Actions

Work Header

The Time for Home

Chapter 16: Fairy Tales

Summary:

Even the peace of Rivendell can be broken.

Chapter Text

Lord Elrond was very much what Bilbo had expected from all he had heard of the elf. Completely calm, seemingly unflappable, and with an aura of wisdom which led you to believe he had the answer to any question you might think to ask him.

Bilbo had thought himself far beyond the days of innate belief in someone else, but Elrond might well be able to prove him wrong. Even if his home was full of chairs which did not allow Bilbo to bend his knees whilst seated, and tables that were at eye-level when Bilbo sat at them.

Elrond really ought to commission some hobbit-sized furnishings for visitors, Bilbo mused, completely forgetting for a moment that he was the only hobbit in Middle Earth likely to actually venture as far as Rivendell.

‘You fear that these orcs will not necessarily abandon thoughts of the Shire just because the dwarves are no longer there,’ Lord Elrond was saying now. They were in Elrond’s library, with the dwarves eating rowdily in a dining room not far away. Bilbo had claimed first audience and Thorin, still in the overly polite mood which had been putting Bilbo on edge since they left the Shire, had not objected.

Bilbo liked to think he had learned his lesson about jumping to conclusions. He had been trying not to see Thorin’s show of good manners, and insistence that they accompany Bilbo to Rivendell, as a comment on his ability to take care of himself.

It just didn’t come naturally.

When someone tried to protect him, his instinct was to argue, to insist that he was perfectly capable of getting where he needed to go on his own.

The same when someone suddenly started offering help over awkward bits of road, or tree limbs that were blocking their way.

He was not a child.

He did not need to be taken care of by one older and more experienced at travelling than himself. He’d been going hither and thither through the Shire and the lands immediately beyond for years, entirely on his own, and he had managed perfectly well, thank you very much.

It had taken a great effort of will not to announce all of this to the King of Ered Luin at high volume and with great emphasis, but Bilbo was managing.

Nor was he above taking advantage of Thorin’s behaviour when it suited his purposes.

‘Yes, that is what concerns me,’ Bilbo responded to Elrond’s query, gazing abstractedly at the table for a moment as he worked things through in his head. ‘The orcs have no reason to believe the dwarves are gone, not when we destroyed all of their scouts and there was no one to tell the tale of their departure. If they knew Thorin and his Company were there, it would make sense for them to come looking when all goes quiet. If they choose to search the Shire, there’s no reason to think they won’t do damage while they are there. We both know how few defences hobbits truly have. The Rangers cannot be everywhere.’

‘And that is why you have come to me,’ Elrond concluded gently. ‘To ask for protection for your fellows.’

Bilbo only nodded. It went against the grain to ask for more help from the elves, who had once offered him so much and to whom he still owed a debt for that help, but he could not protect all of the Shire himself.

Without the dwarves, he would never have seen off that first group of orcs. A second, possibly bigger, band would certainly be beyond him.

‘We will assist, of course,’ Elrond confirmed, and Bilbo tried not to slump with relief. He had not expected to be rebuffed, but to hear such an easy agreement was still a blessing. ‘The protection of the Shire should not be a task the Rangers undertake entirely alone, not when danger is this close at hand. I will send Elladan and Elrohir with two patrols to tend to the borders. We will see that the orcs do not encroach any further than they already have. They will not find the Shire the easy pickings they might think, Bilbo. This I promise you.’

‘Thank you,’ Bilbo breathed, smiling up at the Lord of Rivendell. ‘That is very kind.’

‘It is very practical,’ Elrond replied, though the smile he offered Bilbo in turn was all kindness. ‘The Shire is, with a few very small exceptions, one of the great bastions of peace and goodness left in Middle Earth, Bilbo. It would be remiss of me, as part of the White Council, to allow it to fall to evil.’

Bilbo paused, the words he had been about to say stuck in his throat as he considered this new idea. He had never considered the Shire in such terms before. To him it had always just been home, and a rather uncomfortable one since his mother’s death.

Having one’s sense of security stripped away tended to change the way one viewed everything, even one’s home.

‘That seems strange to you?’ Elrond questioned gently.

‘I… don’t know,’ Bilbo answered slowly. ‘It has never seemed so very good to me; only full of gossips, and those who want their safe, comfortable life at the expense of ever knowing what is really going on outside their narrow world. Those who would deride anyone who wishes to be their own protection, rather than relying solely on others for anything more serious than a fight at the inn.’

‘I think it is perhaps much like Rivendell,’ Elrond proposed thoughtfully, which made Bilbo’s head come up sharply. In his mind, Rivendell and the Shire were worlds apart. Elrond laughed.

‘Not in particulars, Bilbo,’ he amended softly. ‘It is simply that Rivendell, like the Shire, is not for everyone. I try to create a sanctuary here. A place of tranquillity. A place which is, in its own small way, outside of time. For some, that balm of peace is exactly what is needed. They have travelled here in the past, for reasons of their own, and have never left because they need what it holds. For others, more than a few days here makes them begin to jump out of their own skin. My ward, Estel, is not quite in that category, but I suspect he is not far off some days. He always wishes to be doing, moving. A life of contemplation will not be his. Perhaps the life of a Shire-hobbit was not meant to be yours. The Valar have done stranger things to their children.’

‘That is an interesting thought,’ was Bilbo’s non-committal response. He was unwilling to say more when such an idea had only just been sprung on him. Elrond did not seem to mind.

‘Like many interesting thoughts,’ he said easily, ‘it will perhaps take a little time to digest. Now, if your companions have finished digesting the fare I have on offer, I should probably speak to Thorin Oakenshield. If nothing else, I would like to propose that I trade the services of his most excellent Steward and young Master Ori for some supplies. I have a particular dwarven text which does not wish to translate into anything resembling sense when I make the attempt. Perhaps a dwarf will have better luck!’

***

‘You should come with us, you know,’ Bofur declared. After returning to the dwarves following his conversation with Elrond, Bilbo had decided to take an evening stroll around Rivendell to think. Somehow, and he had no idea how, Bofur had ended up accompanying him.

‘You have said so more than once,’ Bilbo acknowledged wryly, shaking his head. Bofur had been stuck on this theme for almost a week now, though he at least had the goodness to start on the topic only when they were alone. The last thing Bilbo needed was all of the Company wading in on one side or other of the debate.

‘Then clearly that means I must be right,’ Bofur replied, completely without logic.

‘I begin to perceive a major fault in your education,’ Bilbo told him, with great amusement. ‘Contrary to what you have clearly been taught, Bofur, he who speaks most often is not always in the right!’

‘Nonsense,’ Bofur proclaimed, the size of his grin showing that he was enjoying himself thoroughly. ‘Don’t know who put that ridiculous idea in your head, lad, but you should know that I always speak most often and so am always right.’

‘What would Bifur have to say to that, I wonder?’ Bilbo pondered, unable to help grinning in response. He had noticed early on that - despite Bofur’s loud, exuberant nature - it was the quieter Bifur who ruled that particular family grouping. Much as Balin ruled over Dwalin with a velvet-covered fist of iron.

‘Nothing I’d translate for you,’ Bofur answered, laughing. ‘Only problem is, Bombur would probably tell you instead. Anyway, don’t think you’ll be distracting me like that. Why won’t you join us? You said you’d like to see more of the world than your Shire. What better way than to come on with us? You could be the first hobbit to go all the way to the Iron Hills.’

‘Given that I am the first hobbit in living memory to travel all the way to Rivendell,’ Bilbo countered with asperity, ‘I think perhaps I have come far enough. I will be putting up with little comments about this for years.’

‘Might as well be hung for a sheep as for a lamb,’ was Bofur’s prosaic reply. ‘If they’re going to mutter anyway, what does it matter how far you’ve gone? Besides, the longer you’re with us, the longer it is before you have to start putting up with those little comments.’

‘Delay the pain as long as possible?’ Bilbo asked. ‘Not a very dwarf-ly attitude, is it?’ He immediately winced at the cattiness in his voice, but Bofur waved him off the moment he tried to apologise.

‘Ah, never you mind,’ the dwarf dismissed. ‘Takes more than that to penetrate a hide this thick.’ There was a pause while they continued to walk, Bofur letting the harsh words drift off into the night before he started on his topic again.

‘Really, Bilbo, you should join us,’ he insisted. ‘I know we’re not the best-behaved bunch you’ll ever meet, but we’ve not been that unbearable, have we? The boys would love to have you with us, and so would I. I haven’t travelled as far as Erebor before. Not many of us have. The more friends we have with us as we go, the better, and you’re part of the Company now.’

‘I do not think your King believes so,’ Bilbo commented. ‘He has little faith in my abilities; I doubt he wishes to take dead weight on your journey.’

‘Dead weight?’ Bofur asked disbelievingly. ‘Where on earth did you get that idea?’

‘He keeps a constant eye on me,’ Bilbo began to list, ticking off on his fingers. ‘He’s been helping me down from heights I am perfectly capable of managing myself, he lifted me over that tree trunk a few days ago when I was already halfway over…’

‘And you think Thorin’s treating you a bit more carefully because you can’t take care of yourself?’ Bofur continued, still sounding entirely startled by the idea.

‘Well, isn’t he?’ Bilbo asked brusquely. ‘He was willing to go out of your way just to get me here!’

‘He was treating an honoured guest with courtesy,’ Bofur contradicted forcefully, eyeing Bilbo as if he had suddenly grown an extra head. Bilbo resisted the urge to elbow him in the stomach in response. ‘Bilbo, you gave us a lot of help in the Shire. Thorin is obliged, under dwarven custom, to make recompense for that help.’

‘You helped with the orcs,’ Bilbo objected, but Bofur waved that away with a flick of his hand.

‘That was as much for us as for you,’ he pointed out. ‘You were the one who originally told us so. To take your help and then do nothing to help you in return would dishonour Thorin, and through him Ered Luin. The least he could do was see you to Rivendell safely. As for the rest, he was… treating you a bit like Dís, I suppose.’

When Bilbo gave him a questioning look, Bofur clarified, ‘His sister. Thorin always says she’s perfectly capable of taking care of herself in any situation he could name, but that doesn’t mean she should have to. Dís does a lot for Thorin, as you’ve done a lot for us, so Thorin tries to take some of the annoying little difficulties life’s full of out of her way. That’s what he was doing with you, I think. Just trying to make things a bit easier.’

Bofur seemed very pleased with his summary, as if he’d managed to explain himself exactly as he meant to, for once, and Bilbo found himself speechless for the second time in one day.

Thorin was treating Bilbo like his sister.

That was…

Unexpected.

Yavanna above, what was he meant to do with that?

***

Thorin’s conversation with Elrond had apparently gone fairly well, for their King closed the door quite gently as he entered the parlour where the Company had gathered… minus Bofur and Bilbo, who were off doing who knew what somewhere else. Ori was beginning to think that Bofur was attempting to cause the first ever instance of stone-sense in a non-dwarf by teaching Bilbo about it in the greatest depth.

It made him a little jealous, really. Ori had never had much chance to study stone-sense properly, and he’d always wondered what it would be like to hear the stone the way Bofur and Bifur did.

No matter, if they were going to stay here for a few days - and the way Thorin calmly took a seat suggested that they were - then at least Ori would have chance to draw the view that Elladan had been talking about.

As long as he could get Nori to stop mentally carving the elves apart long enough to accompany him, of course. He did not think for a second that his brothers were going to let him go alone. What they thought the elves were going to do to him, Ori didn’t know. The only thing Ori could think they might try was suddenly tipping him off the edge of a cliff, and… well, they could do, of course, but Ori had no idea what the point of the exercise would be.

Brothers. Sometimes their overprotective instincts really did defy all reason.

‘We will stay three days,’ Thorin informed the Company. ‘Lord Elrond is happy to supply us, and it would appear he is also happy to take Balin’s expertise as part exchange for the goods.’

‘I am useful like that,’ Balin told them with a beatific smile, which caused Dwalin to snort and kick his brother’s ankle idly from the chair opposite.

‘I would ask all of you to avoid the elves as much as possible,’ were Thorin’s next words, and Ori felt the smile fall off his face. He had so wanted…

‘Without needlessly offending our hosts, Ori,’ Thorin continued, with barely a pause. ‘You have received an invitation which seems to be in good faith. I would be displeased to find the elves had had their gentler feelings hurt for no reason.’

Ori allowed himself to smile again. He’d heard Bilbo grumble sometimes about Thorin’s lack of care for others – the hobbit seemed to have got the impression that Thorin’s problem with their names was because he could not tell them apart, and Ori had not got around to correcting him yet – but Ori knew better. Thorin had set this up so Nori and Dori could not forbid him from going, which was just the sort of kindness their King liked to hide under all his gruff orders.

‘Other than that,’ Thorin ordered, ‘try to keep to yourselves. We are not among friends here, even if the elves have given me no cause for true concern. We are on display, as we were in the Shire, and I would have no… misunderstandings before we leave.’

Of course, it was at that exact moment that there was a crash outside, and they all heard Bofur exclaim loudly, ‘Oh, sorry about that, lass. They’re a lot more fragile than they look, aren’t they?’

Thorin closed his eyes with a truly pained expression upon his face. Dwalin groaned. Bombur winced.

Bifur rose to his feet, with Balin only a moment behind him, and headed off to find out what his cousin had got into this time.

***

Bofur did not seem to have caused any lasting harm to relations with the elves, thank Mahal and all his siblings, but nonetheless Thorin’s brief moment of peace was shattered only half a day later.

He heard the commotion, if such it could be called when the elves took everything so calmly, just after lunch. The boys were dragging him off to show him the shards of Narsil, which they had found during their wanders. As the blade was a fine example of dwarven craftsmanship, Thorin was more than happy to be accosted and was quietly enjoying the way that Fíli and Kíli talked over the top of each other constantly as each tried to be the first to tell him all about their find.

Sometimes, as in the Shire, he could see so clearly the adults they were becoming.

Sometimes, as now, he could see nothing but the children he had watched over all their lives.

It was the sound of hooves clattering into a courtyard that alerted him to the arrival of a new guest, and the speed with which those hooves appeared to be moving caught Thorin’s attention immediately. The boys, hearing the same thing he did, also quieted and paused.

‘Uncle?’ Fíli asked, waiting for instruction.

‘Let us go and see who that is,’ Thorin said, after a moment’s thought. ‘We can return to see Narsil later.’

The boys immediately started back the way they had come, and Thorin moved quickly to get ahead of them. An ill feeling was crawling down his spine and, whatever this was, his nephews would not be the first to face it.

He had gone no more than fifty feet when Dwalin joined them. Thorin noticed that Dwalin was tense with readiness, and the feeling of foreboding only strengthened.

‘What is it?’ Thorin asked him lowly, using Khuzdul as he slipped back into the mindset he was most familiar with, wary and ready for any eventuality.

‘Tharkûn,’ Dwalin growled. ‘The elves began speaking of him as soon as crossed the border into their valley.’

Tharkûn.

The wizard.

No wonder Thorin had such a bad feeling about this.

He had thought the wizard’s meddling in their affairs was done. Gandalf had tried to make himself useful, but when he had visited Ered Luin it had been plain that he had some purpose he was not telling Thorin of. Certainly, his ‘helpful’ mention of Bilbo Baggins’ name had not been as simple as it seemed, for Bilbo bore him no great love and they had not had a smooth beginning with the hobbit. That it had all worked out well in the end was more by luck than by design, or so it appeared to Thorin.

When Gandalf had left them, Thorin had fervently hoped that was the last he would see of him for many years.

He had a kingdom to secure. He did not have time for the plots of a wizard. No matter how well-intentioned those plots might be.

By the time they arrived at the courtyard where guests were welcomed, Gandalf was already deep in conversation with Lord Elrond. They both looked up when they caught a glimpse of the small party of dwarves approaching, and Gandalf smiled widely.

‘Ah, Thorin,’ he greeted. ‘I am glad to find you here. I was not sure how far advanced your journey would be. I feared I would have to follow you across the Misty Mountains.’

He did not seem the slightest bit perturbed by Thorin’s wary expression, nor by the way that Dwalin, Fíli and Kíli were gathered about their King like a suspicious honour guard. Of course, none of them truly thought that Gandalf was going to try and hurt Thorin. That was ridiculous.

They just did not trust him.

Well, Thorin and Dwalin did not trust him, and that was enough for the boys.

‘You are in luck, as you can see,’ Thorin told the wizard carefully. ‘We leave shortly. What need did you have of me?’

‘A few words,’ Gandalf said, giving nothing away, as usual. ‘I hope your business in the Shire went well?’

‘It was concluded adequately,’ Thorin replied, determined to be no more forthcoming than Gandalf was. Let him be on the receiving end of some of his own cryptic nonsense for a change.

‘Mithrandir, perhaps you would like to have your words with Thorin inside?’ Lord Elrond suggested easily, not at all disturbed by the wizard’s unexpected arrival, or by Thorin’s clear unhappiness at seeing him. ‘You are cluttering up my courtyard somewhat, and we are expecting a patrol in soon.’

‘Of course,’ Gandalf said graciously. ‘Thorin, if you would join me?’

Thorin almost growled. This was not Gandalf’s kingdom any more than it was Thorin’s; the wizard had no right to treat Thorin as if he were a visiting vassal.

‘I think we would do better if both of you joined me,’ Lord Elrond commented, still apparently unperturbed, but with a sharper look in his eyes than they had held only moments ago. ‘After all, Gandalf, I presume you wish to use my study for your discussion, and I fear without me you will find yourself locked out.’ He held a key up between long, slim fingers, as if to use it as evidence to prove his case.

Perhaps the elves were not so bad after all.

***

Thorin had bidden the boys return to their exploring, and had dispatched Dwalin to keep an eye on them, before following Lord Elrond to his study once again. It was a pleasant, cosy room; while Thorin was by no means the scholar that Balin was, he was still intrigued by some of the texts held here, and in another life he might have whiled away a week or two investigating what the shelves held.

This was not another life, however, and frankly he had seen enough of this room for one week.

Possibly for a year.

‘I believe I may have a solution to your ongoing problem, Thorin,’ Gandalf announced within moments of their sitting down. For one who had a professed dislike of wasting time, Gandalf seemed to have a strange aversion to speaking clearly. Thorin had only met him once before, but even then the desire to point out the contradiction had been strong.

He had resisted, but only because he had not wished to face Balin’s wrath when he discovered that Gandalf would not be assisting them with his connections after all, because Thorin had mortally insulted him.

One never knew when wizards would choose to be sensitive about such things.

‘Indeed,’ was all Thorin said instead, waiting to see what Gandalf would come out with, though he was itching to hurry events along.

‘Yes,’ Gandalf continued serenely. ‘You are, I believe, in need of a way of keeping your people safe for many years to come. The agreement with the hobbits, as we all know, is not an ongoing solution to your problem.’

‘Thus I will visit my cousin, and seek his aid,’ Thorin reminded the wizard. Gandalf was old even by elven standards. Perhaps he had forgotten that this strategy had already been agreed by the dwarves and explained to him when they previously met.

‘Yet Dáin has his own kingdom to care for,’ Gandalf pointed out, ‘and may not be able to give all you might wish. Surely you would be safer with a more dependable answer to the problem.’

Thorin had tried, truly he had, but he was a dwarf known for his ability to survive overwhelming odds, not for his patience.

‘Spit it out, Gandalf,’ he snapped, temper worn thin by all the tiptoeing around the point. ‘What is it you suggest?’

‘Only that you find a true home for your people,’ Gandalf replied, tone sharp in the face of Thorin’s temper. ‘Or re-find, I should perhaps say. Reclaim Erebor, Thorin. Then your people will never need worry about their survival again.’

‘Gandalf!’ Lord Elrond began to object, as animated as Thorin had ever seen him. His horror at the idea, at what it suggested, was entirely apparent to Thorin, but it was unnecessary.

Thorin had his own answer on the tip of his tongue.

‘I have no time to waste on fairy tales, Wizard,’ he said plainly, his tone as hard as the rock of their former home. ‘If that is all you have for me, you might have saved yourself a journey.’

******