadoc, and so do I. If I do not have another to support my version of events, then we will either have Lobelia Sackville-Baggins petitioning to have me removed as Master of Bag End for seeing orcs where there are none, or half of the Shire pestering us day and night convinced that one of the orcs escaped and is camping in their back garden!’
There was no immediate response from the Master of Buckland, but the young hobbit who had been introduced as his son, Rorimac, laughed quietly.
‘That’s true enough,’ he told Bilbo with a friendly smile. ‘That woman would do anything to get her hands on Bag End, and goodness knows the Bounders have enough trouble with nervous hobbits as it is. Gammer Goold had the whole clan in an uproar a fortnight ago, claiming that there was a bear prowling in the back garden. It turned out one of the dogs had jumped into a haystack and come back covered in the stuff.’ He paused for a moment, as if thinking, but Thorin was almost certain it was for effect only. ‘Perhaps I’d better come with you, Bilbo.’
‘That is a fine idea, Rory,’ Master Baggins uttered with visible relief. When the Master of Buckland seemed likely to object, his son offered him a sunny smile.
‘Father, if there are dangers near Buckland then people will feel much better if they are sure that they have been dealt with. Who better to reassure them than one of our family? Even Lobelia would have to think twice before questioning the word of a Brandybuck. Besides, I can hardly ask another of the Bounders to do this if I am reluctant to go myself.’
Thorin took this to mean that Rorimac was serving time as a Bounder as training for his future role, which made him think well of the young hobbit. A willingness to serve one’s people from an early age was a good sign in a ruler. It was one of the things that had endeared Fíli and Kíli to the dwarves of Ered Luin. They were always willing to help however they could, no matter how dirty the job.
Unless it involved paperwork, of course, but Thorin and Dís were working on that.
Gorbadoc Brandybuck surveyed his son critically for a long moment before giving a reluctant sigh.
‘Very well, Rory,’ he said with exasperation. ‘I imagine I will have as much success deterring you as I normally do – which is to say none at all. Go ahead with them, but mind you’re careful. Dealing with orcs is not a job for a Bounder!’
Master Baggins gave an extremely disdainful sniff at that. Thorin wasn’t sure if it was because he disagreed or because he agreed all too well. Thorin was beginning to realise that Master Baggins’ opinion of his fellow hobbits, especially those charged with defending their borders, was not generally high.
It was one of the reasons that Thorin was inclined to like this Rorimac. Bilbo had seemed happier to see and deal with him than he had any of the other hobbits they had been introduced to so far. That suggested he had a fair amount of sense, always a good trait in one who would be following you into battle.
Not that Thorin intended to let the hobbits too near to the fighting. An orc pack was clearly a far greater danger than they were used to dealing with, and, as a warrior and a King, Thorin was responsible for defending those weaker and less able to defend themselves. There was no reason they should have to get very involved when he had capable fighters with him.
***
‘I beg your pardon?’ Bilbo exploded. It had been two days since they’d left Brandy Hall, and they had travelled steadily during that time. Bilbo might never have found the orcish camp originally if he hadn’t been able to follow one of the orcs to it, but once you knew where it was it was fairly easy to reach. They had followed the river to the Great East Road, then followed the Road until they were near. The final stretch had been across the countryside, skirting the edge of the Old Forest, but there had been little to trouble them. This close to the edge, most of the trees were firmly asleep, much to Bilbo’s relief.
Give him an orc over a moving, vindictive tree any day of the week.
Although, apparently, King Thorin had no intention of giving him either.
‘What do you mean, stay here?’ Bilbo continued, giving the King of Ered Luin his fiercest glare. ‘How, exactly, were you intending to find the orcs without the only person who knows where they are?’
‘Lad, we’ve been hunting orcs in the wild since before you were born,’ Dwalin explained. Bilbo transferred the glare to him, not liking the patronising tone at all. ‘You’ve given us a good idea of where to look. I doubt we’ll have any trouble.’
Bilbo heard a comment in that strange dwarven language he couldn’t make out, followed immediately by at least three cries of, ‘BIFUR!’ King Thorin gave Bifur a look which could have frozen the Brandywine.
Bifur just shrugged, pointed at Bilbo, pointed in the direction of the Barrow Downs and uttered something else Bilbo didn’t understand at all. He guessed from the dwarf’s gestures and expression that Bifur was supporting his cause and suppressed the urge to shout, ‘Exactly!’
It was never wise to agree with something you didn’t fully understand, just in case. Elladan and Elrohir had taught him that the hard way.
‘Bifur has a point,’ Óin contributed. ‘We could find the orcs on our own, but why take the extra effort when we have a guide?’
‘The hobbits asked us to deal with the problem, Óin,’ King Thorin responded. His voice was as grave as it had been when he informed Bilbo and Rory that they need come no further. Those had been his exact words. As if they had somehow become irrelevant in the space of a few seconds, when they had been valued travelling companions only a moment before. ‘That is part of the bargain, our skill in turn for theirs. Taking them further into danger surely breaks the spirit of that agreement.’
‘It most certainly does not!’ Bilbo objected. ‘I had no intention of sitting this fight out, any more than I would have done if we had summoned the Rangers. I have no need of protection, King Thorin. Either yours or anyone else’s. These will not be the first orcs I have faced.’
The look on King Thorin’s face made it plain that he was not convinced by these statements, and the very idea that someone might think Bilbo were lying boiled his blood.
Thankfully for the budding relationship between the dwarves and the hobbits, Rory intervened.
‘King Thorin, my role in this is to confirm that the orcs have been dealt with fully. I can hardly do that from five miles away.’
‘We will happily escort you to the battlefield once the fighting is done,’ King Thorin offered. Bilbo almost sneered. How gracious of him!
‘No,’ Rory countered, ‘I’m afraid that would, to use your phrase, break the spirit of the agreement. The idea is that I confirm that all of the orcs were present and were killed. I cannot do that without seeing the fight myself. Nor can Bilbo, unless he took a mental inventory of every orc present.’
‘Are you implying that we might lie about whether we killed all of the orcs to cheat your people?’ Nori interjected. His tone suggested that he was more impressed with Rory’s gall than offended by the implied insult.
King Thorin’s expression strongly suggested that he and Nori disagreed on this issue.
‘Not at all,’ Rory countered calmly. ‘Two days’ travel is quite enough to convince me that you are dwarves of your word. I am simply saying that I wish to be able to give my word to my fellow hobbits with complete honesty, and that is easiest done if Bilbo and I are close enough to see the battle.’
All of the dwarves turned to look at their King for his response. Rory turned instead to Bilbo and winked.
He was trying to get Bilbo close enough to the battlefield to take part in the fight. Close enough to prove to this dwarven King what a hobbit could do if necessary.
Bilbo intended to do exactly that.
While Rory and Bilbo had had their silent conversation, another must have been taking place between King Thorin and his Company. When Bilbo turned his attention back to them, King Thorin was nodding his head reluctantly.
‘Dwalin, Kíli, stay with them,’ he commanded. Both dwarves nodded immediately and moved closer to the hobbits. Bilbo did not kick them in the shins, but only because he was a hobbit of great restraint.
Also because they were wearing thick leather boots and it was possible he’d have broken a toe, but the part about restraint sounded better.
‘Rest for another ten minutes,’ King Thorin finished. ‘Then we move out.’
***
Really, Dwalin thought irritably, some people just would not be helped.
They called in experts to solve a problem, offered goods in exchange for services (or the possibility of goods, anyway, but the dwarves were desperate enough to take what they could get), and then still wanted to be in the thick of the situation.
It just made no sense.
Why hire a blacksmith and then forge the sword yourself?
Especially if you were going to be so prickly about the whole thing. Master Baggins clearly fancied himself a warrior, that move he had pulled when Dwalin arrived at Bag End had shown that much, and his pride was ruffled by their suggestion that he let the real warriors take over now.
It was not that Dwalin didn’t think the lad had some good training. He was sure he did. No one without it would have got the drop on the Guard Captain of Ered Luin, no matter how distracted he was by thoughts of food.
Dwalin just couldn’t see how the hobbit could have gained much fighting experience in a place as peaceful as the Shire. Experience he would desperately need to make up for his small size.
Dwalin could admit that he was not entirely confident about taking Ori and Dori into battle… or Bofur and Bombur, for that matter. None of them were fully trained warriors and Dwalin didn’t like endangering those he was unsure of if there was another option. But at least Ori, or Bofur, or any of the dwarves, had the strength to make up some of their lack of skill. Crack something’s skull hard enough and it wouldn’t have chance to exploit your weaknesses.
Ah well, they were about to find out if this had all been a huge mistake. The orcs were just over the next rise, and Master Baggins had pulled his sword from its sheath.
As they crested the rise, Dwalin was pleased to see that Rory had the sense to hold his club by his side whilst also staying carefully positioned behind Kíli, where he would be safer. Kíli would be holding position at the rear with Ori, shooting from afar rather than being in the thick of the action. It would reduce the risk of Rory being trampled, if nothing else.
Below, the orcs were mostly sprawled on the ground around their thrown-together camp, which was situated in the lee between two small hills. A couple were making a cursory attempt at keeping watch, but this mostly involved sitting nearer to the two most obvious entrances and keeping their weapons lying next to them.
It was exactly the sort of laziness that Dwalin would expect from orcs, as well as the usual lack of imagination. They always prepared for the sort of frontal attacks that they favoured. They rarely looked upwards.
Thorin and Dwalin had spent most of their lifetime assisting orcs in regretting that carelessness whenever possible.
Now, Thorin was gesturing the various members of the Company to the places he had chosen for them. Nori, by far the quietest of them all, crept as far down the hill as he felt comfortable with. Fíli, on the other side, waited for him to get into position and then trod carefully down until he drew even with Nori. Dwalin and Glóin were dispatched to the far ends of the rise, where they could descend quickly to bottleneck the path.
Thorin himself then descended the centre of the hill, remaining several feet further up than Nori and Fíli, and gestured for the rest to fan out above him. Dwalin could see his friend watching the orcs carefully, waiting for the ideal moment to strike, and could feel the grin widening on his face.
Nori was right (though Dwalin would never say such a thing aloud for fear he would swallow his own tongue in horror).
There was nothing Dwalin loved quite so much as delivering a direct, uncomplicated sword-blow to the heart.
Today would be a good day.
***
Thorin stood utterly still on the hillside, surveying the orcs below with calculating eyes. He had been in similar positions so many times, watching and waiting, knowing that the right moment would come.
It had been one of the areas in which he and Thror had disagreed most loudly during the War with the Orcs. Thror had always favoured bold attacks, charging headfirst at their enemy, throwing his dwarves against superior forces and letting fate decide the outcome.
Thorin had favoured tactics that might actually allow them to win.
He enjoyed a headlong charge as much as the next dwarf, but not if it left half of those under his command dead come battle’s-end. He had argued time and again that they would do better to ambush parties of orcs, to whittle their forces down slowly over time. Those were the tactics Thorin had used whenever possible, and a number of other captains had begun to do the same.
Thror had been incensed over Thorin’s continued disobedience. They had quarrelled and quarrelled, at first in private and then, as Thror’s temper frayed, in the middle of war councils. Finally, Thorin’s parents had begged him to bend, to avoid a rift with his grandfather which could not be healed.
So Thorin had bent. He had held his tongue. He had followed meekly when they were commanded to Azanulbizar.
And he had lost Frerin, and his father, and the madman wearing his grandfather’s face too.
That was the last time he had willingly bent to anyone.
Finally, Thorin felt what he had been waiting for. He doubted he could explain it to anyone else, that moment when he knew the timing was perfect. Sometimes it was obvious; something occurred at exactly the right time and all of their enemies left themselves vulnerable as they focused on the distraction.
Sometimes it was not obvious at all. There was just something, a feeling in the air, which told Thorin that guards were down and minds were wandering. That no attention was being paid to possible attacks.
Either way, it was the perfect moment.
He raised his hand, knowing that his Company would be waiting for his signal, then jerked it forward.
Mere breaths later, the whistle of an arrow flew past, followed almost immediately by a stone hurtling at speeds a hand could never match. The youngest member of his Company had reminded Thorin of a magpie in the last few days, constantly picking up stones as they walked and checking them for size and weight. By that morning, Ori’s collection had been truly impressive. Now he put it to good use. The stone struck an orc on the forehead just as Kíli’s arrow found the heart of one of the largest orcs in the pack. Both dropped to the ground, dead in an instant.
Cries of surprise, curses and hurled abuse echoed from below as the orcs reacted to the sudden deaths of their comrades. A few of the more intelligent ones began looking for the source of the attack and, spotting the dwarves, yelled and ran to attack. As Kíli and Ori fired again, Fíli and Nori joined the battle. Nori whipped three throwing knives out almost quicker than Thorin could see, felling the orcs heading for their position. Fíli had another target, taking careful aim before he buried his throwing axe in the head of the biggest warg before the orcs’ leader could mount it.
The orc roared in anger, focusing in on Fíli in an instant and charging in his direction, determined to make Thorin’s nephew pay for killing his mount. At that point, Thorin decided that the element of surprise had well and truly expired. He ran down the hill at an angle that would allow him to cut the orcs’ leader off before he could reach Fíli, raising his sword as he prepared to do battle. Behind him, he could feel the rest of the Company descending as well, choosing their targets and moving in. Out of the corner of his eye, Thorin could already see Glóin immersed in a fight with two mounted orcs, striking out and then retreating so that the two wargs ended up head-butting and clawing one another instead of him. Instinct won out over training, and the orcs soon had bigger problems than Glóin on their hands as they struggled to tear their mounts away from one another.
The leader of the orcs was still thirty feet from Fíli when Thorin reached him, immediately slashing at the orc’s neck to gain his attention. The orc was clearly not a master of concentration for, having blocked the blow, he abandoned his previous intention easily enough and turned to engage Thorin instead.
‘Dwarf,’ the creature snarled at Thorin, ‘good of you to make life easy. We thought we’d have to find your little…,’ he uttered a word in the Black Speech which Thorin chose not to try to decipher, ‘but you’ve delivered yourself like a good slave.’
Thorin twisted to the side to dodge the sword-blow that accompanied this outlandish statement, turning in a full circle around the orc to stab at its unprotected back. He opened a deep cut in the orc’s side and it roared again as the wound began to bleed profusely.
‘What are you talking about?’ Thorin growled at the orc, abandoning his usual policy of refusing to talk to things that were attacking him. He generally didn’t care why something was trying to kill him, but this was such a bizarre turn of events that he knew he needed to probe further.
The orc simply snarled again as it changed position and aimed a mighty swing at Thorin’s head. Thorin blocked and stepped back, forcing the orc to follow him if it wanted to stay within range. Conveniently, the movement took them further away from Fíli, though Thorin suspected the orc was now so focused on him that it had forgotten its original aim.
‘Tell me what you mean,’ Thorin insisted, staring intently at the orc and searching for something that might get him a reaction. ‘Or are you only trained to say one phrase? You utter meaningless rubbish to fool people into believing you can actually think?’
They exchanged several more blows whilst the orc insulted Thorin in both Westron and Black Speech, but Thorin wasn’t interested in anything except the answer to his question. Instead he manoeuvred himself between the orc and Fíli’s position, pressing the creature until it was on the retreat. As he’d hoped, the orc finally responded to his query in an attempt to distract Thorin from the fight.
‘We were sent to catch you,’ the orc said, with a grating, wheezing laugh that made Thorin wince. ‘Get the dwarves and bring them to me. The King and the Princes. I have a surprise for them.’ The last was clearly the orc quoting its orders, and Thorin ran them through his mind swiftly. Someone had meant to catch him, and Fíli and Kíli as well. Who? Why?
Either way, it gave him an advantage here. The orc had said catch, not kill. Whoever this was wanted them alive.
‘Who sent you?’ Thorin demanded. ‘Who gives your orders?’ The orc had gone silent again, and Thorin cursed silently.
Then, suddenly, he heard a shout of horror from behind him. Cursing aloud this time, he swiped his sword at the orc’s belly in the split second it looked away from him, opening a wound on its stomach in the hope it would buy him some time. As the orc stumbled back, Thorin whirled towards the hill, only to see Kíli lunging at an orc who had flanked him and was stabbing viciously at a startled Rorimac. The hobbit managed to smack the orc’s sword away with the club he wielded, then took several hasty steps back before it could attack again. Kíli, bow abandoned, threw himself bodily at Rorimac’s attacker and took it to the ground, smashing its head on a nearby rock and then, in the seconds that gave him, drawing a dagger from his boot and slitting its throat.
Thorin could already tell, from the graceless way that Kíli had handled the situation, that his youngest nephew had been caught entirely off guard, and he knew they would have to talk later. Kíli had been trained better than that and whatever had gone wrong had nearly cost poor Rorimac his life.
That situation dealt with, Thorin turned back to his own opponent… only to find the orc gurgling on the ground, hands failing to hold his innards in place. Rushing forward, Thorin grabbed it by its scraggly hair and pulled its head up.
‘Who sent you?’ he asked urgently. ‘Tell me and I’ll give you a quick death.’
‘Too… late…,’ the orc gasped, a maliciously satisfied smile on its lips. It took one last rattling breath and collapsed back to the ground, clearly dead.
Slamming his hand to the ground in frustration, Thorin looked up to find that many of the orcs had already been dealt with. Only a handful remained now, harried by Thorin’s Company and fighting less to kill than to escape from the battlefield.
‘KEEP ONE ALIVE!’ Thorin bellowed across the field. Even as he did so, Dwalin took out two orcs in one great swing, his face growing thunderous as he realised he had unintentionally disobeyed an order from his King. Bombur stopped aiming at his opponent’s head and began going for the legs instead, trying to prevent it from escaping, but the creature’s warg broke free of its battle with Bifur and came to its master’s aid. The orc lunged onto its back and began to ride away, and Ori and Kíli were forced to take the pair down to prevent them fleeing.
Thorin turned frantically and realised that there was a last hope. Almost on the other side of the battlefield from Thorin, Master Baggins was facing two orcs. His face was set with a cold fury as he ducked and dodged, dealing shallow wounds at every turn. The orcs, large and clumsy, were unable to catch their faster quarry, though they came closer than Thorin would have liked more than once. How had the hobbit been allowed to join the battle? He ought to have been back with Kíli and Ori.
Thorin moved to help Master Baggins, worried both about his chance of getting the information he needed and his chance of getting the hobbit home safe and sound. Yet, even as he did so, he came to a startling realisation.
Master Baggins was not struggling.
He was simply biding his time.
Each of the orcs was now bleeding from multiple slices to their legs and torsos, some deeper than Thorin had first realised. Black liquid slicked the floor around their feet and they slipped, turned even clumsier by the lack of grip and the loss of blood. Master Baggins, barefoot in the hobbit fashion which Thorin found so odd, did not even seem to notice that the floor was bloody. The rage on his face would have been truly frightening if he had not been so small, and the clinical way that he manipulated his prey stunned Thorin. Ducking another failed blow, Master Baggins took his sword in both hands, crouched low and then propelled himself upwards with his sword-tip raised, shoving it into the heart of the closest attacker.
The orc dropped like a stone as Master Baggins wrenched his sword free, turning his attention to his final attacker.
‘Master Baggins, take him alive,’ Thorin shouted desperately, but to Thorin’s disbelief the hobbit ignored him completely. Rather than simply hamstringing his foe, which would have been easy enough considering its other injuries, the hobbit took advantage of the orc’s faltering steps to trip it and bring it to the ground.
‘Don’t,’ Thorin roared, one final time, sure that Master Baggins must be able to hear him by now, but he was ignored once again. Lips twisting in disgust, the hobbit swiftly cut the orc’s throat.
Seconds later, almost gasping with both exertion and incredulous anger, Thorin reached the hobbit and grabbed his shoulders, startling him out of an apparent stupor. He only vaguely recognised that Master Baggins had not moved since he dealt with his final opponent; that he had, instead, been staring at the body on the ground with unseeing eyes. He was too outraged to give that much thought.
‘What were you doing?’ Thorin demanded, so livid he had to force the words out. ‘Why did you not take it alive as I ordered?’
******
