Actions

Work Header

The Time for Home

Chapter 9: Bewilderment

Summary:

There's always more than one side...

Chapter Text

‘I….’ Master Baggins stuttered, eyes coming up to meet Thorin’s slowly. ‘What?’

The expression on his face looked most like bewilderment, as if he wasn’t quite sure what Thorin had said or how he had come to be there.

Thorin opened his mouth to speak again, then stopped. He considered the hobbit for a moment, noting not just his blank appearance, but also the way he was trembling slightly.

He looked across at the nearest of his Company, Fíli, and raised a querying eyebrow.

‘I don’t think he heard you, Uncle,’ Fíli said simply. Thorin looked down at Master Baggins once more, and sighed.

From twenty feet away it had seemed impossible that the hobbit might not have heard him. Thorin’s bellowing could have woken the dead. It had, on several occasions, easily woken those who were so drunk that they might as well have been dead only moments before.

He didn’t think he’d ever been too quiet before.

Except that it did not appear to have been volume that was the problem. Not if the hobbit’s demeanour was a guide. He took a deep breath, and forced himself to relax his grip.

‘Master Baggins, I was asking…’ he began to say, but before he could finish Kíli, Ori and Rorimac came hurtling up.

‘Bilbo, are you alright?’ Rorimac called over the top of Thorin’s words. ‘Look at you, you’re shaking!’ To Thorin’s irritation, Rorimac pulled Master Baggins out of Thorin’s grip with so much as a by-your-leave and tugged him closer so he could inspect him.

Thorin ignored the fact that there was no good reason why Rorimac would need to ask his leave to do so.

That wasn’t the pertinent point.

‘I’m fine,’ Master Baggins protested, though to Thorin’s ears it sounded instinctive and unconvincing. ‘I’m fine, Rory,’ he insisted, pulling away from his friend. ‘It’s excess energy, that’s all.’

‘It’s not excess energy that leaves you unable to hear a bellowed order when it’s issued right next to you, lad,’ Dwalin advised knowingly. He was eyeing Bilbo with what Thorin knew was empathy and understanding, but something about what Dwalin said seemed to put Master Baggins’ back up immediately.

‘Order?’ he exclaimed. ‘Whose order would that be? You said something about that as well,’ he accused, rounding on Thorin in an instant. Whatever had been wrong with him, it seemed to have dissipated now.

‘It was a battle, Master Baggins,’ Thorin pointed out in response, ‘and I was leading it. Dwalin would consider anything I said in such a situation to be an order. As would I,’ he added, with a firm glance at the indignant hobbit.

‘Well I would not,’ Master Baggins objected strenuously. ‘I am not under your command, Master Oakenshield!’ Thorin noticed that his title had disappeared all of a sudden. Mahal, this hobbit really did have a problem with anything resembling a leader, didn’t he? Thorin’s sympathy was beginning to dwindle, much as he knew he should hold onto it. Master Baggins had been truly unwell at the end of the battle, Thorin was sure of it.

‘Is that how you were trained, lad?’ Balin asked, before Thorin could speak. That was probably for the best. ‘Did those who taught you to fight expect you to enter battle and do whatever you pleased, no matter what everyone else was doing?’

Master Baggins did a very good impression of Thorin, some minutes ago. He opened his mouth, then closed it again without saying anything. His expression was mutinous, but he did not comment.

‘The orcs may have had valuable information,’ Thorin said into the silence. He was proud of himself for keeping most of the harshness out of his tone. ‘However you wish to view my words – request, order, prayer to the Valar – I had wished to take one of them alive so I could extract that information.’

‘We were here to kill them, not have a nice chat with them,’ Master Baggins informed him. ‘What information could they possibly have had that would have been of interest?’

‘They might have told me,’ Thorin answered, voice tight with restrained temper, ‘who had sent them to hunt myself and my nephews. That is the sort of information I find very useful!’ Master Baggins was clearly determined to strike out at him and Thorin would not be drawn into an argument, but he could not prevent himself venting some of his frustration.

Master Baggins’ mouth pinched together and he stared at Thorin for long seconds before responding.

‘I did not hear you,’ he stated when he finally did so.

‘So I had gathered,’ Thorin bit out.

‘They were hunting you?’ Master Baggins asked after a few breaths.

‘So their leader claimed,’ Thorin confirmed.

‘That is not good,’ Master Baggins muttered, almost to himself. ‘Why would they be hunting you?’

‘A question we would all like answered, I think,’ Balin interjected again, ‘Alas, we are now unlikely to find an answer here.’

‘It’s unlikely,’ Dwalin agreed, ‘but not impossible. Search the corpses,’ he commanded the Company, and they moved to do so. Nori, Dori and Ori all pulled faces, each likely for a different reason, but they complied nonetheless.

Dwalin did not move. He surveyed Master Baggins closely, taking in every detail from head to foot.

‘Does that happen in every battle, lad?’ he asked, and his tone was as gentle as Thorin had ever heard it, save for when the boys were little.

Master Baggins stared straight ahead and refused to meet their eyes.

‘No,’ he answered shortly, though at least he did not snap Dwalin’s head off. After a pause, he added, ‘I haven’t fought a lot of orc packs. Not like that.’

‘So it’s the orcs that are the problem?’ Dwalin queried.

‘Yes.’

‘Alright then,’ Dwalin said softly. ‘If I’d known, I’d have kept a closer eye. You’ve been well-trained,’ was his final remark before he departed.

Master Baggins looked at Thorin defiantly, almost daring him to ask further questions.

Thorin didn’t. He recognised the look of one who had been pushed far enough for one day. If it were likely they would fight another battle together, then he would want answers and reassurances. For now, their battle was done. Why rake over someone else’s wounds when there was no need?

Instead, Thorin turned and walked to join Fíli and Kíli in searching for something, anything, which might tell them who wanted them so badly.

***

They found nothing.

They hadn’t really expected to. Orcs weren’t the sort for carrying written orders and, while they had some symbols on their gear which might have told another orc something, none of them meant anything to the Company.

Of course, being orcs, there was every chance that the gear had been stolen and passed around at least five different companies since it was made. There was no guarantee it would have told them anything useful.

Thorin kicked the nearest corpse in anger, feeling his temper bubbling close to the surface again. He turned his back on the orc he had been searching and took several deep breaths as he tried to push the anger and frustration back down. A little temper would always be excused amongst dwarves, but his Company did not need to see him losing his hold on himself, much as he wished to rant and rave and punch something fifty times.

How could they hold negotiations with the hobbits in the face of this? It would only take a hint that the dwarves, far from solving the problem, had actually been the reason for the orcish presence on their borders and that would be it.

All of this would be nothing but a waste of precious time which Thorin could have spent travelling to the Iron Hills.

He turned back to the orc to give it one last kick, on the theory that it might not make things better but could not possibly make them any worse, only to discover that he was no longer alone.

‘OW!’ Fíli exclaimed indignantly as he hopped on one foot. Thorin’s kick appeared to have caught his ankle. Luckily the boot-leather was thick enough to absorb much of the blow, but even so it had to have been forceful enough to hurt. ‘Uncle! What did I do?’

‘Wrong place, wrong time,’ Thorin quickly reassured him, moving to support his nephew as he guided him down to the ground. ‘Here, let me check that.’

‘No, it’s fine,’ Fíli dismissed swiftly. ‘Even if it had done any damage, we’d be better not taking the boot off. If we can’t get it back on again afterwards, I’ll look like a right idiot tramping into Brandy Hall with only one shoe on.’

‘I am almost certain that Óin would not agree with that sage healer’s advice,’ Thorin said sternly, giving Fíli his best parental look of disapproval. Fíli waved him off immediately.

‘It’s nothing, Uncle. It only hurt in the moment because I wasn’t expecting it.’

Thorin considered him carefully for another second, then nodded reluctantly.

‘Very well, then,’ he agreed. ‘Up you get.’ He stepped back, watching as Fíli hauled himself easily to his feet and confidently tested the weight on his ankle. There seemed to be no real pain from it and he walked comfortably enough, so Thorin let him be.

He managed not to laugh when Fíli, returning to Kíli’s side, did a brief jig just to prove to Thorin that all was well. If he had to glare in order to suppress the laugh, then that was no business of anyone else’s.

There was no need for Master Baggins to look at him in such a dire manner.

***

With nothing of any use to be found where they were, all they could do was begin the return journey to Brandy Hall. They were only about two miles into the journey when Rory decided to break the silence and inform the dwarves of the agreement he and Bilbo had reached.

They had spoken quickly and quietly as the dwarves searched for information on the battlefield, and hadn’t taken long to agree that there was no need, currently at least, to tell anyone that the orcs had been hunting the dwarven Company.

Rory had stated, and Bilbo had agreed, that they could hardly blame the dwarves for the evil intentions of a pack of orcs they had clearly had no knowledge of. If they had known they were being hunted, then King Thorin would not have been so desperate and panicky at the realisation that the orcs were after him and his nephews.

The best they could do, in Bilbo’s opinion, at least, was ensure that a deal was reached early on and that the dwarves were soon on their way. The border patrols would have to be increased anyway, now that the Shire knew there were orcs abroad. The reason why those orcs were there changed very little.

No doubt Gorbadoc and Fortinbras would take a slightly different view, but Bilbo and Rory could both foresee what would happen if news got out, and neither of them wished an entire colony to risk starvation for the sake of kneejerk reactions.

Bilbo had also, as they were having this conversation, kept a close eye on King Thorin. He did not know what to make of the dwarf, and none of the new evidence he was accumulating helped him at all in making a decision.

The King had grabbed and shouted at him, which usually would have been good cause for Bilbo to give him the dressing down of his life and send him on his way instantly, but then had calmed when he realised Bilbo was… slightly absent. He had clearly been irritated by the situation, but he had not pushed for an explanation for Bilbo’s behaviour as most would, which left Bilbo with some gratitude. Even the elves he had trained with had found Bilbo’s occasional lapses unnerving, but the dwarves had, after the initial shock, followed their King’s lead and taken it all in their stride.

In fact, Bilbo could have sworn that Dwalin had given him a compliment.

As if that was not confusing enough, King Thorin simply could not seem to be consistent in the way he treated others of his party.

Kicking his nephew had clearly been accidental and had been followed with immediate concern; yet, only moments later, he had been back to glaring at the lad for a little light-hearted fun.

Both boys clearly adored their Uncle, but was he worthy of that adoration, or was it simply the behaviour of those who did not know any better?

Bilbo did not know.

He did know that he was now committed to helping these dwarves as far as he possibly could.

The last few days had reinforced his conclusion that most of them were good, decent people who had simply fallen on hard times. They were willing to work to earn the help of the hobbits, as their fight today had proved, and also to risk themselves for others. Rory had told him of his moment of danger during the battle, and how thoroughly Prince Kíli had moved to deal with it. Even more, how horrified he had been that Rory had been in danger at all and how concerned he had been about whether Rory was injured.

They were caring people, beneath the wariness and gruffness, and Bilbo would help them as they had helped him here.

He was certain that both Fortinbras and Gorbadoc would take his warnings more seriously now that he had firm proof that he had not been imagining things, and the borders of the Shire were not the impenetrable barrier they preferred to imagine.

***

They camped as evening began to fall, some distance from the eaves of the Old Forest, well out of the way of any unusually energetic trees. Kíli and Ori had caught several rabbits on their travels, and Bilbo had contributed one or two of his own, so Bombur prepared a rabbit stew that somehow managed to taste better than any other trail food Bilbo had ever had.

He was full and, as long as he did not think about his earlier lapse, which as always he was very determinedly not doing, well satisfied with the day’s events.

The day had been pleasantly warm and, with the fire going, Bilbo began to feel almost too warm and also rather sleepy. Unwilling to fall asleep yet, he decided to take a short walk. The area had been devoid of danger as they travelled so he had little to fear, though he strapped on his sword before he left just in case.

It was only when he’d ambled some distance from the camp that he realised he was not the only one who had wandered off.

He heard King Thorin first.

‘I have told you before, Kíli, that you cannot always watch where Fíli is in battle. I separated the two of you for a reason. You chose to train with different weapons, and that means I will send you to do different tasks.’

‘I know, Uncle,’ Prince Kíli responded, voice small and sad.

‘You say you do,’ King Thorin countered, ‘and yet after almost every battle we must have this same conversation. You are not concentrating on what you ought to be doing because you are constantly trying to watch Fíli’s back instead, and today Rorimac was very nearly badly hurt because of it. You should have seen that orc well before it reached the hobbit. When you are defending someone, as you had been chosen to defend him, you watch all possible routes of approach, not just the ones most convenient to you.’

‘I didn’t…’ Kíli began to say, but then he stopped again. ‘I’m sorry, Uncle. I will do better, I promise.’

‘You will need to,’ King Thorin said gravely. Bilbo had crept closer during their exchange, though he knew he should not, and he was now close enough to see King Thorin grasp Kíli’s shoulders as he had grasped Bilbo’s earlier. ‘If you cannot learn to focus on the commands you have been given first, and your own wishes second, then you will be no good to any army, Kíli. Not even mine.’

It seemed as if King Thorin held his nephew’s gaze for several breaths, forehead pressed close to Kíli’s as if to drum his point home even further, before letting him go and turning to leave. Kíli also moved away, at a rather quicker pace, all but running to where his brother sat with others of the Company.

Bilbo felt himself frowning fiercely at Kíli’s clear distress and, rather than moving away to pretend he had never been there and had heard nothing, he moved to stand clearly in King Thorin’s way.

‘Master Baggins?’ King Thorin queried in surprise, stopping abruptly to avoid tripping over Bilbo. ‘What are you doing out here?’

‘I was getting a little air,’ Bilbo said shortly. Determined to say his piece, he allowed no further time for small talk. ‘You should not be so hard on them!’

Immediately, King Thorin’s spine stiffened and he straightened to his full height without seeming to realise what he was doing.

‘I beg your pardon?’

‘Your nephews, Thorin,’ Bilbo clarified, dropping all titles as he decided he needed to talk to the uncle rather than the king. ‘You are needlessly harsh with them. Kíli knew he had done wrong, his behaviour with Rory this afternoon proved that. There was no need to belabour the point just now.’

‘Not that I can see how that is any of your business…’ Thorin growled, face going flat, ‘but there is nothing needless about it. Pressure applied correctly turns metal into a sword.’

‘And too much pressure turns stone into nothing but gravel!’ Bilbo responded immediately, irritated to be dismissed in such a trite way. ‘You cannot treat those boys as if they are inanimate objects which need to be bashed into the form you expect them to fulfil. They are people and, for some reason, people who love you dearly. Kíli seemed crushed after your telling off.’

‘Kíli was upset because he knew he had done wrong and that he had not taken the advice he has been given several times by several people, including his mother, Dwalin, Balin, and Fíli, as well as myself,’ Thorin insisted. He stopped abruptly, and Bilbo sensed that he was about to walk away and end the conversation. Then, surprisingly, he continued. ‘I do them no favours if I do not point out when they are making mistakes, Master Baggins. I assure you, whatever hurt Kíli might feel now, it is nothing to how he would have felt had Rorimac died this afternoon due to his distraction. Kíli will always be a Prince. He will eventually be expected to lead dwarves into battle, as I was already doing at his age. It is bad enough to lose those you simply could not save. To lose others due to carelessness is the worst feeling in the world. I would rather bruise my nephews’ feelings than have them bear that weight all their lives!’

Coming to the end of this speech, King Thorin looked startled, as if he had said a great deal that he had not meant to. Bilbo also felt rather startled.

He had begun this discussion because he had been angry at Thorin’s seeming lack of care for his nephews, and because he had assumed that the dwarf’s glares and harsh words meant he cared about them only as soldiers.

He had not expected so impassioned a lecture on Kíli’s emotional state

‘I will always be both their Uncle and their King, Master Baggins,’ the dwarf offered softly, though he seemed as surprised to speak as Bilbo was to hear him continue the conversation. ‘It is not the privilege of royalty to care only for one's own family. My boys must be prepared to lead, even if I would never wish such a burden upon them. They have no choice. No more than I did.’

With that, Thorin turned and walked away, leaving Bilbo alone.

Alone, and more confused than ever.

******